Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Spanish (Latin American)
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
Here's Einstein predicting gravitational waves, laying the foundation for a
laser, and 100 years later, his gravitational waves are found with
Einstein was kind of smart from the time I first started working on
gravitational waves until we succeeded with 50 years.
Some things take a long time. We do build on each other. None of them by
themselves are smart enough.
This Nobel Prize really belongs to a thousand people.
If I can see farther than others, it's because I've stood on the shoulders of
giants who have come before me. And that's the nature of science.
It's very promising, but it's going to continue on into the next generation
before the ultimate success is had very, very, very probably.
This is StarTalk.
I'm your host, Neil deGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist. And today,
we're featuring one of our one -on -one conversations.
This time with Professor of Theoretical Physics, Kip Thorne. Kip Thorne, welcome
to StarTalk.
Pleasure to be with you, Neil. Oh my gosh, we are coming from your home
in Pasadena, California.
son designed this part of the house and built it, and my brother designed and
built all the furniture.
These are really useful people to have in the family.
It's a wonderful family to be in.
They're the practical ones.
I've actually known you for some time, not that we were beer drinking buddies,
but... I think we've drunk beers together in the Canary Islands. Yes, we
Okay, okay.
I stand corrected.
But... My first exposure to you was you were one of the three authors of this
book called Gravitation.
And we used to joke, of course, it was the only book where you learned about it
just by carrying it around.
And I think we probably wrote it before you were born.
Possibly. Possibly.
Although I'm older than you might think.
This book is a graduate level treatise on basically Einstein's general.
Theory of relativity.
At the time I acquired the paperback of it, which this is, it's tough making a
paperback this thick, but this has the exact proportions of what was then the
Manhattan Yellow Page.
So we used to call it the phone book. Yes.
Just affectionately, may I add. It was brilliantly conceived because I don't
know if you can notice on camera, there are tabs are different.
The color is white and black.
And they represent two different paths through the book.
One is sort of the elementary path and one the more advanced path, except it
looked advanced to me at the time. So whose idea was this to come up with this
book? Coming up with the book, I think it was sort of grew out of discussions
that Charlie Misner, John Wheeler, my PhD advisor, and I had.
A few years after I got my PhD. Those are the three co -authors there. Those
the three co -authors. And so it sort of grew organically.
That's the best kind of projects they have. In the 1960s and early 1970s.
Yes, I was born before the 60s.
Oh, really?
So on here is Charlie Misner, who was at the University of Maryland.
Yes. And so my copy of this, I had you sign it.
And then I spent a year teaching at the University of Maryland. So I quickly
went over to his office and had him sign it. But before then, I started out in
graduate school at the University of Texas where John Archibald Wheeler had,
they stole him from Princeton, I think is what that, or lured him from
Princeton, I think. Yeah, that's inaccurate.
And so I had all three of them sign it. In fact, John Wheeler's.
course that he taught in general relativity is where I met my wife.
Wow. She has a PhD in mathematical physics. So we met in relativity class.
thought I'd say that.
Very romantic place to meet.
Very romantic.
Very romantic.
And John Wheeler used to give out a penny if you caught an error that he
committed on the front board. So I have one of his pennies.
I don't remember.
It was not a big day. It was like.
It was a typo or something, the written version of a typo.
So anyhow,
it's just a delight to meet again with you.
And what prompted this was our, you know, you have a lot of
accolades, of course, including the Nobel Prize.
Okay. But more importantly than that, you were science advisor on the film
Interstellar. Well, I was more than science advisor. Yes, you were. You were
executive producer.
I was more than executive producer. It grew out of a treatment that Linda Ope's
an ex -girlfriend of mine. Oh, Linda Ope's a big producer of sci -fi films.
Yeah, a big producer of films of a wide variety. But Linda and I dated in 1979,
80.
She was too high strung for me and I was too nerdy for her, but we became close
friends. Wow.
Who knows this? Why didn't I know this?
No, stop.
Where would one learn this?
We need a physicist gossip column. Is that right? It was some years later
Carl Sagan, who set us up on a blind date, by the way, we met. Okay.
Some years later.
And Linda called me up and said, would you like to brainstorm with me for a
movie? Wow.
And we did. And that's how Interstellar was born.
So was that at the time? It really was the creation of the Nolan brothers
because they took what we had given them, which was basically a structure
a venue for the movie, the warped side of the universe.
And they ran with it and changed our story almost completely.
And made it into a great film.
All the seeds came out of Linda and me.
At the time, I mean, you're a professor at Caltech, the Richard Feynman
professor at Caltech, now emeritus.
Caltech is a pretty high -level place.
How was it viewed for you to say, guys, hold on, I'm going to make a movie now?
How is that received by your colleagues?
I think they were all enthusiastic.
Caltech is a different kind of a place than some other more stuffy university.
Oh, okay. Okay. I never hung out much at Caltech. I couldn't judge the mood or
the tone.
Yeah. No, look, we're on the edge of Hollywood.
The Hollywood folks come over and, you know, Big Bang Theory was based on
Caltech. Right. They didn't call it Caltech. What did they call it? They did
call it Caltech in the first few.
Okay. And then they stopped using the Caltech name because the shirts, that's
Hollywood speak for the attorneys.
Oh, yeah, the stiff shirts, yeah, up in the office. The shirts got scared that
they might do something on screen that the Caltech shirts wouldn't like and the
Caltech shirts might sue the Hollywood shirts. Okay. And so they stopped using
Caltech name. And in the film, which I adored.
What was it called? Real Genius?
Yeah. Real Genius. They were at Pacific Tech, all right? That was where all the
smart kids were.
So, of course, Pasadena is in, like, I can't say foothills of Hollywood, but
have a proximal awareness of this huge industry.
Yeah. And you know that science fiction matters as a genre.
Well, and some of us love it.
I love it. I sign up every time.
Interstellar, I think it introduced many people to authentic gravitational
physics for the very first time.
Well, Interstellar was unlike almost any other film. I think there were
precursors in 2001 and in Contact.
Yeah, Carl Sagan's Contact.
Carl Sagan's Contact.
And the point is that science...
Lots of science was baked into that film from the very beginning because of the
way it was born and because of the close, close collaboration I had with
Nolan brothers.
And built in right from the very beginning.
Baked in.
Baked in. And a science in which the guideline that we worked from is
that nothing in the movie would violate well -established physical laws and all
the wild things would at least spring.
from science in some manner.
As any good science fiction story should be, but there's not enough.
Well, there's nothing wrong with fantasy films, the Harry Potter style, for
example. It's just a different genre.
By the way, that film, you...
You must have known. You said, okay, we're going to have to help people out.
Give a guy a break, okay?
They're trying to see the movie. They're trying to follow what's going on. What
the hell is happening?
Why did the guy get old?
Why is he younger than his mother? What's going on?
And you upped and said, let's help a person out. Yeah, well, I would put it a
little differently.
I saw it as a superb opportunity to use this film as a motivator
interested or intrigued in science.
And then there would be a bridge to the science through this book. Admit it, you
created a gateway film. It was a gateway film, yes. So The Science of
Interstellar, New York Times bestseller, Kip Thorne, with a foreword written by,
of course, Christopher Nolan.
And spoiler alert, this book explains the fantastic climax and ending
of Interstellar. And so let me tell you how this issue came about.
Chris said to me early on, I would like to make a film where the ending is as
mysterious as the ending of 2001, Space Odyssey.
That's a high bar.
That's a high bar. But he greatly admires Stanley Kubrick and that film.
And so somewhat later on, as we were talking about the ending and we had lots
conversations about the ending, he said, well, you can explain the ending in
this book that you're.
planning to write.
So he volunteered you to write the book.
Well, no, I was already planning to write the book, but he identified that
the place where the ending will get explained. He was not going to explain
ending. He would leave it mysterious. Not in this film. He was pulling a
on us. That's right.
In fact, we interviewed Christopher Nolan. If you're an archive diver, we've
a whole episode with Christopher Nolan, even before Interstellar was...
And as we know, so many of his movies he plays with time in some kind of
interesting way. If I remember correctly, he talks about how
Space Odyssey was to him back in 1968.
That would have been.
So let me ask you just a couple of things about the storyline.
And I have an issue with it, if I may.
I don't know if I ever went public on this, but I figure...
I'm in front of the man himself, so if I have an issue, it would be here and
now. You're going to get turned into a journalist who's challenging me? I don't
know. Going to give me a tough time? Yeah.
This can't be just all, okay, softball. Let's play a little hardball.
So I guess my issue, we're looking for a planet.
Again, this is in the themes of the movie.
We're looking for a planet like Earth, similar enough to Earth, That we can
people there to continue our civilization and our species.
Is that a fair characterization of a plot line? The plot line. Okay. And it
turns out there's like a wormhole that can make that happen a little faster.
Because otherwise you don't live long enough to travel the distances with the
rockets available to hit those destinations. Okay.
I'm just thinking, this blight on the crops.
that was starving everyone on Earth, requiring that we jump ship, literally
ship to go find another ship, another spaceship planet.
It seems to me that whatever effort it takes to find another Earth, travel
through a wormhole, ship a billion, terraform it, ship a billion people
whatever that effort is, seems to me to be a bigger effort.
than just telling the biologists, come up with a serum that could fix the
Even today, we have full knowledge of crop genomes. Just fix it.
Whatever it is, just go in there, nip -tuck the DNA, fix it.
Isn't that cheaper, easier, faster than wormholing your way off this planet?
That's where I'm coming from.
So you think that all problems can be solved by humans with human technology
a time scale?
You have such faith in humans.
Come on. So I'm the optimist here. Okay, so let me describe.
This characterizes how this movie was done.
So when it was Jonah Nolan, Chris's brother, who came up with the idea that
wanted a blight or something like that.
And so we said, okay, we will bring together.
The best biologists we can, who are experts on these kinds of things, put
together, mostly Caltech biologists, and
we had a dinner, and we brought out very expensive wine for them to drink, and
we set up a recording.
In vino veritas, okay? In truth, there is wine. In wine, there is truth, yes.
And so we...
I had a conversation that lasted about three or four hours at the Caltech
Faculty Club, the Athenaeum, about what would be the best backstory here. There
are two types of blights.
There are generalized blights that attack lots of crops.
Lots of different species of crops. Lots of different species of crops.
But they are generally fairly benign blights. And then there are...
Blights that are very specific to a particular crop, and they can be very
blights that may totally wipe out that species on Earth even. But basically for
Earth and life on Earth to survive, you better not have a vicious generalized
blight.
But according to the biologists that I discussed this with, they didn't know of
anything that would prevent the development.
of a very vicious generalized blight.
So that's what occurs in this movie. And it's something that biologists have
never seen, but they cannot rule it out.
Okay, so let me repeat what I think you said. They have vicious lethal blights
that attack a species, less lethal generalized blights that cross species
boundaries, and they can't rule out a lethal...
that would cross species.
That's right. And so that's what's happening in this film.
That's what's happening in the film. Okay. And that's what they just,
biologists, are on Earth in the back.
Okay, I'll give you that. Okay. Okay, so anyway, this film is full of
backstories because of the way we did it. As I say again, it's unlike almost
other film in that these issues were...
Like that. We're vetted. We're vetted by the world's best experts in the process
of the writing of the screenplay.
Okay. As we're diving into Kip Thorne's impressive work, one thing is clear.
His theories have reshaped our understanding of the universe.
So you might think the latest Nobel Prize for physics would go to someone
Thorne, but it went to computer scientists instead.
Their contributions to machine learning is... undeniable, but still a surprise
for the world of physics.
Some reports focus on the godfather of AI regretting his invention, while
don't exactly see the problem.
In moments like this, access to diverse perspectives is critical, making ground
news essential.
They're a platform created by a former NASA engineer who saw a bigger problem
down here on Earth than up in space.
and the way we consume information and how heavily that shapes our world views.
Ground News responsibly uses technology to add clarity to a world full of
opposing opinions by showing perspectives from around the world, how
sources and blind spots so you can see important stories barely receiving
attention. Here's why that matters.
Critical thinking drives the pursuit of understanding complex concepts. It
challenges established beliefs, and it's the only way we can make new
discoveries. So for those of us who are curious enough to dive into new
perspectives, now is the perfect time to give Ground News a try. Take advantage
of their massive 50 % discount on their top -tier Vantage plan and get access to
every feature we've shown and more.
for only a limited time. Use our link at ground .news .com or scan the QR code
to subscribe.
As we continue exploring Kip Thorne's groundbreaking theories, remember,
News can bring that same level of critical thinking to how you stay
Now, back to the show.
Well, I got another one.
Okay, you're one for one. All right. When they're on the black hole planet.
Okay? And then they see this wave coming.
Okay, it's Miller's planet. Miller's planet, sorry. That's the water planet.
planet orbiting gargantuan.
Gargantua. Okay?
The strength of tidal forces are highly sensitive to the distance you are to
that which is causing the tides.
Highly sensitive.
Okay? But every illustration I've drawn or taught about tides, they're not so
peaky. They're much...
broader in their representation on a planet.
And so there they are, wading in water, but then they see this
single wave come. And if it is a single wave, as we've seen with tsunamis, it
actually takes water away from what's ahead of it.
Because it can't just be water out of nowhere. It's drawing water from its
vicinity. So my two issues was, if it's tidal, would it be that peaky?
And if it's any kind of wave, how could it still leave the water laying around
its vicinity and then just be that big as it came by?
There is a type of wave called a solitary wave on water.
You could tell me you brought wave people together and had that lunch.
No.
This particular kind of wave was discovered in the 1700s by, I've
who, a...
physicist in England who saw a boat that was being pulled by horses.
And it was just starting up. And it created this wave that traveled down a
channel, a canal.
And it was peaked like the wave in Interstellar. Though the wave in
Interstellar, I have to admit, it was exaggerated.
I don't mind exaggeration. There was some exaggeration in the peak. But it
traveled down the channel. It never broke.
Most waves at the ocean, they break.
Okay, just so we can get the picture because we're talking about centuries
When you say a channel, that would be a channel or a canal.
A canal. And then there's a towpath on the side. And then people and more
beasts of burden would drag things through the canal. Because they
don't typically have current. Drag a barge down the canal. A barge, exactly.
And so this barge was dragged down the canal.
And it was just starting up and it created this wave.
On the startup.
On the startup. And it just headed out and just took off and went down the
channel. And this guy got on his horse and he followed down the channel.
You've got to love curious physics.
Nothing gets by. And it went down the channel for, I don't know, a mile or two
without changing its shape, without breaking. Without breaking.
And so the theory of these waves is that
there are two different effects that cause a wave to steepen or
disperse, and the two can balance each other out in a stable sort of a way. And
give it longer life. And give it long life.
Aside from the issue of friction, if there were no friction, it would just
forever and keep propagating in a very stable way.
There's a mathematics behind it, something called the Cordevec -DeVries
that this is a solution of. But anyway, these waves then... So that equation,
I presume, has both kinds of waves in equilibrium somehow represented as a
static wave. The dispersion...
And the steepening. The steepening is due to nonlinearities. The dispersion is
due to the fact that the higher parts of the water travel faster than the lower
parts of the water.
I didn't know that.
Up here at the ocean, you see a little tiny wave. It travels quite slowly. You
see a big wave. It travels quite fast.
And that's why the crest of the wave will actually break before the rest of
wave gets there. Yeah, that's right. Is that part of the reason? That's right.
Unless that's being balanced out.
Cool. By dispersion, which is – Cool.
Anyway. I love it. No, it's good. Good. No, I'm loving it. I'm getting this
slightly confused. But anyway, the two effects balance each other to produce
this very stable solitary wave.
And so in the movie – but for this stable solitary wave, the height of the
is – and I've forgotten the number, but it's something like six times higher
than the depth of the water. Got it.
So there's a problem now in the movie because they're walking around in
water, and this wave is high, and so it's got to be deep water.
Okay. But they're on an island.
This is the back story. Again, there's always a back story. So they're on a
subterranean, a subsurface island. You've got to read it in my book. Okay.
They're on an island.
They're on an island, and this wave diffracts around the island. They hardly
notice the island at all.
So, again, it's all explainable, except there is a bit of exaggeration.
The CTI wave was made somewhat more
peaked. We'll give you that.
It's a movie, and it's Hollywood.
What you're saying is this wave might have been caused by some effect other
the tidal forces of the black hole. Yeah, well, this wave is caused, in
the fact that time has much slowed on this planet. So the
planet has been put into the orbit around Gargantua not that long ago as
the planet, though it's a long, long time ago as seen from far away.
It's like Mercury, like the moon keeps one face toward Earth or Mercury keeps
one face toward the sun due to tidal effects.
This planet is distorted by tidal effects and it's swinging back and
has not yet settled down to one face toward the planet. And that swinging
and forth is generating this wave.
It's all in the book. He weaseled out of another one. Okay.
There's an enormous amount of science in that book.
I must admit that when I went through the book. And one last point. You didn't
study it carefully enough.
One last point. We took our show to Oxford recently, and I
interviewed at Oxford, I think it was a postdoc, and his name was Andrew
Mummery.
And he showed us a recent paper he published. I don't know if you've seen
recently, like within the past 18 months.
And he's a theoretical physicist.
And he alerted me to something I'd never knew.
I love the field, but it's not my active professional field. That in the
vicinity of a black hole, there is an innermost orbit.
Because, of course, you can orbit any source of gravity, even if it's a black
hole.
For black holes in particular, there's an orbit within which the orbit is no
longer stable and it will spiral into the black hole itself. And according to
his calculation, to get the time dilation necessary in the scene with the
hole planet, which was huge. Remember, they were on the planet for like 15
minutes or whatever. One hour on the planet is seven years.
Seven years up in their spaceship, okay?
And the guy where they left there, he's like gray and unshaven and everything.
And we're like, oh my gosh, there's some serious Einsteinian physics going on
here. His calculations show that for that difference, for that extreme
difference in time dilation, requires that planet orbit so close to the black
hole there would be in the unstable zone.
And so I just thought I'd... Tell you that.
My calculation says otherwise.
And where's his Nobel Prize? The other guy's? The formula is in the book.
In this book? Yeah. So we don't have to go to your graduate textbook for that?
Well, not for the answer. Okay.
If you want to derive the formula, that's a lot of work.
So let me tell you the story behind this. Oh, so everyone's got a story.
Christopher Nolan says to me one day, he says, I want the hero in
Cooper, the hero in this movie, to go down onto this planet.
Cooper played by Matthew McConaughey. That's right.
Professor Brand's daughter is played by Jessica Chastain.
Christopher Nolan says to me, he says, I want in this movie that one hour on
Miller's planet is seven years.
up at very high orbit or back on Earth.
He prescribed that?
Yes, and I said to him, that's impossible because the planet will fall
black hole.
He said, go do a real calculation. I've already learned that your off -the -cuff
reactions can be wrong, and I should not trust you unless you do a real
calculation. There's a good Hollywood producer.
Go back and give me the answer I'm looking for.
Well, and so I went back home, and I did a real calculation, and I was amazed.
that the last stable circular orbit, which is what we're talking about, is
if the planet spins fast enough, the last circular stable orbit can
have as high a redshift, as high a time difference
as you might wish.
It requires that this black hole spin extremely close to the maximum
possible spin.
And so in the book, I give the formula for what is the spin of the black hole
that is required to produce a given amount of slowing of time. I did not
that. And so it's an approximate formula. But it's a formula that can be
derived.
Or a bit of algebra. Okay, so the one one would just learn about would
be the lowest stable orbit around a non -rotating black hole. That's right. And
that's a clean... That's a clean problem.
Clean problem. That's what I was thinking when I said I want this. When I
that if I made the black hole spin, that it would get closer, but I couldn't
imagine. I could not imagine that nature would provide it an
orbit.
For a black hole, it spins fast enough that it can provide this much of a
slowing of time. But it does. It does. At least, unless I made a mathematical
error. But I don't think that's likely because I use Mathematica.
Okay. You had tools to help you do this.
To check my calculations. Because it's not just an analytic solution.
Well, it is an analytic solution.
But it's very complicated. But it's very complicated.
Okay. Well, it's a power series solution.
In the end.
I think our hero character is inside the black hole. We come to understand this.
And he has access to a timeline that wouldn't otherwise be available to him.
he sees his daughter's bookshelf.
Well, he's no longer inside the black hole.
Where is he when he's doing this? So this is the key thing that's not
that you only understand if you read my book.
You didn't read it well enough.
Busted. No, I read a lot of it. I read some of the biology. And it was a long
time ago, too. Yes, okay.
So when he gets inside the black hole, he is scooped up
by a spacecraft that was built by this advanced
civilization that provided the wormhole to him and to humanity.
And it's called the Tesseract.
And the Tesseract is a four -dimensional cube, four spatial dimensions. And
that's why in there you saw, I guess, the past and future all kind of
simultaneously. It felt very higher dimensional.
Yeah, that's right. So the Tesseract, so let me back up. I'll tell you a story.
So early on when we were working on the film,
And Christopher Nolan said to me he wanted to take his hero
back to Earth, Cooper back to Earth, by a different route than the wormhole, 10
billion light years away from the Earth. How's he going to do it if it doesn't
go through a wormhole?
He said, well, I want to take him back faster than the speed of light.
And, of course, I say to Chris.
You can't do that. It violates the laws of physics. He says, go do a real
calculation.
I said, I don't have to do a real calculation.
And so we discussed this for a week. And then he threw in the towel. He said,
okay, I believe you.
And so what do we do? And so I said, well, you put him, he goes inside the
hole.
He gets deposited on the three -dimensional surface of a four
sphere. And this four -dimensional sphere,
is a spacecraft that can go into the bulk, into the higher dimension.
And it goes out of the black hole, not through the horizon. It can't do that.
goes up through the fourth dimension. Up through the fourth space dimension, or
what's called the fifth dimension in the movie. Time is the fourth dimension.
And goes back to Earth. And the distance back to the Earth is less than the
distance between the Earth and the sun.
Even though it's 10 billion light years inside of our universe.
Up in the bulk, it's a very short distance. And so he can get back very
This is the higher dimensional space -time in which we are now having this
event. So he gets back very quickly, riding on the surface of this four
-dimensional sphere. He said, I like it all entirely, except I'm going to use a
four -dimensional cube instead of a four -dimensional sphere. That's a
tesseract. Yes. And so that's what happens.
And when you see Cooper out there sort of...
Flailing around at the beginning of the Tesseract scene.
He's being carried by the Tesseract back to Earth. But you don't know that's
what's happening until you read my book. By agreement between Chris and me.
That's the only way anyone's ever going to know. So anyway, he's carried back to
Earth. And then everything is happening when the Tesseract is docked in the
higher dimension.
Giving access to his life.
In that past time. That's right. So it's docked in his home in his daughter's
bedroom. Okay, so now he's pushing books off the shelves that land
on the floor, and through some clever cryptographic judgment, he's spelling
words with the first letter of the title of each book.
Okay, here's my issue.
I had no problems with Tesseract, Black Hole.
Fourth dimension, five dimensions.
How does he know the title of each book from the other
side of the book?
Well, I don't remember. That's how he's actually.
He's pushing books. I know he's pushing. I know he's pushing books out from this
side. Yeah. Yeah. And all he sees is the other side of the library. I guess I
had forgotten that he was spelling things out based on.
The first word.
Oh, you forgot.
I forgot or I didn't know.
Or you're wrong.
So that was one of my issues there.
That one, I don't know.
Oh, okay.
Okay. I don't know. Okay. So you're three for four.
He probably has a photographic memory. A photographic memory of the other side
of the book. Yeah.
What's this I hear?
that you can use a wormhole to travel backwards in time. Does the math check
out? Does the Einsteinian physics check out? And does that mean I will just show
up a younger version of myself and shake my own hand? Is that what you mean by
that? Or do I no longer exist in the time that I left for my younger version
myself to see that?
And wasn't there, didn't Hawking put forth a...
time travel prevention conjecture or something?
What's going on there?
So this is all an outgrowth of my phone conversation with Carl Sagan
when he was working on the novel for Contact,
where he triggered me to start thinking about wormholes.
And then having started to think about wormholes, it became pretty obvious to
rather quickly that if I give my wife, Sarah Lee,
one mouth of a wormhole, and she carries it at high speed in a rocket ship out
into space and then back, and I keep the other mouth at home.
If she sees me age by 50 years back on Earth, well, she ages only one year
out and coming back.
But if we look through the wormhole at each other, we see each other aging at
the same rate.
Just imagine we hold hands and we look at each other's wristwatches. They're
ticking away at the same rate. So through the wormhole, we've aged at the
rate. We're the same age.
But looking through outside the wormhole. Through a normal universe.
She's aged one year and I'm aged 50 years. Something weird has happened. The
wormhole has become a time machine.
If I just go over and go into her mouth, wormhole mouth, and come out, I'll meet
my younger self.
Okay, now Hawking said, no, we're not going to allow this. There's some
conjecture.
yet to be discovered, that'll tell you you can't do that. Well, so we get
You're going too fast. I'm going too fast. Sorry.
So then I talked to friends at the University of Chicago.
It's crucial to talk to friends.
They tell you where you're all at. They tell you when you made a mistake.
They straighten you out. And they pointed out to me that...
It might be that when the time machine is turned on, it'll self -destruct,
basically, they said.
I said, I don't understand.
They said, go do a calculation. So I went and did a calculation.
And the issue is, and they had guessed, and basically, it's
oversimplified, but Bob Garoach and Robert Wald at Chicago.
Anyway, it turns out that...
At the moment that you can first time travel, the first thing that goes
it can be vacuum fluctuations of light, say, that enter her mouth or the
wormhole, come out of my mouth and go back and arrive back at her mouth at the
very moment they started out. Now you have twice as much at the same place in
space and time.
So this is a runaway.
So it's a runaway.
You now have twice as much, and then it goes around again. Now you have four
times as much. It goes around again. So this runaway builds up.
Just like the feedback between a microphone and a speaker.
Precisely. And it just runs away. It just runs away. It runs away. And this
runaway shows up in the quantum mechanical calculation that I did.
You're bumming me out. Together with Sung Won Kim, a Korean postdoc of mine.
Okay, I want to be a movie director and say, go home and figure out how to do
this.
Pull another rabbit out of the hat here.
Well, anyway, we discovered this.
Stephen, I think, and one of his, Stephen Hawking, and a student of his, I
think, had more or less the same discovery at the same time.
Except Stephen probably just did it all in his head.
That's the way Stephen is.
Anyway, so.
And then Stephen and I started corresponding about it by email and
the phone about it and so forth. It appeared to me, looking at the details
the calculation, that in fact the explosion, if I designed the time
right, the details of the explosion would not be strong enough to destroy
wormhole.
And Stephen then showed me that I was wrong.
And we argued back and forth for a while. Finally, we came to agree that
explosion becomes strong enough that quantum gravity enters in and then holds
the answer tightly in its grip.
And so we won't know whether the time machine self -destructs until we
understand the laws of quantum gravity. So let me be fun and obscure here. But
then we come to the Hawking.
Cosmic censorship conjecture. That's what it's called.
Yeah. The conjecture that, in fact, in the end, the laws
of quantum gravity won't save the day. The wormhole will be destroyed.
And any time machine that any advanced civilization makes will be destroyed
they try to turn it on by these vacuum fluctuations.
And thereby, as Hawking says, Keeping the universe safe for historians of all
species.
It reminds me of the ultraviolet catastrophe where you run the
is going to blow up. How does this even work? And then out comes the discovery
of the quantum, which saves the day.
Right. And this is, it could be a calculation waiting for another branch
physics to open or another progress in the known branches of physics to
The LIGO team has, has perfected a technique called quantum precision
measurement, which is based on manipulating vacuum fluctuations in
circumvent the uncertainty principle.
And so this business of manipulating vacuum fluctuations is something we do
modern physics.
If memory serves, Carl Sagan came up to you and said, for contact, I want to go
far distances quickly.
How am I going to do it? Can you cook up a wormhole for me?
Carl phoned me back in the 80s.
When he's writing the novel, because obviously the novel predated the movie.
That's right.
And he said that he wanted, that he has written, he'd already
written the book, the novel.
It was already in page proof.
And he said, I've got this novel. It's in page proof. The publisher's not going
to be happy if I change it, but I really need some help to see what the truth
is, and then we'll figure out how to deal with this.
And he said that I have my heroine traveling through a black
hole to get to the Star Vega.
And I said, that's...
Rather dangerous.
There's a singularity in there.
There's a singularity in there and you can't get through to the Star Vega.
So what you actually need is a wormhole.
But there is an issue that wormholes implode. They collapse so quick that
nothing can get through.
But I'll see if I can figure out how to hold a wormhole open just for you, Carl.
And so I was going with – It's like rent -a -physicist.
It's like whatever your needs are. So I was getting in a car that morning to
ride with my former wife to our daughter's graduation up at Santa Cruz.
And so Linda said, I'll drive and you calculate.
Okay. So she drove and I calculated and I fiddled around and then it became
fairly obvious.
Turns out some other physicists figured this out sooner, but that's the usual
thing with me.
I figure it out, and then I go see if people know this before or not.
So anyway, I figured out that if you had what I
like to call exotic matter that repels gravitationally, and you put it inside
the throat of a wormhole, that can hold the wormhole open. It would be like
pushing it.
Yeah, that's right. It basically repels the walls of wormhole to hold them open.
And it turns out that that will do it. But you have to have
enough exotic matter to hold the wormhole open. And I
deduced a formula for how much you had to have. And it basically says the
following.
If you move through the wormhole... Let the record show he's about to describe.
How to make a wormhole. No, no. Only how much you thought it mattered.
That sounds like a recipe to me.
So you travel through the wormhole as close to the speed of light as you
possibly can.
Just as close to the speed of light.
And you add up all the energy density
all the way through the wormhole of stuff that's in the wormhole.
The net has to be negative, and then you can hold the wormhole open. So it
basically means you've got more negative energy in there than positive energy.
We have nothing known as exotic matter.
Oh, yes, we do.
What? Yeah.
Oh, is this in your basement?
What?
What do you mean, oh, yes, we do?
Okay, what?
What is our exotic matter that would fulfill this purpose?
Should we turn off the camera now?
Is the government going to show up in your driveway?
Okay, go.
Men in black. I learned about this from Yakov Borisovich Zeldovich in Moscow.
Zeldovich. Zeldovich was one of the inventors of the Russian hydrogen bomb.
Okay. And I learned this from him. All right. He was really brilliant. I
about vacuum fluctuation.
And how important they can be and how powerful it can be if you can manipulate
them.
And so if you take a box and you remove everything that can possibly
be removed from the box, you're left in the end with tiny
fluctuations of everything that possibly could have been in the box.
So electric fields.
You have fluctuating electric fields, fluctuating magnetic fields, fluctuating
protons, electrons, fluctuating Neal Tysons across Tysons.
So this creates a form of pressure inside the box? Well, so there's
pressure and not vanishing energy due to renormalization.
Now that's a nasty word in physics.
You can measure energy by whether it produces gravity or not.
And although these fluctuations that are there, you can think of them as
particles, say particles of light, flashing in and out of existence
why is this not... The virtual particles that people speak of.
So it's virtual particles.
It is that. Okay. We've spoken about those on our show before. Okay. So you
virtual particles. With Brian Greene, in fact. So you have virtual particles in
the vacuum. Popping in and out of existence.
Popping in and out. And you can't stop it. You can't prevent it.
However, you can take fluctuations from one region and borrow them and put them
in another adjacent region for a little while.
Or if you put an electrically conducting sheet, say a sheet of
superconducting metal here, then that will suppress the fluctuating
electric fields parallel to the metal because they would create an infinite
current flowing in that metal. And that would wipe out the
electric field parallel to the metal.
Is that the effect?
An element of the Casimir effect? Yes, that's the Casimir effect. It is, yeah,
where you have two parallel plates evacuated between them. That's right.
there's a point where they actually feel a whole other force attracting them.
And so what that force really is, is in the region between them, the
vacuum fluctuations are suppressed.
And so you have negative energy in between.
That negative energy is sucking them together.
And you have...
They can do work on you. If you're holding on to these plates and they
each other. You have to put energy to resist it.
You put energy in. As they go together, they do work on you.
The electromagnetic field between two plates in the Casimir effect is exotic.
Okay. So you have this in your basement is what you're telling me. I don't have
it in my basement, but physicists do this.
Let me just say as a side remark.
Having learned a lot about vacuum fluctuations, we in LIGO and our gravity
project. I'll just make the remark that the LIGO team
has perfected a technique called quantum precision measurement, which is based
on manipulating vacuum fluctuations in order to circumvent the uncertainty
principle.
The business of manipulating vacuum fluctuations is something we do in
physics. And it is something then that you can imagine, you can ask,
can a very advanced civilization manipulate vacuum fluctuations
adequately in order to make enough exotic matter inside a
wormhole to hold the wormhole open?
And so I pose this as a question to my physicist colleagues,
stimulated by Carl Sagan, him wanting to send his
heroin through a black hole. I said, no use a wormhole.
And so we've got to hold it open. And so, physicist colleagues, please help
figure out, can an advanced civilization do this? And the answer is we still
don't know.
Forty years later now, we still don't know. Right. Well, we're doing magic
compared to what anyone thought was possible 50 years ago. Certainly the
quantum physics. We're on the centennial of the decade of quantum discovery.
Back in the 1920s. Well, I was very close friends with Carl Sagan, and I
developed close friendship with Christopher Nolan.
Chris has a very different background.
He knows a lot of science, but he's learned it all by browsing the web.
And he knows it well enough to ask me hard questions, just like
you do.
But he asked them first, so I have the answers now.
And it has inspired me to ask questions.
And then I sort of translate to and give to colleagues because my colleagues are
smarter than I am.
My role is to pass on interesting questions. You're the conduit for this.
Conduit for interesting questions for my colleagues to work on. So, dude, you
can't leave well enough alone.
Einstein says maybe there are gravitational waves emanating.
from major gravitational disturbances in the universe, and you've got to go up
and find them.
But you're not the first to have attempted this, right? At the University
Maryland, there was Weber, I think.
What's his first name? Joe. Joe Weber, of course, who had a cylinder, if I
remember correctly, where he was trying to measure whether if a gravitational
wave washed over it, he could detect a distortion in the shape of the cylinder,
I think, was the goal.
The gravitational wave would drive vibrations of the cylinder, end -to -end
vibrations. Okay. And so he instrumented it to search for changes
in the amplitude and phase of vibrations of the cylinder. The cylinder is at a
finite temperature, so it's always vibrating a little bit because it's a
temperature. And so he instrumented it with what's called...
piezoelectric transducers, transducers that he glued around the middle of the
cylinder, that when they were squeezed, they would generate an electrical
voltage that he could measure.
And they're amazing things, these piezoelectric transducers, just
amazing. You squeeze them a tiny, tiny bit and you get a big voltage out.
Joe Weber was tremendously creative.
I think he was working on that while I was at the University of Maryland. I was
there in the 80s. I think he was still working on it. Yeah, that's right. So he
began working on it in the late 60s, early 70s, and
announced that he was seeing possible evidence for gravitational waves.
There was a lot of skepticism at the time. Yeah, that's right.
I'm sorry.
He started working on it in the late 50s, early 60s, announced in 69 that he
seeing some possible evidence of gravitational waves.
And a number of other physicists around the world built similar detectors.
And the bottom line in the end, after a period of shaking out, was that others
were not seeing gravitational waves. And that's the only way science works.
One person's result is not a result until somebody else, a competitor,
else who uses different wall current, somebody from another country. You need
multiple verifications. But on the other hand, Weber, Joe, he
started the field.
He triggered this work.
The approach that he invented for searching for gravitational waves was
dominant approach.
From then until the 2000s. And a number of other research groups built similar
detectors and improved them better and better and better over that period of
time. On that model. On that model.
So, I mean, I have enormous respect for what he did.
Now you decided to, you and others, decided to look differently for them.
well, so Ray Weiss, Reiner.
Ray, his friends call him, at MIT was the primary inventor of an alternative
technique. It was the technique that ultimately succeeded.
He wrote a technical paper about the
technique that identified all of the kinds of noise that you would have to
with and explained how you might deal with them.
and did an analysis of how good this detector could be.
And he put it all in this paper. So there's the recipe. Oh, my gosh. It was
recipe for how to go forward. And he wrote this in 1972.
And Ray, being Ray, didn't publish this because I think he figured you don't
publish until you have built one and seen a gravitational wave.
However,
Ray sent...
copies of this around all his colleagues.
And he put it into quarterly reports of the MIT laboratory
in which he worked.
And so it is probably the most influential non -published paper,
that I know of, in physics.
I mean, it was a tour de force, and it triggered...
The next generation. That actually succeeded.
I was fortunate enough to visit because there are two LIGO experiments, one in
Louisiana and the other one is in Hanford, Washington.
Why do you have two?
Because you can't just have one result.
You're looking for an effect that is so small that you wouldn't believe it
unless you see it on two independent instruments. There you go.
You've got these pathways.
Are they a kilometer long?
Four kilometers long. Four kilometers long.
Evacuated. You send a beam of light that is split from a laser that's split.
These are at 90 -degree angles.
And they go to the end. They get reflected back.
And you rejoin them.
And you want to see if their waves line up.
And if they line up, then each direction is identical.
You can go home.
If they're slightly different, then one of these legs experienced a different
encounter with the fabric of the space -time continuum than the other did.
So actually what you want to do is you make them slightly different in the
place. So that means you send your laser light in from this direction.
there's a beam splitter where the light gets split in two to go down the two
arms.
So the laser light goes in like that. There's this beam splitter, so the light
gets split in two into one arm in that direction and the other arm in this
direction.
And then it comes back and recombines in the beam splitter. The laser light was
coming in from this direction, but when it recombines, a
little bit of light goes out in a perpendicular direction.
So you have a laser here and you have an output over there. And the output
direction is the direction it has a signal. And if the length of one
arm is shortened and the length of the other arm is lengthened.
And that would only happen because a gravitational wave washed over that arm.
That's right.
you get a change in how much light is coming out to the output.
All right, so you're trying to find a length difference, and
if I remember the materials from the press releases, that is equivalent to
-tenth the diameter of a proton?
No, it's equivalent to, it's 10 million times smaller than an atom.
And a hundred times smaller than a proton. One one hundredth the diameter
proton. Meanwhile, all the world is vibrating because everything is at a
temperature. And cool it as much as you want, there's still vibrations.
And somebody is walking down the street. I remember being on campus there. Can I
call it a campus? That's what it was.
And you can detect.
Cars on the road a mile away.
You have to insulate this.
That's half the science done for the experiment.
You should get a Nobel Prize for that.
Well, that's what the Nobel Prize was given for.
To have successfully insulated the effect you're trying to measure.
So the way I like to describe it is you're bouncing light off these mirrors.
And you're looking for a motion of the mirrors that is 10 million times smaller
than the atoms of which the mirrors are made.
And, well, the mirrors, the atoms in the mirrors themselves are vibrating
because they're at finite temperature.
A finite amount is about the same as their size.
So 10 million times smaller than the atoms and 10 million times smaller than
vibrations the atoms are undergoing.
So once again, in physics, there's a phenomenon we're trying to measure, but
it's kind of buried, and you need a way to get to it.
And it seems like half, if not more than half, of the effort is how brilliant
is your engineer that you've brought on to the task to accomplish this?
How good are your tools?
It's not just the idea.
It's now you've got to make the damn measurement.
And it's not obvious. You need very talented people assembled for this.
Absolutely. And so that was the issue is how good a team can you put together?
So when I learned of Ray Weiss's idea and I saw and I knew roughly
how strong the strongest gravitational waves would be, I knew already then that
it would be necessary to.
This would be the collision of two black holes.
Collision of two black holes. And you can't just summon that up. There has to
real things in the universe that might produce that. That's right. You can't
just wish for it. But based on what we knew about the universe at the time, I
was estimating a wave strength that was roughly correct.
And it was at that level that you would have to monitor the motion of these
mirrors at 10 million times smaller than the atoms in the mirrors.
And I thought to myself, that's crazy.
And so in this book, which was published in 1973,
we went to press just after Ray Weiss wrote his seminal paper.
I had not yet really studied that paper fully, but I just
knew that this was crazy.
It describes in a few words Ray's idea in here. And then it says, I
think there's an exercise where it says, show why this is not very promising.
Just a mild, gentle. Because it is a textbook, right? You get to declare
Students challenged to show. Well, it could not be a very good idea in 1973.
But fast forward a half a century.
So it is.
In 1853, flying is not a good idea, right? That's why flying isn't a good
But that was the central issue.
If we worked for a few decades, did we have a shot at success?
In 1973, I thought, no, no way.
But by 1975, I had turned around.
I'd had long conversations with Ray.
I'd had long conversations with Vladimir Brzezinski, a colleague in Moscow.
I had done lots of calculations of my own, and I came to the conclusion that
had a real shot at success if you put together a superbly strong team and
you worked at it for a few decades.
And you need money, and you were well -supported, I think, by the National
Science Foundation. Well, not yet. So at that point, NSF had given Ray $60
,000 to get started.
And that's how much he had in the 1970s from the National Science Foundation.
He also had some money from the Air Force Office of Scientific Research. I'm
sure how much he had, or he had had that until in the Vietnam era, they stopped
supporting science due to something called the Mansfield Amendment, American
politics. And that's when NSF picked him up and gave him $60 ,000.
That was a drop in the bucket compared to what was needed.
And NSF wasn't about ready to put big money in.
This required some members of your team to appear in front of Congress to defend
this. That's correct.
But that was much later. The issue was getting started.
And so how did we get started? Caltech is a very different kind of an
institution than any other I've ever dealt with.
At Caltech, I was able to propose to my colleagues.
We get into this field that we build a experimental program in parallel with
Ray Weiss's program at MIT.
So the chair of the Division of Physics, Mathematics, and Astronomy at Caltech
set up a committee to look at it.
Committee looked at it for about six months, detailed study, came back
enthusiastic, said, let's go ahead.
And so Caltech put private money.
about $2 million of its own private money to get started.
And that inflates to about $12 million today.
Private money when nobody else is putting anything in.
You're right. That's a very different culture at Caltech, as you described.
once that had happened, and we had brought Ron Drever from Scotland to
experimental effort, then NSF.
And NSF stood up and took notice.
They did their own study of this and came up with the same conclusion. They
started funding us and Ray Weiss, and it became a Caltech -MIT collaboration.
Let's fast forward to 2016, where you make the first detection.
You announce it in 16. You announce it in 16. By the way, I would later learn
that when I visited the facility, in Louisiana, you already had made the
detection.
And you'd be happy to know that everyone was completely zip -mouthed about it
until it was official. Because I have this huge internet following, right? And
people were totally zip -mouthed. I swear I didn't know about it until the
release came. We were all sworn to secrecy. Yes, yes. And so the
a first detection came from the second facility built in Hanford.
And at that point, you have a time delay because gravitational waves move at the
speed of light, correct? And Earth is a finite size. And so all that worked out.
Yeah, yeah. And so it was just seven milliseconds.
Time difference.
A second time difference because the waves came up from the south. They
the Earth around the tip of the Antarctic Peninsula, traveled through
It came up through the Earth in Louisiana first, and in Washington State
second, seven milliseconds later.
And then the waves were unaffected by all the matter of the Earth.
And they couldn't see the difference between Earth and no Earth.
And they couldn't see the difference between detector and no detector. They
very hard to detect. They were doing their thing.
So what impresses me greatly, is here we have a prediction made by Albert
Einstein in 1916 or 15, whatever. Albert Einstein, in a little -known fact, I
mean, physicists know this, but I don't think the public knows, Einstein laid
out the equations for the stimulated emission of radiation, which is the
physical foundation of a laser.
He wrote that down first.
And a laser would take a few decades to actually be built into the 1950s.
And I'm just saying, here's Einstein predicting gravitational waves, laying
foundation for a laser, and 100 years later, his gravitational waves are found
with lasers.
So these are crumbs spilling off his plate.
Einstein was kind of smart.
And lo and behold, nobody's surprised, the Nobel Prize goes to this project.
And you, along with Ray Weiss and Barry Barish.
share the Nobel Prize. What year was that?
2017.
So they apologized to us that they didn't give us in 16 because we didn't
announce it until past their deadline for nominations.
They delay anyway.
They said it obviously.
It was obvious the prize was going for this. It was just obvious.
Hey, StarTalk fans, I don't know if you know this, but the audio version of the
podcast,
actually posts a week in advance of the video version. And you can get that in
Spotify and Apple Podcasts and most other podcast outlets that are out
Multiple ways to ingest all that is cosmic on StarTalk.
You can't be a general relativity Einstein guy without being a black hole
So forgive me for asking you to...
retell a story you've probably told a thousand times.
But there's some famous bet you made, was it with Preskill, with some other
physicist? Preskill and Hawking. And Stephen Hawking.
By the way, I was at the University of Texas when Preskill was there. I think
was like a postdoc or something. He was just starting out.
That's how old I am. I'm an old guy.
You're a young kid. I'm an old man.
So you made a bet.
And let me see if I can.
set the table here.
A black hole, once we all agree that they exist, we can ask other questions.
When you have something outside the black hole and it falls in, what happens
that information that was contained in that object?
Is it gone forever and is that okay?
Because information theory was a whole branch of science, shall I call it
science, that was rising up at around the same time and entropy.
became a buzzword among many.
So what was the bet and how was it ultimately resolved?
The bet was between Stephen Hawking and me on one side and John Preskill
on the other side.
It was over whether or not information does get lost in black holes.
And why is that so bad?
Okay, so it's bad because
the fundamental laws of quantum mechanics as they are normally
Physicists are widely agreed that quantum physics is fundamental
and that quantum physics underlies all of physics.
It's the most successful theory ever put forth of the universe. And classical
physics, where there are not these quantum fluctuations, there are not
probabilities.
That arises from quantum physics as an approximation under ordinary everyday
circumstances. There are many people who caricature science, physics in
particular, by saying, well, we used to think classical physics was it, but now
we discard it in favor of quantum physics. But that's not true.
No, quantum physics absorbed, as well as relativity, general relativity,
absorbing Newtonian gravity.
It's not discarded. It's a bigger understanding, a deeper understanding.
I just want to emphasize that. Many people get that confused.
So quantum physics is normally formulated, is almost
universally viewed, has built right into it from the very beginning
the fact that information cannot be lost.
Now, these words, information cannot be lost, are a translation into everyday
language of something else, which is not everyday language, which says that the
evolution of everything in the universe is unitary.
And so those are buzzwords that are not part of the normal lexicon. But I want
to say, just to say that, to indicate that there's...
Some very, very extremely precise version of this, of which information is
lost, is a colloquial way of saying it. Okay. But it would represent a violation
of some fundamental tenets of quantum theory. That's right.
Stephen Hawking, back when he was visiting Caltech.
Who, by the way, we've interviewed for StarTalk in our archives.
Check it out.
In 1974, 70.
He spent a year in my research group at Caltech.
We were very close friends.
And during that period, he having discovered something called Hawking
which is a very slow evaporation of a black hole that emits radiation and
evaporates.
He then, while he was here, began to look much more deeply at quantum theory
black holes.
And he came up with a prediction that information really is lost.
And when black holes evaporate, you could form a black hole.
If you waited long enough, much longer than the age of the universe for normal
black holes, the black hole would evaporate and all the information that
into the black hole would be gone. The black hole would be gone. You just
lost the information that no longer is there.
And that was...
Complete violation of the normal tenets of quantum mechanics.
And yet he was claiming that that was true.
He wrote a paper on this with all the technical details.
He couldn't get it published.
It was so obvious. It had to be wrong, but nobody could see anything wrong in
his calculation.
And so he had to fight for more than a year to get it published. If you look at
this paper.
You see the submission date. As all research papers give you. Yeah, they
you a submission date, and then you usually have a revised date, and then
published. There's no revised date. There's a submission date, and the
publication date is like nearly a year and a half later.
He fought for a whole year, more than a year, to get this thing published.
And physicists have struggled with this ever since.
And those of us whose roots are in relativity tended to believe Hawking.
And those of us whose roots were in, who grew up with quantum mechanics instead
of relativity first, those of us who were enamored of relativity tended to
believe Hawking. And so Hawking and I made this bet with Preskill, whose roots
were in.
And he's the junior of you both, right? He's the junior of us all. He's a young
whippersnapper coming up. He is now the Richard P. Feynman Professor of
Theoretical Physics at Caltech.
I'm the Richard P. Feynman Professor of Theoretical Physics Emeritus.
Emeritus, okay.
I'm a young whippersnapper. Oh, man, don't take your job in a minute. So I
turned the chair over to John.
I mean, John is brilliant. He's a hell of a lot smarter than I am.
A hell of a lot smarter. Anyway, so.
So we made this bet, and this was in a period when Hawking was starting to
Caltech for typically three to six weeks every year. Was he yet wheelchair
-bound? Oh, yeah. He was wheelchair -bound going way back to about 1970.
Okay. And this is 1990.
Oh, whoa. Much later. Okay.
We made the bet around 1990.
So the stage is set.
The cage match is set. You and Stephen Hawking, titans in your field, in your
subject, conclude, yeah, information is lost.
Especially if Hawking radiation, you can evaporate the black hole and everything
is gone. There's no memory of what was there. Preskill is declaring that
information is not lost and his roots are deep in quantum physics, which we
has never been shown to be wrong.
And they're both smarter than I am, and they both know a lot more about quantum
physics than I do.
Because we'll return to this, but let me just explain that through my whole
career, I've thought that quantum gravity, combining general relativity
quantum physics, was the most important area of physics of all. But I also made
a decision when I was very young, I will never work in quantum gravity because
the field is too crowded.
There are too many smart people there.
I'm smart enough to pick really important problems that I can solve that
else is working on.
And they'll only figure out later that I'm right, that those problems are
important. But I won't touch a problem wherever it is. We've got a million
people in the room. There's just too many smart people in the room.
So anyway, so they have now agreed that information is not lost.
So Hawking conceded, and by association with you, or have you still a holdout on
this? I'm still a holdout.
Okay. And what led to this concession, if I understand correctly?
So he, Stephen, together with a student, was working on an
idea for how the information might be recovered.
And he basically said that...
In quantum physics, if you form a black hole and then it evaporates, there's
also a tiny probability the black hole never formed in the first place, and the
information sneaks out through the root where it didn't form in the first place.
I'm sorry, that sounded like a cop -out.
Yeah, it does sound like a cop -out, but it's very clever, and it's in keeping
with how physics works.
But it's not obvious that it's right. But it's conceivable that this is what
happened. What about the idea?
So maybe I've misunderstood.
So I've got to go back to see where I've said this, even publicly.
I thought as the black hole evaporates, because the energy, the gravitational
energy in the vicinity of a black hole can spontaneously make a pair of
particles. And one particle escapes, the other one falls into the black hole.
And this just keeps going until there's no black hole left.
But the particle that escapes, if you inventory those particles, they're real
particles. And don't you recover all the particles that went in in the first
place? You recover all the energy.
But not the inventory of particles. You don't get the same particles
necessarily. Okay, then I misunderstood that.
I think I've been wrong.
I thought you get particle for particle. They come out, which blew my mind.
I don't think, certainly there's no proof that that's the case. Certainly no
proof that that's the case, and I don't think it is the case. Okay, so you guys
lost the bet.
Well, no.
Hawking concedes the bet. Hawking concedes the bet. And what was at stake
this? The loser will give the winner an encyclopedia filled with information.
that somehow escaped the black hole.
So information is the penalty gift. That's right.
Stephen Hawking conceded the bet at a big international conference on general
relativity and gravitation in Dublin, Ireland, in early 2000.
Were there gaffes in the audience? There were rumors that he was going to
concede. And so there was a big ceremony that I played some role in the
ceremony, but I didn't concede myself.
And so Stephen gave Preskill, who's a big baseball fan, an encyclopedia
of American baseball.
Oh, any kind of encyclopedia. Well, that was his idea.
That's clever.
And less expensive.
Yeah. I didn't concede for a peculiar reason.
there is an alternative formulation of quantum mechanics in which information
could be lost. It's due to Feynman, called a sum -over -histories
And as I say, I don't work in quantum theory in
any deep sort of way. I do in terms of quantum technology, which we needed for
LIGO, but that's a separate story.
Two of the very deepest physicists in working in
quantum theory of my lifetime were Murray Gelman and
Jim Hartle.
Jim Hartle at Santa Barbara, Gelman at Caltech, and then he moved to the Santa
Fe Institute in retirement.
Gelman is credited with...
proposing quarks as the fundamental particle of... The giants of theoretical
physics when I was a young physicist at Caltech were Gelman and Feynman.
Two colleagues of mine that I enormously respect.
So Gelman and Hartle took Feynman's
path integral or some of our history's approach to quantum mechanics and they
developed it further in a form that they could apply it to to the universe.
And then they, Hartle has used that to study quantum
cosmology, the quantum mechanical description of the birth of the universe
how it has evolved.
That particular approach to quantum mechanics, Hartle took it and he showed
that approach can deal perfectly well with information loss.
And it deals with it, it arises because of what we call closed time like curves.
There's a certain probability for backward time travel in quantum physics.
In this Feynman -Galman -Hardell approach,
there's a certain probability for backward time travel. And if you can
backward time travel at the quantum level, then you lose information.
And there's sort of an elegant mathematical formulation here. Quantum
so weaselly this way. Well, that's not the standard version of quantum
mechanics, but that was the version that Feynman and that Hartle and Gelman
needed in order to do the quantum mechanics of the entire universe and the
of the universe.
So we're getting into this issue of the birth of the universe and quantum.
quantum gravity here.
And I am rather enamored of this approach, although I don't
do it. I just look on the sidelines and admire these people who are smarter than
I am and who have the courage to work in a crowded field.
But I'm just so impressed with this and with the fact that within that
formulation you can lose information.
Is that the start of a formulation that will one day marry general relativity
and quantum physics? Well, it does do that.
It's not... It's knocking on the door. It's knocking on the door.
So remind me, now, you're Professor Horn in this
question, what is the problem with general relativity not melding together
quantum physics?
What is the real holdup there?
Well, the real holdup is that they are logically incompatible with each other,
and so something has to give.
And that's because general relativity requires space to be continuous.
You have a continuum space, and it's a very definite space. It's not a space
where you have a certain probability that space is warped in this way and
another probability it's warped in that way. In fact, there are no probabilities
at all. Yeah, there are classical probabilities, but not.
Quantum. Not quantum probabilities. And so at the smallest scale, they're
incompatible. The smallest scale, they're incompatible in any place where
gravity becomes extremely strong, they're incompatible. So the smallest
they're incompatible even here in this room, but also they're incompatible in
the birth of the universe when gravity was extremely strong. They're
incompatible in the core of a black hole.
Our gravity is extremely strong.
They're incompatible.
If you try to make a time machine, Hockey and I independently with our
have identified a process whereby if a very advanced civilization tries to make
a time machine, it will quite possibly explode at the moment you try to turn it
on.
And that's also controlled by these laws of quantum gravity.
So that's why we haven't seen any.
time travelers yet. That may be the reason. They're all dead trying to turn
the machine. That's right.
What you're saying is Einstein puts forth the general theory of relativity,
which is so successful in so many realms, and it picked up where Newtonian
gravity failed, yet we must confess or concede that there's a limit to
how far general relativity goes, although we've yet to find a limit to...
quantum physics so the betting the betting pool will say general relativity
going to succumb to quantum physics in some way yeah that that's one way to say
it they certainly there is the s incompatibility between the two and
theorists are trying to be the they're like performing the shotgun wedding
between the two branches of physics somehow yeah and i i do think again
in from the outside since i've chosen not to work in this field String theory
likely to be a successful route into the correct laws of quantum gravity. Yeah,
but they've been at it for 50 years. Oh, yeah. 40, 40 years. That's not very
long. Come on. I'm 84 years old. Come on.
That's just a drop in the bucket. Come on. Wait, but Einstein went from special
relativity to general relativity in 10 years.
Kepler went from weird nested solids to… The Kepler's three laws of motion
in 10 years. And that's lone scientists. We've been working to try to do
controlled fusion for a lot longer than, more than 50
years. LIGO took 50 years from the time I first started working on gravitational
waves until we succeeded. It was 50 years.
Some things take a long time.
Yeah, but LIGO is a machine.
The merging of quantum physics and general relativity are ideas.
Could it be, and I've said this, I don't want to say this to you because you're
Kip Thorne, but I've said this to Brian Green, okay? Because Brian Green is like
my generation.
I said to Brian Green, I said, Brian, you've been working on string theory for
decades.
Maybe all of you are just too stupid to figure it out and we're waiting for
someone else to be born into this field to then solve it and went into the ways
none of the rest of you can.
None of them are saying, I'm too stupid to figure this out.
Let me choose another profession.
No, they're saying the problem is too hard. And if you go 40 years of really
smart people not figuring something out, that tells me either they're barking up
the wrong tree or none of them are smart enough.
Am I overreacting here? I think you have to remember that we do build on each
other. None of them by themselves are smart enough.
Okay. But the community, again, it's like...
This Nobel Prize really belongs to a thousand people. It doesn't belong to
With the genesis in Joe Weber.
With the genesis in Joe Weber.
Newton spoke of standing on the shoulders of giants, and that really is
If I can see farther than others, it's because I've stood on the shoulders of
giants who have come before me.
And that's the nature of science.
The struggles that our colleagues have been having with string theory and M
-theory and quantum gravity, we've learned an enormous amount.
It shows it's very promising, but it's going to continue on into the next
generation before the ultimate success is had very, very, very probably.
Those are like final words right there.
I've heard rumor that whichever faculty of Caltech gets a Nobel
Prize, they get a parking spot with their name on it.
Is that true?
At Caltech, a Nobel Prize does not get you a parking spot with your name on it.
You have to pay for the parking spot just as much as you do without a Nobel
Prize. That was such a fun rumor, though. I heard that.
That's true at USC, but it's not true at Caltech.
Okay. Because there's just too many of you all running around with Nobel
The parking spots are too valuable.
So true at USC. Yeah, it's true at USC. All right. So you're 84. You have 84
years of wisdom.
coursing in your veins and arteries. Are there any projects you're working on in
the next several years?
So I made a gradual transition, conscious, away from science,
away from scientific research, beginning around 15 years ago.
Oh.
I would like to believe I can live to 110.
That's my...
intended goal.
And so for the next remaining decades, I wanted
to do things that I really enjoyed. And I've enjoyed science.
I've been a conventional Caltech professor for half a century.
Enormously enjoyed it. Enormously enjoyed working with students.
I trained over 50 PhD students who did far more important research than I
did.
Been there, done that.
And I have worked in all these areas of science, and I've had enormous fun, but
I've turned them over to the younger generation, and they're smarter than I
Okay, so what are you, surfing now, or skydiving? Okay, you're taking up
other... So I decided that I would like to spend a few
decades doing creative work at the interface between science and the arts.
Oh. So Interstellar is an example. That was going to be released in September,
and then they delayed it to the holiday season in December.
So the re -release of Interstellar. The re -release to December 2024.
That's right. That's right.
That was enormously enjoyable.
From that, I learned how great it can be to collaborate with
somebody as brilliant and as completely different than I am, Christopher Nolan.
So my most recent collaboration has been a book of poetry and paintings with
Leah Halloran about the warped side of the universe and my poetry, my
attempts at poetry and her paintings, but just trying to see whether it's
possible by tightly integrating paintings with verse to convey
the essence of issues in science.
the essential features without conveying the precise details.
No, that's not the right genre for precise details.
But anyway, so I've been enjoying that.
By the way, I've always felt that way about Van Gogh's Starry Night. Yes.
Where you look at that painting and you say, this is clearly not what he saw,
but it's definitely what he felt.
Yes, yes. And you get to experience the universe through his own lens.
Yes. And so I've always appreciated art when it plays that role.
I have a second movie that's been in the works for more than a decade. Can you
tell? Well, it's just something that I started with Stephen Hawking and Linda
Obst, who is my partner on starting Interstellar.
It is wonderful to work with.
That movie might never get made. I'm not going to tell you what it's about,
aside from the fact that it's sci -fi.
And it's solid sci -fi. That's how it's built in from the outset.
So if that does not work out in the end, then I may try turning it into a
novel. I've never tried to write a novel. I don't know whether I can, but
would be fun to try.
And actually, the thing that I have put almost...
A large fraction of my effort and the lion's share of my effort since the
beginning of the pandemic is a history of the LIGO project, the LIGO
gravitational wave project, because that is, I think, pretty clearly the
technically most difficult thing that's ever been done by physicists.
By anybody.
By anybody. Yeah, probably by anybody.
One one -hundredth the diameter of a proton? That's anybody.
And success.
required both amazing, developing amazing technology, new technologies.
It required developing computer simulations of
colliding black holes, required developing quantum precision measurement
technology that is now in LIGO and playing a major role where you
what's called the Heisenberg uncertainty principle.
My mind is still partly blown by having By you having said that, you're
bypassing Heisenberg's uncertainty principle. Yeah, that's right. By
manipulating vacuum fluctuations, just like advanced civilizations
might do as a routine thing. So we developed this new
area of technology for Eichel.
But it was also a very political thing. How do you get a billion dollars of
taxpayer money?
for a field that didn't exist when you began.
And should they bet on you and not someone else? That's right. And plus, I
you even had naysayers, if I remember correctly.
Colleagues would say, this is a pipe dream.
We had political battles in Washington.
Yeah. Tell me who the naysayers were. I got people to take care of them. They
were some of the leading astronomers.
I got people to take care of them. You want my people to...
No, they've come around.
You think? Okay.
They've come around because this is so exciting now that LIGO succeeded.
But the sociology of the transition from small science to big science is a very
rocky process. And that's the right word, sociology, because that's what it
I don't like working in a big science project. It's not for me.
It's like working in a crowded field. It's not for me.
But this had to make the transformation. It wouldn't have happened otherwise. It
wouldn't have happened otherwise.
The genius of Barry Barish in making that happen and the genius of Robbie
in getting us partway there at the very beginning is our initial director, who
was the one that sold it to Congress and really got us going.
It's a very complicated story, and I have a set
of...
five collaborators that have been working on this history.
We just finished draft six and sent it out to like a colleague to comment on.
And I have been getting back huge numbers of comments and it'll take me
years, I think.
So anyway, this history, because of the nature of this project, it's a very
interesting, complex history that is quite important for the history of
Especially when you consider Most people knew nothing of LIGO until they see the
headline that it discovered gravitational waves.
And why would they have any thought of what challenges preceded that?
You know, they just read the result. Oh, scientists discover this.
Well, how about the, like you said, the politics, the sociology.
The genesis, who's standing on whose shoulders, who are the naysayers, all
has to be overcome.
The international collaboration, key input from the Soviet Union in the
of the Cold War.
And it's just a fascinating story and
enormous fun.
You know, Arthur C.
Clarke said, he said, in space where there is no air.
A flag will not wave.
So maybe the universe is not a place where we should be waving flags.
Collaboration is what gets you there. I like that.
So Kip, this has been a delight. Thanks for making time.
A lot of fun.
For StarTalk.
I look forward to the release of, the re -release of Interstellar.
We were recording this before that has come out.
You already know this, but let me reaffirm that that film just took people
ride far beyond anything they had imagined.
It had kind of an impact on people in the way 2001 A Space Odyssey did. It was
mysterious, it was modern, it was the future, but it was still relevant.
But it left you with more questions to ask than questions answered. And you
want that, I think. Yeah, and that was...
Really, the genius of Christopher Nolan taking some science that
he and I had put together, but combining it with a human story that was
powerful.
And with marquee director and marquee actors that made sure it would get
noticed. And music.
Yes. I went to a concert by Hans Zimmer. That was Hans Zimmer, yes.
Just, I think, the night before last.
And he, but I didn't know there, but he basically said that certain
pieces of the music in Interstellar were as close to perfection as he has
achieved. Wow. I'm going to give it another listen. Because there is no 2001
without its musical track. With the Strauss waltzes, the... This is very
different. I mean, it's all Zimmer's.
original music and it's a remarkable score uh just amazing i'd look forward
to your next 25 years when you live to 110 uh maybe we can do a reprise of this
conversation we'll check in on that see how you've been coming along dude thanks
a lot thanks great to see you again thanks this has been a special
exclusive one -on -one between star talk and hip thorn Nobel
laureate, even let me touch his medal.
First time I've ever touched a Nobel Prize.
Well, the medal that really belongs to a thousand.
The medal earned by a huge team, as he humbly declares.
And as we enter a new era of science, where collaborations are really how this
works, especially where you have international collaborations, you have
scientists getting along, even at times when the leaders of their countries are
in conflict. That's just messed up.
That's messed up. I'm Neil deGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist for
StarTalk. As always, I bid you to keep looking up.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.