Original subtitles

Vincent: This is where the wealthy and the powerful rule.

It is her world,

A world apart from mine.

Her name... Is catherine.

From the moment I saw her, she captured my heart

With her beauty,

Her warmth and her courage.

I knew then, as I know now,

She would change my life...

Forever.

Catherine: He comes from a secret place, far below the city streets,

Hiding his face from strangers,

Safe from hate and harm.

He brought me there to save my life.

And now, wherever I go, he is with me in spirit.

For we have a bond stronger than friendship or love.

And although we cannot be together,

We will never, ever be apart.

????

????

(knocking)

What is it, catherine?

What makes you so sad?

Sometimes I see things...

And I can't help but wonder

If there's any hope left for any of us.

I have known that feeling.

A father...

Beats his child to death.

What does that say about us?

About our world and the way we treat each other?

Evil exists, it's real.

We know that.

But when it touches little children...

...It tells us that no one anywhere is safe.

We have children living with us below

Who have suffered more in their young years

Than anyone should be allowed in 100 lifetimes.

Where's the hope?

Within you.

Within us.

We must not let it die.

We must protect it...

For each other.

(car horns honking)

She's inside with her lawyer.

I'll be here, but I don't think you'll need me.

I'm peter rundler, mrs. Nolan's lawyer.

Catherine chandler.

Mrs. Nolan...

You understand the da's office is considering

A grant of immunity for you to testify against your husband.

Before I decide whether to recommend that course,

I'll need to ask you a few questions.

My client doesn't want to answer any questions

Until she has immunity.

She doesn't want to incriminate herself.

Mr. Rundler, I already have your client's

Latest statements to the police.

I'm only asking her to illuminate some points

Which are likely to be raised in court.

There are very sensitive issues with mrs. Nolan.

It was so quiet.

That's how I knew it was bad.

Usually, there was screaming or yelling.

(sighs)

Mrs. Nolan,

In what condition was jonathan when you found him?

No.

No.

I'm sorry, mrs. Nolan,

But we're preparing a case

For your husband's grand jury hearing.

We need to know what your testimony

Will be.

Joe: Don't you get it?

Prosecute her, and we lose her testimony.

Then all we have against nolan is circumstantial.

She is an accessory to her own child's murder.

She should pay for that!

Maybe. Maybe she'll be paying for it for the rest of her life.

(scoffs) that is not what I meant.

Cathy, you're thinking with your heart.

So will the jury.

Look, I am not going to debate the ethics

Of granting molly nolan immunity,

Because she is the key to this thing.

That's what moreno thinks, that's what I think,

And that's all there is to it.

How can you be so reductive, joe?

It's not that simple.

In a court of law, and for our purposes,

It is that simple.

As simple as the fact that you and I both know

Richard nolan is guilty.

(sighs)

So, I'm just supposed to put aside my feelings?

If it interferes with your work, absolutely.

Tell me now-- are you going to work with me on this or not?

Do you want me to get somebody else?

I want to do this.

I just...

(sighs)

It's hard for me to separate myself like that.

(sighs)

I know.

(subway car chugging)

(subway car clanging)

(groans softly)

(groaning softly)

Man: Did the grand jury indict?

Is the case going to trial?

Man #2: Excuse me, sir. Yes, it is.

Is it true mrs. Nolan lied to the police several times

Before blaming her husband?

I'm afraid I can't comment on substantive details

Of the prosecution, gentlemen.

Why was nolan the only one accused?

What about his wife?

Come on, fellas, you know how it works.

All I can tell you is

The grand jury found probable cause

To believe a felony was committed by the defendant.

Richard nolan will be tried by a jury of his peers.

Isn't this just a political ploy

By the d.A., grabbing after headlines

By going after a wall street celebrity?

The district attorney works for the people.

You, me, and everyone else in this city.

He believes richard nolan committed a crime

Against the people.

If the man is guilty, we intend to make him pay.

That's our job.

What about the culpability of his wife?

What about his alibi...?

(sighs) wow.

Do I know you?

I don't know.

(both laughing)

Joe: So what do you think about them letting cameras

Into the courtroom?

The truth?

Yeah.

I think it's intrusive, voyeuristic,

And completely unnecessary.

I'm sorry you feel that way.

Can I bother you two a minute?

Sure, boss. Come on in.

Why don't you have a seat.

No. I'll just be a minute.

By the way, you did a great job with the grand jury.

Thanks.

Uh, I just got word that, uh,

Virginia sheets is defending nolan.

From boggs and macmillan?

Who's virginia sheets?

One of macmillan's pit bull prot矇g矇s.

She's out of yale, an incredible string of wins.

Oh.

Yeah, between sheets and this whole media thing,

This case is becoming very emotional.

(sighs)

This was a tough call for me.

Really a tough one, but, uh,

I have decided I want catherine to head up the prosecution.

What?!

Sorry, joe.

Sir, I-I'm very flattered,

But... Do you think that's such a good idea?

I mean, joe's has all the trial experience...

I know that.

He's been after me for months to give you more.

Look, you're going to have

To trust me on this one.

I've been in this game longer

Than both of you.

It doesn't hurt matters at all

That the people still identify with catherine chandler.

Because I was a victim?

Well, maybe you don't like to see that exploited,

But that is strong stuff to a jury,

And it may be the one advantage we need

If we really want to put this guy away.

Which is the bottom line.

Anyway, we got to speak.

Joe, I'm...

(sighs)

I'm really sorry.

I know how much you wanted this case.

Hey, come on, radcliffe.

I'm a team player.

But I got to tell you, I think moreno's logic stinks.

So do I. I'm not blaming you.

I'm just wondering what the hell I've been doing around here

For the past seven years.

Joe!

(indistinct, overlapping voices)

Child's voice: Please, please.

Daddy?!

(distant crying)

Child's voice: Help me.

(child crying)

(child crying)

Child's voice: Help me.

Pascal: Vincent?

Here.

What is it?

Can't you hear it? A child crying.

Listen.

I must find this child.

I'm sorry, vincent.

No one knows where these voices come from.

Where are you?

Where are you?!

(paper crinkling)

(clears throat)

By his own admission,

We know that richard nolan has, on a number of occasions,

Physically abused his wife, molly.

Ladies and gentlemen, the state will show

That mr. Nolan also abused his son jonathan.

On February the 6th,

Richard nolan carried his pattern of abuse too far.

On that night, he beat his five-year-old son jonathan

To death.

What makes mr. Nolan's crime so reprehensible

Is that it was not just a single act of violence

But rather a sequence of acts,

All of which display

A cold and complete disregard for human life.

The sequence began

When mr. Nolan savagely beat his son

For interrupting a telephone conversation.

The coroner will testify

That just one of the many blows

Was powerful enough to snap the child's neck.

Mr. Nolan then ordered his wife

To call for help only after he'd left the apartment

To establish an alibi.

She was expected to lie,

To claim that the child had fallen.

But when the police arrived,

Molly nolan was so distraught over the death of her son

That she couldn't keep the story straight.

And when the police became suspicious,

Mr. Nolan had no choice

But to blame his wife.

Mr. Nolan expects you to set him free.

He expects you to recognize him as a man

Of prominence and respectability,

A man who could never commit a crime like this.

Ladies and gentlemen, the state will show

That on February the 6th,

Mr. Nolan brutally beat his five-year-old son to death

Then coerced his wife into lying to the police.

And then, mr. Nolan met his daughter, amy

For a pleasant dinner.

Phillips: The great irony in this trial

Is that my client arrives here today after having spent

The last five years of his life

Helping his desperately sick wife, molly.

Mrs. Nolan is a highly unstable woman

And an admitted alcoholic.

Now... If there were any sense

In these proceedings,

In my opinion, we wouldn't be trying richard nolan

At all for this crime.

But since richard nolan is the one on trial, we must consider

The merits of the prosecution's case against him.

And our defense is very simple.

Mr. Nolan cannot have committed this crime,

Because he was not there when it happened.

He was with his teenage daughter

From a previous marriage, amy nolan,

As she will testify.

Look at the facts.

And the facts will indicate...

Mr. Nolan

Is an innocent man.

Anchor (on tv): Now we join our live at 5:00 news team

With the latest on the nolan case.

Reporter: So how do you think mr. Nolan

Is taking the pressure?

Think you have him on the run?

Catherine: Nobody is chasing mr. Nolan.

All we're after is the truth here.

And another thing, it would be nice

If you people would stop treating this case

Like a celebrity divorce.

This trial is not about wall street or high society,

It is about the victims--

Victims of a crime too many of us pretend isn't there.

(reporters clamoring)

Man: What message is this sending to the city?

(reporters continue clamoring)

Coroner: Well, in addition, he had numerous contusions

On his face and chest,

As well as a cut on his scalp above the temple.

And the cause of death?

Fractured spinal column.

It would take a great deal of force

To break bone like that,

Wouldn't it, doctor?

Oh, yes.

Would a woman of my size and strength,

Let's say, have trouble doing it?

In my opinion, it would be very difficult, yes.

Phillips: Be honest with me, doctor.

There is no way that you can estimate with certainty

Whether one individual can or cannot inflict

A certain degree of bodily injury to another.

Am I right?

Oh, in many cases, one could possibly say...

But in this case,

Can you determine such a thing with any certainty?

Well... Not with absolute certainty.

No further questions.

Catherine: When mrs. Nolan showed you her son,

Was he still alive?

Not as far as I could tell.

I couldn't find a pulse.

And what did you do?

I gave him cpr.

Was no good.

I decided to wait for the ambulance guys.

And this is when you questioned mrs. Nolan?

Right.

Officer alburg, you have stated

That it was when you questioned mrs. Nolan

That you first became suspicious of her husband.

Was he there at the time?

Not in the beginning.

Then why did you become suspicious?

All I did was ask her where he was,

And she got all crazy.

What did she say?

First, she said she didn't know where he was.

Then, she said he'd be back soon.

Then, she got all confused, and finally, she said

I should just ask him what happened.

Phillips: You said you found it

Suspicious when mr. Nolan reacted calmly

When he found out about his son's death.

It didn't seem to come as a surprise to him.

If you were responsible for your child's death, officer,

Would you be calm?

Or would you, perhaps more likely, be upset,

Like mrs. Nolan?

Objection! Hypothetical.

The witness is not an expert.

Sustained.

Withdraw the question.

(spectators whispering)

Mrs. Nolan, I understand it's...

I...

I don't think I can stand it...

Talking about it.

I know.

But we have to get these details clear in your mind.

Tomorrow, your husband's attorneys will do

Everything they can to make you contradict yourself.

Do I have to go up there?

There's no other way?

I'm afraid not.

Their best defense is to make you appear guilty.

Make me appear guilty, hmm?

What if I am guilty?

You're just like everybody else.

You think I should be up on the stand there with him.

No.

No, of course not.

I should just get used to it.

Nobody will ever understand.

Molly...

I want to understand.

You know how he did it?

He told me he loved me.

When he hit me,

He used to tell me that it was for my own good

And he did it because he loved me.

Just to hear him say it was worth the pain.

So I let him.

And it kept getting worse.

And I just...

Kept letting him.

You never fought back?

I couldn't.

You never...

Thought you deserved better?

(voice breaking): No.

Oh, my...

(sobbing)

You do, molly.

(sobbing): Oh, I don't think so.

I don't think so, cathy.

It wasn't you.

You didn't hurt him. You never touched him.

I didn't help him. I didn't help him.

You were afraid for your life.

Everyone knows that.

Do they?

They will.

I promise.

Molly...

Make your husband pay for what he did.

You can do that tomorrow when you speak in court.

(sniffles)

(sighs)

I'll try.

(whispering): Okay.

Let's get back to what happened when the police...

Thank you, cathy.

Thank you.

(child groaning)

(groaning)

Boy: Help me.

Help me.

Help me.

Help me.

Help me.

Help me!

Help me.

(sobbing): Help me.

Help me.

Help me.

(sobbing): Help me.

(sobbing): Help me. Help me.

Help me. Help me.

Help me. Help me.

(growling)

(screaming)

(panting)

(subway train passing in distance)

(subway train passing in distance)

Catherine: Mrs. Nolan,

When you and your husband were first taken into custody,

You told the police

That your husband had been away from the apartment

When your son sustained injuries in a fall.

Was this true?

Mrs. Nolan, I have to ask you to speak up.

What is your answer?

(softly): No.

(clearing throat): No.

Why would you lie to the police

Like this, molly?

I had already lost my son jonathan,

And I was afraid of losing richard, too.

You loved your husband and you wanted to protect him?

Yes.

Was there another reason?

Yes.

And what was that?

He told me that...

He told you what, molly?

He told me...

That...

(whimpers)

Molly.

You said that the first story was a lie,

But later you went on to tell the truth.

You did the right thing.

Tell us the truth now.

(crying): I can't.

Did your husband hit jonathan that night?

(sniffles)

Did he?

Your honor, she's harassing her own witness.

Ms. Nolan, do you intend to answer the question?

I can't, I can't.

If you don't answer the question,

Then I'll have to ask you to step down.

Answer the question, molly.

Answer for jonathan.

I'm sorry.

The witness will have to step down.

Phillips: Your honor, her testimony must be disallowed.

I can't cross-examine if she can't speak.

She can speak.

She won't speak for the same reason she kept quiet

The night her son was killed.

Because she is scared to death of him!

Your honor. Ms. Chandler,

Another word and you'll be in contempt.

Your honor, if the witness won't testify,

I move that this case be dismissed

On the grounds of insufficient evidence.

Ms. Chandler?

I have to rule on this.

Do you have other witnesses to call?

Your honor, under the circumstances,

I move that my witness be allowed to testify on videotape.

There have been other precedents in abuse cases

Where the victims were allowed...

Those precedents were for testimony by children only.

They don't apply here.

My client deserves the right to face his accuser.

I'm sorry, ms. Chandler, your motion is denied.

Well, then, I... I'll need a...

I-I would like to request a continuance.

Does defense counsel have any objection?

My client deserves the right to a speedy trial.

Motion for dismissal is denied.

A continuation is granted for 24 hours.

(strikes gavel)

Reporter (over tv): The city council is still at a stalemate

On the battery park low income housing development.

Also coming up on the news at 10:00,

A setback for the prosecution

In the nolan case as da's prosecutor catherine chandler

Loses control of her star witness

On the stand.

We'll have more after this.

(changes channel)

No, I think miss chandler is doing a fine job.

If the prosecution is having problems,

It says more about the strength of their case

Than the strength of their legal help.

(knocks)

(sighs)

I'm glad to see you.

Tell me.

(sighs)

It's not going well.

The helpers bring glowing reports.

No, not anymore.

We've had a setback.

What happened?

I underestimated the power of the man we're prosecuting.

I underestimated his control.

He sits in that courtroom

With the best defense lawyers money can buy,

Listening to the atrocities that he's committed

With cold, dead eyes.

He's making a mockery of this trial and of a child's death,

And I can't do anything.

You must continue fighting.

I know.

Even if there is nothing you can do.

You must do it for the child,

For his memory,

And for all of us who refuse to accept that child's death

Alone in a room.

That child's suffering must not be forgotten.

It won't, vincent.

It must not be forgotten!

(sighs)

Because that child stands in silent judgment of us all.

(sighs)

????

Got enough there for two?

(sighs)

You scared me.

Sorry.

I really am sorry, cathy.

If you've come to offer your help,

I think it's a little late.

You don't need my help.

Never did.

(scoffing): Now you're being sarcastic.

I've been watching you, kiddo.

Every move.

I've been like every other new yorker

These past few weeks-- glued to the tube,

And I got to tell you, I've never felt so proud.

Thank you, joe.

I never expected that.

So, tomorrow's the big day.

What's the new game plan?

The daughter, amy nolan.

Sounds good to me.

Go after the credibility of nolan's alibi.

What's this?

I'm not sure the judge will allow it.

You've got to use this.

Yeah, I guess so.

Cathy, the verdict is going to ride

As much on emotions as facts.

When the dust settles,

You'll realize you did amy nolan the greatest favor of her life.

Phillips: So just to clarify the facts one last time.

You were with your father constantly from the hours

Of 7:30 to 9:00 p.M. On the evening of February 6?

Yes.

And at no time did he leave your company for more than

A few minutes, is that right?

Yes.

Thank you, amy.

I have nothing more, your honor.

The defense... Rests.

Ms. Chandler?

Your witness.

Thank you, your honor.

Hello, amy.

My name is catherine chandler,

And my job

Is to find the truth.

I just want you to know that whatever happens,

I don't mean to hurt you.

On the evening of February 6,

Your father took you out for dinner.

Is this correct?

Yes.

What restaurant did your father

Take you to that night, amy?

A little thai place near my apartment.

Do you go there often?

I guess.

So you would say it's one of your favorites?

Sure.

How nice that your father remembers

Some of your favorite things.

So you would say you and your father are very close?

Yes.

Did you know your father

Physically abused your stepmother?

Objection, your honor! She's harassing the witness

For irrelevant information!

Your honor, I am trying to establish the credibility

Of the most important witness in this trial.

Objection overruled.

The witness may answer the question.

No, I didn't know.

Do you know if your father was physically abusive

To your stepbrother, jonathan?

No.

Do you think this kind of physical abuse is wrong, amy?

I don't know.

I guess so.

Did your father ever abuse you?

No.

Amy, I have here your medical records

For the past several years.

Objection, irrelevant.

Overruled.

Two years ago, you were treated for a fractured wrist.

Do you remember how that happened, amy?

I'm not sure.

It says here

That you tripped and fell.

Was that what happened?

I guess.

And one month later,

You were at the hospital again.

This time you needed stitches in your ear.

Do you remember how this happened?

I... I think I fell down again.

Are you certain?

Is that how you recall it?

I'm not positive.

These are serious accidents, amy.

Don't you think it's strange

That you don't remember how they happened?

I remember.

Well, then... Can you explain these injuries to us?

No, I can't.

This file goes on and on.

Would you like me to read it to the court?

What about this fractured rib?

And this infected bruise over your right eye?

And this broken finger?

Can you explain these injuries?

No.

Amy, your father did these things to you, didn't he?

Yes.

And you also knew also knew that he beat molly

And your brother jonathan.

Isn't that true?

We have to hear your answer, young lady.

(sobbing): Yes.

Isn't that why you testified

That you were with your father at 7:30 that night--

Because you were afraid that he would hurt you

If you didn't?

No.

Amy, are you saying that he was with you that night?

(sniffles)

Yes.

Your stepbrother jonathan is dead.

Are you certain that this is your answer?!

Yes.

No more questions, your honor.

You may step down.

Sheets: This case is as simple

As the facts presented in this courtroom:

Mr. Nolan was not present at the scene of the crime,

So he must be innocent.

Even if you doubt the testimony that places him elsewhere,

You must remember

That the prosecution has given no conclusive evidence

To incriminate him:

No means, no motive,

And most important, no witness to the crime.

But since the issue has been raised--

And I'm sure it will be present in your minds

When you deliberate--

Let me address the issue of richard nolan's humanity.

It is true that mr. Nolan

Has abused members of his family,

And frankly, knowing that he is a man of education

And great accomplishment, we must wonder why.

The answer is--

Like so many in our society who abuse others--

Richard nolan was as a child abused himself.

It's a tragic reality

That people who are abused often become abusers themselves.

Whether this is because they retain some vestige

Of aggression that needs to be vented,

Or simply that they become conditioned

To communicating with violence we don't know.

All we know is that these victims

Become like carriers of a deadly disease.

But, ladies and gentlemen...

My client did not kill his son.

Whatever else you may think of richard nolan,

You be sure when you deliberate this charge,

You remember,

There is far more than a shadow of a doubt

That he was even present.

(spectators murmuring)

Thank you.

We've just heard

That richard nolan is a man suffering from a disease.

He passed that disease to his wife, we're told.

She passed it to their son,

And the boy died from it.

Very simple.

And the name that's been given this disease, is abuse.

Well...

I will agree that there is a disease here,

And I'll agree

That richard nolan suffers from it.

But I won't agree that it's contagious,

And I won't agree that it's fatal,

And I won't even agree to its name.

Ladies and gentlemen,

I would like to tell you about a place.

It's a special place I know,

Where this disease does not exist.

It is a place that many people go to

When they've been in pain,

When they've been abused,

So the disease does come there...

But it never stays.

It is in our hearts,

In that room

Where hatred and cruelty do not belong.

I have told you

That richard nolan's disease needed a different name.

The name that I would give it is heartlessness.

Only a man with an empty heart

Could brutalize and terrorize the ones

That loved him.

I believe that richard nolan has no heart.

And I believe that the proof of that is

On molly nolan's lonely face.

And we also know why that woman could never have hurt her child.

She sat on that stand,

When all of us knew what richard nolan had done to her,

And still she could not speak against him,

Because she knew that to do so would bring pain

To someone that she loved.

Molly nolan has a heart.

(catherine sighs)

I am asking you

To go to that place in your hearts...

To find justice for a brutally murdered little boy.

That place is where the truth lives.

That place is where each of us carries the cure

To this terrible disease.

(sighs)

Have you reached a verdict?

Yes, we have, your honor.

We find the defendant guilty

Of murder in the second degree.

(widespread murmuring)

(sighs)

(reporters clamoring)

Catherine: Let me just make a brief statement.

We are very happy

That justice was done in this courtroom today.

A guilty man will pay for his crime.

But justice will not be served in thousands of other places

In this city

Until we all confront the fact of a crime

That happens everywhere, and every day.

It's not just my job to stop it.

It's our job.

(reporters clamoring)

Excuse me.

Excuse us.

It's over.

We won.

Good.

It's a beginning.

Where are the voices?

It's all so quiet.

Sometimes when the winds shift,

The voices, the echoes are lost.

Are you sad, vincent?

More than once I've...

...Heard a child's voice crying out.

There was no way I could reach it, no way I could even find it.

All I could do was stand here

And listen to it cry,

And wonder...

How can we begin to love life?

How can we accept its gifts?

How can we forget even for a moment

When children suffer the way they do?

(sighs)

We can only start with ourselves, I guess,

With our own lives...

...To try to touch the ones

That cross our paths.

That's what you did for me

The night you found me.

It's everything you've given me from that moment on.

We won today

Because we had the truth

And it touched people.

People recognize it in their hearts.

It can't be denied

And there is a great power in that.

So we keep fighting.

Yes.

We keep fighting.

????