Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:07,921 --> 00:00:13,988
**
2
00:00:13,988 --> 00:00:16,888
Berlinger: In the small town
of Chillicothe, Ohio,
3
00:00:16,888 --> 00:00:19,221
six women have gone missing --
4
00:00:19,221 --> 00:00:21,654
young mothers
caught in a vicious cycle
5
00:00:21,654 --> 00:00:24,554
of addiction and prostitution.
6
00:00:24,554 --> 00:00:27,054
Four of them
have turned up dead.
7
00:00:27,054 --> 00:00:32,621
Woman: I found a woman's body
in the creek.
8
00:00:32,621 --> 00:00:34,054
Berlinger:
I'm Joe Berlinger.
9
00:00:34,054 --> 00:00:37,488
I'm a documentary filmmaker
and an activist.
10
00:00:37,488 --> 00:00:39,954
I'm working with
forensic intelligence analyst
11
00:00:39,954 --> 00:00:41,221
Angela Clemente
12
00:00:41,221 --> 00:00:44,488
and former FBI agent
Steve Bongardt...
13
00:00:44,488 --> 00:00:46,121
We'd really like
to talk to you.
14
00:00:46,121 --> 00:00:49,154
...to find out what
happened to these women.
15
00:00:49,154 --> 00:00:50,454
We got to get justice.
16
00:00:50,454 --> 00:00:53,488
All of us in here
have to get justice.
17
00:00:53,488 --> 00:00:56,121
Berlinger: As we delve deeper
into these cases,
18
00:00:56,121 --> 00:00:58,021
our investigation expanded
19
00:00:58,021 --> 00:01:02,454
to nine victims
across three cities in Ohio.
20
00:01:02,454 --> 00:01:05,854
A prominent drug trafficker
in the area,
21
00:01:05,854 --> 00:01:08,188
Ernest "Dollar Bill" Moore,
22
00:01:08,188 --> 00:01:10,954
emerged as a common
person of interest
23
00:01:10,954 --> 00:01:14,621
in more than half
of the victims' cases.
24
00:01:14,621 --> 00:01:16,854
All the girls
that have passed away
25
00:01:16,854 --> 00:01:19,554
and that have, you know,
been found missing,
26
00:01:19,554 --> 00:01:22,721
Dollar Bill knew
every one of them.
27
00:01:22,721 --> 00:01:25,088
And in the death
of Tameka Lynch,
28
00:01:25,088 --> 00:01:27,288
sources point to Crail Brooks,
29
00:01:27,288 --> 00:01:29,588
a man who worked
with Dollar Bill.
30
00:01:29,588 --> 00:01:34,288
**
31
00:01:34,288 --> 00:01:37,854
And now we're on the verge
of a major breakthrough
32
00:01:37,854 --> 00:01:42,088
that could blow
this investigation wide open.
33
00:01:42,088 --> 00:01:45,288
So there's potentially
a graveyard out there.
34
00:01:45,288 --> 00:01:47,888
Yeah. We could have
a killing field out here.
35
00:01:47,888 --> 00:01:50,454
Ruth: There's somebody out there
that knows what went on,
36
00:01:50,454 --> 00:01:52,688
but they just won't tell
because they're scared.
37
00:01:52,688 --> 00:01:54,688
Magill:
So we pray, "Our Father..."
38
00:01:54,688 --> 00:01:57,088
Heather:
He put the gun to my chest,
and he said, "Live or die."
39
00:01:57,088 --> 00:01:58,888
Landrum:
Everybody who knows information
40
00:01:58,888 --> 00:02:01,521
that tries to come out and talk
about it, they end up dead.
41
00:02:01,521 --> 00:02:03,154
Coleman: He gave her
a hot shot of heroin.
42
00:02:03,154 --> 00:02:05,354
Kellough: And I said,
"I know who your son is,
43
00:02:05,354 --> 00:02:07,621
and I know what he did, too."
44
00:02:07,621 --> 00:02:10,254
Sam: If she's out there,
please just let her go
45
00:02:10,254 --> 00:02:13,321
[Echoing]
and let her come home.
46
00:02:13,321 --> 00:02:15,788
[ Cheers and applause ]
47
00:02:15,788 --> 00:02:18,588
**
48
00:02:18,588 --> 00:02:21,621
[ Indistinct chanting ]
49
00:02:21,621 --> 00:02:23,488
Hayes: You can't even walk into
a public restroom
50
00:02:23,488 --> 00:02:25,121
without seeing the remains
of someone
51
00:02:25,121 --> 00:02:28,288
who's been struggling
with a drug addiction.
52
00:02:28,288 --> 00:02:30,088
We're not going to be
that generation
53
00:02:30,088 --> 00:02:32,588
that leaves the remains of
our struggles and our addictions
54
00:02:32,588 --> 00:02:35,854
laying around for the other
people to have to bear with us.
55
00:02:35,854 --> 00:02:39,288
Berlinger:
Despite the opiate epidemic
that our country is facing,
56
00:02:39,288 --> 00:02:42,088
the next generation
is taking on the problem
57
00:02:42,088 --> 00:02:43,321
and making a difference.
58
00:02:43,321 --> 00:02:45,854
[ All chant indistinctly ]
59
00:02:45,854 --> 00:02:48,821
High school kids
across Southern Ohio
60
00:02:48,821 --> 00:02:52,621
are signing up in record numbers
for voluntary drug testing
61
00:02:52,621 --> 00:02:55,954
as part of a unique program
called MADE.
62
00:02:55,954 --> 00:02:57,688
**
63
00:02:57,688 --> 00:03:02,388
MADE is an acronym for "My
Attitude Determines Everything."
64
00:03:02,388 --> 00:03:03,988
The unique thing
about this program
65
00:03:03,988 --> 00:03:05,588
is that it is student led.
66
00:03:05,588 --> 00:03:07,721
It is students
around you saying,
67
00:03:07,721 --> 00:03:10,088
"Hey, there's
a better option."
68
00:03:10,088 --> 00:03:12,088
I have great pride
in my town,
69
00:03:12,088 --> 00:03:16,721
and I've seen what drugs
have done to it.
70
00:03:16,721 --> 00:03:20,188
And I don't want to see
drugs take over.
71
00:03:20,188 --> 00:03:25,521
And this club has given us the
power to affect those our age,
72
00:03:25,521 --> 00:03:27,754
and that's going
to affect our future.
73
00:03:27,754 --> 00:03:30,254
It's so refreshing
to talk to you guys.
74
00:03:30,254 --> 00:03:33,421
I mean, really,
it's very inspiring.
75
00:03:33,421 --> 00:03:35,921
Although the future
looks bright for these kids,
76
00:03:35,921 --> 00:03:38,321
there is much to be done today.
77
00:03:38,321 --> 00:03:41,088
**
78
00:03:41,088 --> 00:03:43,088
All of the missing
and murdered women
79
00:03:43,088 --> 00:03:45,421
were victims of the drug scourge
80
00:03:45,421 --> 00:03:48,521
that is currently
plaguing the nation.
81
00:03:48,521 --> 00:03:50,688
Throne: There is no question
in my mind --
82
00:03:50,688 --> 00:03:53,888
multiple people
know what happened
83
00:03:53,888 --> 00:03:56,221
with all of these women,
84
00:03:56,221 --> 00:03:59,321
and we need those folks
to come forward.
85
00:03:59,321 --> 00:04:01,988
[ Sobbing ]
86
00:04:01,988 --> 00:04:04,088
The families need it.
87
00:04:04,088 --> 00:04:06,221
Law enforcement needs it.
88
00:04:06,221 --> 00:04:08,588
The community needs it.
89
00:04:08,588 --> 00:04:11,154
It's always in the back
of our heads, you know?
90
00:04:11,154 --> 00:04:13,788
What -- What happened?
91
00:04:13,788 --> 00:04:16,554
**
92
00:04:16,554 --> 00:04:19,121
Berlinger: In the case
of Shasta Himelrick...
93
00:04:20,754 --> 00:04:24,554
...we uncover shocking
new information linking her
94
00:04:24,554 --> 00:04:28,321
to one of Chillicothe's
most notorious drug dealers.
95
00:04:28,321 --> 00:04:33,888
**
96
00:04:33,888 --> 00:04:37,154
All right. Let's talk about
Shasta Himelrick,
97
00:04:37,154 --> 00:04:41,921
last seen alive
on December 26, 2014.
98
00:04:41,921 --> 00:04:43,888
Man: Today, the Ross County
coroner confirmed
99
00:04:43,888 --> 00:04:46,121
the body pulled
from the Scioto River yesterday
100
00:04:46,121 --> 00:04:47,488
was Shasta Himelrick.
101
00:04:47,488 --> 00:04:49,388
The coroner said she drowned.
102
00:04:49,388 --> 00:04:51,954
**
103
00:04:51,954 --> 00:04:56,621
Ruled a suicide. Family doesn't
believe it was a suicide.
104
00:04:56,621 --> 00:05:01,088
Clemente: She was pregnant,
and she was excited about it.
105
00:05:01,088 --> 00:05:03,988
Shortly before her death,
Shasta discovered
106
00:05:03,988 --> 00:05:08,521
she was going to have a baby
with her boyfriend, Mike Owes.
107
00:05:08,521 --> 00:05:13,221
Dutchess:
December 16th of 2014, she said,
108
00:05:13,221 --> 00:05:15,454
"I found out that
I'm having a baby.
109
00:05:15,454 --> 00:05:18,221
I'm just so happy.
I really want this."
110
00:05:18,221 --> 00:05:22,988
And that was the end
of our conversation.
111
00:05:22,988 --> 00:05:27,221
Berlinger:
Although friends and family
say she inherited $50,000,
112
00:05:27,221 --> 00:05:32,721
Shasta's financial records
show a deposit of just $35,800
113
00:05:32,721 --> 00:05:37,721
after her father died
in August of 2014.
114
00:05:37,721 --> 00:05:40,521
Reportedly, most of it
was spent on drugs
115
00:05:40,521 --> 00:05:44,188
and her boyfriend, Mike Owes,
who has a long rap sheet,
116
00:05:44,188 --> 00:05:48,388
including assault
and drug possession.
117
00:05:48,388 --> 00:05:51,121
I got Shasta's
bank statements.
118
00:05:51,121 --> 00:05:56,721
On 12/26, sometime between
midnight and 3:15 a.m.,
119
00:05:56,721 --> 00:05:58,821
she takes out $20,
120
00:05:58,821 --> 00:06:02,721
and then later,
$43 at the Speedway,
121
00:06:02,721 --> 00:06:05,221
and that was the last
of her money.
122
00:06:05,221 --> 00:06:07,454
Mm.
123
00:06:07,454 --> 00:06:13,688
Who would go to the ATM
at 3:15 at the Speedway,
124
00:06:13,688 --> 00:06:15,288
not buy anything,
125
00:06:15,288 --> 00:06:18,188
and just withdraw
your last bit of money
126
00:06:18,188 --> 00:06:20,454
if you're intending
to kill yourself?
127
00:06:20,454 --> 00:06:23,954
That doesn't
make sense to me.
128
00:06:23,954 --> 00:06:27,088
Winfield: That night, Shasta had
text messages back and forth
129
00:06:27,088 --> 00:06:28,788
between Michael Owes,
130
00:06:28,788 --> 00:06:31,721
which, you know, turns this
into a disagreement.
131
00:06:31,721 --> 00:06:34,854
Shasta wanted Michael
to stay with her
132
00:06:34,854 --> 00:06:37,121
because it was their first
Christmas together.
133
00:06:37,121 --> 00:06:40,688
He had went out to another house
134
00:06:40,688 --> 00:06:43,388
where he had a known girl
135
00:06:43,388 --> 00:06:46,588
that he had associated
with in the past.
136
00:06:46,588 --> 00:06:49,088
Berlinger:
Shasta's last text to Mike Owes
137
00:06:49,088 --> 00:06:53,421
was at 3:33 a.m. on the night
she went missing.
138
00:06:53,421 --> 00:06:55,421
This message reportedly revealed
139
00:06:55,421 --> 00:06:59,088
Shasta's despondent
state of mind
140
00:06:59,088 --> 00:07:02,454
and seemed to tip the scales
in the coroner's decision
141
00:07:02,454 --> 00:07:05,854
to rule her death a suicide.
142
00:07:05,854 --> 00:07:08,921
Woman:
If you hadn't had
143
00:07:08,921 --> 00:07:11,821
the text messages
on that phone,
144
00:07:11,821 --> 00:07:14,921
would you have
ruled differently?
145
00:07:14,921 --> 00:07:19,254
It's hard to say if I would
have ruled differently.
146
00:07:19,254 --> 00:07:22,254
If we didn't have
the text messages --
147
00:07:22,254 --> 00:07:26,421
That's a very hard thing
to guess at.
148
00:07:26,421 --> 00:07:29,521
If I had no other evidence,
149
00:07:29,521 --> 00:07:33,654
I would have had to say
likely undetermined.
150
00:07:33,654 --> 00:07:37,788
Berlinger:
Shasta's abandoned car was found
near the railroad tracks
151
00:07:37,788 --> 00:07:42,821
next to the Higby Road Bridge
at 7:32 a.m.
152
00:07:42,821 --> 00:07:47,321
The driver and passenger-side
doors were wide open.
153
00:07:47,321 --> 00:07:49,154
**
154
00:07:49,154 --> 00:07:51,788
Winfield: There was blood that
was found inside her vehicle,
155
00:07:51,788 --> 00:07:53,788
on the cellphone,
156
00:07:53,788 --> 00:07:56,321
and then in the front part
of the vehicle, as well.
157
00:07:56,321 --> 00:07:59,521
There was indications
that she had self-mutilated
158
00:07:59,521 --> 00:08:01,254
with a razor blade.
159
00:08:01,254 --> 00:08:04,188
We're seeing a lot more of that
with the drug trade,
160
00:08:04,188 --> 00:08:07,088
where people is, you know,
cutting their self a lot.
161
00:08:07,088 --> 00:08:09,421
But I know that
those incision marks
162
00:08:09,421 --> 00:08:11,688
did not cause her
to bleed to death.
163
00:08:11,688 --> 00:08:15,321
Those did not contribute
to her death.
164
00:08:15,321 --> 00:08:17,554
Dutchess:
It just doesn't make any sense.
165
00:08:17,554 --> 00:08:19,554
I don't think Shasta
committed suicide.
166
00:08:19,554 --> 00:08:22,554
I think somebody had
threw her off the bridge.
167
00:08:22,554 --> 00:08:29,921
**
168
00:08:29,921 --> 00:08:31,721
Pettler:
It's the location on the bridge,
169
00:08:31,721 --> 00:08:35,088
I think, that's so
significant to us here.
170
00:08:35,088 --> 00:08:38,088
It's so close to the shore.
171
00:08:38,088 --> 00:08:39,688
It's not the middle.
172
00:08:39,688 --> 00:08:41,854
-That's pretty shallow.
-Yeah.
173
00:08:41,854 --> 00:08:44,588
Berlinger:
After reviewing Shasta's case,
174
00:08:44,588 --> 00:08:47,254
Laura Pettler,
a forensic criminologist
175
00:08:47,254 --> 00:08:49,921
who specializes
in crime-scene staging,
176
00:08:49,921 --> 00:08:52,221
takes Angela and Steve
to the bridge
177
00:08:52,221 --> 00:08:56,554
where 20-year-old Shasta
allegedly jumped to her death.
178
00:08:56,554 --> 00:09:01,088
Oddly, her shoes were found
perfectly placed together.
179
00:09:01,088 --> 00:09:03,121
Would it be more
consistent with suicide
180
00:09:03,121 --> 00:09:05,088
to jump in the deep water?
Yes.
181
00:09:05,088 --> 00:09:07,288
Rather than jump
in the shallow water?
182
00:09:07,288 --> 00:09:08,954
Yes.
183
00:09:08,954 --> 00:09:11,821
**
184
00:09:11,821 --> 00:09:13,388
Pettler:
In the National Weather Service,
185
00:09:13,388 --> 00:09:16,921
it reported that
the water in this river
186
00:09:16,921 --> 00:09:18,888
crested at
three feet that night.
187
00:09:18,888 --> 00:09:20,654
Bongardt:
Mm. That's it.
188
00:09:20,654 --> 00:09:23,121
You would think from that kind
of a fall in shallow water,
189
00:09:23,121 --> 00:09:25,221
you might have a chance
of injuring yourself.
190
00:09:25,221 --> 00:09:27,921
Berlinger: But according
to the autopsy report,
191
00:09:27,921 --> 00:09:32,254
there were no injuries
on Shasta's body.
192
00:09:32,254 --> 00:09:34,921
Pettler:
We know from the victimology
that she was a good swimmer.
193
00:09:34,921 --> 00:09:38,654
Clemente: She was a very good
swimmer, and she loved water.
194
00:09:38,654 --> 00:09:41,088
Berlinger: How could an
accomplished swimmer like Shasta
195
00:09:41,088 --> 00:09:45,888
have jumped off a 40-foot bridge
into less than 3 feet of water
196
00:09:45,888 --> 00:09:50,588
and drowned to death and have no
physical injuries to her body?
197
00:09:50,588 --> 00:09:53,088
**
198
00:09:53,088 --> 00:09:55,988
There is such a thing
as a perfect homicide,
199
00:09:55,988 --> 00:09:58,954
and usually, it revolves
around a staged suicide, right?
200
00:09:58,954 --> 00:10:01,821
Is it possible
that Shasta's shoes
201
00:10:01,821 --> 00:10:05,621
were placed on the bridge
to make it look like she jumped?
202
00:10:05,621 --> 00:10:07,921
**
203
00:10:07,921 --> 00:10:11,588
Police checked out
Mike Owes' alibi.
204
00:10:11,588 --> 00:10:13,588
Lavender:
Michael Owes was investigated.
205
00:10:13,588 --> 00:10:15,088
He took a polygraph,
206
00:10:15,088 --> 00:10:17,788
and he was pretty much cleared
by polygraph.
207
00:10:17,788 --> 00:10:20,221
Berlinger: But according to
a confidential source
208
00:10:20,221 --> 00:10:21,788
we're calling "Timothy,"
209
00:10:21,788 --> 00:10:25,321
Shasta may have been hiding
a deadly secret.
210
00:10:25,321 --> 00:10:28,288
What about the theory
that Shasta was an informant?
211
00:10:28,288 --> 00:10:29,521
You had heard that?
212
00:10:34,654 --> 00:10:38,288
**
213
00:10:38,288 --> 00:10:41,354
What about the theory
that Shasta was an informant?
214
00:10:41,354 --> 00:10:42,788
You had heard that?
215
00:10:42,788 --> 00:10:46,221
**
216
00:10:46,221 --> 00:10:51,021
Berlinger:
News that Shasta may have been
a police informant is troubling,
217
00:10:51,021 --> 00:10:53,688
especially when some
of our confidential sources
218
00:10:53,688 --> 00:10:56,554
tell us that Mike Owes ran drugs
219
00:10:56,554 --> 00:11:01,988
for one of Ohio's most brutal
drug dealers, Dollar Bill,
220
00:11:01,988 --> 00:11:04,088
and even more alarming,
221
00:11:04,088 --> 00:11:08,654
that Shasta herself was also
connected to Dollar Bill.
222
00:11:08,654 --> 00:11:10,988
Shasta and Dollar Bill
were together?
Mm-hmm.
223
00:11:10,988 --> 00:11:13,188
What were they doing
when you saw them?
224
00:11:13,188 --> 00:11:20,988
**
225
00:11:20,988 --> 00:11:22,921
Mm-hmm.
226
00:11:22,921 --> 00:11:27,521
**
227
00:11:27,521 --> 00:11:29,821
Berlinger:
Our sources tell us
that drug dealers
228
00:11:29,821 --> 00:11:31,988
routinely use female addicts
229
00:11:31,988 --> 00:11:35,421
in their ruthless drug-
and sex-trafficking rings.
230
00:11:35,421 --> 00:11:38,954
And according to Dollar Bill's
former associate,
231
00:11:38,954 --> 00:11:40,954
a man we're calling "Austin,"
232
00:11:40,954 --> 00:11:45,354
Dollar Bill also used Shasta
to transport his drugs.
233
00:11:45,354 --> 00:11:51,288
**
234
00:11:51,288 --> 00:11:55,754
If Shasta was an informant
and she snitched on Dollar Bill,
235
00:11:55,754 --> 00:11:59,321
could that have been
a motive for murder?
236
00:11:59,321 --> 00:12:03,821
Could Shasta's death, like many
of the other victims' cases,
237
00:12:03,821 --> 00:12:06,821
be tied to Dollar Bill?
238
00:12:06,821 --> 00:12:09,754
Sadly, these questions
may never be answered
239
00:12:09,754 --> 00:12:11,254
unless Shasta's case
is reopened.
240
00:12:11,254 --> 00:12:16,088
**
241
00:12:16,088 --> 00:12:18,154
But while we were investigating
242
00:12:18,154 --> 00:12:21,388
Ernest "Dollar Bill" Moore
in Chillicothe,
243
00:12:21,388 --> 00:12:23,321
he was negotiating a plea deal
244
00:12:23,321 --> 00:12:26,521
on a separate federal
drug-trafficking charge
245
00:12:26,521 --> 00:12:29,388
for selling narcotics
across state lines.
246
00:12:29,388 --> 00:12:39,088
**
247
00:12:39,088 --> 00:12:41,921
According to Dollar Bill's
plea agreement,
248
00:12:41,921 --> 00:12:44,688
he was cooperating
with law enforcement
249
00:12:44,688 --> 00:12:47,321
in exchange
for a reduced sentence.
250
00:12:47,321 --> 00:12:49,321
It would be an ironic twist
251
00:12:49,321 --> 00:12:53,221
if the man who claimed
he couldn't tolerate informants
252
00:12:53,221 --> 00:12:57,521
has seemingly become
an informant himself.
253
00:12:57,521 --> 00:13:00,254
But that irony
leaves little comfort
254
00:13:00,254 --> 00:13:02,788
for the victims' families.
255
00:13:02,788 --> 00:13:04,554
And the families
deserve closure.
256
00:13:04,554 --> 00:13:06,654
They deserve
the right person
257
00:13:06,654 --> 00:13:08,888
that, you know,
gets held accountable.
258
00:13:08,888 --> 00:13:11,221
You know, justice needs
to be served.
259
00:13:11,221 --> 00:13:13,421
**
260
00:13:13,421 --> 00:13:15,888
Man: Police are treating
Sayre's death as a homicide,
261
00:13:15,888 --> 00:13:19,288
and the person responsible
is still out there.
262
00:13:19,288 --> 00:13:22,888
Berlinger: Tiffany Sayre is the
only victim that law enforcement
263
00:13:22,888 --> 00:13:26,988
is currently investigating
as a homicide.
264
00:13:26,988 --> 00:13:29,654
Her family has been
fighting for answers
265
00:13:29,654 --> 00:13:32,921
since she disappeared
in May of 2015.
266
00:13:32,921 --> 00:13:34,954
**
267
00:13:34,954 --> 00:13:37,288
Ruth: Can you tell him?
Who's this?
268
00:13:37,288 --> 00:13:39,221
Rylee:
Mommy. There's Mommy.
269
00:13:39,221 --> 00:13:42,121
There's Mommy. There's Mommy.
270
00:13:42,121 --> 00:13:45,121
There's me and Mommy.
271
00:13:45,121 --> 00:13:48,588
Ruth: She promised
the girls ice cream.
272
00:13:48,588 --> 00:13:50,621
[ Voice breaking ]
Tiff never did show up.
273
00:13:50,621 --> 00:13:52,821
**
274
00:13:52,821 --> 00:13:54,288
Woman:
I have an emergency.
275
00:13:54,288 --> 00:14:00,654
I found a woman's body
in the creek.
276
00:14:00,654 --> 00:14:05,954
The day I went to identify
the body, after I saw her,
277
00:14:05,954 --> 00:14:08,521
I walked out,
told the funeral director,
278
00:14:08,521 --> 00:14:10,188
"That's not my niece."
279
00:14:10,188 --> 00:14:21,288
**
280
00:14:21,288 --> 00:14:23,221
Berlinger:
After two long years,
281
00:14:23,221 --> 00:14:27,354
the Sayre family finally has
some measure of closure,
282
00:14:27,354 --> 00:14:30,121
but they still don't know
what happened to Tiffany
283
00:14:30,121 --> 00:14:32,188
the night she disappeared.
284
00:14:32,188 --> 00:14:34,521
Sharing their frustration,
285
00:14:34,521 --> 00:14:37,154
we decide to follow up
one more time
286
00:14:37,154 --> 00:14:40,388
with the last person
to see Tiffany alive,
287
00:14:40,388 --> 00:14:42,288
Jessie Sanford.
288
00:14:42,288 --> 00:14:44,154
**
289
00:14:44,154 --> 00:14:46,621
So, come on in and --
290
00:14:46,621 --> 00:14:47,788
-You remember Joe.
-Hey, there.
291
00:14:47,788 --> 00:14:49,321
-Hi.
-Good to see you again.
292
00:14:49,321 --> 00:14:50,888
-You, too.
-Thanks for coming.
293
00:14:50,888 --> 00:14:52,521
Mm-hmm.
294
00:14:52,521 --> 00:14:54,354
When you talked to us
last time, you --
295
00:14:54,354 --> 00:14:57,088
-Different situation, right?
-Yes.
296
00:14:57,088 --> 00:14:58,988
I went to prison.
297
00:14:58,988 --> 00:15:05,288
**
298
00:15:05,288 --> 00:15:11,554
**
299
00:15:11,554 --> 00:15:13,788
Tell me about
that last night
300
00:15:13,788 --> 00:15:17,288
before she went missing.
301
00:15:17,288 --> 00:15:21,354
That night, we went out
and copped some dope.
302
00:15:21,354 --> 00:15:24,721
That was probably about,
I want to say 11:00.
303
00:15:24,721 --> 00:15:26,088
-Mm-hmm.
-And then we went back
304
00:15:26,088 --> 00:15:29,088
to my dad's house.
We got high.
305
00:15:29,088 --> 00:15:31,121
She told me
she was ready to go.
306
00:15:31,121 --> 00:15:33,888
She's like, "I wish somebody
would walk me home."
307
00:15:33,888 --> 00:15:38,554
I walked her down the steps,
and I went and laid down.
308
00:15:38,554 --> 00:15:40,554
Berlinger: What do you think
happened to her?
309
00:15:40,554 --> 00:15:44,621
I've thought about this
the whole time I was in prison.
310
00:15:44,621 --> 00:15:48,588
Dollar was trapping
out of a house on Sugar Street
311
00:15:48,588 --> 00:15:51,854
that was right beside the alley
that she went in to go home.
312
00:15:51,854 --> 00:15:55,254
**
313
00:15:55,254 --> 00:15:57,688
So that night,
there's a good chance
314
00:15:57,688 --> 00:16:00,088
that Dollar Bill was selling
out of that house --
315
00:16:00,088 --> 00:16:02,688
That's what I think.
316
00:16:02,688 --> 00:16:04,254
Could you talk
a little bit more about
317
00:16:04,254 --> 00:16:05,854
her relationship
with Dollar Bill?
318
00:16:05,854 --> 00:16:07,754
-Just a --
-They tricked together.
319
00:16:07,754 --> 00:16:10,688
Did Tiffany ever steal
from Dollar Bill?
320
00:16:10,688 --> 00:16:12,821
She stole
from many people.
321
00:16:12,821 --> 00:16:14,254
Mm-hmm?
322
00:16:14,254 --> 00:16:17,488
That's the addict
in people.
323
00:16:17,488 --> 00:16:19,088
You feel like
there's something
324
00:16:19,088 --> 00:16:21,688
you could've done
differently that night?
325
00:16:21,688 --> 00:16:23,821
I wish I would've
walked her home.
326
00:16:23,821 --> 00:16:25,788
But then you would've been
in this situation.
327
00:16:25,788 --> 00:16:28,088
Maybe they wouldn't
take us both.
328
00:16:28,088 --> 00:16:30,088
**
329
00:16:30,088 --> 00:16:32,754
It's okay.
330
00:16:32,754 --> 00:16:35,488
You feel guilty, right?
331
00:16:35,488 --> 00:16:36,688
You don't --
You shouldn't --
332
00:16:36,688 --> 00:16:38,688
You're having
survivor's guilt, right?
333
00:16:38,688 --> 00:16:40,854
Yeah.
'Cause you were
with her that night.
334
00:16:40,854 --> 00:16:42,621
Yeah.
335
00:16:42,621 --> 00:16:47,254
This picture was actually taken
the day before she went missing.
336
00:16:47,254 --> 00:16:51,088
How somebody can do that to
somebody who's so beautiful --
337
00:16:51,088 --> 00:16:55,654
**
338
00:16:55,654 --> 00:16:57,288
[ Buttons beeping ]
339
00:16:57,288 --> 00:16:59,754
Berlinger: Armed with
the information that Dollar Bill
340
00:16:59,754 --> 00:17:01,521
was selling drugs
out of a house
341
00:17:01,521 --> 00:17:04,654
on the same route
Tiffany took to walk home,
342
00:17:04,654 --> 00:17:07,554
we reach out to some
of Dollar Bill's associates
343
00:17:07,554 --> 00:17:11,821
to learn more about the night
Tiffany went missing.
344
00:17:11,821 --> 00:17:15,921
Arlene Avery, one of
Dollar Bill's accomplices
345
00:17:15,921 --> 00:17:18,188
in the Arthur Hamlin
torture case,
346
00:17:18,188 --> 00:17:21,688
agrees to speak
to us from prison.
347
00:17:21,688 --> 00:17:23,888
Woman: This call is from
a correction facility
348
00:17:23,888 --> 00:17:26,688
and is subject
to monitoring and recording.
349
00:17:26,688 --> 00:17:28,621
Arlene?
350
00:17:29,388 --> 00:17:32,388
Hi. How are you?
This is Angela Clemente.
351
00:17:32,388 --> 00:17:36,321
So you were one of Dollar Bill's
drivers in the summer of 2015.
352
00:17:36,321 --> 00:17:37,821
Is that right?
353
00:17:37,821 --> 00:17:44,721
**
354
00:17:44,721 --> 00:17:51,654
**
355
00:17:51,654 --> 00:17:55,421
According to Arlene Avery,
Officer Chip Campbell
356
00:17:55,421 --> 00:17:57,754
of the Chillicothe
Police Department
357
00:17:57,754 --> 00:17:59,921
had a conversation
with Dollar Bill
358
00:17:59,921 --> 00:18:04,121
about the night Tiffany Sayre
disappeared.
359
00:18:04,121 --> 00:18:08,254
Why did Chip Campbell
call Dollar Bill?
360
00:18:08,254 --> 00:18:15,821
**
361
00:18:15,821 --> 00:18:23,421
**
362
00:18:23,421 --> 00:18:24,954
Oh, because Tiffany
called him
363
00:18:24,954 --> 00:18:27,154
on the night
that she went missing?
364
00:18:27,154 --> 00:18:28,321
Wow. Okay.
365
00:18:28,321 --> 00:18:30,388
Yeah, this is
very helpful, Arlene.
366
00:18:30,388 --> 00:18:32,654
Thank you so much.
I really appreciate it, Arlene.
367
00:18:32,654 --> 00:18:35,488
You're great. Thank you.
368
00:18:35,488 --> 00:18:37,921
Bye-bye.
369
00:18:37,921 --> 00:18:41,454
Clemente: That's a really
explosive piece of information.
370
00:18:41,454 --> 00:18:44,088
You know, with Tiffany Sayre
calling Dollar Bill
371
00:18:44,088 --> 00:18:45,721
the night
that she went missing,
372
00:18:45,721 --> 00:18:48,154
and you couple that
with the information
373
00:18:48,154 --> 00:18:50,921
that we've now found out
that he had a trap house
374
00:18:50,921 --> 00:18:54,921
on the way where she was walking
down that alley,
375
00:18:54,921 --> 00:18:58,588
that's something that raises
a red flag to me right away.
376
00:18:58,588 --> 00:19:01,488
Berlinger: Could Tiffany
have met Dollar Bill
377
00:19:01,488 --> 00:19:05,588
on that fateful night,
never to be seen again?
378
00:19:11,188 --> 00:19:14,621
Berlinger: Because of the new
information we have uncovered,
379
00:19:14,621 --> 00:19:17,454
it's time for one of
our periodic updates
380
00:19:17,454 --> 00:19:19,388
with the victims' families.
381
00:19:19,388 --> 00:19:23,821
**
382
00:19:23,821 --> 00:19:26,654
Thanks for seeing us.
383
00:19:26,654 --> 00:19:30,154
We've been working on this for
quite a while, as you know,
384
00:19:30,154 --> 00:19:34,088
and we just wanted to kind of
update you a little bit
385
00:19:34,088 --> 00:19:36,221
and check in with you, and --
386
00:19:36,221 --> 00:19:38,488
You guys has worked
really hard on this case.
387
00:19:38,488 --> 00:19:42,088
And you have been there
from day one of this,
388
00:19:42,088 --> 00:19:45,954
and you deserve the closure
as much as we do.
389
00:19:45,954 --> 00:19:48,221
Clemente: So, you want
to start with Jessie?
390
00:19:48,221 --> 00:19:49,954
-Good to see you again.
-You, too.
391
00:19:49,954 --> 00:19:51,388
-Thanks for coming.
-Mm-hmm.
392
00:19:51,388 --> 00:19:53,354
Berlinger: We did
a filmed interview with her.
393
00:19:53,354 --> 00:19:55,621
Bongardt: And one of the things
that she told us
394
00:19:55,621 --> 00:19:57,288
is that when Tiffany
left that night,
395
00:19:57,288 --> 00:19:59,854
she went by a trap house
396
00:19:59,854 --> 00:20:01,788
that Dollar Bill
was operating out of,
397
00:20:01,788 --> 00:20:03,721
And his trap house
was on that alley,
398
00:20:03,721 --> 00:20:05,854
just around the corner
from here.
399
00:20:05,854 --> 00:20:09,821
**
400
00:20:09,821 --> 00:20:12,454
We do know there was
a call made that night
401
00:20:12,454 --> 00:20:15,821
from Tiffany
to Dollar Bill.
402
00:20:15,821 --> 00:20:17,821
This is all circumstantial
type evidence, right,
403
00:20:17,821 --> 00:20:20,821
but it's how
you build a case.
404
00:20:20,821 --> 00:20:24,121
Clemente: We're hearing that, a
lot of times, he would retaliate
405
00:20:24,121 --> 00:20:25,721
if someone owed him money.
406
00:20:25,721 --> 00:20:27,821
-He was her drug supplier.
-Right.
407
00:20:27,821 --> 00:20:30,821
She owed him money,
I would say.
408
00:20:30,821 --> 00:20:33,221
As we learn more and more
about Dollar Bill,
409
00:20:33,221 --> 00:20:35,021
he's got
an explosive personality,
410
00:20:35,021 --> 00:20:37,488
and it wouldn't be
any problem
411
00:20:37,488 --> 00:20:40,354
for him to act out
against her.
412
00:20:40,354 --> 00:20:44,954
[ Voice breaking ]
I heard her scream that night.
413
00:20:44,954 --> 00:20:47,554
She called me.
I could swear it was her.
414
00:20:47,554 --> 00:20:51,221
"Mamaw! Grandma!"
And I didn't hear her anymore.
415
00:20:51,221 --> 00:20:53,854
You thought you heard that the
night that she went missing?
I thought I did. Yes.
416
00:20:53,854 --> 00:20:56,021
It was her voice.
I'm positive.
417
00:20:56,021 --> 00:20:58,788
I know I wasn't dreaming.
It had to be her.
418
00:20:58,788 --> 00:21:00,421
And then we never
found her no more,
419
00:21:00,421 --> 00:21:02,788
never heard from her
no more.
420
00:21:02,788 --> 00:21:05,588
I empathize
with your plight.
421
00:21:05,588 --> 00:21:07,588
**
422
00:21:07,588 --> 00:21:09,921
Berlinger: When I first read
about these cases, I just --
423
00:21:09,921 --> 00:21:11,854
It broke my heart.
424
00:21:11,854 --> 00:21:14,888
[ Crying ] You don't know
how much it means to me.
425
00:21:14,888 --> 00:21:18,254
And my niece is my world.
426
00:21:18,254 --> 00:21:21,521
She's not my child,
but she is my firstborn niece
427
00:21:21,521 --> 00:21:23,254
and I loved her dearly.
428
00:21:23,254 --> 00:21:24,888
Your courage is amazing.
429
00:21:24,888 --> 00:21:27,354
Clemente:
Yeah. You've done great.
430
00:21:27,354 --> 00:21:30,121
We're going to, you know,
continue doing this.
431
00:21:30,121 --> 00:21:32,954
We're in this for as long
as we need to be.
432
00:21:32,954 --> 00:21:37,588
**
433
00:21:37,588 --> 00:21:40,521
Berlinger:
Having learned that Tiffany
may have been in contact
434
00:21:40,521 --> 00:21:43,188
with Dollar Bill
on the day she disappeared,
435
00:21:43,188 --> 00:21:48,788
we returned to another case
that has parallels to hers.
436
00:21:48,788 --> 00:21:53,354
Like Tiffany, Tameka Lynch's
body was found in water
437
00:21:53,354 --> 00:21:57,254
near Bainbridge,
20 miles from Chillicothe.
438
00:21:57,254 --> 00:22:01,688
Man: Detectives say the body
is 30-year-old Tameka Lynch.
439
00:22:01,688 --> 00:22:03,654
Investigators
took her fingerprints
440
00:22:03,654 --> 00:22:06,754
to compare to
the badly decomposed remains.
441
00:22:06,754 --> 00:22:08,988
**
442
00:22:08,988 --> 00:22:11,088
Berlinger:
Nearly three years later,
443
00:22:11,088 --> 00:22:14,621
Tameka's mother is still
struggling to comprehend
444
00:22:14,621 --> 00:22:17,121
what happened to her daughter.
445
00:22:17,121 --> 00:22:19,954
Although no eyewitness
has stepped forward,
446
00:22:19,954 --> 00:22:21,988
the sources we've spoken to
447
00:22:21,988 --> 00:22:24,921
claim that they've heard
what happened to Tameka
448
00:22:24,921 --> 00:22:27,754
directly from
the persons responsible.
449
00:22:27,754 --> 00:22:30,421
**
450
00:22:30,421 --> 00:22:33,954
On May 24th,
Tameka Lynch's naked body
451
00:22:33,954 --> 00:22:35,954
is found in Paint Creek.
452
00:22:35,954 --> 00:22:39,588
This is the first body
found of the Chillicothe Six.
453
00:22:39,588 --> 00:22:41,254
So, let's talk about
Crail Brooks,
454
00:22:41,254 --> 00:22:44,688
low-level drug dealer
working with Dollar Bill.
455
00:22:44,688 --> 00:22:48,588
Multiple charges of domestic
violence and assault.
456
00:22:48,588 --> 00:22:51,488
Crail Brooks was arrested
for drug trafficking
457
00:22:51,488 --> 00:22:53,788
just 12 days
after Tameka was found,
458
00:22:53,788 --> 00:22:58,821
6 minutes from where
Tameka's body was found.
459
00:22:58,821 --> 00:23:02,654
Berlinger:
Several individuals allege
that Tameka was at a party
460
00:23:02,654 --> 00:23:07,088
in Bainbridge with Crail Brooks.
461
00:23:07,088 --> 00:23:08,988
Do you know if Tameka
was murdered?
462
00:23:08,988 --> 00:23:11,088
And, if so, by who?
463
00:23:11,088 --> 00:23:14,754
Uh, yes.
Yes, she was.
464
00:23:14,754 --> 00:23:18,088
**
465
00:23:18,088 --> 00:23:20,754
Berlinger:
You know, she might have
been killed with a hot shot,
466
00:23:20,754 --> 00:23:23,354
you know, a purposeful
mixture of drugs
467
00:23:23,354 --> 00:23:24,888
that will kill you.
468
00:23:24,888 --> 00:23:26,988
Bongardt: Could make it
look like an overdose,
469
00:23:26,988 --> 00:23:29,488
but it's actually a homicide.
470
00:23:29,488 --> 00:23:32,688
Berlinger: At one of our
meetings with Tameka's mother,
471
00:23:32,688 --> 00:23:35,421
she shared her
suspicions with us.
472
00:23:35,421 --> 00:23:43,721
**
473
00:23:43,721 --> 00:23:47,154
I think the story that
we've heard is true --
474
00:23:47,154 --> 00:23:49,521
Crail.
475
00:23:49,521 --> 00:23:52,188
Berlinger: Now we head over
to see Tameka's mother
476
00:23:52,188 --> 00:23:53,921
to let her know
what we've been able
477
00:23:53,921 --> 00:23:58,088
to find out about Crail Brooks
and to give her a warning.
478
00:23:58,088 --> 00:24:04,288
**
479
00:24:04,288 --> 00:24:05,788
-Hi!
-Good to see you.
480
00:24:05,788 --> 00:24:08,788
How are you?
481
00:24:08,788 --> 00:24:10,788
How you been?
Hanging in there?
482
00:24:25,888 --> 00:24:28,621
Bongardt:
With regards to your daughter,
483
00:24:28,621 --> 00:24:30,888
it wasn't your
traditional serial killer.
484
00:24:30,888 --> 00:24:34,288
It wasn't a stranger
that did this to her.
485
00:24:34,288 --> 00:24:38,954
It was somebody that
she knew fairly well.
486
00:24:38,954 --> 00:24:45,154
And our confidential sources
have told us that...
487
00:24:45,154 --> 00:24:49,388
Crail Brooks
and Dollar
488
00:24:49,388 --> 00:24:54,088
were involved
with Tameka's death.
489
00:24:54,088 --> 00:25:00,788
**
490
00:25:00,788 --> 00:25:07,454
**
491
00:25:07,454 --> 00:25:09,521
-You okay?
-Mm-hmm.
492
00:25:09,521 --> 00:25:11,188
It's hard to hear.
493
00:25:11,188 --> 00:25:15,188
**
494
00:25:15,188 --> 00:25:17,121
Crail is in prison now,
495
00:25:17,121 --> 00:25:20,188
and he's going to get out
in a couple months.
496
00:25:20,188 --> 00:25:22,321
Really?
497
00:25:22,321 --> 00:25:25,188
So we wanted to make sure
that, you know,
498
00:25:25,188 --> 00:25:27,188
you were not
kept in the dark.
499
00:25:27,188 --> 00:25:29,654
And while we still have
an ongoing investigation,
500
00:25:29,654 --> 00:25:31,688
we're going to
continue doing that.
501
00:25:31,688 --> 00:25:33,188
Even when
the cameras are gone,
502
00:25:33,188 --> 00:25:35,221
you know, you're going
to not get rid of me.
503
00:25:35,221 --> 00:25:36,954
Great.
[ Both laugh ]
504
00:25:36,954 --> 00:25:39,288
We want to find answers.
505
00:25:39,288 --> 00:25:41,788
We feel we're getting
closer to the truth.
506
00:25:41,788 --> 00:25:44,754
**
507
00:25:47,588 --> 00:25:53,454
**
508
00:25:53,454 --> 00:25:55,554
What we do know is,
Charlotte Trego
509
00:25:55,554 --> 00:25:58,688
was the first one
to go missing in Chillicothe.
510
00:25:58,688 --> 00:26:01,088
Man: Trego, who went missing
May 2014,
511
00:26:01,088 --> 00:26:03,221
is one of
three missing persons cases
512
00:26:03,221 --> 00:26:06,688
Chillicothe police are pursuing.
513
00:26:06,688 --> 00:26:09,088
Clemente:
We know that the last contact,
514
00:26:09,088 --> 00:26:11,354
of course, was with her mom
on May 3rd,
515
00:26:11,354 --> 00:26:15,454
and we also know that Charlotte
was driving back and forth
516
00:26:15,454 --> 00:26:17,088
to Gallipolis,
517
00:26:17,088 --> 00:26:20,454
helping Dollar Bill
do business there.
518
00:26:20,454 --> 00:26:24,221
And then, of course, Charlotte
said she owed Dollar Bill money,
519
00:26:24,221 --> 00:26:26,721
so that's really important.
520
00:26:26,721 --> 00:26:32,121
**
521
00:26:32,121 --> 00:26:37,521
**
522
00:26:37,521 --> 00:26:40,921
Berlinger: Our investigation
takes an unexpected turn
523
00:26:40,921 --> 00:26:43,288
when new information surfaces
524
00:26:43,288 --> 00:26:47,421
that seem to contradict
our previous theory.
525
00:26:47,421 --> 00:26:49,721
So, you've uncovered
some good information.
526
00:26:49,721 --> 00:26:52,254
I have.
527
00:26:52,254 --> 00:26:56,188
While Angela was investigating
the cases of Tameka Lynch
528
00:26:56,188 --> 00:26:58,088
and Charlotte Trego,
529
00:26:58,088 --> 00:27:02,288
several people came forward
with compelling new leads.
530
00:27:02,288 --> 00:27:04,454
**
531
00:27:04,454 --> 00:27:06,288
And these are the people
who now have become
532
00:27:06,288 --> 00:27:08,188
confidential sources
for you, right?
533
00:27:08,188 --> 00:27:10,988
-Yes.
-So what is the motivation
534
00:27:10,988 --> 00:27:12,754
for these people
coming forward now?
535
00:27:12,754 --> 00:27:15,321
Why are these people
wanting to give information?
536
00:27:15,321 --> 00:27:18,354
Dollar Bill was just sentenced
to 22 years in prison.
537
00:27:18,354 --> 00:27:21,688
He's not as much of a threat
to them anymore.
538
00:27:21,688 --> 00:27:24,121
And then the second reason,
539
00:27:24,121 --> 00:27:27,088
they're hearing that Crail
is going to get out of prison.
540
00:27:27,088 --> 00:27:29,454
In December, so they're
concerned for their safety
541
00:27:29,454 --> 00:27:31,188
because he's getting
out of prison?
542
00:27:31,188 --> 00:27:33,454
Correct.
543
00:27:33,454 --> 00:27:36,488
Obviously, we spent
a lot of time
544
00:27:36,488 --> 00:27:40,754
believing that Charlotte met
her demise in Gallipolis,
545
00:27:40,754 --> 00:27:43,854
and that the body
was buried
546
00:27:43,854 --> 00:27:45,921
on that property.
547
00:27:45,921 --> 00:27:47,288
What I'm hearing now is
548
00:27:47,288 --> 00:27:49,454
sources were saying,
that were close to Dollar,
549
00:27:49,454 --> 00:27:54,121
he was throwing out
information that was inaccurate
550
00:27:54,121 --> 00:27:55,921
to throw people off.
551
00:27:55,921 --> 00:27:57,788
So, to misdirect everyone
to think
552
00:27:57,788 --> 00:27:59,788
it might have happened
in Gallipolis
553
00:27:59,788 --> 00:28:01,821
when, in fact,
it hadn't.
554
00:28:01,821 --> 00:28:03,354
Correct.
555
00:28:03,354 --> 00:28:06,254
But in a surprising twist,
this new information
556
00:28:06,254 --> 00:28:10,154
points back to the original
leads we had uncovered.
557
00:28:10,154 --> 00:28:12,888
**
558
00:28:12,888 --> 00:28:14,254
Remember everybody
was talking
559
00:28:14,254 --> 00:28:15,821
about that big party
in Bainbridge?
560
00:28:15,821 --> 00:28:17,654
Yeah, the Bainbridge party.
Yes.
561
00:28:17,654 --> 00:28:20,854
What I learned
was that Charlotte and Tameka
562
00:28:20,854 --> 00:28:23,188
-were together.
-The evening of the party?
563
00:28:23,188 --> 00:28:26,221
The evening of the party.
564
00:28:26,221 --> 00:28:28,821
Now we're heading right
into Bainbridge.
565
00:28:28,821 --> 00:28:31,888
We're almost here, and we're
going to the first location
566
00:28:31,888 --> 00:28:35,888
that my sources have told me
that this big party happened.
567
00:28:35,888 --> 00:28:45,588
**
568
00:28:45,588 --> 00:28:47,821
-So, this is the --
-So, this is the party place.
569
00:28:47,821 --> 00:28:50,921
This is the party place.
570
00:28:50,921 --> 00:28:54,421
This trailer is allegedly
where Charlotte and Tameka
571
00:28:54,421 --> 00:28:56,821
went to party with one
of their drug dealers,
572
00:28:56,821 --> 00:28:59,588
Crail Brooks.
573
00:28:59,588 --> 00:29:02,954
They were together, and there
were a lot of people there,
574
00:29:02,954 --> 00:29:06,488
so there's a lot of sources to
identify that they were there.
575
00:29:06,488 --> 00:29:09,154
What were the last few weeks
of their life like?
576
00:29:09,154 --> 00:29:10,788
What state were they in?
577
00:29:10,788 --> 00:29:13,154
Both of them were in
very heavy addiction.
578
00:29:13,154 --> 00:29:15,588
Charlotte owed money.
Tameka owed money.
579
00:29:15,588 --> 00:29:17,088
They were robbing people,
580
00:29:17,088 --> 00:29:19,421
and this can make
a drug dealer angry,
581
00:29:19,421 --> 00:29:21,454
if you're owing them money
and you're not paying
582
00:29:21,454 --> 00:29:23,154
and you're ripping
people off.
583
00:29:23,154 --> 00:29:24,921
And remember
our timeline?
584
00:29:24,921 --> 00:29:27,288
This is why, you know,
Charlotte may not have been
585
00:29:27,288 --> 00:29:30,721
heard from, you know,
too much by her mother.
586
00:29:30,721 --> 00:29:33,921
There was that long gap
where she was not heard from,
587
00:29:33,921 --> 00:29:37,754
which, you know, made us think
that they didn't die together.
588
00:29:37,754 --> 00:29:38,921
Right.
589
00:29:38,921 --> 00:29:40,254
So what do
your sources tell us?
590
00:29:40,254 --> 00:29:44,388
What happened
in that trailer?
591
00:29:44,388 --> 00:29:48,488
Here's a piece that I can't
give too much information.
592
00:29:48,488 --> 00:29:51,888
Angela explains
that she can't divulge on camera
593
00:29:51,888 --> 00:29:55,788
all of the information her
confidential informants gave her
594
00:29:55,788 --> 00:29:58,921
because certain details
might reveal their identity
595
00:29:58,921 --> 00:30:02,554
to the killers,
and thus endanger their lives.
596
00:30:02,554 --> 00:30:05,221
This is the first time
I think I've done a show
597
00:30:05,221 --> 00:30:08,621
where it's,
like, so current
598
00:30:08,621 --> 00:30:10,921
and it's leading
to a prosecution
599
00:30:10,921 --> 00:30:12,388
that my natural tendency
600
00:30:12,388 --> 00:30:14,254
is to want to reveal
certain information.
601
00:30:14,254 --> 00:30:16,988
So it's a little frustrating.
Yes.
602
00:30:16,988 --> 00:30:20,621
It seems we now know where
the party took place,
603
00:30:20,621 --> 00:30:23,154
but we still don't know when.
604
00:30:23,154 --> 00:30:24,921
Clemente:
One of my sources said
605
00:30:24,921 --> 00:30:27,821
that there was very bad storms
that night,
606
00:30:27,821 --> 00:30:30,588
and it knocked out a lot
of power around Bainbridge.
607
00:30:30,588 --> 00:30:33,154
So you take that timeline,
and you look.
608
00:30:33,154 --> 00:30:35,654
Was there a storm
during any of this period
609
00:30:35,654 --> 00:30:38,654
between when Charlotte went
missing and Tameka went missing?
610
00:30:38,654 --> 00:30:42,254
And the one day
that comes up is the 21st.
611
00:30:42,254 --> 00:30:44,388
And the coroner said
that Tameka was found
612
00:30:44,388 --> 00:30:45,621
three days
after she had died.
613
00:30:45,621 --> 00:30:48,888
Right.
She was found on the 24th,
614
00:30:48,888 --> 00:30:52,554
three days exactly
before that night.
615
00:30:52,554 --> 00:30:55,321
It fits with
the coroner's statement.
616
00:30:55,321 --> 00:30:58,154
It was a very specific
piece of information.
617
00:30:58,154 --> 00:31:01,088
Yeah.
So, just to be clear,
618
00:31:01,088 --> 00:31:02,521
in fairness,
619
00:31:02,521 --> 00:31:04,621
none of this has been proven
in a court of law,
620
00:31:04,621 --> 00:31:08,121
-so these are all just theories.
-Right. Right.
621
00:31:08,121 --> 00:31:10,788
But, remember, again,
there were a lot of people here.
622
00:31:10,788 --> 00:31:12,454
So, a lot of people
are talking.
623
00:31:12,454 --> 00:31:15,154
Yeah. So, where are we
going to go now?
624
00:31:15,154 --> 00:31:18,554
The next place we're going
to go is where
625
00:31:18,554 --> 00:31:22,888
Tameka was
potentially dumped.
626
00:31:22,888 --> 00:31:24,521
Angela believes
that at some point
627
00:31:24,521 --> 00:31:27,721
on the night of May 21, 2014,
628
00:31:27,721 --> 00:31:31,954
Charlotte and Tameka left
the party to buy cigarettes.
629
00:31:31,954 --> 00:31:35,088
Then they either returned
to the trailer
630
00:31:35,088 --> 00:31:37,621
or to another location
down the street,
631
00:31:37,621 --> 00:31:39,388
where Crail Brooks
would be arrested
632
00:31:39,388 --> 00:31:41,321
on drug trafficking charges
633
00:31:41,321 --> 00:31:44,321
just 2 weeks later.
634
00:31:44,321 --> 00:31:46,688
Either way, Tameka died
635
00:31:46,688 --> 00:31:49,088
soon after they got back
from the store.
636
00:31:49,088 --> 00:31:51,288
**
637
00:31:51,288 --> 00:31:54,454
Under what circumstances?
How did it happen?
638
00:31:54,454 --> 00:31:57,821
Now, I'm getting two
different pieces on this,
639
00:31:57,821 --> 00:32:00,788
but most of them are saying
640
00:32:00,788 --> 00:32:05,088
that Tameka received
a hot shot.
641
00:32:05,088 --> 00:32:09,421
Charlotte, apparently,
when she watched Tameka die,
642
00:32:09,421 --> 00:32:11,088
she did freak out.
643
00:32:11,088 --> 00:32:13,254
Why was she given
a hot shot -- Tameka?
644
00:32:13,254 --> 00:32:16,221
She was given a hot shot
because she owed money.
645
00:32:16,221 --> 00:32:18,754
Charlotte and Tameka owed
Crail and Dollar money.
646
00:32:18,754 --> 00:32:22,088
And they're not tolerating
being owed money
647
00:32:22,088 --> 00:32:24,854
because they want
to send a message
648
00:32:24,854 --> 00:32:27,854
that you can't not
pay the drug dealer?
649
00:32:27,854 --> 00:32:29,854
Right.
Dollar was very angry
650
00:32:29,854 --> 00:32:32,754
with anybody
that even owed him $20,
651
00:32:32,754 --> 00:32:35,921
even though he was dealing
with a lot higher numbers.
652
00:32:35,921 --> 00:32:39,721
When someone owed him money,
he was not going to allow that.
653
00:32:39,721 --> 00:32:43,121
The perfect murder weapon
is giving someone a hot shot
654
00:32:43,121 --> 00:32:45,388
that's an addict.
655
00:32:45,388 --> 00:32:48,788
Although the hot shot
theory is still very plausible,
656
00:32:48,788 --> 00:32:52,088
some of Angela's
other sources now say
657
00:32:52,088 --> 00:32:55,088
that Tameka died from
an accidental overdose
658
00:32:55,088 --> 00:32:57,088
and that they
dumped her body
659
00:32:57,088 --> 00:33:01,188
in order to avoid being held
responsible for her death.
660
00:33:01,188 --> 00:33:04,521
**
661
00:33:04,521 --> 00:33:07,988
And, so, your confidential
source told you
662
00:33:07,988 --> 00:33:12,254
that this was the site
where Tameka was dumped, right?
663
00:33:12,254 --> 00:33:13,988
For me, investigatively,
664
00:33:13,988 --> 00:33:16,854
I think this is
the most plausible spot
665
00:33:16,854 --> 00:33:18,988
that it actually happened.
666
00:33:18,988 --> 00:33:20,454
Right.
667
00:33:20,454 --> 00:33:22,821
According to
the autopsy report,
668
00:33:22,821 --> 00:33:25,754
Tameka had injuries
to her head and chest
669
00:33:25,754 --> 00:33:28,988
that would be consistent
with being thrown off a bridge.
670
00:33:28,988 --> 00:33:31,488
**
671
00:33:31,488 --> 00:33:33,588
The water levels were high.
672
00:33:33,588 --> 00:33:36,088
It flowed down that way.
673
00:33:36,088 --> 00:33:38,354
Her body got caught
on that sandbar
674
00:33:38,354 --> 00:33:40,688
and couldn't go any further
when the water went down.
675
00:33:40,688 --> 00:33:42,754
Yeah.
676
00:33:42,754 --> 00:33:45,421
This is not that secluded
a road, actually,
677
00:33:45,421 --> 00:33:47,454
so do you think they
would be brazen enough
678
00:33:47,454 --> 00:33:49,188
to dump a body at night?
679
00:33:49,188 --> 00:33:50,854
We've learned that it was
a stormy night.
680
00:33:50,854 --> 00:33:52,521
-Right.
-We didn't know that before.
681
00:33:52,521 --> 00:33:56,154
You know, stormy, dark, you
know, no streetlights, raining,
682
00:33:56,154 --> 00:33:58,354
probably not many people
are going to be out.
683
00:33:58,354 --> 00:34:00,088
And the bridge being low,
684
00:34:00,088 --> 00:34:03,654
I think it would be easy for --
Open the door and push.
685
00:34:03,654 --> 00:34:07,688
-I mean, it's --
-Right. It is pretty low.
686
00:34:07,688 --> 00:34:11,254
In fact, so low it's
making me a little nervous.
Right.
687
00:34:11,254 --> 00:34:14,521
So do we have information about
how many people were involved?
688
00:34:14,521 --> 00:34:16,088
No. No.
689
00:34:16,088 --> 00:34:17,654
I don't.
690
00:34:17,654 --> 00:34:19,421
Okay.
691
00:34:19,421 --> 00:34:21,254
Berlinger: This scenario
seems to be consistent
692
00:34:21,254 --> 00:34:22,754
with what Artie Hamlin,
693
00:34:22,754 --> 00:34:25,921
Dollar Bill's former associate,
told us.
694
00:34:25,921 --> 00:34:28,321
-Okay.
-Okay?
695
00:34:28,321 --> 00:34:29,988
-Okay. Okay.
-Okay? Yeah.
696
00:34:29,988 --> 00:34:34,154
**
697
00:34:34,154 --> 00:34:37,188
There was some
corroboration there.
698
00:34:37,188 --> 00:34:38,688
It's like
this is the spot.
699
00:34:38,688 --> 00:34:42,154
Clemente: Exactly.
700
00:34:42,154 --> 00:34:45,354
But another mystery remains.
701
00:34:45,354 --> 00:34:49,954
After they dumped Tameka's body,
what happened to Charlotte?
702
00:34:54,654 --> 00:34:56,521
**
703
00:34:56,521 --> 00:34:58,088
Berlinger:
The next day, we set out
704
00:34:58,088 --> 00:35:01,088
to retrace what may have been
the last hours
705
00:35:01,088 --> 00:35:04,188
of Charlotte Trego's life.
706
00:35:04,188 --> 00:35:06,954
According to some of
Angela's sources,
707
00:35:06,954 --> 00:35:09,921
after Charlotte witnessed
Tameka's death,
708
00:35:09,921 --> 00:35:13,654
she was then taken
to a remote wooded area.
709
00:35:13,654 --> 00:35:17,088
Thanks to specific
GPS coordinates
710
00:35:17,088 --> 00:35:19,588
that Angela
was able to secure,
711
00:35:19,588 --> 00:35:23,121
we can now to zero in
on the exact location.
712
00:35:23,121 --> 00:35:25,088
**
713
00:35:25,088 --> 00:35:27,988
How confident are you
about this information?
714
00:35:27,988 --> 00:35:30,288
I'm very confident.
715
00:35:30,288 --> 00:35:32,188
Slow down.
716
00:35:32,188 --> 00:35:35,288
It's right here.
717
00:35:35,288 --> 00:35:36,688
-In here?
-Yep.
718
00:35:36,688 --> 00:35:39,454
This is the location
right here.
719
00:35:44,988 --> 00:35:47,521
-Yeah.
-'Cause it's private property.
720
00:35:47,521 --> 00:35:49,821
Okay.
Well, let's check it out.
721
00:35:55,088 --> 00:35:58,688
Well, this is it.
722
00:35:58,688 --> 00:36:01,221
It's really deep in.
723
00:36:01,221 --> 00:36:03,854
You have to walk
quite a ways.
724
00:36:03,854 --> 00:36:05,421
Can see how dense, you know,
725
00:36:05,421 --> 00:36:09,988
as far as, like,
it goes back really far.
726
00:36:09,988 --> 00:36:13,988
Was Charlotte alive
when she was brought here?
727
00:36:13,988 --> 00:36:16,488
Was she killed here?
Was she burned here?
728
00:36:16,488 --> 00:36:20,321
The elements that I can say
729
00:36:20,321 --> 00:36:23,421
that won't hurt
the integrity of the case --
730
00:36:23,421 --> 00:36:26,154
Right, 'cause there's certain
details that you can't reveal
731
00:36:26,154 --> 00:36:29,088
because it's such
singular information
732
00:36:29,088 --> 00:36:32,688
that it will point a finger
to your confidential sources,
733
00:36:32,688 --> 00:36:34,388
and we need to protect
those sources
734
00:36:34,388 --> 00:36:37,521
as well as protect the integrity
of the investigation.
735
00:36:37,521 --> 00:36:39,321
So I understand
there are certain things
736
00:36:39,321 --> 00:36:41,321
-you can't even tell me.
-Right.
737
00:36:41,321 --> 00:36:42,821
The one thing I can say,
738
00:36:42,821 --> 00:36:46,088
it's supposed to have
been Crail and Dollar
739
00:36:46,088 --> 00:36:51,754
and potentially one or two
other people that came out here,
740
00:36:51,754 --> 00:36:55,821
that Charlotte was alive
when she arrived here.
741
00:36:55,821 --> 00:37:00,788
Once Charlotte saw Tameka die,
she freaked out,
742
00:37:00,788 --> 00:37:04,321
and they felt that
she was a liability now.
743
00:37:04,321 --> 00:37:07,954
She was, you know,
a potential witness to this.
744
00:37:07,954 --> 00:37:09,721
She would inform on them.
745
00:37:09,721 --> 00:37:11,221
She was an addict,
you know?
746
00:37:11,221 --> 00:37:12,721
"Look, we need
to get rid of her."
747
00:37:12,721 --> 00:37:16,088
-Right.
-And so she did die here.
748
00:37:16,088 --> 00:37:19,154
**
749
00:37:19,154 --> 00:37:20,921
Hmm.
750
00:37:20,921 --> 00:37:24,721
Angela can't reveal the details
of her source's account
751
00:37:24,721 --> 00:37:27,154
of how Dollar Bill
and Crail Brooks
752
00:37:27,154 --> 00:37:31,421
allegedly killed Charlotte
in these woods,
753
00:37:31,421 --> 00:37:35,921
but she does share some
startling new information.
754
00:37:35,921 --> 00:37:39,221
When I was told
about this location,
755
00:37:39,221 --> 00:37:42,754
that there were not
just Charlotte's body here,
756
00:37:42,754 --> 00:37:45,954
but there are others.
757
00:37:45,954 --> 00:37:49,221
So, there's potentially
a graveyard out there.
758
00:37:49,221 --> 00:37:50,954
Yeah. We could have
a killing field out here.
759
00:37:50,954 --> 00:37:54,254
This could be
their dumping spot
760
00:37:54,254 --> 00:37:56,721
and murder spot, actually.
761
00:37:56,721 --> 00:37:58,221
-I --
-And what if we're wrong?
762
00:37:58,221 --> 00:38:00,354
What if there's
nothing out there?
763
00:38:00,354 --> 00:38:02,221
I do feel that she's here.
764
00:38:02,221 --> 00:38:04,188
Charlotte and
I don't know who else,
765
00:38:04,188 --> 00:38:05,954
but I do feel
that she's here.
766
00:38:05,954 --> 00:38:09,088
The information was
just too specific.
767
00:38:09,088 --> 00:38:12,188
What's the next step from
an investigative standpoint?
768
00:38:12,188 --> 00:38:14,154
I believe this is
a federal case,
769
00:38:14,154 --> 00:38:17,521
because Dollar Bill was
distributing and, you know --
770
00:38:17,521 --> 00:38:19,154
Distributing drugs
across state lines.
771
00:38:19,154 --> 00:38:20,121
Right.
772
00:38:20,121 --> 00:38:21,321
They're going to Mexico,
773
00:38:21,321 --> 00:38:22,854
bringing the drugs in
from Mexico.
774
00:38:22,854 --> 00:38:25,088
Then there's murder,
also, so,
775
00:38:25,088 --> 00:38:27,554
you know, there's
a lot of elements
776
00:38:27,554 --> 00:38:29,988
that raises it to
a level of RICO.
777
00:38:29,988 --> 00:38:31,221
RICO.
Yes.
778
00:38:31,221 --> 00:38:39,488
**
779
00:38:39,488 --> 00:38:42,688
The next step is the property
needs to be secured,
780
00:38:42,688 --> 00:38:44,888
and they need to come
in here and do a search,
781
00:38:44,888 --> 00:38:47,954
so in order to do that,
this is private property,
782
00:38:47,954 --> 00:38:49,321
so they need to get
a search warrant
783
00:38:49,321 --> 00:38:52,088
to go in there
and search the property.
784
00:38:52,088 --> 00:38:54,721
In order to get
law enforcement involved,
785
00:38:54,721 --> 00:38:58,121
Angela reaches out
to her contact at BCI,
786
00:38:58,121 --> 00:39:01,721
Ohio's Bureau
of Criminal Investigation.
787
00:39:01,721 --> 00:39:07,188
I have a location of where
Charlotte's remains might be.
788
00:39:07,188 --> 00:39:10,521
You're going to want to get
a search warrant
789
00:39:10,521 --> 00:39:12,088
for this particular property
790
00:39:12,088 --> 00:39:14,788
and actually get out there
as soon as possible
791
00:39:14,788 --> 00:39:17,454
so that anything isn't moved.
792
00:39:17,454 --> 00:39:24,421
**
793
00:39:24,421 --> 00:39:27,121
Berlinger:
As we wait for BCI's response,
794
00:39:27,121 --> 00:39:29,854
we head out to update
Charlotte's mother,
795
00:39:29,854 --> 00:39:31,754
Yvonne Boggs.
796
00:39:31,754 --> 00:39:33,621
She's a little tricky
to update,
797
00:39:33,621 --> 00:39:35,854
because, you know,
798
00:39:35,854 --> 00:39:37,888
she's probably still
holding out hope
799
00:39:37,888 --> 00:39:39,754
that her daughter
is alive.
800
00:39:39,754 --> 00:39:42,954
I think that
she's extremely fragile,
801
00:39:42,954 --> 00:39:45,254
and any parent would
hold out hope that --
802
00:39:45,254 --> 00:39:46,754
-Of course. Of course.
-You know?
803
00:39:46,754 --> 00:39:50,221
[ Railroad crossing
bells dinging ]
804
00:39:50,221 --> 00:39:52,521
[ Train horn blows ]
805
00:39:52,521 --> 00:39:57,554
**
806
00:39:57,554 --> 00:40:00,421
Berlinger:
When we started this, we said
we would keep you updated
807
00:40:00,421 --> 00:40:03,588
and tell you some of
the things we've discovered.
808
00:40:03,588 --> 00:40:05,221
Yeah.
809
00:40:05,221 --> 00:40:08,188
Berlinger: As gently as we can,
we let Yvonne know
810
00:40:08,188 --> 00:40:11,188
that Charlotte may have
witnessed Tameka's death
811
00:40:11,188 --> 00:40:12,888
and may have been taken out
812
00:40:12,888 --> 00:40:16,521
to a remote location
in the woods and killed.
813
00:40:16,521 --> 00:40:19,554
**
814
00:40:19,554 --> 00:40:22,788
We have an indication
of where those woods might be
815
00:40:22,788 --> 00:40:26,921
where her remains could be,
so I know that's hard to hear.
816
00:40:26,921 --> 00:40:29,854
Yeah.
817
00:40:29,854 --> 00:40:32,888
I mean, as far as "remains,"
but --
818
00:40:32,888 --> 00:40:36,854
**
819
00:40:36,854 --> 00:40:40,088
[ Sighs ]
820
00:40:40,088 --> 00:40:41,288
I don't know if I'm really
821
00:40:41,288 --> 00:40:43,388
letting all this
sink in right now.
822
00:40:43,388 --> 00:40:45,388
I mean, it may hit me later.
I don't know.
823
00:40:45,388 --> 00:40:47,121
-Yeah.
-But --
824
00:40:47,121 --> 00:40:50,188
You know, even though
we're ending our filming,
825
00:40:50,188 --> 00:40:52,621
we're going to continue,
you know,
826
00:40:52,621 --> 00:40:55,354
to try to do
what we can here.
827
00:40:55,354 --> 00:40:57,721
And Angela is,
you know, tireless,
828
00:40:57,721 --> 00:40:59,554
and she's going
to keep working on it
829
00:40:59,554 --> 00:41:02,854
even with the cameras
not around, so...
830
00:41:02,854 --> 00:41:05,154
-And we appreciate that. We do.
-Yeah.
831
00:41:05,154 --> 00:41:07,321
[ Railroad crossing
bells dinging ]
832
00:41:07,321 --> 00:41:14,454
**
833
00:41:14,454 --> 00:41:17,854
Berlinger:
We started this investigation
wondering if these young women
834
00:41:17,854 --> 00:41:21,354
had fallen victim
to a serial killer.
835
00:41:21,354 --> 00:41:25,088
Everybody's scared,
but damn if I'm gonna back down.
836
00:41:25,088 --> 00:41:27,188
I want to know what happened
to my granddaughter.
837
00:41:27,188 --> 00:41:29,921
Berlinger: But accusations
of police corruption
838
00:41:29,921 --> 00:41:32,354
made us dismiss this theory.
839
00:41:32,354 --> 00:41:35,088
They don't give two shits
about these girls.
840
00:41:35,088 --> 00:41:37,621
Where is the accountability?
841
00:41:37,621 --> 00:41:40,354
I just want my baby girl
to come home.
842
00:41:40,354 --> 00:41:43,621
Berlinger: But, ironically,
we've come full circle.
843
00:41:43,621 --> 00:41:45,821
Could it be
that the person responsible
844
00:41:45,821 --> 00:41:48,088
for these disappearances
and deaths
845
00:41:48,088 --> 00:41:50,921
is a different kind
of serial killer?
846
00:41:50,921 --> 00:41:54,188
Not a deranged stranger
lurking in the shadows,
847
00:41:54,188 --> 00:41:58,921
but local heroin dealers killing
their victims in plain sight?
848
00:41:58,921 --> 00:42:01,388
Sometimes bringing cameras,
you know,
849
00:42:01,388 --> 00:42:04,354
allows things to come out
into the sunshine.
850
00:42:04,354 --> 00:42:06,388
Or maybe the serial killer
851
00:42:06,388 --> 00:42:09,088
is simply heroin addiction
itself
852
00:42:09,088 --> 00:42:11,088
and all of its collateral damage
853
00:42:11,088 --> 00:42:13,088
that is plaguing this community
854
00:42:13,088 --> 00:42:15,888
and many others
all across America.
855
00:42:15,888 --> 00:42:19,088
[ Siren wails,
indistinct radio chatter ]
856
00:42:19,088 --> 00:42:21,888
Sadly, there will be
many more victims
857
00:42:21,888 --> 00:42:25,654
of drug-related sex trafficking
and violent crime
858
00:42:25,654 --> 00:42:28,988
unless our communities
can effectively combat
859
00:42:28,988 --> 00:42:31,754
this devastating
opiate epidemic
860
00:42:31,754 --> 00:42:36,354
that is gripping the nation.
861
00:42:36,354 --> 00:42:46,354
**
862
00:42:46,354 --> 00:42:56,354
**
863
00:42:56,354 --> 00:42:57,621
**
864
00:43:01,188 --> 00:43:11,088
**
865
00:43:11,088 --> 00:43:20,688
**
866
00:43:23,688 --> 00:43:27,688
Preuzeto sa www.titlovi.com
65571
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.