Original subtitles

so intel versus amd but with a twist

neither of these systems have a

dedicated gpu both of them are running

just the integrated graphics on the cpu

now both of these teams have the best

what they can offer on this side the 8

core ryzen 7 5700 g and on this one the

core i9 11 900k also eight car chip what

i want to know is as a creator would it

be possible to edit some of the video

without the dedicated graphics card on

premiere pro for example you know just

while you're waiting for your graphics

card to arrive well let's find out

[Music]

the intel is called like the best gaming

chip whereas this one is just like

somewhere in the middle the intro also

cost quite a bit more i think it's

important to mention the test bench

setup so both of them are kind of like

open air test bench setups but we're

both running the same ram with the same

speed of ram the only thing i've changed

with the amd's cpu configuration on bios

is enabled position boost overdrive just

to push a little bit more power through

because it's only 65 watt chip whereas

the intel is 125 watt and intel actually

does it kind of on stock settings but

pushes so much more power through the

chip that it's rated so we just enabled

that on amd as well so premiere pro is

open both of these premiere pro things

are exactly the same projects as you can

see now if you want to just make sure

which one is which then if you look like

on the top of the premiere pro over here

you can see amd ryzen as one of them and

then on this side we have intel so you

know like which pc is which and which

one are we using so let's start with

intel so this is eleven nine hundred k

so this is um eight bit four to zero 60

frames per second 4k

clip and if you're looking at this

timeline performance

i mean this is very very good this is

hardware accelerated so the actual

graphics is playing this back but when

we're pressing play

10 frames we dropped 10 frames let's

press play again yeah it starts a little

bit to drop frames but then keeps

playing like the rest of the system so

if we look at what's used the gpu is

eighty percent used over here as you can

see this is completely

edible editable this is completely

editable of codec over here if you're

using like 8-bit 4k footage and this is

full resolution if we put it to half

resolution

i mean check this out this is buttery

buttery but buttery smooth absolutely no

problem as you can see

this is not very good when moving around

on the timeline

it's not

quite as smooth as intel really i would

say but still i think it's all right if

you press play

we're doing the same drop in a few

frames but a little bit less than intel

let's have a look at over here and the

graphics is less used it looks like the

graphics has more power and oomph to it

but maybe probably the intel quick sync

works better on premiere pro than on the

amd verizon on on this particular codec

now actually when it's loaded a little

bit

to be honest it's quite smooth actually

yeah i think intel's like producing more

frames on the timeline but both of them

are pretty pretty smooth and like able

to

play this back so 8-bit 4-0 kodak 4k

both of them are pretty good but i think

intel has a little bit of an edge let's

move on to this is 10 bit 420 so the bit

depth has changed a little bit it's

still um h264 so not high efficiency

codec

okay let's press play over here looks

like it's playing it back quite

easily here as you can see the memory

usage goes up quite a bit because our

memory is actually using the gpu memory

and it's using the actual system memory

as well so the memories using both job

let's move on to intel let's do exactly

the same thing over here

yeah i think the quick sync is

truly like a bit quicker

there's a little bit like artifacts when

when playing around with intel it makes

some kind of weird squares i'm not sure

if you can see that on the screen but if

you press play 33

used infographics i think both of these

are actually very very similar like the

timeline moving on the header is i think

a little bit like snappier on intel just

because of the quick sync system how

they've utilized the hardware over there

and that's better so i think a little

bit of an edge here to intel as well

let's move on to four to two so now this

is completely cpu bound codec so if we

press

this play now here

as you can see our gpu is not doing as

much and our cpu here boom should be

doing quite a bit as you can see 40.

obviously the gpu is still like playing

it back but as you can see the video

decoding like on here it's just playing

it back but here the 422

we're dropping one frame

doing exactly the same

four two two

it's like all right not bad actually

full resolution zero frames dropped

let's have a look at the

cpu is utilized about 30 percent it's

it's all right looks like it's playing

it back no problem timeline performance

actually is quite all right as well

timeline is a bit choppy as well

but

i think they're both equal on this one

let's try um 4 to 260 frames per second

as well so this is a little bit more

just a lot more frames

yeah intel is dropping constantly

footage over here

frames the gpu is completely maxed out

cpu is like

almost there pressing play over here

full resolution

17 frame dropped both of the drop in

frames

let's see which drops more frames looks

like amd gpu actually has more overhead

headroom because it's utilized less but

just the drivers and i think how adobe

is working there's a better like driver

support than just hardware support on

intel than on amd because as you can see

intel gpu is like 100 utilized and cpu

is about 80 90 utilized and over this

timeline we dropped 142 frames let's

have a look at amd look there was about

maybe 40 utilized and 70 to 80 utilized

so much less utilized and 270 frames

dropped just a little conclusion on the

side over here if you have mirrorless

footage like from any of the cameras

10-bit 8-bit 4k whatever frame rates

then the intel one actually because of

the quick sync on adobe premiere pro has

an edge over here let's move on to a

little bit more complex codecs we have

the redraw 4k okay this is full

resolution let's have a look how well

does this work over here

wow okay this is very very smooth look

at this

this is smooth as anything

so i'm just gonna press play over here

because that's very smooth let's see on

in the intel system

i don't know if you can notice this but

on here

the amd was very like smooth on the

playback whereas the intel is some kind

of like there's like artifacts over here

when it's when it's playing back and

it's it's smooth but it there is some

artifacts so let's press play and see

if it can play it back okay amd finished

now

and we dropped two frames so basically

no frames this could have been like just

an

error you know and how many whoa whoa

okay intel now dropped 209 frames

compared to basically no frames on the

amd

so when we're comparing red footage the

amd has a much better edge than intel

over here let's move on to canon c200

and we're gonna

put this on like half

resolution

half the resolution and

it's quite smooth but there's quite a

lot of artifacts as well it looks like

like some random glitches and stuff are

going on happening over there so it's

playing back actually not bad on half

the resolution let's move on to the amd

system over here

let's have a look at this as well so

half the resolution

okay this is interesting

so what i can notice over here is that

amd has less artifacts actually

so the amd system what i'm scrolling

through is is

as smooth as intel's but it doesn't have

as much artifact so i would say like the

timeline performance is a little bit

better over here so let me just press

play somewhere over here and let's see

what happens

seems like it's playing it back no

problem let's move back to the intel

system intel system here is still

playing it back but as you can see

there's like artifacts there's like some

kind of stripes and things going through

it doesn't look as good over here so

yeah both of them are equal but i'd

still give a little bit of an edge to

the ryzen system just because of the

less artifacts and it just feels like

it's it's a bit better red 5k now okay

full resolution 5k footage

timeline it's all right but it's hard to

know here because there's not a lot of

movement so what we're going to do is

we're going to press play and see how

many frames we're dropping i mean looks

like it's a bit more choppier on the

intel system

but let's just press play see what

happens on the amd system

we dropped 185 frames we understand a 5k

is already a little bit difficult it

looks like the cpu was the bottleneck

over here as you can see eight cars just

isn't quite enough to

start playing back 5k footage and then

on the intel we

have lost 228 so intel did even even

worse so if you look here

intel had like gpu and cpu maxed out so

let's move on to red 6k kodak

let's see if there's any difference over

here i mean check this intel's

constantly pulling like 183

85 190 watts to play this back

let's move on to 6k whoa

check the timeline performance here on

ryzen system

this is completely acceptable

so if you press play let's see what

happens but that was very very

interesting so we're pressing play

look the ryzen system is pulling less

than half of the

about 70 to 80 watts of power

and the cpu was the bottleneck over here

let's have a look what happened on the

intel system we dropped

2415 frames amd dropped

230 frames that's interesting so let's

go to b raw 6k which is quite an easy

codec to edit we're looking at the

timeline performance over here intel has

some artifacts going on

but looks like

you could do some b-raw editing over

here that's no problem okay see the

similar thing

like when moving around the timeline amd

funnily enough even though

it maybe produces slightly less frames

on the scrubbing

it is smooth and it's not as distracting

seeing some kind of artifacts on the

timeline because for me as an editor it

would make me feel like whoa is is the

footage like shot weird is there some

corruption of the files what's going on

over there on the intel system but in

here i know okay it's been shot very

good let's press play let's see what

happens

full resolution like full 8 6k timeline

playback over here 103 frames dropped

over here what is the bottleneck

probably the gpu over here

a lot of memories being used here as

well

121 frames dropped whoa until still

actually won on this

for some reason amd can't just play it

back even though there's much more

headroom as you can see the gpu over

here it's still dropping a lot more

frames than

intel 256 so we'll still have to give

intel the lead on this one so might as

well just try something ridiculous this

is canon r5 8k and we're going to start

quarter resolution because there's no

point even trying a full resolution

but this

yo this is absolutely smooth but there's

still some artifacts going on like some

weird stripes

like some blocking or whatever it's

called i'm just gonna press play because

that was pretty impressive okay that is

smooth and i would say

this is better

on much better than amd just because

there's less artifacts the artifacts on

intel is really really annoying so

intel's almost finished this sequence

and intel has actually dropped two

frames during this playback which is

very interesting so you can definitely

edit some even r5 footage if you don't

have a gpu on the intel 11 900k so amd

at the moment is dropping zero frames

zero frames dropped i think we're gonna

have to give this to the amd system i

think red raw 8k and 12k there's no

point in testing these because like

if you're editing these types of footage

you probably have the cash to actually

buy a

dedicated gpu as well so there's no

point in actually trying that so the

conclusion is this

both of these chips can actually edit

some of the mirrorless camera footage

like 4k 60 frames per second up to there

402 or 420 gpu accelerated not both of

them can actually do but intel has an

edge over there just because of the

quick sync support on the premiere pro

and how it utilizes this igpu inside

there it is better it's smoother

experience there might be a little bit

more arty effects but that's that now

the interesting thing here is that amd

actually has quite a lot more overhead

in terms of the upgrade ability because

this one is as good as it gets on intel

system so if you get like another gpu

your cpu is is that's it that's to the

wall you can't go anywhere else whereas

on the amd there's quite a bit of

upgrades actually there if you get a gpu

there and then you can actually put much

better cpus in there ryzen 9s there's a

few ryzen 9's over there which is

amazing the amd also uses much less

energy or electricity it's got a little

bit of an edge over there if you're

thinking about view upgrade path for

this moment at this like point in time

without the dedicated gpu we have to

give the win to intel so this was

premiere pro if you want to know what

the difference is in resolve stay tuned

for the next video likes if you enjoyed

it subs if you want to see more and i'll

see in the next video thanks guys for

watching

[Music]