Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
WEBVTT
00:01.106 --> 00:03.787
Previously on Proven Innocent...
00:04.070 --> 00:05.546
What are you doing, Maddie?
00:05.583 --> 00:07.743
I need to figure out
what really happened to Rosemary.
00:07.841 --> 00:09.460
You sure you really want to do this?
00:09.516 --> 00:10.976
Ever since I saw Bellows,
00:11.023 --> 00:12.265
it triggered something in me.
00:12.302 --> 00:14.191
I was just doing my job,
and I honestly thought
00:14.228 --> 00:16.111
you were guilty. In fact, I still do.
00:16.449 --> 00:18.741
I announce my candidacy
for attorney general
00:18.802 --> 00:20.501
to the great state of Illinois.
00:20.596 --> 00:22.003
I got a line on Madeline Scott.
00:22.121 --> 00:24.172
- Bring me something good.
- You know I will.
00:24.290 --> 00:25.657
You think that I killed Rosemary?
00:25.659 --> 00:27.175
I don't know what to think anymore.
00:27.269 --> 00:29.510
I told myself I wouldn't come
until I found your killer.
00:29.629 --> 00:31.590
I swear to you I'll find them.
00:34.416 --> 00:35.582
The moment I was accused
00:35.619 --> 00:37.158
of Rosemary Lynch's murder,
00:37.195 --> 00:39.848
the world saw me as a different person.
00:40.228 --> 00:42.820
I wasn't Madeline Scott
anymore. I was someone else.
00:46.009 --> 00:47.973
I was the party girl,
00:48.010 --> 00:50.351
the sex maniac, a killer.
00:52.767 --> 00:53.832
Hi.
00:53.869 --> 00:55.197
I was also the innocent victim.
00:55.234 --> 00:56.236
- Thanks.
- Hi.
00:56.273 --> 00:59.237
The wrongly accused,
the girl in trouble.
01:05.396 --> 01:08.789
But however they saw me,
inside I felt the same.
01:09.200 --> 01:11.974
Eventually, the inside changed, too.
01:12.445 --> 01:14.958
When you live day to day
behind prison bars,
01:15.064 --> 01:17.415
you begin to forget who you are.
01:18.958 --> 01:21.700
You lose yourself.
01:22.349 --> 01:26.089
One day, you realize
you've become something else.
01:26.536 --> 01:29.685
Well, the Madeline Scott
that I know and love,
01:29.722 --> 01:32.856
she's fierce,
inside the courtroom and out.
01:33.857 --> 01:36.984
Every wrongfully accused person
faces the same challenge.
01:37.078 --> 01:40.146
How do we stop letting others
define who we are?
01:40.347 --> 01:41.583
Thank you, Pastor,
01:41.620 --> 01:43.177
for that lovely sermon.
01:43.255 --> 01:45.159
It was very inspirational.
01:45.196 --> 01:47.130
For some more than others.
01:47.193 --> 01:49.130
Michael's in a world
of his own sometimes.
01:49.205 --> 01:52.091
The boy is 14 years old.
We both know what that means.
01:52.128 --> 01:54.185
Ezekiel,
01:54.222 --> 01:56.172
can I have a private word with you?
01:58.279 --> 01:59.911
How old was William in this picture?
01:59.948 --> 02:01.377
He'd just turned 14.
02:01.414 --> 02:04.019
- Same age as your boy.
- You don't say.
02:04.056 --> 02:06.706
William is 19 now, a gifted young man
02:06.743 --> 02:08.509
and still a person of faith.
02:08.547 --> 02:10.894
When Patricia joined the church
a few months back,
02:10.946 --> 02:12.111
I started to visit him.
02:12.148 --> 02:14.275
The pastor has been a godsend.
02:14.428 --> 02:17.320
I-I still can't believe
any of this is real.
02:17.417 --> 02:19.297
Two days after that picture was taken,
02:19.334 --> 02:20.836
William was arrested for murder.
02:20.968 --> 02:22.609
They locked him up for life.
02:22.707 --> 02:25.533
Tried him as an adult
because he looked like an adult.
02:25.570 --> 02:27.061
It happens all the time.
02:27.219 --> 02:29.055
When a judge sees
what he thinks is a man
02:29.092 --> 02:30.692
in his courtroom,
he treats him like one.
02:30.748 --> 02:33.591
My nephew didn't shoot
any liquor store owner.
02:33.750 --> 02:36.372
William has been suffering
in prison for five years.
02:36.467 --> 02:38.815
He's lost all hope, Ezekiel.
02:38.945 --> 02:40.608
We need you.
02:42.488 --> 02:45.022
Why don't you start by telling
me how all this happened.
02:45.139 --> 02:47.325
Well, that's the crazy part.
02:47.482 --> 02:49.774
William confessed.
02:56.420 --> 02:58.120
So...
02:58.566 --> 03:00.837
the police asked for your help.
03:04.056 --> 03:05.470
And you had the gun that killed
03:05.507 --> 03:07.341
the liquor store owner in your bedroom?
03:08.873 --> 03:10.503
Rabbit gave it to me.
03:11.074 --> 03:13.709
Rabbit. Does he have a last name?
03:18.550 --> 03:20.813
He looks like this, though.
03:24.768 --> 03:26.841
This is incredible.
03:32.944 --> 03:34.944
These are amazing.
03:37.334 --> 03:39.283
He's called Soul Brother.
03:39.459 --> 03:41.186
It's about an archangel
who saves humanity
03:41.223 --> 03:42.506
but still can't get a cab.
03:45.774 --> 03:47.665
Yeah, I feel that.
03:48.045 --> 03:50.251
So, did you tell the police
about Rabbit?
03:55.037 --> 03:57.085
They said I made him up.
03:57.280 --> 03:58.631
They said lots of stuff,
03:58.668 --> 04:00.444
But none of it's true.
04:00.481 --> 04:02.201
I don't know what you want me to say.
04:03.083 --> 04:05.273
How about starting with the truth?
04:07.380 --> 04:09.806
Pastor White said you get people
out of jail.
04:10.111 --> 04:11.585
We both do.
04:12.147 --> 04:14.466
We don't always win,
but we do our best.
04:14.858 --> 04:16.945
You'll do God's will.
04:17.307 --> 04:19.437
And that will be good enough.
04:24.201 --> 04:26.213
We'll do our best for you, William.
04:28.000 --> 04:34.074
Advertise your product or brand here
contact www.OpenSubtitles.org today
04:44.193 --> 04:46.138
William got railroaded.
04:46.208 --> 04:49.161
We need to take this case apart
piece by piece,
04:49.198 --> 04:51.007
starting with the confession.
04:51.357 --> 04:53.161
He was only 14 years old,
04:53.198 --> 04:54.745
and the police questioned him
for 20 hours.
04:54.769 --> 04:56.326
Where was his aunt during all of this?
04:56.363 --> 04:58.732
Working three jobs.
She consented to an interview
04:58.769 --> 05:00.292
that became an interrogation.
05:00.356 --> 05:01.880
She didn't even know he was a suspect.
05:01.917 --> 05:03.149
So no lawyers.
05:03.186 --> 05:05.099
And no physical evidence
of him at the scene,
05:05.136 --> 05:06.787
and no testimony putting him there.
05:06.826 --> 05:08.599
Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa.
Huge problem, though.
05:08.623 --> 05:10.235
The murder weapon was found
in his bedroom.
05:10.259 --> 05:13.396
Given to him by a guy called Rabbit.
05:13.485 --> 05:15.559
Now, William only turned
the gun over to the police
05:15.596 --> 05:17.645
because he thought he was helping them.
05:17.682 --> 05:20.006
We need to find grounds
to get this back in court.
05:20.068 --> 05:22.373
Well, we should eviscerate
defense counsel.
05:22.467 --> 05:24.891
William's murder trial
lasted only one day.
05:25.046 --> 05:27.047
I've had dental work
that lasted longer than that.
05:27.566 --> 05:29.733
Jury deliberation took four days.
05:29.921 --> 05:31.161
Must have been a holdout.
05:31.255 --> 05:32.755
We need to track down that jury.
05:33.570 --> 05:35.078
Vi?
05:36.171 --> 05:38.374
Not Radcliff the Madcliff.
05:38.483 --> 05:41.187
- Is that a person?
- He's the jury administrator.
05:41.224 --> 05:42.880
He's been asking me out for six months.
05:43.008 --> 05:45.289
So what's the problem? You're on
dating apps all the time.
05:45.316 --> 05:46.776
There are many problems with Radcliff.
05:46.800 --> 05:49.226
He has 50 birds, for starters.
05:49.263 --> 05:52.525
Violet... it's only one date.
05:52.693 --> 05:55.935
It's the fastest way to find out
who the holdout juror is.
05:56.640 --> 05:58.122
Fine.
05:58.231 --> 06:00.214
But you people owe me.
06:02.177 --> 06:04.685
Hey, Radcliff, it's Violet.
06:04.722 --> 06:06.684
- About that date.
- Really?
06:06.789 --> 06:08.914
I just need a little favor.
06:09.242 --> 06:11.698
I was the holdout on the jury.
06:11.786 --> 06:13.971
William seemed like a good kid.
06:14.044 --> 06:16.725
There was something sweet about him.
06:16.911 --> 06:19.007
He was scared. Overwhelmed.
06:19.177 --> 06:20.794
What made you change your mind?
06:20.895 --> 06:23.286
The foreman would bring in
the newspaper every day.
06:23.323 --> 06:26.348
They were running a series
on the man he shot,
06:26.385 --> 06:28.237
Wan Lee Kim.
06:28.559 --> 06:30.106
It was awful.
06:30.143 --> 06:31.473
Did this influence your vote?
06:31.510 --> 06:32.726
Absolutely.
06:32.888 --> 06:36.046
After I read it, I voted to convict.
06:36.427 --> 06:37.755
Thank you.
06:37.833 --> 06:39.810
Your Honor, this is clearly
jury misconduct.
06:39.879 --> 06:41.162
Indeed.
06:41.209 --> 06:44.904
I hereby find reversible error
in the original trial.
06:44.941 --> 06:46.969
Mr. Hurston is granted a new trial.
06:47.006 --> 06:49.273
Let's get it right this time.
06:50.931 --> 06:52.405
We're just getting started.
06:52.442 --> 06:54.750
This is a step in the right direction.
06:55.455 --> 06:57.997
If you say so, Mr. Boudreau.
06:58.995 --> 07:01.967
I can't believe I agreed
to go out with Radcliff.
07:02.529 --> 07:04.672
- Did I mention birds?
- Hey, who knows...
07:04.709 --> 07:05.989
you may discover you love birds.
07:06.013 --> 07:08.179
Or get avian flu.
07:10.023 --> 07:13.079
Maybe I should date question mark guy.
07:13.539 --> 07:15.663
He is such a hottie.
07:16.875 --> 07:18.851
- Who is he?
- Jim something.
07:18.888 --> 07:21.179
Rosemary dated him
the summer before she died.
07:21.984 --> 07:25.043
I broke up with Jim,
and he showed up at Stanford,
07:25.080 --> 07:26.246
like a stalker.
07:26.283 --> 07:28.631
It was so creepy.
07:29.481 --> 07:30.839
It ended badly.
07:30.876 --> 07:33.534
Well, it seems like he should've
been the main suspect.
07:33.594 --> 07:35.446
Why didn't anybody find him?
07:35.535 --> 07:37.441
My original lawyer
searched every town
07:37.478 --> 07:38.781
within a hundred miles.
07:38.917 --> 07:40.378
Maybe we should try again.
07:40.472 --> 07:43.776
No, I don't have a last name,
description.
07:44.394 --> 07:45.706
Nothing.
07:45.792 --> 07:47.238
I bet I can dig something up.
07:47.316 --> 07:49.156
Yeah, have at it.
07:56.291 --> 07:58.207
You looking for this?
08:00.019 --> 08:03.129
Carlos Rafael Gomez, aged 22.
08:03.247 --> 08:05.210
His face looks just like yours.
08:05.308 --> 08:06.794
Where'd you get this?
08:06.902 --> 08:08.785
Jared knows this guy.
08:08.830 --> 08:09.845
Do you know how much trouble
08:09.869 --> 08:11.182
you'd get into if you got caught?
08:11.206 --> 08:13.179
You get arrested,
thrown into the system,
08:13.216 --> 08:15.598
life as you know it would be over.
08:15.863 --> 08:18.311
- I-I didn't even...
- You don't get it, do you?
08:18.542 --> 08:20.340
You're a black boy living in Chicago.
08:20.377 --> 08:23.097
You got a target on your back
the moment you leave this house.
08:23.175 --> 08:25.003
So now you're officially grounded.
08:25.099 --> 08:27.300
What? For how long?
08:27.337 --> 08:29.966
You can't see that far into the future.
08:39.376 --> 08:40.869
Hey, maybe this Rabbit will just
08:40.905 --> 08:42.962
hop out of his hole and just confess.
08:42.999 --> 08:44.406
We got to find him first.
08:44.443 --> 08:45.534
Yeah, we're trying.
08:45.571 --> 08:47.283
Meantime, we could go after
the detectives
08:47.320 --> 08:48.655
who coerced William's confession.
08:48.692 --> 08:51.830
The arresting officer
is a Detective Joe Folino.
08:51.898 --> 08:53.815
- Damn it.
- Crap.
08:53.908 --> 08:55.079
Am I missing something?
08:55.119 --> 08:57.099
He's a jerk, but juries love him.
09:04.044 --> 09:05.723
What the hell?
09:08.711 --> 09:10.029
What are you doing here?
09:10.066 --> 09:11.328
Hello, Madeline.
09:11.383 --> 09:13.718
Just couldn't pass up a chance
to dance with you again.
09:13.755 --> 09:16.222
Should be fun. I'll lead.
09:25.727 --> 09:27.352
The kid confessed.
09:27.440 --> 09:30.216
Detective Folino, do people sometimes
09:30.253 --> 09:32.680
falsely confess to crimes
they did not commit?
09:32.717 --> 09:36.089
Sure. And some people fake it
in the sack, too,
09:36.126 --> 09:37.584
but, I've been doing it long enough
09:37.608 --> 09:39.558
to know the difference.
09:39.677 --> 09:41.339
So you have no concerns?
09:41.376 --> 09:43.913
I have zero concerns
about this confession.
09:43.950 --> 09:45.633
Zero. He's the killer.
09:45.791 --> 09:47.410
Nothing further.
09:49.405 --> 09:51.116
Confessions are typically confirmed
09:51.153 --> 09:53.523
using a written statement
or a videotape.
09:53.905 --> 09:55.464
Why wasn't that done for William?
09:55.538 --> 09:58.429
I videotaped him,
but the file got corrupted.
09:58.466 --> 10:00.524
So you have no proof of a confession?
10:00.561 --> 10:03.153
The defendant led me straight
to the murder weapon,
10:03.418 --> 10:04.940
hidden in his bedroom.
10:05.015 --> 10:06.977
Now, when you questioned
William, he told you who
10:07.004 --> 10:08.256
- gave him that gun, didn't he?
- Yeah.
10:08.280 --> 10:10.038
- He said it was a rabbit.
- He said
10:10.075 --> 10:11.359
it was someone nicknamed Rabbit.
10:11.406 --> 10:12.708
Yeah, but I don't know no Rabbit,
10:12.732 --> 10:14.390
so obviously, the defendant was lying.
10:14.427 --> 10:16.402
No. You were lying, weren't you?
10:16.584 --> 10:19.385
You told him you needed his help
finding the real killer.
10:19.422 --> 10:21.313
You never told him he was a suspect.
10:21.428 --> 10:24.404
How does it feel deceiving
a 14-year-old boy?
10:24.441 --> 10:26.311
Objection. Counsel is badgering.
10:26.348 --> 10:29.235
Sustained. Are we about done,
Mr. Boudreau?
10:29.272 --> 10:30.780
Yes, Your Honor.
10:33.881 --> 10:35.334
We should put William on the stand.
10:35.371 --> 10:38.146
No. I'm not exposing him to Bellows.
10:38.295 --> 10:41.490
He'll force William to admit to
his confession, and we'll lose.
10:41.527 --> 10:43.060
No dice on the wascally wabbit.
10:43.097 --> 10:44.350
I canvassed the whole neighborhood,
10:44.374 --> 10:46.349
and no one's heard of him
or they're not talking.
10:46.386 --> 10:47.913
Well, he's got to be somewhere.
10:48.026 --> 10:49.767
William didn't just make him up.
10:49.862 --> 10:51.037
Find him.
10:51.074 --> 10:52.534
Yeah, man.
That's what I'm trying to do.
10:52.558 --> 10:53.752
We will find him.
10:53.789 --> 10:56.654
But first, we need to verify
William's alibi.
10:56.754 --> 10:58.787
This photo was taken on the day
of the murder.
10:58.899 --> 11:00.734
If we can establish a time of day...
11:00.771 --> 11:02.020
Let me see that.
11:04.335 --> 11:06.132
That's Brainiac Comics on Damen Avenue.
11:06.169 --> 11:07.218
They're open 1000 to 400,
11:07.242 --> 11:08.534
except for Wednesdays and Saturdays,
11:08.558 --> 11:10.408
which is new comic release day.
11:11.460 --> 11:12.716
Closet geek.
11:12.761 --> 11:15.820
- But too good for the bird guy?
- Comic books are not birds.
11:15.857 --> 11:17.249
Great!
11:18.039 --> 11:19.713
Track down the owner.
11:25.458 --> 11:27.148
What's up with Boudreau?
11:27.731 --> 11:29.450
Why is he so cranky?
11:30.005 --> 11:31.895
Doesn't want to let down William.
11:32.035 --> 11:33.726
Or his church.
11:40.942 --> 11:43.305
Hey! I just reached the next circuit.
11:43.342 --> 11:45.166
And you just reached my last nerve.
11:45.272 --> 11:46.949
Grounded means no video games.
11:46.996 --> 11:48.324
Yeah, whatever.
11:48.426 --> 11:50.642
- Excuse me?
- Nothing.
11:50.748 --> 11:52.990
You think you a man now?
11:53.449 --> 11:56.715
Fake IDs, impressing
your friends buying beers.
11:56.754 --> 11:59.180
- You know, when I was your age...
- I know, I know.
11:59.242 --> 12:00.981
You got in trouble, got beat up,
12:01.018 --> 12:03.270
but then you found God.
Look, I'm not you.
12:03.307 --> 12:05.187
Hey, you ain't gonna be
disrespecting me, homey.
12:05.264 --> 12:06.712
Now, this is my house.
12:06.770 --> 12:09.168
You do as I say,
or you can get the hell out.
12:09.246 --> 12:11.126
That's fine with me.
12:28.340 --> 12:29.926
- Thank you.
- Thank you.
12:29.963 --> 12:31.674
So, um... so, tell me something.
12:31.711 --> 12:34.363
How's the, how's the trial going?
12:34.400 --> 12:36.100
- Awful.
- Yeah?
12:36.434 --> 12:38.848
Every time I see Bellows,
I want to jam my pen in his eye.
12:38.885 --> 12:39.957
God.
12:41.654 --> 12:43.896
Sorry, I know you were
just asking to be polite.
12:43.969 --> 12:45.473
It's okay.
12:45.838 --> 12:48.156
The truth is refreshing
when you're dating someone.
12:51.762 --> 12:53.085
We're dating?
12:53.122 --> 12:55.613
Well, you know,
we're out on a date, so yeah.
12:55.754 --> 12:57.697
OKAY, NOTE TO SELF She doesn't
like the word "dating."
12:57.721 --> 13:00.072
No, no, it's...
13:01.254 --> 13:03.652
It's not that, I just, um...
13:04.770 --> 13:06.323
I never learned how to do this.
13:06.371 --> 13:08.473
I didn't get to go to college
and fumble around
13:08.510 --> 13:10.020
like everyone else.
13:10.194 --> 13:13.793
You've been out for what...
been out... six years?
13:15.050 --> 13:17.051
There's more to you,
there's more to your identity
13:17.088 --> 13:18.696
than just prison.
13:19.520 --> 13:21.804
There is?
13:22.097 --> 13:23.533
And what would that be?
13:23.570 --> 13:25.160
I don't know.
13:25.934 --> 13:27.410
But I'm hoping to find out.
13:34.420 --> 13:36.121
Dance?
13:36.744 --> 13:38.590
Or don't you dance, either?
14:13.262 --> 14:14.912
I should go.
14:32.395 --> 14:34.443
Thank you all
so much for coming out today.
14:34.519 --> 14:37.428
I'm Madeline Scott, and it is my...
14:37.883 --> 14:40.434
Thank you. Thank you.
14:40.576 --> 14:43.511
And it is my privilege and my honor
14:43.531 --> 14:47.599
to announce the candidacy
and my wholehearted support
14:47.636 --> 14:49.854
of Evan Esteban-Miller
14:49.891 --> 14:51.757
for the attorney general of Illinois!
14:53.943 --> 14:56.099
Unlike his opponent, Gore Bellows,
14:56.240 --> 14:58.802
Evan is a talented, fair-minded,
14:58.857 --> 15:01.213
successful trial lawyer.
15:01.331 --> 15:02.583
Gore Bellows' prosecutions
15:02.620 --> 15:04.444
are corrupt, and he has...
15:05.029 --> 15:07.544
I expect you to stab me in the
back, Susan, but in the front?
15:07.581 --> 15:09.076
Grow up, Gore.
15:09.133 --> 15:10.964
I had her on the show
because she gets ratings.
15:10.988 --> 15:13.541
Not news. She's only
doing it to get to me.
15:13.602 --> 15:14.857
Well, hell hath no fury
15:14.894 --> 15:17.099
like a woman wrongfully
imprisoned for a decade.
15:17.136 --> 15:18.472
You don't know the evidence.
15:18.755 --> 15:19.813
She and her brother
15:19.850 --> 15:21.792
killed that girl,
and now they're both free.
15:22.292 --> 15:23.888
So, what do you want?
15:24.021 --> 15:25.685
Besides the pleasure of your company?
15:25.740 --> 15:28.844
- My. Are we flirting?
- Is it working?
15:28.907 --> 15:30.909
The charm thing does not work on me.
15:30.986 --> 15:32.260
Now, tell me what you want
15:32.297 --> 15:34.605
and, more significantly,
how it benefits me.
15:34.642 --> 15:36.961
Equal time, and...
15:37.020 --> 15:38.572
the Marquez trial's coming up.
15:38.609 --> 15:40.228
I'll give you exclusive access.
15:40.355 --> 15:42.595
You'll still have to respond
to Madeline Scott's attacks.
15:42.626 --> 15:43.997
No Madeline, no airtime.
15:44.115 --> 15:46.131
It just so happens I have
an idea that will bring me
15:46.155 --> 15:48.018
in direct conflict with Madeline Scott.
15:48.095 --> 15:50.314
Are you talking about
the liquor store murder trial?
15:50.395 --> 15:51.888
It's good,
but you're gonna have to do better
15:51.912 --> 15:52.830
than that for my show.
15:52.867 --> 15:54.895
Rosemary Lynch's parents.
15:55.231 --> 15:57.668
I'm gonna use them in a new
campaign for victims' rights.
15:57.707 --> 15:59.174
Once they're
front and center with me...
15:59.198 --> 16:02.333
- I can bring up Madeline Scott.
- And remind your audience
16:02.370 --> 16:03.955
that the only reason she's famous
16:04.169 --> 16:06.164
is because she murdered
an innocent girl.
16:09.533 --> 16:10.991
That's hot.
16:13.779 --> 16:15.954
State of Illinois v. Levi Scott.
16:16.114 --> 16:17.289
Mr. Scott,
16:17.326 --> 16:18.985
- you finally joined us.
- Your Honor,
16:19.022 --> 16:20.344
my client consents
16:20.381 --> 16:22.365
to the plea arrangement agreed
upon with the prosecution.
16:22.389 --> 16:24.484
- The plea is off the table.
- What?
16:24.521 --> 16:27.090
Mr. Duncan, I am not fond
of these kinds of maneuvers.
16:27.218 --> 16:29.715
I'm aware, Your Honor,
but new evidence has surfaced.
16:29.810 --> 16:32.252
A sworn affidavit
from the complaining witness,
16:32.289 --> 16:33.789
Heather Husband.
16:33.866 --> 16:35.328
She asserts that the defendant
16:35.365 --> 16:37.534
took a swing at them
with a baseball bat.
16:38.943 --> 16:41.038
- No, Brian came at me.
- Mr. Scott.
16:41.075 --> 16:42.795
- Levi.
- We're amending our complaint
16:42.832 --> 16:44.256
to assault with a deadly weapon.
16:44.375 --> 16:46.570
In light of Mr. Scott's
prior drug arrests,
16:46.607 --> 16:49.332
we will be seeking the
maximum of 25 years in prison.
16:49.422 --> 16:52.322
Your Honor, this is outrageous.
The State's amended complaint
16:52.359 --> 16:54.051
creates new facts out of thin air.
16:54.482 --> 16:56.398
You can dispute those facts
at the trial.
16:56.435 --> 16:58.575
We're moving forward. Next case.
16:58.669 --> 17:01.497
Maddie, I can't go to prison.
I can't. I will die in there.
17:01.590 --> 17:03.020
What happens if we go to prison?
17:03.065 --> 17:05.332
Okay? I can't do it! I can't!
17:07.252 --> 17:09.694
State of Illinois v. Conway.
17:09.934 --> 17:11.568
You're a lying bitch.
17:11.817 --> 17:13.092
Great defense.
17:13.167 --> 17:15.403
Did they teach you that
in law school or in prison?
17:15.440 --> 17:17.535
Good one, babe.
17:27.042 --> 17:29.113
Hurston, up against the wall. Now.
17:30.229 --> 17:33.426
Hey, hey, hey, hey!
Don't touch my drawings!
17:33.463 --> 17:34.785
This all looks like contraband.
17:34.822 --> 17:36.446
We're gonna have to confiscate this.
17:36.581 --> 17:38.176
It's all I got!
17:38.322 --> 17:40.288
Get off me!
17:49.661 --> 17:51.942
A search of inmate
Hurston's cell uncovered
17:51.969 --> 17:53.840
some hand-drawn artwork.
17:53.950 --> 17:56.981
The images are violent, alarming.
17:57.207 --> 17:59.212
What do the drawings of William Hurston
17:59.249 --> 18:00.734
reveal about his psyche?
18:00.801 --> 18:02.066
Well, as you can see,
18:02.103 --> 18:04.317
he's obsessively drawn the same event
18:04.354 --> 18:06.664
- over and over again.
- No, no!
18:06.957 --> 18:08.550
Is that an admission of guilt?
18:08.587 --> 18:10.866
Objection. Calls for speculation.
18:11.000 --> 18:13.051
Dr. Gregson is not
just the prison warden.
18:13.088 --> 18:16.663
He is also an expert in
forensic evaluation of inmates.
18:16.958 --> 18:19.689
He is here to provide
his expert opinion.
18:19.726 --> 18:21.887
Overruled. Go ahead, Dr. Gregson.
18:21.935 --> 18:25.458
A compulsion to reenact a crime
is a way of dealing with guilt.
18:25.495 --> 18:27.347
To a reasonable degree
of medical certainty,
18:27.384 --> 18:29.814
these drawings are tantamount
to another confession
18:29.851 --> 18:31.460
to killing Mr. Kim.
18:31.667 --> 18:33.500
Nothing further.
18:34.411 --> 18:37.060
Isn't it also reasonable
to assume that these drawings
18:37.097 --> 18:39.314
are a product of William's imagination?
18:39.411 --> 18:41.444
The level of detail suggests otherwise.
18:41.481 --> 18:42.531
Really?
18:42.575 --> 18:45.364
Because in this drawing,
William is holding
18:45.401 --> 18:48.042
a sharp Afro pick
that looks about two feet long.
18:48.079 --> 18:51.323
And in this drawing, he has wings.
18:51.503 --> 18:54.425
So, are you saying
that William had wings
18:54.462 --> 18:57.412
and carried an Afro pick when he
allegedly committed this crime?
18:57.503 --> 18:59.509
- Of course not.
- William has spent
18:59.792 --> 19:02.116
five years in prison.
19:02.163 --> 19:04.295
Isn't it possible that he thinks daily
19:04.332 --> 19:06.006
about the charges that put him there,
19:06.043 --> 19:09.253
and that all this is just an
exploration of that injustice?
19:09.290 --> 19:10.673
I suppose it's possible, but...
19:10.710 --> 19:12.798
And so wouldn't that
actually make these drawings
19:12.835 --> 19:14.633
the opposite of a confession?
19:14.751 --> 19:16.170
Objection. Argumentative.
19:16.207 --> 19:18.538
Withdrawn. Nothing further.
19:24.818 --> 19:26.381
Yo, Rabbit. I'm...
19:29.108 --> 19:30.526
I'm not a cop!
19:40.056 --> 19:42.241
Rabbit! I'm not a cop.
20:10.618 --> 20:12.249
I'm sorry, man. I just...
20:12.485 --> 20:13.917
I can't run anymore.
20:14.791 --> 20:17.212
I'm not here to arrest you.
I'm not a cop, Rabbit.
20:17.399 --> 20:18.449
Rabbit?
20:18.486 --> 20:20.497
Sorry, I-I don't know your real name.
20:21.178 --> 20:22.895
Rabbit was my brother.
20:22.989 --> 20:24.781
He got shot in Fuller Park.
20:24.881 --> 20:26.506
He died a year ago.
20:32.465 --> 20:34.394
Mr. and Mrs. Lynch,
I can't tell you how much
20:34.431 --> 20:37.576
I appreciate you coming down
here on this important issue.
20:37.927 --> 20:39.867
So you want to create a new law
20:39.945 --> 20:42.092
- for victims' rights?
- Exactly.
20:42.154 --> 20:44.324
We intend to introduce legislation
20:44.361 --> 20:45.849
that makes it more difficult
20:45.886 --> 20:49.370
for guilty people like Madeline
and Levi Scott to be exonerated.
20:49.446 --> 20:53.240
I was told you had new evidence
in Rosemary's investigation.
20:53.304 --> 20:56.224
Well, no new evidence, per se,
20:56.396 --> 20:58.990
but we want to apply
the same rigors to her case.
20:59.027 --> 21:01.416
So we're just here for you to use us
21:01.453 --> 21:03.240
to score political points?
21:04.154 --> 21:05.744
Thank you...
21:05.792 --> 21:07.482
- but no, thank you.
- Mr. Lynch,
21:07.519 --> 21:09.107
you don't need to...
21:09.373 --> 21:11.833
Charles and I divorced
several years ago.
21:12.688 --> 21:14.365
Please continue.
21:15.193 --> 21:18.763
It is my hope to name
the bill after your daughter
21:18.807 --> 21:21.427
and that you will help advocate
for its passage.
21:21.580 --> 21:24.766
I want the world to remember
the name Rosemary Lynch.
21:25.240 --> 21:27.415
I'll do anything I can to help you.
21:27.717 --> 21:31.638
You might not want to attack
Madeline and Levi directly.
21:31.717 --> 21:33.588
Charles thinks they're innocent,
21:33.665 --> 21:35.498
and he might oppose the bill if you do.
21:35.638 --> 21:37.482
What do you think, Mrs. Lynch?
21:37.553 --> 21:39.779
I think they're guilty as hell.
21:49.639 --> 21:51.479
Hey, I just jaywalked.
Are you gonna arrest me?
21:51.974 --> 21:53.599
What do you want, Bodie?
21:53.701 --> 21:55.535
Dinner, foreplay.
21:55.848 --> 21:57.782
Not necessarily in that order.
22:00.134 --> 22:01.271
Yeah?
22:05.472 --> 22:07.092
What's for dinner?
22:07.278 --> 22:08.709
Coq au vin.
22:08.746 --> 22:10.380
- Your place?
- Your place.
22:10.589 --> 22:11.823
I'll bring the merlot.
22:11.928 --> 22:14.052
Yeah, and the handcuffs.
22:14.206 --> 22:15.638
I always do.
22:15.735 --> 22:18.114
Yeah, you do.
22:18.271 --> 22:21.536
Now, before this, bacchanal begins,
22:22.341 --> 22:23.775
I need a little favor.
22:24.294 --> 22:26.324
Can you help me find a Rabbit?
22:27.067 --> 22:28.809
Is that a sex thing?
22:29.083 --> 22:31.474
No, it's the name of a guy.
22:31.647 --> 22:32.920
I need his file.
22:32.957 --> 22:34.640
He died a year ago in Fuller Park.
22:34.677 --> 22:36.510
Well, if I do, you got to be my rabbit.
22:37.044 --> 22:38.745
That's definitely a sex thing.
22:47.583 --> 22:49.942
Hey, how are you doing
on Madeline Scott?
22:50.450 --> 22:53.419
Joe, you know, I'm still...
I'm still thinking on that one.
22:53.520 --> 22:56.003
Think faster.
This thing's starting to drag.
22:56.865 --> 22:58.534
If you can get her to
admit she had something
22:58.558 --> 23:00.205
to do with Rosemary Lynch's death,
23:00.242 --> 23:02.208
you'll get your pick of assignments.
23:04.009 --> 23:06.224
- London?
- Hey, wherever you want.
23:06.279 --> 23:08.279
But it's got to be good.
23:10.692 --> 23:13.009
Hey, I found out more
about our dead Rabbit.
23:13.046 --> 23:14.953
His real name is Derrick Johnston.
23:15.325 --> 23:16.863
And looking at his arrest record,
23:16.947 --> 23:18.504
I definitely think he's the shooter.
23:18.731 --> 23:20.888
Burglary, assault.
23:20.997 --> 23:22.490
The police must have never
even looked at him
23:22.514 --> 23:24.685
- for the liquor store murder.
- Of course not.
23:24.778 --> 23:26.427
How did you get the police report?
23:26.528 --> 23:29.271
Don't worry about it.
But wait, there's more...
23:29.380 --> 23:31.285
if you look at the name
of the arresting officer
23:31.346 --> 23:33.372
on the assault charge.
23:36.754 --> 23:37.906
Radcliff.
23:38.069 --> 23:39.544
Hi, Violet.
23:40.960 --> 23:43.277
Hey, you ready for our lunch?
23:46.711 --> 23:49.303
I-I brought along Curveball
23:49.489 --> 23:50.804
so you can meet him.
23:50.896 --> 23:52.064
You brought a bird.
23:52.101 --> 23:54.008
That's really adorable.
23:54.294 --> 23:56.185
Does Curveball like baseball?
23:56.380 --> 23:59.071
No, I-I named him
after the double agent
23:59.190 --> 24:01.505
that lied to us during the Iraq War.
24:02.036 --> 24:03.575
His sister's Rumsfeld.
24:06.185 --> 24:07.420
Yeah.
24:07.669 --> 24:09.232
I hate you.
24:09.602 --> 24:11.286
Let's go.
24:13.614 --> 24:16.460
Detective Folino,
we appreciate you coming back.
24:16.497 --> 24:18.067
We just have a few more questions.
24:18.192 --> 24:19.653
Do you recall William telling you
24:19.690 --> 24:23.603
someone named Rabbit gave him
the gun that shot Mr. Kim?
24:23.724 --> 24:26.432
And you told the court
you didn't know him?
24:26.526 --> 24:28.267
That's right. Never heard of him.
24:28.708 --> 24:31.700
Well, his real name
was Derrick Johnston.
24:31.737 --> 24:32.905
Have you heard of him?
24:32.942 --> 24:34.919
Maybe. Name sounds familiar.
24:34.982 --> 24:36.331
I bet it does.
24:36.560 --> 24:39.052
Your Honor, we'd like
to enter into the record
24:39.247 --> 24:42.060
an arrest report for Derrick Johnston
24:42.130 --> 24:44.278
on November 12, 2013.
24:44.338 --> 24:46.445
Assault with a deadly weapon.
24:46.609 --> 24:48.642
The arrest was made by the witness,
24:48.771 --> 24:50.896
Detective Joseph Folino.
24:50.933 --> 24:52.513
Now, your hand-written notes
24:52.550 --> 24:54.208
are on that report. Correct, Detective?
24:54.245 --> 24:55.951
- Correct.
- And what name did you use
24:55.988 --> 24:58.458
for Mr. Johnston at
the time of his arrest?
25:01.061 --> 25:03.043
Rabbit.
25:03.341 --> 25:05.825
And the date of that
arrest occurred before
25:05.862 --> 25:07.271
you arrested William.
25:07.739 --> 25:09.234
- True?
- Yes.
25:09.528 --> 25:11.569
So when William said Rabbit
25:11.606 --> 25:13.388
gave him that gun,
25:13.575 --> 25:16.309
you knew exactly who he was
talking about, didn't you?
25:16.347 --> 25:18.099
I-I don't know if I recall if I...
25:18.136 --> 25:19.802
But you never questioned
25:19.888 --> 25:21.913
a known felon.
25:22.661 --> 25:25.975
Look, criminals blame other
criminals when they're caught.
25:26.044 --> 25:28.216
That's probably why I didn't pursue it.
25:28.313 --> 25:30.052
The case against William was tight.
25:30.089 --> 25:32.442
It was tight
because you made it that way.
25:34.138 --> 25:36.002
By refusing to listen
25:36.039 --> 25:38.390
to a 14-year-old boy.
25:40.158 --> 25:41.942
I'm finished with this witness.
25:52.380 --> 25:54.988
How come you didn't testify
at the original trial?
25:55.159 --> 25:57.342
I didn't know it was happening.
25:57.896 --> 26:00.614
Afterwards, someone told me
William had shot someone.
26:00.671 --> 26:02.005
I was stunned.
26:02.128 --> 26:04.045
He was a sweet kid.
26:05.337 --> 26:07.488
Dave, shoo.
26:08.710 --> 26:11.470
The fanboys... they love me.
26:13.177 --> 26:14.653
Do you know anything about this?
26:14.727 --> 26:17.461
Sure. That's William
with Fordson Frank.
26:17.568 --> 26:19.247
He's a comic book legend.
26:19.364 --> 26:20.954
I took this picture myself.
26:21.638 --> 26:23.457
You did?
26:23.677 --> 26:25.458
Do you remember taking this photo?
26:25.495 --> 26:29.497
Yes. My signings were always
200 to 500,
26:29.567 --> 26:31.057
Saturday afternoons.
26:31.151 --> 26:32.435
I checked my calendar,
26:32.472 --> 26:36.114
and Fordson Frank was there
March 22, 2014.
26:36.195 --> 26:39.547
And Wan Lee Kim was shot
at 300 p.m. on that day.
26:40.036 --> 26:41.942
Can you say definitively
26:41.979 --> 26:44.536
that William was in your store
at that time?
26:44.581 --> 26:46.072
Absolutely.
26:46.322 --> 26:48.339
Thank you, Mr. Toth.
26:49.847 --> 26:53.934
How many people in attendance
that day, Mr. Toth?
26:54.771 --> 26:55.915
Ballpark.
26:55.952 --> 26:57.243
Maybe 40.
26:57.344 --> 26:58.584
And you're positive
26:58.621 --> 27:01.466
William was in your store
the whole time?
27:01.536 --> 27:03.181
Relatively positive.
27:03.299 --> 27:06.017
Relatively. I see.
27:06.135 --> 27:08.638
Tell that
to Mr. Kim's widow and children,
27:08.913 --> 27:11.689
who miss their father
and husband every day.
27:12.130 --> 27:14.724
"Relatively" doesn't bring him back.
27:14.761 --> 27:17.638
"Relatively" does not prove
that William Hurston was
27:17.675 --> 27:20.216
in your store when Mr. Kim
was murdered, does it?
27:20.284 --> 27:22.403
You murdered Rosemary!
27:22.646 --> 27:24.880
You're lying, Madeline.
27:34.426 --> 27:36.161
Ezekiel?
27:37.864 --> 27:39.817
When is William going to testify?
27:39.917 --> 27:41.326
We weren't planning on that.
27:41.406 --> 27:45.153
Mr. Boudreau, the jury thinks
my nephew is a monster.
27:45.255 --> 27:47.278
Put him on the stand.
Let them see who he is.
27:47.315 --> 27:50.316
William is not the sweet
14-year-old boy you remember.
27:50.958 --> 27:52.786
We put him on the stand, we could lose.
27:52.823 --> 27:55.741
- You don't know that.
- She's right. We don't.
27:55.778 --> 27:57.249
I didn't testify at my trial.
27:57.286 --> 27:59.393
I've always regretted it.
We should give William a chance.
27:59.417 --> 28:01.231
This case isn't about you, Madeline.
28:01.478 --> 28:03.487
I never said that it was.
28:05.005 --> 28:07.470
You hired me to protect your nephew.
28:07.858 --> 28:09.874
Let me do that.
28:10.020 --> 28:11.954
I'll see you both tomorrow.
28:15.888 --> 28:18.208
Don't ever contradict me
in front of a client again.
28:18.245 --> 28:21.130
Don't ever talk to me like that
in front of a client again.
28:31.157 --> 28:32.827
I'm just...
28:33.106 --> 28:35.149
not feeling myself.
28:35.980 --> 28:37.828
I'm angry at everyone.
28:38.352 --> 28:42.188
My law partner, my kids, my wife.
28:42.313 --> 28:44.446
She thinks I'm talking
to my pastor right now.
28:44.574 --> 28:46.924
But you came to a therapist instead.
28:47.120 --> 28:49.797
What do you think brought on
this shift in you?
28:50.031 --> 28:51.622
I have a client.
28:52.063 --> 28:54.805
He was convicted of murder
when he was 14,
28:55.019 --> 28:58.963
but he's six-foot-four
and looks a lot older.
29:00.334 --> 29:03.243
- So they never saw the kid in him.
- Your son...
29:03.348 --> 29:06.866
um, Michael... he's, he's 14?
29:08.832 --> 29:10.938
I found a... a fake ID.
29:11.157 --> 29:12.758
I don't know
if Michael used it or not...
29:12.795 --> 29:15.040
But you're worried.
29:18.198 --> 29:21.086
When I was 14,
I was a punk on the street.
29:21.854 --> 29:25.556
Our folks were so busy with
work, they barely missed me.
29:26.102 --> 29:29.218
I did whatever I wanted, so I
got in all kinds of trouble.
29:29.714 --> 29:32.715
I got beat within an inch of my life.
29:34.523 --> 29:35.979
I ended up running to the church,
29:36.016 --> 29:39.768
because, you know, it's a sanctuary.
29:41.039 --> 29:43.001
When I woke up the next morning,
29:43.235 --> 29:45.659
the light streaming
through the windows,
29:46.032 --> 29:48.070
I saw the face of Jesus,
29:48.555 --> 29:50.072
and I felt this...
29:51.313 --> 29:55.094
endless love, like I had finally
found what I needed.
29:56.256 --> 29:59.407
Why are you telling me this now?
30:04.958 --> 30:07.776
I guess we're all just
a little lost when we're 14.
30:08.054 --> 30:10.221
But you found your way.
30:10.683 --> 30:12.384
But will he find his?
30:13.051 --> 30:14.450
Michael?
30:14.813 --> 30:16.857
Let me ask you this.
30:17.136 --> 30:19.303
Does Michael know you're there for him?
30:20.698 --> 30:22.548
I don't know what he knows.
30:23.852 --> 30:26.700
Well, then maybe
you should let him hear you,
30:27.055 --> 30:29.004
and then really listen
30:29.515 --> 30:31.610
to what he has to say.
30:40.124 --> 30:43.884
Listen... I owe you an apology.
30:44.217 --> 30:46.686
I was, um, frustrated,
30:46.748 --> 30:49.155
and, you know, Michael's
been acting up lately and...
30:49.205 --> 30:51.608
You're afraid Michael
could end up like William.
30:51.826 --> 30:53.244
Yeah, but...
30:53.826 --> 30:56.123
I shouldn't have taken it out
on you and everyone, so...
30:56.209 --> 30:58.231
It's all right. We understand.
30:58.436 --> 31:00.592
It's actually what I wanted
to talk to you about.
31:00.803 --> 31:02.897
I still think
we need to let William testify.
31:02.980 --> 31:04.561
You didn't let me finish
31:04.598 --> 31:05.891
what I wanted to say to William's aunt,
31:05.915 --> 31:07.039
so you need to hear me now.
31:07.201 --> 31:09.123
- All right.
- At my trial,
31:09.160 --> 31:11.585
my lawyer was afraid,
just like you are now.
31:11.772 --> 31:13.522
He thought the jury would hate me.
31:13.607 --> 31:16.016
I felt powerless and alone.
31:16.160 --> 31:18.752
That is exactly how William
is feeling right now.
31:18.881 --> 31:21.459
He won't say it, but deep down,
he wants to tell the world
31:21.496 --> 31:23.830
what really happened to him.
We need to give him that.
31:24.071 --> 31:25.696
You're right.
31:25.975 --> 31:27.928
I am afraid.
31:28.303 --> 31:30.022
Bellows is gonna come down
on William hard,
31:30.059 --> 31:31.817
and I don't know
how he's gonna respond,
31:31.854 --> 31:33.354
and the jury may hate him.
31:33.487 --> 31:35.787
Or they may really care about him,
31:36.239 --> 31:38.397
just like I know you do.
31:40.605 --> 31:42.123
Yeah.
31:42.943 --> 31:44.357
You're right.
31:45.631 --> 31:46.780
They need to hear him,
31:46.799 --> 31:49.133
just like they needed to hear you.
31:52.012 --> 31:55.013
We're gonna need you
to testify, William.
31:55.216 --> 31:58.076
Now, they're gonna ask you
why you confessed,
31:58.467 --> 32:00.219
why you had the gun that shot Mr. Kim.
32:00.741 --> 32:03.062
We need you to explain
to the jury what happened,
32:03.099 --> 32:04.890
just like you told us.
32:05.538 --> 32:07.371
You think you can do that?
32:11.459 --> 32:14.052
We want to show the jury
who the real William is.
32:14.624 --> 32:16.936
Not the kid who spent years in prison.
32:17.100 --> 32:19.624
The artist who loves comic books,
32:19.694 --> 32:22.387
who loves to draw.
32:35.214 --> 32:36.589
Okay.
32:37.558 --> 32:39.558
I'll testify.
32:43.456 --> 32:45.839
You did admit that you shot and killed.
32:45.858 --> 32:47.382
Wan Lee Kim, correct?
32:48.081 --> 32:49.480
Yes, but I...
32:49.517 --> 32:51.289
And now you want us to believe
that you didn't mean it?
32:51.313 --> 32:52.839
- I didn't.
- So you lied.
32:52.924 --> 32:54.514
You're a liar. You're lying now
32:54.551 --> 32:56.564
because you want to get yourself
out of trouble, aren't you?
32:56.588 --> 32:58.862
- Stop saying that!
- You're lying, Madeline.
32:58.956 --> 33:02.544
No one believes you!
It's time to tell the truth.
33:02.581 --> 33:04.957
You murdered Rosemary.
33:05.143 --> 33:06.667
No, it-it ain't like that.
33:06.704 --> 33:09.456
You say that now, but that is
certainly not what you said
33:09.532 --> 33:12.667
at the time of the murder,
when you confessed.
33:15.486 --> 33:17.069
No further questions.
33:24.288 --> 33:25.788
William,
33:26.503 --> 33:28.123
how old are you in this photo?
33:28.905 --> 33:30.565
Fourteen.
33:34.363 --> 33:35.862
14 years old.
33:35.924 --> 33:38.737
And the detectives
questioned you for 20 hours?
33:39.009 --> 33:41.135
All I wanted was to go home.
33:41.909 --> 33:44.034
- To see your auntie?
- Yeah.
33:44.071 --> 33:46.432
And that's what the police
promised you, right?
33:46.542 --> 33:48.235
That if you confessed,
33:48.542 --> 33:50.659
you'd finally get to see her again?
33:51.006 --> 33:53.167
They said I'd get to go home.
33:54.645 --> 33:57.062
It's the only place
I've ever felt safe.
33:58.284 --> 33:59.766
My auntie...
34:00.003 --> 34:02.658
she bought me all my pencils
and drafting paper.
34:02.947 --> 34:04.033
She loved me.
34:04.070 --> 34:05.394
I still do.
34:05.431 --> 34:07.831
William Hurston only, please.
34:08.753 --> 34:10.569
What else did the police say?
34:10.818 --> 34:12.693
That I could trust them.
34:13.487 --> 34:15.112
That they needed me.
34:15.339 --> 34:17.556
They needed my help
to find the shooter.
34:19.797 --> 34:21.589
That I'd be a hero.
34:24.196 --> 34:26.034
So I showed them the gun,
34:26.469 --> 34:28.257
told them about Rabbit.
34:31.003 --> 34:33.292
But I didn't kill nobody.
34:33.524 --> 34:35.143
Heroes are the good guys.
34:35.234 --> 34:37.543
I'm a good guy.
34:38.109 --> 34:39.908
I was tired.
34:39.972 --> 34:42.514
I wanted to go home.
34:48.032 --> 34:50.120
Nothing further, Your Honor.
34:59.746 --> 35:02.254
- You should do the closing.
- No.
35:02.402 --> 35:05.090
No, I'm too close. I don't want
to get too emotional.
35:05.187 --> 35:07.587
Easy, William found you for a reason.
35:07.904 --> 35:09.236
He needs you.
35:10.831 --> 35:12.301
Okay.
35:13.627 --> 35:15.223
I'll do my best.
35:20.092 --> 35:21.758
What?
35:22.397 --> 35:24.413
I found Rosemary's mystery man.
35:24.967 --> 35:27.553
I checked flight records
for Rosemary's Stanford weekend.
35:27.590 --> 35:29.940
Checked every flight between
Chicago and the Bay Area,
35:29.977 --> 35:32.686
and I searched every person
named Jim or James,
35:32.869 --> 35:34.477
and I came up empty.
35:34.678 --> 35:38.530
But then I found a familiar name
on one of the flights.
35:39.296 --> 35:40.351
Levi.
35:42.944 --> 35:44.928
Rosemary was afraid of Levi.
35:44.999 --> 35:46.686
That doesn't mean he killed her.
35:46.747 --> 35:48.374
It means he could have.
35:48.739 --> 35:51.444
There's plenty of
reasonable doubt in this case.
35:54.577 --> 35:55.977
There's plenty of reasonable doubt.
35:56.369 --> 35:59.217
There's plenty of
reasonable doubt in this case.
36:01.428 --> 36:04.889
Hey, no matter how much
you push me away,
36:05.007 --> 36:07.059
no matter how much you think
you don't need me anymore,
36:07.083 --> 36:08.186
I love you,
36:08.346 --> 36:10.671
and I'm not going anywhere,
no matter what.
36:14.811 --> 36:17.491
Um, cool.
36:17.897 --> 36:20.240
I'm gonna get some ice cream.
36:21.157 --> 36:22.631
You want some?
36:22.712 --> 36:24.646
I'm good, but thanks.
36:26.105 --> 36:28.741
There's plenty of reasonable doubt.
36:36.770 --> 36:39.229
Imagine a 14-year-old boy you know.
36:39.864 --> 36:42.871
He's confident, maybe overly so,
36:42.934 --> 36:45.957
still learning about the world,
trying to fit in,
36:45.994 --> 36:48.494
impressing his friends
and making mistakes.
36:48.659 --> 36:50.254
Now imagine that same young boy
36:50.291 --> 36:52.049
in a room
with an experienced detective,
36:52.281 --> 36:55.442
and that detective confuses him
with empty promises.
36:55.691 --> 36:57.924
All he wants is to be believed.
36:58.324 --> 37:00.519
There's terror in his eyes.
He just wants it to end.
37:00.613 --> 37:02.154
He wants to go home.
37:03.807 --> 37:05.285
Can you see it?
37:05.474 --> 37:06.974
Because I can.
37:07.056 --> 37:10.067
And truth be told,
it keeps me up at night.
37:10.262 --> 37:12.803
Because no matter how much
you love and prepare your child,
37:12.840 --> 37:15.098
you can't protect them from everything.
37:15.439 --> 37:17.379
Now, isn't it possible...
37:18.302 --> 37:21.457
more likely than not,
that this young boy,
37:21.567 --> 37:24.526
hungry for approval,
told that trained detective
37:24.621 --> 37:26.910
what he thought he wanted to hear?
37:27.699 --> 37:29.184
Now, if you believe that's possible,
37:29.221 --> 37:30.715
that's reasonable doubt.
37:31.632 --> 37:33.270
The State would want you to believe
37:33.307 --> 37:34.817
that no one would ever confess
37:34.854 --> 37:37.186
to a crime they did not commit.
37:38.353 --> 37:41.371
But use your common sense
and life experience.
37:41.763 --> 37:43.487
We all know that's not true,
37:44.270 --> 37:45.990
and they know it.
37:46.379 --> 37:48.164
Now imagine William Hurston.
37:48.299 --> 37:52.160
He was that scared,
lonely 14-year-old boy.
37:53.327 --> 37:55.332
And that detective tricked him
37:55.692 --> 37:59.692
into admitting to a crime
he did not commit.
38:01.967 --> 38:04.476
And that's what this case
boils down to.
38:05.893 --> 38:10.529
And that's why you should
find William not guilty.
38:12.485 --> 38:14.098
Thank you.
38:21.078 --> 38:22.393
We learn in Leviticus
38:22.430 --> 38:24.153
that when anybody becomes aware
of the fact
38:24.190 --> 38:27.312
that they are guilty,
they must confess.
38:27.695 --> 38:30.648
That is exactly what happened
with this defendant.
38:30.703 --> 38:32.703
Don't let Mr. Boudreau
and Ms. Scott confuse you.
38:35.484 --> 38:37.328
Did William Hurston
38:37.365 --> 38:40.399
shoot and kill Wan Lee Kim?
38:41.187 --> 38:43.867
I say, beyond a shadow
of a doubt, the answer is yes.
38:44.458 --> 38:46.435
Now, Ms. Scott and Mr. Boudreau
would have you believe
38:46.459 --> 38:48.407
that Detective Folino exerted
38:48.444 --> 38:52.130
some sort of power over the defendant,
38:52.348 --> 38:54.609
by calling into question
his character...
38:54.646 --> 38:57.647
a respected detective with
the Chicago Police Department.
38:57.898 --> 39:00.067
Now, you heard Detective Folino.
39:00.354 --> 39:02.234
By no measure...
39:02.389 --> 39:05.715
did he strong-arm this defendant.
39:06.113 --> 39:09.719
He conducted a fair
and thorough interview
39:10.015 --> 39:11.807
and obtained a confession.
39:12.977 --> 39:15.654
Now, I ask you for a moment
to consider the victim,
39:15.951 --> 39:17.344
Wan Lee Kim.
39:17.445 --> 39:21.143
Think about the fear in his eyes
39:21.766 --> 39:24.830
when this young man
held a gun to his head
39:24.906 --> 39:26.555
and shot him.
39:26.789 --> 39:28.734
Think about that moment.
39:29.715 --> 39:33.703
The moment when he realized
he was about to die.
39:34.484 --> 39:35.901
Ladies and gentlemen,
39:38.197 --> 39:41.570
If he didn't do it, why did he confess?
39:41.828 --> 39:43.244
Why?
39:45.543 --> 39:48.969
Because he did do this heinous crime.
39:49.797 --> 39:52.357
On behalf of the People
of the State of Illinois,
39:52.513 --> 39:56.398
I'm asking that you find him
guilty of murder.
40:01.942 --> 40:04.027
Appearances matter.
40:04.472 --> 40:07.689
What the world sees in us
sets expectations.
40:07.910 --> 40:10.691
The world defined William
Hurston by the way he looked.
40:10.780 --> 40:11.980
No, no!
40:12.063 --> 40:13.195
They labeled him a killer,
40:13.222 --> 40:15.371
and they treated him like one.
40:16.699 --> 40:19.959
But inside, he screamed back,
40:20.746 --> 40:23.296
"I'm not a killer."
40:23.910 --> 40:25.949
"I'm a superhero."
40:27.629 --> 40:29.271
Jury's back.
40:36.302 --> 40:38.026
Have you reached a verdict?
40:38.105 --> 40:40.691
- We have, Your Honor.
- How find you?
40:40.762 --> 40:41.991
We find the defendant,
40:42.028 --> 40:44.711
William Richmond Hurston, not guilty.
40:47.777 --> 40:50.387
Mr. Hurston, you are free to go.
40:51.153 --> 40:53.004
Thank you.
40:56.915 --> 40:59.249
Thank you so much.
41:00.519 --> 41:03.551
If we make the next news cycle,
no one will even notice.
41:03.626 --> 41:05.609
- Are we ready?
- All set.
41:05.691 --> 41:07.691
It's time we change the narrative.
41:08.092 --> 41:09.925
I don't like the word "victim."
41:09.995 --> 41:11.421
I prefer "survivor,"
41:11.588 --> 41:14.035
because that's what happens
when a crime occurs
41:14.258 --> 41:15.902
and you're the one left standing.
41:16.048 --> 41:17.668
You survive.
41:19.222 --> 41:21.176
I will work with state legislators
41:21.213 --> 41:23.387
to enact Rosemary's Law,
41:23.650 --> 41:26.076
named in honor of Rosemary Lynch,
41:26.318 --> 41:28.543
whose mother, a survivor,
41:29.022 --> 41:31.006
we have here today.
41:32.085 --> 41:33.590
Mrs. Lynch.
41:33.863 --> 41:36.130
Barbara Lynch knows that there
is a pervasive injustice
41:36.167 --> 41:37.668
in our society.
41:38.057 --> 41:41.541
With Rosemary's Law,
we can bring justice to her
41:41.730 --> 41:43.465
and to all survivors,
41:43.588 --> 41:48.113
because no survivor
should be silenced or alone.
41:57.743 --> 42:01.258
How did you get in here?
42:01.377 --> 42:02.893
Mom gave me a spare key.
42:02.930 --> 42:04.539
She wouldn't do that.
42:04.680 --> 42:07.142
I came to talk to you
about my assault case.
42:07.235 --> 42:08.477
You broke into my place.
42:08.514 --> 42:11.492
What the hell is all this, Maddie?
42:13.070 --> 42:14.708
What happened between you and Rosemary?
42:14.766 --> 42:16.599
Stop talking to me like a lawyer!
42:16.636 --> 42:18.486
Stop acting like a criminal.
42:18.560 --> 42:20.094
I know you followed her to Stanford.
42:20.131 --> 42:22.298
She was scared of you.
42:23.899 --> 42:25.842
No, um, no, no.
42:25.879 --> 42:27.766
L-Let me just explain that.
42:30.427 --> 42:32.361
You're afraid of me?
42:33.172 --> 42:35.219
I think that you should leave.
42:39.023 --> 42:40.791
Okay.
42:42.928 --> 42:44.636
Okay, I'll go.
43:00.864 --> 43:03.290
I love you, sis.
43:06.543 --> 43:08.126
I love you, too.
43:12.004 --> 43:16.004
Synced & corrected by PopcornAWH
www.addic7ed.com
43:17.305 --> 43:23.297
Support us and become VIP member
to remove all ads from www.OpenSubtitles.org
51041
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.