Original subtitles

Stop! I will kill you!

Wake up! Wake up, damn it! He got a message to us.

Croatoan is coming for Audrey, so we're making our stand.

I've lost so much to the Troubles: my sister, my daughter...

I'm not going to let anything else get taken from me again.

If we can't build a new barn, we can't defeat Croatoan.

I have to get these things to do something...

- Why have you brought me here? - Howard!

Can you use this to build a new barn? - The Aether core

has been cracked. The stability is compromised.

- Did it damage you? - Yes.

Who did this to Howard?

- Duke! - Croatoan must be controlling him somehow.

- Duke, why are you doing this? - I am doing

what my family was created to do.

Duke...

Please, no!

I don't want to stop.

- Duke, let me go. - And I am finally taking orders

from the person I was always meant to.

Is anybody out there?

Please!

LET ME OUT!

Hello, dove!

You hungry?

You know, I gave you that nickname...

...Dove. Not because you were peaceful.

Hardly!

No, I gave it to you because I saw that you could soar.

Croatoan?

Not "Dad"?

Alright.

But clearly, we have a lot of catching up to do.

We covered the whole waterfront. No sign of her.

Damn it... Dwight, what happened?

McHugh and I went by Hamlin's house,

hoped we could use his Trouble to find Audrey, but Duke got to him first.

That makes four troubled people that Duke murdered -- all last night.

He's got to be collecting Troubles for Croatoan.

Is that why you got my guys pulling Troubled people off the street?

Keep 'em safe from Duke, stash 'em in here?

- Or are you using them as bait? - Both.

Your guys know the plan and they're on board.

If we catch Duke, we can force him to tell us where Croatoan's hiding Audrey.

I know what you're thinking, Dwight, but I'm not doing this just because it's Audrey.

I'm good with this. We need her.

She's our only hope to cure the Troubles.

Duke...

Get him!

- Get his arms! -Hold on, don't get too close.

Just--

Everyone, stand back! Don't shoot!

Duke, Duke! Stop!

Duke... Please.

- Stop... -Nathan...

McHugh...

- Hold him down. - Whatever you're going to do,

do it now!

Hell of a plan, Nathan,

but it actually worked.

Now what do we do to keep him under control?

- Chain him up. - Chain him up, guys!

What's going to stop Duke from using

Hailie's Trouble to phase through them?

'Cause they're made from an old Trouble by a prison guard

who wanted to stop Hailie's great grandfather from escaping.

He couldn't phase through. Duke won't be able to either.

Now we've just got to get him to talk.

You look nervous. So unlike you.

- Let me go. - Are you thirsty?

Where is Duke? What have you done with him?

I could get you some coffee. You liked coffee,

even when you were a little girl.

You were adorable.

You loved coffee, you loved

music, you loved dogs...

- So many of the same things-- - Shut up!

Shut up.

Why? Don't you want to know?

We have all those things back home.

- What home? - Ours! Yours and mine.

It has similarities to this world, but it is

far more advanced, now.

Except for a few warts.

It's wonderful.

I'm going back there, and I'm taking you with me. You'll be

- much happier there. - You don't know anything

- about me. - That's not true, Dove.

This room...

It's just like the room you grew up in.

I love it.

You mean Mara's room.

Is that what this is about?

You want your daughter back?

Well, you can't have her.

Mara's dead.

Mara's dead, I know.

But you're still my daughter.

And yes,

I want you back.

I just need to know that Dave's death

counted for something, that he didn't die in vain.

This new barn --

when it cures the Troubles, will it stop Croatoan?

Yes.

The Aether core will act as a power source,

drawing like to like.

It will pull out all the Aether, everything from the Void,

including Croatoan, and send it back.

What's your role in all this?

My function is similar to, um...

Well, think of it like a ship,

and I am its captain.

I tell all the pieces how to work together; what to do and when to do it.

So what's next?

What else do we need to complete the new Barn?

Once the Aether core is repaired, you will have

all the materials you need. But, uh,

I can't operate it -- not anymore.

What?

Back at the police station,

when I attempted to create the Barn

with the damaged Aether core, I was...

...compromised.

I can no longer serve as the Barn's controller.

Chains seem to be working as advertised.

Laverne's keeping an eye on him too.

Good.

So you're just going to go in there and talk to him?

- What do you even say to that? - That is still Duke.

- He's still in there. - Why, because his eyes change back?

How can you be sure?

You saw what happened when he had me by the throat.

He could have killed me.

He recognized me, hesitated.

That's the real Duke. That's who I'm going to talk to.

I've heard this song before, Nathan. - And I was right before.

Back in my father's cabin,

Duke bought me time to try and draw Audrey out of Mara

and it worked.

He deserves the same chance she had.

OK. But who knows what Croatoan did to him.

The Duke we knew --

I'm afraid we lost him forever.

Let's find out.

You should eat this! You love it.

I am not your daughter. I will never be your daughter.

Family's not a choice.

How can you talk about family like it means anything to you?

You kill your family.

You murdered Charlotte.

Your wife. My mother.

I loved your mother. She wasn't destroyed

by me, she was...

...contaminated by weak minds.

When she turned against me...

Broke my heart.

Then, when she started searching

for a cure for the Troubles...

That could have been disastrous for both of us.

I couldn't let that happen.

So I had to make a choice.

A very difficult choice.

No.

You killed James.

My son.

I had to!

That's how much I love you.

If I hadn't killed him,

Lucy would have -- and then all of Mara's work,

your work would have been undone.

Worse than that, the Barn would have sent you home

and I would have lost you forever.

Do you think that's an excuse?

Excuses

are for people who regret what they've done. I don't.

Because everything, I did it for you.

You're everything to me.

I need you to understand that.

Do you?

I want some coffee.

- I'll get it. -Black.

See? I knew that.

So...

Who am I talking to right now? Duke?

Do I not look like Duke Crocker?

- The one I grew up with? - Now, why would you say that?

Your eyes -- they've gone back to normal.

Whatever Croatoan did to you, it's wearing off.

Boo.

Nothing is wearing off.

This is what I am.

I am the person who took Audrey Parker.

No. You are the guy

who didn't just kill me when he had the chance.

Because you remembered who you really are.

You remember Audrey, too.

I do.

Mmm...

I know how much you really care about her,

how much she means to you.

Shouldn't you be more concerned

with how she feels about me?

We both know that sometimes

Audrey likes the bad boys.

And now that I have found my true self, well...

We may go all the way this time.

Well, I'm glad you brought that up.

What happened between you two in Colorado...

It meant something.

I mean, I know it did for her, I'm sure it did for you, too.

I want you to remember that.

What that felt like.

Remember that moment, remember how much

Audrey means to you,

because right now, she needs you.

Please tell me where she is.

You are pathetic.

Did you really think that reminding me

of kissing that dead fish would change anything?

This isn't some magical spell

that you can break with the power of love.

This is what

I am.

I don't believe that.

It doesn't matter what you believe.

You've already lost.

She's gone.

- We'll find her. - Good luck.

Croatoan was hiding inside of Dave.

You remember Dave --

old and bald and knew every hidden corner of Haven.

This is a disaster!

Everything we've done,

all our efforts undone by a stupid artificial intelligence

that can't remember what it was programmed to do?

By that logic, you are now insulting a malfunctioning--

Oh, shut up! Why can't you be more helpful?

You were always full of advice when it came to getting

Mara's incarnations back

That was by design.

My mission was to ensure that the Barn

performed precisely as it was supposed to.

Everything I did was in service of that primary function.

So then why can't we just give you a new primary function? - I'm not just a program.

you can simply rewrite and reboot.

I was once a man.

What?

By your calendar, it was

several centuries ago.

I lived in the same world

as Charlotte, Mara, and her father.

After Mara

created the Troubles,

I was the one that captured her, brought her to justice.

And you helped construct her punishment,

her prison?

By design, it required a dedicated warden,

one that deeply felt the need for her punishment.

When I tracked Mara here,

I saw what she had done to those people.

There was a...

A young boy...

The Trouble Mara gave him

was...intolerable.

His life unlivable. I had to end his suffering.

I had to...

I couldn't let that happen to my family.

So you sacrificed yourself to protect your loved ones.

Your home.

As I said,

that was centuries ago.

The importance of what I was doing

was clear because it was personal.

But after what happened in the police station,

after I was compromised, I...

I can't remember them anymore.

Without that personal connection,

you can't operate the new Barn.

No.

That, uh...

That couldn't have been easy. You OK?

No.

But it was worth it.

What Duke said about Croatoan knowing

all of Haven's secrets because he was part of Dave --

We should send someone to talk to Vince,

see if he knows where his brother would stash a prisoner.

- "Someone" meaning not you? - Duke is still in there.

I know it, I just need to keep pushing.

I'll go. McHugh's on his way in, he can back you up.

Dwight, I know you think that

- Duke's a lost cause, but-- - Hey, if anyone can get through to him, it's you.

You've known each other your whole lives, and maybe that's why he didn't kill you.

And reminding us about Dave, maybe that's Duke's way

of helping us out without tipping Croatoan off.

What you're doing, I...

I think it's working.

Hey. What needs doing?

Keep an eye on things in there. Nathan's making progress, but--

If things go south, you want me to take care of Crocker? - Ah, well...

No.

No, Nathan's right. Duke's still in there.

Hasn't always gotten along with the Guard, but he's one of us.

- No man left behind? - Yeah.

Help Nathan out any way you can, OK?

Here we go.

You said the Troubles

- were Mara's "work". - Yes.

Your work, really.

Following in your father's footsteps.

I hope it's not too hot.

Oh, Audrey...

I don't want to hurt you, you're my daughter!

And even if I did, poison -- not my style.

Yum-yum!

How could you call the Troubles "work"?

I understand why they frighten you.

It's because you're not seeing them clearly.

You're not seeing their full potential, what they can accomplish. What you're seeing

is the risks,

the damage. Doesn't have to be that way.

No, it doesn't.

OW, GOD!

No, please. Don't.

I need to teach you a lesson,

but not what you think.

Let's see what we have here. Ooh! Snapped clean through.

Must hurt -- but you've always been tough.

Luckily for you, your father knows what he's doing.

There you are, as good as new.

How did you do that?

I used the Troubles.

You can control the Troubles that you take from people? You can use them?

Yes.

And now Duke

is out there harvesting more for you,

- isn't he? - Just the ones I need

for my protection.

I survived in the Void

filled with Aether

for centuries.

You learned to master the Troubles.

I wish you'd stop calling them "the Troubles".

They're gifts, and in the right hands --

my hands -- they can accomplish anything.

Today wasn't the first time you've been my patient.

When you were a little girl,

I used Aether

to save your life.

What?

How?

I think it's time you heard my side of the story,

the one your mother never wanted you to hear.

Come back soon.

How's it going?

Duke's in there, but it's slow.

Maybe it's time we try a different course of action.

That chain you found got me thinking;

some Guard buddies of mine have old Troubles that can make Duke talk.

Use an old Trouble to torture him?

I've done a lot of damage by picking up the enemy's weapon.

I'll do you one better.

- Let's hear it. - What if we use an old Trouble

- to bring the real Duke back? - It's good.

And if it works,

we'll have a double agent embedded right by Croatoan's side.

Go grab the census of Troubles we've been putting together.

It's guarded -- tell them I sent you.

If there is one that can bring Duke back, it's in there.

I'm on it. What are you going to do?

Get back in there,

find that part of Duke I saw and grab on,

give us a fighting chance.

We need some help finding Audrey. Something Duke said

made us think that she's being kept at one of Dave's old hideouts.

- So, I figured-- - Deserted farmhouse, County Road 19

- on the outskirts of town. - That was...quick.

That's where we planned to hide out if things in Haven ever completely fell apart.

Guess we missed our chance.

You foolish old ghost.

Your brother was a good man.

He gave his life for this town.

I'm sure you would have done the same thing.

You said you aren't able to operate the new Barn,

but what they did to you,

turning you into the Barn's controller --

could you do it to someone else?

Could you do it...to me?

Back home, the work I was doing was

decades ahead of my contemporaries

and light years ahead of what minds here have dreamed up.

But success breeds envy, and eventually

the others grew timid,

afraid of progress.

They weren't timid. You were reckless.

Charlotte told me why you were banished.

You were experimenting with Aether from the Void.

I bet she didn't tell you why.

When you were a little girl,

you were sick. You were very, very sick.

No cure, no hope of survival/

You were our only child.

We were devastated.

I couldn't let you go.

So I took a risk, and it worked.

I introduced Aether into your immune system

to modify your natural antibodies.

I used Aether

to save your life.

You put Aether into your own daughter?

Yes, but it was like bringing you back from the dead.

The others were willing to let you go, but not me.

Your mother, she gave birth to you,

but all that you are, the miracle that you've become,

is all thanks to me.

I created you.

You're my daughter.

Twice.

We'll stay here as long as it takes,

because I know that you're still in there, Duke.

Croatoan's inside your head,

controlling you, but you can

- force him out. - You...

...are wrong.

Since when do you let someone tell you what to do?

Don't let him control you.

This isn't you.

Wrong again.

For the first time in my life, I know exactly who I am.

This is what I was

always meant to be.

Please...

Nathan...

Help me!

You're fighting him.

What can I do, how do I help?

- I don't know. - You can do this.

You can beat him, Duke. I know you can.

Come on.

What you did for me,

what you did for your daughter --

it was courageous.

Had to. Couldn't lose you.

But it doesn't excuse what you've done to the people here.

Being in the Void for all of those years, maybe it,

it changed you. It corrupted you.

What I endured in the Void has only made me stronger.

All those years in that place,

the only thing that kept me going was you.

I survived so I could return to you.

But at what cost?

The man who would do anything to save his daughter --

he would hate the person you've become.

No. I'm the same man I was back then.

Because everything I did was for you, to get you back.

I told you. I am not your daughter.

Mara is dead.

Names don't matter.

You're still my daughter.

My creation.

And you're still special.

I made you that way. Don't you feel that?

What you did with the Aether,

you said it made me special.

But how?

Why?

You need me for something.

All the facility and knowledge

necessary to operate a new construct are contained

- within that controller crystal. - But creating a new controller,

someone to steer the ship, as you put it --

that requires

- another sacrifice. - Yes.

I understand your commitment,

but biologically,

I don't even know if you'd be fit to serve as the controller.

You volunteered to serve as Mara's warden

because you knew it was the only way

to protect the ones you love. Now that was your purpose!

My dedication was paramount, but I can make no guarantees it will work the same for you.

But I have to try.

I've dedicated my life to Haven.

Leading the Guard for all those years,

using The Herald to cover up the Troubles,

all of it because I love this town.

The people here, I've seen what they've been through,

witnessed so much suffering,

lost a...

I've lost so much because of the Troubles.

And now I can play a part

in ending them -- forever.

The transformation process

to controller will kill you,

even if it doesn't succeed.

So be it.

This is my purpose.

You can control the Troubles,

you have Duke out there collecting the ones that you want,

so why do you need me?

What I did with the Aether to save Mara

changed her,

gave her a special bond with the Aether.

She could do things with it

nobody else could.

But can't you create Troubles on your own?

Yes, of course, but they pale in comparison

to the kind of things she could do.

And now that singular gift is yours.

I will never create Troubles for you.

Why not? You did it before when you touched Duke.

People were dying!

- I did what I had to do. - Exactly!

- Just like your father! - But why?

Why do you want me to make Troubles?

Because...

I want to take my daughter back where she belongs.

I want to take you home. If you would just

embrace what you are,

you could realize your full potential.

You do that, we can create the Troubles we need,

then we can take back what's rightfully ours,

reclaim our home from those who banished us,

show them what Aether is truly capable of.

Show them the power

that they were too cowardly to claim as their own.

And we'd do it together.

Father, daughter...

I'm going to rip open

a tear in the Void and flood this world with Aether.

Welcome to our laboratory.

Oh, Audrey, join me. You don't belong here.

You can't save these people. You can't save Haven!

What I have planned

has already begun.

Tell me you got something.

I've been looking through this Trouble census, and you're right. This thing's a gold mine!

You got psychic communication, there's a puppet master Trouble.

There's got to be something in here that can break Croatoan's

- hold over Duke. - Good work.

Now we just pickour best

shot and--

That's spooky. He can't hear us in here, can he?

Yes!

He can.

Thank you for bringing that, McHugh.

- How did he... - Damn it.

I'll take that Trouble census now.

What do you mean, "It's begun"?

- What's happening out there? - Just what I expected.

People are playing their parts perfectly.

Nathan is doing everything he can to save Duke,

Duke is showing him just enough

of his lost friend to keep hope alive,

just enough for Nathan to keep Duke close.

And it will cost him.

What is happening with Nathan?

This is your big moment.

Will you defend that with your life?

Stay out of this!

How did you get free?

Well, now why go around something

when you can just bust right through it?

- So easily fooled... - Croatoan...

...planned this?

Wanted you to get caught?

You faked this all just so you could get your hands on this?

That's right, exactly.

It's like a menu of Troubles.

Now we can just

pick and choose our favourites,

and then drink them up.

We will be

unstoppable. It's ironic;

all of the times that you've asked me to kill for you --

look what I have become,

what you turned me into.

You wanted a Crocker --

well, here I am.

Please, I am begging you: don't kill him.

- Why? - You don't need to.

If you are as powerful as you say,

it doesn't matter.

Dad...

Please!

Remember this:

it isn't you.

- Please, don't kill him! - Dove, dove, dove, it's alright!

I've decided to let Nathan live.

Why?

'Cause that's what you wanted.

It doesn't change anything!

I will never help you,

- no matter what you do. - Yes you will.

And I never expected just to

talk you into helping me;

no, today was about finding out what you really care about.

Nathan.

I needed to find out how much you care about him

and the others.

You'd do anything to protect them, wouldn't you?

- If you hurt them, I swear-- - Hurt them?

Haven't you been listening? I'm going to help them.

I'm going to use all the powers I've gathered

to give them what they truly want, what you truly want for them.

- What? - I'm going to make them happy.

Is that what you did with Duke?

Well...

Duke spent his life searching for his identity.

Now he's found it.

You're free to go.

Why would you just let me walk out?

Well, I want you to be with them, your friends. I want you to see

the gifts I offer, the happy lives

that they can live.

And what you'll be ripping away from them

if you still refuse to join me.

Daddy?

What's wrong, Daddy? Say something.

Lizzie... But you...

Vince?

Vince?

Howard, I need your help finding Vince.

Vince?

Vince...

Oh, my God...

What have you done?

What I had to.

And I know exactly what we have to do

to send Croatoan screaming back to hell.