Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:08,921 --> 00:00:11,098
In the criminal justice
system,
2
00:00:11,098 --> 00:00:12,403
the people are represented
3
00:00:12,403 --> 00:00:15,145
by two separate,
yet equally important groups:
4
00:00:15,145 --> 00:00:16,973
the police,
who investigate crime,
5
00:00:16,973 --> 00:00:19,845
and the district attorneys,
who prosecute the offenders.
6
00:00:19,845 --> 00:00:22,370
These are their stories.
7
00:00:22,370 --> 00:00:24,415
- Mr. Zanford! Mr. Zanford!
- How do you feel about
8
00:00:24,415 --> 00:00:25,764
your wife serving you
with divorce papers
9
00:00:25,764 --> 00:00:27,070
on the floor of the stock
exchange this morning?
10
00:00:27,070 --> 00:00:29,333
Blindsided.
How the hell would you feel?
11
00:00:29,333 --> 00:00:30,856
Um, excuse me!
I have one more question.
12
00:00:30,856 --> 00:00:33,207
Do you have a minute?
- Toxicity and negativity
13
00:00:33,207 --> 00:00:35,165
are contrary
to everything Mark Zanford
14
00:00:35,165 --> 00:00:37,124
has spent the last 20 years building.
15
00:00:37,124 --> 00:00:39,604
His app, Connectivity,
promotes healthy,
16
00:00:39,604 --> 00:00:42,303
positive connections,
and so does Mark.
17
00:00:42,303 --> 00:00:44,348
Will your personal problems
impact the company?
18
00:00:44,348 --> 00:00:46,785
Do you think that's why
the stock price is off 10%?
19
00:00:46,785 --> 00:00:49,875
Mark's wife tried
to ruin his moment in the sun.
20
00:00:49,875 --> 00:00:53,401
That alone should tell you
what kind of a woman she is.
21
00:00:53,401 --> 00:00:55,577
This whole nightmare
is your fault.
22
00:00:55,577 --> 00:00:58,188
I'm not the one shagging
a 20-year-old yoga teacher.
23
00:00:58,188 --> 00:01:00,756
Just do your job.
24
00:01:03,846 --> 00:01:05,108
[exhales]
25
00:01:05,108 --> 00:01:07,241
DOA is Dana Clarkson.
26
00:01:07,241 --> 00:01:09,765
43 years old, single, no kids.
27
00:01:09,765 --> 00:01:11,419
Lives on Central Park West.
28
00:01:11,419 --> 00:01:12,942
Possible strangulation.
29
00:01:12,942 --> 00:01:14,509
[whistles, sighs]
30
00:01:14,509 --> 00:01:16,989
Bruises on her face,
abrasions on her hands.
31
00:01:16,989 --> 00:01:18,600
She put up a fight.
32
00:01:18,600 --> 00:01:20,080
Have the MLI bag her hands
and get a sexual assault kit.
33
00:01:20,080 --> 00:01:21,081
You get a time of death?
34
00:01:21,081 --> 00:01:22,386
MLI puts it at some time
35
00:01:22,386 --> 00:01:23,822
between 8:00 and midnight
last night.
36
00:01:23,822 --> 00:01:25,128
Witnesses?
37
00:01:25,128 --> 00:01:26,956
Woman who runs
the laundromat called it in.
38
00:01:26,956 --> 00:01:29,393
Found the body on the stairs
when she came to open up.
39
00:01:29,393 --> 00:01:30,655
How about cameras?
40
00:01:30,655 --> 00:01:31,917
Nothing so far.
41
00:01:31,917 --> 00:01:33,789
She's still got
her credit cards and cash.
42
00:01:33,789 --> 00:01:35,573
Her phone is missing,
43
00:01:35,573 --> 00:01:37,401
assuming she had one with her,
of course.
44
00:01:37,401 --> 00:01:39,099
Found this on the ground.
45
00:01:39,099 --> 00:01:40,926
[tense music]
46
00:01:40,926 --> 00:01:42,406
Connectivity.
47
00:01:42,406 --> 00:01:44,278
Must have been
at some sort of event.
48
00:01:44,278 --> 00:01:46,367
Looks like
she was a crisis consultant.
49
00:01:46,367 --> 00:01:49,631
Yeah, well,
some things aren't fixable.
50
00:01:53,287 --> 00:01:56,246
[dramatic music]
51
00:01:56,246 --> 00:02:03,427
♪
52
00:02:39,376 --> 00:02:41,378
Dana Clarkson
was at your event last night.
53
00:02:41,378 --> 00:02:42,553
That's correct.
54
00:02:42,553 --> 00:02:43,859
What were you two arguing
about?
55
00:02:43,859 --> 00:02:45,643
Arguing?
56
00:02:45,643 --> 00:02:47,732
This whole nightmare
is your fault.
57
00:02:47,732 --> 00:02:50,692
I'm not the one shagging
a 20-year-old yoga teacher.
58
00:02:50,692 --> 00:02:52,128
I was venting.
59
00:02:52,128 --> 00:02:53,434
Half of Dana's job
is putting up
60
00:02:53,434 --> 00:02:55,349
with loudmouthed alphas
like me.
61
00:02:55,349 --> 00:02:56,959
Where did you
and Ms. Clarkson go
62
00:02:56,959 --> 00:02:58,134
after you got in the car?
63
00:02:58,134 --> 00:02:59,657
I went to my apartment.
64
00:02:59,657 --> 00:03:01,442
Dana was supposed
to go to hers.
65
00:03:01,442 --> 00:03:02,878
- Supposed to?
- Yeah.
66
00:03:02,878 --> 00:03:03,966
She got a text.
67
00:03:03,966 --> 00:03:05,272
Uh, made her really mad,
68
00:03:05,272 --> 00:03:06,969
and she asked my driver
to pull over.
69
00:03:06,969 --> 00:03:08,449
And she got out of the car.
70
00:03:08,449 --> 00:03:11,843
Can you think of anyone
who didn't like Dana?
71
00:03:11,843 --> 00:03:12,888
Yeah, lots of people.
72
00:03:12,888 --> 00:03:14,890
She had sharp elbows.
73
00:03:14,890 --> 00:03:16,718
That's why I hired her.
74
00:03:16,718 --> 00:03:19,808
Did any of those people
show up to your IPO party?
75
00:03:19,808 --> 00:03:22,811
My crazy soon-to-be ex-wife
tried to crash the event.
76
00:03:22,811 --> 00:03:25,161
What,
Dana got involved in that?
77
00:03:25,161 --> 00:03:26,423
She did, yeah,
she called security,
78
00:03:26,423 --> 00:03:28,730
had them toss her out.
79
00:03:28,730 --> 00:03:31,298
That's what a crisis manager does.
80
00:03:31,298 --> 00:03:33,256
Then my wife went crazy.
81
00:03:33,256 --> 00:03:35,302
Started swearing at Dana.
82
00:03:35,302 --> 00:03:37,608
She threw a glass at her.
83
00:03:37,608 --> 00:03:39,523
And she threatened to kill her.
84
00:03:39,523 --> 00:03:41,960
She blames Dana
for ruining her career.
85
00:03:41,960 --> 00:03:42,918
Did she?
86
00:03:44,746 --> 00:03:47,879
I didn't pay Dana 500 grand
for nothing.
87
00:03:50,099 --> 00:03:52,710
Hey, I just got off the phone
with the medical examiner.
88
00:03:52,710 --> 00:03:55,844
Cause of death
was mechanical asphyxiation.
89
00:03:55,844 --> 00:03:57,976
She thinks the killer
may have used some kind
90
00:03:57,976 --> 00:03:59,369
of soft piece of clothing.
91
00:03:59,369 --> 00:04:02,590
They found some blue
and white and maroon fibers
92
00:04:02,590 --> 00:04:04,113
on her throat.
- Necktie?
93
00:04:04,113 --> 00:04:05,070
They think it's a scarf.
94
00:04:05,070 --> 00:04:06,507
Forensics shows some kind
95
00:04:06,507 --> 00:04:09,379
of high-end mulberry silk.
- DNA?
96
00:04:09,379 --> 00:04:11,425
Yeah,
they found some skin cells
97
00:04:11,425 --> 00:04:12,904
underneath
the victim's fingernails,
98
00:04:12,904 --> 00:04:15,037
so we're just waiting
on the results now.
99
00:04:15,037 --> 00:04:17,909
Well, it wasn't Zanford.
The driver backs up his story.
100
00:04:17,909 --> 00:04:19,346
Does the driver know why
Dana got out
101
00:04:19,346 --> 00:04:20,738
of the car so suddenly?
102
00:04:20,738 --> 00:04:23,001
Nah, he just pulled over
and she just hopped out.
103
00:04:23,001 --> 00:04:24,568
What about Zanford's wife?
104
00:04:24,568 --> 00:04:26,396
She's bitter as hell,
that's for sure.
105
00:04:26,396 --> 00:04:29,094
Her social media is a--
practically a tribute
106
00:04:29,094 --> 00:04:30,313
to her hatred of Dana Clarkson.
107
00:04:30,313 --> 00:04:33,142
Yeah, and she doesn't just
talk the talk.
108
00:04:33,142 --> 00:04:34,622
There's violence in her past.
109
00:04:34,622 --> 00:04:37,929
Last year she was accused
of assaulting her assistant.
110
00:04:37,929 --> 00:04:40,410
Well, last night
she was assaulting martinis.
111
00:04:40,410 --> 00:04:42,412
This is her at the Lava Club.
112
00:04:42,412 --> 00:04:43,848
Is that in Midtown?
113
00:04:43,848 --> 00:04:44,893
East 53rd.
114
00:04:44,893 --> 00:04:46,590
Not far
from the murder scene.
115
00:04:46,590 --> 00:04:49,941
Yeah, and I bet
she owns a few silk scarves.
116
00:04:49,941 --> 00:04:52,553
Let's find out where she lives,
get a search warrant.
117
00:04:55,860 --> 00:04:59,299
Why is the story
of a crazy woman so compelling?
118
00:04:59,299 --> 00:05:01,649
Pretty simple--you threatened
to kill Dana Clarkson
119
00:05:01,649 --> 00:05:03,085
a few hours
before she was killed.
120
00:05:03,085 --> 00:05:06,349
Okay, do you know
how many people hated Dana?
121
00:05:06,349 --> 00:05:07,829
So you admit, you hated her?
122
00:05:07,829 --> 00:05:09,613
Yes, definitely.
123
00:05:09,613 --> 00:05:12,050
She planted fake stories
about me having affairs,
124
00:05:12,050 --> 00:05:13,530
being an alcoholic.
125
00:05:13,530 --> 00:05:15,793
Last night
she paid a photographer
126
00:05:15,793 --> 00:05:17,882
to trip me outside of some club
127
00:05:17,882 --> 00:05:19,841
just to make me look like
a drunken fool.
128
00:05:19,841 --> 00:05:22,017
- What do you got?
- Ms. Zanford...
129
00:05:24,454 --> 00:05:27,152
You wanna explain this?
130
00:05:27,152 --> 00:05:29,111
[tense music]
131
00:05:29,111 --> 00:05:30,199
Um...
132
00:05:30,199 --> 00:05:31,722
[handcuffs clinking]
It's...
133
00:05:31,722 --> 00:05:34,029
it's--it's not--
it's not what you think.
134
00:05:34,029 --> 00:05:35,770
Well,
I think you're under arrest
135
00:05:35,770 --> 00:05:38,468
for the murder
of Dana Clarkson.
136
00:05:44,082 --> 00:05:46,563
Like I keep telling you,
I didn't kill her.
137
00:05:46,563 --> 00:05:48,391
The shirt is being tested
for DNA.
138
00:05:48,391 --> 00:05:51,568
When the blood comes back
as Dana Clarkson's,
139
00:05:51,568 --> 00:05:53,570
the time
for explanations will be over.
140
00:05:53,570 --> 00:05:56,356
Now is your chance to get out
in front of this.
141
00:06:00,316 --> 00:06:05,103
Uh, blood
on that shirt isn't Dana's.
142
00:06:05,103 --> 00:06:07,149
It's mine.
143
00:06:07,149 --> 00:06:10,152
[somber music]
144
00:06:10,152 --> 00:06:12,937
♪
145
00:06:12,937 --> 00:06:14,417
You self-harm?
146
00:06:14,417 --> 00:06:16,637
Yes.
147
00:06:16,637 --> 00:06:21,424
I started
when I was a teenager and...
148
00:06:21,424 --> 00:06:25,428
then when Mark and I separated,
149
00:06:25,428 --> 00:06:28,300
people started attacking me online.
150
00:06:28,300 --> 00:06:30,781
I just felt very alone.
151
00:06:30,781 --> 00:06:34,306
♪
152
00:06:34,306 --> 00:06:37,397
Uh, forensics. Not a match.
153
00:06:37,397 --> 00:06:39,311
You're free to go, ma'am.
154
00:06:39,311 --> 00:06:41,270
Officer Preston's
gonna show you out.
155
00:06:46,231 --> 00:06:49,104
The skin cells found under
the victim's fingernails
156
00:06:49,104 --> 00:06:50,453
weren't a match.
157
00:06:50,453 --> 00:06:52,629
The DNA belongs to a man, so...
158
00:06:52,629 --> 00:06:54,762
So we're looking for a man
with no criminal record.
159
00:06:54,762 --> 00:06:56,459
Mostly likely someone
with a personal grudge
160
00:06:56,459 --> 00:06:57,895
against the vic.
- That's right.
161
00:06:57,895 --> 00:06:59,201
So we're gonna keep digging.
162
00:06:59,201 --> 00:07:00,681
We're gonna look
into her personal life,
163
00:07:00,681 --> 00:07:02,944
into her professional life.
164
00:07:02,944 --> 00:07:05,555
Someone with a job like that is
bound to have a lot of enemies.
165
00:07:05,555 --> 00:07:10,038
♪
166
00:07:10,038 --> 00:07:11,953
Dana was
a never-let-'em-see-you-sweat
167
00:07:11,953 --> 00:07:13,433
kind of woman.
168
00:07:13,433 --> 00:07:15,783
Came from nothing,
grew up in rural West Virginia.
169
00:07:15,783 --> 00:07:17,959
Her father was a coal miner.
170
00:07:17,959 --> 00:07:20,614
She worked like hell
to build her firm, her life.
171
00:07:20,614 --> 00:07:22,137
The day of the murder,
172
00:07:22,137 --> 00:07:23,486
anything
out of the ordinary happen?
173
00:07:23,486 --> 00:07:26,620
She had a lunch with someone.
174
00:07:26,620 --> 00:07:28,056
The name wasn't
on her calendar,
175
00:07:28,056 --> 00:07:29,492
which was weird.
176
00:07:29,492 --> 00:07:31,494
Well,
everybody's got secrets.
177
00:07:31,494 --> 00:07:33,017
When she came back
from lunch,
178
00:07:33,017 --> 00:07:34,497
she asked
for the nonemergency number
179
00:07:34,497 --> 00:07:37,282
for the local police precinct.
180
00:07:37,282 --> 00:07:38,806
Where was this lunch?
181
00:07:38,806 --> 00:07:41,852
I'll get that for you.
182
00:07:41,852 --> 00:07:43,550
I just--
[sighs]
183
00:07:43,550 --> 00:07:47,118
I--I can't believe Dana's dead.
184
00:07:47,118 --> 00:07:48,903
How'd you know her?
185
00:07:48,903 --> 00:07:51,688
Well, we've been friends
for, like, 20 years,
186
00:07:51,688 --> 00:07:53,037
since college.
187
00:07:53,037 --> 00:07:54,778
We get together ever time
I'm in the city.
188
00:07:54,778 --> 00:07:57,259
I--I live in Zurich full-time.
189
00:07:57,259 --> 00:08:00,697
But she is--
190
00:08:00,697 --> 00:08:03,483
was an amazing woman.
191
00:08:03,483 --> 00:08:05,441
I always told her,
if I weren't gay,
192
00:08:05,441 --> 00:08:07,182
I'd have proposed years ago.
193
00:08:07,182 --> 00:08:09,271
[chuckles]
194
00:08:09,271 --> 00:08:10,838
Did anything happen
during lunch,
195
00:08:10,838 --> 00:08:13,667
something that would upset her
enough to call the police?
196
00:08:15,320 --> 00:08:18,976
Dana was worried about
this ex-boyfriend.
197
00:08:18,976 --> 00:08:20,674
Was he harassing her?
198
00:08:20,674 --> 00:08:22,806
More like stalking.
199
00:08:22,806 --> 00:08:26,331
I mean, he reappeared
in her life a few months ago.
200
00:08:26,331 --> 00:08:28,420
And she told him, like,
"Leave me alone,"
201
00:08:28,420 --> 00:08:30,161
but he wouldn't let it go.
202
00:08:30,161 --> 00:08:32,555
She was terrified.
203
00:08:32,555 --> 00:08:34,426
Was he ever violent with her?
204
00:08:34,426 --> 00:08:36,211
Yeah,
when they were together,
205
00:08:36,211 --> 00:08:37,952
she ended up
in the emergency room.
206
00:08:37,952 --> 00:08:39,910
I mean, at least once.
207
00:08:39,910 --> 00:08:41,433
Maybe twice.
208
00:08:41,433 --> 00:08:43,131
You got this guy's name?
209
00:08:48,353 --> 00:08:49,877
Dana and I had dated
a few years ago,
210
00:08:49,877 --> 00:08:52,749
even lived together,
on paper at least.
211
00:08:52,749 --> 00:08:54,185
What does that mean?
212
00:08:54,185 --> 00:08:55,665
She wasn't ready
for real intimacy.
213
00:08:55,665 --> 00:08:58,407
- She broke it off?
- It--it was amicable.
214
00:08:58,407 --> 00:09:00,365
We wanted different things.
- Amicable?
215
00:09:00,365 --> 00:09:01,758
We checked
her hospital records.
216
00:09:01,758 --> 00:09:04,369
She was admitted to the ER
at least twice
217
00:09:04,369 --> 00:09:05,457
while you guys were dating.
218
00:09:05,457 --> 00:09:06,720
One for a cut above her eye,
219
00:09:06,720 --> 00:09:09,636
and the other
for a broken wrist, so...
220
00:09:09,636 --> 00:09:10,854
What the hell are you trying
to say, that I had something
221
00:09:10,854 --> 00:09:12,029
to do with that?
222
00:09:12,029 --> 00:09:13,509
- Correct.
- Well, you're wrong.
223
00:09:13,509 --> 00:09:14,423
Maybe.
224
00:09:14,423 --> 00:09:15,467
Just have a few more questions
225
00:09:15,467 --> 00:09:17,731
and we'll be out of your hair.
226
00:09:17,731 --> 00:09:19,776
When's the last time you spoke
to Dana?
227
00:09:19,776 --> 00:09:21,082
A while back.
228
00:09:21,082 --> 00:09:23,084
At the height of the pandemic,
she reached out.
229
00:09:23,084 --> 00:09:25,652
- Why is that?
- She was lonely.
230
00:09:25,652 --> 00:09:27,436
That was the last time
we spoke.
231
00:09:27,436 --> 00:09:29,220
Yeah, we're not buying a word
of this nonsense.
232
00:09:29,220 --> 00:09:32,572
Phone records show that you
and Dana exchanged phone calls
233
00:09:32,572 --> 00:09:34,661
as recently as three days ago.
234
00:09:34,661 --> 00:09:36,227
Excuse me.
235
00:09:36,227 --> 00:09:38,621
Oh, sorry.
236
00:09:38,621 --> 00:09:41,058
- What's going on?
- It's all right, honey.
237
00:09:41,058 --> 00:09:42,669
These men are just leaving.
238
00:09:42,669 --> 00:09:45,672
[tense music]
239
00:09:45,672 --> 00:09:50,328
♪
240
00:09:50,328 --> 00:09:51,634
Well,
he's lying through his teeth.
241
00:09:51,634 --> 00:09:53,854
Yeah, we got enough
for a search warrant.
242
00:09:53,854 --> 00:09:56,421
Let's get patrol
to come seal off the location.
243
00:09:58,467 --> 00:09:59,990
Whoa, whoa. Hold up.
244
00:09:59,990 --> 00:10:01,775
What you got?
245
00:10:01,775 --> 00:10:08,608
♪
246
00:10:11,698 --> 00:10:13,264
Does that look like silk
to you?
247
00:10:13,264 --> 00:10:16,267
Maroon, blue, and white
like the ME said.
248
00:10:16,267 --> 00:10:17,486
Uh-huh.
249
00:10:17,486 --> 00:10:19,401
What are you
still doing here?
250
00:10:19,401 --> 00:10:21,490
Sir, you mind
stepping outside?
251
00:10:21,490 --> 00:10:23,710
Just step outside.
252
00:10:23,710 --> 00:10:25,015
Let's go.
253
00:10:25,015 --> 00:10:26,800
We need to talk to you
down at the precinct.
254
00:10:26,800 --> 00:10:29,585
♪
255
00:10:36,331 --> 00:10:38,159
I've never seen
that scarf before.
256
00:10:38,159 --> 00:10:41,728
We found it in your trash.
257
00:10:41,728 --> 00:10:43,555
I didn't kill Dana.
258
00:10:43,555 --> 00:10:45,383
I would never do something
like that, ever!
259
00:10:45,383 --> 00:10:46,646
So why did you lie to us
260
00:10:46,646 --> 00:10:48,473
about being on the phone
with her recently?
261
00:10:48,473 --> 00:10:50,171
We have the phone records.
262
00:10:50,171 --> 00:10:52,129
I just got married.
263
00:10:52,129 --> 00:10:54,001
I didn't want my wife
to find out.
264
00:10:54,001 --> 00:10:56,481
She gets jealous
of ex-girlfriends,
265
00:10:56,481 --> 00:10:57,657
especially Dana.
266
00:10:57,657 --> 00:10:59,571
Still doesn't explain why
267
00:10:59,571 --> 00:11:02,662
you were on the phone
with Dana recently.
268
00:11:02,662 --> 00:11:04,359
She was having
money problems.
269
00:11:04,359 --> 00:11:05,665
So she hit you up for money?
270
00:11:05,665 --> 00:11:07,667
Yes, which was concerning
271
00:11:07,667 --> 00:11:09,712
because she never asks
for help.
272
00:11:09,712 --> 00:11:12,019
She solves everyone else's
problems, you know?
273
00:11:12,019 --> 00:11:14,499
So I knew that she was
in some real trouble.
274
00:11:14,499 --> 00:11:15,979
Did you lend her any money?
275
00:11:15,979 --> 00:11:18,199
No, I was trying
to figure out a way
276
00:11:18,199 --> 00:11:20,114
to broach the subject
with my wife, but--
277
00:11:20,114 --> 00:11:23,552
That still does not explain
the scarf,
278
00:11:23,552 --> 00:11:28,513
the murder weapon that we found
outside of your house.
279
00:11:28,513 --> 00:11:30,820
If I really killed her
with that scarf,
280
00:11:30,820 --> 00:11:32,692
would I be stupid enough
to just toss it
281
00:11:32,692 --> 00:11:34,606
on the top of a damn trash bin?
282
00:11:37,000 --> 00:11:39,002
Ay, forensics
and the scarf came back.
283
00:11:39,002 --> 00:11:42,397
So Dana Clarkson's DNA
and blood are all over it,
284
00:11:42,397 --> 00:11:44,181
but no trace of Dr. Royce.
285
00:11:44,181 --> 00:11:47,271
And his story about
Dana's financials checks out.
286
00:11:47,271 --> 00:11:48,664
She was underwater.
287
00:11:48,664 --> 00:11:49,970
Bank account was near zero,
288
00:11:49,970 --> 00:11:51,667
mortgage was 90 days delinquent,
289
00:11:51,667 --> 00:11:54,017
and she owed over 200,000
in credit cards.
290
00:11:54,017 --> 00:11:55,845
But she was successful, right?
291
00:11:55,845 --> 00:11:57,368
I mean,
she had a thriving business.
292
00:11:57,368 --> 00:11:58,456
Sure looked that way.
293
00:11:58,456 --> 00:11:59,849
So where'd all the money go?
294
00:11:59,849 --> 00:12:01,024
She have an addiction?
295
00:12:01,024 --> 00:12:03,766
Drugs, gambling,
private planes maybe?
296
00:12:03,766 --> 00:12:05,246
No indication
of anything like that,
297
00:12:05,246 --> 00:12:06,987
but a few hours
before the murder,
298
00:12:06,987 --> 00:12:08,466
her credit card was frozen.
299
00:12:08,466 --> 00:12:13,602
A dinner charge was declined
for 3,700 at Chez Roget.
300
00:12:13,602 --> 00:12:15,299
Check out the time
of the charge.
301
00:12:15,299 --> 00:12:17,040
9:17 p.m.
302
00:12:17,040 --> 00:12:20,435
That is about the time
she was in Mark Zanford's car.
303
00:12:20,435 --> 00:12:22,785
Cannot be in two places
at once.
304
00:12:22,785 --> 00:12:24,744
You better shine your shoes, fellas.
305
00:12:24,744 --> 00:12:25,832
You're about to go
to a restaurant
306
00:12:25,832 --> 00:12:29,226
that charges $3,700 for dinner.
307
00:12:29,226 --> 00:12:31,098
[whistles]
308
00:12:33,100 --> 00:12:35,058
No,
she doesn't look familiar.
309
00:12:35,058 --> 00:12:36,451
You remember
a card being declined
310
00:12:36,451 --> 00:12:38,148
for a $3,700 dinner?
311
00:12:38,148 --> 00:12:40,672
I do, but it was a man
using the card.
312
00:12:40,672 --> 00:12:41,804
What was his name?
313
00:12:41,804 --> 00:12:45,286
Uh,
his name was Dana Clarkson.
314
00:12:46,940 --> 00:12:48,680
If the card was declined,
315
00:12:48,680 --> 00:12:50,770
who ended up paying the bill?
316
00:12:50,770 --> 00:12:52,815
The woman he was with.
317
00:12:52,815 --> 00:12:54,991
Can I have her name?
318
00:12:54,991 --> 00:12:57,777
Our regulars rely
on our discretion.
319
00:12:57,777 --> 00:12:59,474
Yeah,
we're homicide detectives,
320
00:12:59,474 --> 00:13:00,954
not gossip columnists.
321
00:13:03,434 --> 00:13:05,697
Grace Pollard.
322
00:13:05,697 --> 00:13:06,742
The lawyer?
323
00:13:06,742 --> 00:13:09,658
[suspenseful music]
324
00:13:09,658 --> 00:13:12,269
Huh.
325
00:13:12,269 --> 00:13:14,097
I know who she is.
326
00:13:14,097 --> 00:13:21,017
♪
327
00:13:21,017 --> 00:13:23,846
Two nights ago,
you had dinner at Chez Roget.
328
00:13:23,846 --> 00:13:25,630
Your companion's credit card
was declined,
329
00:13:25,630 --> 00:13:27,328
and you ended up
paying the bill.
330
00:13:27,328 --> 00:13:28,982
Can you tell us
who you were with?
331
00:13:28,982 --> 00:13:30,853
Unfortunately,
I can't even confirm
332
00:13:30,853 --> 00:13:32,333
I was at that restaurant.
333
00:13:32,333 --> 00:13:34,291
Miss Pollard, the man
you were having dinner with
334
00:13:34,291 --> 00:13:36,119
tried to use the credit card
of a woman
335
00:13:36,119 --> 00:13:38,426
who was found strangled
and beaten to death
336
00:13:38,426 --> 00:13:40,689
less than two hours later.
337
00:13:45,607 --> 00:13:47,870
Are you asserting
attorney-client privilege?
338
00:13:47,870 --> 00:13:49,785
I can neither affirm
nor deny,
339
00:13:49,785 --> 00:13:51,961
and if you don't have
a warrant,
340
00:13:51,961 --> 00:13:54,181
I'm going to have to ask you
to leave.
341
00:13:54,181 --> 00:14:01,144
♪
342
00:14:02,711 --> 00:14:04,669
Why the hell
would Grace Pollard
343
00:14:04,669 --> 00:14:06,323
stonewall
a homicide investigation?
344
00:14:06,323 --> 00:14:08,673
Maybe she was with a client,
trying to protect him.
345
00:14:08,673 --> 00:14:10,458
From what is the question.
346
00:14:10,458 --> 00:14:11,763
We could get a subpoena,
347
00:14:11,763 --> 00:14:13,243
force her to give it up
in the grand jury.
348
00:14:13,243 --> 00:14:14,854
No, no,
she would rather go to jail
349
00:14:14,854 --> 00:14:16,116
than break confidentiality.
350
00:14:16,116 --> 00:14:17,857
Yeah, as long as the media
covers her story.
351
00:14:17,857 --> 00:14:18,901
Hold on a second.
352
00:14:18,901 --> 00:14:21,164
This woman has done a lot
of good.
353
00:14:21,164 --> 00:14:23,732
She's responsible
for getting date rape codified
354
00:14:23,732 --> 00:14:25,429
as a felony.
355
00:14:25,429 --> 00:14:26,996
She's a pioneer.
356
00:14:26,996 --> 00:14:28,606
She's been leading the charge
for women
357
00:14:28,606 --> 00:14:31,914
long before any of us even knew
about Me Too or Time's Up.
358
00:14:31,914 --> 00:14:33,742
- Fair enough.
- No arguments. She's a boss.
359
00:14:33,742 --> 00:14:35,309
[knock at door]
- Hey. I got something--
360
00:14:35,309 --> 00:14:37,180
security footage
from outside the restaurant
361
00:14:37,180 --> 00:14:39,617
about 15 minutes
after the card was declined.
362
00:14:39,617 --> 00:14:42,316
Can you punch in
on that face?
363
00:14:42,316 --> 00:14:43,926
I can send it to FAS
for facial rec.
364
00:14:43,926 --> 00:14:45,014
Don't bother.
365
00:14:45,014 --> 00:14:46,363
It's the guy who had lunch
366
00:14:46,363 --> 00:14:47,321
with Dana Clarkson,
367
00:14:47,321 --> 00:14:49,323
the college friend from Zurich.
368
00:14:49,323 --> 00:14:51,716
Pierre Briones.
369
00:14:51,716 --> 00:14:53,893
I'll check for an address.
370
00:14:55,764 --> 00:14:57,722
Here he is, Pierre Briones.
371
00:14:57,722 --> 00:15:00,377
Rents a townhouse
on 38th and 3rd.
372
00:15:00,377 --> 00:15:02,205
That's three blocks
from the murder.
373
00:15:02,205 --> 00:15:09,169
♪
374
00:15:10,997 --> 00:15:12,476
This guy wasn't visiting
from Zurich.
375
00:15:12,476 --> 00:15:14,130
He lives here.
376
00:15:18,743 --> 00:15:20,876
Hey, Detective,
come look at this.
377
00:15:20,876 --> 00:15:22,269
What you got?
378
00:15:25,185 --> 00:15:26,795
Nice work.
379
00:15:32,453 --> 00:15:33,454
Thank you.
380
00:15:38,546 --> 00:15:39,808
Andrew Hilton.
381
00:15:43,638 --> 00:15:45,945
Julian Matias.
382
00:15:48,599 --> 00:15:51,602
Vincent Balanza.
383
00:15:51,602 --> 00:15:53,474
Jeez.
384
00:15:55,563 --> 00:15:58,305
Dana Clarkson's
bank account info.
385
00:16:00,046 --> 00:16:01,221
Bag all this.
386
00:16:06,052 --> 00:16:07,836
This guy's got more passports
than James Bond.
387
00:16:07,836 --> 00:16:09,229
He's got a pile
of Dana Clarkson's
388
00:16:09,229 --> 00:16:11,796
financial records,
credit card applications,
389
00:16:11,796 --> 00:16:13,537
loan information,
all in her name.
390
00:16:13,537 --> 00:16:14,756
Wow, this guy's a real pro.
391
00:16:14,756 --> 00:16:15,757
Yeah, he is.
392
00:16:15,757 --> 00:16:17,802
[both laugh]
393
00:16:17,802 --> 00:16:20,805
[tense music]
394
00:16:20,805 --> 00:16:23,286
Stop, police!
395
00:16:23,286 --> 00:16:30,250
♪
396
00:16:37,692 --> 00:16:38,998
[car horn honks]
- [grunts]
397
00:16:38,998 --> 00:16:41,043
Whoa, whoa, whoa!
What are you doing?
398
00:16:41,043 --> 00:16:48,181
♪
399
00:16:52,098 --> 00:16:55,144
[car horns and alarms blaring]
400
00:17:10,725 --> 00:17:13,641
[both grunting]
401
00:17:15,295 --> 00:17:16,861
[groans]
402
00:17:16,861 --> 00:17:19,908
Pierre Briones,
you're under arrest
403
00:17:19,908 --> 00:17:21,214
for the murder
of Dana Clarkson.
404
00:17:21,214 --> 00:17:22,563
Too bad she's gone.
405
00:17:22,563 --> 00:17:24,478
You could use
a good crisis manager.
406
00:17:29,222 --> 00:17:31,485
Calling docket ending
in 9604,
407
00:17:31,485 --> 00:17:34,923
People v. Pierre Briones,
also known as Julian Matias,
408
00:17:34,923 --> 00:17:38,535
also known as Andrew Hilton,
also known as Vincent Balanza,
409
00:17:38,535 --> 00:17:40,581
also known as--
- What's his actual name?
410
00:17:40,581 --> 00:17:43,105
The defendant's true name
is Devon Miller.
411
00:17:43,105 --> 00:17:45,499
Mr. Miller pleads not guilty.
412
00:17:45,499 --> 00:17:47,240
I assume the people
are seeking remand?
413
00:17:47,240 --> 00:17:49,590
He's the very definition
of a flight risk.
414
00:17:49,590 --> 00:17:52,332
He has eight aliases
and nine dates of birth.
415
00:17:52,332 --> 00:17:54,247
My client has never been
convicted of a crime.
416
00:17:54,247 --> 00:17:56,466
In fact, he's never even been
arrested before.
417
00:17:56,466 --> 00:17:57,859
I'll hear your argument,
Ms. Maroun.
418
00:17:57,859 --> 00:17:59,730
The people's theory
is that the defendant
419
00:17:59,730 --> 00:18:02,168
romanced the victim,
Dana Clarkson,
420
00:18:02,168 --> 00:18:04,866
conned her out of almost
$1/2 million,
421
00:18:04,866 --> 00:18:07,173
and when she found out,
he killed her.
422
00:18:07,173 --> 00:18:09,218
The victim's body
was found three blocks
423
00:18:09,218 --> 00:18:10,437
from Mr. Miller's home.
424
00:18:10,437 --> 00:18:12,439
He lied to police
about both the nature
425
00:18:12,439 --> 00:18:14,615
of their relationship
and his true identity,
426
00:18:14,615 --> 00:18:18,053
and his DNA was found under
Ms. Clarkson's fingernails.
427
00:18:18,053 --> 00:18:20,403
The DNA merely proves
there was physical contact
428
00:18:20,403 --> 00:18:22,144
sometime that day.
429
00:18:22,144 --> 00:18:23,667
And the prosecutor failed
to mention
430
00:18:23,667 --> 00:18:26,148
that the murder weapon was
found at another man's home.
431
00:18:27,889 --> 00:18:30,544
Sounds like the people have
their work cut out for them.
432
00:18:30,544 --> 00:18:32,937
Bail is set at $1 million.
433
00:18:32,937 --> 00:18:35,201
[suspenseful music]
434
00:18:35,201 --> 00:18:37,333
Uh, one sec.
435
00:18:40,336 --> 00:18:42,164
Thank you so much.
Appreciate it.
436
00:18:42,164 --> 00:18:43,296
Yeah, I mean...
437
00:18:43,296 --> 00:18:45,428
Mr. Miller
will post bail forthwith.
438
00:18:48,562 --> 00:18:50,825
He's got profiles
on four dating sites
439
00:18:50,825 --> 00:18:53,523
mostly catered to older,
affluent singles.
440
00:18:53,523 --> 00:18:56,613
And the two women
we know he's dated
441
00:18:56,613 --> 00:19:00,008
are both sophisticated,
intelligent women.
442
00:19:00,008 --> 00:19:01,444
It's not about intelligence.
443
00:19:01,444 --> 00:19:04,055
He's an emotional predator.
444
00:19:04,055 --> 00:19:06,841
Thank God
I'm in a relationship.
445
00:19:06,841 --> 00:19:08,930
Lucky you.
446
00:19:08,930 --> 00:19:12,368
It's--it's hard meeting people
these days.
447
00:19:12,368 --> 00:19:16,242
[chuckles]
Online dating is a nightmare.
448
00:19:16,242 --> 00:19:17,982
That's how I met my partner.
449
00:19:17,982 --> 00:19:21,203
It's a numbers game, but you
have to put yourself out there.
450
00:19:21,203 --> 00:19:23,336
Oh, I put myself out there.
451
00:19:23,336 --> 00:19:26,295
I met my first husband
the old-fashioned way,
452
00:19:26,295 --> 00:19:28,689
drunk as hell at a biker bar
in Queens.
453
00:19:28,689 --> 00:19:33,041
And then my second husband
I met through mutual friends.
454
00:19:33,041 --> 00:19:34,521
I'm single now.
455
00:19:34,521 --> 00:19:36,784
I did get the Financial Frauds
report back,
456
00:19:36,784 --> 00:19:40,266
and this guy has conned
a slew of women.
457
00:19:40,266 --> 00:19:41,832
He's run up their credit cards.
458
00:19:41,832 --> 00:19:44,748
He persuaded them
to get car loans, mortgages,
459
00:19:44,748 --> 00:19:46,837
to wire money into his account.
460
00:19:46,837 --> 00:19:49,753
And judging by all the timing
of these transactions,
461
00:19:49,753 --> 00:19:52,060
he's just using one woman
to pay for the next.
462
00:19:52,060 --> 00:19:54,410
Wasn't he having dinner
with that lawyer Grace Pollard?
463
00:19:54,410 --> 00:19:56,151
- Yeah.
- You think it was a date?
464
00:19:56,151 --> 00:19:57,239
Possibly.
465
00:19:57,239 --> 00:19:58,632
I mean, we tried
to question her,
466
00:19:58,632 --> 00:20:00,590
and she invoked
attorney-client privilege.
467
00:20:00,590 --> 00:20:02,766
I followed up.
She refused to speak with me,
468
00:20:02,766 --> 00:20:05,595
so I issued a subpoena,
but she got it quashed.
469
00:20:05,595 --> 00:20:09,077
Look, we will get you a list
of all his other victims.
470
00:20:09,077 --> 00:20:11,514
- Thank you.
- All right.
471
00:20:11,514 --> 00:20:14,256
None of the victims
are willing to testify.
472
00:20:14,256 --> 00:20:15,736
Subpoena them.
473
00:20:15,736 --> 00:20:18,565
These women were conned,
but they're not stupid.
474
00:20:18,565 --> 00:20:20,219
We force them on the stand,
they'll refuse
475
00:20:20,219 --> 00:20:21,568
to admit they were duped.
476
00:20:21,568 --> 00:20:23,526
The financial records
will refute that.
477
00:20:23,526 --> 00:20:24,832
We have documents.
478
00:20:24,832 --> 00:20:26,573
We have evidence
that shows he has their money.
479
00:20:26,573 --> 00:20:27,835
They'll call it a loan,
480
00:20:27,835 --> 00:20:31,012
say they expect him
to pay them back.
481
00:20:31,012 --> 00:20:33,014
Good news is,
we have a clear motive.
482
00:20:33,014 --> 00:20:35,451
Dana Clarkson was planning
to expose Miller.
483
00:20:35,451 --> 00:20:37,061
[phone vibrates]
484
00:20:38,149 --> 00:20:40,108
What?
485
00:20:40,108 --> 00:20:41,501
Miller just fired his lawyer.
486
00:20:41,501 --> 00:20:43,067
He's gonna represent himself.
487
00:20:51,728 --> 00:20:53,600
This is a thinly veiled attempt
488
00:20:53,600 --> 00:20:55,123
to manipulate the process.
489
00:20:55,123 --> 00:20:57,821
The defendant is trying
to create an appealable issue.
490
00:20:57,821 --> 00:21:00,128
If he's convicted,
he'll ask for a new trial,
491
00:21:00,128 --> 00:21:01,956
claiming ineffective counsel.
492
00:21:01,956 --> 00:21:04,001
Also going pro se
allows the defendant
493
00:21:04,001 --> 00:21:06,787
to cross-examine
and intimidate our witnesses.
494
00:21:06,787 --> 00:21:09,093
It also allows him
to speak directly to the jury
495
00:21:09,093 --> 00:21:10,312
without being placed under oath
496
00:21:10,312 --> 00:21:12,009
or being subject
to cross-examination,
497
00:21:12,009 --> 00:21:14,838
which means he can say whatever
he wants with no repercussions.
498
00:21:14,838 --> 00:21:16,797
So what are you asking me
to do?
499
00:21:16,797 --> 00:21:19,800
To appoint stand-by counsel,
a lawyer who is required
500
00:21:19,800 --> 00:21:21,715
to comply with the rules
of professional responsibility
501
00:21:21,715 --> 00:21:23,630
who Ms. Maroun and I
can confer with.
502
00:21:23,630 --> 00:21:25,240
What do you say about that,
Mr. Miller?
503
00:21:25,240 --> 00:21:26,633
They can confer with me.
504
00:21:26,633 --> 00:21:28,548
I am happy to confer.
505
00:21:28,548 --> 00:21:30,376
And I should be able
to handle the rules of evidence
506
00:21:30,376 --> 00:21:32,334
as I did graduate
summa cum laude
507
00:21:32,334 --> 00:21:35,206
from Harvard College, and then
I went to Columbia Law School,
508
00:21:35,206 --> 00:21:37,078
so I should be fine.
509
00:21:37,078 --> 00:21:39,341
He was expelled from Columbia
for cheating.
510
00:21:39,341 --> 00:21:40,864
Excuse me.
The Sixth Amendment
511
00:21:40,864 --> 00:21:42,692
to the United States Constitution
512
00:21:42,692 --> 00:21:45,565
affords me the right
to represent myself.
513
00:21:49,395 --> 00:21:50,831
Okay, Mr. Miller.
514
00:21:50,831 --> 00:21:52,572
I'm allowing your application.
515
00:21:52,572 --> 00:21:55,575
You may act as your own lawyer.
516
00:21:55,575 --> 00:21:57,098
Thank you, Your Honor.
517
00:21:57,098 --> 00:22:00,057
[tense music]
518
00:22:00,057 --> 00:22:03,931
♪
519
00:22:09,066 --> 00:22:12,331
The defendant preyed
on intelligent,
520
00:22:12,331 --> 00:22:14,637
accomplished women,
521
00:22:14,637 --> 00:22:17,640
women who worked hard
to earn their money,
522
00:22:17,640 --> 00:22:20,382
but also their reputation.
523
00:22:20,382 --> 00:22:23,733
And who would rather face
financial ruin
524
00:22:23,733 --> 00:22:27,389
than go public and report what
had happened to them.
525
00:22:27,389 --> 00:22:31,001
But he underestimated
Dana Clarkson,
526
00:22:31,001 --> 00:22:35,919
a crisis manager who was
determined to expose him
527
00:22:35,919 --> 00:22:38,400
and make him pay
for what he had done.
528
00:22:38,400 --> 00:22:40,620
On the day of the murder,
529
00:22:40,620 --> 00:22:42,012
Ms. Clarkson met
with the defendant
530
00:22:42,012 --> 00:22:45,407
at Soho House for lunch,
demanding her money back.
531
00:22:45,407 --> 00:22:48,279
He made empty promises
to repay her,
532
00:22:48,279 --> 00:22:51,108
but later that night,
533
00:22:51,108 --> 00:22:53,067
when Ms. Clarkson discovered
534
00:22:53,067 --> 00:22:55,765
that he was still using
her credit card,
535
00:22:55,765 --> 00:22:58,377
she went to his home
to confront him.
536
00:22:58,377 --> 00:23:00,422
And in response,
537
00:23:00,422 --> 00:23:03,817
he savagely beat
538
00:23:03,817 --> 00:23:07,908
and strangled her to death.
539
00:23:07,908 --> 00:23:09,039
Don't be fooled
540
00:23:09,039 --> 00:23:12,434
by the defendant's
charming demeanor.
541
00:23:12,434 --> 00:23:14,044
After you've heard
all the evidence,
542
00:23:14,044 --> 00:23:17,396
you will learn
what Dana Clarkson learned
543
00:23:17,396 --> 00:23:18,745
the hard way...
544
00:23:21,530 --> 00:23:22,618
He's a con man.
545
00:23:25,447 --> 00:23:28,058
And a cold-blooded killer.
546
00:23:35,457 --> 00:23:38,112
Hi. Good morning.
547
00:23:38,112 --> 00:23:40,201
[exhales]
548
00:23:40,201 --> 00:23:43,465
I'm not a big-shot lawyer
like Mr. Price over there.
549
00:23:46,599 --> 00:23:48,557
And I'm fighting for my life.
550
00:23:48,557 --> 00:23:51,734
So please, I just ask,
be patient with me.
551
00:23:51,734 --> 00:23:54,171
I loved Dana Clarkson.
552
00:23:54,171 --> 00:23:56,435
I loved her.
She was a beautiful person,
553
00:23:56,435 --> 00:23:57,610
inside and out.
554
00:23:57,610 --> 00:24:00,264
Brilliant. Talented.
555
00:24:00,264 --> 00:24:02,571
So please, I just ask,
let's not speak of her
556
00:24:02,571 --> 00:24:03,572
like she's some piece
of evidence
557
00:24:03,572 --> 00:24:05,008
in this sham of a trial.
558
00:24:09,665 --> 00:24:12,755
Look, I didn't kill Dana.
559
00:24:12,755 --> 00:24:15,454
I would never, ever hurt her.
560
00:24:15,454 --> 00:24:17,760
Yes,
I saw her the day she died.
561
00:24:17,760 --> 00:24:19,762
Lots of people saw her
after our lunch.
562
00:24:19,762 --> 00:24:21,938
Any one of them could have
harmed her.
563
00:24:21,938 --> 00:24:24,288
She spent the evening
with the notoriously volatile
564
00:24:24,288 --> 00:24:26,639
tech mogul Mark Zanford.
565
00:24:26,639 --> 00:24:28,728
Maybe he killed her.
566
00:24:28,728 --> 00:24:31,600
Or it could have been
her abusive ex-boyfriend.
567
00:24:31,600 --> 00:24:33,907
Police found the murder weapon
at his home.
568
00:24:33,907 --> 00:24:35,212
[laughs]
569
00:24:36,736 --> 00:24:39,216
But it's not my job
to figure out who killed Dana.
570
00:24:39,216 --> 00:24:41,305
I have news for you:
it's not your job either.
571
00:24:41,305 --> 00:24:44,134
You know whose job it is?
572
00:24:44,134 --> 00:24:46,006
His.
573
00:24:46,006 --> 00:24:47,355
The prosecutor's.
574
00:24:47,355 --> 00:24:49,749
[tense music]
575
00:24:49,749 --> 00:24:52,403
And you'll see he has
fabricated a case against me.
576
00:24:52,403 --> 00:24:54,405
Mm.
577
00:24:54,405 --> 00:24:57,583
A case full of gaping holes.
578
00:24:57,583 --> 00:25:01,238
And in so doing,
he has deprived Dana Clarkson,
579
00:25:01,238 --> 00:25:06,548
my Dana, of the justice
and respect she deserves.
580
00:25:08,594 --> 00:25:11,335
Thank you.
581
00:25:11,335 --> 00:25:15,731
♪
582
00:25:15,731 --> 00:25:18,865
Mr. Price, you may call
your first witness.
583
00:25:18,865 --> 00:25:20,519
People call
Detective Jalen Shaw.
584
00:25:20,519 --> 00:25:22,564
Objection.
585
00:25:22,564 --> 00:25:23,739
What's the objection?
[laughs]
586
00:25:23,739 --> 00:25:25,436
Witness hasn't even taken
the stand yet.
587
00:25:25,436 --> 00:25:28,091
Detective Shaw's testimony
should be excluded.
588
00:25:28,091 --> 00:25:30,180
I was never advised
of my Miranda rights.
589
00:25:30,180 --> 00:25:32,531
The time for a motion
to suppress hearing
590
00:25:32,531 --> 00:25:34,315
has long passed.
591
00:25:37,144 --> 00:25:38,580
I agree
592
00:25:38,580 --> 00:25:41,888
under normal circumstances.
593
00:25:41,888 --> 00:25:45,282
But since Mr. Miller
is a pro se defendant,
594
00:25:45,282 --> 00:25:49,243
I have no choice
but to allow some latitude.
595
00:25:49,243 --> 00:25:52,202
I'm excusing the jury while
we hold an evidentiary hearing.
596
00:25:54,248 --> 00:25:56,076
Thank you so much,
Your Honor.
597
00:25:56,076 --> 00:26:03,039
♪
598
00:26:06,826 --> 00:26:09,350
Detective Cosgrove and I
spoke to Mr. Miller
599
00:26:09,350 --> 00:26:10,612
for about 20 minutes.
600
00:26:10,612 --> 00:26:12,571
Can you characterize
the conversation?
601
00:26:12,571 --> 00:26:14,007
It was cordial.
602
00:26:14,007 --> 00:26:15,530
The defendant lied to you.
603
00:26:15,530 --> 00:26:17,053
He did.
604
00:26:17,053 --> 00:26:19,447
He said his name
was Pierre Briones,
605
00:26:19,447 --> 00:26:21,144
that he lived in Zurich,
606
00:26:21,144 --> 00:26:24,495
that he and Dana Clarkson
were old college friends,
607
00:26:24,495 --> 00:26:26,889
and that he was gay.
608
00:26:26,889 --> 00:26:28,761
Thank you. Nothing further.
609
00:26:30,763 --> 00:26:32,895
There were two of you, yeah?
610
00:26:32,895 --> 00:26:34,636
I was with my partner, correct.
611
00:26:34,636 --> 00:26:35,811
Both of you were carrying
612
00:26:35,811 --> 00:26:39,336
fully loaded
automatic handguns, yeah?
613
00:26:39,336 --> 00:26:41,121
We were on duty.
614
00:26:41,121 --> 00:26:42,470
You ambushed me.
615
00:26:42,470 --> 00:26:45,125
You told me I wasn't free
to leave, didn't you?
616
00:26:45,125 --> 00:26:46,256
Absolutely not.
617
00:26:46,256 --> 00:26:47,344
No, no. I stood up.
618
00:26:47,344 --> 00:26:48,737
I asked to consult
with an attorney.
619
00:26:48,737 --> 00:26:50,565
You told me to sit down,
620
00:26:50,565 --> 00:26:52,959
that I wasn't "going anywhere"
till you were done.
621
00:26:52,959 --> 00:26:54,656
That never happened.
622
00:26:54,656 --> 00:26:56,223
You grilled me
for over an hour.
623
00:26:56,223 --> 00:26:57,964
If you're gonna let
the defendant testify,
624
00:26:57,964 --> 00:26:59,530
can we at least place him
under oath?
625
00:26:59,530 --> 00:27:01,445
Sit down, Mr. Price.
626
00:27:01,445 --> 00:27:04,013
You violated my rights
under Miranda v. Arizona.
627
00:27:04,013 --> 00:27:06,189
Your Honor, I request
that you allow my application
628
00:27:06,189 --> 00:27:07,843
to suppress.
629
00:27:07,843 --> 00:27:09,540
The burden falls
on the prosecution.
630
00:27:09,540 --> 00:27:12,108
You should have videotaped
the defendant's statement.
631
00:27:12,108 --> 00:27:14,633
He wasn't even a suspect
at the time.
632
00:27:16,330 --> 00:27:18,245
I'm granting
the defendant's application.
633
00:27:18,245 --> 00:27:21,117
Thank you, Your Honor.
Thank you.
634
00:27:28,342 --> 00:27:30,736
So you can't tell the jury
about Miller's lies
635
00:27:30,736 --> 00:27:32,215
to the detectives,
636
00:27:32,215 --> 00:27:34,870
but you should be able
to prove your case.
637
00:27:34,870 --> 00:27:36,524
Well, it's not just the lies.
638
00:27:36,524 --> 00:27:39,309
He'll explain away the DNA
found under her nails
639
00:27:39,309 --> 00:27:41,790
with a false claim
that she touched his arm
640
00:27:41,790 --> 00:27:43,139
earlier in the day.
641
00:27:43,139 --> 00:27:45,751
And we don't have
any other women
642
00:27:45,751 --> 00:27:48,971
to show that he has a pattern
of fraud.
643
00:27:48,971 --> 00:27:50,494
You're telling me
if the case were to go
644
00:27:50,494 --> 00:27:52,192
to the jury today, you'd lose?
645
00:27:52,192 --> 00:27:54,324
We might not even make it
over the rail.
646
00:27:54,324 --> 00:27:57,719
Judge could dismiss it outright
for lack of evidence.
647
00:27:59,199 --> 00:28:00,983
Sounds like
he's playing the judge and jury
648
00:28:00,983 --> 00:28:02,724
the way he played your victim.
649
00:28:02,724 --> 00:28:05,074
Just about sums it up.
650
00:28:05,074 --> 00:28:08,904
And if he's acquitted,
he'll be right back at it.
651
00:28:08,904 --> 00:28:10,166
You need to pivot.
652
00:28:10,166 --> 00:28:13,343
Link Miller
to the murder weapon.
653
00:28:13,343 --> 00:28:15,824
Put the scarf in his hands.
- Tried.
654
00:28:15,824 --> 00:28:17,478
No one saw him plant it.
655
00:28:17,478 --> 00:28:18,914
We checked surveillance video,
656
00:28:18,914 --> 00:28:22,048
subpoenaed GPS
in his car and phone.
657
00:28:22,048 --> 00:28:24,703
Focus on the scarf,
not the defendant.
658
00:28:24,703 --> 00:28:27,793
If the fabric is as rare
and expensive
659
00:28:27,793 --> 00:28:29,708
as forensics indicate,
660
00:28:29,708 --> 00:28:31,622
only a handful
of stores sell it.
661
00:28:31,622 --> 00:28:33,407
Find out where he bought it.
662
00:28:35,409 --> 00:28:37,933
Men like Miller don't buy
their own luxury items.
663
00:28:37,933 --> 00:28:40,980
Then track down whoever
bought it for him.
664
00:28:46,768 --> 00:28:50,337
I can prove
you bought the scarf.
665
00:28:50,337 --> 00:28:53,209
Sales clerk remembers
selling it to you.
666
00:28:53,209 --> 00:28:54,820
I have a video of you
in the store,
667
00:28:54,820 --> 00:28:56,647
and I have your credit card statement.
668
00:28:56,647 --> 00:28:58,954
It was a client gift.
669
00:28:58,954 --> 00:29:00,477
We both know
that's not the nature
670
00:29:00,477 --> 00:29:01,914
of your relationship.
671
00:29:01,914 --> 00:29:04,264
You bought it
on Valentine's Day.
672
00:29:05,744 --> 00:29:07,267
I know this must be difficult.
673
00:29:07,267 --> 00:29:10,009
You have no idea
what you're talking about.
674
00:29:11,401 --> 00:29:14,665
If you call me to testify,
I will assert privilege.
675
00:29:14,665 --> 00:29:16,885
I'll challenge it and win.
676
00:29:16,885 --> 00:29:19,061
- I'll take the Fifth.
- I'll immunize you.
677
00:29:19,061 --> 00:29:21,455
And if I refuse to comply?
678
00:29:24,675 --> 00:29:26,547
Every survivor,
679
00:29:26,547 --> 00:29:30,203
every prosecutor in the country
owes you a debt of gratitude
680
00:29:30,203 --> 00:29:32,683
for all that you've done
to give a voice
681
00:29:32,683 --> 00:29:34,381
to sexual assault victims,
682
00:29:34,381 --> 00:29:36,992
promote equal pay
for equal work,
683
00:29:36,992 --> 00:29:40,561
women's healthcare, Title IX.
684
00:29:40,561 --> 00:29:45,087
But you're an essential witness
in a murder case,
685
00:29:45,087 --> 00:29:48,003
in the murder of another woman.
686
00:29:48,003 --> 00:29:51,006
And you and you alone
can put the murder weapon
687
00:29:51,006 --> 00:29:53,269
in the defendant's hands.
688
00:29:53,269 --> 00:29:56,316
My detractors
have been searching
689
00:29:56,316 --> 00:30:00,450
for a way to undermine me
and the causes that I champion
690
00:30:00,450 --> 00:30:02,670
for years.
691
00:30:02,670 --> 00:30:06,979
You are handing it to them
on a silver platter.
692
00:30:06,979 --> 00:30:09,590
People will understand.
693
00:30:09,590 --> 00:30:14,508
You were looking for connection
and companionship.
694
00:30:14,508 --> 00:30:16,249
[suspenseful music]
695
00:30:16,249 --> 00:30:18,773
That doesn't make you weak.
696
00:30:18,773 --> 00:30:20,122
It makes you human.
697
00:30:20,122 --> 00:30:25,345
I'm begging you,
Ms. Maroun...
698
00:30:25,345 --> 00:30:29,828
if you believe in the women
that I have helped,
699
00:30:29,828 --> 00:30:33,048
put your money
where your mouth is
700
00:30:33,048 --> 00:30:36,878
and do not put me
on the witness stand.
701
00:30:36,878 --> 00:30:43,319
♪
702
00:30:47,889 --> 00:30:49,848
Grace Pollard, of all people,
703
00:30:49,848 --> 00:30:51,371
should be leading the charge,
704
00:30:51,371 --> 00:30:53,939
helping us send Devon Miller
to prison.
705
00:30:53,939 --> 00:30:55,462
Her ego is getting
in the way.
706
00:30:55,462 --> 00:30:57,116
No, it's about legacy,
707
00:30:57,116 --> 00:30:59,770
preserving all the causes
she's advanced.
708
00:30:59,770 --> 00:31:01,816
And therefore,
I hope you're not suggesting
709
00:31:01,816 --> 00:31:03,818
we dismiss a murder charge.
710
00:31:03,818 --> 00:31:05,254
We could offer a plea.
711
00:31:05,254 --> 00:31:06,952
Man One, 15 years.
712
00:31:06,952 --> 00:31:09,780
Miller goes to prison.
713
00:31:09,780 --> 00:31:11,565
Grace Pollard
retains her reputation.
714
00:31:11,565 --> 00:31:14,350
Murder trumps humiliation.
715
00:31:14,350 --> 00:31:17,397
Grace Pollard and her causes
will recover.
716
00:31:17,397 --> 00:31:19,138
Easy for you to say.
717
00:31:19,138 --> 00:31:20,139
Excuse me?
718
00:31:20,139 --> 00:31:21,836
Men bounce back
from scandals,
719
00:31:21,836 --> 00:31:23,316
not women.
720
00:31:23,316 --> 00:31:25,448
You have no idea
how hard she had to fight
721
00:31:25,448 --> 00:31:27,015
to accomplish what she has.
722
00:31:27,015 --> 00:31:29,365
This will stain her
and all she's fought for.
723
00:31:29,365 --> 00:31:31,933
It'll be the excuse not
to take her
724
00:31:31,933 --> 00:31:34,805
or her causes seriously.
725
00:31:34,805 --> 00:31:37,286
I hear you.
726
00:31:37,286 --> 00:31:41,421
But Grace Pollard is gonna have
to testify.
727
00:31:41,421 --> 00:31:43,902
Subpoena her if necessary.
728
00:31:48,645 --> 00:31:49,951
Ms. Pollard,
were you involved
729
00:31:49,951 --> 00:31:51,997
in a romantic relationship
with the defendant?
730
00:31:51,997 --> 00:31:53,694
Your Honor,
I'd object to that question
731
00:31:53,694 --> 00:31:55,391
as being overly broad.
732
00:31:55,391 --> 00:31:57,872
Ms. Pollard,
please leave the objections
733
00:31:57,872 --> 00:31:59,787
to counsel on the case.
734
00:31:59,787 --> 00:32:01,702
And who's representing
my interests?
735
00:32:01,702 --> 00:32:03,182
The people certainly aren't.
736
00:32:03,182 --> 00:32:06,098
I'm instructing you
to answer the question.
737
00:32:09,666 --> 00:32:11,668
We were involved briefly, yes.
738
00:32:11,668 --> 00:32:12,713
For about ten months, correct?
739
00:32:12,713 --> 00:32:13,888
Approximately.
740
00:32:13,888 --> 00:32:15,846
You ever loan him money?
741
00:32:15,846 --> 00:32:17,413
I'm out somewhere
in the neighborhood
742
00:32:17,413 --> 00:32:19,850
of $200,000.
743
00:32:21,461 --> 00:32:22,766
Did you ever give him gifts?
744
00:32:22,766 --> 00:32:24,725
Let's just cut to the chase,
shall we?
745
00:32:24,725 --> 00:32:27,119
I gave him a silk scarf.
746
00:32:29,773 --> 00:32:31,123
This silk scarf?
747
00:32:31,123 --> 00:32:31,993
Yes.
748
00:32:31,993 --> 00:32:35,997
Was this in his possession
749
00:32:35,997 --> 00:32:37,520
the night
of Dana Clarkson's murder?
750
00:32:37,520 --> 00:32:39,653
It was.
751
00:32:39,653 --> 00:32:42,047
Thank you.
752
00:32:48,792 --> 00:32:50,881
[exhales]
753
00:32:50,881 --> 00:32:52,100
Hi, Grace.
754
00:32:55,408 --> 00:32:57,236
You were in my brownstone
755
00:32:57,236 --> 00:32:59,673
the night Dana Clarkson
was murdered, weren't you?
756
00:32:59,673 --> 00:33:01,631
Objection. No foundation.
757
00:33:01,631 --> 00:33:02,937
Overruled.
758
00:33:02,937 --> 00:33:06,245
[tense music]
759
00:33:06,245 --> 00:33:08,638
I was.
760
00:33:08,638 --> 00:33:14,253
You heard Dana bang
on the door, call my name?
761
00:33:14,253 --> 00:33:15,950
I did.
762
00:33:15,950 --> 00:33:18,387
An old flame had reappeared
in my life,
763
00:33:18,387 --> 00:33:21,738
and you were
understandably angry,
764
00:33:21,738 --> 00:33:23,044
maybe even jealous?
765
00:33:23,044 --> 00:33:24,263
Your Honor,
he's badgering the witness.
766
00:33:24,263 --> 00:33:26,091
Can he step away
from the witness box?
767
00:33:26,091 --> 00:33:27,657
Step back, Mr. Miller.
768
00:33:27,657 --> 00:33:29,442
Yeah, of course.
769
00:33:29,442 --> 00:33:31,661
Sorry.
770
00:33:32,532 --> 00:33:35,796
I wish I'd have known
who you really are.
771
00:33:35,796 --> 00:33:38,755
Mm-hmm, you were so angry,
in fact,
772
00:33:38,755 --> 00:33:41,802
that you grabbed that scarf
and ran out the door.
773
00:33:41,802 --> 00:33:43,064
- That's a lie.
- Objection.
774
00:33:43,064 --> 00:33:44,805
- That's just--
- You killed Dana Clarks--
775
00:33:44,805 --> 00:33:46,285
- That is absurd!
- Your Honor--
776
00:33:46,285 --> 00:33:47,590
Your Honor!
- Didn't you?
777
00:33:47,590 --> 00:33:49,810
- That is--that is--
- All right, all right.
778
00:33:49,810 --> 00:33:52,900
Let's everybody calm down.
779
00:33:52,900 --> 00:33:54,641
You have anything to back
that up, Mr. Miller?
780
00:33:54,641 --> 00:33:55,729
I do, actually.
781
00:33:55,729 --> 00:33:57,470
Yeah, I have a tape.
782
00:33:57,470 --> 00:33:59,472
I--I have never heard
about a tape.
783
00:33:59,472 --> 00:34:01,039
This violates the rules
of discovery
784
00:34:01,039 --> 00:34:03,476
and it's unfair surprise.
785
00:34:03,476 --> 00:34:07,654
I will see you all
in my chambers now.
786
00:34:07,654 --> 00:34:12,006
♪
787
00:34:12,006 --> 00:34:14,139
A sex tape, are you serious?
788
00:34:14,139 --> 00:34:15,836
How is that even
remotely relevant?
789
00:34:15,836 --> 00:34:17,577
It was taken in my home.
790
00:34:17,577 --> 00:34:20,319
It puts Ms. Pollard right near
the scene of the crime,
791
00:34:20,319 --> 00:34:21,972
and it goes to her state
of mind at the time,
792
00:34:21,972 --> 00:34:24,018
which you'll see from the tape,
793
00:34:24,018 --> 00:34:25,106
she was in a rage.
794
00:34:25,106 --> 00:34:28,066
I mean, angry enough to kill.
795
00:34:29,371 --> 00:34:31,504
- Play it.
- Your Honor, I object.
796
00:34:31,504 --> 00:34:34,072
I wanna see if it has any
evidentiary value.
797
00:34:34,072 --> 00:34:35,682
Play the tape.
798
00:34:35,682 --> 00:34:36,857
There you go.
799
00:34:36,857 --> 00:34:38,989
Take off your blouse.
- [sighs]
800
00:34:38,989 --> 00:34:41,035
Yes, sir.
801
00:34:41,035 --> 00:34:42,080
Tell me what you want.
802
00:34:42,080 --> 00:34:43,429
Don't talk.
803
00:34:43,429 --> 00:34:44,473
Get on the bed.
804
00:34:44,473 --> 00:34:46,562
[both moan]
805
00:34:46,562 --> 00:34:48,347
[knock at door]
Ah, who's that?
806
00:34:48,347 --> 00:34:50,349
Pierre,
I know you're in there.
807
00:34:50,349 --> 00:34:51,480
It's an ex, okay?
Don't worry.
808
00:34:51,480 --> 00:34:53,308
- Get rid of her.
- Open the door!
809
00:34:53,308 --> 00:34:54,657
Get her the hell out of--
810
00:34:54,657 --> 00:34:57,443
This tape is a pretext
to publicly shame a woman
811
00:34:57,443 --> 00:35:00,794
for being vulnerable, intimate,
for--for trusting someone.
812
00:35:00,794 --> 00:35:02,752
Are you really gonna allow
that tape to be aired
813
00:35:02,752 --> 00:35:03,840
in your courtroom?
814
00:35:03,840 --> 00:35:06,104
Watch yourself, Ms. Maroun.
815
00:35:06,104 --> 00:35:08,062
I find the tape
to be exculpatory,
816
00:35:08,062 --> 00:35:11,283
and distasteful as I find it,
817
00:35:11,283 --> 00:35:13,198
I'm granting you your request.
818
00:35:13,198 --> 00:35:14,982
- Thank you.
- But I warn you,
819
00:35:14,982 --> 00:35:16,418
tread lightly.
820
00:35:19,291 --> 00:35:22,250
If you didn't consent
to the recording,
821
00:35:22,250 --> 00:35:24,383
I can go back in there,
ask the judge to suppress it.
822
00:35:24,383 --> 00:35:31,303
♪
823
00:35:31,303 --> 00:35:35,307
Well, he's not allowed
to play the entire tape.
824
00:35:35,307 --> 00:35:40,181
It will be limited in scope.
- I am half-naked, Mr. Price,
825
00:35:40,181 --> 00:35:43,053
asking a man, that man,
826
00:35:43,053 --> 00:35:46,013
to take charge of my body.
827
00:35:49,190 --> 00:35:51,453
Do you understand how
that looks?
828
00:35:54,282 --> 00:35:57,590
It looks like a woman engaged
in a consensual act,
829
00:35:57,590 --> 00:35:58,591
making a choice.
830
00:35:58,591 --> 00:36:00,419
It will be my undoing.
831
00:36:00,419 --> 00:36:02,464
The jury will see right
through his whole charade.
832
00:36:02,464 --> 00:36:07,948
I've seen thousands of women
torn to shreds on the stand.
833
00:36:07,948 --> 00:36:11,256
It always comes down
to one thing:
834
00:36:11,256 --> 00:36:12,822
sex.
835
00:36:12,822 --> 00:36:15,651
You've made a career out
of encouraging other women
836
00:36:15,651 --> 00:36:17,871
to stand up for themselves.
837
00:36:17,871 --> 00:36:20,221
Now that it's your turn, what,
838
00:36:20,221 --> 00:36:22,484
you're just gonna try
and look the other way?
839
00:36:25,922 --> 00:36:27,315
You can do this.
840
00:36:29,665 --> 00:36:31,537
Judge is waiting.
841
00:36:31,537 --> 00:36:38,283
♪
842
00:36:38,283 --> 00:36:39,458
It's an ex, okay?
Don't worry.
843
00:36:39,458 --> 00:36:41,373
- Get rid of her.
- Open the door!
844
00:36:41,373 --> 00:36:43,766
- Get her the hell out--
- Okay, all right.
845
00:36:49,207 --> 00:36:51,600
That was you on the tape?
846
00:36:51,600 --> 00:36:53,907
You're trying
to slut-shame me, Mr. Miller?
847
00:36:53,907 --> 00:36:55,256
I'll take that as a yes.
848
00:36:55,256 --> 00:36:57,302
Okay, Mr. Miller.
Let's move on.
849
00:36:57,302 --> 00:36:59,434
So you admit you were
in my home
850
00:36:59,434 --> 00:37:01,436
when Dana Clarkson was banging
on the door that night?
851
00:37:01,436 --> 00:37:04,091
- Yes, I was.
- And you were livid, correct?
852
00:37:04,091 --> 00:37:06,136
No, I was annoyed.
853
00:37:06,136 --> 00:37:07,486
I wanted to have sex.
854
00:37:07,486 --> 00:37:10,880
[jurors mumbling indistinctly]
- Hmm.
855
00:37:10,880 --> 00:37:12,360
Nothing further.
856
00:37:26,679 --> 00:37:28,898
What Mr. Miller just did
in this courtroom
857
00:37:28,898 --> 00:37:31,292
reveals who he is,
858
00:37:31,292 --> 00:37:33,729
not who you are,
isn't that true?
859
00:37:33,729 --> 00:37:36,645
Objection! Leading.
860
00:37:36,645 --> 00:37:38,865
Overruled.
861
00:37:38,865 --> 00:37:40,388
Yes.
862
00:37:40,388 --> 00:37:43,348
He's a liar
and a ruthless sociopath
863
00:37:43,348 --> 00:37:45,001
with no regard for others.
864
00:37:45,001 --> 00:37:48,266
And that sex tape
was a cheap ploy
865
00:37:48,266 --> 00:37:51,399
designed to intimidate you,
wasn't it?
866
00:37:51,399 --> 00:37:53,358
If it was, it didn't work.
867
00:37:53,358 --> 00:37:55,142
Mr. Miller tried
to demean you?
868
00:37:55,142 --> 00:38:00,321
I will not be demeaned
for being a woman,
869
00:38:00,321 --> 00:38:04,325
for being a human, in full.
870
00:38:04,325 --> 00:38:06,066
At times, I'm a professional,
871
00:38:06,066 --> 00:38:07,720
at times, I'm a a friend,
872
00:38:07,720 --> 00:38:09,330
at times,
873
00:38:09,330 --> 00:38:15,162
I am a woman
seeking physical intimacy.
874
00:38:15,162 --> 00:38:18,078
When I fight for the rights
of women,
875
00:38:18,078 --> 00:38:19,340
I fight for their right
876
00:38:19,340 --> 00:38:22,561
to enjoy
the full human experience.
877
00:38:22,561 --> 00:38:26,565
It is what we all hope for
in life.
878
00:38:26,565 --> 00:38:33,528
♪
879
00:38:38,141 --> 00:38:39,839
Did you kill Dana Clarkson?
880
00:38:39,839 --> 00:38:41,754
No, I did not.
881
00:38:41,754 --> 00:38:44,974
Mr. Miller killed her.
882
00:38:44,974 --> 00:38:47,281
What makes you so sure?
883
00:38:47,281 --> 00:38:51,198
He left the house
with the scarf.
884
00:38:51,198 --> 00:38:53,113
He was gone
for about 20 minutes.
885
00:38:53,113 --> 00:38:56,595
When he came back,
he was disheveled,
886
00:38:56,595 --> 00:38:59,380
and he poured himself
a tall glass of whiskey.
887
00:39:02,340 --> 00:39:06,953
And why should
this jury believe you?
888
00:39:06,953 --> 00:39:09,042
I'm sitting here,
889
00:39:09,042 --> 00:39:11,740
exposing
the most intimate details
890
00:39:11,740 --> 00:39:14,395
of my life.
891
00:39:14,395 --> 00:39:19,139
I have everything to lose
and nothing to gain.
892
00:39:19,139 --> 00:39:26,364
♪
893
00:39:29,367 --> 00:39:31,847
No further questions.
894
00:39:31,847 --> 00:39:38,854
♪
895
00:40:01,050 --> 00:40:02,704
How do you find?
896
00:40:02,704 --> 00:40:05,359
We find the defendant,
Devon Miller,
897
00:40:05,359 --> 00:40:07,927
guilty of murder
in the second degree.
898
00:40:11,365 --> 00:40:12,758
Thank you for your service.
899
00:40:12,758 --> 00:40:14,281
[handcuffs clicking]
900
00:40:14,281 --> 00:40:21,244
♪
901
00:40:28,861 --> 00:40:30,732
Ms. Pollard.
902
00:40:34,214 --> 00:40:39,611
That verdict was a referendum
on his guilt and your courage.
903
00:40:42,265 --> 00:40:45,747
You think this is a victory?
904
00:40:45,747 --> 00:40:52,058
♪
905
00:40:52,058 --> 00:40:54,452
You feel like a drink?
906
00:40:57,150 --> 00:40:59,195
I can't.
907
00:40:59,195 --> 00:41:00,370
I have a date.
908
00:41:03,156 --> 00:41:05,463
Well, have fun.
909
00:41:05,463 --> 00:41:08,770
And make sure
he only has one passport.
910
00:41:08,770 --> 00:41:15,734
♪
911
00:41:24,917 --> 00:41:27,876
[dramatic music]
912
00:41:27,876 --> 00:41:34,840
♪
913
00:41:54,990 --> 00:41:57,906
[wolf howls]
61773
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.