Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
As passengers, every time we board a plane, we place our trust in the pilots,
airline and the aircraft manufacturer.
It was the first time ever on an aircraft for the family.
And while flying remains the safest form of travel, accidents still happen.
A jetliner on fire over one of the world's largest cities.
Using survivors' stories, accident reports and black box data, we
experienced the final moments on board these notorious flights.
I felt heat, really intense heat.
There was quite a bit of panicking, people screaming.
But could the outcome have been different?
Using a team of highly skilled commercial, military and aerobatic
pilots and our own flight simulator... This is as big an emergency as you can
get. We show you the pressure inside the cockpit.
I don't think the wing is going to stay on that long.
Mayday, mayday, mayday. I just want to get this thing on the ground as quickly
as possible.
How will their vastly different training affect the outcome?
And with hindsight, what would they do differently?
Being on the fire in the air is the worst thing you can think of. That wing
may come off altogether.
In 1968, I was living in Southampton where I was born.
My mum and dad wanted to immigrate to Australia. My dad thought it would be a
lovely place to come and live and start new lives.
My dad was a plasterer and they were crying out for tradespeople and more
people to immigrate here.
We were called Ten Pound Poms, the nickname given to us.
for your family to immigrate to Australia?
My dad was a bricklayer and they needed people.
So my mum and dad thought it was a great thing to start a new life.
I am the youngest of five children.
My older brother, Trevor, he was devastated.
He didn't want to leave at all.
We have very strict parents, so it didn't matter what thoughts we had, we
just... had to go along.
On the 8th of April 1968, BOAC Flight 712, nicknamed Whiskey Echo,
was scheduled to depart from London Heathrow and make its way to Sydney,
Australia, with a first stop in Zurich.
The aircraft for this flight was a Boeing 707-465 Intercontinental.
The Boeing 707 was the first commercial jet that really
changed the aviation world.
Everything these airplanes offered was better. Instead of the vibration of
piston engine airplanes, this airplane was fast, it was high, it was quieter,
it was smoother, it went further, it got there quicker.
It was a great airplane. It was selling like hotcakes for Boeing. It was very
much the airplane that everybody wanted to travel in.
Entering service in 1958,
the 707 was the first long-range narrow-bodied airliner produced by
Boeing.
Later variants were able to carry over 200 passengers up to 5,000 miles, making
it a versatile and reliable transatlantic aircraft for the
burgeoning jet age.
With its swept wing design, earlier 707 models were powered by four Pratt &
Whitney JT4A turbojet engines.
each producing 15,800 pounds of thrust.
More than a thousand 707s were produced across its many variants, making it the
most successful airliner of its era and the aircraft of choice for airlines all
over the globe, including the British Overseas Airways Corporation.
BOAC was very much seen as the national airline.
Strongly expected to buy British aeroplanes. But the fact is that the new
modern aeroplane of the time was the Boeing 707, US made.
So the compromise was we could buy an American aeroplane, we were going to fit
it with British Rolls-Royce engines.
So Rolls-Royce was not only a car company, but a jet engine company. And
they came up with a better engine than what Pratt & Whitney had at the time,
which was a turbojet engine.
So this particular airplane was installed with the very first successful
turbofan engines, the Rolls-Royce Conway.
Created in 1960, the Rolls-Royce Conway turbofan jet engine was designed as a
highly efficient means of propulsion, specifically for large intercontinental
passenger aircraft.
The Conway engines developed by Rolls-Royce were more reliable and
allowed for better fuel economy over a greater range.
significantly boosting the efficiency of the 707s purchased by BOAC.
Whiskey Echo was one of the earlier models that had three crew members in
the cockpit.
You had a captain, a first officer, and then a flight engineer sitting behind
them to operate all of the systems on the airplane.
However, there were five people in this cockpit, not just three, because you had
what they called check airmen. You had pilots in the cockpit that were checking
the performance of the actual flight crew.
In charge of BOAC Flight 712 that day was the experienced Captain Cliff
Taylor.
Monitoring his performance was Supervisory Check Captain Geoffrey Moss,
another experienced airman.
Also in the cockpit was Senior First Officer Francis Kirkland.
Behind them was Engineer Officer Thomas Hicks.
And sitting at the navigator station was Junior First Officer John Hutchinson.
My name's John Hutchinson.
I'm a professional pilot who learnt his trade in the Royal Air Force in 1955 is
when I started, so quite a long time ago.
But I knew from about the age of seven or eight that I wanted to fly
aeroplanes. There's something about the concept of flight that just fired
my imagination, and I knew fine well that that's what I wanted to do.
When I left the Air Force, I then ended up joining BOAC in 1966 and
I became a first officer on the Boeing 707.
On the day of the flight, I have memories of us arriving at the airport.
There was a family photo taken before we left with all our family and friends
there too.
say goodbye to us, then got excited to be on board the plane as it was the
first time ever on an aircraft for the family.
Once aboard the aircraft, the passengers of BOAC Flight 712 that day were to be
looked after by six experienced cabin crew, including 22-year-old Jane
Harrison, the youngest member, who had been a flight attendant with BOAC for
two years.
So I get onto the crew bus and find myself sitting next to Jane Harrison.
I believe she was going to a friend's wedding or something in Australia, and
she was quite excited about that.
We started the engines up, taxied out, everything was completely normal, and,
you know, we're waiting for the clearance for takeoff.
To help us experience and investigate this flight, we've assembled our own
simulator. By inputting real-life flight data and interrogating cockpit voice
recordings, our pilots are able to recreate the flight profile and give us
a better understanding of what happened inside the cockpit.
Today, Wing Commander Andy Green will fly the Boeing 707-400 series, following
the exact same actions as Captain Cliff Taylor.
on boac flight 712.
everyone possibly decline gear travels green lights are out i can remember
about 20 25 seconds after we got airborne there was this great big bang
and a violent lurch and i realized something fairly catastrophic had
happened Immediately the number two engine has wound all the way back to
zero. So putting the initial control corrections in, we have full power on
the other three, climbing away.
I've throttled back on the number two engine.
The captain called for a severe engine failure drill.
We are still climbing. A thousand feet speed is low, so I'm going to drop the
nose slightly to accelerate.
Check, Captain. Captain Moss then shouted out, Bloody hell, the entire
wing's on fire.
That was the first I knew that we'd actually got a fire on board.
This aircraft, the whole of the left wing appears to be burning. There's a
lot going on. Looking out of that window and just seeing orange, I felt heat,
really intense heat.
We will declare a mayday, tell air traffic that we have a problem and need
to get back on the ground very quickly.
Being on the fire in the air is kind of the worst thing you can think of.
You've got fuel, you can't run away from it, you've got lots of air coming in.
It's starting to damage the structure of the wing to the point that maybe that
wing may come off altogether.
The crew needed to get the airplane on the ground immediately.
Soon after takeoff, Whiskey Echo experienced a massive catastrophic fire,
which is one of the most dangerous and hazardous situations that can occur.
In a shocking sequence of events.
BOAC Flight 712 has developed a massive, uncontrollable fire on its portside wing
only a minute after takeoff.
As the aircraft continues to speed through the sky around Heathrow, airflow
across the burning wing works only to further fuel the flames.
The crew has one goal in mind, get their stricken 707 on the ground as soon as
possible.
Having a wing on fire, airborne, and you can't put the fire out. You've got to
land straight away.
They went from an engine failure to not just an engine fire, but the whole wing
on fire. It would be a terrifying situation.
Aeroplanes are pretty much universally made of some form of aluminium alloy.
Aluminium starts to soften somewhere around 120 or 130 Celsius.
Clearly, the temperatures in the fire are going to be much higher than that.
Suddenly, the pylon supporting the number two engine melts through.
and completely unknown to the flight crew, the engine falls from the
aircraft. But the damage does not stop there.
It's going to be burning through hydraulic lines, control cables.
The controls themselves, the ailerons and the flaps, will start to burn away.
Damage to any of the primary flight controls or their physical connections
to the cockpit would greatly impact Captain Taylor's chances of getting
Flight 712 on the ground safely.
This is as big an emergency as you can get, and I want an immediate landing.
This is a pretty intense situation.
There were bells and warning horns going off.
Acting on impulse and amidst mounting pressure in the cockpit, the first
officer mistakenly cancels the fire warning bell.
The flight engineer then pulls the engine's shut-off handle, but does not
activate the engine's fire extinguisher system.
So the captain then calls for a fire drill on that engine.
So here's this first officer and flight engineer.
They've done an after take-off check, so in the middle of a severe engine failure
drill, they're now doing a fire drill. It got a bit intense, to put it mildly.
The heat got more intense.
We'd been told by our mother, you sit in your seat. So I knew not to move,
because I would have been in trouble. And just leaning, pulling away from it.
There was quite a bit of panicking, what I can remember hearing people screaming.
Talking to air traffic, I need to land right now.
With the Mayday call in effect, air traffic control at Heathrow, who can see
the flaming 707 from their control tower, have begun communicating with the
crew. In an emergency, teams on the ground will do everything in their power
to aid the plane in distress.
Runways will be cleared, flights will be held or diverted.
and emergency services will be standing by.
They had informed us that they'd shut the whole airport down, so we knew that
Heathrow was completely available to us.
Heathrow's air traffic control suggests to Captain Cliff Taylor that he returned
to runway 28L, the runway he had taken off from only minutes before.
In an emergency, though, where to land is ultimately the pilot's choice.
Jeff Moss, the route check captain at this stage, He said to Cliff Taylor, you
can't go round for a full circuit to land on that runway we took off from.
He said the wing will burn through and we'll end up crashing in the middle of
London. He said you've got to land on 05.
This would only require the aircraft to complete a much shorter loop back
around, saving them precious time.
As we do the turn back towards the airfield, I should be looking straight
at 05, right?
But this option comes with its own drawbacks.
Now, 05 was a short runway. It was only about 6,000 feet long, so it was about
half the runway length.
And Cliff Taylor really wasn't very happy at this idea. It had no instrument
landing system, no sort of guidance system. It meant he was going to have to
judge a visual approach onto 05.
A traditional landing involves pilots utilizing the runway's instrument
landing system, or ILS.
a ground-based system which provides precise guidance to aircraft on final
approach.
Without this, Captain Taylor will need to pull off a full visual approach on
runway 05R, requiring him to judge the aircraft's height and lateral position
using only what he can see from the cockpit windows.
He was quite resistant and really didn't want to do this.
Jeff Moss in the end more or less said to him, I'm not asking you to land on
05, I'm telling you to land on 05.
05 right, the quickest, easiest, safest way to get the aeroplane down on the
ground. In fact I can see a runway straight ahead of me, that might even be
05 right.
Pulling the power back, we're fast, I'm going to take the gear now anyway.
And we're now long finals for 05.
The fire, the flames, it seemed like such a long time to be looking out at
that and feeling that heat.
I'm wanting to get away from that heat. I can see it now. That wing was next to
me.
While Captain Cliff Taylor begins his approach, the rest of the crew work
furiously to keep on top of the mounting workload.
They had to do a top of descent check, a field approach check and a landing
check, never mind doing sort of radio calls to Heathrow Control Tower to
inform them of what our intentions were.
Cliff Taylor then did the most immaculate approach on this 707.
Still got plenty of speed. All the guys down the back, brace, brace.
Air traffic knows we're doing an emergency landing.
And it'll be thrust reverse on one and four after landing.
So he pulled off this absolutely immaculate landing right at the
beginning of the runway and brought the aeroplane to a halt.
So full thrust reverse on the outboard engines, full braking.
And now it's a case of getting everybody off as quickly as possible.
Because we'd still have the left wing on fire.
Shutting down, closing down all the engines, evacuate.
They still weren't out of the woods by a long shot. The fire had spread from the
wing to the fuselage, so it was imperative that the passengers were
evacuated promptly.
So once they landed, they began to immediately evacuate the airplane.
You had smoke billowing, there was chaos everywhere.
A second ferocious fire has started in the aircraft's tail cone.
and is making its way up the fuselage towards the terrified passengers.
The cabin crew has begun deploying a number of the aircraft's evacuation
slides.
Back then it took a little more time to manually set up the slides and plus
there was a fire on the left side of the airplane so they couldn't adequately use
some of those exits.
On BOAC 712, only two evacuation slides are successfully inflated, both on the
right-hand side of the aircraft.
Those on the left-hand side either malfunction or are too close to the fire
to be usable.
The fire was now really spreading rapidly. In fact, during the evacuation,
the left-wing fuel tank exploded.
Everything on the left-hand side of the airplane was completely unusable because
it was just a wash with burning fuel.
and the occasional explosions, a fuel tank or a tyre exploded, and the
aeroplane would lurch one way and lurch the other way.
Passengers Cheryl Hay and Andrew Cooper, both young children travelling with
their families, wait anxiously for help to come.
I can remember the heat of the fire of the exploding engine.
Oh, the heat was intense, and the smell, the smell of the smoke and the jet fuel.
I can smell it now.
So there's a lot of chaos going on.
The fire service is yet to arrive at the scene of the flaming 707, and with no
means of suppression, the fire grows with every passing second.
The main fire station was north of 28 right.
Now, there was a smaller fire station close to runway 05, but they only had a
couple of fire engines.
The main fire engines then had to get to the scene of where 712 ended up.
You're talking close to a mile. It's a long distance.
With the fire raging, Junior First Officer John Hutchinson leaves the
flight deck to assist the cabin crew with their evacuation of the passengers.
At this stage, there was only one slide available to them. That was the forward
slide, the galley slide on the right-hand side of the airplane, and
about 20 got out over the right-hand overwing.
and jumped off the wing onto the concrete.
And I think most of those people who did that ended up with broken ankles or
broken legs.
As the fire and smoke worsen, the cabin crew of BOAC 712 urge apprehensive
passengers to jump from the available emergency doors.
And my mum went out on that wing.
I think they were too afraid to jump, so they went back in.
The next thing I remember, my dad scooped myself and my sister up. I went
down with my dad, running away, hearing the popping, the windows, the
explosions. Next thing I can remember is being on the floor, crawling through
smoke to the screens of my mother.
The air hostess pushed my mum and dad out of the door.
My dad threw me out of the door just before he got pushed.
I remember running to my mum, who was under the aircraft, covered
in jet fuel.
In around 90 seconds, the cabin crew have managed to evacuate more than 100
terrified passengers.
But the emergency is far from over.
I was now with the captain, Cliff Taylor.
And we jointly realised that there didn't appear to be anybody else up
there. And we then went out of the right-hand window down the flight deck
escape rope.
Once the flight crew is clear, a headcount reveals that even in the chaos
of the evacuation, all apart from four passengers and one crew member are
accounted for.
At that moment, a lone figure can be seen standing in the aft right door.
Cabin crew member Jane Harrison.
Those on the ground shout for her to jump to safety, but she turns and heads
back into the smoke-filled cabin.
She could have saved her life, but she went back into the aircraft to try and
rescue these four passengers and died in the attempt.
Very brave lady.
At the time, I can remember my mum, my dad, screaming for my sister while
being on the runway, but unknown to us, she was trapped in the plane.
My brother, I can remember him saying he could not undo her seatbelt and she
couldn't undo it herself.
And with the panic of the crowd, his hand was pulled out of her hand.
And then the next thing I know, we were told we lost my sister Jacqueline.
So my memories of my sister are very vague because it was so traumatic.
What actually happened on BOAC Flight 712 that day?
Why did one of the aircraft's four engines fail and ignite so soon after
take-off?
And why was it that the resulting fire managed to spread so ferociously in such
a short space of time?
The answer involves one of the components within the number two engine,
an engine which was replaced only days before.
The airplane lines up, winds all four engines up. Charges off down the runway,
there is a bang and the number two engine winds down. What has happened is
that one of the rotating stages inside the engine has actually catastrophically
failed and had what's called an uncontained failure.
A turbofan jet engine contains a number of pressure compressors, each filled
with rapidly spinning bladed wheels, to enable more efficient combustion by the
engine.
On BOAC Flight 712, Fatigue failure caused one of these compressor wheels to
rupture on takeoff, resulting in jagged metal fragments blasting out from within
the engine's casing.
Because of the incredible forces it's spinning at, it's like a bomb going off.
The bits that go downwards just fall on the ground, no harm done to the
aeroplane. The bits that go upwards go up through the engine and then punch a
hole through the wing.
As the fragments explode through the 707's portside wing, they sever Engine
2's high-pressure fuel supply line.
This causes highly flammable jet fuel to begin pouring out of the open line at a
rate of around 50 gallons a minute, dousing the aircraft's wing.
Within a matter of seconds, this had ignited.
The whole wing being on fire meant that eventually the pylon which is the
structure that supports the engine, burned through and the entire engine
fell away.
After engine two had fallen from the stricken 707 mid-flight, it had
miraculously landed in a flooded gravel pit to the southwest of the airport.
We had no idea the engine had fallen off at all, none at all. Could have landed
anywhere, could have landed in a hospital, a school, anywhere, causing
immense damage, and it went into a gravel pit.
How does it come to pass that a component failure can occur on a piece
of equipment as heavily scrutinized as a commercial jet engine?
As it transpires, this wasn't the first time that this plane had been involved
in such a situation.
The airplane previously had a vent in Honolulu, where on takeoff, the number
four engine had a turbine failure. The board had stayed on the runway, but it
caused serious damage to the airplane.
The Honolulu incident caused an almost identical wing fire on the aircraft,
resulting in BOAC undertaking a major overhaul of Whiskey Echo, including the
replacement of all four engines at the end of 1967.
The following year, and only three days before BOAC Flight 712, the No. 2 engine
was again replaced, this time with one which had run almost 15,000 hours since
its construction in 1961.
What's interesting to me about this is this engine had been for overhaul and
had a higher vibration level than BOAC would accept.
However, it met Rolls-Royce standards.
During maintenance, jet engines are routinely measured for levels of
operational vibration to detect issues such as rotor imbalance, bearing wear or
component damage, ensuring safety and optimal performance.
So essentially, Rolls-Royce, who were the original equipment manufacturer, had
assured BOAC that the engine was within specs and serviceable.
So Whiskey Echo is fitted with an engine that is certified for service, but which
contains an undetected metal fatigue crack, making it a ticking time bomb.
With the failure of the engine seemingly inevitable, How did the chain of events
in the busy cockpit of the 707 impact the situation?
As the engine fire starts, warnings occur on the flight deck that this is
happening. And instantly, pretty much everyone starts doing stuff, starts
pressing buttons.
The fundamental issue is that they misidentified the problem.
they initially saw an engine failure and started on the engine failure drill then
one of the pilots looked out of the window and noticed that they the whole
wing was on fire so they stopped the engine failure drill and moved on to the
engine fire drill the first officer it would appear in the midst of all this
unconsciously i would suspect cancels the fire warning bell And unfortunately,
although the flight engineer reached out to pull the handle for the fire
extinguisher, he didn't actually pull it, which means not only did the fire
extinguisher not fire, but the fuel pumps didn't shut down, the hydraulic
valves didn't shut down, so the fuel flow kept going, the fire kept going.
That was a pure human factors failing in a busy cockpit while they were jumping
from one set of checks to the other.
I mean, it's not just that... There's a fire on board, but there are bells,
there are alarms, there are flashing lights.
All of this is creating this kind of heady environment.
It's not surprising that in the midst of all that, several of the five human
beings involved don't do things exactly as per procedure.
Despite the initial confusion on the flight deck, Captain Taylor went against
the suggestion of Heathrow's air traffic control to land on runway 28L, opting
instead for the closer but shorter runway 05R to get the plane on the
ground faster.
A decision which likely saved many lives.
The crew was under huge pressure, having had a bang, an engine failure. Then the
wing is on fire. They are seconds away potentially from that wing failing.
They're now going to put down an aeroplane which they know has a major
problem. Physically, one of the engines has fallen off. The fact that they're
also doing it on one of the non-standard runways, they have no glide slope
information. They are literally just looking out and judging that visually.
They get the aeroplane down in less than three minutes.
That's vanishingly unusual for an airliner. The problem with that...
is that the firefighting teams weren't ready for that type of fire in that spot
on the runway.
The fire station was probably the furthest from where the right airplane
landed that you could get on this airport at the time. And so they got
there as fast as they could.
Unfortunately, it would have been better if they had gotten there sooner.
A fatigue failure on the number two engine caused an explosion.
which resulted in a massive fire on the wing.
The flight crew, initially unaware of the fire, set about running a different
drill, the confusion of the cockpit resulting in the fire extinguisher not
being activated.
And the fire service were delayed in reaching the stricken aircraft once it
had landed.
Despite the captain's decision to land on the closer runway 05R, which almost
certainly saved lives, Four passengers and one crew member still perished
during the evacuation of BOAC Flight 712.
It's shocking to see that only five people died because that entire airplane
is literally destroyed by flames.
The death count could have been a lot higher. That whole crew, from the pilots
who got it down on the ground so quickly and safely in an unusual circumstance,
right through to the flight lieutenant who...
carried on beyond the last moment, saving passengers.
That's an amazing response by the whole crew.
Today, commercial pilot Lauren Wilson and A380 pilot and instructor Sam Watmo
join pilot and aviation journalist Dave Unwin in the simulator to recreate BOAC
Flight 712 for themselves.
When faced with the same rapidly unfolding set of circumstances, will
they manage to match the achievement of Captain Taylor and get their stricken
707s back on the ground as quickly as he did in 1968?
Rotating.
Positive rate of climb, going to raise the gear.
Big bang, looks like we've had some kind of issue on engine number two.
And the levers kick back.
In your failure to checklist.
Aircraft started to roll left, correcting that with a bit of right
rudder. Most important thing is to fly the aeroplane. Just like Flight 712, all
three of our simulator pilots have experienced a sudden and unexplained
failure of their number two engine.
With only three working engines, they each must decide on their next course of
action quickly.
For me, it looks like an engine failure number two.
I believe we might even have lost the engine completely because we've got no
indications whatsoever at the moment. Unusual situation.
Still climbing, but it's not doing what it was.
This is a mayday now.
At this point, each of our simulator pilots is made aware of the ferocious
fire on the port side wing.
As the engine falls away and the fire spreads, the structural integrity of the
aircraft is now at grave risk.
They must all work to get their planes on the ground as soon as possible.
Mayday, mayday, mayday.
Whiskey Echo turning left for an immediate return to Heathrow.
Test pilot Dave Unwin has decided against bringing his plane back around
for a landing on his take-off runway of 28L.
I don't think the wing is going to stay on that long.
I'm going to try and get us back on the 05.
It's not easy.
It didn't work out for me at all.
With his wing on fire, A380 pilot and instructor Sam Watmo has decided to fly
a full loop and attempt a landing back on runway 28L.
Now it's a race against time, getting this aeroplane back on the ground, but
without making such a mess of the approach that actually we put the
aircraft in further danger.
It's quite a long way to get to runway 28L.
So I'm working very hard now to actually position the aircraft to get us back
onto that runway.
Coming in as fast as I dare without risking the aeroplane any further.
Made a mess of the approach there.
Commercial pilot Lauren Wilson decides that a full go-around to 28L will take
too long.
So in the interest of time...
decides to fly a 180 loop and attempt a landing on 1-0 left.
I'm just going to put it straight down on 1-0 left. We are on fire. Gear is
coming down.
Don't care about the speed at the moment. I just want to get this thing on
the ground as quickly as possible because a structural fire is incredibly
dangerous.
Okay, we are on short final.
Gear is down. Speed's quite high.
Very, very long runway. I'm just going to do my best to get this thing on the
ground. as quickly as i can over the flap
right we're very very
fast come on get down don't bounce don't bounce and we're on the ground
full braking full reverse on the three we've got bringing
her to a stop as quickly as i can Shut all the other engines down and we'll get
everyone out evacuating on the runway from the right-hand side. And that is
about that.
With no prior knowledge of the situation, all three of our simulator
pilots chose different runways.
Sam Watmo and Dave Unwin were unable to land the 707. Only Lauren Wilson landed
successfully.
Now, fully aware of what's about to happen, how will our pilots react during
their second attempts?
Dave Unwin has opted for another attempt on runway 05R, the same runway
BOAC712's Captain Taylor landed on in 1968.
This is a closer option, but is a much shorter runway, and one which lacks
landing assistance systems.
Yeah, having the wing on fire is definitely up there with things you
don't want to have happening.
We have no idea how much longer the wing's even going to stay on.
Coming a little bit fast.
It may stop, it may not. It's not easy.
Well, we're down.
It wasn't pretty.
With time running out and the knowledge of his previous failed attempt, Sam
Watmo also opts to try for a landing on the closer runway, 05R.
So rolling out there, let's get this speed under control.
This is going to be an emergency landing.
The plane handling now is actually getting a little bit worse.
It's becoming a little bit trickier to control as the aircraft is slowing down.
So start slowing the airplane down and taking the wheels down there, coming in.
Speed's coming back nicely.
Selecting full reverse thrust and maximum braking, stopping us on runway
05 right there.
Quite a tough landing there.
Having been the only pilot to successfully land on her first attempt,
Lauren Wilson this time opts to fly a teardrop back to runway 05R.
Height is good. Runway's at 9 o'clock. I'm going to keep the turn coming. All I
want to do is get it back on the ground.
OK, I've got runway in sight.
Gear's coming down now.
Getting lined up.
Speed's coming back.
Let's have some speed brake.
OK, lining up on 05.
Speed is still quite high.
Flaps are all the way down.
Full braking, full reverse.
Hopefully we're going to stop before the end.
OK, bang, the parking brake will be going on. Everything's going to get shut
down and, yeah, initiating the evacuation now.
On their second attempts, all three of our simulator pilots opted for runway
05R. With the benefit of hindsight, they mirrored the actions of Captain Cliff
Taylor. successfully landing their 707s as fast as possible, knowing the fire
was burning through the wing.
I can't imagine what that must have been like for a real crew experiencing that,
you know, and seeing the flames and the smoke and everything. It must have been
absolutely terrifying.
So that took me seven minutes. The fact that this crew did it in under four
minutes, to me, is an incredible feat of decisiveness. Actually, to me, that was
really quite incredible and they did a great job.
The wing catching fire.
It's something we definitely don't practice for, and that's really upped
the ante considerably.
I think they did a really good job in very, very trying circumstances.
This was such a well-known and extensively studied incident that 60
years later we're still talking about it.
It has helped produce the safety culture we know today.
One of the things that really...
with the importance of what we now call cockpit resource management.
They do scenarios in the cockpit, get the crews to work together, communicate
together. So that kind of confusion is greatly reduced.
It's a whole different world of when this accident happened and the way
pilots are trained today.
One very significant change took place. The severe engine failure drill was
jettisoned. BOAC decreed after that.
In the event of a severe engine failure with no fire warning, you go straight
into a fire drill regardless.
Although Captain Taylor managed to land the burning plane in under four minutes,
five people lost their lives during the evacuation.
The lessons learned from this incident also addressed how to better evacuate an
airplane and fight fires on airplanes.
Around the world, changes to safety procedures have been made.
Inflatable escape slides have seen huge improvement in their functionality,
reliability and deployment speed since the late 60s.
Modern slides are now self-supporting and capable of full automatic inflation
in 10 seconds.
This, combined with emergency cabin lighting, faster exit doors, fire
-retardant cabin lining materials, and crew training have resulted in
significant enhancements in aviation safety.
Airport firefighting has seen improvements made to rapid response
training, optimal vehicle positioning and equipment reliability for maximum
effectiveness in an emergency.
The catastrophic engine failure on BOAC 712, which resulted in metal shards
rupturing fuel lines and causing a massive wing fire, was caused by
undetected metal fatigue.
One other big change came in the way aircrafts and their components were
subsequently inspected, to identify weak spots and avoid this in the future.
two, three inspection cycles that'll find that crack before it propagates to
failure. And so all those things got much better in time because of an
accident like this.
It's afterwards that you realize the full sort of trauma of what you've been
through.
The flight crew all ended up in the medical center.
And it was while we were in that medical centre that we heard that Jane Harrison
had died.
We believe that one of our girls was still on board, and I'm very sorry about
it.
How are you feeling, Patrick?
Sad.
She was quite rightly awarded posthumously a George Cross.
And she's the only female, certainly at that time, ever to have been awarded a
George Cross in peacetime.
I think it's very important that people realise what cabin crew are on an
aircraft for.
When you've got this very well-trained cabin crew, your chances of survival are
greatly enhanced.
One of the many groups whose flight that day was cut short was the family of
Cheryl Hay.
who eventually made their way from England to Australia, never to return.
Within a week, we were back on board.
Yeah, because we had nowhere to go.
I wanted to see Australia, so I've done small flights. I could never do a haul
to England. I could never go home.
I would love to go back.
I would love to go back. My aunties, my cousins, I had hoped to get back before
one of my aunties passed, but I couldn't do it.
I couldn't do it.
The Cooper family also made a second attempt to emigrate from England to
Australia. My family attempted to take a second aircraft.
Its first stop was Zurich. On landing, I went hysterical on board
the plane, shouting, don't chuck me out the door.
We ended up coming by ship, so it was a six-week cruise to Australia.
And I've never been on a passenger plane since the incident, as I don't know how
I would cope.
After a trauma like what we went through, I value life quite a lot.
I try to enjoy life day by day, take things as they come.
I had a sister born here in 1970,
Michelle, and we were grateful for having another sister.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.