Original subtitles

intel versus amd always a good

comparison now this over here is the

ryzen 7 5700g so the latest apu from amd

and it cost roughly around 350 pounds

something like that or dollars this over

here is the intel i9 11 900k

and that costs around 550 or 600 pounds

somewhere around there quite a bit more

expensive but does that mean it's better

when you don't have a dedicated graphics

card well in this video we're gonna find

out which is better in davinci resolve

when you're editing and maybe waiting

for your future graphics card

so you might be thinking that this is

not a fair comparison because the intel

cost so much more than the

amd system if you look at it this way

both of them have 8 cars and 16 threads

both of them have the latest technology

what amd and intel offer amd has

actually a better or more powerful gpu

inside if you do a geekbench test but

the intel has a bit more powerful cpu

inside maybe 5 to 15 depending on a test

much more powerful in multi-core

performance single core performance is

quite a bit better than on the amd so as

you can see they both have weaknesses

and strengths so interesting is what is

the actual performance on the live

program so if you want to check out

these systems or these like test bench

setups check them out in the description

below i'm going to leave both of them

down there so we have davinci resolve

17.3 open on both of these systems i'm

also using the full hd timeline at the

moment over here because i think if

you're moving to 4k you probably you can

still export that or upscale it to 4k if

you want to when you're exporting this

but i think like timeline come on let's

let's work it like that so we know how

good it is so this over here is a 4k 422

10 bit which isn't actually hardware

accelerated but the timeline performance

is so smooth so i'm just going to press

play and let's see what happens over

here as well

so as you can see the gpu is quite a bit

utilized

uh cpu is you know 20 it's all right but

we placed back 24 frames per second as

you can see over there no problem this

is 4k 42 to 25 frames per second a

little bit lower still 10 bit

and let's have a look at similar setup

over here let's move on to here this is

s i

so it's a bit less compressed codec from

sony a7s iii and honestly it's buttery

buttery smooth so if you don't have a

gpu

look at this it's brilliant it's it's

absolutely fantastic

super super smooth no problem here

this little bit timeline performance is

a little bit more odd but if you go to

si again

that's brilliant

25 frames per second is somehow hard but

it does an arcade job like this is this

is brilliant like just look how smooth

this is press play

here

start playing it back no problem look

like gpu is 11 utilized it's nothing

let's move on to 60 frames per second

let's see if 4k 60 frames is something

that we can do on these systems so i

have two clips over here one of them is

4k

4 to 0 8 bit so something that you would

see like your from your mirrorless

camera

it's not

able to produce as many like frames as

before because the 60 frames on the

timeline but let's press play see if

yeah it's fine no problem

looks like it's

no problem

look maximum we've used is 74 watts on

the amd now this over here is 42 to 10

bit this is h.264 as well

and looks like it's playing it back all

right

[Music]

60 frames per second 402 that's very

hard because this should go all on the

cpu

so if you press play here yeah see like

all the cpu this was a spike over there

not so much on the gpu but cpu

definitely was used a lot more 60 frames

per second

it's not doing that great of a job to be

honest

i think amd was playing this back much

much better even this 8-bit let's see

the 4-2-bit

it's very laggy as well so let's see if

it can actually play it back yeah plays

back 24 frames per second when you scrub

on the timeline it still takes a little

bit of time to think and then playback

but it's able to do it

let's have a look at this 422 now

it plays back

cpu is that much utilized let's see

what's happening over here

well okay we're using quite a lot more

energy than or electricity than the amd

system but it's still able to do it no

problem 4k redraw let's see what can it

do over here

let's have a look timeline performance

it's quite okay actually

i mean to be honest it's very nice place

it back no problem

very good as well

like i've got nothing bad to say about

the scrubbing of the timeline let's

press play see what happens

oh

see

amd can't play it back

that is fascinating well eventually like

the uh amd system catches up as well so

if i'm gonna

okay

[Music]

so the first clip is something where it

struggles the second clip is all right

interesting the dci 4k is a bit easier

for it to play back even though there's

more frames than

the ultra hd first clip which actually

has less frames per second as well so

that's interesting if you press play on

the second clip it plays back in

normally but that is a weird phenomenon

phenomenon phenomenon

phenomenon fin whatever the word is c200

rather than very very smooth playback

like okay the first bit here is a little

bit choppy so let's press play see if we

can do that

i mean i'd say it's completely

editable

whoa

this feels a little bit smoother

and when pressing play it feels more

responsive

i think i'm gonna give the edge to amd

system over here 5k redraw okay

timeline performance so so let's press

play see what happens

amd system is not playing this back

like at all that's interesting i think

it's literally just a driver

driver issue over here because

if we look if we press play

nothing gets utilized actually in here

hardly the gpu harder the cpu it just

stops like playing it back interesting

the timeline performance is worse than

until then amd amd was like

a bit more responsive

so let's press play see what happens

here

plays back

okay

eventually catches up and plays back 24

frames per second cpu is 100 utilized

here

we'll give the win on 5k to intel

moving on to 6k

the timeline is

not so responsive let's press play see

what happens

okay

can it catch up

no not really this is can't do it redraw

is a little bit hard for intel system

see amd actually produces more frames on

the timeline

which is interesting

this timeline is much more responsive

than intel system

but when we press play

i think i'm going to give the edge here

to the amd but like what you could do is

also like timeline half the resolution

and then when it's half the resolution i

think it's gonna

play it back no it doesn't actually it's

just the codec support on the gpu and on

the cpu it just can't figure it out the

red raw is hard for it to play back so

let's move on to the 6k b-roll which

should be like a native kodak black

magic codec whoa

see something's going on over here

what is going on this oh i think it's

literally that the amd

amd gpu can't actually decode that

footage or even the cpu it doesn't know

like what to do with the b-roll when it

stops

it's all right when we screw around

it makes random things if you press play

it plays it back but you've got some

weird artifacts going on over here

timeline is

is okay but like playing back is a

little bit choppy to be honest like

b-roll is very nice kodak to edit the

gpu is only utilized because it's 6k but

like the actual codec is quite all right

but i think intel still has the edge

over here last thing i want to try is a

canon r5 8k so we know that the red is

quite hard for this

like both of the systems to playback but

let's have a look at like canon r5 8k

like this is amd system over here and

scrubbing on the timeline it's a bit of

a lag

and it

it can't quite do it press play see if

it does anything

so it

nah it just can't quite play it back but

this clip for example on amd system

plays back quite all right so let's move

on to the intel system let's see if

that's any different scrubbing on the

timeline

i'd say the amd

was a bit better

because this is completely like laggy

and let's have a look what's maxed out

i think it's the ram it can't just use

that much ram but let's press play see

if that's any different that's

interesting that was quite laggy at

first but now plays back quite normally

let's see if you press play again

i think intel system has an edge over

here so in conclusion if you want to do

some video editing the intel 11900k is

much better on davinci resolve than the

ryzen 7 5700 g

just because just the hardware like how

they talk together with the program the

hardware and the program works so much

better the amd has the hardware there

but for some reason just can't utilize

it the cpu is not utilized the gpu is

not utilized so we have to wait for amd

to talk with davinci resolve and about

blackmagic and to like figure out how

they can utilize this so the intel has

quite a bit of an edge so i wouldn't go

with amd if you want to do some editing

i think if it's lower like you know 4k

or less editing you can do it on the amd

as well because

what amd offers you've got a massive

upgrade path where on the intel you know

that's it in here you can put even 12

core 16 core cpus where this 8 core is

the maximum for this platform at the

moment so hopefully this helps you to

decide which one do you want to go for

maybe if you don't have a gpu you know

like what the actual performance is when

working with these cpus here which

platform is better

the amd or intel system hopefully this

helped you likes if you enjoyed it subs

if you like to see more and my friends i

will see you in the next time if you

want to check out these systems i'm

going to leave them below thanks guys

for watching bye

[Music]