Original subtitles

[Applause]

on fire please

[Music]

foreign

[Music]

[Music]

foreign

[Music]

[Music]

it's all sticky

now that's full of nutrients

spread that on the bulbs we bought today

wait a few weeks and Miss tubes in town

of course of course

you ever build a boat like that Daddy no

that's a grain ship last thing we were

gearing up for were icebreakers

daddy when are you gonna go back to work

soon I hope

what do you say we pick up some petunias

pansies little angel phases then

just like yours

[Music]

appreciative car

[Music]

yes uh let's keep going with that one

400 on movie quotes we didn't exactly

believe your story Mr Shaughnessy we

believe you're 200 Patrick Bruce who's

the Maltese Falcon what is the Maltese

Falcon yes let's finish it out 500

please Patrick do you Alice no more

dad took me to see one of the ships he

built today and you missed it I even got

to steer it

Kelly why do you tell her those stories

you know it just sets her off sorry

you're always lying shut up Liar Liar

lie girl stalker

stop it settle down NeNe I didn't want

to see the stupid ship anyway

catch me you get a shot here get a shot

see we got all these pansies and Kelly

wants to put a rock garden Kelly come

here here Kelly let's get a shot hey

Kelly

shoot I had Amber's here wait a second

on your face angel hey hi Amber

it's a pretty dress thank you

so key where's my oldest daughter right

here say hello Grandma

[Music]

it's just a tooth coming in mom it was

shaped like that when they're teasing

she feels feverish Christina but if

you're going on yeah we'll put this on

yeah talk to Jonah hi no he was playing

soccer but he looked around like maybe

he was looking for you no way he still

likes you we don't even talk I mean I

haven't said a word to him since fifth

grade he's still like I don't think so

over

no

look at that kid he's always walking

around on tiptoe like he's uh on

eggshells you know that's the problem

with growing up in a house full of women

he's six years old dad give him a break

see what I mean come on let's go get

some cake

careful that means you're shift in not

until nine

could you do me a favor

did you clean up a bit afterwards please

yeah sure

like the post office any better now well

it pays the bills and that's what counts

right yeah what is it oh what is it

keep an eye on Kelly okay yeah right

like one of my smarty pants gonna listen

to me

the reason that you and Kelly can't

stand each other is because you're cut

from the same sloth you two open your

mouths I never know what story is going

to come out

you're a good kid Christina

[Applause]

here Brat Stop it hey Kelly cut it up

started it

Kelly

[Music]

hi

[Music]

I think the kids have been getting into

the records again

find The White Album filed under w

ow how'd the party go okay

Kelly's ticked off again

what is it this time well she wants to

go out with Amber after school

she knows you've got that interview with

Pac West

yeah wouldn't that be nice just think

sixty thousand dollars a year for a week

vacation

no more babysitting

give my wife back to where she belongs

[Music]

oh go come on don't I'm filthy I don't

care

Patrick in the bathroom again

wait no

don't

well smart ass

how many times Kelly how many you know

he's terrified of being left alone in

the bathroom Kelly you know that he was

bugging me well let's just see how you

got it

Phil please take the kids downstairs

I'm sorry but I've had it up to here

with these scenes of hers

yeah

please please

[Music]

mommy

no don't

hahaha

[Applause]

can I sleep with you tonight

foreign

did he hurt you much

I hate him

he'll be different in the morning

I still hate him

it was just a spanking

[Music]

tough he's not gonna hurt me again

[Music]

morning hi

missed the spot

you're not still pissed off at me

you don't have to worry Kelly

will always be my special angel you know

that don't you

sure

still love me

yeah

give me out

remember girls it's your body if you

don't want somebody touching you just

say no but what if you pulled into a car

or something

you can't say no but that's not gonna

stop them no it isn't care about my dad

that's why it's important for each of us

myself included

he's got a job interview today all I

gotta do is make sure I'm home before

five yeah but Nene will tell if she does

I'll kill her she knows that well what

about Patrick he never talks to anyone

anyway it's still important to let them

know how you feel

dorianna Mrs Hildebrandt when my cousin

told about her father touching her the

police came and took him away and now

he's in jail and their mom's on welfare

it's never easy

her family had to change

there he is there's Jonah do you like

his hair like that no it was nicer

longer that's what I think too it's got

pretty eyes

oh no it's my dad

I thought I'd find you here Dad no Daddy

wait I'm dad please

just get in the car

[Music]

How Could You Kelly I mean what the hell

were you thinking maybe the kids alone

you are so lucky young lady my interview

was cast

your message

I'll tell Mom

oh you go right ahead you don't think

she's gonna be pissed when she finds out

what you've done that's not what I was

shut up

tired of you and your moods

get down

[Music]

I am so sick of you embarrassing me you

think I want people to know I'm with you

huh

[Music]

I'm sorry Mom I really am

you gotta start thinking Cal

you got a brain you gotta start using it

I'm

married

what can you bring me a cup of coffee

please

here

you go make your peace with your father

there you go

dad

I know what that was all about this

afternoon with those boys

you may think that I don't but I do

I had one daughter who slept her way

into an early marriage I don't want to

have another one

you hear me

mom

how come dad's so nice

and sometimes she's

got a lot on his mind Cal

it's hard for a man like your father to

be out of work

it's like that even when he's working

he's a good father kill he's doing the

best he can

mom

what would you do

I mean

what would happen

if Dad was

well

if he was doing stuff to me

what do you mean

I don't know stuff

Kelly I don't know

what now

but I don't think I like it one little

bit

foreign

ers

come on

let's go to bed

huh

[Music]

so what happened I'm grounded for how

long he didn't say

I'm gonna get him your dad how

I've got a plan

Mrs Hildebrandt

Kelly come on in

what can I do for you

yes

it's my dad

what about your dad

he has sex with me

[Music]

have you heard from the mother no we

left a message at the post office in

case she shows up there damn I'd like to

talk to her before I take the girl to

the clinic

and Kelly has been abused you know I

can't comment on that she's a good kid

she wouldn't lie look you were right to

call us in well what about the police

maybe we should call them ministry will

take care of that Mrs Hildebrand just

give us the time we need to finish our

investigation all right all right

Kelly

can you come with me

Kelly

she's 11 years old for Christ I'm sorry

Ms Wilson but I told you when you called

Dr Kerr is the only doctor who's

available on such short notice

I'm sorry Bob it's just I was expecting

Dr Foster well she won't be on till

tomorrow afternoon

maybe we should come back you'd

understand wouldn't you Bob

well why don't we let um Kelly decide

hi Kelly I'm Dr Kerr

are you going to look at me not if you

don't want me to

will I have to get undressed I'm afraid

so but Miss Wilson will come in with you

and we'll give you a gown

okay

[Applause]

[Music]

nervous

It's Gonna Hurt isn't it yes it will a

little bit

now Kelly I need you to lie down and

scoot your bum down at the very end here

that's it

now this next part's kind of

embarrassing but uh could you put your

feet in those holders there

hi Kelly

I have to look inside you

do you understand that

can I go home after that

[Music]

okay here we go

[Music]

foreign

the kid just went through female hell

and she's well she's playing cribbage

I don't know she's probably winning

uh listen if a foster home becomes

available page me immediately all right

thanks bye

so she has been abused

I didn't say that

then what would you say I could say it's

a definite possibility

and is that what you'd say on this fan

I can't change what hasn't happened

Janice

I don't understand I thought if I told

that you'd take them away

you did the right thing Kelly now don't

get me wrong it's just that there's

reports that have to be made and people

contacted and there just isn't enough

time today I know that sounds horrible

we'll do what I can tonight but really

honey I don't think anything will happen

until the morning what if my dad wants

to have sex with me tonight

then you dial 9-1-1

can you call me

all right listen if you have any

questions if you get scared at all don't

hesitate to call me

you're gonna be all right

bye there I'll see you tomorrow

who's that

none of your business well maybe I'll

tell Dad on you we're not supposed to go

into stranger's class maybe I'll dump

water on you tonight when you're asleep

and tell everyone you still pee the bed

anyway she's not a stranger

four five six seven eight

eight okay it says take a ride on the

reading if you pass go collect 200 all

right does it really say that Daddy you

lucky bum

Gilbert Jonathan Farrell yes would you

please stand up Mr Farrell foreign

please fingers laced Gilbert Jonathan

Farrell you are under arrest for sexual

assault

you need not say anything there's got to

be some mistake no wait

oh my God what is happening what are you

doing with my husband daughter Kelly has

made a complaint ma'am a social worker

will be here soon Mr Pharaoh anything

you do say may be used as evidence and

you have the right to retain and

instruct legal counselves

I don't understand any of this

[Music]

[Music]

oh Kelly

what have you done to this family now

[Music]

[Music]

[Applause]

thank you

mess There's No Smoking Gun anywhere in

here that's for sure Kelly

you go in there you tell them the truth

hi I'm Susan miore I'm the Crown Council

working on your case this is Mr Reimer

he's my associate

over there is Connie Connie is going to

be taking some notes while we talk okay

please sit down

now I know you're probably a little bit

nervous but there's really no need to be

because all we need you to do is tell

the truth okay

I will okay

hi Kelly how are you I'm okay

listen I'm sorry oh I didn't hear about

the meeting until just about a minute

ago okay can we continue

Kelly yesterday you told your school

counselor that your father had had sex

with you is that right yes now what

exactly did you mean by that

well he he does stuff what kind of stuff

does he do

sex stuff

uh now does he do that all the time or

did he do it just once I don't know I

mean it was it wasn't just once

when was the last time that your father

did sex stuff to you it was after me I'm

sorry I can't I can't hear you and if I

can't hear you Connie can't hear you

her younger sister Jean

Kelly

I know this must be very difficult but I

have to ask you to tell me exactly

what your father did to you that night

tell her what you told me

well can you speak up please

I I guess my father

he he put his his thing inside me

did you get that no

can you say again what you just said

my father he he put his his thing inside

me

I don't care what you say there was not

any damn social worker

nobody asked any questions oh I know is

that some cops came into my home last

night and took my husband away and

nobody nobody even had the decency to

tell me where he was being taken granted

there was a bit of a mix-up last night

it's a mix-up but that doesn't negate

the fact that sexual assault is an

extremely serious Church

no sexual assault that's what I'm

telling you yes I hear what you're

telling me it's our responsibility to

investigate the evidence as thoroughly

as we can

thank you

do you believe her

the question is do you believe her

the medical evidence is a little

underwhelming isn't it

if you win this one it could attract a

lot of attention

give your leg up on the competition

Kelly Farrell is telling the truth

and her father did what she said he did

I want to be the woman that puts him

where he belongs

Gilbert Jonathan Farrow you were charged

that between the first day of April 1986

and the 27th day of April 1992 in the

province of British Columbia you did for

a sexual purpose touched directly or

indirectly with a part of your body or

with an object the body of Kelly Farrow

a person under the age of 14 years

contrary to section 151 of the criminal

code of Canada account number two you

are charged that between the first day

of April 1986 and the 27th day of April

1992. you did for a sexual purpose

invite counsel or incite Kelly Farrell a

person under the age of 14 years to

touch directly or indirectly with a part

of the body or with an object the body

of Gilbert Jonathan Farrell contrary to

section 152 of the criminal code of

Canada what is Mr Pharaoh's plea

not guilty your honor

piece of cake

well she seems like a good lawyer I

brought you raises I think she's tough

you know but that's what I need right

now right and I got your new toothbrush

here

she's expensive mayor it could mean our

savings

all right yeah

I got you some of these farmer sausages

you like I thought Christina could fry

them up with some

he likes them with Anna's seat idiot mom

Kelly's a [ __ ]

hey

are you listening to me young lady I

don't want to hear you calling her that

name ever again

but she's ruining everything no she's

not her sister

well Kelly's just got a few problems

she's working through right now that's

all

take Nini upstairs for a minute sure

come on kid I'll show you our teeth adds

his train set yeah

yeah but that's not possible they have

physical evidence that you had sex with

Kelly

a kid that she was swooning after Jonah

Collins

or maybe she's going to be ridiculous

dad

I got a kid in my own now so I gotta

write you did something anything to

Kelly I want to know about it right now

Christina no Mary she's right

it's got to be said

I made a lot of mistakes in my life but

I cut back in the booze and I live by

the book but the evidence skill well

they're wrong or there's a reason for it

I don't know but it's going to come up

mayor

just got to give Kelly a chance

okay

I learned from almost Losing You

Christina how much I really love my kids

and I swear to God I swear to both of

you

I did nothing to Kelly

[Music]

did you find anything yet two parking

tickets things like that but certainly

nothing in his past to suggest incest

the kids see our shrink yeah look

at this

look at that oh nice I've got one just

like it on my fridge at home

Harry that's a penis

and here I thought my boy had drawn a

train

Pendergast is a loud Brown and second

psychologist

which will effectively cross out our

guy's testimony who have they got

a professional witness Dr Judith Ray she

seems to think that abused children hate

the smell of tuna fish because it

reminds them of vaginal secretions makes

you wonder who she's been dating doesn't

it

Kelly it would go a lot faster if you

just cooperate but it's always the same

things over and over and over again come

on Kelly

Daddy

Kelly if you're not going to take this

seriously

okay

Kelly

what is this

a drawing

and it is of what

I don't know a submarine

Kelly

do you like seafood

I'd be surprised if they didn't write

about it generally the longer the

sentence the bigger the movie deal we're

making my father out to be some kind of

Beast

he's inside

actually

I came to see you

I need you to understand Chrissy I know

you don't want to testify I don't think

you understand

my father and I didn't get along for a

long time

you seem to have a good relationship now

we're working on it

Christina

I need you to testify for your father

you need me to testify against my sister

is that what you're saying

all right

I need you to testify against your

sister

foreign

[Music]

and here

she keeps screwing herself up

what about tape

I can't take the chance

we've got two videotaped testimonies up

for review by the Supreme Court as it is

we get a negative decision on just one

of them and this case is going to be

thrown out on appeal

actually now that Pendergast is on the

case

nice white middle-aged male judge

the star luck

maybe we should risk the video no

strong kid should be fine

she just needs to get used to the system

that's all

you seem pretty confident that she's

going to stand up against cross

he stood up against her father didn't

she

where's Kelly I don't know

Kelly hurry up you know I've gotta drop

Patrick and your sisters before I go to

work she's in the bathroom crying I was

not crying little liar oh Mom fight your

own battles I don't have time for this

right now

you're a liar you're always lying shut

up liar liar liar I told you to shut up

big fat ugly liar

mom just because Dad doesn't let you do

things horrible horrible liar I didn't

lie I didn't

do you understand

do anything both of you I didn't lie mom

I didn't why doesn't anyone believe me I

did

I've had it

[Music]

[Applause]

foreign

get lost

I believe you Kelly

big deal

do you want me to lock you in the

bathroom brat

Z

I know she thinks you can do it all in

one day

you told the police that your dad's been

abusing you it's the truth

but I thought you said you had a plan I

thought you said you were gonna get rid

of your dad yeah but I how could you be

so mean

you know you used to be so nice

[Music]

we told them everybody knows why'd you

tell them why Mimi I hate you

you're not my sister you're not

[Music]

[Applause]

[Music]

I heard

it's been pretty rough huh

everyone thinks I'm lying

you know you aren't alone Kelly

what do you mean

you'll have to trust me when I tell you

that there are other girls in this

school who are going through the exact

same thing you are

but nobody's told me that

well maybe they're not as strong as you

are

what you've done by coming forth and

telling is a very brave thing

but everyone hates me they don't hate

you Kelly

they just don't understand

you see people think that sexual assault

is about sex

but it isn't

when your father molested you it wasn't

for sex Kelly

it was for power

then

I'm not a [ __ ]

oh honey no

[Music]

what you are is a little girl

should be leading a little girl's life

[Music]

it's big isn't it

yeah

is this where I'm gonna be

Miss Murray

I don't know if I can do this anymore

Kelly I know you must be really nervous

and that's very understandable you know

the thing you have to remember though is

that what you're doing

is an important thing

it's important to you but it's also

important to a lot of other kids who are

abused all over Canada

that's where my dad's gonna be

yeah

yeah but look I'll be right over there

if you get scared you just look at me

okay

why don't we go over your testimony

again then we'll talk about that okay

okay do you want to sit up there where

you'll be

[Music]

okay

tell me again

what happened on the night of ninny's

party

I spanked her hard

I would say so yes

yes

did you use your belt or your hand

by hand

or her panties on or off

off

hesitation that'll kill you

be direct taking off a pair of panties

to administer his spanking is not a

sexual act so don't make it sound like

one

other than that I think you're ready

how come you haven't asked me if I'm uh

guilty or not

into my case

this is great I got a big trial starting

tomorrow on my key witness is getting

cold feet I hope this isn't a Vengeance

case Janice oh look Gilbert found is

guilty and you know it then you better

get the girl under control

sorry James yes all about Terry 500

Graham green wrote the screenplay then

the book about the search for this Harry

Patty this is the third man

so I need the name

foreign

Bruce who's Harry lime Harry lime who

was the third man but since this is wild

about Harry we would like you to come up

with the individual's name all right

that wraps it up for the Jeopardy round

Frank in the lead 4 200 Bruce next with

3200 Patty on the board with 1100 she

will select first in Double Jeopardy

which will begin right after this break

[Applause]

[Music]

[Applause]

oh

I don't know

she likes this one

I think the Paisley looks better go with

the Paisley

she doesn't like the Paisley

[Music]

thank you

[Music]

[Laughter]

[Music]

[Applause]

when you examined Kelly Farrow what were

your conclusions Dr Kerr

there was evidence of anal interference

and dilation

these terms

Ellie's anus had been enlarged

in your experience

occur naturally

no ma'am in my experience anus dilation

of Kelly's type is related to the

insertion of an object either singly or

repeatedly

I see

okay

Dr Kerr you mentioned the words Kelly's

type

now does that imply more than one type

of anal interference and dilation yes it

does but in Kelly's case

you would say that her dilation would be

due to the insertion of an object yes

like a penis exactly

exactly or possibly

possibly

then it is possible that something else

could have caused the dilation yes it is

possible thank you doctor

Dr Kerr did you find semen in Kelly's

anus

no scarring nothing out of the ordinary

and in her vagina

pardon me

was Kelly farrow's hymen breached

um no it wasn't

in fact there was no tearing of her

hymen at all was there no

so then and correct me if I'm wrong

Kelly Farrow is still a virgin yes

doctor well technically yes thank you

doctor

[Applause]

she was nervous scared

I remember Kelly asking what would

happen if her father wanted to have sex

with her that night what did you advise

her to do if that happened

to call both 9-1-1 and myself

did she call you no my Superior gave me

the go-ahead to bring the police in and

Mr Farrell was arrested that night

thank you no further questions

Miss Wilson

were you present when Gilbert Farrow was

arrested

no I wasn't isn't it common practice for

a social worker to be at the residence

in a case such as this to counsel the

family yes it is why weren't you there

Ms Wilson

the police and the ministry uh I guess

you could say we got our wires crossed

I have been under the impression that

the arrest would be carried out the

following morning

and I wasn't notified

bureaucratic mix-up

I guess you could call it that here's

Wilson how long you've been with the

ministry as a social worker

one year

and how many cases similar to this one

have you seen brought to trial

this is my first

I have no more questions for this

witness your honor

oh she's a sweet child it was sometimes

Kelly has problems concentrating but she

always manages to maintain a c to C plus

average thank you certainly she has some

difficulty relating specific incidents

thank you Mrs Hildebrand that'll be all

difficulty relating specific incidents

is that another way of saying Kelly lies

no not at all

Kelly

well she has trouble sometimes following

a story from beginning to end but that

type of behavior is not inconsistent

with sexually abused children really

have you had special training in dealing

with sexually abused children

well no I haven't perhaps you've taken

workshops no then how did you come by

this knowledge I read the statistics

Miss Brown

this Hildebrandt even though you

yourself admit your lack of training in

sex education although you do admit to

being well read you teach an Abuse

Prevention class in your school don't

you yes I do

is Kelly in that class

yes is dorianatoma in that class yes

do you remember what dorianna told the

class the day before Kelly made her

accusation

she told us

that her cousin had been molested by her

father

the day before Kelly made her accusation

and what did doriana say her cousin did

about it

she called the police and they took him

away

boy that girl better be gangbusters

tomorrow she's all we've got left the

tide does seem to be turning

foreign

[Music]

[Laughter]

[Music]

do you Kelly Farrow swear to tell the

truth the whole truth and nothing but

the truth so help you God

I do

it was usually when my mom was at work

but sometimes she was home the night of

Nene's party was your mother at home no

I mean

she wasn't home but then she came home

were you alone with your father at some

point that evening

yes

in the bathroom

where was your mother at that point

she was downstairs with ninny and

Patrick

so you're alone in the bathroom

with your father

up and then

Kelly

what did your father do

he told me

that I was bad

and that he had to show me how to be

good

how was he going to show you how to be

good

he had sex with me

oh

he put

he put his penis in my rear end

and he moved it up and down

and it hurt

did you tell him that it hurt

yeah

well then what did he say when you told

him that it hurt

she told me to relax

Kelly you've told us that your father

had sex with you for quite a while

didn't you tell on him till now

because

I thought everyone would say that it was

my fault

that I caused it

because if it just happened once and I

told

then it wouldn't it be my fault

but I let my dad do it again

and I had gone back

then I was bad

and it was my fault

it was your fault

hey

Kelly hi

[Music]

hi

hi I read about you in the paper

yesterday

they don't name names or anything but

I know it's here

if your father did those things to you

what you said

I'm glad you're taking him to court

bye

all right Kelly I want to take you back

to last Friday

when you told the court that your father

asked you to touch his penis

do you remember that

yes

but isn't it true that it was you who

asked and not your father

Kelly

did you ask your father if you could

touch his penis Kelly

yes

why did you want to touch it Kelly

because I'd never touched one before and

did you touch your father's penis again

after that

no

no Kelly I want you to think back to the

night of Nene's party

the night you say your father had sex

with you

were you angry with your father that

night Kelly

yes

and what did you do to your brother that

night

you mean the bathroom yes

I locked him in

why

because he didn't like it

were you mad at him he was bugging me

was your father angry with you about

locking your brother in the bathroom yes

what did he do he sent mom downstairs

with Nene and Patrick then he made me go

into the bathroom with him did he spank

you there

yes

but then he

then he would

he had sex with me

did he put his penis in your vagina no

but you say that he did put his penis in

your rear end yes

why didn't you tell

I couldn't Kelly

you said that your father's been having

sex with you all this time and you've

never told

do you like hugs Kelly yes kisses

yes then isn't it possible that your

father hugged you and kissed you the way

any father would hug and kiss his

daughter and that you liked these

feelings your honor

and that you became confused

no

can I

do love your dad

I do you love your dad

yes do you love your brother Patrick

yes

that you hurt him didn't you

you locked him in the bathroom

the thing he hates the most in all the

world the thing he fears the most

why did you do that I was mad at him and

are you mad at your father Kelly

yes

what is this Kelly

a soap crayon mm-hmm have you ever owned

one yes your honor I failed to see the

relatives I have no more questions

it's me Ori that concludes the case for

the crown wrong

[Music]

[Music]

your dad called

what did he want

he was worried about you

[Music]

I said it was difficult for you today in

court

[Music]

I don't know what to believe

I mean you say that you're telling the

truth

and your dad he says he is

and I feel like I'm being pulled in all

of these different directions and

[Music]

I just want to curl up and go to sleep

you know what I mean

[Music]

we were a family once Kell

and then one day I woke up and it was

all taken away

and I keep

asking myself

what did I do wrong I must have done

something wrong

because I'm being made to choose between

my daughter

and my husband

[Music]

but I don't know what to do

[Music]

thank you

[Music]

hey Kelly listen me and Amber were

talking and well if your dad did do

those things to you how come you didn't

tell him not to I did

but you're gonna do all that stuff

did he give you money to do it

[ __ ]

Kelly are you cutting class

can I come

you want to see a movie

I mean maybe they're right maybe it is

my fault no don't think that way

don't worry Anne's just a jerk so was

Amber

didn't even tell you I called yesterday

we did

I was worried I guess

all I know is what's in the papers

I was thinking that maybe tomorrow I

would skip out of school and then no

I mean please don't it would be well you

know it would just be so wrong

I don't know

the movies

do you have any idea how worried I've

been here I am thinking you've been

kidnapped and you've been to the movies

bye kill

bye

you don't have to be here Kelly

yes I do

well frankly during our session I found

Kelly Farrow to be uncommunicative

belligerent

I don't know whether she was telling me

the truth or not about anything

perhaps even she doesn't know

Dr Ray do you think Kelly Farrell lied

about her father having sex with her yes

I do why do you think Kelly would

falsely accuse her father I feel there's

a high probability that she is using the

accusation as an expression of anger

toward her father

most likely because she fears losing his

love and attention to the younger

children

how would you explain the difference

between telling the truth and telling a

lie well when you tell the truth because

it actually happened

and when you're lying you're just making

things up and what happens when you make

things up

when you lie sometimes I get spanked

because you're not supposed to lie it's

and you know what happens when you lie

in court

you get put in jail

ninny do you know what being abused

means yes my mom told me

it means when somebody does something to

you when you don't want them to or they

do something that makes you feel bad

has your father ever abused you Nini no

have you ever seen your father abusing

Kelly no she's lying did Kelly ever tell

you that your father had been abusing

her no he just spanked her because she

was bad

on the night of your birthday party Nene

Kelly had just been punished and she got

into bed with you did she say anything

to you that night

yes

she said she was gonna fix our daddy so

he'd never hurt her again

thank you Nene

[Music]

what are you doing here

we've been married for 22 years don't

just think I know your secrets by now

[Music]

God Mary

[Music]

[Applause]

what went on behind the door oh please

not you too no no it's not that I it's

not that I don't believe you it's just

that

I need to hear you say it I need to hear

you say the words

[Music]

I I had to swear to God I swear to you

nothing

[Music]

I don't know why

uh Gill and Kelly they've always had a

on off relationship one day they love

each other and the next day can't be in

the same room without irritating each

other

feel about this

well I I just always attributed it to

Kelly's becoming a teenager

Gill and Christina are our eldest they

went through a similar thing when she

was Kelly's Age Mrs Farrow do you

believe that your husband has been

abusing your daughter

no

I mean how how could he have and I would

know wouldn't I am

my God I could never live with myself if

I thought that something like that was

going on it's

foreign

it's just

it's too horrible

one last question Mrs Farrow

how would you describe your sex life

pardon between your husband and yourself

would you say it was active semi-active

non-existent

well it's um

it's quite active actually

my mom and dad didn't believe in showing

their affections

I've always been determined that my own

children wouldn't go through what I did

so yes I've hugged and kissed Kelly many

times

Mr Farrell have you ever touched Kelly's

genitals yes of course when I bathed her

or on those few occasions when I've had

this bank or I've obviously touched her

bottom and we have heard Kelly admit to

touching your penis once out of

curiosity why did you allow that because

it was out of curiosity it wasn't sexual

I was getting dressed Kelly came in she

wanted to know what a penis felt like so

I let her touch it then I finished

dressing it was as simple as that Mr

Farrow have you ever abused your

daughter Kelly Farrow no I have not

have you ever done anything that in

hindsight you feel might be misconstrued

as abusing your daughter no I have not I

am truthfully innocent

I've never had or entertained thoughts

of having sexual relations with my

daughter Kelly

and Kelly said I had sex with her

she lied I I don't know why but she

didn't tell the truth

if I was guilty I'd be man enough to

stand up and admit it

more questions for this witness your

honor

the night of Gene's party

what went on behind that bathroom door

between you and your daughter I spent

Kelly

I used my hand and yes I took off her

panties because that's the way my father

did it to me and his father did it to

him and it looks like I made a big

mistake because I'm paying for it but I

swear to God I did not do anything to

Kelly that a million other fathers

aren't doing to their children right now

Madam counselor dinner is served

you too huh

we went this close here feed the bubby

foreign

we could have done something important

with this one

you're giving up on the kid

or you're giving up on yourself

she got a fork

hey hon where's that honest seed

is Dad here

back West called him in for a second

interview

where you been

your mom's talked to Kelly

how did it go

she wouldn't talk to me

time

if something's been going on you can't

just leave Kelly up there all by

yourself

For Better or For Worse Christina I

meant it how could you keep

I'm sorry I I didn't mean it the way it

sounded it's just look if you know

something

you've got to tell Christina

you say your husband took this the

afternoon of Nene's party yes

just a few hours before your sister

Kelly alleges the sexual incident took

place

well

he was like a pretty happy family to me

your honor may I remind my learned

colleague that her expertise lies in the

judicial process and not in familial

relations

perhaps you have a question you'd like

to ask Mrs Brown

my apologies your honor unto you Ms

miori

Christina

I want to take you back to a night four

years ago when you were babysitting

Kelly

do you remember the night I'm referring

to yes Mom and Dad were out at a party

and Kelly was in the bathtub

we're Nini and Patrick at this point

Patrick was asleep in his crib Nene was

supposed to be in bed but she wasn't she

came into the bathroom while I was with

Kelly so I took her to her room and I

stayed there with her until she went to

sleep what happened then

I went back into the bathroom and Kelly

told me that her bottom hurt did she say

why

yes

she had stuck a soap crayon in her rear

end

similar to this one yes

go on

she couldn't get it out so you did what

I took it out did you ever tell your

parents about this not until a few weeks

ago when I heard that Cali's anus was

enlarged

why didn't you tell them sooner Kelly

asked me not to

I mean it was a pretty stupid thing to

do

Christina

I want you to think very carefully about

this next question

do you have any idea why Kelly has

accused her father of molesting her

Kelly's always made up stories you know

she doesn't like to take the blame for

anything

but I don't know why she's doing this

maybe she wants to get Dad back for what

Christina

for loving me more than her I guess

liar

Kelly we are losing this case because of

you do you understand

I need to know if there are other things

that you haven't told me

you deal with throwing out here

[Music]

can I live with you Mrs Hildebrandt what

you're the only one that really cares

about me I promise I'll be good I'll

cook dinner and I'll clean up and

everything I won't be any trouble I

promise Kelly please

I'm your counselor and I'm your friend

but I'm not your family

I have a husband and a little girl of my

own I have to take care of

[Music]

so sure she was telling the truth

foreign

I wouldn't know

the way

she's not talking to me

you want me to give it a try

just wait until I leave okay I don't

think I can handle any more stress today

is your dad watching Annie hey he's

getting pretty good at it

oh give Patrick a bath before he goes to

bed with you

hi you like that huh yep I do

sure

[Music]

[Music]

hey Gunner

foreign

it's okay to admit you were wrong

what

tell them you lied then everything can

get back to normal

go away

why are you doing this because what Dad

did was wrong dad says you're lying

maybe I am

are you Kelly

I gotta know

you understand that don't you why you

don't live here anymore so why shouldn't

it matter to you

I'm the one that's still here I'm the

one that matters too Kelly it's not you

now Chrissy it's me and it's wrong and

you know it because you know don't you

you know

and I knew

and you know cause now I know you know

you knew

you know you knew Christy you did

[Music]

I picked them up and put them in a towel

get out but I don't know why get out

oh Patrick

I am so sorry

[Music]

I am so sorry I didn't know I swear

you can tell the truth now right

oh god

what the hell is going on you need me

for Christ's sake stay with the kids

thank you

[Music]

[Music]

[Applause]

[Music]

[Applause]

[Music]

[Applause]

[Music]

hi Christy

hi honey you know I think Annie's

getting a little ration of the army you

might want to have your pediatrician

take a look at her Amy I want you to

take any downstairs and give her a

bottle do you know how to do that I'm

not a baby

you lied to me you son of a [ __ ] angel

don't you dare call me that

damn right I'm wrong

please don't hurt your mother you know

what that would do

here

get out

I don't have any other place to go

I really give a damn

Daddy

[Music]

don't do this Christina please don't

hurt your family

[Music]

I know you angel please don't hurt her

Christina please

please please

open the door please

[Music]

come on

[Music]

my father always told me that

he loved me the most that I was his

special angel

that I was

yes

I

too

would you like a glass of water Mrs

beresic yes sir thank you

thank you

take your time

Christina

I'm sorry uh

I'm going to come right to the point

here

is it your sister who is lying or is it

your father

I'm sorry I didn't hear you

she didn't lie

is it your testimony

that you now believe that Kelly was

telling the truth

yes

I'm sorry

she's lying there you know that so you

are now saying that your sister was

abused by your father you're on her eyes

I'd like to hear this Mrs Brown did you

actually witness this abuse no

you have previously testified that Kelly

has never told you that she was being

abused is that right

so

what makes you now say that she was

telling the truth

because she wasn't the first one

I think I was

six maybe seven

it was just touching it first you know

while he was

watching me

but then at night he would come into the

bathroom

[Music]

and he'd take up my clothes

anyway

and it's hands I remember

touching and

yes and

he had sex with me

anally or vaginally oh it was always

anally because daddy said that it wasn't

really sex unless it was done in the

vagina

how often did this happen

two

three times a month till I left home

you had no idea that he was doing the

same thing to Kelly

[Music]

[Applause]

I was hoping

why didn't you tell anyone

your mother anyone what was happening to

you because you told me not to

he told you not to yes because he was my

father

that son of a [ __ ] was making his way

through the whole family Kelly

I owe you an apology

I'm sorry

it's okay everyone always thinks I'm

lying

she's working on the Harris case which

is the one

older brother that was molesting the

kids

Miss Wilson Mr Sparrow can you give me a

minute thanks

about that counseling you're interested

not for me but

I know that nothing has happened it's

for the children you know the trial and

everything well as soon as there's an

opening I'll make sure you're notified

Kelly

what

do you hate Daddy

do yes

I do too

but sometimes I love him too

I don't love him never I hate Daddy

because he's mean hurt me

let me hurt you

hurt Chrissy

he made me promise not to tell

me too

daddy goes to jail before a long time

[Music]

I don't know

I hope he goes to jail forever so he

gets old I'll be real big and I'll make

him stop because he's not gonna never

hurt us again never

[Music]

foreign

[Music]

people believe me now Daddy

you said they wouldn't but they do

honey I don't know why you're doing this

but I've never stopped loving you I want

you to know that

I always thought I was the bad one

but I'm not

you're the bad one

because you're the adult

and I was just a kid

Kelly

still my special angel

you were wrong

Gilbert Jonathan Farrell

on the charge of inviting counseling or

inciting Kelly Farrell to touch directly

or indirectly the body of the accused

I find you not guilty

on counts one and three Gilbert Jonathan

Farrell that you did commit sexual

assault on Kelly Farrow

I find you guilty on both counts

Mr Pharaoh your conduct toward your

daughter has been beyond the standards

of decency or morality

that you would use your child for your

own sexual satisfaction is both

repugnant and depraved

you are reminded into custody for a

period of 10 months with a further two

years of probation during which you have

no contact with any child under the age

of 18 without the presence of another

adult

and I advise you and your lawyer now Mr

Pharaoh that I'm asking Crown to

initiate a thorough investigation into

the allegations the court has since

heard from your eldest daughter

Christina barazak I would also strongly

suggest that your relationships with

your two youngest children be

investigated as well

and Kelly

there can be no correlation between age

and honesty

and the court does believe you to be

honest the strength and courage that

you've shown during this trial are to be

both commended and admired in a person

of such Tender Years

I trust that the ministry will assist

you in the years of healing that now lie

ahead of you good luck Kelly

case closed

[Music]

[Applause]

[Music]

[Music]

thank you

[Music]

[Music]

foreign

why did we have to start hating each

other

because you went away

and you didn't take me with you

[Music]

I'm sorry

[Music]

it's okay

[Music]

foreign

[Music]

[Music]

[Music]