Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:00,101 --> 00:00:01,962
NARRATOR: In the criminal
justice system,
2
00:00:02,031 --> 00:00:05,653
sexually based offenses
are considered especially heinous,
3
00:00:05,761 --> 00:00:06,918
In New York City,
4
00:00:06,992 --> 00:00:09,887
the dedicated detectives
who investigate these vicious felonies
5
00:00:09,956 --> 00:00:13,475
are members
of an elite squad known as the Special Victims Unit,
6
00:00:13,552 --> 00:00:15,517
These are their stories,
7
00:00:18,047 --> 00:00:19,875
DOCTOR: Mandibular
and orbital fractures.
8
00:00:19,946 --> 00:00:23,102
BIunt-force trauma
to the back of the head and Ioss of consciousness.
9
00:00:23,176 --> 00:00:25,968
Five-centimeter
knife Iaceration below the right clavicle.
10
00:00:26,038 --> 00:00:28,002
He wanted to disfigure her.
And kill her.
11
00:00:28,070 --> 00:00:30,556
DOCTOR: Nearly succeeded, too.
I'm surprised she survived.
12
00:00:30,634 --> 00:00:33,256
Radio car found her outside
a warehouse in Chinatown.
13
00:00:33,330 --> 00:00:34,692
Responding to a burglar alarm.
14
00:00:34,761 --> 00:00:35,885
DOCTOR: Lucky for her.
15
00:00:35,960 --> 00:00:37,118
Yeah, Iucky.
16
00:00:37,193 --> 00:00:38,418
What else?
17
00:00:38,491 --> 00:00:41,283
Distinct fingerprint bruising
above her knees, and these.
18
00:00:41,355 --> 00:00:43,511
Burns,
Iikely from a cigarette.
19
00:00:43,585 --> 00:00:46,514
Maybe abuse,
but it's a strange pattern.
20
00:00:46,582 --> 00:00:47,740
This might interest you.
21
00:00:50,211 --> 00:00:51,540
Maybe a gang member.
22
00:00:51,610 --> 00:00:52,633
BENSON: Rape kit?
23
00:00:52,709 --> 00:00:56,534
PIenty of fluids, all tainted.
Used some kind of cleaning solution.
24
00:00:56,604 --> 00:00:59,727
Smelled Iike bleach.
She'II be out of it for a while.
25
00:00:59,801 --> 00:01:01,060
You won't get anything
tonight.
26
00:01:01,133 --> 00:01:02,688
Okay. Thanks.
27
00:01:02,765 --> 00:01:05,852
She's gonna
have plates in her face for the rest of her Iife.
28
00:01:05,927 --> 00:01:07,447
A Iot of rage.
29
00:01:07,625 --> 00:01:10,350
BIeach. Guy's meticulous.
30
00:01:10,423 --> 00:01:11,717
And confident.
31
00:01:11,854 --> 00:01:13,716
Squad guys took these.
32
00:01:13,886 --> 00:01:17,211
AIIey where they found her,
full view of the street.
33
00:01:17,615 --> 00:01:20,907
So we got a burglary
and a rape in close proximity.
34
00:01:21,378 --> 00:01:22,603
Maybe a dump job.
35
00:01:22,675 --> 00:01:24,469
You believe in coincidences?
36
00:02:13,286 --> 00:02:15,841
According to Robbery,
the perps broke into the warehouse
37
00:02:15,917 --> 00:02:19,277
and made out with 50 grand
in these, high-speed computer processors.
38
00:02:19,346 --> 00:02:22,672
Five masked men, they jumped
the janitor and Iocked him in the utility closet.
39
00:02:22,742 --> 00:02:23,933
This is the only exit.
40
00:02:24,007 --> 00:02:26,233
Leading to our second
crime scene.
41
00:02:26,306 --> 00:02:30,256
STABLER: Victim is Helen Chen,
19. She Iives a few blocks down on Hester.
42
00:02:30,866 --> 00:02:32,763
This is where the uniform
found her.
43
00:02:32,831 --> 00:02:35,589
Among a whole bunch of
computer parts, probably dropped on the way out.
44
00:02:35,661 --> 00:02:36,990
Burglary alarm was silent.
45
00:02:37,060 --> 00:02:39,784
By the time the patrol car
got here, she was the only one here.
46
00:02:39,857 --> 00:02:42,785
You got five guys in
the warehouse. Maybe a sixth out here to commit the rape.
47
00:02:42,853 --> 00:02:44,216
Or we're talking two crimes.
48
00:02:44,286 --> 00:02:46,908
Either way, robbery perps
had to see her on the way out.
49
00:02:46,982 --> 00:02:50,069
Our best Iead is a possible
gang tattoo on her shoulder.
50
00:02:51,177 --> 00:02:52,936
Women aren't members
of Asian gangs.
51
00:02:53,009 --> 00:02:55,269
They're associates
through a brother or boyfriend.
52
00:02:55,339 --> 00:02:57,030
They use them
to carry drugs and guns.
53
00:02:57,104 --> 00:02:58,568
Women are Iess Iikely
to get hassled by cops.
54
00:02:58,636 --> 00:03:00,429
Well, so far our only witness
is the victim.
55
00:03:00,500 --> 00:03:02,623
We'II hit the hospital,
see what she has to say.
56
00:03:02,698 --> 00:03:04,423
The body art suggests
she associates
57
00:03:04,496 --> 00:03:06,959
with some of the more unsavory
elements in society.
58
00:03:07,027 --> 00:03:10,886
I got a guy down in
Gang Intel. He's probably seen every tat in town.
59
00:03:15,317 --> 00:03:19,245
Tattoos, cigarette burns,
all could indicate Chinese gang activity,
60
00:03:19,312 --> 00:03:21,674
but they signify
different things.
61
00:03:21,743 --> 00:03:26,568
The burns could mean
initiation, number of kills, punishment.
62
00:03:26,904 --> 00:03:28,528
What's this mean?
63
00:03:30,267 --> 00:03:31,732
Could be Chinese gang.
64
00:03:31,799 --> 00:03:33,093
Define "could be."
65
00:03:33,164 --> 00:03:36,285
Well, a Iot of Chinese gang
tattoos use versions of snakes or dragons,
66
00:03:36,360 --> 00:03:37,949
but I haven't seen
this one before.
67
00:03:38,025 --> 00:03:40,544
For gang intelligence,
you don't have many answers.
68
00:03:40,622 --> 00:03:43,642
Look, I worked two years
in Chinatown undercover.
69
00:03:43,719 --> 00:03:45,649
I barely scratched
the surface.
70
00:03:45,717 --> 00:03:48,407
You think you'II get somewhere
with a rape investigation?
71
00:03:48,480 --> 00:03:50,341
Chinatown's got no Iove
for cops.
72
00:03:50,412 --> 00:03:52,171
Well, they're just gonna
have to get over that.
73
00:03:52,243 --> 00:03:54,705
What's your take
on the warehouse robbery?
74
00:03:54,773 --> 00:03:57,566
Computer parts heist
does sound Iike Asian gang activity.
75
00:03:57,637 --> 00:04:00,464
We've been building cases
against several gangs of high-tech crime.
76
00:04:00,534 --> 00:04:03,587
Same profit margin
as drug trafficking, nowhere near the jail time.
77
00:04:03,664 --> 00:04:06,059
Only question is,
where does this rape fit in?
78
00:04:06,127 --> 00:04:08,988
A Iot of Asian gangs use rape
as a form of punishment.
79
00:04:09,057 --> 00:04:11,487
Maybe your victim
broke the rules.
80
00:04:12,121 --> 00:04:14,641
Helen, we're trying to
find out who did this to you.
81
00:04:14,718 --> 00:04:17,203
So, when you're able,
we'd Iike to talk to you about it.
82
00:04:17,282 --> 00:04:18,372
Don't make her cry.
83
00:04:18,447 --> 00:04:20,875
She starts to choke
and they have to snap her jaw open again.
84
00:04:20,944 --> 00:04:22,966
I told you, she can't talk.
85
00:04:23,042 --> 00:04:26,130
Yeah, but you can, Johnny.
Come here. Come here.
86
00:04:29,735 --> 00:04:32,630
Okay. What was your sister
doing in that alley?
87
00:04:32,698 --> 00:04:33,685
(GRUNTING)
88
00:04:33,764 --> 00:04:35,852
I don't know. Walking home.
89
00:04:37,027 --> 00:04:39,421
What happened to your arm?
I burned it.
90
00:04:39,490 --> 00:04:42,453
Yeah, with a Iaser
to remove a gang tattoo.
91
00:04:42,521 --> 00:04:43,508
I'm not in a group.
92
00:04:43,586 --> 00:04:46,174
So it's just Helen?
She rob the warehouse?
93
00:04:47,715 --> 00:04:52,040
I used to be with a group.
Ghost Shadows. But I got out a Iong time ago.
94
00:04:52,110 --> 00:04:53,335
What about your sister?
95
00:04:53,408 --> 00:04:56,268
She's still in,
with her yue nan boyfriend.
96
00:04:56,338 --> 00:04:58,269
And what's that?
What's yue nan?
97
00:04:58,337 --> 00:05:02,287
Vietnamese. Dao Tran.
He's the one banging.
98
00:05:02,532 --> 00:05:04,791
Last week, I told him
to stay away from Helen.
99
00:05:04,863 --> 00:05:07,916
Punk said he'd kill me
if I got in between them.
100
00:05:07,992 --> 00:05:10,887
She thinks she can
protect him. Not anymore.
101
00:05:11,554 --> 00:05:14,018
I should've made sure
he stayed away from her permanently.
102
00:05:14,086 --> 00:05:15,709
Dao Tran's boys
hit that warehouse.
103
00:05:15,784 --> 00:05:18,610
Well, how do you know
if you're out? Maybe it was one of your old friends.
104
00:05:18,680 --> 00:05:21,439
Try this on. It was your boys
who robbed the warehouse,
105
00:05:21,511 --> 00:05:24,303
and then they rape the sister
of the guy who turns his back on them.
106
00:05:24,374 --> 00:05:26,599
Ghost Shadows didn't do this.
107
00:05:26,771 --> 00:05:29,928
They know I'd kill anybody
who tried to hurt her.
108
00:05:30,001 --> 00:05:31,862
(HELEN GRUNTING)
109
00:05:31,966 --> 00:05:34,793
So where can we find
this Dao Tran?
110
00:05:35,962 --> 00:05:40,082
Pho Hoa Restaurant on Canal.
AII the Born to Kill boys hang there.
111
00:05:41,022 --> 00:05:42,351
Born to Kill?
112
00:05:42,421 --> 00:05:44,009
Yeah. From Vietnam War.
113
00:05:44,719 --> 00:05:48,169
It's what the American
soldiers used to write on their helmets.
114
00:05:49,946 --> 00:05:51,103
(SPEAKING FOREIGN LANGUAGE)
115
00:05:51,178 --> 00:05:52,836
HOSTESS: We closed now.
Come back Iater.
116
00:05:52,909 --> 00:05:55,032
BENSON: Where's Dao Tran?
Not here.
117
00:05:55,239 --> 00:05:56,828
Good afternoon, boys.
118
00:05:56,905 --> 00:05:59,198
Kind of early to be out
of school. What, you all sick?
119
00:05:59,269 --> 00:06:01,096
(SPEAKING FOREIGN LANGUAGE)
120
00:06:01,500 --> 00:06:02,758
Let's take their temperature.
121
00:06:02,831 --> 00:06:03,818
No trouble now.
122
00:06:03,897 --> 00:06:05,622
You're closed, we heard.
123
00:06:07,326 --> 00:06:08,518
Hey, wait.
124
00:06:08,592 --> 00:06:09,816
Hey!
125
00:06:15,984 --> 00:06:19,707
See how messy things can get
when you don't cooperate, Dao?
126
00:06:24,007 --> 00:06:26,029
How's your Iove Iife, Dao?
127
00:06:27,038 --> 00:06:28,968
I hear you and Helen Chen
have been dating.
128
00:06:29,036 --> 00:06:30,331
We broke up.
129
00:06:30,402 --> 00:06:33,660
Why? She doesn't Iike
being burned with cigarettes?
130
00:06:34,663 --> 00:06:35,923
I don't know
what you're talking about.
131
00:06:35,994 --> 00:06:38,457
Kind of Iike you don't know
Helen's in the hospital?
132
00:06:38,525 --> 00:06:39,717
What happened?
133
00:06:39,790 --> 00:06:43,310
STABLER:
She was raped and beaten and Ieft in an alley for dead.
134
00:06:43,387 --> 00:06:44,647
God, no.
135
00:06:44,718 --> 00:06:46,511
Why don't we stop
with the performance, Dao?
136
00:06:46,583 --> 00:06:48,842
I swear. We haven't
seen each other for a week.
137
00:06:49,213 --> 00:06:51,178
We wanted people to think
we weren't together anymore.
138
00:06:51,244 --> 00:06:53,400
People? Like your boys
in Born to Kill?
139
00:06:53,475 --> 00:06:54,997
Now we know
her brother's in a gang.
140
00:06:55,073 --> 00:06:58,502
Maybe your boys didn't Iike
you dating a Chinese girl.
141
00:07:00,234 --> 00:07:02,357
They jumped her
to teach you a Iesson? No.
142
00:07:02,432 --> 00:07:04,554
Or maybe it had nothing
to do with them.
143
00:07:04,630 --> 00:07:06,753
Johnny Chen said that you're
not good enough for Helen.
144
00:07:06,828 --> 00:07:08,451
He embarrassed you,
made you feel stupid.
145
00:07:08,525 --> 00:07:11,510
But you're not stupid.
You're a smart guy, right?
146
00:07:11,588 --> 00:07:13,814
You raped her
while your friends robbed the warehouse.
147
00:07:13,886 --> 00:07:17,507
I didn't rape Helen.
I Iove her.
148
00:07:22,875 --> 00:07:24,533
Ghost Shadows
did the warehouse.
149
00:07:24,608 --> 00:07:26,128
BENSON: How do you know?
150
00:07:26,339 --> 00:07:27,826
Helen told me.
151
00:07:28,670 --> 00:07:30,530
She was their Iookout.
152
00:07:31,200 --> 00:07:32,993
I tried to stop her.
153
00:07:35,696 --> 00:07:37,284
Johnny did this.
154
00:07:38,426 --> 00:07:41,718
So you want us to believe
that her own brother raped her.
155
00:07:41,789 --> 00:07:43,547
He ordered it.
Prove it.
156
00:07:43,619 --> 00:07:48,206
Look, Helen didn't want to
bang with him, but he's got this control over her.
157
00:07:48,281 --> 00:07:50,245
I mean, you know those
burn marks on her arm?
158
00:07:50,313 --> 00:07:53,434
Well, Johnny made her
do that to herself, because of me.
159
00:07:55,240 --> 00:07:56,466
Johnny did this.
160
00:07:56,539 --> 00:07:57,595
Okay.
161
00:07:57,672 --> 00:08:02,723
Well, it's still
your word against his.
162
00:08:05,395 --> 00:08:07,916
Ask Helen.
She knows what he can do.
163
00:08:09,558 --> 00:08:12,385
STABLER: Helen,
we can't help you if you're protecting your brother.
164
00:08:12,453 --> 00:08:14,509
Now, we know he's involved
in your attack.
165
00:08:14,585 --> 00:08:15,811
That's not true.
166
00:08:15,884 --> 00:08:17,541
BENSON: Well,
then tell us what is.
167
00:08:17,615 --> 00:08:20,510
'Cause right now
our best suspect is Dao Tran.
168
00:08:20,578 --> 00:08:22,566
No, it's not Dao. He Ioves me.
169
00:08:22,644 --> 00:08:24,573
STABLER: Well, your brother
made you burn your arm.
170
00:08:24,641 --> 00:08:26,764
You think he cares
what happens to you?
171
00:08:29,136 --> 00:08:30,724
Did you see him?
172
00:08:33,964 --> 00:08:35,587
I don't remember.
173
00:08:37,060 --> 00:08:39,955
I got hit. Passed out.
174
00:08:41,190 --> 00:08:44,277
Johnny must have seen you
when he robbed that warehouse.
175
00:08:44,353 --> 00:08:47,180
He was going to Iet you die
in that alley.
176
00:08:47,749 --> 00:08:49,235
It wasn't him.
177
00:08:49,813 --> 00:08:52,503
STABLER: Well, it may
have been one of his crew.
178
00:08:52,876 --> 00:08:56,498
Helen, tell us where he is.
Come on.
179
00:09:02,899 --> 00:09:07,621
They have a house,
where they keep scores.
180
00:09:15,784 --> 00:09:18,940
Get off me, man. Get off me.
181
00:09:20,779 --> 00:09:22,333
That's our grieving brother
right there.
182
00:09:22,410 --> 00:09:24,873
Look who it is,
Mister Intelligence. Our friend from Gang Intel.
183
00:09:24,941 --> 00:09:27,302
It's not what it Iooks Iike.
BENSON: Looks Iike a bust to me.
184
00:09:27,371 --> 00:09:28,597
Thanks to our rape victim.
185
00:09:28,669 --> 00:09:30,997
You knew her tattoo
meant Ghost Shadows and you Iied about it.
186
00:09:31,067 --> 00:09:32,191
Look, I couldn't tell you.
187
00:09:32,265 --> 00:09:34,286
We had a 15-month
investigation riding on this.
188
00:09:34,363 --> 00:09:35,589
You're talking about
stolen property,
189
00:09:35,663 --> 00:09:37,183
we're talking about a girl
that was brutalized.
190
00:09:37,260 --> 00:09:39,519
Are we going to debate now
about whose job is more important?
191
00:09:39,590 --> 00:09:42,577
No, we're gonna debate
about you helping our guy get away with rape.
192
00:09:42,655 --> 00:09:44,084
You're Iooking at Johnny Chen
for this, right?
193
00:09:44,152 --> 00:09:45,481
He knows who raped her.
194
00:09:45,552 --> 00:09:46,981
He's yours. Hey.
195
00:09:47,348 --> 00:09:48,335
With our gratitude.
196
00:09:48,414 --> 00:09:49,572
Thanks.
197
00:09:53,276 --> 00:09:56,239
I didn't do nothing.
I provide for Helen. I take care of her.
198
00:09:56,306 --> 00:09:57,894
Did you provide for her
to get raped?
199
00:09:57,970 --> 00:09:59,525
No. Never.
200
00:09:59,636 --> 00:10:02,564
Well, robbery places you
at the scene of her attack there, Johnny.
201
00:10:02,632 --> 00:10:03,756
Do you want to go down
for this?
202
00:10:03,831 --> 00:10:06,226
You want to go down for raping
and beating your own sister?
203
00:10:08,126 --> 00:10:10,351
When we went in, she was okay.
204
00:10:16,816 --> 00:10:17,906
Okay.
205
00:10:19,181 --> 00:10:20,474
And when you came out?
206
00:10:22,277 --> 00:10:25,637
I didn't see her. Thought
she got scared and ran off.
207
00:10:25,973 --> 00:10:27,232
But then...
208
00:10:27,304 --> 00:10:28,734
STABLER: But then what?
209
00:10:29,603 --> 00:10:30,861
I found her.
210
00:10:31,800 --> 00:10:32,924
I thought you said
you didn't see her.
211
00:10:32,998 --> 00:10:37,789
I found her and then she was
so beat up. Nobody was around.
212
00:10:37,860 --> 00:10:42,912
We heard sirens.
Then it got so crazy, and she Iooked dead.
213
00:10:43,387 --> 00:10:44,975
So you saved your own ass.
214
00:10:48,913 --> 00:10:50,571
(KNOCKING ON DOOR)
215
00:10:51,312 --> 00:10:52,673
CRAGEN: Detectives?
216
00:10:58,737 --> 00:11:00,462
BIeach man is back.
217
00:11:02,399 --> 00:11:04,363
When?
Half an hour ago in Chinatown.
218
00:11:04,430 --> 00:11:05,452
The victim get a good Iook?
219
00:11:05,529 --> 00:11:07,015
She's dead.
220
00:11:11,822 --> 00:11:13,480
Victim's Asian?
221
00:11:13,554 --> 00:11:15,177
From what I can tell,
it's your guy.
222
00:11:15,584 --> 00:11:18,376
BIeach to clean up, beat her
around the face and head.
223
00:11:18,448 --> 00:11:20,310
He's getting a Iot more
enthusiastic.
224
00:11:20,379 --> 00:11:23,739
But still had the presence
of mind to get rid of his DNA.
225
00:11:23,809 --> 00:11:25,397
Not necessarily.
226
00:11:27,105 --> 00:11:29,693
BENSON: BIood under
the fingernails. She fought back.
227
00:11:29,768 --> 00:11:32,163
OFFICER: Must've made him
pretty angry.
228
00:11:32,931 --> 00:11:34,623
Imagine carving
someone's body.
229
00:11:37,694 --> 00:11:40,486
I'm gonna guess this slur
points to motive.
230
00:11:40,823 --> 00:11:42,049
He's a racist.
231
00:11:44,086 --> 00:11:46,981
Her name was Lucy Zhang.
She was visiting her mother in Chinatown.
232
00:11:47,050 --> 00:11:50,534
She cut across the park
to catch the six train to the Upper East Side.
233
00:11:50,612 --> 00:11:51,668
CRAGEN: Gang connections?
234
00:11:51,744 --> 00:11:54,037
Nothing.
She was a CPA, no record.
235
00:11:54,408 --> 00:11:57,372
The ME thinks that the racial
epithet was cut postmortem
236
00:11:57,438 --> 00:11:59,493
with a straight blade
from a utility knife.
237
00:11:59,569 --> 00:12:02,997
Nothing Iike this M.O.
in our 61s. We're back where we started.
238
00:12:03,232 --> 00:12:05,320
Then we need a new profile.
239
00:12:06,395 --> 00:12:09,846
The brutality indicates
a tremendous amount of anger towards Asian women.
240
00:12:09,924 --> 00:12:12,352
Probably was victimized
by Asians at some point.
241
00:12:12,421 --> 00:12:14,510
It took time and effort
to cut up the victim Iike that.
242
00:12:14,586 --> 00:12:16,879
He's confident enough
to believe he's not gonna get caught.
243
00:12:16,950 --> 00:12:18,437
Yeah, but he wasn't always.
244
00:12:18,515 --> 00:12:21,671
A search through the past
few years should reveal smaller acts of aggression.
245
00:12:21,745 --> 00:12:24,299
Peeping, exposure, violence
with consensual partners,
246
00:12:24,375 --> 00:12:25,499
up to outright assaults.
247
00:12:25,574 --> 00:12:26,663
An awful Iot of ground
to cover.
248
00:12:26,739 --> 00:12:27,964
CRAGEN: Maybe not.
249
00:12:28,037 --> 00:12:29,626
I'II call the bias task force.
250
00:12:29,702 --> 00:12:33,187
Have them send over files
on hate crimes against Asian women.
251
00:12:33,531 --> 00:12:34,552
CRAGEN: Anything?
252
00:12:34,630 --> 00:12:38,184
Just reams of complaints
about racist scum. Haven't ruled out anybody so far.
253
00:12:38,260 --> 00:12:40,883
Year ago, a peeping Tom
was hitting Chinatown.
254
00:12:40,957 --> 00:12:44,680
Could be our guy, but he was
good at it, ran away before anybody could see him.
255
00:12:44,753 --> 00:12:47,181
Girl got shoved
on East Broadway five months ago,
256
00:12:47,250 --> 00:12:48,475
perp threw out a racial slur.
257
00:12:48,548 --> 00:12:50,841
No description,
then he disappeared into the crowd.
258
00:12:50,912 --> 00:12:52,036
What is this guy, invisible?
259
00:12:52,110 --> 00:12:54,267
Nothing on the blood
from under the victim's nails?
260
00:12:54,342 --> 00:12:55,771
STABLER:
Still waiting on serology.
261
00:12:55,839 --> 00:12:58,496
For someone careful enough
to clean up his evidence with bleach,
262
00:12:58,570 --> 00:13:02,259
he's careless to Ieave behind
his own blood. His rage may be escalating.
263
00:13:02,333 --> 00:13:04,058
Still doesn't help us
if he's not in the database.
264
00:13:04,130 --> 00:13:05,493
BENSON:
AII right, Iisten to this.
265
00:13:05,562 --> 00:13:09,513
A woman answered a personal ad
in a Chinese-Ianguage newspaper.
266
00:13:09,758 --> 00:13:13,550
Guy pulled a utility knife
on the first date. She dropped the complaint the next day.
267
00:13:13,621 --> 00:13:14,982
Got scared.
268
00:13:15,451 --> 00:13:16,507
Let's go.
269
00:13:16,584 --> 00:13:19,479
Could take hours
to track down a translator.
270
00:13:19,547 --> 00:13:21,102
Doc, can you translate?
271
00:13:21,178 --> 00:13:23,472
What, you just assume
I speak Chinese?
272
00:13:23,542 --> 00:13:26,062
No. I heard you order
take-out once.
273
00:13:31,568 --> 00:13:34,258
Sonja came from China Iast
summer to Iive with her aunt.
274
00:13:34,331 --> 00:13:35,658
She didn't know anyone.
275
00:13:35,728 --> 00:13:38,715
She decided to meet people
through personals in the China Sun,
276
00:13:38,892 --> 00:13:40,651
(SPEAKING FOREIGN LANGUAGE)
277
00:13:47,649 --> 00:13:50,011
I wrote him a Ietter.
He wrote back right away.
278
00:13:50,080 --> 00:13:53,008
He said that he was a engineer
from Beijing.
279
00:13:54,009 --> 00:13:57,596
We wrote three or four times
a week. He sounded as Ionely as I was.
280
00:13:57,671 --> 00:13:59,692
How did they arrange to meet?
281
00:13:59,769 --> 00:14:01,357
(SPEAKING FOREIGN LANGUAGE)
282
00:14:04,863 --> 00:14:07,588
We were going to have dinner
at a restaurant close by.
283
00:14:07,660 --> 00:14:09,624
But when I arrived,
it was all Iies.
284
00:14:14,520 --> 00:14:16,415
What does that mean, all Iies?
285
00:14:16,650 --> 00:14:18,410
(SPEAKING FOREIGN LANGUAGE)
286
00:14:24,808 --> 00:14:26,930
She says he wasn't Chinese.
287
00:14:27,505 --> 00:14:28,992
He was black.
288
00:14:30,335 --> 00:14:33,457
How many African-American
males speak and write Chinese well enough
289
00:14:33,532 --> 00:14:35,257
to fool a native speaker?
290
00:14:35,529 --> 00:14:39,321
Well, he could be a student
or work at the World Bank or the UN or...
291
00:14:39,492 --> 00:14:41,115
Why Iie about being Chinese?
292
00:14:41,189 --> 00:14:43,709
Because he knows she'II never
go out with him if he's not,
293
00:14:43,787 --> 00:14:46,511
and then he expects
that once they've met, she'II be so taken with him
294
00:14:46,584 --> 00:14:51,341
that his ethnicity
won't matter. Her reaction to his race is what sets him off.
295
00:14:51,612 --> 00:14:55,165
The P.O. box he used
was a cash deal. Personal ad was done over the phone.
296
00:14:55,241 --> 00:14:57,295
He used a stolen credit card.
297
00:14:57,605 --> 00:14:59,092
Let's follow the money.
298
00:14:59,170 --> 00:15:01,292
Sorry, I have a 4:00
at a brokerage house.
299
00:15:01,367 --> 00:15:04,796
I can't believe they're not
online trading yet. I'm designing their website.
300
00:15:04,863 --> 00:15:06,690
Mr. Tang, how is it
a month went by
301
00:15:06,761 --> 00:15:08,658
before you realized
your credit card was stolen?
302
00:15:08,725 --> 00:15:09,781
Yeah, that sucked.
303
00:15:09,858 --> 00:15:11,685
Well, I was in Paris
and then Bern.
304
00:15:11,756 --> 00:15:13,878
They're dying for HTML
speakers out there,
305
00:15:13,953 --> 00:15:16,439
and I get back and there's
all these random charges.
306
00:15:16,517 --> 00:15:18,571
Do you have any idea
who might have stolen it?
307
00:15:18,648 --> 00:15:21,202
I wish. It was the week
I went out of town.
308
00:15:21,278 --> 00:15:23,572
I was just kind of crazy,
so I guess I just Ieft it somewhere.
309
00:15:23,643 --> 00:15:25,005
Not too worried about money,
I guess.
310
00:15:25,074 --> 00:15:28,163
Well, the credit card company
was cool. They didn't make me pay.
311
00:15:28,238 --> 00:15:29,462
Some weird charges, though.
312
00:15:29,536 --> 00:15:31,524
I mean, whoever took it
probably didn't want his wife to know.
313
00:15:31,600 --> 00:15:32,689
Why? What do you mean?
314
00:15:32,765 --> 00:15:35,388
Well, the guy was definitely
getting some action.
315
00:15:35,463 --> 00:15:39,584
I have the statement
right here. Look, China Girl, 200 bucks.
316
00:15:42,389 --> 00:15:43,613
Massage parlor in Chinatown.
317
00:15:43,686 --> 00:15:45,775
Where no one actually
gets a massage.
318
00:15:46,983 --> 00:15:48,175
Police.
319
00:15:49,114 --> 00:15:50,271
I'II need to see
a search warrant.
320
00:15:50,346 --> 00:15:52,401
Just calm down.
We're not Vice. We're not INS.
321
00:15:52,477 --> 00:15:54,338
We're Iooking for
one of your customers.
322
00:15:54,409 --> 00:15:57,700
I maintain the strictest
confidentiality policy with our clients.
323
00:15:57,771 --> 00:16:01,200
That's great.
Now, if you want a raid here, I can arrange that.
324
00:16:07,194 --> 00:16:09,589
We're Iooking for a man
that came in here about two weeks ago.
325
00:16:09,658 --> 00:16:13,642
African-American.
He used a credit card with the name Larry Tang.
326
00:16:15,784 --> 00:16:17,510
Come on, now.
Receipts. Give it up.
327
00:16:17,583 --> 00:16:21,477
No need. I remember this guy.
He tried to kill one of my girls.
328
00:16:27,971 --> 00:16:29,027
Hey.
STABLER: Sorry to interrupt.
329
00:16:29,104 --> 00:16:31,999
Jiang Li? We'd Iike to
have a word with you.
330
00:16:35,163 --> 00:16:38,523
Can you tell us about the man
who attacked you?
331
00:16:41,422 --> 00:16:44,409
Looked young, Iike 20s.
332
00:16:45,418 --> 00:16:47,507
Nothing special about him.
333
00:16:47,583 --> 00:16:50,636
Came in for a massage.
Didn't Iike it, I guess.
334
00:16:50,980 --> 00:16:53,306
We're not Iooking
to set you up.
335
00:16:53,643 --> 00:16:56,571
Just tell us the truth.
It stays right here.
336
00:16:57,205 --> 00:16:59,532
He said he wanted
a girlfriend.
337
00:17:00,968 --> 00:17:04,624
Don't understand why
the racist son of a bitch came to Chinatown.
338
00:17:04,698 --> 00:17:06,524
He paid you
to be his girlfriend?
339
00:17:07,927 --> 00:17:10,253
It was fine,
just regular stuff.
340
00:17:11,690 --> 00:17:13,744
Except he couldn't do it.
341
00:17:14,353 --> 00:17:16,647
I don't know,
I guess I Iaughed.
342
00:17:16,750 --> 00:17:19,542
I didn't mean anything.
He got mad.
343
00:17:22,145 --> 00:17:25,538
Tells me he want to tie me up.
Sometimes I do that.
344
00:17:26,739 --> 00:17:29,826
But this guy,
I had a bad feeling. So I said no.
345
00:17:29,902 --> 00:17:31,491
BENSON: Did he hurt you?
346
00:17:33,365 --> 00:17:35,386
Punched me a couple times.
347
00:17:36,561 --> 00:17:39,046
Pull out this
Iittle army knife.
348
00:17:41,124 --> 00:17:42,712
Call me names.
349
00:17:43,520 --> 00:17:45,643
What did he do with the knife?
350
00:17:55,707 --> 00:17:58,135
Do you think
you could describe him to a sketch artist?
351
00:18:01,234 --> 00:18:05,128
Faxed the sketch to area
schools with Chinese Ianguage programs. Zero.
352
00:18:05,197 --> 00:18:06,525
Nothing door-to-door, either.
353
00:18:06,595 --> 00:18:08,025
So what are we missing?
354
00:18:08,093 --> 00:18:11,148
I mean, here's a guy
who immerses himself into another culture.
355
00:18:11,223 --> 00:18:14,414
Masters the Ianguage,
Iies about his own ethnicity.
356
00:18:14,486 --> 00:18:17,744
Then destroys the very culture
that he's imitated. Why?
357
00:18:17,816 --> 00:18:20,371
He's chosen a culture
that's traditionally insular,
358
00:18:20,447 --> 00:18:22,932
particularly among
the older generation.
359
00:18:23,010 --> 00:18:27,699
I know that if my sister dated
a black man, my parents would've strongly objected.
360
00:18:28,571 --> 00:18:31,499
So this guy puts himself
in a position to get rejected,
361
00:18:31,567 --> 00:18:34,189
not only as a man,
but as a non-Asian.
362
00:18:34,364 --> 00:18:36,919
It's Iike he wants an excuse
to get mad.
363
00:18:36,995 --> 00:18:38,220
Very possibly.
364
00:18:38,293 --> 00:18:41,721
None of which helps
if we're working off a bad sketch.
365
00:18:42,422 --> 00:18:45,385
Got a hit on the DNA
from under the victim's nails. African-American.
366
00:18:45,452 --> 00:18:49,039
Sent up on multiple rape
and homicide. Just released from CIinton Iast year.
367
00:18:49,114 --> 00:18:50,874
So where is he now?
368
00:18:54,309 --> 00:18:55,966
STABLER:
Where can we find him?
369
00:18:56,040 --> 00:18:57,164
That's Starnes.
370
00:18:59,169 --> 00:19:00,226
BENSON: What's wrong with him?
371
00:19:00,302 --> 00:19:03,992
Progressive MS.
This is a halfway house for men with disabilities.
372
00:19:04,064 --> 00:19:06,052
He's been pretty bad off
for a few years now.
373
00:19:06,130 --> 00:19:07,616
Mistake at the Iab?
374
00:19:07,694 --> 00:19:08,784
Maybe.
375
00:19:10,224 --> 00:19:14,175
Mr. Starnes,
we're investigating a series of rapes in Chinatown.
376
00:19:14,486 --> 00:19:16,451
I ain't helping no cops.
377
00:19:16,552 --> 00:19:19,514
But your DNA was all over
one of the victims, and she's dead.
378
00:19:19,581 --> 00:19:21,477
So maybe you want to help
yourself.
379
00:19:21,545 --> 00:19:24,270
I can't even get out
of this chair, boy.
380
00:19:24,475 --> 00:19:28,062
And if I could, it wouldn't be
to get with no downtown bitch.
381
00:19:31,068 --> 00:19:33,690
You got any brothers,
cousins around?
382
00:19:33,999 --> 00:19:36,587
Someone who might
want to set you up?
383
00:19:40,525 --> 00:19:43,715
Mr. Starnes,
do you have any children?
384
00:19:45,286 --> 00:19:48,715
Never had the pleasure.
You offering?
385
00:19:49,548 --> 00:19:50,977
You've raped a Iot of women.
386
00:19:51,045 --> 00:19:52,976
So it's possible
that you have kids out there
387
00:19:53,044 --> 00:19:55,200
that you don't even
know about, right?
388
00:19:55,274 --> 00:19:57,000
I suppose so, Iady.
389
00:20:04,298 --> 00:20:06,783
PCR typing only Iooked
at 10 genetic markers.
390
00:20:06,862 --> 00:20:09,417
Sometimes a person can have
a close enough match
391
00:20:09,492 --> 00:20:11,457
to score a hit
within the database.
392
00:20:11,524 --> 00:20:12,885
Can you do another test?
393
00:20:12,955 --> 00:20:15,782
I ran a Y-chromosome
on Starnes and the perp.
394
00:20:15,852 --> 00:20:19,746
The Y-chromosome is passed
from father to son within a family Iine.
395
00:20:19,813 --> 00:20:25,105
Grandfathers, fathers,
brothers, sons, nephews will have virtually identical Ys.
396
00:20:25,907 --> 00:20:28,336
There's no doubt about it.
These guys are blood relatives.
397
00:20:28,405 --> 00:20:30,163
Well, Halfway House
and prison records
398
00:20:30,235 --> 00:20:32,631
says that Starnes has
no Iiving male relative.
399
00:20:32,700 --> 00:20:36,150
That we know of.
He's a rapist. Our perp could be this guy's son.
400
00:20:36,229 --> 00:20:38,658
Makes sense.
Their DNA is similar.
401
00:20:38,892 --> 00:20:42,218
Well, I guess
being a psychopath runs in the family.
402
00:20:42,556 --> 00:20:47,915
Vital statistics confirm
Starnes was not named on any birth certificate as a father.
403
00:20:47,982 --> 00:20:49,537
So we're Ieft with
his victims.
404
00:20:49,614 --> 00:20:51,272
Starnes got sent up
on four rapes.
405
00:20:51,346 --> 00:20:53,900
We ran the victims' names.
One came back. Martha Shelby.
406
00:20:53,976 --> 00:20:56,632
Had a child that fits
the timeframe, no father Iisted.
407
00:20:56,707 --> 00:20:58,399
AII right, Iet's find her.
408
00:20:58,471 --> 00:21:00,628
Now what about victims
they couldn't pin on him?
409
00:21:00,702 --> 00:21:02,961
He Iooked good for three
unsolved rapes in Harlem,
410
00:21:03,032 --> 00:21:05,394
but none of the victims
had a child within nine months.
411
00:21:05,464 --> 00:21:07,052
AII right, keep Iooking.
What else?
412
00:21:07,128 --> 00:21:10,318
Starnes had a Iive-in
girlfriend that alibied him on a couple of collars.
413
00:21:10,391 --> 00:21:12,684
Pamela Tatum. She had a baby
while they were Iiving together.
414
00:21:12,755 --> 00:21:16,275
There's no father
on the birth certificate. He'd be 23 now.
415
00:21:16,352 --> 00:21:19,405
He's old enough
to be a suspect. Track him and the mother down.
416
00:21:19,481 --> 00:21:22,966
What's the odds that
both the father and son turn out to be rapists?
417
00:21:23,044 --> 00:21:25,701
You know,
some geneticists theorize that violence is inherited.
418
00:21:25,774 --> 00:21:29,168
Oh, that's right.
It's not my fault, I was just born to kill.
419
00:21:29,237 --> 00:21:30,532
It's a theory.
420
00:21:30,603 --> 00:21:32,089
Well, it's ridiculous.
421
00:21:32,167 --> 00:21:34,960
It's another way for people
not to take responsibility for their actions.
422
00:21:35,031 --> 00:21:36,722
Let's find the guy first.
423
00:21:36,795 --> 00:21:39,781
We can discuss
the Human Genome Project Iater.
424
00:21:42,850 --> 00:21:43,837
You all right?
425
00:21:43,916 --> 00:21:45,311
Yeah. Let's go.
426
00:21:49,076 --> 00:21:52,526
Been a Iong time
since anybody's asked me about Daniel.
427
00:21:52,772 --> 00:21:54,793
I was 17 when I was raped.
428
00:21:54,937 --> 00:21:57,491
Three months Iater,
doctor told me I was pregnant.
429
00:21:57,567 --> 00:21:59,122
I didn't know what to do.
430
00:21:59,199 --> 00:22:01,991
According to the birth
certificate, you kept him.
431
00:22:02,062 --> 00:22:06,114
I didn't think I could handle
an abortion. But in the end it didn't matter.
432
00:22:07,155 --> 00:22:08,518
What do you mean?
433
00:22:08,588 --> 00:22:12,277
I went into Iabor two months
early. Daniel Iived two hours.
434
00:22:13,716 --> 00:22:17,167
I know this sounds awful,
but in a way Daniel's death was a relief.
435
00:22:17,246 --> 00:22:21,798
I don't know that I could have
Iived with a constant reminder of what happened to me.
436
00:22:25,635 --> 00:22:27,600
Thank you for your time.
437
00:22:33,293 --> 00:22:37,812
AII right. So now we go back
Iooking at rapes that Starnes wasn't connected to.
438
00:22:37,889 --> 00:22:40,647
Unsolved rapes from
20 years ago. It should be easy enough to crack.
439
00:22:40,719 --> 00:22:42,343
You got a better idea?
440
00:22:42,418 --> 00:22:44,574
Yeah,
Iet's continue to pretend this isn't bothering you.
441
00:22:44,648 --> 00:22:46,441
EIIiot, knock it off.
442
00:22:49,243 --> 00:22:51,036
You're gonna tell me
what Professor Shelby said in there,
443
00:22:51,107 --> 00:22:53,128
that's not getting to you?
444
00:22:54,304 --> 00:22:55,462
I'm a child of rape, EIIiot.
445
00:22:55,536 --> 00:22:58,464
I've known that
for a very Iong time, and I appreciate your concern.
446
00:22:58,532 --> 00:22:59,861
I really do.
447
00:22:59,932 --> 00:23:02,758
But I've dealt with it.
So I'm fine.
448
00:23:12,451 --> 00:23:14,642
How'd I know that bastard
would come back to haunt me?
449
00:23:14,714 --> 00:23:15,737
How'd I know it?
450
00:23:15,813 --> 00:23:17,675
When's the Iast time
you seen Harold Starnes?
451
00:23:17,745 --> 00:23:21,797
Right before he got arrested.
Wised up and threw him out finally.
452
00:23:21,907 --> 00:23:23,064
How Iong did you
Iive with him?
453
00:23:23,138 --> 00:23:24,602
Let him stay with me
two years,
454
00:23:24,670 --> 00:23:27,394
just after he got evicted
from that dump in FIatbush.
455
00:23:27,467 --> 00:23:28,659
Know how he thanks me?
456
00:23:28,733 --> 00:23:31,786
Rapes and kills my best friend
in my own building.
457
00:23:31,862 --> 00:23:33,292
Where was your son
at that time?
458
00:23:33,361 --> 00:23:36,188
I had Michael about a year
before I kicked Harry out.
459
00:23:36,258 --> 00:23:38,652
He didn't want much to do
with a baby anyway.
460
00:23:38,721 --> 00:23:40,481
Is Harry Michael's father?
Hell, no.
461
00:23:40,553 --> 00:23:41,608
Mind if I ask who is?
462
00:23:41,684 --> 00:23:43,739
That animal is not
Michael's father.
463
00:23:43,816 --> 00:23:45,904
But you were Iiving with him
when Michael was born.
464
00:23:45,980 --> 00:23:48,772
I had a Iot of boyfriends
back in the day,
465
00:23:48,843 --> 00:23:51,602
and if you trying to make me
feel Iike a whore, forget about it.
466
00:23:51,674 --> 00:23:53,160
We're not trying to do that,
Miss Tatum.
467
00:23:53,239 --> 00:23:55,532
What you want to know
all this for?
468
00:23:55,603 --> 00:23:56,726
MUNCH:
DNA found at a crime scene.
469
00:23:56,801 --> 00:23:59,322
Looks Iike Starnes has a son
who may be following in his footsteps.
470
00:23:59,398 --> 00:24:00,590
Know anything about it?
471
00:24:00,663 --> 00:24:01,992
You kidding me. No.
472
00:24:02,063 --> 00:24:04,355
Would you account
for your whereabouts in the past few days?
473
00:24:04,426 --> 00:24:07,718
I was at my girlfriend's in DC
for the Iast two weeks.
474
00:24:07,789 --> 00:24:09,912
Just got back this morning.
AII right. That's enough.
475
00:24:09,987 --> 00:24:12,916
My son is not a rapist.
I want you to Ieave.
476
00:24:13,016 --> 00:24:14,275
Why don't you just
come with us?
477
00:24:14,348 --> 00:24:16,437
Take a few tests, and we can
clear this whole thing up.
478
00:24:16,513 --> 00:24:18,601
That man is not
Michael's father.
479
00:24:18,677 --> 00:24:20,641
But you don't know
for sure, do you?
480
00:24:20,708 --> 00:24:21,933
Get out.
481
00:24:22,773 --> 00:24:26,064
If you're innocent, you don't
have anything to hide.
482
00:24:29,099 --> 00:24:31,892
He fits the profile.
Could we compel a oral swab?
483
00:24:31,963 --> 00:24:34,221
It's worth a shot. Let's see
what Cabot has to say.
484
00:24:34,293 --> 00:24:35,349
Hey.
485
00:24:37,856 --> 00:24:40,717
Man, I didn't hurt anybody.
I swear.
486
00:24:40,785 --> 00:24:42,409
Then take the test.
It's real easy.
487
00:24:43,116 --> 00:24:46,375
Look, I know what Starnes did,
and I don't want to know if I'm his son.
488
00:24:46,447 --> 00:24:48,240
There's no other way?
489
00:24:50,010 --> 00:24:51,870
Would you be willing
to stand in a Iineup?
490
00:24:51,940 --> 00:24:54,062
Yeah. Tell me when and where.
491
00:24:55,270 --> 00:24:58,062
We need an interpreter
to call in Sonja Yung for the Iineup.
492
00:24:58,133 --> 00:25:00,324
Cancel it.
Michael Tatum's alibi cleared.
493
00:25:00,397 --> 00:25:02,917
He agreed to do it.
His mother Iived with Starnes for two years.
494
00:25:02,995 --> 00:25:06,787
No, he's not our guy.
He was seen in DC when the attacks occurred.
495
00:25:06,857 --> 00:25:08,786
Where are we
on unsolved rapes?
496
00:25:08,854 --> 00:25:11,976
Nowhere. We don't have
a known address for Starnes before 1977.
497
00:25:12,051 --> 00:25:13,811
Which means he could've
been active anywhere.
498
00:25:13,883 --> 00:25:16,607
We got five boroughs'
worth of cold cases to wade through.
499
00:25:16,680 --> 00:25:21,164
Not necessarily. Pamela Tatum
said that Starnes Iived in FIatbush before Harlem.
500
00:25:21,374 --> 00:25:23,633
Police never Iooked at Starnes
for rapes in Brooklyn.
501
00:25:23,705 --> 00:25:26,861
Well, that sounds Iike a place
to start. Get the files.
502
00:25:30,563 --> 00:25:31,789
STABLER: Where's your son now?
503
00:25:31,863 --> 00:25:35,053
I don't know. Sometimes
Darrell doesn't come home.
504
00:25:36,125 --> 00:25:37,452
Thank you.
505
00:25:38,588 --> 00:25:44,674
Mrs. Guan, our records
indicate that you were a victim of rape in 1977.
506
00:25:46,080 --> 00:25:47,136
Yes.
507
00:25:49,143 --> 00:25:51,573
Did you become pregnant
because of that rape?
508
00:25:51,641 --> 00:25:52,730
Why?
509
00:25:52,805 --> 00:25:56,097
We're investigating attacks
against Asian women in the area.
510
00:25:56,168 --> 00:25:58,598
Here? That man is here?
511
00:25:58,766 --> 00:26:02,195
The man who attacked you will
spend the rest of his Iife in a wheelchair.
512
00:26:05,292 --> 00:26:07,256
Was he Darrell's father?
513
00:26:10,120 --> 00:26:11,516
Yes.
514
00:26:12,751 --> 00:26:14,044
I found out I was pregnant,
515
00:26:14,115 --> 00:26:19,304
and I thought maybe something
good could come out of what happened to me.
516
00:26:19,443 --> 00:26:21,066
Is this your son?
517
00:26:22,340 --> 00:26:24,202
His 21st birthday.
518
00:26:27,535 --> 00:26:28,896
Mrs. Guan,
519
00:26:29,764 --> 00:26:32,556
blood was found
at a murder scene that may belong to Darrell.
520
00:26:32,628 --> 00:26:33,752
So we need to know
where he is.
521
00:26:33,827 --> 00:26:37,017
Darrell would never...
He's a good boy.
522
00:26:37,090 --> 00:26:38,282
We just want to talk with him.
523
00:26:46,247 --> 00:26:47,767
It's my fault.
524
00:26:49,510 --> 00:26:53,529
I had hoped that because
he was my son, they would have Ioved him.
525
00:26:54,171 --> 00:26:55,227
BENSON: Who?
526
00:26:56,569 --> 00:27:00,657
My family.
Everyone in Chinatown.
527
00:27:03,195 --> 00:27:06,918
I moved in
with my mother and father because I had no money.
528
00:27:07,723 --> 00:27:11,651
When they saw him,
they told me to give him away.
529
00:27:13,117 --> 00:27:15,240
He's half-devil, they said.
530
00:27:15,482 --> 00:27:20,964
The children in the
neighborhood would hurt him, push him, kick him.
531
00:27:23,572 --> 00:27:28,556
Every day he'd cry, beg me
not to make him Ieave the apartment.
532
00:27:28,733 --> 00:27:30,197
Why didn't you move away?
533
00:27:34,093 --> 00:27:36,523
I guess part of me hated him,
too.
534
00:27:43,017 --> 00:27:47,671
Have you seen anything that
makes you suspect Darrell's done something wrong?
535
00:27:52,639 --> 00:27:54,762
That photo Iooks nothing
Iike the sketch of Darrell.
536
00:27:54,837 --> 00:27:56,925
Those victims had to have
known he was half-Asian.
537
00:27:57,001 --> 00:27:58,364
Why would they Iie?
538
00:27:58,434 --> 00:28:03,360
Look at this. Thrill Killing:
True Portrayals of America's Most Vicious Murders,
539
00:28:03,428 --> 00:28:04,415
Hunting Human Beings,
540
00:28:04,494 --> 00:28:05,481
Might explain these.
541
00:28:05,559 --> 00:28:07,351
BIood?
Okay. We gotta get CSU in here.
542
00:28:07,423 --> 00:28:09,081
Oh, my God.
543
00:28:09,155 --> 00:28:10,278
Where is he?
544
00:28:14,782 --> 00:28:16,769
BENSON: Excuse me,
is Darrell Guan here?
545
00:28:16,847 --> 00:28:18,707
No, he's on deliveries.
Be back in an hour.
546
00:28:18,777 --> 00:28:21,206
We'II need to see those
addresses now.
547
00:28:21,274 --> 00:28:22,932
Won't take me a minute.
548
00:28:23,006 --> 00:28:24,560
Should've known
Darrell was up to something.
549
00:28:24,637 --> 00:28:26,396
Why?
Well, a couple of women complained.
550
00:28:26,469 --> 00:28:27,456
Kept asking them out.
551
00:28:27,534 --> 00:28:28,623
Are all your customers
in the computer?
552
00:28:28,699 --> 00:28:30,186
Yeah.
May I?
553
00:28:35,858 --> 00:28:37,345
STABLER: Find anything?
554
00:28:37,623 --> 00:28:39,916
Helen Chen and Lucy Zhang's
mother are both in here.
555
00:28:39,986 --> 00:28:42,314
AIong with their
home addresses.
556
00:28:42,652 --> 00:28:44,808
Victim's address
at the touch of a button.
557
00:28:44,881 --> 00:28:46,210
Call for back up.
558
00:28:53,039 --> 00:28:54,526
(BELL RINGING)
559
00:29:12,650 --> 00:29:14,138
Darrell, stop.
560
00:29:14,948 --> 00:29:16,139
Police!
561
00:29:16,546 --> 00:29:18,011
Stop! Police!
562
00:29:19,842 --> 00:29:22,771
Freeze. Police!
Okay. I didn't do anything.
563
00:29:26,968 --> 00:29:30,158
Liv. AII right, we got him.
We got him, we got him.
564
00:29:33,428 --> 00:29:34,790
STABLER: You got it?
565
00:29:38,189 --> 00:29:39,653
What is it?
566
00:29:40,653 --> 00:29:42,049
It's bleach.
567
00:29:49,909 --> 00:29:52,372
Counselor,
I'm glad I ran into you.
568
00:29:52,439 --> 00:29:56,299
Expect an updated witness Iist
on the Guan case by the end of the week.
569
00:29:56,435 --> 00:29:58,263
You're representing
Darrell Guan?
570
00:29:58,334 --> 00:30:01,319
Little below your usual
tax bracket requirement, isn't he, Margo?
571
00:30:01,397 --> 00:30:03,758
I'm defending him pro bono.
572
00:30:03,828 --> 00:30:04,884
Looking for headlines.
573
00:30:04,959 --> 00:30:08,649
Looking to save a Iife.
Keep the death penalty off the table.
574
00:30:08,723 --> 00:30:11,947
Your client
planned his attacks and tried to cover his crimes.
575
00:30:12,019 --> 00:30:13,506
He intentionally
selected his victims
576
00:30:13,583 --> 00:30:16,138
based on race,
national origin, ancestry and gender.
577
00:30:16,214 --> 00:30:18,733
That's five
of the nine criteria under the Hate Crimes Act,
578
00:30:18,811 --> 00:30:20,469
which is an automatic
sentence enhancement.
579
00:30:20,710 --> 00:30:22,730
He's not guilty of murder one.
580
00:30:22,807 --> 00:30:25,292
The victim's blood was found
on Darrell's clothing.
581
00:30:25,370 --> 00:30:27,391
His DNA was found under
one of the victim's nails.
582
00:30:27,468 --> 00:30:30,226
The bottle of bleach used
in both crime scenes was found in his possession.
583
00:30:30,298 --> 00:30:33,090
What exactly is
your definition of guilt?
584
00:30:33,228 --> 00:30:36,678
Guilt, noun.
From the Middle English G-I-L-T.
585
00:30:36,757 --> 00:30:39,913
The fact of being responsible
for the commission of an offense.
586
00:30:39,987 --> 00:30:42,474
Operative word being
"responsible."
587
00:30:43,250 --> 00:30:46,406
Not guilty by reason
of mental disease or defect.
588
00:30:47,578 --> 00:30:50,268
My parents made me
read the dictionary.
589
00:30:54,004 --> 00:30:56,696
Margo Nelson's got
a PhD in molecular biology,
590
00:30:56,769 --> 00:30:57,994
in addition to her Iaw degree.
591
00:30:58,067 --> 00:31:00,122
So what the hell is she doing
defending a rapist?
592
00:31:00,198 --> 00:31:02,388
Trying to set a precedent,
I think. Look at her witnesses.
593
00:31:02,462 --> 00:31:04,890
A geneticist, a biologist,
a genetic psychologist.
594
00:31:04,959 --> 00:31:06,515
AII for an insanity defense.
595
00:31:06,591 --> 00:31:09,077
Not guilty by reason
of DNA. PIease.
596
00:31:09,222 --> 00:31:12,706
She's trying to get the State
to pay for genetic testing on Guan and Harold Starnes.
597
00:31:12,784 --> 00:31:15,247
Prove the sins of the father
are visited on the son.
598
00:31:15,314 --> 00:31:16,609
Wait, wait, wait.
599
00:31:16,680 --> 00:31:21,334
The Frye standard
precludes scientific evidence
600
00:31:21,408 --> 00:31:24,064
not generally accepted
by the scientific community.
601
00:31:24,138 --> 00:31:27,726
So file a motion in Iimine.
Just keep it out.
602
00:31:27,800 --> 00:31:30,627
I'm not sure that I can.
Nelson's got science on her side.
603
00:31:30,697 --> 00:31:33,217
It's a generally accepted
theory that violence and genes are Iinked.
604
00:31:33,295 --> 00:31:35,282
They're Iinked, not causative.
605
00:31:35,360 --> 00:31:37,845
Do you trust a jury to make
that distinction? I don't.
606
00:31:37,923 --> 00:31:40,478
It's your job to make sure
that they can.
607
00:31:40,554 --> 00:31:42,108
I've got George Huang
doing a psych exam.
608
00:31:42,185 --> 00:31:45,545
Hopefully, he can prove
Darrell knew exactly what he was doing.
609
00:31:45,615 --> 00:31:48,134
Listen to me,
if Nelson pulls this off,
610
00:31:48,211 --> 00:31:50,641
it's a Pandora's box
for criminal prosecution,
611
00:31:50,709 --> 00:31:54,637
because everything can be
blamed on the confluence of bad genes.
612
00:31:54,705 --> 00:31:57,190
And then no one
is truly responsible for their own actions.
613
00:31:57,268 --> 00:31:58,426
That's what I'm afraid of.
614
00:31:58,500 --> 00:32:00,986
Good,
then don't Iet it happen.
615
00:32:07,123 --> 00:32:08,815
Do you know why I'm here,
Darrell?
616
00:32:08,889 --> 00:32:10,375
To see if I'm crazy.
617
00:32:10,453 --> 00:32:15,210
To see if you're competent
to stand trial. Why? Do you think that you're crazy?
618
00:32:16,847 --> 00:32:18,674
If I say no, I get
the death penalty, right?
619
00:32:18,744 --> 00:32:21,763
Usually the Iawyers Iet me
make the diagnosis, not the defendant.
620
00:32:21,841 --> 00:32:24,067
But I'm just wondering
what you think.
621
00:32:25,137 --> 00:32:26,658
You're Chinese.
622
00:32:27,335 --> 00:32:28,821
Why, yes, I am.
623
00:32:31,164 --> 00:32:32,389
So am I.
624
00:32:34,427 --> 00:32:37,254
Actually, you're half-Chinese,
aren't you?
625
00:32:41,586 --> 00:32:43,413
You're tow gee,
626
00:32:45,215 --> 00:32:48,735
You think that
I'm the privileged and spoiled Iandowner?
627
00:32:48,845 --> 00:32:52,534
Isn't that what
the native Chinese call the American-born Chinese?
628
00:32:52,607 --> 00:32:55,535
But you're American-born
as well, aren't you?
629
00:32:58,001 --> 00:33:00,896
Was it difficult for you
growing up in Chinatown?
630
00:33:00,963 --> 00:33:01,951
No.
631
00:33:02,029 --> 00:33:03,324
You speak the Ianguage
very well.
632
00:33:03,395 --> 00:33:05,880
You know the customs
probably better than I do.
633
00:33:05,958 --> 00:33:10,283
But I imagine for many people
in Chinatown, you were still an outcast.
634
00:33:10,354 --> 00:33:11,444
Didn't bother me.
635
00:33:11,520 --> 00:33:13,608
The kids probably
picked on you when you were growing up.
636
00:33:13,683 --> 00:33:14,739
That must have been difficult.
637
00:33:14,816 --> 00:33:17,869
Even your own family
must have treated you differently.
638
00:33:18,279 --> 00:33:20,764
What do you know
about your father?
639
00:33:22,241 --> 00:33:23,432
Enough.
640
00:33:23,572 --> 00:33:26,057
How old were you
when you found out that he'd raped your mom?
641
00:33:26,136 --> 00:33:29,429
I don't remember. Young.
My mother's mother told me.
642
00:33:30,165 --> 00:33:31,686
Why did she tell you that?
643
00:33:31,764 --> 00:33:32,854
Haak gwai,
644
00:33:33,660 --> 00:33:36,522
BIack devil.
She called you that?
645
00:33:38,056 --> 00:33:39,714
It doesn't matter.
646
00:33:42,917 --> 00:33:45,778
What about your father?
How do you feel about your father?
647
00:33:51,508 --> 00:33:53,529
I'm nothing Iike him.
648
00:33:54,538 --> 00:33:56,967
Look at what you've done,
Darrell.
649
00:33:57,036 --> 00:33:59,590
Your whole Iife you've tried
not to be Iike him.
650
00:33:59,666 --> 00:34:02,186
But you're violent.
You hurt people.
651
00:34:02,330 --> 00:34:05,383
You rape them.
Like father, Iike son.
652
00:34:12,485 --> 00:34:13,710
Get out!
653
00:34:14,716 --> 00:34:17,440
MAN: Darrell, calm down.
Take it easy.
654
00:34:17,746 --> 00:34:20,073
Okay, okay, okay.
Take it easy.
655
00:34:21,341 --> 00:34:22,703
Gee, okay.
656
00:34:26,303 --> 00:34:30,992
Have you discovered
what some theorists term the "violence gene"?
657
00:34:31,530 --> 00:34:34,857
Well, there is no
"violence gene" per se,
658
00:34:34,927 --> 00:34:39,081
and violent behavior can be
Iinked to the expression of several abnormal genes.
659
00:34:39,155 --> 00:34:40,245
For instance?
660
00:34:40,320 --> 00:34:45,543
A defective DRD2 A1 allele
may Iead to pleasure-seeking
661
00:34:45,615 --> 00:34:49,009
or addictive behavior,
as well as violence.
662
00:34:49,345 --> 00:34:52,795
You conducted several
DNA tests on Mr. Guan.
663
00:34:52,874 --> 00:34:55,735
Does he suffer from this
particular gene abnormality?
664
00:34:55,804 --> 00:34:56,826
Yes, he does.
665
00:34:56,902 --> 00:34:59,695
And what about his biological
father, Harold Starnes?
666
00:34:59,766 --> 00:35:02,661
He suffers from
the exact same abnormality.
667
00:35:02,829 --> 00:35:05,223
Mr. Starnes
is a convicted rapist.
668
00:35:05,292 --> 00:35:09,516
Would you say that his son
inherited these violent tendencies from his father?
669
00:35:09,588 --> 00:35:12,245
Objection. No matter
how much research Dr. Coffey has done,
670
00:35:12,318 --> 00:35:14,215
he cannot definitively
answer that question.
671
00:35:14,283 --> 00:35:18,676
I agree. Let's try and keep it
out of the realm of science fiction, Miss Nelson.
672
00:35:18,977 --> 00:35:21,941
Are gene mutations inherited,
Dr. Coffey?
673
00:35:22,009 --> 00:35:23,495
Certainly they can be.
674
00:35:23,573 --> 00:35:28,466
I mean, take for instance
the genetic disease cystic fibrosis.
675
00:35:28,700 --> 00:35:32,356
Both parents must possess
the recessive gene and pass it on to the child
676
00:35:32,463 --> 00:35:34,393
in order for the child
to have the illness.
677
00:35:34,461 --> 00:35:38,150
If they don't have the gene,
the child will not get the illness.
678
00:35:38,223 --> 00:35:42,583
Would a person with cystic
fibrosis have any control over contracting the disease?
679
00:35:42,652 --> 00:35:45,910
No. He will have inherited
the gene at conception.
680
00:35:45,982 --> 00:35:49,637
And Iike that disease,
if a child inherited genes that made him violent,
681
00:35:49,711 --> 00:35:52,639
he wouldn't have any control
over that either, correct?
682
00:35:52,707 --> 00:35:53,763
That's correct.
683
00:35:53,839 --> 00:35:59,027
So from a genetic standpoint,
since Harold Starnes was a violent man,
684
00:36:00,099 --> 00:36:02,823
it's not completely out
of the realm of possibility
685
00:36:02,896 --> 00:36:05,325
that his son was born violent,
as well.
686
00:36:05,393 --> 00:36:08,787
Objection. How did we go from
talking about inherited genes to inherited behavior?
687
00:36:08,856 --> 00:36:10,785
I apologize.
I'II try to speak slowly
688
00:36:10,853 --> 00:36:13,180
and use smaller words
so you can keep up with us.
689
00:36:13,251 --> 00:36:14,341
RIDENOUR: Counselor.
690
00:36:14,416 --> 00:36:17,538
Dr. Coffey has not
specifically proven inherited behavior.
691
00:36:17,613 --> 00:36:19,940
Are we just going to
make up new theories as we go along?
692
00:36:20,010 --> 00:36:23,461
No, I think it's better that
we take the word of an assistant district attorney
693
00:36:23,540 --> 00:36:25,197
over that
of a scientific expert.
694
00:36:25,270 --> 00:36:28,165
Objection sustained.
Move it along, Miss Nelson.
695
00:36:28,234 --> 00:36:30,357
Nothing further, Your Honor.
696
00:36:32,330 --> 00:36:36,757
Are all people with
a defective DRD2 A1 allele rapists, Dr. Coffey?
697
00:36:36,824 --> 00:36:41,115
Well, the gene defect
predisposes one towards violent behavior.
698
00:36:41,186 --> 00:36:43,342
That wasn't the question,
I will rephrase it.
699
00:36:43,417 --> 00:36:47,175
If a man has a defect,
is he absolutely going to be a rapist?
700
00:36:47,246 --> 00:36:49,177
No. Not absolutely.
701
00:36:49,710 --> 00:36:51,368
We know with
the cystic fibrosis gene
702
00:36:51,441 --> 00:36:53,530
if a child inherits the gene
from each of the parents,
703
00:36:53,605 --> 00:36:55,763
he or she will have
the disease.
704
00:36:55,837 --> 00:36:58,130
Is that the case with
the so-called "violent gene"?
705
00:36:58,201 --> 00:37:00,720
Well, a causative connection
has not yet been established.
706
00:37:00,797 --> 00:37:03,522
But aren't you asserting
your research predicts violent behavior
707
00:37:03,595 --> 00:37:05,559
based on genetic makeup?
708
00:37:05,759 --> 00:37:09,347
No. There are other factors
such as upbringing.
709
00:37:09,421 --> 00:37:13,440
You never mentioned that
in your testimony. It sounded to me as if you were saying
710
00:37:13,518 --> 00:37:16,276
genes are the only factor
in violent behavior.
711
00:37:16,348 --> 00:37:19,106
Well, I can't very well speak
to the influence of environment.
712
00:37:19,178 --> 00:37:20,472
I am a geneticist.
713
00:37:20,543 --> 00:37:22,631
I see. So your testimony now
714
00:37:22,707 --> 00:37:25,671
is that violent behavior is,
in fact, a combination of many factors,
715
00:37:25,738 --> 00:37:27,099
not just genetic.
Yes.
716
00:37:27,169 --> 00:37:29,631
So, in truth, you really can't
speak to the topic at all, can you?
717
00:37:29,699 --> 00:37:30,755
Objection.
RIDENOUR: Counselor?
718
00:37:30,831 --> 00:37:33,057
Withdrawn. Nothing further.
719
00:37:36,858 --> 00:37:39,720
NELSON: Complex
scientific evidence aside,
720
00:37:39,789 --> 00:37:42,274
this case is about
the choices we make
721
00:37:42,818 --> 00:37:45,406
and the choices
that are made for us.
722
00:37:45,682 --> 00:37:49,303
Did Darrell Guan choose
for his father to rape his mother,
723
00:37:49,578 --> 00:37:52,200
to be brought up
in a community, in a family,
724
00:37:52,274 --> 00:37:56,066
that every single day berated,
belittled and stigmatized him?
725
00:37:56,403 --> 00:37:59,093
Did he choose to have
a genetic defect?
726
00:37:59,467 --> 00:38:00,897
No.
727
00:38:02,795 --> 00:38:07,621
And now we're supposed to
tell him, "Well, too bad. You should have known better."
728
00:38:08,256 --> 00:38:13,841
Darrell was born and Iived
in hell. His grandmother called him the devil.
729
00:38:13,917 --> 00:38:15,904
Well, of course he was.
730
00:38:15,981 --> 00:38:18,467
He was engineered,
by nature and by nurture,
731
00:38:18,546 --> 00:38:21,236
to be exactly
what he turned out to be.
732
00:38:22,208 --> 00:38:24,228
And that is not his fault.
733
00:38:31,497 --> 00:38:34,426
Yes, Darrell Guan
had a difficult Iife.
734
00:38:36,026 --> 00:38:38,081
He was raised knowing
the only reason he exists
735
00:38:38,158 --> 00:38:40,780
is because his mother
was violently raped.
736
00:38:40,854 --> 00:38:44,804
One could understand why
he wouldn't grow up to be a well-adjusted adult.
737
00:38:45,049 --> 00:38:47,568
But that's not an excuse
for murder.
738
00:38:48,845 --> 00:38:53,169
In a civilized society,
we have to take responsibility for our actions.
739
00:38:53,773 --> 00:38:57,962
If we start to justify all
antisocial behavior under the pretense it isn't our fault,
740
00:38:58,034 --> 00:39:01,258
then the entire structure
of the Iaw is meaningless.
741
00:39:01,498 --> 00:39:06,891
In the end, it comes down to
what it is to be a human being.
742
00:39:08,023 --> 00:39:11,349
We're not just a product
of our genetic programming,
743
00:39:11,519 --> 00:39:15,913
nor are we solely molded
and motivated by our childhood experiences.
744
00:39:15,981 --> 00:39:19,909
The defense would have you
believe Darrell Guan's Iife was beyond his control.
745
00:39:19,977 --> 00:39:23,598
But the truth is, he was in
complete control at the time he committed his crimes.
746
00:39:23,673 --> 00:39:26,102
He specifically
chose his victims,
747
00:39:26,169 --> 00:39:30,563
not because of some
biological imperative, but because of opportunity.
748
00:39:31,465 --> 00:39:33,291
He knew what he was doing
was wrong,
749
00:39:33,362 --> 00:39:36,258
and he did everything
he could to get away with it.
750
00:39:38,156 --> 00:39:41,676
Darrell Guan chose
the course of his Iife.
751
00:39:44,017 --> 00:39:47,139
Make him take responsibility
for it.
752
00:40:00,799 --> 00:40:01,855
(KNOCK ON DOOR)
753
00:40:01,931 --> 00:40:03,054
Come in.
754
00:40:03,129 --> 00:40:04,525
BENSON: Hey.
755
00:40:04,994 --> 00:40:07,514
The verdict came in
on the Darrell Guan case.
756
00:40:07,824 --> 00:40:09,187
He's guilty on all charges.
757
00:40:09,256 --> 00:40:10,345
I heard.
758
00:40:11,354 --> 00:40:14,145
That was a tough case for me.
759
00:40:16,415 --> 00:40:19,503
Seems to have been
a tough case for you, as well.
760
00:40:25,538 --> 00:40:27,660
My mother was a rape victim.
761
00:40:29,733 --> 00:40:31,889
She got pregnant. She had me.
762
00:40:32,530 --> 00:40:35,617
So, yeah, it was personal.
763
00:40:38,956 --> 00:40:42,782
I think I'd be Iying
if I didn't admit that that's probably the biggest reason
764
00:40:42,852 --> 00:40:46,507
that I decided to become
a cop. You know, to join SVU.
765
00:40:47,713 --> 00:40:51,573
I used to think that
it was because I wanted to do something good,
766
00:40:51,643 --> 00:40:53,935
you know, make a difference.
767
00:40:55,537 --> 00:40:58,261
But you're questioning
those reasons now?
768
00:41:00,798 --> 00:41:03,159
I don't know. You know, I...
769
00:41:04,994 --> 00:41:06,788
I mean, Iook at my job. I'm...
770
00:41:08,257 --> 00:41:12,379
I have to be aggressive,
even violent.
771
00:41:14,384 --> 00:41:17,437
And you think that makes you
Iike Darrell Guan.
772
00:41:21,176 --> 00:41:24,333
Well, Iook at Darrell Guan.
773
00:41:26,736 --> 00:41:31,027
I keep trying to convince
myself that he had a choice.
774
00:41:31,698 --> 00:41:36,624
You know, be a rapist,
don't be a rapist. Be violent, don't be violent. But...
775
00:41:39,156 --> 00:41:43,550
If he had this aggression
inside him,
776
00:41:43,618 --> 00:41:46,604
even violence, then,
777
00:41:49,078 --> 00:41:50,599
does he have a choice?
778
00:41:52,108 --> 00:41:53,538
Does anyone?
779
00:41:58,267 --> 00:42:00,493
You don't hurt people, OIivia.
780
00:42:01,931 --> 00:42:03,792
You protect them.
781
00:42:04,861 --> 00:42:07,551
You're proof that
we do have a choice.
782
00:42:17,946 --> 00:42:19,843
Or...
783
00:42:21,875 --> 00:42:24,168
Or maybe I'm just Iucky.
784
00:42:24,218 --> 00:42:28,768
Repair and Synchronization by
Easy Subtitles Synchronizer 1.0.0.0
64516
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.