Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:01,106 --> 00:00:03,787
Previously on Proven Innocent...
2
00:00:04,070 --> 00:00:05,546
What are you doing, Maddie?
3
00:00:05,583 --> 00:00:07,743
I need to figure out
what really happened to Rosemary.
4
00:00:07,841 --> 00:00:09,460
You sure you really want to do this?
5
00:00:09,516 --> 00:00:10,976
Ever since I saw Bellows,
6
00:00:11,023 --> 00:00:12,265
it triggered something in me.
7
00:00:12,302 --> 00:00:14,191
I was just doing my job,
and I honestly thought
8
00:00:14,228 --> 00:00:16,112
you were guilty. In fact, I still do.
9
00:00:16,449 --> 00:00:18,741
I announce my candidacy
for attorney general
10
00:00:18,802 --> 00:00:20,501
to the great state of Illinois.
11
00:00:20,596 --> 00:00:22,003
I got a line on Madeline Scott.
12
00:00:22,121 --> 00:00:24,172
- Bring me something good.
- You know I will.
13
00:00:24,290 --> 00:00:25,657
You think that I killed Rosemary?
14
00:00:25,659 --> 00:00:27,175
I don't know what to think anymore.
15
00:00:27,269 --> 00:00:29,510
I told myself I wouldn't come
until I found your killer.
16
00:00:29,629 --> 00:00:31,590
I swear to you I'll find them.
17
00:00:34,416 --> 00:00:35,582
The moment I was accused
18
00:00:35,619 --> 00:00:37,158
of Rosemary Lynch's murder,
19
00:00:37,195 --> 00:00:39,848
the world saw me as a different person.
20
00:00:40,228 --> 00:00:42,820
I wasn't Madeline Scott
anymore. I was someone else.
21
00:00:42,881 --> 00:00:45,482
(indistinct chatter)
22
00:00:46,009 --> 00:00:47,973
I was the party girl,
23
00:00:48,010 --> 00:00:50,351
the sex maniac, a killer.
24
00:00:50,525 --> 00:00:51,996
(buzzer blares)
25
00:00:52,767 --> 00:00:53,832
Hi.
26
00:00:53,869 --> 00:00:55,197
I was also the innocent victim.
27
00:00:55,234 --> 00:00:56,236
- Thanks.
- Hi.
28
00:00:56,273 --> 00:00:59,237
The wrongly accused,
the girl in trouble.
29
00:01:00,348 --> 00:01:02,279
(grunting)
30
00:01:05,396 --> 00:01:08,789
But however they saw me,
inside I felt the same.
31
00:01:09,200 --> 00:01:11,974
Eventually, the inside changed, too.
32
00:01:12,445 --> 00:01:14,958
When you live day to day
behind prison bars,
33
00:01:15,064 --> 00:01:17,415
you begin to forget who you are.
34
00:01:18,958 --> 00:01:21,700
- You lose yourself.
- (door closes, lock clicks)
35
00:01:22,349 --> 00:01:26,089
One day, you realize
you've become something else.
36
00:01:26,536 --> 00:01:29,685
Well, the Madeline Scott
that I know and love,
37
00:01:29,722 --> 00:01:32,856
she's fierce,
inside the courtroom and out.
38
00:01:33,857 --> 00:01:36,984
Every wrongfully accused person
faces the same challenge.
39
00:01:37,078 --> 00:01:40,146
How do we stop letting others
define who we are?
40
00:01:40,347 --> 00:01:41,583
Thank you, Pastor,
41
00:01:41,620 --> 00:01:43,177
for that lovely sermon.
42
00:01:43,255 --> 00:01:45,159
It was very inspirational.
43
00:01:45,196 --> 00:01:47,130
For some more than others. (chuckles)
44
00:01:47,193 --> 00:01:49,130
Michael's in a world
of his own sometimes.
45
00:01:49,205 --> 00:01:52,091
The boy is 14 years old.
We both know what that means.
46
00:01:52,128 --> 00:01:54,185
- (light laughter)
- Ezekiel,
47
00:01:54,222 --> 00:01:56,172
can I have a private word with you?
48
00:01:58,279 --> 00:01:59,911
How old was William in this picture?
49
00:01:59,948 --> 00:02:01,377
He'd just turned 14.
50
00:02:01,414 --> 00:02:04,019
- Same age as your boy.
- You don't say.
51
00:02:04,056 --> 00:02:06,706
William is 19 now, a gifted young man
52
00:02:06,743 --> 00:02:08,510
and still a person of faith.
53
00:02:08,547 --> 00:02:10,894
When Patricia joined the church
a few months back,
54
00:02:10,946 --> 00:02:12,111
I started to visit him.
55
00:02:12,148 --> 00:02:14,275
The pastor has been a godsend.
56
00:02:14,428 --> 00:02:17,320
I-I still can't believe
any of this is real.
57
00:02:17,417 --> 00:02:19,297
Two days after that picture was taken,
58
00:02:19,334 --> 00:02:20,836
William was arrested for murder.
59
00:02:20,968 --> 00:02:22,609
They locked him up for life.
60
00:02:22,707 --> 00:02:25,533
Tried him as an adult
because he looked like an adult.
61
00:02:25,570 --> 00:02:27,061
It happens all the time.
62
00:02:27,219 --> 00:02:29,055
When a judge sees
what he thinks is a man
63
00:02:29,092 --> 00:02:30,650
in his courtroom,
he treats him like one.
64
00:02:30,748 --> 00:02:33,591
My nephew didn't shoot
any liquor store owner.
65
00:02:33,750 --> 00:02:36,372
William has been suffering
in prison for five years.
66
00:02:36,467 --> 00:02:38,815
He's lost all hope, Ezekiel.
67
00:02:38,945 --> 00:02:40,608
We need you.
68
00:02:42,488 --> 00:02:45,022
Why don't you start by telling
me how all this happened.
69
00:02:45,139 --> 00:02:47,325
Well, that's the crazy part.
70
00:02:47,482 --> 00:02:49,774
William confessed.
71
00:02:56,420 --> 00:02:58,120
So...
72
00:02:58,566 --> 00:03:00,837
the police asked for your help.
73
00:03:04,056 --> 00:03:05,470
And you had the gun that killed
74
00:03:05,507 --> 00:03:07,341
the liquor store owner in your bedroom?
75
00:03:08,873 --> 00:03:10,503
Rabbit gave it to me.
76
00:03:11,074 --> 00:03:13,709
Rabbit. Does he have a last name?
77
00:03:18,550 --> 00:03:20,813
He looks like this, though.
78
00:03:24,768 --> 00:03:26,841
This is incredible.
79
00:03:32,944 --> 00:03:34,944
These are amazing.
80
00:03:37,334 --> 00:03:39,283
He's called Soul Brother.
81
00:03:39,459 --> 00:03:41,186
It's about an archangel
who saves humanity
82
00:03:41,223 --> 00:03:42,506
but still can't get a cab.
83
00:03:42,543 --> 00:03:44,084
(chuckles)
84
00:03:45,774 --> 00:03:47,665
Yeah, I feel that.
85
00:03:48,045 --> 00:03:50,251
So, did you tell the police
about Rabbit?
86
00:03:55,037 --> 00:03:57,085
They said I made him up.
87
00:03:57,280 --> 00:03:58,631
They said lots of stuff,
88
00:03:58,668 --> 00:04:00,444
(echoing): but none of it's true.
89
00:04:00,481 --> 00:04:02,201
I don't know what you want me to say.
90
00:04:03,083 --> 00:04:05,273
How about starting with the truth?
91
00:04:07,380 --> 00:04:09,806
Pastor White said you get people
out of jail.
92
00:04:10,111 --> 00:04:11,585
We both do.
93
00:04:12,147 --> 00:04:14,466
We don't always win,
but we do our best.
94
00:04:14,858 --> 00:04:16,945
You'll do God's will.
95
00:04:17,307 --> 00:04:19,437
WILLIAM and EASY:
And that will be good enough.
96
00:04:24,201 --> 00:04:26,213
We'll do our best for you, William.
97
00:04:44,193 --> 00:04:46,138
William got railroaded.
98
00:04:46,208 --> 00:04:49,161
We need to take this case apart
piece by piece,
99
00:04:49,198 --> 00:04:51,007
starting with the confession.
100
00:04:51,357 --> 00:04:53,161
He was only 14 years old,
101
00:04:53,198 --> 00:04:54,732
and the police questioned him
for 20 hours.
102
00:04:54,769 --> 00:04:56,326
Where was his aunt during all of this?
103
00:04:56,363 --> 00:04:58,732
Working three jobs.
She consented to an interview
104
00:04:58,769 --> 00:05:00,292
that became an interrogation.
105
00:05:00,356 --> 00:05:01,880
She didn't even know he was a suspect.
106
00:05:01,917 --> 00:05:03,149
So no lawyers.
107
00:05:03,186 --> 00:05:05,099
And no physical evidence
of him at the scene,
108
00:05:05,136 --> 00:05:06,787
and no testimony putting him there.
109
00:05:06,826 --> 00:05:08,586
Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa.
Huge problem, though.
110
00:05:08,623 --> 00:05:10,222
The murder weapon was found
in his bedroom.
111
00:05:10,259 --> 00:05:13,396
Given to him by a guy called Rabbit.
112
00:05:13,485 --> 00:05:15,559
Now, William only turned
the gun over to the police
113
00:05:15,596 --> 00:05:17,645
because he thought he was helping them.
114
00:05:17,682 --> 00:05:20,006
We need to find grounds
to get this back in court.
115
00:05:20,068 --> 00:05:22,373
Well, we should eviscerate
defense counsel.
116
00:05:22,467 --> 00:05:24,891
William's murder trial
lasted only one day.
117
00:05:25,046 --> 00:05:27,047
I've had dental work
that lasted longer than that.
118
00:05:27,566 --> 00:05:29,733
Jury deliberation took four days.
119
00:05:29,921 --> 00:05:31,161
Must have been a holdout.
120
00:05:31,255 --> 00:05:32,755
We need to track down that jury.
121
00:05:33,570 --> 00:05:35,078
Vi?
122
00:05:36,171 --> 00:05:38,374
Not Radcliff the Madcliff.
123
00:05:38,483 --> 00:05:41,187
- Is that a person?
- He's the jury administrator.
124
00:05:41,224 --> 00:05:42,880
He's been asking me out for six months.
125
00:05:43,008 --> 00:05:45,279
So what's the problem? You're on
dating apps all the time.
126
00:05:45,316 --> 00:05:46,763
There are many problems with Radcliff.
127
00:05:46,800 --> 00:05:49,226
He has 50 birds, for starters.
128
00:05:49,263 --> 00:05:52,525
Violet... it's only one date.
129
00:05:52,693 --> 00:05:55,935
It's the fastest way to find out
who the holdout juror is.
130
00:05:56,640 --> 00:05:58,122
Fine.
131
00:05:58,231 --> 00:06:00,214
But you people owe me.
132
00:06:02,177 --> 00:06:04,685
Hey, Radcliff, it's Violet.
133
00:06:04,722 --> 00:06:06,684
- About that date.
- RADCLIFF (on phone): Really?
134
00:06:06,789 --> 00:06:08,914
I just need a little favor.
135
00:06:09,242 --> 00:06:11,698
I was the holdout on the jury.
136
00:06:11,786 --> 00:06:13,971
William seemed like a good kid.
137
00:06:14,044 --> 00:06:16,725
There was something sweet about him.
138
00:06:16,911 --> 00:06:19,007
He was scared. Overwhelmed.
139
00:06:19,177 --> 00:06:20,794
What made you change your mind?
140
00:06:20,895 --> 00:06:23,286
The foreman would bring in
the newspaper every day.
141
00:06:23,323 --> 00:06:26,348
They were running a series
on the man he shot,
142
00:06:26,385 --> 00:06:28,237
Wan Lee Kim.
143
00:06:28,559 --> 00:06:30,106
It was awful.
144
00:06:30,143 --> 00:06:31,473
Did this influence your vote?
145
00:06:31,510 --> 00:06:32,726
Absolutely.
146
00:06:32,888 --> 00:06:36,046
After I read it, I voted to convict.
147
00:06:36,427 --> 00:06:37,755
Thank you.
148
00:06:37,833 --> 00:06:39,810
Your Honor, this is clearly
jury misconduct.
149
00:06:39,879 --> 00:06:41,162
Indeed.
150
00:06:41,209 --> 00:06:44,904
I hereby find reversible error
in the original trial.
151
00:06:44,941 --> 00:06:46,969
Mr. Hurston is granted a new trial.
152
00:06:47,006 --> 00:06:49,273
Let's get it right this time.
153
00:06:50,931 --> 00:06:52,405
We're just getting started.
154
00:06:52,442 --> 00:06:54,750
This is a step in the right direction.
155
00:06:55,455 --> 00:06:57,997
If you say so, Mr. Boudreau.
156
00:06:58,995 --> 00:07:01,967
I can't believe I agreed
to go out with Radcliff.
157
00:07:02,529 --> 00:07:04,672
- Did I mention birds?
- Hey, who knows...
158
00:07:04,709 --> 00:07:05,976
you may discover you love birds.
159
00:07:06,013 --> 00:07:08,179
(laughing): Or get avian flu.
160
00:07:10,023 --> 00:07:13,079
Maybe I should date question mark guy.
161
00:07:13,539 --> 00:07:15,663
He is such a hottie.
162
00:07:16,875 --> 00:07:18,851
- Who is he?
- Jim something.
163
00:07:18,888 --> 00:07:21,179
Rosemary dated him
the summer before she died.
164
00:07:21,984 --> 00:07:25,043
I broke up with Jim,
and he showed up at Stanford,
165
00:07:25,080 --> 00:07:26,246
like a stalker.
166
00:07:26,283 --> 00:07:28,631
(echoing): It was so creepy.
167
00:07:29,481 --> 00:07:30,839
It ended badly.
168
00:07:30,876 --> 00:07:33,534
Well, it seems like he should've
been the main suspect.
169
00:07:33,594 --> 00:07:35,446
Why didn't anybody find him?
170
00:07:35,535 --> 00:07:37,441
Oh, my original lawyer
searched every town
171
00:07:37,478 --> 00:07:38,781
within a hundred miles.
172
00:07:38,917 --> 00:07:40,378
Maybe we should try again.
173
00:07:40,472 --> 00:07:43,776
No, I don't have a last name,
description.
174
00:07:44,394 --> 00:07:45,706
Nothing.
175
00:07:45,792 --> 00:07:47,238
I bet I can dig something up.
176
00:07:47,316 --> 00:07:49,156
Yeah, have at it.
177
00:07:56,291 --> 00:07:58,207
You looking for this?
178
00:08:00,019 --> 00:08:03,129
Carlos Rafael Gomez, aged 22.
179
00:08:03,247 --> 00:08:05,210
His face looks just like yours.
180
00:08:05,308 --> 00:08:06,794
Where'd you get this?
181
00:08:06,902 --> 00:08:08,785
Jared knows this guy.
182
00:08:08,830 --> 00:08:09,832
Do you know how much trouble
183
00:08:09,869 --> 00:08:11,144
you'd get into if you got caught?
184
00:08:11,206 --> 00:08:13,179
You get arrested,
thrown into the system,
185
00:08:13,216 --> 00:08:15,598
life as you know it would be over.
186
00:08:15,863 --> 00:08:18,311
- I-I didn't even...
- You don't get it, do you?
187
00:08:18,542 --> 00:08:20,340
You're a black boy living in Chicago.
188
00:08:20,377 --> 00:08:23,097
You got a target on your back
the moment you leave this house.
189
00:08:23,175 --> 00:08:25,003
So now you're officially grounded.
190
00:08:25,099 --> 00:08:27,300
What? For how long?
191
00:08:27,337 --> 00:08:29,966
You can't see that far into the future.
192
00:08:30,325 --> 00:08:31,721
(scoffs)
193
00:08:33,345 --> 00:08:34,886
(door slams)
194
00:08:39,376 --> 00:08:40,869
Hey, maybe this Rabbit will just
195
00:08:40,906 --> 00:08:42,962
hop out of his hole and just confess.
196
00:08:42,999 --> 00:08:44,406
We got to find him first.
197
00:08:44,443 --> 00:08:45,534
Yeah, we're trying.
198
00:08:45,571 --> 00:08:47,283
Meantime, we could go after
the detectives
199
00:08:47,320 --> 00:08:48,655
who coerced William's confession.
200
00:08:48,692 --> 00:08:51,830
The arresting officer
is a Detective Joe Folino.
201
00:08:51,898 --> 00:08:53,815
- Damn it.
- Crap.
202
00:08:53,908 --> 00:08:55,079
Am I missing something?
203
00:08:55,119 --> 00:08:57,099
He's a jerk, but juries love him.
204
00:09:00,372 --> 00:09:02,330
(quiet chatter)
205
00:09:04,044 --> 00:09:05,723
What the hell?
206
00:09:08,711 --> 00:09:10,029
What are you doing here?
207
00:09:10,066 --> 00:09:11,328
Hello, Madeline.
208
00:09:11,383 --> 00:09:13,718
Just couldn't pass up a chance
to dance with you again.
209
00:09:13,755 --> 00:09:16,222
Should be fun. I'll lead.
210
00:09:25,727 --> 00:09:27,352
The kid confessed.
211
00:09:27,440 --> 00:09:30,216
Detective Folino, do people sometimes
212
00:09:30,253 --> 00:09:32,680
falsely confess to crimes
they did not commit?
213
00:09:32,717 --> 00:09:36,089
Sure. And some people fake it
in the sack, too,
214
00:09:36,126 --> 00:09:37,571
but, uh, I've been doing it long enough
215
00:09:37,608 --> 00:09:39,558
- to know the difference.
- (quiet laughter)
216
00:09:39,677 --> 00:09:41,339
So you have no concerns?
217
00:09:41,376 --> 00:09:43,913
I have zero concerns
about this confession.
218
00:09:43,950 --> 00:09:45,633
Zero. He's the killer.
219
00:09:45,791 --> 00:09:47,410
Nothing further.
220
00:09:49,405 --> 00:09:51,116
Confessions are typically confirmed
221
00:09:51,153 --> 00:09:53,523
using a written statement
or a videotape.
222
00:09:53,905 --> 00:09:55,464
Why wasn't that done for William?
223
00:09:55,538 --> 00:09:58,429
I videotaped him,
but the file got corrupted.
224
00:09:58,466 --> 00:10:00,524
So you have no proof of a confession?
225
00:10:00,561 --> 00:10:03,153
The defendant led me straight
to the murder weapon,
226
00:10:03,418 --> 00:10:04,940
hidden in his bedroom.
227
00:10:05,015 --> 00:10:06,977
Now, when you questioned
William, he told you who
228
00:10:07,004 --> 00:10:08,244
- gave him that gun, didn't he?
- Yeah.
229
00:10:08,280 --> 00:10:10,038
- He said it was a rabbit.
- Uh, he said
230
00:10:10,075 --> 00:10:11,359
it was someone nicknamed Rabbit.
231
00:10:11,406 --> 00:10:12,695
Yeah, but I don't know no Rabbit,
232
00:10:12,732 --> 00:10:14,390
so obviously, the defendant was lying.
233
00:10:14,427 --> 00:10:16,402
No. You were lying, weren't you?
234
00:10:16,584 --> 00:10:19,385
You told him you needed his help
finding the real killer.
235
00:10:19,422 --> 00:10:21,313
You never told him he was a suspect.
236
00:10:21,428 --> 00:10:24,404
How does it feel deceiving
a 14-year-old boy?
237
00:10:24,441 --> 00:10:26,311
Objection. Counsel is badgering.
238
00:10:26,348 --> 00:10:29,235
Sustained. Are we about done,
Mr. Boudreau?
239
00:10:29,272 --> 00:10:30,780
Yes, Your Honor.
240
00:10:33,881 --> 00:10:35,334
We should put William on the stand.
241
00:10:35,371 --> 00:10:38,146
No. I'm not exposing him to Bellows.
242
00:10:38,295 --> 00:10:41,490
He'll force William to admit to
his confession, and we'll lose.
243
00:10:41,527 --> 00:10:43,060
No dice on the wascally wabbit.
244
00:10:43,097 --> 00:10:44,337
I canvassed the whole neighborhood,
245
00:10:44,374 --> 00:10:46,349
and no one's heard of him
or they're not talking.
246
00:10:46,386 --> 00:10:47,913
Well, he's got to be somewhere.
247
00:10:48,026 --> 00:10:49,767
William didn't just make him up.
248
00:10:49,862 --> 00:10:51,037
Find him.
249
00:10:51,074 --> 00:10:52,521
Yeah, man.
That's what I'm trying to do.
250
00:10:52,558 --> 00:10:53,752
We will find him.
251
00:10:53,789 --> 00:10:56,654
But first, we need to verify
William's alibi.
252
00:10:56,754 --> 00:10:58,787
This photo was taken on the day
of the murder.
253
00:10:58,899 --> 00:11:00,734
If we can establish a time of day...
254
00:11:00,771 --> 00:11:02,020
Let me see that.
255
00:11:04,335 --> 00:11:06,132
That's Brainiac Comics on Damen Avenue.
256
00:11:06,169 --> 00:11:07,205
They're open 10:00 to 4:00,
257
00:11:07,242 --> 00:11:08,522
except for Wednesdays and Saturdays,
258
00:11:08,558 --> 00:11:10,408
which is new comic release day.
259
00:11:11,460 --> 00:11:12,716
Closet geek.
260
00:11:12,761 --> 00:11:15,820
- But too good for the bird guy?
- Comic books are not birds.
261
00:11:15,857 --> 00:11:17,249
Great!
262
00:11:18,039 --> 00:11:19,713
Track down the owner.
263
00:11:25,458 --> 00:11:27,148
What's up with Boudreau?
264
00:11:27,731 --> 00:11:29,450
Why is he so cranky?
265
00:11:30,005 --> 00:11:31,895
Doesn't want to let down William.
266
00:11:32,035 --> 00:11:33,726
Or his church.
267
00:11:34,360 --> 00:11:36,693
(engine revving)
268
00:11:40,942 --> 00:11:43,305
Hey! I just reached the next circuit.
269
00:11:43,342 --> 00:11:45,166
And you just reached my last nerve.
270
00:11:45,272 --> 00:11:46,949
Grounded means no video games.
271
00:11:46,996 --> 00:11:48,324
(quietly): Yeah, whatever.
272
00:11:48,426 --> 00:11:50,642
- Excuse me?
- Nothing.
273
00:11:50,748 --> 00:11:52,990
Oh, you think you a man now?
274
00:11:53,449 --> 00:11:56,715
Fake IDs, impressing
your friends buying beers.
275
00:11:56,754 --> 00:11:59,180
- You know, when I was your age...
- I know, I know.
276
00:11:59,242 --> 00:12:00,981
You got in trouble, got beat up,
277
00:12:01,018 --> 00:12:03,270
but then you found God.
Look, I'm not you.
278
00:12:03,307 --> 00:12:05,128
Hey, you ain't gonna be
disrespecting me, homey.
279
00:12:05,264 --> 00:12:06,712
Now, this is my house.
280
00:12:06,770 --> 00:12:09,168
You do as I say,
or you can get the hell out.
281
00:12:09,246 --> 00:12:11,126
That's fine with me.
282
00:12:14,549 --> 00:12:17,633
(upbeat jazz playing)
283
00:12:28,340 --> 00:12:29,926
- Thank you.
- Thank you.
284
00:12:29,963 --> 00:12:31,674
So, um... so, tell me something.
285
00:12:31,711 --> 00:12:34,363
How's the, uh... how's the trial going?
286
00:12:34,400 --> 00:12:36,100
- (sighs) Awful.
- Yeah?
287
00:12:36,434 --> 00:12:38,848
Every time I see Bellows,
I want to jam my pen in his eye.
288
00:12:38,885 --> 00:12:39,957
Oh, God.
289
00:12:39,994 --> 00:12:41,410
(both laugh)
290
00:12:41,654 --> 00:12:43,896
Sorry, I know you were
just asking to be polite.
291
00:12:43,969 --> 00:12:45,473
It's okay.
292
00:12:45,838 --> 00:12:48,156
The truth is refreshing
when you're dating someone.
293
00:12:49,746 --> 00:12:51,491
(both laugh)
294
00:12:51,762 --> 00:12:53,085
We're dating?
295
00:12:53,122 --> 00:12:55,613
Well, you know,
we're out on a date, so yeah.
296
00:12:55,754 --> 00:12:57,684
Okay, note to self: she doesn't
like the word "dating."
297
00:12:57,721 --> 00:13:00,072
(laughs) No, no, it's...
298
00:13:01,254 --> 00:13:03,652
It's not that, I just, um...
299
00:13:04,770 --> 00:13:06,323
I never learned how to do this.
300
00:13:06,371 --> 00:13:08,473
I didn't get to go to college
and fumble around
301
00:13:08,510 --> 00:13:10,020
like everyone else.
302
00:13:10,194 --> 00:13:13,793
You've been out for what...
been out... six years?
303
00:13:15,050 --> 00:13:17,051
There's more to you,
there's more to your identity
304
00:13:17,088 --> 00:13:18,696
- than just prison.
- (piece ends)
305
00:13:19,520 --> 00:13:21,804
- There is, huh?
- (scattered applause)
306
00:13:22,097 --> 00:13:23,533
And what would that be?
307
00:13:23,570 --> 00:13:25,160
I don't know.
308
00:13:25,934 --> 00:13:27,410
But I'm hoping to find out.
309
00:13:27,680 --> 00:13:30,748
(band playing mid-tempo song)
310
00:13:34,420 --> 00:13:36,121
Dance?
311
00:13:36,744 --> 00:13:38,590
Or don't you dance, either?
312
00:13:59,031 --> 00:14:00,598
(chuckles)
313
00:14:13,262 --> 00:14:14,912
I should go.
314
00:14:32,395 --> 00:14:34,443
- (applause) -Thank you all
so much for coming out today.
315
00:14:34,519 --> 00:14:37,428
- I'm Madeline Scott, and it is my...
- (whooping, cheering)
316
00:14:37,883 --> 00:14:40,434
Thank you. Thank you.
317
00:14:40,576 --> 00:14:43,511
And it is my privilege and my honor
318
00:14:43,531 --> 00:14:47,599
to announce the candidacy
and my wholehearted support
319
00:14:47,636 --> 00:14:49,854
of Evan Esteban-Miller
320
00:14:49,891 --> 00:14:51,757
for the attorney general of Illinois!
321
00:14:51,860 --> 00:14:53,318
(applause, whooping)
322
00:14:53,943 --> 00:14:56,099
Unlike his opponent, Gore Bellows,
323
00:14:56,240 --> 00:14:58,802
Evan is a talented, fair-minded,
324
00:14:58,857 --> 00:15:01,213
successful trial lawyer.
325
00:15:01,331 --> 00:15:02,583
Gore Bellows' prosecutions
326
00:15:02,620 --> 00:15:04,444
- are corrupt, and he has...
- (click)
327
00:15:05,029 --> 00:15:07,544
I expect you to stab me in the
back, Susan, but in the front?
328
00:15:07,581 --> 00:15:09,076
Oh, grow up, Gore.
329
00:15:09,133 --> 00:15:10,951
I had her on the show
because she gets ratings.
330
00:15:10,988 --> 00:15:13,541
Not news. She's only
doing it to get to me.
331
00:15:13,602 --> 00:15:14,857
Well, hell hath no fury
332
00:15:14,894 --> 00:15:17,099
like a woman wrongfully
imprisoned for a decade.
333
00:15:17,136 --> 00:15:18,472
You don't know the evidence.
334
00:15:18,755 --> 00:15:19,813
She and her brother
335
00:15:19,850 --> 00:15:21,792
killed that girl,
and now they're both free.
336
00:15:22,292 --> 00:15:23,888
So, what do you want?
337
00:15:24,021 --> 00:15:25,685
Besides the pleasure of your company?
338
00:15:25,740 --> 00:15:28,844
- Oh, my. Are we flirting?
- Is it working?
339
00:15:28,907 --> 00:15:30,909
The charm thing does not work on me.
340
00:15:30,986 --> 00:15:32,260
Now, tell me what you want
341
00:15:32,297 --> 00:15:34,605
and, more significantly,
how it benefits me.
342
00:15:34,642 --> 00:15:36,961
Equal time, and...
343
00:15:37,020 --> 00:15:38,572
the Marquez trial's coming up.
344
00:15:38,609 --> 00:15:40,228
I'll give you exclusive access.
345
00:15:40,355 --> 00:15:42,589
You'll still have to respond
to Madeline Scott's attacks.
346
00:15:42,626 --> 00:15:43,997
No Madeline, no airtime.
347
00:15:44,115 --> 00:15:46,118
It just so happens I have
an idea that will bring me
348
00:15:46,155 --> 00:15:48,018
in direct conflict with Madeline Scott.
349
00:15:48,095 --> 00:15:50,314
Are you talking about
the liquor store murder trial?
350
00:15:50,395 --> 00:15:51,876
It's good,
but you're gonna have to do better
351
00:15:51,912 --> 00:15:52,830
than that for my show.
352
00:15:52,867 --> 00:15:54,895
Rosemary Lynch's parents.
353
00:15:55,231 --> 00:15:57,668
I'm gonna use them in a new
campaign for victims' rights.
354
00:15:57,707 --> 00:15:59,161
Once they're
front and center with me...
355
00:15:59,198 --> 00:16:02,333
- I can bring up Madeline Scott.
- And remind your audience
356
00:16:02,370 --> 00:16:03,955
that the only reason she's famous
357
00:16:04,169 --> 00:16:06,164
is because she murdered
an innocent girl.
358
00:16:06,331 --> 00:16:08,048
(exhales softly)
359
00:16:09,533 --> 00:16:10,991
That's hot.
360
00:16:13,779 --> 00:16:15,954
State of Illinois v. Levi Scott.
361
00:16:16,114 --> 00:16:17,289
Mr. Scott,
362
00:16:17,326 --> 00:16:18,985
- you finally joined us.
- Your Honor,
363
00:16:19,022 --> 00:16:20,344
my client consents
364
00:16:20,381 --> 00:16:22,352
to the plea arrangement agreed
upon with the prosecution.
365
00:16:22,389 --> 00:16:24,484
- The plea is off the table.
- What?
366
00:16:24,521 --> 00:16:27,090
Mr. Duncan, I am not fond
of these kinds of maneuvers.
367
00:16:27,218 --> 00:16:29,715
I'm aware, Your Honor,
but new evidence has surfaced.
368
00:16:29,810 --> 00:16:32,252
A sworn affidavit
from the complaining witness,
369
00:16:32,289 --> 00:16:33,789
Heather Husband.
370
00:16:33,866 --> 00:16:35,328
She asserts that the defendant
371
00:16:35,365 --> 00:16:37,534
took a swing at them
with a baseball bat.
372
00:16:37,625 --> 00:16:38,906
(grunts)
373
00:16:38,943 --> 00:16:41,038
- No, Brian came at me.
- Mr. Scott.
374
00:16:41,075 --> 00:16:42,795
- (whispers): Levi.
- We're amending our complaint
375
00:16:42,832 --> 00:16:44,256
to assault with a deadly weapon.
376
00:16:44,375 --> 00:16:46,570
In light of Mr. Scott's
prior drug arrests,
377
00:16:46,607 --> 00:16:49,332
we will be seeking the
maximum of 25 years in prison.
378
00:16:49,422 --> 00:16:52,322
Your Honor, this is outrageous.
The State's amended complaint
379
00:16:52,359 --> 00:16:54,051
creates new facts out of thin air.
380
00:16:54,482 --> 00:16:56,398
You can dispute those facts
at the trial.
381
00:16:56,435 --> 00:16:58,575
We're moving forward. Next case.
382
00:16:58,669 --> 00:17:01,497
Maddie, I can't go to prison.
I can't. I will die in there.
383
00:17:01,590 --> 00:17:03,020
What happens if we go to prison?
384
00:17:03,065 --> 00:17:05,332
Okay? I can't do it! I can't!
385
00:17:07,253 --> 00:17:09,695
State of Illinois v. Conway.
386
00:17:09,934 --> 00:17:11,568
You're a lying bitch.
387
00:17:11,817 --> 00:17:13,092
Great defense.
388
00:17:13,168 --> 00:17:15,403
Did they teach you that
in law school or in prison?
389
00:17:15,440 --> 00:17:17,535
BRIAN (chuckling): Good one, babe.
390
00:17:27,043 --> 00:17:29,113
Hurston, up against the wall. Now.
391
00:17:30,229 --> 00:17:33,426
Hey, hey, hey, hey!
Don't touch my drawings!
392
00:17:33,463 --> 00:17:34,785
This all looks like contraband.
393
00:17:34,822 --> 00:17:36,446
We're gonna have to confiscate this.
394
00:17:36,581 --> 00:17:38,176
It's all I got!
395
00:17:38,322 --> 00:17:40,288
(grunts) Get off me!
396
00:17:40,868 --> 00:17:43,060
(grunting and groaning)
397
00:17:45,823 --> 00:17:47,624
(coughs)
398
00:17:49,661 --> 00:17:51,942
A search of inmate
Hurston's cell uncovered
399
00:17:51,969 --> 00:17:53,840
some hand-drawn artwork.
400
00:17:53,950 --> 00:17:56,981
The images are violent, alarming.
401
00:17:57,207 --> 00:17:59,212
What do the drawings of William Hurston
402
00:17:59,249 --> 00:18:00,734
reveal about his psyche?
403
00:18:00,801 --> 00:18:02,066
Well, as you can see,
404
00:18:02,103 --> 00:18:04,317
he's obsessively drawn the same event
405
00:18:04,354 --> 00:18:06,664
- over and over again.
- No, no! (screams)
406
00:18:06,957 --> 00:18:08,550
Is that an admission of guilt?
407
00:18:08,587 --> 00:18:10,866
Objection. Calls for speculation.
408
00:18:11,000 --> 00:18:13,051
Dr. Gregson is not
just the prison warden.
409
00:18:13,088 --> 00:18:16,663
He is also an expert in
forensic evaluation of inmates.
410
00:18:16,958 --> 00:18:19,689
He is here to provide
his expert opinion.
411
00:18:19,726 --> 00:18:21,887
Overruled. Go ahead, Dr. Gregson.
412
00:18:21,935 --> 00:18:25,458
A compulsion to reenact a crime
is a way of dealing with guilt.
413
00:18:25,495 --> 00:18:27,347
To a reasonable degree
of medical certainty,
414
00:18:27,384 --> 00:18:29,814
these drawings are tantamount
to another confession
415
00:18:29,851 --> 00:18:31,460
to killing Mr. Kim.
416
00:18:31,667 --> 00:18:33,500
Nothing further.
417
00:18:34,411 --> 00:18:37,060
Isn't it also reasonable
to assume that these drawings
418
00:18:37,097 --> 00:18:39,314
are a product of William's imagination?
419
00:18:39,411 --> 00:18:41,444
The level of detail suggests otherwise.
420
00:18:41,481 --> 00:18:42,531
Really?
421
00:18:42,575 --> 00:18:45,364
Because in this drawing,
William is holding
422
00:18:45,401 --> 00:18:48,042
a sharp Afro pick
that looks about two feet long.
423
00:18:48,079 --> 00:18:51,323
And in this drawing, he has wings.
424
00:18:51,503 --> 00:18:54,425
So, are you saying
that William had wings
425
00:18:54,462 --> 00:18:57,412
and carried an Afro pick when he
allegedly committed this crime?
426
00:18:57,503 --> 00:18:59,509
- Of course not.
- William has spent
427
00:18:59,792 --> 00:19:02,116
five years in prison.
428
00:19:02,163 --> 00:19:04,295
Isn't it possible that he thinks daily
429
00:19:04,332 --> 00:19:06,006
about the charges that put him there,
430
00:19:06,043 --> 00:19:09,253
and that all this is just an
exploration of that injustice?
431
00:19:09,290 --> 00:19:10,673
I suppose it's possible, but...
432
00:19:10,710 --> 00:19:12,798
And so wouldn't that
actually make these drawings
433
00:19:12,835 --> 00:19:14,633
the opposite of a confession?
434
00:19:14,751 --> 00:19:16,170
Objection. Argumentative.
435
00:19:16,207 --> 00:19:18,538
Withdrawn. Nothing further.
436
00:19:24,818 --> 00:19:26,381
Yo, Rabbit. I'm...
437
00:19:26,473 --> 00:19:28,075
(grunts)
438
00:19:29,108 --> 00:19:30,526
I'm not a cop!
439
00:19:40,056 --> 00:19:42,241
Rabbit! I'm not a cop.
440
00:20:10,618 --> 00:20:12,249
I'm sorry, man. I just...
441
00:20:12,485 --> 00:20:13,917
I can't run anymore.
442
00:20:14,791 --> 00:20:17,212
I'm not here to arrest you.
I'm not a cop, Rabbit.
443
00:20:17,399 --> 00:20:18,449
Rabbit?
444
00:20:18,486 --> 00:20:20,497
Sorry, I-I don't know your real name.
445
00:20:21,178 --> 00:20:22,895
Rabbit was my brother.
446
00:20:22,989 --> 00:20:24,781
He got shot in Fuller Park.
447
00:20:24,881 --> 00:20:26,506
He died a year ago.
448
00:20:32,465 --> 00:20:34,394
Mr. and Mrs. Lynch,
I can't tell you how much
449
00:20:34,431 --> 00:20:37,576
I appreciate you coming down
here on this important issue.
450
00:20:37,927 --> 00:20:39,867
So you want to create a new law
451
00:20:39,945 --> 00:20:42,092
- for victims' rights?
- Exactly.
452
00:20:42,154 --> 00:20:44,324
We intend to introduce legislation
453
00:20:44,361 --> 00:20:45,849
that makes it more difficult
454
00:20:45,886 --> 00:20:49,370
for guilty people like Madeline
and Levi Scott to be exonerated.
455
00:20:49,446 --> 00:20:53,240
I was told you had new evidence
in Rosemary's investigation.
456
00:20:53,304 --> 00:20:56,224
Well, no new evidence, per se,
457
00:20:56,396 --> 00:20:58,990
but we want to apply
the same rigors to her case.
458
00:20:59,027 --> 00:21:01,416
So we're just here for you to use us
459
00:21:01,453 --> 00:21:03,240
to score political points?
460
00:21:04,154 --> 00:21:05,744
Thank you...
461
00:21:05,792 --> 00:21:07,482
- but no, thank you.
- Mr. Lynch,
462
00:21:07,519 --> 00:21:09,107
you don't need to...
463
00:21:09,373 --> 00:21:11,833
Charles and I divorced
several years ago.
464
00:21:12,688 --> 00:21:14,365
Please continue.
465
00:21:15,193 --> 00:21:18,763
It is my hope to name
the bill after your daughter
466
00:21:18,807 --> 00:21:21,427
and that you will help advocate
for its passage.
467
00:21:21,580 --> 00:21:24,766
I want the world to remember
the name Rosemary Lynch.
468
00:21:25,240 --> 00:21:27,415
I'll do anything I can to help you.
469
00:21:27,717 --> 00:21:31,638
You might not want to attack
Madeline and Levi directly.
470
00:21:31,717 --> 00:21:33,588
Charles thinks they're innocent,
471
00:21:33,665 --> 00:21:35,498
and he might oppose the bill if you do.
472
00:21:35,638 --> 00:21:37,482
What do you think, Mrs. Lynch?
473
00:21:37,553 --> 00:21:39,779
I think they're guilty as hell.
474
00:21:49,639 --> 00:21:51,323
Hey, I just jaywalked.
Are you gonna arrest me?
475
00:21:51,974 --> 00:21:53,599
What do you want, Bodie?
476
00:21:53,701 --> 00:21:55,535
Dinner, foreplay.
477
00:21:55,848 --> 00:21:57,782
Not necessarily in that order.
478
00:21:58,210 --> 00:21:59,742
(groaning)
479
00:22:00,134 --> 00:22:01,271
Yeah?
480
00:22:01,308 --> 00:22:02,583
(groans)
481
00:22:03,086 --> 00:22:04,959
(groans loudly)
482
00:22:05,472 --> 00:22:07,092
What's for dinner?
483
00:22:07,278 --> 00:22:08,709
Coq au vin.
484
00:22:08,746 --> 00:22:10,380
- Your place?
- Your place.
485
00:22:10,589 --> 00:22:11,823
I'll bring the merlot.
486
00:22:11,928 --> 00:22:14,052
Yeah, and the handcuffs.
487
00:22:14,206 --> 00:22:15,638
I always do.
488
00:22:15,735 --> 00:22:18,114
Yeah, you do. (sighs)
489
00:22:18,271 --> 00:22:21,536
Now, before this, uh, bacchanal begins,
490
00:22:22,341 --> 00:22:23,775
I need a little favor.
491
00:22:24,294 --> 00:22:26,324
Can you help me find a Rabbit?
492
00:22:27,067 --> 00:22:28,809
Is that a sex thing?
493
00:22:29,083 --> 00:22:31,474
No, it's the name of a guy.
494
00:22:31,647 --> 00:22:32,920
I need his file.
495
00:22:32,957 --> 00:22:34,640
He died a year ago in Fuller Park.
496
00:22:34,677 --> 00:22:36,510
Well, if I do, you got to be my rabbit.
497
00:22:37,044 --> 00:22:38,745
Oh, that's definitely a sex thing.
498
00:22:47,583 --> 00:22:49,942
Hey, how are you doing
on Madeline Scott?
499
00:22:50,450 --> 00:22:53,419
Joe, you know, I'm still...
I'm still thinking on that one.
500
00:22:53,520 --> 00:22:56,003
Think faster.
This thing's starting to drag.
501
00:22:56,865 --> 00:22:58,521
If you can get her to
admit she had something
502
00:22:58,558 --> 00:23:00,205
to do with Rosemary Lynch's death,
503
00:23:00,242 --> 00:23:02,208
you'll get your pick of assignments.
504
00:23:04,009 --> 00:23:06,224
- London?
- Hey, wherever you want.
505
00:23:06,279 --> 00:23:08,279
But it's got to be good.
506
00:23:10,692 --> 00:23:13,009
Hey, I found out more
about our dead Rabbit.
507
00:23:13,046 --> 00:23:14,953
His real name is Derrick Johnston.
508
00:23:15,325 --> 00:23:16,863
And looking at his arrest record,
509
00:23:16,947 --> 00:23:18,504
I definitely think he's the shooter.
510
00:23:18,731 --> 00:23:20,888
Burglary, assault.
511
00:23:20,997 --> 00:23:22,478
The police must have never
even looked at him
512
00:23:22,514 --> 00:23:24,685
- for the liquor store murder.
- Of course not.
513
00:23:24,778 --> 00:23:26,427
How did you get the police report?
514
00:23:26,528 --> 00:23:29,271
Don't worry about it.
But wait, there's more...
515
00:23:29,380 --> 00:23:31,285
if you look at the name
of the arresting officer
516
00:23:31,346 --> 00:23:33,372
on the assault charge.
517
00:23:36,754 --> 00:23:37,906
Radcliff.
518
00:23:38,069 --> 00:23:39,544
Hi, Violet.
519
00:23:40,960 --> 00:23:43,277
Hey, you ready for our lunch?
520
00:23:46,711 --> 00:23:49,303
I-I brought along Curveball
521
00:23:49,489 --> 00:23:50,804
so you can meet him.
522
00:23:50,896 --> 00:23:52,064
Oh, you brought a bird.
523
00:23:52,101 --> 00:23:54,008
That's really adorable.
524
00:23:54,294 --> 00:23:56,185
Uh, does Curveball like baseball?
525
00:23:56,380 --> 00:23:59,071
No, I-I named him
after the double agent
526
00:23:59,190 --> 00:24:01,505
that lied to us during the Iraq War.
527
00:24:02,036 --> 00:24:03,575
His sister's Rumsfeld.
528
00:24:03,612 --> 00:24:05,111
(laughs)
529
00:24:06,185 --> 00:24:07,420
Yeah.
530
00:24:07,669 --> 00:24:09,232
I hate you.
531
00:24:09,602 --> 00:24:11,286
Let's go.
532
00:24:13,614 --> 00:24:16,460
Detective Folino,
we appreciate you coming back.
533
00:24:16,497 --> 00:24:18,067
We just have a few more questions.
534
00:24:18,192 --> 00:24:19,653
Do you recall William telling you
535
00:24:19,690 --> 00:24:23,603
someone named Rabbit gave him
the gun that shot Mr. Kim?
536
00:24:23,724 --> 00:24:26,432
And you told the court
you didn't know him?
537
00:24:26,526 --> 00:24:28,267
That's right. Never heard of him.
538
00:24:28,708 --> 00:24:31,700
Well, his real name
was Derrick Johnston.
539
00:24:31,737 --> 00:24:32,905
Have you heard of him?
540
00:24:32,942 --> 00:24:34,919
Maybe. Name sounds familiar.
541
00:24:34,982 --> 00:24:36,331
I bet it does.
542
00:24:36,560 --> 00:24:39,052
Your Honor, we'd like
to enter into the record
543
00:24:39,247 --> 00:24:42,060
an arrest report for Derrick Johnston
544
00:24:42,130 --> 00:24:44,278
on November 12, 2013.
545
00:24:44,338 --> 00:24:46,445
Assault with a deadly weapon.
546
00:24:46,609 --> 00:24:48,642
The arrest was made by the witness,
547
00:24:48,771 --> 00:24:50,896
Detective Joseph Folino.
548
00:24:50,933 --> 00:24:52,513
Now, your hand-written notes
549
00:24:52,550 --> 00:24:54,208
are on that report. Correct, Detective?
550
00:24:54,245 --> 00:24:55,951
- Correct.
- And what name did you use
551
00:24:55,988 --> 00:24:58,458
for Mr. Johnston at
the time of his arrest?
552
00:25:01,061 --> 00:25:03,043
- Rabbit.
- (gallery murmuring)
553
00:25:03,341 --> 00:25:05,825
And the date of that
arrest occurred before
554
00:25:05,862 --> 00:25:07,271
you arrested William.
555
00:25:07,739 --> 00:25:09,234
- True?
- Yes.
556
00:25:09,528 --> 00:25:11,569
So when William said Rabbit
557
00:25:11,606 --> 00:25:13,388
gave him that gun,
558
00:25:13,575 --> 00:25:16,309
you knew exactly who he was
talking about, didn't you?
559
00:25:16,347 --> 00:25:18,099
I-I don't know if I recall if I...
560
00:25:18,136 --> 00:25:19,802
But you never questioned
561
00:25:19,888 --> 00:25:21,913
a known felon.
562
00:25:22,661 --> 00:25:25,975
Look, criminals blame other
criminals when they're caught.
563
00:25:26,044 --> 00:25:28,216
That's probably why I didn't pursue it.
564
00:25:28,313 --> 00:25:30,052
The case against William was tight.
565
00:25:30,089 --> 00:25:32,442
It was tight
because you made it that way.
566
00:25:34,138 --> 00:25:36,002
By refusing to listen
567
00:25:36,039 --> 00:25:38,390
to a 14-year-old boy.
568
00:25:40,158 --> 00:25:41,942
I'm finished with this witness.
569
00:25:52,380 --> 00:25:54,988
How come you didn't testify
at the original trial?
570
00:25:55,159 --> 00:25:57,342
I didn't know it was happening.
571
00:25:57,896 --> 00:26:00,614
Afterwards, someone told me
William had shot someone.
572
00:26:00,671 --> 00:26:02,005
I was stunned.
573
00:26:02,128 --> 00:26:04,045
He was a sweet kid.
574
00:26:05,337 --> 00:26:07,488
Dave, shoo.
575
00:26:08,710 --> 00:26:11,470
The fanboys... they love me.
576
00:26:13,177 --> 00:26:14,653
Do you know anything about this?
577
00:26:14,727 --> 00:26:17,461
Sure. That's William
with Fordson Frank.
578
00:26:17,568 --> 00:26:19,247
He's a comic book legend.
579
00:26:19,364 --> 00:26:20,954
I took this picture myself.
580
00:26:21,638 --> 00:26:23,457
You did?
581
00:26:23,677 --> 00:26:25,458
Do you remember taking this photo?
582
00:26:25,495 --> 00:26:29,497
Yes. My signings were always
at the same time: 2:00 to 5:00,
583
00:26:29,567 --> 00:26:31,057
Saturday afternoons.
584
00:26:31,151 --> 00:26:32,435
I checked my calendar,
585
00:26:32,472 --> 00:26:36,114
and Fordson Frank was there
March 22, 2014.
586
00:26:36,195 --> 00:26:39,547
And Wan Lee Kim was shot
at 3:00 p.m. on that day.
587
00:26:40,036 --> 00:26:41,942
Can you say definitively
588
00:26:41,979 --> 00:26:44,536
that William was in your store
at that time?
589
00:26:44,581 --> 00:26:46,072
Absolutely.
590
00:26:46,322 --> 00:26:48,339
Thank you, Mr. Toth.
591
00:26:49,847 --> 00:26:53,934
How many people in attendance
that day, Mr. Toth?
592
00:26:54,771 --> 00:26:55,915
Ballpark.
593
00:26:55,952 --> 00:26:57,243
Maybe 40.
594
00:26:57,344 --> 00:26:58,584
And you're positive
595
00:26:58,621 --> 00:27:01,466
William was in your store
the whole time?
596
00:27:01,536 --> 00:27:03,181
Relatively positive.
597
00:27:03,299 --> 00:27:06,017
Relatively. I see.
598
00:27:06,135 --> 00:27:08,638
Tell that
to Mr. Kim's widow and children,
599
00:27:08,913 --> 00:27:11,689
who miss their father
and husband every day.
600
00:27:12,130 --> 00:27:14,724
"Relatively" doesn't bring him back.
601
00:27:14,761 --> 00:27:17,638
"Relatively" does not prove
that William Hurston was
602
00:27:17,675 --> 00:27:20,216
in your store when Mr. Kim
was murdered, does it?
603
00:27:20,284 --> 00:27:22,403
You murdered Rosemary!
604
00:27:22,646 --> 00:27:24,880
You're lying, Madeline.
605
00:27:34,426 --> 00:27:36,161
Ezekiel?
606
00:27:37,864 --> 00:27:39,817
When is William going to testify?
607
00:27:39,917 --> 00:27:41,326
We weren't planning on that.
608
00:27:41,406 --> 00:27:45,153
Mr. Boudreau, the jury thinks
my nephew is a monster.
609
00:27:45,255 --> 00:27:47,278
Put him on the stand.
Let them see who he is.
610
00:27:47,315 --> 00:27:50,316
William is not the sweet
14-year-old boy you remember.
611
00:27:50,958 --> 00:27:52,786
We put him on the stand, we could lose.
612
00:27:52,823 --> 00:27:55,741
- You don't know that.
- She's right. We don't.
613
00:27:55,778 --> 00:27:57,249
I didn't testify at my trial.
614
00:27:57,286 --> 00:27:59,380
I've always regretted it.
We should give William a chance.
615
00:27:59,417 --> 00:28:01,231
This case isn't about you, Madeline.
616
00:28:01,478 --> 00:28:03,487
I never said that it was.
617
00:28:05,005 --> 00:28:07,470
You hired me to protect your nephew.
618
00:28:07,858 --> 00:28:09,874
Let me do that.
619
00:28:10,020 --> 00:28:11,954
I'll see you both tomorrow.
620
00:28:15,888 --> 00:28:18,208
Don't ever contradict me
in front of a client again.
621
00:28:18,245 --> 00:28:21,130
Don't ever talk to me like that
in front of a client again.
622
00:28:31,157 --> 00:28:32,827
I'm just...
623
00:28:33,106 --> 00:28:35,149
not feeling myself.
624
00:28:35,980 --> 00:28:37,828
I'm angry at everyone.
625
00:28:38,352 --> 00:28:42,188
My law partner, my kids, my wife.
626
00:28:42,313 --> 00:28:44,446
She thinks I'm talking
to my pastor right now.
627
00:28:44,574 --> 00:28:46,924
But you came to a therapist instead.
628
00:28:47,120 --> 00:28:49,797
What do you think brought on
this shift in you?
629
00:28:50,031 --> 00:28:51,622
I have a client.
630
00:28:52,063 --> 00:28:54,805
He was convicted of murder
when he was 14,
631
00:28:55,019 --> 00:28:58,963
but he's six-foot-four
and looks a lot older.
632
00:29:00,334 --> 00:29:03,243
- So they never saw the kid in him.
- Your son...
633
00:29:03,348 --> 00:29:06,866
um, Michael... he's, uh... he's 14?
634
00:29:07,007 --> 00:29:08,557
(exhales)
635
00:29:08,832 --> 00:29:10,938
I found a... a fake ID.
636
00:29:11,157 --> 00:29:12,758
I don't know
if Michael used it or not...
637
00:29:12,795 --> 00:29:15,040
But you're worried.
638
00:29:15,222 --> 00:29:16,856
Hmm.
639
00:29:18,198 --> 00:29:21,086
When I was 14,
I was a punk on the street.
640
00:29:21,854 --> 00:29:25,556
Our folks were so busy with
work, they barely missed me.
641
00:29:26,102 --> 00:29:29,218
I did whatever I wanted, so I
got in all kinds of trouble.
642
00:29:29,714 --> 00:29:32,715
I got beat within an inch of my life.
643
00:29:34,523 --> 00:29:35,979
I ended up running to the church,
644
00:29:36,016 --> 00:29:39,768
because, you know, it's a sanctuary.
645
00:29:41,039 --> 00:29:43,001
When I woke up the next morning,
646
00:29:43,235 --> 00:29:45,659
the light streaming
through the windows,
647
00:29:46,032 --> 00:29:48,070
I saw the face of Jesus,
648
00:29:48,555 --> 00:29:50,072
and I felt this...
649
00:29:51,313 --> 00:29:55,094
endless love, like I had finally
found what I needed.
650
00:29:56,256 --> 00:29:59,407
Why are you telling me this now?
651
00:30:04,958 --> 00:30:07,776
I guess we're all just
a little lost when we're 14.
652
00:30:08,054 --> 00:30:10,221
But you found your way.
653
00:30:10,683 --> 00:30:12,384
But will he find his?
654
00:30:13,051 --> 00:30:14,450
Michael?
655
00:30:14,813 --> 00:30:16,857
Let me ask you this.
656
00:30:17,136 --> 00:30:19,303
Does Michael know you're there for him?
657
00:30:20,698 --> 00:30:22,548
I don't know what he knows.
658
00:30:23,852 --> 00:30:26,700
Well, then maybe
you should let him hear you,
659
00:30:27,055 --> 00:30:29,004
and then really listen
660
00:30:29,515 --> 00:30:31,610
to what he has to say.
661
00:30:40,124 --> 00:30:43,884
Listen... I owe you an apology.
662
00:30:44,217 --> 00:30:46,686
I was, um, frustrated,
663
00:30:46,748 --> 00:30:49,155
and, you know, Michael's
been acting up lately and...
664
00:30:49,205 --> 00:30:51,608
You're afraid Michael
could end up like William.
665
00:30:51,826 --> 00:30:53,244
Yeah, but...
666
00:30:53,826 --> 00:30:56,123
I shouldn't have taken it out
on you and everyone, so...
667
00:30:56,209 --> 00:30:58,231
It's all right. We understand.
668
00:30:58,436 --> 00:31:00,592
It's actually what I wanted
to talk to you about.
669
00:31:00,803 --> 00:31:02,897
I still think
we need to let William testify.
670
00:31:02,980 --> 00:31:04,561
- Uh...
- You didn't let me finish
671
00:31:04,598 --> 00:31:05,879
what I wanted to say to William's aunt,
672
00:31:05,915 --> 00:31:07,039
so you need to hear me now.
673
00:31:07,201 --> 00:31:09,123
- All right.
- At my trial,
674
00:31:09,160 --> 00:31:11,585
my lawyer was afraid,
just like you are now.
675
00:31:11,772 --> 00:31:13,522
He thought the jury would hate me.
676
00:31:13,607 --> 00:31:16,016
I felt powerless and alone.
677
00:31:16,160 --> 00:31:18,752
That is exactly how William
is feeling right now.
678
00:31:18,881 --> 00:31:21,459
He won't say it, but deep down,
he wants to tell the world
679
00:31:21,496 --> 00:31:23,830
what really happened to him.
We need to give him that.
680
00:31:24,071 --> 00:31:25,696
You're right.
681
00:31:25,975 --> 00:31:27,928
I am afraid.
682
00:31:28,303 --> 00:31:30,022
Bellows is gonna come down
on William hard,
683
00:31:30,059 --> 00:31:31,817
and I don't know
how he's gonna respond,
684
00:31:31,854 --> 00:31:33,354
and the jury may hate him.
685
00:31:33,487 --> 00:31:35,787
Or they may really care about him,
686
00:31:36,239 --> 00:31:38,397
just like I know you do.
687
00:31:40,605 --> 00:31:42,123
Yeah.
688
00:31:42,943 --> 00:31:44,357
You're right.
689
00:31:45,631 --> 00:31:46,780
They need to hear him,
690
00:31:46,799 --> 00:31:49,133
just like they needed to hear you.
691
00:31:52,012 --> 00:31:55,013
We're gonna need you
to testify, William.
692
00:31:55,216 --> 00:31:58,076
Now, they're gonna ask you
why you confessed,
693
00:31:58,467 --> 00:32:00,219
why you had the gun that shot Mr. Kim.
694
00:32:00,741 --> 00:32:03,062
We need you to explain
to the jury what happened,
695
00:32:03,099 --> 00:32:04,890
just like you told us.
696
00:32:05,538 --> 00:32:07,371
You think you can do that?
697
00:32:11,459 --> 00:32:14,052
We want to show the jury
who the real William is.
698
00:32:14,624 --> 00:32:16,936
Not the kid who spent years in prison.
699
00:32:17,100 --> 00:32:19,624
The artist who loves comic books,
700
00:32:19,694 --> 00:32:22,387
who loves to draw.
701
00:32:35,214 --> 00:32:36,589
Okay.
702
00:32:37,558 --> 00:32:39,558
I'll testify.
703
00:32:43,456 --> 00:32:45,839
You did admit that you shot and killed
704
00:32:45,858 --> 00:32:47,382
Wan Lee Kim, correct?
705
00:32:48,081 --> 00:32:49,480
Yes, but I...
706
00:32:49,517 --> 00:32:51,277
And now you want us to believe
that you didn't mean it?
707
00:32:51,313 --> 00:32:52,839
- I didn't.
- So you lied.
708
00:32:52,924 --> 00:32:54,514
You're a liar. You're lying now
709
00:32:54,551 --> 00:32:56,552
because you want to get yourself
out of trouble, aren't you?
710
00:32:56,588 --> 00:32:58,862
- Stop saying that!
- You're lying, Madeline.
711
00:32:58,956 --> 00:33:02,544
No one believes you!
It's time to tell the truth.
712
00:33:02,581 --> 00:33:04,957
You murdered Rosemary.
713
00:33:05,143 --> 00:33:06,667
No, it-it ain't like that.
714
00:33:06,704 --> 00:33:09,456
You say that now, but that is
certainly not what you said
715
00:33:09,532 --> 00:33:12,667
at the time of the murder,
when you confessed.
716
00:33:15,486 --> 00:33:17,069
No further questions.
717
00:33:24,288 --> 00:33:25,788
William,
718
00:33:26,503 --> 00:33:28,123
how old are you in this photo?
719
00:33:28,905 --> 00:33:30,565
Fourteen.
720
00:33:34,363 --> 00:33:35,862
14 years old.
721
00:33:35,924 --> 00:33:38,737
And the detectives
questioned you for 20 hours?
722
00:33:39,009 --> 00:33:41,135
All I wanted was to go home.
723
00:33:41,909 --> 00:33:44,034
- To see your auntie?
- Yeah.
724
00:33:44,071 --> 00:33:46,432
And that's what the police
promised you, right?
725
00:33:46,542 --> 00:33:48,235
That if you confessed,
726
00:33:48,542 --> 00:33:50,659
you'd finally get to see her again?
727
00:33:51,006 --> 00:33:53,167
They said I'd get to go home.
728
00:33:54,645 --> 00:33:57,062
It's the only place
I've ever felt safe.
729
00:33:58,284 --> 00:33:59,766
My auntie...
730
00:34:00,003 --> 00:34:02,658
she bought me all my pencils
and drafting paper.
731
00:34:02,947 --> 00:34:04,033
She loved me.
732
00:34:04,070 --> 00:34:05,394
I still do.
733
00:34:05,431 --> 00:34:07,831
William Hurston only, please.
734
00:34:08,753 --> 00:34:10,569
What else did the police say?
735
00:34:10,818 --> 00:34:12,693
That I could trust them.
736
00:34:13,488 --> 00:34:15,112
That they needed me.
737
00:34:15,339 --> 00:34:17,557
They needed my help
to find the shooter.
738
00:34:19,798 --> 00:34:21,589
That I'd be a hero.
739
00:34:24,196 --> 00:34:26,034
So I showed them the gun,
740
00:34:26,470 --> 00:34:28,257
told them about Rabbit.
741
00:34:31,003 --> 00:34:33,292
But I didn't kill nobody.
742
00:34:33,524 --> 00:34:35,143
Heroes are the good guys.
743
00:34:35,234 --> 00:34:37,544
I'm a good guy.
744
00:34:38,109 --> 00:34:39,908
I was tired.
745
00:34:39,972 --> 00:34:42,515
I wanted to go home.
746
00:34:48,032 --> 00:34:50,120
Nothing further, Your Honor.
747
00:34:59,746 --> 00:35:02,254
- You should do the closing.
- Oh, no.
748
00:35:02,402 --> 00:35:05,090
No, I'm too close. I don't want
to get too emotional.
749
00:35:05,187 --> 00:35:07,587
Easy, William found you for a reason.
750
00:35:07,904 --> 00:35:09,236
He needs you.
751
00:35:10,831 --> 00:35:12,301
Okay.
752
00:35:13,627 --> 00:35:15,223
I'll do my best.
753
00:35:20,092 --> 00:35:21,758
What?
754
00:35:22,397 --> 00:35:24,413
I found Rosemary's mystery man.
755
00:35:24,967 --> 00:35:27,553
I checked flight records
for Rosemary's Stanford weekend.
756
00:35:27,590 --> 00:35:29,940
Checked every flight between
Chicago and the Bay Area,
757
00:35:29,977 --> 00:35:32,686
and I searched every person
named Jim or James,
758
00:35:32,869 --> 00:35:34,477
and I came up empty.
759
00:35:34,678 --> 00:35:38,530
But then I found a familiar name
on one of the flights.
760
00:35:39,296 --> 00:35:40,351
Levi.
761
00:35:40,424 --> 00:35:41,881
(exhales sharply)
762
00:35:42,944 --> 00:35:44,928
Rosemary was afraid of Levi.
763
00:35:44,999 --> 00:35:46,686
That doesn't mean he killed her.
764
00:35:46,747 --> 00:35:48,374
It means he could have.
765
00:35:48,739 --> 00:35:51,444
There's plenty of
reasonable doubt in this case.
766
00:35:54,577 --> 00:35:55,880
There's plenty of reasonable doubt.
767
00:35:56,369 --> 00:35:59,217
There's plenty of
reasonable doubt in this case.
768
00:36:01,428 --> 00:36:04,889
Hey, no matter how much
you push me away,
769
00:36:05,007 --> 00:36:07,046
no matter how much you think
you don't need me anymore,
770
00:36:07,083 --> 00:36:08,186
I love you,
771
00:36:08,346 --> 00:36:10,671
and I'm not going anywhere,
no matter what.
772
00:36:14,811 --> 00:36:17,491
(clears throat) Um, cool.
773
00:36:17,897 --> 00:36:20,240
I'm gonna get some ice cream.
774
00:36:21,157 --> 00:36:22,631
You want some?
775
00:36:22,712 --> 00:36:24,646
I'm good, but thanks.
776
00:36:26,105 --> 00:36:28,741
There's plenty of reasonable doubt.
777
00:36:36,770 --> 00:36:39,229
Imagine a 14-year-old boy you know.
778
00:36:39,864 --> 00:36:42,871
He's confident, maybe overly so,
779
00:36:42,934 --> 00:36:45,957
still learning about the world,
trying to fit in,
780
00:36:45,994 --> 00:36:48,494
impressing his friends
and making mistakes.
781
00:36:48,659 --> 00:36:50,254
Now imagine that same young boy
782
00:36:50,291 --> 00:36:52,049
in a room
with an experienced detective,
783
00:36:52,281 --> 00:36:55,442
and that detective confuses him
with empty promises.
784
00:36:55,691 --> 00:36:57,924
All he wants is to be believed.
785
00:36:58,324 --> 00:37:00,519
There's terror in his eyes.
He just wants it to end.
786
00:37:00,613 --> 00:37:02,154
He wants to go home.
787
00:37:03,807 --> 00:37:05,285
Can you see it?
788
00:37:05,474 --> 00:37:06,974
Because I can.
789
00:37:07,056 --> 00:37:10,067
And truth be told,
it keeps me up at night.
790
00:37:10,262 --> 00:37:12,803
Because no matter how much
you love and prepare your child,
791
00:37:12,840 --> 00:37:15,098
you can't protect them from everything.
792
00:37:15,439 --> 00:37:17,379
Now, isn't it possible...
793
00:37:18,302 --> 00:37:21,457
more likely than not,
that this young boy,
794
00:37:21,567 --> 00:37:24,526
hungry for approval,
told that trained detective
795
00:37:24,621 --> 00:37:26,910
what he thought he wanted to hear?
796
00:37:27,699 --> 00:37:29,184
Now, if you believe that's possible,
797
00:37:29,221 --> 00:37:30,715
that's reasonable doubt.
798
00:37:31,632 --> 00:37:33,270
The State would want you to believe
799
00:37:33,307 --> 00:37:34,817
that no one would ever confess
800
00:37:34,854 --> 00:37:37,186
to a crime they did not commit.
801
00:37:38,353 --> 00:37:41,371
But use your common sense
and life experience.
802
00:37:41,763 --> 00:37:43,487
We all know that's not true,
803
00:37:44,270 --> 00:37:45,990
and they know it.
804
00:37:46,379 --> 00:37:48,164
Now imagine William Hurston.
805
00:37:48,299 --> 00:37:52,160
He was that scared,
lonely 14-year-old boy.
806
00:37:53,327 --> 00:37:55,332
And that detective tricked him
807
00:37:55,692 --> 00:37:59,692
into admitting to a crime
he did not commit.
808
00:38:01,967 --> 00:38:04,476
And that's what this case
boils down to.
809
00:38:05,893 --> 00:38:10,529
And that's why you should
find William not guilty.
810
00:38:12,485 --> 00:38:14,098
Thank you.
811
00:38:21,078 --> 00:38:22,393
We learn in Leviticus
812
00:38:22,430 --> 00:38:24,153
that when anybody becomes aware
of the fact
813
00:38:24,190 --> 00:38:27,312
that they are guilty,
they must confess.
814
00:38:27,695 --> 00:38:30,648
That is exactly what happened
with this defendant.
815
00:38:30,703 --> 00:38:32,703
Don't let Mr. Boudreau
and Ms. Scott confuse you.
816
00:38:32,806 --> 00:38:34,990
This is a very simple question:
817
00:38:35,484 --> 00:38:37,328
did William Hurston
818
00:38:37,365 --> 00:38:40,399
shoot and kill Wan Lee Kim?
819
00:38:41,187 --> 00:38:43,867
I say, beyond a shadow
of a doubt, the answer is yes.
820
00:38:44,458 --> 00:38:46,422
Now, Ms. Scott and Mr. Boudreau
would have you believe
821
00:38:46,459 --> 00:38:48,407
that Detective Folino exerted
822
00:38:48,444 --> 00:38:52,130
some sort of power over the defendant,
823
00:38:52,348 --> 00:38:54,609
by calling into question
his character...
824
00:38:54,646 --> 00:38:57,647
a respected detective with
the Chicago Police Department.
825
00:38:57,898 --> 00:39:00,067
Now, you heard Detective Folino.
826
00:39:00,354 --> 00:39:02,234
By no measure...
827
00:39:02,389 --> 00:39:05,715
did he strong-arm this defendant.
828
00:39:06,113 --> 00:39:09,719
He conducted a fair
and thorough interview
829
00:39:10,015 --> 00:39:11,807
and obtained a confession.
830
00:39:12,977 --> 00:39:15,654
Now, I ask you for a moment
to consider the victim,
831
00:39:15,951 --> 00:39:17,344
Wan Lee Kim.
832
00:39:17,445 --> 00:39:21,143
Think about the fear in his eyes
833
00:39:21,766 --> 00:39:24,830
when this young man
held a gun to his head
834
00:39:24,906 --> 00:39:26,555
and shot him.
835
00:39:26,789 --> 00:39:28,734
Think about that moment.
836
00:39:29,715 --> 00:39:33,703
The moment when he realized
he was about to die.
837
00:39:34,484 --> 00:39:35,901
Ladies and gentlemen,
838
00:39:35,984 --> 00:39:38,008
you must ask yourselves one question:
839
00:39:38,197 --> 00:39:41,570
If he didn't do it, why did he confess?
840
00:39:41,828 --> 00:39:43,244
Why?
841
00:39:43,820 --> 00:39:45,502
The answer is simple:
842
00:39:45,543 --> 00:39:48,969
because he did do this heinous crime.
843
00:39:49,797 --> 00:39:52,357
On behalf of the People
of the State of Illinois,
844
00:39:52,513 --> 00:39:56,398
I'm asking that you find him
guilty of murder.
845
00:40:01,942 --> 00:40:04,027
Appearances matter.
846
00:40:04,472 --> 00:40:07,689
What the world sees in us
sets expectations.
847
00:40:07,910 --> 00:40:10,691
The world defined William
Hurston by the way he looked.
848
00:40:10,780 --> 00:40:11,980
No, no! (screams)
- (gunshot)
849
00:40:12,063 --> 00:40:13,195
They labeled him a killer,
850
00:40:13,222 --> 00:40:15,371
and they treated him like one.
851
00:40:16,699 --> 00:40:19,959
But inside, he screamed back,
852
00:40:20,746 --> 00:40:23,296
"I'm not a killer."
853
00:40:23,910 --> 00:40:25,949
"I'm a superhero."
854
00:40:27,629 --> 00:40:29,271
Jury's back.
855
00:40:36,302 --> 00:40:38,026
Have you reached a verdict?
856
00:40:38,105 --> 00:40:40,691
- We have, Your Honor.
- How find you?
857
00:40:40,762 --> 00:40:41,991
We find the defendant,
858
00:40:42,028 --> 00:40:44,711
William Richmond Hurston, not guilty.
859
00:40:44,879 --> 00:40:47,004
(gasping, cheering)
860
00:40:47,777 --> 00:40:50,387
Mr. Hurston, you are free to go.
861
00:40:51,153 --> 00:40:53,004
- Thank you.
- (gallery murmuring)
862
00:40:56,915 --> 00:40:59,249
- Thank you so much.
- Mm.
863
00:41:00,519 --> 00:41:03,551
If we make the next news cycle,
no one will even notice.
864
00:41:03,626 --> 00:41:05,609
- Are we ready?
- All set.
865
00:41:05,691 --> 00:41:07,691
It's time we change the narrative.
866
00:41:08,092 --> 00:41:09,925
I don't like the word "victim."
867
00:41:09,995 --> 00:41:11,421
I prefer "survivor,"
868
00:41:11,588 --> 00:41:14,035
because that's what happens
when a crime occurs
869
00:41:14,258 --> 00:41:15,902
and you're the one left standing.
870
00:41:16,048 --> 00:41:17,668
You survive.
871
00:41:19,222 --> 00:41:21,176
I will work with state legislators
872
00:41:21,213 --> 00:41:23,387
to enact Rosemary's Law,
873
00:41:23,650 --> 00:41:26,076
named in honor of Rosemary Lynch,
874
00:41:26,318 --> 00:41:28,543
whose mother, a survivor,
875
00:41:29,022 --> 00:41:31,006
we have here today.
876
00:41:32,085 --> 00:41:33,590
Mrs. Lynch.
877
00:41:33,863 --> 00:41:36,130
Barbara Lynch knows that there
is a pervasive injustice
878
00:41:36,167 --> 00:41:37,668
in our society.
879
00:41:38,057 --> 00:41:41,541
With Rosemary's Law,
we can bring justice to her
880
00:41:41,730 --> 00:41:43,465
and to all survivors,
881
00:41:43,588 --> 00:41:48,113
because no survivor
should be silenced or alone.
882
00:41:57,743 --> 00:42:01,258
(gasps) How did you get in here?
883
00:42:01,377 --> 00:42:02,893
Mom gave me a spare key.
884
00:42:02,930 --> 00:42:04,539
She wouldn't do that.
885
00:42:04,680 --> 00:42:07,142
I came to talk to you
about my assault case.
886
00:42:07,235 --> 00:42:08,477
You broke into my place.
887
00:42:08,514 --> 00:42:11,492
What the hell is all this, Maddie? Huh?
888
00:42:13,070 --> 00:42:14,708
What happened between you and Rosemary?
889
00:42:14,766 --> 00:42:16,599
Stop talking to me like a lawyer!
890
00:42:16,636 --> 00:42:18,486
Stop acting like a criminal.
891
00:42:18,560 --> 00:42:20,094
I know you followed her to Stanford.
892
00:42:20,131 --> 00:42:22,298
She was scared of you.
893
00:42:23,899 --> 00:42:25,842
No, um, no, no.
894
00:42:25,879 --> 00:42:27,766
L-Let me just explain that.
895
00:42:30,427 --> 00:42:32,361
You're afraid of me?
896
00:42:33,172 --> 00:42:35,219
I think that you should leave.
897
00:42:39,023 --> 00:42:40,791
Okay.
898
00:42:42,928 --> 00:42:44,636
Okay, I'll go.
899
00:43:00,864 --> 00:43:03,290
I love you, sis.
900
00:43:06,543 --> 00:43:08,126
I love you, too.
901
00:43:12,004 --> 00:43:16,004
synced & corrected by PopcornAWH
www.addic7ed.com
65694
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.