Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
Sometimes I feel like looking for Christina Whittaker
is the one constant in my life.
It's seen me through apartments and jobs.
And relationships and deaths.
It's always there.
What if I fail?
I've gotten to the point where it's literally breaking me.
It's breaking me financially, it's breaking me emotionally.
I'm scared for my safety.
The thing that I'm scared about the most
is what is my life going to be like
if I'm not looking for Christina Whittaker.
She's become such a part of my life.
I don't know, I keep saying that, you know, she's dead.
Cindy's gotta learn to let her go, but I feel like
I need to learn to learn how to let her go too.
It's been six weeks since Darin committed suicide
and I still cannot believe it.
I've spoken to his family and friends and...
no one seems to know why he's taken his own life.
Why are we here, dude?
Like, I was supposed to be at his house, like drinking beer right now,
like, talking about like, "did you see another HPD car go by?"
Yeah, are they coming for us?
I may never know why Darin did what he did, but
I know that I have to keep pushing...
to finish what I started.
Christina Whittaker has been missing for nearly 11 years.
And I feel like at this point, it's do or die to find out.
What happened to her?
Over the past eight weeks, I've been chasing
two promising leads from the prison informant,
who I discovered within HPD's records.
The first centers around new information that suggests
Christina was working as a confidential informant
for the Hannibal PD.
I've suspected she was involved with the PD for a while now.
And the Intel I've gotten from him so far, has checked out.
The second lead I'm pursuing is coming from the same informant.
He appears to have in-depth knowledge
regarding the whereabouts of Christina's remains.
And he promises to lead me there.
Proving Christina was recruited by HPD
and was working undercover on their behalf would be a game changer.
CIs regularly find themselves in dangerous situations.
And if Christina's cover was blown, that could've given someone
a strong criminal motive to harm her.
I've been sending aerial photos to my informant
and exchanging calls with him to hone in the exact location he claims she's buried.
Across the river from Hannibal in Pike County, Illinois.
Okay.
He said when you're coming down this road,
you'll see a house on the left
and there's like a little path on the right.
I've been consulting with the Pike County sheriff
to help identify the correct section of the riverbank
my source is describing.
It's imperative to pinpoint the exact location
before we bring in the resources needed to conduct an official search.
As for verifying whether or not Christina was a CI,
it appears we are on the verge of finally discovering the truth.
Hey, we got the records.
The probation records?
Yes, probation records.
The judge released them to give me a copy of the whole file.
And Christina was listed as a CI.
No way!
We were absolutely right.
Okay.
Yeah, we'll have to get together and we'll have to go over these.
'Cause they are just amazing.
On June 3rd 2008,
a year and a half before she goes missing,
it says that Christina was pulled over for driving while revoked.
Her license had been revoked because of other traffic incidents from before.
According to these probation reports, the officer says
she can get out of it if she works for the DA.
It looks like the probation officer told Christina "to think about it."
- And the long-term effect of being a CI." - Yes.
It doesn't say
what they wanted her to do as a CI.
But, one of Christina's friends told me about
this incident of getting pulled over.
But she said she got pulled over because of drugs.
- Christina gets pulled over at 1:00 p.m. - Yes.
At 2:00 p.m, the probation officer was called to HPD because
a girl said that Christina came over to her house
and dropped a pound of cocaine on her table.
Where the hell did she get a pound of cocaine from?
Right, we... we don't know the answer to that.
Because HPD denies that Christina was ever a CI for them.
Denies it.
Ah, now let me ask you this.
If Christina was pulled over for buying drugs
from an undercover or another CI,
would it be in their interest to not write up a ticket,
to say that we caught her with drugs?
- Does that happen? - Yes, yes.
- Yeah. - Here, come here.
The ticket...
says...
Uh...
"Driving while revoked."
Driving while revoked...
could have been used as probable cause to pull her over.
- Outside of saying, "this girl had a pound of cocaine." - Ah...
They don't wanna put that out there that she was caught with drugs
and then all of a sudden it just goes away?
You want someone to suspect that she was a CI?
Well, if they charge her with driving while revoked, the penalty is not that great.
So, it's not a big surprise that she didn't go to jail.
You cunning, cunning folk.
I located a source.
They'd also been a CI for HPD.
And her HPD officer advised her to not be around Christina Whittaker,
because she was probably wearing a wire.
For a police officer,
to turn out...
- one CI to another... - Mmm-hmm.
...is extremely dangerous.
You can get these people killed.
Why make this girl a CI is like what pisses me off.
She's convenient.
My source was right.
Despite HPD's denials,
Christina was working as a CI.
And the implications are massive.
Did the HPD put her in harm's way?
Did her undercover work lead to her disappearance?
And could this explain HPD's reluctance
to share information about the case
with me or with any outside investigator?
My prison informant has turned out to be
a very reliable source.
And that gives me a lot of confidence that his Intel
about the location of Christina's remains is solid.
Towards the ri... Oh, damn!
Oh, I think I know exactly what you're talking about.
It's like in the wooded area. There's a wooded area... yes, okay.
Oh, my God, okay.
This is the closest I have felt to finding Christina in 11 years.
After all this time, and after reaching so many dead ends,
this feels real.
Like I'm a breath away from finally finding Christina.
It's like, this time I feel like,
the pieces of the puzzle are falling into place.
Since it was 11 years ago, all of this stuff wasn't here.
All this... these sheds and stuff, those beams, all of this equipment.
You guys said that there was some trouble
around then of like breaking-up meth labs and...
Yeah... this whole area.
-Yeah, they knew... people knew it was secluded. -Oh, yeah, yeah.
Yeah, yeah.
I think this is our area.
- That... brushy area back there. - Yeah.
Could be that.
And they have a couple dogs.
So, they'll run the dogs one at a time.
They sort of check each other out.
Get to work.
I didn't even want the cameras down there.
I just wanted the dog to be able to concentrate and do his thing.
The dog seems interested in that little empty space in between
those trees, you know what I mean?
Okay, get to work.
Oh...
There's a second dog coming out now.
Seems like all the dogs have headed in the same direction.
Let's go down and have a look.
Okay.
Oh...
Right.
Oh, boy!
Did the dog have a positive hit on that refrigerator?
- She gave her indication. - All right.
If the dog did a little growl, you got the final one.
- The dog did? - Uh-huh.
Ah, look at that.
We had a pretty good hit over here.
In this area where they said it would be.
We had two cadaver dogs hit on the same area,
which is a old, rusty refrigerator
that is lying face down partially sunken in the mud.
Yeah, this happened...
it would have been almost 11 years ago now.
Sounds like we have forensics team on the way.
The way those dogs were right here, I really feel confident that
there has to be something there.
I mean, it's pretty remarkable. If it's not...
- The fridge, it's somewhere, you know... - Yeah.
I can make sure that you have the description of what she was wearing.
White tennis shoes, jeans...
She had like a little, like, purse with her.
It was like a pink, like, Playboy bunny purse.
I don't think that's ever been found.
First guy is here to photograph the scene.
Just really document and photographs.
And then we're gonna go ahead and roll it over.
Open it and see if there's anything in it.
I don't know what to feel.
But also like the... might not be in the fridge.
You know, if she's under, could be buried somewhere in this area under.
I all of a sudden just felt very surreal.
Like, everything around here is like not reality
'cause this is just so crazy.
Yep, of course, yes.
Yeah, okay. All right, thank you.
We just got word that the sheriff
does not want cameras on the fridge,
in case there is a body inside.
She's not in there.
The dogs did alert in the area around the fridge, so, they're gonna dig the whole thing up.
Yeah, of course.
So right here is where...
You're not finding anything, huh?
I have to say I'm so impressed with how fast you brought things in to clear this area.
It's... insanely incredible.
They dug up the entire area. She's not there.
And I told the sheriff that I'll tell our guy, "You need to talk to the sheriff."
You can be anonymous, but you need to talk to him."
Aw, man.
Man!
Fuck.
See, this is why you don't get your hopes up.
- It's exhausting. - Huh?
I said it's exhausting.
Christina's case doesn't have a chance with HPD.
If it was in their hands, they probably would have solved it in like two weeks.
- You know? - Right.
That's what I think.
I don't know. I don't know what to do.
I can't just be digging holes all over Missouri and Illinois.
You know? I don't know.
Yeah.
I don't know.
I'm tired. I'm so tired.
I have some really upsetting news tonight.
I found out that the reason that
Darin committed suicide, which was kind of murky to me
when I found out it had happened
was because he was caught with child pornography.
Um... what?
I...
I trusted him with my life.
To me the shining star in Hannibal was this person.
I started thinking...
what am I doing?
I can't trust this family.
Sometimes I feel like I doubt myself when I'm with them.
But then I... I anchor myself in people.
That I would have never thought would've done something like this.
And that's a lie.
I don't... I...
literally don't know what's up or what's down right now.
The people that I thought were the good guys
and the people that I'm afraid are the predators like,
what if that's all screwed up?
You know? Why am I doubting Cindy and trusting Darin?
Darin turned out to be a freaking pedophile.
So what am I supposed to do?
I don't know who to trust.
So, what else did you hear about Darin?
Oh, God.
He was?
Shut your camera off for a second.
Darin didn't leave the Sheriff's Department
because they were corrupt.
He was forced out because he was corrupt.
Really? This is nuts.
This is just... it's unbelievable.
Someone in his family told me that they found out
that he had hard drives full of photographs of underage girls.
I don't know if he was a consumer
of these alleged photos or if he took them himself.
What did you find out?
I'm starting to trip out about
his motives for helping me.
If he's got all of these
photos and stuff of young girls,
like, who knows if like,
Christina could've been one of those girls.
Did he want to be close to this case, you know?
At this point I have to question everything.
When I heard that he did what he did...
And I thought, "Bet they got him on child stuff,"
because when my daughter was younger, he was always trying to
photograph her in bikinis and stuff.
I said, "Dude, she's like 15.
And she's not gonna go over there and parade around in her little bikinis
so you can take pictures of her in front of these balloons and stuff."
He was a freak.
My mind couldn't have been any more blown and I'm like...
Oh, it is such a bigger problem than anybody even realizes.
So, I'm telling you, those hard drives... He's worried about something.
I can almost guarantee you
that there is tons of photographs
on them hard drives what he's worried about.
You know, just a mere possession of them
is going to get you thrown in prison.
So... and then if you transmitted them over the lines,
the feds are going to have a heyday with you.
It's been a lot.
Just it... less than 24 hours since that broke to us.
- And we were just like... - I didn't know you guys had used him.
He was a... he became a good friend of mine,
you know.
I think he's got this personality of...
he isn't going to do anything for you just to help out the cause.
I'm sorry your friend turned out not to be such
a great person, but it happens.
It's the 11-year anniversary of Christina's disappearance.
Normally, I'd be calling Cindy on this day to ask her how she's feeling.
Um... but...
I haven't known what to say since I saw those home movies.
Cindy may have plenty of reasons
why she hides things because
she may feel that mistakes made in the past
have no relevance to Christina's disappearance.
And why set herself up to be judged
for things that happened a long time ago?
Everyone's made mistakes. I know I have.
I emotionally attached myself to a family
that I really wanted to help.
Investigators are warned not to get too close to a victim
or their family members.
It'll cloud your judgement. I get that now more than ever.
And seeing those home movies made me realize
that if we don't put every possible clue and potential
motive on the table,
it leaves us trying to solve a puzzle without all the pieces.
We're never going to get the full picture.
Which may mean we won't ever find Christina.
Over the years, Christina's friends told me that she left
after an intense argument with Cindy.
And I've wondered all this time,
could that claim be true?
And what could be so serious
that Christina would be motivated to leave because of it?
Many people who claim that Christina and Cindy fought,
insist they know the reason why.
Seven people...
some who claimed first-hand knowledge
have told me...
that Christina was being sexually abused...
by her step-father, Alex.
I heard something about Alex.
Christina, she brought that stuff up.
What did she tell you?
Said he... molested her, younger age.
Her and her daddy had a little falling out and she brought that stuff up.
She came home drunk. He told her to come home drunk or whatever
and she came home drunk and he had his way with her
the way I understood it. I don't know.
Alex did a lot of bad things to Christina at a real young age.
And Christina learned that if she allowed it...
as she caught on eventually
she could start getting things in return.
I first heard the Alex accusations years ago.
And I wanted to dismiss them as nasty, unfounded rumors.
As time went on, the list of accusers grew.
I'm just at the point right now where I can't ignore these allegations.
But I'm not a trained investigator.
I don't know how to even begin
to question somebody who is accused of sexual abuse.
However, as a police investigator,
Gina learned how to approach people accused of sex crimes.
And we thought it would be more appropriate for her to talk to Alex.
So, there was never any...
No.
Well, me and my wife split up one time.
We wasn't split up very long. We got back together.
But you think that's where the rumor started
is when you and Cindy split up for a little bit...
That's about the time.
I think. Yeah.
I left and then Christina got kicked out just for short time too.
And that stupid-ass rumor started.
You know, that we staying together and she was only...
- 17 or 18, so... - Mmm-hmm.
Why would people say that though, Alex?
Do you think they saw something or mistook something or...
I don't know.
I mean, when we had parties and stuff she would
come over and flop on your lap
- I mean, mine... and sit on her lap... - Yeah.
- As a teenager. - Right.
It kind of makes me sick, you know,
that people even think that.
Alex categorically denies these allegations.
He says that they are nothing more than ugly rumors.
And since no one that has come forward with these allegations can offer any proof,
I have nothing to go on.
Since I joined the search for Christina,
I've always felt two entities have withheld important details about the case.
The Hannibal PD and Cindy.
I now know that the HPD has had plenty to hide.
And while Cindy hasn't always been honest,
I believe she loves her daughter very much
and wants her to be found.
However, if she holds back information,
it makes it that much more difficult
for those trying to assist her.
Marita Malone, who was a special agent for the FBI
for nearly 30 years
has become an advisor to me.
And she believes that she can get Cindy to open up in ways that I can't.
I feel like this is it.
My best shot to make sure I'm getting the truth.
Once and for all.
There aren't too many missing person's families
that have kept the case alive as much as you have.
I mean, you have really done an outstanding job.
We need your honesty.
We're trying to help you
and I have to ask you some difficult questions.
- Okay. - They're not to hurt you or Christina.
They're just questions that we have to ask. Okay?
Do you think that a family member
might be covering up something about what happened to her?
No.
Not at all.
Brian? He won't talk to us, you know?
He won't talk to me about Christina. I know.
In all my heart, I know he would never have anything to do with her
being missing or hurting her like that. No.
Brian has...
a history of physical abuse.
Is it possible...
that something like this in the family happened to her?
- No. - No?
I don't believe that at all.
- I have no reason to believe anything like that. - Yeah.
I was raised in a family where, you know, violence...
- I mean my dad, you know, was... you know... - Yeah.
He had been in the war and you know, he demonstrated violence.
- Yes. - You know, toward my mom and I was raised with brothers.
You know what I mean? Somebody hits me, I'm gonna hit them back.
- Yeah. - You know I never initiated fights and Brian...
My son Brian never... He's never been barely the one to initiate fights.
But if somebody hits him, he's gonna hit 'em back.
I mean honestly, I raised my kids like that.
I raised Christina like that.
- Somebody hits you, you know, take up for yourself. - Yeah.
You know they'd argue amongst each other, they'd feel very guilty about it.
And it sounds like Brian felt really bad
about when he beat Christina.
He felt so bad he tried to kill himself over it.
So, yeah, he took it pretty bad.
I don't think when she went missing... they may not have been like
- where they was, you know, before that fight. - Yeah.
Some of the people we interviewed
felt that she ran away because
she was tired of being sexually abused.
See, I never...
By Alex.
Alex had cheated on me with an ex.
The next morning I kick him out of the house.
Well, here comes Christina in, high after she had been out all night.
And I kicked her out.
After that, that's when those rumors started.
I appreciate you're addressing that. Thank you.
For it to have grown into that,
I mean, it's ridiculous.
It is absolutely ridiculous. It never happened.
Yeah.
Christina, had evidently a sexual relationship
with some of the police officers.
Yeah.
They'd had some of them that were investigated
because she was a minor, you know?
-Yeah -And her and her friend had, uh...
They'd had parties and had them come to, you know,
their parties and stuff.
Yeah.
Me and Alex, we were pretty,
you know, pretty shook up about it.
Do you know who those officers were?
I think was one of them and I don't really remember.
- Yeah. - I really don't remember.
You know, any of the other's names or...
She also was, as you probably know, a confidential informant.
- I believe that. - Was one of her handlers?
I'm not sure.
I know she got into an accident and got tickets
for driving on a suspended license.
And she had told me she had worked it out.
You know and had it where she's, you know...
She's going to go to court and get her license back.
- Mmm-hmm. - It was actually ,
car was parked in front of his house, I guess
and that's the car she had hit it and ran.
She did have something going on with that accident, I think.
- To get the ticket straightened out and... - Yeah.
I don't know what it was.
And could it had something to do with her going missing? Definitely.
I tried to put evidence behind everything that
I'm telling you here.
Maybe Darcy Morris picked her up
and took her and pimped her perhaps in Peoria.
Then perhaps based on what we saw, maybe killed her.
You know what? I know that was one of the first things they said.
Even after they took her, I heard that in December.
- Mmm. - After she went missing.
You know, they killed her and got rid of her body, whatever.
I don't believe it for a minute.
I just don't think they wanted us to search for her.
I believe she's still in Peoria.
I can stand out there with them fliers,
always get leads on her.
Always people recognized her.
I have had them tell me that girl's not missing.
She walks around here. I've seen her.
She's not missing.
I said maybe not to you, but she is to me.
Christina's not dead, I'll never believe it.
Looking back, I may have not been there for like she needed me to be.
She was using the street drugs and, you know, I just beat myself up
because I feel like I let her down.
She was vulnerable and Hannibal Police just
denied to me that she was ever an informant about anything.
Now, I mean that I know, of course I'm gonna be upset.
I just, when it comes to Christina, I'm so drained and I'm so tired.
I'm just tired.
There's a... there's a in town...
Deputy officer.
Whatever they call him...
Completely stable...
...got Christina, when she was 17, her and Breezy using cocaine.
She had never used drugs.
Police introduced her to alcohol and drugs.
I could just shoot one of them. That deputy ,
when I stare him down, he gets so uncomfortable, he's gotta leave the room.
He can't look at me.
And I feel like going up to him, you have no idea...
I just wanna put my hands around his neck.
Stuff like that makes you... makes you want to hurt somebody.
Like everything I've done over these years, I've failed Christina because
I've not brought her home and I've failed Alex
and Brea 'cause I can't bring her mom home to her.
In the 11 years that I have known Cindy,
she's never been so open about who Christina was
and what her life was really like.
And today,
she made it clear that she
blames men sworn to protect Christina's life,
for destroying it.
Her anger, frustration
and resentment towards the Hannibal PD
is finally boiling over.
I've requested on-camera interviews with
representatives of the Hannibal Police Department
numerous times.
Those requests have all been ignored or declined.
In April of 2021,
I sent a list of more than 80 questions
to HPD Chief, Lyndell Davis.
I offered the chief or any other officer from the department,
the opportunity to provide written responses.
So far, HPD has not replied.
Here's a sampling of the questions I was hoping the HPD would answer.
How did Christina come to be a confidential informant
and what type of charge was she facing
when she was enlisted as a CI?
As a CI, was Christina tasked with extracting information
and/or buying Narcotics from known drug dealers?
Was Christina's work as confidential informant for the HPD
tied directly or indirectly to her disappearance?
I then asked Chief Davis if he was aware
Christina had a sexual relationship
with any member of the HPD?
And if any HPD officer had been disciplined
because of their relationship with Christina.
No current employee of the Hannibal PD has answered
a single one of my questions.
But after a year's long search
I've located a former member of the force,
who is willing to talk about his experience working for the HPD.
Out of fear of retribution,
he has asked that his identity be concealed.
When I first started with the Hannibal Police Department,
it was pretty ideal.
A river town.
It was different and exciting at the same time.
I worked with good officers at that time.
I had been on for several years
when there were some chiefs that were changed.
That was when things kinda started to go downhill.
The leadership had their own agenda.
Good officers either were manipulated
or forced out eventually.
I know through what I had heard
that there were officers that were
sleeping with confidential informants and possibly
placing evidence on people to make arrests.
I was approached, when I was a detective,
that I needed to develop more CIs.
The problem with that was a lot of my CIs were people that I didn't put on the books
I didn't want anybody else to know my CIs.
I wanted to protect my CIs.
If you're going to change the corruption in Hannibal,
there needs to be
an investigation of the Hannibal Police Department
by the Department of Justice.
Back in 2008,
I started this project, not about Christina Whittaker,
I started it about
missing adults and the families who are trying to
carry on but still carry hope
that they were going to find their loved one.
And I got so wrapped up in one of those families...
I'm Cindy Young. My daughter Christina's been missing nine months today.
When I met Cindy in 2010...
That's me and her last summer acting goofy.
...I made a promise to her.
I was going to do everything in my power to help find Christina Whittaker.
To say that I was naive when I made that promise,
is an understatement.
But I dove in, head first, with the best intentions
and for the past 11 years, I've rarely come up for air.
But the answers I've been searching for,
remain out of focus.
And out of reach.
Christina Whittaker is still missing.
And her family still doesn't have answers.
Are you counting your eggs before they're hatched?
Yep.
What're you doing today, poots?
- Enjoying my 18th birthday. - Is it your birthday?
Eighteen. Show me love, people!
I just don't want her forgotten.
That's a big worry of mine. I don't want people to forget her.
This journey has been exhausting.
And it's left me frustrated and jaded.
I can't keep going back into this town. It's too dangerous.
It's taking a toll on my life. I have to move on.
But I don't think I'll ever give up on Christina.
Because eventually, someone's going to tell me the truth.
And if I become too jaded and walk away completely,
I'm going to miss my chance to solve this.
Now, more than ever, I'm convinced.
Someone knows something.
I think a lot of someones know something.
is calling you from County Detention Center.
Press one to accept the data charges of this call.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.