Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:56,007 --> 00:00:59,682
A SOCIAL GENOCIDE
2
00:02:39,967 --> 00:02:41,844
To those who resisted
3
00:02:42,087 --> 00:02:44,555
during all those years
4
00:02:44,767 --> 00:02:47,327
To their dignity and their courage
5
00:02:52,247 --> 00:02:54,124
Argentina, October 2001:
6
00:02:54,447 --> 00:02:58,645
The government of the Alliance
loses the legislative elections.
7
00:02:58,847 --> 00:03:02,920
President De la R�a
refuses to change his policies.
8
00:03:08,367 --> 00:03:10,119
In 2 years of power,
9
00:03:10,327 --> 00:03:14,843
his progressive program was replaced
by the plans of the IMF,
10
00:03:15,047 --> 00:03:18,437
a continuation
of the policies of Carlos Menem.
11
00:03:24,367 --> 00:03:26,562
The recession deepens
12
00:03:32,247 --> 00:03:35,239
Millions are poverty-stricken
and unemployed
13
00:03:36,727 --> 00:03:39,924
Massive flight of capital
14
00:03:45,927 --> 00:03:48,680
Bank-accounts are blocked
15
00:03:51,767 --> 00:03:55,396
The crisis worsens
16
00:03:57,767 --> 00:04:00,486
December 19, 2001
17
00:04:03,007 --> 00:04:04,565
In view of the situation,
18
00:04:04,887 --> 00:04:06,605
I have decreed a state of siege
19
00:04:06,767 --> 00:04:08,405
for the entire country,
20
00:04:08,727 --> 00:04:10,718
and informed Congress of it.
21
00:04:11,967 --> 00:04:14,765
Our country is going througha difficult period...
22
00:04:45,247 --> 00:04:47,078
Kick 'em all out!
23
00:04:47,247 --> 00:04:49,363
Every one of them!
24
00:04:53,927 --> 00:04:56,725
The government must resign
25
00:04:56,927 --> 00:04:59,760
Together, we'll never be defeated!
26
00:05:06,927 --> 00:05:08,758
After many years
27
00:05:09,047 --> 00:05:11,641
of apathy in the country,
28
00:05:12,567 --> 00:05:14,239
the insurrection exploded.
29
00:05:16,007 --> 00:05:18,999
This spontaneous revoltof "faceless" people
30
00:05:19,167 --> 00:05:21,761
meant saucepans were being banged
31
00:05:21,967 --> 00:05:23,559
in every neighborhood,
32
00:05:23,887 --> 00:05:26,924
all the wayto the city's vital centers.
33
00:05:28,207 --> 00:05:31,597
People took to the streets,
34
00:05:31,807 --> 00:05:33,445
without getting any orders.
35
00:05:33,607 --> 00:05:36,519
I've been out of work
for six weeks,
36
00:05:36,687 --> 00:05:38,996
and I've slaved away
my whole life.
37
00:05:39,207 --> 00:05:41,084
I don't want a state of siege,
38
00:05:41,247 --> 00:05:45,035
or to be a pawn
of the International Monetary Fund.
39
00:05:45,247 --> 00:05:47,158
It's an outdated economic model.
40
00:05:47,327 --> 00:05:50,603
De la R�a must resign,
and all the swindlers with him.
41
00:06:30,687 --> 00:06:32,518
December 20, 2001
42
00:06:33,607 --> 00:06:35,996
We're dying of hunger!
43
00:06:43,527 --> 00:06:45,757
"In glory we shall die!"
44
00:06:45,927 --> 00:06:48,566
"In glory we shall die!"
45
00:06:56,567 --> 00:07:01,118
"This square belongs to the Mothers,
46
00:07:01,807 --> 00:07:03,525
"not to cowardly others!"
47
00:07:06,647 --> 00:07:08,444
"This square belongs to the Mothers,
48
00:07:08,607 --> 00:07:10,359
"not to cowardly others!"
49
00:07:34,647 --> 00:07:35,841
You bastards!
50
00:07:39,047 --> 00:07:42,005
We're not in a dictatorship anymore!
51
00:07:42,167 --> 00:07:43,964
Bunch of idiots!
52
00:07:44,127 --> 00:07:46,004
Armed baboons!
53
00:07:55,727 --> 00:07:57,797
Who ordered you out?
54
00:07:58,007 --> 00:07:59,645
Can you kill a woman?
55
00:07:59,807 --> 00:08:03,402
Can you kill a whole nation
because you're ordered to?
56
00:08:03,727 --> 00:08:06,400
Repression fails to empty
the Plaza de Mayo
57
00:08:44,167 --> 00:08:47,443
Hundreds of citizens
rally to the movement
58
00:08:47,687 --> 00:08:50,485
"The people won't clear out!"
59
00:08:59,607 --> 00:09:01,882
And the people don't clear out.
60
00:09:02,767 --> 00:09:05,486
They're workers, housewives,
61
00:09:05,927 --> 00:09:08,999
employees, pensioners, students,
62
00:09:09,727 --> 00:09:12,685
the heirs of those who,for decades,
63
00:09:13,127 --> 00:09:16,802
defied the dictatorshipsand the persecutions,
64
00:09:17,207 --> 00:09:19,323
put up withthe policies of austerity,
65
00:09:19,487 --> 00:09:21,000
and were betrayed
66
00:09:21,527 --> 00:09:23,119
by democracy.
67
00:09:26,767 --> 00:09:29,565
What happened in Argentina?
68
00:09:31,127 --> 00:09:34,483
How was it possiblethat in so rich a country
69
00:09:35,087 --> 00:09:37,726
so many people were hungry?
70
00:09:41,727 --> 00:09:46,403
The country had been ransackedby a new form of aggression,
71
00:09:48,087 --> 00:09:51,204
committed in time of peaceand in a democracy.
72
00:09:51,927 --> 00:09:55,078
A daily and silent violence
73
00:09:58,567 --> 00:10:00,797
that causedgreater social disruption,
74
00:10:03,887 --> 00:10:06,242
more emigration and death,
75
00:10:06,807 --> 00:10:09,367
than the terrorismof the dictatorship
76
00:10:09,527 --> 00:10:11,836
and the Falkland Islands war.
77
00:10:22,367 --> 00:10:26,121
THE NEVER-ENDING DEBT
78
00:10:29,447 --> 00:10:32,837
Ever since Independence,almost 200 years ago,
79
00:10:33,207 --> 00:10:36,119
Argentina's foreign debthas been a source
80
00:10:36,287 --> 00:10:39,199
of impoverishment and corruption
81
00:10:39,367 --> 00:10:42,245
and the biggest scandals.
82
00:10:44,967 --> 00:10:49,836
Since the first loannegotiated by Rivadavia in 1824
83
00:10:50,447 --> 00:10:53,120
with the British bankBaring Brothers,
84
00:10:54,287 --> 00:10:58,599
the debt was usedto enrich Argentinean financiers,
85
00:10:59,687 --> 00:11:01,359
to control the finances
86
00:11:01,527 --> 00:11:04,837
and empty the countryof its wealth.
87
00:11:06,487 --> 00:11:11,163
This foreign debt alwayswent hand in hand with big business,
88
00:11:11,327 --> 00:11:15,115
and with the complicityof nearly every government,
89
00:11:15,527 --> 00:11:20,043
from Miter and Quintana,to Menem and De la R�a.
90
00:11:25,247 --> 00:11:29,923
The policy of indebtednessgave rise in Argentina
91
00:11:30,087 --> 00:11:33,875
to generationsof technocrats and bureaucrats,
92
00:11:34,127 --> 00:11:39,155
who favored banksand international corporations
93
00:11:39,327 --> 00:11:41,238
over their own country.
94
00:11:43,847 --> 00:11:47,840
Educated at Harvard, Chicago,Oxford or Buenos Aires,
95
00:11:48,247 --> 00:11:52,035
their portraits hangin the official galleries.
96
00:11:54,247 --> 00:11:58,479
There you can see19th century lobbyists,
97
00:11:58,807 --> 00:12:01,321
like Manual Garc�a and Bel�ustegui,
98
00:12:01,487 --> 00:12:05,162
or the latest headsof the public banking system,
99
00:12:05,407 --> 00:12:08,479
Pedro Pou,Macarrone and Colombo,
100
00:12:10,447 --> 00:12:12,881
administrators of a debt
101
00:12:13,207 --> 00:12:16,005
that was born in the 1970s
102
00:12:16,327 --> 00:12:18,443
under the military dictatorship.
103
00:12:22,487 --> 00:12:25,126
We have turned the page
104
00:12:25,487 --> 00:12:29,162
of government interventionism...
105
00:12:30,767 --> 00:12:32,200
The present debt
106
00:12:32,367 --> 00:12:34,198
was the illegitimate offspring
107
00:12:34,447 --> 00:12:36,517
of the military dictatorship.
108
00:12:37,807 --> 00:12:42,119
Even though the Courtsdemonstrated its fraudulent origins,
109
00:12:42,967 --> 00:12:46,596
the pressure of the Establishmentwon the day.
110
00:12:49,327 --> 00:12:50,919
From then on,
111
00:12:51,207 --> 00:12:53,562
it dictated national policies
112
00:12:53,727 --> 00:12:56,366
and depleted the public heritage.
113
00:13:00,967 --> 00:13:02,923
All this is perfectly symbolized
114
00:13:03,247 --> 00:13:07,479
by the statue of George Canning,an advocate of colonial policies,
115
00:13:08,247 --> 00:13:13,002
that was donatedby the British Government in 1857,
116
00:13:13,847 --> 00:13:17,237
in recognition of the debt.
117
00:13:27,727 --> 00:13:30,241
American defeat in Vietnam
118
00:13:32,447 --> 00:13:34,881
Conservatives return to power
119
00:13:36,247 --> 00:13:38,681
Crisis and rising oil prices
120
00:13:40,767 --> 00:13:42,962
Petrodollars flood the world
121
00:13:47,167 --> 00:13:49,761
Banks offer credit at 3%
122
00:13:49,967 --> 00:13:52,925
Birth of the Third-world debt
123
00:14:08,087 --> 00:14:10,043
Interest rates reach 16%
124
00:14:12,447 --> 00:14:14,597
Bankruptcy of indebted countries
125
00:14:20,407 --> 00:14:24,798
An alliance of foreign banksand multinationals
126
00:14:24,967 --> 00:14:27,925
comes to power in Argentina.
127
00:14:28,567 --> 00:14:31,479
After 7 yearsof neo-liberal policies,
128
00:14:31,767 --> 00:14:36,966
the dictatorship leaves a countrybled dry, with a foreign debt
129
00:14:37,167 --> 00:14:40,159
of 45 billion dollars,
130
00:14:40,767 --> 00:14:43,759
of which halfis a private debt.
131
00:14:46,567 --> 00:14:48,922
23 billion
132
00:14:49,087 --> 00:14:53,285
is owed by multinationalsoperating in the country
133
00:14:53,887 --> 00:14:56,242
like Citibank, First Boston,
134
00:14:56,407 --> 00:15:00,798
Chase Manhattan,Bank of America, Banco de Italia,
135
00:15:00,967 --> 00:15:05,085
Banco de Londres, Banco Espa�ol,Banco Franc�s, Deutsche Bank,
136
00:15:05,247 --> 00:15:08,205
Banco R�o and Banco Quilmes,
137
00:15:08,367 --> 00:15:10,358
Banco Galicia and many more.
138
00:15:10,847 --> 00:15:14,601
And by multinationalslike Esso, Fiat, IBM,
139
00:15:14,767 --> 00:15:18,919
Ford, Mercedes Benz, Swift, Pirelli,
140
00:15:19,087 --> 00:15:24,366
as well as local groups owned byP�rez Companc, Bulgheroni-Bridas,
141
00:15:24,527 --> 00:15:27,439
Macri, Techint, Fortabat,
142
00:15:27,607 --> 00:15:31,122
Pescarmona, Gruneisen, Soldati,
143
00:15:31,327 --> 00:15:34,285
Cogasco, Celulosa and others.
144
00:15:35,007 --> 00:15:37,521
An excessive private debt
145
00:15:37,687 --> 00:15:42,078
that a top bureaucrat of thedictatorship saddled the State with:
146
00:15:42,247 --> 00:15:44,078
Domingo Cavallo.
147
00:15:49,167 --> 00:15:54,400
A "super-Minister" of Finance in theMenem and De la R�a governments,
148
00:15:54,727 --> 00:15:59,243
he is responsibleof the unending growth of the debt
149
00:15:59,407 --> 00:16:03,719
and the worst pillage ever sufferedby the Argentinean people.
150
00:16:09,487 --> 00:16:11,443
THIEVES, BANKERS, GOVERNMENTS
151
00:16:11,647 --> 00:16:14,400
GIVE US BACK OUR DOLLARS
152
00:16:17,007 --> 00:16:18,520
What did you say?
153
00:16:19,287 --> 00:16:21,721
The police protects the thieves,
Mr. Solanas.
154
00:16:21,887 --> 00:16:23,684
The world's turned upside-down.
155
00:16:24,287 --> 00:16:28,041
Now people must
demonstrate peacefully
156
00:16:28,207 --> 00:16:31,916
to defend their savings,
that were confiscated by the banks
157
00:16:32,087 --> 00:16:34,317
with government complicity.
158
00:16:34,767 --> 00:16:37,725
The State
should guarantee citizens' rights,
159
00:16:37,887 --> 00:16:39,605
not steal them.
160
00:16:46,607 --> 00:16:48,643
Thieves!
161
00:16:50,687 --> 00:16:53,360
A dollar at a time,
162
00:16:53,527 --> 00:16:57,440
I saved during
the 25 years I worked,
163
00:16:57,607 --> 00:17:01,077
so I could live decently
when I retired,
164
00:17:01,247 --> 00:17:02,839
not on a State pension.
165
00:17:03,127 --> 00:17:05,163
Why don't the banks
treat us
166
00:17:05,327 --> 00:17:07,841
like their foreign customers?
167
00:17:08,167 --> 00:17:11,955
I chose private banks,
I didn't trust ours.
168
00:17:12,127 --> 00:17:14,960
I already got swindled in 1989.
169
00:17:15,127 --> 00:17:17,118
But I must be stupid.
170
00:17:17,527 --> 00:17:21,076
What do they want? A bomb?
That's not my style,
171
00:17:21,327 --> 00:17:23,602
that's why
I'm banging on my pan.
172
00:17:23,767 --> 00:17:25,837
I used to cook with it
for my kids.
173
00:17:26,247 --> 00:17:31,002
Every time I look at it,
I'll be reminded of those scoundrels,
174
00:17:31,167 --> 00:17:32,839
but I'll know I fought
for my rights.
175
00:17:33,367 --> 00:17:36,279
I'm the oldest newsvendor
in Avellaneda.
176
00:17:36,447 --> 00:17:39,007
For 65 years I've sold newspapers.
177
00:17:39,167 --> 00:17:41,727
All my savings
are in Citibank.
178
00:17:41,887 --> 00:17:45,277
The manager of the agency
says they'll return them to me,
179
00:17:45,447 --> 00:17:47,199
it's a lie!
180
00:17:47,727 --> 00:17:51,879
Everything I saved by making
sacrifices is in their hands.
181
00:17:53,647 --> 00:17:55,205
In fact, the foreign banks
182
00:17:55,367 --> 00:17:58,279
owe money to the Argentineans.
183
00:17:58,567 --> 00:18:01,365
In a way,
it's a reversed debt.
184
00:18:01,527 --> 00:18:05,361
The parent companies must be
responsible for the deposits.
185
00:18:05,887 --> 00:18:09,846
That was decided by law
in Argentina in 1971,
186
00:18:10,087 --> 00:18:12,123
in the well-known Swift Deltec case,
187
00:18:12,287 --> 00:18:16,838
which established that
parent companies were responsible
188
00:18:17,367 --> 00:18:19,801
for the debts of their subsidiaries.
189
00:18:19,967 --> 00:18:23,926
It's a swindle
to make the government responsible
190
00:18:24,087 --> 00:18:26,282
for the debts of the banks.
191
00:18:26,647 --> 00:18:28,478
What about our foreign debt?
192
00:18:28,647 --> 00:18:31,445
In many ways,
that debt is illegitimate.
193
00:18:31,607 --> 00:18:33,802
In a fundamental way:
194
00:18:33,967 --> 00:18:37,164
It's illegitimate
to repay the banks
195
00:18:37,327 --> 00:18:39,636
with 18 million people
poverty-stricken
196
00:18:39,807 --> 00:18:41,763
and 9 million paupers.
197
00:18:41,927 --> 00:18:43,804
There's a human priority.
198
00:18:44,687 --> 00:18:48,726
Then the banks
charged usurious interest rates.
199
00:18:48,887 --> 00:18:55,156
If they'd charged
normal interest rates,
200
00:18:55,327 --> 00:18:59,400
the foreign debt
would have been paid off by 1988.
201
00:18:59,647 --> 00:19:01,000
What was this swindle?
202
00:19:01,167 --> 00:19:04,284
The parent companies
made loans to their subsidiaries,
203
00:19:04,447 --> 00:19:06,961
so these were internal movements.
204
00:19:07,287 --> 00:19:10,757
These loans
were assigned to the foreign debt,
205
00:19:10,927 --> 00:19:13,885
when in fact
they were internal to the companies.
206
00:19:14,207 --> 00:19:19,201
Dollars were bought here, and placed
in accounts in the United States.
207
00:19:19,367 --> 00:19:22,803
With this deposit as collateral,
you got a loan
208
00:19:22,967 --> 00:19:25,959
to purchase more dollars
and so on,
209
00:19:26,127 --> 00:19:28,687
because of the difference
in interest rates.
210
00:19:29,007 --> 00:19:32,317
It's what's known
as "bicycling" funds,
211
00:19:32,487 --> 00:19:33,920
and many got rich on it.
212
00:19:34,087 --> 00:19:37,762
The main beneficiaries
were the big conglomerates,
213
00:19:37,927 --> 00:19:39,883
as usual.
214
00:19:41,287 --> 00:19:43,926
At the endof Alfons�n's presidency,
215
00:19:44,087 --> 00:19:48,797
the foreign debtwas close to 54 billion dollars.
216
00:19:49,447 --> 00:19:54,999
Menem let the creditorsdetermine what they were owed.
217
00:19:55,247 --> 00:19:57,556
The Congressnever debated on the debt,
218
00:19:57,727 --> 00:19:59,718
neglecting the Constitution
219
00:19:59,887 --> 00:20:02,606
and a decision by the law courts.
220
00:20:02,767 --> 00:20:04,359
Ten years later,
221
00:20:04,527 --> 00:20:08,042
the debt reached130 billion dollars.
222
00:20:08,447 --> 00:20:12,486
People have a false ideaof the debt.
223
00:20:12,687 --> 00:20:13,915
You get into debt,
224
00:20:14,087 --> 00:20:16,123
then you say it's bad.
225
00:20:16,967 --> 00:20:19,276
But indebtednessis what enables credit.
226
00:20:19,567 --> 00:20:21,762
Indebtedness is beneficial.
227
00:20:21,927 --> 00:20:25,602
We are going to develop creditfor everyone...
228
00:20:25,767 --> 00:20:27,837
Owing money is fine.
229
00:20:29,967 --> 00:20:32,481
A good example
230
00:20:32,807 --> 00:20:37,403
is what the North Americans
invented around 1898,
231
00:20:37,567 --> 00:20:40,001
at the time they occupied Cuba.
232
00:20:40,167 --> 00:20:41,964
Some Spanish banks
233
00:20:42,127 --> 00:20:45,437
had granted loans
to the colonial government of Cuba.
234
00:20:45,607 --> 00:20:47,245
The North Americans said:
235
00:20:47,407 --> 00:20:53,676
If the Cuban people
didn't benefit from these loans,
236
00:20:53,847 --> 00:20:55,519
there's no public debt.
237
00:20:55,727 --> 00:20:57,718
In 1923,
238
00:20:58,527 --> 00:21:01,200
a British bank,
239
00:21:01,367 --> 00:21:03,483
the Royal Bank of Canada,
240
00:21:03,927 --> 00:21:07,681
lent a petty tyrant of Costa Rica,
241
00:21:07,847 --> 00:21:09,485
called Tinoco,
242
00:21:09,647 --> 00:21:13,686
a sum that he used
for personal goals.
243
00:21:13,847 --> 00:21:17,920
The Royal Bank of Canada
asked Costa Rica for repayment.
244
00:21:18,087 --> 00:21:20,203
There was a lawsuit,
245
00:21:20,367 --> 00:21:24,360
of which the arbitrator was
an ex-president of the United States,
246
00:21:24,527 --> 00:21:26,483
President William Taft.
247
00:21:26,647 --> 00:21:29,957
President Taft
ruled in the litigation, saying:
248
00:21:30,167 --> 00:21:32,442
It's about a private debt,
249
00:21:32,607 --> 00:21:34,962
not a public debt.
250
00:21:35,127 --> 00:21:39,120
You can't have
a public debt without a "public",
251
00:21:39,287 --> 00:21:42,916
with the public
as the beneficiary of the debt.
252
00:21:43,607 --> 00:21:47,441
These operations
never benefited the public,
253
00:21:47,607 --> 00:21:49,245
quite the contrary.
254
00:21:49,407 --> 00:21:54,322
It's the person
who shops in a supermarket
255
00:21:54,487 --> 00:21:57,047
and pays VAT
256
00:21:57,207 --> 00:21:59,596
who ends up paying
257
00:21:59,767 --> 00:22:03,965
for the private debts
of big enterprises,
258
00:22:04,127 --> 00:22:05,765
or of very rich people.
259
00:22:06,367 --> 00:22:09,279
The problem of private debts,
260
00:22:10,327 --> 00:22:14,286
that were illicitly nationalized
261
00:22:15,367 --> 00:22:16,800
by Mr. Cavallo,
262
00:22:16,967 --> 00:22:19,765
must absolutely be reexamined.
263
00:22:19,927 --> 00:22:21,201
What is this theory?
264
00:22:21,367 --> 00:22:24,040
It's the theory
of the Odious Debt.
265
00:22:24,567 --> 00:22:28,765
A director of the IMF,
Karen Lissakers,
266
00:22:28,927 --> 00:22:31,487
representing the United States,
said:
267
00:22:31,647 --> 00:22:35,799
"If we applied
the theory of the Odious Debt,
268
00:22:36,047 --> 00:22:39,562
"the Third World's debt
would no longer exist."
269
00:22:42,927 --> 00:22:46,715
A CHRONICLE OF TREASON
270
00:22:50,567 --> 00:22:52,046
Democracy was re-established
271
00:22:52,207 --> 00:22:55,199
with the Radical Ra�l Alfons�n
272
00:22:55,607 --> 00:22:58,485
and his social-democrat approach.
273
00:22:59,607 --> 00:23:01,962
He promisedto defend human rights,
274
00:23:02,127 --> 00:23:04,561
to fight poverty
275
00:23:04,727 --> 00:23:09,926
and to show that in a democracy"you get education, care, and food".
276
00:23:14,087 --> 00:23:17,523
We have the huge responsibility
277
00:23:18,767 --> 00:23:21,201
of guaranteeing democracy
278
00:23:21,367 --> 00:23:25,883
and respect for human dignityin Argentina.
279
00:23:29,007 --> 00:23:30,122
As we've said,
280
00:23:30,407 --> 00:23:32,841
this means that the State
281
00:23:33,047 --> 00:23:36,801
cannot bowto international financial groups,
282
00:23:37,687 --> 00:23:41,919
or to privileged local groups...
283
00:23:42,087 --> 00:23:43,839
But the State was bankrupt,
284
00:23:44,087 --> 00:23:45,839
and had to make a choice.
285
00:23:48,567 --> 00:23:51,365
Economy minister Grinspun,suggested repudiating the debt
286
00:23:51,527 --> 00:23:54,246
and favoring growth.
287
00:23:54,447 --> 00:23:58,645
Alfons�n won't go along,and yields to financial power.
288
00:23:58,927 --> 00:24:02,476
The only solutionis a policy of austerity,
289
00:24:02,687 --> 00:24:04,598
that will be very hard
290
00:24:04,767 --> 00:24:07,361
and require great effortsby everyone.
291
00:24:07,887 --> 00:24:11,436
It's called,my dear compatriots,
292
00:24:11,927 --> 00:24:14,202
an economy of war.
293
00:24:14,367 --> 00:24:17,996
We must all learn from it.
294
00:24:21,607 --> 00:24:25,202
This drastic measureis called "Plan Austral".
295
00:24:25,527 --> 00:24:26,801
Once more,
296
00:24:26,967 --> 00:24:29,162
huge public funds
297
00:24:29,327 --> 00:24:32,285
are transferred to the banksand big corporations.
298
00:24:33,247 --> 00:24:36,125
Alfons�n says two things at once:
299
00:24:36,447 --> 00:24:38,199
He promises to repudiate the debt
300
00:24:38,407 --> 00:24:43,117
but orders the presidentof the Central Bank to legitimize it.
301
00:24:45,927 --> 00:24:48,395
He favors prosecuting Army officers
302
00:24:48,567 --> 00:24:50,797
for their crimesduring the dictatorship,
303
00:24:51,327 --> 00:24:53,283
but two years later,
304
00:24:53,727 --> 00:24:57,242
the "Due Obedience" lawsexonerate crimes committed
305
00:24:57,447 --> 00:24:59,005
on orders of a superior.
306
00:25:01,847 --> 00:25:04,236
Laws that resultedfrom the insurrection
307
00:25:04,407 --> 00:25:07,444
of the rebel"painted face" officers.
308
00:25:08,847 --> 00:25:11,042
People took to the streets
309
00:25:11,207 --> 00:25:13,243
and defied the tanks...
310
00:25:13,807 --> 00:25:16,765
We've had enough of jackboots!
311
00:25:20,127 --> 00:25:23,358
Alfons�n amnesties the rebels.
312
00:25:23,527 --> 00:25:25,438
Dear compatriots,
313
00:25:26,727 --> 00:25:28,718
Happy Easter!
314
00:25:31,327 --> 00:25:34,080
The insurgents...
315
00:25:35,407 --> 00:25:38,285
have put down their weapons.
316
00:25:40,567 --> 00:25:42,364
Among them,
317
00:25:42,967 --> 00:25:46,243
were heroes of the Falklands war,
318
00:25:47,087 --> 00:25:49,555
who had strayed...
319
00:25:53,127 --> 00:25:55,322
The electoral defeatof the Radical party
320
00:25:55,807 --> 00:25:57,843
accelerates the crisis.
321
00:25:58,527 --> 00:26:02,042
Stockmarket instabilityand hyperinflation
322
00:26:02,207 --> 00:26:05,119
lead to runs on the supermarkets.
323
00:26:06,167 --> 00:26:08,237
I've decided to resign
324
00:26:08,727 --> 00:26:11,719
from the jobof President of Argentina...
325
00:26:14,727 --> 00:26:16,558
Alfons�n has to resign
326
00:26:16,727 --> 00:26:20,117
6 months before the endof his mandate.
327
00:26:34,047 --> 00:26:36,242
The neo-Peronist Carlos Menem
328
00:26:36,887 --> 00:26:38,718
becomes President
329
00:26:38,887 --> 00:26:41,401
after having,for many years, governed
330
00:26:41,567 --> 00:26:43,842
the province of La Rioja,
331
00:26:44,047 --> 00:26:46,242
one of the poorest in the nation.
332
00:26:49,447 --> 00:26:51,165
His lightning rise
333
00:26:51,567 --> 00:26:54,604
coincidedwith the fall of the Berlin wall
334
00:26:54,767 --> 00:26:57,520
and the ideasof the "Consensus of Washington".
335
00:27:00,007 --> 00:27:03,283
With his franknessand his preacher's gestures,
336
00:27:03,567 --> 00:27:07,276
he promises a Productivist Revolutionand big wages.
337
00:27:10,727 --> 00:27:15,198
He has long sideburnslike the old rebel Facundo Quiroga,
338
00:27:15,527 --> 00:27:17,836
the "Tiger of the Plains".
339
00:27:23,127 --> 00:27:25,641
For every Argentinean, standing,
340
00:27:26,047 --> 00:27:28,641
for poor children who are hungry,
341
00:27:28,807 --> 00:27:31,480
or who are sad,
342
00:27:31,647 --> 00:27:33,956
for our brothers without work,
343
00:27:34,127 --> 00:27:36,402
for the homes without a roof,
344
00:27:36,647 --> 00:27:38,877
for the tables without bread,
345
00:27:39,047 --> 00:27:40,765
for our homeland,
346
00:27:40,927 --> 00:27:43,805
I ask you to follow me,
347
00:27:44,087 --> 00:27:45,440
follow me,
348
00:27:45,607 --> 00:27:47,677
I won't betray you,
349
00:27:47,847 --> 00:27:49,963
I won't betray you...
350
00:27:52,207 --> 00:27:54,437
As God is my witness,
351
00:27:55,207 --> 00:27:57,357
and facingthe judgment of History,
352
00:27:57,887 --> 00:27:59,957
let me proclaim:
353
00:28:00,367 --> 00:28:04,326
Argentina, get up and walk!
354
00:28:04,767 --> 00:28:06,644
Sisters and brothers,
355
00:28:07,207 --> 00:28:10,517
in a single voiceI say to the world:
356
00:28:11,047 --> 00:28:13,607
"This is the advent
357
00:28:14,167 --> 00:28:16,362
of a new and glorious Nation."
358
00:28:20,927 --> 00:28:25,000
This is the era of the theoryof the "End of History",
359
00:28:26,207 --> 00:28:29,756
of the single-mindednessof globalization
360
00:28:30,127 --> 00:28:34,359
and of neo-liberal democraciesin Latin America.
361
00:28:36,807 --> 00:28:39,082
Long live Carlos Sa�l Menem!
362
00:28:43,007 --> 00:28:44,440
A few days later,
363
00:28:44,607 --> 00:28:48,441
he abandons his sideburnsand his promised reforms,
364
00:28:48,607 --> 00:28:51,075
and betrays his voters:
365
00:28:51,927 --> 00:28:56,557
His program becomes thatof the liberal conservative minority,
366
00:28:57,287 --> 00:29:00,836
directed by the former rebel officerAlvaro Alsogaray.
367
00:29:01,207 --> 00:29:04,483
Everything has changed now,there's a new relationship
368
00:29:05,087 --> 00:29:07,362
between conservativesand Peronists.
369
00:29:07,927 --> 00:29:10,316
We appear to be the same,
370
00:29:10,487 --> 00:29:12,717
but a fundamental change
371
00:29:12,927 --> 00:29:14,918
amongst us has occurred.
372
00:29:15,087 --> 00:29:17,647
Historically, it's only fair,
373
00:29:17,807 --> 00:29:21,083
that a neo-Peronist presidentshould bring this about...
374
00:29:23,847 --> 00:29:25,917
No one before Menem
375
00:29:26,087 --> 00:29:29,238
had dared to carry treason so far,
376
00:29:29,607 --> 00:29:31,996
or undertaken so cynically
377
00:29:32,567 --> 00:29:35,127
actions that harmed the Nation.
378
00:29:36,567 --> 00:29:38,319
The two-faced gameof the new leader
379
00:29:39,247 --> 00:29:43,479
will pulverize 50 yearsof popular resistance:
380
00:29:44,207 --> 00:29:48,246
He imposes allegianceto the global model,
381
00:29:48,407 --> 00:29:50,682
amnesties the leaders of the junta,
382
00:29:50,847 --> 00:29:53,122
and betrays millions of workers
383
00:29:53,487 --> 00:29:55,682
who lived through the repression.
384
00:29:58,007 --> 00:30:00,475
He abandonspopular anti-imperialism
385
00:30:00,647 --> 00:30:04,162
and non-alignmentextolled by Per�n and Evita
386
00:30:04,327 --> 00:30:08,161
and initiates a "physical relationship"with the United States.
387
00:30:09,727 --> 00:30:14,198
His policies will be dictatedby the World Bank and the IMF.
388
00:30:21,447 --> 00:30:24,803
But Menemis not the only one who betrayed.
389
00:30:25,607 --> 00:30:28,360
Many of the politicaland union leaders
390
00:30:29,327 --> 00:30:32,876
dumped overboarda whole life of resistance.
391
00:30:33,207 --> 00:30:35,880
Many of themaccepted arrangements
392
00:30:36,047 --> 00:30:38,038
and opted for indemnifications.
393
00:30:39,887 --> 00:30:41,479
Others climbed
394
00:30:42,007 --> 00:30:46,364
onto the bandwagonof privatizations.
395
00:31:03,127 --> 00:31:04,560
Senator Cafiero,
396
00:31:04,727 --> 00:31:07,878
you are a historic leader
of the Peronist party.
397
00:31:08,047 --> 00:31:10,197
How do you explain
Menem's treason?
398
00:31:10,807 --> 00:31:14,117
It happens frequently
399
00:31:14,287 --> 00:31:18,200
in the political life
of every nation.
400
00:31:18,367 --> 00:31:22,838
There's a small French book,
"In Praise of Treason",
401
00:31:23,087 --> 00:31:25,726
where they prove
402
00:31:26,007 --> 00:31:28,999
that treason
is part and parcel of politics.
403
00:31:29,167 --> 00:31:32,000
To succeed, you have to lie.
404
00:31:32,167 --> 00:31:36,240
If you say what you think,
no one will vote for you.
405
00:31:36,407 --> 00:31:39,046
That's what happened
in Argentina,
406
00:31:39,207 --> 00:31:42,324
but much more intensely,
let's face it,
407
00:31:42,487 --> 00:31:44,318
when Menem was in power.
408
00:31:44,487 --> 00:31:48,719
He even admitted
he hid his goals to get elected.
409
00:31:49,127 --> 00:31:52,085
Of course, in my opinion,
410
00:31:52,727 --> 00:31:55,366
it's politically unethical,
411
00:31:55,527 --> 00:31:57,404
but that's the reality.
412
00:31:57,567 --> 00:32:01,480
Then, some international
parameters changed...
413
00:32:02,967 --> 00:32:05,606
And the model gradually
exhausted itself.
414
00:32:06,407 --> 00:32:08,398
How do you explain
415
00:32:08,767 --> 00:32:11,042
the existence
of a real "mafiocracy"?
416
00:32:12,007 --> 00:32:15,795
Economic power,
banks and the political class...
417
00:32:15,967 --> 00:32:17,685
On that, Pino,
418
00:32:19,927 --> 00:32:22,077
I won't pass judgment...
419
00:32:23,607 --> 00:32:26,917
how can I put it...
in an absolute way.
420
00:32:27,447 --> 00:32:29,961
My long experience
421
00:32:30,127 --> 00:32:32,721
has taught me
that things are relative.
422
00:32:32,887 --> 00:32:34,525
It's not all black or white,
423
00:32:34,687 --> 00:32:36,757
things aren't corrupt or pure.
424
00:32:36,927 --> 00:32:40,078
Argentinean society as a whole
425
00:32:40,247 --> 00:32:42,044
can't call itself pure
426
00:32:42,207 --> 00:32:45,244
and assign corruption
to the ruling classes.
427
00:32:45,407 --> 00:32:49,161
The ruling classes
come from that society.
428
00:32:49,367 --> 00:32:51,927
On one hand,
we politicians have been a failure,
429
00:32:52,087 --> 00:32:54,317
and I'll assume
my part of responsibility.
430
00:32:55,767 --> 00:32:57,598
But on the other hand...
431
00:32:58,327 --> 00:33:01,717
many of the ruling circles
let us down,
432
00:33:01,887 --> 00:33:04,879
and to reach a verdict on everyone,
433
00:33:05,047 --> 00:33:07,686
I'd say we're all in Dante's hell.
434
00:33:09,927 --> 00:33:11,883
Undoubtedly,
435
00:33:12,767 --> 00:33:15,042
treason is very effective.
436
00:33:18,327 --> 00:33:23,242
Treason
has phenomenal political power,
437
00:33:23,687 --> 00:33:26,076
precisely because it's treason.
438
00:33:27,367 --> 00:33:29,403
It's insidious,
439
00:33:29,567 --> 00:33:33,082
it sneaks up behind you,
without warning,
440
00:33:33,247 --> 00:33:35,477
where you least expect it.
441
00:33:35,647 --> 00:33:38,115
Otherwise it wouldn't be treason.
442
00:33:39,327 --> 00:33:42,285
In this sense,
the neo-Peronist party
443
00:33:43,727 --> 00:33:49,165
was the most brilliant
representative
444
00:33:49,327 --> 00:33:51,318
of Cafiero's point of view.
445
00:33:52,167 --> 00:33:56,160
If you ask Argentinean society
to choose
446
00:33:56,327 --> 00:33:59,160
between San Mart�n
- our national hero - and Spiderman,
447
00:33:59,327 --> 00:34:01,318
it'll vote for San Mart�n.
448
00:34:01,487 --> 00:34:04,479
But between
Spiderman and Superman,
449
00:34:04,647 --> 00:34:08,959
how can you fault society
for the consequences of that choice?
450
00:34:09,447 --> 00:34:10,766
So we have...
451
00:34:11,527 --> 00:34:13,722
a society with a weakened role,
452
00:34:14,247 --> 00:34:18,763
a party that betrays its historic ideas
and surrenders to the enemy,
453
00:34:18,927 --> 00:34:23,762
a working-class movement
eroded by de-industrialization,
454
00:34:23,927 --> 00:34:25,758
infested with traitors...
455
00:34:26,367 --> 00:34:31,361
Law courts
that pay lip-service to all that,
456
00:34:31,527 --> 00:34:35,236
Opposition parties
without much room to maneuver...
457
00:34:35,407 --> 00:34:37,045
and the result of it all is...
458
00:34:37,687 --> 00:34:41,805
THE REPUBLIC DETERIORATES
459
00:34:54,047 --> 00:34:56,277
Menem's neo-liberal model
460
00:34:56,727 --> 00:35:01,562
is inseparable from the deteriorationof the republic and corruption.
461
00:35:03,727 --> 00:35:07,959
His political planneeds a biased Supreme Court
462
00:35:08,127 --> 00:35:10,766
and federal law courtsunder his control,
463
00:35:10,927 --> 00:35:15,603
and for special powersto be delegated by Parliament.
464
00:35:18,687 --> 00:35:22,680
In one month,he got his Law of Laws passed,
465
00:35:22,847 --> 00:35:24,724
the Reform of the State,
466
00:35:24,887 --> 00:35:28,118
that opened up for himthe door to privatizations.
467
00:35:28,487 --> 00:35:31,399
Today the Senate is debating
468
00:35:31,847 --> 00:35:34,725
a fundamental law for the country.
469
00:35:35,127 --> 00:35:37,357
For the first time,
470
00:35:37,567 --> 00:35:40,365
we are going to attack head on
471
00:35:40,527 --> 00:35:42,961
the structural weaknesses
472
00:35:43,567 --> 00:35:46,957
of the State as a whole,
473
00:35:48,207 --> 00:35:51,438
notably of its public corporations.
474
00:35:51,607 --> 00:35:53,438
We must be grateful
475
00:35:53,687 --> 00:35:56,042
to the President of the Republic,
476
00:35:56,207 --> 00:35:58,721
because this law is the beginning
477
00:35:58,887 --> 00:36:01,355
of the Productivist Revolution.
478
00:36:06,927 --> 00:36:11,557
Democracy was ridiculed
by Parliament
479
00:36:11,727 --> 00:36:13,683
during the Menem era.
480
00:36:13,887 --> 00:36:17,357
He gave Ministries
extraordinary powers,
481
00:36:17,527 --> 00:36:21,156
absolute powers,
total public power.
482
00:36:21,367 --> 00:36:24,006
He gave Ministries the power
483
00:36:24,167 --> 00:36:26,886
to privatize State enterprises,
484
00:36:27,047 --> 00:36:29,117
without inventories, balance sheets,
485
00:36:29,287 --> 00:36:31,642
without verifying beforehand
486
00:36:31,807 --> 00:36:36,164
if these enterprises
generated profits or losses.
487
00:36:36,327 --> 00:36:39,444
Meaning that this vote
488
00:36:39,607 --> 00:36:43,441
was the starting point
of the plunder of State property.
489
00:36:43,807 --> 00:36:44,762
Who voted for it?
490
00:36:44,927 --> 00:36:47,077
The neo-Peronists,
491
00:36:47,247 --> 00:36:49,283
the Radicals, very obligingly...
492
00:36:49,767 --> 00:36:53,123
I remember very well
the Radical Jaroslavsky
493
00:36:53,287 --> 00:36:55,755
ordering many of his congressmen
494
00:36:55,927 --> 00:36:57,883
to withdraw from the House
495
00:36:58,047 --> 00:37:01,676
so that the neo-Peronists
could pass these laws.
496
00:37:02,167 --> 00:37:04,556
Rarely does everything enable
497
00:37:04,727 --> 00:37:07,321
a minority to come to power
498
00:37:08,767 --> 00:37:11,076
without throwing a bomb,
499
00:37:11,247 --> 00:37:13,317
or firing a shot.
500
00:37:13,847 --> 00:37:17,442
Yet that's
what the conservative Alsogaray got
501
00:37:17,607 --> 00:37:19,598
for the Reform of the State.
502
00:37:19,767 --> 00:37:23,646
This reform gave Menem,
503
00:37:23,807 --> 00:37:25,604
absolute, dictatorial powers,
504
00:37:25,767 --> 00:37:28,725
that even the dictator Videla
never had.
505
00:37:28,887 --> 00:37:32,084
- Alsogaray said it openly.
- What did he say?
506
00:37:32,247 --> 00:37:33,885
He told the neo-Peronists
507
00:37:34,047 --> 00:37:37,278
that they were taking part
in an extraordinary moment,
508
00:37:37,887 --> 00:37:39,764
that they'd have total power.
509
00:37:39,927 --> 00:37:42,999
But now,
this ostensibly democratic power
510
00:37:43,167 --> 00:37:45,158
was going to be held
511
00:37:45,327 --> 00:37:48,797
by those who once censored,
executed and slaughtered.
512
00:37:49,047 --> 00:37:51,641
That's what Alsogaray brought about.
513
00:37:53,287 --> 00:37:56,802
How far would they go?
What were they capable of?
514
00:37:56,967 --> 00:37:58,320
Of a lot more.
515
00:37:58,487 --> 00:38:00,364
And they kept it up.
516
00:38:01,367 --> 00:38:03,517
There were denunciations
517
00:38:03,687 --> 00:38:07,965
over the privatization
of the national oil company YPF.
518
00:38:08,127 --> 00:38:11,358
A congressman denounced
the remittance to senators
519
00:38:11,527 --> 00:38:13,961
of a bribe of 8 million dollars,
520
00:38:14,127 --> 00:38:15,640
then denied it hours later.
521
00:38:17,647 --> 00:38:19,524
Of 130 congressmen present,
522
00:38:19,687 --> 00:38:22,520
114 voted "Yes",
523
00:38:23,167 --> 00:38:25,078
10 voted "No",with 1 abstention.
524
00:38:26,087 --> 00:38:28,681
We should be delighted
525
00:38:28,847 --> 00:38:32,237
that the Housewas able to perform its duties.
526
00:38:32,407 --> 00:38:36,036
For Argentina,this is a day of jubilation.
527
00:38:36,207 --> 00:38:37,242
From now on,
528
00:38:37,447 --> 00:38:39,597
the oil belongs to the provinces,
529
00:38:39,767 --> 00:38:43,442
YPF will be quotedon the stockmarket
530
00:38:43,607 --> 00:38:45,438
and benefitfrom private investment.
531
00:38:45,607 --> 00:38:47,563
Thanks to this, old-age pensioners,
532
00:38:47,727 --> 00:38:51,117
will benefitfrom billions of dollars...
533
00:38:51,407 --> 00:38:53,204
These fine words
534
00:38:53,607 --> 00:38:56,883
hid one of the most odious acts
535
00:38:57,047 --> 00:38:59,481
that Parliament committed.
536
00:38:59,967 --> 00:39:02,879
With the help of bribed congressmen,
537
00:39:03,407 --> 00:39:07,082
it voted the privatizationof YPF and Gas del Estado,
538
00:39:08,567 --> 00:39:11,877
the two biggestArgentinean companies.
539
00:39:13,687 --> 00:39:15,757
The country lost enterprises
540
00:39:15,967 --> 00:39:19,243
that financed its infrastructures,
541
00:39:19,487 --> 00:39:22,240
and of courseold-age pensioners and workers
542
00:39:22,487 --> 00:39:24,557
got swindled.
543
00:39:28,567 --> 00:39:31,365
The opposition couldn't prevent it,
544
00:39:32,127 --> 00:39:35,164
though dissident Peronistsformed
545
00:39:35,367 --> 00:39:36,846
the "Group of Eight".
546
00:39:37,047 --> 00:39:38,480
Reforming the State
547
00:39:38,647 --> 00:39:40,000
doesn't mean privatizing it.
548
00:39:40,167 --> 00:39:42,123
In an emergent country,
549
00:39:42,287 --> 00:39:45,245
you don't begin with layoffs.
550
00:39:45,647 --> 00:39:49,196
Other opponentsof the oil company plunder
551
00:39:49,687 --> 00:39:51,962
were threatened or attacked.
552
00:39:53,527 --> 00:39:54,642
In May 1991,
553
00:39:55,847 --> 00:39:59,726
for having filed chargesagainst Menem
554
00:39:59,887 --> 00:40:01,957
for dismantling the YPF,
555
00:40:02,447 --> 00:40:06,326
I got 6 bullets in my legs.
556
00:40:07,767 --> 00:40:11,476
The privatization of YPFis madness.
557
00:40:11,647 --> 00:40:13,319
It's an outrageous theft.
558
00:40:13,847 --> 00:40:17,283
Of course there was corruption!
It's a fact.
559
00:40:17,447 --> 00:40:19,722
It goes hand in hand
with privatization.
560
00:40:19,887 --> 00:40:22,560
Just look at the heritage
of those who voted for it.
561
00:40:22,727 --> 00:40:26,083
I mean the leaders.
Look at them...
562
00:40:28,127 --> 00:40:31,039
There's no evidence...
563
00:40:31,967 --> 00:40:35,118
Nobody saw suitcases
full of dollars.
564
00:40:35,967 --> 00:40:38,686
Yet it was never denied.
565
00:40:39,087 --> 00:40:42,045
There were so many lobbies,
566
00:40:42,247 --> 00:40:46,001
so much money to be made,
again and again,
567
00:40:46,167 --> 00:40:48,806
so many deals made on the quiet...
568
00:40:49,367 --> 00:40:51,835
while the media praised
569
00:40:52,007 --> 00:40:55,477
the advantages of privatization.
570
00:40:55,647 --> 00:40:58,241
Like the TV journalist Neustadt.
571
00:41:00,487 --> 00:41:02,842
He had high ratings.
572
00:41:03,087 --> 00:41:04,805
Not only the politicians,
573
00:41:04,967 --> 00:41:08,960
we reporters and the media,
also played a role.
574
00:41:09,127 --> 00:41:11,800
How long must we put up
with this idiocy?
575
00:41:11,967 --> 00:41:15,482
TV and radio
in the hands of idiots,
576
00:41:15,647 --> 00:41:18,605
for a nation of idiots?
How long?
577
00:41:21,327 --> 00:41:24,239
The Congressof this mafioso decade,
578
00:41:24,767 --> 00:41:28,601
that voted such disgraceful lawsagainst the Nation,
579
00:41:29,167 --> 00:41:32,762
needed the police to protect it.
580
00:41:34,327 --> 00:41:37,842
The people were so outraged
581
00:41:38,247 --> 00:41:41,842
that each weekbrought its share of protests.
582
00:41:44,687 --> 00:41:48,441
Pensioners, teachers,civil servants,
583
00:41:49,527 --> 00:41:51,483
students, workers,
584
00:41:51,687 --> 00:41:53,803
and the unemployedfrom every profession.
585
00:41:59,047 --> 00:42:01,481
It was the beginning of a dark era:
586
00:42:01,687 --> 00:42:05,236
The national budgethad to be approved in Washington
587
00:42:05,407 --> 00:42:07,477
before it was by our Congress.
588
00:42:07,647 --> 00:42:10,798
The governmentasked for people's understanding,
589
00:42:10,967 --> 00:42:14,164
because the countrywas on its knees...
590
00:42:31,367 --> 00:42:35,360
"We were called the hand-raisers
591
00:42:35,687 --> 00:42:40,238
"We were devoted, committed
592
00:42:40,447 --> 00:42:44,645
"We voted with our eyes closed
593
00:42:44,887 --> 00:42:49,881
"As the party asked us to
594
00:42:50,207 --> 00:42:53,836
"We were called the hand-raisers
595
00:42:54,287 --> 00:42:58,599
"We legislated without remembering,
596
00:42:58,807 --> 00:43:03,323
"And our voters, we betrayed
597
00:43:03,487 --> 00:43:08,515
"And we didn't hear their boos..."
598
00:43:15,287 --> 00:43:19,041
THE ECONOMIC MODEL
599
00:43:22,447 --> 00:43:25,962
The instrumentused to apply the neo-liberal model
600
00:43:26,447 --> 00:43:29,166
was the Convertibility Plan
601
00:43:30,407 --> 00:43:34,525
that liberalized importsand was based on a lie:
602
00:43:35,287 --> 00:43:37,596
One peso equaled one dollar.
603
00:43:39,967 --> 00:43:41,923
It managed to stop inflation,
604
00:43:42,087 --> 00:43:45,079
but left our nation's industriesdefenseless.
605
00:43:46,447 --> 00:43:49,883
Until then, the countryproduced 95% of what it consumed
606
00:43:50,047 --> 00:43:52,402
and exported machine-tools,
607
00:43:52,567 --> 00:43:54,797
trains,and household electrical goods.
608
00:43:55,967 --> 00:43:58,003
Henceforth, it imported fabrics,
609
00:43:58,207 --> 00:44:01,802
meat, dairy products,fruit and pasta...
610
00:44:16,047 --> 00:44:18,197
The country was "dollarized":
611
00:44:18,767 --> 00:44:22,203
You could pay for anythingin pesos or dollars.
612
00:44:24,167 --> 00:44:26,283
But with zero inflation rate,
613
00:44:26,487 --> 00:44:28,682
credit outfits and banks
614
00:44:28,847 --> 00:44:33,523
lent at usurious ratesof 50% per year,
615
00:44:33,807 --> 00:44:37,686
when in the U.S. And Europe,the rates were 7%.
616
00:44:40,887 --> 00:44:42,639
The euphoriaof peso/dollar parity
617
00:44:43,567 --> 00:44:46,479
made tradesmen and small businessesunable to compete
618
00:44:46,647 --> 00:44:48,842
and bankrupts them.
619
00:44:51,167 --> 00:44:54,876
Hundreds of factoriesand workshops disappeared:
620
00:44:55,047 --> 00:44:58,164
In textiles, metallurgy,automobile spare parts,
621
00:44:58,327 --> 00:45:01,364
consumer goodsand many other areas.
622
00:45:13,807 --> 00:45:15,604
These were the years of flaunting
623
00:45:15,767 --> 00:45:18,759
illegally acquired wealth.
624
00:45:19,127 --> 00:45:21,641
Let's try not to steal for 2 years.
625
00:45:22,487 --> 00:45:25,081
Bribes and swindles are permitted.
626
00:45:25,687 --> 00:45:28,247
If you put your hand in the till,
627
00:45:29,007 --> 00:45:29,837
do it discreetly!
628
00:45:30,047 --> 00:45:32,322
Life is privatized and walled in.
629
00:45:32,847 --> 00:45:35,884
Security agentsand country clubs...
630
00:45:36,047 --> 00:45:37,878
The land of"Rich and Famous"...
631
00:45:38,127 --> 00:45:39,116
You're a Peronist?
632
00:45:39,327 --> 00:45:40,521
Always have been.
633
00:45:40,687 --> 00:45:42,882
... and of pizza with champagne.
634
00:45:48,887 --> 00:45:51,276
The media
as the driving force of change
635
00:45:52,287 --> 00:45:54,437
Meddling with the YPF,with oil,
636
00:45:54,607 --> 00:45:56,165
was sacrilege.
637
00:45:56,327 --> 00:45:59,558
It was like offendingthe tango or the flag.
638
00:45:59,767 --> 00:46:02,361
The State meant corruption
and bureaucracy.
639
00:46:02,567 --> 00:46:06,162
Oil undergroundis no good to anyone.
640
00:46:06,367 --> 00:46:08,642
Private ownership
is modern and efficient
641
00:46:09,567 --> 00:46:10,966
Everyone has the right
642
00:46:11,167 --> 00:46:13,522
to a little frivolity.
643
00:46:16,127 --> 00:46:19,358
Your lover-boy imageembarrasses you?
644
00:46:19,727 --> 00:46:21,718
The opposite: It helps me.
645
00:46:23,767 --> 00:46:26,406
Politics become a spectacle
646
00:46:26,647 --> 00:46:29,081
My love, it's really hot here...
647
00:46:29,287 --> 00:46:32,438
He's so cute!Politicians are handsome now.
648
00:46:39,527 --> 00:46:41,882
I'm thrilledby this economic model.
649
00:46:42,047 --> 00:46:43,036
It's a lie,
650
00:46:43,847 --> 00:46:45,041
a total lie,
651
00:46:45,287 --> 00:46:46,959
that it creates poverty.
652
00:46:50,927 --> 00:46:53,361
We've lived here a long time:
653
00:46:53,527 --> 00:46:56,644
The politicians
always make promises.
654
00:46:56,847 --> 00:46:59,441
But our local representatives,
655
00:46:59,607 --> 00:47:02,440
never did anything for us.
656
00:47:02,767 --> 00:47:04,485
So we, who live here,
657
00:47:04,687 --> 00:47:07,599
decided to block the road,
658
00:47:08,127 --> 00:47:12,598
so that they'd understand
what our daily life is like.
659
00:47:12,847 --> 00:47:15,725
Kids can't get to school.
660
00:47:16,447 --> 00:47:18,881
Patients can't be moved,
661
00:47:19,087 --> 00:47:21,237
as ambulances can't get through.
662
00:47:21,407 --> 00:47:24,444
We want to live decently,
we deserve it.
663
00:47:24,607 --> 00:47:26,837
We're poor, humble,
664
00:47:27,007 --> 00:47:28,804
but we're not fooled
665
00:47:28,967 --> 00:47:31,481
when they offer us a meal, clothing,
666
00:47:31,647 --> 00:47:33,638
booties for babies...
667
00:47:36,447 --> 00:47:39,484
We wanted them to build drainage.
668
00:47:39,647 --> 00:47:42,115
There was money,
everything that was needed.
669
00:47:42,287 --> 00:47:45,438
But they kept the money.
670
00:47:46,207 --> 00:47:49,563
When it comes to stealing,
671
00:47:49,727 --> 00:47:52,685
they are the masters.
672
00:47:52,847 --> 00:47:55,156
They teach people how to steal.
673
00:47:58,087 --> 00:48:01,636
We're no longer just teachers,
674
00:48:02,287 --> 00:48:05,279
now we're also social workers.
675
00:48:05,727 --> 00:48:07,604
Moms come and ask
676
00:48:07,767 --> 00:48:10,440
if we don't have extra sneakers...
677
00:48:10,607 --> 00:48:12,598
We take care
of the whole community.
678
00:48:12,767 --> 00:48:16,043
When there's flooding,
we become the emergency shelter.
679
00:48:16,247 --> 00:48:18,442
We put up the students,
680
00:48:18,607 --> 00:48:20,757
when the roof of their house
blows away,
681
00:48:20,927 --> 00:48:22,804
when they have nowhere to sleep.
682
00:48:22,967 --> 00:48:25,640
The kids are worried
for their families,
683
00:48:25,887 --> 00:48:27,923
and want to take home
684
00:48:28,087 --> 00:48:31,363
any remaining sandwiches.
685
00:48:31,527 --> 00:48:34,121
We can't make them concentrate,
686
00:48:34,287 --> 00:48:36,118
their minds are on other things.
687
00:48:36,727 --> 00:48:39,639
Sometimes, they faint.
688
00:48:39,807 --> 00:48:41,399
Then we ask them:
689
00:48:41,567 --> 00:48:45,037
"What did you eat yesterday?
And this morning?"
690
00:48:45,207 --> 00:48:47,846
They answer: "Soup, tea..."
691
00:48:48,887 --> 00:48:51,355
They faint very often.
692
00:48:51,527 --> 00:48:53,757
We've got used to it.
693
00:48:56,887 --> 00:48:58,764
But it's shameful.
694
00:49:02,447 --> 00:49:06,963
The Convertibility Planwas part of a global project
695
00:49:07,127 --> 00:49:11,643
linked to a debtthat had become irredeemable.
696
00:49:15,527 --> 00:49:17,279
In 1992,
697
00:49:18,207 --> 00:49:20,198
Finance Minister Cavallo negotiated
698
00:49:20,407 --> 00:49:23,717
with the U.S. Secretaryof the Treasury, Nicholas Brady,
699
00:49:23,887 --> 00:49:27,038
exchanging this debtagainst our national heritage,
700
00:49:27,247 --> 00:49:29,283
for a bargain price.
701
00:49:30,647 --> 00:49:34,640
State enterprises are purchased,with national bonds
702
00:49:34,807 --> 00:49:38,595
pegged at 15% of their face value,
703
00:49:38,967 --> 00:49:41,765
but redeemable at 100%.
704
00:49:43,847 --> 00:49:46,122
This agreement made the country lose
705
00:49:46,287 --> 00:49:49,120
more that 30 billion dollars.
706
00:49:49,887 --> 00:49:52,481
PRIVATIZATIONS
707
00:49:55,407 --> 00:49:57,398
The Argentine government
708
00:49:58,287 --> 00:50:00,005
achieved tonight
709
00:50:00,207 --> 00:50:03,040
seven fundamental privatizations,
710
00:50:03,607 --> 00:50:06,724
in seven strategic sectorsfor the country.
711
00:50:06,887 --> 00:50:10,516
We'll move onto the privatization of TV,
712
00:50:10,767 --> 00:50:12,485
of phone companies,
713
00:50:12,727 --> 00:50:15,366
of a forthcoming tollbooth system,
714
00:50:15,607 --> 00:50:19,885
of forthcoming road and railwayconcessions,
715
00:50:20,167 --> 00:50:22,840
as well asthe privatization of radio,
716
00:50:23,007 --> 00:50:24,565
without forgetting, of course,
717
00:50:24,927 --> 00:50:28,283
the privatizationof the national airline.
718
00:50:28,687 --> 00:50:32,202
We've elaboratedour Ten Commandments,
719
00:50:32,367 --> 00:50:35,598
the Menemist Ten Commandmentsfor the Reform of the State.
720
00:50:35,767 --> 00:50:37,086
Commandment number 1,
721
00:50:37,247 --> 00:50:39,602
Menem doesn't know it yet,
722
00:50:39,807 --> 00:50:43,163
is taken from one of his speeches:
723
00:50:43,567 --> 00:50:47,003
"Nothing belonging to the Statewill remain in its hands."
724
00:50:53,087 --> 00:50:54,805
Nothing was spared.
725
00:50:56,167 --> 00:50:59,716
No matter what it was,or how much it cost,
726
00:50:59,927 --> 00:51:02,839
or how and why it was sold.
727
00:51:11,527 --> 00:51:14,325
Cued by the methodsof other centuries,
728
00:51:14,647 --> 00:51:17,115
these privatizations
729
00:51:17,327 --> 00:51:21,445
were an extensionof the old colonial expropriations.
730
00:51:22,207 --> 00:51:25,244
Once, the Potos� was robbedof its silver and gold.
731
00:51:25,767 --> 00:51:30,045
Now oil, water,and communications are stolen.
732
00:51:31,327 --> 00:51:35,718
The foreign companiesdid in our country
733
00:51:35,887 --> 00:51:39,880
what they couldn't doin their own countries.
734
00:51:41,087 --> 00:51:42,918
Non-execution of works
735
00:51:43,527 --> 00:51:46,325
They were exonerated
736
00:51:46,487 --> 00:51:47,681
for the non-execution of works.
737
00:51:47,847 --> 00:51:50,122
Rates were raised
738
00:51:50,327 --> 00:51:54,240
to make the users
pay for the investments.
739
00:51:54,407 --> 00:51:56,875
No new capital was needed.
740
00:51:57,447 --> 00:51:59,642
The more you risk,
the more you earn.
741
00:51:59,807 --> 00:52:04,164
In Argentina, no risks
yielded huge profits.
742
00:52:04,367 --> 00:52:06,801
Outstanding profitability
743
00:52:08,367 --> 00:52:12,485
They either doubled or tripled
the rates in dollars.
744
00:52:13,087 --> 00:52:16,682
26 privatized concerns,
13% of the total number,
745
00:52:16,847 --> 00:52:19,042
pocketed 60% of the income.
746
00:52:19,487 --> 00:52:21,523
26 privatized concerns
60% of the income
747
00:52:22,527 --> 00:52:23,880
France Telecom in Argentina
748
00:52:24,047 --> 00:52:27,278
had a profitability of 15%
749
00:52:27,447 --> 00:52:29,244
and Telef�nica of 16%,
750
00:52:29,407 --> 00:52:32,126
whereas the ten biggest
international operators
751
00:52:32,287 --> 00:52:35,279
only average
a profitability of 5,4%.
752
00:52:35,647 --> 00:52:37,763
5% worldwide
16% in Argentina
753
00:52:38,367 --> 00:52:43,122
These concerns are private here,
and public in their own countries.
754
00:52:43,407 --> 00:52:45,125
Stripping
755
00:52:46,087 --> 00:52:49,796
The Argentinean enterpriseswere sold without debts.
756
00:52:49,967 --> 00:52:53,084
The State took careof the 150000 layoffs
757
00:52:53,247 --> 00:52:55,807
required by the purchasers.
758
00:52:56,407 --> 00:53:00,116
The main investorswere Spanish and French:
759
00:53:00,327 --> 00:53:03,603
The profitable ENTEL was soldfor a fifth of its value
760
00:53:03,767 --> 00:53:06,076
to Telef�nica and France Telecom,
761
00:53:06,247 --> 00:53:09,922
who saddled itwith a 6 billion dollar debt.
762
00:53:11,287 --> 00:53:15,997
Aerol�neas Argentinaswas profitable and owned 37 planes.
763
00:53:16,967 --> 00:53:20,403
The Spanish line Iberia mortgagedthem to purchase the business,
764
00:53:20,567 --> 00:53:23,240
and stripped it of all its assets.
765
00:53:25,967 --> 00:53:29,437
The State water utility was takenover by a European syndicate
766
00:53:29,607 --> 00:53:32,804
headed by Suez and Vivendi.
767
00:53:33,247 --> 00:53:35,966
After making it owe8 times its assets,
768
00:53:36,127 --> 00:53:38,721
huge profits were made,
769
00:53:38,887 --> 00:53:41,799
but the works agreed towere not completed.
770
00:53:42,167 --> 00:53:45,842
800000 people were leftwithout drinking water,
771
00:53:46,207 --> 00:53:48,767
and a million peoplehad no sewers.
772
00:53:54,927 --> 00:53:57,236
The worse case is probably
773
00:53:57,527 --> 00:54:00,246
the dislocation of the railroads
774
00:54:01,007 --> 00:54:05,205
that dealt a fatal blowto regional economies.
775
00:54:05,767 --> 00:54:08,406
Thousands of families had to move.
776
00:54:10,567 --> 00:54:13,718
36000km of tracks existed,
777
00:54:14,207 --> 00:54:16,163
now only 8000 remain.
778
00:54:17,447 --> 00:54:20,086
There were 95000 jobs,
779
00:54:20,767 --> 00:54:22,644
now only 15000 are left.
780
00:54:23,927 --> 00:54:27,886
Ten years later, the Statepays out more and more subsidies,
781
00:54:28,047 --> 00:54:29,765
and now owes the World Bank
782
00:54:29,927 --> 00:54:34,079
700 million dollarsborrowed to pay for the layoffs,
783
00:54:34,967 --> 00:54:38,277
and another 700 millionin interest...
784
00:54:39,407 --> 00:54:43,241
Just to suppress 80000 jobs!
785
00:54:48,247 --> 00:54:50,124
Billions in subsidies
786
00:54:51,367 --> 00:54:53,358
Privatizations were supposed
787
00:54:53,527 --> 00:54:55,245
to end the payment of subsidies
788
00:54:55,447 --> 00:54:58,803
that supposedly led
to the public deficit.
789
00:54:59,727 --> 00:55:03,959
The irony today, is that
most of the privatized companies,
790
00:55:04,447 --> 00:55:06,119
are subsidized.
791
00:55:06,607 --> 00:55:10,077
Just for
the national highway system,
792
00:55:10,247 --> 00:55:12,681
the subsidy was
1,1 billion dollars.
793
00:55:13,127 --> 00:55:16,119
And as the 980 million
for acquiring them weren't paid,
794
00:55:16,287 --> 00:55:18,357
they stole a total
of 2 billion dollars!
795
00:55:18,887 --> 00:55:20,798
They never paid the fee
796
00:55:21,087 --> 00:55:22,645
You have to pay a fee
797
00:55:22,807 --> 00:55:26,482
to use public property
belonging to a country.
798
00:55:26,647 --> 00:55:27,841
They never paid it.
799
00:55:28,047 --> 00:55:29,400
- Who didn't pay?
- No one.
800
00:55:29,567 --> 00:55:31,922
Not for the roads,
the postal system, the airports...
801
00:55:32,527 --> 00:55:34,324
Impunity
802
00:55:34,567 --> 00:55:37,764
Legal protection always favored
803
00:55:37,927 --> 00:55:39,804
the conglomerates.
804
00:55:40,007 --> 00:55:43,124
No one negotiated for the consumers.
805
00:55:43,807 --> 00:55:48,278
Why such impunity?
806
00:55:49,127 --> 00:55:50,719
Politics.
807
00:55:51,807 --> 00:55:54,082
Big business
and political scheming.
808
00:55:54,407 --> 00:55:56,602
The big conglomerates
809
00:55:58,247 --> 00:56:02,843
Privatizations were planned inthe interest in the big conglomerates.
810
00:56:03,047 --> 00:56:08,485
They were the ones who financedall the election campaigns,
811
00:56:08,647 --> 00:56:10,365
all the governments,
812
00:56:10,527 --> 00:56:12,518
all the coups d'�tat,
813
00:56:12,687 --> 00:56:16,316
all the major public-worksundertakings.
814
00:56:20,367 --> 00:56:23,916
No other sectorbenefited from such privileges:
815
00:56:24,207 --> 00:56:27,165
Protected markets,astronomical subsidies,
816
00:56:27,807 --> 00:56:31,117
fiscal advantages,rate-overcharging,
817
00:56:31,287 --> 00:56:34,359
exoneration of penaltiesfor non-performance of work,
818
00:56:34,527 --> 00:56:36,199
extensions of concessions,
819
00:56:36,367 --> 00:56:39,643
and conversion into pesosof debts in dollars.
820
00:56:41,367 --> 00:56:45,724
They failed to honortheir contracts with the State,
821
00:56:45,887 --> 00:56:49,323
swindled itand then sued it for damages.
822
00:56:50,807 --> 00:56:52,035
Among these were:
823
00:56:52,807 --> 00:56:55,116
Macri's Socma and Sideco,
824
00:56:55,327 --> 00:56:57,557
Bulgheroni's Bridas,
825
00:56:57,767 --> 00:57:00,235
Fortabat's Loma Negra,
826
00:57:00,447 --> 00:57:02,722
P�rez Companc's Pecom,
827
00:57:02,927 --> 00:57:04,804
Rocca's Techint,
828
00:57:05,047 --> 00:57:08,801
Benito Roggio, Pescarmona,and others.
829
00:57:18,167 --> 00:57:20,635
Unemploymentis spreading like a plague,
830
00:57:20,807 --> 00:57:23,446
contaminating the whole society.
831
00:57:23,607 --> 00:57:28,123
The lines of dole seekersget longer everywhere.
832
00:57:28,847 --> 00:57:32,726
Unemployment has gone from 11%to more than 20%,
833
00:57:32,887 --> 00:57:35,276
not counting the temps.
834
00:57:35,527 --> 00:57:37,995
What's the situation
of the workers?
835
00:57:38,167 --> 00:57:40,078
They've lost their salaries,
836
00:57:40,247 --> 00:57:42,158
their social benefits,
837
00:57:42,327 --> 00:57:44,841
their unemployment insurance,
838
00:57:45,007 --> 00:57:48,602
their accident
and sickness coverage.
839
00:57:48,767 --> 00:57:52,680
More than half of them
are moonlighting,
840
00:57:52,847 --> 00:57:55,202
a social situation
841
00:57:55,367 --> 00:57:58,086
that only prevails in the most
under-developed countries.
842
00:57:58,247 --> 00:58:02,126
People don't dare resist,
they fear layoffs,
843
00:58:02,647 --> 00:58:04,319
and that the next day
844
00:58:04,487 --> 00:58:07,559
there may be no solution at all.
845
00:58:07,727 --> 00:58:10,400
So they agree to salary cuts,
846
00:58:10,567 --> 00:58:12,797
deteriorating work conditions,
847
00:58:12,967 --> 00:58:15,845
working in unsanitary surroundings.
848
00:58:16,127 --> 00:58:18,880
Losing your job
means ending in a void,
849
00:58:19,047 --> 00:58:21,925
joining an army of beggars,
850
00:58:22,127 --> 00:58:24,687
the army of the excluded.
851
00:58:25,607 --> 00:58:29,520
It leads to depression,
to anxiety...
852
00:58:30,767 --> 00:58:32,246
In the Latin-American country
853
00:58:32,407 --> 00:58:35,956
where social rightswere once most advanced,
854
00:58:36,127 --> 00:58:38,118
thousands of destitute people
855
00:58:38,327 --> 00:58:41,285
flock to the churchof San Cayetano,
856
00:58:41,447 --> 00:58:43,403
patron saint of work,
857
00:58:43,567 --> 00:58:45,478
asking for help.
858
00:58:48,407 --> 00:58:51,444
THE LIQUIDATION OF OIL
859
00:58:53,287 --> 00:58:55,642
Argentina is a unique case
860
00:58:55,807 --> 00:58:57,320
in the world and in Latin America.
861
00:58:57,687 --> 00:59:00,759
No other country gave up
862
00:59:00,927 --> 00:59:04,158
its gas and oil
without losing a war.
863
00:59:04,687 --> 00:59:08,077
The country was truly betrayed
864
00:59:09,007 --> 00:59:10,804
by the ruling class.
865
00:59:10,967 --> 00:59:13,925
Mexico, Brazil and Venezuela
866
00:59:14,087 --> 00:59:16,521
never privatized their oil.
867
00:59:16,687 --> 00:59:20,566
Why was the sale of YPF
such an atrocity?
868
00:59:20,727 --> 00:59:25,039
Because of the role that YPF played
869
00:59:25,207 --> 00:59:26,686
in the country,
870
00:59:26,887 --> 00:59:29,685
and in the world oil-market.
871
00:59:29,887 --> 00:59:32,082
You have to remember
that when Mosconi
872
00:59:32,247 --> 00:59:35,842
created YPF, the first
State enterprise in the world,
873
00:59:36,007 --> 00:59:39,636
oil was considered
to be very strategic,
874
00:59:39,807 --> 00:59:43,846
and the sale of fuel
to be of national interest.
875
00:59:44,007 --> 00:59:46,123
If the international price rose,
876
00:59:46,287 --> 00:59:49,324
YPF kept the price low,
877
00:59:49,487 --> 00:59:52,684
according to its costs
and not the market price.
878
00:59:53,127 --> 00:59:57,518
YPF was created in 1923
879
00:59:57,687 --> 01:00:00,360
on orders of General Mosconi.
880
01:00:01,727 --> 01:00:06,005
In 1907, oil had been discoveredin Patagonia.
881
01:00:08,487 --> 01:00:10,045
In spite of its detractors,
882
01:00:10,807 --> 01:00:13,446
the oil company was developed
883
01:00:13,607 --> 01:00:16,121
without the need for foreign funds,
884
01:00:16,287 --> 01:00:19,040
and became a modelfor Latin America.
885
01:00:21,567 --> 01:00:24,365
It expanded so rapidly
886
01:00:24,527 --> 01:00:28,042
that it earned as much for the countryas the province of Buenos Aires.
887
01:00:28,207 --> 01:00:32,917
Its reserves were estimatedto be worth 200 billion dollars.
888
01:00:37,367 --> 01:00:42,885
To privatize it, they had
to commit many irregularities.
889
01:00:43,367 --> 01:00:46,006
Actually, if the law was applied,
890
01:00:46,167 --> 01:00:48,635
most private concessions
would be invalid.
891
01:00:48,967 --> 01:00:52,846
Argentina could soon rebuild
its national oil company,
892
01:00:53,207 --> 01:00:56,199
if it had true political motivation.
893
01:00:58,687 --> 01:01:00,359
The strategic reserves,
894
01:01:00,567 --> 01:01:02,205
where the greatest sums
were invested,
895
01:01:02,367 --> 01:01:05,086
were awarded for 25 years,
896
01:01:05,247 --> 01:01:08,159
for a price equivalent
to 9 months of production.
897
01:01:08,927 --> 01:01:11,395
They were so poorly sold
898
01:01:11,567 --> 01:01:15,162
that Menem
had to deal with it personally.
899
01:01:15,967 --> 01:01:19,084
$19 for shares
that were worth $38...
900
01:01:19,247 --> 01:01:22,876
350 million shares at $19,
is a gigantic swindle.
901
01:01:23,567 --> 01:01:27,446
They even hired
the McKinley company
902
01:01:27,607 --> 01:01:30,360
to underestimate the reserves.
903
01:01:30,527 --> 01:01:35,123
A year later, the reserves reappeared
in the accounts at their real value.
904
01:01:35,327 --> 01:01:37,636
So they sold, say,
a reserve for 100,
905
01:01:37,807 --> 01:01:40,765
when it was worth 140.
906
01:01:41,247 --> 01:01:43,477
A cartel of four multinationals
907
01:01:43,647 --> 01:01:48,437
applied the highest rates
on earth to us
908
01:01:48,607 --> 01:01:51,360
and paid the lowest royalties.
909
01:01:51,527 --> 01:01:55,076
Who checks up?
They pump as much they want?
910
01:01:55,247 --> 01:01:57,681
They make a declaration
under oath.
911
01:01:57,847 --> 01:01:58,643
Meaning?
912
01:01:58,807 --> 01:02:00,240
By a declaration under oath,
913
01:02:00,407 --> 01:02:04,559
informing the Argentineans
how much they pumped.
914
01:02:04,767 --> 01:02:09,795
The reserves, the facilities,
were sold for a pittance.
915
01:02:10,367 --> 01:02:11,766
They didn't have to do anything.
916
01:02:11,927 --> 01:02:15,761
The site was there,
with the staff and the facilities,
917
01:02:15,927 --> 01:02:20,478
and everything
needed to transport the oil.
918
01:02:21,007 --> 01:02:26,684
A high quality infrastructure
that belonged to YPF.
919
01:02:27,207 --> 01:02:31,359
They didn't have to do anything,
because a concern like YPF
920
01:02:31,527 --> 01:02:33,677
had completely planned
921
01:02:33,887 --> 01:02:36,924
its future 20 years ahead.
922
01:02:37,087 --> 01:02:38,805
Now they were exploiting it,
923
01:02:38,967 --> 01:02:41,720
benefiting
from their State acquisitions,
924
01:02:41,887 --> 01:02:45,641
in terms of oil
and gas infrastructures.
925
01:02:45,807 --> 01:02:48,037
That's the reality of Argentina.
926
01:02:51,087 --> 01:02:54,966
You can't understandindustrial development in Argentina
927
01:02:55,367 --> 01:02:56,720
and Patagonia,
928
01:02:56,887 --> 01:02:59,355
without knowing about YPF.
929
01:02:59,927 --> 01:03:01,918
It had developed pipelines,
930
01:03:02,487 --> 01:03:05,206
steel plants, roads and factories,
931
01:03:05,847 --> 01:03:08,725
and given birth to dozens of towns,
932
01:03:08,887 --> 01:03:12,277
geared to the social needsof their inhabitants.
933
01:03:13,207 --> 01:03:15,004
In particular:
934
01:03:15,487 --> 01:03:18,320
Comodoro Rivadavia, Caleta Olivia,
935
01:03:18,567 --> 01:03:21,206
Cutral-C� and Plaza Huincul,
936
01:03:21,447 --> 01:03:24,120
which was the first oil-town
937
01:03:24,727 --> 01:03:26,922
in the province of Neuqu�n.
938
01:03:29,487 --> 01:03:32,559
All these empty,
walled up buildings,
939
01:03:32,767 --> 01:03:34,485
lying neglected,
940
01:03:34,687 --> 01:03:36,279
were Camp 1,
941
01:03:36,487 --> 01:03:38,318
the administration block,
942
01:03:38,527 --> 01:03:40,279
the heart of YPF.
943
01:03:40,767 --> 01:03:42,883
When it was privatized,
944
01:03:43,047 --> 01:03:46,278
people had to leave
to look for another livelihood.
945
01:03:46,447 --> 01:03:49,439
They abandoned their homes,
946
01:03:49,607 --> 01:03:51,802
in search of new horizons.
947
01:03:52,567 --> 01:03:54,364
Were you adequately paid?
948
01:03:54,567 --> 01:03:57,286
The wages? No problem...
949
01:03:58,247 --> 01:04:02,684
Here, no one was ever needy.
950
01:04:03,727 --> 01:04:06,321
What happened was a crime,
a murder.
951
01:04:06,487 --> 01:04:10,116
No one ever imagined
this could happen.
952
01:04:12,487 --> 01:04:17,083
Privatizations were done
almost without inventories.
953
01:04:17,287 --> 01:04:20,996
YPF left behind lots of things
that disappeared.
954
01:04:21,247 --> 01:04:23,477
Large motors, for instance...
955
01:04:23,647 --> 01:04:27,117
Vehicles, new equipment,
956
01:04:27,487 --> 01:04:30,524
drilling bits, tools, clothing...
957
01:04:30,927 --> 01:04:35,205
No track was kept of many items
that were never found.
958
01:04:36,087 --> 01:04:38,157
You can dismantle a hangar
959
01:04:38,367 --> 01:04:40,483
without anyone asking questions.
960
01:04:40,687 --> 01:04:42,405
This is what's left of PEXSE,
961
01:04:42,567 --> 01:04:45,604
a company created
by the oil-workers union SUPE
962
01:04:45,767 --> 01:04:50,397
to make the workers believe
they could be entrepreneurs.
963
01:04:50,927 --> 01:04:54,522
The company went bankrupt,
owing us money.
964
01:04:55,367 --> 01:04:58,677
The SUPE executives
were in on the fraud.
965
01:04:58,847 --> 01:05:02,635
They knew very well
that YPF would be dismantled.
966
01:05:08,407 --> 01:05:11,160
People accepted
$40 or $50000 dollars
967
01:05:11,327 --> 01:05:13,238
and agreed to get fired.
968
01:05:13,407 --> 01:05:16,877
They were paid to take
a training course in pastry-making,
969
01:05:17,127 --> 01:05:21,200
data processing, anything,
for a year.
970
01:05:21,927 --> 01:05:26,762
They accepted privatization
and layoffs without a struggle
971
01:05:26,927 --> 01:05:28,599
because they had money
in their pockets.
972
01:05:28,767 --> 01:05:30,837
Then they spent this money,
973
01:05:31,007 --> 01:05:35,080
bought a car, enlarged their home,
started a business.
974
01:05:35,407 --> 01:05:37,079
Did it create many unemployed?
975
01:05:37,247 --> 01:05:40,523
Between 5000 and 7000,
maybe more.
976
01:05:40,687 --> 01:05:44,123
There are no reliable figures,
977
01:05:44,567 --> 01:05:46,842
but it's known to be
in the thousands.
978
01:05:47,007 --> 01:05:50,204
There were thousands
of us semi-employed,
979
01:05:50,367 --> 01:05:52,244
trying to get by.
980
01:05:55,847 --> 01:05:59,362
The unemployedweren't all from YPF.
981
01:06:01,287 --> 01:06:03,118
Thousands of others came
982
01:06:03,407 --> 01:06:05,363
from the factories and businesses
983
01:06:05,527 --> 01:06:07,199
that also had to close.
984
01:06:07,767 --> 01:06:09,359
Some years later,
985
01:06:10,167 --> 01:06:12,203
during the winter of 1996,
986
01:06:12,607 --> 01:06:16,156
there was a revolt in Cutral-C�.
987
01:06:18,047 --> 01:06:19,765
We're starving!
988
01:06:19,967 --> 01:06:23,516
We give them gas,oil, electricity!
989
01:06:23,927 --> 01:06:26,521
Unable to find work,
990
01:06:27,007 --> 01:06:31,080
thousands of unemployedblocked the main highway
991
01:06:31,247 --> 01:06:33,522
for days and nights,
992
01:06:33,687 --> 01:06:36,599
in freezing temperatures,
993
01:06:37,247 --> 01:06:40,876
and facingthe charges of the state police.
994
01:06:51,047 --> 01:06:52,400
That single victory
995
01:06:53,167 --> 01:06:55,886
created the "piquetero" movement
996
01:06:56,047 --> 01:06:58,561
with its "roadblocks".
997
01:07:00,567 --> 01:07:05,277
I cannot rule on this.The police and I are withdrawing.
998
01:07:05,447 --> 01:07:09,326
This judge orderedthe state police to withdraw.
999
01:07:09,527 --> 01:07:11,916
The people has won!
1000
01:07:30,247 --> 01:07:33,045
Natural-gas field of Loma de la Lata
1001
01:07:33,767 --> 01:07:36,998
Gas del Estado
was the pride of the Argentineans.
1002
01:07:37,167 --> 01:07:41,046
It was a showpiece
for companies all over the world.
1003
01:07:41,207 --> 01:07:42,322
Why?
1004
01:07:43,887 --> 01:07:46,447
It managed the extraction of gas,
1005
01:07:46,607 --> 01:07:49,280
despite of the remoteness
of the deposits,
1006
01:07:49,447 --> 01:07:51,802
like clockwork.
1007
01:07:51,967 --> 01:07:56,279
Europeans copied it,
and even some North Americans.
1008
01:07:57,927 --> 01:07:59,280
In 50 years of existence,
1009
01:07:59,447 --> 01:08:03,406
it provided natural gas
to 5 million Argentineans,
1010
01:08:03,567 --> 01:08:06,286
whereas in 90 years
of British companies,
1011
01:08:06,447 --> 01:08:09,757
only 300000 Argentineans
got high-priced imported gas.
1012
01:08:11,127 --> 01:08:14,881
The Petrobras company
estimated that Gas del Estado
1013
01:08:15,047 --> 01:08:17,083
was worth 25 billion dollars.
1014
01:08:17,607 --> 01:08:21,316
After being appraised
by international consultants,
1015
01:08:21,807 --> 01:08:24,924
it was sold
for 2,5 billion dollars.
1016
01:08:25,087 --> 01:08:27,157
- Ten times less?
- Precisely.
1017
01:08:30,167 --> 01:08:34,683
Repsol polluted the areato such an extent
1018
01:08:34,847 --> 01:08:36,360
that the Mapuche Indians
1019
01:08:36,527 --> 01:08:40,156
lodged a complaintwith international organizations.
1020
01:08:41,607 --> 01:08:44,838
Here, a member of our community
1021
01:08:45,047 --> 01:08:46,605
built a home
1022
01:08:46,767 --> 01:08:48,803
but couldn't move in.
1023
01:08:48,967 --> 01:08:52,084
When he dug a well to pump water,
1024
01:08:52,247 --> 01:08:54,681
he realized that in fact,
1025
01:08:55,087 --> 01:08:57,078
it was gasoline
1026
01:08:57,247 --> 01:08:59,317
that was coming out.
1027
01:08:59,927 --> 01:09:01,679
This is the pipe...
1028
01:09:02,607 --> 01:09:06,202
installed by my father in 1995,
1029
01:09:06,687 --> 01:09:09,759
so he could pump water to drink
1030
01:09:11,487 --> 01:09:13,205
and irrigate.
1031
01:09:13,367 --> 01:09:15,835
You'll see what he got...
1032
01:09:16,687 --> 01:09:18,643
It's gasoline.
1033
01:09:18,927 --> 01:09:20,155
I'll show you,
1034
01:09:21,847 --> 01:09:24,486
It's pure gasoline.
1035
01:09:26,487 --> 01:09:29,047
Seven years ago, supposedly,
1036
01:09:29,207 --> 01:09:31,675
Repsol decontaminated this area.
1037
01:09:31,847 --> 01:09:35,999
What you pump out
is almost hi-octane gas.
1038
01:09:43,967 --> 01:09:45,923
Not only on these 55 hectares.
1039
01:09:46,087 --> 01:09:48,885
The whole ground water
is contaminated,
1040
01:09:49,127 --> 01:09:50,560
to the very bottom...
1041
01:09:50,727 --> 01:09:54,163
Where the ground water begins.
1042
01:09:55,127 --> 01:09:58,881
CORPORATISM
AND MAFIOCRACY
1043
01:10:03,007 --> 01:10:04,565
Menem concludes a pact
1044
01:10:04,767 --> 01:10:07,042
with Alfons�n for his re-election,
1045
01:10:07,207 --> 01:10:09,323
in exchangefor a constitutional reform
1046
01:10:09,487 --> 01:10:12,081
that includes new statutes
1047
01:10:12,367 --> 01:10:14,642
and an extra senator
1048
01:10:15,007 --> 01:10:16,804
for the Radical party.
1049
01:10:18,887 --> 01:10:20,639
The "Olivos Pact",
1050
01:10:20,847 --> 01:10:22,963
or bi-party pact,
1051
01:10:23,127 --> 01:10:26,039
is signedwithout consultations or debate,
1052
01:10:26,207 --> 01:10:28,482
behind the backs of the citizens,
1053
01:10:28,647 --> 01:10:31,639
in order to guaranteethe continuity of the model.
1054
01:10:35,407 --> 01:10:38,205
This reform legitimizes Menem,
1055
01:10:38,367 --> 01:10:42,406
who has enactedmore than 300 decree-laws,
1056
01:10:43,047 --> 01:10:46,278
ten times morethan in Argentina's whole history.
1057
01:10:49,287 --> 01:10:53,439
The partieshave nothing left to propose.
1058
01:10:53,687 --> 01:10:56,440
Radicalism and neo-Peronism
1059
01:10:56,647 --> 01:10:59,115
are emptied of their substance.
1060
01:10:59,967 --> 01:11:02,242
They become organizations
1061
01:11:02,487 --> 01:11:05,285
for doling out public appointments:
1062
01:11:06,847 --> 01:11:09,725
A corporation of professionals
1063
01:11:10,127 --> 01:11:12,243
without any ideology
1064
01:11:12,407 --> 01:11:17,037
that infects nearlyall political parties,
1065
01:11:18,287 --> 01:11:22,326
whose only loyaltyis to their own privileges.
1066
01:11:34,207 --> 01:11:38,519
The once-powerfulCGT workers union
1067
01:11:38,927 --> 01:11:42,124
is now a ghost of its former self.
1068
01:11:42,687 --> 01:11:45,360
Its zealous association with Menem
1069
01:11:45,527 --> 01:11:48,599
finally drove the workers away.
1070
01:12:06,487 --> 01:12:08,557
As they hugged each other,
1071
01:12:09,087 --> 01:12:11,681
the union bigwigs
1072
01:12:12,807 --> 01:12:15,002
betrayed the workers
1073
01:12:15,527 --> 01:12:18,087
and amassed private wealth.
1074
01:12:33,047 --> 01:12:35,481
The Supreme Court
1075
01:12:39,367 --> 01:12:42,040
The court of impunity
1076
01:12:45,207 --> 01:12:49,246
No court was as criticized
and challenged
1077
01:12:49,967 --> 01:12:54,358
as the Menem era court
1078
01:13:28,047 --> 01:13:31,403
Argentinean society faults
the Supreme Court
1079
01:13:31,607 --> 01:13:34,360
for its role in a mafioso pact
of impunity
1080
01:13:34,527 --> 01:13:38,406
set up in the country in the 1990s.
1081
01:13:38,567 --> 01:13:42,276
It is blamed
for authorizing and legalizing
1082
01:13:42,447 --> 01:13:45,359
the sale of State-owned corporations
1083
01:13:45,527 --> 01:13:47,518
at odious prices,
1084
01:13:47,687 --> 01:13:50,997
stripping pensioners
of their rights,
1085
01:13:51,167 --> 01:13:54,079
stripping workers of their rights,
1086
01:13:54,247 --> 01:13:59,367
and finally
for exonerating politicians
1087
01:13:59,527 --> 01:14:02,644
who committed offenses
while in public office.
1088
01:14:04,847 --> 01:14:06,838
For dozens of years,
1089
01:14:07,567 --> 01:14:12,038
no important bureaucrat whocommitted an offense against the State
1090
01:14:12,647 --> 01:14:14,444
has been sentenced.
1091
01:14:19,047 --> 01:14:21,800
Menem's second term
1092
01:14:26,407 --> 01:14:29,365
Protected by corrupt judges,
1093
01:14:29,567 --> 01:14:34,277
the sinister allianceof politicians and union-leaders
1094
01:14:34,847 --> 01:14:37,361
with big business,
1095
01:14:38,207 --> 01:14:41,085
consolidates the mafiocracy.
1096
01:14:50,127 --> 01:14:52,766
Gentlemen, it's no easy task
1097
01:14:52,927 --> 01:14:55,646
to lead a country,
1098
01:14:56,207 --> 01:15:00,120
especially in suchhard and complex times,
1099
01:15:00,287 --> 01:15:02,517
where notions like homeland,
1100
01:15:02,687 --> 01:15:05,565
common good, morality,
1101
01:15:05,767 --> 01:15:08,600
respect of othersand social friendship
1102
01:15:08,967 --> 01:15:11,481
are so damaged
1103
01:15:11,647 --> 01:15:13,524
or discredited...
1104
01:15:25,087 --> 01:15:26,156
Eat what?
1105
01:15:26,647 --> 01:15:28,763
I have 7 children, no work...
1106
01:15:30,967 --> 01:15:32,798
I have nothing.
1107
01:15:32,967 --> 01:15:35,322
No mattress, no blanket.
1108
01:15:35,967 --> 01:15:37,958
We're totally indigent.
1109
01:15:49,607 --> 01:15:51,484
Come see my shack.
1110
01:15:52,887 --> 01:15:54,559
Come see it.
1111
01:15:58,887 --> 01:16:00,206
See how I live.
1112
01:16:00,407 --> 01:16:02,921
Everything's wet.
No one helps us.
1113
01:16:03,367 --> 01:16:07,838
They must think we're dogs,
us and our kids.
1114
01:16:08,127 --> 01:16:09,446
I never got help.
1115
01:16:09,607 --> 01:16:13,122
I have no right to anything,
I'm not paid anything.
1116
01:16:13,287 --> 01:16:17,166
I give my youngest some boiled maze
or boiled rice.
1117
01:16:17,327 --> 01:16:19,557
I have nothing, that's the truth.
1118
01:16:19,727 --> 01:16:23,402
I have no way to get another home.
1119
01:16:23,567 --> 01:16:26,957
They promised,
they put down my name, that's all.
1120
01:16:27,127 --> 01:16:29,163
The same as for others.
1121
01:16:29,847 --> 01:16:31,838
Mariela, come see...
1122
01:16:32,087 --> 01:16:35,523
My sister tells me:
"Go to the doctor,
1123
01:16:36,247 --> 01:16:39,398
"you're not well, you're so skinny."
1124
01:16:39,607 --> 01:16:41,643
I can't take it anymore.
1125
01:16:41,807 --> 01:16:44,765
It's intolerable.
There's no work,
1126
01:16:44,927 --> 01:16:48,442
I can't feed my little girl
and that hurts.
1127
01:16:48,967 --> 01:16:52,084
She asks when we're going to eat,
1128
01:16:52,247 --> 01:16:54,044
but there's nothing.
1129
01:16:54,207 --> 01:16:58,166
A child can't understand,
but you have to tell the truth.
1130
01:16:58,367 --> 01:17:02,758
It hurts to have to say
I have nothing, but it's true.
1131
01:17:04,167 --> 01:17:07,682
MAFIOCRACY
1132
01:17:08,887 --> 01:17:14,166
The mafiocracy unites businessmen,politicians and magistrates,
1133
01:17:14,327 --> 01:17:16,636
traffickers and bureaucrats,
1134
01:17:16,807 --> 01:17:19,605
union leaders and media moguls.
1135
01:17:20,407 --> 01:17:23,399
Their complicity was only matched
1136
01:17:23,567 --> 01:17:26,001
by their hypocrisy.
1137
01:17:27,127 --> 01:17:30,164
The commission
on money-laundering
1138
01:17:30,447 --> 01:17:32,085
showed how
1139
01:17:32,247 --> 01:17:35,762
the dirty money
from drugs and corruption
1140
01:17:35,927 --> 01:17:38,919
left Argentina
via dummy companies
1141
01:17:39,127 --> 01:17:42,403
located mainly in Uruguay,
1142
01:17:42,607 --> 01:17:45,485
where they were managed,
1143
01:17:45,647 --> 01:17:48,764
toward relay-banks
in the U.S. Or in Switzerland.
1144
01:17:48,967 --> 01:17:50,446
Money-laundering
1145
01:17:50,647 --> 01:17:54,276
We investigated
Citibank, Credit Suisse,
1146
01:17:54,447 --> 01:17:56,836
Trainers Bank, JP Morgan...
1147
01:17:57,087 --> 01:18:00,477
Argentina was the center
of their illicit operations,
1148
01:18:00,847 --> 01:18:02,838
via Citibank,
Banco Rep�blica,
1149
01:18:03,887 --> 01:18:06,117
and Monetta's Federal Bank.
1150
01:18:07,007 --> 01:18:08,759
Ra�l Monetta: Menem's banker.
1151
01:18:09,047 --> 01:18:10,446
Monetta owned
1152
01:18:10,647 --> 01:18:13,605
60% of the media in Argentina.
1153
01:18:13,767 --> 01:18:16,156
Of the media? Like what?
1154
01:18:16,327 --> 01:18:19,319
Like cable channels,
Telef�, Azul Televisi�n,
1155
01:18:19,487 --> 01:18:23,560
Radio Continental, Editorial
Atl�ntida, Torneos y Competencias,
1156
01:18:23,727 --> 01:18:26,924
provincial cable stations,
Cablevisi�n...
1157
01:18:27,087 --> 01:18:32,002
He was also the biggest shareholder
of Telef�nica Argentina.
1158
01:18:33,647 --> 01:18:35,877
And on top of it well-connected
1159
01:18:36,487 --> 01:18:39,285
to political power
and the Supreme Court.
1160
01:18:39,447 --> 01:18:42,359
The very same Supreme Court
that allowed
1161
01:18:42,527 --> 01:18:45,325
telephonic rates to be altered
1162
01:18:45,487 --> 01:18:48,047
favoring France Telecom
and Telef�nica
1163
01:18:48,207 --> 01:18:50,357
against international competition.
1164
01:18:50,527 --> 01:18:53,439
Curiously, it seems
1165
01:18:53,607 --> 01:18:55,677
that a member of the Supreme Court,
1166
01:18:55,847 --> 01:18:58,725
a cousin by marriage
of Monetta's lawyer,
1167
01:18:58,887 --> 01:19:02,277
received $800000 dollars
1168
01:19:02,447 --> 01:19:04,438
sent to the Citibank of New York.
1169
01:19:04,767 --> 01:19:07,520
What are the global estimates
1170
01:19:07,687 --> 01:19:10,326
of kickbacks
connected to privatizations?
1171
01:19:10,487 --> 01:19:13,843
- Between 5 and 10 billion dollars.
- And who were the perpetrators?
1172
01:19:14,247 --> 01:19:17,045
Mainly Cavallo, Menem and Kohan,
1173
01:19:17,527 --> 01:19:19,404
in the last ten years,
1174
01:19:19,567 --> 01:19:22,877
and for money-laundering,
the Banco General de Negocios.
1175
01:19:23,047 --> 01:19:25,766
We also discovered
1176
01:19:25,927 --> 01:19:28,725
bribes paid
during Alfons�n's government,
1177
01:19:28,887 --> 01:19:31,640
mainly to the central Bank,
1178
01:19:31,807 --> 01:19:36,005
from the BCCI,
a bank that laundered drug-money,
1179
01:19:36,207 --> 01:19:39,119
that financed
80% of Menem's campaign.
1180
01:19:39,687 --> 01:19:43,396
There is a definite complicity
between the political class,
1181
01:19:43,567 --> 01:19:44,795
the narcotraffickers,
1182
01:19:45,007 --> 01:19:48,443
and encouragement of capital flight.
1183
01:19:49,087 --> 01:19:51,157
Kickbacks
1184
01:19:52,047 --> 01:19:53,878
Plunder of public funds
1185
01:19:54,047 --> 01:19:57,198
via dividendsand rate-overcharging
1186
01:19:57,407 --> 01:20:00,843
was the normfor government contracts.
1187
01:20:01,047 --> 01:20:05,677
Over 20% of government investmentsis estimated
1188
01:20:05,887 --> 01:20:08,242
to have vanished in "commissions".
1189
01:20:08,407 --> 01:20:12,161
Minister Manzano said,referring to the President:
1190
01:20:12,327 --> 01:20:14,682
"I steal for the crown."
1191
01:20:37,607 --> 01:20:41,236
A major source of corruptionwas the PAMI,
1192
01:20:41,407 --> 01:20:43,841
the pensioners' health-insuranceorganization.
1193
01:20:44,007 --> 01:20:46,965
The system of illicit contracts
1194
01:20:47,127 --> 01:20:50,676
made with companiesowned by bureaucrats
1195
01:20:50,847 --> 01:20:53,236
lasted during several governments.
1196
01:21:02,527 --> 01:21:05,200
A monument to corruption
1197
01:21:05,447 --> 01:21:08,086
The Yacyret� Dam, N.E. Argentina
1198
01:21:09,087 --> 01:21:13,285
Yacyret� is one of the biggestearthfill dams in the world,
1199
01:21:13,447 --> 01:21:16,200
with a retaining damon the river Paran�
1200
01:21:16,367 --> 01:21:19,086
that is 67km long.
1201
01:21:20,447 --> 01:21:23,757
This huge worksite,financed by Argentineans,
1202
01:21:24,127 --> 01:21:26,925
fed the country's slush funds,
1203
01:21:27,567 --> 01:21:29,478
ever since the dictatorship.
1204
01:21:31,087 --> 01:21:34,841
How did corruption
at Yacyret� dam operate?
1205
01:21:35,527 --> 01:21:38,325
Overestimation of costs,
1206
01:21:38,487 --> 01:21:40,557
overdue work schedules.
1207
01:21:40,727 --> 01:21:44,720
Today, the site,
is still not completed,
1208
01:21:44,887 --> 01:21:46,878
and still generates costs.
1209
01:21:47,047 --> 01:21:49,436
It has reached
13 billion dollars...
1210
01:21:49,607 --> 01:21:51,598
And we still don't know
when it will end.
1211
01:21:51,767 --> 01:21:54,076
5 times the estimate?
1212
01:21:54,247 --> 01:21:56,283
I'll give you an example:
1213
01:21:56,447 --> 01:21:58,836
In 1985,
there was a cost reappraisal
1214
01:21:59,007 --> 01:22:01,282
estimated at 30 million dollars,
1215
01:22:01,607 --> 01:22:04,440
that was presented several times
to the World Bank
1216
01:22:04,607 --> 01:22:07,075
and the Inter-American Bank
of Development.
1217
01:22:07,247 --> 01:22:10,876
It was finally signed in 1989
1218
01:22:11,047 --> 01:22:13,686
for 180 million dollars.
1219
01:22:13,927 --> 01:22:15,406
Many accepted it.
1220
01:22:15,567 --> 01:22:17,080
Some didn't.
1221
01:22:17,247 --> 01:22:20,603
They were excluded from Yacyret�
by the auditors.
1222
01:22:20,767 --> 01:22:22,917
- You, among others?
- Yes.
1223
01:22:23,407 --> 01:22:26,797
- Who headed the auditing firm?
- Mr. Carretoni.
1224
01:22:28,967 --> 01:22:33,916
He was campaign-manager
for Alfons�n,
1225
01:22:34,087 --> 01:22:36,157
then for Angeloz.
1226
01:22:36,327 --> 01:22:38,124
A member of the Assembly?
1227
01:22:38,287 --> 01:22:41,597
Yes, for the reform
of the Constitution in 1994.
1228
01:22:41,767 --> 01:22:46,682
Mr. Carretoni, owned the leading
auditing firm in Argentina,
1229
01:22:47,247 --> 01:22:52,196
and was the father-in-law
of the construction company's boss.
1230
01:22:52,367 --> 01:22:53,356
Say that again...
1231
01:22:53,527 --> 01:22:55,119
Mr. Carretoni
1232
01:22:55,287 --> 01:22:58,438
was the father-in-law of Mr. Risso.
1233
01:22:58,807 --> 01:23:03,005
So the head of the audit cabinet
that had to control costs,
1234
01:23:03,167 --> 01:23:05,920
completion date
and technical quality,
1235
01:23:06,087 --> 01:23:08,760
was the builder's father-in-law?
1236
01:23:08,927 --> 01:23:10,645
Precisely.
1237
01:23:18,127 --> 01:23:20,925
Arms smuggling
1238
01:23:21,127 --> 01:23:23,960
We sent arms to Ecuador,
1239
01:23:24,407 --> 01:23:25,999
that was at war with Peru,
1240
01:23:26,167 --> 01:23:30,479
when Argentina was guaranteeing
a truce between the two countries.
1241
01:23:30,647 --> 01:23:35,801
We also sent arms
to Croatia and Bosnia,
1242
01:23:35,967 --> 01:23:38,083
violating UN dispositions.
1243
01:23:38,247 --> 01:23:41,319
Those implicated
were the Army factories,
1244
01:23:41,487 --> 01:23:45,116
the top army brass,
the R�o Tercero factory,
1245
01:23:45,287 --> 01:23:48,677
through which most arms passed
1246
01:23:48,847 --> 01:23:51,839
coming from the North,
a free-zone.
1247
01:23:52,447 --> 01:23:53,357
What happened?
1248
01:23:53,527 --> 01:23:57,998
The R�o Tercero factory
was blown up, causing 7 deaths.
1249
01:23:58,727 --> 01:24:01,002
As I started
a procedure in March, 1995,
1250
01:24:01,207 --> 01:24:04,483
they tried to erase
all traces of the explosion,
1251
01:24:04,687 --> 01:24:07,838
all documents,
inventories, fingerprints,
1252
01:24:08,327 --> 01:24:09,999
anything that could prove
1253
01:24:10,207 --> 01:24:12,402
that it wasn't an accident,
1254
01:24:12,567 --> 01:24:15,923
but a planned act
to conceal their crime.
1255
01:24:16,967 --> 01:24:20,516
Who was part of this plot?
1256
01:24:21,447 --> 01:24:23,961
Its leader was
1257
01:24:24,127 --> 01:24:26,925
an ex-president of the republic,
Carlos Menem,
1258
01:24:27,127 --> 01:24:30,836
but many others are implicated.
1259
01:24:31,007 --> 01:24:34,795
Many other shady events occurred:
1260
01:24:34,967 --> 01:24:36,241
"Suicides",
1261
01:24:36,447 --> 01:24:37,766
accidental deaths...
1262
01:24:37,927 --> 01:24:39,406
A helicopter crashed
1263
01:24:39,607 --> 01:24:42,440
opposite the race track,
on a polo field,
1264
01:24:42,647 --> 01:24:45,400
causing the death of a key figure...
1265
01:24:45,567 --> 01:24:47,319
General Andreoli...
1266
01:24:48,007 --> 01:24:51,920
The "suicide" with his wrong hand
of Captain Estrada,
1267
01:24:52,087 --> 01:24:55,204
who had been part
of the "terror groups",
1268
01:24:55,367 --> 01:24:58,518
during the country's darkest hours.
1269
01:24:58,687 --> 01:24:59,836
Today,
1270
01:25:00,327 --> 01:25:02,283
a question needs to be clarified:
1271
01:25:02,447 --> 01:25:04,677
Where's the money they stole?
1272
01:25:09,967 --> 01:25:13,243
Carlos Menem,his brother-in-law Emir Yoma,
1273
01:25:13,407 --> 01:25:15,284
Cavallo and others,
1274
01:25:15,487 --> 01:25:17,637
implicated in arms smuggling,
1275
01:25:18,367 --> 01:25:20,119
were arrested.
1276
01:25:22,207 --> 01:25:26,041
But the Supreme Courtset them free.
1277
01:25:28,287 --> 01:25:32,075
These offensesconcerned leaders at all levels.
1278
01:25:32,287 --> 01:25:35,279
Ministers, judges,top bureaucrats
1279
01:25:35,447 --> 01:25:38,484
were hauled into law-courtsfor corruption.
1280
01:25:39,047 --> 01:25:42,005
Neo-Peronists: Alberto Kohan,
1281
01:25:42,447 --> 01:25:45,200
Gerardo Sofovich,Juan Carlos Alderete,
1282
01:25:45,367 --> 01:25:48,325
Matilde Men�ndez,Mar�a Julia Alsogaray,
1283
01:25:48,847 --> 01:25:51,077
Carlos Grosso, Claudia Bello,
1284
01:25:51,607 --> 01:25:54,519
Triaca, Dadone, Grisanti,
1285
01:25:55,247 --> 01:25:57,841
Amira and Emir Yoma,Vico and Spadone.
1286
01:25:58,007 --> 01:25:59,520
Radical civil servants:
1287
01:25:59,727 --> 01:26:03,117
Delconte, Mazorinoand many others.
1288
01:26:03,527 --> 01:26:07,759
Presidential candidates:Angeloz and Massachessi.
1289
01:26:09,607 --> 01:26:13,839
I'll lead the struggleagainst corruption.
1290
01:26:14,047 --> 01:26:16,197
All the cases were dismissed
1291
01:26:16,447 --> 01:26:18,039
The threats concerned
1292
01:26:18,207 --> 01:26:20,596
a gold exporting business,
1293
01:26:20,767 --> 01:26:22,803
with phony financial records.
1294
01:26:23,367 --> 01:26:24,800
The gold mafia
1295
01:26:25,007 --> 01:26:27,646
"If you don't want trouble...
1296
01:26:27,847 --> 01:26:28,643
Drug trafficking
1297
01:26:29,047 --> 01:26:31,686
"...stay out of this."They slashed my arm.
1298
01:26:32,047 --> 01:26:33,400
During the Menem years...
1299
01:26:33,607 --> 01:26:34,676
"Parallel" Customs officers
1300
01:26:34,887 --> 01:26:39,165
... the mafiosi thrivedunder an obliging government,
1301
01:26:39,367 --> 01:26:41,278
and have ever since.
1302
01:26:42,247 --> 01:26:43,839
The Buenos Aires police mafia
1303
01:26:44,567 --> 01:26:48,640
Among their deeds:Abductions for extortion,
1304
01:26:48,847 --> 01:26:49,996
murders...
1305
01:26:50,207 --> 01:26:51,481
IBM-Banco Naci�n affair
1306
01:26:52,607 --> 01:26:53,960
... car thefts,
1307
01:26:54,167 --> 01:26:56,397
trigger-happy deaths,
1308
01:26:57,687 --> 01:27:02,124
fake accidentsand unexplained suicides.
1309
01:27:04,447 --> 01:27:05,721
Deadly bomb attacks
1310
01:27:07,727 --> 01:27:09,001
Israeli Embassy
1311
01:27:10,487 --> 01:27:11,806
AMIA Jewish center
1312
01:27:13,407 --> 01:27:14,726
106 deaths
1313
01:27:17,007 --> 01:27:19,760
Crimes still unpunished
1314
01:27:21,327 --> 01:27:23,283
The betrayals of the Alliance
1315
01:27:23,847 --> 01:27:26,520
In the Argentinaof the mafia organizations,
1316
01:27:26,687 --> 01:27:28,439
the Alliance campaigns
1317
01:27:28,647 --> 01:27:31,605
on promises to create jobsand fight corruption,
1318
01:27:32,927 --> 01:27:37,079
but without altering the economicmodel or the foreign debt.
1319
01:27:37,767 --> 01:27:39,405
Made up of the Radical party
1320
01:27:39,567 --> 01:27:42,445
and center-left parties,
1321
01:27:42,647 --> 01:27:45,923
it promises to investigatebureaucrats, but disregards
1322
01:27:46,127 --> 01:27:48,516
corrupt privatizations
1323
01:27:48,687 --> 01:27:51,076
or financial plundering.
1324
01:27:51,567 --> 01:27:53,364
Good luck!
1325
01:27:54,487 --> 01:27:57,126
The team of Fernando De la R�aand Carlos Alvarez
1326
01:27:57,287 --> 01:28:01,041
beats the neo-Peronist candidateEduardo Duhalde.
1327
01:28:03,007 --> 01:28:08,035
The new government continuesthe IMF's recessionist policy.
1328
01:28:09,727 --> 01:28:11,080
Long live De la R�a!
1329
01:28:11,287 --> 01:28:13,278
Don't disappoint us!
1330
01:28:14,327 --> 01:28:15,521
Once more,
1331
01:28:15,727 --> 01:28:19,686
the voters mandate is betrayed:
1332
01:28:19,847 --> 01:28:21,758
Civil servants' salariesare lowered
1333
01:28:22,247 --> 01:28:24,283
and taxes raised.
1334
01:28:28,687 --> 01:28:31,485
In Spain, De la R�a,offers to extend
1335
01:28:31,647 --> 01:28:35,322
the concession of Argentina'srichest gas reserves,
1336
01:28:35,487 --> 01:28:36,886
Loma de la Lata,
1337
01:28:37,047 --> 01:28:39,163
to the Repsol oil company.
1338
01:28:39,927 --> 01:28:43,283
Worth 50 billion dollars,
1339
01:28:43,447 --> 01:28:45,403
they are illicitly surrendered
1340
01:28:46,007 --> 01:28:48,965
for 300 million dollars.
1341
01:28:52,127 --> 01:28:54,482
The government bribes the Senate
1342
01:28:54,687 --> 01:28:57,759
to get it to passa controversial labor law.
1343
01:28:58,607 --> 01:29:01,440
Vice-president Alvarezdoesn't question the law,
1344
01:29:01,687 --> 01:29:04,884
but wants the bribery investigated.
1345
01:29:07,047 --> 01:29:10,676
I hereby resign irrevocably
1346
01:29:10,847 --> 01:29:13,725
as vice-president of the Nation,
1347
01:29:14,207 --> 01:29:16,880
so as not to harm the President,
1348
01:29:17,047 --> 01:29:19,436
or jeopardize our institutions...
1349
01:29:19,687 --> 01:29:21,996
Alvarez abandons his voters
1350
01:29:22,167 --> 01:29:25,045
and worksfor the return of Cavallo.
1351
01:29:26,367 --> 01:29:30,645
Appointed again as a super-Minister,Cavallo renegotiates the debt.
1352
01:29:30,807 --> 01:29:33,640
This operation,baptized "mega-exchange",
1353
01:29:33,847 --> 01:29:36,725
is another swindlethat costs the country
1354
01:29:36,887 --> 01:29:39,196
55 billion dollars.
1355
01:29:44,087 --> 01:29:48,797
The "Argentinean miracle"ended in social disaster.
1356
01:29:49,527 --> 01:29:53,281
Cavallo's planswiped out the middle class,
1357
01:29:53,567 --> 01:29:55,285
made the rich richer
1358
01:29:55,487 --> 01:29:57,637
and the poor poorer.
1359
01:29:59,047 --> 01:30:01,003
60% of the wealth
1360
01:30:01,207 --> 01:30:04,995
wound up in the handsof the richest 10%.
1361
01:30:10,647 --> 01:30:12,638
People are suffering!
1362
01:30:12,847 --> 01:30:14,121
People are hungry!
1363
01:30:14,287 --> 01:30:16,403
We're not guerrillas!
1364
01:30:17,967 --> 01:30:20,845
De la R�a opts for repression:
1365
01:30:21,607 --> 01:30:24,599
Two unemployed youthsare murdered in Corrientes,
1366
01:30:24,807 --> 01:30:26,843
as a bridgeis cleared of protesters,
1367
01:30:27,567 --> 01:30:31,526
3 "piqueteros"are gunned down in Salta and Jujuy.
1368
01:30:33,127 --> 01:30:35,595
Never had an elected president
1369
01:30:36,287 --> 01:30:40,280
caused so many deathsin such short time.
1370
01:30:41,127 --> 01:30:44,278
SOCIAL GENOCIDE
1371
01:31:30,847 --> 01:31:33,964
Here, we foresaw exactly
1372
01:31:34,127 --> 01:31:36,766
the effects of the austerity plans
1373
01:31:37,527 --> 01:31:40,963
adopted by the country.
The well-known austerity plans,
1374
01:31:41,127 --> 01:31:44,437
of the era of Alfons�n, of Menem...
1375
01:31:44,607 --> 01:31:48,282
These measures
meant the hospital would receive
1376
01:31:48,447 --> 01:31:51,245
a huge number
of underfed people,
1377
01:31:51,447 --> 01:31:54,200
underfed kids with their families.
1378
01:31:54,367 --> 01:31:57,279
We would say to each other:
1379
01:31:57,447 --> 01:32:00,962
"This one, in 2 or 3 months,
will need a bed."
1380
01:32:01,127 --> 01:32:04,597
An incredible number
of undernourished kids.
1381
01:32:05,487 --> 01:32:08,877
We said: Enough!
In 1982, we took to the streets,
1382
01:32:09,047 --> 01:32:12,084
formed a major movement,
that the press took up,
1383
01:32:12,247 --> 01:32:14,477
and reached the whole country.
1384
01:32:15,807 --> 01:32:18,162
But the policy continued.
1385
01:32:18,367 --> 01:32:20,358
The policy of austerity...
1386
01:32:20,607 --> 01:32:24,122
Each time it was like a stab
in the back for us doctors.
1387
01:32:24,287 --> 01:32:28,360
We knew that
4 to 6 months later,
1388
01:32:28,527 --> 01:32:31,485
the kids born then
would be so poorly fed
1389
01:32:31,647 --> 01:32:36,118
that a huge amount of them
would wind up in here.
1390
01:32:36,887 --> 01:32:40,084
That's why we wrote
this text saying:
1391
01:32:40,247 --> 01:32:43,398
"Others decide,
but we see them dying."
1392
01:32:43,807 --> 01:32:46,560
When we started
to find out what to do,
1393
01:32:46,727 --> 01:32:50,322
we translated books from English.
1394
01:32:50,527 --> 01:32:54,076
We found some solutions there
for balancing liquids,
1395
01:32:54,247 --> 01:32:56,966
salts, and proteins.
1396
01:32:57,287 --> 01:33:01,200
But we were so overcrowded,
1397
01:33:01,367 --> 01:33:04,882
and then we read
a little Argentinean book,
1398
01:33:05,087 --> 01:33:07,555
by a man called Juan P. Garrahan...
1399
01:33:08,167 --> 01:33:11,284
He wrote: "Undernourishment
1400
01:33:11,607 --> 01:33:15,236
"is a socio-economic
and cultural disease
1401
01:33:15,407 --> 01:33:19,958
that can be cured
by giving everyone a job."
1402
01:33:21,127 --> 01:33:26,759
He doesn't say:
"By giving food to everyone."
1403
01:33:27,047 --> 01:33:30,039
That triggered things off,
we got it...
1404
01:33:31,287 --> 01:33:35,121
Why send
an undernourished kid home?
1405
01:33:35,287 --> 01:33:37,039
What's the country doing?
1406
01:33:37,807 --> 01:33:40,196
We had a scientific approach,
1407
01:33:40,367 --> 01:33:43,643
but this year,
it's become exponential.
1408
01:33:44,207 --> 01:33:48,405
Before, we had
about 18% underfed kids.
1409
01:33:48,647 --> 01:33:52,322
Now it's close to 80%.
1410
01:34:30,927 --> 01:34:34,363
In garbage dumps,
all those abandoned children,
1411
01:34:34,527 --> 01:34:37,200
pregnant girls of 14 or 15,
1412
01:34:37,367 --> 01:34:40,006
the kids called "nobody's kids",
1413
01:34:40,607 --> 01:34:42,563
only eat every other day.
1414
01:34:42,727 --> 01:34:45,560
Should I tell a 14-year old mother:
1415
01:34:45,727 --> 01:34:48,321
"To fight your baby's diarrhea,
1416
01:34:48,487 --> 01:34:52,116
"you need chicken,
polenta, milk,
1417
01:34:52,287 --> 01:34:53,686
"clean water..."
1418
01:34:53,887 --> 01:34:56,242
It's totally unethical,
1419
01:34:56,407 --> 01:34:58,716
an inconceivable cruelty.
1420
01:34:59,047 --> 01:35:02,596
How can I say that,
if she's eating garbage?
1421
01:35:02,767 --> 01:35:04,678
These children live on garbage.
1422
01:35:05,087 --> 01:35:09,239
The survivors of the 3rd generation
of underfed people
1423
01:35:09,407 --> 01:35:11,682
are giving birth to these kids.
1424
01:35:12,687 --> 01:35:15,599
A lot of kids die.
1425
01:35:15,767 --> 01:35:17,325
Those that survive
1426
01:35:17,527 --> 01:35:21,645
are smaller, weaker,
and have less intellectual capacity.
1427
01:35:22,487 --> 01:35:26,765
But they're people like any others,
with feelings.
1428
01:35:27,207 --> 01:35:29,516
To consider them...
1429
01:35:30,687 --> 01:35:34,236
as a sub-species of society,
1430
01:35:34,407 --> 01:35:35,886
is revolting.
1431
01:35:36,047 --> 01:35:38,686
They're people like you and me.
1432
01:35:38,847 --> 01:35:41,805
They have the same rights as others,
1433
01:35:41,967 --> 01:35:44,322
they suffer like others,
1434
01:35:44,527 --> 01:35:47,325
if their child dies or gets sick,
1435
01:35:47,487 --> 01:35:50,923
they have a right to a home,
with drinking water,
1436
01:35:51,087 --> 01:35:53,885
and food daily, and a job.
1437
01:35:55,207 --> 01:35:57,402
We speak of human rights...
1438
01:35:57,567 --> 01:36:00,286
What rights do these people have,
1439
01:36:00,447 --> 01:36:03,120
when they're put down this way?
1440
01:36:15,047 --> 01:36:17,322
I really feel
1441
01:36:17,487 --> 01:36:20,285
that a certain part of society
1442
01:36:20,447 --> 01:36:23,280
wants to get rid of these people.
1443
01:36:23,727 --> 01:36:26,560
As if they were bothered by them.
1444
01:36:26,727 --> 01:36:28,683
What part?
1445
01:36:29,407 --> 01:36:32,126
We know who:
Those who grabbed everything.
1446
01:36:32,327 --> 01:36:36,286
90% are paupers,
and 10% own everything.
1447
01:36:36,687 --> 01:36:39,155
That's not a system...
1448
01:36:39,327 --> 01:36:42,478
I'm 54 and it's always the same.
1449
01:36:42,647 --> 01:36:44,444
That same old austerity.
1450
01:36:44,607 --> 01:36:47,644
They always go back
to the same things.
1451
01:36:47,887 --> 01:36:49,878
They don't give a damn.
1452
01:36:50,367 --> 01:36:51,686
And the kids
1453
01:36:51,847 --> 01:36:55,078
have no place at the table
and aren't fed.
1454
01:36:55,287 --> 01:36:58,279
The people we don't want to see
in this country
1455
01:36:58,567 --> 01:37:02,003
are those who are born,
who live and die
1456
01:37:02,167 --> 01:37:05,284
without ID's,
without legal existence.
1457
01:37:05,687 --> 01:37:07,882
The other Argentina,
the hidden one.
1458
01:37:08,047 --> 01:37:10,800
Those who've been excluded,
1459
01:37:11,567 --> 01:37:13,842
for whom nothing is done,
1460
01:37:14,007 --> 01:37:17,795
who shouldn't be allowed
to reproduce,
1461
01:37:17,967 --> 01:37:20,083
who should be taken out
of circulation,
1462
01:37:20,567 --> 01:37:23,957
of whom no one dares say yet:
"Let's hide them."
1463
01:37:27,847 --> 01:37:30,156
When our country
1464
01:37:30,607 --> 01:37:33,917
produces enough commodities to feed
1465
01:37:34,127 --> 01:37:36,880
300 million people,
1466
01:37:37,727 --> 01:37:39,797
the level of poverty denounced
1467
01:37:40,047 --> 01:37:42,402
in the film"The Hour of the Furnaces"
1468
01:37:42,567 --> 01:37:44,603
in the 1960s,
1469
01:37:44,847 --> 01:37:50,160
never foresaw the incredibleneo-liberal genocide of the 1990s.
1470
01:37:54,407 --> 01:37:57,843
Curable diseasesand undernourishment
1471
01:37:58,327 --> 01:38:00,795
cause every day in Argentina
1472
01:38:00,967 --> 01:38:03,276
the death of 55 children,
1473
01:38:03,447 --> 01:38:06,484
35 youths and adults
1474
01:38:07,047 --> 01:38:08,844
and 10 elderly people.
1475
01:38:09,647 --> 01:38:14,004
An averageof 35000 people per year.
1476
01:39:37,087 --> 01:39:40,682
The international organizations
1477
01:39:42,687 --> 01:39:44,643
This country was held upto the world
1478
01:39:44,807 --> 01:39:46,638
as a model to follow.
1479
01:39:47,207 --> 01:39:48,481
The IMF
1480
01:39:48,647 --> 01:39:51,036
applauded Menem in Washington
1481
01:39:51,207 --> 01:39:53,926
for the "Argentinean miracle."
1482
01:39:55,887 --> 01:39:59,243
President,this photo will be great for me.
1483
01:39:59,407 --> 01:40:02,285
- For me, too.- I don't know...
1484
01:40:05,487 --> 01:40:09,275
They say that a photowith the devil is dangerous.
1485
01:40:09,447 --> 01:40:11,199
Come on...
1486
01:40:14,647 --> 01:40:19,323
Our government's responsibilityin social genocide
1487
01:40:20,007 --> 01:40:24,080
doesn't exonerate internationalorganizations, or their proxies,
1488
01:40:24,647 --> 01:40:26,763
the United States and Europe,
1489
01:40:26,927 --> 01:40:31,318
or the unfair North-Southcommercial relationships.
1490
01:40:32,447 --> 01:40:35,280
These neo-racist programs
1491
01:40:35,807 --> 01:40:39,516
that generated huge profitsat the cost of segregation
1492
01:40:39,687 --> 01:40:44,477
and the premature deathof millions of people,
1493
01:40:44,847 --> 01:40:49,238
are peacetime crimesagainst humanity.
1494
01:40:49,967 --> 01:40:52,435
Their authors
1495
01:40:52,847 --> 01:40:54,963
cannot go unpunished.
1496
01:41:00,487 --> 01:41:02,876
A quarter of century later,
1497
01:41:03,287 --> 01:41:06,643
the economic resultsare disastrous:
1498
01:41:06,807 --> 01:41:11,198
The public and private debtrose from 7,8 billion
1499
01:41:11,367 --> 01:41:15,155
to 170 billion dollars,
1500
01:41:15,327 --> 01:41:19,639
and 150 billion morewere paid out for services,
1501
01:41:19,807 --> 01:41:24,164
and a similar sumwas sent abroad.
1502
01:41:24,527 --> 01:41:28,839
Argentina lost another 150 billion
1503
01:41:29,007 --> 01:41:33,842
because of agricultural subsidiesin Europe and the U.S.
1504
01:41:34,687 --> 01:41:36,917
Since 1999,
1505
01:41:37,367 --> 01:41:39,676
growth is non-existent,
1506
01:41:39,927 --> 01:41:42,964
and the countryis heading toward devaluation
1507
01:41:43,127 --> 01:41:45,004
and bankruptcy.
1508
01:41:48,127 --> 01:41:51,802
THE BEGINNING OF THE END
1509
01:41:55,007 --> 01:41:57,441
Going over this memoir,
1510
01:41:57,687 --> 01:42:02,556
it may appearthat the reality can't be changed,
1511
01:42:03,047 --> 01:42:06,676
that the plunderers won the day,
1512
01:42:07,007 --> 01:42:09,157
and we are the losers.
1513
01:42:13,287 --> 01:42:16,085
It's closer to the opposite:
1514
01:42:16,927 --> 01:42:20,522
Neither the dictatorship,Menem, or De la R�a
1515
01:42:20,727 --> 01:42:23,195
brought their projects to fruition,
1516
01:42:24,887 --> 01:42:29,358
and the wealth they gave awayisn't lost forever:
1517
01:42:29,607 --> 01:42:31,837
It can be recovered.
1518
01:42:41,887 --> 01:42:46,278
The neo-liberal modelended in a mass sell-off,
1519
01:42:46,847 --> 01:42:50,442
but those responsibleweren't able to sell everything:
1520
01:42:51,407 --> 01:42:53,682
Not the major public banks,
1521
01:42:53,847 --> 01:42:56,566
or the bigR�o Santiago shipyards,
1522
01:42:56,767 --> 01:42:59,804
or the nuclear power plants,or Yacyret�,
1523
01:43:00,007 --> 01:43:02,362
or Salto Grande, or Epec.
1524
01:43:20,807 --> 01:43:22,126
Menem and De la R�a
1525
01:43:22,847 --> 01:43:26,886
weren't ableto impose a repressive solution,
1526
01:43:28,247 --> 01:43:30,317
or to silence the protests
1527
01:43:30,487 --> 01:43:33,479
against mafioso and police crimes,
1528
01:43:35,327 --> 01:43:39,161
or to stop the persistent actionof the Mothers,
1529
01:43:39,327 --> 01:43:42,876
Grandmothers and Childrenof the "disappeared".
1530
01:44:00,007 --> 01:44:02,965
A new spirit kept them at bay:
1531
01:44:03,887 --> 01:44:07,243
That of all the struggles,the rallying to causes,
1532
01:44:08,247 --> 01:44:12,365
in the social movementsthat grew during the decade:
1533
01:44:13,447 --> 01:44:15,244
The local organizations,
1534
01:44:15,967 --> 01:44:19,357
the "piqueteros", canteens,and neighborhood assemblies,
1535
01:44:20,247 --> 01:44:23,125
the occupation of landand settlements,
1536
01:44:23,847 --> 01:44:27,362
the huge nation-wide marchand hundreds of other marches,
1537
01:44:27,567 --> 01:44:29,319
national strikes...
1538
01:44:30,807 --> 01:44:32,763
the CTA movement,
1539
01:44:33,287 --> 01:44:35,278
the factoriesreclaimed by the workers,
1540
01:44:36,447 --> 01:44:39,598
the successive demos of pensioners,
1541
01:44:40,687 --> 01:44:43,155
the struggles of women farmhands,
1542
01:44:43,407 --> 01:44:45,682
students and bank depositors,
1543
01:44:45,847 --> 01:44:48,441
storekeepers, artists...
1544
01:44:48,807 --> 01:44:53,323
It all ledto the big December, 2001 uprising:
1545
01:44:53,487 --> 01:44:57,685
As on October 17, 1945and in C�rdoba in 1969,
1546
01:44:58,367 --> 01:45:01,643
Argentinean history was changed.
1547
01:45:40,727 --> 01:45:42,797
My heart has closed up tight
1548
01:45:43,527 --> 01:45:45,836
so it can survive
1549
01:45:46,127 --> 01:45:48,243
Living so I can save
1550
01:45:48,647 --> 01:45:51,161
my skin,which is all I have left
1551
01:45:55,367 --> 01:45:57,562
My soul is wasting away
1552
01:46:02,247 --> 01:46:04,841
Don't think, don't protest
1553
01:46:05,247 --> 01:46:07,636
Don't even try, don't interfere
1554
01:46:07,807 --> 01:46:09,763
Anyway, nothing makes sense
1555
01:46:10,527 --> 01:46:12,757
Our lives are preordained
1556
01:46:12,967 --> 01:46:15,879
In this apocalyptic comedy
1557
01:46:16,047 --> 01:46:18,720
We're all headedfor the slaughterhouse
1558
01:46:18,967 --> 01:46:21,322
We're not eliminatedthe same old way
1559
01:46:21,487 --> 01:46:24,206
Now we're toldto make ourselves disappear
1560
01:46:24,367 --> 01:46:27,040
Asking questions without answers
1561
01:46:27,207 --> 01:46:29,926
Protesting without hassling anyone
1562
01:46:30,087 --> 01:46:32,601
Domesticated, neutralized, paralyzed
1563
01:46:33,007 --> 01:46:35,043
When will we wake up?
1564
01:46:35,247 --> 01:46:37,807
There's no work,might as well split
1565
01:46:37,967 --> 01:46:40,800
Human dignityis as good as dead
1566
01:46:41,007 --> 01:46:43,362
Everything's hangingby a thread
1567
01:46:43,567 --> 01:46:46,365
What's differencebetween dead or alive?
1568
01:46:46,527 --> 01:46:48,722
I refuse to shut my mouth now
1569
01:46:48,887 --> 01:46:51,765
I'm not hereto spread around bad news
1570
01:46:52,007 --> 01:46:54,646
They haven't won yet,so choose
1571
01:46:54,807 --> 01:46:57,480
You got balls or not?
1572
01:46:57,887 --> 01:46:59,764
I'm bug 'em,but they listen to me
1573
01:46:59,927 --> 01:47:02,805
Friend I'm not scaredto go against the grain
1574
01:47:02,967 --> 01:47:05,401
And I encourageall those who fight
1575
01:47:05,567 --> 01:47:08,525
To join us in our struggle
1576
01:47:08,887 --> 01:47:11,447
My heart has closed up tight
1577
01:47:11,727 --> 01:47:14,287
so it can survive
1578
01:47:14,527 --> 01:47:16,916
Living so I can save
1579
01:47:17,087 --> 01:47:19,237
my skin,which is all I have left
1580
01:47:19,407 --> 01:47:20,920
That's the bind we're in
1581
01:47:23,567 --> 01:47:25,922
My soul's an empty shell
1582
01:47:28,967 --> 01:47:31,527
I want a miracleto make us wake up
1583
01:47:31,687 --> 01:47:34,360
I want a miracleto make everyone rise up
1584
01:47:34,527 --> 01:47:36,518
Don't expect anythingfrom destiny
1585
01:47:36,687 --> 01:47:39,520
What we needis for the earth to quake
1586
01:47:39,687 --> 01:47:41,837
I'm gonna talk and act,I won't stop
1587
01:47:42,367 --> 01:47:45,086
My poetry'sgonna penetrate your soul
1588
01:47:45,247 --> 01:47:48,000
and if it entersthrough the wrong hole,
1589
01:47:48,207 --> 01:47:51,324
You put the vaseline there, pal...
1590
01:47:59,647 --> 01:48:01,399
Dammit to hell!
1591
01:48:01,807 --> 01:48:03,286
Let's kill 'em all!
1592
01:48:28,167 --> 01:48:30,806
In the faceof these violent events,
1593
01:48:30,967 --> 01:48:33,162
let's not get carried away...
1594
01:48:35,807 --> 01:48:38,401
President De la R�a resigns
1595
01:48:57,527 --> 01:49:00,200
"I'll only like
1596
01:49:00,687 --> 01:49:03,440
"Cavallo and De la R�a
1597
01:49:04,087 --> 01:49:07,159
"when they are in jail!"
1598
01:49:08,647 --> 01:49:11,320
34 deaths
1599
01:49:16,647 --> 01:49:20,196
First Argentinean victory
against globalization
1600
01:52:00,487 --> 01:52:03,047
Carlos Menem pulls out
of the run-off
1601
01:52:03,207 --> 01:52:05,516
in the 2003 presidential elections.
1602
01:52:05,687 --> 01:52:08,884
N�stor Kirchner
is elected President of Argentina.
1603
01:52:10,447 --> 01:52:12,039
The information
contained in this film
1604
01:52:12,287 --> 01:52:15,085
came from official Argentinean
and international sources
1605
01:53:52,247 --> 01:53:54,715
Subtitles: A. Whitelaw
1606
01:53:56,247 --> 01:53:59,159
Subtitling Titra Film Paris
126939
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.