All language subtitles for Comment (1978) eng

af Afrikaans
ak Akan
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bem Bemba
bn Bengali
bh Bihari
bs Bosnian
br Breton
bg Bulgarian
km Cambodian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
chr Cherokee
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch
en English
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
ee Ewe
fo Faroese
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gaa Ga
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gn Guarani
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ia Interlingua
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
rw Kinyarwanda
rn Kirundi
kg Kongo
ko Korean
kri Krio (Sierra Leone)
ku Kurdish
ckb Kurdish (Soranî)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Laothian
la Latin
lv Latvian
ln Lingala
lt Lithuanian
loz Lozi
lg Luganda
ach Luo
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mfe Mauritian Creole
mo Moldavian
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
sr-ME Montenegrin
ne Nepali
pcm Nigerian Pidgin
nso Northern Sotho
no Norwegian
nn Norwegian (Nynorsk)
oc Occitan
or Oriya
om Oromo
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt-BR Portuguese (Brazil)
pt Portuguese (Portugal)
pa Punjabi
qu Quechua
ro Romanian
rm Romansh
nyn Runyakitara
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
sh Serbo-Croatian
st Sesotho
tn Setswana
crs Seychellois Creole
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhalese
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish
es-419 Spanish (Latin American)
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
tt Tatar
te Telugu
th Thai
ti Tigrinya
to Tonga
lua Tshiluba
tum Tumbuka
tr Turkish Download
tk Turkmen
tw Twi
ug Uighur
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
wo Wolof
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu

Original subtitles

What we don't see is what directs.

What is this?

Well, it's the look.

That's obvious!

Yes, but there is something that's not obvious about that.

I don't know, we have to imagine something.

It'll be the story of a guy.

Should i turn right?

No...

Oh yes, right.

And this guy get some news from another guy.

The other guy is his father.

You turn right and then we drive on straight.

Okay.

Then we turn right again and...

We go on straight.

We have to go all the way around.

Around the question!

...who gets some news from somebody else...

...whom he didn't ask anything.

And the other guy talks to him about a woman.

You know my father wrote to me the day before yesterday.

I thought he didn't know your address.

I'd sent it to him anyway.

What did he want from you?

Nothing special.

He talks about his work,

that he had an argument, that they're doing a newspaper.

Moreover it doesn't interest me anymore.

Work is everything for him.

Not everybody is like that, so everything's all right, isn't it?

Yes.

Exactly.

A woman he had a relationship with during work...

- You said to go right? - Yes, that's it.

Are you scared?

Yes, a little.

You know it's the first time i've made love with a girl like you.

What's so different about me?

You don't talk much.

So it's no better than your father!

You see in your gestures...

...there's speech.

But... In the form of silence.

And i like that silence.

Turn right.

This guy writes to his sun that...

...he's communicated with a woman...

...at the place where they both work.

I'm turning right.

Are you sure you'd rather not go to my place?

Yes, i'm sure.

He communicated with a woman, he had a relationship with her.

A relationship of production.

You're ready?

Yes, yes. We can start.

Okay, start!

With the comrades,

we had decided to make a little video film...

...in order to show how the newspaper...

...and the printing press functioned.

Odette and myself had been asked to produce it.

Odette was a former delegate from the pro-socialist union.

She came from the computer department of the Credit Lyonnais.

Every night after work,

we'd settle in the printing house's basement to watch what we'd done

...without being bothered.

We said jokingly,

that it would be the first real film of the Alliance of the Left.

At first, everything went smoothly.

But... What's happening?

Well, we cut here.

What do you mean "we cut here"?

Well, because we've decided to.

"We", who's "we" who decided to cut?

Listen, we cut here.

But there's something after, so we don't see it?

We cut here.

It's incredible! We're in a democracy, yes or no?

I want to see the whole thing and then we'll decide...

...if we cut here or somewhere else. Is that possible?

- Can we see the whole thing? - I tell you that we cut here.

I want to see the whole thing once, then we'll decide.

Okay then, if you want to see the whole thing.

Go on!

At the central committee, they had been very happy with my initiative.

It was the time of the big newspaper strikes...

which workers resisted against the violent attacks of the bosses.

It was becoming important to show how the media worked

when they were at the hands of the communists.

Information...

The hands and the eyes...

...were going to be scrutinized,

and all that because of a simple photograph of Portugal...

...that the newspaper had published along with a text that i'd done...

...which described the situation there.

...because the power is here, not elsewhere...

In any case that seems to interest you since you turned around!

Well, there was some noise.

Well, so the noise has no relation to information?

When Vietnam made some noise nobody turned around?

Yes, but here it's simply a working conflict.

As a union delegate you've no right to say that a working conflict is simple.

Then what was happening? Something on Portugal was dictated at full speed

and i think that the speed has something to do with the way news are given.

At least in a daily newspaper.

Well, enough is enough!

Let's watch what follows.

Work is also daily.

You see, kiddo...

even if we don't see each other since you moved out of Paris,

I thought these things would interest you.

Particularly as you have always preferred manual labor.

You see, i'm beginning to see...

that what's wrong today with manual labor...

is that it's intellectual labor at first.

At first, it's writing.

Things aren't going well,

not going well at all.

- What do you mean? - Yes, how isn't it going well?

How isn't this noise going well?

How aren't those hands going well?

I don't understand.

One says...

In Portugal things are fine, but in France they aren't. Or...

In France things are fine, but in Portugal they aren't.

One says "Things are fine at home"

But how things are for one or for Portugal nobody ever says.

I don't understand.

Listen, what do you talk about in this little video film?

I thought it was clear.

We wanted to show how a newspaper is made.

- Not any newspaper! - Of course not.

We wanted to show how information is manufactured by us, communists.

Well perhaps before showing it, you should look a little!

- That's what we're doing! - Yes? And what do we see?

Well, a prime printing house.

Computer programmers.

Photocomposition.

Computer processing.

Yes, a modern information house...

for men and women who struggle for an advanced democracy.

You don't even know what a typewriter is.

Come on!

No, we don't know how it works. We don't know any more...

A typewriter...

Normal programs on Radio France from midnight on.

Soon a 7th government in Portugal...

for the moment State Secretaries won't even sit in the parliament.

They feel that popular pressure is too strong.

Okay. Well, what happened is that we started again from scratch.

So you show us how a typewriter works.

I don't know, we can imagine something.

You know, when you dictated at full speed something on Portugal?

So what?

We can start from there. We can do it again.

What do you mean "do it again"?

Yes, replay it. The two of us, here.

To see what happened.

Okay well, let's start.

The image of these soldiers in uniform...

...already an army for the people...

Let's go slower, let's analyze it.

So "in uniform"...

...already an army for the people...

...whistling the Internationale...

...surrounded by 20,000 people...

...is going to weigh heavily on the process.

- A delegate... - Okay.

Let's stop here and see.

What?

See that...

That...

Hear it too...

We'll have to talk about the noise too.

But what is unseen is what directs.

- What's that? - Well, it's the look.

- What's that? - It's the look.

Well that's obvious.

Yes, but there's something that's not obvious about all that.

What?

Read your text.

Yes, and then?

Wait, we are going to watch my hands again.

In fact when you look carefully, it's a funny job.

You don't notice anything special?

With regard to what?

When you're reading your text.

Do it once again.

Cut it, will you!

We're looking, come on, once again.

Your look was doing that.

My look was doing like your hands if that's what you mean.

No, that's the point, it's my hands that do like your eyes.

And hands aren't made to see.

Therefore it's a blind man's job.

In fact when you look carefully, it's a funny job.

My hands go in all ways, in all directions...

but it's as if there's one,

one which is the leader,

and what directs is the meaning of a sentence.

Yes, it's as if i was blind,

and i was finding my way through a straight corridor.

And every time i stumble, it puts me back on the right path.

And i'm being watched.

The image of these soldiers in uniform...

...already an army for the people...

...whistling the Internationale surrounded by 20,000 people...

...would weigh heavily on the process.

THE IMAGE OF THESE SOLDIERS IN UNIFORM,

ALREADY AN ARMY FOR THE PEOPLE,

WHISTLING THE INTERNATIONALE...

I had decided to walk back to the printer's.

Lights were still on in the Communist Party's building...

where i had gone to say that it was beginning to turn sour.

A MODERN PRINT AND INFORMATION HOUSE FOR MEN AND WOMEN

WHO STRUGGLE FOR AN ADVANCED DEMOCRACY.

I warned them that they'd find themselves with a leftist film.

LANGUAGE ID THE PLACE

WHERE THE EXECUTIONER TRANSFORMS THE VICTIM

INTO ANOTHER EXECUTIONER.

[???

No, that's not how it is and you don't want to see how.

For Odette it was still something else.

She hated in leftism what related still to the Communist Party...

just as you can hate in a kid what comes from his father.

Finally, it's because of her,

yes, because of that...

that i started thinking of you again.

Well we'll have to talk about noise again.

But what is unseen...

...is what directs.

What's that?

Well, it's the look.

What look did i give you when you came out of your mother's cunt?

Probably we didn't have any relationship,

maybe we had a lot.

But after all, between children and parents...

how and with what love is labor is distributed?

You see at the beginning, there's not Portugal first...

and then the typewriter.

There is the typewriter first,

and then Portugal that enters through this machine.

Yes, you say it enters, but it exists too.

Okay but how does it manage to get out,

how does it manage, Portugal?

How does it go from entrance to exit?

That question at least can be asked: how does it go from entrance to exit?

Shit! Since our power as journalists lies here, not elsewhere...

neither in France, nor in Portugal, but in between.

- You received my letter? - Yes, i did.

So?

I don't know what to say.

I'm a little embarrassed.

- By what's in it? - Yes.

When you talk about my ass like that...

I don't know what to say.

It's not very easy to use silence to communicate.

You say you like my silence because there's speech in them.

But this speech has to make noise...

when it's money or work that's talked about.

Then i don't know how come.

And when we quarrel, i feel we don't communicate.

All day long at work it's impossible to talk about love.

And at night...

there's something else again which's impossible.

Yes, i'm fine.

It's not enough to say i'm fine.

...the seriousness, even the anxiety of this civilian.

One feels that they agree...

and at the same time it's like a confrontation.

It's different from the images...

one is accustomed to see about Portugal that one has seen...

- till now and where the crowd... - Who's speaking?

A guy i know. Works at Thomson Corporation.

...on the thesis that they are happy to meet.

It seems to me that...

Listen, it's not me you should stare at!

In fact they're raising their fist against a third one who's absent,

or it could be against each other, it's hard to say.

If i look at this photo...

i see a civilian with a rather...

violent expression which....

which causes the other to raise his fist.

Then there seems to be...

a row of soldiers. Some fists raised...

but it doesn't seem very collective.

One doesn't know what is the relationship established.

I didn't find that what Odette wanted to do was so dumb.

To start with an image...

just as science starts with atoms...

and see how it holds together.

In my opinion, she should've asked the comrades of the joint production...

committee to work with them,

not people from the outside.

I say that, but in fact,

i know it's impossible.

A worker from the book industry would never make a judgment...

on the novel he prints.

Nor would those of a weapon factory...

say anything about the weapons they make.

So what's the work about?

I don't know. There's like a double reality;

solidarity and...

violence.

Odette has wanted to talk about this image.

But for the guy who dictated it, no interest, as usual.

So she had revolted,

and it was that revolt that i had cut.

as if this revolt were not part of the job.

...all this violence, all these...

As a matter of fact, it was the job.

As little as if the soldier was a mannequin...

and the guy gave his life.

That's a musician,

a piano teacher.

Yes, that's very interesting,

but there are too many silences.

All that should be cut.

Yes, the silence. You must wring its neck!

Silence is embarrassing, isn't it?

So many means to communicate,

but no means to use them.

Power of the radio,

impotence of the listeners...

and as a result, no work put into love,

no love put into work.

Odette was right:

if Portugal concerned us in any way,

we should say where it did concern us.

...the Portuguese "third way" between socialism and communism.

During the Kissinger - Brejnev dialogue,

Brejnev said that they wouldn't interfere in the Portuguese situation,

and that Portuguese should solve their problems themselves.

A French reaction:

We learned that some measures would be taken against the wave of...

anti-communist violence in the north, as well as the disagreements in the army.

I feel that everyone wants to shout,

and that...

some people observe who don't know...

What strikes me is the...

brutal gesture of the raised...

fist moving forward...

of the guy whose other hand...

grasps the soldier's fist...

and there is a double reality...

or the solidarity and violence.

Why the fuck is that photograph here?

She said "try to remember"...

In fact i remembered very well.

"So why are you asking?' she said.

Okay, it's a picture of the "Joint Francais" factory on strike...

that we had heavily broadcasted four years ago to support them.

But what's the relation to Portugal? At first sight,

i didn't see and she opened my eyes.

THREE WHAT?

To say Portugal had been tried in France,

but it had been deformed.

On the same occasion, but in another form.

Form, formation, formless.

LAUGHTER OR TEARS WEAPONS

For the fascist leaders it's very different.

Of course, there are some difficulties.

The population still hasn't responded to the problem.

In a similar situation, would you shoot us?

Do you mind if i watch a second time?

No.

There's some truth in what you say.

But it's not clear.

Where do you want to go?

Several things can already be seen.

In a newspaper, one prints information, okay?

Okay.

How does it get printed?

With machines.

With printing machines and by whom?

Hands...

The hands of the workers...

- Directed by what? - A look.

...in the same way it happened in Chile...

It's funny that a look should be what directs.

...one receives images but in fact...

You see when you look at this image of Portugal for example,

that your eyes are going everywhere, they go up and down, all over:

you wander...

So what?

If one had to define what your head is doing,

it'd be something like drawing.

So what?

Then your hands don't draw because they go in the same direction...

THE IMAGES OF THESE SOLDIERS IN UNIFORM

ALREADY AN ARMY FOR THE PEOPLE WHISTLING THE INTERNATIONALE

Don't you think it's philosophy?

No.

Maybe not.

What you mean is i do like that.

To look...

Like that...

To say what's in it.

Yes but in fact you don't say it.

Because you're led by the movements of the hands you placed on the typewriter.

And you forget what you've seen.

- No, i don't forget at all. - Anyway you don't rely on it to think.

To think?

I was beginning to see why...

she wished to bring together these two photographs.

Just to think.

Simply to bring together two simple images. Simple...

Simple because they show simple people.

Who, however, because they dare revolt,

begin something complex.

And if one could see that hope was still searching for words,

despair had already found them.

Yes, to begin to think that with our pencils,

we probably had erased as much and more than we had written.

Even when...

we thought we were writing.

Do you remember that too?

Those beautiful blue eyes blurred by indignation.

That's what we said at the time of the "Joint Francais" affair.

TO GO ON STRIKE, THAT'S JOY.

But when one looks carefully,

that mouth really seemed to laugh.

But when one looks carefully,

when one removes the 4 letters "reve" of the word "greve",

when courage has failed,

one should have the courage to say...

that it wasn't courage, but weakness.

Odette asked me if i knew how to read between the lines.

I said "Not very well".

she said it was a huge failure, because the counter-revolution...

knows very well.

It creeps between two sentences exactly as in phone conversations,

where in order to double the traffic,

the telephone engineers place a conversation...

into the silences of another.

Instead of tiring yourself in shouting for 50 years...

"Death to fascism! ",

you would have done better to shout Shannon's theorems.

See, a text that won't do.

She added: "Do you have any idea how it happens?'

On Wednesday, you shouted at Marian,

because she didn't stop making mistakes.

This is what she'd written:

"But how come?', you wondered, "She's a good girl".

It happens that she was trying to decide...

if she would keep her baby,

or get an abortion.

And she was on her 6th week.

And this urgent problem doubled with your 7PM issue to be finished.

And that was happening because her hands were getting mixed up.

That's an image "that weighs heavily on the process".

If she could have seen the image to rest her hands and rely on it,

she would have made fewer mistakes...

for herself and for you journalist.

For Odette, objectivity had become a crime.

Criminals, those who were paid to give news about the others...

without talking about them.

Criminals, those who speak about them...

without using the other's voice.

A strike takes place for silence, i knew it.

so when i had talked about the "Joint Francais" or "Lipp",

why didn't i go on a speech strike?

Why? Because in fact, under the cover of the other's,

it's your speech that you sold.

Your crime was to keep your place

while putting yourself at the other's...

Your crime was to keep your place while putting yourself at the other's.

You journalist trash.

You journalist trash.

The speed with which my desire represented another's....

all that ended in making noise.

But there is also...

the wall of images,

that transforms itself into a wall of silence.

Noise of silence...

Silence before the storm...

Storm before the night...

Fascist night...

Deformation, information...

WHEN IT'S THE AGE OF DARKNESS WILL THERE STILL BE SONGS?

It's true that i didn't know how to answer this question.

Say it, all that you know is that in the age of darkness,

one will sing the song of darkness.

And the words? Look:

There's never an "either/or".

Never one problem and two solutions.

Always two problems and one solution.

There must never be "equal labor, equal wages".

On the contrary, there must be "unequal labor..."

"equal wages".

There isn't a "problem of the couple".

There are two problems.

A male problem and a female problem.

And one solution.

One solution.

One solution.

There's one photo-problem and one text-problem.

One solution, one newspaper.

One information.

There's no choice between day and night.

Live or die; you don't have the choice.

The only choice is that there is none.

He seems to be crying. He cries...

The other is almost crying.

You say fascism.

But if the gun is me for instance,

well fascism is also the two together.

That's because you haven't seen anything.

You saw nothing at '68, nothing at Hiroshima.

Because your hands ended in directing your eyes.

You see nothing because it's already written, you don't see Vietnam.

You don't see unemployment, you don't see women.

Your eyes do what your hands should do.

And it's tragic because it's not manual labor.

When Marian gets back home, she will even be happy...

to do the laundry or wash the dishes, to touch her kid.

At least her hands escape and find a meaning.

Not a great one, but at least it's something.

You can't, you're a journalist but you can't see, you won't see.

Even if you wanted to, you couldn't see anymore.

How does it get printed in one's memory and how does it do?

What it does is to direct your life, always in the same direction.

In fact you're afraid to see this picture of Portugal, it scares you.

This guy seems a little crazy.

Is he were a pop singer you'd accept quite well his mouth and gestures,

maybe a little clumsy but rather handsome.

After having told a worker to go on strike,

would you dare to dance with him because he obeyed you?

But why don't you say what this photograph might remind you of?

You, not anyone else.

I, reader, who receives it thanks to you, journalist,

I need a text which would help me to know where i am.

You, however, are scared to see where you are.

And i think that when one is scared,

it's because one is scared to lose one's place.

It seems really aggressive.

Pressing on a piece of paper that cuts all the noise...

Lights were still on at the Central Committee.

They chewed me out.

I walked back to the newspaper, thinking about this German writer,

who said: "What's wrong isn't that the world is sad, but that it's big".

There's a photo...

on Portugal...

and a text all around it.

You see,

i did what i'd been told.

I made up an excuse...

to call for a meeting of the joint production committee...

to try to put her in the minority through a democratic vote.

...at the newspaper, a photograph cannot be published without text.

I'd like to talk about that, right now for instance.

I think that they hadn't got it at all,

but something had touched them.

Maybe Odette had a loose screw,

but she had loosened them up.

...between the soldiers and the people...

there is solidarity and violence at the same time.

That's not the point, the contrast is trying to see why...

you systematically bring back the ambiguity,

if you've the photo alone and with he text as well.

This ambiguity inevitably needs to be explained by text.

The text doesn't explain the photo.

There's written: "Porto, September '22, demonstration of 10,000 soldiers...

who joined 10,000 people marching in the street.

The photograph has nothing to do with this text.

The person who did this article put it there for another reason.

And there's no explanation for it.

With a certain type of text,

you can perfectly reduce it to one or two sentences.

You would reconstruct, starting with the photograph.

As soon as they move, photographs become cinema.

It's funny, i was struck by the sincerity of those guys

as well as their enormous stupidity.

That's not their fault.

As soon as they expressed an idea, they were over their heads.

No, not their fault.

They should've watched TV,

Iistened to the radio, read the newspaper...

Therefore it was their fault all the same.

After a while, i started to Look at the photographs,

published here and there, left and right...

which Colette had collected as documentation.

...a text that would be too long to develop.

You should therefore work your text and your photo...

in a way that's totally related.

Totally related.

Relations between men...

go through relations from man to woman.

...at this moment you say the photo is commenting on the text...

in a way that allows you to speak about this commentary...

at the same time about the way it happens to comment.

Don't you think that the reader will comment on the photo by himself...

even if the text is a little different?

What do you mean?

Then, you entered the corridor.

Your mother's cunt.

Several months late you came out of this corridor.

The tunnel, the canal.

Your mother had received a signal.

How does she communicate it?

How does it go in and out of the machine?

The reproduction machine...

The machine to make copies, you a copy of me.

But maybe your mother has made mistakes in copying.

Maybe, even surely, she transmitted information...

that she shouldn't have.

Your reasoning is what interests me.

Really, when i see this photo that was made in Portugal by someone,

I'd like that person to speak about the moment the picture was taken,

and why this picture and not another.

...i don't think we can make it without speaking of the one...

who looks at the photograph announces where he's looking from.

Information, deformation, fascism.

The formidable energy released by revolutionary Europe.

The image which more than one German person dreams about at night.

The image which more than one German person dreams about at night.

The image which more than one German person dreams about at night.

He doesn't see anything because he doesn't want to see.

Because one could perfectly well see nothing.

...that would be the relationship of the reader to the reading of a newspaper.

Here you don't account for the reader.

You had deformed my image.

What would i do now?

...proposing to slow down at one given moment...

and making a mistake.

It has to be the people who complain that everything goes too quickly.

For instance, i've never seen a journalist not complaining that it's going too fast.

Well if you tell him instead of writing...

40,000 words, write only 30, you'll have more time.

He doesn't want to because it's more tiring.

Yes, one makes relationships rather than one truth.

Spain '36,

don't read "to die on one's feet instead of living on one's knees".

Because to wash all the blood shed by Franco,

the Spanish people will have to go on their knees like a cleaning lady.

Spain '75. The reign of the uniform.

Was it worth it to chop off the king's head in '89?

Thanks to ITT, the uniform reigns in Chile too.

Algeria '56, if the Communist Party abstains from voting to dispatch soldiers,

say it abstains from commenting on this image and say it at once.

Yes, a few words. Which ones?

Hi, how are you doing?

How are you not doing?

Step by step... Directing my life...

How does it get printed in my memory?

Which printer...

You journalist trash!

That's true, as a printer, i had become the king of true things,

instead of saying and showing how things really are.

Well yes, i've told many stories,

but never how i was part of the story, of history. As a result...

How do you go from one place to another?

How does a "page 2" follow?

It's a strike at the Renault car factory.

The 376 workers from the big press who went...

on strike March 21st provoked a reaction.

One print's one's point of view, it's not philosophy, it's biology.

Come on!

No, you won't see how it's not coming on.

From Renault to Palestine...

From night to day...

From night to day, from love to work...

Where does all this happen? With us.

Yes, this "us" is here indeed...

when i'm writing that Portugal concerns us.

Odette had taped the discussion.

And we watched with a slight feeling of an end of something.

Or a beginning.

Or both.

Suddenly i decided to support Odette,

and to face the political bureau,

which as i knew from a friend of the central committee...

had already decided to do everything to stifle our little enterprise.

Little?

Maybe not so little.

Ultimately,

what was Odette saying,

with this little video film?

That the TV and the press were rotten...

and since we watched it and read it...

that our eyes are rotten,

and our mouths and our hands.

In short it was cancer,

and we had it first we didn't say so.

We didn't say so because we didn't know.

We didn't know because we didn't want to.

We didn't want to because we couldn't.

We couldn't because we didn't show.

We didn't show because we didn't want to.

We agreed to show advertisements saying that...

"something's happening every second in the Galleries Lafayette store".

We didn't say what...

because we had sold our silence too.

So this is the result,

nothing gets through in love letters anymore.

A blind love like vacation postcards.

You remember this Czechoslovakian hand writing:

"chains of humanity are made with the paper of bureaucrats".

And technique today...

is the violent activity of the knowledge.

The image of these soldiers in uniform...

Do it once again.

Cut it, will you!

We're looking, come on, once again.

Your look was doing that.

My look was doing like your hands if that's what you mean.

No, that's the point, it's my hands that do like your eyes.

And hands aren't made to see.

Therefore it's a blind man's job.

In fact when you watch closely, it's a funny job.

They go in all ways, my hands, in all directions,

but it's as if there's one,

one which is the leader,

and what directs is the meaning of a sentence.

Yes, it's as if i was blind,

and i was finding my way through a straight corridor.

And every time i stumble, it puts me back on the right path.

And i'm being watched.

And i'm being watched.

What directs is the meaning of a sentence.

He doesn't see anything because he doesn't want to see.

Because one could perfectly well see nothing.

Business is a daily death sentence.

The meaning of a sentence... Work is freedom.

We have the right to work.

We have the right to freedom.

That falls without saying. No one recovers.

It's said that telexes "fall" on the teleprinter.

Spain, Vietnam, Chile, Palestine.

And behind, you and me.

To inform, to disguise, to deform,

with such news, always past history...

to us and we're happy for that anyway,

unless it becomes Vietnam, Chile, Palestine, Ireland, etc.

While the comrades were still arguing before the vote,

we'd gone in the office next door,

to continue this little video film, we had two votes that were surely for us,

Michel and myself and Odette.

Then the others;

Paul maybe,

Isabelle certainly not.

For Christine, Odette said no,

i said yes.

Claude, probably yes, Jean Pierre, no.

For Paul, impossible to know.

Jose, no. Francis, no. Mario, yes or no.

Hector, yes. Jacques, no.

The evening came and finally,

the committee decided unanimously to finish this little video film,

and then to fight for its distribution.

Well, you happy now?

Everything's settled.

What's wrong with you?

You look glum.

Anyway it's gonna go back to the big bosses and...

it'll surely be put down.

What did we finally try to say in this little video film?

Anyway, it'll be put down.

It won't.

It will, i tell you it will. I know them, it will.

I tell you it won't. No need to worry.

It won't.

It won't. That's all.

It'll be like fascism.

What, what fascism?

Don't you know fascism?

The evening came.

A young guy from the committee whom i'd never seen before...

came to bring the directions.

Absolute veto.

Odette had sneered,

and i had tried to argue a little as was foreseen.

Besides Francis and Juliet,

everybody else had chickened out.

A long silence still full of work set up in the office...

after everybody had left.

We still took a few notes.

I proposed to go to dinner to get our strength back.

And i invited her.

All this was just a beginning.

But she refused.

The winter holidays were beginning

and she had to prepare her daughter's things,

she was leaving for holiday camp.

She said we'd see each other again after the holidays.

She wanted to think about all that.

Maybe she would finish the little video film somewhere else,

sine it was definitely impossible here, despite wordy promises.

Then i never saw her again.

Turn down the volume!

The neighbor is freaking out over the radio!

Are you alright?

Half past five this morning, Franco is dead.

You don't want to see how i'm not!

Flags face the windows...

No, it's not going well, but you don't want to see how.

A numerous and silent crowd with several women in tears...

A FILM BETWEEN ACTOR AND SPECTATOR

A FILM BETWEEN ACTIVE AND SPECTATOR

A FILM BETWEEN ACTIVE AND PASSIVE

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.