All language subtitles for The.End.of.Meat.2017.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP2.0.H.264-NTG

af Afrikaans
ak Akan
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bem Bemba
bn Bengali
bh Bihari
bs Bosnian
br Breton
bg Bulgarian
km Cambodian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
chr Cherokee
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch
en English Download
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
ee Ewe
fo Faroese
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French Download
fy Frisian
gaa Ga
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German Download
el Greek
gn Guarani
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ia Interlingua
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
rw Kinyarwanda
rn Kirundi
kg Kongo
ko Korean
kri Krio (Sierra Leone)
ku Kurdish
ckb Kurdish (Soranî)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Laothian
la Latin
lv Latvian
ln Lingala
lt Lithuanian
loz Lozi
lg Luganda
ach Luo
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mfe Mauritian Creole
mo Moldavian
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
sr-ME Montenegrin
ne Nepali
pcm Nigerian Pidgin
nso Northern Sotho
no Norwegian
nn Norwegian (Nynorsk)
oc Occitan
or Oriya
om Oromo
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt-BR Portuguese (Brazil)
pt Portuguese (Portugal) Download
pa Punjabi
qu Quechua
ro Romanian
rm Romansh
nyn Runyakitara
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
sh Serbo-Croatian
st Sesotho
tn Setswana
crs Seychellois Creole
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhalese
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish Download
es-419 Spanish (Latin American)
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
tt Tatar
te Telugu
th Thai
ti Tigrinya
to Tonga
lua Tshiluba
tum Tumbuka
tr Turkish
tk Turkmen
tw Twi
ug Uighur
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
wo Wolof
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu
Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated: 1 00:00:11,791 --> 00:00:13,333 ♪♪ 2 00:00:13,375 --> 00:00:15,750 [announcer] There's beef. 3 00:00:15,791 --> 00:00:18,208 There's pork and ham. 4 00:00:18,250 --> 00:00:20,625 There's lamb. 5 00:00:20,666 --> 00:00:24,500 Meat and eggs help the body grow and make it strong. 6 00:00:24,541 --> 00:00:26,750 [audio slows, stops] Meat is good for you... 7 00:00:28,791 --> 00:00:33,083 [man] It was just like... meat, meat, meat, meat and meat and more meat. 8 00:00:33,125 --> 00:00:34,750 And man, they like meat! 9 00:00:34,791 --> 00:00:37,250 [man 2] It was like nonstop. 10 00:00:37,291 --> 00:00:39,250 E. coli, salmonella, people getting sick, 11 00:00:39,291 --> 00:00:40,958 and I'm sure some people died from it. 12 00:00:41,000 --> 00:00:43,875 [newswoman] Eating processed meat can cause cancer. 13 00:00:43,916 --> 00:00:47,916 [man over phone] We can assure consumers that our beef is safe. 14 00:00:47,958 --> 00:00:50,875 [newswoman] Rats, foxes, even minks 15 00:00:50,916 --> 00:00:53,375 are being fraudulently sold as beef or mutton. 16 00:00:53,416 --> 00:00:55,375 [newsman] Meat consumption is rising 17 00:00:55,416 --> 00:00:57,583 in many countries despite warnings. 18 00:00:57,625 --> 00:01:00,750 [man] This is the big elephant in the room that nobody's talking about. 19 00:01:00,791 --> 00:01:03,000 [man 2] It's very tasty. 20 00:01:03,041 --> 00:01:06,708 [newswoman] Livestock contributes more to climate change than cars. 21 00:01:06,750 --> 00:01:11,500 [newsman] 1.8 million hectares of the Amazon are cut down each year, 22 00:01:11,541 --> 00:01:15,583 75% attributed to the expansion of cattle ranches. 23 00:01:15,625 --> 00:01:18,583 [newsman] Perhaps one of the most shocking things about factory farms 24 00:01:18,625 --> 00:01:21,041 is that there's almost no one watching them. 25 00:01:21,083 --> 00:01:24,666 [woman] Is this a sort of a cultural war right now? 26 00:01:24,708 --> 00:01:26,708 ♪ 27 00:01:28,875 --> 00:01:30,166 [male narrator] Meat. 28 00:01:30,208 --> 00:01:32,583 For most of us, it was and is 29 00:01:32,625 --> 00:01:35,125 an integral part of the diet. 30 00:01:35,166 --> 00:01:38,708 But recently, meat has lost its mythical status. 31 00:01:38,750 --> 00:01:41,333 Once a symbol of prosperity and power, 32 00:01:41,375 --> 00:01:44,083 meat consumption has become problematic, 33 00:01:44,125 --> 00:01:46,333 for the planet and for ourselves. 34 00:01:46,375 --> 00:01:50,208 Eating a steak or a burger is no longer a luxury, 35 00:01:50,250 --> 00:01:52,291 and we've gotten more and more disconnected 36 00:01:52,333 --> 00:01:54,833 from where our meat actually comes from. 37 00:01:54,875 --> 00:01:58,750 Meat-free diets are a growing trend in Western countries. 38 00:01:58,791 --> 00:02:00,958 Although this is not a new idea, 39 00:02:01,000 --> 00:02:05,166 plant-based diets are becoming increasingly popular in Germany. 40 00:02:05,208 --> 00:02:08,458 This made me wonder what the world would look like 41 00:02:08,500 --> 00:02:12,000 were we no longer eating animals. 42 00:02:12,041 --> 00:02:15,125 And so I set out to connect with the pioneers 43 00:02:15,166 --> 00:02:16,625 of the vegan revolution in Germany, 44 00:02:16,666 --> 00:02:18,208 met with researchers 45 00:02:18,250 --> 00:02:21,416 examining the effects of a plant-based diet, 46 00:02:21,458 --> 00:02:24,708 traveled to the first vegetarian city in the world, 47 00:02:24,750 --> 00:02:28,041 learned about the lives of rescued farm animals, 48 00:02:28,083 --> 00:02:30,250 spoke with philosophers and lawyers 49 00:02:30,291 --> 00:02:32,708 working to have animals' interests considered, 50 00:02:32,750 --> 00:02:34,375 and talked to scientists 51 00:02:34,416 --> 00:02:37,291 developing meat-free future foods. 52 00:02:37,333 --> 00:02:40,750 But first, I wanted to learn more about the origins of meat 53 00:02:40,791 --> 00:02:43,291 and our treatment of farmed animals. 54 00:02:54,791 --> 00:02:56,833 [man] Well, first of all, I was raised being taught 55 00:02:56,875 --> 00:02:59,083 that the domestication of other animals 56 00:02:59,125 --> 00:03:03,208 was a great thing for humanity and a great thing for animals. 57 00:03:03,250 --> 00:03:08,250 But then over time, I came to learn that actually it was a lie, 58 00:03:08,291 --> 00:03:11,208 that other animals were captured, they were enslaved, 59 00:03:11,250 --> 00:03:13,250 they were biologically manipulated. 60 00:03:13,291 --> 00:03:16,083 I thought they were desecrated. 61 00:03:16,125 --> 00:03:20,583 In my work, I refer to that practice as "domesecration." 62 00:03:20,625 --> 00:03:23,916 Once the domesecration of other animals started, 63 00:03:23,958 --> 00:03:28,500 men got on their backs and they began to go long distances, 64 00:03:28,541 --> 00:03:32,041 they began to use other horses as instruments of warfare and violence, 65 00:03:32,083 --> 00:03:34,291 raiding more sedentary peoples 66 00:03:34,333 --> 00:03:37,041 and killing people, enslaving them. 67 00:03:37,083 --> 00:03:41,250 So, for example, when the Europeans 68 00:03:41,291 --> 00:03:44,791 invaded the Americas, they could only conduct that invasion 69 00:03:44,833 --> 00:03:47,916 through the use of horses as instruments of war 70 00:03:47,958 --> 00:03:52,250 and cows and pigs and sheep as laborers and as rations, 71 00:03:52,291 --> 00:03:55,875 and they needed land to grow more animals, 72 00:03:55,916 --> 00:03:58,208 to facilitate further invasion. 73 00:03:58,250 --> 00:04:00,458 So the oppression of the other animals 74 00:04:00,500 --> 00:04:03,416 was deeply entangled with the fates 75 00:04:03,458 --> 00:04:05,625 of the indigenous peoples, 76 00:04:05,666 --> 00:04:08,750 as the more land that they needed for ranching, 77 00:04:08,791 --> 00:04:12,041 the more people were killed, their land was taken. 78 00:04:12,083 --> 00:04:15,833 Once they cleared that land, then they developed railroads 79 00:04:15,875 --> 00:04:19,291 and began to transport these animals back to cities 80 00:04:19,333 --> 00:04:21,416 like Chicago and Cincinnati. 81 00:04:21,458 --> 00:04:23,833 Large slaughterhouses begin to develop, 82 00:04:23,875 --> 00:04:26,375 then marketing firms begin to develop, 83 00:04:26,416 --> 00:04:28,916 and feed firms begin to develop, 84 00:04:28,958 --> 00:04:31,791 and banks began to get their share of this, 85 00:04:31,833 --> 00:04:35,208 and retail organizations begin growing 86 00:04:35,250 --> 00:04:37,541 and then fast-food organizations crop up. 87 00:04:37,583 --> 00:04:39,083 Then we see the formation 88 00:04:39,125 --> 00:04:42,458 of this animal industrial complex. 89 00:04:42,500 --> 00:04:45,708 There's a great political power, ideological power, 90 00:04:45,750 --> 00:04:47,666 and economic power, 91 00:04:47,708 --> 00:04:51,291 and they continue to drive 92 00:04:51,333 --> 00:04:53,666 increased consumption, 93 00:04:53,708 --> 00:04:57,125 all to garner profits for those in the industry. 94 00:04:57,166 --> 00:04:59,791 So... 95 00:04:59,833 --> 00:05:03,208 domesecration has been horrific for the world and other animals, 96 00:05:03,250 --> 00:05:08,083 and it's time that we begin to stop that and change the course of world history. 97 00:05:08,125 --> 00:05:10,750 [narrator] This is me at nine years old 98 00:05:10,791 --> 00:05:13,541 meeting a cow for the first time. 99 00:05:13,583 --> 00:05:16,375 And this is me about to eat a cow. 100 00:05:16,416 --> 00:05:20,083 Back then, I had no idea where the meat on my plate came from, 101 00:05:20,125 --> 00:05:22,833 and I wonder now why it took me so long 102 00:05:22,875 --> 00:05:27,166 to start questioning what, or rather whom, I was eating. 103 00:05:27,208 --> 00:05:32,333 [pigs snorting, squealing] 104 00:05:34,625 --> 00:05:37,125 [woman] That's just the worst part of my job. 105 00:05:37,166 --> 00:05:39,666 I got to come and go. 106 00:05:39,708 --> 00:05:44,000 I got to go in and photograph and witness and experience 107 00:05:44,041 --> 00:05:47,708 the horror and the pain, but I got to leave. 108 00:05:47,750 --> 00:05:49,708 And they don't get to leave. 109 00:05:49,750 --> 00:05:52,208 I can complain about, you know, 110 00:05:52,250 --> 00:05:55,416 the smell on my clothes and the camera months later, 111 00:05:55,458 --> 00:05:59,958 but, like, they're in it all the time, that's their life. 112 00:06:00,000 --> 00:06:03,125 That is the only thing that they experience in life, this. 113 00:06:03,166 --> 00:06:06,208 This is where they live and this is where they will die, 114 00:06:06,250 --> 00:06:09,750 except for when they get put on a transport and go to slaughter. 115 00:06:09,791 --> 00:06:11,916 Unbelievable. 116 00:06:14,916 --> 00:06:18,333 But these things happen behind walls 117 00:06:18,375 --> 00:06:20,583 in these dark, horrible, stinky places, 118 00:06:20,625 --> 00:06:22,875 where no one's allowed to enter, 119 00:06:22,916 --> 00:06:26,166 where we get put in jail, we get arrested, 120 00:06:26,208 --> 00:06:28,958 we get charged if we enter these places. 121 00:06:29,000 --> 00:06:31,000 There's a reason for that. 122 00:06:31,041 --> 00:06:33,125 It's to protect the business 123 00:06:33,166 --> 00:06:37,375 because the business would fail if we knew. 124 00:06:39,041 --> 00:06:42,541 My way of effecting change, as well, is storytelling. 125 00:06:42,583 --> 00:06:45,291 People remember emotions and stories 126 00:06:45,333 --> 00:06:48,250 more often than they remember statistics, 127 00:06:48,291 --> 00:06:52,000 and so I tell stories about the individuals I've met around the world. 128 00:06:52,041 --> 00:06:54,500 Bears rescued from bear bile farms, 129 00:06:54,541 --> 00:06:56,750 pigs rescued from factory farms. 130 00:06:56,791 --> 00:07:01,250 Show the photos of Julia the pig, Sonny the calf, 131 00:07:01,291 --> 00:07:03,916 and Miracle the bear. 132 00:07:03,958 --> 00:07:06,916 You could hear a pin drop when I'm doing these talks, 133 00:07:06,958 --> 00:07:09,000 and they're leaning forward in their chairs 134 00:07:09,041 --> 00:07:12,458 and they're engaged and it's because it's storytelling. 135 00:07:12,500 --> 00:07:14,875 And then they go off and they share these stories. 136 00:07:14,916 --> 00:07:18,666 Um, so things are getting worse in some places, 137 00:07:18,708 --> 00:07:21,375 but they're getting better in a lot of places as well. 138 00:07:21,416 --> 00:07:23,875 We're seeing meat-eating growing in certain countries, 139 00:07:23,916 --> 00:07:26,000 but we're seeing it decline in other countries. 140 00:07:26,041 --> 00:07:30,791 We're seeing laws changing, very much so in Europe. 141 00:07:30,833 --> 00:07:35,458 Better welfare laws and all sorts of "improvements," 142 00:07:35,500 --> 00:07:37,916 but then enforcement is a problem. 143 00:07:37,958 --> 00:07:41,250 I've been to plenty of farms where the laws have changed 144 00:07:41,291 --> 00:07:43,166 two, three years ago, 145 00:07:43,208 --> 00:07:45,333 and the farmers haven't implemented anything 146 00:07:45,375 --> 00:07:49,333 because the fine is less expensive 147 00:07:49,375 --> 00:07:52,791 than having to reformat their entire farm. 148 00:07:57,750 --> 00:08:01,708 [man] So I went undercover in an industrialized slaughterhouse 149 00:08:01,750 --> 00:08:03,708 because I was interested in understanding 150 00:08:03,750 --> 00:08:06,583 how massive processes of violence work 151 00:08:06,625 --> 00:08:09,375 in what we call modern civilized society. 152 00:08:14,208 --> 00:08:16,083 Slaughterhouses, for the most part, 153 00:08:16,125 --> 00:08:19,333 are located far out of urban areas. 154 00:08:19,375 --> 00:08:22,916 They're located in rural areas where the vast majority of urban consumers 155 00:08:22,958 --> 00:08:26,625 will never have to confront what takes place inside of them. 156 00:08:26,666 --> 00:08:28,875 They're also hidden socially. 157 00:08:28,916 --> 00:08:31,916 We delegate the work of killing to a group of people 158 00:08:31,958 --> 00:08:34,166 who have very little rights. 159 00:08:34,208 --> 00:08:37,500 We also hide them linguistically, right? 160 00:08:37,541 --> 00:08:41,125 Steers become steaks and heifers become hamburgers. 161 00:08:41,166 --> 00:08:43,458 We hide places of violence. 162 00:08:43,500 --> 00:08:47,250 We hide places of ugliness, so that we can continue to live 163 00:08:47,291 --> 00:08:50,208 as if they didn't exist, while still relying 164 00:08:50,250 --> 00:08:52,416 on their products in our everyday lives. 165 00:08:55,083 --> 00:08:57,791 Two months into my fieldwork, 166 00:08:57,833 --> 00:09:00,250 six cattle escaped from a slaughterhouse 167 00:09:00,291 --> 00:09:02,458 up the street from the one that I was working in. 168 00:09:02,500 --> 00:09:05,125 Three of them made an immediate run 169 00:09:05,166 --> 00:09:08,333 for the parking lot of Saint Francis of Assisi Catholic Church. 170 00:09:08,375 --> 00:09:11,500 These cows were captured and taken back to the slaughterhouse, 171 00:09:11,541 --> 00:09:15,541 but one of the cows made a run down the main boulevard in Omaha 172 00:09:15,583 --> 00:09:18,125 and then took a turn into an alleyway. 173 00:09:18,166 --> 00:09:21,083 The escape took place during the afternoon break 174 00:09:21,125 --> 00:09:24,000 for the slaughterhouse that I was working in, 175 00:09:24,041 --> 00:09:26,500 and me and some of the other slaughterhouse workers 176 00:09:26,541 --> 00:09:29,166 watched as the Omaha Police Department 177 00:09:29,208 --> 00:09:31,750 pursued this cow into an alleyway 178 00:09:31,791 --> 00:09:36,000 that ended in a chain-link fence bordering our slaughterhouse. 179 00:09:36,041 --> 00:09:39,333 And when the police failed to herd her into a trailer, 180 00:09:39,375 --> 00:09:42,416 they opened fire on her with shotguns and killed her. 181 00:09:43,625 --> 00:09:47,416 And the next day, the newspaper in Omaha 182 00:09:47,458 --> 00:09:50,583 featured this escape and killing on its front page, 183 00:09:50,625 --> 00:09:54,916 under the headline "Freedom is fleeting for cattle in plant escape." 184 00:09:54,958 --> 00:09:57,333 And in the lunchroom at the slaughterhouse, 185 00:09:57,375 --> 00:10:00,833 the workers expressed a sense of disgust and outrage 186 00:10:00,875 --> 00:10:03,375 at the killing of this one animal. 187 00:10:03,416 --> 00:10:05,833 "They shot her just like they shot an unarmed man 188 00:10:05,875 --> 00:10:08,125 from Mexico last year," 189 00:10:08,166 --> 00:10:10,916 Julio, one of the quality control workers said. 190 00:10:10,958 --> 00:10:14,125 And then the lunch period ended, 191 00:10:14,166 --> 00:10:17,041 and we all went back to our places on the kill floor 192 00:10:17,083 --> 00:10:21,958 where we proceeded to kill another 1,250 animals 193 00:10:22,000 --> 00:10:24,166 for the remainder of the day. 194 00:10:26,291 --> 00:10:30,958 [narrator] Social media has radically changed the distribution of information. 195 00:10:31,000 --> 00:10:34,541 Images and videos highlighting the plight of farm animals 196 00:10:34,583 --> 00:10:36,916 are now reaching a global audience 197 00:10:36,958 --> 00:10:40,458 that is increasingly seeking transparency and knowledge 198 00:10:40,500 --> 00:10:43,666 surrounding the sourcing of their food. 199 00:10:43,708 --> 00:10:48,833 A video by Toronto Pig Save activist Anita Krajnc made headlines worldwide 200 00:10:48,875 --> 00:10:52,041 when she was charged for giving water to thirsty pigs 201 00:10:52,083 --> 00:10:55,833 on a hot day outside a Toronto slaughterhouse. 202 00:10:58,166 --> 00:11:02,750 Toronto Pig Save and the sister groups are about bearing witness. 203 00:11:02,791 --> 00:11:07,125 And that is the idea that when there is injustice in your community, 204 00:11:07,166 --> 00:11:10,083 you need to be present and be there and try to help. 205 00:11:10,125 --> 00:11:14,166 And so, for animals, the darkest place is a slaughterhouse. 206 00:11:14,208 --> 00:11:18,375 So Toronto Pig Save holds vigils outside slaughterhouses. 207 00:11:18,416 --> 00:11:20,458 [woman] Here comes the truck! 208 00:11:22,375 --> 00:11:24,500 [woman] I know, babies! 209 00:11:24,541 --> 00:11:26,375 I love you. 210 00:11:28,666 --> 00:11:31,458 ♪ 211 00:11:34,541 --> 00:11:37,000 -[truck hydraulics hiss] -[pig squeals] 212 00:11:37,041 --> 00:11:40,833 [pigs snorting] 213 00:12:02,208 --> 00:12:05,916 [pigs snorting and squealing] 214 00:12:12,291 --> 00:12:14,291 ♪ 215 00:12:26,291 --> 00:12:29,791 [Anita] I think a lot of people felt hopeless before, saying, 216 00:12:29,833 --> 00:12:33,083 "Oh, it's never going to change. People are not going to stop eating meat." 217 00:12:33,125 --> 00:12:36,500 And then they see these people doing vigils saying, "This is wrong, stop this." 218 00:12:36,541 --> 00:12:39,750 They find that very empowering and encouraging. 219 00:12:39,791 --> 00:12:44,208 I think if more and more people bear witness firsthand, 220 00:12:44,250 --> 00:12:47,666 it will change them, and they would not participate 221 00:12:47,708 --> 00:12:51,250 in violence against these animals if they saw the animals firsthand. 222 00:12:51,291 --> 00:12:53,291 I have no doubt about it. 223 00:12:53,333 --> 00:12:55,583 [clattering] 224 00:12:55,625 --> 00:12:58,541 [narrator] While in Toronto, I came across someone else 225 00:12:58,583 --> 00:13:00,583 who was changing hearts and minds 226 00:13:00,625 --> 00:13:03,250 and had a huge following on social media. 227 00:13:03,291 --> 00:13:06,250 Her name is Esther the Wonder Pig. 228 00:13:06,291 --> 00:13:07,708 One for you. 229 00:13:09,250 --> 00:13:12,000 [man] The story behind Esther is interesting. 230 00:13:12,041 --> 00:13:16,250 She was a very unplanned and last-minute addition to our family. 231 00:13:19,708 --> 00:13:22,125 We were duped, you know. 232 00:13:22,166 --> 00:13:25,333 We were under the impression that she was a mini pig. 233 00:13:25,375 --> 00:13:30,291 And, you know, man, there's nothing mini about her. 234 00:13:30,333 --> 00:13:33,250 [man 2] We'd fallen in love in a pretty crazy way. 235 00:13:33,291 --> 00:13:35,708 The thought of getting rid of her was terrifying. 236 00:13:35,750 --> 00:13:38,333 It was really, really upsetting. 237 00:13:38,375 --> 00:13:41,041 I mean, we both knew in the back of our minds 238 00:13:41,083 --> 00:13:44,208 that we were gonna be on one hell of a bumpy road. 239 00:13:44,250 --> 00:13:47,125 We didn't know it was gonna be a 500-pound road. 240 00:13:47,166 --> 00:13:50,500 Yeah, I mean, but we love all of her. 241 00:13:50,541 --> 00:13:53,333 You know, she can put on 500 more pounds 242 00:13:53,375 --> 00:13:56,666 and she's still welcome to do as she please. 243 00:13:56,708 --> 00:13:58,583 You know, she's part of the family, 244 00:13:58,625 --> 00:14:01,000 and it's not her fault she got that big. 245 00:14:04,666 --> 00:14:07,083 We created the Facebook page 246 00:14:07,125 --> 00:14:09,625 and it was just fun-loving photos of Esther, 247 00:14:09,666 --> 00:14:12,166 and then we threw it out to our family and friends, 248 00:14:12,208 --> 00:14:14,333 and within a day there was a hundred likes, 249 00:14:14,375 --> 00:14:16,625 and we were just like, whoa, like a hundred. 250 00:14:16,666 --> 00:14:19,708 The next day it was 300 and the next day it was 500, 251 00:14:19,750 --> 00:14:24,583 1,000, 2,000, 8,000, it just started going like clockwork. 252 00:14:24,625 --> 00:14:28,750 And it was at 8,000... 8,000 likes. 253 00:14:28,791 --> 00:14:33,041 We woke up and our phones were maxed out. 254 00:14:33,083 --> 00:14:38,875 Somebody in Hong Kong had sent us a text. 255 00:14:38,916 --> 00:14:43,791 She said, "You guys are in Hong Kong's biggest newspaper." 256 00:14:43,833 --> 00:14:47,125 It was that moment that I was like, 257 00:14:47,166 --> 00:14:50,583 "Wow, like, what is going on?" 258 00:14:50,625 --> 00:14:54,000 ♪ 259 00:14:54,041 --> 00:14:56,041 [keyboard clacking] 260 00:15:23,375 --> 00:15:25,625 You have this lightbulb moment. 261 00:15:25,666 --> 00:15:28,458 We had a lightbulb moment when we were cooking bacon on the stove, 262 00:15:28,500 --> 00:15:32,500 and Esther's five pounds at our feet, 263 00:15:32,541 --> 00:15:34,500 waiting for something to fall off the stove, 264 00:15:34,541 --> 00:15:37,083 and I was like, "Oh, my gosh," it just happened. 265 00:15:37,125 --> 00:15:38,958 -It was like this bulb. -Can't do this. 266 00:15:39,000 --> 00:15:41,875 Like, it just, it was a crazy moment, 267 00:15:41,916 --> 00:15:44,333 and, um... 268 00:15:44,375 --> 00:15:46,958 we never ate meat after that point. 269 00:15:48,416 --> 00:15:50,708 [Steve] It's all her. It's all her. 270 00:15:50,750 --> 00:15:55,333 She's got this amazing ability to get into your head. 271 00:15:55,375 --> 00:15:58,666 That's what's happening all over, 272 00:15:58,708 --> 00:16:00,666 you know, all around us, globally. 273 00:16:00,708 --> 00:16:02,416 It's all over the world. 274 00:16:02,458 --> 00:16:04,583 We hear from people all over the world. 275 00:16:08,833 --> 00:16:11,916 Yeah, one of the most amazing signs of her intelligence 276 00:16:11,958 --> 00:16:14,375 was, usually, she'd go into the kitchen 277 00:16:14,416 --> 00:16:17,000 and she would open a door, try to pull food out, 278 00:16:17,041 --> 00:16:20,625 and just cause chaos, so she got in trouble every time, obviously. 279 00:16:20,666 --> 00:16:23,458 And a few weeks in, you'd walk into the kitchen, 280 00:16:23,500 --> 00:16:25,875 you'd find a cupboard door open and nothing wrong. 281 00:16:25,916 --> 00:16:28,208 What the hell is that? And you'd find a basket out on the floor, 282 00:16:28,250 --> 00:16:30,333 and, what is going on, you know? 283 00:16:30,375 --> 00:16:33,708 And we finally figured out one day that it was her going in. 284 00:16:33,750 --> 00:16:35,708 She'd open the cupboard and then she'd leave the room 285 00:16:35,750 --> 00:16:37,583 and leave it alone for a minute, 286 00:16:37,625 --> 00:16:39,583 and then she'd go back again a second later 287 00:16:39,625 --> 00:16:41,375 and she'd pull out whatever food she wanted, 288 00:16:41,416 --> 00:16:44,166 but she'd leave it on the floor, and then she'd leave again. 289 00:16:44,208 --> 00:16:46,750 Then the third time in, she would go into the kitchen, 290 00:16:46,791 --> 00:16:49,125 grab the food and then run out of the kitchen, 291 00:16:49,166 --> 00:16:52,666 down the hallway to the bedroom with whatever it was she stole. 292 00:16:52,708 --> 00:16:56,166 Uh, and, I mean, in our minds it was her 293 00:16:56,208 --> 00:17:00,125 breaking it down into individual steps and an individual process, 294 00:17:00,166 --> 00:17:02,500 increasing her chances of success, right? 295 00:17:02,541 --> 00:17:05,500 She was quiet. She'd come back in and-- 296 00:17:05,541 --> 00:17:09,291 [Derek] Check us out. Just to like, "Oh, it's normal, everything's fine." 297 00:17:09,333 --> 00:17:11,166 Give you a false sense of security, 298 00:17:11,208 --> 00:17:16,208 and then go back in and just chaos ensues. 299 00:17:18,166 --> 00:17:20,166 [keyboard clacking] 300 00:17:23,458 --> 00:17:26,791 As hard as it was, it's been the most rewarding 301 00:17:26,833 --> 00:17:29,250 and, you know, amazing experience 302 00:17:29,291 --> 00:17:31,875 I think we've ever had and probably ever will have. 303 00:17:31,916 --> 00:17:34,375 Who gets to live with a pig like that 304 00:17:34,416 --> 00:17:36,291 and have those experiences? 305 00:17:36,333 --> 00:17:38,958 I mean, it was incredible, it was incredible. 306 00:17:39,000 --> 00:17:42,708 [sizzling] 307 00:17:42,750 --> 00:17:45,833 [woman] Over human history, meat became 308 00:17:45,875 --> 00:17:48,916 this food for sharing and for celebrations. 309 00:17:48,958 --> 00:17:53,166 This is why during festivities, usually in most cultures, 310 00:17:53,208 --> 00:17:55,875 you have meat at the center, as a centerpiece. 311 00:17:55,916 --> 00:17:58,916 You have the Thanksgiving turkey for example, in the United States. 312 00:17:58,958 --> 00:18:01,250 Meat was always important in that way. 313 00:18:01,291 --> 00:18:03,875 It became so ingrained in our traditions 314 00:18:03,916 --> 00:18:06,666 in this kind of feeling of commonality, 315 00:18:06,708 --> 00:18:11,041 of sharing with other people, that it's hard to let it go as well for that reason, 316 00:18:11,083 --> 00:18:14,083 because if you say no to the Thanksgiving turkey, 317 00:18:14,125 --> 00:18:18,333 it's also saying, in a way, no to your traditions, to your family, to your friends. 318 00:18:20,125 --> 00:18:22,833 Definitely cultures change slowly. 319 00:18:22,875 --> 00:18:26,625 You see the meat industry is putting a lot of marketing 320 00:18:26,666 --> 00:18:32,208 and advertising and so on to keep up all this kind of symbolism 321 00:18:32,250 --> 00:18:36,083 that meat has, it lives on, especially, for example, for masculinity. 322 00:18:38,208 --> 00:18:40,208 [narrator] The land of bratwurst and schnitzel 323 00:18:40,250 --> 00:18:43,125 is renowned for its heavy reliance on meat. 324 00:18:43,166 --> 00:18:45,958 Germans eat an estimated 60 kilograms, 325 00:18:46,000 --> 00:18:50,750 or roughly 132 pounds, of meat each, every year. 326 00:18:50,791 --> 00:18:53,333 But scandals such as mad cow disease 327 00:18:53,375 --> 00:18:55,375 and wrongfully labeled horse meat 328 00:18:55,416 --> 00:18:58,666 have led to a loss of confidence in the industry. 329 00:18:58,708 --> 00:19:01,291 Climate change, as well as the recurring images 330 00:19:01,333 --> 00:19:03,625 of animal mistreatment in factory farms 331 00:19:03,666 --> 00:19:07,208 led to a public debate about the animals on our plate, 332 00:19:07,250 --> 00:19:10,708 and suddenly plant-based diets were a newly found interest. 333 00:19:10,750 --> 00:19:13,166 Presented to a health-conscious audience, 334 00:19:13,208 --> 00:19:16,750 vegan cookbooks that promised weight loss and wellness benefits 335 00:19:16,791 --> 00:19:18,958 were popping up on best-seller lists, 336 00:19:19,000 --> 00:19:22,500 attracting attention from mainstream media and beyond. 337 00:19:22,541 --> 00:19:25,083 Plants are no longer a side dish 338 00:19:25,125 --> 00:19:28,208 but the creative and healthy main course. 339 00:19:28,250 --> 00:19:32,083 Numerous vegan restaurants have cropped up all over the country 340 00:19:32,125 --> 00:19:35,125 and many more have added vegan options. 341 00:19:35,166 --> 00:19:37,625 Supermarkets are stocking vegan products 342 00:19:37,666 --> 00:19:39,416 and the number of vegan cookbooks 343 00:19:39,458 --> 00:19:41,208 has grown exponentially, 344 00:19:41,250 --> 00:19:44,041 from only 23 in 2012 345 00:19:44,083 --> 00:19:47,333 to 220 in 2016. 346 00:19:47,375 --> 00:19:49,583 With the highest number of vegan restaurants 347 00:19:49,625 --> 00:19:54,291 and spearheaded by the world's first 100% vegan supermarket chain, 348 00:19:54,333 --> 00:19:57,958 Berlin has become the vegan capital of Europe. 349 00:20:03,791 --> 00:20:05,750 [wrappers crackling] 350 00:20:05,791 --> 00:20:07,083 Mmm! 351 00:21:31,666 --> 00:21:34,541 [narrator] I wondered how the vegan explosion in Germany 352 00:21:34,583 --> 00:21:39,250 had impacted the largest producer of tofu and meat alternatives in Europe: 353 00:21:39,291 --> 00:21:42,500 Tofutown, formerly called Viana. 354 00:25:49,208 --> 00:25:52,583 [narrator] "The sausage is the cigarette of the future." 355 00:25:52,625 --> 00:25:55,875 This quote by the CEO of Rugenwalder Muhle, 356 00:25:55,916 --> 00:25:58,166 a traditional sausage producer in Germany, 357 00:25:58,208 --> 00:26:00,750 caused a stir in the world of meat. 358 00:26:00,791 --> 00:26:05,666 At the IFFA, the number one international trade fair for the meat industry, 359 00:26:05,708 --> 00:26:10,750 I was hoping to find out if this was indeed where this sector was heading. 360 00:29:25,708 --> 00:29:27,500 [narrator] We live during a time 361 00:29:27,541 --> 00:29:31,125 where our impact on the planet has become so destructive 362 00:29:31,166 --> 00:29:33,708 that, akin to other natural forces, 363 00:29:33,750 --> 00:29:38,333 humanity has become a global geophysical force in itself. 364 00:29:38,375 --> 00:29:42,291 Scientists call this period the Anthropocene, 365 00:29:42,333 --> 00:29:45,125 the age of humans. 366 00:29:45,166 --> 00:29:47,416 During our relatively short time on Earth, 367 00:29:47,458 --> 00:29:50,583 we have made a mark on our climate, our land, 368 00:29:50,625 --> 00:29:53,208 our air and our oceans. 369 00:29:53,250 --> 00:29:56,083 It's a mark we continue making every day 370 00:29:56,125 --> 00:29:58,958 and which will be felt for generations to come. 371 00:29:59,000 --> 00:30:01,916 Each year we breed, raise and kill 372 00:30:01,958 --> 00:30:05,083 56 billion farmed animals. 373 00:30:05,125 --> 00:30:07,125 This system is responsible 374 00:30:07,166 --> 00:30:10,083 for 18% of greenhouse gas emissions, 375 00:30:10,125 --> 00:30:12,708 uses a third of all fresh water, 376 00:30:12,750 --> 00:30:16,625 occupies 45% of the Earth's total land, 377 00:30:16,666 --> 00:30:20,250 has destroyed 70% of the Amazon rain forest, 378 00:30:20,291 --> 00:30:23,750 and has become the greatest threat to biodiversity. 379 00:30:23,791 --> 00:30:28,083 And while 11% of the world's population suffers from malnutrition, 380 00:30:28,125 --> 00:30:30,541 we feed half of the world's grain 381 00:30:30,583 --> 00:30:33,750 to animals slated for slaughter. 382 00:30:33,791 --> 00:30:38,166 So what would happen if meat disappeared from the planet? 383 00:30:38,208 --> 00:30:42,625 How could the end of meat affect the planet, the animals, 384 00:30:42,666 --> 00:30:44,625 and our own lives? 385 00:30:44,666 --> 00:30:46,958 The global population is projected 386 00:30:47,000 --> 00:30:50,333 to grow to nearly 10 billion people by 2050. 387 00:30:50,375 --> 00:30:53,375 As nations urbanize and citizens become wealthier, 388 00:30:53,416 --> 00:30:56,250 they consume more resource-intensive foods, 389 00:30:56,291 --> 00:30:57,958 such as meat and dairy, 390 00:30:58,000 --> 00:31:00,750 intensifying the already enormous burden 391 00:31:00,791 --> 00:31:04,583 on our ecosystems, the animals, our health, 392 00:31:04,625 --> 00:31:07,208 and perhaps especially the climate. 393 00:31:07,250 --> 00:31:08,958 The most common indicator 394 00:31:09,000 --> 00:31:11,625 for humans' massive impact on the environment 395 00:31:11,666 --> 00:31:15,625 is the increase in greenhouse gas emissions. 396 00:31:15,666 --> 00:31:19,041 In London, I wanted to learn more about the relationship 397 00:31:19,083 --> 00:31:21,666 between meat and our climate. 398 00:31:21,708 --> 00:31:24,833 [woman] Here at Chatham House we've been working on meat consumption 399 00:31:24,875 --> 00:31:27,833 and climate change and the interaction between the two 400 00:31:27,875 --> 00:31:29,750 for about two years now. 401 00:31:29,791 --> 00:31:32,166 We recognize that the livestock sector 402 00:31:32,208 --> 00:31:35,625 is a major driver of climate change but one that's often overlooked. 403 00:31:35,666 --> 00:31:38,833 So we wanted to try and explore why that's the case 404 00:31:38,875 --> 00:31:41,708 and what could be done to try and address this awareness gap 405 00:31:41,750 --> 00:31:43,916 in what we're calling the cycle of inertia, 406 00:31:43,958 --> 00:31:48,500 by which governments aren't taking action on a really critical issue. 407 00:31:48,541 --> 00:31:51,375 We found in our survey of 12 countries 408 00:31:51,416 --> 00:31:54,958 that 83% of participants, respondents, 409 00:31:55,000 --> 00:31:58,875 recognize that human activity is a major driver of climate change, 410 00:31:58,916 --> 00:32:04,083 but only 30% recognize the livestock sector as a key driver. 411 00:32:04,125 --> 00:32:06,375 That's really striking because we know 412 00:32:06,416 --> 00:32:10,416 that the livestock sector contributes 15% of greenhouse gas emissions, 413 00:32:10,458 --> 00:32:14,125 which is roughly equivalent to every vehicle on the planet, 414 00:32:14,166 --> 00:32:15,791 so we're talking about a major source here 415 00:32:15,833 --> 00:32:18,333 of which people aren't aware. 416 00:32:18,375 --> 00:32:21,625 We don't learn about the climate impact of food production at schools, 417 00:32:21,666 --> 00:32:24,875 we don't see it on a day-to-day basis in the mainstream media. 418 00:32:26,666 --> 00:32:30,250 Without tackling global overconsumption of meat, 419 00:32:30,291 --> 00:32:34,000 we will inevitably see dangerous levels of climate change, 420 00:32:34,041 --> 00:32:37,375 that we'll face more frequent supply shocks, 421 00:32:37,416 --> 00:32:39,583 so a situation in which crops fail 422 00:32:39,625 --> 00:32:43,000 and we have less food supply than we might otherwise expect. 423 00:32:44,500 --> 00:32:46,583 [narrator] In early 2016, 424 00:32:46,625 --> 00:32:49,500 a team of researchers from the University of Oxford 425 00:32:49,541 --> 00:32:54,208 released a study about the climate and health benefits of various diets. 426 00:32:54,250 --> 00:32:56,500 The worldwide media response was enormous. 427 00:32:56,541 --> 00:33:01,708 This was the first global study that estimated what would happen 428 00:33:01,750 --> 00:33:05,708 if we stopped eating meat and animal products altogether. 429 00:33:07,000 --> 00:33:09,125 [man] Previous studies have mostly looked 430 00:33:09,166 --> 00:33:12,375 at the environmental benefits of dietary change. 431 00:33:12,416 --> 00:33:15,958 We modeled three dietary scenarios, 432 00:33:16,000 --> 00:33:19,416 diets that conformed to global dietary guidelines. 433 00:33:19,458 --> 00:33:22,583 On top of this, we implemented two vegetarian scenarios, 434 00:33:22,625 --> 00:33:26,583 one which is a normal lacto-ovo vegetarian scenario 435 00:33:26,625 --> 00:33:30,208 and one vegan scenario, which doesn't include any animal products. 436 00:33:31,916 --> 00:33:35,208 Continuing our diets from now to 2050 437 00:33:35,250 --> 00:33:38,041 would mean a huge increase in greenhouse gas emissions. 438 00:33:38,083 --> 00:33:40,500 We project that greenhouse gas emissions would be increased 439 00:33:40,541 --> 00:33:42,458 by about 50%. 440 00:33:42,500 --> 00:33:47,208 If people change from their expected diets 441 00:33:47,250 --> 00:33:49,708 to global dietary guidelines, 442 00:33:49,750 --> 00:33:50,958 then greenhouse gas emissions 443 00:33:51,000 --> 00:33:52,208 could be reduced 444 00:33:52,250 --> 00:33:53,458 by about a third. 445 00:33:53,500 --> 00:33:54,708 If people went 446 00:33:54,750 --> 00:33:55,958 to a vegetarian diet, 447 00:33:56,000 --> 00:33:57,208 that would increase 448 00:33:57,250 --> 00:33:58,583 to about two-thirds, 449 00:33:58,625 --> 00:33:59,833 and then if people even went 450 00:33:59,875 --> 00:34:01,083 to a vegan diet, 451 00:34:01,125 --> 00:34:02,791 that would result in reductions 452 00:34:02,833 --> 00:34:04,375 in greenhouse gas emissions 453 00:34:04,416 --> 00:34:05,791 of about 70%, 454 00:34:05,833 --> 00:34:07,250 so more than two-thirds. 455 00:34:07,291 --> 00:34:09,708 So the headline results of our study 456 00:34:09,750 --> 00:34:13,208 were that a move to more plant-based diets 457 00:34:13,250 --> 00:34:15,416 could reduce greenhouse gas emissions 458 00:34:15,458 --> 00:34:17,083 of up to two-thirds 459 00:34:17,125 --> 00:34:21,250 and result in reduced climate damages 460 00:34:21,291 --> 00:34:23,166 and reduced expenditure 461 00:34:23,208 --> 00:34:27,791 for healthcare-related services of $1.5 trillion. 462 00:34:32,208 --> 00:34:35,958 So, this is gonna pass right through your digestive tract... 463 00:34:36,000 --> 00:34:39,750 [man] If a physician is practicing medicine in the West, 464 00:34:39,791 --> 00:34:41,875 in developed nations, 465 00:34:41,916 --> 00:34:46,333 the vast majority of patients that we are seeing 466 00:34:46,375 --> 00:34:49,666 and the litany of diseases they bring in 467 00:34:49,708 --> 00:34:54,625 are the result of them running a high fat, 468 00:34:54,666 --> 00:34:57,958 high animal protein, high sugar food stream 469 00:34:58,000 --> 00:35:00,541 through their bloodstream and their tissues, 470 00:35:00,583 --> 00:35:02,916 hour after hour, day after day. 471 00:35:04,958 --> 00:35:07,958 We used to think that food just brings in calories 472 00:35:08,000 --> 00:35:12,125 for energy and proteins for structural building uses, 473 00:35:12,166 --> 00:35:15,000 but we now know that food brings in information. 474 00:35:15,041 --> 00:35:18,000 It turns genes on and turns genes off, 475 00:35:18,041 --> 00:35:20,583 genes that stabilize your tissues, 476 00:35:20,625 --> 00:35:23,500 that suppress cancer growth, that suppress inflammation, 477 00:35:23,541 --> 00:35:26,166 and that's what whole plant foods do, 478 00:35:26,208 --> 00:35:31,500 as opposed to animal-based foods that stimulate growth hormones 479 00:35:31,541 --> 00:35:35,166 and processes that promote cancer growth, 480 00:35:35,208 --> 00:35:38,500 that are oxidizing agents that damage our tissues. 481 00:35:38,541 --> 00:35:42,125 Oh, I have thought about the day 482 00:35:42,166 --> 00:35:46,541 when all Americans, all people around the world, are eating a plant-based diet. 483 00:35:46,583 --> 00:35:50,166 A vast number of ill people in our country 484 00:35:50,208 --> 00:35:52,375 would dwindle down rapidly. 485 00:35:52,416 --> 00:35:57,250 The trillions of dollars that we spend on just treating their symptoms, 486 00:35:57,291 --> 00:36:00,250 the surgeries not done and stents not placed 487 00:36:00,291 --> 00:36:02,375 and scans not ordered, 488 00:36:02,416 --> 00:36:07,208 the economics actually should drive this change in awareness as well. 489 00:36:07,250 --> 00:36:09,750 So there's a lot of positive forces converging. 490 00:36:09,791 --> 00:36:12,666 I'm just hoping we have enough time 491 00:36:12,708 --> 00:36:15,958 for this widespread knowledge to sink in 492 00:36:16,000 --> 00:36:19,125 and be acted upon by enough people. 493 00:36:22,625 --> 00:36:26,041 [Springmann] The findings of our study with regards to health are that, 494 00:36:26,083 --> 00:36:28,708 if people change their diets 495 00:36:28,750 --> 00:36:32,416 to diets that would be in line with global dietary guidelines, 496 00:36:32,458 --> 00:36:34,791 then about five million lives 497 00:36:34,833 --> 00:36:36,500 could be saved. 498 00:36:36,541 --> 00:36:37,750 If people went 499 00:36:37,791 --> 00:36:39,000 to vegetarian diets, 500 00:36:39,041 --> 00:36:40,250 that would increase 501 00:36:40,291 --> 00:36:41,625 to seven million lives saved, 502 00:36:41,666 --> 00:36:43,041 and if they went to vegan diets, 503 00:36:43,083 --> 00:36:44,291 that would increase 504 00:36:44,333 --> 00:36:46,833 to eight million lives saved. 505 00:36:46,875 --> 00:36:51,208 So almost any major, um... region and country 506 00:36:51,250 --> 00:36:54,375 could expect large savings due to dietary change. 507 00:36:57,041 --> 00:37:00,791 We indeed believe that governments have a major role to play 508 00:37:00,833 --> 00:37:03,958 by shaping the food environment that we are all in, 509 00:37:04,000 --> 00:37:08,083 for example, by mandating food labeling, 510 00:37:08,125 --> 00:37:12,333 taxing, for example, foods in regards to their greenhouse gas emissions, 511 00:37:12,375 --> 00:37:14,708 which would encourage the consumption 512 00:37:14,750 --> 00:37:17,208 of environmentally more sustainable foods 513 00:37:17,250 --> 00:37:21,541 and reduce the consumption of highly greenhouse gas emitting foods, 514 00:37:21,583 --> 00:37:23,791 such as animal products. 515 00:37:25,875 --> 00:37:28,000 [narrator] While I was researching 516 00:37:28,041 --> 00:37:30,750 the effects of meat consumption on biodiversity, 517 00:37:30,791 --> 00:37:33,916 I came across a quote that stuck with me. 518 00:37:33,958 --> 00:37:37,666 "You eat a steak, you kill a lemur in Madagascar. 519 00:37:37,708 --> 00:37:40,625 You eat a chicken, you kill an Amazonian parrot." 520 00:37:40,666 --> 00:37:42,916 It was a comment made by a researcher 521 00:37:42,958 --> 00:37:45,583 on a study about the destruction of habitat 522 00:37:45,625 --> 00:37:47,916 for animal pasture and feed crops. 523 00:37:47,958 --> 00:37:51,958 I met with the author of the paper in Miami, Florida. 524 00:37:53,541 --> 00:37:55,916 [man] Currently, there is a mass extinction, 525 00:37:55,958 --> 00:37:59,250 that's called the sixth mass extinction. 526 00:37:59,291 --> 00:38:03,833 If you look at natural background rates of extinction occurring in the world, 527 00:38:03,875 --> 00:38:06,500 that's been going on for millions of years, 528 00:38:06,541 --> 00:38:11,041 we're at an accelerated rate, about a thousand times 529 00:38:11,083 --> 00:38:13,500 what natural background rates are. 530 00:38:13,541 --> 00:38:15,416 [insects chirruping] 531 00:38:15,458 --> 00:38:17,500 [birds calling] 532 00:38:17,541 --> 00:38:20,750 Biodiversity, it's the fabric of life. 533 00:38:20,791 --> 00:38:24,041 It's the enormous assemblage of animals and plants 534 00:38:24,083 --> 00:38:28,708 that exist on this planet that we barely understand right now. 535 00:38:28,750 --> 00:38:32,125 Tropical countries are blanketed in this biodiversity. 536 00:38:32,166 --> 00:38:35,000 It's very important for us to protect that, 537 00:38:35,041 --> 00:38:38,333 not only because of what we know about it right now 538 00:38:38,375 --> 00:38:40,958 but because of what we don't know about it. 539 00:38:41,000 --> 00:38:43,000 We need to keep that around for future generations 540 00:38:43,041 --> 00:38:45,375 for them to discover and understand 541 00:38:45,416 --> 00:38:48,833 and develop products for human beings that are beneficial 542 00:38:48,875 --> 00:38:54,416 but also just for the right of life to exist and flourish and evolve in the future. 543 00:38:54,458 --> 00:38:59,250 The strongest force driving extinction around the world is animal product consumption 544 00:38:59,291 --> 00:39:01,541 because it is responsible for the destruction 545 00:39:01,583 --> 00:39:03,541 of more habitats around the world 546 00:39:03,583 --> 00:39:05,333 than any other human activity. 547 00:39:07,458 --> 00:39:11,833 If we look at the Amazon, which is the largest tropical forest in the world, 548 00:39:11,875 --> 00:39:14,458 it's the heart of biodiversity. 549 00:39:14,500 --> 00:39:19,125 Over 75% of all the deforested land in the Amazon 550 00:39:19,166 --> 00:39:22,250 has been cut to produce livestock, 551 00:39:22,291 --> 00:39:27,583 either to directly put cattle on pasture that is grown there instead of the forest, 552 00:39:27,625 --> 00:39:31,458 or to plant soy or corn which is fed to livestock 553 00:39:31,500 --> 00:39:35,708 and nowadays shipped all around the world to feed livestock in other countries. 554 00:39:35,750 --> 00:39:39,583 So the destruction of the Amazon has been driven 555 00:39:39,625 --> 00:39:42,875 by animal product consumption, period. 556 00:39:42,916 --> 00:39:46,083 If everyone on the planet went vegan, 557 00:39:46,125 --> 00:39:50,333 that would free up an enormous amount of land to be used for other resources. 558 00:39:50,375 --> 00:39:53,958 So one thing that could be done is restoring habitats 559 00:39:54,000 --> 00:39:57,333 to traditional natural ecosystems, connecting them together, 560 00:39:57,375 --> 00:40:01,125 creating corridors between endangered habitats. 561 00:40:01,166 --> 00:40:05,416 At the same time, it could allow the development of biofuels 562 00:40:05,458 --> 00:40:08,000 on properties as well 563 00:40:08,041 --> 00:40:12,208 so that we could become more of a carbon neutral society. 564 00:40:12,250 --> 00:40:14,125 There's a lot of innovation that could occur 565 00:40:14,166 --> 00:40:17,000 on those properties if we pull meat consumption 566 00:40:17,041 --> 00:40:20,166 and meat production off of those lands. 567 00:40:23,416 --> 00:40:26,958 [narrator] A diet rich in meat would require a 50% increase 568 00:40:27,000 --> 00:40:30,125 in global cropland area by 2050. 569 00:40:30,166 --> 00:40:34,416 If the world went vegan in 2050, we would require less cropland 570 00:40:34,458 --> 00:40:37,208 than we did in the year 2000. 571 00:40:37,250 --> 00:40:40,125 This would allow us to reforest an area 572 00:40:40,166 --> 00:40:43,666 around the size of the entire Amazon rain forest. 573 00:40:43,708 --> 00:40:47,458 Pastures cover a quarter of our global land mass. 574 00:40:47,500 --> 00:40:51,083 Bill Ripple, an ecologist from the University of Oregon, 575 00:40:51,125 --> 00:40:54,208 is researching what happens to pastures 576 00:40:54,250 --> 00:40:57,375 when animals no longer graze. 577 00:40:57,416 --> 00:41:00,166 [Ripple] At the Hart Mountain National Wildlife Refuge, 578 00:41:00,208 --> 00:41:05,041 the managers removed all the cattle in 1990. 579 00:41:05,083 --> 00:41:11,375 We found a decrease of 90% in the amount of bare soil. 580 00:41:11,416 --> 00:41:14,541 We found an increase in willow. 581 00:41:14,583 --> 00:41:19,791 That increase is 388%, so that's significant 582 00:41:19,833 --> 00:41:24,041 because willow is an important biodiversity indicator 583 00:41:24,083 --> 00:41:26,291 for these streamside areas, 584 00:41:26,333 --> 00:41:30,916 because many species of plants and animals 585 00:41:30,958 --> 00:41:33,375 are correlated with the abundance 586 00:41:33,416 --> 00:41:35,875 of willow and aspen. 587 00:41:39,250 --> 00:41:44,958 This is about a 70-centimeter diameter aspen tree, 588 00:41:45,000 --> 00:41:47,375 originated in the 1800s, 589 00:41:47,416 --> 00:41:50,166 before livestock arrived on Hart Mountain. 590 00:41:50,208 --> 00:41:53,541 I think the importance of Hart Mountain here 591 00:41:53,583 --> 00:41:57,125 is because it's a rare case where we've documented 592 00:41:57,166 --> 00:42:01,291 what happens when cattle are removed from a landscape, 593 00:42:01,333 --> 00:42:05,125 what happens when cattle are removed from streamside areas. 594 00:42:05,166 --> 00:42:08,125 Today, animal agriculture uses a big percentage 595 00:42:08,166 --> 00:42:11,250 of the land surface, 596 00:42:11,291 --> 00:42:15,125 and if that could be converted to more natural uses, 597 00:42:15,166 --> 00:42:19,125 I think biodiversity would increase in those cases 598 00:42:19,166 --> 00:42:23,416 where there's less grazing, less feed crop production. 599 00:42:25,333 --> 00:42:28,500 ♪ 600 00:42:53,125 --> 00:42:55,000 [narrator] One of the countries 601 00:42:55,041 --> 00:42:58,125 that featured frequently in my research was India. 602 00:42:58,166 --> 00:43:00,250 In a few years, it will be 603 00:43:00,291 --> 00:43:03,083 the most populous country on Earth. 604 00:43:03,125 --> 00:43:06,375 I kept wondering, what does a society look like 605 00:43:06,416 --> 00:43:10,041 when 32% of its population is vegetarian? 606 00:43:10,083 --> 00:43:14,916 A staggering 400 million people in India don't eat any meat. 607 00:43:17,541 --> 00:43:20,375 Followed by 80% of the population, 608 00:43:20,416 --> 00:43:23,500 Hinduism is the major religion of India. 609 00:43:23,541 --> 00:43:26,958 Hindus advocate nonviolence and respect for all life, 610 00:43:27,000 --> 00:43:30,625 embracing vegetarianism. 611 00:43:30,666 --> 00:43:35,625 Culturally, we have what I love to call a mild indifference towards animals, 612 00:43:35,666 --> 00:43:41,375 which is the reason you see animals all around you when you live. 613 00:43:41,416 --> 00:43:44,750 You have your birds of all sorts are not getting shot down. 614 00:43:44,791 --> 00:43:47,291 You have dogs, of course, you have cows. 615 00:43:47,333 --> 00:43:50,541 Your monkeys in cities, you know. 616 00:43:50,583 --> 00:43:53,750 We see ourselves more as a unified whole, 617 00:43:53,791 --> 00:43:57,458 where there is a place for all other elements of nature as well. 618 00:43:57,500 --> 00:43:59,541 -[pedestrians chatting] -[horns honking] 619 00:44:03,041 --> 00:44:05,791 [narrator] Cows in India are a common sight. 620 00:44:05,833 --> 00:44:08,791 Around 50 million stray cattle and stray dogs 621 00:44:08,833 --> 00:44:12,041 roam the streets of India in search of food. 622 00:44:12,083 --> 00:44:14,208 Once the provider for the family, 623 00:44:14,250 --> 00:44:18,333 cows are now seen by Hindus as a maternal figure, 624 00:44:18,375 --> 00:44:22,416 males and females alike sacred for their generosity. 625 00:44:22,458 --> 00:44:25,333 The slaughter of cows is banned in most parts of India. 626 00:44:25,375 --> 00:44:29,916 Violators of the ban may face up to ten years in prison. 627 00:44:34,333 --> 00:44:38,416 [woman] People think that Indians treat cows as a holy animal, 628 00:44:38,458 --> 00:44:41,791 but the reality is far from it. 629 00:44:41,833 --> 00:44:46,958 India is apparently the largest producer of milk in the world, 630 00:44:47,000 --> 00:44:52,083 so it comes as no surprise that India is also the largest exporter of beef 631 00:44:52,125 --> 00:44:56,041 and fifth largest exporter of leather products. 632 00:44:58,041 --> 00:45:00,666 Because of the ban on cow slaughter, 633 00:45:00,708 --> 00:45:03,583 dairy owners use buffaloes, because, of course, buffaloes 634 00:45:03,625 --> 00:45:06,583 are exempted from this law. 635 00:45:08,375 --> 00:45:10,791 [horn honks] 636 00:45:10,833 --> 00:45:14,916 There's another very small section of dairy owners 637 00:45:14,958 --> 00:45:17,708 who actually leave their animals on the road. 638 00:45:17,750 --> 00:45:21,750 Now, one weird thing, that this concept 639 00:45:21,791 --> 00:45:23,958 of leaving animals free on the road 640 00:45:24,000 --> 00:45:26,625 is much better than the animals being in the dairy, 641 00:45:26,666 --> 00:45:29,208 but they don't have access to food and water, 642 00:45:29,250 --> 00:45:32,958 so they're left with no choice but to find food in garbage bins. 643 00:45:33,000 --> 00:45:35,958 Most of these throwaway eatables 644 00:45:36,000 --> 00:45:38,875 are disposed of in a plastic bag which is tied. 645 00:45:38,916 --> 00:45:41,583 These animals can't open the bag 646 00:45:41,625 --> 00:45:44,708 so they inevitably eat these bags 647 00:45:44,750 --> 00:45:47,083 along with the food items in it. 648 00:45:56,041 --> 00:45:58,875 [woman] In the urban youth that is going to all these colleges, 649 00:45:58,916 --> 00:46:02,333 even the way these big corporates are coming to India 650 00:46:02,375 --> 00:46:04,208 and sort of targeting the youth, 651 00:46:04,250 --> 00:46:07,333 the consumption of non-veg is definitely rising 652 00:46:07,375 --> 00:46:11,458 in the urban elite youth who think it's cool or hip 653 00:46:11,500 --> 00:46:14,583 to sort of consume non-veg, to say that, 654 00:46:14,625 --> 00:46:16,750 "Oh, I'm being open-minded and liberal 655 00:46:16,791 --> 00:46:19,125 and saying I can have non-veg, it's a right." 656 00:46:21,208 --> 00:46:24,458 [Sharma] As middle-class incomes grow 657 00:46:24,500 --> 00:46:26,500 with growing economy, 658 00:46:26,541 --> 00:46:30,875 that's when the consumption of luxury items increases, 659 00:46:30,916 --> 00:46:36,375 and cheese and dairy and more eggs and meats, 660 00:46:36,416 --> 00:46:39,083 including exotic meats is all a part of that continuum. 661 00:46:39,125 --> 00:46:44,291 If we can simply hold steady 662 00:46:44,333 --> 00:46:47,916 the rate of growth of non-vegetarianism, that will be a big victory. 663 00:46:50,958 --> 00:46:53,833 [narrator] Palitana, a city in the state of Gujarat 664 00:46:53,875 --> 00:46:56,875 in northern India, made headlines in 2014 665 00:46:56,916 --> 00:47:00,625 as the first vegetarian city in the world. 666 00:47:00,666 --> 00:47:03,166 Also known as the city of temples, 667 00:47:03,208 --> 00:47:06,833 Palitana is one of the most holy sites to the Jains, 668 00:47:06,875 --> 00:47:10,458 an ancient religion said to be even older than Buddhism. 669 00:47:10,500 --> 00:47:12,500 [Indian instruments playing] 670 00:47:31,958 --> 00:47:35,458 [speaking foreign language] 671 00:47:35,500 --> 00:47:38,791 The Jain Dharma believes in nonviolence. 672 00:47:40,625 --> 00:47:43,291 No birds, no animals, no insects, 673 00:47:43,333 --> 00:47:46,333 no human beings should be harmed. 674 00:47:46,375 --> 00:47:52,166 Each and every living beings have the right to live. 675 00:47:52,208 --> 00:47:55,791 You live and let live others. 676 00:47:59,708 --> 00:48:01,375 Last hundred years... 677 00:48:03,166 --> 00:48:06,041 many slaughterhouses are allowed. 678 00:48:06,083 --> 00:48:09,500 That's why it's our duty to stop them. 679 00:48:09,541 --> 00:48:13,083 If they are not Jains, so what? 680 00:48:13,125 --> 00:48:15,166 This is the holy place. 681 00:48:15,208 --> 00:48:18,125 You can't kill any living beings. 682 00:48:18,166 --> 00:48:19,875 You can't harm them. 683 00:48:19,916 --> 00:48:24,041 [newscaster speaking foreign language] 684 00:48:24,083 --> 00:48:29,250 [Maharaj] All the monks of Palitana, we went to fast. 685 00:48:29,291 --> 00:48:33,416 If Gujarat government 686 00:48:33,458 --> 00:48:38,500 will not stop the slaughtering, then we'll sacrifice our lives 687 00:48:38,541 --> 00:48:40,083 for the animals. 688 00:48:40,125 --> 00:48:44,250 I announced, "If you want flesh, 689 00:48:44,291 --> 00:48:48,750 we will donate our meat, our own meat." 690 00:48:48,791 --> 00:48:51,833 You cut us, you kill us. 691 00:48:51,875 --> 00:48:55,416 So you eat of our flesh. You eat of our body. 692 00:48:57,875 --> 00:49:01,541 [narrator] A vegetarian zone was established in 1999, 693 00:49:01,583 --> 00:49:05,500 two kilometers along the main road leading to the temple hill. 694 00:49:05,541 --> 00:49:09,458 In an area of 250 meters to each side, the sale of meat, 695 00:49:09,500 --> 00:49:12,208 fish, and eggs is banned by law. 696 00:49:12,250 --> 00:49:15,291 The aim of the monks is to establish a larger zone 697 00:49:15,333 --> 00:49:18,708 within a nine-kilometer radius around the city. 698 00:49:21,333 --> 00:49:24,583 All butchers, we took meeting here. 699 00:49:24,625 --> 00:49:28,666 Approximately 80 to 90 butchers came here. 700 00:49:28,708 --> 00:49:34,625 So we give them options that whatever your need is, 701 00:49:34,666 --> 00:49:36,833 we will help you. 702 00:49:36,875 --> 00:49:39,833 We gave them money for change their professions. 703 00:49:39,875 --> 00:49:42,875 [men speaking foreign language] 704 00:49:44,541 --> 00:49:46,166 [narrator] The former butchers, 705 00:49:46,208 --> 00:49:48,250 who now had grocery and clothing stores, 706 00:49:48,291 --> 00:49:50,333 did not want to speak on camera, 707 00:49:50,375 --> 00:49:52,916 but they denied having received a compensation 708 00:49:52,958 --> 00:49:55,958 and said they felt ashamed of their former profession. 709 00:49:56,000 --> 00:50:00,333 The Muslim community, which accounts for 25% of the city's population 710 00:50:00,375 --> 00:50:03,750 compared to only 3% Jains, was not happy about the ban 711 00:50:03,791 --> 00:50:07,250 and deemed their religious freedom had been violated. 712 00:50:08,541 --> 00:50:10,833 When I discovered a backyard slaughterhouse, 713 00:50:10,875 --> 00:50:12,583 the meat had already been sold 714 00:50:12,625 --> 00:50:15,125 and the leftovers were fed to the dogs. 715 00:50:15,166 --> 00:50:18,291 The butchers were suspicious and reluctant to talk, 716 00:50:18,333 --> 00:50:20,833 similar to the city officials who referred me 717 00:50:20,875 --> 00:50:23,833 to the district headquarters in Bhavnagar. 718 00:50:25,958 --> 00:50:31,208 [Maharaj] We trust on Lord Adinath that very soon 719 00:50:31,250 --> 00:50:35,750 the entire Palitana, holy city, vegetarian zone, 720 00:50:35,791 --> 00:50:38,083 vegetarian city. 721 00:50:38,125 --> 00:50:41,125 And not only Palitana. 722 00:50:41,166 --> 00:50:43,958 My wish is 723 00:50:44,000 --> 00:50:46,916 that whatever the missions going from Palitana, 724 00:50:46,958 --> 00:50:51,916 it should be whole, toward the entire world. 725 00:50:51,958 --> 00:50:54,333 Whole world should be vegetarian. 726 00:50:58,208 --> 00:51:01,375 [narrator] In Mumbai, I wanted to learn more about Jainism 727 00:51:01,416 --> 00:51:05,166 and got in touch with Pramoda Chitrabhanu, a vegan Jain. 728 00:51:05,208 --> 00:51:08,125 I met her in the district of Malabar Hill, 729 00:51:08,166 --> 00:51:11,125 one of the most posh residential areas in Mumbai 730 00:51:11,166 --> 00:51:14,250 and an exclusively vegetarian neighborhood. 731 00:51:16,583 --> 00:51:19,916 Ahimsa is the center of this philosophy 732 00:51:19,958 --> 00:51:24,750 because in 599 BC, Lord Mahavira, 733 00:51:24,791 --> 00:51:29,125 who was the last apostle of the Jain religion, 734 00:51:29,166 --> 00:51:34,250 he said that those who disregard and disrespect 735 00:51:34,291 --> 00:51:39,208 the existence of life in earth, water, fire, air, 736 00:51:39,250 --> 00:51:42,625 vegetation, and all life forms, 737 00:51:42,666 --> 00:51:46,291 disregards and disrespects his own existence 738 00:51:46,333 --> 00:51:50,333 because all life are intertwined with each other. 739 00:51:54,333 --> 00:51:59,750 The best means to stop these people from eating meat 740 00:51:59,791 --> 00:52:02,750 would be through educating. 741 00:52:02,791 --> 00:52:05,083 Education is the only way. 742 00:52:05,125 --> 00:52:10,250 I don't think so by stopping and burning the slaughterhouses, all those things. 743 00:52:10,291 --> 00:52:13,458 And to stop that, one has to go out 744 00:52:13,500 --> 00:52:15,541 and educate them, talk to them, 745 00:52:15,583 --> 00:52:19,083 make them understand why we are talking about this, 746 00:52:19,125 --> 00:52:23,791 make them understand that animals are not a commodity. 747 00:52:28,000 --> 00:52:31,000 [narrator] My experience in India left me wondering 748 00:52:31,041 --> 00:52:33,833 what our cities and communities could look like 749 00:52:33,875 --> 00:52:37,416 if we no longer viewed animals as commodities. 750 00:52:37,458 --> 00:52:40,666 In Leipzig, I met with artist Hartmut Kiewert, 751 00:52:40,708 --> 00:52:45,333 who envisions a very different way of living with animals. 752 00:53:50,625 --> 00:53:52,708 [pig snorts] 753 00:54:05,083 --> 00:54:06,708 [pig snorts] 754 00:55:01,791 --> 00:55:05,041 [narrator] During my research, I came across the "Zoopolis," 755 00:55:05,083 --> 00:55:07,291 a term describing an environment 756 00:55:07,333 --> 00:55:11,333 in which humans and animals not only coexist 757 00:55:11,375 --> 00:55:15,541 but also thrive alongside one another. 758 00:55:15,583 --> 00:55:19,416 [woman] The idea of Zoopolis arose from the idea 759 00:55:19,458 --> 00:55:23,541 that urban theory, ideas about the city and how cities work, 760 00:55:23,583 --> 00:55:26,416 were really only about people, 761 00:55:26,458 --> 00:55:30,041 and when I started thinking about, "Well, who actually lives in cities?" 762 00:55:30,083 --> 00:55:33,083 it was clear that, and it is clear that, 763 00:55:33,125 --> 00:55:35,458 there's a lot of nonhumans that live in cities, 764 00:55:35,500 --> 00:55:41,375 and so I wanted to create what I called a transspecies urban theory, 765 00:55:41,416 --> 00:55:44,083 and also a transspecies urban practice 766 00:55:44,125 --> 00:55:47,500 in which built environment professionals-- 767 00:55:47,541 --> 00:55:49,833 environmental designers, architects, planners, 768 00:55:49,875 --> 00:55:52,083 landscape architects, engineers-- 769 00:55:52,125 --> 00:55:56,333 actually thought about nonhuman residents of cities 770 00:55:56,375 --> 00:55:58,833 as well as human inhabitants and their needs. 771 00:55:58,875 --> 00:56:01,875 But I think it raises the question 772 00:56:01,916 --> 00:56:03,916 of how do you include animals 773 00:56:03,958 --> 00:56:06,458 in a democratic decision-making process, 774 00:56:06,500 --> 00:56:09,291 in a discourse of citizenship, 775 00:56:09,333 --> 00:56:14,208 in a way that makes their... 776 00:56:14,250 --> 00:56:20,041 needs and wants and desires part of the conversation? 777 00:56:21,875 --> 00:56:23,625 [narrator] Two Canadian philosophers 778 00:56:23,666 --> 00:56:27,458 turned the concept of the Zoopolis into a radical claim, 779 00:56:27,500 --> 00:56:31,791 going so far as to consider animals our co-citizens. 780 00:56:31,833 --> 00:56:33,708 While most animal rights philosophers 781 00:56:33,750 --> 00:56:37,250 call for a separation of the world's humans and animals, 782 00:56:37,291 --> 00:56:40,000 Will Kymlicka and Sue Donaldson believe 783 00:56:40,041 --> 00:56:42,625 that a shared world is possible. 784 00:56:44,333 --> 00:56:47,666 [Donaldson] If we look around just out the window here, 785 00:56:47,708 --> 00:56:50,958 we see all kinds of animals who make their homes 786 00:56:51,000 --> 00:56:54,125 in our cities, our communities, our houses, 787 00:56:54,166 --> 00:56:58,000 and the idea that we could somehow live separately from animals 788 00:56:58,041 --> 00:57:00,750 and avoid domination and exploitation that way 789 00:57:00,791 --> 00:57:02,208 is completely unrealistic. 790 00:57:04,416 --> 00:57:07,333 [Kymlicka] Yeah, so we distinguish three categories, 791 00:57:07,375 --> 00:57:10,333 or three broad patterns, of relationships. 792 00:57:10,375 --> 00:57:14,083 So domesticated animals we think should be seen as 793 00:57:14,125 --> 00:57:16,083 members of our society, 794 00:57:16,125 --> 00:57:18,416 and the way in which we affirm membership is through citizenship. 795 00:57:18,458 --> 00:57:21,500 So we should think of domesticated animals as our co-citizens, 796 00:57:21,541 --> 00:57:23,666 and that means, like other citizens, 797 00:57:23,708 --> 00:57:28,000 they would have the rights to protection from harm, 798 00:57:28,041 --> 00:57:30,541 rights to health care, 799 00:57:30,583 --> 00:57:33,708 rights to political representation 800 00:57:33,750 --> 00:57:35,958 to have their interests taken into account. 801 00:57:36,000 --> 00:57:38,916 And, of course, the right to live here and rights of residency. 802 00:57:41,250 --> 00:57:45,791 The second category concerns animals who continue to live 803 00:57:45,833 --> 00:57:48,916 independently of humans on their own habitat. 804 00:57:48,958 --> 00:57:51,125 So there's not much wilderness left in this world, 805 00:57:51,166 --> 00:57:53,666 we keep conquering and colonizing, 806 00:57:53,708 --> 00:57:55,875 so we recognize rights of territory 807 00:57:55,916 --> 00:57:57,625 and the rights of wilderness animals 808 00:57:57,666 --> 00:57:59,791 to live autonomously on their territory. 809 00:57:59,833 --> 00:58:05,000 And in political theory, we bundle these rights to territory and autonomy 810 00:58:05,041 --> 00:58:07,375 under the idea of sovereignty, 811 00:58:07,416 --> 00:58:09,916 so we should think of wild animals 812 00:58:09,958 --> 00:58:11,916 as having sovereignty rights 813 00:58:11,958 --> 00:58:14,083 over themselves and their territory. 814 00:58:15,958 --> 00:58:17,500 And the third category, 815 00:58:17,541 --> 00:58:19,416 which is in some ways the least studied, 816 00:58:19,458 --> 00:58:21,666 the least theorized in the animal rights debate, 817 00:58:21,708 --> 00:58:25,875 concerns the nondomesticated animals who live amongst us. 818 00:58:25,916 --> 00:58:29,541 So, urban wildlife, to simplify it. 819 00:58:29,583 --> 00:58:32,750 Crows, pigeons, ducks, mice, 820 00:58:32,791 --> 00:58:34,375 squirrels. 821 00:58:34,416 --> 00:58:36,583 So in our view, we need to recognize 822 00:58:36,625 --> 00:58:39,000 that these animals live amongst us, 823 00:58:39,041 --> 00:58:41,125 and so they have residency rights 824 00:58:41,166 --> 00:58:43,333 and we need to learn to coexist. 825 00:58:43,375 --> 00:58:46,750 So they have rights to be accommodated 826 00:58:46,791 --> 00:58:49,041 in this shared space. 827 00:58:49,083 --> 00:58:51,916 But that's a looser kind of relationship 828 00:58:51,958 --> 00:58:55,333 than with citizenship, and so we call that "denizenship." 829 00:58:59,750 --> 00:59:01,708 So, so long as we are committed to the idea 830 00:59:01,750 --> 00:59:03,458 that we're going to be living together 831 00:59:03,500 --> 00:59:05,500 with at least some domesticated animals, 832 00:59:05,541 --> 00:59:08,750 what we want is a way of framing that relationship 833 00:59:08,791 --> 00:59:13,250 that imposes on us an obligation to be responsive to them, 834 00:59:13,291 --> 00:59:16,541 to the animals, and that's what we view citizenship as doing. 835 00:59:19,625 --> 00:59:23,875 [narrator] It was difficult to picture a world with animals as our co-citizens. 836 00:59:23,916 --> 00:59:26,458 But there were already tiny communities 837 00:59:26,500 --> 00:59:29,916 where this idea didn't seem too far from reality. 838 00:59:29,958 --> 00:59:33,166 German author and activist Hilal Sezgin 839 00:59:33,208 --> 00:59:35,291 moved from the city to the countryside 840 00:59:35,333 --> 00:59:38,416 and unintentionally adopted a herd of sheep. 841 00:59:38,458 --> 00:59:41,166 [ducks quacking] 842 01:01:09,708 --> 01:01:11,000 [harrumphs] 843 01:02:20,791 --> 01:02:23,000 [keyboard clacking] 844 01:02:23,041 --> 01:02:25,333 [Steve] Hmm, she's due for a family walk. 845 01:02:26,916 --> 01:02:28,916 ♪ 846 01:02:36,208 --> 01:02:40,583 [narrator] I heard that someone else had traded life in suburbia for the countryside. 847 01:02:40,625 --> 01:02:42,333 Esther the Wonder Pig. 848 01:02:42,375 --> 01:02:43,958 Through a crowd-funding campaign, 849 01:02:44,000 --> 01:02:47,083 Steve, Derek and Esther founded a farm sanctuary 850 01:02:47,125 --> 01:02:49,125 just outside of Toronto. 851 01:02:50,291 --> 01:02:54,083 [Derek] So Happily Ever Esther Farm Sanctuary is 50 acres, 852 01:02:54,125 --> 01:02:59,041 and half of it is treed and the other half is fields. 853 01:02:59,083 --> 01:03:02,500 We had an Indiegogo fundraising campaign, 854 01:03:02,541 --> 01:03:07,083 and in 60 days, we raised $450,000. 855 01:03:10,000 --> 01:03:12,208 So this is the forest paddock. 856 01:03:12,250 --> 01:03:15,833 And... here's someone living a dream. 857 01:03:15,875 --> 01:03:18,625 -[Steve chuckles] -Here's Leonard. 858 01:03:18,666 --> 01:03:21,041 There's a gate up there that allows him to get into that area 859 01:03:21,083 --> 01:03:24,583 from behind the barn and into the barn, so he can go wherever he wants. 860 01:03:24,625 --> 01:03:28,583 You know, pigs in the wild will travel six to eight miles in a day. 861 01:03:28,625 --> 01:03:32,750 The second we opened up the gate for the big pigs to come into the woods, 862 01:03:32,791 --> 01:03:36,458 they were like, "What?" You know, "This is awesome!" 863 01:03:37,958 --> 01:03:40,250 I love seeing the pigs in the woods just chill, 864 01:03:40,291 --> 01:03:42,833 like Esther when she's walking through the woods. 865 01:03:42,875 --> 01:03:46,000 She's just in her element, she's so happy. 866 01:03:49,416 --> 01:03:53,916 The idea behind a sanctuary is to just let the animals be themselves. 867 01:03:53,958 --> 01:03:57,041 It's really neat to see an animal come here all on their own, 868 01:03:57,083 --> 01:04:00,833 you know, just one, and see how they start integrating in 869 01:04:00,875 --> 01:04:03,791 and creating friendships with different animals 870 01:04:03,833 --> 01:04:07,750 and cross-species where everybody fits in. 871 01:04:07,791 --> 01:04:10,291 You know, not everybody gets along, 872 01:04:10,333 --> 01:04:12,666 and we recognize that too, and they don't have to, 873 01:04:12,708 --> 01:04:15,208 'cause there's two sides to the fence. 874 01:04:15,250 --> 01:04:17,666 They can be on that side or they can be on this side. 875 01:04:17,708 --> 01:04:21,666 It's just about recognizing the needs for them. 876 01:04:26,791 --> 01:04:28,958 [narrator] The idea of farm sanctuaries 877 01:04:29,000 --> 01:04:31,541 is to provide a safe haven for animals 878 01:04:31,583 --> 01:04:34,708 that were rescued or escaped from factory farms 879 01:04:34,750 --> 01:04:36,625 and slaughterhouses. 880 01:04:36,666 --> 01:04:39,333 Here, they are cared for and given the opportunity 881 01:04:39,375 --> 01:04:43,750 to behave as naturally as possible in a protective environment. 882 01:04:43,791 --> 01:04:47,375 I was wondering what the people who are running these sanctuaries 883 01:04:47,416 --> 01:04:50,666 had learned from living so closely with farmed animals 884 01:04:50,708 --> 01:04:52,458 over the years. 885 01:04:54,625 --> 01:04:57,583 [man] Farm Sanctuary started back in the mid 1980s 886 01:04:57,625 --> 01:05:00,375 to combat the abuses of factory farming, 887 01:05:00,416 --> 01:05:03,750 and we started by investigating farms and stockyards and slaughterhouses. 888 01:05:03,791 --> 01:05:06,875 We'd find living animals literally thrown in trash cans 889 01:05:06,916 --> 01:05:08,583 or on piles of dead animals. 890 01:05:08,625 --> 01:05:10,375 We started rescuing them 891 01:05:10,416 --> 01:05:12,375 and we were selling vegan hot dogs 892 01:05:12,416 --> 01:05:14,958 at Grateful Dead shows to fund the work. 893 01:05:15,000 --> 01:05:16,458 And we now have three sanctuaries, 894 01:05:16,500 --> 01:05:18,125 one in New York, two in California. 895 01:05:19,208 --> 01:05:21,625 The first animal farm sanctuary rescue was Hilda, 896 01:05:21,666 --> 01:05:26,666 who was a sheep, who was left on a pile of dead animals behind a stockyard. 897 01:05:26,708 --> 01:05:29,333 The maggots were so thick, you could hear them buzzing 898 01:05:29,375 --> 01:05:31,166 as they devoured these carcasses. 899 01:05:31,208 --> 01:05:33,833 And out of this pile, a sheep lifts her head. 900 01:05:33,875 --> 01:05:38,291 And we were stunned that a living animal would be discarded like garbage this way. 901 01:05:38,333 --> 01:05:41,583 And we picked her off the dead pile thinking she would have to be euthanized. 902 01:05:41,625 --> 01:05:45,333 But as the veterinarian started looking at her and examining her, 903 01:05:45,375 --> 01:05:48,291 she started perking up and then she stood up, 904 01:05:48,333 --> 01:05:51,708 and she lived a good, long life. 905 01:05:51,750 --> 01:05:55,208 And ultimately all of us, human beings and other animals, 906 01:05:55,250 --> 01:05:57,458 want to live a good, long life, 907 01:05:57,500 --> 01:06:00,708 and farm animals are not given that opportunity. 908 01:06:00,750 --> 01:06:02,333 [engine idling] 909 01:06:02,375 --> 01:06:04,333 [woman] Hi! 910 01:06:09,625 --> 01:06:11,833 Animals at farm animal sanctuaries 911 01:06:11,875 --> 01:06:16,083 behave very differently than if you were to meet them out on a farm. 912 01:06:16,125 --> 01:06:18,875 Many of these animals are incredibly resilient 913 01:06:18,916 --> 01:06:21,583 and they've lost their fear of people, 914 01:06:21,625 --> 01:06:24,583 and that allows people to see their personalities. 915 01:06:24,625 --> 01:06:26,166 [sniffing] 916 01:06:27,208 --> 01:06:31,291 We had these three turkeys, Boone, Alphonso and Hershel, 917 01:06:31,333 --> 01:06:34,041 and so in the early days, they would follow us everywhere, 918 01:06:34,083 --> 01:06:36,583 when we were doing tours and taking people around. 919 01:06:36,625 --> 01:06:38,541 And sometimes you can tell 920 01:06:38,583 --> 01:06:41,875 it's like a wife has brought her husband and her kids, 921 01:06:41,916 --> 01:06:46,041 and she's the one who has compassion in her heart for animals 922 01:06:46,083 --> 01:06:48,250 and she's trying to expose her family to it. 923 01:06:48,291 --> 01:06:50,166 We see this a lot. 924 01:06:50,208 --> 01:06:51,541 [turkey gobbling] 925 01:06:51,583 --> 01:06:54,125 So this father was walking around, 926 01:06:54,166 --> 01:06:57,000 and you could tell he just sort of kept to himself 927 01:06:57,041 --> 01:07:00,041 and had his hands in his pockets and was sort of marveling 928 01:07:00,083 --> 01:07:03,625 and laughing and smirking at the turkeys as they would follow around, 929 01:07:03,666 --> 01:07:07,625 and if the kids would laugh or clap their hands, the turkeys would respond. 930 01:07:07,666 --> 01:07:12,500 But at the end of the tour, I looked over and he was petting Hershel's head, 931 01:07:12,541 --> 01:07:16,250 and then he sort of squatted down and he was face to face with Hershel, 932 01:07:16,291 --> 01:07:19,458 and I saw like a tear stream down his face, 933 01:07:19,500 --> 01:07:23,916 and he said to his kids that he was wrong all these years 934 01:07:23,958 --> 01:07:27,583 and that he was so resistant to his wife, their mother, 935 01:07:27,625 --> 01:07:32,083 and that he never realized that they could be so friendly 936 01:07:32,125 --> 01:07:34,750 and that they had such unique personalities 937 01:07:34,791 --> 01:07:38,125 and that he could ever find himself being so fond of a turkey. 938 01:07:41,958 --> 01:07:43,708 ♪ 939 01:07:49,208 --> 01:07:51,041 [children calling] 940 01:07:55,958 --> 01:07:57,791 [narrator] It is the first open day of the year 941 01:07:57,833 --> 01:08:01,708 at Friend Animal Rescue in Kent, England. 942 01:08:01,750 --> 01:08:04,541 I came here to learn how visitors interact 943 01:08:04,583 --> 01:08:07,458 with farmed animals at a sanctuary. 944 01:08:07,500 --> 01:08:09,916 [lively chattering] 945 01:08:11,875 --> 01:08:15,625 [man] When I first turned up here, I was a committed meat eater. 946 01:08:17,416 --> 01:08:19,583 And I met Marion. 947 01:08:19,625 --> 01:08:22,958 I just saw this little woman here on her own 948 01:08:23,000 --> 01:08:26,750 with all these pigs and cows and sheep and horses, 949 01:08:26,791 --> 01:08:30,166 just caring for them, feeding them and watering them. 950 01:08:30,208 --> 01:08:33,458 I was just like, wow, it was like a Disney cartoon. 951 01:08:33,500 --> 01:08:35,375 It inspired me. 952 01:08:35,416 --> 01:08:37,833 I firmly believed I had to eat meat. 953 01:08:37,875 --> 01:08:42,250 And on the premise, really, if I didn't, I would get sick, possibly die. 954 01:08:42,291 --> 01:08:47,375 So when she was explaining to me about the industry, 955 01:08:47,416 --> 01:08:49,875 the farmed animal industry and what happens, 956 01:08:49,916 --> 01:08:52,541 they're slaughtered so young, for example. 957 01:08:52,583 --> 01:08:55,000 Most of them are babies, under a year old. 958 01:08:55,041 --> 01:08:58,791 You kind of-- I got defensive, I think a lot of people did. 959 01:08:58,833 --> 01:09:00,833 [woman] You like carrots, don't you? 960 01:09:00,875 --> 01:09:02,333 Oh! [laughs] 961 01:09:02,375 --> 01:09:05,166 [Eaton] There's only so many farmed animals 962 01:09:05,208 --> 01:09:07,375 because people choose to eat them. 963 01:09:08,291 --> 01:09:11,000 When you start meeting these animals, 964 01:09:11,041 --> 01:09:13,791 it brings out a softer side, 965 01:09:13,833 --> 01:09:17,000 and I think you have to be very, very kind of fix minded 966 01:09:17,041 --> 01:09:21,041 or very almost brutal to suddenly meet these animals 967 01:09:21,083 --> 01:09:23,500 and decide, "I could just carry on eating them." 968 01:09:24,791 --> 01:09:27,500 It affected me big-time, to such an extent, 969 01:09:27,541 --> 01:09:30,250 not only did I become vegan, 970 01:09:30,291 --> 01:09:35,083 I ended up staying 15 years, marrying Marion, 971 01:09:35,125 --> 01:09:36,958 and it changed my life forever. 972 01:09:38,791 --> 01:09:43,416 So that would be a very good example of what this place does. 973 01:09:43,458 --> 01:09:45,916 [cow moos] 974 01:09:45,958 --> 01:09:48,833 [crowd laughs] 975 01:09:48,875 --> 01:09:51,125 [horse snorts] 976 01:09:51,166 --> 01:09:52,958 [narrator] The Erdlingshof, 977 01:09:53,000 --> 01:09:55,541 a small sanctuary in the Bavarian forest, 978 01:09:55,583 --> 01:09:58,416 has a special focus on male cows 979 01:09:58,458 --> 01:10:01,416 who are rescued from the dairy industry. 980 01:10:37,333 --> 01:10:39,541 [water rushing] 981 01:11:08,208 --> 01:11:10,208 ♪ 982 01:11:13,541 --> 01:11:18,333 [Baur] Sanctuaries provide a sort of aspiration 983 01:11:18,375 --> 01:11:21,125 to the kind of world we could create, 984 01:11:21,166 --> 01:11:25,416 one where the animals live with us and we live with them, 985 01:11:25,458 --> 01:11:30,666 and nobody has to be afraid of anybody because we're not killing and eating them. 986 01:11:30,708 --> 01:11:34,541 Now, there are also animals that are carnivores, 987 01:11:34,583 --> 01:11:38,333 and that creates some challenging situations 988 01:11:38,375 --> 01:11:41,500 for somebody with a vegan mindset. 989 01:11:41,541 --> 01:11:45,291 But at the end of the day, certain animals don't have a choice. 990 01:11:45,333 --> 01:11:48,250 Lions cannot live on plants. 991 01:11:48,291 --> 01:11:50,708 Human beings do have a choice. 992 01:11:50,750 --> 01:11:54,583 We can live and we can thrive eating plants instead of animals. 993 01:11:54,625 --> 01:11:58,666 [narrator] The role of animals in society has evolved dramatically. 994 01:11:58,708 --> 01:12:03,500 We've learned a lot about animals' cognitive abilities and social development. 995 01:12:03,541 --> 01:12:07,041 Pigs, for example, share a number of cognitive capacities 996 01:12:07,083 --> 01:12:09,416 with other highly intelligent species, 997 01:12:09,458 --> 01:12:14,875 yet the law still considers all animals mere things. 998 01:12:14,916 --> 01:12:17,458 [woman] There are laws affecting all animals. 999 01:12:17,500 --> 01:12:20,166 Within the United States, we have the Animal Welfare Act. 1000 01:12:20,208 --> 01:12:22,041 Sadly, though it's called the Animal Welfare Act, 1001 01:12:22,083 --> 01:12:26,000 it doesn't cover farm animals, so it doesn't cover 99% of the animals 1002 01:12:26,041 --> 01:12:28,625 in industrial use in the United States, 1003 01:12:28,666 --> 01:12:30,625 and there are other important exceptions as well, 1004 01:12:30,666 --> 01:12:32,458 but let's face it, that's the big exception. 1005 01:12:32,500 --> 01:12:35,458 It's all the animals, basically, from a statistical point of view. 1006 01:12:35,500 --> 01:12:38,958 All the animals are farm animals, they're not protected by federal law. 1007 01:12:41,125 --> 01:12:45,291 [man] For hundreds of years, there's been this high, thick legal wall, 1008 01:12:45,333 --> 01:12:48,125 and on one side of that are all the legal things 1009 01:12:48,166 --> 01:12:50,125 and the other side are the legal persons. 1010 01:12:50,166 --> 01:12:52,416 If you take a snapshot in 2015, 1011 01:12:52,458 --> 01:12:55,541 all the nonhuman animals of the world are on the thing side 1012 01:12:55,583 --> 01:12:58,083 and all the human beings are on the person side. 1013 01:12:58,125 --> 01:13:00,083 It wasn't always that way. 1014 01:13:00,125 --> 01:13:02,083 Two hundred years ago, women might have been things. 1015 01:13:02,125 --> 01:13:04,333 Slaves were things, children were things, 1016 01:13:04,375 --> 01:13:08,375 but right now, all nonhuman animals are things 1017 01:13:08,416 --> 01:13:10,000 and all humans are persons. 1018 01:13:10,041 --> 01:13:12,041 And the work of the Nonhuman Rights Project, 1019 01:13:12,083 --> 01:13:14,875 especially the initial goal, is to break through that wall 1020 01:13:14,916 --> 01:13:19,958 and begin bringing as many nonhuman animals as possible 1021 01:13:20,000 --> 01:13:23,791 through that wall from the side of the things to the side of the persons. 1022 01:13:23,833 --> 01:13:26,583 Things are slaves and slaves are things. 1023 01:13:26,625 --> 01:13:29,541 When humans were slaves, they were treated horrendously. 1024 01:13:29,583 --> 01:13:33,416 Nonhumans are slaves, they're treated horrendously as well. 1025 01:13:33,458 --> 01:13:36,125 And if they're not treated horrendously, 1026 01:13:36,166 --> 01:13:39,666 like my dog Yogi who's running around here, 1027 01:13:39,708 --> 01:13:42,333 he's not treated horrendously at all. 1028 01:13:42,375 --> 01:13:45,291 He's a very happy dog. 1029 01:13:45,333 --> 01:13:49,833 But it's really because I want to treat him that way. 1030 01:13:49,875 --> 01:13:52,750 If I want him killed, he would be killed. 1031 01:13:52,791 --> 01:13:55,875 If I want to do something to him that doesn't amount to cruelty, 1032 01:13:55,916 --> 01:13:58,208 I could do something to him. 1033 01:13:58,250 --> 01:14:00,875 And that's not right. 1034 01:14:02,833 --> 01:14:04,708 [woman] Any lawyer working for social change 1035 01:14:04,750 --> 01:14:07,333 will tell you that the law usually follows society 1036 01:14:07,375 --> 01:14:09,333 and not the other way around. 1037 01:14:09,375 --> 01:14:11,666 And what we've seen over the last few decades 1038 01:14:11,708 --> 01:14:14,375 is that society has made tremendous strides 1039 01:14:14,416 --> 01:14:19,208 in understanding that animals are deserving of our compassion and our respect. 1040 01:14:19,250 --> 01:14:23,541 We now know that, in all the ways that matter, animals are just like us. 1041 01:14:23,583 --> 01:14:29,083 They feel fear, they feel pain, but they also experience joy and positive emotions. 1042 01:14:29,125 --> 01:14:32,708 One meaningful legal change that we can make for animals tomorrow 1043 01:14:32,750 --> 01:14:36,875 is to give them the right to have someone represent their interests in court. 1044 01:14:36,916 --> 01:14:39,458 Obviously animals can't speak for themselves, 1045 01:14:39,500 --> 01:14:43,458 and in that respect they're just like children or incapacitated people 1046 01:14:43,500 --> 01:14:46,583 who have special advocates who go to court for them. 1047 01:14:46,625 --> 01:14:48,750 We could set up the same system for animals 1048 01:14:48,791 --> 01:14:51,708 so that lawyers can go speak on behalf of animals, 1049 01:14:51,750 --> 01:14:54,916 represent their interests and ensure that they're protected. 1050 01:14:54,958 --> 01:14:59,541 [Sullivan] As people become more concerned, there will be more regulation. 1051 01:14:59,583 --> 01:15:01,958 Then the products will become more expensive, 1052 01:15:02,000 --> 01:15:04,666 the use will be reduced. 1053 01:15:04,708 --> 01:15:08,208 I don't think there will ever be a law against eating meat, 1054 01:15:08,250 --> 01:15:12,250 but I think that the day will come when it will become socially unacceptable. 1055 01:15:12,291 --> 01:15:15,666 I don't see... I think that it's so interesting 1056 01:15:15,708 --> 01:15:18,666 that 98% of this country eats meat. 1057 01:15:18,708 --> 01:15:22,375 It seems very unlikely that we could pass a law prohibiting it at this point, 1058 01:15:22,416 --> 01:15:24,250 and yet even at this very moment, 1059 01:15:24,291 --> 01:15:26,708 they're nervous that that could happen, 1060 01:15:26,750 --> 01:15:28,791 that their meat will be taken away from them. 1061 01:15:28,833 --> 01:15:32,333 I don't see that that's the way that the law will evolve. 1062 01:15:32,375 --> 01:15:34,666 I do see it as the way that society will evolve. 1063 01:15:34,708 --> 01:15:36,958 I do see that the law will evolve 1064 01:15:37,000 --> 01:15:40,916 to get more and more strict in its regulation of the industries. 1065 01:15:42,458 --> 01:15:45,583 [narrator] The number of plant-based alternatives is growing, 1066 01:15:45,625 --> 01:15:50,416 with taste and texture growing ever closer to actual animal products. 1067 01:15:50,458 --> 01:15:55,041 But there is something else making headlines around the world: cultured meat. 1068 01:15:55,083 --> 01:15:59,416 The same technique used to grow human tissue in regenerative medicine 1069 01:15:59,458 --> 01:16:04,583 is now used to produce meat without killing animals. 1070 01:16:04,625 --> 01:16:08,833 In August of 2013, the first hamburger grown in a lab 1071 01:16:08,875 --> 01:16:13,708 was presented to 200 journalists from around the world in London. 1072 01:16:13,750 --> 01:16:16,625 Financed by Google co-founder Sergey Brin, 1073 01:16:16,666 --> 01:16:22,708 the cost of the patty was estimated to be 250,000 Euros. 1074 01:16:22,750 --> 01:16:25,500 Okay, everyone sitting here with bated breath 1075 01:16:25,541 --> 01:16:27,666 is dying to see what's underneath the cloche, 1076 01:16:27,708 --> 01:16:31,083 so can you do the honors and lift the lid on your creation? 1077 01:16:31,125 --> 01:16:32,416 I can. 1078 01:16:32,458 --> 01:16:34,958 [woman] Okay. Now, obviously... 1079 01:16:35,000 --> 01:16:37,291 [man] Why do we need cultured meat? 1080 01:16:37,333 --> 01:16:40,375 It's basically because none of the substitutes so far 1081 01:16:40,416 --> 01:16:45,000 have been sort of capable of completely mimicking 1082 01:16:45,041 --> 01:16:47,791 the meat experience, if you like. 1083 01:16:47,833 --> 01:16:51,208 Uh, and in my mind, people want meat 1084 01:16:51,250 --> 01:16:53,375 and not meat substitutes, 1085 01:16:53,416 --> 01:16:57,166 unless the meat substitute at some point becomes so good 1086 01:16:57,208 --> 01:17:00,666 that you cannot distinguish them from the real thing. 1087 01:17:02,291 --> 01:17:05,083 Uh, we, uh... 1088 01:17:05,125 --> 01:17:08,833 [Post] Better food security for the entire population. 1089 01:17:08,875 --> 01:17:11,041 Less impact on the environment. 1090 01:17:11,083 --> 01:17:13,666 And less animal welfare issues. 1091 01:17:13,708 --> 01:17:16,083 Those are the three major concerns. 1092 01:17:16,125 --> 01:17:20,083 And for those important reasons, I really hope that at some point 1093 01:17:20,125 --> 01:17:24,416 we can deliver a product, so that people can still eat their beloved meat 1094 01:17:24,458 --> 01:17:26,750 without the negative consequences. 1095 01:17:27,875 --> 01:17:30,333 We use cells from a cow. 1096 01:17:30,375 --> 01:17:33,041 We harvest them through a harmless procedure, 1097 01:17:33,083 --> 01:17:36,541 and they have cells-- we all have cells in our muscles-- 1098 01:17:36,583 --> 01:17:39,416 that are sitting there waiting to repair an injury. 1099 01:17:39,458 --> 01:17:42,625 And they have the capacity to multiply, 1100 01:17:42,666 --> 01:17:45,083 so we take them out of the cow, 1101 01:17:45,125 --> 01:17:48,541 expand them in the lab until we have 40 billion cells. 1102 01:17:48,583 --> 01:17:50,250 And we do it in a particular way 1103 01:17:50,291 --> 01:17:53,000 so that they form real muscle fibers, 1104 01:17:53,041 --> 01:17:54,875 and that's the basis for our meat. 1105 01:17:54,916 --> 01:17:56,833 So if you have a lot of those muscle fibers, 1106 01:17:56,875 --> 01:17:59,125 we can basically make a hamburger out of them. 1107 01:18:01,458 --> 01:18:03,166 [narrator] Apart from meat, I learned 1108 01:18:03,208 --> 01:18:04,625 that there were also a number of startups 1109 01:18:04,666 --> 01:18:06,833 working on other cultured products 1110 01:18:06,875 --> 01:18:09,291 to replace their animal-derived counterparts 1111 01:18:09,333 --> 01:18:11,083 in the near future. 1112 01:18:13,666 --> 01:18:15,333 [woman] The mission of New Harvest 1113 01:18:15,375 --> 01:18:18,208 is to accelerate the post-animal bio-economy. 1114 01:18:18,250 --> 01:18:21,083 So we're trying to build a whole new economy 1115 01:18:21,125 --> 01:18:24,041 where animal products are made without animals, 1116 01:18:24,083 --> 01:18:28,750 and New Harvest's role is in providing that initial catalytic step 1117 01:18:28,791 --> 01:18:33,916 that helps researchers get a first amount of data done or a first prototype done 1118 01:18:33,958 --> 01:18:36,083 so that once they have that prototype, 1119 01:18:36,125 --> 01:18:39,791 other investors and other funders will get involved. 1120 01:18:42,041 --> 01:18:46,125 Cultured meat is getting a cell and then dividing the cell. 1121 01:18:46,166 --> 01:18:49,375 So there's no reason for GMO to be involved at all 1122 01:18:49,416 --> 01:18:52,083 in the production of cultured meat. 1123 01:18:52,125 --> 01:18:54,333 Cultured meat will not come from a lab. 1124 01:18:54,375 --> 01:18:57,541 The actual vision of this future is one that looks like a brewery, 1125 01:18:57,583 --> 01:19:01,625 and you go to a brewery and you see these gigantic stainless-steel tanks, 1126 01:19:01,666 --> 01:19:05,458 and you don't perceive the brewer as a scientist, 1127 01:19:05,500 --> 01:19:09,208 you think of him as an artisan or a crafts person. 1128 01:19:09,250 --> 01:19:13,250 You know, I've been combing the comments of cultured meat and cultured milk 1129 01:19:13,291 --> 01:19:16,166 and cultured egg articles for a long time, 1130 01:19:16,208 --> 01:19:18,791 and a lot of people are like, "Well, if this tastes as good, 1131 01:19:18,833 --> 01:19:22,166 then how could I choose something that came from a slaughtered animal 1132 01:19:22,208 --> 01:19:25,125 if what my experience is is the same?" 1133 01:19:27,833 --> 01:19:30,625 [narrator] In San Francisco, several companies are working 1134 01:19:30,666 --> 01:19:33,458 on animal products without the animal. 1135 01:19:33,500 --> 01:19:37,541 Indie Bio is a startup accelerator for synthetic biology. 1136 01:19:37,583 --> 01:19:39,708 Backed by a venture capital fund, 1137 01:19:39,750 --> 01:19:43,291 companies that join the program receive a quarter million dollars 1138 01:19:43,333 --> 01:19:47,666 and the lab space to reach a prototype in just four months. 1139 01:19:48,833 --> 01:19:50,833 [man] Indie Bio is an accelerator 1140 01:19:50,875 --> 01:19:52,833 for early stage biotechnology companies. 1141 01:19:52,875 --> 01:19:57,500 The vision was to create something totally new. 1142 01:19:57,541 --> 01:20:00,208 We think we can use biology to replace animals, 1143 01:20:00,250 --> 01:20:04,208 so instead of domesticating animals, we're domesticating cells. 1144 01:20:04,250 --> 01:20:06,583 And we're really focusing on a new paradigm 1145 01:20:06,625 --> 01:20:09,625 in producing the foods and goods that people want, 1146 01:20:09,666 --> 01:20:14,333 without the environmental or ethical aspects of using animals. 1147 01:20:19,083 --> 01:20:22,916 [man] We're making gelatin without the animal. 1148 01:20:22,958 --> 01:20:26,791 So there are a litany of consumer goods 1149 01:20:26,833 --> 01:20:30,041 that contain gelatin that many people don't realize, 1150 01:20:30,083 --> 01:20:34,041 in everything from yoghurt to gummi bears, 1151 01:20:34,083 --> 01:20:36,166 industrial applications, medicines. 1152 01:20:36,208 --> 01:20:38,000 So the approach that we're taking 1153 01:20:38,041 --> 01:20:41,000 is to engineer microbial factories 1154 01:20:41,041 --> 01:20:43,541 that can make the same exact gelatin 1155 01:20:43,583 --> 01:20:46,125 that people would get out of animal tissues, 1156 01:20:46,166 --> 01:20:50,000 but instead of taking it from an animal and doing it in a top-down approach, 1157 01:20:50,041 --> 01:20:55,500 we're building it from scratch with stuff like yeast. 1158 01:20:55,541 --> 01:20:58,000 How long will it take? Are we talking about five years? 1159 01:20:58,041 --> 01:21:00,541 Are we talking about ten years? I hope it's five, 1160 01:21:00,583 --> 01:21:04,000 when we see the last animal product taken off the shelf 1161 01:21:04,041 --> 01:21:09,083 and replaced with a biologically derived, clean version of that product, 1162 01:21:09,125 --> 01:21:11,958 whether it's meat or whether it's milk or whether it's eggs. 1163 01:21:14,291 --> 01:21:17,541 [narrator] Not far away, in a space for DIY biology, 1164 01:21:17,583 --> 01:21:22,333 a group of biohackers is working on what most people say they could never give up: 1165 01:21:22,375 --> 01:21:24,458 cheese. 1166 01:21:24,500 --> 01:21:26,916 [man] Real Vegan Cheese is a project 1167 01:21:26,958 --> 01:21:28,833 to basically make cheese 1168 01:21:28,875 --> 01:21:31,541 that is exactly like cow's milk cheese, 1169 01:21:31,583 --> 01:21:35,875 or any other animal cheese, but make it without using animals. 1170 01:21:35,916 --> 01:21:39,916 And so the way we do this is we search databases 1171 01:21:39,958 --> 01:21:45,458 that give us the sequence of DNA which encodes for the proteins in milk. 1172 01:21:45,500 --> 01:21:49,666 We then take that information and go to a synthesis service 1173 01:21:49,708 --> 01:21:51,625 that makes us that snippet of DNA. 1174 01:21:51,666 --> 01:21:53,791 We put it into yeast. 1175 01:21:53,833 --> 01:21:56,625 That yeast then starts producing that protein. 1176 01:21:56,666 --> 01:21:59,833 So now these yeasts are sort of like our dairy. 1177 01:21:59,875 --> 01:22:02,291 Sort of like, instead of milking cows, 1178 01:22:02,333 --> 01:22:04,791 we're actually just getting these proteins out of the yeast. 1179 01:22:04,833 --> 01:22:07,291 This is important because these proteins 1180 01:22:07,333 --> 01:22:10,583 are what give milk all of its really interesting properties 1181 01:22:10,625 --> 01:22:13,416 and what gives cheese the properties that you associate with cheese. 1182 01:22:13,458 --> 01:22:16,500 Things like meltability, stretchability, that texture. 1183 01:22:16,541 --> 01:22:19,208 Those proteins are the most important thing. 1184 01:22:19,250 --> 01:22:21,208 So that's what the project is. 1185 01:22:21,250 --> 01:22:23,791 It's taking yeast and making these exact same proteins 1186 01:22:23,833 --> 01:22:27,208 so we can make real cheese which is also vegan. 1187 01:22:27,250 --> 01:22:29,208 [device rattling] 1188 01:22:29,250 --> 01:22:31,458 What we get out, if we do our job well, 1189 01:22:31,500 --> 01:22:33,125 is exactly like what the cows produce. 1190 01:22:33,166 --> 01:22:34,875 The protein is identical. 1191 01:22:34,916 --> 01:22:37,791 So once it's purified, this is not genetically modified. 1192 01:22:37,833 --> 01:22:39,541 It's a natural product. 1193 01:22:41,916 --> 01:22:45,000 So our future plans, once we can make cheese 1194 01:22:45,041 --> 01:22:47,833 out of our yeast-cultured proteins, 1195 01:22:47,875 --> 01:22:52,916 are to file intellectual property, file a patent on this, 1196 01:22:52,958 --> 01:22:56,000 but then abandon it, so that it is in the public record, 1197 01:22:56,041 --> 01:22:58,541 it is prior art but we don't own any rights to it. 1198 01:22:58,583 --> 01:23:01,916 You could imagine that if someone like, uh... 1199 01:23:01,958 --> 01:23:04,958 someone who is also involved in the dairy industry directly, 1200 01:23:05,000 --> 01:23:07,916 if they developed this and owned all the IP, 1201 01:23:07,958 --> 01:23:10,958 they could make a few products just for vegans 1202 01:23:11,000 --> 01:23:14,125 but they could prevent someone else from pushing it far enough 1203 01:23:14,166 --> 01:23:16,375 that it would challenge their existing business. 1204 01:23:16,416 --> 01:23:20,500 So we don't want someone who has an interest in dairy continuing 1205 01:23:20,541 --> 01:23:23,416 to own all of the rights to this. 1206 01:23:23,458 --> 01:23:26,208 If it's open source, no one can do that. 1207 01:23:29,041 --> 01:23:31,958 [narrator] While I was researching future foods, 1208 01:23:32,000 --> 01:23:34,666 I came across a recent discovery by scientists 1209 01:23:34,708 --> 01:23:36,208 from the University of Oregon. 1210 01:23:36,250 --> 01:23:38,583 They said they had found the unicorn, 1211 01:23:38,625 --> 01:23:40,958 an algae that is healthier than kale 1212 01:23:41,000 --> 01:23:44,666 and when deep fried, tastes like bacon. 1213 01:23:47,208 --> 01:23:50,666 [man] We started out with about 40 or so ideas. 1214 01:23:50,708 --> 01:23:55,958 And today I have three of the five that we tested. 1215 01:23:56,000 --> 01:24:00,791 This here is a rice cracker. These are going to be a little bit more savory 1216 01:24:00,833 --> 01:24:05,041 and bring out a little bit of that umami taste that's in the seaweed. 1217 01:24:05,083 --> 01:24:07,375 And then this is just kind of an interesting way 1218 01:24:07,416 --> 01:24:10,708 to use a bit of the salt that you would find 1219 01:24:10,750 --> 01:24:13,041 in kind of those ocean tastes. 1220 01:24:13,083 --> 01:24:15,250 Dulse is a bit of a novel ingredient 1221 01:24:15,291 --> 01:24:17,958 that many people in America aren't very familiar with, 1222 01:24:18,000 --> 01:24:20,458 outside of sushi or seaweed salads. 1223 01:24:20,500 --> 01:24:23,291 So it's nice to kind of be at the forefront 1224 01:24:23,333 --> 01:24:27,125 of getting this ingredient into kind of the mainstream. 1225 01:24:27,166 --> 01:24:30,708 [sizzling] 1226 01:24:30,750 --> 01:24:35,375 [man] You know, in 2025, there will be 7 1/2 billion people on Earth. 1227 01:24:35,416 --> 01:24:37,375 And every human being 1228 01:24:37,416 --> 01:24:41,208 needs roughly 50 grams of protein a day to live, 1229 01:24:41,250 --> 01:24:46,583 so the world's gonna demand 400 million grams of carbohydrates a day. 1230 01:24:46,625 --> 01:24:50,666 And we figured out that, at least with this dulse, 1231 01:24:50,708 --> 01:24:53,875 if we had a 25 by 25 mile stretch in the ocean 1232 01:24:53,916 --> 01:24:55,833 off the Oregon coast, 1233 01:24:55,875 --> 01:24:58,750 we could grow enough protein to feed the world, just like that. 1234 01:24:58,791 --> 01:25:02,125 So the potential is extremely large. 1235 01:25:02,166 --> 01:25:04,375 [thunder rumbling] 1236 01:25:07,708 --> 01:25:12,333 [man] Uh, well, people got very interested in the dulse story 1237 01:25:12,375 --> 01:25:14,875 because of its link to bacon, 1238 01:25:14,916 --> 01:25:18,458 and the fact that it has some of the flavors of bacon 1239 01:25:18,500 --> 01:25:22,583 and is also nutritionally much better for you than bacon, 1240 01:25:22,625 --> 01:25:25,583 it doesn't have the cholesterol and the high-fat content, 1241 01:25:25,625 --> 01:25:28,000 makes it very appealing to people. 1242 01:25:35,500 --> 01:25:38,500 Ah, how are the dulse looking? 1243 01:25:38,541 --> 01:25:41,125 Ah. Looking good. 1244 01:25:41,166 --> 01:25:43,958 Yeah. That's fantastic. 1245 01:25:44,000 --> 01:25:45,375 Bubbling away. 1246 01:25:47,708 --> 01:25:52,000 So these are our 6,000-liter tanks. 1247 01:25:52,041 --> 01:25:56,208 So we're hoping to produce about 30 pounds of dulse per week 1248 01:25:56,250 --> 01:25:57,750 from these tanks. 1249 01:26:00,750 --> 01:26:04,541 What we found with dulse is that it grows vegetatively. 1250 01:26:04,583 --> 01:26:08,375 So what you can do is you can basically break a plant apart 1251 01:26:08,416 --> 01:26:11,166 and each piece will grow into a new plant. 1252 01:26:11,208 --> 01:26:13,458 So it's very, very easy to grow, 1253 01:26:13,500 --> 01:26:15,416 and this is one of the great benefits 1254 01:26:15,458 --> 01:26:18,791 of this type of cultivation. 1255 01:26:20,583 --> 01:26:23,250 It has a good protein content, 1256 01:26:23,291 --> 01:26:25,583 high iodine, high potassium. 1257 01:26:25,625 --> 01:26:29,250 And so in many respects, it is a superfood. 1258 01:26:31,375 --> 01:26:34,541 It has a lot of potential, I think, in the long-term future 1259 01:26:34,583 --> 01:26:38,416 as an alternative to some of these other terrestrial crops, 1260 01:26:38,458 --> 01:26:41,500 and also an alternative to meat. 1261 01:26:41,541 --> 01:26:44,541 So the amino acid profile is pretty good, 1262 01:26:44,583 --> 01:26:46,500 and it has the savory flavor, 1263 01:26:46,541 --> 01:26:51,166 so I think there's a very good potential for it. 1264 01:27:08,458 --> 01:27:12,500 [Post] So, what we are doing, we are taking a small sample from a cow. 1265 01:27:12,541 --> 01:27:17,541 Use its muscle-specific stem cells 1266 01:27:17,583 --> 01:27:20,583 that have sort of a limited capacity to proliferate. 1267 01:27:20,625 --> 01:27:23,958 That means that we have to go back to the cow after a certain period 1268 01:27:24,000 --> 01:27:26,125 and get new stem cells. 1269 01:27:26,166 --> 01:27:29,291 And then it's not a completely animal-free product, 1270 01:27:29,333 --> 01:27:32,750 but I don't really think that's that important. 1271 01:27:32,791 --> 01:27:35,666 Maybe for vegans it is, but for most people, it may not be. 1272 01:27:35,708 --> 01:27:39,000 Still we would be able, and that's obviously the condition, 1273 01:27:39,041 --> 01:27:42,166 we would be able to reduce the total number of cows tremendously. 1274 01:27:42,208 --> 01:27:47,791 Even if it will not reduce energy consumption, 1275 01:27:47,833 --> 01:27:51,750 then it will still reduce methane emission, 1276 01:27:51,791 --> 01:27:55,875 so it will still have an effect on our greenhouse gas emission. 1277 01:27:55,916 --> 01:27:58,208 But we are more ambitious than that. 1278 01:27:58,250 --> 01:28:00,875 We really want to reduce energy consumption as well. 1279 01:28:02,583 --> 01:28:04,375 I'm saying that there's nothing in it, 1280 01:28:04,416 --> 01:28:06,625 but that's not completely true. 1281 01:28:06,666 --> 01:28:08,041 There is... 1282 01:28:08,083 --> 01:28:11,416 Oh, this is just a small-scale cell culture, 1283 01:28:11,458 --> 01:28:13,125 but it's tiny. 1284 01:28:13,166 --> 01:28:17,958 Tiny muscle rings in these little wells. 1285 01:28:18,000 --> 01:28:20,875 We are never, with this cultured beef program, 1286 01:28:20,916 --> 01:28:22,875 are never going to be as efficient 1287 01:28:22,916 --> 01:28:25,708 and as friendly to the environment 1288 01:28:25,750 --> 01:28:29,291 or to animals as a vegetarian or a vegan diet. 1289 01:28:29,333 --> 01:28:33,416 We will never achieve that level of efficiency. 1290 01:28:33,458 --> 01:28:38,041 So if vegetarians and vegans start to eat this, 1291 01:28:38,083 --> 01:28:41,208 that's sort of the opposite of what my goal is 1292 01:28:41,250 --> 01:28:43,208 in this whole endeavor. 1293 01:28:46,833 --> 01:28:49,166 The target group is pretty much myself, 1294 01:28:49,208 --> 01:28:53,125 the people who are stubbornly eating meat, 1295 01:28:53,166 --> 01:28:55,750 while knowing that they probably should not. 1296 01:28:57,791 --> 01:29:00,208 If at some point we are capable 1297 01:29:00,250 --> 01:29:02,875 of producing exactly the same tissue, 1298 01:29:02,916 --> 01:29:05,666 exactly the same sort of sensory quality of meat, 1299 01:29:05,708 --> 01:29:08,166 at a competitive price, 1300 01:29:08,208 --> 01:29:13,666 I think it will eradicate traditional livestock meat production. 1301 01:29:19,541 --> 01:29:21,916 [Nibert] It's absolutely imperative 1302 01:29:21,958 --> 01:29:24,291 that people recognize 1303 01:29:24,333 --> 01:29:29,125 that one of the worst practices ever developed on the planet 1304 01:29:29,166 --> 01:29:33,166 was this consumption of other animals for food and using them for resources, 1305 01:29:33,208 --> 01:29:36,000 and we're never going to get our societies back on track 1306 01:29:36,041 --> 01:29:38,583 unless we step back from that practice, 1307 01:29:38,625 --> 01:29:41,208 and we can begin to do that, first of all, 1308 01:29:41,250 --> 01:29:42,833 by changing the way that we eat. 1309 01:29:42,875 --> 01:29:45,291 Nothing serious is going to change 1310 01:29:45,333 --> 01:29:49,291 until there's just a catastrophe that forces us to change. 1311 01:29:49,333 --> 01:29:53,375 And my best guess, it would be something related to the... 1312 01:29:53,416 --> 01:29:56,041 It could be an issue about tainted food, 1313 01:29:56,083 --> 01:29:58,875 but more likely it's going to be an environmental catastrophe 1314 01:29:58,916 --> 01:30:02,541 that we just realize that we're killing the planet, and then... 1315 01:30:02,583 --> 01:30:05,166 we'll be forced to engage in some radical rethinking, 1316 01:30:05,208 --> 01:30:06,958 not because we suddenly care about animals 1317 01:30:07,000 --> 01:30:08,875 but just because we're destroying our own existence. 1318 01:30:11,166 --> 01:30:14,250 [narrator] Reflecting on my search for a post-meat world, 1319 01:30:14,291 --> 01:30:18,041 the resource-intensive methods of animal production seem outdated, 1320 01:30:18,083 --> 01:30:21,083 especially in the light of the challenges 1321 01:30:21,125 --> 01:30:23,500 we'll face in the near and far future. 1322 01:30:23,541 --> 01:30:26,583 What we eat has tangible consequences, 1323 01:30:26,625 --> 01:30:28,208 for the world around us 1324 01:30:28,250 --> 01:30:31,458 and for the trillions of nonhuman animals. 1325 01:30:31,500 --> 01:30:33,500 The end of meat as we know it 1326 01:30:33,541 --> 01:30:36,000 might just be the best solution we have 1327 01:30:36,041 --> 01:30:40,208 to save ourselves, the animals and the planet. 1328 01:30:43,083 --> 01:30:47,083 Of course, if we're talking about stopping meat overnight, 1329 01:30:47,125 --> 01:30:51,000 that would be a problem because overnight we'd have lots of people going jobless. 1330 01:30:51,041 --> 01:30:54,000 But the truth is that all industries evolve. 1331 01:30:54,041 --> 01:30:56,125 Everything changes. 1332 01:30:56,166 --> 01:30:59,291 If you talk to people about cars coming, for example, 1333 01:30:59,333 --> 01:31:02,291 everybody would be worrying, what's going to happen to the horse carriages? 1334 01:31:02,333 --> 01:31:05,833 Right? But it doesn't happen overnight, thankfully, and everybody adapts. 1335 01:31:30,833 --> 01:31:32,833 ♪ 1336 01:31:55,416 --> 01:31:58,333 [Sullivan] There is a vision of the future 1337 01:31:58,375 --> 01:32:01,958 that doesn't include the exploitation of animals. 1338 01:32:02,000 --> 01:32:06,333 You don't get somewhere unless you envision it. 1339 01:32:06,375 --> 01:32:09,083 And people really seem to have trouble envisioning 1340 01:32:09,125 --> 01:32:12,125 this world without animal exploitation. 1341 01:32:12,166 --> 01:32:15,083 We've always done it, so we'll always continue to do it. 1342 01:32:15,125 --> 01:32:17,041 But if you take a step back 1343 01:32:17,083 --> 01:32:19,791 and look at where technology is, 1344 01:32:19,833 --> 01:32:22,541 what we do to animals is just insane. 1345 01:32:31,750 --> 01:32:35,208 [Brown] The first time I had visited a farm animal sanctuary, 1346 01:32:35,250 --> 01:32:37,125 blew my mind. 1347 01:32:37,166 --> 01:32:39,125 There was nothing like it. 1348 01:32:39,166 --> 01:32:42,625 I could not believe, not only what I was learning at the time 1349 01:32:42,666 --> 01:32:45,000 about the sheer number of farmed animals 1350 01:32:45,041 --> 01:32:48,208 who suffer and who are killed for human consumption, 1351 01:32:48,250 --> 01:32:50,583 but then to get to know them 1352 01:32:50,625 --> 01:32:53,583 and to realize that these are the individuals 1353 01:32:53,625 --> 01:32:56,375 who make up those statistics, 1354 01:32:56,416 --> 01:32:58,375 and the statistics can be staggering, 1355 01:32:58,416 --> 01:33:00,500 but it's even more overwhelming 1356 01:33:00,541 --> 01:33:03,166 when you get to know the victims. 1357 01:33:03,208 --> 01:33:06,041 And that affects me to every cell of my being, 1358 01:33:06,083 --> 01:33:09,458 because this is the social justice movement of our times. 1359 01:33:09,500 --> 01:33:12,166 It affects the most number of beings. 1360 01:33:16,708 --> 01:33:19,208 [Post] Twenty years from now, we will look back 1361 01:33:19,250 --> 01:33:21,416 with a completely different perspective 1362 01:33:21,458 --> 01:33:23,958 and our kids will say to each other, 1363 01:33:24,000 --> 01:33:27,041 "Well, you know, in the days of our parents, 1364 01:33:27,083 --> 01:33:31,166 they still killed animals for our food supply." 1365 01:33:31,208 --> 01:33:35,041 And they will probably look at that as sort of barbarian. 1366 01:33:39,000 --> 01:33:42,000 ♪ 116174

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.