Original subtitles

[Upbeat music]

[People clamoring]

[Laughing]

[Gasps]

[All laughing]

Tell me this isn't what I think it is.

I can teach you how to use it.

Use it? I don't even want to touch it.

[Doorbell rings]

Um, can everyone do the math?

This plus this equals... This.

[Laughing]

We've had a complaint about the noise.

I'm so sorry, I didn't even know...

No. I'm the one that's sorry.

You're in flagrant violation of penal code 10-65.

'I have a search warrant here.'

now, assume the position.

[Upbeat music on stereo]

[All cheering]

[Laughing]

[Cheering]

Turn that thing off.

I don't want Jeffrey to see this.

He would kill me.

I made him promise no strippers at his bachelor party.

[Doorbell ringing]

[Music stops]

It's the groom.

[All clamoring]

What's going on?

[Laughs]

Your secret's safe with me, ladies, okay?

[Laughing]

But remember, you got one more week of freedom.

'Alright, I'm going to go'

but I do have just one more thing

to say to my bride.

♪ Someday ♪

♪ when I'm awfully low ♪

♪ when the world is cold ♪

♪ I will feel a glow ♪

♪ just thinking of you ♪

♪ and the way you look tonight ♪♪

[Applause]

[Doorbell ringing]

Hey, sis, we're here.

It's the biggest day of your life.

- 'Kat?' - maybe she and Jeffrey eloped.

Oh, no way, Jeffrey's parents would flip.

You heard his dad's toast last night.

"I have finally found the daughter I never had."

Oh, my god, it's so beautiful.

Is she wearing her hair up or down?

Up with the curl ringlets.

[Gasps] That'll look great.

Kat? Kat!

[Screaming]

(Ortiz) Katrina Moore.

Killed the night before her wedding.

- You're kidding? - It gets worse.

She was a schoolteacher.

First grade, 25 years old.

Graduated from the university of Texas in '02.

Lived alone, by all accounts, the real deal.

Kind to animals, takes in strays.

Basically. Her sister found her.

Any other family members in town?

No, her sister was the only living relative.

The victim's bridesmaids were coming over

to help her with her wedding dress.

- Oh, this is tragic. - Cause of death?

Strangled with a Teddy.

A Teddy she received at her bachelorette party last weekend.

How's this a sex crime, other than the Teddy?

I mean, I know you're on loan

from the sex crimes division but..

(Ortiz) 'Let me make one thing clear.'

everything is about sex.

'Now the me will make the final determination'

but it looks like rape to me.

We found skin under the nails

and hair pulled from the root in her hand.

(Steve) 'You think it's a predator?'

are there any sex offenders who live nearby?

Actually, it looks like the victim knew her attacker.

How do you figure that?

It appears they had a drink together.

Now there were two sets of prints.

One belonged to the victim.

And the other was a partial print from an unknown male.

Now, Katrina and her fiance weren't living together

so our theory is miss Moore was home alone

she invited this guy in, they had a beer

then he raped and killed her.

Who's your suspect?

Well, the fiance is a person of interest.

You've got statistics on your side.

And a shaky alibi.

Preliminary reports put time of death between 11:00 P.M.

And 1:00 in the morning.

Now, the groom was with his parents until 11:45

then he says he went home alone and went to bed.

- You think he did it? - It's possible.

No sign of forced entry, she knew the guy.

Maybe the groom got cold feet.

The night before the wedding.

Uber wedding. Huge, like, 750 guests.

The pressure could've gotten to him.

I asked the groom to come in for questioning.

His parents gave him an alibi, but...

Okay. Bring the parents in, too.

Sit him down, see if you can ferret out the situation

without causing too much duress.

I was supposed to watch my bride..

Walking down the aisle this morning.

We were supposed to spend the rest of our lives together.

The police are determined to find Katrina's killer.

But in order to do that

they need to rule you out as a suspect

as quickly as possible.

You can't think Jeffrey had anything to do with this.

(Sam) 'We told you he was with us last night.'

we-we came back to our house after the rehearsal dinner.

We need a DNA sample

to compare to what was found at the crime scene.

'It's standard procedure.'

if you volunteer, we can do this without a subpoena.

You found DNA?

What do you mean, like b-blood or something?

We found semen.

We believe Katrina was raped before she was murdered.

Raped?

Someone... raped her and then strangled her?

'Oh, my god!'

but she was..

You don't understand.

My son and his fiancee were saving themselves for marriage.

We signed covenant cards

we made a pledge that we were going to wait

'until we were married.'

she was a virgin.

We both are.

The groom's prints were in Katrina Moore's house

but they were not on the beer bottles.

'The me is still working on the DNA results'

but we have no evidence of the fiance being at the scene.

So, no other suspect?

Oh, we did pull the victim's cell phone records.

And found a series of calls from a Houston phone number.

One of those disposable cell phones.

'No credit check required kind of deal.

Difficult to trace to the actual person.

But I did call the number.

A guy answered. His name's Rodney Wallace.

- He told me he was in Houston. - He told you his name?

I told him I was calling from the state lottery.

(Maureen) 'Well, were you able to get a read on the guy?'

do we have any reason to suspect him of anything?

Well, for one thing, he lied.

His cell phone signal was bouncing off a tower

right here in Indianapolis.

He's here in town.

(Ortiz) Not only is he here

but he flew in the night before Katrina Moore was murdered.

(Maureen) Sounds like we need to sit Mr. Wallace down

for a little chat.

I heard..

What happened to Kat.

It's awful.

Kat and I had a lot of history.

Remained tight ever since college.

What brought you to Indianapolis, Rodney?

[Sighs] Business.

What kind of business you in?

I'm self-employed.

That business take you to Katrina's house Friday night?

She might've asked me to stop over.

Phone records indicate that you started calling Katrina

right after her engagement announcement

appeared in your Alma mater's alumni magazine.

The weeks leading up to the wedding

you sometimes called as much as five, six times a day.

Kat and me were tight.

When you went to her house Friday night, what'd you do?

Want to know the truth?

I think Kat was getting cold feet

'about the wedding thing.'

and what gave you that impression?

Look, we didn't plan for anything to happen.

It just did.

Do you know what a covenant card is?

Katrina had pledged herself to Jeffrey.

They were saving themselves for marriage.

Kat told him she was a virgin?

Like Kat was really something.

Well, now you starting to sound like the jilted boyfriend.

- You got it all wrong. - Do we?

I'm not some angry ex-boyfriend.

I'm her loving ex-husband.

[Dramatic music]

We just heard back from the Houston police department.

You have a record, Mr. Wallace.

And that partial print we found at Katrina's place

matched to your prints.

You tried to strangle your previous girlfriend.

We were horsing around and it got out of hand.

You purchased a one-way ticket to Indianapolis, rod.

You think your ex-wife was going to cancel her wedding

invite you to shack up with her?

Did you kill her when she refused?

Katrina was my wife.

We had sex that night just like we had many, many times before.

When I left, she was alive and she was happy.

Now, I got a funny feeling that the DNA we get

from your water bottle here, is gonna match

the skin we found under Katrina's fingernails.

You know what? I'd like a lawyer.

I'm not answering any more of your questions

until I get one.

Detective Ortiz, why don't you book Mr. Wallace?

Get him a lawyer.

Gladly.

Police have somebody in custody.

- Do you recognize this man? - No.

Katrina never mentioned the name Rodney Wallace to you?

No. Why? She know him?

(Female #1) 'Oh, my god.'

so you do recognize him.

I never seen his face, but I do recognize that name.

He was an old boyfriend of Kat's.

We were engaged for over a year

and she never mentioned a boyfriend.

I mean, this is completely..

Whoever he is, he's lying.

Katrina told me everything.

You know she went to college in Houston?

Yeah. She lived in a sorority. She sang in a choir.

She double majored in education and Spanish.

Nothing about a boyfriend.

If she had a boyfriend, I would know.

When my sister came home from college one summer

she told me about a guy.

This guy.

Apparently, he was a total manipulator

and she was young and dumb.

And, you know, everyone's entitled

to one crazy ex-boyfriend.

She made me promise not to tell anybody about it.

I was her only family.

Did she tell you she was married to him?

I'm sorry, you said what?

Rodney Wallace says he and Katrina were married.

- And you believed him? - Jeffrey, we checked it out.

They were married.

'But it was only for a short time.'

Katrina divorced him four months later.

You know, she signed a covenant card with Jeffrey?

She was really just so crazy about him.

And she really was a new person.

So, I covered for her.

We made a pledge to each other.

I know this is hard to hear.

I loved her so much.

And I keep thinking..

This can't get any worse, but..

It just did.

We uncovered an orgy of bodily fluids

semen, blood, saliva.

Your victim had blood under her nails

semen in her body.

'I even found skin between her teeth.'

and?

All came from the same source, your guy with the water bottle.

Rodney Wallace.

And what about the rest of the evidence

found at the scene, like the beer bottles?

I tested it and found..

Saliva on one bottle matches the victim

and the other belongs to Mr. Wallace.

And the Teddy?

Had traces of Mr. Wallace's blood and saliva.

'Based on the skin in the victim's teeth'

and the blood on the Teddy

I'd say that your bride bit this guy.

Hard.

Then we're certain that this was rape?

The totality of the physical evidence

indicate that it was rape, but..

You know I don't like buts.

But the vaginal bruising and tearing was inconclusive.

So, in theory

it could have been consensual.

Well, anything is theoretically possible.

[Sighs] Let's cut to the chase, annabeth, you've got nothing.

Then you're client won't mind being searched.

- For what? - A bite Mark.

Katrina Moore had skin in her teeth.

She bit your client during the course of the rape.

I told you we had sex, we were married.

Rodney. We're happy to submit to a search.

Don't I have a fifth amendment right here?

Oh, would you like a warrant?

'Cause I could have one here within the hour

along with a less cheery disposition.

We're happy to submit to a superficial search.

Rodney.

Stand up for me and take your shirt off.

So, I've got nothing on your client?

There's not enough to arraign him.

It could've been consensual.

Defensive bites on a forearm, in what universe?

In a universe of a trial where the burden

is on the state to prove, beyond a reasonable doubt

that my client raped and killed his ex-wife.

My client says Katrina liked it rough.

She may have, but if you add that bite Mark

to your client's history of violence towards women

specifically his assault and battery conviction in '99.

Oh, you know priors aren't admissible

unless he takes the stand.

Which he won't.

Your client tried to strangle his ex-girlfriend

and luckily she didn't die.

That sounds like a mo to me.

No, it sounds prejudicial.

And I think we both know a judge will agree.

(Annabeth) 'I wanted you to be the first to know'

'we're charging Rodney Wallace with Katrina's murder.'

his semen was a match.

'His skin was under her nails.'

his DNA was found in her teeth.

She fought back.

Rodney is claiming that their sex was consensual.

That's not possible.

The defense is going to try to make it

look like consensual sex.

'And then sow seeds of doubt'

about who committed the murder.

Now, I have to warn you, this is going to be a dogfight.

They're going to put Kat on trial.

That's what you're saying, isn't it?

The defendant has a right to mount a defense.

(Jeffrey) 'What about her rights?'

what about Katrina's right to her dignity?

That's just not how the system is set up.

I have to ask.

'Is there anything we should know about?'

anything she regretted?

Just Rodney.

Four years ago

when Katrina Moore was only 21 years old

she made a mistake.

She secretly married this man.

Rodney Allen Wallace.

'The marriage only lasted four months'

'but she never told anyone about it.'

not even her sister.

Katrina had the marriage annulled and moved here.

'She had outgrown this man and this marriage.'

she wanted to put the past behind her.

And she thought she had.

But..

When Mr. Wallace found out that she was engaged

to marry a man she'd met at church, he got angry.

Evidence will show

Mr. Wallace started contacting her.

He called her repeatedly over six months

and then he flew to Indianapolis

two days before her wedding.

This is a portrait of a man obsessed.

'The evidence will also show'

that the night before her wedding

Rodney Wallace attacked

raped

and viciously murdered Katrina Moore.

(Chung) 'Rodney Wallace is anything but a predator.'

'he respected his ex-wife's wishes'

to keep their relationship a secret.

The fact is, Katrina Moore kept a lot of things secret.

She promised her fiance that she was a virgin.

'She lied to her family and she lied to her church'

about who she really was.

The evidence will show that Katrina Moore led a double life.

'Now my client went to see his ex-wife'

the night before her wedding because she invited him.

They had sex. Wild, rough sex.

'Now, it's possible'

that someone seized the moment to frame my client.

It's possible that her fiance

learned his bride was cheating on him

the night before their wedding

and flew into a murderous rage.

But the state cannot prove

that my client raped his ex-wife.

Nor can they prove beyond a doubt that he killed her.

(Annabeth) 'How would you describe this particular bite?'

(male #1) 'I'd categorize it'

'as a classic defensive wound.'

why?

(Male #1) 'It's on the outside of the forearm'

as if the victim were being pinned down.

The victim was strangled with a piece of lingerie

that was wrapped around her neck.

A Teddy, just like this one.

'Can you please describe how the defendant'

might have gotten this wound on his arm?

Sure. May I demonstrate?

The accused put the Teddy

around the victim's neck

like so.

Based on the bite Mark

'it appears that the defendant used his arm'

'to pin Katrina down.'

and mind you, they were lying down.

She bit down on his arm

then he continued to pull the lingerie

tighter and tighter causing his flesh to tear

like you see in the photo

until Ms. Moore lost consciousness

and then her jaws disengaged.

Thank you.

Is forensic odontology an exact science?

It's based on calculations and precise measurements

which are then interpreted by a trained individual.

(Chung) So, it's guesswork, really?

And you're guessing this was a defensive wound.

Objection, your honor.

The defense is goading the witness.

Pose a direct question or be seated, counsel.

You're interpreting that this was a defensive wound

but you can't say for sure, yes or no?

- Well, in my opinion... - Yes or no?

No.

(Chung) 'In a recent study, 26 members'

of the American board of forensic odontologist

participated in a bite Mark proficiency test.

Any idea how they did?

They failed 63 percent of the time.

(Chung) That's more than inexact.

That's sounds like criminal negligence.

(Male #1) 'That's one study.'

'but the fact remains'

'the defendant's flesh was in the victim's teeth.'

she bit him.

And she bit him hard.

There were bruises on the victim's back

shoulders and buttocks, consistent with having been

knocked to the floor.

Her neck was extremely bruised.

Are you certain this was the Teddy used

to strangle Katrina Moore?

Yes, the ligature marks on the victim's neck

are consistent with that Teddy found at the scene.

And you're sure Rodney Wallace was the one that did it?

(Female #2) 'According to our pathologist, his blood and saliva'

'were on the material.'

(Maureen) 'Thank you.'

no further questions.

Is it possible that the bruises and bite marks you described

were a result of rough sex?

I've examined a lot of sexual assault victims

and in my opinion, this was unequivocally a rape.

Thank you.

Your honor, the defense would like to enter into the record

an additional piece of evidence

'not currently on the exhibit list.'

your honor, the defense is barred from adding new evidence.

I'm well aware of the rules of discovery.

'Court will recess for 15 minutes.'

counselors, in my chambers.

We'll find out what this is.

It would be unusual for the judge

to let something in this late.

When did this disc come into your possession, Ms. Chung?

I've been aware of it since the beginning of the case.

Can you tell me why on earth

you withheld it until this moment?

Because the me has unequivocally

accused my client of rape, and I have evidence

'that directly refutes that.'

in other words, you're sandbagging

the prosecution with this stunt.

I had no way of knowing the me's testimony

would so forcefully impugn my client.

'We have the right to rebut.'

what could this disc possibly depict other than a relationship

from a different time under different circumstances?

Why don't we look?

[Dramatic music]

I want to warn the court

that what you're about to see

is of a graphic, sexual nature

'and that the purpose of viewing it here today'

'is to shed light on the very serious matter before us.'

Rod, what's this camera doing in here?

Oh, my god! What are you doing?

- 'What?' - 'no, keep going.'

I was just acting, keep going.

(Rodney) 'You like it? You like it, don't you?'

[both moaning]

Oh, get your hands off me, yes!

'Don't stop, don't stop!'

(Rodney) 'You want it, don't you? Say it!'

(Katrina) 'I want it.'

'hurt me.'

hurt me.

[Breathing heavily]

'Hurt me.'

how would you describe this sexual encounter?

Was it rape?

- No. - So, it was consensual?

Objection, the witness is not a sexual behaviorist.

Sustained.

The tape we just saw was recorded several years ago

but for all we know Katrina Moore continued having

perverted sexual encounters just like this

with any number of men, isn't that true?

Objection, the victim's sexual history

is not on trial here.

Stay on track, counselor.

Is it possible that my client

had rough sex with Katrina Moore

'on the night in question?'

the kind of sex depicted on this DVD.

Katrina Moore was brutally strangled.

Did they happen simultaneously?

Can you determine a precise window of time

between the sexual encounter and the strangulation?

- Not precisely, no. - 'No?'

'so, five minutes, ten minutes'

an hour could've passed.

- 'Correct?' - yes.

In other words, it is entirely plausible

that my client left after having consensual sex

'with Katrina Moore, and afterwards'

someone else killed her.

'Maybe her fiance'

'or some other unknown sexual partner.'

- objection. - Overruled.

Is it possible?

Yes.

How could you let that happen?

I mean, he just showed a porn movie of..

Do you have any idea what this is doing to me?

To Katrina's memory?

Okay, it's not as bad as it seems.

We have a strong case for murder.

So the defense is throwing mud at the victim, it's a stunt.

'And we're gonna make sure the jury sees through it.'

but, this could get worse before it gets better.

How is that possible?

The defense is putting Rodney on the stand.

I-It's a last-ditch effort to cast him in a favorable light.

You can't let him go up there

and say whatever sicko thing he damn well pleases.

(Maureen) 'We're going to cross examine him tomorrow, Jeffrey.'

this is a good thing.

We're gonna try to get him to incriminate

himself in open court.

Look, Jeffrey, the tape hurt us

but this trial's not over, you can't lose hope.

Hope is something I don't have a lot of right now.

The DVD was bad, but there were parts in there

the judge wouldn't let be shown in court

that were a lot worse.

Katrina had her wild side.

All rise.

'The state of Indiana versus Rodney Allen Wallace.'

the honorable judge salter presiding.

Be seated, come to order.

Defense council, you can call your next witness.

Your honor, the defense calls Rodney Wallace to the stand.

[Gunshots]

[People screaming]

[Gunshot]

Freeze! Freeze! Keep your hands up!

Somebody call an ambulance!

[Dramatic music]

[Indistinct chatter]

[Dramatic music]

Jeffrey.

Why?

Why did you do this?

I had to. For Kat.

I don't think there's a person in that courtroom

who doesn't feel for you.

But the fact is, you shot a man.

He's dead.

Do you have any idea what he stole from us?

Do you?

Kat and I were gonna start a family.

You didn't give the system a chance, it was working.

No.

I kept looking at the jury.

They were gonna let him go, I could feel it.

I know what I did was wrong.

But I loved her.

I loved her so much.

She was such a good person.

Jeffrey, I talked to the foreman.

'The DVD had no bearing at all.'

they were gonna convict.

[Sighing]

(Steve) How did this happen?

How did he get the gun in the courthouse?

(Maureen) 'The guard searched his bag'

but the gun was hidden in an inside pocket.

It's my fault.

He caught me outside, we walked in together

through the attorney's entrance.

No, it's the guard's job to insure security.

Everybody knows if you walk in with a prosecutor

you barely get a second glance.

Don't be so hard on yourself.

Security didn't do their job.

She's a perfectionist, she doesn't know

how to give herself a break.

That said, you are gonna have to

talk to internal affairs

and prepare a statement for the press.

And the judge is gonna declare a mistrial

and with it goes hundreds of hours of this office's time.

In the meantime, we need to decide

how to handle the shooter.

'Take ten, get yourself together.'

we'll meet in my office.

- Annabeth. - Hmm?

Mm.

I thought you quit when you got..

Nah, I wasn't gonna light it.

I always loved smoking.

I can't..

For the life of me, remember why I quit.

My mom smoked through her pregnancy

and I have photos to prove it.

Where did you get that?

My purse.

Don't tell Jack.

I was never any good at smoking.

I tried

but I'm not a very good deviant

no matter how much I wanna be.

I've prosecuted dozens of murder cases.

But this one happened right in front of me, you know?

I walked the guy with a gun into the courtroom.

It wasn't your fault.

'Hey.'

it wasn't your fault.

Thanks, Maureen.

This is a really disgusting habit, isn't it?

Ugh, I wish someone would just..

Outlaw it and spare me the trouble of being tempted.

Jeffrey Drake smuggled a loaded gun into the courtroom

and shot Mr. Wallace three times at close range.

Now, there is no doubt in my mind

that he meticulously planned this

and that he intended to kill him.

Which means, we have every right

to charge Jeffrey Drake with murder.

As much as I hate what went on in that courthouse

Jeffrey wasn't in his right mind.

He just lost the love of his life.

He's not a cold-blooded killer.

So, what are you saying?

I-I'm saying that if I were on that jury

I don't think I'd convict.

Not for murder, not for life in prison.

(Maureen) Is that the message we want to send?

People can take the law into their own hands

if they don't like the way a trial is going?

But putting a bereaved fiance

through a murder trial and losing

is not gonna make it any better.

He's already given this office a black eye

we need to cut our losses.

It wasn't too long ago

we are less than half a generation out

from the days when men stood outside of jails with ropes

because they didn't like the legal process.

Why do you think I became a prosecutor?

(Steve) I get that.

And I don't like this any more than you do.

But annabeth is right.

Any juror this side of the Bible belt

will not put Jeffrey in jail for this

which means if we take this to trial, he will walk.

That's a free pass, Maureen, versus, uh..

Voluntary man?

We need to make a deal.

He murdered a man

the law presumes to be innocent

until proven guilty, and we should stand up for that.

Voluntary manslaughter is not a slap on the wrist.

He should do jail time.

Then get with his lawyer and see that he does.

I know you're devastated.

And our hearts went out to you throughout this entire ordeal.

But that does not excuse what you've done.

(Male #2) 'I doubt that you will find a judge'

who will even make my client post bail

for taking out the man who raped

'and murdered his bride'

'the night before they were married.'

he packed a gun in his bag.

It's a crime of passion

it's involuntary.

He voluntarily pulled the trigger.

No jury is gonna give him jail time.

It's involuntary manslaughter, or we're done here.

Involuntary is two-to-eight.

- Suspended. - Forget it.

Four years with possibility

'which means he serves two'

or I'm done here.

Done.

(Jeffrey) 'I just snapped.'

'i couldn't sleep.'

'and every time I closed my eyes..'

'...i kept seeing that tape of them having sex.'

like animals.

So I got a gun.

And I hid it in my bag.

And I snuck it into the courtroom.

And I killed him..

For what he did to my girl.

To Katrina.

I can still see rod's mug.

It was like he was

winking at me through the camera

while he was violating the woman

that I was gonna marry.

He kept calling Katrina a bitch.

A damn bitch, a dirty bitch.

It was like raping her

and murdering her wasn't enough.

He had to ruin her reputation

and humiliate my family.

So I shot him.

Are you satisfied?

I have to show the tape to my boss.

Get it transcribed and prepared for signatures.

We can sign the papers in my office tomorrow morning.

Outstanding. We'll see you then.

[Dramatic music]

Do you have a copy of the DVD played in court?

- The sex tape? - 'Yeah.'

uh.. Yeah, here.

Rod, what's this camera doing in here?

Oh, my god, what are you doing?

What?

The judge ruled to exclude this section of the DVD.

[Moaning]

(Rodney) You know you want it, bitch.

'You know you want it!'

'damn bitch, dirty bitch.'

Jeffrey referred to that in his confession.

'That was never played in court.'

I'm not following.

He kept calling Katrina a bitch.

'A damn bitch, a dirty bitch.'

the only way he could've known about this is

if he'd seen the DVD before it was presented in court.

And if he'd seen it before, then he knew about Rodney.

- And her past. - About the marriage.

I am so not liking where this is going.

So, if Jeffrey Drake knew about Rodney and the tape

why didn't he report it immediately?

Because Jeffrey Drake and Rodney Wallace

were in this together somehow.

'That's what we're saying, right?'

it looks like Katrina's past

and future were conspiring

to end her present.

(Steve) 'We just need to prove it.'

where are we on the plea agreement?

Oh, we have the deal, it hasn't been entered, yet.

He's supposed to come in tomorrow to sign it.

[Scoffs] And he's out on bail.

'Okay, stall him for a few days.'

but be careful, don't tip Jeffrey off.

He catches wind of this and he's guilty

he's on the first plane to Mexico.

Okay, tell me you got something.

I wanna know the whole how

when and the why of the Jeffrey-Rodney connection.

Maureen's trying to suss out the sister

without letting on what we're doing.

See if we can tie Jeffrey to Rodney.

But, since the police were never looking to connect them

we're thinking maybe there's something we missed.

"To see what is in front of your nose

is a constant struggle." George orwell.

I found something interesting.

Rodney was allowed one call a day

while being held at county during the trial.

Guess who he called the day

before Jeffrey shot him in court.

- Jeffrey. - What?

Rodney called Jeffrey from jail?

Their conversation lasted four minutes.

And the following morning Jeffrey shot him.

Geez, was it something he said?

Okay, okay.

The man who raped and killed the bride

the night before her wedding

called her fiance from jail.

What does at prove?

It proves they knew each other.

And now we need to prove

conspiracy to commit murder.

(Female #1) 'I haven't been able to bring myself'

to touch any of Kat's things since it happened.

When my grandmother died, it took us six months

to go through her things.

And then what did you do with everything?

Am I supposed to give a wedding dress to charity?

There's no easy way to do this.

- Do you mind if I look around? - No.

Do you know if your sister told Jeffrey about her past?

About Rodney?

I thought I was the only one who knew about Rodney.

I didn't even know that they'd been married.

Did Katrina keep a diary?

Did she keep old letters?

'Day planners, anything we might've missed?'

not that I'm aware of.

What's all this?

That's stuff that the hotel sent back.

It was in the honeymoon suite.

Kat had it all planned out.

She had stacked the fridge

with champagne and strawberries.

Do you know what's on this?

Kat told me that she had made a DVD

to give to Jeffrey on their wedding night, but..

I couldn't bring myself to watch it.

I keep spinning my wheels on this one.

If Rodney Wallace was coming to Indianapolis

to kill Katrina, then why get a one-way plane ticket?

'How was he expecting to get back to Texas?'

- rental car? - No.

He turned his in the day before we picked him up.

He killed his ex, then turned his rental car in

with no way of getting home?

That is weird.

Whoa.

According to his intake report when we arrested him

Rodney had the keys to a 2005 Cadillac

listed among his affects.

Doesn't Jeffrey's family own a dealership?

Uh-huh.

You think Jeffrey gave Rodney a Cadillac for killing Katrina?

I'll check with the impound lot to see if any cars

were towed away from the motel.

And have your guys check Jeffrey's work phone records

and e-mails to see if there was any communication.

I got a buddy in the Houston pd

who says rod owed his bookie $40,000.

And he's got a price on his head.

Oh, we need to find that Cadillac.

You gotta see what's on here.

Jeffrey.

Let me ask you something.

Do you recognize this car?

It's a 2005 caddy.

The vin number indicates

it came from your dealership.

Where are you going with this?

Well, the terms of the deal stipulate

that Jeffrey be completely forthright with us

on all aspects of the crime

otherwise the deal is off

'and we'll charge you for Rodney's murder.'

I gave that car to Katrina as a wedding gift.

Any idea how the keys

ended up in Rodney's possession?

M-Maybe she gave it to him somehow.

Maybe he was blackmailing her.

Are you sure you never came into contact with Rodney?

Of course I'm sure.

I had no idea about a previous marriage

or even who Rodney was.

'If I had known anything'

I would have come to you immediately.

My god.

The man killed my fiancee.

We have evidence that shows

you gave a $40,000 car to Rodney Wallace.

'You forged the title'

you took it off the books and you spread the cost

around your inventory.

'You're a smart guy, Jeffrey'

but you hired an amateur to kill your fiancee.

So Rodney has a car from Jeff's lot, big deal.

It doesn't even begin to prove conspiracy to commit murder

if that's where you're going.

Why did you call Texas

from your work phone?

And why were you exchanging e-mails

'with a man you claim you didn't know existed?'

'and why did he call you from jail'

on your cell phone the night before you killed him?

This is all circumstantial.

Really? Well, then what is this?

Katrina left this for you in your honeymoon suite..

For the morning after your wedding.

(Katrina on TV) 'If you're seeing this now, Jeffrey, we're married.'

'this video is for you'

'and only you.'

'so you know how grateful I am'

'for marrying me and loving me'

forgiving my past.

My sins, my mistakes

especially rod.

'I would've understood if you walked away three weeks ago'

'but you showed me your true self'

and you still wanted to marry me.

(Male #2) 'Jeffrey, as your lawyer'

I'm advising you not to say anything further.

Your client played us.

You knew about Katrina's past and you couldn't forgive her.

'Tell me, how did it work?'

did Rodney blackmail her

or did he blackmail you?

Rodney called Katrina three weeks before

our wedding to blackmail her.

I know because she told me.

She told me everything.

About the marriage.

All of it.

So I called up this Rodney character

and I told him to take a hike.

Then he sent me a tape

of them having sex.

She never said anything about that.

And that..

Was it.

So you had her killed because she lied to you?

Why not just cancel the wedding and walk away?

She was supposed to be a virgin!

I was saving myself!

For what?

So she could use me

and my family and my money?

So she could humiliate me.

There were 750 people showing up that day

to watch us take our vows before god.

I don't believe in divorce.

'So, what?'

I'm to be saddled

with a whore for a wife?

'If she wasn't a pervert'

and a liar and a slut

none of this would've happened.

None of it!

(Katrina on TV) I chose your favorite passage to be read at our wedding.

First corinthians.

"Faith, hope, charity

the greatest of these is charity."

'Some translations it reads'

"faith, hope and love."

'That's you, Jeffrey.'

'you've showed me what love is.'

love is forgiveness.

Forgiveness?

Forgiveness for what?

She told him the truth.

I don't think he understood her.

And I think he loved the idea of her.

I think he was in love with the idea of a virgin.

So he paid her ex-husband to kill her.

"Love is patient

love is kind.."

My maid of honor read this passage at my wedding.

(Katrina on TV) '"...It keeps no record of wrongs.'

"love does not delight in evil

"but rejoices in truth.

Love bears all things and believes..."

"all things, hopes all things

"endures all things.

"When I was a child I spoke as a child

'"I understood as a child'

'"I thought as a child'

'"but when I grew up, I put away childish things.'

'"and now abide faith, hope, and love.'

'"these three.'

'but the greatest of these is love."'

(Annabeth) Stay tuned for scenes from our next episode.

[Theme music]