Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:37,524 --> 00:00:42,524
Subtitles by explosiveskull
2
00:04:10,565 --> 00:04:12,441
Witnesses
said a white man
3
00:04:12,443 --> 00:04:15,402
with a Marine haircut
met Jeffrey Laude,
4
00:04:15,404 --> 00:04:16,861
who was dressed as a woman
5
00:04:16,863 --> 00:04:20,702
at a nightclub in Olongapo City
on Saturday night.
6
00:04:35,883 --> 00:04:37,924
The body
of 26-year-old Laude
7
00:04:37,926 --> 00:04:40,970
was found in this
hotel in Olongapo City.
8
00:04:40,972 --> 00:04:42,929
American troops
there were on a break
9
00:04:42,931 --> 00:04:45,892
from military exercises
for the Philippines.
10
00:04:48,563 --> 00:04:50,813
I first learned
about Jennifer Laude
11
00:04:50,815 --> 00:04:53,857
through social media.
12
00:04:53,859 --> 00:04:58,278
I felt a connection
to her immediately,
13
00:04:58,280 --> 00:05:03,118
just as a Filipino trans woman.
14
00:07:29,265 --> 00:07:30,890
Reports out
of the Philippines
15
00:07:30,892 --> 00:07:33,893
say the Marine and the
victim met in a nightclub.
16
00:07:33,895 --> 00:07:36,311
The two left the club with
one of Jennifer's friends
17
00:07:36,313 --> 00:07:37,938
and went to a hotel
where they were
18
00:07:37,940 --> 00:07:40,232
captured by security cameras.
19
00:07:40,234 --> 00:07:42,400
Three other Marines
are being questioned
20
00:07:42,402 --> 00:07:44,404
as possible witnesses.
21
00:08:45,799 --> 00:08:49,009
She was just a very
natural person.
22
00:08:49,011 --> 00:08:51,803
She was a very giving person.
23
00:08:51,805 --> 00:08:56,057
She was kind, friendly
to everyone, open-minded.
24
00:08:56,059 --> 00:09:00,021
She was just trying to
live a very normal life.
25
00:09:00,023 --> 00:09:02,483
This is not an isolated case.
26
00:09:44,317 --> 00:09:46,776
From day one that we
handled this case,
27
00:09:46,778 --> 00:09:49,903
we already know the
Laudes' situation.
28
00:09:49,905 --> 00:09:52,156
That's the very reason
why Harry and I
29
00:09:52,158 --> 00:09:56,076
offered our services pro bono.
30
00:09:56,078 --> 00:10:00,330
If you don't have money, you
don't have access to justice.
31
00:10:00,332 --> 00:10:04,210
What kind of a self-respecting
country can we be
32
00:10:04,212 --> 00:10:06,921
if we cannot even
implement our laws
33
00:10:06,923 --> 00:10:08,839
when they are breached
in our territory
34
00:10:08,841 --> 00:10:12,053
and when a victim is a Filipino?
35
00:10:12,845 --> 00:10:14,552
You know, I ask you one thing.
36
00:10:14,554 --> 00:10:18,431
For who it is more
fun in the Philippines
37
00:10:18,433 --> 00:10:21,476
for the Philippine people
or for the U.S. soldiers,
38
00:10:21,478 --> 00:10:25,815
who having everything they
want with no response taken,
39
00:10:25,817 --> 00:10:28,024
and for the cheapest money
they can get?
40
00:10:28,026 --> 00:10:30,404
That's all I wanted
to say about that.
41
00:10:36,410 --> 00:10:38,952
- Can you hear me?
- Yes, I can hear you.
42
00:10:38,954 --> 00:10:40,454
I guess
a good place to start
43
00:10:40,456 --> 00:10:44,332
would be to ask you how
your relationship began.
44
00:10:44,334 --> 00:10:46,252
You know, love on
the first sight
45
00:10:46,254 --> 00:10:49,754
is something which I have
considered unrealistic.
46
00:10:49,756 --> 00:10:54,301
But she was even more adorable,
natural person when we met
47
00:10:54,303 --> 00:10:56,595
and after three, four days,
48
00:10:56,597 --> 00:11:00,559
it was clear for me that this
was the person of my life.
49
00:11:01,476 --> 00:11:04,436
What do you
think happened that night?
50
00:11:04,438 --> 00:11:06,564
The only person
who could tell us
51
00:11:06,566 --> 00:11:09,609
what was her intention
to be there that evening
52
00:11:09,611 --> 00:11:11,527
is Jennifer herself.
53
00:11:11,529 --> 00:11:14,446
Unlike other ladyboys
probably have to work
54
00:11:14,448 --> 00:11:19,784
that way every night, she had
different chances than that.
55
00:11:19,786 --> 00:11:22,537
Whatever she did
to end up there,
56
00:11:22,539 --> 00:11:24,956
it has nothing to do with
what happened inside.
57
00:11:24,958 --> 00:11:27,252
Simply nothing.
58
00:11:27,629 --> 00:11:30,796
You know, she was killed on
the 11th of October.
59
00:11:30,798 --> 00:11:32,797
October 1, we got
the confirmation
60
00:11:32,799 --> 00:11:34,341
that her visa is granted.
61
00:11:34,343 --> 00:11:39,346
Here in Germany, the official
wedding date was set.
62
00:11:39,348 --> 00:11:42,351
Her wedding dress
was bought already.
63
00:11:43,226 --> 00:11:45,894
We are just inches away to make
64
00:11:45,896 --> 00:11:49,441
our both dream of life
come true.
65
00:12:09,670 --> 00:12:11,836
How the killing of a
trans Filipina woman
66
00:12:11,838 --> 00:12:14,923
ignited an
international incident.
67
00:12:14,925 --> 00:12:16,676
On October 11 of last year,
68
00:12:16,678 --> 00:12:20,012
the U.S. Marines stationed
aboard the USS Peleliu
69
00:12:20,014 --> 00:12:21,555
got their first night of liberty
70
00:12:21,557 --> 00:12:24,683
after their Tarawa-class
amphibious assault ship
71
00:12:24,685 --> 00:12:26,687
docked in Subic Bay.
72
00:12:28,271 --> 00:12:30,690
Private First Class
Joseph Scott Pemberton,
73
00:12:30,692 --> 00:12:33,692
a 19-year-old from New Bedford,
Massachusetts,
74
00:12:33,694 --> 00:12:36,362
eagerly disembarked
with his battle buddies
75
00:12:36,364 --> 00:12:40,034
Bennett Dahl, Daniel Pulido,
and Jairn Rose.
76
00:12:44,329 --> 00:12:46,162
Jennifer first
left her apartment
77
00:12:46,164 --> 00:12:48,206
with her friend, Jamille.
78
00:12:48,208 --> 00:12:51,543
They took a tricycle
to Ambyanz Nightclub
79
00:12:51,545 --> 00:12:55,215
and arrived there at
approximately 10:30.
80
00:12:57,342 --> 00:12:58,551
The club
was a frequent hangout
81
00:12:58,553 --> 00:13:01,553
for sex workers known
as Pocahontases,
82
00:13:01,555 --> 00:13:04,764
a riff on pok-pok, a
Tagalog term for slut,
83
00:13:04,766 --> 00:13:07,726
which also alludes to
the former colonizers
84
00:13:07,728 --> 00:13:10,147
who often patronize them.
85
00:13:11,899 --> 00:13:13,523
The most dogged of these women,
86
00:13:13,525 --> 00:13:15,359
those who quickly
latch onto the arms
87
00:13:15,361 --> 00:13:17,737
of the men pouring
off the ships,
88
00:13:17,739 --> 00:13:19,321
are usually transgender.
89
00:13:19,323 --> 00:13:22,242
But the foreign soldiers
rarely learned that.
90
00:13:23,660 --> 00:13:27,204
Approximately at 10:45,
91
00:13:27,206 --> 00:13:29,623
Private First Class
Joseph Scott Pemberton
92
00:13:29,625 --> 00:13:33,087
entered Ambyanz with
three other Marines.
93
00:13:33,670 --> 00:13:35,128
The
women had been working
94
00:13:35,130 --> 00:13:37,965
since the soldiers went
on liberty that afternoon.
95
00:13:37,967 --> 00:13:41,093
And by 10:45, when
Laude met Pemberton,
96
00:13:41,095 --> 00:13:43,638
she'd already been
with three clients.
97
00:13:43,640 --> 00:13:46,931
"Jennifer was exhausted,"
said another friend Charis.
98
00:13:46,933 --> 00:13:50,438
"We work as hard as we can
when the soldiers are here."
99
00:13:51,356 --> 00:13:53,272
Within a few minute of meeting,
100
00:13:53,274 --> 00:13:56,316
Pemberton and Laude left
for the Celzone Lodge,
101
00:13:56,318 --> 00:13:58,277
a motel across the street,
102
00:13:58,279 --> 00:14:01,571
accompanied by Laude's friend,
Barbie Gelviro.
103
00:14:01,573 --> 00:14:04,867
According to Elias,
the cashier bellboy,
104
00:14:04,869 --> 00:14:07,494
Pemberton, Jennifer,
and Barbie
105
00:14:07,496 --> 00:14:12,166
entered Celzone Lodge at
approximately 11:05 p.m.
106
00:14:12,168 --> 00:14:14,712
Elias assigned them
room number one.
107
00:14:16,923 --> 00:14:19,255
Gelviro stayed
with the couple for a minute
108
00:14:19,257 --> 00:14:21,050
to help negotiate a rate.
109
00:14:21,052 --> 00:14:23,594
Laude suggested 5,000 pesos,
110
00:14:23,596 --> 00:14:28,224
but Pemberton only wanted
to pay 1,000, about $25.
111
00:14:28,226 --> 00:14:30,558
Laude, nervous that
Pemberton might discover
112
00:14:30,560 --> 00:14:33,646
the girls were trans, quickly
agree to the lower rate
113
00:14:33,648 --> 00:14:36,401
and rushed her friend
out of the room.
114
00:14:37,193 --> 00:14:38,817
About 30 minutes
after the group
115
00:14:38,819 --> 00:14:40,360
had arrived at the motel,
116
00:14:40,362 --> 00:14:42,529
Pemberton casually walked
out of his room alone,
117
00:14:42,531 --> 00:14:46,200
leaving the door
slightly ajar behind him.
118
00:14:46,202 --> 00:14:49,244
He seemed unperturbed as
he passed the front desk
119
00:14:49,246 --> 00:14:52,080
and walked down the
steps into the night.
120
00:14:52,082 --> 00:14:53,916
His curfew was
rapidly approaching
121
00:14:53,918 --> 00:14:57,628
and he and his shipmates
needed to return together.
122
00:14:57,630 --> 00:15:01,423
Elias expected that
Jennifer would shortly follow.
123
00:15:01,425 --> 00:15:06,179
But 15 minutes have passed,
no one came out of the room.
124
00:15:08,057 --> 00:15:09,724
As they were about
to go to sleep,
125
00:15:09,726 --> 00:15:11,142
Pemberton approached Rose
126
00:15:11,144 --> 00:15:13,436
and asked to talk
to him in private.
127
00:15:13,438 --> 00:15:15,729
They walked over to
the front of the ship
128
00:15:15,731 --> 00:15:17,440
far from human ears,
129
00:15:17,442 --> 00:15:20,526
with only the ocean
and the sky to listen.
130
00:15:20,528 --> 00:15:24,071
Pemberton said that
he saw it had a dick.
131
00:15:24,073 --> 00:15:26,282
He told Rose he got so angry,
132
00:15:26,284 --> 00:15:28,952
that he choked it from behind.
133
00:15:29,911 --> 00:15:33,874
"I think I killed a
he-she," Pemberton said.
134
00:15:38,462 --> 00:15:42,840
The medical report
would show that Jennifer
135
00:15:42,842 --> 00:15:48,512
died of asphyxia due to
strangulation and drowning
136
00:15:48,514 --> 00:15:52,599
and the same is reflected
in her death certificate.
137
00:15:52,601 --> 00:15:56,438
Her entire back
was black and blue.
138
00:17:54,640 --> 00:17:56,349
In so far as the citizenry,
139
00:17:56,351 --> 00:17:59,060
the Filipino citizenry
is concerned,
140
00:17:59,062 --> 00:18:00,477
this is duly served.
141
00:18:00,479 --> 00:18:03,857
The notice is duly served
to the person of Pemberton.
142
00:18:30,968 --> 00:18:32,385
You cannot help this case.
143
00:18:32,387 --> 00:18:34,344
You cannot help the Laudes.
144
00:18:34,346 --> 00:18:37,723
If you just know things
about the killing,
145
00:18:37,725 --> 00:18:39,975
if you just know
things about the murder
146
00:18:39,977 --> 00:18:42,686
because it's not a
simple case of murder.
147
00:18:42,688 --> 00:18:45,063
At the police station,
then I will have to
148
00:18:45,065 --> 00:18:47,692
check it one-by-one against...
149
00:18:47,694 --> 00:18:50,485
The relationship between the
U.S. and the Philippines
150
00:18:50,487 --> 00:18:55,532
is really a relationship between
151
00:18:55,534 --> 00:19:00,081
a colonizer and a
colony or a neo-colony.
152
00:19:08,922 --> 00:19:11,006
This is the
story of the Philippines,
153
00:19:11,008 --> 00:19:13,091
a nation of islands
on the eastern rim
154
00:19:13,093 --> 00:19:15,721
of the vast Pacific Ocean.
155
00:19:21,811 --> 00:19:25,603
Discovered over 400 years ago
by the explorer Magellan,
156
00:19:25,605 --> 00:19:27,439
the Philippines were
ruled by the Spaniards
157
00:19:27,441 --> 00:19:30,111
for more than 200 years.
158
00:19:39,579 --> 00:19:42,621
We are a colony of
the United States.
159
00:19:42,623 --> 00:19:45,625
We were purchased allegedly,
from Spain.
160
00:19:45,627 --> 00:19:49,462
We were said to have been
granted independence.
161
00:19:49,464 --> 00:19:51,630
But in exchange,
we've had to agree
162
00:19:51,632 --> 00:19:54,591
that U.S. bases will remain
in the Philippines.
163
00:21:04,956 --> 00:21:09,582
The VFA stands for
Visiting Forces Agreement.
164
00:21:09,584 --> 00:21:12,878
This VFA really comes
into play in this case
165
00:21:12,880 --> 00:21:16,299
because it reads about
how the Philippines
166
00:21:16,301 --> 00:21:18,553
should treat the U.S. soldiers.
167
00:21:28,771 --> 00:21:30,312
What exactly
is legal hold?
168
00:21:30,314 --> 00:21:32,898
It may be one of the best things
we have in the Philippines.
169
00:21:32,900 --> 00:21:35,400
Legal hold means that if
you're charged with a crime
170
00:21:35,402 --> 00:21:38,821
under local laws, you'll be
turned over to U.S. authorities
171
00:21:38,823 --> 00:21:41,074
rather than left
in a local lock-up.
172
00:21:42,159 --> 00:21:43,242
Put it this way,
173
00:21:43,244 --> 00:21:45,202
it would be unthinkable
for a foreign soldier
174
00:21:45,204 --> 00:21:47,746
to commit murder in America
175
00:21:47,748 --> 00:21:49,956
and not be apprehended
by U.S. police
176
00:21:49,958 --> 00:21:52,752
and not be tried by U.S. courts.
177
00:21:52,754 --> 00:21:54,253
But what's happened in this case
178
00:21:54,255 --> 00:21:56,964
is we have an instance
where an American Marine
179
00:21:56,966 --> 00:21:59,634
committed a non-service
related offense.
180
00:21:59,636 --> 00:22:01,676
Number one, he
remains in the custody
181
00:22:01,678 --> 00:22:03,012
of American soldiers.
182
00:22:03,014 --> 00:22:05,723
Number two, he was never
physically investigated
183
00:22:05,725 --> 00:22:07,183
by Philippine authorities.
184
00:22:07,185 --> 00:22:09,769
Number three, his attendance
in court proceedings
185
00:22:09,771 --> 00:22:13,397
is a matter of cooperation
with American authorities
186
00:22:13,399 --> 00:22:17,443
rather than as part of
mandatory judicial proceedings.
187
00:22:17,445 --> 00:22:20,029
With the VFA, it's like
188
00:22:20,031 --> 00:22:22,990
the Filipinos are being
served on a silver platter.
189
00:22:22,992 --> 00:22:24,617
Here are the Philippines,
kill them.
190
00:22:24,619 --> 00:22:26,910
Here are the Filipinas,
rape them.
191
00:22:26,912 --> 00:22:28,663
Because even if
you are convicted,
192
00:22:28,665 --> 00:22:31,456
your custody will be transferred
to the U.S. Embassy;
193
00:22:31,458 --> 00:22:33,044
it's like you're free.
194
00:22:34,419 --> 00:22:37,545
It's a wrap
for U.S. President Barack Obama.
195
00:22:37,547 --> 00:22:40,006
The U.S. reached a
10-year defense deal
196
00:22:40,008 --> 00:22:42,801
to allow more U.S. troops
in the Philippines.
197
00:22:42,803 --> 00:22:44,887
As the U.S. is now
trying even to expand
198
00:22:44,889 --> 00:22:46,388
its presence in the Philippines
199
00:22:46,390 --> 00:22:49,433
through the Enhanced Defense
Cooperation Agreement,
200
00:22:49,435 --> 00:22:52,811
the bigger question is, "What's
in it for the Filipinos?"
201
00:22:52,813 --> 00:22:54,230
To our Filipino Armed Forces,
202
00:22:54,232 --> 00:22:56,314
thank you for being such
an outstanding ally.
203
00:22:56,316 --> 00:22:58,192
God bless the Republic
of the Philippines.
204
00:22:58,194 --> 00:23:00,360
God bless the
United States of America.
205
00:23:00,362 --> 00:23:03,656
God bless the alliance
between our great nations.
206
00:23:03,658 --> 00:23:04,823
Thank you.
207
00:26:30,406 --> 00:26:35,283
♪ If you think that I'm
still holdin' on ♪
208
00:26:35,285 --> 00:26:39,082
♪ Maybe you should go
and love yourself ♪
209
00:26:52,428 --> 00:26:53,595
Bye!
210
00:28:42,871 --> 00:28:45,705
I mean, that is really
not only unjust
211
00:28:45,707 --> 00:28:47,416
to the family of Laude,
212
00:28:47,418 --> 00:28:50,254
but also unjust to
the Filipino people.
213
00:29:05,268 --> 00:29:07,188
Let me see the documents.
214
00:29:11,942 --> 00:29:15,445
The entire documents
are in there.
215
00:29:20,368 --> 00:29:23,037
The report is very frustrating.
216
00:29:41,555 --> 00:29:44,891
Yeah, was taken
by the Americans.
217
00:29:45,184 --> 00:29:47,642
Remember our Filipino
police authorities
218
00:29:47,644 --> 00:29:52,566
was unable to get the
KamaSutra condom wrapper.
219
00:29:54,026 --> 00:29:56,651
Yeah, it was only the
American authorities,
220
00:29:56,653 --> 00:30:00,281
the NCIS agent who
got hold the condom,
221
00:30:00,283 --> 00:30:02,073
the KamaSutra condom wrapper,
222
00:30:02,075 --> 00:30:04,703
not our authorities.
223
00:30:05,455 --> 00:30:07,540
That is very interesting to me.
224
00:30:21,888 --> 00:30:26,643
In my family, I'm the only one
who's able to finish college.
225
00:30:27,101 --> 00:30:29,601
My father is a tricycle driver
226
00:30:29,603 --> 00:30:32,481
and my mother does
not have regular work.
227
00:30:33,107 --> 00:30:35,148
He's a typical father
228
00:30:35,150 --> 00:30:40,321
who thinks that daughters
need not go to college.
229
00:30:40,323 --> 00:30:43,450
After all, they'll
just get married.
230
00:30:44,284 --> 00:30:47,160
I was telling myself,
"No, I have to finish.
231
00:30:47,162 --> 00:30:48,620
"I have to reach college.
232
00:30:48,622 --> 00:30:51,793
I have to be able to do
something to help the family."
233
00:30:59,883 --> 00:31:03,010
A lot of people would think that
murder is always premeditated.
234
00:31:03,012 --> 00:31:04,844
There are other two elements:
235
00:31:04,846 --> 00:31:07,764
the abuse of superior
strength and the cruelty.
236
00:31:07,766 --> 00:31:12,436
That's the reason why
they had been saying that
237
00:31:12,438 --> 00:31:16,314
after all Jennifer is a trans,
but he is still a man.
238
00:31:16,316 --> 00:31:19,150
The Marines, you know,
yes they have training.
239
00:31:19,152 --> 00:31:22,530
But they only spend a few hours
240
00:31:22,532 --> 00:31:25,824
in actual military training.
241
00:31:25,826 --> 00:31:29,160
That is to weaken
242
00:31:29,162 --> 00:31:32,247
our allegation that there
is some kind of abuse
243
00:31:32,249 --> 00:31:33,832
of superior strength.
244
00:31:33,834 --> 00:31:38,670
Definitely there is no doubt
that a Marine, an elite force,
245
00:31:38,672 --> 00:31:42,300
certainly has the
superior strength
246
00:31:42,302 --> 00:31:44,968
over every other individual.
247
00:31:44,970 --> 00:31:49,639
Because if not, what difference
does a U.S. Marine soldier make?
248
00:31:49,641 --> 00:31:52,517
If, in this case,
249
00:31:52,519 --> 00:31:56,187
Pemberton gets convicted
and then after that,
250
00:31:56,189 --> 00:32:00,443
he will be incarcerated
not in the Philippines.
251
00:32:00,445 --> 00:32:03,446
My goodness, that
will all the more show
252
00:32:03,448 --> 00:32:06,743
how lopsided this
VFA agreement is.
253
00:32:07,869 --> 00:32:09,203
Jennifer is dead.
254
00:32:09,704 --> 00:32:12,204
Nothing can beat that,
nothing can change that.
255
00:32:12,206 --> 00:32:13,747
Jennifer is dead.
256
00:32:13,749 --> 00:32:15,457
Who killed Jennifer?
257
00:32:15,459 --> 00:32:18,795
A lot of evidence
points to Pemberton.
258
00:32:30,099 --> 00:32:36,438
♪ Skyfall ♪
259
00:32:40,776 --> 00:32:44,237
Woo, good job!
260
00:32:45,238 --> 00:32:46,321
What else do you wanna sing?
261
00:32:46,323 --> 00:32:47,865
You wanna do Lady Gaga?
262
00:32:47,867 --> 00:32:48,868
Sure.
263
00:32:49,576 --> 00:32:51,077
"Poker Face",
"Born This Way".
264
00:32:51,079 --> 00:32:52,911
Yeah, I like "Poker Face".
265
00:32:52,913 --> 00:32:55,248
When did you arrive?
266
00:32:55,958 --> 00:32:57,457
I can't even remember anymore.
267
00:32:57,459 --> 00:33:00,794
Oh, I didn't tell the
Laudes that you interview...
268
00:33:00,796 --> 00:33:03,004
Just actually not
thinking not in terms.
269
00:33:03,006 --> 00:33:07,426
You were just like catch up
with Jamille, Charis and Barbie.
270
00:33:07,428 --> 00:33:09,261
What's she doing now?
271
00:33:09,263 --> 00:33:11,805
- What is she doing?
- She's still in Olongapo.
272
00:33:11,807 --> 00:33:13,933
She doing the same thing.
273
00:33:13,935 --> 00:33:15,850
They call it freelancing.
274
00:33:15,852 --> 00:33:17,811
I think they're still
in a lot of ways
275
00:33:17,813 --> 00:33:19,522
processing what happened.
276
00:33:19,524 --> 00:33:22,440
It's the same thing
where they have to deal
277
00:33:22,442 --> 00:33:25,403
with their feelings
and their fears.
278
00:33:25,405 --> 00:33:28,283
I know that you did
attend one of the...
279
00:33:29,199 --> 00:33:32,451
The hearings in Congress
or in the Senate.
280
00:33:32,453 --> 00:33:35,079
There's been a lot
of movement towards
281
00:33:35,081 --> 00:33:37,415
getting an exhumation order.
282
00:33:37,417 --> 00:33:40,501
They both have this.
283
00:33:40,503 --> 00:33:46,465
Every time the lawyers who's
cosponsoring their bills now,
284
00:33:46,467 --> 00:33:49,303
would mention they're doing
that for Jennifer Laude.
285
00:33:50,971 --> 00:33:52,681
It's really nice.
286
00:33:53,599 --> 00:33:55,974
This issue put the
spotlight on our community.
287
00:33:55,976 --> 00:34:00,146
We actually consider
this a watershed moment
288
00:34:00,148 --> 00:34:03,357
in the history of the
Philippine transgender movement
289
00:34:03,359 --> 00:34:07,903
because for the first time,
people are seeing us.
290
00:34:12,660 --> 00:34:14,285
Transgender people
have always been part
291
00:34:14,287 --> 00:34:16,495
of the history of this country
292
00:34:16,497 --> 00:34:19,914
and that goes back through
Pre-Colonial times.
293
00:34:19,916 --> 00:34:21,916
We saw that in the
Babaylan Chronicles,
294
00:34:21,918 --> 00:34:25,838
which are documents
written by Spanish priests.
295
00:34:25,840 --> 00:34:28,841
They took note of
male-bodied people
296
00:34:28,843 --> 00:34:31,928
who carried themselves
as women.
297
00:34:33,055 --> 00:34:36,349
The work as spiritual
leaders of their communities
298
00:34:36,351 --> 00:34:39,019
were known as the Babaylan.
299
00:34:40,146 --> 00:34:41,646
There's always a sermon.
300
00:34:41,648 --> 00:34:44,439
The establishment of religion
301
00:34:44,441 --> 00:34:48,903
were so that my kind of people
302
00:34:48,905 --> 00:34:53,075
were slowly pushed into
the margins of society.
303
00:34:54,077 --> 00:34:58,370
How the church vanquished
the Babaylan or the Shaman,
304
00:34:58,372 --> 00:35:01,247
it had to make the
Babaylan somewhat scary
305
00:35:01,249 --> 00:35:04,419
so called her a
witch and a swine.
306
00:35:07,673 --> 00:35:09,631
We were othered by the church.
307
00:35:09,633 --> 00:35:11,425
Our bodies are not acceptable.
308
00:35:11,427 --> 00:35:14,555
Our identities are
not acceptable.
309
00:35:15,555 --> 00:35:19,934
We've been forced to be
part of niche industries
310
00:35:19,936 --> 00:35:22,979
like the beauty industry
or the sex industry.
311
00:35:22,981 --> 00:35:26,691
The transgender movement
itself has to work.
312
00:35:26,693 --> 00:35:28,943
They eradicate the
notion that you need
313
00:35:28,945 --> 00:35:31,738
to sell your body
in order to survive.
314
00:35:33,407 --> 00:35:35,283
In the meantime, a lot
of my trans friends
315
00:35:35,285 --> 00:35:36,908
are actually doing sex work.
316
00:35:36,910 --> 00:35:39,370
They're saying that
it's survival sex work
317
00:35:39,372 --> 00:35:41,457
and I completely
understand that.
318
00:35:54,887 --> 00:35:56,428
Your first time in a
foreign country
319
00:35:56,430 --> 00:35:58,763
can be quite an ordeal
if you let it.
320
00:35:58,765 --> 00:36:01,350
Here in the Philippines,
you'll find a lifestyle
321
00:36:01,352 --> 00:36:03,852
that's different
from life in America.
322
00:36:03,854 --> 00:36:06,146
With a little knowledge of
what this assignment is like
323
00:36:06,148 --> 00:36:07,439
before you get there though,
324
00:36:07,441 --> 00:36:10,358
it can be a richly-rewarding
experience.
325
00:36:18,952 --> 00:36:20,620
We know for a
fact that whenever
326
00:36:20,622 --> 00:36:23,247
there's increased military
presence in a certain country,
327
00:36:23,249 --> 00:36:28,461
it always encourages the selling
of bodies for sexual services.
328
00:36:28,463 --> 00:36:30,629
It encourages the
exploitation of women,
329
00:36:30,631 --> 00:36:33,256
girls, female identified.
330
00:36:33,258 --> 00:36:35,469
So that includes
transgender women.
331
00:36:38,639 --> 00:36:42,932
If you're a trans woman,
all the doors close to you.
332
00:36:42,934 --> 00:36:44,059
I mean...
333
00:36:44,061 --> 00:36:46,437
You're not welcome to
certain establishments.
334
00:36:46,439 --> 00:36:48,689
You're discriminated in school.
335
00:36:48,691 --> 00:36:50,816
You're discriminated at work.
336
00:36:50,818 --> 00:36:53,151
You're discriminated in public
337
00:36:53,153 --> 00:36:54,988
and even in your private life.
338
00:36:57,115 --> 00:36:59,658
Whether or not Jennifer Laude
was a sex worker
339
00:36:59,660 --> 00:37:03,037
is something that only
Jennifer Laude can answer.
340
00:37:12,131 --> 00:37:13,713
The
U.S. serviceman accused
341
00:37:13,715 --> 00:37:16,175
of killing transgender woman,
Jennifer Laude,
342
00:37:16,177 --> 00:37:19,387
faces prosecutors as
his trial begins today.
343
00:37:19,389 --> 00:37:21,555
Pemberton's lawyers
didn't confirm
344
00:37:21,557 --> 00:37:24,015
whether their client will
take the witness stand
345
00:37:24,017 --> 00:37:27,938
or if a plea bargain
agreement is being considered.
346
00:43:20,457 --> 00:43:23,124
There are many
differences in our lives,
347
00:43:23,126 --> 00:43:25,461
but the one thing
we do have in common
348
00:43:25,463 --> 00:43:27,881
is that trans experience.
349
00:43:28,800 --> 00:43:30,466
If the circumstances
were different,
350
00:43:30,468 --> 00:43:33,010
our lives could've
totally been reversed
351
00:43:33,012 --> 00:43:35,472
and I could be in her situation.
352
00:43:43,398 --> 00:43:46,106
She had this sort of like habit
of putting her arm around me
353
00:43:46,108 --> 00:43:48,360
and we were to talk
confidentially together.
354
00:43:53,365 --> 00:43:57,075
In a way, I am kind
of a manifestation of
355
00:43:57,077 --> 00:43:59,370
what she hoped for Jennifer.
356
00:43:59,372 --> 00:44:01,914
That I'm the person
who is trans,
357
00:44:01,916 --> 00:44:05,084
who has moved to
a foreign country
358
00:44:05,086 --> 00:44:09,173
and has made a good
life for myself.
359
00:44:15,430 --> 00:44:18,097
She would say something like,
"You'd be even more beautiful
360
00:44:18,099 --> 00:44:21,477
if you put on more
makeup like Jennifer."
361
00:44:21,769 --> 00:44:23,896
She also called me Ganda.
362
00:48:32,186 --> 00:48:33,644
A day
before testifying
363
00:48:33,646 --> 00:48:35,729
in the Olongapo Regional
Trial Court,
364
00:48:35,731 --> 00:48:38,024
Lisa Pemberton visited
her youngest son,
365
00:48:38,026 --> 00:48:40,151
Lance Corporal Joseph Pemberton.
366
00:48:40,153 --> 00:48:42,613
Very difficult.
367
00:48:42,863 --> 00:48:46,034
He's always been our angel.
368
00:48:46,450 --> 00:48:50,202
I know Joseph would rather
die for his country
369
00:48:50,204 --> 00:48:52,204
than be in this situation.
370
00:48:52,206 --> 00:48:53,539
Mrs. Pemberton
denies her son
371
00:48:53,541 --> 00:48:55,916
is angry with members
of the gay community.
372
00:48:55,918 --> 00:48:58,628
She explains Joseph has
been exposed to the issue
373
00:48:58,630 --> 00:49:00,254
since he grew up with a sister
374
00:49:00,256 --> 00:49:02,715
who was a member of
the LGBT community.
375
00:49:02,717 --> 00:49:05,925
His own sister is lesbian,
getting married next month.
376
00:49:05,927 --> 00:49:08,262
He was supposed to be the
best man in the wedding.
377
00:49:08,264 --> 00:49:09,638
She says
she can empathize
378
00:49:09,640 --> 00:49:13,017
with the Laude family for
the loss of their loved one.
379
00:49:13,019 --> 00:49:15,852
I feel very sorry
for their loss
380
00:49:15,854 --> 00:49:19,900
and what they've
had to go through.
381
00:50:49,197 --> 00:50:52,115
In this case, there's
a 30-minute gap
382
00:50:52,117 --> 00:50:58,079
wherein the room where Laude
was, was totally unsecured.
383
00:50:58,081 --> 00:51:01,751
We cannot say that
384
00:51:01,753 --> 00:51:05,588
it was Pemberton
who killed Laude.
385
00:51:05,590 --> 00:51:09,758
When he left Laude in the
bathroom, Laude was still alive.
386
00:51:09,760 --> 00:51:13,845
So, now, since Laude's dead,
probably the question is,
387
00:51:13,847 --> 00:51:15,015
"Who killed Laude?"
388
00:51:58,726 --> 00:52:01,059
Obviously there's
somebody on the internet
389
00:52:01,061 --> 00:52:05,398
who's invested in humanizing
him in that specific way
390
00:52:05,400 --> 00:52:08,108
and he's presenting him
as this all-American guy,
391
00:52:08,110 --> 00:52:10,070
which he is, he has that image.
392
00:52:15,242 --> 00:52:17,158
They know he's from New Bedford.
393
00:52:17,160 --> 00:52:19,452
Pemberton's sister is a lesbian,
394
00:52:19,454 --> 00:52:24,126
so he's not antipathetic
towards LGBT people.
395
00:52:28,006 --> 00:52:31,090
Rather than this Marine
396
00:52:31,092 --> 00:52:36,720
who is raised in a
culture of LGBT phobia,
397
00:52:36,722 --> 00:52:41,768
it makes him more
complex than that.
398
00:52:42,894 --> 00:52:46,731
There's also a lot
invested in making
399
00:52:46,733 --> 00:52:49,943
Joseph Scott Pemberton
into this monster.
400
00:52:50,778 --> 00:52:54,280
Even if somebody is
out really thinking
401
00:52:54,282 --> 00:52:57,283
that they don't have these
views against trans people,
402
00:52:57,285 --> 00:52:58,950
especially trans women.
403
00:52:58,952 --> 00:53:00,995
There's all of this
sort of like surrounding
404
00:53:00,997 --> 00:53:05,041
environmental and societal
messages they're receiving
405
00:53:05,043 --> 00:53:08,963
that would lead them to
these types of actions.
406
00:53:16,970 --> 00:53:18,803
Still in the Philippines,
the camp of the slain
407
00:53:18,805 --> 00:53:20,805
transgender Filipina,
Jennifer Laude,
408
00:53:20,807 --> 00:53:23,892
denied reports that they
are pushing for a deal
409
00:53:23,894 --> 00:53:28,356
for 38 million pesos
and six U.S. Visas
410
00:53:28,358 --> 00:53:30,106
in exchange for dropping
the murder case
411
00:53:30,108 --> 00:53:33,234
against U.S. Marine,
Joseph Scott Pemberton.
412
00:53:33,236 --> 00:53:35,988
The denial followed reports
that Pemberton's lawyer,
413
00:53:35,990 --> 00:53:39,367
Rowena Flores, received new
demands from the Laudes family
414
00:53:39,369 --> 00:53:41,079
in exchange for
dropping the case.
415
00:54:45,684 --> 00:54:48,227
- Hey.
- I don't really care
416
00:54:48,229 --> 00:54:52,731
that much what happens to
Pemberton because, you know,
417
00:54:52,733 --> 00:54:55,151
I accept that what will
happen to Pemberton is a
418
00:54:55,153 --> 00:54:56,401
political decision.
419
00:54:56,403 --> 00:54:58,613
But what I can't accept is
420
00:54:58,615 --> 00:55:01,823
that the further
humiliation of the family,
421
00:55:01,825 --> 00:55:05,785
the further disrespect, the
further dishonoring on Jennifer
422
00:55:05,787 --> 00:55:08,289
because she was not political.
423
00:55:08,291 --> 00:55:11,709
Pemberton probably is political,
but Jennifer never was.
424
00:55:11,711 --> 00:55:13,126
It was never her intention
425
00:55:13,128 --> 00:55:18,592
to be part of any
political crap like this.
426
00:55:20,177 --> 00:55:21,843
For the first
time since being accused
427
00:55:21,845 --> 00:55:23,720
in the killing of
Filipino transgender
428
00:55:23,722 --> 00:55:26,765
Jennifer Laude,
October 11, 2014,
429
00:55:26,767 --> 00:55:29,100
U.S. Marine Lance Corporal
Joseph Pemberton
430
00:55:29,102 --> 00:55:31,437
testified in court
as a defense witness
431
00:55:31,439 --> 00:55:33,606
in his own murder trial.
432
00:55:33,608 --> 00:55:35,274
Thinking they were real women,
433
00:55:35,276 --> 00:55:37,651
he said he accepted their
offer of checking in
434
00:55:37,653 --> 00:55:40,946
at the Celzone Lodge Motel
to have paid sex.
435
00:55:40,948 --> 00:55:43,448
Barbie performed
oral sex on Pemberton
436
00:55:43,450 --> 00:55:45,242
then immediately left the room.
437
00:55:45,244 --> 00:55:48,454
After a few minutes, Jennifer
did the same to Pemberton.
438
00:55:48,456 --> 00:55:51,624
But when he wanted more,
he was surprised to find out
439
00:55:51,626 --> 00:55:54,167
Jennifer was also
a man like himself.
440
00:55:54,169 --> 00:55:57,379
He said he felt that
he was being raped.
441
00:55:57,381 --> 00:56:00,383
He was so repulsed
and so disgusted
442
00:56:00,385 --> 00:56:02,635
because he did not
give his consent
443
00:56:02,637 --> 00:56:04,887
to allow a man to
do that to him.
444
00:56:04,889 --> 00:56:07,472
Pemberton acted only in defense
445
00:56:07,474 --> 00:56:09,851
of his life and honor.
446
00:57:11,247 --> 00:57:13,830
The verdict is expected
tomorrow, the Laude murder case.
447
00:57:13,832 --> 00:57:16,041
If it is a conviction,
the Olongapo Court
448
00:57:16,043 --> 00:57:18,711
will have to determine where
U.S. Marine serviceman
449
00:57:18,713 --> 00:57:21,046
Joseph Scott Pemberton
will be detained.
450
00:57:21,048 --> 00:57:26,301
We are confident that the
court will acquit our client.
451
00:57:26,303 --> 00:57:29,972
We believe there is
reasonable doubt.
452
00:57:29,974 --> 00:57:32,475
Barbie was not an eyewitness.
453
00:57:32,477 --> 00:57:34,854
She didn't see anybody killed.
454
00:58:31,202 --> 00:58:32,994
Harry will no longer
come here.
455
00:58:32,996 --> 00:58:34,912
He'll go stay with the church.
456
00:59:51,157 --> 00:59:55,325
- Justice for Laude!
- Justice for Laude!
457
00:59:55,327 --> 01:00:00,372
- Justice for Laude!
- Justice for Laude!
458
01:00:00,374 --> 01:00:04,878
- Justice for Laude!
- Justice for Laude!
459
01:00:16,974 --> 01:00:18,307
We are an independent country.
460
01:00:18,309 --> 01:00:21,312
Therefore, he should be
detained in a Philippine jail.
461
01:03:11,189 --> 01:03:12,981
Oh my goodness.
462
01:03:12,983 --> 01:03:15,401
This is not the voice
of complete justice,
463
01:03:15,403 --> 01:03:19,323
but we had to recognize
that there is victory here.
464
01:03:25,454 --> 01:03:27,581
He's considered a
national prisoner.
465
01:04:26,014 --> 01:04:27,974
Pemberton
was surrounded
466
01:04:27,976 --> 01:04:30,309
by two layers of security.
467
01:04:30,311 --> 01:04:33,979
In the inner circle
are US servicemen,
468
01:04:33,981 --> 01:04:37,651
while in the outer circle
are Philippine authorities.
469
01:04:53,751 --> 01:04:55,334
Just want to
get permission from a source
470
01:04:55,336 --> 01:04:58,504
present in the courtroom
that the court has called
471
01:04:58,506 --> 01:05:01,423
for a session to hear the
motion of the defense
472
01:05:01,425 --> 01:05:05,512
to satisfy the order
of the court.
473
01:07:07,635 --> 01:07:11,387
Did the verdict surprise
you at all in any way?
474
01:07:11,389 --> 01:07:13,597
You know, it not surprises me.
475
01:07:13,599 --> 01:07:15,557
For me, it was very clear
form the beginning that
476
01:07:15,559 --> 01:07:21,229
Pemberton would not serve
any day in Philippine trial
477
01:07:21,231 --> 01:07:22,898
whatever counts.
478
01:07:22,900 --> 01:07:28,361
What is the reason to give
him a special treatment?
479
01:07:28,363 --> 01:07:31,073
No one else in the
world would get...
480
01:07:31,075 --> 01:07:35,410
Obviously the reason is that
they know whatever they do
481
01:07:35,412 --> 01:07:38,664
is setting a precedent and
they don't want to be put
482
01:07:38,666 --> 01:07:41,834
in a position where American
military service members
483
01:07:41,836 --> 01:07:44,378
are in danger when
they're overseas.
484
01:07:44,380 --> 01:07:48,173
And so, they're not going
to be able to guarantee
485
01:07:48,175 --> 01:07:50,508
his safety in Philippine prison.
486
01:07:50,510 --> 01:07:53,845
If you go to jail in America
487
01:07:53,847 --> 01:07:56,807
regardless of your
nationality or whatever,
488
01:07:56,809 --> 01:07:59,894
you go to a regular jail, you
don't get a special treatment.
489
01:07:59,896 --> 01:08:02,812
You have to pay the
consequence on what you did.
490
01:08:02,814 --> 01:08:08,028
Referring to the location
and the law you are under.
491
01:08:24,879 --> 01:08:26,673
Hello!
492
01:08:47,485 --> 01:08:50,735
Then tomorrow, we'll
be filing a criminal case
493
01:08:50,737 --> 01:08:55,242
in disobedience through
unlawful order of the court.
494
01:08:55,660 --> 01:08:58,454
Then we're planning
to file a petition.
495
01:09:31,528 --> 01:09:37,158
Even assuming there
is superior strength,
496
01:09:37,160 --> 01:09:38,827
abuse should be proved.
497
01:09:55,637 --> 01:09:57,552
'Cause there's no
second degree murder.
498
01:09:57,554 --> 01:09:59,137
- In the Philippines, yeah.
- In the Philippines,
499
01:09:59,139 --> 01:10:00,306
which is really weird to me.
500
01:10:00,308 --> 01:10:01,766
Because I think
usually in the states
501
01:10:01,768 --> 01:10:03,351
for it to be first
degree murder,
502
01:10:03,353 --> 01:10:05,352
it has to be premeditated.
503
01:10:05,354 --> 01:10:06,604
That's true.
504
01:10:06,606 --> 01:10:10,735
So, that's sort of a...
Yeah, and it's weird.
505
01:10:12,862 --> 01:10:15,613
Does manslaughter exist
in the Philippine?
506
01:10:15,615 --> 01:10:17,489
- No, it's doesn't.
- No?
507
01:10:17,491 --> 01:10:20,493
But again, the way the
judge wrote the verdict
508
01:10:20,495 --> 01:10:23,703
was such that she was
giving all these excuses
509
01:10:23,705 --> 01:10:25,748
in the guise of mitigating
circumstances saying,
510
01:10:25,750 --> 01:10:26,873
"Well, he was drunk.
511
01:10:26,875 --> 01:10:28,918
"It was like a crime of passion,
512
01:10:28,920 --> 01:10:32,171
so we can forgive
him for that."
513
01:10:32,173 --> 01:10:33,254
It was crazy.
514
01:10:33,256 --> 01:10:35,091
After the verdict was read,
515
01:10:35,093 --> 01:10:38,552
then the Americans refused to
give him up to the local police.
516
01:10:38,554 --> 01:10:41,012
It kinda shows that
the Americans aren't
517
01:10:41,014 --> 01:10:42,431
running everything.
518
01:10:42,433 --> 01:10:44,182
It's not completely
orchestrated then.
519
01:10:44,184 --> 01:10:45,519
Oh please Meredith, come on.
520
01:10:46,896 --> 01:10:48,436
Of course they were
running the show.
521
01:10:48,438 --> 01:10:50,898
- I just mean...
- That was how I felt.
522
01:10:50,900 --> 01:10:54,694
I mean, the DOJ's,
I'm sure it.
523
01:10:54,696 --> 01:10:58,029
All I mean is that
it was a surprise
524
01:10:58,031 --> 01:11:01,492
to the Americans that
the order was for
525
01:11:01,494 --> 01:11:03,202
him to go to Bilibid.
526
01:11:03,204 --> 01:11:06,038
That's like a capitulation
on the part of the judge
527
01:11:06,040 --> 01:11:08,708
because when it was read
and the verdict was read,
528
01:11:08,710 --> 01:11:11,836
we felt like the judge was
keeping both parties happy.
529
01:11:11,838 --> 01:11:13,421
She convicted him
of a crime that was
530
01:11:13,423 --> 01:11:15,463
of a lower degree than murder
531
01:11:15,465 --> 01:11:18,967
when it was so clear as daylight
that it was freakin' murder.
532
01:11:18,969 --> 01:11:21,386
The fact that they
weren't prepared
533
01:11:21,388 --> 01:11:25,266
for the custody thing to happen
534
01:11:25,268 --> 01:11:29,270
was really fascinating to me
from a journalistic perspective.
535
01:11:29,272 --> 01:11:31,939
I would ask you to do some
research of that notion
536
01:11:31,941 --> 01:11:36,276
because America as a superpower
is in control of this.
537
01:11:36,278 --> 01:11:38,361
I'm so happy that I'm having
this conversation with you
538
01:11:38,363 --> 01:11:40,405
because now as an
American person
539
01:11:40,407 --> 01:11:43,074
who has Filipino lineage,
540
01:11:43,076 --> 01:11:44,577
you have your foot
on the Philippines
541
01:11:44,579 --> 01:11:46,537
and your foot in America.
542
01:11:46,539 --> 01:11:48,748
You are now in a position
to tell this story
543
01:11:48,750 --> 01:11:52,376
and to be honest about
any court power relations
544
01:11:52,378 --> 01:11:54,169
between our countries.
545
01:11:54,171 --> 01:11:57,465
That's really the culprit,
it all goes back to that.
546
01:11:57,467 --> 01:12:00,342
Jennifer's death is a result
547
01:12:00,344 --> 01:12:03,303
of continued American
imperialism in the Philippines.
548
01:12:03,305 --> 01:12:05,933
There is no denying that.
549
01:12:06,267 --> 01:12:07,557
Yeah.
550
01:12:07,559 --> 01:12:09,017
At 5:30 tonight, a New Bedford
Marine in jail
551
01:12:09,019 --> 01:12:11,102
for killing a
transgender Filipino
552
01:12:11,104 --> 01:12:13,814
is asking a judge to
overturn his conviction.
553
01:12:13,816 --> 01:12:15,941
The court will start to hear
of Pemberton's appeal
554
01:12:15,943 --> 01:12:17,320
on Thursday.
555
01:12:21,741 --> 01:12:23,740
The aftermath of a
U.S. Marine's conviction
556
01:12:23,742 --> 01:12:26,662
in the death of a
Philippine trans woman.
557
01:12:29,040 --> 01:12:30,789
It's close to midnight
in early December
558
01:12:30,791 --> 01:12:33,919
on Waterfront Road in
Olongapo, Philippines.
559
01:12:34,795 --> 01:12:37,171
Dimly lit by yellow
tungsten lamps,
560
01:12:37,173 --> 01:12:40,298
women's figures in tight
clothing walk down the street,
561
01:12:40,300 --> 01:12:42,762
shadows covering their faces.
562
01:12:44,054 --> 01:12:46,931
U.S. service members used to be
able to roam around the area
563
01:12:46,933 --> 01:12:49,725
outside the former base
during their leisure time.
564
01:12:49,727 --> 01:12:51,810
But since Laude's
death last year,
565
01:12:51,812 --> 01:12:54,105
the U.S. Military has
confined service members
566
01:12:54,107 --> 01:12:55,358
to the feed port.
567
01:12:56,651 --> 01:12:59,485
A young woman with hair
halfway down her back
568
01:12:59,487 --> 01:13:01,611
walks alone in Waterfront.
569
01:13:01,613 --> 01:13:03,114
Her figure is slim and taller
570
01:13:03,116 --> 01:13:05,660
than most of the girls
on the street.
571
01:13:11,749 --> 01:13:13,666
"I take my customers here,"
as she gestures
572
01:13:13,668 --> 01:13:16,211
towards the darkness
beyond the road.
573
01:13:17,796 --> 01:13:20,047
Roseanne claims she's 17,
574
01:13:20,049 --> 01:13:22,635
but her voice hasn't
noticeably dropped.
575
01:13:23,177 --> 01:13:24,885
Even though Pemberton
killed Laude
576
01:13:24,887 --> 01:13:27,053
after finding out she was trans,
577
01:13:27,055 --> 01:13:28,847
Roseanne insists that
she needs to keep
578
01:13:28,849 --> 01:13:31,475
her transgender status
from U.S. service members
579
01:13:31,477 --> 01:13:33,354
who pay her for sex.
580
01:13:42,030 --> 01:13:44,029
In the verdict's
aftermath, local officials
581
01:13:44,031 --> 01:13:46,907
and residents are eager for
U.S. troops to come back
582
01:13:46,909 --> 01:13:49,954
and bring money into the
city as they once did.
583
01:14:00,048 --> 01:14:01,713
Locals have even
accused the Laudes of being
584
01:14:01,715 --> 01:14:04,717
selfish by not settling
the case early.
585
01:14:04,719 --> 01:14:06,302
By having gone to trial,
586
01:14:06,304 --> 01:14:09,387
the liberty privileges for
U.S. troops remain suspended,
587
01:14:09,389 --> 01:14:11,891
which in turn has
directly led to hundreds,
588
01:14:11,893 --> 01:14:15,560
if not thousands of locals
losing their sources of income.
589
01:14:15,562 --> 01:14:22,109
Just imagine some businessman
lose about 20 million pesos
590
01:14:22,111 --> 01:14:26,404
in business opportunities
because Americans are not having
591
01:14:26,406 --> 01:14:30,327
their liberty or their rest
and recreational activities.
592
01:14:30,620 --> 01:14:32,078
"We expect liberty will resume
593
01:14:32,080 --> 01:14:35,416
now that Pemberton has been
convicted," Cortez says.
594
01:14:36,166 --> 01:14:38,249
Jennifer's mother,
Julita Laudes,
595
01:14:38,251 --> 01:14:41,252
sits on her brown-floral
print couch.
596
01:14:41,254 --> 01:14:44,424
Despite the conviction,
she is far from satisfied.
597
01:14:49,429 --> 01:14:51,763
Other locals express
a mixture of sympathy
598
01:14:51,765 --> 01:14:53,599
and rejection when it
comes to the presence
599
01:14:53,601 --> 01:14:56,310
of transgender sex workers
in Olongapo.
600
01:14:56,312 --> 01:14:58,520
A souvenir vendor on
Waterfront Road
601
01:14:58,522 --> 01:15:01,190
says that he is indifferent
to the Pemberton verdict
602
01:15:01,192 --> 01:15:03,859
and wishes only that full
liberty would resume,
603
01:15:03,861 --> 01:15:07,073
so that ordinary people in
Olongapo can have income.
604
01:15:27,509 --> 01:15:29,302
Down the street,
a female bystander
605
01:15:29,304 --> 01:15:31,971
sitting on a nearby
park bench shouts back,
606
01:15:31,973 --> 01:15:34,806
"Transgenders need to be
kicked out of Olongapo."
607
01:15:34,808 --> 01:15:36,891
Another taxi driver replies,
608
01:15:36,893 --> 01:15:38,644
"Their words hurt too much.
609
01:15:38,646 --> 01:15:41,148
Those are our fellow Filipinos."
610
01:15:44,986 --> 01:15:46,985
Roseanne is worried about
people identifying her
611
01:15:46,987 --> 01:15:49,531
and finding out
she's a sex worker.
612
01:15:50,073 --> 01:15:52,992
Her mother is not aware
she is doing sex work.
613
01:15:52,994 --> 01:15:54,409
According to the young woman,
614
01:15:54,411 --> 01:15:56,745
she thinks I'm just looking
for a handsome boyfriend
615
01:15:56,747 --> 01:15:58,957
who'll take me to America.
616
01:16:01,001 --> 01:16:02,959
As Roseanne continues
to roam the streets
617
01:16:02,961 --> 01:16:05,171
of Olongapo at night,
she has to believe
618
01:16:05,173 --> 01:16:08,173
that she will encounter
men like Jennifer's fiancé
619
01:16:08,175 --> 01:16:11,845
and not a man like the kind
who ended Jennifer's life.
620
01:16:16,433 --> 01:16:20,685
I think all the Filipinos
wanted to have that big change.
621
01:16:20,687 --> 01:16:24,190
I think he's the
number one candidate
622
01:16:24,192 --> 01:16:25,858
who's running for presidency.
623
01:16:25,860 --> 01:16:28,735
I know he can
do what he promise
624
01:16:28,737 --> 01:16:32,364
that substantial changes will
happen the next six months.
625
01:16:32,366 --> 01:16:34,699
The headline
confirms it:
626
01:16:34,701 --> 01:16:36,159
Rodrigo Duterte will be
627
01:16:36,161 --> 01:16:38,663
the new president
of the Philippines.
628
01:16:38,665 --> 01:16:40,413
He captured
domestic and international
629
01:16:40,415 --> 01:16:42,958
attention with speeches
peppered with obscene jokes
630
01:16:42,960 --> 01:16:44,459
about sex and rape
631
01:16:44,461 --> 01:16:47,003
and for undiplomatic remarks
about some key players
632
01:16:47,005 --> 01:16:49,590
in the country's politics
including Australia,
633
01:16:49,592 --> 01:16:51,552
the United States and China.
634
01:17:05,983 --> 01:17:11,404
America, prepare to
leave the Philippines.
635
01:17:11,406 --> 01:17:14,073
Prepare for the
event to a repeal
636
01:17:14,075 --> 01:17:18,454
for the abrogation of the
visiting of this country.
637
01:18:38,910 --> 01:18:41,534
On this day two years ago,
transgender woman Jennifer Laude
638
01:18:41,536 --> 01:18:44,622
was found dead in a motel
room in Subic, Zambales.
639
01:18:44,624 --> 01:18:47,749
Now U.S. Marine Lance Corporal
Joseph Scott Pemberton
640
01:18:47,751 --> 01:18:49,168
was found guilty
of killing Laude
641
01:18:49,170 --> 01:18:52,587
is detained in a
facility in Quezon City.
642
01:18:52,589 --> 01:18:55,173
Behind this
fence is a detention facility
643
01:18:55,175 --> 01:18:58,052
for Lance Corporal
Joseph Scott Pemberton.
644
01:18:58,054 --> 01:19:00,846
No movement can be
detected in the facility.
645
01:19:00,848 --> 01:19:02,722
Space between the
two cargo containers
646
01:19:02,724 --> 01:19:06,894
converted into rooms is
covered with tarpaulin.
647
01:19:06,896 --> 01:19:08,604
Guards from the
Bureau of Corrections
648
01:19:08,606 --> 01:19:11,649
manning the facility
are nowhere in sight.
649
01:19:11,651 --> 01:19:14,735
The Court of Appeal still has
to rule on Pemberton's appeal.
650
01:19:14,737 --> 01:19:18,780
The Laude family continues
to seek justice for Jennifer.
651
01:19:18,782 --> 01:19:22,368
The family would like to
put an end to this case also.
652
01:19:22,370 --> 01:19:25,162
Because for as long
as there is an appeal,
653
01:19:25,164 --> 01:19:31,170
the appeal prolongs their agony.
654
01:21:43,010 --> 01:21:44,260
The U.S. Government's position
655
01:21:44,262 --> 01:21:47,178
is they will pay if there's
finality to the case.
656
01:21:47,180 --> 01:21:49,515
Finality meant Pemberton
should be allowed
657
01:21:49,517 --> 01:21:52,142
to go back to the United States.
658
01:21:52,144 --> 01:21:53,769
This was a very clear instance
659
01:21:53,771 --> 01:21:56,730
where the U.S. Government
took advantage of poverty
660
01:21:56,732 --> 01:22:00,568
in attempting to release
661
01:22:00,570 --> 01:22:03,361
one of their Marines
from incarceration
662
01:22:03,363 --> 01:22:05,700
arising from a
criminal conviction.
663
01:22:45,572 --> 01:22:47,949
President Duterte is
the very first president
664
01:22:47,951 --> 01:22:50,909
that allocated for an
independent foreign policy.
665
01:22:50,911 --> 01:22:54,622
I stand solidly behind
him that the presence
666
01:22:54,624 --> 01:22:57,458
of US troops in the Philippines
667
01:22:57,460 --> 01:23:00,168
is a blatant violation
of our sovereignty.
668
01:23:00,170 --> 01:23:02,837
It's a hold-over from
the Colonial Times
669
01:23:02,839 --> 01:23:04,507
and should finally end.
670
01:23:04,509 --> 01:23:09,302
I am a president
of a sovereign state
671
01:23:09,304 --> 01:23:12,767
and we have long-ceased
to be a colony.
672
01:23:20,441 --> 01:23:22,443
New England trip:
673
01:23:23,820 --> 01:23:27,240
hot summer day,
no one on the road.
674
01:23:28,616 --> 01:23:32,537
Greek restaurant, regulars.
675
01:23:33,745 --> 01:23:36,790
Are these people aware of who
Joseph Scott Pemberton is?
676
01:23:39,960 --> 01:23:44,506
Plan for today: go to
Robin Street, home address.
677
01:23:47,427 --> 01:23:49,429
It's at a curve in the road.
678
01:23:55,601 --> 01:23:59,731
Simple-wooden fence,
very modest house.
679
01:24:01,398 --> 01:24:03,026
Working-class family.
680
01:24:07,487 --> 01:24:11,325
Greater New Bedford
Technical Vocational School,
681
01:24:12,492 --> 01:24:15,330
far from the famous
schools of Boston.
682
01:24:17,165 --> 01:24:20,043
Boston: Harvard or MIT?
683
01:24:22,629 --> 01:24:24,252
I wonder what this high school
684
01:24:24,254 --> 01:24:27,717
taught Pemberton
about LGBT people.
685
01:24:29,509 --> 01:24:33,680
Cement grounds,
uniform green grass.
686
01:24:35,933 --> 01:24:38,686
Had Pemberton ever had
a girlfriend before?
687
01:24:42,939 --> 01:24:46,652
Fresh, unlike the
salty air of Olongapo.
688
01:24:48,821 --> 01:24:51,780
Joseph Scott Pemberton
grew up close to the water
689
01:24:51,782 --> 01:24:55,035
and dreamed of being
some place open.
690
01:24:56,204 --> 01:24:59,331
Isn't that why so many
young men join the military?
691
01:25:03,378 --> 01:25:05,377
Nancy, he did it.
692
01:25:05,379 --> 01:25:07,422
He's guilty, that's it.
693
01:25:11,052 --> 01:25:12,762
Let's think about forgiveness.
694
01:25:13,388 --> 01:25:15,346
If he spends 30 years in jail,
695
01:25:15,348 --> 01:25:18,101
he won't have any life
left when he comes back.
696
01:25:23,481 --> 01:25:25,358
Do you happen to
live in New Bedford?
697
01:25:27,735 --> 01:25:30,319
I'm doing a story about
Joseph Scott Pemberton.
698
01:25:30,321 --> 01:25:32,407
I just wonder if you've
heard of the case.
699
01:25:46,295 --> 01:25:49,254
I can see oil trails
that remind me
700
01:25:49,256 --> 01:25:52,007
of oil slicks in Olongapo.
701
01:26:50,192 --> 01:26:52,944
The president is winding
up his trip to Asia
702
01:26:52,946 --> 01:26:54,819
and the Philippines,
his last stop,
703
01:26:54,821 --> 01:26:56,529
before returning home tomorrow.
704
01:26:56,531 --> 01:26:58,324
He appeared to give
the country's leader
705
01:26:58,326 --> 01:27:00,659
a pass on human rights.
706
01:27:00,661 --> 01:27:01,993
President Trump grimaced through
707
01:27:01,995 --> 01:27:04,329
the traditional Asia
summit handshake,
708
01:27:04,331 --> 01:27:06,039
but did not shy
away from praising
709
01:27:06,041 --> 01:27:09,668
controversial Philippine
President Rodrigo Duterte.
710
01:27:09,670 --> 01:27:11,962
Duterte's accused of
ordering death squads
711
01:27:11,964 --> 01:27:14,715
style killings of thousands
of Filipino drug dealers
712
01:27:14,717 --> 01:27:17,133
and users without trial.
713
01:27:17,135 --> 01:27:19,845
His troops have
killed more than 7,000 people
714
01:27:19,847 --> 01:27:21,721
since Duterte came into power.
715
01:27:21,723 --> 01:27:25,352
But he's a potential ally in
the region on North Korea.
716
01:27:26,187 --> 01:27:28,186
The president's visit
sparking protests.
717
01:27:28,188 --> 01:27:31,481
Riot police using water
cannons to disperse the crowds.
718
01:27:31,483 --> 01:27:33,359
Mr. Trump winding
down his Asian tour
719
01:27:33,361 --> 01:27:35,069
with a toast and a tribute.
720
01:27:38,198 --> 01:27:40,699
Duterte serenading the
US Commander-in-Chief
721
01:27:40,701 --> 01:27:43,535
with the lyrics, "You are
the light in my world."
722
01:27:43,537 --> 01:27:47,289
No VFA,
no fascist U.S.A.
723
01:27:47,291 --> 01:27:51,543
No Trump, no VFA,
no fascist U.S.A.
724
01:27:51,545 --> 01:27:55,799
No Trump, no VFA,
no fascist U.S.A.
725
01:29:08,872 --> 01:29:11,289
I was just
thinking about
726
01:29:11,291 --> 01:29:14,209
how important this spot has been
727
01:29:14,211 --> 01:29:17,212
and how it was the
focus in so much media
728
01:29:17,214 --> 01:29:19,967
and, you know, sort
of, Jennifer's death.
729
01:29:21,844 --> 01:29:26,305
There's this weird surreal
way we just imagined
730
01:29:26,307 --> 01:29:28,807
these past two years.
731
01:29:28,809 --> 01:29:31,312
What does it actually mean?
732
01:29:49,330 --> 01:29:51,872
I always get
affected when I hear
733
01:29:51,874 --> 01:29:54,711
of a trans person
being murdered.
734
01:29:56,004 --> 01:29:59,841
A year ago, I also lost
a friend to violence.
735
01:30:01,759 --> 01:30:03,761
She just become another
statistic.
736
01:30:05,595 --> 01:30:08,140
She had more than
20 stab wounds.
737
01:30:09,392 --> 01:30:11,184
She was unrecognizable.
738
01:30:13,562 --> 01:30:18,190
There is the lack of justice
in many trans people's lives.
739
01:30:18,192 --> 01:30:22,028
If members of our community
are killed every day,
740
01:30:22,030 --> 01:30:24,072
then there is no
justice in the world.
741
01:30:37,003 --> 01:30:40,921
If Pemberton
is acquitted,
742
01:30:40,923 --> 01:30:46,010
oh my goodness, that would
really affect my whole belief
743
01:30:46,012 --> 01:30:50,015
in this judicial,
or legal system.
744
01:30:51,643 --> 01:30:53,767
For me it's really
more than Laude's case,
745
01:30:53,769 --> 01:30:55,685
it's our sovereignty here.
746
01:30:55,687 --> 01:30:57,896
It's our freedom here.
747
01:30:57,898 --> 01:31:02,193
It's our right to
determine our own path
748
01:31:02,195 --> 01:31:05,404
without intervention
of a foreign power.
749
01:31:14,624 --> 01:31:16,873
My community
has been ravaged
750
01:31:16,875 --> 01:31:21,421
by violence consistently
year after year.
751
01:31:23,758 --> 01:31:25,298
Me continuing to do my work,
752
01:31:25,300 --> 01:31:29,928
continuing to strive for
justice and acceptance
753
01:31:29,930 --> 01:31:35,476
is somehow a way
to commemorate her.
754
01:32:23,153 --> 01:32:28,153
Subtitles by explosiveskull
59537
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.