Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:02,563 --> 00:00:05,658
This program me contains scenes which
some viewers may find upsetting
2
00:01:28,683 --> 00:01:31,658
A whole body in a sealed freezer.
3
00:01:32,723 --> 00:01:33,938
It's shocking.
4
00:01:33,963 --> 00:01:35,458
It really is.
5
00:01:35,483 --> 00:01:39,978
West Midlands Police forensic lead
Sonia Parkinson
6
00:01:40,003 --> 00:01:45,138
has been called to investigate the
discovery of a body at a waste site.
7
00:01:45,163 --> 00:01:48,778
You couldn't expect anyone
to visually identify them.
8
00:01:48,803 --> 00:01:51,938
I mean, for one thing, it's just
too harrowing for someone.
9
00:01:53,523 --> 00:01:56,818
You can just see how
emaciated the person is.
10
00:01:56,843 --> 00:01:58,618
Almost skeletal.
11
00:02:00,163 --> 00:02:02,738
Someone's died
and the body has been concealed.
12
00:02:03,883 --> 00:02:05,818
Who would do that?
13
00:02:07,163 --> 00:02:08,338
Why?
14
00:02:12,443 --> 00:02:16,178
Have they been murdered
and put in there to hide them?
15
00:02:17,723 --> 00:02:20,698
The death is suspicious,
so we need to find out
16
00:02:20,723 --> 00:02:24,178
who it was and how they've ended up
17
00:02:24,203 --> 00:02:26,138
being stored in a freezer.
18
00:02:28,323 --> 00:02:30,778
Forensics don't lie.
19
00:02:30,803 --> 00:02:33,858
We recover evidence
and the evidence tells a story.
20
00:02:37,483 --> 00:02:39,978
A search of the skip yard records
21
00:02:40,003 --> 00:02:43,298
shows that the freezer was dropped
off by a council removal team.
22
00:02:43,323 --> 00:02:44,698
Right.
23
00:02:51,163 --> 00:02:53,418
With the body removed
for a postmortem,
24
00:02:53,443 --> 00:02:56,098
Sonia and the team can start
to examine the freezer.
25
00:02:58,163 --> 00:03:00,018
It smells as well. Mm.
26
00:03:01,643 --> 00:03:04,098
This is going to need
to be recovered.
27
00:03:05,763 --> 00:03:09,498
We've got some flies from, like,
from this edge, I think.
28
00:03:09,523 --> 00:03:12,458
Ancl we've still got some
liquid in there, haven't we?
29
00:03:12,483 --> 00:03:14,138
We need to take a sample of that.
30
00:03:15,843 --> 00:03:18,818
Obviously, the freezer
had defrosted,
31
00:03:18,843 --> 00:03:20,818
the body had been removed
32
00:03:20,843 --> 00:03:25,498
so all that is left
is putrefied body...
33
00:03:27,163 --> 00:03:31,138
...which would indicate that
it's been there for some time.
34
00:03:33,643 --> 00:03:37,938
The sample could provide a
DNA profile of the deceased,
35
00:03:37,963 --> 00:03:41,098
but there's a risk its DNA volume
might already be lost
36
00:03:41,123 --> 00:03:43,618
due to decomposition.
37
00:03:43,643 --> 00:03:45,898
Everything degrades
over a matter of time
38
00:03:45,923 --> 00:03:47,978
and that's the same for
forensic evidence, really.
39
00:03:49,003 --> 00:03:51,258
Well, I know a couple of these
have come from the scene
40
00:03:51,283 --> 00:03:53,098
along with the freezer.
41
00:03:53,123 --> 00:03:56,458
Yeah, it's there. It's the contents
of these bags, I think.
42
00:03:57,763 --> 00:04:00,258
The bags brought to the site
with the freezer
43
00:04:00,283 --> 00:04:03,658
will be examined for evidence,
which may help identify the body.
44
00:04:05,603 --> 00:04:08,138
Or the person who
placed it in the freezer.
45
00:04:13,683 --> 00:04:18,538
You want to be able to do your job
to the best of your ability.
46
00:04:18,563 --> 00:04:22,658
Any sort of evidence that's there,
you don't want to miss it.
47
00:04:22,683 --> 00:04:26,258
You want to get everything that you
can to get justice for the person.
48
00:04:27,283 --> 00:04:28,498
Fingerprints.
49
00:04:28,523 --> 00:04:31,378
We're looking
for any potential DNA -
50
00:04:31,403 --> 00:04:33,298
drinks bottles,
51
00:04:33,323 --> 00:04:35,898
erm, paperwork.
52
00:04:37,123 --> 00:04:39,418
The problem is
we've got contamination
53
00:04:39,443 --> 00:04:44,178
because it's a skip yard that has
rubbish delivered on a daily basis
54
00:04:44,203 --> 00:04:46,738
from around the West Midlands.
55
00:04:46,763 --> 00:04:49,818
There are lots of things at a scene
56
00:04:49,843 --> 00:04:52,698
that probably are completely
irrelevant to us.
57
00:04:56,803 --> 00:05:00,738
It's got maggots all around it,
like around the stitching and stuff.
58
00:05:00,763 --> 00:05:03,218
We know the body's decomposed,
59
00:05:03,243 --> 00:05:05,738
but we don't know how long
it's been there.
60
00:05:07,003 --> 00:05:11,058
Weird, isn't it? Yeah. Why's it
got maggots? Why's maggots...? Yeah.
61
00:05:11,083 --> 00:05:13,538
Ancl maggots can give us
an idea of time of death.
62
00:05:15,803 --> 00:05:17,858
The flies lay the eggs on the body,
63
00:05:17,883 --> 00:05:19,618
the eggs turn into maggots,
64
00:05:19,643 --> 00:05:22,418
feed off the body
cos it's full of nutrients.
65
00:05:22,443 --> 00:05:26,378
They then revert back into flies
and the whole cycle goes.
66
00:05:26,403 --> 00:05:28,938
Ancl depending on how many maggots
we have
67
00:05:28,963 --> 00:05:31,178
and what type of maggots they are,
68
00:05:31,203 --> 00:05:34,818
we can normally tell
what cycle it's in.
69
00:05:34,843 --> 00:05:39,058
With the site search concluded,
the freezer can be removed
70
00:05:39,083 --> 00:05:42,618
to look for clues of who the
deceased is and how they died.
71
00:05:44,483 --> 00:05:47,338
Could there be
fingerprints on the freezer?
72
00:05:47,363 --> 00:05:50,938
Were they alive
when they were put in that freezer?
73
00:05:52,523 --> 00:05:56,618
If we find other people's
fingerprints there, then why?
74
00:05:56,643 --> 00:06:00,058
What connection have they got
with that person's death?
75
00:06:18,083 --> 00:06:23,178
The forensic postmortem begins with
an initial examination of the body.
76
00:06:28,403 --> 00:06:31,418
Certainly profoundly decomposed.
77
00:06:33,323 --> 00:06:35,418
He's got a sock on his hand. Yeah.
78
00:06:36,403 --> 00:06:37,738
Strange.
79
00:06:39,643 --> 00:06:44,298
Forensic pathologist Dr Matt Lyall
notes physical features,
80
00:06:44,323 --> 00:06:47,418
which could help identify
the deceased.
81
00:06:48,963 --> 00:06:53,218
Over the course of my career
I've undertaken a thousand or so
82
00:06:53,243 --> 00:06:56,898
specifically forensic examinations.
83
00:06:59,003 --> 00:07:00,258
I've never...
84
00:07:01,323 --> 00:07:04,178
...seen a case quite like it before.
85
00:07:04,203 --> 00:07:06,898
Certainly quite frail-looking.
86
00:07:09,123 --> 00:07:13,338
The body is a very important
piece of evidence.
87
00:07:15,083 --> 00:07:18,138
You will often get clues
as to why they have died.
88
00:07:20,163 --> 00:07:22,978
The body was that of...
89
00:07:24,323 --> 00:07:29,058
...an adult male, probably white.
90
00:07:29,083 --> 00:07:32,098
Likely more advanced years.
91
00:07:32,123 --> 00:07:35,538
The head hair
appeared to be grey-white.
92
00:07:35,563 --> 00:07:40,258
A greying short moustache
and beard were evident.
93
00:07:41,843 --> 00:07:45,858
We try to find clues
as to the identity of the body.
94
00:07:47,283 --> 00:07:50,258
Does he have tattoos
that might assist us?
95
00:07:50,283 --> 00:07:53,658
Are there scars on the body
that suggest previous surgery?
96
00:07:54,963 --> 00:07:57,138
It might be a little scar.
It's not the best.
97
00:07:59,523 --> 00:08:05,258
The body was clearly altered
by decompositional change,
98
00:08:05,283 --> 00:08:08,258
with widespread discolouration
99
00:08:08,283 --> 00:08:10,778
of the skin's surface.
100
00:08:12,283 --> 00:08:15,458
What happens with decomposition
101
00:08:15,483 --> 00:08:18,458
is largely driven by bacteria.
102
00:08:18,483 --> 00:08:22,018
Those bacteria are normally
kept in check
103
00:08:22,043 --> 00:08:24,658
because we're alive, we
have an immune system
104
00:08:24,683 --> 00:08:26,698
and we have defences against them.
105
00:08:26,723 --> 00:08:29,578
But when you die,
106
00:08:29,603 --> 00:08:33,618
the bacteria multiply and
cause the body to decompose.
107
00:08:33,643 --> 00:08:36,698
There are a number
of very superficial...
108
00:08:37,923 --> 00:08:42,818
...ovoid areas of apparent
epidermal detachment.
109
00:08:43,883 --> 00:08:47,298
The skin will start to degrade,
110
00:08:47,323 --> 00:08:52,698
so it can go from green to a sort of
darker green to black in places.
111
00:08:54,323 --> 00:08:56,258
Can you take a piccy of that,
Sonia, as is?
112
00:08:57,963 --> 00:09:01,378
Once the initial
examination is done,
113
00:09:01,403 --> 00:09:04,418
Sonia can turn her attention
to the man's identity.
114
00:09:06,123 --> 00:09:09,498
Right, shall we have a go
at these fingerprints?
115
00:09:09,523 --> 00:09:14,538
Normally, we take fingerprints
at postmortems by using a powder.
116
00:09:14,563 --> 00:09:17,898
But this guy's fingers
were so decomposed,
117
00:09:17,923 --> 00:09:20,178
in the end I photographed them.
118
00:09:20,203 --> 00:09:22,138
R-middle.
119
00:09:23,363 --> 00:09:24,778
R-ring.
120
00:09:26,243 --> 00:09:29,858
Fingerprints are one of the
last things that degrade,
121
00:09:29,883 --> 00:09:33,658
but obviously in this case it
will be more difficult to identify
122
00:09:33,683 --> 00:09:36,658
the person if they're on record.
123
00:09:36,683 --> 00:09:39,818
The photographs of the man's
fingerprints will be searched
124
00:09:39,843 --> 00:09:42,018
against the
police national database.
125
00:09:50,363 --> 00:09:53,698
Police have traced the van that
took the freezer to the waste site
126
00:09:53,723 --> 00:09:55,458
to an address in Birmingham.
127
00:10:00,923 --> 00:10:03,698
Homicide detectives
join the forensic team
128
00:10:03,723 --> 00:10:05,338
for a search of the flat.
129
00:10:06,483 --> 00:10:09,018
We will investigate
any suspicious death.
130
00:10:10,483 --> 00:10:13,938
And if you've got a body
in a freezer,
131
00:10:13,963 --> 00:10:16,058
that looks like s0me0ne's
tried to get rid of it,
132
00:10:16,083 --> 00:10:18,458
then it is a murder inquiry.
133
00:10:24,443 --> 00:10:26,698
Your mind is racing.
134
00:10:26,723 --> 00:10:29,098
You think, "What am I
going to find in here?
135
00:10:30,523 --> 00:10:32,738
"What else will be here?
136
00:10:35,003 --> 00:10:38,418
"Will there be a scene?
Will there be blood splatter?
137
00:10:38,443 --> 00:10:40,858
"ls there a possibility of finding
other bodies in there?"
138
00:10:45,763 --> 00:10:49,578
You just never know
until you open that door.
139
00:10:54,443 --> 00:10:56,538
Do you want me to go first?
140
00:11:13,123 --> 00:11:15,498
Any sort of evidence that we
could find in that flat
141
00:11:15,523 --> 00:11:19,178
to link anyone to it,
we're looking out for.
142
00:11:19,203 --> 00:11:20,818
Is the power on?
143
00:11:20,843 --> 00:11:22,018
No. No.
144
00:11:39,643 --> 00:11:41,098
Oh, God.
145
00:11:44,003 --> 00:11:48,578
So this is the cupboard where
146
00:11:48,603 --> 00:11:50,338
the freezer has been.
147
00:12:05,083 --> 00:12:09,458
The reality of what has actually
happened is quite bleak.
148
00:12:11,043 --> 00:12:14,778
That's liquid that's
leaked out of the freezer.
149
00:12:16,243 --> 00:12:20,138
There's dead maggots
and putrefied liquid on the floor.
150
00:12:21,283 --> 00:12:23,258
Whether it was here all the time,
151
00:12:23,283 --> 00:12:25,458
obviously we don't know
at the moment, but...
152
00:12:25,483 --> 00:12:28,378
And there's no power socket
in there? No.
153
00:12:29,443 --> 00:12:33,578
There's no plug socket,
which means when the freezer
154
00:12:33,603 --> 00:12:37,458
had been sitting here for however
long it had been in there for,
155
00:12:37,483 --> 00:12:40,138
potentially it hadn't
even been plugged in,
156
00:12:40,163 --> 00:12:42,218
which would increase
the decomposition.
157
00:12:44,563 --> 00:12:47,178
KNOCKING ON DOOR
158
00:12:47,203 --> 00:12:50,258
With confirmation that the body
was in the flat,
159
00:12:50,283 --> 00:12:53,018
detectives start speaking
to neighbours
160
00:12:53,043 --> 00:12:56,258
to find out if they noticed
anything unusual.
161
00:12:56,283 --> 00:12:58,258
Hello, sorry to intrude,
my name's Pauljones.
162
00:12:58,283 --> 00:12:59,778
I'm a detective from the police.
163
00:12:59,803 --> 00:13:03,338
We want to find out
who's been living there,
164
00:13:03,363 --> 00:13:06,218
what's been happening,
who's been in and out,
165
00:13:06,243 --> 00:13:09,738
what can we find that could help us
progress our investigation.
166
00:13:09,763 --> 00:13:12,978
Sorry to bother you.
We're from the police.
167
00:13:13,003 --> 00:13:16,018
We're not sure, we're just doing
an investigation at the moment.
168
00:13:16,043 --> 00:13:19,218
The smell, I reported this, right?
Oh, go on, who did you report it to?
169
00:13:19,243 --> 00:13:21,498
I reported it to the
building administration,
170
00:13:21,523 --> 00:13:23,498
which totally ignored me twice.
171
00:13:23,523 --> 00:13:25,818
I said some stench and,
like, really terrible smell
172
00:13:25,843 --> 00:13:28,898
is coming out of the apartment.
When was that?
173
00:13:28,923 --> 00:13:31,298
That was back in Novemb...
In December, sorry.
174
00:13:31,323 --> 00:13:33,338
In December? OK.
175
00:13:33,363 --> 00:13:36,778
So if there's something going on,
I would like to see them. OK.
176
00:13:36,803 --> 00:13:39,418
So sorry to disturb you,
but you've been very helpful.
177
00:13:49,163 --> 00:13:50,498
The neighbour's saying, then,
178
00:13:50,523 --> 00:13:53,418
he's reported a smell in November
or December.
179
00:13:53,443 --> 00:13:56,458
Somebody's taken record...
You know, we just need
180
00:13:56,483 --> 00:13:58,578
clarification around it all.
MUFFLED SPEECH
181
00:13:58,603 --> 00:14:02,818
Well, yeah. Because...but then you'd
think they'd cross-reference, yeah.
182
00:14:04,683 --> 00:14:06,658
If the neighbour's dates
are accurate,
183
00:14:06,683 --> 00:14:08,938
the man could have been dead
nine months
184
00:14:08,963 --> 00:14:11,418
before his body was discovered
at the waste site.
185
00:14:13,883 --> 00:14:18,858
Are we potentially looking
at somebody who's been murdered
186
00:14:18,883 --> 00:14:21,018
and put in a freezer?
187
00:14:21,043 --> 00:14:26,578
Are we looking at somebody
who has died of natural causes?
188
00:14:27,763 --> 00:14:31,018
There could be of fences
of concealing a body,
189
00:14:31,043 --> 00:14:33,978
preventing unlawful burial
of a body.
190
00:14:35,043 --> 00:14:37,658
We need to work out
what's happened to this person.
191
00:14:49,043 --> 00:14:52,458
Poor guy. Been bundled up
in a freezer and dumped.
192
00:14:52,483 --> 00:14:55,538
As police search records
of who lived in the flat,
193
00:14:55,563 --> 00:14:59,538
photographs of the man's
fingerprints are examined
194
00:14:59,563 --> 00:15:03,658
to see if he can be identified using
the police national database.
195
00:15:06,723 --> 00:15:10,338
So we start off by scanning
one of the photographs on.
196
00:15:14,363 --> 00:15:18,738
The national database holds seven
million sets of fingerprints.
197
00:15:19,963 --> 00:15:22,498
It's a great tool,
but the limitations are
198
00:15:22,523 --> 00:15:25,778
you've got to have been convicted
of an offence previously.
199
00:15:27,363 --> 00:15:31,138
So all I'm doing here is marking up
the ridge characteristics.
200
00:15:32,563 --> 00:15:35,738
With the national database,
there's an algorithm that runs,
201
00:15:35,763 --> 00:15:38,378
looking for those ridges,
looking for those characteristics.
202
00:15:40,043 --> 00:15:42,418
The first challenge
is the quality of fingerprints.
203
00:15:42,443 --> 00:15:46,938
All this here, because of how
the skin has started to decay,
204
00:15:46,963 --> 00:15:49,258
we can't actually use any
of that information.
205
00:15:49,283 --> 00:15:52,498
So we'll actually remove those,
then mark them up myself
206
00:15:52,523 --> 00:15:55,458
just to make sure
they're in the correct place.
207
00:15:55,483 --> 00:15:58,578
That algorithm, it's not foolproof.
208
00:15:58,603 --> 00:16:00,738
How it searches is only as good
209
00:16:00,763 --> 00:16:03,698
as the fingerprints
that have been put in.
210
00:16:05,563 --> 00:16:07,898
You can see things
with your naked eye
211
00:16:07,923 --> 00:16:10,818
that don't necessarily show
on a computer screen.
212
00:16:11,923 --> 00:16:14,098
We make sure that
all that information
213
00:16:14,123 --> 00:16:15,858
that's in that deceased's
set of prints
214
00:16:15,883 --> 00:16:19,058
is definitely in a fingerprint form.
215
00:16:24,723 --> 00:16:26,498
So that's been launched.
216
00:16:27,843 --> 00:16:29,858
Ancl our results are already back.
217
00:16:32,803 --> 00:16:35,338
So the system always
sends back the top 15.
218
00:16:36,603 --> 00:16:38,338
The computer is saying,
219
00:16:38,363 --> 00:16:42,538
I think it's one of these
15 possible people.
220
00:16:42,563 --> 00:16:45,098
So you've still got 15 people
to check.
221
00:16:47,603 --> 00:16:50,058
So this is what's called
a twin loop pattern.
222
00:16:50,083 --> 00:16:52,298
So it's where it loops up to the top
223
00:16:52,323 --> 00:16:54,698
and then comes back down
and curves back around.
224
00:16:54,723 --> 00:16:57,418
We know that this is
just a loop pattern
225
00:16:57,443 --> 00:17:01,458
so just by that pattern alone, we
can say that it's not that person.
226
00:17:03,363 --> 00:17:05,218
Fingerprints isn't guesswork.
227
00:17:05,243 --> 00:17:07,658
You've got to be certain.
228
00:17:09,523 --> 00:17:14,178
Again, our short area here
isn't in this area.
229
00:17:15,603 --> 00:17:19,658
So the person that has been found,
230
00:17:19,683 --> 00:17:22,418
their fingerprints are not held
within the national database.
231
00:17:28,243 --> 00:17:32,418
While fingerprinting has not yielded
any clues to the man's identity,
232
00:17:32,443 --> 00:17:36,538
detectives have been trying to track
down the last resident of the flat
233
00:17:36,563 --> 00:17:38,378
where the freezer was removed from.
234
00:17:40,323 --> 00:17:43,458
Officers have spoken
to Citizen Housing,
235
00:17:43,483 --> 00:17:46,338
I think they act on behalf
of Birmingham City Council,
236
00:17:46,363 --> 00:17:49,898
they're the ones that own
the property.
237
00:17:51,163 --> 00:17:54,938
The tenancy was in the name
of john Wainwright. Yep.
238
00:17:54,963 --> 00:17:56,738
He was the sole occupant,
239
00:17:56,763 --> 00:18:00,218
although it does say that he'd been
living at the address with his son,
240
00:18:00,243 --> 00:18:02,258
Damion johns on.
241
00:18:02,283 --> 00:18:05,098
I think they moved in in 2015.
242
00:18:05,123 --> 00:18:09,498
A search of police records reveals
that officers attended the flat
243
00:18:09,523 --> 00:18:13,258
nine months ago
after reports of a disturbance.
244
00:18:22,723 --> 00:18:24,818
Damion Johnson opened the door.
245
00:18:28,363 --> 00:18:30,538
I want to go through the bodycam,
246
00:18:30,563 --> 00:18:34,738
just to get an idea of how
he reacted towards officers.
247
00:18:39,683 --> 00:18:41,818
He's initially quite obstructive,
248
00:18:41,843 --> 00:18:44,178
but obviously they're
in the flat with him now.
249
00:18:53,883 --> 00:18:56,058
We know that Damion isn't
actually the tenant.
250
00:18:56,083 --> 00:18:58,098
We know the tenant is john.
251
00:18:58,123 --> 00:19:02,618
But officers attending, they haven't
seen john in the premises.
252
00:19:03,763 --> 00:19:06,218
So bear in mind, I want to look
for this freezer as well
253
00:19:06,243 --> 00:19:08,338
as they're going around
on the footage.
254
00:19:10,683 --> 00:19:13,458
That's the cupboard, isn't it...
On the right-hand side.
255
00:19:13,483 --> 00:19:16,618
...that the freezer was found in?
Yeah. But the d00r's closed to that.
256
00:19:21,683 --> 00:19:24,218
OK. So he's talking about his dad.
257
00:19:24,243 --> 00:19:26,658
That's what he calls john.
258
00:19:26,683 --> 00:19:29,778
He's suggesting that john
has passed away.
259
00:19:29,803 --> 00:19:33,178
But obviously he hasn't reported
the death of john.
260
00:19:34,243 --> 00:19:36,378
What was he thinking?
261
00:19:44,563 --> 00:19:47,258
He could be panicking because he
knows that he's got a body
262
00:19:47,283 --> 00:19:50,098
in that flat and the officers
are there. Yeah.
263
00:19:50,123 --> 00:19:53,458
He's worried about, "God, if they
start looking around this flat,
264
00:19:53,483 --> 00:19:55,778
"|'m in a lot of trouble." Yeah.
265
00:19:57,643 --> 00:20:02,018
Damion has informed the officers
john has passed away.
266
00:20:02,043 --> 00:20:04,458
So when they've then spoken
to the housing company
267
00:20:04,483 --> 00:20:08,498
to inform them of this,
Damion was evicted.
268
00:20:08,523 --> 00:20:13,218
That happened nine months
before the flat has been cleared.
269
00:20:15,003 --> 00:20:18,258
We know that nobody's
been in that flat since.
270
00:20:19,523 --> 00:20:21,898
It could be
john might be still alive,
271
00:20:21,923 --> 00:20:23,578
we haven't got a death record.
272
00:20:23,603 --> 00:20:27,298
But I think, based on what we know,
we have got to suspect
273
00:20:27,323 --> 00:20:31,698
quite strongly that that is john
whose body was in the freezer.
274
00:20:35,003 --> 00:20:38,818
Now detectives have a
lead on the name of the deceased...
275
00:20:40,243 --> 00:20:43,658
...a photograph of john Wainwright
is sent to a specialist
276
00:20:43,683 --> 00:20:47,698
in dental forensics to try
and formally confirm his identity.
277
00:20:55,523 --> 00:20:57,538
I've been supplied with some,
278
00:20:57,563 --> 00:21:00,218
I think it was Facebook photos
of this individual.
279
00:21:07,603 --> 00:21:12,898
I've also got the CT scans
from West Midlands Police,
280
00:21:12,923 --> 00:21:16,338
so 3D images of the skull,
281
00:21:16,363 --> 00:21:19,658
and so we could potentially do a
282
00:21:19,683 --> 00:21:23,058
superimposition of the skull
283
00:21:23,083 --> 00:21:27,178
over the image I've been
supplied with by the police.
284
00:21:28,323 --> 00:21:32,938
We do identification cases all
the time from dental records,
285
00:21:32,963 --> 00:21:36,738
but in the absence
of any other information,
286
00:21:36,763 --> 00:21:39,138
such as DNA, fingerprints
287
00:21:39,163 --> 00:21:41,978
or dental information,
288
00:21:42,003 --> 00:21:45,578
potentially we can use
craniofacial superimposition.
289
00:21:47,363 --> 00:21:49,058
It's pushing the boundaries.
290
00:21:49,083 --> 00:21:51,938
This is really the sort of
last resort
291
00:21:51,963 --> 00:21:54,058
of trying to identify their remains.
292
00:21:57,323 --> 00:22:00,378
From the images of the skull,
293
00:22:00,403 --> 00:22:03,818
we can create almost like what
we call a hollow volume overlay.
294
00:22:05,963 --> 00:22:09,098
If you've got a three-dimensional
CT scan of the skull,
295
00:22:09,123 --> 00:22:12,778
it gives me a bit more leeway
to position the skull
296
00:22:12,803 --> 00:22:16,698
on the software
into the right position
297
00:22:16,723 --> 00:22:18,978
that the photograph's
been taken from.
298
00:22:19,003 --> 00:22:21,898
Ancl then from that
I can actually use that
299
00:22:21,923 --> 00:22:24,538
to create the overlay
to do the superimposition.
300
00:22:25,723 --> 00:22:30,218
So we're examining the shape
of the actual skull, the cranium.
301
00:22:30,243 --> 00:22:34,538
We're looking at the position
of the eye sockets themselves.
302
00:22:34,563 --> 00:22:37,618
The nasal aperture,
the hole where the nose is,
303
00:22:37,643 --> 00:22:40,618
and then obviously
the shape of the cheekbones.
304
00:22:40,643 --> 00:22:43,738
Ancl what we're looking at is
if we can move the size
305
00:22:43,763 --> 00:22:47,898
and the position of it, is that
consistent with the images
306
00:22:47,923 --> 00:22:49,978
that we're seeing
of that individual?
307
00:22:51,763 --> 00:22:53,458
You can never make an assumption
308
00:22:53,483 --> 00:22:55,698
that it's definitely
this individual.
309
00:22:55,723 --> 00:22:58,098
So there's a bit of
apprehension, thinking,
310
00:22:58,123 --> 00:23:00,538
is it going to match
or is it not going to match?
311
00:23:00,563 --> 00:23:02,738
Ancl if it doesn't match
then, obviously, potentially,
312
00:23:02,763 --> 00:23:04,378
is it somebody else?
313
00:23:12,483 --> 00:23:15,458
I can confirm that with
the shape of the skull,
314
00:23:15,483 --> 00:23:18,738
the position of the eye sockets,
the shape of the cheekbones,
315
00:23:18,763 --> 00:23:20,098
it certainly fits.
316
00:23:20,123 --> 00:23:22,298
Anatomically, there's consistency.
317
00:23:24,963 --> 00:23:28,898
So whilst it doesn't
give 100% identification,
318
00:23:28,923 --> 00:23:31,618
I'm satisfied that the remains
that we're looking at
319
00:23:31,643 --> 00:23:35,578
are the individual
that we suspect it is.
320
00:23:36,843 --> 00:23:39,738
Four days after the
body's discovery,
321
00:23:39,763 --> 00:23:42,658
police confirm the deceased
as john Wainwright.
322
00:23:44,843 --> 00:23:49,018
An arrest warrant is issued for his
flatmate and carer -
323
00:23:49,043 --> 00:23:50,498
Damion Johnson.
324
00:23:52,243 --> 00:23:56,098
john has been put in the freezer
and nobody's reported that,
325
00:23:56,123 --> 00:23:57,818
which is a crime.
326
00:23:57,843 --> 00:24:00,658
And until we find out
how john has died
327
00:24:00,683 --> 00:24:04,498
we are looking at the offence
of murder.
328
00:24:04,523 --> 00:24:07,938
So the priority is to arrest
Damion and get his account.
329
00:24:10,123 --> 00:24:11,978
POLICE SIREN WAILS
330
00:24:12,003 --> 00:24:13,538
Hiya, it's Brandon from Pear Tree.
331
00:24:13,563 --> 00:24:16,018
just to let you know we've got
one en route from Derby
332
00:24:16,043 --> 00:24:18,418
on suspicion of murder.
333
00:24:18,443 --> 00:24:20,858
Through there, to the desk, please.
334
00:24:20,883 --> 00:24:24,138
In the neighbouring
county of Derbyshire...
335
00:24:24,163 --> 00:24:25,618
just put your arms up for us.
336
00:24:25,643 --> 00:24:30,058
...homicide detectives have located
key suspect Damion Johnson.
337
00:24:34,883 --> 00:24:36,858
TAPE MACHINE BEEPS
338
00:25:44,483 --> 00:25:47,458
Damion's admission means
john Wainwright's body
339
00:25:47,483 --> 00:25:51,898
was concealed in the freezer, not
for nine months as police thought,
340
00:25:51,923 --> 00:25:53,618
but for nearly two years.
341
00:26:53,883 --> 00:26:55,538
TAPE MACHINE BEEPS
342
00:26:57,203 --> 00:27:00,258
Sometimes the death
of somebody close to you
343
00:27:00,283 --> 00:27:02,858
could cause some kind of breakdown,
344
00:27:02,883 --> 00:27:05,138
and you can understand how people
345
00:27:05,163 --> 00:27:08,458
don't want to let go
of their loved one.
346
00:27:08,483 --> 00:27:11,338
Right, mate, you're coming with me.
347
00:27:11,363 --> 00:27:15,578
But if you're evicted from somewhere
and you know that your loved one
348
00:27:15,603 --> 00:27:18,578
is in that flat by themselves
in a freezer...
349
00:27:20,563 --> 00:27:24,018
...how much was that person
a loved one?
350
00:27:26,883 --> 00:27:31,258
With no forensic evidence
that he caused John's death,
351
00:27:31,283 --> 00:27:34,898
Damion is released on bail
pending further investigation.
352
00:27:41,243 --> 00:27:45,018
So the interview,
did he go "no comment" throughout?
353
00:27:45,043 --> 00:27:49,058
Prepared statement or...?
He remained silent. OK.
354
00:27:49,083 --> 00:27:52,938
Nicola meets with senior
investigating officer Stu
355
00:27:52,963 --> 00:27:54,618
to review their next steps.
356
00:27:56,283 --> 00:27:59,938
There were a few little bits
that he gave, but not much at all.
357
00:27:59,963 --> 00:28:02,938
So no detail about the passing
away of natural causes?
358
00:28:02,963 --> 00:28:06,058
No, he wouldn't answer
any questions in relation
359
00:28:06,083 --> 00:28:09,098
to where he'd found john,
how he had found john.
360
00:28:09,123 --> 00:28:13,538
Ancl then, have we got any
next of kin for Mr Wainwright?
361
00:28:13,563 --> 00:28:14,698
No, we haven't.
362
00:28:14,723 --> 00:28:19,458
At this moment in time we have no
friends and no family identified.
363
00:28:19,483 --> 00:28:22,018
So all the witnesses
you're going to give me now
364
00:28:22,043 --> 00:28:24,698
are friends or family
of the suspect? Yeah.
365
00:28:24,723 --> 00:28:28,898
They all stated the same thing, that
they knew the victim
366
00:28:28,923 --> 00:28:33,018
for about 20, 30 years
through the suspect.
367
00:28:33,043 --> 00:28:35,898
They think that the victim
helped the suspect
368
00:28:35,923 --> 00:28:39,378
with some kind of
housing arrangements.
369
00:28:39,403 --> 00:28:43,218
Ancl finances -
the flat's in Mr Wainwright's name.
370
00:28:43,243 --> 00:28:45,178
Anything at all on that?
371
00:28:45,203 --> 00:28:47,098
That needs further work,
372
00:28:47,123 --> 00:28:49,578
but due to the age gap between
victim and suspect,
373
00:28:49,603 --> 00:28:52,458
which is around 20 years,
374
00:28:52,483 --> 00:28:55,698
the suspect would call the victim
Dad.
375
00:28:55,723 --> 00:28:57,898
OK. That's interesting.
376
00:28:59,243 --> 00:29:00,698
Ancl is that because...?
377
00:29:00,723 --> 00:29:05,178
I know he's 20 or 30 years older
so he was, what, early 70s? Yeah.
378
00:29:05,203 --> 00:29:09,098
Our victim, was he in ill health,
did he need caring?
379
00:29:09,123 --> 00:29:13,498
So Damion and his friends
say that victim had dementia,
380
00:29:13,523 --> 00:29:16,778
he was falling, he was declining.
381
00:29:16,803 --> 00:29:20,218
So had the friends witnessed this
themselves? Not really, no.
382
00:29:20,243 --> 00:29:23,978
They would only ever see john
really for fleeting moments
383
00:29:24,003 --> 00:29:26,218
if they ever went to the flat.
384
00:29:26,243 --> 00:29:28,978
And Damion told them
when john's died,
385
00:29:29,003 --> 00:29:32,418
his sister has come to take care of
the funeral arrangements. Yeah.
386
00:29:33,803 --> 00:29:37,698
But there was no funeral. But john's
death is never registered.
387
00:29:39,763 --> 00:29:42,818
Damion has given us
that prepared statement...
388
00:29:44,283 --> 00:29:48,258
“but he hasn't told us
how john has died.
389
00:29:48,283 --> 00:29:52,538
Potentially, Damion doesn't want
to implicate himself in a murder.
390
00:29:52,563 --> 00:29:56,338
But until we get results of
the forensic postmortem,
391
00:29:56,363 --> 00:29:59,218
he will still be a murder suspect.
392
00:29:59,243 --> 00:30:03,178
So I just want to be 100% certain,
393
00:30:03,203 --> 00:30:06,178
when he puts him into a freezer,
394
00:30:06,203 --> 00:30:09,218
was he alive and suffocated
in the freezer?
395
00:30:09,243 --> 00:30:14,258
Ancl is there any damage,
are there any scrapings?
396
00:30:14,283 --> 00:30:16,018
We need to look at that freezer
397
00:30:16,043 --> 00:30:18,778
to see if john's fingerprints
are on the inside.
398
00:30:20,163 --> 00:30:24,298
We are reliant upon
the forensics to help us
399
00:30:24,323 --> 00:30:26,978
piece together what
has happened to john.
400
00:30:33,163 --> 00:30:34,298
OK.
401
00:30:36,003 --> 00:30:40,898
Forensic technicians Kat Harold and
Dani McGarry prepare to chemically
402
00:30:40,923 --> 00:30:44,858
treat the freezer to search for the
presence of fingerprints within it.
403
00:30:47,323 --> 00:30:50,378
If the victim's fingerprints
are found inside,
404
00:30:50,403 --> 00:30:53,378
this could suggest
he was put into the freezer alive.
405
00:30:57,603 --> 00:31:00,898
This is cyanoacrylate,
superglue,
406
00:31:00,923 --> 00:31:03,098
that we put in here,
407
00:31:03,123 --> 00:31:05,738
and this is like a hot plate.
408
00:31:05,763 --> 00:31:11,698
So this will heat up, and then that
will circulate the superglue around
409
00:31:11,723 --> 00:31:16,018
the cabinet and it will rehydrate
any fingermarks that are in there.
410
00:31:17,283 --> 00:31:21,698
Cyanoacrylate reacts with
our chloride irons within our sweat,
411
00:31:21,723 --> 00:31:23,298
and it deposits
412
00:31:23,323 --> 00:31:25,538
a white substance.
413
00:31:25,563 --> 00:31:28,618
So that then is visible.
414
00:31:32,483 --> 00:31:36,498
I mean, it's hard to see
on a white freezer.
415
00:31:38,323 --> 00:31:40,498
The hard thing with this case is
416
00:31:40,523 --> 00:31:43,658
the cyanoacrylate process
is a white deposit.
417
00:31:43,683 --> 00:31:47,818
So the white deposit
on the white freezer isn't ideal.
418
00:31:49,963 --> 00:31:52,298
Which is why we've got
the Basic Yellow 40,
419
00:31:52,323 --> 00:31:55,578
which is a staining agent,
which can stick to,
420
00:31:55,603 --> 00:31:58,418
it adheres to the cyanoacrylate.
421
00:31:58,443 --> 00:32:02,258
The fingermarks are more visible
under fluorescent light.
422
00:32:03,403 --> 00:32:07,218
Ancl hopefully we can enhance them
and go on to...
423
00:32:08,723 --> 00:32:10,818
...get a proper fingerprint.
424
00:32:13,603 --> 00:32:15,978
No. No.
425
00:32:25,203 --> 00:32:26,778
No value, Kat.
426
00:32:26,803 --> 00:32:28,338
Let's do the lid.
427
00:32:34,003 --> 00:32:36,498
Yes. There's some stuff on there.
428
00:32:36,523 --> 00:32:39,978
Oh, my... There's loads.
It goes right across. Oh...
429
00:32:41,883 --> 00:32:43,298
Yeah, they're lovely, they are.
430
00:32:43,323 --> 00:32:47,018
Right. I can't believe how much
has showed up now, can you?
431
00:32:51,323 --> 00:32:55,338
The prints on the lid are
photographed and digitally enhanced,
432
00:32:55,363 --> 00:32:58,098
so that they can be analysed
by the fingerprint bureau.
433
00:33:00,443 --> 00:33:01,898
UK?
434
00:33:04,243 --> 00:33:07,738
This is definitely
a case that we won't forget.
435
00:33:09,643 --> 00:33:13,938
How do you explain the fingermarks
on the inside of the lid?
436
00:33:14,963 --> 00:33:19,138
Are they the man that
was inside of the freezer?
437
00:33:19,163 --> 00:33:22,018
Were they his trying to get out?
438
00:33:30,043 --> 00:33:33,978
Fingerprint expert Claire Lynch
will compare the print
439
00:33:34,003 --> 00:33:36,538
to those taken from john Wainwright
at the postmortem.
440
00:33:40,123 --> 00:33:43,698
They are not suitable enough to
go into the national database,
441
00:33:43,723 --> 00:33:46,818
there's just too much background
information
442
00:33:46,843 --> 00:33:48,778
from the lid of the freezer.
443
00:33:48,803 --> 00:33:52,658
So I'm going to first check
to make sure the pattern
444
00:33:52,683 --> 00:33:57,818
that we've got matches the patterns
that this gentleman has.
445
00:34:00,963 --> 00:34:04,498
So we know whose fingerprint this
is, this is from the deceased.
446
00:34:04,523 --> 00:34:06,378
We don't know whose
fingerprint this is.
447
00:34:06,403 --> 00:34:08,658
So we want everything to match.
448
00:34:08,683 --> 00:34:11,898
So if the characteristic
isn't in the right place,
449
00:34:11,923 --> 00:34:15,018
in the right position, then
it's definitely not that person.
450
00:34:19,403 --> 00:34:21,338
We call it coincident sequence.
451
00:34:23,283 --> 00:34:26,498
It's just where we have
the same characteristics
452
00:34:26,523 --> 00:34:30,178
in the same relationship to each
other, in the same placement
453
00:34:30,203 --> 00:34:32,138
from one to the other.
454
00:34:32,163 --> 00:34:34,178
So we're looking for...
455
00:34:37,203 --> 00:34:39,018
...this ridge ending here.
456
00:34:42,883 --> 00:34:44,698
We've got a ridge ending here.
457
00:34:47,003 --> 00:34:48,698
Ancl a ridge ending here.
458
00:34:48,723 --> 00:34:52,538
So we know that we need
to get those two above that.
459
00:34:52,563 --> 00:34:56,578
It takes one characteristic to say
that it's not an identification.
460
00:34:56,603 --> 00:34:59,298
OK. One, two, three.
461
00:34:59,323 --> 00:35:03,418
And what would be the fourth ridge
would be that ridge ending.
462
00:35:03,443 --> 00:35:05,658
So one, two, three.
463
00:35:05,683 --> 00:35:07,538
That's not there.
464
00:35:09,483 --> 00:35:13,298
We can discount the deceased
for this print
465
00:35:13,323 --> 00:35:17,338
just based on these two points
not being in the same,
466
00:35:17,363 --> 00:35:19,138
in the correct position.
467
00:35:25,003 --> 00:35:28,818
None of the fingerprints that we
had on the inside of the freezer lid
468
00:35:28,843 --> 00:35:30,498
belonged to the deceased.
469
00:35:31,563 --> 00:35:35,058
We have to assume
he was put into that freezer
470
00:35:35,083 --> 00:35:36,938
when he was dead.
471
00:35:43,843 --> 00:35:47,338
Detectives are searching
for any evidence
472
00:35:47,363 --> 00:35:50,538
which might confirm
Damion's statement.
473
00:35:50,563 --> 00:35:53,258
So this is the
recovered Facebook account
474
00:35:53,283 --> 00:35:56,298
of Damion johns on,
475
00:35:56,323 --> 00:35:59,658
even though it's under his previous
name -jasonjohnson.
476
00:35:59,683 --> 00:36:03,818
DC Pauljones accesses
Damion's social media posts
477
00:36:03,843 --> 00:36:06,378
from around the time
he claims john died.
478
00:36:08,083 --> 00:36:12,018
His state of mind at the interview,
obviously he was very distraught.
479
00:36:12,043 --> 00:36:14,898
His suggestion is that he just
wasn't thinking straight.
480
00:36:16,923 --> 00:36:19,818
We can see an entry made by Damion.
481
00:36:21,163 --> 00:36:23,658
"Still can't come to
grips with reality.
482
00:36:23,683 --> 00:36:26,978
"We lived together for 21 years,
and now you're not here.
483
00:36:27,003 --> 00:36:28,858
"You were my world."
484
00:36:30,203 --> 00:36:31,738
It seems heartfelt.
485
00:36:35,443 --> 00:36:38,858
And he's made tribute to
sort of how much he misses him.
486
00:36:40,923 --> 00:36:42,698
"I can't believe
it's a year ago today
487
00:36:42,723 --> 00:36:46,658
"that you've closed your beautiful
blue eyes and you've drifted away."
488
00:36:46,683 --> 00:36:50,298
And the interesting thing on that
is the date
489
00:36:50,323 --> 00:36:53,818
on that entry of
24th of September 2019.
490
00:36:55,563 --> 00:36:59,218
So Damion's saying that john's died
a year previous to that,
491
00:36:59,243 --> 00:37:01,738
so 24th of September 2018.
492
00:37:03,443 --> 00:37:05,938
He's remembering the death of john
493
00:37:05,963 --> 00:37:10,378
and he's put dates on those
Facebook pages, so I can backtrack.
494
00:37:13,123 --> 00:37:16,898
Now, it might be that he has got
a genuine care for john
495
00:37:16,923 --> 00:37:19,978
and maybe it is a relief to him
to finally think,
496
00:37:20,003 --> 00:37:22,818
"At least now I can get this
out in the open."
497
00:37:24,443 --> 00:37:27,418
But then there's a period
where clearly Damion's
498
00:37:27,443 --> 00:37:30,138
living in that flat...
499
00:37:31,763 --> 00:37:36,418
...with somebody he's saying he
cares deeply for, he loves,
500
00:37:36,443 --> 00:37:37,938
in a freezer,
501
00:37:37,963 --> 00:37:39,938
just next to him.
502
00:37:41,203 --> 00:37:42,898
It is very, very strange.
503
00:37:44,283 --> 00:37:47,058
it just makes you wonder
if this emotion's genuine.
504
00:37:48,403 --> 00:37:50,098
Is it calculated?
505
00:37:51,443 --> 00:37:54,258
Are these the posts of a man who
wanted to give the impression
506
00:37:54,283 --> 00:37:56,538
of someone who was caring?
507
00:38:03,883 --> 00:38:07,698
Right, I'll try to pick out anything
that looks like an injury.
508
00:38:07,723 --> 00:38:09,978
With no obvious cause of death,
509
00:38:10,003 --> 00:38:14,378
the forensic team still have
to establish how john died.
510
00:38:16,283 --> 00:38:18,538
Because his death
has been concealed,
511
00:38:18,563 --> 00:38:21,778
is it because someone else is
responsible for his death?
512
00:38:21,803 --> 00:38:25,818
Or is this natural causes?
513
00:38:25,843 --> 00:38:27,738
One of the things that I do
514
00:38:27,763 --> 00:38:30,738
is shed a light on what
could have happened here.
515
00:38:35,763 --> 00:38:39,338
His poor nose has had better times,
hasn't it?
516
00:38:40,763 --> 00:38:42,258
It's a bit distorted.
517
00:38:46,043 --> 00:38:48,338
He's definitely broken
the cheekbone.
518
00:38:48,363 --> 00:38:50,858
The cheekbone's bust there.
519
00:38:52,003 --> 00:38:54,538
I think we need to check it out,
don't we?
520
00:38:55,763 --> 00:38:58,218
Despite advanced decomposition,
521
00:38:58,243 --> 00:39:01,658
Dr Lyall is able to identify
signs of trauma.
522
00:39:04,043 --> 00:39:08,738
There looked to be signs of injury
to the bones of the man's face.
523
00:39:08,763 --> 00:39:10,898
If they are fractures,
524
00:39:10,923 --> 00:39:13,458
have they occurred close
to the time of death,
525
00:39:13,483 --> 00:39:15,818
and therefore could they be linked
to injuries
526
00:39:15,843 --> 00:39:18,338
that have been connected
to the death?
527
00:39:18,363 --> 00:39:20,898
Or are these older injuries?
528
00:39:22,963 --> 00:39:25,138
He's lost some teeth.
529
00:39:26,563 --> 00:39:28,458
Can we do these sockets?
530
00:39:28,483 --> 00:39:31,058
You know, I mean, they're all
kind of distorted, and I don't know.
531
00:39:31,083 --> 00:39:33,298
HE SNIFFS
532
00:39:33,323 --> 00:39:36,338
I'm just wondering if he has had
some sort of bash on his face.
533
00:39:38,403 --> 00:39:41,738
The injuries by themselves,
all they will do
534
00:39:41,763 --> 00:39:44,058
is show that there has been
trauma to the face.
535
00:39:44,083 --> 00:39:47,138
They will not of themselves
536
00:39:47,163 --> 00:39:50,458
prove necessarily
how they've been caused.
537
00:39:52,043 --> 00:39:55,018
Photographs of john's cheekbones
and teeth are taken
538
00:39:55,043 --> 00:39:58,138
for further forensic analysis.
539
00:40:00,803 --> 00:40:03,698
Right, we've got thyroid times one.
540
00:40:04,803 --> 00:40:06,658
Prostate times one.
541
00:40:06,683 --> 00:40:09,938
Pancreas/ liver.
542
00:40:09,963 --> 00:40:14,258
Tissue samples of major
organs will also be examined
543
00:40:14,283 --> 00:40:16,938
for evidence of death
by natural causes.
544
00:40:24,563 --> 00:40:27,058
So we're looking at the shape
of the socket
545
00:40:27,083 --> 00:40:29,538
and the actual...
the shape of the gum itself.
546
00:40:30,763 --> 00:40:34,178
In Sheffield, Dr Kouble examines
the photos of the teeth
547
00:40:34,203 --> 00:40:36,098
and facial trauma
548
00:40:36,123 --> 00:40:39,498
to determine whether the injuries
were caused at the time of death.
549
00:40:41,763 --> 00:40:45,858
So in the lower jaw, I can see
that there isn't a hole there,
550
00:40:45,883 --> 00:40:47,458
there's a space where the tooth was.
551
00:40:48,603 --> 00:40:51,178
Certainly on the lower jaw some
of the teeth have been lost
552
00:40:51,203 --> 00:40:54,098
antemortem, so during life.
553
00:40:54,123 --> 00:40:56,578
Ancl we can tell that they've
been lost during life
554
00:40:56,603 --> 00:40:59,258
because the bone heals up
and the gum heals up,
555
00:40:59,283 --> 00:41:02,658
and the bone actually goes smoother
so you don't have an open socket.
556
00:41:03,803 --> 00:41:06,898
Ancl then moving onto the upper jaw,
557
00:41:06,923 --> 00:41:08,778
there's evidence of what?
558
00:41:08,803 --> 00:41:12,258
One, two, three, four, five sockets,
559
00:41:12,283 --> 00:41:14,658
or open holes, where the teeth roots
560
00:41:14,683 --> 00:41:17,098
will have been in
the jawbone itself.
561
00:41:18,243 --> 00:41:21,458
Potentially, there's evidence there
these may have been lost
562
00:41:21,483 --> 00:41:23,418
either just before death
563
00:41:23,443 --> 00:41:25,898
or postmortem, after death.
564
00:41:25,923 --> 00:41:28,138
But there's actually a tear
565
00:41:28,163 --> 00:41:30,418
and there's damage
in the actual bone
566
00:41:30,443 --> 00:41:32,938
that would be on the outer
surface of the root.
567
00:41:34,123 --> 00:41:37,578
In this case there's a clear
laceration on the gum
568
00:41:37,603 --> 00:41:40,978
and that's an indication
that tooth hasn't just dropped out.
569
00:41:41,003 --> 00:41:44,178
That's an indication that that
tooth's actually been knocked out
570
00:41:44,203 --> 00:41:45,818
or had some sort of trauma to it.
571
00:41:45,843 --> 00:41:48,858
Had that occurred before death,
572
00:41:48,883 --> 00:41:50,978
potentially that would
have healed up.
573
00:41:51,003 --> 00:41:54,018
Ancl this is obviously an open wound.
574
00:41:56,123 --> 00:41:59,938
It could be a punch or some
sort of impact from an object
575
00:41:59,963 --> 00:42:02,618
or it could be some
sort of traumatic fall,
576
00:42:02,643 --> 00:42:04,978
where they've knocked a tooth out.
577
00:42:06,523 --> 00:42:08,058
Ancl then in addition to this
578
00:42:08,083 --> 00:42:11,738
we can see there's also fractures
on the bones as well.
579
00:42:11,763 --> 00:42:14,698
So the right cheekbone's
been fractured
580
00:42:14,723 --> 00:42:18,178
and the maxilla, the upper jaw, has
been fractured as well
581
00:42:18,203 --> 00:42:20,738
on the right side.
582
00:42:20,763 --> 00:42:23,458
We've also got a fracture
of the nasal bones as well.
583
00:42:24,483 --> 00:42:26,298
We've got a number of injuries
584
00:42:26,323 --> 00:42:28,858
which are probably from
high-impact trauma,
585
00:42:28,883 --> 00:42:32,178
trauma of sufficient force
to have knocked teeth out,
586
00:42:32,203 --> 00:42:33,938
to have actually broken bones.
587
00:42:35,923 --> 00:42:40,258
But facial factures per se
and dental injuries per se
588
00:42:40,283 --> 00:42:42,458
generally wouldn't contribute
to somebody's death.
589
00:42:42,483 --> 00:42:45,578
It's not confirmation this
individual's been murdered.
590
00:42:47,163 --> 00:42:50,058
All I can comment on
is this trauma's occurred
591
00:42:50,083 --> 00:42:51,378
at or around the time of death.
592
00:43:03,163 --> 00:43:06,018
With evidence suggesting
john suffered injuries
593
00:43:06,043 --> 00:43:07,578
at the time of his death...
594
00:43:11,483 --> 00:43:16,018
...police bring Damion back in
to question his earlier account.
595
00:43:21,723 --> 00:43:24,178
So, Damion, when you were arrested
596
00:43:24,203 --> 00:43:28,298
you gave a prepared statement
about john.
597
00:43:28,323 --> 00:43:32,378
You said that he died of natural
causes. Can you explain that to us?
598
00:43:32,403 --> 00:43:34,618
Ancl how he actually died?
599
00:43:34,643 --> 00:43:36,858
He just started to lose weight.
600
00:43:36,883 --> 00:43:39,298
I just carried on each day
as I always did.
601
00:43:39,323 --> 00:43:41,418
I'd go and check on him
to make sure he was washing
602
00:43:41,443 --> 00:43:43,658
cos sometimes he'd just
sit in the bathroom.
603
00:43:43,683 --> 00:43:45,138
But he just went downhill.
604
00:43:46,163 --> 00:43:47,378
It was strange.
605
00:43:49,083 --> 00:43:52,738
So there's a pathologist report.
606
00:43:52,763 --> 00:43:57,898
What he found is that the right side
of john's cheekbone was fractured.
607
00:43:57,923 --> 00:44:01,218
This fracture would have been
caused by a direct force or impact.
608
00:44:01,243 --> 00:44:02,658
Not by me.
609
00:44:02,683 --> 00:44:05,418
He's got a fractured nose...
610
00:44:06,603 --> 00:44:07,978
...just before his death.
611
00:44:10,243 --> 00:44:11,978
Can you explain that? No.
612
00:44:12,003 --> 00:44:13,538
He's got, erm...
613
00:44:14,683 --> 00:44:16,058
...missing teeth...
614
00:44:17,843 --> 00:44:20,058
...and lacerations to his lips.
615
00:44:20,083 --> 00:44:23,498
So put it into our terms,
it looks like somebody's...
616
00:44:23,523 --> 00:44:25,218
Smacked him in the mouth.
617
00:44:25,243 --> 00:44:28,818
Smacked him in the mouth,
to make him lose five teeth. Yeah.
618
00:44:28,843 --> 00:44:30,778
Do you remember that?
I don't remember that.
619
00:44:30,803 --> 00:44:33,618
Did you cause those injuries?
Not as far as I know.
620
00:44:36,203 --> 00:44:39,538
That's quite a vague answer -
not as far as you know.
621
00:44:39,563 --> 00:44:42,618
I would have no reason to hurt him.
622
00:44:44,923 --> 00:44:48,298
So had there been any other
incidents, any more falls or any...?
623
00:44:48,323 --> 00:44:50,938
Oh, he'd pinball through his...
around his room.
624
00:44:50,963 --> 00:44:53,698
There was a couple of times
I went in his room and...
625
00:44:55,163 --> 00:44:57,538
...he didn't have a Scooby-Doo
who I was,
626
00:44:57,563 --> 00:45:00,938
and he'd get... He'd go for me.
627
00:45:00,963 --> 00:45:02,978
Ancl how did you react to that?
628
00:45:03,003 --> 00:45:04,178
I've...
629
00:45:05,403 --> 00:45:08,378
...grabbed him. I've not grabbed
his... I've held his hands,
630
00:45:08,403 --> 00:45:10,738
he's sat down and I've left.
631
00:45:10,763 --> 00:45:13,498
I walk away from situations,
632
00:45:13,523 --> 00:45:16,898
and I've come back about
half an hour, 40 minutes later
633
00:45:16,923 --> 00:45:18,698
and it's like it never happened.
634
00:45:18,723 --> 00:45:21,338
Have you ever had to strike him?
Good God, no.
635
00:45:24,363 --> 00:45:26,298
I'd hurt myself first.
636
00:45:27,683 --> 00:45:29,858
I'd put myself in danger first.
637
00:45:34,763 --> 00:45:36,338
We'll have a little break.
638
00:45:36,363 --> 00:45:37,978
Have a breather, yeah?
639
00:45:44,763 --> 00:45:47,738
You can see the...
640
00:45:47,763 --> 00:45:52,338
...the basic outline of
the individual tissue.
641
00:45:52,363 --> 00:45:55,258
The samples from John's organs
are examined
642
00:45:55,283 --> 00:45:58,098
for any signs that he died
from natural causes.
643
00:46:00,283 --> 00:46:03,818
Looking at the samples
from the heart, from the lungs,
644
00:46:03,843 --> 00:46:05,538
from the liver,
645
00:46:05,563 --> 00:46:08,538
we can establish whether those
organs are healthy
646
00:46:08,563 --> 00:46:10,338
or whether they're unhealthy.
647
00:46:10,363 --> 00:46:11,978
Ancl if they're unhealthy,
648
00:46:12,003 --> 00:46:14,658
is it a disease that could have
caused death?
649
00:46:18,483 --> 00:46:20,258
This is the lung.
650
00:46:20,283 --> 00:46:23,178
There are all these holes
you can see in the tissue.
651
00:46:23,203 --> 00:46:27,018
Now, sometimes people with
a condition called emphysema
652
00:46:27,043 --> 00:46:29,218
or pulmonary emphysema,
653
00:46:29,243 --> 00:46:32,578
they can have large air spaces
in their lungs.
654
00:46:32,603 --> 00:46:35,458
But the problem with decomposition
655
00:46:35,483 --> 00:46:37,578
is that there can be a lot
of gas formation,
656
00:46:37,603 --> 00:46:41,658
and that gas formation can
sometimes mimic emphysema.
657
00:46:43,363 --> 00:46:48,298
These are small samples
that I took from the heart.
658
00:46:49,483 --> 00:46:51,618
Ancl this is one
of the arteries here.
659
00:46:51,643 --> 00:46:53,418
Ancl this bit here...
660
00:46:54,963 --> 00:46:58,498
...is some fibrous atheroma
661
00:46:58,523 --> 00:46:59,978
with calcium in it.
662
00:47:00,003 --> 00:47:03,538
So normally that wall
should only be this,
663
00:47:03,563 --> 00:47:05,938
you know, should be like that thick.
664
00:47:05,963 --> 00:47:09,298
Whereas instead,
the wall here is expanded by this.
665
00:47:10,763 --> 00:47:12,978
He has atheroma -
666
00:47:13,003 --> 00:47:16,938
fatty accumulation
that happens within arteries.
667
00:47:18,283 --> 00:47:20,938
It's very common,
usually as you get older,
668
00:47:20,963 --> 00:47:24,658
people have got more
atheroma in their arteries.
669
00:47:24,683 --> 00:47:29,018
This man certainly has some
coronary artery disease,
670
00:47:29,043 --> 00:47:31,858
but just because he has
some coronary artery disease
671
00:47:31,883 --> 00:47:33,858
doesn't mean that
that's why he's cited.
672
00:47:34,923 --> 00:47:38,458
The problem is that although
we have the finding in the heart,
673
00:47:38,483 --> 00:47:41,658
the degree of decomposition
means that it is difficult
674
00:47:41,683 --> 00:47:44,578
to exclude or confirm
whether that caused death.
675
00:47:46,083 --> 00:47:48,378
This man could have had
high blood pressure.
676
00:47:48,403 --> 00:47:50,658
He could have had diabetes.
677
00:47:50,683 --> 00:47:53,058
There are some early
changes of that,
678
00:47:53,083 --> 00:47:56,058
but again these are kind
of background findings
679
00:47:56,083 --> 00:47:58,698
that are not going to explain
why he's died suddenly.
680
00:48:01,803 --> 00:48:05,178
So...we have a number
of question marks.
681
00:48:07,363 --> 00:48:10,378
We've got
symptoms that potentially fit
682
00:48:10,403 --> 00:48:13,258
death from some sort of
natural process,
683
00:48:13,283 --> 00:48:17,378
but the internal organs, like
everything else, are decomposed.
684
00:48:18,443 --> 00:48:21,498
So how this man has died
685
00:48:21,523 --> 00:48:23,018
remains unclear.
686
00:48:33,483 --> 00:48:37,658
So looking at john, he had a number
of regular monthly payments
687
00:48:37,683 --> 00:48:40,618
into his Barclays account
for his pension,
688
00:48:40,643 --> 00:48:42,938
but also from DWP.
689
00:48:42,963 --> 00:48:48,218
Detectives continuing to investigate
Damion's relationship with john
690
00:48:48,243 --> 00:48:51,378
have now accessed details
of john's finances.
691
00:48:53,443 --> 00:48:57,178
You would expect post john's
death that there wouldn't be any
692
00:48:57,203 --> 00:48:58,978
financial transactions,
693
00:48:59,003 --> 00:49:01,698
but there are quite a number.
694
00:49:01,723 --> 00:49:06,058
A lot of small transactions,
£15, £20, etc.
695
00:49:06,083 --> 00:49:08,658
A great portion of these
transactions have come from
696
00:49:08,683 --> 00:49:10,978
one of the newsagents
just around the corner
697
00:49:11,003 --> 00:49:14,378
from where Damion would still have
been living at that time.
698
00:49:14,403 --> 00:49:18,458
So it would strongly suggest
that Damion
699
00:49:18,483 --> 00:49:21,898
had been using john's card
700
00:49:21,923 --> 00:49:24,578
and fraudulently taking money
out of his account.
701
00:49:24,603 --> 00:49:27,138
There's a total of over £17,000.
702
00:49:30,323 --> 00:49:33,898
Although Damion referred to
his relationship with john
703
00:49:33,923 --> 00:49:38,418
as father and son,
he didn't actually have any rights
704
00:49:38,443 --> 00:49:41,178
to john's money or
any of his belongings.
705
00:49:42,803 --> 00:49:46,418
One hypothesis around
Damion's motivation
706
00:49:46,443 --> 00:49:50,138
is he gains financially
707
00:49:50,163 --> 00:49:53,498
by not reporting john's death.
708
00:49:55,283 --> 00:49:57,578
I've just noticed something.
709
00:49:59,323 --> 00:50:04,698
This is the computerised record for
the purchase of the chest freezer.
710
00:50:05,843 --> 00:50:09,138
The freezer was ordered
711
00:50:09,163 --> 00:50:10,818
on the 25th of September.
712
00:50:11,963 --> 00:50:16,938
Alarmingly, that would coincide to
when the Facebook entries are made,
713
00:50:16,963 --> 00:50:19,538
when Damion is saying
that john's cited.
714
00:50:23,283 --> 00:50:28,058
I expected the freezer to have been
in the property long beforehand.
715
00:50:28,083 --> 00:50:32,818
But Damion Johnson has ordered
the chest freezer himself.
716
00:50:39,363 --> 00:50:41,818
This new evidence raises questions
717
00:50:41,843 --> 00:50:46,298
about whether Damion concealed
John's body for financial gain.
718
00:50:52,483 --> 00:50:56,658
So between September 18 andjuly 20,
719
00:50:56,683 --> 00:51:01,498
£17,000 is taken
from John's bank account.
720
00:51:02,803 --> 00:51:04,138
Did you take that money?
721
00:51:05,203 --> 00:51:06,898
No.
722
00:51:06,923 --> 00:51:09,498
No? No, I didn't.
723
00:51:09,523 --> 00:51:12,298
You carried on claiming
the Carer's Allowance for john
724
00:51:12,323 --> 00:51:14,538
after he's passed away.
725
00:51:14,563 --> 00:51:17,098
That's £258 a month.
726
00:51:17,123 --> 00:51:20,178
And you'd probably,
if we hadn't discovered John,
727
00:51:20,203 --> 00:51:21,898
still be claiming that benefit now.
728
00:51:24,483 --> 00:51:26,458
No comment. Oh, my God.
729
00:51:29,123 --> 00:51:33,578
We'll move on now to
the freezer itself.
730
00:51:33,603 --> 00:51:37,858
When you placed John
into the freezer,
731
00:51:37,883 --> 00:51:40,738
has anybody assisted you placing him
into the freezer?
732
00:51:40,763 --> 00:51:42,258
No, I did that.
733
00:51:42,283 --> 00:51:43,938
All by yourself?
734
00:51:43,963 --> 00:51:45,938
Yes, unfortunately.
735
00:51:47,243 --> 00:51:49,818
I didn't... Oh, it's vile.
736
00:51:49,843 --> 00:51:52,658
I didn't expect him
to go in the way he did.
737
00:51:53,763 --> 00:51:56,978
His head, oh, went down.
738
00:51:58,403 --> 00:52:03,578
So just going slightly back to
the dental injuries, the teeth.
739
00:52:03,603 --> 00:52:05,978
Could any of those injuries
have been caused
740
00:52:06,003 --> 00:52:08,138
as you placed him into
the chest freezer?
741
00:52:08,163 --> 00:52:09,418
I don't know.
742
00:52:11,323 --> 00:52:14,018
I wanted it over and done with.
743
00:52:14,043 --> 00:52:17,298
How long had you had that
freezer before John passed away?
744
00:52:17,323 --> 00:52:19,618
It was bought for food.
745
00:52:19,643 --> 00:52:22,538
I saw a cheap chest freezer.
746
00:52:22,563 --> 00:52:25,098
"Oh, I'll have that.
Oh, that looks good."
747
00:52:26,603 --> 00:52:28,498
just...
748
00:52:28,523 --> 00:52:33,378
That freezer was purchased
on the 25th of September,
749
00:52:33,403 --> 00:52:35,818
and that's the same day john's cited.
750
00:52:38,643 --> 00:52:41,738
Are you trying to tell us
it's just a fluke?
751
00:52:44,043 --> 00:52:49,138
It's been delivered three clays
later, on the 28th of September,
752
00:52:49,163 --> 00:52:51,698
and you placed him
into a chest freezer.
753
00:52:51,723 --> 00:52:53,258
It wasn't bought for that.
754
00:52:54,723 --> 00:52:58,098
Your original prepared statement
you'd given,
755
00:52:58,123 --> 00:53:01,898
you were overcome with grief,
you're absolutely distraught
756
00:53:01,923 --> 00:53:03,538
about what's happened.
757
00:53:03,563 --> 00:53:07,138
I'll tell you that there's a motive
for not reporting what's happened.
758
00:53:07,163 --> 00:53:10,258
No... No.
There is. There isn't.
759
00:53:10,283 --> 00:53:14,218
I'll put it to you that the reason
you haven't reported John's passing
760
00:53:14,243 --> 00:53:17,058
is for your own selfish...
No. ..gains. Nope.
761
00:53:18,083 --> 00:53:19,298
Let's face facts.
762
00:53:20,363 --> 00:53:22,698
You knew if you'd reported his death
763
00:53:22,723 --> 00:53:25,018
that the flat
would be taken off you.
764
00:53:25,043 --> 00:53:28,938
You were living in that flat
for an extra 18 months rent-free,
765
00:53:28,963 --> 00:53:33,778
all the bills paid for and you still
got access to John's bank account.
766
00:53:33,803 --> 00:53:36,418
Is that not the case? No.
767
00:53:36,443 --> 00:53:38,178
Absolutely not.
768
00:53:41,723 --> 00:53:45,978
Damion doesn't seem to
have any job or income.
769
00:53:46,003 --> 00:53:49,418
He had a lifestyle with john.
770
00:53:49,443 --> 00:53:52,378
He had his Carer's Allowance,
771
00:53:52,403 --> 00:53:56,658
and he appears to have just
continued in that
772
00:53:56,683 --> 00:53:58,418
with the passing of john.
773
00:53:59,763 --> 00:54:04,298
Our investigation shows this is
a calculated decision-making process
774
00:54:04,323 --> 00:54:06,538
to conceal the body.
775
00:54:12,643 --> 00:54:15,858
With all forensic examinations
completed,
776
00:54:15,883 --> 00:54:19,018
the pathologist meets with
the police forensic team
777
00:54:19,043 --> 00:54:22,098
to review his conclusions
on John's cause of death.
778
00:54:24,723 --> 00:54:27,738
Within the limits of
what we've had to work with,
779
00:54:27,763 --> 00:54:30,258
very decomposed...
780
00:54:31,523 --> 00:54:33,938
...adult male,
781
00:54:33,963 --> 00:54:37,738
major findings of note are,
he has...
782
00:54:39,403 --> 00:54:41,138
...fractured right cheekbone.
783
00:54:42,603 --> 00:54:46,098
He has fracturing of his nose,
784
00:54:46,123 --> 00:54:48,858
more to the right side.
785
00:54:48,883 --> 00:54:51,898
The further work on those
show that they could be caused
786
00:54:51,923 --> 00:54:54,458
by some sort of heavy fall.
787
00:54:54,483 --> 00:54:59,338
In terms of natural disease
he does have some atheroma,
788
00:54:59,363 --> 00:55:02,898
you know, the sort of fatty deposits
in blood vessels.
789
00:55:04,443 --> 00:55:06,498
Ancl he's certainly got quite a bit
in the aorta,
790
00:55:06,523 --> 00:55:08,058
the biggest artery in the body.
791
00:55:08,083 --> 00:55:13,898
He's got some calcification and
atheroma to the coronary arteries,
792
00:55:13,923 --> 00:55:16,138
but the disease there doesn't strike
you immediately
793
00:55:16,163 --> 00:55:18,458
as an explanation for his death.
794
00:55:18,483 --> 00:55:22,178
So, I think, cause of death -
unascertained.
795
00:55:22,203 --> 00:55:24,458
I mean, it will probably
never be ascertained.
796
00:55:27,483 --> 00:55:30,018
It is frustrating,
797
00:55:30,043 --> 00:55:33,978
but it's not always possible
to say how that person has cited.
798
00:55:34,003 --> 00:55:37,418
We're looking at this
two years down the line,
799
00:55:37,443 --> 00:55:41,018
and when there's a delay
it's a lot trickier for us.
800
00:55:41,043 --> 00:55:44,418
At the end of the clay
you can't go for a murder charge
801
00:55:44,443 --> 00:55:47,938
when you haven't got the evidence
in front of you.
802
00:55:49,723 --> 00:55:52,978
The Crown Prosecution Service
authorises charges
803
00:55:53,003 --> 00:55:56,978
for Damion Johnson
of three counts of fraud
804
00:55:57,003 --> 00:56:01,258
and of preventing the lawful burial
of john Wainwright.
805
00:56:06,803 --> 00:56:09,658
Very sad story, unfortunately.
806
00:56:09,683 --> 00:56:11,978
That is the one thing I'm left with,
807
00:56:12,003 --> 00:56:15,818
it's an overwhelming feeling
of how sad the whole thing is.
808
00:56:38,963 --> 00:56:42,858
It matters to do the right thing
when someone's cited.
809
00:56:42,883 --> 00:56:45,498
That is why I do this job.
810
00:56:45,523 --> 00:56:47,698
That is part of forensics.
811
00:57:10,643 --> 00:57:13,978
Forensics was critical in this case
812
00:57:14,003 --> 00:57:17,178
in helping identify the deceased,
813
00:57:17,203 --> 00:57:21,018
so that he is treated
814
00:57:21,043 --> 00:57:24,058
with the dignity and respect
815
00:57:24,083 --> 00:57:28,298
that, up until this point,
he hasn't had in death.
816
00:57:30,763 --> 00:57:33,498
What happened to john,
it's just horrific.
817
00:57:33,523 --> 00:57:36,858
It's just,
you just can't do that to people.
818
00:57:40,003 --> 00:57:44,458
I think that Damion kind of owed it
to john to be upfront and honest
819
00:57:44,483 --> 00:57:47,538
and just say what happened.
820
00:57:47,563 --> 00:57:50,898
Ancl I suppose to a degree
he's clone that by pleading.
821
00:57:53,483 --> 00:57:56,458
People have a right to be buried,
822
00:57:56,483 --> 00:57:59,818
a right to be laid to rest,
823
00:57:59,843 --> 00:58:02,458
and that had been taken
away from him.
824
00:58:10,683 --> 00:58:13,858
What does it take to
work in forensic science?
825
00:58:13,883 --> 00:58:17,018
To find out more
and watch exclusive interviews
826
00:58:17,043 --> 00:58:20,098
with some of the programme's
featured investigators,
827
00:58:20,123 --> 00:58:25,138
visit...
828
00:58:25,163 --> 00:58:27,658
...and follow the links
to The Open University.
68032
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.