Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:02,050 --> 00:00:05,445
[siren wailing in distance]
2
00:00:05,488 --> 00:00:08,709
ANNOUNCER: ...combination,
really controlling the pace...
3
00:00:08,752 --> 00:00:10,667
[continues indistinctly]
4
00:00:10,711 --> 00:00:12,713
[phone vibrating]
5
00:00:14,976 --> 00:00:17,979
ANNOUNCER: That's the thing
about these two fighters,
6
00:00:18,023 --> 00:00:20,416
they both have
excellent footwork.
7
00:00:31,253 --> 00:00:33,690
SAM:
Dad?
8
00:00:38,652 --> 00:00:40,828
What are you doing?
9
00:00:40,871 --> 00:00:42,917
You should be
asleep, pal.
10
00:00:42,960 --> 00:00:45,093
I hear noise.
11
00:00:45,137 --> 00:00:47,226
That's just the TV.
12
00:00:47,269 --> 00:00:49,228
All right? Now
close your eyes.
13
00:00:49,271 --> 00:00:51,273
I'm not tired.
14
00:00:51,317 --> 00:00:53,449
[knocking on door]
15
00:00:53,493 --> 00:00:56,757
All right. I got business.
16
00:00:56,800 --> 00:00:59,455
All right? You stay in this bed.
You hear me?
17
00:01:00,674 --> 00:01:03,198
I see you out of this bed,
you and me got big problems.
18
00:01:03,242 --> 00:01:04,547
Yes, sir.
19
00:01:04,591 --> 00:01:06,593
All right.
20
00:01:12,729 --> 00:01:14,514
[front door opens]
21
00:01:14,557 --> 00:01:16,342
MAN: What's happening, man?JOSEPH: Yo, what's good, man?
22
00:01:16,385 --> 00:01:17,778
What you need?MAN: Back up. Back up, man!
23
00:01:17,821 --> 00:01:19,301
I'll take it all.
Give me the roll!
24
00:01:19,345 --> 00:01:22,217
Just give me the cash!
Give me the roll!
25
00:01:22,261 --> 00:01:25,307
[overlapping chatter]
26
00:01:25,351 --> 00:01:26,917
[clattering]
27
00:01:26,961 --> 00:01:28,919
[grunting]
28
00:01:28,963 --> 00:01:30,530
JOSEPH:
No, no. No!
29
00:01:30,573 --> 00:01:31,705
[gunshots]
30
00:01:31,748 --> 00:01:34,142
[screams]
31
00:01:47,460 --> 00:01:49,026
[knocking on glass]
32
00:01:49,070 --> 00:01:50,289
Your 10:00 a.m. is here.
33
00:01:53,509 --> 00:01:54,989
Dr. Harper came
to see me yesterday.
34
00:01:55,032 --> 00:01:57,165
He has a rather
daunting legal problem,
35
00:01:57,209 --> 00:01:58,427
and I immediately thought
36
00:01:58,471 --> 00:02:01,430
we're gonna need some
more hands on deck.
37
00:02:01,474 --> 00:02:04,216
Well, before I sign on
for the big voyage,
38
00:02:04,259 --> 00:02:06,174
let's begin at
the beginning.
39
00:02:06,218 --> 00:02:08,089
Why don't you tell me
what's going on?
40
00:02:08,133 --> 00:02:09,656
I'm a pediatrician.
41
00:02:09,699 --> 00:02:13,050
I live in White Plains
just outside the city.
42
00:02:13,094 --> 00:02:16,880
I was in my offices here
in Midtown, seeing a patient,
43
00:02:16,924 --> 00:02:18,491
just after 11:00
yesterday morning,
44
00:02:18,534 --> 00:02:21,363
when the police showed up
to arrest me.
45
00:02:21,407 --> 00:02:22,756
What for?
46
00:02:22,799 --> 00:02:26,063
The execution-style murder
47
00:02:26,107 --> 00:02:28,457
of a heroin dealer in the Bronx.
48
00:02:28,501 --> 00:02:30,720
Okay.
49
00:02:30,764 --> 00:02:32,679
HARPER:
By the way,
50
00:02:32,722 --> 00:02:36,509
I don't believe that I have been
in the Bronx in over a decade.
51
00:02:36,552 --> 00:02:40,513
I have never ever
in my life done heroin.
52
00:02:40,556 --> 00:02:43,733
I'm not sure I'd know what it
was if it were in front of me.
53
00:02:43,777 --> 00:02:48,738
I've not fired a gun that shoots
anything bigger than a BB.
54
00:02:48,782 --> 00:02:52,699
And I was home
with my wife and two girls
55
00:02:52,742 --> 00:02:57,530
when this...
execution took place.
56
00:02:57,573 --> 00:03:00,533
Why do you think
they arrested you?
57
00:03:02,404 --> 00:03:06,278
DNA evidence was recovered from
under the victim's fingernails,
58
00:03:06,321 --> 00:03:08,367
the result of a struggle
with the killer.
59
00:03:08,410 --> 00:03:10,238
And?
60
00:03:10,282 --> 00:03:13,372
It appears to belong
to Dr. Harper.
61
00:03:13,415 --> 00:03:14,982
How close a match?
62
00:03:15,025 --> 00:03:18,638
100%.
63
00:03:20,422 --> 00:03:23,512
Not a lot of wiggle room there.
64
00:03:23,556 --> 00:03:26,428
Our new client,
Dr. Michael Harper,
65
00:03:26,472 --> 00:03:28,517
is out on $1 million bail
after having been arrested
66
00:03:28,561 --> 00:03:30,867
for the murder
of Joseph Lowell,
67
00:03:30,911 --> 00:03:33,479
a heroin dealer who was killed
in his apartment in the Bronx.
68
00:03:33,522 --> 00:03:35,611
[quietly]: We only represent
the best clients.
69
00:03:35,655 --> 00:03:37,396
MARISSA:
No sign of a break-in,
70
00:03:37,439 --> 00:03:40,486
which suggests the perpetrator
was a known acquaintance.
71
00:03:40,529 --> 00:03:42,531
Additionally, he had
just received a text
72
00:03:42,575 --> 00:03:45,882
from someone with an
untraceable burner phone.
73
00:03:45,926 --> 00:03:48,450
Joseph, the drug dealer,
was killed with his own gun,
74
00:03:48,494 --> 00:03:50,278
which was later discovered
in the Hudson
75
00:03:50,322 --> 00:03:53,020
with no recoverable prints.
76
00:03:53,063 --> 00:03:55,022
So is Dr. Harper in fact
77
00:03:55,065 --> 00:03:57,459
a known acquaintance
of this Joseph Lowell?
78
00:03:57,503 --> 00:04:00,419
He claims to have
never heard his name
79
00:04:00,462 --> 00:04:03,726
before the police showed up
at his medical practice.
80
00:04:03,770 --> 00:04:05,554
Okay, so if he's innocent,
81
00:04:05,598 --> 00:04:08,296
then how did his DNA end up
on this dead drug dealer?
82
00:04:08,340 --> 00:04:10,167
At the moment,
no one can answer that question,
83
00:04:10,211 --> 00:04:11,821
but Bull thinks
it may have something to do
84
00:04:11,865 --> 00:04:14,302
with the way the police
made their DNA match.
85
00:04:14,346 --> 00:04:15,564
What do you mean?
86
00:04:15,608 --> 00:04:16,826
After the police found
87
00:04:16,870 --> 00:04:19,394
what they suspected
was the murderer's DNA
88
00:04:19,438 --> 00:04:21,570
under the victim's fingernails,
they ran the sample
89
00:04:21,614 --> 00:04:24,530
through their internal database,
and they came up dry.
90
00:04:24,573 --> 00:04:27,794
I'm confused. Then how
did they make the match?
91
00:04:27,837 --> 00:04:29,622
They didn't, but it turns out
that one of these
92
00:04:29,665 --> 00:04:32,494
big for-profit
genealogy companies did.
93
00:04:32,538 --> 00:04:34,670
Dr. Harper's wife had sent them
94
00:04:34,714 --> 00:04:37,064
some of her husband's DNA
as a birthday present.
95
00:04:37,107 --> 00:04:39,196
He's an only child,
both his parents
96
00:04:39,240 --> 00:04:41,721
had passed two years ago,
and he's got no sons.
97
00:04:41,764 --> 00:04:43,940
He started talking to her
about how he felt
98
00:04:43,984 --> 00:04:45,246
he didn't really know
where he came from,
99
00:04:45,290 --> 00:04:47,379
didn't really have
a handle on his roots.
100
00:04:47,422 --> 00:04:49,642
That he was likely
the last of his family,
101
00:04:49,685 --> 00:04:51,513
but he really had no idea
who his family was.
102
00:04:51,557 --> 00:04:53,559
It seemed like the perfect gift.
103
00:04:53,602 --> 00:04:54,995
Wait. You're talking
about one of those places
104
00:04:55,038 --> 00:04:56,605
you send a cheek swab into
105
00:04:56,649 --> 00:04:58,912
to find out what country
your relatives came from?
106
00:04:58,955 --> 00:05:00,696
TAYLOR: Is it
even legal for them
107
00:05:00,740 --> 00:05:03,264
to turn over your private
information like that?
108
00:05:03,308 --> 00:05:05,092
I'm betting they had
a search warrant.
109
00:05:05,135 --> 00:05:07,312
They sure did.
It was all on the up-and-up.
110
00:05:07,355 --> 00:05:09,531
Perfectly admissible in court.
111
00:05:09,575 --> 00:05:12,099
DNA? That's a,
that's a tough one.
112
00:05:12,142 --> 00:05:15,407
Did you know that 95% of jurors
are willing to convict
113
00:05:15,450 --> 00:05:17,452
based on DNA evidence alone?
114
00:05:17,496 --> 00:05:19,585
CHUNK: Okay, so
let's review.
115
00:05:19,628 --> 00:05:21,935
This man had no
relationship to the victim,
116
00:05:21,978 --> 00:05:25,242
had no criminal record,
no history of drug abuse,
117
00:05:25,286 --> 00:05:27,636
had no ties to the
crime whatsoever.
118
00:05:27,680 --> 00:05:30,291
And where did he say he was
the night of the killing?
119
00:05:30,335 --> 00:05:31,901
Home with his family.
120
00:05:31,945 --> 00:05:35,165
Well, then there must have been
a mistake, right?
121
00:05:36,210 --> 00:05:38,081
Now all we have to do
is prove it.
122
00:05:38,125 --> 00:05:39,474
CHUNK: Your posture should be relaxed.
123
00:05:39,518 --> 00:05:43,565
More than anything, we want
you to appear comfortable.
124
00:05:43,609 --> 00:05:45,698
You don't want to look
like you're trying too hard.
125
00:05:45,741 --> 00:05:47,700
The jury can almost
always sense it.
126
00:05:47,743 --> 00:05:49,397
Trying too hard to what?
127
00:05:49,441 --> 00:05:51,399
Save my husband's life?
128
00:05:51,443 --> 00:05:53,401
Look, I know
that this is difficult,
129
00:05:53,445 --> 00:05:55,403
but alibis from family members
130
00:05:55,447 --> 00:05:57,318
are the toughest
to get a jury to trust.
131
00:05:57,362 --> 00:05:59,146
You'd be surprised,
the things that people say
132
00:05:59,189 --> 00:06:00,756
to protect their spouses.
133
00:06:00,800 --> 00:06:04,194
We were home, with our kids,
watching television in bed.
134
00:06:04,238 --> 00:06:07,589
If I had known I would have
to prove this in a trial...
135
00:06:10,462 --> 00:06:13,073
I'm sorry.
136
00:06:13,116 --> 00:06:15,423
[sighs]
137
00:06:15,467 --> 00:06:17,425
He's a pediatrician.
138
00:06:17,469 --> 00:06:21,124
He makes kids feel better
when they're sick.
139
00:06:21,168 --> 00:06:23,562
He comforts them
when they're scared.
140
00:06:23,605 --> 00:06:24,780
That's who he is.
141
00:06:24,824 --> 00:06:25,912
Well, there you go.
142
00:06:25,955 --> 00:06:27,957
That's what
the jury needs to know.
143
00:06:28,001 --> 00:06:30,264
That's what the jury
needs to understand.
144
00:06:30,307 --> 00:06:33,615
You know I'm the one who sent
his DNA to that company.
145
00:06:33,659 --> 00:06:35,835
Michael had nothing
to do with it.
146
00:06:35,878 --> 00:06:38,707
This... is my fault.
147
00:06:38,751 --> 00:06:40,753
Mrs. Harper, you...It was a couple years ago.
148
00:06:40,796 --> 00:06:43,320
I'd completely forgotten about
it until I got that e-mail.
149
00:06:43,364 --> 00:06:45,845
E-mail?
150
00:06:45,888 --> 00:06:48,587
What do you know about
the Fourth Amendment?
151
00:06:48,630 --> 00:06:51,590
Uh, unreasonable search
and seizure.
152
00:06:51,633 --> 00:06:53,592
It's one of
my favorites.
153
00:06:53,635 --> 00:06:57,509
Why? You got a pop quiz coming
up in constitutional law?
154
00:06:57,552 --> 00:06:59,119
Michael's wife is the one
155
00:06:59,162 --> 00:07:02,165
that sent his DNA sample
to that genealogy company.
156
00:07:02,209 --> 00:07:04,385
I know that.But did you know this?
157
00:07:04,429 --> 00:07:05,734
A few days before the arrest,
158
00:07:05,778 --> 00:07:07,475
she got an e-mail
from the company.
159
00:07:07,519 --> 00:07:09,825
It said they had received
a duplicate sample
160
00:07:09,869 --> 00:07:11,653
and that they wanted to know
161
00:07:11,697 --> 00:07:13,960
if it was from her
or another family member.
162
00:07:14,003 --> 00:07:16,223
She just told you that?
163
00:07:16,266 --> 00:07:17,746
I'm like a human can opener.
164
00:07:17,790 --> 00:07:19,531
People spend time with me,
and they can't help themselves.
165
00:07:19,574 --> 00:07:20,749
All right.
166
00:07:20,793 --> 00:07:22,969
So where are you going
with this?
167
00:07:23,012 --> 00:07:26,059
Well, we know the police were
at a dead end.
168
00:07:26,102 --> 00:07:28,235
They couldn't I.D. the DNA
from the crime scene
169
00:07:28,278 --> 00:07:30,063
using their databases.
170
00:07:30,106 --> 00:07:32,631
So they got a search warrant.
You heard Danny.
171
00:07:32,674 --> 00:07:34,502
But how did they get it?
172
00:07:34,546 --> 00:07:36,591
To get a search warrant,
you need probable cause.
173
00:07:36,635 --> 00:07:38,767
There's no way they could've
known that Michael's wife
174
00:07:38,811 --> 00:07:40,813
sent his DNA
into that genealogy company,
175
00:07:40,856 --> 00:07:43,250
or any genealogy company,
for that matter.
176
00:07:43,293 --> 00:07:44,991
I know it sounds
a little crazy,
177
00:07:45,034 --> 00:07:47,515
but what if, before they got
the search warrant,
178
00:07:47,559 --> 00:07:50,692
they sent a sample of this DNA
to the genealogy company--
179
00:07:50,736 --> 00:07:53,869
every genealogy company--
posing as a customer,
180
00:07:53,913 --> 00:07:55,871
all as part of
an elaborate ruse
181
00:07:55,915 --> 00:07:57,525
to get one of these
companies to verify
182
00:07:57,569 --> 00:07:59,788
they had a match
in their system?
183
00:07:59,832 --> 00:08:01,355
That way, they can go
to a judge, and say,
184
00:08:01,398 --> 00:08:03,879
"We need a warrant
for this particular company."
185
00:08:03,923 --> 00:08:05,838
Pretty good.
186
00:08:05,881 --> 00:08:08,275
The website would've flagged it
as a duplicate match,
187
00:08:08,318 --> 00:08:10,669
alerted the
original customer...
188
00:08:10,712 --> 00:08:13,280
And confirmed to the cops
that the killer's DNA
189
00:08:13,323 --> 00:08:15,325
was in their system,
without even realizing it.
190
00:08:15,369 --> 00:08:16,892
Right.TAYLOR:
So you're thinking
191
00:08:16,936 --> 00:08:18,764
if we take this to a judge,
he or she might rule
192
00:08:18,807 --> 00:08:20,853
all this DNA evidence
collected inadmissible?
193
00:08:22,376 --> 00:08:23,464
It's worth a shot.
194
00:08:23,508 --> 00:08:24,552
Your Honor,
195
00:08:24,596 --> 00:08:26,336
this e-mail was sent
196
00:08:26,380 --> 00:08:28,687
to Mrs. Harper five days
prior to Michael's arrest,
197
00:08:28,730 --> 00:08:30,776
and three days prior
to the application
198
00:08:30,819 --> 00:08:31,994
for a search warrant.
199
00:08:32,038 --> 00:08:33,256
It's clearly a Fourth
Amendment violation.
200
00:08:34,954 --> 00:08:36,782
Uh, exactly how so?
201
00:08:36,825 --> 00:08:38,784
Well, the police
contacted the website
202
00:08:38,827 --> 00:08:40,786
under an assumed identity,
203
00:08:40,829 --> 00:08:43,005
effectively tricking
them into participating
204
00:08:43,049 --> 00:08:44,485
in a law enforcement
investigation
205
00:08:44,529 --> 00:08:45,704
without their knowledge.
206
00:08:45,747 --> 00:08:47,749
And the A.D.A. here
signed off on it.
207
00:08:47,793 --> 00:08:50,796
Your Honor, using a ruse,
lying to a suspect
208
00:08:50,839 --> 00:08:53,189
to elicit information
relevant to a criminal case
209
00:08:53,233 --> 00:08:55,801
is absolutely legal here
in the state of New York.
210
00:08:55,844 --> 00:08:57,759
You didn't lie to a suspect, you
lied to a public corporation.
211
00:08:57,803 --> 00:08:59,935
It has no effect on the
legitimacy of the evidence.
212
00:08:59,979 --> 00:09:02,155
Doesn't say a whole hell
of a lot about the integrity
213
00:09:02,198 --> 00:09:03,417
of the D.A.'s office.
214
00:09:03,460 --> 00:09:04,810
Kind of hard not
to wonder what other rules
215
00:09:04,853 --> 00:09:06,028
you'd be willing to break.
216
00:09:06,072 --> 00:09:06,942
Enough.
217
00:09:06,986 --> 00:09:08,727
Judge Volk, the defense requests
218
00:09:08,770 --> 00:09:11,730
that the court suppress all
evidence relating to this DNA
219
00:09:11,773 --> 00:09:13,819
since it was obtained
through what amounts to
220
00:09:13,862 --> 00:09:15,777
an illegal search and seizure.
221
00:09:15,821 --> 00:09:17,823
Your Honor, you mustn't
suppress that evidence.
222
00:09:17,866 --> 00:09:19,476
T-The government's
entire case...
223
00:09:19,520 --> 00:09:21,914
Exactly! The government's
entire case is built on fruit
224
00:09:21,957 --> 00:09:26,614
from a poisonous tree, and you
must, therefore, suppress it.
225
00:09:26,658 --> 00:09:28,660
The discovery's troubling.
226
00:09:30,226 --> 00:09:31,793
But if the defense takes it up
with anyone,
227
00:09:31,837 --> 00:09:33,926
they should take it up
with the genealogy site.
228
00:09:33,969 --> 00:09:35,928
Not the police.
229
00:09:35,971 --> 00:09:38,670
They were just
doing their job,
230
00:09:38,713 --> 00:09:40,149
trying to find
a cold-blooded killer
231
00:09:40,193 --> 00:09:42,717
who orphaned a little boy.
232
00:09:42,761 --> 00:09:44,197
[exhales]
233
00:09:44,240 --> 00:09:46,199
Are you aware that boy's mother
died when he was a baby?
234
00:09:46,242 --> 00:09:49,028
That man,
whatever his troubles,
235
00:09:49,071 --> 00:09:51,944
was all the boy
had in the world.
236
00:09:51,987 --> 00:09:53,946
Now he's in the system.
237
00:09:53,989 --> 00:09:58,820
Where, in all likelihood,
he'll remain until he turns 18.
238
00:09:58,864 --> 00:10:02,955
Someone has to be held
responsible for that.
239
00:10:06,001 --> 00:10:07,829
The DNA match stands
as evidence.
240
00:10:09,265 --> 00:10:11,528
This trial
will continue.
241
00:10:11,572 --> 00:10:13,574
♪
242
00:10:22,235 --> 00:10:26,239
Anybody here ever heard
of the Phantom of Heilbronn?
243
00:10:26,282 --> 00:10:27,544
Female serial killer,
244
00:10:27,588 --> 00:10:29,721
terrorized France,
Germany, Austria,
245
00:10:29,764 --> 00:10:31,374
from 1993 to 2009?
246
00:10:33,115 --> 00:10:36,423
DNA evidence linked her
to over 40 crimes,
247
00:10:36,466 --> 00:10:39,861
including six murders.
248
00:10:39,905 --> 00:10:42,690
And when I say "linked her,"
I mean figuratively,
249
00:10:42,734 --> 00:10:44,518
because even though
they had all this DNA,
250
00:10:44,561 --> 00:10:45,954
they had no idea who she was.
251
00:10:47,434 --> 00:10:49,001
Three different countries.
252
00:10:49,044 --> 00:10:52,526
No apparent links at all
between the victims.
253
00:10:52,569 --> 00:10:54,049
Made no sense.
254
00:10:54,093 --> 00:10:56,051
I sense a punch line coming.
255
00:10:56,095 --> 00:10:58,575
Well, the police
finally tracked that DNA
256
00:10:58,619 --> 00:11:00,447
to a sweet old woman in Latvia
257
00:11:00,490 --> 00:11:04,146
who was working in a factory,
manufacturing cotton swabs.
258
00:11:04,190 --> 00:11:06,409
I'm guessing
the same cotton swabs
259
00:11:06,453 --> 00:11:09,891
used to gather the DNA evidence
from the crime scenes.
260
00:11:09,935 --> 00:11:12,154
What happened?
261
00:11:12,198 --> 00:11:15,157
She must have contaminated them
with her own DNA.
262
00:11:15,201 --> 00:11:16,855
Validate that man's parking.
263
00:11:16,898 --> 00:11:19,640
All right, until we find
our own little Latvian woman
264
00:11:19,684 --> 00:11:22,599
working in a Q-tip factory,
we need to find jurors whose
265
00:11:22,643 --> 00:11:24,558
psychological makeup
266
00:11:24,601 --> 00:11:26,386
will allow
them to look
267
00:11:26,429 --> 00:11:29,389
past what seems to be
incontrovertible evidence.
268
00:11:29,432 --> 00:11:31,434
How in the world
do you do that?
269
00:11:31,478 --> 00:11:34,394
We look for jurors
who rely on an affect heuristic
270
00:11:34,437 --> 00:11:35,612
when it comes
to decision-making.
271
00:11:35,656 --> 00:11:38,441
I have no idea
what you're talking about.
272
00:11:38,485 --> 00:11:42,097
A heuristic is a kind
of mental shortcut
273
00:11:42,141 --> 00:11:44,186
we all use to make decisions
throughout the day,
274
00:11:44,230 --> 00:11:46,580
and when those decisions are
allowed to be colored
275
00:11:46,623 --> 00:11:48,713
by our mood or our feelings
276
00:11:48,756 --> 00:11:50,497
in the moment
we make the decision,
277
00:11:50,540 --> 00:11:52,107
that is called
an affect heuristic.
278
00:11:52,151 --> 00:11:55,632
Essentially, we want jurors
who go with their gut.
279
00:11:55,676 --> 00:11:57,286
Why?
280
00:11:57,330 --> 00:11:59,114
Because the one thing there's no
denying is that when you first
281
00:11:59,158 --> 00:12:00,899
meet our client,
"killer" is not the word
282
00:12:00,942 --> 00:12:02,248
that pops into your head.
283
00:12:02,291 --> 00:12:03,815
Yeah, the guy's likable.
284
00:12:03,858 --> 00:12:05,468
You trust him.
285
00:12:05,512 --> 00:12:07,514
Not withstanding
the charges against him,
286
00:12:07,557 --> 00:12:09,516
he strikes you as a good man.
287
00:12:09,559 --> 00:12:11,474
Yeah.And the thing
about jurors is,
288
00:12:11,518 --> 00:12:13,607
if their first impression
is positive, they are gonna
289
00:12:13,650 --> 00:12:15,478
struggle with the idea
290
00:12:15,522 --> 00:12:17,654
that they need
to modify that impression.
291
00:12:17,698 --> 00:12:20,353
And the seemingly irrefutable
DNA evidence
292
00:12:20,396 --> 00:12:23,008
will have less impact.LINDSEY:
And what do I need
293
00:12:23,051 --> 00:12:26,446
to ask them to figure out if
they have this, um, this...?
294
00:12:26,489 --> 00:12:28,622
Affect heuristic?Yes.
295
00:12:28,665 --> 00:12:31,625
You don't have
to ask them anything.
296
00:12:31,668 --> 00:12:33,801
You just have to open your eyes.
297
00:12:33,845 --> 00:12:36,935
BULL: Older woman in the
gray sweater is looking
298
00:12:36,978 --> 00:12:39,372
at Michael like he's her
grandson. We want her.
299
00:12:40,808 --> 00:12:42,331
But we haven't even
talked to her yet.
300
00:12:42,375 --> 00:12:44,812
Words lie,
body language doesn't.
301
00:12:44,856 --> 00:12:46,509
She likes him.
302
00:12:46,553 --> 00:12:47,815
But at the end of the day,
303
00:12:47,859 --> 00:12:49,817
it can't just be
about an affect heuristic.
304
00:12:49,861 --> 00:12:52,602
That might net us one
or two friends on the jury,
305
00:12:52,646 --> 00:12:54,822
but we're gonna need
to broaden our search.
306
00:12:54,866 --> 00:12:57,129
Target jurors
with pessimism bias, as well.
307
00:12:57,172 --> 00:12:58,870
BENNY:
People who tend to exaggerate
308
00:12:58,913 --> 00:13:00,480
the likelihood
that negative things
309
00:13:00,523 --> 00:13:01,786
are going to happen to them.
310
00:13:01,829 --> 00:13:05,528
Why would I want these people
on my jury?
311
00:13:05,572 --> 00:13:07,095
Because our narrative is that
312
00:13:07,139 --> 00:13:10,098
Michael is an innocent man,
wrongly accused.
313
00:13:10,142 --> 00:13:12,579
I believe
jurors with pessimism bias
314
00:13:12,622 --> 00:13:14,973
will put themselves
in Michael's shoes.
315
00:13:15,016 --> 00:13:18,454
And the fear of something
like this happening to them--
316
00:13:18,498 --> 00:13:21,936
it will likely dilute
the importance of the evidence.
317
00:13:21,980 --> 00:13:24,199
LINDSEY:
Good morning.Good morning.
318
00:13:24,243 --> 00:13:25,592
Do you like to travel?
319
00:13:25,635 --> 00:13:27,159
I honestly couldn't say.
320
00:13:27,202 --> 00:13:28,551
I haven't done much of it.
321
00:13:28,595 --> 00:13:30,336
Any particular reason?
322
00:13:30,379 --> 00:13:33,078
I guess maybe
I just feel safer at home.
323
00:13:33,121 --> 00:13:34,949
LINDSEY:
Safer how?
324
00:13:34,993 --> 00:13:37,734
Can't get in a plane crash
if you don't get on a plane.
325
00:13:37,778 --> 00:13:38,866
Can't have terrorists
take over your hotel
326
00:13:38,910 --> 00:13:40,259
if you don't go
to the hotel
327
00:13:40,302 --> 00:13:41,608
in the first place.
328
00:13:45,568 --> 00:13:48,441
This juror is acceptable
to the defense, Your Honor.
329
00:13:48,484 --> 00:13:50,835
Acceptable to the prosecution.
330
00:13:50,878 --> 00:13:52,575
Fantastic.
331
00:13:52,619 --> 00:13:55,317
We have ourselves a jury.
332
00:13:55,361 --> 00:13:56,579
We'll see all of you here
333
00:13:56,623 --> 00:13:59,452
bright and early tomorrow
to start trial.
334
00:13:59,495 --> 00:14:02,498
So we've got four out
of 12 jurors that are at least
335
00:14:02,542 --> 00:14:04,761
inclined
to look past the evidence.
336
00:14:04,805 --> 00:14:05,937
I'll take it.
337
00:14:05,980 --> 00:14:07,677
All I need is one
to get a mistrial.
338
00:14:07,721 --> 00:14:10,115
BENNY:
Talk about being happy
339
00:14:10,158 --> 00:14:12,378
in your work...
340
00:14:13,683 --> 00:14:16,382
Yeah. Wonder what that's about.
341
00:14:17,426 --> 00:14:19,602
Everything all right?
342
00:14:19,646 --> 00:14:20,734
Dr. Harper?
343
00:14:22,649 --> 00:14:25,739
What does the D.A.'s office know
that we don't?
344
00:14:25,782 --> 00:14:27,175
What do you mean?
345
00:14:27,219 --> 00:14:28,829
What kind of question is that?
346
00:14:28,873 --> 00:14:30,178
Look, I get it.
347
00:14:30,222 --> 00:14:32,050
The D.A.'s office has DNA
348
00:14:32,093 --> 00:14:34,530
that would seem
to prove you did this,
349
00:14:34,574 --> 00:14:36,402
and supposedly
that's all they have,
350
00:14:36,445 --> 00:14:38,099
but common sense would suggest
351
00:14:38,143 --> 00:14:40,362
that in the absence
of any other link
352
00:14:40,406 --> 00:14:41,798
to this crime, at least
353
00:14:41,842 --> 00:14:44,323
one juror is gonna
take exception to the idea
354
00:14:44,366 --> 00:14:46,107
of putting you behind bars
for the rest of your life.
355
00:14:46,151 --> 00:14:48,805
But the A.D.A. is not
acting that way.
356
00:14:48,849 --> 00:14:51,460
In fact, he's acting
like he has you dead to rights,
357
00:14:51,504 --> 00:14:53,636
and I would like to know why.
358
00:14:53,680 --> 00:14:56,857
Well, I can't help you
with that.
359
00:14:56,901 --> 00:14:59,468
You never met the victim?Never.
360
00:14:59,512 --> 00:15:01,775
Never purchased illegal drugs?Never.
361
00:15:01,818 --> 00:15:03,559
Never consumed heroin?
Never tried to buy heroin?
362
00:15:03,603 --> 00:15:05,692
You never contemplated
trying to buy heroin?
363
00:15:05,735 --> 00:15:06,693
Of course not!
364
00:15:06,736 --> 00:15:08,825
Then why is the A.D.A.
so damn sure
365
00:15:08,869 --> 00:15:11,393
he can draw a line
between you and the victim?
366
00:15:11,437 --> 00:15:13,700
Or is it between you and heroin?
367
00:15:13,743 --> 00:15:15,658
Just trust me,
368
00:15:15,702 --> 00:15:17,269
whatever it is,
they're gonna find it.
369
00:15:17,312 --> 00:15:19,401
[sighs]
370
00:15:19,445 --> 00:15:21,621
And if I'm gonna
keep you out of prison,
371
00:15:21,664 --> 00:15:24,102
I need to know about it.
372
00:15:26,669 --> 00:15:29,846
Can we go somewhere
a little more private?
373
00:15:29,890 --> 00:15:33,633
HARPER:
Couple of years ago, I broke
my ankle playing basketball.
374
00:15:33,676 --> 00:15:37,942
Emergency room doctor
prescribed oxycodone.
375
00:15:37,985 --> 00:15:40,857
I took it.
376
00:15:40,901 --> 00:15:43,686
I kept taking it,
even after my ankle healed.
377
00:15:46,037 --> 00:15:48,474
And I'd never done drugs before.
378
00:15:48,517 --> 00:15:52,260
I mean, never so much
as smoked pot in college.
379
00:15:53,783 --> 00:15:55,742
It was so serene being high.
380
00:15:55,785 --> 00:15:58,266
So tranquil.
381
00:15:58,310 --> 00:16:00,007
Mm.
382
00:16:00,051 --> 00:16:02,531
I never experienced that before.
383
00:16:02,575 --> 00:16:04,838
You ever write your
own prescription?
384
00:16:04,881 --> 00:16:06,187
A doctor writing
his own prescription
385
00:16:06,231 --> 00:16:07,797
for a controlled substance--
386
00:16:07,841 --> 00:16:10,713
the AMA would not
look kindly on that.
387
00:16:10,757 --> 00:16:12,150
No. Never.
388
00:16:12,193 --> 00:16:14,500
The prescriptions were
all legitimate.
389
00:16:14,543 --> 00:16:16,850
All from other doctors.
390
00:16:18,547 --> 00:16:20,636
Of course,
my wife figured it out.
391
00:16:21,855 --> 00:16:25,076
Mm, she knew
something was going on.
392
00:16:25,119 --> 00:16:26,860
She threw away the pills
393
00:16:26,903 --> 00:16:29,994
and threatened to leave
with the kids if I didn't quit.
394
00:16:30,037 --> 00:16:33,258
Did you go to rehab?
395
00:16:33,301 --> 00:16:34,955
No, I did it myself.
396
00:16:34,999 --> 00:16:38,089
It was rough, but...
I was lucky.
397
00:16:38,132 --> 00:16:41,048
I was able to do it on my own.
398
00:16:41,092 --> 00:16:44,399
My wife's the only one
who knows.
399
00:16:44,443 --> 00:16:46,227
I wouldn't count on that.
400
00:16:46,271 --> 00:16:48,055
I'm sure the A.D.A.
has already gone
401
00:16:48,099 --> 00:16:50,753
through your prescription
records, and once
402
00:16:50,797 --> 00:16:52,712
he sees multiples on the oxy,
he is gonna make the case
403
00:16:52,755 --> 00:16:56,063
that you got tired of having to
beg your doctors to supply you
404
00:16:56,107 --> 00:16:59,545
with drugs and switched
to heroin, which is what happens
405
00:16:59,588 --> 00:17:02,983
more often than not
when people get hooked on oxy.
406
00:17:03,027 --> 00:17:06,334
But... that would be a lie.
407
00:17:06,378 --> 00:17:10,904
Look, I swear to you,
I have never done heroin,
408
00:17:10,947 --> 00:17:14,908
and I've never heard
of this man.
409
00:17:16,910 --> 00:17:20,392
I did not,
I could not kill that man.
410
00:17:20,435 --> 00:17:22,437
[clicks tongue]
411
00:17:22,481 --> 00:17:24,483
Okay.
412
00:17:24,526 --> 00:17:28,356
Then we're not putting the wife
on the stand.
413
00:17:28,400 --> 00:17:29,836
Jody? She's his alibi.
414
00:17:29,879 --> 00:17:32,839
Well, no. She is also the
only one who knows that he had
415
00:17:32,882 --> 00:17:35,102
an addiction
to opioid painkillers,
416
00:17:35,146 --> 00:17:38,975
the most common gateway drug
to heroin, which is what
417
00:17:39,019 --> 00:17:40,542
the murder victim was selling.
418
00:17:40,586 --> 00:17:42,675
But what if
the A.D.A. calls her?
419
00:17:42,718 --> 00:17:45,939
Well, then we'll just have
to claim spousal privilege.
420
00:17:45,982 --> 00:17:48,855
I mean,
she's married to the accused.
421
00:17:48,898 --> 00:17:50,900
They can't compel her
to take the stand.
422
00:17:50,944 --> 00:17:55,209
I don't like it,
but what choice do we have?
423
00:17:56,254 --> 00:17:58,821
Morning.
Get your scorecards.
424
00:17:58,865 --> 00:18:01,998
You can't tell the players
without a scorecard.
425
00:18:05,132 --> 00:18:06,438
What's going on?
426
00:18:06,481 --> 00:18:08,527
He's springing
a new witness on us.
427
00:18:08,570 --> 00:18:11,747
I don't know who he is
or how he ties in to all this.
428
00:18:11,791 --> 00:18:13,836
Do you know a Dr. David Parsons?
429
00:18:15,838 --> 00:18:18,058
He's my neighbor.
430
00:18:18,102 --> 00:18:20,016
Just your neighbor?
431
00:18:20,060 --> 00:18:22,541
Well, he's a doctor.
432
00:18:22,584 --> 00:18:25,674
Your oxy connection, right?
433
00:18:32,986 --> 00:18:35,119
COLLINS:
Dr. Parsons, how do you
know Dr. Michael Harper?
434
00:18:35,162 --> 00:18:38,165
We've been neighbors and friends
for the past seven years.
435
00:18:38,209 --> 00:18:42,387
Around the same age,
both in the same profession.
436
00:18:42,430 --> 00:18:45,520
And have you ever treated
Dr. Harper as a patient?
437
00:18:45,564 --> 00:18:48,088
Depends on how
you define "patient."
438
00:18:48,132 --> 00:18:50,046
He is a friend.
439
00:18:50,090 --> 00:18:53,137
And I did help him
with some follow-up
440
00:18:53,180 --> 00:18:55,704
after he broke his ankle
a few years ago.
441
00:18:55,748 --> 00:18:58,011
What kind of follow-up?
442
00:18:59,055 --> 00:19:01,188
Pain management.
443
00:19:01,232 --> 00:19:05,453
This was a few months
after he broke it.
444
00:19:05,497 --> 00:19:09,022
He told me
the ankle was still acting up.
445
00:19:09,065 --> 00:19:11,764
And so you wrote him
a prescription for oxycodone?
446
00:19:11,807 --> 00:19:13,374
An opiate?
447
00:19:13,418 --> 00:19:14,767
I did.
448
00:19:14,810 --> 00:19:16,638
Did you believe he was in pain?
449
00:19:16,682 --> 00:19:18,423
Most definitely.
450
00:19:18,466 --> 00:19:21,077
Most definitely?
451
00:19:21,121 --> 00:19:23,297
The truth is,
you had no way
452
00:19:23,341 --> 00:19:25,473
of really knowing,
did you, Dr. Parsons?
453
00:19:29,738 --> 00:19:32,306
Did you?
454
00:19:32,350 --> 00:19:34,656
The witness will please
answer the question.
455
00:19:36,832 --> 00:19:38,747
I depended largely
456
00:19:38,791 --> 00:19:42,664
on Dr. Harper's
anecdotal impressions,
457
00:19:42,708 --> 00:19:45,101
but that's true
with many patients.
458
00:19:45,145 --> 00:19:48,540
But again, it had been
three months since the accident.
459
00:19:48,583 --> 00:19:50,455
Yeah, that's true,
but it is not unusual for...
460
00:19:50,498 --> 00:19:52,108
In fact, you didn't write
him one prescription.
461
00:19:52,152 --> 00:19:53,371
You wrote him
three, didn't you?
462
00:19:53,414 --> 00:19:55,111
Over a period
of about six weeks.
463
00:19:55,155 --> 00:19:58,202
And was that it, or
did he ask for another?
464
00:20:02,728 --> 00:20:05,948
I'd like to remind you
you are under oath, Dr. Parsons.
465
00:20:08,777 --> 00:20:10,736
Yes, he did.
466
00:20:10,779 --> 00:20:14,218
But you said "no"?
467
00:20:16,698 --> 00:20:18,657
I became concerned.
468
00:20:18,700 --> 00:20:20,746
I spoke to his wife.Is it safe
469
00:20:20,789 --> 00:20:22,356
to assume
that you no longer thought
470
00:20:22,400 --> 00:20:24,184
he was most definitely in pain?
471
00:20:24,228 --> 00:20:25,838
You could assume that.
472
00:20:25,881 --> 00:20:27,448
And isn't it
true that when
473
00:20:27,492 --> 00:20:29,929
an addict can no longer get
a prescription for oxycodone,
474
00:20:29,972 --> 00:20:32,279
it's common for them
to turn to street drugs?
475
00:20:32,323 --> 00:20:35,326
Most often heroin, which is
exactly what Joseph Lowell sold?
476
00:20:35,369 --> 00:20:36,588
LINDSEY:
Objection!
477
00:20:36,631 --> 00:20:38,242
Speculation.
478
00:20:38,285 --> 00:20:41,288
Dr. Parsons is not an addiction
expert, nor is he a mind reader.
479
00:20:41,332 --> 00:20:44,073
Your Honor,
David Parsons is a doctor,
480
00:20:44,117 --> 00:20:45,901
and his training makes him
intimately familiar
481
00:20:45,945 --> 00:20:48,121
with the world
of opioid painkillers.
482
00:20:48,164 --> 00:20:49,165
I'll allow it.
483
00:20:49,209 --> 00:20:50,906
COLLINS:
Dr. Parsons,
484
00:20:50,950 --> 00:20:54,301
doesn't oxycodone addiction
commonly lead
485
00:20:54,345 --> 00:20:55,824
to heroin addiction?
486
00:21:01,395 --> 00:21:03,267
[sighs]
487
00:21:03,310 --> 00:21:06,095
Yes.
488
00:21:06,139 --> 00:21:08,663
That's the conventional wisdom.
489
00:21:10,752 --> 00:21:14,278
COLLINS:
No further questions,
Your Honor.
490
00:21:20,545 --> 00:21:24,462
Oh, um, would you have
anything a little stronger?
491
00:21:24,505 --> 00:21:28,857
I might have a little something
under lock and key.
492
00:21:28,901 --> 00:21:30,642
I'll be right back.
493
00:21:32,383 --> 00:21:34,341
BENNY:
You know,
494
00:21:34,385 --> 00:21:37,213
just because a person
abused a prescription drug,
495
00:21:37,257 --> 00:21:39,390
that doesn't make
them a killer.
496
00:21:39,433 --> 00:21:43,132
No. The DNA
makes him a killer.
497
00:21:43,176 --> 00:21:45,352
The oxy habit is
just the assistant
498
00:21:45,396 --> 00:21:47,180
district attorney's way
of dotting all the "I"s
499
00:21:47,223 --> 00:21:48,660
and crossing all the "T"s,
500
00:21:48,703 --> 00:21:52,316
lest any juror try to cultivate
some reasonable doubt.
501
00:21:53,447 --> 00:21:54,970
Anyone else?
502
00:21:55,014 --> 00:21:56,363
Dr. Bull?
503
00:21:56,407 --> 00:21:59,453
Never on a day that ends in "Y."
504
00:22:01,281 --> 00:22:03,501
I'm sorry
I got you all into this.
505
00:22:04,806 --> 00:22:06,242
Who am I kidding?
506
00:22:06,286 --> 00:22:08,375
I'm sorry
I got myselfinto this.
507
00:22:08,419 --> 00:22:09,985
DANNY:
Dr. Bull,
508
00:22:10,029 --> 00:22:11,726
you know, ever since
you told us that story
509
00:22:11,770 --> 00:22:14,381
about the, uh, the old lady
with the cotton swabs,
510
00:22:14,425 --> 00:22:18,298
I've been researching false
positives as they relate to DNA.
511
00:22:18,342 --> 00:22:20,039
And while there
aren't a lot of them,
512
00:22:20,082 --> 00:22:23,172
there was a case in California,
uh, just a few years ago.
513
00:22:23,216 --> 00:22:24,870
Let's see.
514
00:22:24,913 --> 00:22:27,655
Guy was arrested for murder
based solely on DNA evidence,
515
00:22:27,699 --> 00:22:29,091
just like Dr. Harper,
516
00:22:29,135 --> 00:22:31,224
and he swore up and down
he was innocent.
517
00:22:31,267 --> 00:22:32,965
And it turns out, he was.
518
00:22:33,008 --> 00:22:35,402
They figured out
his DNA ended up on the victim
519
00:22:35,446 --> 00:22:37,404
because of something called
"DNA migration."
520
00:22:37,448 --> 00:22:39,363
Never heard of it. You?
521
00:22:39,406 --> 00:22:40,929
No.
522
00:22:40,973 --> 00:22:43,279
It's the secondary
transfer of DNA.
523
00:22:43,323 --> 00:22:45,630
And it happens because
the average person sheds
524
00:22:45,673 --> 00:22:48,633
somewhere between 40
and 50 million skin cells a day.
525
00:22:48,676 --> 00:22:51,766
Turns out we leave them behind
everywhere we go
526
00:22:51,810 --> 00:22:53,638
on everything we touch.
527
00:22:53,681 --> 00:22:56,075
Door handles, elevator buttons,
528
00:22:56,118 --> 00:22:59,165
the creamer jug
at the coffee shop.
529
00:22:59,208 --> 00:23:00,906
Also, they don't stay put.
530
00:23:00,949 --> 00:23:03,430
Those cells, that DNA--
just end up on the next person
531
00:23:03,474 --> 00:23:05,389
who touches the creamer jug.
532
00:23:05,432 --> 00:23:07,347
Sounds like
you may have found a way
533
00:23:07,391 --> 00:23:09,393
to un-dot some "I"s
and uncross some "T"s.
534
00:23:09,436 --> 00:23:11,220
TAYLOR:
So you're saying
535
00:23:11,264 --> 00:23:13,614
a creamer jug or something
like it might explain
536
00:23:13,658 --> 00:23:15,355
how Dr. Harper's DNA
ended up
537
00:23:15,399 --> 00:23:17,096
under the dead man's
fingernails?
538
00:23:17,139 --> 00:23:18,227
Exactly.
539
00:23:18,271 --> 00:23:20,360
Marissa, line up
a DNA expert,
540
00:23:20,404 --> 00:23:23,189
someone who can spoon-feed
this concept to the jury.
541
00:23:23,232 --> 00:23:25,234
You think that'll be enough?
542
00:23:25,278 --> 00:23:29,413
No. We'll need something
concrete, some kind of proof
543
00:23:29,456 --> 00:23:32,764
that our client and
the murder victim were both in
544
00:23:32,807 --> 00:23:34,592
the same place
on the day of the murder.
545
00:23:34,635 --> 00:23:36,115
Taylor, is there
any way you could try
546
00:23:36,158 --> 00:23:38,813
and retrace the steps
of both men that day,
547
00:23:38,857 --> 00:23:42,469
see if there's a point
of intersection,
548
00:23:42,513 --> 00:23:44,428
hopefully a mutual point
of contact?
549
00:23:44,471 --> 00:23:48,127
With a little luck...
and some loud music.
550
00:23:48,170 --> 00:23:51,435
Is that something you might be
available to do tonight?
551
00:23:51,478 --> 00:23:53,393
I think we can make that happen.
552
00:23:53,437 --> 00:23:55,613
[hip-hop music playing nearby]
553
00:23:55,656 --> 00:24:00,182
♪ I'm lit, throw it in the air,
we ain't worried about it... ♪
554
00:24:00,226 --> 00:24:02,446
TAYLOR:
We know Dr. Harper lives here,
555
00:24:02,489 --> 00:24:04,752
and he works here.
556
00:24:04,796 --> 00:24:06,493
He takes the Metro-North Train
557
00:24:06,537 --> 00:24:07,886
from White Plains
to Grand Central.
558
00:24:07,929 --> 00:24:09,496
DANNY:
Makes sense.
559
00:24:09,540 --> 00:24:11,498
And based on the info
from the victim's phone,
560
00:24:11,542 --> 00:24:14,458
we know that after he dropped
his son off at school,
561
00:24:14,501 --> 00:24:16,372
the day of his death,
he came into Manhattan
562
00:24:16,416 --> 00:24:19,898
to "make some deliveries"
and "solicit new business."
563
00:24:19,941 --> 00:24:23,336
Based on where he lived, I
realized it was almost certain
564
00:24:23,379 --> 00:24:26,339
he took the subway
from 180th Street
565
00:24:26,382 --> 00:24:27,732
to...?Grand Central Station.
566
00:24:27,775 --> 00:24:29,298
Exactly.
567
00:24:29,342 --> 00:24:32,214
All right. So, that's our
potential point of intersection,
568
00:24:32,258 --> 00:24:34,347
our haystack.
569
00:24:34,390 --> 00:24:36,523
The good doctor and
the drug dealer are our needles.
570
00:24:36,567 --> 00:24:39,700
[typing]
571
00:24:39,744 --> 00:24:43,574
How did you get this
in the middle of the night?
572
00:24:43,617 --> 00:24:45,706
I just called the MTA.
573
00:24:45,750 --> 00:24:47,621
And they just
gave it to you?
574
00:24:47,665 --> 00:24:50,058
Yup. Of course...
575
00:24:50,102 --> 00:24:53,540
I might have cheated,
might have forgotten to mention
576
00:24:53,584 --> 00:24:57,544
I no longer work
with Homeland.
577
00:24:57,588 --> 00:24:59,590
You're scary.
578
00:24:59,633 --> 00:25:01,896
But still,
it's Grand Central Station.
579
00:25:01,940 --> 00:25:04,116
There's got to be, what,
hundreds of thousands of people
580
00:25:04,159 --> 00:25:05,596
going through there
every day?
581
00:25:05,639 --> 00:25:07,336
How are you gonna
find Dr. Harper?
582
00:25:07,380 --> 00:25:09,643
I already did.
583
00:25:09,687 --> 00:25:11,863
There are only so many
trains from White Plains
584
00:25:11,906 --> 00:25:13,429
that line up with
his office hours.
585
00:25:13,473 --> 00:25:14,996
I worked backward
from there.
586
00:25:15,040 --> 00:25:16,868
Already strung together
all the footage he's in,
587
00:25:16,911 --> 00:25:18,826
from the moment he walks
in the doors at the station
588
00:25:18,870 --> 00:25:20,567
until he gets on the train.
589
00:25:20,611 --> 00:25:23,309
I was just about to review it
when you showed up.
590
00:25:23,352 --> 00:25:26,094
I want you in my lifeboat, baby.
591
00:25:27,313 --> 00:25:29,533
DANNY:
Well, he's pretty relaxed
592
00:25:29,576 --> 00:25:32,579
for a man planning
to kill a guy later that night.
593
00:25:32,623 --> 00:25:34,102
Oh, my God, that's it.
594
00:25:34,146 --> 00:25:35,669
The guy even
595
00:25:35,713 --> 00:25:38,585
grabs Dr. Harper's
arm with his hand,
596
00:25:38,629 --> 00:25:40,544
with his fingernails.
597
00:25:42,241 --> 00:25:43,459
DANNY:
All right, now tell me
598
00:25:43,503 --> 00:25:45,418
you have an angle
where we can see his face.
599
00:25:45,461 --> 00:25:47,463
That's all I've got.
600
00:25:49,378 --> 00:25:51,990
DANNY: [sighs]
This can't be it.
601
00:25:52,033 --> 00:25:54,601
That woman, there?
602
00:25:54,645 --> 00:25:57,212
She's got her phone up
like she's taking a selfie?
603
00:25:58,910 --> 00:26:02,609
What are the chances she has
both our guys in that photo?
604
00:26:02,653 --> 00:26:04,524
Mm, it's a long shot.
605
00:26:04,568 --> 00:26:06,439
You know what's
also a long shot?
606
00:26:06,482 --> 00:26:10,399
That I can figure out
or find out who that woman is,
607
00:26:10,443 --> 00:26:12,401
what her cell phone
IP address is,
608
00:26:12,445 --> 00:26:15,535
crack it
and find the picture.
609
00:26:17,668 --> 00:26:20,627
But is it...
impossible?
610
00:26:24,631 --> 00:26:27,416
Dr. Bull, Mr. Colón?
611
00:26:27,460 --> 00:26:29,636
I was just about to leave my
office when I was delivered
612
00:26:29,680 --> 00:26:32,857
an updated witness list
from the A.D.A.
613
00:26:32,900 --> 00:26:34,510
They're putting Sam Lowell
on the stand.
614
00:26:34,554 --> 00:26:37,601
The victim's son.
He's a child.
615
00:26:37,644 --> 00:26:39,603
COLLINS:
Good morning.
616
00:26:39,646 --> 00:26:42,214
Sam, thank you for
testifying today.
617
00:26:42,257 --> 00:26:43,911
You're welcome.
618
00:26:43,955 --> 00:26:46,261
COLLINS:
You understand this is
619
00:26:46,305 --> 00:26:49,656
a court of law, that when
people sit in that chair
620
00:26:49,700 --> 00:26:51,745
you're sitting in they're
expected to tell the truth?
621
00:26:51,789 --> 00:26:53,268
I know that.
622
00:26:53,312 --> 00:26:54,661
Good.
623
00:26:54,705 --> 00:26:57,925
So with that in mind,
624
00:26:57,969 --> 00:27:01,276
can you tell me about the
night your father was murdered?
625
00:27:01,320 --> 00:27:04,497
Yes, sir.
626
00:27:04,540 --> 00:27:07,631
COLLINS: So after you heard
your father let in a stranger,
627
00:27:07,674 --> 00:27:10,677
you opened your bedroom
door and looked out.
628
00:27:10,721 --> 00:27:12,766
Can you tell us
what you saw?
629
00:27:12,810 --> 00:27:15,639
I saw my...
630
00:27:15,682 --> 00:27:18,903
I saw my dad...
631
00:27:18,946 --> 00:27:21,645
lying on the ground.
632
00:27:21,688 --> 00:27:24,691
There was a lot of blood.
633
00:27:24,735 --> 00:27:27,346
And did you see
anything else?
634
00:27:27,389 --> 00:27:29,914
Did you see anybody else?
635
00:27:29,957 --> 00:27:33,700
I saw... a man.
636
00:27:33,744 --> 00:27:35,702
And that man...
637
00:27:37,138 --> 00:27:39,706
Do you see that man
in this courtroom today?
638
00:27:41,621 --> 00:27:43,188
He's right over there.
639
00:27:43,231 --> 00:27:45,364
[gallery gasping, murmuring]
640
00:27:52,327 --> 00:27:55,809
The simple truth is
they have... your DNA.
641
00:27:55,853 --> 00:27:57,593
They have an eyewitness,
642
00:27:57,637 --> 00:27:59,508
and they have created
a plausible
643
00:27:59,552 --> 00:28:02,207
relationship between you
and the victim
644
00:28:02,250 --> 00:28:06,080
based on your dependence
on oxycodone.
645
00:28:06,124 --> 00:28:09,083
I thought
that you had some theory
646
00:28:09,127 --> 00:28:12,652
about my DNA
and the victim's DNA--
647
00:28:12,696 --> 00:28:14,915
maybe I bumped into him
somewhere.
648
00:28:14,959 --> 00:28:16,917
Grand Central Station.
649
00:28:16,961 --> 00:28:18,745
"He" turned out to be a she.
650
00:28:21,792 --> 00:28:23,924
The girl who tripped
on the stairs?
651
00:28:25,404 --> 00:28:27,928
If only you
had asked me.
652
00:28:27,972 --> 00:28:30,931
I'm sorry
to have gotten your hopes up.
653
00:28:30,975 --> 00:28:33,542
I really do believe
654
00:28:33,586 --> 00:28:36,197
this is the best course
of action.
655
00:28:44,118 --> 00:28:47,731
Gosh. If I had known
I was gonna be so outnumbered,
656
00:28:47,774 --> 00:28:49,863
I'd have brought
more people.
657
00:28:56,696 --> 00:28:59,568
My client has never wavered in
his proclamation of innocence.
658
00:28:59,612 --> 00:29:02,180
And I would not want
these conversations to suggest
659
00:29:02,223 --> 00:29:04,138
otherwise.But?
660
00:29:04,182 --> 00:29:08,621
But... what kind of terms
might we be able to come to
661
00:29:08,664 --> 00:29:12,364
if... Dr. Harper agreed
to plead guilty?
662
00:29:12,407 --> 00:29:15,149
Well...
663
00:29:15,193 --> 00:29:17,717
he's staring at 25
to life right now.
664
00:29:19,197 --> 00:29:20,981
I'd go to 20.
665
00:29:21,025 --> 00:29:22,983
Well, that's not
much of a deal.
666
00:29:23,027 --> 00:29:25,420
The man is in his 40s.
667
00:29:25,464 --> 00:29:27,379
You're right.
668
00:29:27,422 --> 00:29:29,598
Forget it. Let's just
let the jury decide.
669
00:29:29,642 --> 00:29:31,600
15 years to life.
670
00:29:31,644 --> 00:29:34,821
No parole prior
to 15 years served.
671
00:29:34,865 --> 00:29:38,085
Let's keep in mind, he's charged
with killing a drug dealer.
672
00:29:38,129 --> 00:29:41,523
That doesn't make the murder
any less of a crime,
673
00:29:41,567 --> 00:29:43,830
but you never know
what might happen
674
00:29:43,874 --> 00:29:45,397
during jury deliberations.
675
00:29:45,440 --> 00:29:47,791
Someone might seize
on it, and...
676
00:29:49,314 --> 00:29:51,272
15 to life.
677
00:29:51,316 --> 00:29:53,274
You should be a lawyer.
678
00:29:53,318 --> 00:29:55,407
I need 24 hours
to sell it to my client.
679
00:29:55,450 --> 00:29:58,889
I'll call the judge and request
a recess for tomorrow.
680
00:30:01,152 --> 00:30:03,589
HARPER: I can't make sense
of any of it.
681
00:30:03,632 --> 00:30:06,157
I mean, you
are asking me
682
00:30:06,200 --> 00:30:09,029
to willingly agree to...
to give up a minimum
683
00:30:09,073 --> 00:30:11,684
of a decade and
a half of my life.
684
00:30:15,035 --> 00:30:18,473
And my girls will be all
grown up by the time I get out.
685
00:30:20,519 --> 00:30:23,478
My wife...
686
00:30:23,522 --> 00:30:25,654
if she's still willing
to be my wife...
687
00:30:25,698 --> 00:30:29,006
Stop that.
Sorry.
688
00:30:29,049 --> 00:30:31,486
[sighs]
689
00:30:31,530 --> 00:30:33,575
It's just this...
690
00:30:33,619 --> 00:30:36,404
This defies all
logic for me.
691
00:30:38,276 --> 00:30:40,321
I mean, it's...
692
00:30:40,365 --> 00:30:41,975
It's like I'm discovering
693
00:30:42,019 --> 00:30:44,021
that night no longer
follows day,
694
00:30:44,064 --> 00:30:48,068
that the ground is not beneath
us, the sky is not above us.
695
00:30:50,549 --> 00:30:55,206
I never met that man
they said I killed.
696
00:30:55,249 --> 00:30:57,164
And that little boy...
697
00:30:57,208 --> 00:30:59,558
he's wrong...
698
00:30:59,601 --> 00:31:02,648
or confused about
what he saw.
699
00:31:03,692 --> 00:31:05,738
And as far as
700
00:31:05,781 --> 00:31:09,916
the DNA evidence
is concerned,
701
00:31:09,960 --> 00:31:12,136
I'm a doctor.
702
00:31:12,179 --> 00:31:16,096
I'm a man of science. I know
that what they are asserting...
703
00:31:16,140 --> 00:31:18,272
is absolute.
704
00:31:18,316 --> 00:31:20,405
It's unimpeachable.
705
00:31:21,536 --> 00:31:26,237
The only problem
is I'm me,
706
00:31:26,280 --> 00:31:30,415
24 hours a day.
707
00:31:30,458 --> 00:31:33,374
I was not there,
I did not do it,
708
00:31:33,418 --> 00:31:35,637
and I know that with
just as much certainty
709
00:31:35,681 --> 00:31:39,424
as the science is
screaming that I must have.
710
00:31:40,468 --> 00:31:42,383
[Jody sniffles]
711
00:31:42,427 --> 00:31:44,733
If only I didn't
send that sample.
712
00:31:44,777 --> 00:31:47,171
No. Mm-mm.I'm sorry.
713
00:31:50,739 --> 00:31:53,394
It was such a
thoughtful thing.
714
00:31:56,484 --> 00:32:00,010
My parents,
715
00:32:00,053 --> 00:32:04,362
they never liked to
talk about the past.[sniffles]
716
00:32:04,405 --> 00:32:06,625
Whenever I'd ask them
where we came from,
717
00:32:06,668 --> 00:32:09,019
they'd just throw their
hands up in the air
718
00:32:09,062 --> 00:32:11,282
and say we were
Americans.
719
00:32:13,110 --> 00:32:15,764
To finally read about...
720
00:32:15,808 --> 00:32:17,418
my family's history,
721
00:32:17,462 --> 00:32:20,856
the bad parts,
the slave ships...[sniffles]
722
00:32:20,900 --> 00:32:23,424
...the good parts.
723
00:32:24,425 --> 00:32:26,993
That my ancestors fought
724
00:32:27,037 --> 00:32:30,214
side by side with
the colonists to...
725
00:32:30,257 --> 00:32:34,348
secure this freedom for
this country from Britain.
726
00:32:34,392 --> 00:32:36,394
[sniffles]
727
00:32:38,526 --> 00:32:41,529
I'm the last of the line.
728
00:32:43,531 --> 00:32:46,491
And my legacy is...
729
00:32:46,534 --> 00:32:49,450
I killed a man.
730
00:32:52,149 --> 00:32:55,891
Not that I've helped hundreds
of kids get through...
731
00:32:55,935 --> 00:32:59,025
infancy and adolescence
732
00:32:59,069 --> 00:33:01,854
in good health.
733
00:33:04,161 --> 00:33:07,729
Not that I married
this amazing woman.
734
00:33:07,773 --> 00:33:09,340
[sniffles]
735
00:33:09,383 --> 00:33:14,301
And helped bring two phenomenal
girls into this world.
736
00:33:16,173 --> 00:33:17,739
Just...
737
00:33:17,783 --> 00:33:19,915
[sniffles]
738
00:33:19,959 --> 00:33:22,788
...I killed a man.
739
00:33:24,529 --> 00:33:27,227
A man I never met.
740
00:33:34,582 --> 00:33:37,716
I promised the A.D.A. that...
741
00:33:37,759 --> 00:33:41,111
we'd let him know
within 24 hours.
742
00:33:43,156 --> 00:33:44,679
[sniffles]
743
00:33:50,946 --> 00:33:52,905
[elevator bell chimes]
744
00:33:55,125 --> 00:33:57,127
[keys jangling]
745
00:34:07,615 --> 00:34:10,749
7:22 in the morning.
746
00:34:10,792 --> 00:34:12,098
Definitely makes me
an early bird.
747
00:34:12,142 --> 00:34:14,057
Question is,
does that make you two worms?
748
00:34:14,100 --> 00:34:16,711
I couldn't sleep.
749
00:34:16,755 --> 00:34:18,061
I called Taylor.
750
00:34:18,104 --> 00:34:19,671
Luckily, I was alone.
751
00:34:19,714 --> 00:34:22,587
And she agreed to come in here
and help me with something.
752
00:34:22,630 --> 00:34:25,024
Get back to the part where
you said you couldn't sleep.
753
00:34:25,068 --> 00:34:29,028
I just couldn't stop thinking
about poor Dr. Harper.
754
00:34:29,072 --> 00:34:31,204
You were not alone
in that. [sighs]
755
00:34:31,248 --> 00:34:33,989
Something in the way he said
his parents never wanted to talk
756
00:34:34,033 --> 00:34:36,731
about the past, how it
seemed like he's spent...
757
00:34:36,775 --> 00:34:38,994
his whole life feeling...
758
00:34:39,038 --> 00:34:40,822
disconnected.
759
00:34:40,866 --> 00:34:43,173
I'm not unfamiliar
with that feeling.
760
00:34:43,216 --> 00:34:45,827
You're talking about...
761
00:34:45,871 --> 00:34:47,916
being adopted.
762
00:34:47,960 --> 00:34:50,919
[exhales] Dr. Harper
wasn't adopted.
763
00:34:50,963 --> 00:34:53,487
I don't understand
how any of this applies.
764
00:34:54,532 --> 00:34:57,100
Found this 45 minutes ago.
765
00:34:58,927 --> 00:35:01,234
BULL:
What am I looking at?
766
00:35:01,278 --> 00:35:02,670
His mother's
medical records.
767
00:35:02,714 --> 00:35:04,542
The woman he believes
is his mother.
768
00:35:04,585 --> 00:35:07,197
Elinor Harper had
a hysterectomy at 23.
769
00:35:07,240 --> 00:35:08,459
Uterine fibroids.
770
00:35:08,502 --> 00:35:11,462
Dr. Harper came into her life
when she was 28.
771
00:35:11,505 --> 00:35:13,159
She can't be his
biological mother.
772
00:35:13,203 --> 00:35:14,117
It's not possible.
773
00:35:17,381 --> 00:35:20,123
So, why am I looking
at this birth certificate?
774
00:35:20,166 --> 00:35:21,254
I mean, who is this?
775
00:35:21,298 --> 00:35:23,604
Who is... Jackson McKay?
776
00:35:24,649 --> 00:35:26,825
You are, Dr. Harper.
777
00:35:26,868 --> 00:35:29,393
Jackson McKay
was your name
778
00:35:29,436 --> 00:35:31,351
for the first 14 months
of your life,
779
00:35:31,395 --> 00:35:33,614
right up until your parents,
the Harpers,
780
00:35:33,658 --> 00:35:35,268
adopted you.
781
00:35:35,312 --> 00:35:37,096
Adopted?
782
00:35:37,140 --> 00:35:39,098
I'm not adopted.
783
00:35:39,142 --> 00:35:40,230
I know it's got
to come as a shock,
784
00:35:40,273 --> 00:35:42,667
but I have a folder full
of records here
785
00:35:42,710 --> 00:35:45,104
that proves you are.
786
00:35:45,148 --> 00:35:47,367
I'm sorry, why are you
telling us this now?
787
00:35:47,411 --> 00:35:49,978
This is why.
788
00:35:50,022 --> 00:35:52,285
What's this now?
789
00:35:52,329 --> 00:35:55,201
Your brother's
birth certificate.
790
00:35:55,245 --> 00:35:57,769
Your twin brother.
791
00:35:58,813 --> 00:36:01,425
Oh, my God.
792
00:36:01,468 --> 00:36:03,514
The only other person
on the planet
793
00:36:03,557 --> 00:36:07,387
who has exactly the same DNA
that you do.
794
00:36:07,431 --> 00:36:10,651
100% match.
795
00:36:10,695 --> 00:36:13,176
LINDSEY: Can you identify
the man in this photo?
796
00:36:14,220 --> 00:36:16,179
That's Brandon McKay.
797
00:36:16,222 --> 00:36:18,268
[gallery murmuring]
798
00:36:18,311 --> 00:36:20,270
LINDSEY:
And how do you know Mr. McKay?
799
00:36:20,313 --> 00:36:22,228
He's what we would call a client
800
00:36:22,272 --> 00:36:25,797
at the city shelter
on 156th Street where I work.
801
00:36:25,840 --> 00:36:27,277
Like a lot
of our clients,
802
00:36:27,320 --> 00:36:29,670
he would come in when it got
too cold to be on the street.
803
00:36:29,714 --> 00:36:31,019
Objection, Your Honor.
804
00:36:31,063 --> 00:36:33,021
What exactly is the point
of this witness?
805
00:36:33,065 --> 00:36:34,762
I have no idea, Counselor.
806
00:36:34,806 --> 00:36:37,243
But I assure you,
I'm fascinated.
807
00:36:37,287 --> 00:36:39,245
Objection overruled.
808
00:36:39,289 --> 00:36:42,988
You are a social worker
and addiction counselor.
809
00:36:43,031 --> 00:36:45,469
Can you talk about some
of the underlying conditions
810
00:36:45,512 --> 00:36:46,905
that you believe contributed
811
00:36:46,948 --> 00:36:49,299
to Mr. McKay's
chronic homelessness?
812
00:36:49,342 --> 00:36:50,735
Like a lot of our clients,
813
00:36:50,778 --> 00:36:53,172
Mr. McKay struggled
with an addiction to heroin.
814
00:36:53,216 --> 00:36:55,174
And he had a violent streak.
815
00:36:55,218 --> 00:36:56,915
I remember he got
into a fistfight with one
816
00:36:56,958 --> 00:36:59,004
of the other residents
two Christmases ago.
817
00:36:59,047 --> 00:37:01,615
Do you happen to have
his shelter records with you?
818
00:37:01,659 --> 00:37:04,444
I do.And do your records
happen to indicate
819
00:37:04,488 --> 00:37:06,316
Mr. McKay's birth date?
820
00:37:07,360 --> 00:37:10,276
March 2, 1975.
821
00:37:10,320 --> 00:37:14,237
The exact same birth
date as Dr. Harper.
822
00:37:14,280 --> 00:37:16,804
[gallery murmuring]
823
00:37:16,848 --> 00:37:18,197
Give me a sense.
824
00:37:18,241 --> 00:37:20,199
It's starting to look
less like a stoplight
825
00:37:20,243 --> 00:37:22,245
and more like a
Christmas tree in here.
826
00:37:24,638 --> 00:37:28,425
So, what did Brandon McKay
have that my client didn't?
827
00:37:28,468 --> 00:37:30,862
For one, motive.
828
00:37:30,905 --> 00:37:33,517
He was in dire need
of heroin and money.
829
00:37:33,560 --> 00:37:36,346
By robbing the victim's supply,
he could get both.
830
00:37:36,389 --> 00:37:39,392
Second,
opportunity.
831
00:37:39,436 --> 00:37:41,394
He was a known associate
of the victim,
832
00:37:41,438 --> 00:37:45,311
someone Joseph would've let into
his home no questions asked.
833
00:37:45,355 --> 00:37:48,575
And was Dr. Harper identified
by the victim's son?
834
00:37:48,619 --> 00:37:49,924
Of course.
835
00:37:49,968 --> 00:37:53,101
Because he looks exactly like
the murderer.
836
00:37:53,145 --> 00:37:55,190
He's his twin brother.
837
00:37:55,234 --> 00:37:57,932
But the most
important thing
838
00:37:57,976 --> 00:38:01,327
is the one thing
these two men shared.
839
00:38:01,371 --> 00:38:03,416
Their DNA.
840
00:38:03,460 --> 00:38:08,029
Identical twins' DNA
is identical.
841
00:38:08,073 --> 00:38:10,945
A 100% match.
842
00:38:10,989 --> 00:38:13,426
Which means
there is no way to tell
843
00:38:13,470 --> 00:38:16,864
which one of the brothers
committed this crime,
844
00:38:16,908 --> 00:38:19,606
even if, in your hearts,
845
00:38:19,650 --> 00:38:23,088
I think you already know.
846
00:38:27,222 --> 00:38:29,268
Very well then. That concludes
the closing arguments.
847
00:38:29,312 --> 00:38:32,053
And in anticipation
of the jury beginning
848
00:38:32,097 --> 00:38:33,054
their deliberations...
849
00:38:33,098 --> 00:38:34,360
Your Honor,
850
00:38:34,404 --> 00:38:36,884
I apologize for the,
uh, interruption.
851
00:38:36,928 --> 00:38:39,452
But before we ask
the jury to deliberate
852
00:38:39,496 --> 00:38:42,194
upon the evidence
and the testimony,
853
00:38:42,237 --> 00:38:44,414
I was hoping to request
a short recess
854
00:38:44,457 --> 00:38:47,025
so that I might confer
with opposing counsel
855
00:38:47,068 --> 00:38:51,551
and save the court and the jury
some time and...
856
00:38:51,595 --> 00:38:52,552
trouble.
857
00:38:52,596 --> 00:38:54,859
[gavel bangs]
858
00:38:54,902 --> 00:38:58,645
Let's take a 20-minute recess
in my chambers.
859
00:39:00,647 --> 00:39:02,214
What do you think
that means?
860
00:39:02,257 --> 00:39:03,824
Only good things.
861
00:39:06,479 --> 00:39:09,090
[quietly]: Do you
want some company?
862
00:39:09,134 --> 00:39:10,701
Sure.
863
00:39:12,746 --> 00:39:14,705
So,
864
00:39:14,748 --> 00:39:17,708
when he says they're
dropping all the charges...
865
00:39:17,751 --> 00:39:19,362
It means you're free.
866
00:39:19,405 --> 00:39:21,668
It means it's over. They realize
they made a mistake.
867
00:39:21,712 --> 00:39:22,887
BENNY:
A mistake you might
868
00:39:22,930 --> 00:39:24,454
actually want
to sue them for.Mm.
869
00:39:24,497 --> 00:39:27,370
But that's a conversation
we can have another time.
870
00:39:27,413 --> 00:39:30,764
So, now what happens
to my brother?
871
00:39:30,808 --> 00:39:32,592
Will there be
another trial?
872
00:39:32,636 --> 00:39:34,420
Well, if there were,
873
00:39:34,464 --> 00:39:36,683
the same way his DNA
gave us reasonable doubt,
874
00:39:36,727 --> 00:39:38,381
yours would do the same for him.
875
00:39:38,424 --> 00:39:41,384
There's no way, definitively,
876
00:39:41,427 --> 00:39:43,168
to prove which one
of you did it.
877
00:39:43,211 --> 00:39:45,431
So they won't prosecute?
878
00:39:45,475 --> 00:39:46,998
They can't.
879
00:39:47,041 --> 00:39:49,566
Dr. Harper,
the second we found out
880
00:39:49,609 --> 00:39:51,219
that you had
an identical twin,
881
00:39:51,263 --> 00:39:54,222
I had my team out
in the field looking for him.
882
00:39:54,266 --> 00:39:55,789
And we found him.
883
00:39:57,791 --> 00:39:59,184
I'm sorry.
884
00:39:59,227 --> 00:40:01,012
Uh...
885
00:40:01,055 --> 00:40:04,494
he's been in the Philadelphia
City Morgue for three days
886
00:40:04,537 --> 00:40:07,584
as a result of an overdose.
887
00:40:08,411 --> 00:40:10,369
Michael, he was a junkie.
888
00:40:10,413 --> 00:40:11,762
A murderer.
889
00:40:11,805 --> 00:40:14,460
But he looked
just like me.
890
00:40:14,504 --> 00:40:16,810
You're not the same.
891
00:40:16,854 --> 00:40:19,117
I know, but...
892
00:40:19,160 --> 00:40:22,686
still, I looked
him up on-online.
893
00:40:22,729 --> 00:40:25,515
We both played basketball
in high school.
894
00:40:25,558 --> 00:40:27,473
Forward.
895
00:40:27,517 --> 00:40:29,954
We both struggled
with addiction.
896
00:40:29,997 --> 00:40:33,479
I had a few fistfights
when I was young.
897
00:40:33,523 --> 00:40:35,612
We shared some demons.
898
00:40:35,655 --> 00:40:38,049
You're wondering why your life
turned out one way
899
00:40:38,092 --> 00:40:40,443
and his turned out another?No, I know.
900
00:40:40,486 --> 00:40:43,010
I had parents that
put me through school
901
00:40:43,054 --> 00:40:46,187
and a wife that helped
me with my sobriety.
902
00:40:46,231 --> 00:40:47,972
BULL: Maybe.
Let's not forget
903
00:40:48,015 --> 00:40:49,234
about free will.
904
00:40:49,277 --> 00:40:52,542
Our DNA is not our destiny.
905
00:40:52,585 --> 00:40:55,414
We can change it, piece
by piece, choice by choice.
906
00:40:55,458 --> 00:40:56,807
If we're strong enough.
907
00:40:56,850 --> 00:40:58,635
Which you were.
908
00:40:58,678 --> 00:41:00,419
So what about the boy?
909
00:41:00,463 --> 00:41:02,073
The victim's son.
910
00:41:02,116 --> 00:41:03,857
The one who
identified me.
911
00:41:03,901 --> 00:41:05,598
The assistant
district attorney said
912
00:41:05,642 --> 00:41:07,382
he went to live
with his cousins.
913
00:41:07,426 --> 00:41:10,429
They seem happy to have him,
and he seems happy to be there.
914
00:41:12,605 --> 00:41:15,565
You should go home,
play with your kids.
915
00:41:15,608 --> 00:41:17,436
It's a beautiful afternoon.
916
00:41:17,480 --> 00:41:20,483
That it is.
917
00:41:20,526 --> 00:41:23,486
["It's a Family Affair" by Sly
and the Family Stone playing]
918
00:41:24,835 --> 00:41:26,227
LINDSEY: So, what
is everybody else
919
00:41:26,271 --> 00:41:27,620
doing the rest of the day?
920
00:41:27,664 --> 00:41:29,143
Oh, I think I'm going home,
921
00:41:29,187 --> 00:41:30,797
calling my brother and sister.
922
00:41:30,841 --> 00:41:32,538
Wow.
923
00:41:32,582 --> 00:41:34,540
That's a great idea. I think
I'm gonna do the same thing.
924
00:41:34,584 --> 00:41:35,715
Dr. Bull?
925
00:41:35,759 --> 00:41:37,151
Actually, I'm gonna
go back to the office
926
00:41:37,195 --> 00:41:39,153
and try and track down
an old girlfriend.
927
00:41:39,197 --> 00:41:43,506
♪ It's a family affair
928
00:41:43,549 --> 00:41:45,986
♪ It's a family affair.
68576
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.