Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Ewe
Faroese
Filipino
Finnish
French
Frisian
Ga
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Gujarati
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hindi
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Igbo
Indonesian
Interlingua
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Javanese
Kannada
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kurdish (Soranî)
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lingala
Lithuanian
Lozi
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Malayalam
Maltese
Maori
Marathi
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Nigerian Pidgin
Northern Sotho
Norwegian
Norwegian (Nynorsk)
Occitan
Oriya
Oromo
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Punjabi
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Runyakitara
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Serbo-Croatian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Sundanese
Swahili
Swedish
Tajik
Tamil
Tatar
Telugu
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Tshiluba
Tumbuka
Turkish
Turkmen
Twi
Uighur
Ukrainian
Urdu
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof
Xhosa
Yiddish
Yoruba
Zulu
- WELCOME TO INDEPENDENT LENS. I'M AMERICA FERRERA.
WHO HIDES 40,000 BANNED WORKS OF ART FROM THE KGB IN PLAIN SIGHT?
- SO HOW DID THIS HAPPEN,
THE FACT THAT THERE'S SUCH A COLLECTION IN THIS PLACE?
- THESE ARE INDEPENDENT FILMMAKERS AMANDA POPE
AND TCHAVDAR GEORGIEV.
THEY STUMBLED ACROSS AN ART COLLECTION
IN ISLAMIC UZBEKISTAN CREATED SINGLE-HANDEDLY
BY A PENNILESS MAN IN A LAND SUSPICIOUS OF WESTERN ART,
A STORY OF ISLAM, STALIN, THE SILK ROAD,
AND THE RUSSIAN AVANT-GARDE
HIDDEN IN SOME OF THE GREATEST ART
THE WORLD HAS BARELY SEEN.
THE DESERT OF FORBIDDEN ART, NEXT.
[upbeat jazzy music]
¶
THE CORPORATION FOR PUBLIC BROADCASTING,
THE NATIONAL ENDOWMENT FOR THE ARTS,
AND BY CONTRIBUTIONS TO YOUR PBS STATION
FROM VIEWERS LIKE YOU.
- I FOUND THESE PAINTINGS ROLLED UP UNDER THE BEDS
OF OLD WIDOWS,
BURIED IN FAMILY TRASH...
IN DARK CORNERS OF ARTISTS' STUDIOS,
SOMETIMES EVEN PATCHING A HOLE IN THE ROOF.
I ENDED UP WITH A COLLECTION THAT NO ONE IN THE SOVIET UNION
WOULD DARE TO EXHIBIT.
THESE WERE FORBIDDEN WORKS BY ARTISTS
WHO STAYED TRUE TO THEIR VISION AT A TERRIBLE COST.
[gunshot]
- [speaking Russian]
- [speaking Russian]
- RUSSIAN MUSEUMS CAN'T LIVE WITH THE IDEA
THAT SUCH A WONDERFUL COLLECTION WAS TAKEN OUT
FROM RUSSIA TO THIS PROVINCIAL PLACE
SOMEWHERE IN UZBEKISTAN; GOD KNOWS WHERE.
[upbeat eclectic music]
¶
- IT REALLY WASN'T THAT LONG AGO WHEN WHAT WE NOW CALL UZBEKISTAN
WAS ONE OF THE MOST SPECTACULAR CENTERS OF WORLD CULTURE.
THE SILK ROAD RAN RIGHT THROUGH THAT REGION,
BUT FOR A PERIOD OF ALMOST A CENTURY,
UZBEKISTAN HAD BEEN JUST DISTANT PROVINCE
OF THE SOVIET UNION.
WHEN THE SOVIET UNION COLLAPSED, I WAS ASKED TO COVER THIS REGION
THAT NOBODY IN THE WORLD REALLY EVER THOUGHT ABOUT.
FOR THOSE PEOPLE WHO CONSIDER UZBEKISTAN
TO BE HOPELESSLY EXOTIC AND REMOTE,
HOW ABOUT KARAKALPAKSTAN?
IT'S AN INDEPENDENT REPUBLIC WITHIN UZBEKISTAN.
[dog barking]
THE PRINCIPLE CITY IN KARAKALPAKSTAN IS NUKUS.
[goat bleating]
I HAD, I GUESS, ASSUMED THAT THE NUKUS MUSEUM
WOULD BE TO MUSEUMS IN THE WORLD
WHAT NUKUS IS TO THE WORLD,
KIND OF A DUSTY PROVINCIAL TOWN.
IT DIDN'T TAKE ME MORE THAN A FEW MINUTES
OF WALKING AROUND THIS MUSEUM FOR MY JAW TO DROP.
[eclectic violin music]
¶
THE FACT THAT THERE IS SUCH A COLLECTION IN THIS PLACE
AND SUCH A CONCENTRATION OF ART
MAKES IT FAR MORE INTERESTING THAN IF YOU WOULD SEE
THESE SAME PAINTINGS IN A SERIES OF GALLERIES
IN GERMANY OR IN NEW YORK, SO HOW DID THIS HAPPEN?
[light piano music]
¶
- I WAS BORN INTO A LIFE OF PRIVILEGE.
I EVEN HAD A PROPER GOVERNESS IMPORTED FROM FRANCE.
THE LITTLE GIRL WITH A BOW IS ME,
GROOMED IN THE HIGH FASHION OF THE TIMES.
MY FATHER WAS A WEALTHY LAWYER,
WHILE MY MOTHER SPENT HER DAYS PRESIDING OVER TEA.
MY BROTHER WENT TO MILITARY SCHOOL,
AND I WAS SUPPOSED TO FOLLOW IN HIS FOOTSTEPS
AND SERVE THE CZAR.
BUT THEN THE REVOLUTION BROKE OUT.
OUR LIFE TURNED UPSIDE DOWN.
WE WERE NO LONGER THE RULING CLASS.
ONE BY ONE, OUR FRIENDS AND RELATIVES BEGAN TO DISAPPEAR.
WE HAD TO HIDE OUR ARISTOCRATIC ROOTS
AND BLEND IN WITH THE PROLETARIAT,
WHO WERE NOW IN POWER.
I HAD TO PROVE THAT I WAS IDEOLOGICALLY PURE,
SO I TOOK A WORKING-CLASS JOB AS AN ELECTRICIAN.
BUT I DREAMED OF BECOMING AN ARTIST.
I GOT MY OPPORTUNITY
WHEN I JOINED THE FAMOUS KHOREZM ARCHAEOLOGICAL EXPEDITION.
IT WAS THE GREATEST DIG IN SOVIET CENTRAL ASIA,
AS IMPORTANT AS THE DISCOVERY OF TUTANKHAMEN'S TOMB.
- [speaking Russian]
- WHILE EVERYBODY SLEPT DURING THE MIDDAY HEAT,
I PAINTED.
THE DESERT TRAINS THE EYE TO BE ESPECIALLY SENSITIVE
TO SUBTLE AND INTENSE VARIATIONS IN COLOR.
IT IS THE BEST SCHOOL FOR THE PAINTER WHO STRIVES TO GRASP
THE FULL POWER OF HOW COLOR SOUNDS.
- [speaking Russian]
- [speaking Russian]
- IF AN ARTIST OF FALK'S STATURE
TELLS YOU YOU'RE NO GOOD,
YOU KNOW YOU'LL NEVER BE GREAT.
- I DESTROYED ALL MY WORKS
AND CUT MY TIES TO THE ART WORLD.
I DECIDED TO RETURN TO THE DESERT
AND START A NEW LIFE.
- I KNEW SAVITSKY FROM MY CHILDHOOD.
MY GRANDMOTHER WAS ALWAYS FULL OF IRONY
WHEN SHE SAW SAVITSKY, SAYING,
"OH, AGAIN HE CAME TO ASK FOR THIS OLD STUFF."
THIS IS THE CLASSICAL COSTUME OF KARAKALPAK FIANCEE,
WHICH IS EXACTLY THE SAME DENIM CLOTHES
THAT IS POPULAR ALL OVER THE WORLD NOW,
AND KARAKALPAKS WERE USING THESE CLOTHES
FOR MORE THAN THREE CENTURIES.
[both speaking Russian]
- WHEN THE SOVIETS WERE IN POWER,
THEY FELT THAT THE ETHNIC TRADITIONS
OF ALL THESE NATIONALITIES IN WHAT WAS THEN THE SOVIET SOUTH
SHOULD BE REPRESSED.
AND IF YOU HAD TRADITIONAL CLOTHING,
YOU SHOULD HIDE THOSE; YOU SHOULD GET RID OF THOSE.
SAVITSKY SAVED A LOT OF THAT STUFF
THAT MIGHT OTHERWISE HAVE DISAPPEARED.
- THESE TREASURES WOULD REMAIN FOREVER IN MY GARAGE
UNLESS I FOUND A WAY TO GET THE LOCAL COMMUNIST PARTY BOSS
TO GO AGAINST PARTY POLICY.
- [speaking Russian]
- I FINALLY HAD MY MUSEUM,
BUT AS AN ARTIST,
I STILL LONGED TO SEE PAINTINGS.
AROUND THAT TIME, I CAME ACROSS AN ART CATALOG
FROM THE EARLY DAYS OF SOVIET UZBEKISTAN.
- [speaking Russian]
- I WAS SURPRISED THAT I'D NEVER HEARD OF VOLKOV.
IF A WORK SO WANTON HAD FALLEN VICTIM TO CENSORSHIP,
WHAT ELSE WAS OUT THERE?
- [speaking Russian]
- [speaking Russian]
- I TRAVELED ALL OVER UZBEKISTAN
SEARCHING FOR MASTERPIECES THAT THE HISTORY OF OUR TIMES
HAD CONDEMNED TO OBSCURITY.
I FOUND A WHOLE MULTINATIONAL COLLECTIVE OF ARTISTS.
SOME WERE UZBEKS.
OTHERS CAME FROM DISTANT PARTS OF OUR SOVIET UNION.
THEY CAME HERE AFTER THE REVOLUTION.
FOR A BRIEF PERIOD OF TIME IN THE '20s AND '30s,
THEY PAINTED FREELY
FAR AWAY FROM THE KREMLIN'S CENSORSHIP.
UZBEKISTAN BECAME THEIR SECOND MOTHERLAND.
- [speaking Russian]
- THE ARTISTS STROVE TO FIND
THE MOST CONTEMPORARY METHODS AND FORMS
TO DEPICT THE UZBEK PEOPLE AND THEIR CULTURE.
- SO YOU BEGIN TO HAVE A KIND OF A CROSS-FERTILIZATION
OF ONE OF THE GREAT WORLD-CLASS SCHOOLS OF ART,
THE RUSSIAN AVANT-GARDE,
WITH THIS OTHER MORE INTERESTING LOCALLY BASED SCHOOL,
AND THE INFLUENCES THAT CREATED THE RUSSIAN AVANT-GARDE MERGED
AND MELDED WITH THE INFLUENCES THAT CAME OUT OF CENTRAL ASIA.
- MIKHAIL KURZIN CAME ALSO TO UZBEKISTAN
IN THE BEGINNING OF 1920s.
IF WE LOOK AT HIS FIRST IMPRESSIONS OF UZBEKISTAN,
THIS WAS THE NEW; THIS IS THE OLD.
THE OLD SYMBOLIZED THE TRADITION OF ISLAMIC COUNTRY,
WHEN MEN WAS ALLOWED TO HAVE UP TO FOUR WIVES,
SO WE CAN SEE TWO WIVES FOLLOWING THEIR MASTER,
AND THEY'RE WEARING VEILS, THESE PARANJAS.
SARCASM OF KURZIN IS IN THE FACT
THAT THE TWO TRADITIONAL WIVES ARE COMBINED
WITH THE NEW SOVIET KIND OF WIFE IN THE NEW CLOTHES,
IN THE NEW WAY OF BEHAVING.
- PART OF THE REVOLUTION THAT SOVIET RULE BROUGHT
TO CENTRAL ASIA WAS THE LIBERATION OF WOMEN.
[all screaming]
- [speaking Russian]
- CENTRAL ASIA HAD BEEN STUCK IN A FAR-DISTANT PAST,
AND WHEN THE SOVIETS ARRIVED,
IT WAS LIKE A DAWNING OF A HUGE NEW ERA.
LIFE CHANGED IN EVERY WAY FOR THE PEOPLE THAT LIVED THERE.
[eclectic music]
¶
[men chanting]
- THE SOVIETS DECIDED THAT THEY WERE GONNA TURN CENTRAL ASIA
INTO THE REGION WHERE ALL THE COTTON
FOR THE ENTIRE SOVIET UNION WAS GONNA BE PRODUCED.
COTTON IS A VERY WATER-INTENSIVE PROJECT,
AND SO THE SOVIETS BUILT A HUGE NETWORK
OF EXTREMELY INEFFICIENT IRRIGATION CHANNELS,
AND THEY SUCKED THIS WATER PRINCIPALLY OUT OF THE RIVERS
THAT FED INTO THE ARAL SEA.
THIS WAS ONE OF THE WORLD'S LARGEST INLAND SEAS
AND HAD BEEN SINCE TIME IMMEMORIAL.
IT JUST DRIED UP.
THIS ARAL SEA DISASTER
IS TRULY ONE OF THE GREAT ENVIRONMENTAL CATASTROPHES
OF THE 20TH CENTURY.
- AS I WAS WALKING ACROSS THE WASTELAND
OF OUR SOVIET DREAM,
I PITIED VOLKOV FOR HIS IDEALISM.
- THE ARTIST VOLKOV MORE THAN ANYBODY ELSE
HAS GONE ASTRAY.
VOLKOV DOESN'T SEE ANYTHING BUT COLORS.
THE AUDIENCE SAW STARING AT THEM FROM THE WALLS
ROUGHLY SKETCHED MONSTERS,
A DELIBERATE DISTORTION OF REALITY.
[cheers and applause]
- [speaking Russian]
- YOU HAD THESE PAINTINGS
OF HARDWORKING PEASANTS AND FACTORY WORKERS,
ALL OF WHOM WOULD BE VERY HEALTHY AND VIBRANT.
THEY WERE SUPPOSED TO CONVEY THE SATISFACTION AND THE THRILL
THAT PEOPLE FELT OF BEING SOVIET CITIZENS.
[upbeat music]
¶
- IF AN ARTIST WISHED TO WORK OUTSIDE THE SYSTEM
OF SOVIET SOCIALIST REALISM,
THEN THAT ARTIST WOULD INEVITABLY BE REMOVED
FROM THAT SYSTEM,
LIKE A MICROBE FROM THE HEALTHY BODY.
- IN MY DREAM, I SAW A CREATURE,
HIS EYES LIKE THE BARRELS OF A GUN.
I CALLED THE PAINTING FASCISM IS ADVANCING.
[cheers and applause]
- IT WAS A KIND OF A FUTURE VISION
OF THE THREAT THAT WAS COMING.
THE FACT THAT LYSENKO FINISHED HIS LIFE
IN MENTAL HOSPITAL MEANS A LOT.
MANY ARTISTS WERE FORCED TO BE SENT TO MENTAL HOSPITALS.
- SAVITSKY WAS CRITICIZED FOR THIS VERY PAINTING
WHEN IT WAS HUNG ON THE WALLS OF THE MUSEUM.
THE INSPECTION CAME AND SAID,
"YOU MUST TAKE AWAY THIS ANTI-SOVIET WORK.
"IT'S DEGENERATE PAINTING,
SO THERE IS NO PLACE FOR IT IN THE MUSEUM."
- ANTI-SOVIET?
OF COURSE.
DEGENERATE?
[scoffs] NO WAY.
THE NEXT DAY, AFTER THE COMMISSION LEFT,
I PUT IT ON THE WALL AGAIN.
IT WAS TOO GREAT A WORK OF ART TO HIDE.
- HERE IS ANOTHER PAINTING FROM OUR COLLECTION
DONE BY KOMAROVSKY.
HE WAS STUDYING ICON PAINTING.
UNFORTUNATELY, HIS LIFE WAS ENDED
DURING STALIN'S REPRESSIONS
FOR THE ONLY REASON: THAT HE BELIEVED IN GOD.
ALEXANDER NIKOLAEV WAS ALSO REPRESSED.
THE REASON WAS
HIS NONTRADITIONAL SEXUAL ORIENTATION.
- HE WAS ARRESTED AND IMPRISONED FOR HOMOSEXUALITY,
WHICH WAS CONSIDERED TO BE A CRIME IN STALIN'S RUSSIA.
- TWO YEARS AGO,
A NEW INFORMATION ABOUT THIS PAINTING CAME TO US.
WE REALIZED THAT THIS WAS ONLY PART OF THE PAINTING
MADE BY MIKHAIL KURZIN,
AND THE WHOLE PAINTING LOOKS LIKE THIS,
SO IT WAS A BIG DISCOVERY FOR US,
VERY UNEXPECTED.
WE DON'T KNOW WHO CUT THE PAINTING.
THE PHOTOGRAPH CAME FROM THE KGB ARCHIVES,
AND NOW WE LOOK AT THIS PAINTING WITH NEW EYES.
IN KURZIN'S CARICATURE OF WESTERN CAPITALISM,
THE MILLIONAIRES CRADLE THEIR SYMBOLS OF POWER
AGAINST THE BACKGROUND OF EXPLOITED WORKERS.
AT FIRST GLANCE, IT'S HARD TO UNDERSTAND
WHY THE SOVIET SECRET POLICE OBJECTED
TO THIS CRITICISM OF CAPITALISM,
BUT AS YOU TAKE A CLOSER LOOK,
KURZIN'S WORKERS BEAR A STRIKING RESEMBLANCE
TO THE ONES IN STALIN'S LABOR CAMPS.
YOU SEE THE SELF-PORTRAIT OF KURZIN HOLDING A COFFIN,
SO THIS IS A NARRATION OF HOPES,
OF THE DREAMS OF AN ARTIST IN THAT SOCIETY.
- "NOVEMBER 16, 1936,
"INTERROGATION OF THE DEFENDANT,
MIKHAIL IVANOVICH KURZIN.
"QUESTION: TELL THE INVESTIGATOR ABOUT YOUR ANTI-SOVIET SPEECH
"AT THE EXHIBITION OF THE ARTIST MAULT.
"ANSWER: I DON'T REMEMBER THE MATTER
"OF MY ANTI-SOVIET SPEECH,
BECAUSE I WAS DRUNK."
- MIKHAIL KURZIN TRIED TO FOLLOW THE SOVIET PATH
PAINTING FAKE, JOYOUS PEASANTS,
BUT HE COULDN'T STAND IT.
HE USED TO SAY THAT EVEN IN THE CAPITALIST WORLD,
THE ARTISTS ARE LIVING BETTER THAN HERE.
- "FROM THE INTERROGATION OF THE WITNESS
"ALEXANDER NIKOLAEVICH VOLKOV,
"ENCOURAGED TO TESTIFY AGAINST HIS FELLOW ARTIST
AND FRIEND KURZIN."
- IN CONVERSATIONS WITH ME,
KURZIN SAID THAT THE USSR
DOESN'T ALLOW FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION,
POINTING OUT THAT THERE ARE GREATER OPPORTUNITIES
FOR ARTISTS' CREATIVITY IN CAPITALIST COUNTRIES.
- WITNESS ALEXANDER NIKOLAEVICH VOLKOV:
- WE ARE SPEAKING SO MUCH ABOUT THE ARTISTS
WHO WERE REPRESSED IN STALIN'S TIME,
ALL THOSE TERRIBLE STORIES HOW THEY WERE SENT TO GULAGS
OR SOMEWHERE DRIVEN MAD,
BUT WHEN WE COME TO OUR OWN PERSONAL LIFE,
I REALIZED THAT WE ALSO HAVE
VERY MANY...
TRAGIC STORIES AROUND US.
MY FATHER HAD A VERY DIFFICULT LIFE.
HIS FATHER WAS SHOT IN 1938
AS THE ENEMY OF PEOPLE BEING THE PRESIDENT OF KARAKALPAKSTAN,
AND HE JUST WANTED HIS PEOPLE TO BLOSSOM, TO FLOURISH.
NADEZHDA BOROVAYA WAS SENT TO CONCENTRATION CAMP
AS THE WIFE OF AN ADMIRAL WHO WAS REPRESSED.
EVEN CHILDREN WERE SENT TO CONCENTRATION CAMPS,
TO WOMEN'S COLONIES.
ONCE IN 1983,
SAVITSKY PREPARED A BIG PORTION OF THE WORKS
FOR THE ATTENTION OF THE COMMISSION
FROM THE MINISTER OF CULTURE.
HE WAS TO PERSUADE THEM TO GIVE MONEY TO THE MUSEUM
SO THAT HE COULD PAY THE OWNERS.
ONE OF THE ARTISTS THAT WAS PUT ON THE AGENDA
WAS NADEZHDA BOROVAYA.
SAVITSKY WAS VERY TRICKY.
HE SAID THAT THESE WERE...
SHOWING ALL THOSE PEOPLE WHO WERE IN THE DRAWINGS
WITH THE NUMBERS ON THEIR FOREHEADS
AND TERRIBLE SCENES OF LIVES OF THOSE PRISONERS,
SO THE COMMISSION WAS PERSUADED.
THEY DECIDED TO PAY MONEY TO NADEZHDA BOROVAYA,
AND AFTER THE COMMISSION WENT AWAY,
SAVITSKY CAME TO ME AND WHISPERED INTO MY EAR
WITH A SMILE ON HIS FACE
THAT THESE WERE STALIN'S CONCENTRATION CAMPS,
AND I WAS SO SHOCKED.
LATER, I REALIZED THE EXTENT
OF DANGER HE EXPOSED HIMSELF.
- BOROVAYA'S WORKS WERE UNIQUE VISUAL EVIDENCE
OF THE REPRESSIONS.
I HAD TO MAKE SURE THAT ONE DAY PEOPLE COULD SEE THEM.
- MY FATHER WAS INVITED TO WORK
FOR THE REGIONAL COMMUNIST PARTY DEPARTMENT,
AND HE ADVISED SAVITSKY TO BE CAREFUL.
MY FATHER WAS SAYING,
"OH, ONE DAY, YOU WILL GET INTO THE JAIL."
BUT SAVITSKY'S OBSESSION WAS SO STRONG,
HE COULDN'T STOP.
SAVITSKY HEARD ABOUT THIS ARTIST,
URAL TANSYKBAEV, WHO WAS RECOGNIZED BY THE REGIME
AS THE MASTER OF SOCIALIST REALISM.
HE WAS AWARDED MANY STATE PRIZES.
- AT FIRST, I DIDN'T WANT TO GO TO TANSYKBAEV.
HE WAS A FAT CAT ENJOYING ALL THE PERKS
OF A PEOPLE'S ARTIST OF THE USSR.
IN RETURN, HE PAINTED WHAT HE WAS TOLD.
BUT THEN I DISCOVERED THAT TANSYKBAEV HAD BEEN
ONE OF VOLKOV'S FAVORITE STUDENTS.
SO I WENT TO TANSYKBAEV'S STUDIO.
THE WORKS WERE BORING,
BUT I SAW IMMEDIATELY THE HAND
OF SOMEONE WHO KNEW HOW TO PAINT.
HE WAS A BIT SUSPICIOUS OF MY MOTIVES
UNTIL WE FOUND THAT WE BOTH ADMIRED UZBEK FOLK CULTURE.
HE SHOWED ME WATERCOLORS OF VILLAGE LIFE
THAT HE'D DONE AS A YOUNG MAN.
I ASKED HIM IF THESE WERE ALL HE HAD.
- URAL TANSYKBAEV TOOK SAVITSKY INTO THE ATTIC,
OPENED A BIG CHEST,
AND SAVITSKY COULDN'T BELIEVE HIS EYES.
- I HAD STUMBLED UPON A WORLD CREATED BY THE MIND OF A GENIUS.
THESE WORKS THAT HADN'T BEEN EXHIBITED FOR MANY YEARS
SHOCKED ME WITH THEIR ORIGINALITY.
- WE CAN SEE HIS REAL SOUL IN HIS EARLY PAINTINGS.
- HE TOLD ME HOW MUCH HE ADMIRED VAN GOGH,
GAUGUIN, AND SEURAT.
BUT HIS SUBJECTS CAME FROM THE ORIENTAL CULTURE AROUND HIM.
- TANSYKBAEV SAID, "YOU CAN TAKE EVERYTHING,
WHAT YOU LIKE, AND YOU CAN PAY WHEN YOU CAN."
- I QUICKLY TOOK EVERY SINGLE WORK
BEFORE TANSYKBAEV CHANGED HIS MIND.
- NUKUS WAS SO FAR AWAY,
FAR FROM POLITICAL CULTURAL CENTERS.
MAYBE TANSYKBAEV THOUGHT THAT,
"WHO WILL SEE THESE PAINTINGS THERE?"
- ELENA KOROVAY WAS VERY MUCH INTERESTED
BY THE LIFE OF JEWS OF BUKHARA.
NOT THE FACT THAT THEY WERE ISOLATED AND LIVING IN GHETTOS,
BUT SHE SAW THE BEAUTY OF THEIR OCCUPATION.
WE CAN SEE WONDERFUL INDIGO COLORS OF HER DYERS...
OR TAILORS OF BUKHARA.
WE HAVE THE WHOLE CITIES OF THESE WORKS
THAT WERE CREATED BY HER DURING HER STAY IN UZBEKISTAN.
- [speaking Russian]
- FOR ME, KARAKALPAKS ARE INVENTED CREATURES
WITH THEIR CITY NUKUS IN A LAND FAR AWAY,
AND THERE'S SAVITSKY
WITH THE EYES OF A HOOLIGAN PERSUADING ME
THAT I AM OBLIGED TO DONATE TO HIS MUSEUM.
HE LOOKS AT THE PAINTINGS ATTENTIVELY,
METICULOUSLY,
EXAMINES THEM AGAIN AND AGAIN
AT A DISTANCE AND UP CLOSE
BUT DOESN'T GET TIRED.
AS ANY FANATIC, HE'S BORING, A LITTLE,
PRETENDING TO BE INTERESTED IN WHAT I HAVE TO SAY.
BUT I KNOW THE ONLY THING ON HIS MIND
IS GETTING ALL MY WORKS FOR HIS MUSEUM.
- I WOULD LEAVE MOSCOW WITH PILES OF AGING CANVASES
AND BOXES OF DRAWINGS.
I WAS SUCH A SIGHT THAT NO TAXI WOULD STOP FOR ME,
AND THE PORTERS GRUMBLED WHEN I APPEARED
AT THE TRAIN STATION.
- I HAD TRAVELED ACROSS MOTHER RUSSIA FOR THREE DAYS...
UNTIL THE TRAIN TRACKS RAN OUT.
THEN I'D CAMP OUT AND WAIT FOR A TRUCK
TO TRANSPORT ME AND MY TREASURES
ACROSS THE DESERT TO NUKUS.
- IT SEEMS VERY STRANGE THAT HE WOULD HAVE SUCH ENOUGH MONEY
TO HAVE BOUGHT ALL THE PAINTINGS THAT HE BOUGHT.
THESE ARE THOUSANDS OF PAINTINGS.
YES, HE HAD STATE SUBSIDIES FOR HIS MUSEUM,
BUT THOSE STATE SUBSIDIES WERE MEANT TO BE USED
FOR FINANCING EXPEDITIONS INTO THE DESERT,
NOT TO BE BUYING SILLY RUSSIAN ART.
- [speaking Russian]
- ONE CAN FIND ART ANYWHERE.
ALL YOU HAVE TO DO IS LOOK.
- [speaking Russian]
- SO SAVITSKY WAS GRABBED BY DR. EFUNI'S STAFF
AND BROUGHT AGAINST HIS WILL TO MOSCOW.
AND WHEN THEY CHECKED HIS LUNGS,
THEY UNDERSTOOD THAT THIS IS THE END.
THE WHOLE WARD WAS GIVEN TO THIS UNUSUAL PATIENT.
THEY EVEN ALLOWED HIM TO LEAVE THE WARD IF HE NEEDED.
SO WE KNOW THAT SAVITSKY MANAGED
TO COLLECT TWO CONTAINERS OF PAINTINGS AND GRAPHICS
WHILE HE WAS STAYING IN EFUNI'S HOSPITAL.
- [speaking Russian]
- [speaking Russian]
- WE USE THESE TRAYS BECAUSE THE CLIMATE IS VERY DRY IN SUMMER.
IT CAN BE PLUS 50 IN THE SHADOW.
AND WE NEED SOME KIND OF HUMIDIFIERS
FOR THE PAINTINGS.
THIS DOES NOT HELP MUCH, WE KNOW,
BUT THERE IS NO WAY OUT AT PRESENT.
THAT'S WHY WE ARE USING THIS PRIMITIVE METHOD
OF PUTTING VESSELS WITH WATER EVERYWHERE.
- WHEN SAVITSKY CAME TO ME AND SAID,
"I WANT YOU TO BE DIRECTOR," I COULDN'T SAY NO TO HIM.
THE NUKUS MUSEUM HAS BEEN MY LIFE'S WORK FOR 25 YEARS.
KARAKALPAKSTAN IS A VERY POOR COUNTRY,
AND THE ONLY TREASURE THAT IT HAS NOW
IS THIS MUSEUM.
- CENTRAL ASIA IS REALLY NOT A STABLE REGION,
AND UZBEKISTAN IS IN A VERY TURBULENT AREA.
OF COURSE, IT BORDERS ON AFGHANISTAN.
SOME OF THE SAME TRENDS THAT YOU SEE IN AFGHANISTAN
HAVE ALSO EMERGED IN UZBEKISTAN.
- REMEMBERING THE EVENTS IN AFGHANISTAN,
WHEN THOSE RADICALS DESTROYED BUDDHIST STATUES IN BAMYAN,
THIS MEANS DANGER FOR OUR COLLECTION.
[loud explosion]
- THE INFLUENCE OF ISLAMIC FUNDAMENTALISM
COULD GROW SUBSTANTIALLY.
HOW THAT WOULD AFFECT A COLLECTION OF ART
THAT IS ABSTRACT, MODERNISTIC,
AND THAT IS RUN BY A WOMAN COULD BE A LITTLE BIT DISTURBING.
- YOU CAN SEE PILES OF CANVASES
THAT ARE HANGING LIKE THIS.
THEY ARE REAL MASTERPIECES,
BUT THEY WERE NEVER SHOWN TO ANYONE,
BECAUSE THEY NEED TO BE RESTORED.
THEY NEED TO BE FRAMED.
WHEN WE LOOK AT THESE WONDERFUL PAINTINGS,
WE UNDERSTAND THAT PEOPLE ARE MISSING SO MUCH.
THEY CAN'T SEE ALL THESE TREASURES,
AND WE HAVE THOUSANDS OF WORKS LIKE THIS
IN OUR STORAGES.
- WHEN I FOUND THIS MUSEUM STORY,
I CALLED THE NEW YORK TIMES EDITOR,
AND SHE AGREED WITH ME THIS IS REALLY AN EXCLUSIVE.
THERE WERE GONNA BE A LOT OF PEOPLE CHOKING
ON THEIR ENGLISH MUFFINS OVER BREAKFAST ON SUNDAY
WHEN THEY READ THIS ONE.
- THE COLLECTORS FROM THE WEST STARTED TO COME
IN THEIR PRIVATE PLANES
BRINGING BAGS OF MONEY, SHOWING THIS TO US.
THEY WANTED THE BEST PIECES.
AND ALL THE FOREIGNERS USED TO SAY,
"WHY DON'T YOU SELL ONE OR TWO PAINTINGS?"
IT WAS A TRADITION FOR WESTERN MUSEUMS
TO SELL SOMETHING FROM THEIR COLLECTION
IN ORDER TO SETTLE THEIR PROBLEMS.
REMEMBERING THE BIOGRAPHIES OF THE ARTISTS,
THEY WERE SO UNHAPPY DURING THEIR LIVES.
THEY FOUND SHELTER IN NUKUS,
AND EVEN TO THINK OF SELLING THEM SOMEWHERE
WAS VERY DIFFICULT FOR US.
- I VISITED ANOTHER MUSEUM IN ANOTHER CITY
FULL OF ARTIFACTS FROM UZBEK HISTORY,
FANTASTIC FABRICS AND WEAVINGS.
SUDDENLY, A GUY CAME OVER TO ME,
AND THIS WAS THE MUSEUM DIRECTOR.
AND I POINTED TO A WEAVING, AND I SAID,
"THIS IS A SPECTACULAR PIECE OF ART."
AND HE LOOKED AT ME, AND HE SAID, "YOU WANT TO BUY IT?"
AND I SAID, "WHAT?"
- HE SAID, "IF YOU WANT TO TAKE IT,
HOW MUCH WOULD YOU PAY FOR IT?"
SO ESSENTIALLY, WHAT HE WAS SAYING IS,
"COME LOOT MY MUSEUM."
THE IDEA THAT YOU'D BE AN IMPOVERISHED DIRECTOR
OF AN IMPOVERISHED MUSEUM
THAT HAD PILES OF STUFF THAT COULDN'T EVEN EXHIBIT
BUT YOU WOULDN'T SELL A SINGLE PIECE
MUST HAVE BEEN UNIQUE TO MARINIKA.
- SAVITSKY USED TO SAY,
"KEEP THIS COLLECTION TOGETHER BY ALL MEANS.
"ONE DAY, PEOPLE WILL TOTALLY UNDERSTAND THE IMPORTANCE
OF THE MUSEUM."
- I LIKE TO THINK OF OUR MUSEUM
AS A KEEPER OF THE ARTISTS' SOULS.
THEIR WORKS ARE THE PHYSICAL EXPRESSION
OF A COLLECTIVE VISION THAT COULD NOT BE DESTROYED.
Captioning by CaptionMax www.captionmax.com
WE ARE A TEAM BROUGHT UP BY SAVITSKY,
WHO ARE VERY DEDICATED TO THE MUSEUM WORK,
BUT WE ARE PEOPLE OF PRE-PENSION AGE.
OUR CURATORS ARE PAID $30 A MONTH.
Narrator: ALVINA SHPADE
HAS WORKED AT THE MUSEUM FOR 41 YEARS,
BUT NOW SHE CAN NO LONGER RESTORE THE ART.
THE RESTORATION LAB, AND A LARGE PART OF THE COLLECTION,
HAVE LOST THEIR HOME.
THE UZBEK GOVERNMENT HAS DESIGNATED
ONE OF THE TWO MUSEUM BUILDINGS FOR DEMOLITION, WITHOUT WARNING,
WITH NO ALTERNATIVE PLANS FOR HOUSING THE ARTWORKS.
FURTHERMORE, THE NUKUS MUSEUM DIRECTOR,
MARINIKA BABANAZAROVA,
WAS FORBIDDEN TO TRAVEL TO THE U.S.
FOR THE PREMIERE OF THE FILM
AT THE NATIONAL GALLERY IN WASHINGTON, D.C.
AT THE TIME OF THIS BROADCAST DEADLINE,
THE GOVERNMENT HAS DECLINED TO RESPOND TO MEDIA INQUIRIES
REGARDING THEIR ACTIONS.
Babanazarova: I AM REALLY HAVING
VERY SAD THOUGHTS ABOUT THE FUTURE OF THE MUSEUM.
BUT I WANT TO BELIEVE
THAT THIS MUSEUM
WOULD BE SAFE
AND PEOPLE IN OUR COUNTRY
WILL UNDERSTAND THE VALUE
OF THIS COLLECTION.
AS FOR ME, I WILL TRY
TO DO MY BEST, AS FAR AS I CAN DO THIS.
- COMING SOON TO INDEPENDENT LENS...
- WHAT'S YOUR LAST NAME, SWEETHEART?
- BASQUIAT.
announcer: JEAN-MICHEL BASQUIAT WAS A PHENOMENON,
BUT BEING YOUNG, BLACK,
AND THE WORLD'S MOST FAMOUS ARTIST
CAME WITH A PRICE.
- THE PRESSURE OF THAT ARTIFICIAL WORLD
MADE IT DIFFICULT FOR HIM TO DO SOMETHING.
announcer: AN INTIMATE PORTRAIT OF YOUTH,
PASSION, TRAGEDY, AND FAME.
- SEE YOU NEXT TIME ON INDEPENDENT LENS.
announcer: CONNECT WITH INDEPENDENT LENS ONLINE
AT PBS.ORG.
MEET OTHER INDIE FILM FANS, SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS,
WATCH VIDEOS, AND EXPLORE INTERACTIVE FEATURES.
THERE'S ALWAYS MORE TO EVERY PROGRAM
ON OUR WEBSITE.
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.