Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:00,423 --> 00:00:05,757
In the criminal justice system, all defendants
are innocent until proven guilty
2
00:00:05,863 --> 00:00:10,141
either by confession,
plea bargain, or trial by jury.
3
00:00:10,300 --> 00:00:12,465
This is one of those trials.
4
00:00:14,510 --> 00:00:16,675
She said she was staying
with her friend Jennifer.
5
00:00:17,045 --> 00:00:19,158
Out near us at Woodhaven.
6
00:00:20,109 --> 00:00:24,704
When the police called,
they said they found a body.
7
00:00:24,841 --> 00:00:28,720
I thought, "That can't be our daughter."
8
00:00:28,885 --> 00:00:32,764
We knew she was seeing Justin,
but we liked him.
9
00:00:34,310 --> 00:00:36,539
I can't imagine how this could happen.
10
00:00:36,951 --> 00:00:39,427
- I thought Kristen went home.
- Home?
11
00:00:39,592 --> 00:00:43,305
Somebody put two bullets in her head
100 yards from your front door, Justin.
12
00:00:43,582 --> 00:00:45,566
That's your girlfriend.
You don't seem too upset.
13
00:00:45,641 --> 00:00:47,137
I'm upset!
14
00:00:47,472 --> 00:00:50,773
- I'm totally freaked out!
- Let's talk about your buddy Carter.
15
00:00:50,938 --> 00:00:54,157
Carter, you knew Kristen Ames,
Justin's girlfriend?
16
00:00:54,322 --> 00:00:57,788
- I mean, I saw her, yeah.
- You saying you never talked to her?
17
00:00:57,870 --> 00:01:00,676
Like last night before she was killed?
18
00:01:01,129 --> 00:01:05,255
Yeah, actually, uh...
You know, I saw her with her ex.
19
00:01:05,338 --> 00:01:07,814
Her ex-boyfriend, Danny Wallace.
20
00:01:08,144 --> 00:01:12,105
So, Danny, you dated Kristen.
You got dumped.
21
00:01:12,188 --> 00:01:15,901
She starts banging your friend Justin.
Gotta be hard to take.
22
00:01:15,984 --> 00:01:19,285
- That's not how it was.
- What time did you leave last night?
23
00:01:20,770 --> 00:01:22,834
I don't remember.
24
00:01:23,172 --> 00:01:25,978
She was arguing with Danny, not me.
25
00:01:26,060 --> 00:01:30,269
- About what?
- I don't know, they were outside.
26
00:01:30,362 --> 00:01:33,158
And then Justin went out,
you know, to make sure she was okay.
27
00:01:33,240 --> 00:01:35,634
Next thing I heard,
a gun capped two times.
28
00:01:35,716 --> 00:01:38,357
- Danny shot her?
- That's what Justin said.
29
00:01:38,522 --> 00:01:41,411
- Carter told us you did it.
- He's lying.
30
00:01:41,750 --> 00:01:46,124
Kristen told me
Justin and Carter raped her.
31
00:01:46,206 --> 00:01:47,857
I was passed out.
32
00:01:47,857 --> 00:01:49,755
She wanted to go to the cops,
33
00:01:49,804 --> 00:01:53,039
Justin followed her, chased her into
Tompkins Square Park.
34
00:01:53,171 --> 00:01:54,887
He shot her.
35
00:01:55,746 --> 00:02:00,433
- Justin shot her?
- There was nothing I could do, I swear.
36
00:02:02,085 --> 00:02:04,990
- Am I under arrest?
- Not yet, Justin.
37
00:02:05,584 --> 00:02:07,234
But I'd get comfortable.
38
00:02:10,139 --> 00:02:13,440
I wanna call my father.
I want a lawyer.
39
00:02:13,903 --> 00:02:15,619
Justin lawyered up,
40
00:02:15,751 --> 00:02:18,392
and we have conflicting
statements from the other two.
41
00:02:18,590 --> 00:02:21,759
Danny says he saw it go down.
You buy that?
42
00:02:22,045 --> 00:02:24,421
Well, I might have...
43
00:02:24,421 --> 00:02:26,402
Until he took off his jacket.
44
00:02:27,326 --> 00:02:29,637
Nitrate. Gunshot residue?
45
00:02:29,769 --> 00:02:32,014
I'm gonna log it into evidence.
Test for GSR.
46
00:02:32,014 --> 00:02:35,711
All right, I'll get a statement from Danny
and try to get one from Carter.
47
00:02:35,777 --> 00:02:38,682
And you can charge 'em all
with second degree murder.
48
00:02:38,814 --> 00:02:40,267
You know...
49
00:02:40,531 --> 00:02:42,511
I almost believed the kid.
50
00:02:43,735 --> 00:02:45,584
Everybody lies.
51
00:02:48,965 --> 00:03:00,570
Law and Order Trial by Jury
Episode 1x04 - Truth or Consequences
52
00:03:01,537 --> 00:03:15,560
Transcript provided by Raceman
Subtitles: Csivore, Nick Eads, Silverado.
53
00:03:17,011 --> 00:03:29,261
www.forom.com
www.lawandorder-fr.com
54
00:03:35,506 --> 00:03:38,312
Her blood alcohol was four times the limit.
55
00:03:38,395 --> 00:03:42,521
We know Carter and Justin had sex with her,
probably while she was passed out.
56
00:03:42,686 --> 00:03:44,254
Apparently, Danny didn't.
57
00:03:44,419 --> 00:03:47,885
It looks like when she realized she'd been raped,
she threatened to go to the police.
58
00:03:48,050 --> 00:03:50,444
Danny claims he offered to take her.
59
00:03:50,591 --> 00:03:52,365
He says Justin followed them,
60
00:03:52,462 --> 00:03:55,011
pulled her intoTompkins Square Park,
and killed her.
61
00:03:55,704 --> 00:03:57,533
What are you gonna show the Grand Jury?
62
00:03:58,309 --> 00:04:00,221
Well, the gun's probably in the Hudson.
63
00:04:00,609 --> 00:04:03,519
Carter's prints are on shell casings
found at the scene.
64
00:04:04,072 --> 00:04:06,400
And there's nitrates on Danny's jacket,
65
00:04:06,537 --> 00:04:08,921
maybe used to muffle gun shots.
66
00:04:08,948 --> 00:04:11,553
Well, that gets you Danny and Carter,
but what about this third kid?
67
00:04:11,637 --> 00:04:13,272
Well, Justin's our weakest case.
68
00:04:13,410 --> 00:04:15,433
He lawyered up, and we don't
have a statement from him.
69
00:04:15,460 --> 00:04:16,818
We can't even prove rape.
70
00:04:16,901 --> 00:04:19,894
Justin was dating the victim.
The sex could have been consensual.
71
00:04:20,031 --> 00:04:21,278
Doesn't sound like much.
72
00:04:21,971 --> 00:04:23,828
Turn one of the other two against Justin.
73
00:04:23,939 --> 00:04:25,989
Well, Danny's the testimony we need.
74
00:04:26,182 --> 00:04:28,759
He claims he saw the murder
go down, but wasn't part of it.
75
00:04:28,842 --> 00:04:30,976
But Carter's statement
points the finger at Danny.
76
00:04:32,499 --> 00:04:33,525
The poor girl.
77
00:04:34,411 --> 00:04:36,379
The thought of losing
a daughter like that.
78
00:04:37,708 --> 00:04:40,258
Try to make a deal,
but everybody does real time.
79
00:04:40,701 --> 00:04:41,976
Two out of three won't do.
80
00:04:46,151 --> 00:04:48,700
Danny, I'm Dean Conners.
81
00:04:48,783 --> 00:04:50,585
The court assigned me to your case.
82
00:04:50,834 --> 00:04:53,578
- I spoke to your mother.
- That was my grandma.
83
00:04:54,276 --> 00:04:56,909
- My mom's not around.
- Well, then your grandmother.
84
00:04:57,131 --> 00:04:58,323
She's coming to the arraignment.
85
00:04:59,015 --> 00:05:01,066
I'll try to arrange a chance for you to speak.
86
00:05:01,148 --> 00:05:03,060
She doesn't need this kind of grief.
87
00:05:03,199 --> 00:05:07,106
I was just thinking if we needed
to raise money for bail.
88
00:05:07,604 --> 00:05:10,791
I'm not gonna take her money.
She gets some Social Security.
89
00:05:13,699 --> 00:05:15,972
Um, so you spoke to the police.
90
00:05:17,108 --> 00:05:18,272
I told them the truth.
91
00:05:18,880 --> 00:05:22,982
Kristen said that Justin and Carter had raped her,
so I was taking her to the cops.
92
00:05:23,287 --> 00:05:25,864
Justin followed us and shot her.
93
00:05:27,769 --> 00:05:29,405
When that happened, what did you do?
94
00:05:29,488 --> 00:05:31,483
I took off like a coward.
95
00:05:36,114 --> 00:05:39,911
Do you know if they collected any evidence
that could implicate you in the shooting?
96
00:05:39,966 --> 00:05:41,684
I don't know, they took my jacket.
97
00:05:42,544 --> 00:05:43,763
Why did they do that?
98
00:05:44,981 --> 00:05:45,618
Look,
99
00:05:46,644 --> 00:05:48,972
I didn't kill Kristen, I swear.
100
00:05:50,217 --> 00:05:52,240
Danny, look...
101
00:05:53,127 --> 00:05:54,513
I'm not here to judge you.
102
00:05:55,815 --> 00:05:57,229
Or to judge what you've done.
103
00:05:57,782 --> 00:05:59,389
I'm here to advocate for you.
104
00:06:00,248 --> 00:06:00,941
Yeah.
105
00:06:01,494 --> 00:06:02,492
You don't believe me.
106
00:06:02,741 --> 00:06:04,570
- Danny.
- No, you don't. No.
107
00:06:05,900 --> 00:06:07,175
Neither did the cops.
108
00:06:08,726 --> 00:06:09,973
Everyone thinks I'm guilty.
109
00:06:12,772 --> 00:06:13,880
I believe you.
110
00:06:14,904 --> 00:06:15,902
Okay?
111
00:06:18,700 --> 00:06:21,000
Docket number 3304.
112
00:06:21,028 --> 00:06:23,993
People v. Justin Birch.
Charge is murder in the second degree.
113
00:06:24,464 --> 00:06:26,737
- How do you plead?
- Not guilty.
114
00:06:26,846 --> 00:06:29,313
Your Honor, this defendant
has the resources and means to flee.
115
00:06:29,340 --> 00:06:31,419
Given the charge, the people ask for remand.
116
00:06:31,473 --> 00:06:34,466
We ask for ROR to his parents pending trial.
117
00:06:34,937 --> 00:06:36,378
Counsel, approach.
118
00:06:41,144 --> 00:06:42,474
What can we live with here?
119
00:06:42,528 --> 00:06:46,657
Your Honor, I have to seriously question
the legitimacy of the charges.
120
00:06:46,933 --> 00:06:48,069
They have no evidence.
121
00:06:48,124 --> 00:06:50,064
The defense'll get their
discovery when it's time.
122
00:06:50,120 --> 00:06:53,612
Okay, you don't want to show your hand,
fine, counselor, but you'll have to bend.
123
00:06:53,666 --> 00:06:55,633
The victim's parents are here, Your Honor,
124
00:06:55,661 --> 00:06:57,795
expecting to see him held
for their daughter's murder.
125
00:06:57,823 --> 00:07:00,483
So I'll set the bail at 800,000,
and you'll argue it.
126
00:07:00,510 --> 00:07:01,480
And we'll accept it.
127
00:07:01,545 --> 00:07:03,891
From what I understand,
this kid's parents can just write a check.
128
00:07:03,946 --> 00:07:06,995
Look, I said I'll make you look good.
Both of you, step back.
129
00:07:10,120 --> 00:07:12,310
Bail is set at 800,000.
130
00:07:12,337 --> 00:07:16,661
On bond, the defendant will be held
under house arrest with an ankle bracelet.
131
00:07:16,661 --> 00:07:17,603
Next.
132
00:07:20,042 --> 00:07:24,421
I'll have my office draw up the paperwork.
And Justin should be out of here by lunch.
133
00:07:32,285 --> 00:07:34,335
Docket number 33005.
134
00:07:34,391 --> 00:07:37,412
People v. Daniel Wallace.
Charge is murder in the second degree.
135
00:07:37,664 --> 00:07:38,717
Do we have a plea?
136
00:07:39,105 --> 00:07:40,519
Not guilty, Your Honor.
137
00:07:40,573 --> 00:07:44,563
The people would prefer remand, but we'll agree
to the previous bail recommendation.
138
00:07:44,730 --> 00:07:46,143
$800,000?
139
00:07:46,725 --> 00:07:50,023
Your Honor, the people know
my client is without means.
140
00:07:50,382 --> 00:07:52,737
Will the court at least accept a surety of ten percent?
141
00:07:52,765 --> 00:07:54,456
Not on a murder charge.
142
00:07:54,981 --> 00:07:57,808
So the poor sit in jail
while the rich walk free?
143
00:07:57,946 --> 00:08:00,385
So it goes, Mr. Conners.
144
00:08:02,622 --> 00:08:05,065
Docket number 33006.
145
00:08:05,142 --> 00:08:08,916
People v. Carter McSherry.
Charge of murder in the second degree.
146
00:08:12,341 --> 00:08:14,017
The night we first met Danny...
147
00:08:14,481 --> 00:08:16,338
Kristen missed her curfew.
148
00:08:16,947 --> 00:08:19,525
Danny brought her home.
They were both drunk.
149
00:08:20,107 --> 00:08:21,631
And George and I stepped in.
150
00:08:22,549 --> 00:08:24,017
I called his parents.
151
00:08:26,068 --> 00:08:28,563
Well, his grandmother.
His parents aren't even in the picture.
152
00:08:31,443 --> 00:08:33,494
How do you expect a kid like that
to be raised right?
153
00:08:34,769 --> 00:08:36,155
To have good values?
154
00:08:38,349 --> 00:08:40,233
I was worried that Kristen was seeing him.
155
00:08:42,340 --> 00:08:45,444
And now you telling me you're gonna offer
this little son of a bitch a deal?
156
00:08:45,545 --> 00:08:47,014
Well, Danny will serve time.
157
00:08:47,070 --> 00:08:51,365
We're offering him 15 to 25 years
for his testimony against Justin.
158
00:08:51,421 --> 00:08:53,970
All three are responsible
for what happened to Kristen.
159
00:08:54,026 --> 00:08:55,162
15 years?
160
00:08:55,438 --> 00:08:57,405
Not 15 years for our daughter's life.
161
00:08:57,461 --> 00:09:00,315
Mr. Ames, you blame Danny
and I understand that.
162
00:09:00,480 --> 00:09:02,254
But Justin Birch killed her.
163
00:09:02,475 --> 00:09:04,942
A plea from Danny will help us get him.
164
00:09:05,053 --> 00:09:07,214
Kristen didn't get any kind of deal.
165
00:09:09,000 --> 00:09:15,074
Advertise your product or brand here
contact www.OpenSubtitles.org today
166
00:09:16,314 --> 00:09:17,340
That went well.
167
00:09:17,520 --> 00:09:20,152
Well, what plea agreement
ever made everybody happy?
168
00:09:20,236 --> 00:09:22,037
- I'm just saying that...
- Kelly,
169
00:09:22,092 --> 00:09:24,254
we didn't come here for their permission.
170
00:09:24,530 --> 00:09:27,107
A little more reassurance
might have helped, you know?
171
00:09:27,135 --> 00:09:30,100
Some guarantee that he'll be punished.
172
00:09:30,320 --> 00:09:32,759
It would have been a lie.
173
00:09:33,064 --> 00:09:36,223
Well, you brought us down here
for a sneak peek at discovery,
174
00:09:36,388 --> 00:09:38,384
or do I smell a plea bargain?
175
00:09:40,241 --> 00:09:42,430
Your client's conviction is right here.
176
00:09:44,091 --> 00:09:45,117
What's the offer?
177
00:09:45,309 --> 00:09:49,660
For testimony against Justin,
15 to 25, concurrent on all counts.
178
00:09:49,688 --> 00:09:54,482
Tracey, the problem is,
our guys aren't equally guilty here.
179
00:09:54,730 --> 00:09:56,532
He's right, my guy didn't even
leave the apartment.
180
00:09:56,586 --> 00:09:59,302
Peter, I'll be honest.
I know you wanna clear your case.
181
00:09:59,413 --> 00:10:01,741
But Danny's the witness.
He's the one I wanna flip.
182
00:10:01,796 --> 00:10:03,182
So, you're wasting my time.
183
00:10:03,625 --> 00:10:05,399
No, you're plan B.
184
00:10:05,759 --> 00:10:07,200
Danny won't cop to rape.
185
00:10:08,030 --> 00:10:10,053
He didn't witness it,
he only saw the shooting.
186
00:10:10,109 --> 00:10:12,159
Kibre, you need my guy.
187
00:10:12,989 --> 00:10:14,431
Carter gave Justin the gun.
188
00:10:14,486 --> 00:10:16,786
He can give you the rape
and the conspiracy.
189
00:10:17,756 --> 00:10:18,782
Danny can't do that.
190
00:10:23,491 --> 00:10:25,376
All right, that'll get Carter a plea.
191
00:10:26,620 --> 00:10:28,034
But I still want Danny.
192
00:10:29,031 --> 00:10:29,863
I'll talk to him.
193
00:10:31,636 --> 00:10:34,103
They found gunshot residue on your jacket.
194
00:10:34,186 --> 00:10:36,431
If we go to trial,
they very well could convict you.
195
00:10:36,707 --> 00:10:38,175
I wasn't wearing my jacket.
196
00:10:39,755 --> 00:10:42,637
- Justin's gonna walk?
- He's in a position to do that.
197
00:10:43,384 --> 00:10:47,236
He's got all this money,
fancy lawyers. I got what?
198
00:10:49,203 --> 00:10:51,364
It's unfair, I agree.
199
00:10:52,473 --> 00:10:54,884
But Justin's money won't matter
if you cooperate.
200
00:10:55,409 --> 00:10:58,319
Carter's getting the same deal.
Well, Carter raped her.
201
00:10:58,733 --> 00:11:02,031
- Justin shot her. All I did...
- Danny, they got evidence against you.
202
00:11:02,667 --> 00:11:03,693
It's a good offer.
203
00:11:03,970 --> 00:11:06,214
So I'm supposed to say
I'm guilty of something I didn't do.
204
00:11:06,270 --> 00:11:07,545
Well, that's your decision.
205
00:11:08,542 --> 00:11:11,314
But I recommend you take the deal.
206
00:11:20,463 --> 00:11:22,153
We left Justin's place.
207
00:11:22,561 --> 00:11:25,721
I put my jacket on her shoulders
'cause it was pretty cold.
208
00:11:26,746 --> 00:11:28,298
Justin followed us.
209
00:11:29,793 --> 00:11:33,202
He was pretty drunk. He kept threatening her
about if she went to the cops.
210
00:11:33,839 --> 00:11:35,641
Kristen stood up to him, you know?
211
00:11:36,942 --> 00:11:37,912
She pissed him off.
212
00:11:38,189 --> 00:11:41,071
- What did Justin do?
- He hit her in the face.
213
00:11:41,652 --> 00:11:45,088
He pulled a gun.
I was so scared I... I couldn't move.
214
00:11:45,199 --> 00:11:46,446
Where were you all standing?
215
00:11:47,525 --> 00:11:48,883
At the entrance over there.
216
00:11:50,823 --> 00:11:52,181
How did you wind up in here?
217
00:11:53,427 --> 00:11:56,392
Well, she, uh, ran.
218
00:11:56,642 --> 00:11:58,970
And, uh, he chased her,
219
00:12:00,031 --> 00:12:01,629
and he grabbed her arm.
220
00:12:03,789 --> 00:12:06,339
I mean, it happened so fast.
He was cursing at her.
221
00:12:06,366 --> 00:12:09,692
And she's crying, trying to get away.
222
00:12:09,718 --> 00:12:13,072
And then he just started shooting her.
223
00:12:13,487 --> 00:12:15,150
Did he aim the gun at you?
224
00:12:15,400 --> 00:12:16,148
No.
225
00:12:16,978 --> 00:12:17,976
Well, Danny...
226
00:12:18,585 --> 00:12:22,049
You could have shouted for help.
You could have made a run for the police.
227
00:12:22,658 --> 00:12:23,655
I should have.
228
00:12:24,764 --> 00:12:29,060
I wanted to, but I froze.
229
00:12:30,084 --> 00:12:32,273
And then she was gone.
230
00:12:32,772 --> 00:12:34,407
And there was nothing
that I could really do.
231
00:12:40,000 --> 00:12:40,997
Are we done now?
232
00:12:44,157 --> 00:12:45,764
Sure, Danny, we're done.
233
00:12:57,761 --> 00:13:00,366
So you bright Carter and Danny.
234
00:13:00,366 --> 00:13:03,858
I knew you'd flip one...
But, uh, are we in trouble?
235
00:13:03,969 --> 00:13:06,463
Just makes it a
stronger case against Justin.
236
00:13:06,491 --> 00:13:09,068
Oh, please, they can't even
get their stories straight.
237
00:13:09,151 --> 00:13:12,144
Danny says that Justin did the girl.
Carter says that Danny did it.
238
00:13:12,171 --> 00:13:13,307
Then why worry?
239
00:13:14,415 --> 00:13:16,355
You know, you're wasting
your time in the DA's office.
240
00:13:16,411 --> 00:13:17,464
I'd triple what you make.
241
00:13:17,712 --> 00:13:20,012
You don't want me, Norman.
I have scruples.
242
00:13:20,040 --> 00:13:21,425
They have pills for that.
243
00:13:23,713 --> 00:13:26,345
We got two pleas, why not three?
244
00:13:26,678 --> 00:13:29,255
What's the problem, Norman?
My client is innocent.
245
00:13:29,699 --> 00:13:31,528
Well, you can tell that to a jury.
246
00:13:31,583 --> 00:13:33,634
Selection begins three weeks from tomorrow.
247
00:13:33,754 --> 00:13:35,915
Now, Tracey, what about
this motion in limine?
248
00:13:35,999 --> 00:13:39,130
The sexual history of Kristen Ames
is important to our defense.
249
00:13:39,156 --> 00:13:42,094
It's irrelevant, Your Honor.
His client is facing murder charges.
250
00:13:42,122 --> 00:13:45,669
There's a count of aggravated rape which is
an issue at the heart of the people's case.
251
00:13:45,695 --> 00:13:49,686
- It's an excuse to sling mud.
- The victim was known to be promiscuous.
252
00:13:49,796 --> 00:13:54,756
She had sex with my client and
with Carter McSherry that night by choice.
253
00:13:55,337 --> 00:14:00,270
The victim's questionable virtue goes directly
to Danny Wallace's state of mind.
254
00:14:00,409 --> 00:14:02,182
She had sex with two men.
255
00:14:02,513 --> 00:14:05,063
Danny Wallace killed her out of jealousy.
256
00:14:05,118 --> 00:14:06,670
I read the briefs.
257
00:14:07,502 --> 00:14:08,721
You're reaching, counselor.
258
00:14:10,107 --> 00:14:11,049
Anything else?
259
00:14:12,016 --> 00:14:13,929
All right, see you at trial.
260
00:14:15,342 --> 00:14:18,945
Kristen was passed out.
But she woke up while we were doing it.
261
00:14:19,333 --> 00:14:21,356
When she woke up, what was Justin doing?
262
00:14:21,964 --> 00:14:24,458
- Holding her down, I guess.
- Don't guess, Carter.
263
00:14:24,902 --> 00:14:26,260
Did he hold her by the arms?
264
00:14:26,397 --> 00:14:28,087
Details are important here.
265
00:14:28,170 --> 00:14:31,358
- Okay, he held her by the arms.
- Don't make things up.
266
00:14:31,441 --> 00:14:32,743
What do you want me to say?
267
00:14:32,853 --> 00:14:36,317
Justin said I could bang his girlfriend.
What's the big deal?
268
00:14:36,982 --> 00:14:40,418
You wanna help your client out
with the basics of a declarative sentence?
269
00:14:40,556 --> 00:14:41,747
It's your prep, Kibre.
270
00:14:41,886 --> 00:14:44,214
You wanted this deal.
You help make it work.
271
00:14:44,406 --> 00:14:47,150
The defense will use your original
statement from the police.
272
00:14:47,205 --> 00:14:49,838
The fact that you lied about
giving Justin your gun.
273
00:14:49,894 --> 00:14:51,750
They'll say you were lying then.
You could be lying now.
274
00:14:51,778 --> 00:14:53,275
Well, I ain't lying now.
275
00:14:54,520 --> 00:14:56,654
You know what?
I'm done for the day. I got a headache.
276
00:14:56,765 --> 00:14:58,012
Today's it, Carter.
277
00:14:58,567 --> 00:14:59,204
Carter.
278
00:14:59,563 --> 00:15:01,226
Bitch, I said I'm done!
279
00:15:01,446 --> 00:15:06,268
You're done when I say you're done!
Now sit your ass down and answer the questions!
280
00:15:16,101 --> 00:15:17,764
Kristen and Danny took off.
281
00:15:18,291 --> 00:15:20,868
You know, Justin said for me
to give him my gun.
282
00:15:21,562 --> 00:15:23,973
I asked him, "Why?" You know?
283
00:15:24,305 --> 00:15:27,271
He said that he wasn't gonna
let Kristen go to the cops.
284
00:15:27,326 --> 00:15:28,684
So he was just gonna shut her up.
285
00:15:29,625 --> 00:15:32,286
- Shut her up about the rape.
- Yeah.
286
00:15:33,531 --> 00:15:36,053
So Justin took the gun...
287
00:15:36,524 --> 00:15:38,630
...and followed Kristen and Danny out.
288
00:15:39,488 --> 00:15:40,347
Then what?
289
00:15:44,532 --> 00:15:46,306
What did you see or hear?
290
00:15:48,298 --> 00:15:50,377
Oh, yeah, gunshots.
291
00:15:50,488 --> 00:15:54,672
Later, Justin came back and gave me the gun.
He said he capped the bitch.
292
00:15:56,806 --> 00:15:58,192
Well, his words.
293
00:15:59,687 --> 00:16:03,927
- Did you get rid of the murder weapon?
- I threw it off the Williamsburg bridge.
294
00:16:05,783 --> 00:16:06,808
Nothing further.
295
00:16:08,028 --> 00:16:10,355
Fascinating, Mr. McSherry.
296
00:16:12,543 --> 00:16:15,897
Let's talk a little about why you're here.
297
00:16:16,921 --> 00:16:19,221
The deal you made with the DA.
298
00:16:19,330 --> 00:16:23,765
Life in prison without parole to... what?
299
00:16:24,236 --> 00:16:26,425
15 to 25.
300
00:16:26,591 --> 00:16:27,534
Good deal.
301
00:16:27,865 --> 00:16:32,105
Now, did you discuss with the prosecutor
what you were gonna say here?
302
00:16:32,491 --> 00:16:34,764
Did you get your story straight?
303
00:16:34,819 --> 00:16:36,815
- Objection.
- Sustained.
304
00:16:37,423 --> 00:16:41,220
Now, you've had some past
trouble with the law, correct?
305
00:16:41,691 --> 00:16:44,767
Two assault convictions as a juvenile.
306
00:16:45,015 --> 00:16:46,512
One attempted rape.
307
00:16:47,508 --> 00:16:51,388
You served two years
in a juvenile facility, correct?
308
00:16:51,554 --> 00:16:52,746
Basically, yeah.
309
00:16:53,245 --> 00:16:57,790
An experienced criminal knows
the truth gets you nowhere.
310
00:16:57,816 --> 00:16:58,675
Am I right?
311
00:16:58,952 --> 00:17:03,414
You give the police one version. The DA another.
Whatever they want to hear.
312
00:17:03,607 --> 00:17:07,404
- And you get a better deal.
- Objection. Is there a question here?
313
00:17:07,458 --> 00:17:09,425
Sustained. Mr. Rothenberg?
314
00:17:09,619 --> 00:17:14,746
Justin Birch didn't really kill Kristen Ames.
315
00:17:14,857 --> 00:17:15,938
Did he?
316
00:17:22,919 --> 00:17:25,607
Danny stole my gun earlier that night.
317
00:17:26,077 --> 00:17:29,624
He was mad at Kristen because
she had sex with me and Justin.
318
00:17:30,206 --> 00:17:33,393
I wasn't there,
but Justin said Danny shot her.
319
00:17:33,641 --> 00:17:35,332
Nothing he could do about it.
320
00:17:36,468 --> 00:17:37,854
Chambers, Your Honor?
321
00:17:38,352 --> 00:17:39,239
Let's go.
322
00:17:39,266 --> 00:17:41,649
And can Mr. Voight join us as well?
323
00:17:47,831 --> 00:17:49,549
You want to explain that back flip?
324
00:17:49,660 --> 00:17:51,517
He was thoroughly prepped, Your Honor.
325
00:17:51,572 --> 00:17:53,540
Maybe Mr. Voight should answer that.
326
00:17:54,039 --> 00:17:56,450
Was there any inappropriate
contact between you two?
327
00:17:56,499 --> 00:17:57,691
Absolutely not.
328
00:17:58,384 --> 00:18:01,460
Mr. Voight was debriefed
as part of our discovery.
329
00:18:01,820 --> 00:18:03,677
We had dinner and discussed the case.
330
00:18:04,367 --> 00:18:07,415
- We even split the check.
- Interesting. Where'd you go?
331
00:18:07,887 --> 00:18:08,912
Le Bernardin.
332
00:18:09,633 --> 00:18:11,877
Debriefed over a $300 meal?
333
00:18:12,071 --> 00:18:13,568
Sounds like a job audition.
334
00:18:13,623 --> 00:18:15,757
You're a self-righteous bitch, you know that?
335
00:18:16,338 --> 00:18:18,167
Can I quote that to the Ethics Board?
336
00:18:18,195 --> 00:18:21,105
Hey, you can both cool off in a cell
unless you shut the hell up.
337
00:18:21,242 --> 00:18:24,346
Your Honor, we'd like to redirect
Carter McSherry as a hostile witness.
338
00:18:24,373 --> 00:18:26,895
And examine why
he changed his testimony.
339
00:18:26,949 --> 00:18:29,111
That could step on
attorney-client privilege, judge.
340
00:18:29,194 --> 00:18:30,996
Yeah, expose your duplicitous counsel.
341
00:18:31,077 --> 00:18:35,539
Your Honor, these accusations are without merit.
The witness caved on the stand.
342
00:18:35,759 --> 00:18:37,422
There was nothing improper.
343
00:18:38,808 --> 00:18:41,829
I'll let you redirect on
the witnesses' credibility only.
344
00:18:41,884 --> 00:18:43,214
I'm keeping the reins tight.
345
00:18:44,765 --> 00:18:48,035
We'll adjourn for the week
and then resume Monday at 10:00.
346
00:18:51,498 --> 00:18:53,660
Danny, our offer still stands.
347
00:18:54,685 --> 00:18:55,766
You're it, now.
348
00:18:59,430 --> 00:19:01,591
Uh, yeah, okay. I'm up for it.
349
00:19:01,785 --> 00:19:04,501
Listen, they're gonna go after you
for taking this deal.
350
00:19:04,879 --> 00:19:08,676
They'll say you were angry with Kristen
because she slept with Justin and Carter.
351
00:19:08,925 --> 00:19:10,533
- And that you killed her.
- That's a lie.
352
00:19:10,588 --> 00:19:12,251
But they're gonna be tough on you, okay?
353
00:19:12,250 --> 00:19:16,767
So you just have to remember that you're
doing the right thing. You're helping yourself.
354
00:19:17,377 --> 00:19:18,790
I'm doing it for Kristen.
355
00:19:21,893 --> 00:19:23,805
Ms. Kibre, can I ask a favor?
356
00:19:24,747 --> 00:19:25,800
Sure.
357
00:19:29,318 --> 00:19:32,921
There was something that I was
hoping that I could do.
358
00:19:38,239 --> 00:19:41,343
Mr. and Mrs. Ames are here at your request.
359
00:19:41,676 --> 00:19:44,891
They're not under any obligation
to say anything to you.
360
00:19:47,217 --> 00:19:50,432
- I think what Danny wanted to...
- No, no, I got it. Please, I gotta do this.
361
00:19:50,709 --> 00:19:51,291
Please.
362
00:19:55,833 --> 00:19:57,690
I want you to know how sorry I am.
363
00:19:59,963 --> 00:20:00,932
Sorry?
364
00:20:03,925 --> 00:20:05,643
Do you realize what you took from us?
365
00:20:06,974 --> 00:20:07,888
Do you?
366
00:20:08,914 --> 00:20:10,909
Say what you gotta say
and get it over with.
367
00:20:16,530 --> 00:20:20,215
When you wouldn't let Kristen date me,
368
00:20:20,299 --> 00:20:21,851
I got Justin to...
369
00:20:22,570 --> 00:20:25,452
pick her up and bring her out
so that we could see each other.
370
00:20:25,507 --> 00:20:28,750
Because I knew that you would accept him and...
371
00:20:29,360 --> 00:20:30,939
... think that he was good enough.
372
00:20:32,739 --> 00:20:35,400
I never thought Kristen would too.
373
00:20:38,969 --> 00:20:39,911
He didn't love her.
374
00:20:40,909 --> 00:20:41,795
I did.
375
00:20:44,604 --> 00:20:51,394
And I feel like what happened
was my fault for not protecting her.
376
00:20:52,606 --> 00:20:54,061
For not stopping 'em.
377
00:20:57,526 --> 00:21:00,193
I know you hate me,
but you gotta know how sorry I am.
378
00:21:03,830 --> 00:21:06,290
Everyone that hurt Kristen
should be punished.
379
00:21:10,092 --> 00:21:12,656
I want you to know
I'm not taking Ms. Kibre's deal.
380
00:21:13,479 --> 00:21:16,700
- Hold on a second.
- I'm gonna testify against Justin.
381
00:21:16,735 --> 00:21:20,372
But if I'm getting some deal, nobody's
gonna believe that I'm telling the truth.
382
00:21:20,433 --> 00:21:21,992
Danny, we.. Dan, we need to talk about this.
383
00:21:22,027 --> 00:21:22,685
No.
384
00:21:23,412 --> 00:21:26,981
All three of us,
whatever we get we deserve it.
385
00:21:39,057 --> 00:21:43,284
You know, in the best of all worlds
a defendant accepts some responsibilities.
386
00:21:43,388 --> 00:21:44,462
It's kind of refreshing.
387
00:21:44,773 --> 00:21:48,272
He does it because he's guilty
or because he feels guilty?
388
00:21:48,826 --> 00:21:50,836
You mean, suppose he's a good kid?
389
00:21:51,040 --> 00:21:52,252
Suppose he is.
390
00:21:52,703 --> 00:21:54,885
Kind of bothers you, huh?
Not knowing.
391
00:21:55,232 --> 00:21:55,959
Yeah.
392
00:21:56,886 --> 00:21:58,098
Well, let me tell you something.
393
00:21:58,133 --> 00:22:01,493
In this job, never give anybody
the benefit of the doubt.
394
00:22:02,567 --> 00:22:05,477
So Danny helps us convict Justin,
395
00:22:05,512 --> 00:22:08,907
and to repay the favor we lock him away
for the rest of his life?
396
00:22:09,063 --> 00:22:13,463
Any leniency you show is gonna look like
an exchange for a favor.
397
00:22:13,567 --> 00:22:16,684
Now, Rothenberg will cry foul
all the way to the bar.
398
00:22:16,788 --> 00:22:18,313
Wouldn't that be ironic?
399
00:22:18,763 --> 00:22:21,534
Bottom line is, you don't know
what happened that night.
400
00:22:22,072 --> 00:22:24,254
There's no evidence
to exonerate Danny, right?
401
00:22:24,601 --> 00:22:25,744
Just the opposite.
402
00:22:25,917 --> 00:22:29,139
Well, then, thank God for the law.
Just do what it says.
403
00:22:29,658 --> 00:22:32,949
We came with the delusion
that you had a worthwhile offer.
404
00:22:33,253 --> 00:22:35,851
- It's better than a conviction.
- You've convicted him?
405
00:22:36,093 --> 00:22:38,380
We're certainly confident today.
406
00:22:39,090 --> 00:22:43,178
He does 15 to 25 and we'll recommend
that he serve his time downstate.
407
00:22:43,455 --> 00:22:46,538
- So mom and dad can visit.
- No way I'm doing 15 year...
408
00:22:47,647 --> 00:22:49,829
What happened to that girl was awful.
409
00:22:50,367 --> 00:22:54,039
For the sake of tragedy,
I'll accept negligent homicide.
410
00:22:54,073 --> 00:22:57,087
- Right. A class E felony.
- Probation.
411
00:22:57,391 --> 00:23:00,439
Substance abuse counseling.
No time served.
412
00:23:00,508 --> 00:23:02,760
No jury's gonna find your client innocent.
413
00:23:02,795 --> 00:23:05,635
You can't prove the rape.
It means you don't have a motive.
414
00:23:06,043 --> 00:23:09,230
No motive, your evidence means nothing.
415
00:23:09,576 --> 00:23:11,932
Danny Wallace is gonna testify against him.
416
00:23:11,958 --> 00:23:14,140
He took a plea.
No one will believe a word he says.
417
00:23:14,199 --> 00:23:17,275
Danny's not testifying under
protection of a plea agreement.
418
00:23:17,317 --> 00:23:19,700
Makes him a hell of a lot more
credible than your client.
419
00:23:19,784 --> 00:23:21,834
It makes him a defendant, not a witness.
420
00:23:22,943 --> 00:23:25,382
If he doesn't take the stand,
you don't have a case.
421
00:23:26,044 --> 00:23:32,452
If he does, I can ask him anything I want.
422
00:23:36,523 --> 00:23:38,991
Our offer expires with this meeting.
423
00:23:41,416 --> 00:23:44,014
Why prolong the inevitable?
424
00:23:53,410 --> 00:23:55,098
Your office told me you'd be here.
425
00:23:55,272 --> 00:23:56,917
Last place I'd have thought to look.
426
00:23:56,960 --> 00:23:59,818
About the only place I can get any work done.
427
00:23:59,862 --> 00:24:01,507
What can I do for you, Norman?
428
00:24:01,550 --> 00:24:06,184
Oh, I'm just a little curious about what you're up to.
This altruistic nonsense your client is doing.
429
00:24:06,350 --> 00:24:08,688
Danny is just trying to do
the right thing, that's all.
430
00:24:08,740 --> 00:24:12,161
Trying to put an innocent
young man in prison for the rest of his life.
431
00:24:12,204 --> 00:24:13,763
Please, Norman.
432
00:24:13,850 --> 00:24:16,794
There's a lot of gray here for both our guys.
433
00:24:17,227 --> 00:24:21,428
I'm sure a seasoned lawyer
like yourself can smell a win.
434
00:24:22,224 --> 00:24:27,074
The DA's case rests entirely on what Danny says.
435
00:24:27,464 --> 00:24:30,538
If he incriminates himself,
he takes my client down with him.
436
00:24:31,293 --> 00:24:32,678
On the other hand,
437
00:24:33,847 --> 00:24:40,170
if he decides not to testify,
Justin's memory could significantly improve.
438
00:24:41,694 --> 00:24:44,508
Would I get Justin as a witness for Danny's defense?
439
00:24:44,508 --> 00:24:48,449
All we need to do here is raise reasonable doubt.
440
00:24:49,887 --> 00:24:52,571
It's an interesting way to practice law.
441
00:24:55,524 --> 00:24:59,248
Oh, you know, one thing
you're forgetting, Norman.
442
00:25:00,677 --> 00:25:02,410
What if Danny's on the level?
443
00:25:04,441 --> 00:25:06,606
How long have you been doing this?
444
00:25:10,243 --> 00:25:15,180
Your motion is surprising
but valid, Mr. Conners.
445
00:25:15,315 --> 00:25:17,827
Joining these trials certainly
makes economic sense.
446
00:25:17,783 --> 00:25:21,248
Your Honor, binding these
defendants creates complexity.
447
00:25:21,377 --> 00:25:24,712
It had the potential of drawing
a single trial out even longer.
448
00:25:24,842 --> 00:25:28,089
Mr. Conners may not be aware of it, your Honor,
449
00:25:28,228 --> 00:25:32,038
but our defense could put
his client in a negative light.
450
00:25:32,168 --> 00:25:35,979
- You mean, you intend to blame him.
- It's a bit more nuanced than that.
451
00:25:36,256 --> 00:25:38,464
- There's no joint defense?
- No.
452
00:25:38,508 --> 00:25:40,846
Your Honor, my client
was not a party to this crime.
453
00:25:41,192 --> 00:25:44,007
In fact, he intends to testify
against Justin Birch.
454
00:25:44,189 --> 00:25:46,787
And because of that,
the District Attorney would seek to delay...
455
00:25:46,830 --> 00:25:48,952
... my client's trial
until after his testimony.
456
00:25:49,039 --> 00:25:51,334
Now I would not be
providing effective counsel
457
00:25:51,420 --> 00:25:54,495
if I were to let my client sit in jail
for something that he didn't do.
458
00:25:54,807 --> 00:25:57,406
A speedy trial is the very least that he should get.
459
00:25:57,492 --> 00:26:00,740
Then he should move for
a speedy trial, and not a joinder.
460
00:26:02,697 --> 00:26:05,382
Now both defendants
are accused of the same crime.
461
00:26:05,659 --> 00:26:09,513
I don't think antagonistic defenses
is sufficient reason to maintain severance,
462
00:26:09,643 --> 00:26:11,072
especially given the cost.
463
00:26:11,115 --> 00:26:14,579
- Your Honor...
- Ms. Kibre, I'm granting the motion.
464
00:26:20,744 --> 00:26:22,346
What the hell is this about?
465
00:26:22,390 --> 00:26:25,334
You think playing rich against poor
is gonna get Danny a walk?
466
00:26:25,507 --> 00:26:27,672
I don't expect you to defend my client.
467
00:26:27,889 --> 00:26:30,141
My job, I'll do it how I see fit.
468
00:26:30,184 --> 00:26:32,392
What guarantee do I have
that he'll testify?
469
00:26:32,436 --> 00:26:33,951
He says he wants to make this right.
470
00:26:34,057 --> 00:26:35,919
Well, that's not good enough.
471
00:26:36,006 --> 00:26:38,604
Well, it's good enough for me.
472
00:26:42,736 --> 00:26:46,330
Even if Danny's story isn't rock solid,
473
00:26:46,373 --> 00:26:47,802
It could have happened the way he said.
474
00:26:47,821 --> 00:26:49,817
We went with his story
'cause he could get us Justin.
475
00:26:49,885 --> 00:26:52,185
Yeah, that's what we want.
I still don't see the problem.
476
00:26:52,268 --> 00:26:55,815
We believed Danny
and we gave him 15 to 25.
477
00:26:55,869 --> 00:26:58,751
Now, with no deal,
just the mercy of the court,
478
00:26:58,835 --> 00:27:01,301
he gets a jury to believe him, he walks.
479
00:27:02,020 --> 00:27:03,905
Okay, maybe they give him a walk.
480
00:27:04,099 --> 00:27:05,678
That's fine if he's telling the truth.
481
00:27:06,870 --> 00:27:09,060
The worst thing is when you sucker yourself.
482
00:27:12,017 --> 00:27:15,620
Okay, I'm Danny. I'm standing here
rubbernecking Kristen's murder.
483
00:27:15,731 --> 00:27:18,336
She's getting killed,
you're here frozen in fear.
484
00:27:18,756 --> 00:27:22,913
There are at least three different places
that were probably open at 3:00 a.m.
485
00:27:23,106 --> 00:27:26,432
The bar, that restaurant, and that bodega.
486
00:27:26,459 --> 00:27:27,291
What's your point?
487
00:27:28,204 --> 00:27:30,698
Well, why did Danny say
he was standing here?
488
00:27:31,252 --> 00:27:32,250
Right here.
489
00:27:33,275 --> 00:27:34,938
I'm not following you.
490
00:27:35,713 --> 00:27:38,678
Well, If he was lying, why didn't he say
he was two blocks from here?
491
00:27:38,788 --> 00:27:41,226
Or that he ran when
Justin grabbed Kristen,
492
00:27:41,365 --> 00:27:43,859
- then heard the shots?
- Then he's telling the truth.
493
00:27:44,386 --> 00:27:46,270
What if somebody saw him here?
494
00:27:47,643 --> 00:27:50,110
Cops canvassed the area.
There's no witnesses.
495
00:27:50,248 --> 00:27:53,380
Danny told the cops,
"I was scared. I was frozen."
496
00:27:53,796 --> 00:27:56,290
He's thinking there's a witness
that's gonna come forward...
497
00:27:56,298 --> 00:27:58,349
... and say they saw him
in the park that night.
498
00:27:58,959 --> 00:28:02,589
So he makes a statement,
but the witness never turns up.
499
00:28:02,810 --> 00:28:04,389
Now Danny's stuck with his story.
500
00:28:04,445 --> 00:28:06,163
But if there was a witness,
501
00:28:06,329 --> 00:28:08,602
wouldn't he have seen Justin and Kristen?
502
00:28:10,125 --> 00:28:12,480
Not necessarily. It was dark.
503
00:28:13,838 --> 00:28:14,781
Turn around.
504
00:28:16,774 --> 00:28:21,264
He would have had a perfect view
up and down Avenue B and East 7th.
505
00:28:22,676 --> 00:28:24,394
Anybody would have seen him coming.
506
00:28:26,528 --> 00:28:29,272
You're saying he was
playing lookout for Justin.
507
00:28:29,852 --> 00:28:30,822
I don't know.
508
00:28:32,236 --> 00:28:34,314
The kid's either really honest or...
509
00:28:35,887 --> 00:28:37,411
... really smart.
510
00:28:40,404 --> 00:28:43,591
So you're not buying
Danny's sacrificial blamas anymore
511
00:28:43,986 --> 00:28:45,103
Well, I'm not sure.
512
00:28:45,809 --> 00:28:48,479
It's possible Danny
was playing lookout for Justin.
513
00:28:48,501 --> 00:28:50,431
If he thinks somebody
saw him that night,
514
00:28:50,484 --> 00:28:52,730
that may be why he told the police
he witnessed the crime.
515
00:28:52,757 --> 00:28:54,316
You think you could find that witness?
516
00:28:54,395 --> 00:28:56,959
Cops are recanvassing the area
around Tompkins Square Park.
517
00:28:58,144 --> 00:29:02,003
You're telling me your case is entirely
in the hands of a kid...
518
00:29:02,263 --> 00:29:03,770
...who you should be trying to convict.
519
00:29:04,875 --> 00:29:08,840
Look, Dean Conners is not stupid.
He knows how a jury loves an underdog.
520
00:29:09,025 --> 00:29:10,532
Danny will testify.
521
00:29:10,652 --> 00:29:13,725
He'll have to answer the accusations
made by Justin's defense.
522
00:29:13,758 --> 00:29:15,245
I'll take my shot on cross.
523
00:29:15,278 --> 00:29:20,069
Except when you impeach Danny's credibility,
you make everything else he says worthless.
524
00:29:20,242 --> 00:29:21,663
And Justin walks.
525
00:29:22,291 --> 00:29:23,381
There you go, ladies.
526
00:29:23,877 --> 00:29:25,066
You've been outmaneuvered.
527
00:29:25,595 --> 00:29:26,223
Yeah?
528
00:29:28,767 --> 00:29:30,518
Okay, she'll be right down.
529
00:29:31,685 --> 00:29:33,072
Kristen's parents are here.
530
00:29:35,748 --> 00:29:37,533
We've prayed about this.
531
00:29:37,830 --> 00:29:39,713
And Karen and I feel...
532
00:29:41,002 --> 00:29:43,546
Well, we may have misjudged Danny.
533
00:29:44,614 --> 00:29:46,167
We favored Justin...
534
00:29:47,225 --> 00:29:48,645
... for the wrong reasons.
535
00:29:49,108 --> 00:29:51,520
And we pushed Kristen toward him, and...
536
00:29:52,808 --> 00:29:54,295
She died because of it.
537
00:29:55,065 --> 00:29:57,048
Danny cared for her.
538
00:29:57,973 --> 00:30:00,087
We feel some blame for her death.
539
00:30:00,418 --> 00:30:01,706
Mr. and Mrs. Ames,
540
00:30:01,772 --> 00:30:04,680
I sympathize with what
you're going through, I really do.
541
00:30:04,723 --> 00:30:08,358
We wanna ask if the murder charges
against Danny can be dropped.
542
00:30:08,457 --> 00:30:11,563
We don't want him going to prison
for the rest of his life.
543
00:30:12,686 --> 00:30:16,089
See, we've forgiven him in our hearts.
544
00:30:18,633 --> 00:30:21,441
We have evidence
that suggests his involvement.
545
00:30:21,639 --> 00:30:24,018
The law says we hold him accountable.
546
00:30:24,217 --> 00:30:27,091
- He was just a witness.
- We don't know what he was.
547
00:30:27,124 --> 00:30:28,280
He didn't kill her.
548
00:30:28,974 --> 00:30:30,164
You know that.
549
00:30:34,051 --> 00:30:36,133
I'm sorry, I have to prosecute the crime.
550
00:30:42,915 --> 00:30:46,153
And here we see Kristin Ames
leaving the building with Danny Wallace.
551
00:30:46,780 --> 00:30:50,216
Right after that we see Justin Birch
following them out the door.
552
00:30:51,948 --> 00:30:53,666
And what's the time on the footage?
553
00:30:53,897 --> 00:30:56,011
They left the building at 3:27 a.m.
554
00:30:56,111 --> 00:30:59,976
It correlates to the estimated time of death,
which was put between 3:00 and 4:00 a.m.
555
00:31:00,098 --> 00:31:07,102
So you inferred that the murder happened
shortly after all three left the building.
556
00:31:07,300 --> 00:31:08,159
Correct.
557
00:31:11,209 --> 00:31:12,630
Thank you, Detective Saunders.
558
00:31:14,117 --> 00:31:16,628
I was, uh, coming out of the establishment.
559
00:31:17,674 --> 00:31:22,498
And there, by the... by the fence,
where the lady is standing with the dog,
560
00:31:22,531 --> 00:31:26,463
I see this guy standing around.
And he sees me, right?
561
00:31:26,870 --> 00:31:30,008
And I figure, who stands on
a corner... at 3:00 a.m.
562
00:31:30,074 --> 00:31:32,321
- unless he's holdin'?
- Did you approach him?
563
00:31:32,343 --> 00:31:35,218
I got close enough to see
he wasn't a drug dealer, you know?
564
00:31:35,350 --> 00:31:37,432
So I turned around and I walked away.
565
00:31:37,696 --> 00:31:40,901
Half a minute later I heard two gunshots.
566
00:31:42,200 --> 00:31:46,197
- This was the guy you saw, right?
- No. No, that's not him.
567
00:31:46,528 --> 00:31:47,552
All right.
568
00:31:49,369 --> 00:31:50,790
What about this guy?
569
00:31:51,869 --> 00:31:54,678
Yeah, yeah.
Yeah, that... that's him.
570
00:31:55,107 --> 00:31:56,297
That's him for sure.
571
00:31:57,773 --> 00:31:59,722
Did you see anyone else with him?
572
00:31:59,986 --> 00:32:03,489
- Another man and a woman?
- No, just... just... just him.
573
00:32:03,588 --> 00:32:05,570
Why didn't you come forward before now?
574
00:32:05,944 --> 00:32:08,455
You think I'm looking for a headache?
575
00:32:10,702 --> 00:32:16,715
Do you think I could get a ride across town?
I got an appointment for my meds.
576
00:32:20,591 --> 00:32:23,862
We're not actually thinking
of using this guy, are we?
577
00:32:23,895 --> 00:32:24,655
Are you kidding?
578
00:32:24,875 --> 00:32:29,071
Excuse me, I turned Alphabet City
upside down looking for this guy.
579
00:32:29,093 --> 00:32:31,109
His story proves Danny was the lookout.
580
00:32:31,175 --> 00:32:32,695
And thank you for that, Detective.
581
00:32:32,695 --> 00:32:36,164
But I'm not about to stake my case
on the credibility of a perpie witness.
582
00:32:36,847 --> 00:32:38,036
So you're gonna cut him loose.
583
00:32:38,069 --> 00:32:40,812
I didn't say that.
Do an addendum to the witness list.
584
00:32:40,812 --> 00:32:42,662
I'll take it up with the judge in the morning.
585
00:32:42,695 --> 00:32:44,512
But if we're not gonna call him,
what's the point?
586
00:32:44,897 --> 00:32:46,648
He's got scare value.
587
00:32:49,071 --> 00:32:52,078
Your Honor, this witness only
came to our attention last night.
588
00:32:52,177 --> 00:32:53,829
We've moved on, Ms. Kibre.
589
00:32:53,928 --> 00:32:56,274
He's an important percipient witness.
590
00:32:56,373 --> 00:33:00,734
He was near the crime scene and can offer
first-hand observations of the murder.
591
00:33:00,778 --> 00:33:02,925
The prosecution's playing
games here, Your Honor.
592
00:33:02,991 --> 00:33:05,535
I have to agree, Your Honor.
They've already rested their case.
593
00:33:05,601 --> 00:33:09,236
Then we ask to revisit the issue
until after the defense has concluded.
594
00:33:09,302 --> 00:33:11,780
Even on rebuttal, it's unfair surprise.
595
00:33:11,813 --> 00:33:12,573
All right.
596
00:33:12,616 --> 00:33:15,392
We'll take the matter up again
at the appropriate time.
597
00:33:15,392 --> 00:33:16,812
See if a rebuttal's in order.
598
00:33:16,845 --> 00:33:18,828
- Your Honor...
- Bring in the jury.
599
00:33:19,257 --> 00:33:20,876
Let's get this show going.
600
00:33:23,488 --> 00:33:26,353
This witness they're talking
about, you know this guy?
601
00:33:26,353 --> 00:33:28,083
No, of course not.
602
00:33:28,569 --> 00:33:30,407
Well, this is a hell of a surprise.
603
00:33:31,177 --> 00:33:34,231
Look, I didn't see anybody else that night,
if that's what you wanna know.
604
00:33:36,582 --> 00:33:39,717
- I told you, I'm innocent.
- Being innocent isn't enough, Danny.
605
00:33:40,471 --> 00:33:43,363
Innocent people go to prison all the time.
You understand what I'm saying?
606
00:33:45,093 --> 00:33:46,931
I don't know what this guy's gonna say.
607
00:33:47,789 --> 00:33:49,356
What he thinks he saw.
608
00:33:50,627 --> 00:33:52,248
I need you to be straight with me here.
609
00:33:52,275 --> 00:33:53,275
I am, I swear.
610
00:33:53,762 --> 00:33:54,789
Mr. Conners?
611
00:33:55,735 --> 00:33:56,411
Are we ready?
612
00:34:00,729 --> 00:34:03,513
Your Honor, the defense calls Daniel Wallace.
613
00:34:07,456 --> 00:34:09,375
I watched him shoot her twice.
614
00:34:10,267 --> 00:34:11,862
I couldn't breathe.
I couldn't move.
615
00:34:13,371 --> 00:34:16,236
When I finally snapped
out of it, I got nauseous.
616
00:34:16,479 --> 00:34:18,885
- I was sick about it.
- What didn't you help her, Danny?
617
00:34:19,101 --> 00:34:20,317
I wanted to.
618
00:34:21,341 --> 00:34:23,666
I was scared.
I thought Justin was gonna kill me too.
619
00:34:24,233 --> 00:34:26,639
Danny, why are you testifying here today?
620
00:34:28,363 --> 00:34:31,795
Because I feel like I owe it
to Kristen and her family.
621
00:34:33,471 --> 00:34:34,768
No more questions.
622
00:34:46,813 --> 00:34:51,353
Justin dragged Kristin Ames
into the park and murdered her...
623
00:34:51,651 --> 00:34:54,597
while you stood frozen in fear, correct?
624
00:34:54,998 --> 00:34:57,593
- That's right.
- So you were an eyewitness to the crime.
625
00:34:58,025 --> 00:35:00,350
Why did he kill Kristen and let you live?
626
00:35:01,320 --> 00:35:03,185
I don't know. You'd have to ask him.
627
00:35:04,641 --> 00:35:05,939
Why didn't you run for help?
628
00:35:06,074 --> 00:35:07,479
Why didn't you go to the police?
629
00:35:07,587 --> 00:35:08,533
I wish I had.
630
00:35:08,614 --> 00:35:10,695
But I guess I was in shock.
631
00:35:10,749 --> 00:35:12,776
I couldn't believe
what was happening and then...
632
00:35:13,341 --> 00:35:17,801
Afterward I kind of lost my head
seeing Kristen... laying there.
633
00:35:19,391 --> 00:35:23,878
But you had the presence of mind to retrieve
your jacket from right next to the body.
634
00:35:27,249 --> 00:35:28,655
I barely remember doing that.
635
00:35:32,114 --> 00:35:33,439
I'm wondering, Danny...
636
00:35:34,869 --> 00:35:37,221
while you were witnessing
Kristen's murder,
637
00:35:37,978 --> 00:35:40,167
was there anybody in the area?
638
00:35:40,842 --> 00:35:42,788
Anybody who could have seen you?
639
00:35:43,082 --> 00:35:44,947
There might have, uh, been someone.
640
00:35:45,782 --> 00:35:49,268
Now that I think about it,
but he was across the street.
641
00:35:49,322 --> 00:35:51,349
And then he headed in the other direction, so...
642
00:35:52,752 --> 00:35:54,752
You've never mentioned this person before.
643
00:35:58,451 --> 00:35:59,289
I'm sorry.
644
00:36:00,694 --> 00:36:01,316
I forgot.
645
00:36:02,556 --> 00:36:05,421
So it was just that one person.
Nobody else?
646
00:36:05,745 --> 00:36:06,151
No.
647
00:36:08,421 --> 00:36:09,583
How would you know that?
648
00:36:10,475 --> 00:36:11,664
How could you know that?
649
00:36:12,634 --> 00:36:16,661
You testified that you were
facing the opposite direction,
650
00:36:16,740 --> 00:36:21,091
frozen in fear,
watching Justin kill Kristen.
651
00:36:21,925 --> 00:36:24,466
You know, Danny, I'd love to talk about the whole truth...
652
00:36:24,493 --> 00:36:26,628
... and not just the parts that make you look good.
653
00:36:26,695 --> 00:36:28,533
Objection! Argumentative.
654
00:36:28,587 --> 00:36:29,803
Sustained.
655
00:36:29,973 --> 00:36:32,433
Why'd you let Justin kill Kristen Ames?
656
00:36:33,541 --> 00:36:34,352
I didn't.
657
00:36:34,406 --> 00:36:38,460
How'd you feel when Kristen told you
that Justin and Carter had raped her?
658
00:36:38,944 --> 00:36:40,025
I was angry.
659
00:36:40,052 --> 00:36:41,917
That's why me and Kristen
were getting out of there.
660
00:36:41,944 --> 00:36:45,241
Oh, you didn't blame her just a little bit?
Maybe feel a little betrayed?
661
00:36:45,264 --> 00:36:46,778
I didn't do anything to her.
662
00:36:46,832 --> 00:36:50,507
She hurt you all over again that night,
and you didn't believe her, did you?
663
00:36:50,559 --> 00:36:52,829
I loved Kristen.
664
00:36:53,396 --> 00:36:57,153
- Justin killed her right in front of me.
- Oh, Danny, I know he did.
665
00:36:57,610 --> 00:36:59,691
Doesn't mean you didn't want it to happen.
666
00:37:25,516 --> 00:37:26,300
Any news?
667
00:37:26,351 --> 00:37:27,783
Jury just broke for dinner.
668
00:37:28,161 --> 00:37:29,837
I doubt they're coming back tonight.
669
00:37:31,267 --> 00:37:32,753
I know what you're thinking, Tracey.
670
00:37:32,861 --> 00:37:33,699
Don't go there.
671
00:37:34,510 --> 00:37:37,186
I went after Danny.
It didn't help our case.
672
00:37:37,318 --> 00:37:38,534
The jury'll figure it out.
673
00:37:38,777 --> 00:37:42,940
The only thing the jury saw was a prosecutor
beating up on a kid they liked.
674
00:37:46,017 --> 00:37:48,098
He got that look in his eye.
675
00:37:48,179 --> 00:37:50,422
He was lying his heart out.
676
00:37:52,368 --> 00:37:53,260
You saw that.
677
00:37:55,994 --> 00:37:58,048
Yeah, I saw that.
678
00:38:17,539 --> 00:38:18,836
Jury's coming back.
679
00:38:20,998 --> 00:38:21,728
You okay?
680
00:38:24,269 --> 00:38:27,431
The DA made a lot of
accusations without evidence.
681
00:38:28,533 --> 00:38:29,371
You did good.
682
00:38:30,884 --> 00:38:32,290
The jury'll do the right thing.
683
00:38:36,306 --> 00:38:37,279
That, um,
684
00:38:39,901 --> 00:38:41,604
last minute witness.
685
00:38:45,203 --> 00:38:46,825
Kibre was bluffing, right?
686
00:38:53,722 --> 00:38:54,776
Don't tell me...
687
00:38:55,803 --> 00:38:57,803
... that you've been lying to me all this time.
688
00:39:07,704 --> 00:39:08,515
Before...
689
00:39:10,565 --> 00:39:13,160
you said whatever I do,
you weren't here to judge me.
690
00:39:14,944 --> 00:39:15,890
That's right, Danny.
691
00:39:17,562 --> 00:39:18,454
I did say that.
692
00:39:22,427 --> 00:39:23,346
That night...
693
00:39:27,506 --> 00:39:28,992
I told her I still loved her.
694
00:39:35,144 --> 00:39:36,550
And she said I wasn't...
695
00:39:37,577 --> 00:39:39,955
... the type of person
that she wanted to be with.
696
00:39:41,956 --> 00:39:42,929
You know what that meant?
697
00:39:44,037 --> 00:39:44,983
That meant Justin.
698
00:39:47,601 --> 00:39:49,277
I would have done anything for her.
699
00:39:50,737 --> 00:39:51,683
And she...
700
00:39:54,355 --> 00:39:57,139
... screws these guys
right under my nose.
701
00:39:58,990 --> 00:40:00,369
They raped her, Danny.
702
00:40:00,801 --> 00:40:02,909
That is what she said!
703
00:40:03,990 --> 00:40:05,098
What did you do?
704
00:40:12,370 --> 00:40:13,856
I was so mad.
705
00:40:17,262 --> 00:40:18,775
I'm yelling at her.
706
00:40:21,366 --> 00:40:25,339
Justin's yelling at her.
And he starts threatening her with his gun.
707
00:40:29,258 --> 00:40:30,420
And I told him...
708
00:40:31,117 --> 00:40:33,442
...to do it. I didn't care anymore.
709
00:40:38,708 --> 00:40:40,600
I think I loved her too much.
710
00:41:00,196 --> 00:41:02,034
Has the jury reached a verdict?
711
00:41:02,061 --> 00:41:03,196
We have, Your Honor.
712
00:41:03,369 --> 00:41:06,666
For Justin Birch, on the charge
of the indictment, how do you find?
713
00:41:06,774 --> 00:41:09,045
We find the defendant guilty.
714
00:41:11,420 --> 00:41:15,150
For Daniel Wallace, on the charge of
the indictment, how do you find?
715
00:41:15,285 --> 00:41:17,474
We find the defendant not guilty.
716
00:41:24,041 --> 00:41:25,879
Thank you, jury.
You are dismissed.
717
00:41:27,473 --> 00:41:29,122
Congratulations.
718
00:41:59,586 --> 00:42:01,262
You're not celebrating.
719
00:42:02,018 --> 00:42:03,343
What brings you down here?
720
00:42:05,561 --> 00:42:08,291
Rothenberg filed a notice of appeal for Justin.
721
00:42:08,561 --> 00:42:10,967
Probably won't go anywhere, but if it does...
722
00:42:11,075 --> 00:42:13,129
Danny's not my client anymore, Kibre.
723
00:42:16,146 --> 00:42:17,011
He walked.
724
00:42:17,416 --> 00:42:19,497
- You had a good plan.
- Danny's plan.
725
00:42:20,903 --> 00:42:21,876
Smart kid.
726
00:42:24,841 --> 00:42:25,814
You believed him.
727
00:42:26,760 --> 00:42:28,300
Wasn't there a minute you did too?
728
00:42:31,435 --> 00:42:32,625
I wanted to.
729
00:42:33,305 --> 00:43:33,545
Support us and become VIP member
to remove all ads from www.OpenSubtitles.org
58555
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.