All language subtitles for What Bothers Physicists About Black Holes (Interview with Brian Cox)

af Afrikaans
ak Akan
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bem Bemba
bn Bengali
bh Bihari
bs Bosnian
br Breton
bg Bulgarian
km Cambodian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
chr Cherokee
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch
en English
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
ee Ewe
fo Faroese
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gaa Ga
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gn Guarani
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ia Interlingua
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
rw Kinyarwanda
rn Kirundi
kg Kongo
ko Korean
kri Krio (Sierra Leone)
ku Kurdish
ckb Kurdish (Soranรฎ)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Laothian
la Latin
lv Latvian
ln Lingala
lt Lithuanian
loz Lozi
lg Luganda
ach Luo
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mfe Mauritian Creole
mo Moldavian
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
sr-ME Montenegrin
ne Nepali
pcm Nigerian Pidgin
nso Northern Sotho
no Norwegian
nn Norwegian (Nynorsk)
oc Occitan
or Oriya
om Oromo
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt-BR Portuguese (Brazil)
pt Portuguese (Portugal)
pa Punjabi
qu Quechua
ro Romanian
rm Romansh
nyn Runyakitara
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
sh Serbo-Croatian
st Sesotho
tn Setswana
crs Seychellois Creole
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish
es-419 Spanish (Latin American)
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
tt Tatar
te Telugu
th Thai
ti Tigrinya
to Tonga
lua Tshiluba
tum Tumbuka
tr Turkish
tk Turkmen
tw Twi
ug Uighur
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
wo Wolof
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu

Original subtitles

Imagine that you and I are on a mission to fall into a black hole. It's a bit

nasty around these things. You cease to stay together.

We're one long string of atoms?

Well, what are we? Yeah, and then the atoms get separated.

If a black hole will one day end up as nothing, the normal vacuum of space,

happened to you and me? What happened to all of that stuff? I mean, this is the

central question.

The laws of nature are quite clear on this. So that's what bothered everybody.

for a very long time. What happened? What's the end of the story? I'm so

about this. The video you're about to watch is a deep dive into the cutting

research happening right now about black holes.

It's... Awesome. It's the extended cut of an interview that I did with famous

physicist Dr. Brian Cox for a shorter Huge If True episode all about what

actually happen if you fell into a black hole. That episode is incredible, and

I've linked to it in the description.

But there was so much weird and mind -bending stuff in this conversation that

didn't fit into that shorter episode, and I knew that you'd want to see it. So

we decided to release the full extended cut. It's just too cool, and I think

you'll love it. So strap in, because the cutting edge of black holes is

Great. Would you mind just starting us out by introducing yourself however you

like? Yeah, I'm Brian Koch.

And if you want the title, the full title, I'm Professor of Particle Physics

the University of Manchester, Royal Society Professor for Public Engagement

Science and Visiting Scholar at the Crick Institute in London.

And how do you describe what you do every day?

What I do every day?

Physics.

And that's kind of the way that I see myself. If someone asks me what I do, I

say I'm a physicist.

But actually, of course, most of my time now is spent on the public engagement

side. And I kind of fell into that accidentally.

But I still, maybe it's a thing, maybe there's some deep psychological thing

going on. But I never say TV presenter or whatever it is. I just say physicist.

Well, that's what I want to talk to you all about today.

So imagine that you and I are on a mission to fall into a black hole.

And we have some imaginary spaceship that can take us as far and as fast as

want. So we get up, we walk outside, we get into our spaceship.

What now?

What is a black hole and how do we find them?

So a black hole, it's interesting that the idea...

The first glimpse of them, theoretically, came very shortly after

theory of gravity was published, in 1915.

Although it wasn't recognized as such at the time, this glimpse.

But essentially, what does Einstein's theory do? It's important for what

follows. It's a theory of space and time, and how space -time, which is

described as the fabric of the universe,

responds, warps or curves, to matter and energy in the universe.

So the equations, basically the theory that Einstein published all those years

ago, will say, give me some distribution of matter, something like a ball of

matter, and the equations will tell you how the fabric of the universe is

distorted. And by the way, the force of gravity in that theory then is the

response of everything else in the universe to that distortion.

So Einstein would say, what are we feeling now? Newton would say it's a

between us and the Earth.

But Einstein would say there isn't a force. What we're responding to the

distortion in the fabric of the universe created by the Earth.

John Wheeler, actually, the great physicist, put it beautifully.

He said, matter tells space -time how to curve, and space -time tells matter how

to move. And that's it. So that's Einstein's theory.

So in 1916...

shortly after it was published, a man called Karl Schwarzschild remarkably

managed to solve the equations for a perfectly spherical, non -spinning ball

matter. It's the simplest thing you could do, which tells you how space and

are distorted by it. And that's a model for a star.

It's the simplest thing you could do.

So he solved the equations. It's a remarkable thing.

In those equations...

there is a description of a black hole, although it wasn't realized at the time.

It's a remarkable piece, simple piece of mathematics, actually.

So essentially, what's the idea behind a black hole?

One way to think about it is that you could remove, could you remove the star

from this fabric, but leave the distortion behind?

So if you do that, you get the description of a black hole. But you

what would you mean? How can that be?

formed in nature so you think about what a star is then a star is a balancing

act so it's a it's a mainly hydrogen helium collapsing under its own gravity

that's how our sun formed four and a half billion years ago so it's

so what stops it collapsing well as it collapses the core heats up And that

initiates nuclear fusion reactions in the core. In the case of our sun, it's

hydrogen being fused into helium. That releases energy, which creates a

which holds the thing up. So it's balancing, but it needs the fuel.

And it's not infinitely big, of course. So at some point it runs out of nuclear

fuel. And ultimately, no more fusion reactions can occur in any star.

And so the star will resume its collapse.

So the question is, well, is there something that stops it?

Because if there isn't something that stops the collapse, then it will

without limits.

And so actually, if you look at the history of physics in the 20s and 30s,

people were saying, well, we'd like to avoid this idea that the thing will

collapse without limits.

Because if it does, then Schwarzschild's equation predicts some very strange

things indeed. And so people kind of tried to avoid it. It was really

Oppenheimer. and his student Schneider in the late 30s, just before the Second

World War, that showed that really, with some assumptions, it looked like a

massive enough star could actually collapse without limits.

So what does that mean?

Collapse is without limits.

It means that essentially it does what I said.

You essentially remove the star from the fabric of the universe, leaving the

distortion behind.

And the black hole, the idea behind the black hole is... Let's say you take

the sun, the mass of the sun, and you just collapse it and you keep on

collapsing it.

You get to a point when the radius of the sun is not 700 ,000 kilometers,

is what it is in miles, half a million miles.

I'm going to use kilometers because I can't remember the things in miles. Our

audience will appreciate that. Everyone can convert it afterwards, right?

So 700 ,000 kilometers.

And you squash it down.

And you squash it and squash it until its radius becomes three kilometers.

Three.

Then there are several ways to look at this. One is that on the surface, the

speed you'd have to travel to escape its gravitational pull, called the escape

velocity, would exceed the speed of light.

That's one way to think about it.

So even light rays emitted from the surface, if you could squash it down

far. would just stay there. They would not escape because they'd be trying to

at the speed of light and the escape velocity is the speed of light and they

just stop.

So what happens then, if a star collapses inside that number, which for

of the sun, three kilometers, is called the Schwarzschild radius, then it will

collapse without limits.

Nothing will stop it.

And for all you will get is essentially the geometry of space and time, the

curvature. And that's a black hole. So it's a thing that traps light in that

sense. So you think about that.

If you have this surface, and space and time are so distorted there, that if you

go in across that surface, called the event horizon of the black hole, then

can't get out.

One way to think about it is you'd have to travel faster than light to get out.

Another way to think about it is that there's a beautiful model, which is my

favorite model. It's called the river model of a black hole. You can write the

equations, space being like a river that flows into this thing, kind of like a

sinkhole or something in space.

And the river of space flows at the speed of light inwards on the horizon.

And then faster than light, inside.

So if you imagine that you're a photon, a particle of light, you're like a

little fish swimming against the tide.

But if the tide's going at the speed, as fast as you can swim, the speed of

light, you can't get out.

Not only can you not get out, but you're going inwards towards something.

And this thing, this something, is called a singularity.

You say, what is this thing, the singularity? And I think it's really

to picture it as some infinitely dense point to which the star collapsed.

When you draw a map of space and time, what you see really clearly is that this

singularity thing is not a place in space, it's a moment in time.

And it's in fact the end of time in Einstein's theory.

So a way that I often kind of picture it or explain it to myself is that space

and time have become so distorted.

that when you look at it from the outside, they flip -roll.

So space has become time, and time has become space.

In the mathematics, if you put a little graphic up, you'll see that the plus and

minus signs in the Schwarzschilds are quite reversed, right?

And so they flip around, and so they change.

So what you thought of as an infinitely -end place in space to which the star

collapsed has become a moment in time.

And a way to think about why you have to go to it then, it's really beautiful,

because you think it becomes something that's in the future for anyone or

anything that crosses the horizon.

It's in the future.

So it's like, if you say, well, I want to escape this thing, it's like saying,

want to escape tomorrow.

If I said to you, let's run away from tomorrow, you'd go, I can't run away

tomorrow, it's in the future.

That's what this thing behaves like.

So that's the Einsteinian description of a black hole.

I want to take that step by step. Yeah, yeah, there's a lot of it in there, but

it's fun.

Okay, so in order to understand this, let's imagine that we choose the black

hole at the center of our own galaxy. Yeah.

Sagittarius A star, I think it's called. Yeah. I know that we took this picture

of it in 2020.

That is by the Event Horizon Telescope, Sagittarius A star. What are we looking

at here?

So here, the light, you might say, what is the light in this picture?

So it's not from the black hole, because the black hole's trap light.

It's from what's called the accretion disk around the black hole.

So you have to imagine the material spiralling around in orbit, around this

dense object, and very violently orbiting.

And so it heats up and it emits light.

So imagine a flat, thin disk of material around the black hole.

But this does not look like that.

What you're seeing is the distortion, the curvature of the light rays.

We said that you might think, well, light travels in straight lines.

But Einstein's theory says that in the vicinity of this thing, the fabric of

universe itself is distorted.

So the light, the paths of the light rays follow the distortion.

That's why in an animation it looks like it's going over the top and around the

sides at the same time. So what you're seeing, this famous image of a black

hole, like if you think of the film Interstellar, that code, by the way, is

implementation of Einstein's equations.

Kip Thorne and others helped him do that.

So it's really a prediction.

So what you're seeing, if you imagine this disk of material around this thing,

like picture it in your mind's eye pattern, then light rays, let's say from

perspective, from behind the black hole, let's say, on the disk, go around

into your eyes.

Sometimes they orbit and then go around into your eyes.

And they go into your eyes from every point on the disk, from underneath and

the top and behind.

So you have light rays going always around this thing. So you see that.

what you see as an image.

So there's a prediction of Einstein's theory.

which is a real black hole, should look like that. It's a characteristic donut

shape that you see.

Well, here's an image with radio telescopes of such a thing.

And it looks like the prediction. It is a bit blurry, but, you know, this is at

the center of the galaxy.

Very difficult. This was actually the second one that was imaged. The first

was in a galaxy called M87, which is 55 million light years away and is bigger

than this one.

Bigger.

So this one's about 6 million times the mass of the sun, give or take.

The one in M87 is 6 billion times the mass of the sun. So this is the baby

supermassive black hole that we've got. So this is my next question.

Our black hole, how big is it compared to other black holes that we know of?

It's a small -ish one.

And what's the scale?

It's a supermassive black hole. But we think that I would say all galaxies,

maybe there's an exception or so, but pretty much all galaxies have

black holes at their centres.

We don't quite know why, actually. We don't quite know how galaxies form in

early universe. It's one of the...

that the JWST, the James Webb, is looking at in some detail, the new space

telescope. But to good approximation, all galaxies have these things.

And they can be different masses.

So as I said, the M87 galaxy has one that's six billion times the mass rather

than six million times the mass.

But how big is it?

So the number I always remember in my mind is the Schwarzschild radius of the

sun. which is, as we mentioned, it's the radius you'd have to squash the sun

down to make a black hole. And it's three kilometres.

So it goes like the math.

So you can work it out. So if that's six million times the mass of the sun, then

the Schwarzschild radius is six million times three kilometres.

It's kind of easy to do the math, actually.

So that would be the... You might call it... You have to be careful with your

language. But let's... Let's say that this thing is, it gives you an idea of

size of this structure.

So the disk outside it is much bigger.

I did the math with Earth's radius.

Yeah. And it seemed to suggest that we would become a black hole if we

compressed everything on Earth and all of us into something about the size of a

pea. Yeah, that's from memory about 0 .8 centimeters, I think. Something like

that, just less than a centimeter. So you're right about that, that big.

Do black holes that small exist?

No, we don't.

I think so.

So even black holes, the mass of the sun, the sun will not form a black hole.

When it runs out of nuclear fuel, it will collapse. And there's something

can stop it collapsing.

The force of electrons.

Yeah, it's called the white dwarf star.

It's beautiful calculation, by the way, that you can do the calculation. It's

great.

So what stops it, as an aside, is that electrons, there's something called the

Pauli exclusion principle. I read about this, yeah. So electrons don't want to

be close together, roughly speaking, you could say it like that.

So as you squash the thing, the electrons get closer together.

And so they kind of separate away from each other and go into smaller and

smaller little regions of space because they're trying to stay away from each

other. But there's also something called the uncertainty principle, Heisenberg's

uncertainty principle.

So as you confine them in smaller regions, they start jiggling around

faster. And ultimately, you can reach a limit where they're essentially trying

to jiggle at the speed of light and they can't. And so there's a limit to how

much pressure that process can exert.

And it turns out it's 1 .4 times the mass of the sun, which is called the

Chandrasekhar limit.

So you can do that calculation.

But it's a beautiful calculation because you could have worked that out.

not knowing that stars exist.

All you need to know about is quantum mechanics and relativity.

And you can make the calculation, what is the biggest lump of stuff that can be

held up by this jiggling of electrons?

It turns out it's 1 .4 times the mass of the sun. Then you look into the sky and

you see there are these things called white dwarfs, these collapsed stars,

are, and there's none.

More massive than 1 .4 times the mass of the Sun. So it's very beautiful. And

then you can get neutron stars, which are held up by the jiggle in the

But ultimately, if you go to something that's three times the mass of the Sun,

something like that, a bit more, then nothing stops it collapsing.

And that's when you form a black hole.

So the lightest black holes that we know of are around that mass.

And then we know of them that are 10, 20, 30 times the mass of the Sun from

collapsed stars.

And then these things, which are millions of times or even more the mass

sun, which is at the heart of galaxies.

So we've launched in our spaceship. We are hurtling toward this black hole.

Could you walk us through step by step what happens from now until when we hit

the event horizon?

Yeah. So the first thing to say is that it's right at the heart of Einstein's

theory is something called the equivalence principle, which was the

really led Einstein to the theory itself of gravity.

And so you don't feel its pull.

What you do is you just fall freely towards it. So we're falling towards

thing there, and we turn our rocket motors off.

We can't tell.

We can't look outside.

We can't look out the windows. We're just in free fall. We're just floating.

So it's like the astronauts on the International Space Station.

We're just there.

So it's fundamental to Einstein's theory.

It's very important, actually, for the...

problems that follow that we're going to talk about that you just freely fall

towards this thing so we could be approaching this in this room now and we

have no clue that that's what's happening and in fact so we're

event horizon of a very big black hole like this for a black hole of this mass

then we wouldn't even notice something, according to Einstein's theory, as we

fall across the horizon into the interior of the black hole.

So we'd fall across the horizon.

From our perspective in this room, according to Einstein, and we'll go for

caveat a bit later, but according to Einstein, into the interior of the black

hole we go and we notice nothing.

What about when we're in the accretion desk?

Wouldn't we be banged around by a lot of stuff? We might get in a bit of a mess.

But we're talking about the pure gravitational thing. You're absolutely

It's a bit nasty around these things.

But that's nothing to do with the black hole itself.

It's nothing to do with the fundamental physics.

It's all the x -rays and all the nasty gamma, all the stuff that's been

from all this hot material around it.

So, yes.

That would be a problem. But if we had a, let's say that our room, this

spacecraft, is magically insulated from radiation and heat and all those things,

then nothing.

In, we would go into the interior.

The caveat, there's a lot of caveats, but one thing I should say is that it

matters that that description I've given, it's for a supermassive black

If this was a smaller black hole, so smaller, less massive, you know, a few

times the mass of the sun, then at some point you experience what's called tidal

gravity, tidal forces.

So those are the things that raise the tides in the oceans of the Earth.

The tidal forces, we will start to, in our freely falling trajectories towards

the black hole, at some point you start to get... feel the tides, you start to

get stretched and squashed. And we feel it. You would start, you'll feel it

eventually. You'll really feel it eventually because formally, as you get

close to the singularity, you get infinitely stretched and squashed. So

really feel it. I want to talk about that inside.

Yes, that's my favorite one. But for a smaller black hole, as you approach the

horizon, you feel those forces.

But for the big ones, You don't feel the tights until you've gone into the

interior. So we're moving toward the event horizon. We're somehow insulated

the messiness of the accretion disk. We're moving toward it.

I've heard that there's a moment where the physics of this are such that if you

and I are actually falling in, if we look to the left and the right, we would

actually see the back of our own heads.

Yeah. Is that anywhere close to correct? And can you tell me about... the other

little details as we approach the event horizon that you think are important?

Well, one of the biggest details, it's not even a detail, it's one of the most

shocking things about this is I've described this, the earth falling into

black hole.

And we're saying in this room where we can't see out, what do we feel? What can

we measure?

And the answer is you can't measure anything and we don't feel anything

get inside and we approach the singularity for this one.

But from the point of view of someone outside, the description is very

different.

So what would they see happening to us as we fall towards this thing? So even

in Einstein's theory with nothing else, no quantum mechanics or anything.

then what they would see is time tick more slowly for us.

So they would start to see, as we approach the black hole, if they could

watches, if we were transmitting to them or whatever it is, transmitting from

these cameras, we're sending it out to them.

They would see our time tick more slowly, more slowly, more slowly.

And they would see our time stop on the horizon.

So they would never see us fall in.

So from the point of view of someone outside, nothing goes into the black

ever.

So do they see us imprinted there forever, or does the light from us

fade? It would fade, because also you could picture, there are many ways of

picturing it, but you could say this light is climbing away through this

gravitational field, so it's getting stretched.

So we get redder and redder and redder, redshifted, infinitely redshifted.

Time passes more and more slowly until it stops on the horizon when viewed from

the outside.

From our perspective, we look at our watches, they go at one second per

And that's absolutely central. There's nothing weird. Well, there's something

weird there. But there isn't according to Einstein.

So it's pure.

Einstein's theory.

So that's the first thing to say. And it's a clue to the interesting things

about what we're going to talk about, what follows, is that there are

perspectives on what's happening here.

There's a perspective from our point of view, we're going in for a big black

hole. From the point of view of someone outside, we never go in.

And that's going to be kind of important for what follows.

But there's nothing that's not described by Einstein's theory in that.

Hang on, let me show you something else that's really cool. This is my privacy

dashboard. It shows how many data brokers I've gotten myself removed from.

Actually, our sponsor, Incogni, has gotten me removed from. So why does this

matter? Well, data brokers make money buying and selling your information.

Sometimes they sell to businesses, so maybe I get more spam. But also, with

data, these brokers can form a picture of you, a shadow profile, which they can

then use in ways you might not want.

but incogni can force many of them to remove you. Let me show you. So they

out to data brokers on my behalf and they say, hey, remove this person. And

then, crucially, they follow up to make sure that I actually got removed.

I really appreciate this, and I think you might too. If you want to try it

use the code CleoAbram at the link below and get 60 % off an annual plan. Now,

back to Black Hole.

So at this moment, we crossed the event horizon.

Yeah. And we don't feel that... We could have crossed it now.

Just now.

Wouldn't notice.

And...

Our experience now is completely inside the blackness of the black hole from an

outsider's perspective.

Gravity is increasing faster and faster.

And this is where we get to maybe my favorite word that I have learned in the

process, which is when the, my understanding of this is when the

feet is so different from the gravity at your head that you begin to stretch in

a very dramatic way. And this is, Spaghettification.

Yeah. Could you explain what is happening here? Yeah. As we get

One way of thinking about it is that, another way of thinking about it is just

that the distortion in space -time is not constant over the

length of your body.

So when we're falling in, we might as well be, this is Einstein's equivalence

principle in action, we might as well be in flat space because the distortion,

it's like saying, On the surface of the Earth, if you look at a square mile of

the surface of the Earth, you don't see the curvature, right? You have to go to

bigger distances to see that you're on a curved surface.

It's kind of like that. So the distortion...

the difference in gravitational pull as you said or the distortion you don't

feel it until it becomes very distorted or the big gravitational pull when you

get very close to this thing and then you start to see that and actually it

works it's not only stretching it's also squashing so the way the tidal gravity

works is to squash in one direction and pull in the other direction so we are

getting you feel it so you start to feel this strange

sort of sensation of being stretched and squashed.

And as you go closer and closer to the singularity, those effects become much

more extreme.

Until they're so extreme that, first of all, you cease to stay together.

We're one long string of atoms? What are we? And then the atoms get separated,

and then the protons, the quarks inside the protons will get separated.

And ultimately, according to Einstein's theory, the tidal forces become

infinite.

So formally infinite.

And so everything is gone.

Everything's been ripped apart.

And this is what we call the singularity. So the whole thing kind of

extreme and breaks down ultimately in Einstein's picture.

The question that when I began this story, I wanted to ask you is what is at

center of a black hole? But in doing this research, I now understand that

talking about the center is also a little bit incorrect.

Yeah. How should I actually think about what is happening at that singularity?

Well, I mean, the first thing to say is we don't know, right?

We can talk about the current research and speculation.

We don't really have the tools to describe it.

So a way to think about Einstein's theory is that, as I mentioned earlier,

tells you how space and time are distorted.

They also kind of get mixed.

get up from from from the point of view of someone outside so then you'll see

that space and time are getting warped and distorted and as i mentioned they

so mixed up that on the horizon you see that they flip and so the thing to

bear in mind for all that follows with einstein's theory is this very central

idea that if you're freely falling through space or over space

-time, if you like, then in the absence of these tidal effects, you

really cannot tell where you are in the universe. If you're close to a black

hole, close to a big star, orbiting around a galaxy, just falling, whatever

is. So I think that's the key idea, the so -called equivalence principle.

But of course...

As we said before, the thing about a black hole is that you could say, why

I see these effects on the Earth?

This distortion, this mixing.

And you do.

So you see it in GPS satellites, for example.

So if you think about what I said, I said, as you go closer to this thing,

as viewed from the outside, time passes more slowly.

So you could say, well, why doesn't the Earth do that? And it does.

So what you see is that time ticks at a different rate, by which I mean clocks

tick at a different rate, atomic clocks or biological clocks.

So you age at a different rate in orbit than you do on the surface of the Earth.

And you're seeing this is the same effect.

The reason it gets very extreme, I should say, it's quite a big effect for

near the Earth. So the drift is tens of thousands of nanoseconds per day.

The difference in the rate that time passes at the orbit of a

GPS satellite and on the ground.

And we have to accommodate for that when we deal with GPS. It doesn't work.

There's tens of thousands of nanoseconds per day, even around the Earth.

So the question of black hole really is, as you said before, if I could keep the

mass of the Earth the same, but shrink it down to the size of a pea.

then how does that distortion change as I go closer and closer to this immensely

massive P thing?

And this is the effect, that time keeps going more and more slowly from the

perspective of someone outside until you see it stop on the horizon, which as we

said for the Earth is around a centimeter, just a little bit less.

So it's kind of not, in some ways, this behavior of time is not...

unique to a black hole.

It's just that in the black hole, it becomes extreme because the thing is

completely collapsed.

So we have passed through the event horizon. We have been spaghettified. We

hit the end of time.

Yeah.

This is a question I think I know the answer to, but I think it leads us into

our next section.

The question is, can we ever get back out?

So, yeah. So the answer is, According to Einstein's theory, no, because

you've gone to the end of time, right? And there's no way.

Basically, Einstein would say it's all over.

You've got ripped to bits. Everything has got ripped to bits. You've gone to

this infinitely distorted space and time, and it's just done.

What would Stephen Hawking say?

Well, Stephen Hawking initially would have said, in the 1970s,

Well, we should say, what did Stephen Hawking discover in the 1970s?

So in his words, he discovered that black holes ain't so black.

So he said nothing comes out of a black hole.

Everything that goes in goes to the singularity. It's gone forever because

black hole lives forever.

Now, Stephen Hawking calculated that if you do some essentially

quantum mechanics, right, around the horizon of the black hole. So you think

about what happens.

What does the black hole do?

A way of thinking about this is that in quantum mechanics, which means in

reality, in nature, empty space isn't empty. It has a rich structure. So the

vacuum of space has a structure.

And the black hole, you might say, well, this strange behavior of space and

time, it must do something.

And it does.

It disrupts that structure.

And the result is that...

particle photons, essentially, but what's called Hawking radiation, is

from the black hole.

So the result, and there are different ways of thinking about what's happening.

There's the very precise way Stephen Hawking gave an analogy in his paper.

And he said, it's just an analogy.

And people get very worked up online when you talk about his analogy, but

Stephen did write it down, right?

So a way to picture the quantum vacuum.

is that you can imagine particles coming in and out of existence all the time in

the vacuum.

So in accord with the uncertainty principle, they come in and out and in

like that. You can kind of picture it like that.

I emphasize it's not supposed to be a technical description, but you can

picture. So you can picture these in the vicinity of the horizon.

You can picture that this structure gets disrupted.

You could have the situation.

where one of these particles is on the inside and one is on the outside and

we know what's happening to the one on the inside it's going to the singularity

because we said the river of space is going fast in there or whatever

way you want to think about it so the other one is basically made real and and

escaped so that's a picture that steven himself gave um but the upshot is very

accurate the point is that this particle has been shaken out of the vacuum And

it's now a real particle when viewed from the outside.

And it goes away. So what is that? What particle has been emitted? It's the

temperature. It's glowing.

And so that means it's losing energy.

And so that means it has a lifetime.

So over time, and these are enormous times, far greater than the current age

the universe for any black hole that we know of in the universe.

Because we don't know of tiny ones.

So all the ones we know of, the immense lifetimes, in excess of 10 to the power

of 100 years for these supermassive ones, right? Ridiculous times.

But ultimately, they have a lifetime.

And that means one day it will be gone, and space will be all nice and normal

again, right? All you will have left will be the Hawking radiation that's

emitted over these eons of time.

Okay. I think something is missing from my understanding of the universe.

I agree with you. Something is missing in my understanding as well, and

everybody else's.

Here's what I think is missing from mine right now.

So all of this matter has, including us, passed through the event horizon, ended

up at the singularity. It is something in there at the end of time. Yeah, and

would increase the mass of the black hole, and the black hole would grow.

Because you've gone in.

And also, I think that I know that every law that we have about the universe

says that information is conserved.

If a black hole will one day end up as nothing, the

normal vacuum of space, what happened to

you and me? What happened to all of that stuff? I mean, this is the central

question.

Stephen's initial calculation, 1974,

was that this radiation, the Hawking radiation, is

informationless, information -free. So it's not gone away. It's not

the black hole. It turned into the radiation, right?

But his calculation said there's no information in that. It's what's called

thermal, purely thermal. Not surprising if you think about it, because it's been

kind of shaken out of the vacuum of space.

So it's certainly, you would think, got nothing to do with the stuff that falls

in. This is something to do with the horizon.

It's not anything to do with the singularity, this stuff.

So out it comes, and the calculation is very clear.

So that would suggest, as you said, that the information, any record of anything

that fell in will have been erased.

The energy will be the same. The energy is conserved. The black hole hasn't

vanished. It's turned into radiation.

But the radiation contains no trace of anything that fell in. That is weird, as

you said.

Because if you think, let's imagine, you might say, well, what's the difference?

What if I get this piece of paper and set fire to it? It goes, and there's

stuff, ashes and radiation.

Yes. But in principle, then if you could just measure everything,

which you can't, but if you could, then you could reconstruct the information on

the page. And you can see why, because it's got something.

What's happening when you burn it is chemical reactions and there's

whatever it is. But you can trace everything back. So you can say all the

and things are still around and there it is.

In a black hole, you can't.

So it wasn't surprising.

What was surprising is that it appears there is a calculation that tells you

that black holes erase everything.

And as you said, the laws of nature are quite clear on this.

Information does not get destroyed in the universe. It gets scrambled so you

never reconstruct it, but it doesn't get destroyed. So that's what bothered

everybody for a very long time.

What happened? What's the end of the story?

So at the end of the story, we're not at the end of the story yet, but in 2019,

a series of papers were published.

One of the papers was by Jeff Pennington and the other one was by another group

of authors.

But those papers suggest that Stephen missed a bit in his

calculation. Very subtle.

He could have never seen it.

Yeah, I mean, that's why it took, you know, 50 years, right, to see what he'd

missed. But it turns out that the radiation is not information free.

At the end of the process, then all the information about everything that fell

in is imprinted in the radiation, as you would normally expect.

But you might, but then it becomes interesting because you say, well, okay,

there's a calculation and there's mathematics that was done.

But you say, well, what's the picture then? What happened? Because I

if I take this and throw it into the black hole, it's gone across the

It's gone to the singularity.

It's definitely true that nothing comes out of the black hole.

So how is this information about this thing getting imprinted in the

And it turns out that it's not just... Initially, quite a few people thought,

well, it must be just right at the end.

When it's all quantum gravity and all this stuff, so the thing's just about to

disappear back into the universe. And it's getting hotter and hotter, by the

way, as it gets smaller and smaller. So there's more and more, it's getting more

and more violent and something weird happens and everything comes out.

But it was known for a long time, it's worked by a great physicist called Don

Page, that the problem about the information and the

structure of space, these problems occur.

about halfway through the black hole's life.

So it's called the page time.

So the problems with the information structure of this thing occur

way before you should be thinking about quantum gravity and a load of weird

stuff. So there was a big challenge to physics. It's like we should be able to

calculate stuff when the black hole is halfway through its life. There's

weird at the horizon.

But yet something weird appears to be happening. The picture of the thing is

breaking down.

And so then we could skip if you want.

So what is the picture of this? And I should emphasize the health warning

This is ongoing research.

And there is no agreed upon picture.

And there's some other subtleties we'll talk about in a minute.

But a picture of what's happening, this is related to something called the

holographic principle at some level, we think.

So another discovery that was made in the 70s, which is quite interesting, by

quite, I'm using it in the American sense, it's very interesting, is that

Jacob Bekenstein, one of the pioneers along with Stephen Hawking,

what's called the entropy of a black hole. So this thing of the temperature,

Stephen calculated the temperature, that is inscribed on his gravestone in

Westminster Abbey, his equation for the temperature of a black hole. So it's a

huge fundamental discovery.

Temperature is now, we understand it now, we didn't, when we first introduced

the concept, we didn't know about atoms and molecules.

Then we did, and we realised that temperature is about how fast the

parts jiggle.

around of a thing, right? So this water here, heated up, the molecules are

jiggling around faster, that's what temperature is.

This thing, a black hole, think about what this is.

I said the description of it is just space and time. That's all it is. It's

geometry.

So immediately we've got the temperature of a geometry, not a temperature of a

thing made of stuff, but it's just the temperature of space, right?

So that's kind of interesting.

And then Bekenstein calculates that the thing as an entropy, which implies that

it hides information from us. There's a structure, there's information in there.

The entropy turns out to be equal to, equal to, the surface area of the event

horizon in what's called square Planck lengths.

So this is a remarkable idea that you can think of the horizon And I said,

remember, it doesn't really, it's not really there from our perspective.

I said we could be falling through it and I wouldn't notice anything,

to Einstein, in we go.

But then you look at it from the outside and it looks like there's information

encoded on the horizon in pixels that are one plank length in size.

So what does that mean?

Information's encoded in space somehow, on the surface?

And also, by the way, It's weird, isn't it? If I said how much information is

contained in this room, you would say, well, it's to do with the volume of the

room, right? It's the library. It's how many books can I fit in the library?

This is saying, no, at a fundamental level, the amount of information in this

room is determined by the surface area of the room, not the volume.

So it's almost as if nature has said you can paper the outside of the library

with the pages of the book.

But there is no interior to this thing.

So you start to get these hints that there's something very strange going on.

What is happening here?

So we've got this picture now, which was the 1970s, of this thing that has a

temperature and an entropy, which are calculated.

And so that kind of is suggestive of substructure.

But structure of space and time? What do we mean by that? So nobody knows.

Nobody knew that, right?

Then, so there's another thing that comes, another property that then comes,

which is why I was careful about us falling in. And I kept saying, from our

perspective, nothing happens.

So you've got this Hawking radiation.

It's coming from the disruption of the vacuum in one picture.

So it's all there. And it's coming away and it's climbing away from this black

hole. It's losing energy.

And so it's very low temperature by the time you're far away from this thing.

But you go in towards it then.

towards the horizon.

If you lowered a thermometer down from far away, our friends are in a

now, they've got a thermometer and they lower it down.

The idea is that it sees hotter and hotter temperatures because you're

closer and closer to this horizon.

So you've got like a fishing rod and you're sending the thermometer down and

it's going hotter and hotter from the point of view of someone outside.

From the point of view of someone falling in, there's no temperature at

You don't see anything. You don't feel anything. You don't measure any Hawking

radiation. You just go in because you're in free fall.

So from your perspective, nothing's happening.

From the outside, you've got this high temperature.

So from the outside, a description of what happens to us is different.

The description of what happens to us is that we get vaporized.

We never get spaghettified.

As I said, you know, the other thing is we never go in, right? So what happens

to us?

we get vaporized before we cross the horizon.

And all our ashes and all this stuff comes out.

And you could collect it and you could say, well, that's fine.

Great. It's just like burning a piece of paper.

But Einstein's theory is absolutely clear that from our perspective, we go

We get spaghettified.

So from our perspective, our demise, the description of our demise is

spaghettification. Yep.

From the exterior perspective, the description of our demise is

right? So which one is it?

So you say, well, come on, you either get incinerated or spaghettified, which

one?

The modern view, at some level, that is much debated, goes all the way back to

work by Leonard Susskind and Gerard Verhoeft and some others.

It's called black hole complementarity.

And the idea is that both pictures are correct.

from different points of view this is relativity in action right so the idea

both pictures are correct now so there is some it's not as simple as that

and that even is not simple because there's other stuff going on here but so

might say well okay so i understand sort of this idea that the information

essentially you're saying that from the outside

Things fall in and get scrambled up and are somehow stored close to the horizon.

And you can obviously imagine these bits of information coming off the Hawking

radiation. Nothing really goes in.

And so it's fine. I understand how that stuff got out.

But then the question is, what happens?

What's the description of that from our perspective going in then? Because we

definitely went in, right? So we've gone in from our point of view.

What happened?

What's the other description?

Are there two of us?

No, that's a great question. So you might say, well, we get copied then.

So there's a copy of us, mate. It's like Len Suskin calls it a quantum Xerox

machine, I think. So he says, is it a quantum Xerox thing?

Do we get copied?

But there's a very fundamental theorem in quantum mechanics called the no

-cloning theorem, which says you can't copy a quantum state.

You can't copy the information.

And this is fundamental.

So this is a problem in quantum computing when you're trying to... So

copied.

So what's the description? So this is where we get speculative and we're

to understand what the mathematics is saying.

One description of our perspective is, yeah, we go to the singularity, we get

all scrambled up.

And then it looks like...

The interior of the black hole is in some sense the same place as the

You can almost picture wormholes opening up from the interior of the black hole

to the exterior.

And very naively, you imagine our bits of information going through the

wormholes and coming out again.

So we end up outside. The information ends up outside in the Hawking

How it gets there.

Is it really wormholes that are connecting the interior?

Is that what's happening?

There is an idea that's been around for a long time, again, due to Suskind and

others, called ER equals EPR, which is Einstein -Rosen equals Einstein

and Rosen.

So Einstein -Podolsky and Rosen, a very famous paper, was about quantum

entanglement in the 30s. They wrote this paper.

and it was it was they were very concerned about if you have these um

systems that are so -called entangled systems then you can make a measurement

this thing over here and instantly this one which might be a light year away can

will have to reconfigure itself the the classic example is a quantum coin so you

can have a quantum coin in a quantum state which can be heads tails plus

heads, let's say that, with a one over root two, whatever.

So if it's in that state, then it means that's a full description of the state,

heads, tails, plus tails, heads.

It means that if you separate these quantum coins, they could be an

right? You separate the quantum coins to a large distance, then it's still the

case that this thing is in what's called a superposition of heads and tails.

Then you make a measurement of it, you make an observation, whatever you want

describe it.

And if that one comes up head, then you know this one is tails.

Even though before you did anything to this, they were both in this rather

disentangled state, right? So that bothered everybody.

Einstein, Fidelsky and Rosen, and they said maybe there's something else going

on and whatever. But we think that's the way the world is now.

Einstein -Rosen is the paper that Einstein and Rosen wrote, noticing that

Schwarzschild description of a black hole has a wormhole in it.

It's a wormhole. So Einstein -Rosen is a wormhole.

EPR is quantum entanglement.

So there's been this idea that they're the same picture.

So you can picture quantum entanglement somehow.

As a wormhole between the two things? Linking them, yeah.

So this was an idea from a long time ago.

So the picture of a black hole is kind of similar to that in that we're

developing this picture where the interior of the black hole, when viewed

one perspective, is the exterior of the black hole when viewed from another

perspective. And so what you're getting there, we think, and again,

even as I say this, there are papers being written saying different things.

really cutting edge stuff.

But I think what everybody agrees on, pretty much, is that you're seeing

something called the holographic principle at work here.

So it's a dual description of nature.

So there's a very famous paper by Maldacena.

It's called the ADFCFT Conjecture. And I think I'm right in saying it's the most

cited paper in all of theoretical physics.

And it was a very particular model of a quantum mechanic.

on a surface.

That's what CFP, conformal field theory, it means. It's quantum capture on a

surface. And a precise proof that there's a dual description, that this

theory describes an interior geometry of space, which was not there in

the surface theory.

And the space is called an ADS space, or antidepressant space, or whatever. But

it's a perfect proof.

There's a one -to -one description between these two things.

And I think it's fair to say that the black holes, these strange apparent

paradoxes, are telling us that such a thing, our universe, can be described in

such a way.

So there are different ways of describing the same physics.

And they're radically different ways.

Ultimately, the thing is, it shouldn't be so problematic in that.

In both descriptions, the information comes out.

But the way it came out is radically different depending on your point of

And I think most people would say we're seeing glimpses of some kind of

holographic. They're called holographic, by the way, because if you think of

what does it mean to have a complete description of a higher dimensional?

think so let's let's be very concrete this room so let's say that this

is correct and many people think it is by the way for this for this room so we

have a surface surrounding the room the walls and there's a theory that lives

just there and it describes fully everything that's in the room in that

we're holograms We are both holograms because we're described by a theory that

lives on a hologram is a piece of film like that. And it has a perfect, a

perfect hologram would be a perfect 3D image would be encoded in the surface.

So it's a perfect 3D image encoded in this 2D surface.

That really is.

picture that we're talking about here. You can see it with the event horizon

all the information on the outside and the interior there and what happens. So

it looks like we're flipping between descriptions of the world. Does it feel

sometimes like that story about a one -dimensional being meeting a two

-dimensional being and trying to describe their circumstances and then

-dimensional being and that we are somehow like...

seeing the weirdness of our own experience of dimensionality and that

as you said if someone were viewing us from a higher dimension they would see

this somehow clearly and i don't really know what i'm asking no i know you i

know you it's it's kind of yeah you what we seem to be struggling with yeah is

as you said it's almost the same struggle as a two -dimensional being

understand a three -dimensional world Or actually, we do, it's three

-dimensional beings trying to understand the four -dimensional world, which is

what relativity is. We struggle with it. It's hard for us.

So this is a level of abstraction further.

I think one, I saw described, someone described the black hole. Why are we

glimpsing this deeper structure of nature when we think about black holes,

are real things?

And I saw someone say it's almost as if this thing slices through space and

leaves the building blocks of space dangling right at the horizon.

It's this strange behavior of which gravity has created this situation where

you start to come face to face with the, with what?

With the structure of space and time.

So we're talking about, as I said before, that in retrospect, the hints

there with temperature and entropy and information in space, encoded

in space. So it looks like we're starting to glimpse a theory of the

structure of space and time. So this goes by the name of emergent space

So the picture really would be that you have a description.

which looks, by the way, for all the world, like a network of qubits, which

what a quantum computer is.

So it looks like there's a description of the universe that doesn't have space

and time in it, but it's just a network.

It's just information.

And that goes all the way back to John Wheeler. We mentioned him once, the

physicist John Wheeler. He had an idea. He used to call it it from bits.

So it is this, and bits is information.

That's what it looks like we're seeing.

So our window onto this deeper theory, call it quantum gravity if you like, it

has been very simple questions actually about black holes, which are real

things. That very simple question from Stephen Hawking, that's why Hawking's

calculation is so important, because it's the first glimpse of a problem

with our picture of the world.

And it's a very, very precise glimpse.

It's a precise question.

Does this thing destroy information or not? If it doesn't, how does the

information get out?

That's a simple question, but it's led and is still leading, which is why I'm

waving my hands around a lot. You would get a different, different pictures from

any, any, you know, expert who does the calculations. I'm not one of those,

right? But if you talk to someone who does the calculations, they would, not

certain about the physical picture i think it's fair to say so is it fair to

that the specific research into black holes the specific questions that we're

asking about black holes are helping us unlock much much deeper questions about

the universe as a whole exactly it's very well put and it's wonderful and and

one of the wonderful things is that so the the techniques that you develop as a

let's say a phd student or a postdoc or someone who's working in this area the

techniques that you develop to try to understand what the black hole is doing

are the same techniques you need if you want to understand how quantum computers

work so and that's a real engineering question as well as a fundamental

question you know we're trying to build these things we haven't built one that

works in the way we want to yet but obviously google and microsoft and ibm

and others are pouring a lot of money into it because they're profoundly

powerful devices but the insights a lot of insights now

into how they might work and how we might build them is coming from this

of emergent space -time so it's the best example i know of You know, if you say

to a funding agency, I want money to work on black holes.

They go, well, fortunately, they do give us the money.

But they often would go, well, is it any use? I mean, what's the point? You

know, a black hole, does anybody care?

The lesson is that when you study nature and you go to, you try to

study things that you don't understand, that pose profound questions.

about our understanding of physics in this case, then you are, I would say,

likely to learn something useful because you're studying reality.

And this is the best example of that that I know.

Because you're studying completely collapsed stars or the things at the

of galaxies, and you're gaining insight into quantum computers and networks of

qubits and quantum information.

It's the most wonderful thing. It's incredible.

So there's one thing I should mention, a complete picture from the people who

are listening or watching and want to know more. There's a thing which is

important called the firewall paradox, as it was initially introduced.

And it hasn't been resolved yet.

And the problem is that when you disrupt space

in this way, that the black hole does.

And when you try to understand what's happening to the information and

particles that are on one side of the horizon and the other side, you know,

Hawking radiation that we discussed earlier, you do bump up against the

which is that maybe this description of the equivalence principle and of us

freely falling across the horizon from our perspective into the interior of the

black hole, maybe that...

doesn't quite stand up.

So maybe you're getting a challenge to the basis of general relativity.

Maybe it's really true that actually there isn't an interior of the black

Maybe it's really true that you don't go in. There isn't an in, right? And so

you'll see if you go and search through the literature that the firewall paradox

was that these papers were big papers in this debate.

And then some people thought they were solved and other people thought they

weren't solved.

And I think it's fair to say that the jury is still out on these issues.

But the thing to emphasize is it's really, there's something really

going on here.

And it probably, it almost certainly is associated with the nature of space and

time themselves or space -time.

It's associated with geometries of space -time, maybe wormholes, maybe those

kind of things. So it's tremendously interesting.

And you'll see, it's just wonderful to dig into this subject because it's so,

so, it develops so fast.

And our understanding is developing so fast.

But the last thing to say is it does look like there is a description of the

universe that looks like a giant quantum computer.

In some sense, which does not imply that someone built it, right? It doesn't

imply that we're in a simulation.

But it does suggest that there's a good description of reality that you can

write down in the form of some kind of network of entangled qubits, which are

presumably the Planck length inside. Maybe even that's not obvious, right?

something like that.

You know, I came into this story thinking that I was going to tell about

into a black hole and then eventually get to the cutting edge of research into

black holes and that that was going to be the end of the story. But actually

what I'm hearing you say now is that the cutting edge of research into black

holes is actually a cutting edge of research into the universe itself.

And that is just incredibly exciting.

It's really beautiful, isn't it?

They're the window, almost like the Rosetta Stones.

They're allowing us to translate between different pictures of the universe.

All right. So that's probably where we end.

If I rewind for a second, one of my questions to just connect things that I

about the universe, maybe, is what is the relationship, we think, between the

singularity at the center of a black hole and the point that Big Banged?

Oh, so...

It's a very good question.

So the singularity inside a black hole in Einstein's theory is the end of time.

And in Einstein's theory alone of the evolution of the universe, there is

another singularity at the other end of time, which is the Big Bang singularity,

which you might call, you might be tempted to call the beginning of time.

It's a very different singularity.

Black holes are...

maximally scrambled information, the highest entropy things we know of in the

universe. And one of the great mysteries about the origin of the universe is

it's a very low entropy state.

Broadly speaking, if you want to know more about that, Sean Carroll actually

writes a lot about this. There's a lot of interesting stuff to say.

But it's a different kind of singularity.

And so, are they related?

is the question i would say yeah our understanding of them surely is um and

but but it's really not clear and when you add quantum mechanics in then you

begin to ask questions about whether the big bang thing if there is such a thing

as a singularity in the past is it what is it at the beginning of time there's a

thing called a no boundary idea that hawking and others had and Again, all

are off, right? But I think it would be good.

I think it would be good. It is correct to say that I'm sure the understanding

of the two is related, but we understand neither at the moment. I'm

sure that I am garbling fragments of understanding from things that you have

explained. But does it feel related at all that there is...

The hologram principle, the hologram paradox that you described, that we can

described as two -dimensional, that there can be a two -dimensional kind of

description of a huge amount of mass, three -dimensional mass that fell into a

black hole, and that we cannot... Is it possible that we are all living on

the outside of a black hole?

right now what is the question i'm trying to ask no i think i it's a great

question i i think there is a question so there is a cosmological horizon there

are different kinds of cosmological horizons and it is a very good question

but people don't really even know how to phrase it that but could it be that you

can describe the whole universe in terms of a quantum theory living on a

boundary of some description.

And I think the guess is yes, the guess.

But we don't even know what we mean by the boundary.

It's one of the problems here. So the reason that Maldacena was able

to show this work for this very specific thing called ADS space is

because there's a boundary you can identify in that particular.

whereas our universe is digital.

It's not obvious what you mean by a boundary.

It's not really obvious what question.

As you said, it's hard to find the words. We don't really know what

we're asking. But that rough picture that there could be a theory,

a quantum theory somehow, this network of qubits that gives rise to

geometry, space.

is accepted broadly.

But when you try to get into the detail of it, it's only been fully realized for

a very specific model, which is kind of a toy model. It's not our universe. So

it could be that our universe does not admit that description.

Could be. But it's certainly beyond us at the moment, technically.

But it's a wonderful thought.

And actually, there's a paper recently.

So people are beginning to use the Google chip, the Willow chip, which is a

powerful, it's not a quantum computer, it's a proto -quantum computer kind of

thing. And people have started to use it because what it is, is a load of qubits

that you can entangle and you can set it up and it's very well controlled.

So whilst we don't know how to do quantum calculations on the thing,

what you can do is try to say, well, Could I set them up so that it's like

emerges from them? And there was a paper recently where something that was

described in the paper as a one -dimensional wormhole was made.

It wouldn't be in our university thing, but it kind of emerged from this

structure. And that's the kind of picture we're trying to get to.

It's a good paper. It's been peer -reviewed. It's a controversial paper.

see loads of stuff online.

But it's worth looking at those papers. And by the time this is sent out, there

might be some other papers. A lot of people are working on it.

So on also actually building little clocks, little quantum clocks, tiny

because we don't even know what a clock is, right, at the most fundamental

level, because we don't know what time is.

So we're talking about very fundamental questions about reality.

in this research but it all came from these that right which is how cool is

it came from thinking about those things it's so cool and thank you for taking

that question so seriously it's a great question and i think it's really

instructive that um neither of us because nobody has the language

when you get into the real detail you're talking about mathematics ultimately

And even the mathematics is not complete.

So we're talking about research at the cutting edge.

And it takes a long time.

I mean, even quantum mechanics, you think about quantum mechanics, if we

talking about quantum mechanics, this is a hundred year old theory that's very

well tested and very well understood.

But when you try to put it into language to speak about it, it's much easier to

write down the equations or something. I mean, even Feynman.

says that in the Feynman lectures, when he's talking about this thing called the

double slit experiment, it's a great description of the way quantum mechanics

behaves. But ultimately, Feynman says, you know, mathematically, it's the

easiest. I can just write down one line which tells you how this interference

works and all those things.

But then if you try to say, well, what does it mean? What happens? What does it

mean for our picture of reality?

Then we're still arguing about that now.

But the math is easy.

Literally worse because here the math is really difficult and we have no idea

what it's telling us really about reality.

One of the things that I really admire about you and your work is that you have

this sense of wonder at the universe.

And I think that the thing I've most appreciated about it, and I'm sure I

for a lot of people, is that you give that sense of wonder back to people.

You say, hey, don't you remember what it was like when you were a little kid

looking up at the sky? And actually, in fact, as you learn more about the

universe, that sense of wonder can increase, not decrease.

Yeah. And I think that's really special. And I think that people need that.

And first, I just wanted to say thank you.

Thank you. And second, my last question for you is, how do you

feel when you go outside and look up at the night sky, given what you

know? Oh, it's a wonderful question.

And you kind of alluded to it earlier that the

sense of awe and the sense of mystery and beauty

increases the more you know about what you're looking at. It doesn't decrease.

The mysteries, the number of mysteries increases the more you look at it. And

is incomprehensible.

The Milky Way. So it's a beautiful thing to look at. So anybody watching this,

if it's a clear night and you're away from the city lights, you can go out.

We've all looked at the Milky Way at some point.

Even that, if you try and picture what it is, and you learn that it's a galaxy

of, what, 200 billion, maybe 400 billion suns.

What does that mean?

200 billion suns.

Most of them have planets.

So it'll be trillions of planets.

It takes light 100 ,000 years to cross that thing.

None of that is, I think, you can't internalize even that.

And that's kind of a simple thing because it's just a galaxy and we know

galaxies. And then you talk about, as we've talked about, the center of that

galaxy lies this thing, the supermassive black hole.

And then we don't know. We don't know what that thing is. You can look towards

it. So you can look towards Sagittarius.

The further south you are, the easier it'll be to look at. But you can look in

the direction of the centre of the galaxy.

So you can go out, if you're not too far north, and look at that.

You can look at it with your eyes and wonder about it.

So that's what I really believe. I know Richard Feynman said it many years ago,

and many other people have said it, but the more...

you understand about nature, the more mysterious and magical it becomes.

It's a beautiful place, Ben. Thank you so much for your time.

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.