Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
Announcer: Major funding
for "Crime and Punishment in \hAmerica" was provided by...
The Atlantic Philanthropies,
Emerson Collective,
The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation,
and the Park Foundation.
\h\h\h\hMajor funding was also provided by
\hthe following members of The Better Angels Society:
The Fullerton Family \h\hCharitable Fund,
The Just Trust for Education,
Allan and Shelley Holt,
The Tow Foundation,
and the Sozosei Foundation.
Additional support
was provided by
the National Endowment \h\hfor the Humanities,
The Arthur Vining Davis \h\h\h\h\hFoundations,
and by The Better Angels \h\h\h\hSociety members:
John and Catherine Debs,
Timothy Fazio,
\h\hLise Strickler and Mark Gallogly,
the Laurie M. Tisch Illumination Fund,
and these additional funders.
\h\h\h\h\h"Crime and Punishment in America" was made possible,
in part, by contributions \h\h\hto your PBS station
from Viewers Like You. \h\h\h\h\h\hThank you.
Viewer discretion is advised.
The following program contains \h\h\h\h\h\h\hgraphic violence
\h\h\h\h\hwhich may not be suitable for all audiences.
[Horses clopping, carriages creaking]
[Horn honks]
[Dogs barking]
Narrator: In 1896,
a photographer named Clara Sheldon Smith
opened a studio
\h\h\hin the gold rush town of Marysville, California.
[Camera shutter clicking]
She photographed local events, \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hpeople at work,
and made formal portraits.
In 1900, Smith was hired \h\h\h\h\h\h\hby the town
to photograph everyone \h\h\h\harrested there.
♪
Over the next eight years,
\h\hhundreds of people from all walks of life
\h\hand accused of all sorts of crimes
were taken from the jail \h\h\h\h\h\hto her studio
to have their pictures taken.
The portraits she made of them
were not like any mugshots \h\h\h\h\htaken in America.
♪
\h\h\hReginald Dwayne Betts: One of the things that people
actually are afraid to ask folks \h\his why people commit crimes.
And I think one of the reasons \h\h\h\h\hwhy they're afraid is
because people commit crimes for a whole lot of reasons.
\h\h\h\hIf you push me to say why do people commit crimes,
I will say that they're living \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hin environments
\h\h\h\hwith intense emotional challenges
that aren't being addressed.
And you make mistakes.
And you have these moments \h\h\hwhere you fall asleep
in the dream of your enemy.
\hI don't think anybody grows up in the world and says,
"What is the most effective way for me to hurt somebody else?"
♪
Franklin Delano Roosevelt: \h\h\h\h\hA prison to us is
no longer a bastille
to keep people in indiscriminately,
and our object ought to be \h\h\h\h\hto turn them out
\h\h\h\h\h\h\has better citizens than when they went into prison.
J. Edgar Hoover: The Federal \hBureau of Investigation is
waging a relentless warfare against crime and criminals.
Newsreel reader: The king of the gangsters is about
to be taken for a ride \hby your Uncle Samuel.
William Parker: You see, crime \h\hin America is skyrocketing.
\h\h\h\hIt is not a question of the proficiency of the police.
It's a question of \h\hthe indulgences
of the American people.
Policeman: Get your hands up, I said.
Drop that purse and get your hands up.
LD Barkley: We are men. \h\hWe are not beasts,
and we do not intend to be \hdriven or beaten as such.
Doris Tate: We must fight \h\hfor victims' rights,
and we know the victims \h\h\h\hhave no rights.
Speaker: The crime rate \h\h\hisn't going down.
\h\hViolent crime was up 10% across the country last year.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hRonald Reagan: We must make America safe again.
\h\h\h\hIt's time to get these hardened criminals
off the street and into jail.
Speaker: How do you ask somebody to forgive you
for something that is almost impossible to forgive?
Bill Clinton: When you commit \h\h\ha third violent crime,
three strikes and you are out.
Bill Bratton: I'm sensing a fear \h\hamong American police forces
that we are losing the streets.
Betts: Everybody says, \h\h"Why'd you do it?"
But we never have reasons, \h\h\h\h\hnever good ones.
♪
\h\hNarrator: Americans had built the world's first penitentiaries
in the early 1800s with the hope \h\h\h\h\h\h\hthat incarceration
\h\h\h\h\hwould inspire repentance and reform,
and nearly every city \h\h\hhad established
uniformed police forces
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hwith the goal of preventing crime and disorder.
But in the late 19th century, \h\h\h\h\h\hit was clear that
\h\h\h\hneither of these efforts had solved the problem of crime.
In the coming years, across large swaths of the nation,
\h\hthe rule of law would be swept away
\h\h\hby an unprecedented wave of vigilantism and mob justice.
Meanwhile, as millions of poor \himmigrants filled the cities,
a sense of fear and menace began \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hto take hold,
and Americans could not agree
about whether criminals were \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hborn or made.
The most famous trial lawyer in America, Clarence Darrow,
\h\h\h\h\hinsisted that until the United States
addressed the problem \h\h\h\h\hof poverty,
the nation would never solve \h\h\h\hthe problem of crime.
Voice: There is no very great \h\h\h\hdanger of a rich man
going to jail.
Nobody will commit burglary \hwhen he has a house full.
\h\h\h\h\h\hThe only way to cure these conditions is by equality.
There should be no jails.
They do not accomplish what they pretend to accomplish.
\h\h\hIf you would wipe them out, there would be no more criminals
than now.
\h\h\h\hThey are a blot upon any civilization, and a jail
\his an evidence of the lack of charity
of the people on the outside \h\h\h\h\hwho make the jails
and fill them with the victims \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hof their greed.
The laws are really organized
for the protection of the men \h\h\h\h\hwho rule the world.
They were never organized or enforced to do justice.
\hWe have no system for doing justice,
not the slightest in the world.
Clarence Darrow.
[Indistinct conversations]
Voice: As I look back \h\h\h\hon the past,
\h\h\h\h\hI wonder how I ever lived through it all
and escaped the many close calls \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hof death
from the knife, blackjacks, and pistol shots I received.
[Gunshot, people shouting]
The first time I received \h\h\h\h\ha bullet wound
\h\h\hwas in the stomach when I was about 18 years of age.
The shot was fired from a pistol
in the hands of a detective \h\h\hdown in Wall Street,
who, with a large crowd \hof excited men, were
in hot pursuit after me, \h\h\h\h\h\hand shouting,
"Stop! Thief!"
The fact is, I had picked \h\h\hthe pocket of a man
who had a bankbook full of greenbacks
conspicuously sticking up \h\hfrom his coat pocket,
\h\h\h\hand the detective must have seen me do it.
\hI soon got well and strong enough to leave the hospital,
and, through necessity, \h\h\h\h\hwas compelled
to take up my dishonest life \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\honce more.
George Appo.
Narrator: George Appo was born \h\hon the Fourth of July 1856.
His father, Quimbo Appo,
was among the thousands \hof Chinese immigrants
who had come to America \hduring the gold rush.
He settled in the town of Sonora, California.
Voice: One night while asleep in his tent, my father awoke
and saw two Mexicans robbing his partner.
He shot both the Mexicans dead
and left the gold fields
\h\h\h\h\h\hand traveled over the mountains, day and night,
with a gang of Mexicans trying to run him down.
He got safely away.
[George Appo]
Narrator: Quimbo Appo eventually \h\h\h\hmade his way to New York,
where he ran a tea shop \h\hand became a leader
\h\h\h\h\h\hin the city's small Chinese community.
He married a young woman \h\h\h\h\h\hfrom Ireland,
but it was not a happy marriage.
One night, their landlady, \h\h\h\h\h\hMary Fletcher,
\hheard them fighting, and tried to intervene.
\h\h\h\h\hVoice: Our landlady and my father had a quarrel.
Both of them clinched together, \h\hand while in that position,
\h\hshe took up a flatiron and struck him on the back,
\h\hand he stabbed her, and she died instantly.
[George Appo]
Narrator: When New Yorkers \h\h\h\hread in the papers
\h\h\hthat a Chinese man had killed a white woman
\hand injured two others, they took to the streets.
Quimbo was brought \hto the city jail,
\h\hwhere a mob of nearly 1,000 people
threatened to lynch him.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hHe was put on trial for the murder of Mary Fletcher,
and, in less than a day, \h\h\h\h\h\hfound guilty,
\h\h\h\h\h\hand sentenced to ten years' hard labor
to be served at Sing Sing.
George was just three years old.
\h\h\hHis mother was destitute, unable to raise him on her own,
and he was sent to live with a series of foster families.
\hBy the time he was nine, he was fending for himself
\h\hon the streets of one of the roughest,
\h\h\h\hpoorest neighborhoods in America: New York's Five Points.
Timothy Gilfoyle: He never goes \hto school a day in his life.
By the 1860s, there are anywhere \h\hfrom 5,000 to 15,000 children
living on the streets \h\h\h\hof New York,
sleeping in alleyways, \h\h\h\h\h\hon streets,
\h\h\h\hwho have been effectively abandoned
or their parents have died.
\hAnd there's no kind of social system, there's no safety net.
Voice: Around the age of nine,
I started out to sell newspapers \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hfor a living,
and I made the acquaintance of \h\h\h\h\h\htwo boys my own age
who always had plenty of money,
earned, as I believed, \h\hby selling papers.
\hBut I soon found out that they were picking pockets on Broadway
and used the newspapers \h\h\h\h\h\has a cover
to work their crooked business.
[George Appo]
\h\h\h\h\hNarrator: George Appo grew up during the Gilded Age,
\ha time when the gap between rich and poor
was steadily widening.
City streets and squalid \h\htenements were filled
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hwith immigrants struggling simply to survive,
\hwhile financiers and industrialists
\hamassed fortunes building railroads,
manipulating stocks, \hmonopolizing steel,
copper, oil, iron, \hsugar, and coal.
\h\h\h\h\h\hMost purchases and financial transactions
\hwere made in cash, and people sometimes
\hcarried enormous sums in their coat pockets,
making them easy prey \h\hfor pickpockets.
On the crowded sidewalks of \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hManhattan,
where all classes crossed paths,
\h\h\h\ha bank messenger was relieved of $14,000;
a carpet manufacturer lost his company's payroll of $16,000;
a federal judge was separated \h\h\h\h\h\h\hfrom his wallet
containing $75,000 in bonds.
\h\hGeorge Appo learned the pickpocket's trade
from fellow newsboys.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hGilfoyle: There was a very specific
\h\h\h\h\hkind of newsboy pickpocketing technique,
where they would flash \h\h\h\h\hthe newspaper
that they were trying to sell in the face of a pedestrian
\hand their other hand would pick the individual's pocket.
Pickpockets eventually developed \h\h\h\h\h\htheir own vocabulary.
A pickpocket was a "pick," \h\h\ha "wire," a "bugger."
The victim was the "touch."
The person that distracted \hthe touch was a "stall."
They worked very specific areas \h\h\hthat were called "beats."
If you worked in a church, \hyou were a "kirk buzzer."
If you worked on a streetcar, \h\hyou were a "car buzzer."
\h\hVoice: Pickpockets are not \hgifted with second sight;
they watch for signs \h\h\hto guide them.
\hSome nervous people betray themselves to a shrewd thief
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hby their actions, and afterwards think it strange
\h\h\hthat the rogue should have known the very pocket
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hthat they had the roll of greenbacks in.
Inspector Thomas Byrnes.
Narrator: Like many members of New York's Police force,
Inspector Thomas Byrnes \hwas of Irish descent
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hand was familiar with the practices and politics
of Tammany Hall.
Like Appo, he had grown up \h\h\h\h\h\hin Five Points
and was well-acquainted \h\h\hwith street life.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hIn 1880, Byrnes was put in charge
of the city's first centralized \h\h\h\h\hbureau of detectives.
He was given the task
\h\h\h\h\hof protecting the Wall Street bankers
\hwho were making New York the financial capital of the world.
Voice: I went down \h\hto Wall Street
and stationed ten men there.
From then until today,
\h\h\h\h\h\hthey have not lost a ten-cent stamp in Wall Street
by a professional thief; not a penny, not a cent.
[Inspector Thomas Byrnes]
\hGilfoyle: Byrnes establishes something called the Dead Line,
which is, roughly, Fulton Street \h\h\h\h\h\h\hin lower Manhattan,
where he proclaims that any known criminal
that's found below the dead line
\h\h\hwill be subject to immediate arrest.
What this does is it removes the pickpocketing population
from Lower Manhattan
\h\h\h\hand it turns Byrnes into a hero on Wall Street.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hNarrator: North of the dead line,
things were different.
So long as they received \h\h\h\hregular payoffs,
the police didn't interfere \h\h\hwith illegal saloons,
brothels, and gambling houses,
or with the gangs \hof pickpockets.
Gilfoyle: Pickpockets \h\h\hwould be given
what was called a monopoly
\h\h\h\hof a specific block or a specific section of the city
or a specific streetcar \h\h\h\hin many cases.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hNarrator: George Appo worked alone
and did not have an arrangement \h\h\h\h\h\h\hwith the police.
Eventually, his luck ran out.
Voice: One day I noticed \h\h\h\ha big 6-foot man
with his vest unbuttoned
and a heavy gold chain with the bar half out of the buttonhole.
\h\h\h\h\hHe was so tall, I had to stand on tiptoe
in order to abstract \h\h\h\hthe chain bar
and get the whole business.
A fellow in the crowd
\h\hsuddenly jostled me violently by accident.
I almost pulled the vest off the intended victim,
\h\h\h\h\h\hwho grabbed me by the coat collar and my wrist
and caught me with his valuable gold watch and chain in my hand,
and called the police.
\h\h\h\h\hI was brought to police headquarters,
where my photo was taken for the rogues' gallery.
[George Appo]
Narrator: Most big city \h\hpolice departments
photographed men and women \hwhen they were arrested,
and displayed their mugshots
\hin what was called the rogues' gallery.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hBut making positive identifications
from photographs alone \h\h\h\hwas unreliable,
so most police departments
also used an elaborate system of \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hidentification
\h\h\h\h\h\hdeveloped by a French police official,
Alphonse Bertillon.
\h\h\h\h\hAnyone arrested was meticulously measured
from their earlobes \h\hto their feet.
Still, after they were released from custody,
\h\hlaw-breakers could easily relocate and assume an alias.
To alert the public and help
police departments around the country recognize them,
Thomas Byrnes published
"Professional Criminals \h\h\h\h\hof America,"
in which he profiled the 200 men and women
he considered the most prolific \h\h\hcriminals in the nation.
Voice: It is my belief that \h\h\h\h\hif men and women
\h\hwho make a practice of preying upon society
were known to others \hbesides detectives,
a check, if not a complete stop,
would be put to their exploits.
I have, therefore, \htaken this means
of circulating their pictures,
together with accurate \hdescriptions of them,
so that the law-breakers can be \h\h\h\hrecognized at a glance.
[Inspector Thomas Byrnes]
Narrator: Byrnes became famous \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hfor solving
\h\hsome of New York's most spectacular bank robberies
and sensational murders.
[Cell door shuts]
\h\h\hHe and his men extracted information
from suspects and witnesses
\h\h\hwith a potent mix of psychological manipulation,
\h\h\hpromises of leniency, and, if all else failed, brute force.
His approach to interrogation
\h\h\h\hbecame known as the third degree.
Voice: Byrnes usually kept \h\hhis victim in the cells
for 24 hours,
\hwith nothing to read and very little to eat.
\hHe was then brought before the inspector.
Byrnes would rise, walk up to him, and knock him down.
He would then be lifted \h\h\h\h\hto his feet,
and Byrnes would again \h\h\h\hknock him down.
If the prisoner confessed, \h\h\h\h\h\hwell and good;
if not, the knocking down \h\h\h\hwould begin again
until the prisoner \heither confessed
or was carried unconscious \h\h\h\hback to the cells.
George B. McClellan Jr.
Gilfoyle: The public, \hfor the most part,
either doesn't know about it
or is unwilling to charge Byrnes \h\h\h\h\hwith police brutality,
in part because there's \h\h\h\ha growing sense
by the 1870s and the 1880s that \h\h\hcrime is out of control,
\hthat the streets are unsafe, some order needs to be imposed.
And Byrnes, while his methods \h\hmay be less than perfect,
is seen as being responsible \h\hfor providing some order,
for providing safety.
Bratton: The third degree \hwas a means to an end,
where the officer felt justified
in that he was dealing \hwith very bad people.
\h\h\hAnd it's the shame of American policing that
\h\h\h\h\h\hit went on for as long as it did.
But it was condoned. \h\hIt was tolerated.
And it still goes on even today.
\hAnd it's reflective of how far we've come
but how far we still need to go.
\h\h\hVoice: I thought it best to begin this study of criminal man
with a thorough examination of \h\h\h\h\h\hcriminal craniums.
Is it possible that individuals
with such an enormous variety of \h\h\h\h\h\hcranial abnormalities
can have the same level \h\h\h\hof intelligence
and sense of responsibility
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\has men with perfectly normal skulls?
Cesare Lombroso.
\h\h\h\h\hNarrator: The Italian anthropologist Cesare Lombroso
established the field of criminology in the 1870s.
His theory of a criminal type \h\hbased on inherited traits
\h\h\h\hmade sense to many white Protestant Americans,
who were alarmed by the hundreds \h\h\hof thousands of immigrants
arriving in the United States \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hevery year,
\h\h\h\h\h\hmost of them from Southern and Eastern Europe.
Kevin Boyle: People are coming \h\h\hwith different religions;
\h\h\h\h\hpeople are coming with different skin colors;
people are coming with languages
that weren't typically heard \hon the streets of America.
A lot of people look at \h\h\hthat difference,
and they see something dangerous \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hin it.
Narrator: Many Americans \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hembraced
the new pseudoscience of \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\heugenics.
\hWith no evidence, eugenicists claimed
that immigrants and poor people
\hbelonged to inferior races and carried defective traits.
Voice: Unless conditions change,
\h\h\hthe population of the United States will,
\h\h\h\h\h\hon account of the great influx of blood
from Southeastern Europe,
rapidly become darker \h\hin pigmentation,
smaller in stature, \h\hmore mercurial,
\h\h\hmore given to crimes of larceny, kidnapping, assault,
murder, rape and sex-immorality
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hthan were the original English settlers.
Charles Davenport.
\hMelissa Murray: The eugenics movement is enormously popular.
\hThe idea here is that we can actually control
for better traits.
It has the imprimatur of science, of logic.
It is taught at some of the best \h\huniversities in the country.
And it sort of is premised \h\h\h\h\h\h\hon this idea
that really bad character traits
are actually heritable,
so criminality is something \h\h\h\h\hthat you inherit.
\h\h\h\hVoice: We believe it is established beyond controversy
that criminals and paupers, \h\h\hboth are degenerate;
\h\hthe imperfect, worm-eaten, half-rotten fruit of the race.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hWe do not propose to turn the criminal and pauper
\hover to the executioner, as is done in some nations.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hProgress of medical and surgical science
has rendered it possible
\h\hto remove or sterilize the organs of reproduction
\h\h\h\h\hof both sexes without pain or danger.
Henry Boies.
Narrator: Dozens of states \h\h\h\h\h\h\henacted laws
authorizing forced sterilization of those they called "imbeciles,
"drunkards, drug fiends, moral or sexual perverts,
and habitual criminals."
In 1927, the Supreme Court would uphold the practice.
Voice: It is better \hfor all the world
\h\h\h\hif, instead of waiting to execute degenerate offspring
\h\hfor crime or to let them starve for their imbecility,
society can prevent those
\hwho are manifestly unfit from continuing their kind.
Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes.
Narrator: By the end of \h\h\hthe 20th century,
as many as 70,000 men and women
confined in America's prisons, asylums, and other institutions
\h\hhad been sterilized without their consent.
\hKhalil Gibran Muhammad: In a nation purported to be governed
by the rule of law,
the point of the law is not \hto give way to blood lust
because the point of the rule of law is to remind ourselves
that human dignity is sacrosanct
\hand that if we decide to take a person's life
in the name of justice
that it should be humane, \h\h\hit should be just,
it should be transparent,
and all parties involved \hshould be accountable.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hThat's not what happened in this country.
♪
Narrator: Americans have been \h\h\h\h\h\h\htaking the law
into their own hands since Colonial times.
Vigilante mobs lynched people \h\hfor all types of reasons
all across the country.
♪
But after Reconstruction ended and Jim Crow segregation began,
the vast majority of lynchings \h\h\htook place in the South,
\h\h\h\h\h\hand almost all of the victims were Black.
Bryan Stevenson: What happens to \hBlack people is very different
than the mob violence that we saw directed at other people.
It wasn't just to punish \h\h\h\h\h\han individual
for even a perceived crime; it was to maintain a social order.
Voice: If it is necessary, every Negro in Mississippi
will be lynched;
it will be done to maintain \h\h\h\h\hwhite supremacy.
Governor James Vardaman.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hSherrilyn Ifill: Lynching was a crime of terror.
\h\hIt wasn't just to kill the victim.
\h\h\h\hThe reason that lynchings happened on the courthouse lawn,
why the lynching body \h\h\h\hwas left up,
\h\hhanging for hours and, sometimes, days,
was to send a message.
It was to compel Black people
\h\h\hto participate in our own oppression
by policing our own ambitions,
\h\h\hby policing our own exercise of citizenship,
so that we would tell \h\h\h\hour children,
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h"Don't walk on that side of the street,"
"Tip your hat when you see \h\h\h\h\h\h\hthat person,"
"Never talk back."
\h\h\h"Why are you trying to go register to vote?"
Narrator: Between 1877 and 1950, \h\h\h\h\h\hlynch mobs would kill
more than 4,400 Black men, \h\h\hwomen, and children.
\h\h\hVoice: Our country's national crime is lynching.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hIt is not the creature of the hour,
\hthe sudden outburst of uncontrolled fury,
or the unspeakable brutality of \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\han insane mob.
\hIt represents the cool, calculating deliberation
\h\h\h\hof intelligent people who openly avow that there is
an "unwritten law" that \h\h\h\hjustifies them
in putting human beings to death
\h\h\h\hwithout trial by jury and without right of appeal.
Ida B. Wells.
\hNarrator: No one did more to expose the horrors of lynching
than Ida B. Wells.
\h\h\hBorn in slavery during the Civil War,
she moved to Memphis, Tennessee, \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hattended college,
and became a teacher, \h\h\h\h\hjournalist,
\h\h\hand the editor of her own newspaper,
the "Free Speech and Headlight."
\h\h\h\h\hIfill: She had very close friends there,
who ran a very successful \h\h\h\h\h\hgrocery store
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hcalled the People's Grocery Store.
It was so successful, \hthis grocery store
owned by these three Black men,
\hthat it got the attention of white competition in the town,
who attacked the store
and these three Black men \h\h\h\hand lynched them.
These were her friends.
And she was forever changed \h\h\h\h\h\hby this event.
\h\hI call her the first investigative journalist
in the United States.
The subject about which \h\h\hshe was consumed
\h\hand which she chose to investigate were lynchings.
\h\h\h\hVoice: Over a thousand Black men, women, and children
have been thus sacrificed \h\h\hthe past ten years.
Masks have long since \h\hbeen thrown aside
\hand the lynchings of the present day
take place in broad daylight.
\h\h\h\hThe sheriffs, police, and state officials stand by
and see the work done well.
[Ida B. Wells]
\h\hNarrator: In many cases, the Black men who were killed
had been accused of rape \h\h\h\h\hby white women.
\h\hWells wrote that such accusations were
an "old threadbare lie."
She also dared to say in print \h\h\hthat Southern white women
"would marry colored men \h\h\h\h\hif such an act
\h\h\h"would not place them beyond the pale of society
and within the clutches of \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hthe law."
\h\h\hWells' reporting infuriated many whites.
While she was out of town,
\h\ha mob destroyed her printing press
and threatened to kill her.
She never returned to Memphis,
and eventually settled \h\h\h\h\h\hin Chicago.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hVoice: Having destroyed my paper,
had a price put on my life,
and been made an exile from home \h\h\h\hfor hinting at the truth,
I felt that I owed it to myself \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hand to my race
to tell the whole truth
\h\h\h\h\h\hnow that I was where I could do so freely.
[Ida B. Wells]
\h\h\h\h\hIfill: She was just an extraordinary, courageous woman,
\hwho was willing to wade into this most difficult,
\h\h\hviolent subject and speak the truth.
\h\h\h\hShe would show up and ask all the questions
\h\hand learn about the lynching victim
and learn about the encounter
that was said to have set off \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hthe lynching.
\h\h\hAnd she would write about these in her paper.
\h\h\h\h\hNarrator: In 1893, Wells decided to investigate
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\ha lynching in the East Texas town of Paris.
After a child named Myrtle Vance \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hwas killed,
her father, Henry Vance, who was \h\ha police officer in the town,
accused a 17 year old named \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hHenry Smith
of raping, mutilating, and killing the girl.
Ida B. Wells reported
that Smith was known in the town \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hto be
"weak-minded," an "imbecile,"
and that he had been arrested \h\hand beaten several times
by Henry Vance.
But according to Wells, \hthere was no evidence
the child had been mutilated \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hor raped.
The Vance family, she wrote,
had "shamefully exaggerated \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hthe facts
"to inflame the public mind,
"so that nothing less than immediate and violent death
would satisfy the populace."
There was no trial.
Henry Smith's culpability \h\hwas never determined.
Reporters from as far away \h\h\h\h\has New York City
descended upon the town to cover what one newspaper described
as "unparalleled punishment for an unparalleled crime."
\h\h\h\h10,000 people traveled to Paris from across the state,
many on specially chartered trains.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hThe town, the "New York Sun" reported,
went into a "wild frenzy \h\h\h\h\hof excitement."
Voice: "St. Joseph Daily News."
Paris, Texas, is to have \h\ha carnival tomorrow.
A negro, charged with the murder of a girl,
\h\h\h\h\hhas been captured and is to be burned alive.
\h\hNo invitations have been sent out,
\h\h\h\hso that it is presumed it will be an informal affair,
at which everyone will be welcome.
["St. Joseph Daily News"]
\h\h\h\h\hStevenson: The people who carried out lynchings were
\hteachers and bankers and doctors and lawyers
and farmers.
\h\h\h\hThey weren't the extreme elements.
These were the backbone \h\h\hof the community.
And when a lynching took place,
everybody was invited \hto affirm this act,
the morality of this act, \hby their very presence.
\h\h\hThat's why you see 10,000 people showing up
at the lynching of Henry Smith.
Voice: The "New York Sun."
Whiskey shops were closed, unruly mobs were dispersed,
\hand schools were dismissed by a proclamation from the Mayor.
Smith was placed upon \h\ha carnival float
in mockery of a king \h\hupon his throne,
\h\hand followed by the immense crowd,
was escorted through the city
so that all might see \h\h\h\hthe monster.
A scaffold ten feet high \h\h\h\hhad been erected.
The cowering wretch was forced \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hup the steps,
where he was pinned to a stake.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hHenry Vance, the father of Smith's victim,
Vance's son, and two uncles of \hthe child gathered around him
\h\h\h\h\hand began to thrust red-hot irons under his feet.
Every contortion of his body
and every groan that escaped \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hhis lips
\h\h\hbrought forth shouts of approval.
The climax was reached
when the irons were thrust \h\h\h\h\hdown his throat.
\hThe Vances then declared their vengeance satisfied.
Then combustible material was placed under the scaffold,
oil was poured over Smith \h\h\h\hand the platform,
and a match applied.
["The New York Sun"]
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hIfill: This was no ordinary murder.
\h\h\h\h\hThis was torture and murder.
And the part that reinforces \h\h\hthe terror is the fact
that you know no one will ever be held accountable for it.
There's no vindication.
It just is what it is.
\hNarrator: In the days following the lynching,
\h\h\hletters and telegrams poured in to Paris, Texas,
from around the nation.
Most were congratulatory.
Some asked for pieces of \h\h\h\hSmith's clothing
or bits of the scaffolding.
Boyle: If you couldn't be \h\h\h\hat that lynching,
you get to share a piece of it.
\h\hThe industry, really, of lynching photographs,
which goes on for 40 years \h\h\hin the United States,
is a way of sharing \hthat experience.
And they are horrific photos.
It's hard to look at them under any circumstances,
but it becomes incredibly hard \h\h\hwhen you start to think,
\h\h"That's someone's son." "That's someone's brother."
"That's someone's sister." "That's someone's mother."
Muhammad: When I see \h\h\h\hthese images,
\h\hI see them as a reason to care about this history.
Without that, I think we just \h\h\h\hperpetuate the notion
that "It wasn't as bad \h\h\h\has it seems..."
"the stories that, today, \h\hthat need to be told
are really not that important."
\h\hAnd I don't want to be a part of that.
Voice: Among the criminals \hwho fill the prisons are
many who habitually gain \h\h\h\htheir livelihood
\hby the profession of picking pockets.
Not infrequently, the youth \h\hwho begins as a newsboy
develops into the hardened man \h\h\h\h\hwho pauses at nothing
in the fulfillment \h\hof his desires,
\hand unhesitatingly takes the life of a fellow-being.
The "New-York Daily Tribune."
Narrator: George Appo \h\hwas 17 years old
when he was arrested \hfor trying to steal
a gold watch and chain.
\h\h\h\h\h\hAt the station, he gave the police an alias
and lied about his age.
Voice: I pleaded guilty, \h\h\h\hbut through fear
\h\h\h\h\hof being sent to the House of Refuge,
which at that time was \h\ha house of torture,
\h\h\h\h\hI gave the name of George Dixon, age 18.
\hAs the detective had told the judge I was anything but good,
he sent me to state's prison.
[George Appo]
Narrator: Prosecutors and judges \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hsaw to it that
\h\h\h\h\hpickpocketing was punished severely,
in some cases as severely \h\h\h\has violent crime.
\h\hThe judge sentenced Appo to 2 1/2 years of hard labor
\h\h\h\h\hat Sing Sing, which, in the 50 years since its creation,
had become one of the biggest \h\h\hmanufacturing complexes
in the world.
Its workforce--1,200 men and a handful of women--
\h\h\h\h\h\hwas larger than most American factories, steel mills,
and plantations.
Seven days a week, the prisoners \h\h\h\h\h\h\hwere forced to toil
\hfor private contractors: quarrying slabs of marble,
forging molten iron into stoves,
and making hats and chairs.
Gilfoyle: The emphasis is on making a profit.
\h\h\hSo it was actually the contractors that had
more control over the keepers, \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hover the guards
than the warden themselves.
Narrator: In the shops,
contractors made the rules
\hand directed the keepers to discipline any prisoners
who broke them.
When Appo arrived at Sing Sing \hunder the alias George Dixon,
he was surprised to encounter \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hhis father,
\h\h\h\h\h\hwho had completed his ten-year murder sentence,
and was now serving time \h\h\h\h\h\hfor assault.
Voice: My unfortunate father
learned from someone of my being \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hsent there,
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hand instead of being quiet about it,
got permission from the warden \h\h\hto see and speak with me.
The result was "The son of the notorious murderer Quimbo Appo
\h\his now at Sing Sing" got into the newspapers,
and made things in general \h\hvery unpleasant for me.
[George Appo]
\h\h\h\hNarrator: George Appo was assigned to work in the laundry.
In the summer, temperatures \hcould reach 150 degrees.
On his third day there,
Appo accidentally \hburned a shirt,
\hand was beaten with the most feared instrument of punishment
at Sing Sing--the paddle.
[Paddle whacks]
Voice: Fancy for yourself
\h\ha man fastened wrists and ankles,
in a stooping position,
and struck with a piece of \hflexible wood or leather
\h\h\h\h\h\hperforated with holes at the end,
and, when lifted from the naked back, sucks the flesh with it.
[The "Pilot"]
Gilfoyle: The paddle.
It would create a sense of \h\h\h\h\hterror, actually,
\h\h\hin the part of people incarcerated in Sing Sing.
One prison guard actually quit
because when he would enter \h\hthe cafeteria at night,
he remembered seeing men
that had been paddled literally \h\h\h\hcrying at their tables,
praying to the Virgin Mary
because they were in such pain.
Some men tried to commit suicide
upon learning they were about \h\h\h\h\h\h\hto be paddled,
\h\hjumping off from the third or fourth tiers of their cells.
\h\h\hNarrator: Appo managed to survive two years at Sing Sing,
\h\hreturned to New York City, and went back to pickpocketing.
Before long, he was arrested \h\h\h\h\h\hagain, convicted,
and sent back to prison \hfor 2 1/2 more years.
\h\h\h\h\h\hWhen he was released, he resolved to find honest work.
Voice: I started looking for work in a hat factory
and applied for a job.
He asked me where I worked last. \h\h\hI told him in state prison.
\h\h\hHe got up from his chair and said, "We have no vacancy."
I then went to Newark, \h\h\h\h\h\hNew Jersey,
and applied at two different \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hhat factories
but met with no success.
I returned to New York
\h\h\h\h\h\hand went direct into an opium joint at 4 Mott Street,
\h\hwhere I knew I could meet some of my former associates,
\h\h\h\hand I learned the different systems
by which one could \h\hearn money easy
\hand with less risk than picking pockets.
[George Appo]
Narrator: The system for making \heasy money that Appo learned
was called the green goods game,
and it was one of the most \hdevious scams in America.
The con-men who ran it claimed
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hto be selling counterfeit bills--green goods--
that were so well made,
\hthey could easily pass for genuine legal tender.
Their sales pitch was aimed
at anyone thought to be \h\hdown on their luck.
Voice: Dear Sir, your name \hand address was given me
\hby my confidential agent, who said he thought you were a man
in a position to handle \h\hmy goods in safety.
My business is not exactly \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hlegitimate,
but the "Green Articles" \h\h\hI deal in are safe
and profitable to handle.
The sizes are $1.00, $2.00, \h\h\h\h\h\h$5.00, $10.00.
Do you understand?
I remain Yours in Confidence.
[Green goods circular]
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hNarrator: George Appo went to work
for some of the most successful \h\h\h\h\hgreen goods operators
in the country.
\hHis job was to greet unsuspecting customers
at their hotel and escort them \h\h\h\h\hto an office nearby,
where a colleague would show \h\h\hthem the merchandise--
\ha satchel filled with dollar bills.
Gilfoyle: The individual \h\h\hwould be impressed
\h\hby the quality of the counterfeit money
\hand would agree to purchase them.
The money would then \h\hbe put in a bag.
And as the individual \h\h\h\h\hwas paying,
someone would substitute \h\h\h\h\h\hanother bag.
They would come back \h\hto Kansas or Ohio
or wherever they came from.
They would open up the bag, \h\hand it would be filled
with blank paper, a brick, \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hor sawdust.
And the individual \h\hhad no recourse
because they had just attempted
\h\h\h\h\h\hto defraud the federal government.
Narrator: In order to do \h\hbusiness in New York,
\h\h\h\h\hAppo's employers made regular payments to the police,
who looked the other way,
so long as the con men preyed \h\h\honly on out of towners.
\h\h\h\h\hEarly one morning, Appo was sent to Poughkeepsie
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hto reassure two green goods customers,
who had gotten cold feet.
But when he got to their hotel,
\hhe could not convince them to go through with the deal.
Voice: I said to Mr. Hogshead, \h\h"I'm very sorry to hear you
"talk in that manner.
"You are leaving an opportunity \hof your life go by unheeded,
so I will bid you good-bye."
I turned my back to him,
and Hogshead sneakingly took \h\h\h\h\h\hfrom his satchel
a big Colt's revolver,
put it to the back of my right temple,
and shot me. [George Appo]
[Gunshot]
Narrator: Appo somehow survived the shooting,
but he lost his right eye.
He was arrested and charged \hwith aiding and abetting
green goods operators.
George Appo now found himself
on the front page of the newspapers,
recognizable and notorious.
That notoriety would have \hserious repercussions.
\h\hVoice: They are a heartless nation.
The greatest object of their lives seems to be
acquiring possessions, \h\h\h\h\h\hto be rich.
They desire to possess \h\h\hthe whole world,
and we have been driven away \hfrom our beautiful country.
Mysterious Medicine, \h\h\hDakota Nation.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hNarrator: By the late 19th century,
the federal government \h\h\h\h\h\hhad forced
hundreds of thousands \h\hof Native peoples
\h\hto give up their lands and move onto reservations.
The government promised \hto treat reservations
as sovereign territory,
where tribes could make \h\h\h\htheir own laws,
\h\h\h\hand continue to administer justice
according to traditions \h\h\hthey had followed
for thousands of years.
But some in the Federal Bureau \h\h\h\h\h\h\hof Indian Affairs
saw things differently.
\hN. Bruce Duthu: There were folks
within the Bureau of Indian \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hAffairs
that were concerned \h\hthat there was
the propagation of Indigenous culture,
\h\h\h\h\h\hlanguages continued to be spoken, ceremonial life.
Traditional ways of doing things \h\h\h\h\h\hwere still going on,
impeding the work of civilization.
And these government agents had \hbeen pressuring, or lobbying,
Congress for quite some time to \h\h\h\hlegislate in such a way
\h\h\hto clearly give federal administrators that authority
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hto intercede in local internal tribal matters.
\h\h\hNarrator: In 1881, agents in the Bureau of Indian Affairs
in the Dakota Territory \h\hsaw an opportunity
to challenge Native sovereignty.
One of the most powerful men on \hthe Great Sioux Reservation,
the Lakota Chief Spotted Tail,
was killed by Crow Dog, another Lakota leader.
\hDuthu: The very next day, after this act of homicide,
the families came together \h\hand resolved the action
\h\h\h\h\hin a way that was acceptable to all,
through the exchange of \h\h\hblankets, horses,
the payment of some money.
And it wasn't labeling \h\hCrow Dog a criminal
or anything like that.
What it was was symbolic of a commitment by both sides
\h\h\h\hto move forward in a spirit of harmony.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hNarrator: But then federal agents arrested Crow Dog
and charged him with murder,
\h\h\h\h\hsaying he had not been sufficiently punished.
\h\hHe was put on trial, found guilty, and sentenced to hang.
\h\h\h\hWith the help of a court-appointed lawyer,
Crow Dog appealed his conviction
\h\h\h\h\hall the way to the Supreme Court.
The justices overturned \h\hhis guilty verdict,
citing tribal sovereignty, and Crow Dog was released.
Duthu: The court did offer \h\h\h\h\h\ha little advice
to the government to say,
"But it's within your authority \h\h\h\hto change that dynamic
if you so chose."
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hNarrator: Congress began debating a law
\h\h\h\h\hthat would eliminate the authority of Indian tribes
to address serious crimes, including murder and rape.
Voice: Mr. Chairman, I do not believe we shall ever succeed
in civilizing the Indian race \h\h\h\h\huntil we teach them
regard to the law.
Under our present law, \h\hthere is no penalty
that can be inflicted
\h\h\h\h\hexcept according to the custom of the tribe.
They will be civilized \h\ha great deal sooner
by being put under such laws
and taught to regard life
and the personal property of \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hothers.
Congressman Byron Cutcheon.
Narrator: In 1885, Congress passed the Major Crimes Act.
From then on, the federal government could prosecute
any Native person accused of \hcommitting a serious crime
on tribal lands.
\h\h\h\h\h\hNative communities were prohibited from doing much
about serious crimes themselves.
\h\h\h\h\h\hBut Congress failed to allocate adequate resources
for law enforcement \hon reservations.
Many of the crimes the federal government promised to regulate
would go unpunished.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hKevin H. Sharp: The Native American experience
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hgets left out of the conversation a lot.
\h\h\h\h\hBut their experience in the criminal justice system
\h\h\hreally has been one of mistreatment.
And it goes back to the idea
that they didn't deserve \h\hthe same protections
that everybody else got under the Constitution,
at least white people got under the early Constitution.
\h\h\hAnd, so, they have been just ground up and forgotten
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hin this criminal justice conversation.
\h\h\hNarrator: In 1884, Americans were transfixed
by a sensational murder case \h\h\hin Herkimer, New York.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hRoxalana Druse, a 40-year-old wife and mother,
killed her abusive husband.
Then she dismembered and burned his body,
\h\h\h\h\hhoping to destroy the evidence of her crime.
But she was arrested,
found guilty of murder
by an all-male jury,
and sentenced to death.
In the previous decade,
only 12 women had been executed \h\h\h\hin the entire country.
Women's rights groups petitioned \h\h\h\h\h\hthe court for mercy.
Voice: Would a jury of women \h\h\hhave hanged Mrs. Druse?
Why should she not have been tried by a jury of her peers?
It is monstrously unjust
\h\h\hto hold women to a full responsibility before the law
\h\h\hand yet deny them full privileges in law.
Women's only equality in law \h\h\h\h\h\his at the gallows
and in prison, not at the polls.
Mrs. Lillie Devereux Blake.
\h\h\hNarrator: The state did not grant Roxalana Druse a reprieve.
On February 28, 1887, \h\h\hshe was taken from her cell
and led to the jail's yard,
\h\h\h\h\h\hwhere a noose was put around her neck.
Druse did not die quickly.
\h\h\h\h\hIt took 15 minutes for her to strangle to death.
Voice: It is perhaps a little significant that the gallows
is the only piece of machinery \h\hthat has stood stock still
in this era of progress.
\h\h\h\h\h\hThere it stands, the same clumsy, inefficient,
inhuman thing it was
when it first lifted its ghastly framework
into the air of the dark ages.
"Harper's Magazine."
\h\h\h\hMaurice Chammah: Americans have always had
a fair amount of ambivalence \h\habout the death penalty.
Many states abolished it \h\h\h\h\h\hin the 1800s,
including Michigan \h\hand Wisconsin.
But also, there was a movement
to bring executions behind closed doors
\h\hand to make them cleaner and simpler,
so that all we were doing was extinguishing someone's life.
We weren't also torturing them.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hNarrator: After the botched hanging,
New York did away with the gallows
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hand adopted a new method of execution,
\hwhich, according to the "New York Times,"
\h\h\h\hwas a "step forward in the cause of humanity,"
the electric chair.
♪
Voice: It appears that \h\h\hthe police formed
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\ha separate and highly privileged class,
armed with the authority \h\h\h\hand the machinery
for oppression and punishment,
but practically free themselves
\hfrom the operation of the criminal law.
Clarence Lexow.
\h\h\h\h\hNarrator: In 1894, 50 years after New York City
had created the country's first police department,
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hRepublicans in the state legislature,
led by Senator Clarence Lexow,
formed a commission to investigate corruption
in the department.
Chief Thomas Byrnes and his \hofficers found themselves
\h\h\h\hat the center of a political storm.
The Lexow Commission in 1894
is the first instance \h\h\hwhere there is
a massive investigation \hinto police brutality
and police corruption.
Narrator: The Commission wanted \h\hto use the green goods game
to demonstrate the prevalence \h\h\h\hof police corruption,
but they needed an insider to explain how the scam worked.
They subpoenaed George Appo and forced him to testify.
For three hours,
he described what he called \h\h\h\h"police grafting."
Voice: You are well known
to the detectives and policemen
as being engaged in the green goods business?
[John W. Goff]
Voice: Yes, sir.
If I passed by any police
and tried to pick a pocket,
they would see me pretty quick,
but if I passed by them
with a green goods victim,
they bow and look and all that sort of thing.
[George Appo]
Voice: They bow to you?
[Clarence Lexow]
Yes, sir;
I saw one at the Grand Central depot
the other day.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hNarrator: The Commission heard testimony
\h\hfrom people who ran legitimate businesses--
boot-blacks, fruit vendors, \h\h\h\h\h\h\hand grocers.
Police demanded bribes \h\h\h\hfrom them, too,
\h\hand beat those who refused to pay.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hGilfoyle: They demonstrate the existence
of a vast, informal economy
and a network that extends
into all neighborhoods \h\h\h\h\hof the city,
\h\h\hand the profitability of this underground economy
extends into the millions \h\h\h\h\h\h\hof dollars,
\h\h\h\h\h\hlargely protected by the New York City Police.
Narrator: The hearings \h\h\h\h\halso exposed
\h\h\h\hthe hold that Democratic political bosses in Tammany Hall
had over the police department.
To keep their patrons in power,
officers stuffed ballot boxes
and assaulted Republican voters
on election day.
On the stand,
\hChief Thomas Byrnes did not deny that corruption existed,
but said he lacked the power \h\hto do anything about it.
The Lexow Commission concluded \h\hthat the police were guilty
of "oppression, fraud, \htrickery, and crime."
One reporter called the New York Police
"criminals in uniform."
A few months later,
a Progressive New York \h\h\h\h\h\hRepublican
named Theodore Roosevelt
became president of the Board \h\hof Police Commissioners,
\h\h\h\hpromising to reform and professionalize the department.
\h\hVoice: The public may rest assured that
so far as I am concerned,
there will be no politics \h\h\hin the department.
\h\h\h\h\hAll appointments and promotions will be made
for merit only,
and without regard to political \hor religious considerations.
We are all activated \h\h\h\hby the desire
to so regulate this department
\h\hthat it will earn the respect and confidence of the community.
Theodore Roosevelt.
Bratton: That early history \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hof policing
\h\h\h\h\h\hwas shaped by a lot of brutality,
\ha lot of racism, a lot of violence,
\h\h\h\h\ha lot of corruption, a lot of political corruption.
And Teddy Roosevelt was credited
with bringing about \ha lot of reforms
to those negative elements \h\h\h\h\h\h\hof policing.
Narrator: Roosevelt hired \h\h1,700 more officers,
introduced bicycle squads,
\h\h\h\hand demanded that liquor laws be enforced.
He fired hundreds of officers \h\hfor dereliction of duty,
\h\hincluding some who had been accused of brutality and graft
by the Lexow Commission,
and he forced Thomas Byrnes \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hto resign.
But police reform did not last long.
Roosevelt left New York \hfor Washington, D.C.
Some of the officers he fired were reinstated with back pay,
and nothing was done to curtail \hthe use of the third degree.
Thomas Byrnes lived the rest of his life in great comfort.
He had become a very wealthy \hman, thanks to investments
\h\h\h\hmade for him by Wall Street financiers
to whom he had been of service.
Meanwhile, a theater producer \h\h\h\h\h\hwho was producing
\h\ha melodrama about life in the criminal underworld,
called "In the Tenderloin"
offered George Appo \ha starring role.
\h\hEvery night, he reenacted the green goods game onstage.
Audiences were thrilled \h\h\h\h\h\hto see Appo
\h\h\hand several other real criminals perform,
and the show was a hit.
After a brief run in New York, \h\hit went on a national tour.
Gilfoyle: "In the Tenderloin" \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hrepresents
what critics call \h"Freak Drama"--
that individuals that \h\h\hwere associated
with deviant activities
suddenly were being allowed \h\h\hto perform onstage--
\h\h\h\hin some ways in very idealized, dramatic ways that
\h\h\h\h\h\hmade the audience sympathize with the criminal.
Narrator: Before long, other famous outlaws
started appearing on other stages,
including Jesse James' brother \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hFrank.
After the tour, when George Appo \h\h\h\h\h\hreturned to New York,
he was harassed and assaulted \h\h\h\h\hby police officers,
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hwho "feared he knew too much," he said,
"about their crooked dealings."
His underworld associates \h\h\hattacked him, too.
Gilfoyle: His lawyer realized
that it was likely
that he would get killed
by his former associates
in the green goods game.
And a way to protect him was to have him declared insane.
Narrator: On December 24, 1896, \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hAppo was sent
to the Matteawan State Hospital \h\hfor the Criminally Insane.
Voice: When I had been there \h\h\h\h\habout three weeks,
I was surprised, one afternoon, \h\h\hby my unfortunate father
entering the ward and walking \hover to where I was seated,
reading a book.
\hHe began to spring his insane delusions
about his great wealth, \h\h\h\hand that he was
the Commander of the Laws of \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hNature
and was going to blow up \h\h\h\h\hall the prisons
\h\hand, with his army, exterminate all keepers
and doctors in them.
\h\h\hHe then left to attend to his work in the Imbecile Ward.
[George Appo]
Narrator: Quimbo Appo had spent \h\h\h\h\hdecades behind bars,
\h\h\hand his mental health had steadily deteriorated.
At Matteawan, the staff deemed \h\h\h\h\h\h\hhim too dangerous
ever to be released.
He would die there at 90,
decades after his sentence \h\h\h\h\h\h\hhad expired,
and was buried on the grounds \h\h\h\hin an unmarked grave.
\h\h\h\h\hIn 1899, George Appo was declared sane and released.
He was determined, he said,
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hto "break away from the crooked life" for good.
He worked as a handyman \h\h\h\h\h\hin a church
and an undercover investigator \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hof opium dens
for a Progressive reform \h\h\h\h\h\horganization.
His colleagues there \h\h\hencouraged him
to write down the story of his remarkable life.
\hIt was not published until after his death,
but his memoir was one of \h\h\hthe first accounts
\h\h\h\hof life in the underworld written by someone who lived it.
Voice: In conclusion of this truthful statement of my life
up to the present time,
I am glad to be able to say \hthat for nearly 18 years,
I have lived an honorable life,
and for several of these recent years,
I have had steady employment.
A criminal can be reformed
\h\h\hnot through fear of brutal prison discipline,
but by a kind and encouraging \h\hword and a friendly act.
[George Appo]
Narrator: George Appo died of natural causes in 1930
at the age of 73.
An obituary called him \h\h\h"the finest crook
that ever turned a new leaf."
\h\h\hOn September 6, 1901, President William McKinley
\h\h\h\hvisited the Pan-American Exposition in Buffalo, New York.
He was greeting well-wishers
when a man in the receiving \h\h\hline, Leon Czolgosz,
approached the president
\hand shot him twice at point-blank range.
McKinley died a few days later.
Czolgosz told the police
that he was an anarchist.
"I shot the president," he said,
"because he was
"the enemy of the people,
the good working people."
Czolgosz was quickly tried, \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hconvicted,
and sentenced to death in the electric chair.
Seeing an opportunity
to satisfy the public's thirst \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hfor revenge,
America's most famous inventor, \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hThomas Edison,
offered $2,000 for the right \h\h\h\hto film Leon Czolgosz
walking into the death chamber \h\h\h\h\h\h\hat Auburn Prison.
\h\h\h\h\hThe state decides not to let Edison and his film crew
into the actual death chamber.
So they shoot a panning shot of \h\h\h\h\h\h\hthe state prison.
\h\hAnd then they stage a dramatic reenactment
of the death.
♪
\hChammah: It was brilliant PR and helped spread the idea that
electrocutions were cleaner \h\h\h\hand more dignified
\h\hthan a hanging or a firing squad.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hIt looks like a quick, little clean death.
But in reality, people were catching on fire,
\h\hpeople were vomiting from the electric chair.
It was a very grisly way \h\h\hto execute people.
Betts: The electric chair is \h\h\h\ha vehicle of torture.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hIt is not a long kiss good night.
But there's always \hbeen this desire
to give the public a glimpse.
And it's usually to say,
"Let me show the public \h\h\h\h\hthe bad guy.
\h\h\hLet me show the public how we are being kept safe."
\h\h\h\hBut I do think what's fascinating about being able
\h\hto watch this now is you could see that what we always
needed to believe is that, like, \h\h\h\hthe process of punishing
\h\h\hwould not implicate us in the suffering of somebody else.
[Heavy doors shutting]
Narrator: In the early 1900s,
many of America's prisons were nearly 100 years old.
\h\hThe conditions inside them were more deplorable than ever.
Under pressure from labor groups
\h\h\h\h\hwho resented the unfair competition,
New York and many other states had banned private contractors.
\h\h\hBut without their fees, there was not enough funding
for staff or basic supplies.
When prisoners at Sing Sing
were given only rancid food,
they refused to eat it
and rioted in protest.
[People shouting]
The growing prison crisis \h\h\h\hdeeply concerned
Thomas Mott Osborne.
\h\h\h\hLike many Progressive reformers, he was determined
to do something about \h\h\h\hthe problems
that plagued American society.
\hRebecca McLennan: Thomas Mott Osborne
grew up in Upstate New York,
\h\h\hthe son of a very successful businessman.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hHe was a very colorful character.
He actually had quite a bit of experience with theatre,
enjoyed the theatre.
He was a Progressive-era \h\h\h\h\h\h\heccentric,
basically a millionaire,
\h\hwho became very interested in the cause of prison reform,
\h\h\h\h\h\has were many middle- and upper middle-class Americans
in those days.
Voice: It was known already \h\h\h\hthat the conditions
\hat Sing Sing were barbaric, and those at Auburn medieval.
I was interested in the actual effect of the system as a whole
on the prisoners.
I resolved to inform myself
as to the inner conditions \h\h\h\h\h\hof the prisons
and the needs of the inmates.
Thomas Mott Osborne.
Narrator: In September of 1913, Osborne went to Auburn Prison.
He told the 1,400 men there that \h\hhe had been given permission
\h\h\hto do something no other prison reformer had ever done:
spend seven days living behind bars with them.
Voice: Most of the books that \hhave been written about you
by "experts" are based upon the false and cruel assumption
that the prisoner is \h\hnot a human being
\h\h\h\h\hlike the rest of us but a strange sort of animal
called a "criminal."
I am coming here to learn what I can at first hand.
\h\h\h\hTo live your life; to be housed, clothed, fed,
treated in all respects \h\h\hlike one of you.
\h\h\hI want to see for myself exactly what your life is like,
\hnot from the outside looking in but from the inside looking out.
[Thomas Mott Osborne]
\h\h\h\hNarrator: Osborne was fingerprinted, photographed,
\hand measured according to the Bertillon system.
He was given a uniform \h\h\hand an ID number,
and for the next week, he went \h\hby the name of "Tom Brown."
Voice: Cell 15, second tier, \h\h\hnorth wing, Auburn Prison.
\h\h\hI am a prisoner, locked, double locked,
conscious of a horrible feeling \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hof constraint,
of confinement.
How in the world do \h\h\hthey bear it,
\h\h\hthe men who look forward to long years of imprisonment?
\hWhat a commentary on our civilization
that we can do nothing better \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hwith such men
than to throw away their lives and ruin them, body and soul.
God! What a miserable, shameful \h\h\h\h\hwaste of human life,
of human energy!
[Thomas Mott Osborne]
Narrator: Before he left Auburn,
Osborne wanted to experience \h\h\h\hsolitary confinement
\hin the prison's punishment cells,
\h\hwhere the men were kept in total darkness,
allowed just one cup of water and a piece of bread each day.
Voice: I enter my iron cage.
\hIt is absolutely empty of everything except a bucket.
There is no seat, no bed, \h\h\h\hno place to wash,
no water to wash with.
[Thomas Mott Osborne]
\h\h\hNarrator: There were five other men in the solitary cells
near Osborne.
He could not see any of them,
\h\h\h\h\hbut through the door of his cell,
he talked to them for hours.
It was, he remembered,
one of the "most intelligent, \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hinstructive,
and entertaining conversations" \h\h\h\h\h\h\hhe had ever had.
One of the men, who was ill, \h\h\h\h\h\hbecame distraught
\h\h\hwhen he spilled the only cup of water
he would be given that day.
One of the other prisoners spent hours comforting him.
\h\hVoice: Never have I witnessed a finer act of Christian charity
toward suffering humanity,
never more skillful treatment
of a sick and nervous \h\hfellow-creature.
These prisoners are men-- \h\h\h\h\h\h\hreal men--
your brethren and mine.
If you treat them like beasts, it will be hard for them
\h\h\h\h\h\hto keep from degenerating into beasts.
If you treat them like men, you can help them to rise.
The real miracle is
when men who have been treated \h\hfor many years like beasts
persist in retaining \h\h\htheir humanity.
[Thomas Mott Osborne]
\hNarrator: Though Osborne was not the first reformer
to expose terrible conditions \h\h\h\hin America's prisons,
\h\h\h\h\h\hhe was by far the most well-connected.
\h\h\h\hHe published "Within Prison Walls"
about the week he spent
inside Auburn,
and in 1914, he was appointed \h\hthe warden of Sing Sing.
He allowed the prisoners there \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hmore autonomy
\h\h\hand individual freedom than any American prison had,
because, he said,
\h\h\h"It is liberty alone that fits men for liberty."
\h\h\h\h\h\hThe men established a "Mutual Welfare League," that
\h\h\hheld elections, set rules of conduct,
handled disciplinary matters,
and when World War I broke out in Europe,
\h\h\h\h\h\hthey knitted clothes for the Polish Relief Committee.
"It's a real comfort," \h\h\h\h\hone man said,
"to be doing something for those
who are more unfortunate \h\h\h\hthan ourselves."
\h\h\h\hOsborne recruited some of America's leading industrialists
\h\h\h\hto provide classes in automobile maintenance,
\h\h\h\h\h\haccounting, architectural drawing,
and foreign languages,
and to offer the men who took \h\h\hthe classes employment
upon release.
Some began to refer to \h\h\h\h\h\hthe prison
as the "University \h\hof Sing Sing."
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hMcLennan: Now, there was one caveat to this,
which is that Osborne,
and most of the other Progressive reformers,
brought racial prejudice \h\h\hinto that equation.
And a kind of racial hierarchy \h\h\h\h\h\hbegins to play out
in ways that were not \h\hso much the case
in the contracting system, \h\h\h\hironically enough,
because all contractors \h\h\hcared about was,
"Are you fast at making barrels?"
Narrator: Osborne excluded the prison's small Black population
from the training programs.
\h\h\h\h\hThey were assigned to "unskilled" work details.
He also arranged for many of them to be transferred
\h\h\h\hto Clinton, the least reformed
and most violent prison \h\h\h\h\hin the state.
\h\h\h\h\hMcLennan: Osborne had a publicist, and so Sing Sing,
in about a 12-month period, became a really fascinating
national, if not international, \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hshowcase
\h\hfor incarceration in the United States.
Narrator: Progressives like the up-and-coming Democrat
Franklin Delano Roosevelt admired Osborne's reforms,
\h\hbut his approach to running Sing Sing
won him powerful enemies \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\has well.
The Republican governor \hwho had appointed him
resented Osborne's independence,
and he never had the support \hof Tammany Hall Democrats.
McLennan: Tammany Hall was \h\h\h\hlargely responsible
for supplying guards for the institution.
And certainly, he didn't \h\h\h\h\h\hbring them in
on the decision-making process.
He didn't consult with the very \h\hpeople who'd been guarding
the Sing Sing population \h\h\h\hfor generations.
And so between Tammany \hand the Republicans,
Osborne did not consider himself \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\haccountable
or answerable to anybody.
Narrator: When Osborne \h\h\h\hdiscovered that
one of the prisoners at \hSing Sing had had sex
with 21 other men,
\h\hpossibly in exchange for food or other favors,
\h\h\h\hhe disciplined them all in the manner he thought best:
putting them to work \h\hdigging a sewer.
But he chose not to report \h\hany of it to the state,
as was required by law.
When the state superintendent \h\h\h\hof prisons found out
what Osborne had failed to do,
he launched a grand jury \h\h\h\h\hinvestigation.
\h\h22 prisoners were indicted, and so was Thomas Mott Osborne.
\h\h\h\hMcLennan: Osborne is ultimately the target
of a kind of frame-up.
So, his political enemies \hmobilized against him,
and they were effective.
Narrator: Osborne was accused of perjury, neglect of duty,
and, most damaging, \hhaving committed
what the prosecutor called
"various unnatural \hand immoral acts
with the convicts of Sing Sing."
He was eventually cleared \h\h\h\h\hof all charges,
but the damage to his reputation \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hwas done.
McLennan: It ends his career \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hat Sing Sing,
closed down his career as a prison reformer,
and arguably, it ends his life.
He dies a few years later \ha very heartbroken man.
Narrator: There would always \h\h\hbe classes and programs
in some prisons, but few wardens \h\h\h\h\h\h\hwould fully embrace
Osborne's philosophy \hof self-governance
and rehabilitation.
Betts: You see a situation \h\h\h\h\hlike a Sing-Sing,
and you realize that Osborne \h\h\h\h\hinvented this thing
or created this thing
\h\hand did create it with real intentions
that were probably profound.
And the real question becomes,
was there enough time to see \h\h\hif it was sustainable?
And the answer has been no.
\h\h\h\h\h\hThere are always charismatic prison officials,
\h\hcharismatic wardens, but it is a bureaucracy.
And I think a lot of people \hjust kind of are pushing
to keep their jobs.
It's a tragic story
because nobody gets rewarded
for making the lives of people in prison better.
♪
\h\h\h\h\h\hSinger: ♪ It's time for every boy to be a soldier ♪
\h\h\h\h♪ To put his strength and courage to the test... ♪
Narrator: In the spring of 1917,
the United States \hentered the war
\h\hthat had been going on for three years in Europe.
President Woodrow Wilson said \h\h\h\hAmerica was fighting
"to make the world safe for \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hdemocracy."
All through the year,
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hmembers of the National Women's Party
staged silent protests \hfor women's suffrage.
How could the president
\h\hask Americans to fight for liberty overseas, they argued,
when half the population did not \h\h\h\h\hhave the right to vote?
They were the first group \h\h\h\h\h\h\hto protest
in front of the White House, and \h\hthey drew enormous attention.
Angry crowds heckled \h\h\hthe suffragists
and tore their banners.
Police arrested hundreds \h\h\h\h\h\hof the women
for blocking the sidewalk.
72 of them were sent to \hthe Women's Workhouse
in Lorton, Virginia.
The suffragists refused to work.
Some refused to eat and were force-fed.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hOne night, on the orders of the warden,
some were beaten by the guards,
then denied medical attention \hor access to legal counsel.
But they did have access \h\h\h\h\h\hto the press.
Heather Ann Thompson: This is \h\ha really powerful moment
\h\h\h\hfor many people who see these pictures.
\h\h\h\h\hThe idea that women, particularly women of standing,
are going to be locked up \h\h\h\h\h\his an affront
\hto many, at least upper-class women.
And it really does lay bare \h\h\h\h\h\h\hthis question
of who is prison for.
Who is it okay to see locked up?
And who is it not okay \h\h\hto see locked up?
The suffragists understood that.
Narrator: News accounts \h\h\h\hand photographs
of the suffragists' ordeal \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hbehind bars
increased support for their cause.
Within a few years, Congress would pass,
and the states would ratify, \h\h\h\h\hthe 19th amendment,
\hguaranteeing that no American citizen
\h\h\hwould be denied the right to vote "on the basis of sex."
But winning the right to vote \h\hwould make no difference
in the lives of the thousands \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hof women
confined in the nation's \h\h\hprisons and jails.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hVoice: I lived for fourteen months
the life of a federal prisoner
\h\hin the State Penitentiary at Jefferson City, Missouri.
\h\h\hI had, perhaps, a better opportunity
to study female prisoners than any other person has had
who is really interested \hin female delinquency.
I had what the criminologist \h\h\h\h\h\h\hdoes not have--
the actual experience \hof being a convict.
Kate Richards O'Hare.
Narrator: The socialist writer \h\h\h\h\hKate Richards O'Hare
was sent to prison in 1919 \h\h\h\hfor giving a speech
denouncing American \h\h\hparticipation
in the First World War--
\h\ha violation of the Espionage Act,
which made it a crime to say \h\h\h\h\h\h\hor do anything
that could impede \hthe war effort.
\h\h\h\h\h\hO'Hare left behind her husband and four children.
There was no federal prison \h\h\hfor women, so O'Hare
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hserved her time at the Missouri State Penitentiary,
which held 2,500 men \h\h\hand 100 women.
\hVoice: When I went in, I held the convictions--
quite common, I think--
that there is such a thing \h\h\has a "criminal type,"
a distinct "criminal class."
Naturally I studied these women \h\h\h\h\h\hwith keen interest.
But I was never able to discover
the expected physical marks of \h\h\h\h\hthe "criminal type,"
the stigmata of criminalism of \h\h\h\hwhich Lombroso writes,
and of which I had been wont \h\h\h\h\hto speak so glibly.
The only stigmata that I could discover were those of poverty,
\h\h\hexcessive child-bearing, undernourishment, and overwork.
[Kate Richards O'Hare]
Narrator: The women she met in the penitentiary, she said,
were "an indictment of \h\hour social system."
Most were poor.
\hMany had committed petty property crimes
or had been found guilty of \h\h\h\h\h\hprostitution--
\h\ha crime for which their male customers
were almost never punished.
Some of the women O'Hare \h\h\h\h\h\h\hgot to know
\h\h\hhad killed their husbands after enduring years of abuse.
\h\hIn many states, it was not a crime
for a man to beat his wife.
Murray: We understand
that there's violence \h\hwithin families.
But the law doesn't intervene \h\h\h\h\hbecause the husband
is the public face \h\hof the family,
\h\h\hand he is sort of the lord of his castle.
There's also a common law \htradition that husbands
\hhave some right of marital chastisement, which is to say
that they can correct \h\h\h\h\hindividuals
within their households.
\h\hVoice: They were practically all middle-aged, some quite old,
\h\h\hand they were quiet, diffident, toil-worn women;
the type that bears children \h\h\h\h\h\h\huncomplainingly
\h\h\h\h\hand endures poverty and hardship, neglect and brutality.
Then some day, there is laid upon their burden
the last straw,
the repressed emotions, \h\hthe outraged love,
the mother ferocity that makes \ha woman fight for her young,
flame into rebellion;
taut nerves snap, a man is killed,
\h\h\h\h\h\h\ha home broken up, children scattered and branded;
\h\h\h\hand a woman enters the living tomb of a prison
to be forgotten.
[Kate Richards O'Hare]
Narrator: Nothing short \h\h\h\hof a revolution
in the "social machinery" \h\h\h\h\hcould truly fix
\h\hthe "problems of crime and criminals," O'Hare said
when she emerged from prison.
\h\h\h\h\hMeanwhile, Americans must accept some responsibility
\h\h\h\hfor what she called the "stupidities, horrors,
\h\h\h\h"and brutalities of the nation's prison system
"and pave the way for really \hsane and rational handling
\h\hof the problems of human frailty."
Voice: Our whole system of \h\h\h\hdealing with crime
is based on the assumption
\h\h\hthat punishment is a cure for crime.
If I were ruler of the universe, \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hI would see to it
that many more respectable folk \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hwent to prison
\h\hfor the good of their souls and the welfare of the country.
Especially would I see to it \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hthat no judge
ever sat on a criminal bench
\h\h\h\h\huntil he had served at least one year in prison.
[Kate Richards O'Hare]
♪
Beverly Gage: In 1917,
the Bolshevik Revolution \h\h\hhappened in Russia,
the first successful Socialist revolution in world history.
And that produced a deep fear about whether this revolution
that had started in Russia was going to sweep across Europe
\h\h\h\h\hand then, in fact, sweep into the United States.
\h\h\h\h\hSo by 1919, there is growing concern about violence
coming from revolutionaries
from what were considered to be \h\h\h\h\h\h\hsuspect regions--
\h\h\h\h\h\hEastern Europe and Southern Europe, right?
\h\h\h\hHotbeds of anarchism and Communism and Socialism.
Narrator: On June 2, 1919,
\h\h\h\hafter months of sporadic attacks,
revolutionary violence \hfilled the headlines
when bombs planted by followers
of an Italian anarchist
went off nearly simultaneously
in eight cities.
In Washington, D.C., the home
of the United States Attorney General, A. Mitchell Palmer,
was partially destroyed.
Within a few months, Palmer created a "Radical Division"
in the Justice Department.
He put an ambitious 24-year-old \h\hlawyer, John Edgar Hoover,
in charge, and directed him \h\hto round up and deport
thousands of non-citizens
the department suspected of \h\h\hhaving radical ties.
"Out of their sly and crafty eyes,"
the attorney general said,
"leap cupidity, cruelty, \h\hinsanity, and crime;
"from their lopsided faces, \h\h\h\h\h\hsloping brows,
"and misshapen features \h\h\hmay be recognized
the unmistakable criminal type."
Gage: A. Mitchell Palmer \h\h\hcame up with a plan
\hthat would not only rid the United States
of dangerous radicals,
but would serve as a lesson \h\h\hto those left behind.
\h\h\hNarrator: The press and the public supported
the Palmer Raids at first,
but before long, many criticized
\h\h\h\h\hthe mass arrests and deportations of people
who had not been charged \h\h\h\h\hwith any crime
\h\has a violation of civil liberties.
Gage: This was, you know, \h\h\hpolicemen going in,
banging down doors, dragging people out of their houses.
A new civil liberties movement \h\hstarts to point out things
like, "You didn't really have warrants for these arrests."
"You can't really just sweep up \h\h\h\hpeople and deport them
"because they happen to belong \h\h\h\h\h\hto an organization
that you don't like."
These are violations of \h\hfree speech rights.
They are violations of immigration law.
Narrator: For J. Edgar Hoover,
the fiasco provided an indelible lesson.
Gage: The Palmer Raids \hhad been too public.
\h\h\hThere's just a kind of visibility and a physicality
\h\h\h\hto it that he decided wasn't the way to go anymore.
From that moment on, he really tried to rely much, much more
on secret techniques to keep them out of the public eye.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hAnd often, people didn't know what was going on.
\h\h\h\hVoice: A few years ago, the only requirement necessary
for appointment as policeman \h\h\h\h\hwas political pull
and brute strength.
\hMany of the officials made the most of their opportunity
\h\h\hand levied tribute upon the painted women, gamblers,
\h\h\hsaloon keepers, and other evil doers.
\h\h\h\hCollections were systematically conducted
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hby patrolmen, and the proceeds were delivered
to superior officers,
who distributed the funds \hamong the favored ones.
August Vollmer.
\hNarrator: The chief of the Berkeley, California,
Police Department, \h\hAugust Vollmer,
was one of the most respected
\h\h\h\hand most progressive police officials in America.
Like Theodore Roosevelt \h\h\h\h\hin New York,
\hVollmer was determined to reform his department.
He pledged to root out \h\h\h\h\h\hcorruption,
and he forbade the use \hof the third degree,
which he considered torture.
Vollmer hired
former UCLA football star \h\hWalter Arthur Gordon
\h\h\h\h\hto be Berkeley's first Black police officer,
and when some deputies objected, \h\h\h\h\h\h\hVollmer fired them.
♪
He was also a master of public relations.
He agreed to appear in "Officer '444',"
\h\ha series of ten short silent films
\h\h\habout police waging war with the criminal underworld.
♪
McLennan: Vollmer was the most \h\h\hinfluential police chief
we've ever seen.
And I think that what made him \h\h\hfamous and so influential
\hwas that he was able to grasp how American cities had changed
and come up with a policing \hmodel that, in his view,
responded more effectively, \hefficiently, and morally.
Voice: I'll admire you more \h\hif, in the first year,
you don't make a single arrest.
I'm not judging you on arrests.
\h\hI'm judging you on how many people
you keep from doing \hsomething wrong.
Remember, you're almost \h\ha father confessor;
you're to listen to people, \h\hyou're to advise them.
[August Vollmer]
\h\h\h\hMcLennan: He emphasized reinventing the police officer
\h\h\haway from this model of the political appointee
with no particular skills
to someone, ideally, with a college degree
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hbut with at least 3-6 months' worth of training,
who is morally irreproachable
\h\h\h\hand embodies and enforces the law.
Narrator: The primary job of police, Vollmer liked to say,
was stopping crime before it happened.
To train his men,
Vollmer established the first police academy in the nation,
and to educate them, \h\ha college program
with classes on topics ranging from first-aid and psychiatry
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hto eugenics and "the criminal type."
Only "men of good inheritance,
\h\h\hphysically, mentally, and morally," Vollmer said,
"should become police officers."
\h\h\h\h\h\hA veteran of the Spanish-American War,
Vollmer applied the military \h\h\h\hstrategy and tactics
\h\h\h\h\h\hhe learned there to policing in urban America.
He collected data about \h\h\hcriminal activity
\hthat his men plotted onto maps of the city.
\h\h\h\h\hHe also established an intelligence division that
analyzed data, created profiles \h\hof potential law-breakers,
and made predictions about where crime was
most likely to happen.
Voice: An intelligence division \h\h\h\h\h\hmay be as necessary
in a police department
as in the state department \h\h\h\h\hof a government.
It is the only way to find out \h\h\hwhat your enemy is doing,
and the end, in this case,
\h\h\h\h\hwhich is the protection of society, justifies the means.
After all, we're conducting \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\ha war--
a war against the enemies of \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hsociety,
and we must never forget that.
[August Vollmer]
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hMcLennan: When you professionalize police,
there is a separation \hthat is emphasized
between the policed \h\hand the police.
And they begin to live \h\h\h\h\h\helsewhere,
not in the same area \h\hthat they police.
One of the things that is lost \h\h\h\his that police officers
\h\hbecome more removed from their communities.
So there's a more adversarial \h\hrelationship that Vollmer
introduces unwittingly, I think,
and sort of sets us on the path \hto the modern policing model.
♪
Voice: The "Defender" invites \h\h\h\h\hall to come north.
Plenty of room for the good, \h\h\hsober, industrious men.
Plenty of work.
Come join the ranks of the free.
\h\h\h\h\hCast the yoke from around your neck.
See the light.
When you have crossed \h\h\hthe Ohio River,
breathe the fresh air and say, \h\h"Why didn't I come before?"
The "Chicago Defender."
Narrator: For years following \h\h\h\hthe First World War,
African Americans fleeing \h\h\hthe Jim Crow South
arrived in Chicago, New York, \h\hDetroit, and other cities
every month in search of work \h\h\h\h\hand a better life.
Their exodus would be known \h\has the Great Migration.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hStevenson: Six million Black people
fled the American South
during the first half of \h\h\h\hthe 20th Century.
Many of them left lands \h\h\hthat they owned;
they gave up on opportunities \h\h\h\h\h\hto create wealth
for their children and grandchildren
because of terror and violence.
It would be very easy to be hopeless about
\h\h\h\hwhat could be done under those circumstances.
\h\h\h\h\hAnd yet they continued to struggle.
Narrator: In Detroit,
\h\h\h\h\h\hthe fast-growing Black population was crammed
into a neighborhood of run-down \h\h\hrow houses and tenements,
\h\h\horiginally named for its fertile soil--the Black Bottom.
Daniel Baxter: The \h\hchallenge was,
was that it was just \h\h\h\hovercrowded.
There were instances where the housing was
just at a premium to the point
\h\h\h\h\h\hwhere pool halls were actually renting out pool tables
at nighttime for beds.
So, it was really tough.
\h\h\h\h\hAnd then there were some individuals who decided,
"Hey, look, you know, I've done well for myself in life.
\h\h"And I'm going to try to reach out and expand,
and live in nicer surroundings."
And that's the story \h\h\h\hof Dr. Sweet.
\h\h\hNarrator: Dr. Ossian Sweet had grown up in Bartow, Florida,
and moved to Detroit
\h\h\h\h\h\hafter graduating from Howard University Medical School
in 1921.
He built a thriving \hmedical practice,
married Gladys Mitchell,
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hand, in 1924, welcomed a baby girl, Iva.
In the summer of 1925,
the Sweets decided to buy a home
outside the Black Bottom for their growing family.
\hThey had saved more than enough for a down payment,
but finding someone willing \h\h\hto sell them a house
would not be easy.
\h\h\hBoyle: What happens is that as African Americans move North,
Jim Crow follows them.
As that Black population's \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hrising,
white people really start \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hto care.
In Detroit, the system of neighborhood segregation
is solidifying.
And that's happening \h\h\h\hin every city
because it's really easy
for white folks in Chicago \h\h\h\hor Detroit to say,
\h"Well, we believe in racial equality.
\h\h\h\h"It's illegal to segregate schools
in the state of Michigan."
\h\h\h\h"It's illegal to segregate schools
in the state of Illinois."
That's really easy to say \h\h\h\h\hwhen there are
no Black people living near you.
\h\hBut all of a sudden, as that Black population starts to rise,
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hit turns out that the white supremacist mindset is
\h\hnot a Southern mindset; it is an American mindset.
\h\hAnd when that color line starts to build in the North,
the violence comes, too.
Narrator: The Sweets eventually \h\h\h\hfound a house for sale
at 2905 Garland Avenue.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hBaxter: Gladys falls in love with this house.
This house is just \h\hso enchanting.
She loves the living room, \h\h\h\h\hthe dining room.
And Dr. Sweet decides, says, \h\h"Hey, this is it for us."
\h\h\h\h\hNarrator: The owners offered the house to the Sweets
for $18,500, considerably more \h\h\h\hthan its market value.
They agreed to buy it.
\h\hBut that summer, as Ossian and Gladys
prepared to close on the house,
another Black family they knew
\htried to move into a white neighborhood.
Baxter: Dr. A.L. Turner \h\h\h\h\his confronted
by a mob of white folks \h\h\hwith one intent--
to force him out of the house.
They destroy his home.
They break into the home, \h\h\h\h\h\hdrag him out,
place a gun to his head,
and make him sign over the deed to the house.
Dr. Sweet hears about this, \h\h\hand he gets nervous,
and he decides to try to get his deposit back on the house
and not move in.
The challenge that he encounters \h\h\his, is the Black community
began to have conversations \h\h\h\h\hwith him, saying,
"Doc, you've got to do this.
"When you walk into that house, \h\h\hyou're not just going in
"with you, Gladys, and Iva.
"You're going in with the rest \h\h\h\h\h\hof the Black people
that live in the United States \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hof America."
So, he's conflicted.
But he comes to a point \h\h\h\h\h\hof clarity,
where he affirms in his mind
that he'd rather die as a man \h\h\hthan live as a coward.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hNarrator: On Tuesday, September 8th,
\h\hthe Sweets moved into their new home.
They asked several friends \h\h\h\h\h\hand relatives,
\h\hincluding Ossian's younger brother Henry,
to help them defend themselves.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hThey also asked the Detroit police for help,
\h\h\h\h\h\hand a dozen officers were stationed around the house.
\hThroughout the day, everything was calm.
\h\hAs night fell, a crowd gathered outside the house
but then dispersed.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hThe next night, a much larger crowd showed up.
\h\hBoyle: Eight o'clock or so, when the sun's starting to set,
hundreds of white people \h\h\hare on the streets.
There are eleven people \h\h\h\h\hin the house.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hAnd they sit in those windows with rifles.
And there is every question \hinside the Sweets' home:
\hIf the mob starts to push against those police lines,
will the police just give way?
Baxter: At around 8:20 or so, \h\h\h\h\h\h\hthey look out,
and they see a sea of hate.
A mob of more than 500 people
had surrounded the house \h\h\hon Garland Avenue.
And Dr. Sweet turns out the lights in the house.
He's nervous. He runs upstairs.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hNarrator: The crowd surged forward,
shouting racial epithets,
\h\h\hhurling rocks and chunks of coal.
\hWhen a rock broke a window in the second-floor bedroom,
\h\hsome of the men inside opened fire.
[Gunshots]
\h\h\h\h\hBoyle: There were 20, 30 shots out into the darkness,
out towards that crowd.
And the remarkable thing is \honly two people get shot.
The men inside the house say, "What we were really trying
to do was shoot up above them \h\h\h\h\has a warning shot."
Except for Dr. Sweet's \h\h\h\h\hbaby brother,
who's in the house, and says, \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h"I wasn't.
They were going to kill us."
\h\h\hNarrator: Henry Sweet shot two people in the mob.
A man named Leon Breiner \h\h\h\h\h\h\hwas killed;
another man was shot \h\h\h\hin the thigh.
The police rushed into the house
and arrested all eleven people \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hinside.
The district attorney charged them with first-degree murder.
Ifill: Does a Black man have the right to defend his home?
\h\h\h\h\h\hAnd that question continues to resonate today.
We do, in this country,
purport to believe in the castle doctrine,
that a man has the right \h\hto defend his castle.
And what is Ossian Sweet doing \h\h\hbut exercising the right
that every man in America is \h\h\h\h\hpurported to hold,
which is the right to defend his home.
Narrator: Gladys Sweet was \h\h\h\h\hreleased on bail
after three weeks,
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hbut until their trial began in late October,
\h\hDr. Sweet, his brother, and their friends were held
in the Wayne County Jail.
Voice: If it is true \h\h\hthat Dr. Sweet
fired into the crowd of whites
\h\h\h\h\hto keep them from rushing his home,
then he was certainly \hwithin his rights.
White people in Detroit, as well as other cities,
may as well know now as later
that our race will no longer run \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hfrom our homes
because they object to us.
They may as well learn, also, \h\h\h\h\h\hthat we will live
where we can afford to live
if we have to keep an armed guard posted continuously.
If the police cannot protect us \h\h\h\h\h\hfrom mob violence,
then we must be prepared \h\hto protect ourselves.
The "Chicago Defender."
♪
One of the first results of \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hprohibition
was the abolition and closing of \h\hall the saloons in the land.
\h\h\h\h\hWomen are relieved of the fear of a drunken husband.
Children no longer hide \h\h\h\h\h\hwith terror
as they see their father \h\h\h\h\h\hreeling home.
The whole United States is \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hhappier
because the liquor traffic \h\h\h\h\h\h\his an outlaw.
Narrator: When Prohibition \hwent into effect in 1920,
millions of Americans \h\hhad believed that
\h\h\h\h\h\hmaking it illegal to manufacture, transport, and sell
intoxicating liquor
would solve the problems
of alcoholism, domestic abuse, \h\h\h\h\h\hpoverty, and crime.
\h\h\hRafael A. Mangual: The goal with Prohibition
was to get people to drink less.
And by that measure, \h\hit was a success.
People drank less.
So the violence that was \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\ha result
of the consumption of alcohol, \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hthat went down.
But Prohibition created \ha black market demand
that was met.
Narrator: Millions of Americans \h\h\h\h\h\h\hwere not willing
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hto give up beer, wine, and whiskey.
To satisfy their demand,
thousands of illegal saloons \h\hand speakeasies opened up
\h\h\hall over the country, supplied by ordinary people
\h\hwho brewed beer in their basements,
and by legions of racketeers, \hsmugglers, and bootleggers.
\h\h\h\hMuhammad: It created a massive underground economy
\h\h\h\hbecause the appetite for alcohol never went away.
Almost every instance,
none of those establishments \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hcould run
without the direct complicity \h\h\h\h\h\hand participation
of police officers.
Narrator: With the millions \hbootleggers were making,
\h\hthey had more than enough money to pay off politicians
and law enforcement.
Voice: The most important \hpeople in the country--
respectable businessmen, \hpoliticians, senators,
congressmen--they all bought \h\h\h\hillegal booze from me
or from other men in the business.
We had to hire accountants \hand other administrators
\hto make sure that we never ran into trouble
with the authorities.
It's remarkable how loyal people \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hwill be
when you look after them \h\h\has well as we did.
Meyer Lansky.
\h\h\h\hNarrator: In New York, Congressman Fiorello La Guardia
said enforcing Prohibition \h\h\h\h\h\h"would require
"a police force of 250,000 men
and a force of 200,000 more men \h\h\h\hto police the police."
Defiance of Prohibition \h\h\hwas so widespread
that the courts were totally overwhelmed.
To clear their dockets,
judges allowed bootleggers \h\h\h\h\h\hand bar owners
to plead guilty, pay modest fines,
and go right back to business.
With so much money to be made \h\hselling illegal alcohol,
rival bootlegging gangs battled in the streets,
armed with Tommy guns.
Newsreel reader: Two thugs \hwho killed two policemen
\h\hin cold blood met death in this bullet-riddled cab.
The cab itself was hit 42 times \h\h\hin the running gun fight.
Look at those bullet holes.
The crowd, which a few minutes \h\h\h\h\hbefore fled in panic
from the bandits' fire, pressed the police hard
\h\h\hin an attempt to see the dead bandit taken away.
\h\hHe goes to join his two companions,
who died on the way \hto the hospital.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hNarrator: To combat the bootleggers,
Prohibition agents, \h\hlocal sheriffs,
\h\h\h\hand police officers also became heavily armed.
Botched raids by law enforcement \h\h\hfilled the headlines, too.
\h\hOne newspaper reported that the enforcement of Prohibition
had caused the deaths \h\hof 1,360 people.
In response to the violent crime \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hand lawlessness,
Congress increased sentences \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hand fines
for liquor law violations.
Many states also increased penalties and prison terms
for other crimes.
The most draconian was
\h\h\h\h\h\hNew York's habitual offender law,
which mandated life in prison \h\h\h\h\h\h\hwithout parole
for a fourth felony conviction
regardless of the severity \h\h\h\h\h\hof the offense.
23 other states soon followed
New York's example.
In Michigan, Etta Mae Miller,
an impoverished woman who sold \h\h\h\hwhiskey out of her home
to make ends meet,
\h\h\hwas found guilty of a fourth liquor offense.
She was sentenced to life in prison without parole.
Prohibition supporters \h\h\h\h\h\happlauded.
Voice: When one has violated the Constitution four times,
he or she is proved to be \h\han habitual criminal
and should be segregated \h\h\h\h\h\hfrom society
to prevent the production of \h\h\h\hsubnormal offsprings.
Our only regret is that
the woman was not sentenced \h\h\hto life imprisonment
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hbefore her ten children were born.
Dr. Clarence True Wilson,
General Secretary of the Board \h\hof Temperance, Prohibition,
and Public Morals.
\h\h\h\hNarrator: Other Americans believed Miller's punishment was
wildly out of proportion \h\h\h\h\h\hto her crime.
Her conviction caused \h\h\hsuch an outcry
that the governor of Michigan \h\h\hcommuted her sentence,
\h\h\hand she was released after 15 months in prison.
Voice: Possibly the most \h\himportant court case
the Negro has ever figured in
in all the history of \h\hthe United States
is about to be heard \h\h\hout in Detroit.
But thank God Dr. Sweet \h\h\h\h\h\h\hmoved in!
This is the spirit of unity
the Negro must more and more evidence if he is to survive.
He must face death if he is to live!
"Amsterdam News."
Narrator: The Sweets' case \h\h\h\hwas front-page news
in the African American press.
The leading civil rights organization of the day,
the National Association for the \hAdvancement of Colored People,
the NAACP,
took charge of the defense.
\hThe case was certain to be decided by an all-white jury,
so the NAACP resolved to find \h\h\h\h\h\ha white attorney
to bring the case to trial.
Boyle: They need a white lawyer. \h\h\h\h\h\h\hThey can't get one.
No one wants this case. \hThis is a loser case.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hYou could ruin your career with this stuff.
Until they get Clarence Darrow.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hNarrator: Clarence Darrow had become
\hone of the most celebrated courtroom lawyers in America,
defending anarchists' \h\h\hand socialists'
right to free speech;
communists rounded up in the Palmer Raids;
\h\hlabor leaders charged with murder and sedition;
and countless everyday citizens
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hcharged with all manner of crimes.
When two wealthy Chicago \h\h\h\h\h\h\hteenagers,
Nathan Leopold and Richard Loeb, \h\h\h\h\h\h\hkilled a young boy
just to see if they could \h\hget away with murder,
Darrow managed to save them \h\h\hfrom being executed.
In the "trial of the century,"
just a few months before the Sweets were arrested,
Darrow had defended \h\hJohn T. Scopes,
who had broken Tennessee's law
\h\h\h\hagainst teaching the theory of evolution.
Boyle: Clarence Darrow \hdidn't like the law.
He didn't enjoy the law.
He said the law was a "sham."
What he loved was taking a case \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hto court
\hto illustrate some giant issue that he knew would shock people.
Ifill: Enter Clarence Darrow,
\h\h\h\h\h\hwho decides that he will participate in this case.
And that's really powerful \h\h\h\h\h\h\hand important
for elevating this important \h\h\h\h\hcivil rights moment
to--certainly to many \h\h\h\hwhite people,
but also to Black people
\h\hto feel that this case is of such import that Clarence Darrow
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\his willing to associate himself with it.
♪
Narrator: The trial began \h\hon October 30, 1925.
\hHundreds of curious people crowded into the courthouse.
Darrow's co-counsel, \h\h\h\hArthur Hays,
put Dr. Sweet on the stand
and asked him to tell the court \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hwhat happened
on the night of the shooting.
Voice: When did you first observe anything outside?
[Arthur Hays]
Voice: It was about eight o'clock
when something hit the roof of the house.
The mob surged forward 15 or 20 feet.
It looked like a human sea.
Stones kept coming faster.
Another window was smashed.
Then one shot,
then eight or ten from upstairs.
Then it was over.
[Dr. Ossian Sweet]
What was your state of mind at the time of the shooting?
When I opened the door and saw the mob,
I realized I was facing the same mob
that had hounded my people
through its entire history.
Boyle: He walks Dr. Sweet
\h\h\h\h\hthrough his personal experiences,
being a young man coming of age
\h\h\hin a period of intense mob violence.
When he was five years old,
\h\h\h\h\h\hgrowing up in small-time Florida,
the white people of his town--
a tiny, little town \h\hcalled Bartow--
burned a sixteen year old \hto death at the stake.
He was in Washington, D.C., \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hin 1919,
where there was also
a racial pogrom against \h\hAfrican Americans.
And he talks about reading about \h\h\h\h\hwhat happened in Tulsa.
Voice: In my mind, I was confident
of what I was up against,
with my back against the wall.
I was filled with a peculiar fear,
the fear of one who knows the history of my race.
[Dr. Ossian Sweet]
Narrator: The prosecution's case \h\h\h\h\h\hhinged on their claim
that there had been no mob \h\h\h\h\h\h\hin the street
threatening the Sweets.
Michigan Law defined a mob as 30 people or more.
Boyle: What the prosecution does \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\his they
\h\h\hput something like 60 witnesses on the stand
to say there was no mob.
\h\h\h\hSo, you've got people testifying there was no mob,
but there are so many of them \h\h\h\h\h\h\hjust testifying
that they constitute a mob.
\h\h\h\hIt sounds absurd. And it is absurd, right?
But what it really does \h\h\h\his it tells you
about the politicization \h\h\h\h\h\h\hof the law,
that what they're counting on \h\h\h\his that those jurors
would be willing to accept \h\h\hthis absurd argument
because their goal
\h\h\h\h\hisn't to enforce what's written in the books
but what they want to see,
which is that segregation is
the way that the city should be organized,
and a Black man has no real \h\hright to defend himself
against it.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hNarrator: In his closing argument,
\h\h\h\hthe district attorney, Robert Toms, told the jury that
because there had been no mob,
the shooting should be seen \has a simple murder case.
In his closing argument, Clarence Darrow appealed
to the jury's sense of fairness.
Voice: Gentlemen, you know why the mob was there.
They were there to awe, to intimidate,
to scare away, to stone,
to drive by force, if necessary,
a man from a home that was his.
My clients are here charged with murder,
but they are really here because they are Black.
Do you think that all the rights which you
claim for yourselves are to be denied them?
Who are we anyhow?
I have known people with white blood
that were plumb idiots;
the more they had of it, the more idiotic they were.
There are colored people of intellect
and colored people of courage
and colored people who risk their fortunes
and their lives for their independence.
They are reaching all grades of society;
they are coming into every city.
You cannot get rid of them, gentlemen.
They are here.
You cannot turn back the wheels of progress.
The world moves slowly, but it is forever grinding,
and it grinds down injustice
and wrong and prejudice and hate,
even though it is
by the slow and cruel process of years.
[Clarence Darrow]
Narrator: The jury deliberated \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hfor 46 hours
\h\hbut was unable to reach a verdict.
\hJudge Frank Murphy declared a mistrial.
Prosecutors finally released \h\h\hDr. Sweet, his brother,
and the other defendants.
But they also resolved to try the case again.
This time, there would be \h\hjust one defendant--
the only person who had admitted \h\h\h\hto shooting into the mob:
\h\h\h\hOssian Sweet's younger brother Henry.
\h\h\h\hThe prosecution made the same arguments as before,
\h\hbut now Darrow and his co-counsel
went after the state's witnesses \h\h\h\h\hmuch more aggressively.
The jury took 3 1/2 hours \h\h\hto reach a verdict.
They found Henry Sweet \h\h\h\h\h\hnot guilty.
\h\h\h\hBoyle: And there's cheering in the courtroom.
And there is Ossian Sweet \hsitting alone, crying.
\h\h\h\h\hIfill: Henry Sweet being acquitted in this case
sends a wave through the Black community.
\h\hThe worst consequence that we expect to happen
doesn't happen.
\h\h\h\h\h\hA white man is dead and no Black man goes to prison
or is lynched.
\h\h\hIt's a powerful moment in the psychology of Black people
\hin terms of thinking about standing up for their rights.
\h\h\h\hBoyle: What we want civil rights stories to be,
what we want to see in the legal system
\h\his that, yeah, there's injustices
and people struggle \h\h\hagainst them,
and then the injustices \h\h\h\h\h\hare broken.
\h\hAnd that's not what this story is.
Narrator: After the trial, Ossian and Gladys Sweet
tried to resume their life,
\h\hbut they soon discovered that while she had been held
in the Wayne County Jail,
Gladys had contracted \h\h\h\htuberculosis.
When she was released,
Mrs. Sweet passed the disease
on to their two-year-old \h\h\h\h\h\hdaughter Iva.
A few months later, Iva died.
\h\h\hBoyle: The day they buried her, they took her
to the cemetery,
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hand the cortege comes up to the cemetery gates,
and the gatekeeper at the cemetery told them
they had to go around \h\h\h\hthe back way.
And Dr. Sweet pulls out a gun \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hand he says,
"We're going in this gate."
And then a couple of years \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hafter that,
Mrs. Sweet died as well.
It destroyed him.
Narrator: Ossian Sweet \h\h\h\hremarried twice
and divorced twice.
He never had another child,
and eventually, he moved \h\h\h\hinto an apartment
above his medical practice \h\h\hin the Black Bottom.
\hBaxter: In 1958, he sells the home on Garland Avenue
\hto a married couple, African American couple
\h\h\h\h\hby the name of Herbert and Inez Baxter,
my mother and father.
The week after they moved into the home, Dr. Sweet
went to go see my dad, and they had a drink.
\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hDr. Sweet, his whole countenance changed.
\h\h\hAnd my dad said, he said, "Well, Doc, what's the matter?"
He said his eyes welled up.
And Dr. Sweet said, "I wish I'd never bought that house.
\h\h"Everything that I knew and everything that I loved I lost
because of that house."
Two years after that, \hhe commits suicide.
♪
Voice: The policy of America \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hseems to be
to build bigger and better \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hprisons,
\hthe same as bigger and better factories.
\h\h\hThe fierce hatred that has been generated
against the inmates of prison
\h\hhas made judges give longer terms,
and juries find more men guilty and have put in the penitentiary
more people entirely innocent to the act than ever before.
The prisoner today can see
written over the doors \h\h\h\h\hof the prison
what Dante saw over the gates of hell:
"Abandon all hope, ye who enter here."
Clarence Darrow.
Narrator: The harsh laws that \h\h\h\h\h\h\hhad been passed
during Prohibition
had caused more people to spend \h\h\hlonger terms behind bars
with no possibility of parole.
The nation's prisons and jails became dangerously overcrowded;
cells intended for one person \h\h\h\h\hheld three or four.
\hAs conditions deteriorated, prisoners became demoralized,
desperate, and defiant,
and all across the country, \h\h\h\h\h\hthey rebelled.
\hWhen Thomas Mott Osborne's friend Franklin D. Roosevelt
became governor of New York \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hin 1929,
he pushed for repeal of the harshest provisions
\h\h\h\hof the state's habitual offender law,
and promised to modernize \h\h\h\h\h\h\hand reform
New York's notorious prisons.
To reduce overcrowding,
\h\h\hRoosevelt embarked on a prison-building program,
including a $9-million fortress \h\h\h\h\h\hthat was celebrated
as one of the most humane and secure prisons in the country.
\h\h\hIt was the pride of the small upstate village
in which it was located--Attica.
Franklin Delano Roosevelt: \h\h\h\h\hA prison to us is
no longer merely a bastille
to keep people in indiscriminately
with the object solely of \h\h\h\h\h\h\hpunishment.
We have realized especially that \h\hover 90 out of a hundred boys
\h\h\h\hwho go to prison, over 90 of them come back
eventually to be our neighbors \h\h\h\hand live in our midst,
\h\h\h\h\h\h\hand our object ought to be to turn them out
\h\has better citizens than when they went into prison.
Narrator: In the coming decades,
prisons would continue to fill,
as the country was consumed by \h\ha growing sense of menace.
Threats--whether foreign \h\h\h\h\h\hor domestic,
\h\hwhether based in reality, prejudice, or misconception--
would define and redefine \h\h\hwhat was criminal,
and would test the limits \hof justice in America.
♪
♪
Announcer: Next time
on "Crime and Punishment \h\h\h\h\hin America"...
The criminal justice system
\h\h\hcompletely depends on what moment we're in.
Elie Mystal: Simply by being \h\h\h\h\h\hJapanese American
and existing was criminalized.
Gilbert King: A future \hSupreme Court Justice
\his nearly lynched by the side of a river for practicing law.
Khalil Gibran Muhammad: \h\h\hBonnie and Clyde
and John Dillinger become these kind of anti-heroes
who are bucking the system.
\h\hAnnouncer: When "Crime and Punishment in America"
continues next time.
Announcer: Scan this QR code
with your smart device
to dive deeper into the story
of "Crime and Punishment \h\h\h\h\h\h\hin America"
\h\h\h\h\h\hwith interactives, classroom materials, and more.
Announcer: The "Crime and Punishment in America" DVD
is available online \h\h\h\h\h\h\h\hand in stores.
The series is also available \h\h\h\h\h\hwith PBS Passport
and on Amazon Prime Video.
The digital companion soundtrack \h\h\h\his also available online.
♪
♪
♪
Announcer: Major funding
for "Crime and Punishment in \hAmerica" was provided by...
The Atlantic Philanthropies,
Emerson Collective,
The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation,
and the Park Foundation.
\h\h\h\hMajor funding was also provided by
\hthe following members of The Better Angels Society:
The Fullerton Family \h\hCharitable Fund,
The Just Trust for Education,
Allan and Shelley Holt,
The Tow Foundation,
and the Sozosei Foundation.
Additional support
was provided by
the National Endowment \h\hfor the Humanities,
The Arthur Vining Davis \h\h\h\h\hFoundations,
and by The Better Angels \h\h\h\hSociety members:
John and Catherine Debs,
Timothy Fazio,
\h\hLise Strickler and Mark Gallogly,
the Laurie M. Tisch Illumination Fund,
and these additional funders.
\h\h\h\h\h"Crime and Punishment in America" was made possible,
in part, by contributions \h\h\hto your PBS station
from Viewers Like You. \h\h\h\h\h\hThank you.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.