Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:02,004 --> 00:00:05,640
We feel it
every moment of our lives.
2
00:00:05,642 --> 00:00:09,310
But for physicists...
3
00:00:09,312 --> 00:00:14,632
It is the oldest unsolved
mystery of the cosmos.
4
00:00:14,634 --> 00:00:17,518
Why does gravity
make everything attract?
5
00:00:22,524 --> 00:00:27,061
Cutting-edge theory is closing
in on unexpected answers.
6
00:00:28,297 --> 00:00:31,465
Could gravity be another force
in disguise...
7
00:00:33,201 --> 00:00:37,038
A shadow
of a holographic reality,
8
00:00:37,040 --> 00:00:40,608
or a rippling mirage?
9
00:00:40,610 --> 00:00:45,212
Do we, Earth, the Sun,
and the stars
10
00:00:45,214 --> 00:00:47,848
really have weight?
11
00:00:47,850 --> 00:00:52,019
Or is gravity an illusion?
12
00:00:55,624 --> 00:01:00,661
Space, time, life itself...
13
00:01:02,197 --> 00:01:06,767
The secrets of the cosmos
lie through the wormhole.
14
00:01:06,769 --> 00:01:10,769
♪ Through the Wormhole 05x07 ♪
Is Gravity an Illusion?
Original Air Date on July 2, 20
15
00:01:10,793 --> 00:01:16,793
== sync, corrected by elderman ==
@elder_man
16
00:01:20,682 --> 00:01:23,184
The gravitational pull
of the sun
17
00:01:23,186 --> 00:01:26,287
keeps Earth
from flying off into space.
18
00:01:26,289 --> 00:01:30,524
Earth's gravity keeps us
firmly planted on the ground.
19
00:01:30,526 --> 00:01:33,394
This all seems real enough.
20
00:01:33,396 --> 00:01:37,932
But scientists are peering deep
into the fabric of the universe
21
00:01:37,934 --> 00:01:42,036
and are discovering
that gravity...
22
00:01:44,573 --> 00:01:47,908
...may not be what it seems
to be.
23
00:01:47,910 --> 00:01:53,848
Can something feel real
but not actually be real?
24
00:01:56,853 --> 00:01:58,819
There were some days
growing up
25
00:01:58,821 --> 00:02:01,889
when there just wasn't
anything to do.
26
00:02:01,891 --> 00:02:04,909
So we would play simple games
27
00:02:04,911 --> 00:02:07,628
like target practice with rocks.
28
00:02:09,315 --> 00:02:12,767
Gravity always worked.
29
00:02:12,769 --> 00:02:17,505
No matter what I dropped,
I always expected it to fall.
30
00:02:24,663 --> 00:02:28,816
Physicists have their own
expectations about gravity.
31
00:02:28,818 --> 00:02:30,751
They believe it to be
a fundamental force,
32
00:02:30,753 --> 00:02:35,156
an intrinsic cog in
the machinery of the universe.
33
00:02:36,592 --> 00:02:39,226
But experimentalist
Nergis Mavalvala
34
00:02:39,228 --> 00:02:41,796
isn't taking anything
for granted.
35
00:02:41,798 --> 00:02:45,933
So, a fundamental force that --
like gravity,
36
00:02:45,935 --> 00:02:49,904
that describes how
massive objects interact
37
00:02:49,906 --> 00:02:53,074
should be true anywhere you look
in the universe.
38
00:02:53,076 --> 00:02:57,712
Isaac Newton showed
that every object with mass
39
00:02:57,714 --> 00:03:00,648
attracts every other object
with mass.
40
00:03:00,650 --> 00:03:03,350
The greater the mass
and the closer they are,
41
00:03:03,352 --> 00:03:06,787
the greater
the gravitational attraction.
42
00:03:06,789 --> 00:03:08,856
Over 200 years later,
43
00:03:08,858 --> 00:03:12,927
Albert Einstein explained
why this happens.
44
00:03:12,929 --> 00:03:18,466
Space and time are interwoven
into a fabric called spacetime.
45
00:03:18,468 --> 00:03:24,605
Einstein believed that spacetime
could bend.
46
00:03:24,607 --> 00:03:29,110
This distortion is what
we experience as gravity.
47
00:03:29,112 --> 00:03:32,279
And that's how he understood
that objects with mass
48
00:03:32,281 --> 00:03:33,697
attract to each other.
49
00:03:33,699 --> 00:03:36,217
They follow the curvature
of spacetime.
50
00:03:36,219 --> 00:03:38,919
So Einstein's picture of --
of gravity was
51
00:03:38,921 --> 00:03:41,639
that mass tells spacetime
how to curve,
52
00:03:41,641 --> 00:03:44,191
and then the curvature
of spacetime
53
00:03:44,193 --> 00:03:45,359
tells mass how to move.
54
00:03:45,361 --> 00:03:47,762
Einstein also predicted
55
00:03:47,764 --> 00:03:50,765
that when all objects
with mass move,
56
00:03:50,767 --> 00:03:53,734
they trigger
tiny gravitational ripples
57
00:03:53,736 --> 00:03:55,736
in the fabric of spacetime.
58
00:03:55,738 --> 00:04:00,441
Gravitational waves should
permeate the heavens above us.
59
00:04:00,443 --> 00:04:04,378
Nergis believes we should be
able to detect those waves,
60
00:04:04,380 --> 00:04:06,781
if they are big enough.
61
00:04:08,416 --> 00:04:11,986
So if I drop an apple
in the middle of a pond...
62
00:04:13,255 --> 00:04:15,890
And I try to detect
the ripple at the shore,
63
00:04:15,892 --> 00:04:17,491
it's not going to make it.
64
00:04:17,493 --> 00:04:19,760
It was too small of a wave.
65
00:04:19,762 --> 00:04:21,679
Luckily for Nergis,
66
00:04:21,681 --> 00:04:24,365
bodies much more massive
than apples
67
00:04:24,367 --> 00:04:26,233
cause a stir in the heavens.
68
00:04:34,527 --> 00:04:36,644
Awesome! Whoa!
69
00:04:37,913 --> 00:04:40,714
Around the cosmos,
70
00:04:40,716 --> 00:04:42,700
intense gravitational events,
71
00:04:42,702 --> 00:04:46,053
like the collision
of galaxies...
72
00:04:47,323 --> 00:04:50,724
...or the explosions
of giant stars...
73
00:04:51,994 --> 00:04:53,928
...should be sending
massive volleys
74
00:04:53,930 --> 00:04:58,282
of gravitational waves
towards Earth.
75
00:04:58,284 --> 00:05:00,935
Nergis has created a way
to detect them
76
00:05:00,937 --> 00:05:04,939
with the help of collaborators
like Mike Landry.
77
00:05:04,941 --> 00:05:06,157
Nergis and Mike
78
00:05:06,159 --> 00:05:09,276
are part of the largest
experiment ever built
79
00:05:09,278 --> 00:05:12,079
by the National Science
Foundation.
80
00:05:12,081 --> 00:05:13,414
It is known as
81
00:05:13,416 --> 00:05:16,450
the Laser Interferometer
Gravitational Wave observatory,
82
00:05:16,452 --> 00:05:18,219
or L.I.G.O.,
83
00:05:18,221 --> 00:05:20,004
in this behemoth,
84
00:05:20,006 --> 00:05:23,324
laser beams fire down
two vacuum tubes
85
00:05:23,326 --> 00:05:26,026
arranged in an "L" shape.
86
00:05:26,028 --> 00:05:31,115
Each arm is 4 kilometers long.
87
00:05:31,117 --> 00:05:33,634
The laser beams can measure
the length of each arm
88
00:05:33,636 --> 00:05:36,287
with an accuracy
of better than 1 millionth
89
00:05:36,289 --> 00:05:37,805
of the width of an atom.
90
00:05:37,807 --> 00:05:41,842
If a gravitational wave
from any intense cosmic event
91
00:05:41,844 --> 00:05:45,045
up to 500 trillion trillion
miles away
92
00:05:45,047 --> 00:05:46,814
passes through the Earth,
93
00:05:46,816 --> 00:05:49,416
the space inside the tubes
will ripple.
94
00:05:49,418 --> 00:05:51,719
The lasers will detect
the change,
95
00:05:51,721 --> 00:05:54,221
and the alarm bells will ring.
96
00:05:58,493 --> 00:06:02,813
After almost a decade of
listening to the heavens,
97
00:06:02,815 --> 00:06:04,798
L.I.G.O. picked up the sound...
98
00:06:06,134 --> 00:06:07,251
...of crickets.
99
00:06:09,839 --> 00:06:11,388
We didn't observe
a gravitational wave
100
00:06:11,390 --> 00:06:13,908
in the initial science runs
of L.I.G.O.
101
00:06:13,910 --> 00:06:16,911
Nergis, Mike, and the thousands
of scientists at L.I.G.O.
102
00:06:16,913 --> 00:06:18,579
Have one more shot.
103
00:06:18,581 --> 00:06:21,715
They're working
on advanced upgrades
104
00:06:21,717 --> 00:06:25,219
that will increase
L.I.G.O.'s sensitivity tenfold.
105
00:06:25,221 --> 00:06:28,989
But there's no guarantee
they'll ever get a signal.
106
00:06:28,991 --> 00:06:31,659
Well, if we don't detect
gravitational waves
107
00:06:31,661 --> 00:06:34,395
with advanced L.I.G.O.,
well, first, I'll cry.
108
00:06:34,397 --> 00:06:37,581
But then, I think, it's actually
very exciting either way.
109
00:06:37,583 --> 00:06:39,733
If we don't see
gravitational waves,
110
00:06:39,735 --> 00:06:43,203
then it's going to start off
a different kind of revolution,
111
00:06:43,205 --> 00:06:45,806
where there'll be
a lot of head-scratching
112
00:06:45,808 --> 00:06:48,642
about, "what is it about
nature we don't understand?"
113
00:06:48,644 --> 00:06:51,762
Nergis is hopeful.
114
00:06:51,764 --> 00:06:56,083
In fact, in march of 2014,
a group of astronomers
115
00:06:56,085 --> 00:06:58,986
claimed to have detected
gravitational waves
116
00:06:58,988 --> 00:07:01,622
produced by the big bang.
117
00:07:01,624 --> 00:07:03,023
But some scientists take
118
00:07:03,025 --> 00:07:04,475
the deafening silence
at L.I.G.O.
119
00:07:04,477 --> 00:07:08,996
as evidence that gravity may not
be a fundamental force.
120
00:07:08,998 --> 00:07:11,999
When an apple
falls to the earth,
121
00:07:12,001 --> 00:07:15,369
something else could be
pulling it down.
122
00:07:15,371 --> 00:07:18,656
Physicists believe that
everything in the universe,
123
00:07:18,658 --> 00:07:22,142
even the pulse of energy
that we call force,
124
00:07:22,144 --> 00:07:24,979
is made from particles.
125
00:07:24,981 --> 00:07:28,315
Gravity should be no exception.
126
00:07:38,460 --> 00:07:42,279
Zvi Bern is
a particle physicist
127
00:07:42,281 --> 00:07:45,466
with a very active imagination.
128
00:07:47,235 --> 00:07:50,220
He's imagining what a game
of mini golf would look like
129
00:07:50,222 --> 00:07:51,889
if the balls were shrunk
130
00:07:51,891 --> 00:07:54,541
to the size
of subatomic particles
131
00:07:54,543 --> 00:07:58,412
and ruled by the laws
of quantum mechanics.
132
00:08:00,082 --> 00:08:02,282
Quantum mechanics
is full of the strangest things
133
00:08:02,284 --> 00:08:04,435
you can imagine.
134
00:08:04,437 --> 00:08:07,404
The concept of a particle
being at one point,
135
00:08:07,406 --> 00:08:10,758
that becomes a very fuzzy
concept in quantum mechanics.
136
00:08:10,760 --> 00:08:14,061
Subatomic particles
are unlike anything
137
00:08:14,063 --> 00:08:16,213
you can see
with your naked eye.
138
00:08:16,215 --> 00:08:19,633
They become fuzzy
when no one looks at them.
139
00:08:19,635 --> 00:08:24,071
Sometimes they can appear
out of nowhere...
140
00:08:24,073 --> 00:08:26,874
and then suddenly vanish.
141
00:08:26,876 --> 00:08:29,443
Some of these appearing
and disappearing particles...
142
00:08:30,713 --> 00:08:33,580
...transmit the fundamental
forces of nature --
143
00:08:33,582 --> 00:08:37,151
electromagnetism,
the strong force,
144
00:08:37,153 --> 00:08:42,373
the weak force,
and, supposedly, gravity.
145
00:08:42,375 --> 00:08:44,291
I have here a golf ball.
146
00:08:44,293 --> 00:08:46,927
The golf ball represents
a photon.
147
00:08:46,929 --> 00:08:50,597
The photon is the carrier
of the electromagnetic force.
148
00:08:50,599 --> 00:08:55,135
The electromagnetic
force attracts or repels
149
00:08:55,137 --> 00:08:57,971
anything
with an electric charge.
150
00:08:57,973 --> 00:08:59,339
The next golf balls --
151
00:08:59,341 --> 00:09:01,575
these represent
the W and the Z boson.
152
00:09:01,577 --> 00:09:02,860
The W and the Z boson --
153
00:09:02,862 --> 00:09:05,879
these are the carriers
of the weak nuclear interaction.
154
00:09:05,881 --> 00:09:07,181
The weak force causes
155
00:09:07,183 --> 00:09:08,916
the nucleus
of a radioactive atom
156
00:09:08,918 --> 00:09:10,484
to break apart.
157
00:09:10,486 --> 00:09:13,454
The next golf ball --
it represents the gluon.
158
00:09:13,456 --> 00:09:16,457
The gluon is the carrier of
the strong nuclear interaction.
159
00:09:16,459 --> 00:09:19,793
The strong force
binds particles together
160
00:09:19,795 --> 00:09:23,831
to form an atomic nucleus.
161
00:09:23,833 --> 00:09:27,201
Gravity should also be carried
by a particle,
162
00:09:27,203 --> 00:09:32,139
but no one has ever observed
this so-called graviton.
163
00:09:32,141 --> 00:09:35,442
In fact, when physicists
try to calculate
164
00:09:35,444 --> 00:09:38,545
how the theoretical graviton
might work,
165
00:09:38,547 --> 00:09:41,715
they quickly get lost
in impossible math.
166
00:09:41,717 --> 00:09:44,251
Gravity, unfortunately, is one
of our most complicated theories
167
00:09:44,253 --> 00:09:45,886
in the way it interacts.
168
00:09:45,888 --> 00:09:49,389
And what happens is
as you do these calculations,
169
00:09:49,391 --> 00:09:51,742
very quickly you start
encountering expressions
170
00:09:51,744 --> 00:09:53,293
which no computer
in the world,
171
00:09:53,295 --> 00:09:55,045
or all the world's computer --
172
00:09:55,047 --> 00:09:57,764
they couldn't possibly
do those calculations.
173
00:09:59,334 --> 00:10:01,702
But Zvi
has a trick up his sleeve
174
00:10:01,704 --> 00:10:05,606
to calculate whether or not
the graviton exists.
175
00:10:05,608 --> 00:10:10,777
Quantum theory, like mini golf,
is a game of probability.
176
00:10:10,779 --> 00:10:14,648
Trying to hit a hole-in-one
is difficult.
177
00:10:14,650 --> 00:10:17,384
There are so many ways
the ball could go.
178
00:10:18,736 --> 00:10:21,922
But break up the hole
into smaller pieces,
179
00:10:21,924 --> 00:10:24,691
and things are
much more manageable.
180
00:10:30,198 --> 00:10:31,532
Together with some colleagues,
181
00:10:31,534 --> 00:10:35,519
we developed an idea that we
called the Unitarity Method.
182
00:10:35,521 --> 00:10:39,072
And the basic idea of that is,
you take the bigger problem
183
00:10:39,074 --> 00:10:41,742
of these interactions,
these complications,
184
00:10:41,744 --> 00:10:44,144
and then you chop it
into smaller pieces.
185
00:10:44,146 --> 00:10:46,547
And then, by solving
the smaller problems
186
00:10:46,549 --> 00:10:49,233
and assembling it,
you can do a lot better than
187
00:10:49,235 --> 00:10:51,451
if you were just trying to solve
the whole problem at once.
188
00:10:51,453 --> 00:10:54,588
When Zvi and his colleagues
189
00:10:54,590 --> 00:10:56,957
applied their Unitarity Method
to gravitons,
190
00:10:56,959 --> 00:10:59,159
an unexpected result came back.
191
00:10:59,161 --> 00:11:02,062
What we discovered
about the graviton
192
00:11:02,064 --> 00:11:04,498
is that,
in a very precise way,
193
00:11:04,500 --> 00:11:06,767
it can be interpreted
as two copies of gluons.
194
00:11:06,769 --> 00:11:10,320
Which binds
the nuclei of atoms together
195
00:11:10,322 --> 00:11:12,756
through the strong force.
196
00:11:12,758 --> 00:11:15,475
But Zvi and his colleagues
believe gluons
197
00:11:15,477 --> 00:11:18,712
could also be responsible
for gravity.
198
00:11:18,714 --> 00:11:21,882
The graviton could actually be
a pair of gluons.
199
00:11:21,884 --> 00:11:23,834
Everything became
instantly clear,
200
00:11:23,836 --> 00:11:26,103
like a moment of insight,
the "Eureka!" moment.
201
00:11:26,105 --> 00:11:28,188
This is our "Eureka!" moment,
202
00:11:28,190 --> 00:11:30,924
where -- where we really knew
that we understood it.
203
00:11:30,926 --> 00:11:33,860
And the fact that
it came out that simple
204
00:11:33,862 --> 00:11:35,879
really was the great surprise.
205
00:11:35,881 --> 00:11:39,366
We always had suspicions that
something like this was true.
206
00:11:39,368 --> 00:11:41,785
But that it -- it works as
simply as it did --
207
00:11:41,787 --> 00:11:43,403
that was really the big surprise
for us.
208
00:11:43,405 --> 00:11:47,307
Zvi's work could mean
that when an apple falls,
209
00:11:47,309 --> 00:11:51,311
the gravity that pulls it down
is just another manifestation
210
00:11:51,313 --> 00:11:53,113
of the strong force.
211
00:11:53,115 --> 00:11:55,282
The same force that holds
212
00:11:55,284 --> 00:11:57,317
the nucleus of tiny atoms
together
213
00:11:57,319 --> 00:11:59,419
could also be responsible
for holding
214
00:11:59,421 --> 00:12:03,056
colossal celestial bodies
in orbit.
215
00:12:03,058 --> 00:12:07,894
If so,
the universe is awash in gluons,
216
00:12:07,896 --> 00:12:10,564
working together as gravitons.
217
00:12:10,566 --> 00:12:12,499
Every time a pair of gluons
218
00:12:12,501 --> 00:12:15,269
is exchanged
between massive objects,
219
00:12:15,271 --> 00:12:18,505
the objects move
a little bit closer together.
220
00:12:20,341 --> 00:12:22,142
Scientists are discovering
221
00:12:22,144 --> 00:12:24,211
that our assumptions
about gravity
222
00:12:24,213 --> 00:12:27,114
may be almost completely wrong.
223
00:12:28,616 --> 00:12:30,250
A whole new side of gravity
224
00:12:30,252 --> 00:12:32,486
could be waiting to be
discovered.
225
00:12:32,488 --> 00:12:38,992
In fact, we may soon discover
objects that fall up.
226
00:12:41,494 --> 00:12:42,995
Most physicists believe
227
00:12:42,997 --> 00:12:47,699
that gravity is a force
that only attracts.
228
00:12:47,701 --> 00:12:50,803
But cosmologists
have recently discovered
229
00:12:50,805 --> 00:12:54,506
that galaxies appear
to be pushing each other apart
230
00:12:54,508 --> 00:12:57,709
at an ever-increasing rate.
231
00:12:57,711 --> 00:13:01,213
Perhaps it's time to reconsider
232
00:13:01,215 --> 00:13:04,416
what we think we know
about gravity.
233
00:13:11,157 --> 00:13:13,826
Dragan Hajdukovic
is a physicist
234
00:13:13,828 --> 00:13:16,628
at the European Center
for Nuclear Research,
235
00:13:16,630 --> 00:13:19,264
or C.E.R.N.,
in Geneva, Switzerland.
236
00:13:19,266 --> 00:13:21,366
But he does his best work
when visiting
237
00:13:21,368 --> 00:13:24,052
his home country
of Montenegro.
238
00:13:24,054 --> 00:13:28,774
Dragan is using his time at home
to catch up with old friends
239
00:13:28,776 --> 00:13:31,310
and work out a new theory
of gravity --
240
00:13:31,312 --> 00:13:36,615
one that involves the dangerous
material in the universe --
241
00:13:36,617 --> 00:13:38,317
antimatter.
242
00:13:40,487 --> 00:13:45,124
I have a red apple,
which is made from matter,
243
00:13:45,126 --> 00:13:49,495
and a blue one,
which is made from antimatter.
244
00:13:49,497 --> 00:13:53,215
Fortunately,
it's not a true antimatter.
245
00:13:53,217 --> 00:13:58,337
But if we assume that it is,
look what will happen.
246
00:14:03,294 --> 00:14:05,310
Fortunately for us,
247
00:14:05,312 --> 00:14:08,614
there isn't enough antimatter
in the vicinity of Earth
248
00:14:08,616 --> 00:14:10,549
to ever blow it up.
249
00:14:10,551 --> 00:14:13,719
But Dragan thinks that if there
were ever such a thing
250
00:14:13,721 --> 00:14:16,288
as an antimatter apple,
251
00:14:16,290 --> 00:14:19,491
it would have an unusual
gravitational property.
252
00:14:19,493 --> 00:14:23,295
It is quite possible
that antimatter falls up.
253
00:14:24,764 --> 00:14:26,331
Dragan suspects
254
00:14:26,333 --> 00:14:29,368
that antimatter and matter
repel each other,
255
00:14:29,370 --> 00:14:32,004
and that hidden pockets
of antimatter
256
00:14:32,006 --> 00:14:35,491
could be responsible
for pushing the universe apart.
257
00:14:35,493 --> 00:14:38,744
Physicists use the term
"quantum vacuum"
258
00:14:38,746 --> 00:14:40,596
to describe the space
259
00:14:40,598 --> 00:14:43,866
that fills
every corner of the cosmos.
260
00:14:43,868 --> 00:14:45,968
Don't let the name fool you.
261
00:14:45,970 --> 00:14:48,587
It's bubbling
with microscopic activity.
262
00:14:48,589 --> 00:14:51,557
At every point
in the quantum vacuum,
263
00:14:51,559 --> 00:14:55,761
tiny, innocuous pairs of matter
and antimatter particles
264
00:14:55,763 --> 00:14:58,664
are popping
in and out of existence.
265
00:14:58,666 --> 00:15:03,101
They exist for a split-second
before annihilating each other.
266
00:15:03,103 --> 00:15:07,639
There are billions of billions
of billions of billions and --
267
00:15:07,641 --> 00:15:11,460
let's stop, we can continue --
268
00:15:11,462 --> 00:15:15,480
of pairs in the metacube
of the quantum vacuum.
269
00:15:15,482 --> 00:15:19,785
So they must play a role
in theory of gravity.
270
00:15:19,787 --> 00:15:23,188
Think of the quantum vacuum
271
00:15:23,190 --> 00:15:25,524
like a typical Montenegrin town.
272
00:15:25,526 --> 00:15:31,697
Every particle of matter
always dances with a partner.
273
00:15:31,699 --> 00:15:35,534
When a pair of tiny dancers
pops into existence,
274
00:15:35,536 --> 00:15:38,136
the gravity of the matter
is cancelled out
275
00:15:38,138 --> 00:15:42,074
by the antigravity
of the antimatter.
276
00:15:42,076 --> 00:15:44,710
So, normally, no matter how many
pairs of particles
277
00:15:44,712 --> 00:15:47,279
and antiparticles are created,
278
00:15:47,281 --> 00:15:50,782
the resulting
gravitational effect is zero.
279
00:15:50,784 --> 00:15:53,702
But the quantum vacuum doesn't
always exist in a vacuum.
280
00:15:53,704 --> 00:15:56,371
The universe is filled,
281
00:15:56,373 --> 00:16:01,526
after all, with giant islands
of matter called galaxies.
282
00:16:01,528 --> 00:16:03,462
If you put matter inside,
283
00:16:03,464 --> 00:16:06,932
it spoils the symmetry,
284
00:16:06,934 --> 00:16:09,434
and you have
gravitational effects.
285
00:16:10,754 --> 00:16:13,238
At the end
of a Montenegrin folk dance,
286
00:16:13,240 --> 00:16:15,574
male dancers are drawn
into the center
287
00:16:15,576 --> 00:16:18,110
to form a massive structure.
288
00:16:18,112 --> 00:16:22,648
The female dancers
are pushed outwards.
289
00:16:24,051 --> 00:16:25,734
In Dragan's theory,
290
00:16:25,736 --> 00:16:28,620
tiny particles of matter
and antimatter
291
00:16:28,622 --> 00:16:32,724
in the quantum vacuum
follow the same steps.
292
00:16:35,728 --> 00:16:39,531
Galaxies are made of matter.
293
00:16:39,533 --> 00:16:42,868
They pull in the matter
in the quantum vacuum
294
00:16:42,870 --> 00:16:45,304
and push its antimatter away.
295
00:16:45,306 --> 00:16:49,875
So there's slightly less matter
and slightly more antimatter
296
00:16:49,877 --> 00:16:52,244
in the space between galaxies.
297
00:16:52,246 --> 00:16:56,882
So the quantum vacuum becomes
gravitationally repulsive
298
00:16:56,884 --> 00:17:00,052
and galaxies are pushed apart.
299
00:17:00,054 --> 00:17:03,255
Physicists can see
this galactic drift happening.
300
00:17:03,257 --> 00:17:05,574
They are not sure where
the energy
301
00:17:05,576 --> 00:17:07,526
that is causing it comes from,
302
00:17:07,528 --> 00:17:12,280
so they call it dark energy.
303
00:17:12,282 --> 00:17:14,383
But Dragan thinks dark energy
304
00:17:14,385 --> 00:17:16,668
is gravity's
hidden dance partner.
305
00:17:16,670 --> 00:17:21,623
Many physicists tried to explain
the existence of dark energy.
306
00:17:21,625 --> 00:17:25,377
But once again, no one knows
what's dark energy.
307
00:17:25,379 --> 00:17:28,947
Now, what's --
what's the simpler solution --
308
00:17:28,949 --> 00:17:30,716
to invoke dark energy,
309
00:17:30,718 --> 00:17:33,218
or to assume
gravitational repulsion
310
00:17:33,220 --> 00:17:35,287
between matter
and antimatter?
311
00:17:42,162 --> 00:17:44,730
Dragan's theory
is controversial.
312
00:17:44,732 --> 00:17:46,098
But we may soon find out
313
00:17:46,100 --> 00:17:49,868
if gravity has
a repulsive alter ego.
314
00:17:51,070 --> 00:17:53,638
Back at C.E.R.N.,
Dragan's colleagues are using
315
00:17:53,640 --> 00:17:58,276
the Large Hadron Collider
to produce antihydrogen.
316
00:17:58,278 --> 00:18:01,763
If it falls up,
317
00:18:01,765 --> 00:18:05,984
we may finally have
an explanation for dark energy.
318
00:18:05,986 --> 00:18:09,805
Or it could be another
false step on the road
319
00:18:09,807 --> 00:18:11,556
to understanding gravity.
320
00:18:11,558 --> 00:18:14,810
I think that our understanding
is incomplete.
321
00:18:14,812 --> 00:18:18,663
If you try to explain
astronomical phenomena
322
00:18:18,665 --> 00:18:23,001
by our best physics,
it's a disaster.
323
00:18:23,003 --> 00:18:27,055
Our gravitational
theories are broken.
324
00:18:27,057 --> 00:18:29,608
Neither Einstein's theory
nor quantum physics
325
00:18:29,610 --> 00:18:32,544
explains all of what we observe.
326
00:18:32,546 --> 00:18:34,846
Is gravity a trick of the mind?
327
00:18:34,848 --> 00:18:38,917
Or, perhaps,
gravity is what's real,
328
00:18:38,919 --> 00:18:41,753
and reality itself
is the illusion.
329
00:18:43,805 --> 00:18:47,736
Flat because our planet is so large,
330
00:18:48,420 --> 00:18:52,319
Change your perspective
by flying high enough,
331
00:18:52,321 --> 00:18:55,718
and you can see the curvature
of Earth.
332
00:18:55,720 --> 00:18:57,918
If gravity is an illusion,
333
00:18:57,920 --> 00:19:01,051
can we find a new perspective
on it
334
00:19:01,053 --> 00:19:03,650
and see it for what it is?
335
00:19:10,584 --> 00:19:12,682
Princeton University's
Herman Verlinde
336
00:19:12,684 --> 00:19:15,748
is soul searching.
337
00:19:15,750 --> 00:19:19,064
Multiple experiments have shown
that Einstein's theory,
338
00:19:19,066 --> 00:19:22,198
that gravity is the warping
of space and time,
339
00:19:22,200 --> 00:19:24,348
appears to be correct.
340
00:19:24,350 --> 00:19:28,264
But an equally powerful theory,
quantum mechanics,
341
00:19:28,266 --> 00:19:30,613
says that Einstein's theory
cannot explain
342
00:19:30,615 --> 00:19:33,412
what gravity is made of.
343
00:19:33,414 --> 00:19:36,378
Einstein told us that if you
move through space,
344
00:19:36,380 --> 00:19:38,312
you don't notice it,
345
00:19:38,314 --> 00:19:41,878
because space is empty.
It's not made out of anything.
346
00:19:41,880 --> 00:19:44,444
But quantum theory
tells you that actually,
347
00:19:44,446 --> 00:19:47,810
that there must be a granularity
to space,
348
00:19:47,812 --> 00:19:50,693
just like this sand.
349
00:19:56,043 --> 00:19:58,576
Einstein's theory says that
350
00:19:58,578 --> 00:20:01,641
the particle that carries
gravitational force,
351
00:20:01,643 --> 00:20:05,324
the graviton, must float
on the completely smooth surface
352
00:20:05,326 --> 00:20:08,707
of empty space,
like the surface of the sea.
353
00:20:08,709 --> 00:20:11,706
But according
to quantum mechanics,
354
00:20:11,708 --> 00:20:15,372
space is not smooth at all.
355
00:20:15,374 --> 00:20:19,438
It is made up of little grains,
which make for a bumpy ride.
356
00:20:19,440 --> 00:20:22,722
It is a disagreement
that has plagued physicists
357
00:20:22,724 --> 00:20:24,672
for over a century.
358
00:20:24,674 --> 00:20:29,053
But Herman is beginning to think
both theories may be correct,
359
00:20:29,055 --> 00:20:34,453
because reality itself
may be deceiving us.
360
00:20:36,587 --> 00:20:39,403
Einstein famously
got into trouble
361
00:20:39,405 --> 00:20:42,885
by thinking that reality
should really exist,
362
00:20:42,887 --> 00:20:45,868
uh, and he called that
an objective reality.
363
00:20:45,870 --> 00:20:48,034
But in physics,
we know that the --
364
00:20:48,036 --> 00:20:50,234
the world is not quite
what it seems.
365
00:20:50,236 --> 00:20:53,301
Objects that travel
at the speed of light,
366
00:20:53,303 --> 00:20:56,399
like a photon or a graviton,
will see
367
00:20:56,401 --> 00:21:00,066
a dramatically different version
of reality.
368
00:21:00,068 --> 00:21:02,765
When the ball approaches
the speed of light,
369
00:21:02,767 --> 00:21:04,565
something
very strange happens.
370
00:21:04,567 --> 00:21:07,548
The rest of the world seems
to become shorter.
371
00:21:07,550 --> 00:21:09,648
And the faster
the ball goes,
372
00:21:09,650 --> 00:21:11,964
the shorter the rest
of the world becomes,
373
00:21:11,966 --> 00:21:14,597
until it becomes flat
like a plane.
374
00:21:14,599 --> 00:21:17,030
If you were a graviton,
375
00:21:17,032 --> 00:21:21,463
you would be convinced that
you were always standing still
376
00:21:21,465 --> 00:21:26,495
and the entire universe was
a flat sheet in front of you.
377
00:21:27,829 --> 00:21:32,428
We observe particles in our
reality moving in linear paths.
378
00:21:32,430 --> 00:21:34,626
But from a particle's
point of view,
379
00:21:34,628 --> 00:21:38,310
there may be no such thing
as moving at all.
380
00:21:38,312 --> 00:21:43,642
In the late 1960s,
mathematician Roger Penrose
381
00:21:43,644 --> 00:21:46,159
proposed a new way
to see the world.
382
00:21:46,161 --> 00:21:49,591
He said that particles that move
at the speed of light,
383
00:21:49,593 --> 00:21:53,224
like photons
and the theoretical graviton,
384
00:21:53,226 --> 00:21:58,673
experience an alternate reality
he called twistor space,
385
00:21:58,675 --> 00:22:02,856
where points are lines
and lines are points.
386
00:22:02,858 --> 00:22:04,055
In twistor space,
387
00:22:04,057 --> 00:22:07,689
the path that the graviton
travels become points,
388
00:22:07,691 --> 00:22:11,720
so it's a new set of coordinates
for space and for time.
389
00:22:13,522 --> 00:22:15,555
The idea of a hidden reality
390
00:22:15,557 --> 00:22:18,320
seemed preposterous
50 years ago.
391
00:22:20,421 --> 00:22:22,220
But a more recent idea
in physics
392
00:22:22,222 --> 00:22:26,518
suggests Penrose was ahead
of his time.
393
00:22:26,520 --> 00:22:32,518
It is a theory physicists call
the holographic principle.
394
00:22:32,520 --> 00:22:34,185
The holographic principle
395
00:22:34,187 --> 00:22:37,968
is the idea things
that we see in space
396
00:22:37,970 --> 00:22:40,950
are actually sort of
a reflection
397
00:22:40,952 --> 00:22:45,349
of some other reality
on holographic screen.
398
00:22:48,516 --> 00:22:50,816
It's as if
the actual reality
399
00:22:50,818 --> 00:22:54,282
is sitting
on the walls of this room.
400
00:22:54,284 --> 00:22:57,347
Herman is marrying
these two ideas
401
00:22:57,349 --> 00:23:01,680
into twistor holography.
402
00:23:01,682 --> 00:23:03,480
It's a reality-bending theory
403
00:23:03,482 --> 00:23:06,546
where Einstein's gravity
and quantum mechanics
404
00:23:06,548 --> 00:23:09,396
get along just fine.
405
00:23:12,213 --> 00:23:14,845
Einstein's theory requires
406
00:23:14,847 --> 00:23:18,911
that the graviton
move through smooth space.
407
00:23:18,913 --> 00:23:21,277
But in twistor holography,
408
00:23:21,279 --> 00:23:25,793
the path of the graviton's
movement is a point.
409
00:23:25,795 --> 00:23:26,826
It doesn't matter whether
410
00:23:26,828 --> 00:23:29,509
the graviton is floating
on water or sand,
411
00:23:29,511 --> 00:23:31,359
because in this reality,
412
00:23:31,361 --> 00:23:34,941
the graviton stays
completely still.
413
00:23:37,109 --> 00:23:43,207
If Herman is correct, gravity is
real in an altered reality.
414
00:23:43,209 --> 00:23:48,156
And what we experience as
reality could be an illusion,
415
00:23:48,158 --> 00:23:51,806
constructed from something else.
416
00:23:51,808 --> 00:23:53,839
It's kind of like watching
a good TV show.
417
00:23:53,841 --> 00:23:56,771
You might not realize
that an invisible group
418
00:23:56,773 --> 00:23:59,338
behind the scenes created it.
419
00:23:59,340 --> 00:24:00,704
And cut.
420
00:24:00,706 --> 00:24:05,054
Uh, tell me about reality
in life and in physics.
421
00:24:05,056 --> 00:24:06,171
In physics,
422
00:24:06,173 --> 00:24:09,253
reality is sometimes
not unique
423
00:24:09,255 --> 00:24:11,886
and sometimes not...Objective
424
00:24:11,888 --> 00:24:13,903
and sometimes deceptive.
425
00:24:13,905 --> 00:24:19,168
You're sitting here
and you're real to me,
426
00:24:19,170 --> 00:24:22,234
but who knows?
Maybe someone is tricking me.
427
00:24:24,068 --> 00:24:28,567
If gravity is
the universe's greatest mirage,
428
00:24:28,569 --> 00:24:32,267
then it must be created
from something.
429
00:24:32,269 --> 00:24:34,232
A groundbreaking theory
now argues
430
00:24:34,234 --> 00:24:38,232
that gravity could be
another form...
431
00:24:39,368 --> 00:24:41,265
...of pure heat.
432
00:24:46,391 --> 00:24:49,271
The ancient Greeks believed
that fire
433
00:24:49,273 --> 00:24:52,488
was a fundamental element
of the universe.
434
00:24:52,490 --> 00:24:57,654
But thermodynamics, the study
of how microscopic objects
435
00:24:57,656 --> 00:25:02,821
create macroscopic effects,
proved the Greeks incorrect.
436
00:25:02,823 --> 00:25:05,436
Fire is a phenomenon created
437
00:25:05,438 --> 00:25:08,570
from the furious motion
of hot atoms.
438
00:25:08,572 --> 00:25:12,885
Now a bold new theory is setting
the world of physics ablaze.
439
00:25:12,887 --> 00:25:17,385
It suggests that, like fire,
440
00:25:17,387 --> 00:25:22,184
gravity is
a thermodynamic mirage.
441
00:25:26,217 --> 00:25:29,683
The science community
is heralding a recent discovery
442
00:25:29,685 --> 00:25:31,716
as one
of the greatest revelations
443
00:25:31,718 --> 00:25:34,815
of gravitational physics,
444
00:25:34,817 --> 00:25:38,648
and it's all thanks to this man.
445
00:25:38,650 --> 00:25:41,280
No, it's not Herman Verlinde.
446
00:25:41,282 --> 00:25:44,414
It's his identical twin brother,
Erik.
447
00:25:44,416 --> 00:25:46,547
Well, as a child,
Herman and I
448
00:25:46,549 --> 00:25:48,913
discussed a lot about
what we found interesting.
449
00:25:48,915 --> 00:25:51,879
When we would read something,
we would talk about it, and --
450
00:25:51,881 --> 00:25:54,945
and we shared our excitement
in physics.
451
00:25:54,947 --> 00:25:58,445
Erik and Herman lived
similar lives in Holland.
452
00:25:58,447 --> 00:26:01,878
They both got their PhDs in
physics from Utrecht University
453
00:26:01,880 --> 00:26:04,810
and even married two sisters.
454
00:26:04,812 --> 00:26:08,777
But Erik's parallel path
would take a dramatic turn
455
00:26:08,779 --> 00:26:12,776
when a little chaos
showed up at his doorstep.
456
00:26:18,642 --> 00:26:20,941
I was vacationing,
and I came back from a run,
457
00:26:20,943 --> 00:26:24,775
and I came into my apartment,
and then I saw
458
00:26:24,777 --> 00:26:27,774
someone had broken in
and stolen my car key,
459
00:26:27,776 --> 00:26:31,940
my laptop, my passport.
Many things got lost.
460
00:26:31,942 --> 00:26:34,689
Physicists use
the term "entropy"
461
00:26:34,691 --> 00:26:37,472
to describe the amount of chaos
in a system.
462
00:26:37,474 --> 00:26:42,188
Entropy in the universe
is always increasing.
463
00:26:42,190 --> 00:26:44,171
In physics and in life,
464
00:26:44,173 --> 00:26:48,170
things naturally go from order
to disorder.
465
00:26:48,172 --> 00:26:51,437
Turning entropy into order
requires energy,
466
00:26:51,439 --> 00:26:53,536
just like when Erik
had to expend energy
467
00:26:53,538 --> 00:26:56,369
to restore order to his house.
468
00:26:56,371 --> 00:26:59,368
While dealing
with the unexpected chaos,
469
00:26:59,370 --> 00:27:03,501
Erik was hit with a flash
of inspiration.
470
00:27:03,503 --> 00:27:09,801
There is a deep connection
between entropy and gravity.
471
00:27:11,019 --> 00:27:14,316
Imagine traveling to the surface
of a neutron star
472
00:27:14,318 --> 00:27:15,967
where the intense gravity
would make you weigh
473
00:27:15,969 --> 00:27:20,399
140 trillion times more
than you do on Earth.
474
00:27:22,950 --> 00:27:25,631
It's enough to
significantly raise the entropy
475
00:27:25,633 --> 00:27:27,564
of the atoms inside you.
476
00:27:32,048 --> 00:27:35,096
As objects
fall toward a massive body,
477
00:27:35,098 --> 00:27:38,996
they experience an ever stronger
gravitational pull.
478
00:27:38,998 --> 00:27:43,329
And so their entropy
also goes up.
479
00:27:43,331 --> 00:27:46,595
What I realized is that
what causes gravity
480
00:27:46,597 --> 00:27:49,028
is that the apple,
when it's here,
481
00:27:49,030 --> 00:27:52,293
has less entropy than
when it's down on the floor.
482
00:27:52,295 --> 00:27:54,844
And nature tries
to increase entropy,
483
00:27:54,846 --> 00:27:56,726
or tends to increase
entropy.
484
00:27:56,728 --> 00:27:59,459
This is why,
if I let go of the apple,
485
00:27:59,461 --> 00:28:02,726
it will try to get as
much entropy as possible,
486
00:28:02,728 --> 00:28:04,958
and this is why
it's falling.
487
00:28:11,225 --> 00:28:12,923
Erik believes that
objects with mass
488
00:28:12,925 --> 00:28:14,441
feel the force of gravity
489
00:28:14,443 --> 00:28:16,658
because the universe
is increasing
490
00:28:16,660 --> 00:28:22,223
the amount of disorder,
or entropy, deep inside them.
491
00:28:22,225 --> 00:28:24,822
A force that is created
from entropy
492
00:28:24,824 --> 00:28:30,055
is nothing new to physicists
who understand thermodynamics.
493
00:28:30,057 --> 00:28:33,787
In fact, the entropy
inside a hot air balloon
494
00:28:33,789 --> 00:28:35,787
will lift you up into the sky.
495
00:28:37,089 --> 00:28:39,353
So a hot air balloon
contains molecules.
496
00:28:39,355 --> 00:28:41,003
Those molecules are moving.
497
00:28:41,005 --> 00:28:43,269
They want to increase
the entropy,
498
00:28:43,271 --> 00:28:44,386
and this they can do
499
00:28:44,388 --> 00:28:46,953
by getting more space
inside the balloon.
500
00:28:46,955 --> 00:28:48,468
And if the balloon expands,
501
00:28:48,470 --> 00:28:50,418
it actually can do so
by moving up.
502
00:28:50,420 --> 00:28:53,284
The hot air inside the balloon
503
00:28:53,286 --> 00:28:59,916
tries to increase its entropy
by pushing outward and upward.
504
00:28:59,918 --> 00:29:04,649
This results in an emergent
force called buoyancy.
505
00:29:06,417 --> 00:29:08,966
Buoyancy is not a true force.
506
00:29:08,968 --> 00:29:13,081
It's created from the entropy
of air molecules.
507
00:29:13,083 --> 00:29:15,115
Erik thinks that gravity
508
00:29:15,117 --> 00:29:19,363
is also created from the entropy
of something else,
509
00:29:19,365 --> 00:29:21,363
perhaps from disorder
510
00:29:21,365 --> 00:29:24,647
in the very fabric
of space and time.
511
00:29:26,330 --> 00:29:30,312
Erik doesn't yet know
what it is created from,
512
00:29:30,314 --> 00:29:31,946
but he feels sure
513
00:29:31,948 --> 00:29:36,177
gravity cannot be a fundamental
force of the universe.
514
00:29:36,179 --> 00:29:40,876
From the fact that I can derive
gravity from changes in entropy,
515
00:29:40,878 --> 00:29:42,160
that basically means we have
to think about gravity
516
00:29:42,162 --> 00:29:43,410
in a different way.
517
00:29:43,412 --> 00:29:46,360
Instead of assuming it
as a fundamental force,
518
00:29:46,362 --> 00:29:50,542
we can now view it as something
that can be emergent.
519
00:29:54,576 --> 00:29:56,074
We might find out
the truth about gravity
520
00:29:56,076 --> 00:29:59,224
if we could feel it
more intensely.
521
00:29:59,226 --> 00:30:02,574
This is impossible on earth,
where gravity is weak.
522
00:30:02,576 --> 00:30:03,974
But there is a place
in the universe
523
00:30:03,975 --> 00:30:06,740
where gravity reigns supreme...
524
00:30:08,457 --> 00:30:10,640
inside a black hole.
525
00:30:10,642 --> 00:30:14,956
Here, it may completely
incinerate matter
526
00:30:14,958 --> 00:30:18,105
in a wall of gravitational fire.
527
00:30:24,052 --> 00:30:26,450
In unusual situations...
528
00:30:30,767 --> 00:30:31,832
You don't always get
529
00:30:31,834 --> 00:30:35,032
what you expect.
530
00:30:35,034 --> 00:30:36,631
But sometimes
531
00:30:36,633 --> 00:30:40,897
unusual situations lead
to new insights.
532
00:30:40,899 --> 00:30:43,447
To find
the truth about gravity,
533
00:30:43,449 --> 00:30:45,047
physicists are studying it
534
00:30:45,049 --> 00:30:47,397
in a place where
they expect it to...
535
00:30:50,647 --> 00:30:53,696
...Act very strangely.
536
00:30:58,212 --> 00:31:00,261
Physicist Sean Carroll
537
00:31:00,263 --> 00:31:02,695
has a lot on his mind.
538
00:31:02,697 --> 00:31:06,060
Gravity is the hardest problem
in physics,
539
00:31:06,062 --> 00:31:08,227
and he's tackling it head-on.
540
00:31:08,229 --> 00:31:10,925
The fact that gravity is hard
was a surprise to everybody.
541
00:31:10,927 --> 00:31:12,892
We're really gonna need
a breakthrough,
542
00:31:12,894 --> 00:31:16,126
a different way
of thinking about gravity.
543
00:31:16,128 --> 00:31:17,626
Physicists know
544
00:31:17,628 --> 00:31:21,492
where to look for new insights
about gravity...
545
00:31:21,494 --> 00:31:24,158
Inside a black hole.
546
00:31:25,092 --> 00:31:29,240
These cosmic monsters form
when stars collapse.
547
00:31:29,242 --> 00:31:31,506
The entire mass of the star
548
00:31:31,508 --> 00:31:34,006
is compressed
into a single point...
549
00:31:35,158 --> 00:31:38,789
...where gravity reaches
its theoretical maximum.
550
00:31:38,791 --> 00:31:43,955
Surrounding every black hole is
an invisible, intangible shell
551
00:31:43,957 --> 00:31:46,588
known as the event horizon,
552
00:31:46,590 --> 00:31:48,453
the point beyond
which not even light
553
00:31:48,455 --> 00:31:51,403
can escape
the black hole's gravity.
554
00:31:51,405 --> 00:31:54,086
No one knows
what actually exists
555
00:31:54,088 --> 00:31:56,586
on the other side
of this boundary.
556
00:31:56,588 --> 00:31:59,985
The gravitational field in that
region of space is so strong
557
00:31:59,987 --> 00:32:01,419
that it's a one-way ticket.
558
00:32:01,421 --> 00:32:03,402
You can go in, and you can
explore around inside,
559
00:32:03,404 --> 00:32:05,884
but you can never
come back out.
560
00:32:08,752 --> 00:32:10,517
Theoretical physicists like Sean
561
00:32:10,519 --> 00:32:14,283
turn to their imaginations
for answers.
562
00:32:14,285 --> 00:32:18,482
Suppose you're astronaut Alice,
a daring cosmic explorer
563
00:32:18,484 --> 00:32:22,049
willing to take the plunge
into a black hole.
564
00:32:22,051 --> 00:32:24,648
Our current best theory
of gravity says that
565
00:32:24,650 --> 00:32:28,981
you wouldn't even notice
there was an event horizon.
566
00:32:28,983 --> 00:32:31,314
There are certain
cherished principles
567
00:32:31,316 --> 00:32:32,914
that we like to hold on to.
568
00:32:32,916 --> 00:32:35,079
One of them is simply called
no drama.
569
00:32:35,081 --> 00:32:37,946
You could pass right
through the event horizon,
570
00:32:37,948 --> 00:32:39,813
and it wouldn't look
any different
571
00:32:39,815 --> 00:32:41,679
than any other place
in the universe.
572
00:32:41,681 --> 00:32:45,245
So there's no drama when
you're near the black hole.
573
00:32:45,247 --> 00:32:48,078
Physicists have long believed
574
00:32:48,080 --> 00:32:49,844
that when you cross
the event horizon,
575
00:32:49,846 --> 00:32:52,643
nothing dramatic happens
576
00:32:52,645 --> 00:32:55,411
until you're deep inside
the black hole,
577
00:32:55,413 --> 00:32:57,776
and the rising
gravitational intensity
578
00:32:57,778 --> 00:33:02,609
turns you into human spaghetti.
579
00:33:03,776 --> 00:33:05,842
But scientists are learning
580
00:33:05,844 --> 00:33:09,375
that this time-honored story
might not hold up.
581
00:33:10,909 --> 00:33:15,841
The laws of gravity may
break down at the event horizon.
582
00:33:15,843 --> 00:33:19,339
Inside, gravity could be
something entirely different
583
00:33:19,341 --> 00:33:22,306
or not exist at all.
584
00:33:22,308 --> 00:33:24,356
Physicists started to notice
contradictions
585
00:33:24,358 --> 00:33:28,221
after calculating how particles
in and around black holes
586
00:33:28,223 --> 00:33:33,820
connect to each other through
a process called entanglement.
587
00:33:35,505 --> 00:33:37,970
Entanglement says
I could have two electrons,
588
00:33:37,972 --> 00:33:40,504
and I don't know what either
one of them is doing,
589
00:33:40,506 --> 00:33:42,786
but if they're entangled
by measure one,
590
00:33:42,788 --> 00:33:44,836
and I see
it's spinning clockwise,
591
00:33:44,838 --> 00:33:48,036
then I know instantly the other
one is also spinning clockwise.
592
00:33:48,038 --> 00:33:50,968
Another cherished
principle of physics
593
00:33:50,970 --> 00:33:53,868
states that particles
are strictly monogamous.
594
00:33:53,870 --> 00:33:57,500
They can only entangle
with one partner at a time,
595
00:33:57,502 --> 00:33:58,834
no matter what.
596
00:33:58,836 --> 00:34:01,867
But our understanding
of the physics of black holes
597
00:34:01,869 --> 00:34:05,532
seemed to imply that particles
at the event horizon
598
00:34:05,534 --> 00:34:09,165
needed to have
more than one entangled partner.
599
00:34:09,167 --> 00:34:13,765
This was a scenario no physicist
was willing to entertain.
600
00:34:20,032 --> 00:34:21,247
So this is what we call
601
00:34:21,249 --> 00:34:23,629
the Almheiri-Marolf-
Polchinski-Sully paradox,
602
00:34:23,631 --> 00:34:25,430
after the four
Santa Barbara physicists
603
00:34:25,432 --> 00:34:28,246
who proposed it.
604
00:34:28,248 --> 00:34:30,129
The four physicists
605
00:34:30,131 --> 00:34:33,495
proposed a dramatic solution
to the paradox.
606
00:34:33,497 --> 00:34:36,261
It was time to let go
of the cherished principle
607
00:34:36,263 --> 00:34:38,277
of no drama
at the event horizon.
608
00:34:38,279 --> 00:34:43,159
In fact,
something very dramatic happens.
609
00:34:49,526 --> 00:34:51,559
If you went to a event horizon
of a black hole
610
00:34:51,561 --> 00:34:54,792
and visited there, you would be
incinerated by a wall of fire.
611
00:34:54,794 --> 00:34:57,940
Black holes may be surrounded
612
00:34:57,942 --> 00:35:00,790
by a wall of fire so powerful
613
00:35:00,792 --> 00:35:05,457
that it either incinerates
any particle going into it,
614
00:35:05,459 --> 00:35:10,323
or perhaps incinerates the very
fabric of space and time.
615
00:35:10,325 --> 00:35:11,738
If there's a firewall,
that means there's --
616
00:35:11,740 --> 00:35:13,922
somehow, there's a boundary.
There's an edge.
617
00:35:13,924 --> 00:35:17,388
And when you hit that region,
we're not sure what happens.
618
00:35:17,390 --> 00:35:18,971
It seems like maybe
what happens
619
00:35:18,973 --> 00:35:22,871
is that whatever is there
is not space and time anymore.
620
00:35:22,873 --> 00:35:24,420
It's still quantum mechanics,
621
00:35:24,422 --> 00:35:26,720
but it's not good old gravity
and spacetime
622
00:35:26,722 --> 00:35:28,453
as Einstein would have
understood it.
623
00:35:28,455 --> 00:35:31,536
Past the black hole firewall,
624
00:35:31,538 --> 00:35:34,969
gravity could take on
an entirely new form.
625
00:35:34,971 --> 00:35:38,568
If we could find out
exactly what that form is,
626
00:35:38,570 --> 00:35:40,951
we may learn
the true nature of gravity
627
00:35:40,953 --> 00:35:44,067
everywhere else in the cosmos.
628
00:35:45,670 --> 00:35:48,150
Seeing the event horizon
of a black hole
629
00:35:48,152 --> 00:35:51,033
was once thought
to be impossible.
630
00:35:51,035 --> 00:35:54,766
But this astronomer thinks
he has a shot at it.
631
00:35:56,150 --> 00:35:58,564
He's building
the largest telescope
632
00:35:58,566 --> 00:36:00,548
the world has ever seen.
633
00:36:03,525 --> 00:36:06,650
26,000 light-years away,
634
00:36:06,651 --> 00:36:08,861
there's a place
where we could learn
635
00:36:08,862 --> 00:36:10,593
the true nature of gravity.
636
00:36:11,400 --> 00:36:16,482
It's the supermassive black hole
at the center of our galaxy.
637
00:36:16,484 --> 00:36:18,914
Astronomers think
this hole in space
638
00:36:18,916 --> 00:36:22,431
is not much bigger than our sun.
639
00:36:22,433 --> 00:36:25,481
Seeing something that size
so far away
640
00:36:25,483 --> 00:36:30,096
would take a telescope
the size of our planet.
641
00:36:30,098 --> 00:36:33,596
So...Why not build one?
642
00:36:33,598 --> 00:36:37,995
Astronomer Shep Doeleman's
career was launched
643
00:36:37,997 --> 00:36:40,395
when he answered
the call to adventure
644
00:36:40,397 --> 00:36:42,494
and landed...
645
00:36:44,961 --> 00:36:46,327
here.
646
00:36:47,594 --> 00:36:49,193
What excited me about
647
00:36:49,195 --> 00:36:51,226
this particular brand
of radio astronomy
648
00:36:51,228 --> 00:36:53,026
was that you got
to travel the world,
649
00:36:53,028 --> 00:36:54,592
and I said,
"well, that's for me.
650
00:36:54,594 --> 00:36:56,958
I definitely want to go out
into the field and do that."
651
00:36:56,960 --> 00:36:58,158
And then when I got here,
652
00:36:58,160 --> 00:36:59,858
they said "well, largely,
that work's been done."
653
00:36:59,860 --> 00:37:03,491
Shep does most of
his work trapped in his office,
654
00:37:03,493 --> 00:37:05,990
where he often escapes
by daydreaming...
655
00:37:05,992 --> 00:37:11,322
About being the first astronomer
to observe a black hole.
656
00:37:14,008 --> 00:37:16,423
It's one of the hardest problems
in his field,
657
00:37:16,425 --> 00:37:18,788
because astronomers
can only observe objects
658
00:37:18,790 --> 00:37:21,488
that radiate light.
659
00:37:21,490 --> 00:37:23,637
When you ask yourself what
a black hole looks like,
660
00:37:23,639 --> 00:37:26,171
you -- you really have to
begin with,
661
00:37:26,173 --> 00:37:28,054
why do we see black holes
at all?
662
00:37:28,056 --> 00:37:31,853
By definition,
they should be invisible.
663
00:37:31,855 --> 00:37:37,136
When light enters
a black hole, it's gone forever.
664
00:37:37,138 --> 00:37:41,252
But not all of the light around
a black hole gets sucked in.
665
00:37:41,254 --> 00:37:43,785
Some of it bends
around the event horizon,
666
00:37:43,787 --> 00:37:47,418
creating a shadow image
of the black hole.
667
00:37:47,420 --> 00:37:50,550
That image could reveal
how gravity behaves
668
00:37:50,552 --> 00:37:53,316
at the event horizon.
669
00:37:53,318 --> 00:37:56,150
But by the time
the light reaches us,
670
00:37:56,152 --> 00:37:59,848
the signal is so diluted
that shep would need a telescope
671
00:37:59,850 --> 00:38:03,099
thousands of miles across
to pick it up.
672
00:38:04,215 --> 00:38:07,981
So...He set out to build one.
673
00:38:11,848 --> 00:38:15,513
Shep is traveling to exotic
locations around the world,
674
00:38:15,515 --> 00:38:20,412
coordinating a massive
international collaboration.
675
00:38:20,414 --> 00:38:22,296
In the spring of 2015,
676
00:38:22,297 --> 00:38:25,979
nearly all of the world's
high-precision telescopes
677
00:38:25,981 --> 00:38:28,844
will point towards the center
of our galaxy.
678
00:38:28,846 --> 00:38:33,011
So at the center of our galaxy
is an extraordinary object.
679
00:38:33,013 --> 00:38:35,710
It's a supermassive black hole.
680
00:38:35,712 --> 00:38:37,576
And because it is so massive,
681
00:38:37,578 --> 00:38:41,109
and because it's relatively
close to us, we have a shot,
682
00:38:41,111 --> 00:38:43,108
we have a chance
to resolve it.
683
00:38:45,043 --> 00:38:46,841
To resolve
an image of this black hole,
684
00:38:46,843 --> 00:38:49,675
Shep's team devised
a method that turns
685
00:38:49,677 --> 00:38:52,341
a collection of
individual telescopes
686
00:38:52,343 --> 00:38:56,839
into one virtual telescope
the size of our planet.
687
00:38:59,740 --> 00:39:02,223
Well, right now I'm
in the center of the earth,
688
00:39:02,225 --> 00:39:04,005
represented by this ball field.
689
00:39:04,007 --> 00:39:06,972
And we're gonna see water
flying out of a nozzle,
690
00:39:06,974 --> 00:39:08,222
and you can think of that
as light
691
00:39:08,224 --> 00:39:11,355
coming from a cosmic object,
say a black hole.
692
00:39:11,357 --> 00:39:13,537
And a single telescope
can only capture
693
00:39:13,539 --> 00:39:14,937
a small amount of that data.
694
00:39:14,939 --> 00:39:18,837
We're gonna put telescopes
around the entire ball field,
695
00:39:18,839 --> 00:39:21,670
and they're gonna capture all
the water flow and sample,
696
00:39:21,672 --> 00:39:24,069
very comprehensively,
all the data
697
00:39:24,071 --> 00:39:27,001
that we need to make an image
of the object.
698
00:39:33,137 --> 00:39:36,800
When matter falls
into a supermassive black hole,
699
00:39:36,802 --> 00:39:40,667
it spews radiation
out into space.
700
00:39:44,334 --> 00:39:46,133
Shep is trying to reconstruct
701
00:39:46,135 --> 00:39:48,866
the shape of the light
as it leaves its source.
702
00:39:48,868 --> 00:39:51,965
It's just like water
leaving a nozzle.
703
00:39:51,967 --> 00:39:56,098
The further it travels,
the more the spray spreads out.
704
00:39:56,100 --> 00:39:59,196
But if enough collectors
are spread out
705
00:39:59,198 --> 00:40:01,330
over a wide enough area,
706
00:40:01,332 --> 00:40:03,163
the amount caught in each one
707
00:40:03,165 --> 00:40:05,562
would allow you to reconstruct
the shape of the nozzle.
708
00:40:11,696 --> 00:40:15,128
The nozzle of the hose is
spraying information out.
709
00:40:15,130 --> 00:40:16,395
With a single telescope,
710
00:40:16,397 --> 00:40:19,227
or a single cup,
you can only record
711
00:40:19,229 --> 00:40:20,943
or capture part
of the information
712
00:40:20,945 --> 00:40:22,394
coming from the nozzle.
713
00:40:22,396 --> 00:40:25,793
But with many cups spread out
all over the field,
714
00:40:25,795 --> 00:40:27,759
you sample
the full information field
715
00:40:27,761 --> 00:40:29,309
from the object
you're looking at,
716
00:40:29,311 --> 00:40:30,825
in this case, the nozzle.
717
00:40:30,827 --> 00:40:32,492
And you can recreate
and understand
718
00:40:32,494 --> 00:40:34,175
what was happening
when the water left
719
00:40:34,177 --> 00:40:36,391
that very small volume.
720
00:40:36,393 --> 00:40:39,774
Shep's planet-sized
virtual telescope
721
00:40:39,776 --> 00:40:41,873
should have enough resolution
to determine
722
00:40:41,875 --> 00:40:46,623
the gravitational physics
at the edge of a black hole.
723
00:40:46,625 --> 00:40:49,522
Gravity is a theory.
724
00:40:49,524 --> 00:40:52,288
It works very well
on the earth,
725
00:40:52,290 --> 00:40:54,639
but we haven't put it
to ultimate tests.
726
00:40:54,641 --> 00:40:57,821
We haven't put it to the test
where gravity is dominant,
727
00:40:57,823 --> 00:40:59,388
at the edge of a black hole.
728
00:40:59,390 --> 00:41:00,655
So this is one place
729
00:41:00,657 --> 00:41:03,154
where gravity could
conceivably break down.
730
00:41:03,156 --> 00:41:05,819
And it's very important
to test these theories,
731
00:41:05,821 --> 00:41:07,537
because it's the only way
we understand
732
00:41:07,539 --> 00:41:09,153
the nature of reality,
733
00:41:09,155 --> 00:41:12,568
really, the only way we
understand the fundamental basis
734
00:41:12,570 --> 00:41:15,069
of what we believe
about the universe.
735
00:41:19,235 --> 00:41:22,651
Gravity feels real.
736
00:41:22,653 --> 00:41:26,616
It holds all of us to this
little rock we call home.
737
00:41:26,618 --> 00:41:31,149
But gravity may not be
what it seems.
738
00:41:31,151 --> 00:41:33,199
If gravity is an illusion,
739
00:41:33,201 --> 00:41:36,198
then it's time to call
into question
740
00:41:36,200 --> 00:41:40,532
everything we think we know
about the cosmos.
741
00:41:40,534 --> 00:41:45,314
Only when we let go
of what we feel to be correct
742
00:41:45,316 --> 00:41:48,397
can we taste the real truth.
743
00:41:48,597 --> 00:41:49,597
== sync, corrected by elderman ==
@elder_man
59046
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.