Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
As passengers, every time we board a plane, we place our trust in the pilots,
airline and the aircraft manufacturer.
Flying makes a lot of people nervous. I just could not sit in that seat.
And while flying remains the safest form of travel, accidents still happen.
Takes me right back.
Not a day goes by that I don't think about that day.
Using survivor stories, accident reports, and black box data, we
experienced the final moments on board these notorious flights.
I didn't think that it was anything to be nervous about.
There was an audible gasp at that point.
But could the outcome have been different?
Using a team of highly skilled commercial, military and aerobatic
pilots and our own flight simulator... What on earth is going on here? We show
you the pressure inside the cockpit.
And I start to see lightning coming out of that cloud. This is not really a
place we want to be. Suddenly it felt like the aircraft had lost all its lift.
It's a full-blown emergency, there's no doubt about it. How will their vastly
different training affect the outcome?
And with hindsight, what would they do differently?
The storm suddenly intensified. I realised there wasn't anything I could
do. I was along for the ride.
So my name's Andrea Goodkin, and I was a passenger on Delta Flight 191.
I was born in Southern California, but I grew up in Florida.
I was in boarding school.
and got home almost every weekend as much as I could.
It was the summer before my junior year.
I had just got a car for my 16th birthday.
My parents were divorced, so I lived on the southeast coast with my
father.
My father is one of the sweetest human beings on this planet, and I love him
more than anything in the world.
I'm Wendy Robinson-Fernsell, and I was a flight attendant on Delta Flight 191
that took off from Fort Lauderdale on August 2nd, 1985.
I graduated from college in May of 1985.
I interviewed with three airlines, Eastern, Delta, and American.
And I was hired by Delta in January of 1985.
So I went to training in January.
Dallas was where there were openings, so that's where I ended up being sent.
I was there for two months, and then I transferred to Miami-Fort Lauderdale.
Then I was what you call a reserve flight attendant, which just means like
a substitute teacher. So if somebody calls in sick or can't go to work that
day, then you get called in.
The reason I wanted to be a flight attendant for Delta is because I had
lived abroad when I was in college and had traveled extensively in Europe, and
I felt like I didn't know much about my own country, and I wanted to learn more
about the United States, but I saw a lot of airports and hotels.
I found that there was a lot of honey, myths, stewardess, and I thought that
there should be respect for the position because we're there for safety, because
we're there for people's protection.
At the time, I'd only been flying for one day shy of six months.
So I was a brand new flight attendant.
We were going back to Los Angeles because my sister Valerie was
graduating from acupuncture school.
My father got sick and canceled that morning, but I went ahead and was taking
the flight on my own.
We had answer machines back then that you could still hear when someone was
leaving a message, so I didn't answer the phone. And it was the base in Miami
calling to say I had a flight. So I called, they say we have a trip for you,
it's a two-day trip, so you're going to fly to Dallas, Orlando, spend the night
in Orlando, back to Dallas the next day, and then Dallas back to Fort Lauderdale.
Flying makes a lot of people nervous.
It didn't usually make me nervous at all that day.
There was definitely some nervous energy around it.
It became very pronounced once I got onto the airplane.
I just could not sit in that seat.
And I said, hey, can I change to the smoking section?
They said, yeah. And I said, well, I don't have any cigarettes because I
don't really smoke.
I said, so can I run and buy some?
And they said, well, you better run.
I bought some cigarettes, never really smoked them, but I stayed there.
It was like the bulkhead, and I was sitting across from the stewardess. The
protocol is to sign in for your position where you're going to work.
So on an L-1011, there were eight flight attendants. There's eight positions.
And I was the eighth person to sign up for where I was going to work. The D
zone of the L-1011, which was the very back of the plane, which also at the
time, that was the smoking section because we still were allowed to smoke
on planes.
But at the time, I was a smoker, so it didn't bother me to be in that section.
The people in the smoking section were probably more laid back.
It was an easier place to work.
Flight 191 from Fort Lauderdale to Dallas in Los Angeles was a routine
flight operated by Delta, a well-known airline with a long history in aviation.
Delta's reputation at the time was a very strong, well-thought-of airline. It
had a good flight safety department, pilot training.
Founded in Georgia in 1925, Delta Air Service originally served the
agricultural industry, beginning passenger operations four years later.
It thrived, especially through the jet engine age and the airline age. It just
continued to grow and become a staple of domestic American airlines.
Lockheed certainly has its problems at the moment, but one of the things that's
not been affected is the building out here in the California desert of the L
-1011 TriStar airliners.
The L-1011 was the plane used on Delta 191.
Manufactured by Lockheed and in commercial use since 1972.
It was a wide-body airliner, smaller than a Boeing 747.
but still capable of carrying a large passenger load on long-haul flights.
The L-1011 was meant to be a competitor for the DC-10. Like the DC-10, it was
powered by three jet engines.
In the DC-10, the middle engine on the tail was just... up on the tail and was
a straight pipe.
But the L-1011, they put the engine inside of the tail and then had this S
-duct, so the intake was above and in front of the tail.
Less drag and more fuel efficiency.
The L-1011's main competitor, the DC-10, had already been involved in a string of
high-profile accidents, including the tragic Turkish Airlines Flight 981 in
March 1974.
The aircraft crashed into the Ameneville forest outside Paris, killing all 346
occupants on board.
The DC-10 was starting to get a black mark in the public's eye.
The L-1011 at the time was considered a safer airplane.
Delta Flight 191 was scheduled for an afternoon takeoff from Fort Lauderdale
Airport in Florida on August 2, 1985.
The flight was destined for Los Angeles.
with a scheduled stop at Dallas-Fort Worth International Airport.
The L-1011 seats 302 passengers, but only 163 people were on board that day.
There were eight flight attendants and three pilots.
Piloting Delta 191 was Captain Edward Michael Connors Jr.
With him were First Officer Rudolph Price Jr.
and Flight Engineer Nick Nassik.
The crew were like middle-aged.
And they had your typical amount of experience for an airline crew at the
time. Typical flight, probably, you know, scheduled every day for this run.
What was unusual is they had, that day, thunderstorms popping up at various
places throughout Texas and the Gulf Coast.
But other than that, airplane appeared to be normal, and the flight crew
appeared to be typical. There was nothing you would expect to be anything
other than a normal, you know, landing.
To help us experience and investigate this flight, we've assembled our own
simulator. By inputting real-life flight data and interrogating cockpit voice
recordings, our pilots are able to recreate the flight profile and give us
a better understanding of what happened inside the cockpit.
Today, Wing Commander Andy Green and aviation journalist and pilot Dave Unwin
will fly the TriStar L-1011 in our simulator.
Following the exact same route as the crew of Delta Flight 191.
Positive rate.
Gear up.
Today we'll be flying Delta 191 from Fort Lauderdale to Los Angeles LAX
with a stop at Dallas Fort Worth.
Flaps are coming up.
Climbing through 1,000 feet indicated.
Lovely day to go flying.
The forecast was generally nice.
However, there was a long-range warning of possible thunderstorms later on. We
took off and everything was fine. I'm probably over Louisiana, thereabouts. We
hit turbulence, but not enough for the pilots to shut us down. Everybody could
still stay up serving.
The flight was uneventful. There might have been a little turbulence, but
nothing I noticed.
As the aircraft flies past New Orleans, a storm is building.
The crew decide to deviate from the intended route and approach Dallas-Fort
Worth from the north. But as they near the airport, weather conditions begin to
worsen.
There is something.
Big rain cloud activity.
What's known as weather cells, they're showing up on the radar.
Clearly a lot of weather and rain out in front of us.
If you're at an airport and you've got thunderstorms in the vicinity, you try
to give the pilots, the crews, as much information as you possibly can about
where you think the areas are they don't want to fly through.
Dallas-Fort Worth, where the Delta flight was flying into, that's a
large... It will have had all the latest assistances in that time, but of course
we're talking about the 1980s.
As Delta 191 starts its final approach, a small private Learjet lands ahead of
them.
The approach controller asks the crew to reduce its speed to 150 knots to allow
the small aircraft to clear the runway.
As they started approaching the airfield, there were some cumulus
clouds, sort of bubbly, towering ones that build up.
particularly late afternoons in the heat of the summer, and one of these cells
was bubbling up relatively close to the approach path of the flight.
Captain Collins was well known for being a diligent commander who flew
cautiously, circumspectly.
He knew his machine, he knew the weather, and if he could fly around a
thunderstorm, he would. But of course, when you're on the approach...
You don't have that option.
Thunderstorms were an operating hazard. They were difficult to forecast. They
were difficult to see on the radar in 1985.
Every now and then, you finished up flying near or even through one. You
simply learn to deal with it and accept the fact it might happen occasionally.
For an experienced crew, the storm
did not seem to pose a threat.
And, like the aircraft that had landed ahead of them, they push on with their
approach.
We were coming in for landing, it was time to ready the cabin, so I secured
the movie screen, I made sure people had stowed their bags, and it started to get
rough.
I've just seen a flash of lightning out to the left, so it looks like the
forecaster's occasional thunderstorms were spot on.
On approach to the runway, the storm cell in their path develops rapidly.
It was an unusually fast developing cell.
It went from insignificant cloud to a towering thunderstorm with lightning and
rain and huge winds flashing out of the bottom of it.
It became very bumpy, very unusual movements, like it was jumping around.
This was...
More than ordinary turbulence.
I was in the four right jump seat and there was a flight attendant in the four
left jump seat, Jenny.
And I remember looking over at Jenny and I was giving her a look like it's
rough up here.
As Delta 191 pushes further into the storm, the wind grows stronger and
visibility is reduced.
Clouds are building up so quickly and we're now right in one of those.
what's called weather cells, lots of turbulence, lots of rain.
We were side to side. We were up and down. It was a wild ride.
I didn't really think that it was anything to be nervous about until I
looked in front of me where the flight attendant was, and she was scared.
And then I thought, uh-oh, that's not good.
As the crew prepare to land on runway 17L, lightning flashes ahead.
Despite the crew's careful communication with air traffic control and adjustments
to their heading, the storm is now playing havoc with the aircraft's
handling.
They got changes over 20 or 30 seconds of 70 knots from headwind to tailwind.
They had massive downdrafts and then violent changes up and down.
There's a huge amount of turbulence. We are being battered all over the sky by
this right now.
Now the sink rate's really building up.
I don't like this at all.
As I'm pulling the power back, we're actually increasing speed. Looks like
we've got a fair headwind here. So pulling the power all the way back.
As the flight descends through 1,000 feet towards the runway, the aircraft is
now right beneath the storm.
Now we've really got some sink.
Really got something.
We dropped a lot in altitude at one point. I know there was an audible gas
at that point of passenger.
Now the aeroplane's going down really quite quickly.
Now starting to pull.
Losing speed.
I've got full power. It's still sinking.
I started saying out loud the serenity prayer. God grant me the serenity to
accept the things I cannot change, courage to change the things I can, and
the wisdom to know the difference.
But I realized there wasn't anything I could do.
I was along for the ride.
The captain called for toga, which means take off, go around, full engine thrust,
and you configure your airplane.
But it was too late.
That's not going to make it. Hi.
Looked out the window because where I was was over the left wing.
There was smoke and sparks coming off there.
We slammed down on the ground and I thought that was a rough landing, but
I'm really thankful to be on the ground. But we weren't at the airport.
Delta 191 touches down in an empty field over a mile north of the runway.
The aircraft bounces and veers across a highway where it strikes a car, killing
an unsuspecting motorist caught in its path.
As it reaches the airport's edge, the plane crashes into a water tank, causing
it to rotate, break apart and burst into flames.
Everything was on fire.
Like you're inside a volcano and it's really loud. You don't hear anything but
the fire sound.
I know I was moving and burning and churning.
I closed my eyes because I didn't want to know if I was going to burn to death.
I didn't hear people screaming. It was more of an eerily quiet thing
other than that hearing the metal, feeling that whoosh of
the fireball.
The movement stopped, and I was on the ground in my chair.
I took the seatbelt off and I looked around.
Everything was burning or smoking or black.
There were a lot of people.
Just pieces of people.
And it felt like there was nobody else that made it through.
It's a terrible feeling.
feeling like you're kind of alone on the earth, maybe the only person that was
alive.
Delta 191's impact with the water tank was catastrophic. The plane was
destroyed, leaving a trail of burning wreckage over 1,000 feet long.
There was jet fuel everywhere.
I tried to stand up.
And I had blood in my face just dripping into my eyes. I looked at my hands, and
they were just all bloody.
I just kept trying to get up and walk, but I'd fall down and fall down. And
finally, I just didn't try anymore. I couldn't. I was just too weak.
We were at an angle. I remember looking over at Jenny, and I thought she was
dead. I just was in survival mode.
What I ended up doing was going out the side of the plane because there was no
door. There were passengers there.
We tried to move them away from the plane, so we went towards a police car
that was in the distance.
A man came over, and he said, I need to get you help now.
And I said...
Am I going to die?
And he said, I don't know, your legs look really bad.
And then I tried to sit up to look at my legs, and he goes, no, don't look. But I
looked. And the only thing I've ever seen that looked like that was those
movies where someone, like, steps on a landmine.
That's what my legs looked like.
and I went back towards the wreckage to see if there was anybody that I could
help. Then that was a more chaotic scene. That was bodies on the tarmac.
I ran into one of the other flight attendants, and then she and I were
saying, where are the pilots?
Where are the other crew members?
They weren't there.
It was just the three of us that had survived out of eight.
It was a horrific scene to see the fire, the smoke, the bodies.
They came very close to being able to land at the airport but they crashed
just short of it for all the world to see. The impact was so severe, a total
of 137 people killed, 27 survived.
As with any civil airline accident in the United States, the National
Transportation Safety Board, or NTSB, attended the crash site as soon as
possible.
I remember when it happened. There was a full team launch and even extra people
because of the size of it.
Airplane this big, this many passengers, this many fatalities, will usually
double up on the number of people that go.
You need a lot of help.
NGSB looks at everything.
We're looking at maintenance records. We're looking at pilots' records.
We're examining the impact marks.
We're collecting all the information.
We have air traffic control specialists. We have meteorology specialists looking
at the weather.
We looked at all the aspects of this accident trying to see what happened,
what can be improved.
They had a cockpit voice recorder.
They knew the conversations that the crew was having during the fatal
approach. And they could also hear the rain and the wind hitting the structure
of the airplane, which gave them further clues.
Through their analysis, they determined that there were deficiencies. There were
deficiencies with weather reporting.
There were deficiencies with how air crews were trained. And out of that came
many recommendations to improve safety.
Investigators knew that Delta 191 encountered extreme, rapidly changing
weather in its final approach.
But could technology in 1985 have predicted just how extreme it was?
The storm suddenly developed, suddenly intensified to a huge level, and no one
was prepared for that.
All the information they had coming to them sounded pretty benign. Now, of
course, where that weather information is coming from is not where they are.
And that was one of the problems here. This is very localized.
And so the weather reporter, if he's seen data that looks not bad at all.
What no one could have predicted was how fast the storm developed.
In just eight minutes, the cell two miles north of the runway increased from
VIP level one, considered weak, to level 4 very strong.
When Delta 191 arrived five minutes later, it experienced a change of 70
knots from headwind to tailwind.
And perhaps worst of all, a downdraft, a waterfall of air heading straight down
to the ground.
But the storm developed too fast to warn the plane.
The last weather report received was of no concern at all.
You always pass the surface wing to a landing airplane.
So Delta 191 was told that the wind was 0905 knots, gusting 15 knots.
Well, that air traffic controller is being super helpful because I might not
have even mentioned that it was gusting 15 knots.
In the end, the column of wind, the column of the downdraft, literally
pushed them into the ground. We take a look at how bad the winds were after the
airplane hit the water tanks, broke up. The tail section was originally on its
side, but the winds were so strong, it rotated it back upright.
That's a lot of wind.
The question remained.
How had a thunderstorm created wind strong enough to bring down the L-1011?
It took a lot of research from the NTSB to get with the experts and try to get a
full picture of what we were dealing with.
Ted Fujita was a meteorology expert who focused on extreme wind and weather.
As part of the team investigating Flight 191, he had seen this before, through
studying prior extreme weather crashes.
Ted Fujita became one of the experts the NTSB relied on. He was an important
character in putting all this puzzle together.
Fujita brought his expertise in extreme weather to the world of aviation,
conducting research on how wind affects planes.
He was able to demonstrate that Delta 191 had been brought down by a fast
-developing and violent weather condition known as a microburst.
In a thunderstorm, warm air rises, heavy with moisture.
When the updraft ends and the air cools down, a heavy mass of air and water will
plummet to the ground, a phenomenon known as a downburst.
When the air hits the ground, it forms a powerful outflow of wind that can exceed
100 miles an hour.
A downburst under 2.5 miles in diameter is called a microburst, and that's what
brought down Delta 191.
if you wanted to create a weather system to cause airplanes to struggle near
ground you would create the microburst it's the worst of all worlds and that's
exactly what they got the single most dangerous time to encounter a microburst
is when you are low and slow near the ground getting ready to land and it is
of course where you're going to see a microburst because they occur down at
low level underneath things like thunderstorms if all of a sudden the
airplane is going too fast or too slow because the wind speed has changed at 30
or 40 000 feet that's not terribly significant it's inconvenient it'll be
uncomfortable for the passengers but there's no direct safety implication do
that below a thousand feet when you're slow and heavy and just about to land on
an airfield then there are huge safety implications the ntsp had to get up to
speed on microbursts how big are these things no one in the typical aviation
industry seemed to know ted vegeta was
Critical to the NCSB investigation, he had the real research on microbursts to
help us understand more microbursts, the modelling and how it developed.
But there may have been additional factors at play in the crash of Delta
191.
Back in 1985, the technology did not exist in terms of radar and lasers and
the other things that we use nowadays to track wind variations close to
airfields. it was not possible to forecast a microburst. In the case of
Delta 191, it occurred so rapidly that the microburst was still actually
travelling down past the aeroplane before it hit the ground. So they were
literally there at the moment that it was happening.
Timing couldn't have been worse for them.
With hindsight, the crew of Delta 191 seemed to do everything right based on
what they knew.
Even the small plane in front of them flew through the storm, an approach most
pilots of the day would have taken.
They saw the Learjet, a little airplane, landing ahead of them.
And everything indicated, okay, you know, we're a real big airplane. He's a
little guy. If he punched through this, we won't have a problem.
What they didn't realize is how fast this microburst was developing and how
big it was. That was different.
But everything about them said, yeah, we can do this. And as we got into the
investigation, we started collecting more and more data on the fact that How
many pilots during the final landing approach would go through a thunderstorm
or under a thunderstorm?
I'm coming in, he made it, didn't have a problem, why should I have a problem?
Out of 163 people on board the plane, only 27 survived, including passenger
Andrea Goodkin.
who had moved to the rear smoking section of the plane.
The plane broke apart beneath my chair in that row that I had moved to. I was
at the cut-off line.
Everything forward of me was exploded.
One of the luckiest survivors was flight attendant Wendy Robinson Fernsell, who
was seated in the far right jump seat in the smoking section.
I didn't have any burns.
I didn't have any broken bones.
Survival was dependent on where your seat was.
Some passengers survived because of their seat locations.
Others had no chance due to how the crash unfolded.
The crash was very different from where you were sitting. You're further back.
The nose has absorbed a huge amount of energy. But now you do have a problem
that when the wing hit...
The fuel tanks exploded open, and it's dousing out fuel everywhere, and now
you've got a fire problem.
Most of the survivors were on the very aft end of the aircraft.
They were the far back. They were actually, I believe it's called the
smoking section back in those days. They were kind of the furthest away from the
initial impact, and they were the furthest away from where the fire was
developed from the wing fuel tanks.
If you were sitting in a smoking section, you were more likely to
survive. This is one of the times where a cigarette might have saved your life.
They never could believe that I didn't break a single bone.
I was hurt really badly, but it was all soft tissue damage.
The part that was so more difficult than any pain, any fear, was
living when so many people had not.
Could Delta 191 have survived the microburst that pushed it into the
ground, or was the tragic accident unavoidable?
Inside the simulator, can A380 pilot Sam Watmo land the L1011 TriStar at Dallas
-Fort Worth in similar conditions?
So we've made it here to final approach at Dallas-Fort Worth. Looking out the
window, I can see some towering cumulus, so keep an eye out.
Eye on that, just picking up the glide slope there and starting the initial
descent.
Sam is six miles out.
The town cumulus out the window look pretty severe, to be honest.
Big build-ups up to 40, 50, 60,000 feet perhaps.
Not descending now through 2,200 feet.
Sam enters the storm cell.
Turbulence evident there in the...
changing rates of descent there with this wind shear around might
particularly have to carry a few extra knots there oh full power
there hang on suddenly it felt like the aircraft had lost all its lift it was
almost like the hand of god was pushing us down and we just got pushed from the
sky to the ground even with full power on and
Sam will now run the simulation again, but this time he's aware of what's about
to happen.
of that microburst, I'm going to apply full power, which is a lot of power from
these three engines here, and see if the aircraft can fly through and outperform
it. Now I'm ready for it this time, and let's just see if it is indeed at all
flyable.
When you get into the microburst, it's this column of air coming down very
fast. And so you hit it, it's going to try to pitch you up.
If you know you're going to get into this, Keep your power up, maintain your
pitch, and just try to get through this thing as fast as you can. Or just say,
uh-uh, let's go to full power, let's go around.
I'm going to get stabilized nice and early, holding the glide slope and
localizer. Find their sensible approach speed. Been asked to reduce to finer
approach speed there to follow that Learjet in.
So on the localiser, on the glide slope, on speed at the moment, coming through
about 1,700 feet.
As an aircraft flies, air rushes over its wings, creating lift. The aircraft's
speed relative to this flow of air is known as airspeed.
Greater airspeed causes the plane to rise, whilst a reduction in airspeed
causes it to fall.
As the aircraft encounters the microburst, the first thing it
experiences is an increase in airspeed.
Any pilot would intuitively reduce power, reduce thrust, because you don't
want to be fast on the final approach.
Getting high there, so there's the first signs of that weather.
Getting suddenly low there.
Where is it? All over the place, right?
Full power, climbing away, going to retract a stage of flap, get the drag
flap away.
The second phase is the aircraft encounters the downdraft.
This is the centre of the microburst and it increases the sink rate
exponentially. We'll keep this aeroplane trying to fly. Suddenly you come through
the backside of the cell, now the wind is rushing away from you and suddenly
instead of a huge headwind you've got a huge tailwind, you've got even less
flying speed and you're still being pushed down by the downdraft.
Speed's washed off, massive tailwind and got very little indicated airspeed.
Even with prior knowledge of the conditions, SAM was unable to fly
through the microburst.
It highlights the plight of Delta 191's crew, piloting a plane that was being
inexplicably pushed towards the ground.
First officer did a brilliant job of fighting that, so he stayed on the right
approach path. But he was now below 1,000 feet, fighting the controls right
up to the stops, struggling to retain control of the aeroplane as they were
getting close to the ground.
Pilots today are armed with so much more knowledge and technology to help them.
We're able to make much better decisions much earlier on and the likelihood is
that the aircraft wouldn't be put in that position in the first place.
Now that they know what conditions to expect, can Wing Commander Andy Green or
aviation journalist and pilot Dave Unwin successfully fly through the microburst
and land the L-1011 at Dallas-Fort Worth.
Final approach at Dallas-Fort Worth. We're looking at quite a lot of cloud
ahead of us. I'll try and anticipate executing the toga manoeuvre, take off
and go around, full power, nose up, climb away from the ground and abandon
the approach.
Here I am on approach to Dallas-Fort Worth.
Some significant thunderstorm activity out there.
I'm sort of in and out of some fairly strong showers. There's lightning
around.
Some pretty significant precipitation.
Quite turbulent.
We're getting some vertical excursions.
We're getting some roll inputs.
And I'm starting to see lightning coming out of that cloud. This is not really a
place we want to be. Final approach now. We've got the gear down.
Some flap.
Suddenly, we've gained speed.
Dave enters the outflow headwind, the first part of the microburst. Yep. We're
definitely starting to hit some unpleasant weather now.
Got a little bit more speed than normal, but right now that's a good thing.
It's going to help us to survive and control the microburst.
Dave's plane is nose down, sinking fast and losing altitude in the powerful
wind.
And he enters the outflow headwind.
Suddenly the speed is building up, the aeroplane is rolling, I'm struggling to
control it, I'm throttling back, trying to contain the speed, because we've got
a lot of headwind.
Now his plane hits the microburst itself.
And now we're going down quite hard, so I'm going to start to rescue this. Full
power, pulling the nose up.
Andy's plane strikes the ground in front of the runway.
Touched the ground and got airborne again, which is exactly what happened to
Delta 191. The difference is they hit the ground again and the aeroplane broke
up. I'm just trying to just ease us away from the ground. I've got the power now.
Dave is in the tailwind outflow and his plane is pitching wildly in the wind.
I think we missed the ground by feet.
We got low enough, we actually hit the ground.
The wheels would certainly have left some deep furrows short of the runway,
if indeed the aeroplane would have survived that in the real world.
The simple answer as to why I didn't crash, and unfortunately the crew of
Delta 191 did, is that I knew what was going to happen.
is as all pilots know 2020 expecting the downdraft i applied full
power as quickly as i could the problem with these very early turbo fans is that
they're very slow to spool up and so you've got two problems first the
engines have to accelerate and then once the engines have accelerated and they're
producing thrust then the aircraft accelerates that can take six to eight
seconds and sometimes that's all you've got left to live
Despite the tragedy of Delta 191, the crew's attempts to save the aircraft
were heroic.
The microburst winds pushed the plane down at an incredible rate of 5,000 feet
per minute, nearly 60 miles per hour.
By pulling nose up and increasing thrust, they slowed their descent just
600 feet from the ground.
Before they could slow any further, they touched down, just over a mile short of
the runway.
It was an amazing near recovery.
But unfortunately, the microburst was so violent, it probably wasn't survivable
at that stage. We now understand microbursts much better than they did in
1985.
Crews now would react differently, but then it made perfect sense for them to
try and land despite that weather.
The tragedy had highlighted the danger of microbursts and the necessity of
training pilots to deal with them.
Now, because of this horrific accident, pilots are trained and have a lot of
knowledge about how to get out of this situation.
You react immediately.
You go to full power, you go to maximum pitch, and you try to get the best climb
performance you can.
So when you hit the downdraft, you have a chance of gaining altitude in it while
it's trying to push you to the ground.
Delta 191 had highlighted the importance of early detection and avoidance of
conditions that could cause microbursts.
It was a pivotal moment in aviation safety.
Unfortunately, Delta 191 wasn't the first aircraft to have crashed because
of this weather phenomena, but it was the straw that broke the camel's back.
And in the 90s, the FAA mandated that all passenger planes should have a wind
shear detection device on board the aircraft so that this didn't happen
again.
There is now much better weather reporting capability, Doppler radar, low
-level wind shear alerting systems called LWAS that they've placed in more
of these airports now to better pinpoint and characterize hazardous weather to
warn pilots to stay out or to stop their landing.
Airbus came up with, on their side stick controller,
that if you pull the stick back to the backstop and hold it, the airplane will
go to its maximum available pitch in full power on its own. And it's going to
give you the maximum performance to get out of a microburst.
There is a whole dynamics that developed in the industry based on what was
learned from 191.
I've spent a career flying fast jets as a military pilot. I have never seen wind
shear of the sort that Delta 191 experienced.
And part of the reason is because modern weather forecasting, modern technology
and modern awareness of the hazards means that we either avoid areas where
that could happen or we simply don't fly on days where that could happen. And you
can trace modern safety decisions like that all the way back to flights like
Delta 191.
I didn't come on board with the NTSB until 1991, so six years after this. I
knew many of the investigators that investigated this accident.
I realized that this was a watershed event in aviation because of its
horrific images, because of the amount of people that died, and because of the
lessons learned that prevented future accidents related to microbursts.
I died.
I'm sure of it. And I wanted to go.
And I did. I thought of my dad.
And I thought of how much he loves me.
And I thought, if I die right now, it's going to kill him.
I was told that I would never walk normally again.
And I do walk.
I do 12-and-a-half-hour shifts on the floor as a critical care nurse.
I still enjoy doing backflips on a trampoline. And I did something else
I always wanted to do, which was learn how to surf.
Just another experience in life that I'm so immensely grateful
for.
That was my last flight as a flight attendant.
That was it.
August 2nd, 1985.
Never went back.
The smell of jet fuel is something that stays with me.
So every time I board an airplane today, it takes me right back.
I like to tell the crew when I get on board who I am and what I've experienced
because not many people are walking the planet that have survived airplane
crashes.
Not a day goes by that I don't think about that day.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.