All language subtitles for Silent Witness - S26E09 - Southbay (1)

LAUGHTER

You know it's true!

Don't deny it! Don't deny it.

Yep, so, uh...

Yeah, so, Bill was the
pathologist on the first scene

I ever set foot on
as a newly qualified

and somewhat
wet-behind-the-ears forenso.

It was a triple in a basement
launderette, do you remember?

Under a tower block...
Oh, yeah. Yeah?

One of the bodies was
stuffed in a tumble dryer.

Still going round and round.

THEY LAUGH

So, I stood there for
a good ten seconds

looking from one mangled
corpse to another,

until he kindly
put me at my ease.

He said, uh, "Are you waiting
for the cycle to finish?

"Get a bloody move on, lad,
before we're all hung out to dry!"

THEY LAUGH

It's a good line. Good line.

Never forgot. Never forgot it.

Anyway, enjoy your
retirement, Bill.

No-one alive or dead could
say you haven't earned it.

To Bill! DINERS:
To Bill! To Bill!

Support us and become VIP member
to remove all ads from www.OpenSubtitles.org

All right?

Better be some gin in there.

Just the three
shots. BILL CHUCKLES

I was thinking about Spain,

Marbella.

Good for the psoriasis.

And retired villains.

I could keep my
hand in, couldn't I?

PHONE RINGS

Bridget?

It's your bloody retirement do!

Three-line whip, Jack.

Come on, you're off the
clock and you're pissed.

A medicinal two or three.

You're seriously
going to a scene?

Now?

When the Chief
Superintendent calls...

Wait.

I lied.

It was sparkling water.

What...? I had a whisky before my
speech - bit of Dutch courage -

since then, the purest
H2O. I'll drive.

We'll chat in the
car like old times.

I'll get my bag.

PHONE VIBRATES

Hey! How was your speech?

Ah, it was OK.

Look, uh, it might
be a late one.

I need to run Bill
back to Southbay.

Can't he get a cab?

No, it's complicated.

OK.

Well, I love you.

Be safe.

Love you, too.

Bye.

♪ Testator silens

♪ Costestes e spiritu

♪ Silencium

♪ Testator silens... ♪

FAINT SIRENS

FAINT: Get off me! Get off me!

Leave me alone!

Get off me!

Get back here! Andrew!

Andrew!

SHOUTING CONTINUES

Are you OK?

It's not my blood.

It's his.

Leave me alone!

Get your hands off
me. Get your...!

Get your hands off of me.

Thank you.

Ugh!

SHOUTING

Ugh! I don't want
him in my house!

Mike, take it easy! I don't
want him near my kids!

You've had a shock. Get
off me, Ray! It's my house!

Mike! Mike!

That's enough.

Take care of her,
Bill. She's family.

This is Jack.

He's a forensic scientist.

This is Chief
Superintendent Bridget Laing

and Detective Superintendent
Ray Palmer. Are Forensics here?

Delayed at a stabbing
on the seafront.

Where's your gear, Bill?

Oh, I uh...

..I just... I came
from a... thing.

I've got the basics in my car.

Why isn't the whole house
cleared and sealed off?

Want to give me a primer?

The deceased is a Carol Laing.

Upstairs in the master bedroom.

And she's "family" because...?

That angry man outside is
her ex, Sergeant Mike Laing.

Chief Superintendent
Bridget Laing is his mother.

Cosy.

Incestuous, some would say.

Paramedics confirmed
death on arrival,

but they were too late
to attempt any resus. Mm.

The killer used the cord from her
dressing gown to restrain her.

Signs of a struggle.

Jewellery box is emptied out.

Hopefully, someone can
tell us what's missing.

Pool of blood from
the chest wound.

Partial shoeprint in the blood.

Paramedics? Looks
on the small side.

Mm.

There's blood spatter
on the curtains.

Looks like a nice
fingerprint here, too.

More bloody
shoeprints down here.

Who called 999?

The older boy, I think.

Jack Hodgson, DI Andrew
Walsh, DC Meena Puri.

Have they said anything?

Dom said he heard
his mum shouting.

Ryan's said nothing at all.

Can I speak to them?

Briefly?

Briefly.

Hiya.

Which of you's the
Harry Kane fan?

Ryan.

Ryan, do you mind me asking how
your bedside light got broken?

Can I see your
slippers, do you think?

Just the soles? Thank you.

We went to bed early cos
Dad's taking us fishing.

What do you know?

You had the covers
over your head.

Thank you, Jack.

Our CSI Fiona's here, but
thank you for stepping in.

We'll contact you through Bill
Burnett if the need arises.

Oh, from a
continuity-of-evidence angle,

I should finish
what I've started.

Meaning? Complete processing of
the house before the handover.

Honestly, Jack, if you handover
with Fiona, we'll take it from here.

Thanks again, Jack.

Night, Bill.

Go inside, boys.

I'll be right in.

Is there anything
you want to tell me?

How could you even ask?

Spare me the self-righteousness.

Your wife's killed
in front of your kids

and instead of tending to them,

you start punching out car
windows and threatening people!

Andrew shouldn't
even be on this!

He was all over Carol
the minute I moved out!

Good for him! She was
his to begin with!

Give me a fucking break!

Even now, you can only
think of yourself.

That's why the boys
are staying with me.

LOCK CLICKS

Andrew?

I said not to stay up.

There's mac and
cheese in the fridge.

Can't have my
brother going hungry.

I'll heat it up.
I don't want it.

It won't take a
minute. Sit down, Lisa.

Carol's dead.

Murdered.

I hope the kids are OK.

I mean, I hope they
didn't see anything.

Did they?

What a strange question.

Is that all you've
got to say? Sorry.

I always say the wrong thing.

Poor Carol.

SHE SOBS

Come here.

Ugh.

Mike?

Ugh!

Ugh! Mike.

What're you doing?

I'm looking for my
keys to the house.

There's no sign of forced entry,

so if they know I've got a set,

they're going to jump
to one conclusion.

I didn't know you had a set. I
thought you gave them back to Carol.

I did.

I got another set
cut from Ryan's.

You know what, I rebuilt that
house with my bare hands!

They're my kids, too!

Why should I be denied access?

Jesus Christ, Mike!

Before you pile in, all right,

I've already had both
barrels from Mum.

Hey...

It's OK.

Dom?

I heard a voice.

Someone... arguing with Mum.

Was it someone you knew?

A voice you'd heard before?

She was angry.

Mum or the other person?

The other person.

The other person was a woman?

I'll be billing Southbay
for your services.

Time and a half after midnight.

Just wish I'd got to
finish the job, you know?

Doesn't sound like your friend
went in to bat for you very hard.

Yeah, he knows which side
his bread's buttered.

Well, I hope it hasn't
damaged your friendship.

Nah. Be fine.

I did some work down
there a few years back.

Bit of an oddity.

In what sense? In theory,
part of the Constabulary,

in practice, its
own jurisdiction.

Was Chief Superintendent Bridget
Laing still in charge then?

Very much so, but never
had the pleasure. You?

Ah, it doesn't matter.

Is something up?

WHISPERS: I don't know.

For a big man, Bill seemed
awfully diminished last night.

Small.

That's not how you've
described him before. No. No...

But it's the version
I'm stuck with now.

Anyway. I'm sure it's fine.

TV: After the murder of a
mother-of-two in Southbay,

a night of frantic
activity culminated

in the arrest of a serving
police officer this morning.

We'll be speaking...
MOUSE CLICKS

..To the murder of a
mother of two in Southbay,

a night of frantic activity
culminated in the arrest

of a serving
police... MOUSE CLICKS

Just to let you know,
we've obtained a warrant

to search your property,

and that search is
happening right now.

Have you ever been inside
the Laing residence?

Mm...

Last week.

Mike and I ran the boys back.

Did you go upstairs?

No.

Have you seen these keys before?

OK.

And what do they unlock?

Carol's front door.

That's significant, Kate,

for two reasons, one,

there was no sign of
forced entry at the house.

And two, we found these
keys in your coat pocket,

and the most prominent fingerprints
taken from the fob are yours.

Did you use these keys to gain
access to Carol's house last night?

No, I did not.

So, how did you come to
be in possession of them?

I found them in Mike's
jeans and I was annoyed,

so I took them.

Why were you annoyed?

Because I knew what he'd done.

After Carol made Mike
hand over his keys,

he got a copy made
from Ryan's set.

And this made you feel insecure?

Jealous?

Both, probably.

It made me feel like Mike
wasn't ready to move on.

Jealous enough to go and
confront Carol about it?

No.

Well, the evidence suggests
that you did, Kate.

That you attacked her in her bed

whilst her sons slept
just across the hall.

And when she fought back, you
stabbed her through the heart.

It's very obvious why
my client's in custody -

because Southbay
CID bears a grudge.

Equally obvious, there's
no evidence worth the name.

What do you call Carol
Laing's house keys?

Incidental? Irrelevant?

A set of keys?

Charge my client or release her.

Sorry, Bridget,
from a CPS angle,

we need more than the testimony of a
child and some keys. You'll get it.

PHONE RINGS

Bill. Have you heard
about Kate Freeman?

Yes, from the news.

Apparently, her lawyer's got
wind of your involvement.

She's going to make
an approach, Jack,

bring you onside.

Bit previous, isn't it?

She's only been arrested.

A charge is coming, but
you didn't hear it from me.

One of Carol's lads belatedly
spoke up, put Kate at the scene.

I'd appreciate it
if you declined.

With us being friends, it's
just going to get messy.

Not to mention blighting
what'll likely be my last case.

I'm sorry to put you
in this position, Jack.

LIFT DINGS

Miriam? Jack Hodgson.

Good to meet you, Jack, and thank
you for coming on board. OK.

This is Kate Freeman and
her partner, Mike Laing.

Hi.

We met last night. Yeah.

Thanks for you concern, and
I'm sorry if I was rude.

You weren't.

Come and meet the team.

After you.

Go through.

PHONE VIBRATES

And you're a serving
PC at Southbay Police?

Yes... No, I'm on suspension.

OK.

And is the victim, Carol
Laing, known to you?

Yeah.

Carol and I were married.

We separated just
over a year ago.

Then I'm very sorry
for your loss.

Why are you on suspension, Kate?

You're among friends.

They need to know everything
to mount an effective defence.

We really do.

Six months ago, my police
partner, PC Fred Woods,

just... disappeared.

His car was found
by Southbay Bridge.

Fred was a cancer survivor

and a period of remission
had just come to an end.

So, top brass just went straight
to, "He's killed himself",

despite the lack of body, no
note, or anything supporting that.

So, just to be clear, you
thought he HADN'T killed himself?

My mother, Bridget Laing, is the
Chief Super at Southbay Police.

I told Kate to go and
share her concerns.

That was a mistake?

She not only dismissed
my suspicions,

but accused me of leaking
false allegations to the media.

I was placed on suspension
pending a disciplinary hearing.

Did you leak to the media?

No.

But it's your belief
PC Woods was murdered?

Look, sorry,

airing this stuff
got me suspended,

and I just don't think it's
relevant. Can we move on?

Sure.

Why don't you tell us more
about what the police have,

or think they have?

My son, Dom, has made a
statement to Southbay Police

to say that...

..he thought he heard
Kate arguing with Carol.

Obviously, he's mistaken.

Dom, he's the younger of
your boys, right? Yeah.

Why?

I found broken glass
under Ryan's bed.

Felt like he was the one who
might've witnessed something.

Be helpful to know about your
movements last night, Kate.

Um, yeah.

I was home alone all night,

cleaning out the
kitchen cupboards.

And, yes, as a copper, I
know that's a shit alibi.

What about your phone?

Logged as being at her flat
all night, but on charge.

You didn't use it at all?

So it's of scant
use evidentially.

NIKKI: Do we know when the
postmortem's being carried out?

Right now, as we speak.

Then we should be carrying
out our own, as soon as,

and not taking no for an answer.

I'll make a call.

Were you photographed
after you were arrested?

Yeah.

Be prudent for us to
take a set of our own.

CAMERA SHUTTER CLICKS

These bruises are consistent
with someone gripping your arm.

Unless you tell me different.

Mike and I got into a row two
nights ago, and it got physical.

We were both drunk, and
I lost it, basically.

Said I was going to
go to my mate's house.

OK.

Look, Mike was only trying
to get the car keys from me.

You could be facing
life in prison, Kate.

Do you think I don't know that?
We need the truth and nothing but.

What was the row about?

It doesn't matter.

A boss who keeps his hand in?

Especially if the postmortem
could help serve my research.

Dare I ask?

"A computationally approximated
solution for the equation

"for Henssge's
time-of-death estimation."

What she said.

Just so you know, they think
they're doing us a huge favour

in expediting a
second postmortem.

Same day as the coroner
PM is pretty rare.

But the coroner's
signed off on it,

so no need for too much
bowing and scraping.

A second PM, you want to be
thorough, go the extra mile.

I'd like to do a full
light-source examination,

everyone in eyewear, the works.

Are we sure he's not
playing both sides?

He's got an alibi,
right, for Carol?

On duty.

DC Puri.

Need a quick word, Wes.

Can you do that later, please?

Anything I can help
with, Detective?

No. Thank you, Neil. It's
your nephew I'm here to see.

I need to check your
whereabouts last night.

Between 7pm and midnight.

In your own words, please?

Is it about that copper's wife?

Carol something?

I was working in the pub.

Oh.

Plenty of witnesses, then?

No, I were downstairs,
in the cellar.

What were you doing down there?

Burst pipe.

Yeah.

We were ten inches under.

I was up at the bar, so
Wes had to man the pails.

So, your alibi, should you need
one, is a burst pipe and a bucket?

The plumber came around 11.

Helped him pump the rest
out. Isn't that right, Wes?

That's right.

Get you his number if you like.

This is DI Andrew Walsh. He's
heading up the investigation.

We met last night.

Good to meet you, Nikki.

Gabriel. Likewise.

I owe you an apology, Jack.

I might've let my emotions
cloud my judgment last night.

Understandably.

You were close to Carol?

She was my daughter-in-law,
and I'm big on family.

In hindsight, I should've let
you finish processing the scene.

Can we get that in writing?

Given the sensitivity of
Kate Freeman being a serving

Southbay officer, I welcome
the Lyell's involvement.

Not to mention being in a
relationship with your son?

That too.

I'll leave you in
Andrew's capable hands.

Look, I know how it sounds, but
we're only interested in the truth.

We'll share as much of our
investigation as possible.

Nothing less than your
legal requirement.

And we can leave the
adversarial stuff

in favour of good old
mutual cooperation.

Thanks, Andrew.

I'm all for mutual cooperation.

This is the defence
postmortem examination

of the body of Carol Laing.

She shows evidence of
an earlier postmortem

carried out by Dr Bill
Burnett for the coroner.

There is a sutured
postmortem Y-incision

and coronal incision
of the scalp.

There's evidence of a single,
deep wound to her chest.

The bladed weapon has penetrated the
chest within the precordial region.

There's a large complex
injury on the forehead.

Unusual pattern.

Could help ID the
weapon that caused it.

The tissue bridges at
the base of the splits

confirm that they are lacerations
caused by blunt force trauma,

rather than incisions
caused by a cutting edge.

There's a fine fracture
crossing the middle

meningeal artery groove
producing extradural blood.

I don't remember that
from the first PM.

Why was it missed?

I'd offer three reasons.

One, the fracture is very fine.

Two, Dr Burnett failed
to strip the dura mater,

the tough outer layer of the
meninges around the brain.

Three...

..and this is only conjecture...

..he'd already made up his mind.

Whatever the underlying cause,
it was negligent, right?

It's curious, certainly.

After concussion from
a blow to the head,

extradural bleeding occurred
between the outer aspects

of the brain and the
inside of the skull,

which took time to collect.

There's some grooving to
the parahippocampal gyri

at the base of the brain.

Sub uncal herniation.

What does that mean?

It suggests there was sufficient
time not just for the extradural

blood to collect, but for
the brain itself to swell.

I'll take histology samples of
the brain to look for trauma.

That'll help with a timeline.

As will the application
of beta-APP staining.

With the single, deep
wound to the chest,

the blade went through the
left side of the lower sternum,

right where the heart is.

The bladed weapon did
indeed injure the heart.

Here.

There is a stab wound into the
front of the left ventricle.

This is the fatal injury.

Something under the big
toenail on the right foot.

Lights on, please.

Looks like blue paint.

Damage to the nail suggests it
scraped the paint quite hard.

Paint from somewhere
inside the house? Possible.

Although Carol's bedroom
was kind of... brown.

We need to go back and check.

That won't be a problem,
will it, Andrew?

I haven't spoken to
my children again.

It's not allowed.

My wife won't let me.

When I told Rivka that
I wanted to leave,

I hoped that she'd come with me.

Because she had lots
of questions, too.

She told her father

that I was thinking of leaving.

He came to the house...

..my house...

..and he took Rivka
and my children away.

I thought that I'd still
be able to see them.

And I was wrong.

Naive.

And now, she won't even
acknowledge my existence.

I have to break away now.

There won't be any, um...

..closure.

In this situation...

..everyone is a victim.

Victim?

Victim.

Yes.

I have to.

I'm still proud...

..to be Jewish.

And I'm still optimistic
for the future.

My hope is that...

..somehow, I can, um...

..inspire my children.

They can take their
own path if they want.

And I will always
be there for them.

There was a blue
Astra following us.

Where?

I don't know.

I'm jumping at shadows.

The time between the head
blow and the stabbing...

Why would the killer stay longer
than necessary in the house?

And with the boys
asleep upstairs.

Talking of the boys,

what do we think about Dom
hearing his mum and Kate arguing?

I don't know.

Miriam doesn't seem to have
a ready answer, either.

Yeah. Sounds like the fallout of
Mike and Carol's break-up was toxic.

Maybe the boys blamed Kate for
breaking up the family? Mm.

Thanks.

Blue with hints of olive?

Pigeon's Breath?

Always a favourite.

The killer carries the
body up the stairs.

Her feet hit the wall and
her nail scraped the paint.

The half landing's quite tight.

So, he has to turn,
90-degree angle.

Here.

Can you pass the torch?

Discrete distribution.

1mm tops.

Aspirated blood.

Sudden manipulation of the body can
cause exhalations great and small.

Suggests she had some blood
in her airways already. So...

..we know she sustained the head
injury significantly earlier

than the fatal
stabbing in her room,

and we know she was
carried - alive, probably -

up or down the stairs.
Up seems more likely.

So, the head injury was
likely inflicted downstairs.

The grooves in the head
wound, what do you reckon?

I reckon.

Size and shape are
a visual match.

Dumbbells typically come in
pairs. Do you see another one?

We're one short.

You said the kitchen
bin bag was missing?

The killer hits her
with a dumbbell,

and some time later
stabs her with a knife,

gets rid of both
weapons from the scene.

What're we missing?

Blood.

Hit the lights.

That's a fair bit of blood.

Swirl pattern.

Definitely a clean-up job.

Fibres coincident with
areas of strong luminescence

adhered in the blood.

Rust-coloured and white.

Loose item of clothing
perhaps? Scarf, cardigan...

Bill got good
coverage of the scene.

This is a comprehensive set.

He didn't.

You did.

I don't know, just feel a bit...

Conflicted?

A bit shit. About everything.

You don't have any
reason to. No...

He just got tired, I think.

Should've got out sooner.

Easy mistake to make.

There was blood spatter on the
curtains and a fingerprint.

Maybe you weren't
jumping at shadows.

Jack.

DC Puri.

Keeping tabs on us?

I'm sorry? You're
following us.

Afraid we'll find something?

I was told you
requested some evidence.

Ryan Laing's slippers?

Hi. Nikki Alexander.

DC Meena Puri.

Look...

I know the Lyell by reputation, and
I'm relieved you guys are on this.

I'm getting really
tired of hearing that.

Why do you say that?
That you're "relieved"?

I just don't think we should
be jumping to conclusions.

About what?

Kate Freeman's guilt?

About anything.

A PoLSA team searched the
surrounding streets this morning.

I'll find out what
they turned up,

then check with House-To-House
and get back to you.

If you haven't heard
from me by morning...

..call me.

I want to go back to the
crime scene with Ryan Laing.

Yes, I know how potentially
traumatic that could be.

I was thinking more about
the safeguarding red tape.

We've found glass adhered in
blood on one of his slipper.

You see, the layering
tells a story.

It tells us Ryan swept the
glass from his broken light bulb

under his bed after he trod in
his mum's blood in her bedroom.

The bulb was broken on
the night of the attack,

but Ryan chose to hide it.

Question is, why?

Cumulatively, our findings
show that the Crown

have a poor grasp
of what occurred.

They didn't know Carol
was attacked downstairs,

that the dumbbell used
in the attack is missing,

and that the killer
carried Carol upstairs

and waited before stabbing
her to death on her bed.

How can they make a case
against Kate Freeman

when the scene's been
so badly misunderstood?

Good job Burnett's retiring.

His work's borderline
incompetent.

The gap between the head
blow and the fatal stabbing.

We can prove it definitively?

We can try.

Burnett was so sure the
brain bleed was recent

that he didn't
take a trauma set.

We can remedy that. Should
help narrow down the timeframe.

Excellent. Why is
the time important?

Because it suggests a killer
who was comfortable in the house

with the boys asleep upstairs.

Someone who belonged there?

And that's not Kate.

I'm going to head home.

Are you? Yeah.

Feeling my short night.

I need to run the brain
samples through the processor

so they're ready for staining.
Ah, it's a glamorous life.

I'll see you later. OK?

PHONE RINGS

Jack Hodgson.

It's Kate Freeman.

Sorry to call you.

It's OK. What can I do for you?

Miriam, she's a good brief, but
she's such a bull in a china shop.

You asked why I'm on suspension,
and you deserve an answer.

Actually, Nikki asked.

But it would be good
to get more context.

OK...

But I'd rather
meet face-to-face.

I mean, you never
know who's listening.

Hi.

Thanks for coming. No problem.

You and Nikki, you're, um,
you're a couple, right?

And we thought we
hid it so well.

Me and Mike, we only started seeing
each other after he left Carol,

but no-one believes that.

Bridget punished Mike by
putting him back in uniform.

He was a detective before that?

Detective Sergeant.

HE EXHALES

She'll do anything to protect
her family as she sees it.

Total control freak.

And she put you on suspension?

I feel your pain,
Kate, I really do.

Fred wasn't just a bloody
good copper, he was mate.

Then you'll know how hard
he was fighting his cancer.

When someone takes their own life,
the first thing people say is,

"I didn't see it
coming." I don't buy it!

Sorry, ma'am.

Look, Kate. His car was
found at Southbay Bridge.

You know how many people go
over the side there every year?

How few bodies are ever...

Ray Palmer.

I'm sorry?

Fred received a threat-to-life from
Detective Superintendent Ray Palmer.

That's a very serious
allegation, Kate.

Yes, it is.

About a very senior officer.

And we need to be treating Fred's
disappearance as suspicious.

Do you have any evidence
to back this up?

Because there's idle gossip,

and there's trashing
a man's good name.

Only one is forgivable.

Why did Palmer
threaten your partner?

Fred was on a bit of a crusade
about Harbour Fields. Mm-hm.

One night, we pulled
this dealer over

who said he'd been told it was
OK to operate in Harbour Fields.

That he'd been given assurances.

And Fred believed him?

He found evidence Harbour Fields
was being left unpatrolled,

effectively allowing dealers
to sell there with impunity.

Does this have
anything to do with the

"Stop Goshawk
Construction" stuff?

They're seeking to buy
the land, torch the estate

and turn it into
a gated community.

But first, they need the courts to
grant a compulsory purchase order.

Uh-huh, and a rocketing crime rate
goes a long way to secure that.

A long way.

If Fred was right
about this, it stinks.

This is grade-A corruption,

and Bridget didn't
give it a second look?

How about we take a
trip to the bridge?

We've got a clot that's
adherent to the brain.

A fresh clot slides
off the brain.

Conversely, it takes
hours for fibrin to form

and the clot to adhere
to the brain's surface.

There it is in black and white.

We're talking two hours between the
head injury and the fatal stabbing.

Was this area searched?

Not officially, cos his death
wasn't treated as suspicious.

If you were going to throw
yourself off the bridge,

would you really park
all the way down here?

What happened to Woods's car?

It's in his garage.

DOOR BELL RINGS

Hmm, Mike.

Andrew. You should've
said you were coming,

we would've saved you some!

Mike...

I'm really sorry about Carol.

Where are they?

Why don't you sit down for a
minute? I want to see my kids.

Of course. They're
watching TV.

Outside, please.

PHONE RINGS

It's the lab. Answer it.

Speaking.

Coffee?

Find anything?

Bootprints on the
pedal, bit of foliage.

Do you know how the
car was brought here?

Low-loader. They
couldn't find the key.

Is there anything else - anything
at all - that might help us?

I mean, like I said, I
didn't exactly encourage Fred

to air his theories.

Tell me about Palmer, then.

This threat he made.

Fred found evidence
that our patrol grid

had been revised at
the behest of Palmer.

Which is weird in itself.

Why?

CID don't hold sway over uniform
logistics or, to be honest,

have much interest in them.

Did Fred confront Palmer?

Palmer denied it, just told
Fred to wind his neck in.

And then, a week later, Fred finds
himself next to Palmer in the gents.

And as Palmer zips
up, he tells him,

"There's faster ways
to die than cancer."

That night, was Mike talking
about Palmer when he said,

"I don't want him in my house"?

No, DI Andrew Walsh.

Walsh? Mm.

A lot of history
between Mike and Andrew.

When Mike was 11 or 12,

Bridget fostered both Andrew
and his little sister, Lisa.

Wow. Yeah.

They're like brothers, almost.

I wouldn't go that far, but...

PHONE RINGS

It's Miriam.

Hi, Miriam.

Hi, Kate. I need you to get
to the station straightaway.

There's new evidence. DS Ray
Palmer's running the show now.

I'll be right there.

So, Kate...

You said you'd never been
upstairs at the Laing house.

But we've found compelling
evidence that you have.

A hair on Carol's bed not
two feet from her body

bears DNA which is
a 100% match to you.

Then, above the bed, we found
a fingerprint on the curtain.

Again...

..a perfect match to you.

I mean, I can see why you might
want to draw the curtains.

We brought the kids
home the other day,

Mike and I.

Carol was delayed somewhere.

Mike told me to grab a coffee

while he looked for some
clothes he'd left upstairs.

Careful...!

Oh, they're not the kind
of curtains you draw.

Only the best for our Carol.

HE CHUCKLES

That explains it.

Hey?

That's how your
hair got on the bed.

That's how your fingerprint got
on the curtain. It's case closed.

Only one question.

Why did you tell us you'd
never been upstairs?

Hmm?

Why did you lie to us?

People with nothing to
hide, they don't lie, Kate.

She has no alibi worth the name,
a witness puts her at the scene.

She had keys to the house,

and as for her explanation
for the prints and DNA,

don't believe a word of it.

This is Sally.

She's a child social worker.

Sally's going to make
extra sure everything's OK

and that nothing's too much.

Shall we go inside?

Kate Freeman, you're
charged that on 14th August

at Markland Avenue, Southbay,

you did murder Carol Laing
contrary to common law.

I know you went into your mum's
room. That took courage. Yeah?

And you had the presence
of mind to call 999,

tell them what happened,

then go and look after your
brother till the police arrived.

Brilliant.

But something
happened in this room.

Something that caused the
bulb in your lamp to smash.

Something I know you
don't want to talk about.

That's why you swept the
pieces under the bed.

But the thing is, without
that "something", Ryan...

..the story's incomplete.

Now, I might be
completely wrong here,

but I have this sense you
feel bad about something.

If I had to guess...

I'd say... you think
you let your mum down?

That you should've tried harder
to protect her? Save her?

You had no chance, Ryan.

No chance.

I did.

CLATTERING

He had gloves, and...

..he put his hand in my mouth.

His voice was... weird...

..like a bark, but quiet.

Like he was trying to
disguise it, maybe?

He said, "I've got
hidden cameras.

"If you or your brother try to
leave this room, I'll know."

You're sure it was a man?

♪ Testator silens

♪ Costestes e spiritu

♪ Silencium. ♪

Please rate this subtitle at www.osdb.link/bp4eb
Help other users to choose the best subtitles