Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:23,420 --> 00:00:26,089
A billion kilometers from earth,
2
00:00:26,090 --> 00:00:30,349
a small probe uncoupled from
an interplanetary spacecraft
3
00:00:30,350 --> 00:00:32,860
and headed for its target.
4
00:00:41,413 --> 00:00:44,179
It had a date with Jupiter.
5
00:00:46,269 --> 00:00:49,388
In an encounter that
would break all records,
6
00:00:49,389 --> 00:00:51,440
the probe accelerated towards
7
00:00:51,441 --> 00:00:54,291
the largest planet in the solar system,
8
00:00:55,387 --> 00:00:57,878
plunged into its thick clouds,
9
00:00:57,879 --> 00:01:01,945
and was swallowed by its atmosphere.
10
00:01:53,648 --> 00:01:58,635
Without its atmosphere, we
could not live on Earth.
11
00:02:02,604 --> 00:02:04,813
Rain on our faces.
12
00:02:04,814 --> 00:02:06,991
Wind in our hair.
13
00:02:06,992 --> 00:02:09,532
The very air we breath.
14
00:02:09,533 --> 00:02:13,602
Atmosphere is what makes
our planet habitable.
15
00:02:18,963 --> 00:02:21,728
To get an insight into the other planets,
16
00:02:21,729 --> 00:02:25,939
it is vital to understand
how their atmospheres work.
17
00:02:31,190 --> 00:02:35,968
The journey of discovery
began here on Earth.
18
00:02:35,969 --> 00:02:39,308
The first man to explore the
limits of the atmosphere
19
00:02:39,309 --> 00:02:43,399
was U.S. Air Force Colonel Joe Kittinger.
20
00:02:44,288 --> 00:02:47,249
He is still flying at the age of 72.
21
00:02:51,649 --> 00:02:56,639
In 1960 he attempted something
no one had tried before.
22
00:02:56,640 --> 00:03:01,077
To leave the Earth's atmosphere behind.
23
00:03:01,078 --> 00:03:02,452
This was the first time anybody'd ever been
24
00:03:02,453 --> 00:03:03,952
to this high of altitude.
25
00:03:03,953 --> 00:03:05,113
This was the first time man had ever been
26
00:03:05,114 --> 00:03:06,935
in an actual space environment.
27
00:03:06,936 --> 00:03:10,876
So I had some concern about
what was gonna happen.
28
00:03:10,877 --> 00:03:13,695
Project Excelsior was an
attempt to send a man
29
00:03:13,696 --> 00:03:18,655
up to 100,000 feet travelling
in a helium balloon.
30
00:03:18,656 --> 00:03:19,953
If successful,
31
00:03:19,954 --> 00:03:24,324
Joe Kittinger would be the
first human in space.
32
00:03:25,735 --> 00:03:28,212
63,000 feet, that's where a man,
33
00:03:28,213 --> 00:03:30,572
unprotected, his blood would boil.
34
00:03:30,573 --> 00:03:33,092
Actually boil because of lack of pressure.
35
00:03:33,093 --> 00:03:36,471
So for man, space is 63,000 feet.
36
00:03:36,472 --> 00:03:37,991
Any place above that
37
00:03:37,992 --> 00:03:40,443
you die very quickly
without a pressure suit.
38
00:03:48,093 --> 00:03:49,411
The balloon was overhead,
39
00:03:49,412 --> 00:03:51,090
and at the signal they cut the straps
40
00:03:51,091 --> 00:03:55,461
holding the gondola
down, and off I lifted.
41
00:04:19,412 --> 00:04:20,849
I had great confidence in myself,
42
00:04:20,850 --> 00:04:22,629
and the equipment, and the team,
43
00:04:22,630 --> 00:04:24,227
but there's always that unknown.
44
00:04:24,228 --> 00:04:27,428
There's always something that
you may not have covered.
45
00:04:27,429 --> 00:04:31,675
At 50,000 feet Kittinger hit a snag.
46
00:04:31,676 --> 00:04:35,633
The glove on his rudimentary
spacesuit sprung a leak.
47
00:04:35,634 --> 00:04:36,773
Now what that meant was
48
00:04:36,774 --> 00:04:39,493
that the blood would pool in my hand,
49
00:04:39,494 --> 00:04:42,393
and it'd just continually
pool and pool and pool.
50
00:04:42,394 --> 00:04:44,852
But I didn't tell my flight sergeant
51
00:04:44,853 --> 00:04:46,732
because I didn't wanna worry him,
52
00:04:46,733 --> 00:04:48,852
and I also felt that if I had told him,
53
00:04:48,853 --> 00:04:51,192
that he would probably've
made me abort the flight.
54
00:04:51,193 --> 00:04:53,893
I felt that, reasonably
certain, that I could survive
55
00:04:53,894 --> 00:04:57,913
not having a pressure suit
glove on my right hand,
56
00:04:57,914 --> 00:05:00,054
so I continued on.
57
00:05:08,538 --> 00:05:12,315
Overhead the sky was black as it could be.
58
00:05:12,316 --> 00:05:15,625
I couldn't see any stars,
but it was that black.
59
00:05:16,715 --> 00:05:19,332
An hour and a half after lift off,
60
00:05:19,333 --> 00:05:23,293
Kittinger reached 103,000 feet.
61
00:05:23,294 --> 00:05:26,431
I was up on a porch, I was the
highest step in the world,
62
00:05:26,432 --> 00:05:29,060
looking down on our planet.
63
00:05:29,972 --> 00:05:31,821
I could see the clouds below,
64
00:05:31,822 --> 00:05:34,668
and the atmosphere, the haze layer.
65
00:05:34,669 --> 00:05:38,618
It was a very profound feeling that I had.
66
00:05:38,619 --> 00:05:40,486
The realization of really
67
00:05:40,487 --> 00:05:43,326
just how hostile that environment is.
68
00:05:43,327 --> 00:05:46,577
And it's only 20 miles above our earth.
69
00:05:51,637 --> 00:05:55,785
The air outside looks the same,
but there's no air there.
70
00:05:55,786 --> 00:05:58,644
It's like being in an
environment that's cyanide,
71
00:05:58,645 --> 00:06:02,034
and you take one whiff and you're dead.
72
00:06:03,404 --> 00:06:07,311
Just 20 miles down there
was safety, and comfort,
73
00:06:07,312 --> 00:06:10,662
and an environment that man is used to.
74
00:06:12,392 --> 00:06:13,332
Kittinger spent
75
00:06:13,333 --> 00:06:16,991
just 11 minutes on the edge of space,
76
00:06:16,992 --> 00:06:19,598
and then he prepared to return.
77
00:06:19,599 --> 00:06:23,356
So I took that final look around,
I said my silent prayer,
78
00:06:23,357 --> 00:06:26,137
I hit the button to start
the cameras working,
79
00:06:26,138 --> 00:06:28,255
and I jumped from the gondola.
80
00:06:28,256 --> 00:06:29,472
Yeeehoooo!
81
00:06:45,686 --> 00:06:47,922
I fell faced Earth for a little ways
82
00:06:47,923 --> 00:06:50,459
and I had really no sensation of falling,
83
00:06:50,460 --> 00:06:53,603
because I had no visual
reference of anything,
84
00:06:53,604 --> 00:06:56,339
so I thought I was really
suspended in space.
85
00:06:56,340 --> 00:07:00,259
I turned over my back about
this time and I looked up
86
00:07:00,260 --> 00:07:03,457
and the balloon was
racing into the heavens.
87
00:07:03,458 --> 00:07:05,184
I mean at a fantastic rate,
88
00:07:05,185 --> 00:07:07,219
to me it was just flying away.
89
00:07:07,220 --> 00:07:09,271
And what it was, the
balloon was standing still
90
00:07:09,272 --> 00:07:13,067
and I was the one that
was falling so rapidly.
91
00:07:14,834 --> 00:07:18,723
Kittinger fell to Earth
at the speed of sound,
92
00:07:18,724 --> 00:07:22,952
but with no air around
him, it was a silent fall.
93
00:07:24,122 --> 00:07:28,208
I had no ripple of the
fabric in the pressure suit,
94
00:07:28,209 --> 00:07:31,542
and it was a very weird sensation.
95
00:07:34,602 --> 00:07:38,228
After four minutes of
falling through space,
96
00:07:38,229 --> 00:07:41,846
Kittinger began to reenter
the protective blue haze
97
00:07:41,847 --> 00:07:46,723
and was hit by the familiar
world of cloud, sky, and air.
98
00:08:12,744 --> 00:08:16,650
Joe Kittinger had gone
beyond the edge of the sky,
99
00:08:16,651 --> 00:08:19,082
and lived to tell the tale.
100
00:08:20,002 --> 00:08:22,589
15 minutes before I had
been at the edge of space,
101
00:08:22,590 --> 00:08:25,305
and now to me I was in the Garden of Eden.
102
00:08:27,539 --> 00:08:31,455
We really don't appreciate what
a beautiful planet we have.
103
00:08:59,585 --> 00:09:01,412
The atmosphere is a tiny layer.
104
00:09:01,413 --> 00:09:03,413
It's insignificant in terms of mass,
105
00:09:03,414 --> 00:09:05,159
compared to the mass of the planet,
106
00:09:05,160 --> 00:09:08,379
and yet it is so key to our experience
107
00:09:08,380 --> 00:09:11,831
and our very existence here on this planet.
108
00:09:23,021 --> 00:09:27,509
Dave Grinspoon is an atmospheric scientist.
109
00:09:28,921 --> 00:09:30,780
When I first got excited about the planets,
110
00:09:30,781 --> 00:09:32,317
when I was young,
111
00:09:32,318 --> 00:09:34,637
it was the pictures of
the surface of a planet,
112
00:09:34,638 --> 00:09:37,787
it's the most obvious, tangible,
thing that grabs you.
113
00:09:37,788 --> 00:09:39,965
But then as I got into studying planets,
114
00:09:39,966 --> 00:09:43,044
I learned about some of the
frontiers of knowledge,
115
00:09:43,045 --> 00:09:44,504
some of the real mysteries
116
00:09:44,505 --> 00:09:46,684
that were crucial to understanding exactly
117
00:09:46,685 --> 00:09:49,175
how the solar system got
to be the way it is,
118
00:09:49,176 --> 00:09:51,591
how Earth achieved its unique status,
119
00:09:51,592 --> 00:09:53,919
and I found that a lot of the problems
120
00:09:53,920 --> 00:09:55,220
that interested me in that way
121
00:09:55,221 --> 00:09:57,039
had to do with the atmosphere,
122
00:09:57,040 --> 00:09:59,611
with the evolution of the atmosphere.
123
00:10:01,281 --> 00:10:03,778
As far as early astronomers knew,
124
00:10:03,779 --> 00:10:06,368
other planets were just like the moon.
125
00:10:06,369 --> 00:10:09,157
Airless balls of rock.
126
00:10:14,646 --> 00:10:16,550
But in 1761,
127
00:10:16,551 --> 00:10:21,200
a Russian stargazer observed
something very strange.
128
00:10:29,649 --> 00:10:32,304
From an observatory in Saint Petersburg,
129
00:10:32,305 --> 00:10:35,344
Mikhail Lomonosov saw the planet Venus
130
00:10:35,345 --> 00:10:38,976
pass across the face of the sun.
131
00:10:42,886 --> 00:10:45,304
He noticed that the edge of the planet
132
00:10:45,305 --> 00:10:48,755
wasn't hard and crisp like the moon.
133
00:10:49,865 --> 00:10:52,415
Venus seemed fuzzy.
134
00:10:55,805 --> 00:10:58,283
As the planet crept past the sun,
135
00:10:58,284 --> 00:11:02,694
he was astonished to see it
surrounded by a thick halo,
136
00:11:10,044 --> 00:11:14,772
clear evidence of an
atmosphere surrounding Venus.
137
00:11:18,133 --> 00:11:19,949
For 200 years,
138
00:11:19,950 --> 00:11:23,728
what lay below the clouds
remained a mystery.
139
00:11:24,880 --> 00:11:28,467
Could Venus be a world like Earth?
140
00:11:51,377 --> 00:11:55,424
The Russians sent a probe to find out.
141
00:12:13,452 --> 00:12:17,527
As Venera 4 headed for
a splashdown on Venus,
142
00:12:17,528 --> 00:12:19,128
the designer's main worry
143
00:12:19,129 --> 00:12:21,288
was that their spacecraft might sink
144
00:12:21,289 --> 00:12:24,169
and radio contact would be lost.
145
00:12:47,983 --> 00:12:50,774
In October 1967,
146
00:12:50,775 --> 00:12:54,710
radio dishes across Russia
were trained on Venus
147
00:12:54,711 --> 00:12:59,711
eager for news from the
world beneath the clouds.
148
00:13:49,239 --> 00:13:52,615
Under a pressure 15 times that on Earth,
149
00:13:52,616 --> 00:13:55,374
15 miles from the surface of Venus,
150
00:13:55,375 --> 00:13:58,003
Venera 4 was crushed.
151
00:13:58,004 --> 00:14:00,359
The probe didn't splash into an ocean,
152
00:14:00,360 --> 00:14:03,050
it never even came close.
153
00:14:07,620 --> 00:14:12,368
What kind of turbulent world
lay below the clouds of Venus?
154
00:14:13,818 --> 00:14:17,496
The Russians were determined
to land a probe there.
155
00:14:45,127 --> 00:14:48,429
They tested their probes to the limit.
156
00:15:31,623 --> 00:15:35,911
The Soviets set about
recreating Venus on Earth.
157
00:15:36,781 --> 00:15:39,400
To mimic the severe atmospheric conditions,
158
00:15:39,401 --> 00:15:43,791
they built the world's
biggest pressure cooker.
159
00:16:22,539 --> 00:16:24,616
After four years, they had a craft
160
00:16:24,617 --> 00:16:26,816
they hoped was tough enough to survive
161
00:16:26,817 --> 00:16:29,537
the crushing inferno of Venus.
162
00:16:30,397 --> 00:16:31,997
Venera 7.
163
00:16:48,067 --> 00:16:51,084
Just before Christmas, 1971,
164
00:16:51,085 --> 00:16:54,425
Perminov and his team received
the probe's faint signal
165
00:16:54,426 --> 00:16:56,816
reporting touchdown.
166
00:17:07,306 --> 00:17:09,695
They had made it.
167
00:17:23,385 --> 00:17:24,960
The first glimpses we got
168
00:17:24,961 --> 00:17:26,381
of what it really looks like on the surface
169
00:17:26,382 --> 00:17:28,813
were from those Russian Venera pictures
170
00:17:28,814 --> 00:17:31,753
of small pieces of sort of
171
00:17:31,754 --> 00:17:35,164
strange volcanic landscapes on Venus.
172
00:17:39,294 --> 00:17:40,953
Those pictures were mostly of the ground,
173
00:17:40,954 --> 00:17:43,713
but just in the upper
corner of the pictures
174
00:17:43,714 --> 00:17:45,311
you could see a little bit of the sky,
175
00:17:45,312 --> 00:17:48,651
this brightly glowing, but featureless,
176
00:17:48,652 --> 00:17:51,547
because it's cloudy, sky.
177
00:17:51,548 --> 00:17:52,844
I always thought that was really neat.
178
00:17:52,845 --> 00:17:54,565
That you were there on the surface of Venus
179
00:17:54,566 --> 00:17:56,585
and you were just catching
this little glimpse of what it
180
00:17:56,586 --> 00:18:00,505
looked like to actually look
up and see the sky of Venus.
181
00:18:00,506 --> 00:18:02,672
But what had the probe detected
182
00:18:02,673 --> 00:18:05,163
as it fell through that sky?
183
00:18:06,874 --> 00:18:08,272
If you were plummeting down through
184
00:18:08,273 --> 00:18:10,312
the atmosphere of Venus,
185
00:18:10,313 --> 00:18:12,531
first of all you'd have to
make it through the clouds,
186
00:18:12,532 --> 00:18:14,831
which are quite extensive.
187
00:18:14,832 --> 00:18:17,092
They are not like clouds on Earth.
188
00:18:17,093 --> 00:18:19,035
First of all, they cover the entire planet,
189
00:18:19,036 --> 00:18:21,155
and that cloud deck is
more than ten miles thick,
190
00:18:21,156 --> 00:18:22,775
so it'd take you a long
time just to get down
191
00:18:22,776 --> 00:18:24,455
through the clouds.
192
00:18:24,456 --> 00:18:26,054
When you're actually in the
clouds themselves, by the way,
193
00:18:26,055 --> 00:18:29,023
they're very diffused,
it's more like a fog.
194
00:18:30,653 --> 00:18:33,232
But what would it be like to
stand on the surface of Venus?
195
00:18:33,233 --> 00:18:34,692
Now, the first thing that would happen
196
00:18:34,693 --> 00:18:38,191
would be you would scream and
nothing else would happen
197
00:18:38,192 --> 00:18:40,211
because you would be instantly consumed
198
00:18:40,212 --> 00:18:42,710
by the hot, high pressure,
noxious atmosphere.
199
00:18:42,711 --> 00:18:44,690
But assuming you had a
good environmental suit
200
00:18:44,691 --> 00:18:46,470
and you walked out on the surface of Venus,
201
00:18:46,471 --> 00:18:47,911
I think the first thing you would notice
202
00:18:47,912 --> 00:18:50,681
would be the murky red light.
203
00:18:53,571 --> 00:18:55,451
On Venus, in the middle of the day,
204
00:18:55,452 --> 00:18:59,182
it's about as light as on a
deeply overcast day on Earth.
205
00:19:00,032 --> 00:19:02,091
So you would never see the sun
from the surface of Venus,
206
00:19:02,092 --> 00:19:04,661
but there's sunlight filtering
through the clouds.
207
00:19:08,251 --> 00:19:13,390
Venus is a world of unchanging
and extreme weather.
208
00:19:13,391 --> 00:19:16,129
In the high clouds there's
a constant drizzle
209
00:19:16,130 --> 00:19:18,306
of sulfuric acid.
210
00:19:19,376 --> 00:19:22,055
And far below, close to the surface,
211
00:19:22,056 --> 00:19:25,766
an unending stream of
electrical discharges.
212
00:19:58,920 --> 00:20:02,265
Why there is lightning
so far below the clouds,
213
00:20:02,266 --> 00:20:05,606
where it's too hot for
rain, is a mystery.
214
00:20:20,530 --> 00:20:23,661
This hot, high pressure,
corrosive, atmosphere
215
00:20:23,662 --> 00:20:26,532
held one more surprise.
216
00:20:28,182 --> 00:20:31,097
In 1990, an American spacecraft
217
00:20:31,098 --> 00:20:34,589
pierced Venus's clouds with radar.
218
00:20:37,838 --> 00:20:40,437
It saw that some of the
highest mountaintops
219
00:20:40,438 --> 00:20:42,433
were very bright.
220
00:20:42,434 --> 00:20:46,080
As if they were covered
in something reflective.
221
00:20:52,111 --> 00:20:54,611
The high mountain peaks
all around the planet
222
00:20:54,612 --> 00:20:56,867
seemed to be coated with some kind of
223
00:20:56,868 --> 00:20:59,327
metallic or shiny frosting,
224
00:20:59,328 --> 00:21:01,247
something that reflects
a lot of radar energy,
225
00:21:01,248 --> 00:21:03,818
and we don't know what it is.
226
00:21:06,848 --> 00:21:09,067
One idea is that it's
coated with tellurium,
227
00:21:09,068 --> 00:21:10,387
which is a trace metal on Earth,
228
00:21:10,388 --> 00:21:11,967
but may be common enough on Venus
229
00:21:11,968 --> 00:21:13,527
and seems to have just the right properties
230
00:21:13,528 --> 00:21:15,379
so below a certain temperature,
231
00:21:15,380 --> 00:21:17,279
which would mean above a certain altitude,
232
00:21:17,280 --> 00:21:20,199
it may be frosting all
of the peaks of Venus,
233
00:21:20,200 --> 00:21:21,650
the high peaks.
234
00:21:23,120 --> 00:21:24,415
Mountaintops on Earth
235
00:21:24,416 --> 00:21:26,995
are covered with frozen water.
236
00:21:26,996 --> 00:21:31,375
On Venus, the peaks may
be covered in metal.
237
00:21:31,376 --> 00:21:33,371
It seems like there's some
kind of metallic snow
238
00:21:33,372 --> 00:21:35,231
on the highest peaks of Venus,
239
00:21:35,232 --> 00:21:38,402
which is kind of a strange
thing to think about.
240
00:21:50,088 --> 00:21:51,503
Venus turned out to be
241
00:21:51,504 --> 00:21:54,160
far stranger than ever imagined.
242
00:21:55,124 --> 00:21:59,440
But would our other near neighbor
be more similar to Earth?
243
00:22:03,880 --> 00:22:08,880
In 1971, two Russian spacecraft
were on their way to Mars.
244
00:22:52,208 --> 00:22:54,265
As the probes moved in,
245
00:22:54,266 --> 00:22:59,050
Mars was suddenly enveloped
in a giant dust storm.
246
00:24:06,346 --> 00:24:09,889
After transmitting for just 15 seconds,
247
00:24:09,890 --> 00:24:12,280
the probe fell silent.
248
00:24:13,330 --> 00:24:15,209
The flight controllers had no doubt
249
00:24:15,210 --> 00:24:18,500
that the violent dust storm was to blame.
250
00:24:21,870 --> 00:24:26,776
But this was the first picture
from the surface of Mars.
251
00:24:30,426 --> 00:24:33,825
Incomplete and fuzzy, it showed a horizon,
252
00:24:33,826 --> 00:24:38,156
and beyond it, the shadow of a dark sky.
253
00:25:04,878 --> 00:25:06,759
Five years later,
254
00:25:06,760 --> 00:25:10,370
another spacecraft headed
for touchdown on Mars.
255
00:25:18,100 --> 00:25:21,735
This time the probe was American.
256
00:25:21,736 --> 00:25:24,178
It was called Viking.
257
00:25:25,248 --> 00:25:27,004
Okay, maybe we can take this opportunity
258
00:25:27,005 --> 00:25:28,243
to summarize.
259
00:25:28,244 --> 00:25:30,555
Would you like to summarize
where we are today Don?
260
00:25:30,556 --> 00:25:34,951
To date we have of course
landed on the surface of Mars,
261
00:25:34,952 --> 00:25:37,867
and taken pictures both
immediately after landing
262
00:25:37,868 --> 00:25:40,097
and again since then.
263
00:25:40,098 --> 00:25:44,946
At the present time we're
slowly watching the buildup of
264
00:25:44,947 --> 00:25:48,527
data that's going to be
built into a color picture.
265
00:25:48,528 --> 00:25:50,083
And the way we're gonna do it is bring up
266
00:25:50,084 --> 00:25:52,524
first the red, which you see now,
267
00:25:53,464 --> 00:25:57,119
here comes the green, it'll be the second,
268
00:25:57,120 --> 00:25:58,915
and then finally the blue.
269
00:25:58,916 --> 00:26:01,427
You see this last one
coming down, you're again,
270
00:26:01,428 --> 00:26:05,017
now you're gonna see the surface of Mars
271
00:26:05,018 --> 00:26:08,733
as best we can configure it
in color at the present time.
272
00:26:08,734 --> 00:26:11,325
You can see there are a
number of different,
273
00:26:11,326 --> 00:26:14,205
yeah if you douse the
lights, and oh my Gosh!
274
00:26:14,206 --> 00:26:16,881
I wasn't even seeing all the colors.
275
00:26:16,882 --> 00:26:18,518
Look at that.
276
00:26:19,578 --> 00:26:21,829
That's pretty spectacular.
277
00:26:21,830 --> 00:26:22,949
And it does have a reddish hue.
278
00:26:22,950 --> 00:26:24,361
It does have a reddish hue to it,
279
00:26:24,362 --> 00:26:25,931
and look at that sky.
280
00:26:25,932 --> 00:26:27,754
Light blue sky.
281
00:26:35,144 --> 00:26:38,059
But there'd been a mistake.
282
00:26:38,060 --> 00:26:41,639
Because they expected the sky
to be it's familiar color,
283
00:26:41,640 --> 00:26:45,490
the engineers had unwittingly
filtered in too much blue.
284
00:26:46,680 --> 00:26:50,770
The next day they showed
Mars the way it really is.
285
00:26:52,062 --> 00:26:54,981
This world has a pink sky.
286
00:26:54,982 --> 00:26:59,395
It's thin atmosphere is
tinged with red dust.
287
00:26:59,396 --> 00:27:01,741
Mars is a desert world.
288
00:27:01,742 --> 00:27:03,383
From day to night,
289
00:27:03,384 --> 00:27:07,354
the temperature swings by
hundreds of degrees Centigrade.
290
00:27:09,584 --> 00:27:14,573
On Mars the colors of the heavens
are turned on their heads.
291
00:27:14,574 --> 00:27:18,490
Red sky at noon and blue skies at sunset.
292
00:27:44,270 --> 00:27:47,060
How did Mars, Venus, and the Earth
293
00:27:47,061 --> 00:27:50,051
all end up being so different?
294
00:27:55,500 --> 00:27:58,017
It's a puzzle that atmospheric scientists
295
00:27:58,018 --> 00:28:00,768
are just beginning to solve.
296
00:28:10,085 --> 00:28:11,216
A big part of what I study
297
00:28:11,217 --> 00:28:14,956
is trying to understand the
divergence of Earth's atmosphere
298
00:28:14,957 --> 00:28:17,996
from our neighboring
terrestrial planet atmospheres
299
00:28:17,997 --> 00:28:20,176
Mars and Venus.
300
00:28:20,177 --> 00:28:23,778
And I say divergence because
as far as we can tell,
301
00:28:23,779 --> 00:28:26,538
the three probably started
out very similar,
302
00:28:26,539 --> 00:28:29,210
much more similar than they are today.
303
00:28:32,359 --> 00:28:34,954
Four and a half billion years ago,
304
00:28:34,955 --> 00:28:39,570
the planets formed from a
giant cloud of dust and ice.
305
00:28:39,571 --> 00:28:43,828
Mars, Venus, and Earth were
worlds of seething lava,
306
00:28:43,829 --> 00:28:48,479
pummeled by meteorites and
surrounded by a mist of steam.
307
00:28:50,829 --> 00:28:54,128
Mars just didn't have
enough gravity probably,
308
00:28:54,129 --> 00:28:56,109
to hold on to all that atmosphere.
309
00:28:58,219 --> 00:29:01,614
But while the Martian
air was drifting away,
310
00:29:01,615 --> 00:29:06,085
Earth and Venus remained covered
in a thick layer of fog.
311
00:29:09,075 --> 00:29:13,214
After that phase, Earth settled
down and formed oceans.
312
00:29:13,215 --> 00:29:14,747
Okay, it rained.
313
00:29:23,149 --> 00:29:24,960
The same thing may have happened on Venus,
314
00:29:24,961 --> 00:29:27,240
Venus probably had oceans
when it was young,
315
00:29:27,241 --> 00:29:29,620
but that steam in the atmosphere,
316
00:29:29,621 --> 00:29:32,220
with the enhanced sunlight
from being closer to the sun,
317
00:29:32,221 --> 00:29:36,000
led to what we call a runaway greenhouse.
318
00:29:36,001 --> 00:29:39,000
Venus never lost its steamy clouds,
319
00:29:39,001 --> 00:29:41,080
and like a thermal blanket,
320
00:29:41,081 --> 00:29:43,800
they trapped in its heat forever.
321
00:29:43,801 --> 00:29:48,801
The hotter it got, the more
steam boiled off the oceans.
322
00:29:48,833 --> 00:29:52,168
The planet became locked in
a global greenhouse effect,
323
00:29:52,169 --> 00:29:54,998
and it meant disaster.
324
00:29:54,999 --> 00:29:57,670
And eventually we think Venus's oceans
325
00:29:57,671 --> 00:30:00,501
just kept boiling and boiled away.
326
00:30:05,969 --> 00:30:08,322
Now on Earth we have a little
bit of a greenhouse effect,
327
00:30:08,323 --> 00:30:10,202
mostly because of the small amount of CO2
328
00:30:10,203 --> 00:30:12,102
in water vapor in our atmosphere,
329
00:30:12,103 --> 00:30:13,822
and it turns out that's a good thing.
330
00:30:13,823 --> 00:30:16,042
The greenhouse effect
gets a bad rap these days
331
00:30:16,043 --> 00:30:17,442
because of global warming,
332
00:30:17,443 --> 00:30:18,279
and we're all worried about having
333
00:30:18,280 --> 00:30:19,910
too much of a greenhouse effect.
334
00:30:19,911 --> 00:30:22,017
But it's interesting that if
we didn't have one at all
335
00:30:22,018 --> 00:30:24,057
we wouldn't be able to
live here on this planet.
336
00:30:24,058 --> 00:30:26,805
We get about 30 degrees of
warming from Earth's greenhouse,
337
00:30:26,806 --> 00:30:29,265
which is just enough to keep
it in the temperate range
338
00:30:29,266 --> 00:30:31,477
that it's in.
339
00:30:47,089 --> 00:30:49,746
Planetary scientist Andy Ingersoll
340
00:30:49,747 --> 00:30:51,686
believes that the Earth's climate
341
00:30:51,687 --> 00:30:54,637
has one of the most
varied weather patterns.
342
00:30:55,907 --> 00:30:57,806
I would say that we've
343
00:30:57,807 --> 00:31:00,786
learned that there's a
fairly narrow habitable zone
344
00:31:00,787 --> 00:31:02,325
around every star.
345
00:31:03,455 --> 00:31:07,454
Mars is too cold, Venus is too
hot, Earth is just right,
346
00:31:07,455 --> 00:31:11,504
and the extremes are frightening.
347
00:31:14,075 --> 00:31:16,894
For me, I'm a meteorologist really,
348
00:31:16,895 --> 00:31:19,360
fascinating thing about the Earth
349
00:31:19,361 --> 00:31:21,159
compared to the other
planets is that we have
350
00:31:21,160 --> 00:31:25,206
the most unpredictable weather
in the whole solar system.
351
00:31:35,945 --> 00:31:38,739
The dominant weather on Venus seems to be
352
00:31:38,740 --> 00:31:41,870
just the circulation of the atmosphere.
353
00:31:42,800 --> 00:31:45,795
It'd be probably pretty boring
if you could stand the heat.
354
00:31:45,796 --> 00:31:49,836
Day after day of temperatures
hot enough to melt lead.
355
00:31:49,837 --> 00:31:51,587
That's predictable.
356
00:31:53,677 --> 00:31:57,493
On Mars, the dominant weather
that you would notice
357
00:31:57,494 --> 00:32:00,542
would be the day night cycle.
358
00:32:00,543 --> 00:32:02,257
Sort of like living in a desert
359
00:32:02,258 --> 00:32:04,836
or semi-desert area on Earth.
360
00:32:04,837 --> 00:32:07,246
It's another sunny day,
361
00:32:07,247 --> 00:32:09,444
and it'll get cold at night.
362
00:32:10,454 --> 00:32:13,242
And that's predictable, and
it's only in between that,
363
00:32:13,243 --> 00:32:14,630
the Earth is sort of in between,
364
00:32:14,631 --> 00:32:17,559
and that's where the
weather is unpredictable.
365
00:32:18,989 --> 00:32:20,289
There's one other world
366
00:32:20,290 --> 00:32:22,288
with changing weather patterns
367
00:32:22,289 --> 00:32:25,377
and they happen on a dramatic scale.
368
00:32:25,378 --> 00:32:28,502
The giant planet Jupiter.
369
00:32:28,503 --> 00:32:31,191
The whole planet is just atmosphere,
370
00:32:31,192 --> 00:32:33,370
because it's a gas ball.
371
00:32:33,371 --> 00:32:36,930
And there we have examples of
storms that last for 300 years
372
00:32:36,931 --> 00:32:40,652
and maybe even longer than that.
373
00:33:06,192 --> 00:33:09,110
I knew that there were 300 year old storms
374
00:33:09,111 --> 00:33:12,710
and I had this picture of these storms
375
00:33:12,711 --> 00:33:14,589
calmly spinning.
376
00:33:15,519 --> 00:33:18,947
When Voyager got there and started
taking close up pictures,
377
00:33:18,948 --> 00:33:23,177
we realized that at the
smaller scales it was chaos.
378
00:33:24,488 --> 00:33:25,727
Everything was changing,
379
00:33:25,728 --> 00:33:29,576
the little tiny storms were
coming and going every few days,
380
00:33:29,577 --> 00:33:33,313
and yet we had these large
storms that were very stable.
381
00:33:33,314 --> 00:33:36,779
It really deepened the mystery of why the
382
00:33:36,780 --> 00:33:39,791
large storms could have endured.
383
00:33:42,581 --> 00:33:44,880
One of the biggest storms on Jupiter
384
00:33:44,881 --> 00:33:47,552
is marked by its red spot.
385
00:33:47,553 --> 00:33:51,762
And it's been occurring
for around 300 years.
386
00:33:53,392 --> 00:33:55,690
The Great Red Spot is, what,
387
00:33:55,691 --> 00:33:57,729
two or three times the size of the Earth,
388
00:33:57,730 --> 00:34:02,580
but it's only one of a whole
class of large storms.
389
00:34:04,200 --> 00:34:08,144
The next largest class is, was,
390
00:34:08,145 --> 00:34:12,347
three wide ovals that
formed about 60 years ago
391
00:34:13,377 --> 00:34:15,002
and have been sort of
392
00:34:15,003 --> 00:34:17,719
keeping their distance from each other.
393
00:34:28,349 --> 00:34:31,514
But last year two of them merged,
394
00:34:31,515 --> 00:34:35,551
and so it's a kind of historic
event for Jupiter weathermen.
395
00:34:39,142 --> 00:34:43,400
What forces could be
driving the giant storms?
396
00:34:43,401 --> 00:34:45,062
The spacecraft Voyager
397
00:34:45,063 --> 00:34:48,672
was only able to look at Jupiter's surface.
398
00:34:48,673 --> 00:34:50,174
To find out more,
399
00:34:50,175 --> 00:34:54,485
a probe would have to dive right
into those swirling clouds.
400
00:34:59,815 --> 00:35:02,912
NASA put one of its most
experienced engineers
401
00:35:02,913 --> 00:35:05,243
to work on the design.
402
00:35:10,273 --> 00:35:13,059
For Jupiter, the essential problem was
403
00:35:13,060 --> 00:35:16,078
that the planet is so massive, so gigantic,
404
00:35:16,079 --> 00:35:19,178
that in falling into it
from a very great distance
405
00:35:19,179 --> 00:35:22,424
as a probe does, as a
probe approaches a planet
406
00:35:22,425 --> 00:35:26,104
it essentially just falls
into the gravity field.
407
00:35:26,105 --> 00:35:27,824
And the falling into Jupiter
408
00:35:27,825 --> 00:35:32,354
brought you up to speeds of
60 kilometers per second.
409
00:35:32,355 --> 00:35:35,160
If you want to figure
that in miles per hour,
410
00:35:35,161 --> 00:35:36,827
that's a big number.
411
00:35:36,828 --> 00:35:41,828
120, 140,000 miles per
hour, something like that.
412
00:35:42,041 --> 00:35:43,763
Back in the 1960s,
413
00:35:43,764 --> 00:35:46,103
Al Seiff had designed the heat shields
414
00:35:46,104 --> 00:35:49,563
that saved pioneers like John
Glenn and Neil Armstrong
415
00:35:49,564 --> 00:35:52,924
from burning up on reentry.
416
00:36:13,823 --> 00:36:18,489
Seiff had a hand in almost every
spacecraft NASA ever built.
417
00:36:20,916 --> 00:36:22,975
The spacecraft is stable.
418
00:36:22,976 --> 00:36:25,920
Galileo is on its way to another world.
419
00:36:25,921 --> 00:36:28,617
But Jupiter was his biggest challenge.
420
00:36:28,618 --> 00:36:29,905
Fly safe.
421
00:36:29,906 --> 00:36:33,614
We worked, as it turned
out, for nearly 20 years
422
00:36:33,615 --> 00:36:37,794
in getting that experiment
mounted and ready to go
423
00:36:37,795 --> 00:36:40,874
and ready to function
and then finally to fly
424
00:36:40,875 --> 00:36:44,224
way out in the solar
system to that distance,
425
00:36:44,225 --> 00:36:48,493
and of course it was probably
the least certain of success
426
00:36:48,494 --> 00:36:49,993
of any of the missions
427
00:36:49,994 --> 00:36:53,283
because of the challenging
entry conditions.
428
00:37:18,306 --> 00:37:22,594
In December 1995
the Galileo probe
429
00:37:22,595 --> 00:37:26,409
began its kamikaze dive into Jupiter.
430
00:37:57,024 --> 00:38:00,643
The heat shield itself was
made out of carbon phenolic,
431
00:38:00,644 --> 00:38:04,427
and carbon heats up to about 4,000 Kelvin
432
00:38:04,428 --> 00:38:06,056
and then it starts to vaporize,
433
00:38:06,057 --> 00:38:08,487
and that's exactly what
this heat shield did.
434
00:38:11,446 --> 00:38:15,493
The heat shield was about 80% vaporized,
435
00:38:15,494 --> 00:38:17,495
about 20% remaining.
436
00:38:17,496 --> 00:38:20,585
It was white hot, white hot.
437
00:38:22,908 --> 00:38:25,284
Then when the fiery entry was over,
438
00:38:25,285 --> 00:38:28,166
the probe began drifting gently down
439
00:38:28,167 --> 00:38:30,616
into the planet's atmosphere.
440
00:38:34,370 --> 00:38:38,665
It was hoped that Galileo would
detect clouds and rainfall,
441
00:38:38,666 --> 00:38:42,358
and uncover the secrets
of Jupiter's weather.
442
00:38:42,359 --> 00:38:45,465
But Andy Ingersoll was frustrated.
443
00:38:47,042 --> 00:38:51,403
I was surprised at how
little water they found.
444
00:38:51,404 --> 00:38:55,593
Because water is so important
to the weather on Earth,
445
00:38:55,594 --> 00:38:59,501
and it presumably was important
to the weather on Jupiter.
446
00:39:01,275 --> 00:39:04,003
Although Jupiter is covered with clouds,
447
00:39:04,004 --> 00:39:05,762
Galileo had the bad luck
448
00:39:05,763 --> 00:39:09,972
to fall into a narrow gap between them.
449
00:39:09,973 --> 00:39:11,244
It appears that the Galileo probe
450
00:39:11,245 --> 00:39:13,884
went into a desert of Jupiter.
451
00:39:13,885 --> 00:39:15,555
And that if we'd just gone somewhere else
452
00:39:15,556 --> 00:39:18,355
we would have found the rain.
453
00:39:18,356 --> 00:39:21,368
As it sank ever deeper into the atmosphere,
454
00:39:21,369 --> 00:39:23,943
Galileo detected the winds picking up
455
00:39:23,944 --> 00:39:27,406
and the weather becoming
more and more turbulent.
456
00:39:28,805 --> 00:39:30,630
The probe seemed to be getting closer
457
00:39:30,631 --> 00:39:33,532
to the source of the giant storms.
458
00:39:35,615 --> 00:39:38,870
But it could give no more clues.
459
00:39:38,871 --> 00:39:41,290
Three hours after it began its descent,
460
00:39:41,291 --> 00:39:46,029
Galileo ventured too far into
Jupiter's boiling interior.
461
00:39:47,011 --> 00:39:51,454
There was no buoyancy to stop
it from going down and down
462
00:39:51,455 --> 00:39:54,982
and so these very high
temperatures in the interior
463
00:39:54,983 --> 00:39:59,673
ultimately caused the probe
to melt and to vaporize,
464
00:39:59,674 --> 00:40:01,850
and today the Galileo probe
465
00:40:01,851 --> 00:40:04,556
is a part of the atmosphere of Jupiter.
466
00:40:04,557 --> 00:40:07,990
We have actually slightly
contaminated this giant planet.
467
00:40:23,270 --> 00:40:25,594
Was there another world anywhere
468
00:40:25,595 --> 00:40:28,485
that could compare to the Earth?
469
00:40:31,391 --> 00:40:33,744
For centuries, astronomers had watched
470
00:40:33,745 --> 00:40:37,598
a tiny object circling
near the rings of Saturn.
471
00:40:37,599 --> 00:40:39,969
It was bright, like Venus.
472
00:40:39,970 --> 00:40:42,983
It almost seemed to glow.
473
00:40:42,984 --> 00:40:46,118
Could this world have an atmosphere too?
474
00:40:48,047 --> 00:40:51,333
Astronomers could hardly wait to find out.
475
00:40:56,463 --> 00:40:58,714
It was the moon Titan.
476
00:41:07,077 --> 00:41:09,872
I can think about astronomers of yesteryear
477
00:41:09,873 --> 00:41:11,995
like Christiaan Huygens
who discovered Titan,
478
00:41:11,996 --> 00:41:14,295
and the astronomers that came after him,
479
00:41:14,296 --> 00:41:17,462
who spent their lives
looking through telescopes
480
00:41:17,463 --> 00:41:20,695
trying to eke out any little
bit of information they can
481
00:41:20,696 --> 00:41:23,776
about the solar system and
about Titan in particular
482
00:41:23,777 --> 00:41:27,767
and feel a tremendous sense
of sympathy for them.
483
00:41:28,815 --> 00:41:31,783
Modern day planetary scientists like myself
484
00:41:31,784 --> 00:41:34,424
know that we can hypothesize
485
00:41:34,425 --> 00:41:36,029
and come up with all the theories we want,
486
00:41:36,030 --> 00:41:37,922
but eventually we'll get
to where we're going
487
00:41:37,923 --> 00:41:41,120
and we'll be able to see
exactly what the truth is.
488
00:41:42,961 --> 00:41:44,896
The first close up pictures
489
00:41:44,897 --> 00:41:49,897
of this enigmatic moon came in
1980 when Voyager flew by it.
490
00:41:52,751 --> 00:41:53,495
I mean it was clear
491
00:41:53,496 --> 00:41:55,192
that it was a satellite with an atmosphere,
492
00:41:55,193 --> 00:41:56,688
which made it very unique,
493
00:41:56,689 --> 00:41:58,602
because so far up until that point
494
00:41:58,603 --> 00:42:02,254
we associated atmospheres with planets.
495
00:42:02,255 --> 00:42:04,609
The composition of Titan's atmosphere,
496
00:42:04,610 --> 00:42:07,843
the fact that it's 90-95%
molecular nitrogen,
497
00:42:07,844 --> 00:42:10,548
along with the fact that its
atmosphere is pretty dense,
498
00:42:10,549 --> 00:42:13,519
surface pressure is comparable
to that here on the Earth,
499
00:42:13,520 --> 00:42:15,727
a little bit more,
500
00:42:15,728 --> 00:42:18,529
makes it kind of an analog with the Earth,
501
00:42:18,530 --> 00:42:19,630
which is terribly surprising
502
00:42:19,631 --> 00:42:20,972
because no one expected years ago
503
00:42:20,973 --> 00:42:22,776
you'd find an analog of the Earth
504
00:42:22,777 --> 00:42:24,790
out at the distance of Saturn.
505
00:42:27,929 --> 00:42:29,269
The surface of Titan
506
00:42:29,270 --> 00:42:32,648
remained hidden from Voyager's cameras.
507
00:42:35,928 --> 00:42:38,587
But since then, the Hubble space telescope
508
00:42:38,588 --> 00:42:42,489
has managed to peer
through the thick clouds.
509
00:42:44,549 --> 00:42:46,199
There are tantalizing signs
510
00:42:46,200 --> 00:42:49,990
of what look like continents and oceans.
511
00:42:49,991 --> 00:42:54,529
Some say this mysterious moon
has seas of liquid methane.
512
00:42:55,830 --> 00:42:57,677
It is a world planetary scientists
513
00:42:57,678 --> 00:43:01,145
are more eager than ever to explore.
514
00:43:01,146 --> 00:43:04,216
And we, in a matter of,
515
00:43:04,217 --> 00:43:07,138
just a few years once we get to Titan
516
00:43:07,139 --> 00:43:09,448
and once we get to Saturn,
517
00:43:09,449 --> 00:43:12,880
we'll find out a great deal about
518
00:43:12,881 --> 00:43:14,764
what makes this object tick.
519
00:43:48,377 --> 00:43:51,486
Now we have an entire mission
520
00:43:52,676 --> 00:43:54,814
devoted to the study of Saturn,
521
00:43:54,815 --> 00:43:58,179
and Titan is a major
target of this mission.
522
00:43:58,180 --> 00:43:59,302
It's the Cassini mission,
523
00:43:59,303 --> 00:44:01,986
which was launched in October of '97,
524
00:44:01,987 --> 00:44:03,460
and I of course was there
525
00:44:03,461 --> 00:44:06,938
and it was the most spectacular
thing I'd ever witnessed.
526
00:44:11,086 --> 00:44:12,228
It was also very emotional
527
00:44:12,229 --> 00:44:15,682
because I and my colleagues
have spent seven years
528
00:44:15,683 --> 00:44:19,169
developing instrumentation
and the spacecraft itself
529
00:44:20,659 --> 00:44:22,218
to go back to Saturn,
530
00:44:22,219 --> 00:44:26,473
and now we have a six year
wait for it to get there.
531
00:45:07,614 --> 00:45:10,440
In December 2004,
532
00:45:10,441 --> 00:45:14,114
Cassini will release the
European Space Agency probe,
533
00:45:14,115 --> 00:45:15,830
Huygens.
534
00:45:15,831 --> 00:45:19,394
This will embark on a journey
through the clouds of Titan
535
00:45:19,395 --> 00:45:23,162
to the surface of this distant moon.
536
00:45:23,163 --> 00:45:24,961
Parachutes will deploy,
537
00:45:24,962 --> 00:45:28,458
the air shell will be
jettisoned, and the probe,
538
00:45:28,459 --> 00:45:31,758
which is instrumented with six
scientific investigations,
539
00:45:31,759 --> 00:45:34,860
will begin a two and a half hour descent
540
00:45:34,861 --> 00:45:36,577
through the atmosphere.
541
00:45:36,578 --> 00:45:39,173
On the way down it will make
measurements of the pressure,
542
00:45:39,174 --> 00:45:42,241
the temperature, the
composition of the atmosphere,
543
00:45:42,242 --> 00:45:44,985
and it will continue down until it finally
544
00:45:44,986 --> 00:45:48,492
breaks through what we think
to be the lower cloud deck.
545
00:45:58,091 --> 00:45:59,738
The Huygens probe
546
00:45:59,739 --> 00:46:03,346
will slowly sink into
Titan's thick atmosphere,
547
00:46:03,347 --> 00:46:06,522
taking pictures throughout its descent.
548
00:46:13,599 --> 00:46:15,776
We don't know what kind of
material it might land in.
549
00:46:15,777 --> 00:46:19,274
The surface of Titan is likely to be ice
550
00:46:19,275 --> 00:46:22,560
covered with debris that has
rained out of the atmosphere.
551
00:46:22,561 --> 00:46:27,463
There may also be liquid on
the surface, seas and lakes.
552
00:46:32,073 --> 00:46:36,632
With pools of methane,
oily fog, maybe even rain,
553
00:46:36,633 --> 00:46:40,683
Titan could bear some sort
of resemblance to the Earth.
554
00:46:42,233 --> 00:46:45,052
Here is a body with a
surface and an atmosphere.
555
00:46:45,053 --> 00:46:47,212
You could, if properly equipped,
556
00:46:47,213 --> 00:46:49,632
you could walk on the surface of Titan.
557
00:46:49,633 --> 00:46:53,232
And you could see the
results of wind erosion,
558
00:46:53,233 --> 00:46:57,612
and flowing liquids, and
seas, and waves, and winds.
559
00:46:57,613 --> 00:47:01,354
It has almost a feeling of home to it
560
00:47:01,355 --> 00:47:04,627
and I think that's a tremendously
powerful feeling for us.
561
00:47:07,897 --> 00:47:10,136
The Huygens probe has brought back
562
00:47:10,137 --> 00:47:13,936
the spirit of the early days
of planetary exploration,
563
00:47:13,937 --> 00:47:18,466
taking us to a new world
we've never been to before.
564
00:47:18,467 --> 00:47:20,202
Our current knowledge of Titan
565
00:47:20,203 --> 00:47:23,002
is comparable to our knowledge of Venus
566
00:47:23,003 --> 00:47:24,891
in the '50s and '60s.
567
00:47:26,109 --> 00:47:28,800
In those days, when we were
trying to study Venus,
568
00:47:28,801 --> 00:47:32,867
we kind of imagined Earth-like scenarios.
569
00:47:33,801 --> 00:47:36,556
And I suppose we're doing
the same for Titan.
570
00:47:36,557 --> 00:47:38,816
We're imagining lakes,
571
00:47:38,817 --> 00:47:41,556
although we imagine they're
made of hydrocarbons,
572
00:47:41,557 --> 00:47:44,696
but still we sort of feel
comfortable with that concept,
573
00:47:44,697 --> 00:47:47,476
and it may turn out that
Titan is dry as a bone
574
00:47:47,477 --> 00:47:49,167
just like Venus.
575
00:47:55,433 --> 00:47:58,068
You learn humility.
576
00:47:58,069 --> 00:48:00,604
You study the Earth, and you
think you understand it,
577
00:48:00,605 --> 00:48:03,174
and then you say okay, I've
got all these principles,
578
00:48:03,175 --> 00:48:05,316
I'm gonna apply them to another planet,
579
00:48:05,317 --> 00:48:07,426
let's go out there.
580
00:48:07,427 --> 00:48:09,108
You're always surprised,
581
00:48:09,109 --> 00:48:11,948
it's always not what you expected,
582
00:48:11,949 --> 00:48:15,148
and that really teaches
you how little you know.
583
00:48:15,149 --> 00:48:17,051
And how much there is to know.
46115
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.