Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:03,457 --> 00:00:07,471
[narrator]: In Toronto's
war on crime,
2
00:00:07,472 --> 00:00:10,023
the worst offenders are pursued
by the detectives
3
00:00:10,024 --> 00:00:12,851
of the Specialized Criminal
Investigations Unit.
4
00:00:12,852 --> 00:00:14,368
These are their stories.
5
00:00:14,369 --> 00:00:15,540
[echoing gavel]
6
00:00:15,541 --> 00:00:17,678
[tense music]
- Cara.
7
00:00:17,679 --> 00:00:20,057
Cara?
8
00:00:20,058 --> 00:00:22,851
Sometimes we have to admit
what we've done
9
00:00:22,852 --> 00:00:24,816
in order to move on.
10
00:00:24,817 --> 00:00:27,540
- Guess I won't be
moving on then.
11
00:00:27,541 --> 00:00:29,333
Because I didn't do anything.
12
00:00:29,334 --> 00:00:30,886
[laughing]
13
00:00:32,196 --> 00:00:33,645
- I believe you.
14
00:00:37,610 --> 00:00:39,471
- Watch your back, girl.
15
00:00:39,472 --> 00:00:41,092
- Baby killing bitch!
16
00:00:41,093 --> 00:00:42,920
- Come on, Melville,
we'll take the tunnel back.
17
00:00:42,921 --> 00:00:43,954
- Okay, let's settle down
ladies.
18
00:00:43,955 --> 00:00:45,954
- Let's go!
- I got eyes on you.
19
00:00:45,955 --> 00:00:48,231
[door squeaking opens]
20
00:00:50,231 --> 00:00:52,576
[door shutting]
21
00:00:53,058 --> 00:00:55,540
- Guard? What...
22
00:00:55,541 --> 00:00:57,610
[tense music]
23
00:00:58,196 --> 00:01:01,161
[lights click on]
24
00:01:01,162 --> 00:01:03,644
[gasping]
25
00:01:03,645 --> 00:01:06,057
[shouting]
26
00:01:06,058 --> 00:01:09,092
[grunting]
27
00:01:09,093 --> 00:01:12,368
- So you think broken ribs
contributed to the baby's death?
28
00:01:12,369 --> 00:01:15,954
- Injuries an adult
could survive
29
00:01:15,955 --> 00:01:17,920
might be fatal for a child.
30
00:01:17,921 --> 00:01:19,747
So while rib fractures
in general
31
00:01:19,748 --> 00:01:21,126
aren't considered
life threatening,
32
00:01:21,127 --> 00:01:24,023
as the defence expert suggested,
33
00:01:24,024 --> 00:01:26,092
in the case of an infant...
34
00:01:26,093 --> 00:01:27,609
they may be deadly.
35
00:01:27,610 --> 00:01:29,885
- Thank you, Doctor Plath.
36
00:01:29,886 --> 00:01:31,782
- Look what just came
in from Innocence Canada.
37
00:01:31,783 --> 00:01:33,678
- I can't take on any more
cases right now.
38
00:01:33,679 --> 00:01:35,230
- It's about Cara Melville.
39
00:01:35,231 --> 00:01:38,713
[suspenseful music]
40
00:01:38,714 --> 00:01:41,195
- What do you mean,
Cara's getting a new hearing?
41
00:01:41,196 --> 00:01:42,575
What, like parole?
42
00:01:42,576 --> 00:01:44,437
- It's more than just parole,
Mr. Melville.
43
00:01:44,438 --> 00:01:46,195
- What's going on, dad?
44
00:01:46,196 --> 00:01:48,955
- Uh, it's nothing, Audrey.
It's nothing.
45
00:01:50,955 --> 00:01:52,540
Detective Dreyfus,
46
00:01:52,541 --> 00:01:55,299
my ex-wife has only
served a year
47
00:01:55,300 --> 00:01:56,920
for killing
our six-month-old child.
48
00:01:56,921 --> 00:01:58,437
How is that possible?
49
00:01:58,438 --> 00:02:00,609
- They're saying
we missed evidence.
50
00:02:00,610 --> 00:02:05,023
- Due to the potentially
exculpatory evidence
51
00:02:05,024 --> 00:02:08,609
that was not disclosed at
Cara Melville's original trial,
52
00:02:08,610 --> 00:02:10,989
a blonde hair found
on the victim,
53
00:02:10,990 --> 00:02:13,782
six-month-old,
Izzy Melville,
54
00:02:13,783 --> 00:02:17,195
this court has decided
to release Cara Melville
55
00:02:17,196 --> 00:02:19,540
on bail, pending appeal.
[disapproving grunts]
56
00:02:19,541 --> 00:02:22,299
I am satisfied that
there is merit
57
00:02:22,300 --> 00:02:25,162
and she is not a flight risk.
58
00:02:25,163 --> 00:02:28,782
- We won the battle today,
but not the war.
59
00:02:28,783 --> 00:02:30,023
So you sit tight at the motel
60
00:02:30,024 --> 00:02:31,678
and let me focus
on winning your appeal-
61
00:02:31,679 --> 00:02:33,333
- Cara. Cara!
- Dad, please.
62
00:02:33,334 --> 00:02:34,609
- Mr. Melville,
give her some space.
63
00:02:34,610 --> 00:02:36,264
- Stay out of this!
64
00:02:36,265 --> 00:02:37,954
You will not get away with this.
65
00:02:37,955 --> 00:02:39,471
You think one hair
is gonna free you?
66
00:02:39,472 --> 00:02:41,989
- I have way more than one hair,
Tate.
67
00:02:41,990 --> 00:02:46,782
[suspenseful music]
68
00:02:46,783 --> 00:02:49,092
- I went through a lot of
red tape to get this.
69
00:02:49,093 --> 00:02:51,368
I hope you know
what you're doing.
70
00:02:51,369 --> 00:02:52,575
- Thank you, Ms. Shuter.
71
00:02:52,576 --> 00:02:56,092
[pensive music]
72
00:02:56,093 --> 00:02:58,679
[tapping on keyboard]
73
00:03:01,403 --> 00:03:05,714
[suspenseful music]
74
00:03:13,507 --> 00:03:16,162
[soft gasping]
75
00:03:18,955 --> 00:03:20,264
What do you want?
76
00:03:20,265 --> 00:03:21,714
- We need to talk.
77
00:03:27,196 --> 00:03:29,886
[door opening]
[gasping]
78
00:03:31,162 --> 00:03:33,920
[tense music]
79
00:03:33,921 --> 00:03:35,368
[knocking at door]
80
00:03:35,369 --> 00:03:37,024
- Ms. Melville?
81
00:03:39,231 --> 00:03:41,231
Ms. Melville?
82
00:03:42,679 --> 00:03:44,333
Hey, it's Management.
83
00:03:44,334 --> 00:03:46,023
I just need to check
your breaker.
84
00:03:46,024 --> 00:03:47,714
I'm coming in.
85
00:03:51,472 --> 00:03:54,300
[tense music continues]
86
00:03:59,472 --> 00:04:01,609
[muttering]: What the hell?
87
00:04:01,610 --> 00:04:05,231
[slow, continuous dripping]
88
00:04:17,852 --> 00:04:20,127
Jesus Christ.
89
00:04:22,231 --> 00:04:25,058
[theme song]
90
00:04:59,273 --> 00:05:04,437
- Sorry to get you guys out here
in the middle of the night,
91
00:05:04,438 --> 00:05:05,851
but we've got a weird one
on our hands.
92
00:05:05,852 --> 00:05:07,092
- You know what they say...
93
00:05:07,093 --> 00:05:08,506
- No rest for the wicked?
94
00:05:08,507 --> 00:05:10,333
Excuse me, sir.
Are you the manager?
95
00:05:10,334 --> 00:05:12,161
- Yeah.
Hi, I'm Jonas.
96
00:05:12,162 --> 00:05:14,299
- Detective Bateman.
This is Detective Graff.
97
00:05:14,300 --> 00:05:16,540
- Yeah, look,
I didn't do anything. Okay?
98
00:05:16,541 --> 00:05:18,161
The power went out
around eight,
99
00:05:18,162 --> 00:05:20,471
so I went in to flip the breaker
and she was already dead, man.
100
00:05:20,472 --> 00:05:22,126
It's like the freaking
shining in there.
101
00:05:22,127 --> 00:05:23,575
- Alright, thanks, Jonas.
102
00:05:23,576 --> 00:05:26,333
You can give your statement
to the officer over there.
103
00:05:26,334 --> 00:05:28,437
- You might wanna, uh,
check his phone for photos.
104
00:05:28,438 --> 00:05:29,713
- Yeah.
105
00:05:29,714 --> 00:05:32,402
- Got a name on the victim?
- Cara Melville.
106
00:05:32,403 --> 00:05:35,782
- As in the, uh,
just got bail after
107
00:05:35,783 --> 00:05:37,782
being imprisoned
for killing her kid,
108
00:05:37,783 --> 00:05:39,644
Cara Melville?
- Yup.
109
00:05:39,645 --> 00:05:41,816
Told you it was weird.
110
00:05:41,817 --> 00:05:44,816
[suspenseful music]
111
00:05:44,817 --> 00:05:46,713
Jonas found Cara in the tub.
112
00:05:46,714 --> 00:05:49,402
Her head was there,
her feet were there.
113
00:05:49,403 --> 00:05:51,299
EMT tried to save her, but...
114
00:05:51,300 --> 00:05:55,195
- But a hairdryer in the bath
is instant death?
115
00:05:55,196 --> 00:05:56,782
- Yeah.
116
00:05:56,783 --> 00:05:58,644
Blew the motel's power too,
117
00:05:58,645 --> 00:06:01,299
which tells us two things.
This place isn't up to code
118
00:06:01,300 --> 00:06:04,678
and the time of death was
8 PM when the lights went out.
119
00:06:04,679 --> 00:06:06,057
- And she's been living here
120
00:06:06,058 --> 00:06:07,678
ever since she left
prison, yeah?
121
00:06:07,679 --> 00:06:10,264
- Broke, divorced, no family.
122
00:06:10,265 --> 00:06:11,851
She had nowhere else to go.
123
00:06:11,852 --> 00:06:14,955
- And something tells me
she was safer on the inside.
124
00:06:16,058 --> 00:06:17,885
Any, uh, forced entry?
125
00:06:17,886 --> 00:06:19,264
- Jonas said the door
was locked,
126
00:06:19,265 --> 00:06:21,092
but it's one of those
cheap push buttons,
127
00:06:21,093 --> 00:06:23,195
so anyone could have popped it
in on their way out.
128
00:06:23,196 --> 00:06:24,609
There's still cash in her purse,
129
00:06:24,610 --> 00:06:26,299
so it doesn't seem
like a botched robbery.
130
00:06:26,300 --> 00:06:27,747
- What about CCTV?
131
00:06:27,748 --> 00:06:30,023
- Security cameras are broken.
- Hmm.
132
00:06:30,024 --> 00:06:31,816
- That's why I called you.
I can't tell if
133
00:06:31,817 --> 00:06:35,713
this is an accident, foul play,
or self-inflicted.
134
00:06:35,714 --> 00:06:37,782
- Well, if Cara was so close
to real freedom,
135
00:06:37,783 --> 00:06:40,333
why would she end it all
with a hairdryer?
136
00:06:40,334 --> 00:06:43,057
- Well, this doesn't seem
like surrender to me.
137
00:06:43,058 --> 00:06:45,575
Looks like a fight.
138
00:06:45,576 --> 00:06:47,920
That cut on her head
wasn't caused by
139
00:06:47,921 --> 00:06:50,540
flailing or falling in the tub.
140
00:06:50,541 --> 00:06:52,644
- And the tile's too smooth.
141
00:06:52,645 --> 00:06:54,954
Her skin's split.
It's a vertical laceration,
142
00:06:54,955 --> 00:06:57,065
so she must've hit her head
on a sharp edge.
143
00:06:57,783 --> 00:06:59,334
- Okay.
144
00:07:00,024 --> 00:07:03,713
Well, for her sake, let's make
the, uh, invisible visible.
145
00:07:03,714 --> 00:07:05,713
Play this out with me.
- Okay, let's give it a whirl.
146
00:07:05,714 --> 00:07:07,506
I'm Cara.
Cara's in the bathroom.
147
00:07:07,507 --> 00:07:11,300
- Okay. Killer enters.
148
00:07:11,783 --> 00:07:13,609
Makes a sound.
149
00:07:13,610 --> 00:07:15,471
- Cara hears the noise,
opens the door.
150
00:07:15,472 --> 00:07:17,609
- Killer pounces.
Fast.
151
00:07:17,610 --> 00:07:20,506
- Right. There's no signs of
a struggle, so killer grabs her,
152
00:07:20,507 --> 00:07:22,437
knocks her head
into this doorframe.
153
00:07:22,438 --> 00:07:24,851
Now, she's about my height,
so that would be...
154
00:07:24,852 --> 00:07:25,954
there?
155
00:07:25,955 --> 00:07:28,437
I mean, there's no blood.
156
00:07:28,438 --> 00:07:30,954
- Yeah, looks like
it's been wiped by, uh,
157
00:07:30,955 --> 00:07:33,954
something that's messed
with the paint there.
158
00:07:33,955 --> 00:07:36,506
We're gonna need, uh,
a photo and swab of this mark.
159
00:07:36,507 --> 00:07:37,885
- Copy.
160
00:07:37,886 --> 00:07:40,782
[sighing]
- Okay, so Cara's knocked out.
161
00:07:40,783 --> 00:07:42,920
Killer throws her
into the tub and then
162
00:07:42,921 --> 00:07:44,954
chucks the hairdryer
in after her.
163
00:07:44,955 --> 00:07:48,162
- He then leaves under the cover
of darkness.
164
00:07:48,748 --> 00:07:51,782
Okay. So. Who?
165
00:07:51,783 --> 00:07:54,023
Who had it out for Cara?
166
00:07:54,024 --> 00:07:56,093
[suspenseful music]
167
00:07:57,403 --> 00:07:59,264
- Is this her ex-husband?
168
00:07:59,265 --> 00:08:01,714
- Yeah, that's Tate Melville.
169
00:08:03,093 --> 00:08:05,333
[echoing gavel]
170
00:08:05,334 --> 00:08:07,230
- My dad's in Kingston
for a job.
171
00:08:07,231 --> 00:08:09,057
Early morning hot tub install.
172
00:08:09,058 --> 00:08:10,299
He drove out there last night.
173
00:08:10,300 --> 00:08:12,230
Why?
174
00:08:12,231 --> 00:08:15,126
- Audrey, are you aware of what
happened to your former stepmom?
175
00:08:15,127 --> 00:08:18,747
- I never wanna hear anything
about Cara ever again.
176
00:08:18,748 --> 00:08:21,333
She's the worst thing
that ever happened to my dad.
177
00:08:21,334 --> 00:08:23,747
- Unfortunately,
we have to inform you
178
00:08:23,748 --> 00:08:26,057
that, uh, Cara was murdered
last night.
179
00:08:26,058 --> 00:08:28,506
At the motel
where she was living.
180
00:08:28,507 --> 00:08:30,540
- What?
181
00:08:30,541 --> 00:08:32,747
Wait, you guys don't think
182
00:08:32,748 --> 00:08:35,230
my dad had something
to do with this, do you?
183
00:08:35,231 --> 00:08:36,575
- We just need to speak
with him.
184
00:08:36,576 --> 00:08:38,161
- He didn't do anything.
185
00:08:38,162 --> 00:08:40,885
A lot of people were upset
that Cara got bail.
186
00:08:40,886 --> 00:08:43,195
Me, my dad, Detective Dreyfus.
187
00:08:43,196 --> 00:08:44,747
Oh, and in case you
were wondering,
188
00:08:44,748 --> 00:08:46,747
I was at school last night,
George Brown.
189
00:08:46,748 --> 00:08:48,333
- We're not accusing you,
Audrey.
190
00:08:48,334 --> 00:08:52,057
- Good.
I don't wanna talk anymore.
191
00:08:52,058 --> 00:08:53,885
[tense music]
192
00:08:53,886 --> 00:08:55,161
- It's alright.
193
00:08:55,162 --> 00:08:57,782
If you, uh, just ask your dad
to give us a call
194
00:08:57,783 --> 00:08:59,472
when he gets in.
195
00:09:00,955 --> 00:09:03,575
- Tate was angry Cara got out.
196
00:09:03,576 --> 00:09:05,920
But he wouldn't do this.
197
00:09:05,921 --> 00:09:08,437
He's a good, hardworking man.
198
00:09:08,438 --> 00:09:09,816
- But Tate's in the wind.
199
00:09:09,817 --> 00:09:12,437
- And his ex-wife allegedly
killed their kid,
200
00:09:12,438 --> 00:09:15,126
I mean, it looks like motive
to me, Detective Dreyfus.
201
00:09:15,127 --> 00:09:16,437
- Allegedly?
202
00:09:16,438 --> 00:09:19,609
- And what's up with this,
uh, missing hair?
203
00:09:19,610 --> 00:09:20,920
How'd it get her an appeal?
204
00:09:20,921 --> 00:09:22,402
- The hair wasn't entered
into evidence
205
00:09:22,403 --> 00:09:23,782
because I didn't see it.
206
00:09:23,783 --> 00:09:25,540
Neither did Doctor Plath.
207
00:09:25,541 --> 00:09:26,989
[papers rustling]
- Here are my autopsy photos
208
00:09:26,990 --> 00:09:28,402
from when I examined the victim.
209
00:09:28,403 --> 00:09:30,333
[sighing]
As you can see,
210
00:09:30,334 --> 00:09:33,333
there are no blonde hairs
on Izzy's hand.
211
00:09:33,334 --> 00:09:35,989
- And this is the police photo
taken in the ER
212
00:09:35,990 --> 00:09:38,126
after resuscitation
efforts ceased.
213
00:09:38,127 --> 00:09:40,299
Do you see any hairs
around the hand?
214
00:09:40,300 --> 00:09:42,609
[grunting]: Well, maybe see
something
215
00:09:42,610 --> 00:09:45,264
near the middle finger?
But I can't be sure.
216
00:09:45,265 --> 00:09:47,678
- Imagine you're in the ER
a few feet from the body,
217
00:09:47,679 --> 00:09:49,989
you can understand why
I didn't see it back then.
218
00:09:49,990 --> 00:09:51,782
- Yeah.
- Neither did the coroner.
219
00:09:51,783 --> 00:09:53,057
- Yes, the body and bedding
220
00:09:53,058 --> 00:09:55,057
were bagged and brought
to me directly.
221
00:09:55,058 --> 00:09:56,540
We're checking through
that old evidence
222
00:09:56,541 --> 00:09:57,506
to see if it was missed.
223
00:09:57,507 --> 00:09:58,678
- We know who didn't miss it,
224
00:09:58,679 --> 00:09:59,989
was Innocence Canada.
225
00:09:59,990 --> 00:10:02,368
- Cara contacted them
after she went to prison.
226
00:10:02,369 --> 00:10:04,437
They went through her file,
looking for a way
227
00:10:04,438 --> 00:10:05,540
to get her out.
228
00:10:05,541 --> 00:10:08,816
Now, at 300 times magnification,
229
00:10:08,817 --> 00:10:11,471
guess the blonde hair's
pretty clear.
230
00:10:11,472 --> 00:10:12,920
[Bates]: Yeah.
[sighing]
231
00:10:12,921 --> 00:10:15,092
Okay, so this picture
proved that some evidence
232
00:10:15,093 --> 00:10:18,644
went undisclosed and that was
enough to get Cara her appeal?
233
00:10:18,645 --> 00:10:22,644
- Hmm. That and the testimony
of the ER doctor, Garvey.
234
00:10:22,645 --> 00:10:24,540
Supposedly,
he remembered seeing it,
235
00:10:24,541 --> 00:10:26,816
but he didn't mention that
to me at the time.
236
00:10:26,817 --> 00:10:29,747
Honestly, I think the hair
is a contaminant.
237
00:10:29,748 --> 00:10:32,816
Wasn't Audrey's or Cara's
'cause both are brunette.
238
00:10:32,817 --> 00:10:35,264
- And-and Tate was out
of town on business.
239
00:10:35,265 --> 00:10:36,264
- Yes.
240
00:10:36,265 --> 00:10:37,954
Cara was an alcoholic.
241
00:10:37,955 --> 00:10:39,471
She fell off the wagon.
242
00:10:39,472 --> 00:10:42,057
Guess Izzy wasn't easy
to be alone with.
243
00:10:42,058 --> 00:10:44,816
- Medical report indicate
she suffered from colic.
244
00:10:44,817 --> 00:10:46,230
- Cara needed a break.
245
00:10:46,231 --> 00:10:49,506
She contacted Audrey
to watch Izzy, went drinking.
246
00:10:49,507 --> 00:10:51,575
She got back by 10 PM,
247
00:10:51,576 --> 00:10:53,575
sent Audrey home
to her mom's house.
248
00:10:53,576 --> 00:10:55,540
She woke up at five
in the morning
249
00:10:55,541 --> 00:10:57,161
to find Izzy convulsing.
250
00:10:57,162 --> 00:10:58,644
- Subdural hematoma.
251
00:10:58,645 --> 00:11:00,437
Shaken baby syndrome.
252
00:11:00,438 --> 00:11:01,713
With trauma like that,
253
00:11:01,714 --> 00:11:03,954
the timeline between
injury and death
254
00:11:03,955 --> 00:11:05,161
is four to six hours.
255
00:11:05,162 --> 00:11:08,024
- Cara was alone
with Izzy for seven.
256
00:11:08,196 --> 00:11:09,851
So you do the math.
257
00:11:09,852 --> 00:11:13,714
- Okay. So you think Cara
got out on a technicality.
258
00:11:15,127 --> 00:11:16,877
Did you happen to tell
her ex that?
259
00:11:18,921 --> 00:11:20,782
[sighing]
260
00:11:20,783 --> 00:11:22,713
- Dad, I've been calling
and texting!
261
00:11:22,714 --> 00:11:26,023
- I know, I know, I'm sorry.
Come here, come here.
262
00:11:26,024 --> 00:11:27,989
- Feels like it's happening
all over again.
263
00:11:27,990 --> 00:11:29,506
- Hey, hey. It's not.
264
00:11:29,507 --> 00:11:31,195
I promise it's over.
265
00:11:31,196 --> 00:11:33,816
It's all over now, okay?
266
00:11:33,817 --> 00:11:35,816
[suspenseful music]
267
00:11:35,817 --> 00:11:37,816
- What do you mean,
it's over now?
268
00:11:37,817 --> 00:11:39,230
[grunting]
269
00:11:39,231 --> 00:11:40,851
- Means I'll take care
of the cops,
270
00:11:40,852 --> 00:11:42,747
you don't have to deal
with any of that.
271
00:11:42,748 --> 00:11:45,023
- Did you go see Cara
last night?
272
00:11:45,024 --> 00:11:46,230
- Why would I do that?
273
00:11:46,231 --> 00:11:47,885
- To see if
she was telling the truth?
274
00:11:47,886 --> 00:11:52,057
- No, listen, the truth
is that Cara killed Izzy.
275
00:11:52,058 --> 00:11:54,471
And nothing's gonna change that.
276
00:11:54,472 --> 00:11:56,024
Okay?
- Okay.
277
00:11:57,024 --> 00:11:58,540
[kissing]
278
00:11:58,541 --> 00:11:59,714
- It'll be okay, Audrey.
279
00:12:00,748 --> 00:12:03,369
[suspenseful music]
280
00:12:06,058 --> 00:12:09,230
- A grief-stricken father riled
up by an irate detective...
281
00:12:09,231 --> 00:12:11,920
- Goes to Cara's hotel
to exact revenge.
282
00:12:11,921 --> 00:12:14,920
Pretty good place to kill
somebody and get away with it.
283
00:12:14,921 --> 00:12:16,920
- Yeah, the room is basically
a dirty bomb with DNA,
284
00:12:16,921 --> 00:12:18,264
it'll be hard to find
a real suspect.
285
00:12:18,265 --> 00:12:19,885
- Ordinarily,
I'd agree with you.
286
00:12:19,886 --> 00:12:22,230
Everyone and their mother
has been in that room.
287
00:12:22,231 --> 00:12:23,885
But I found something
under Cara's nails.
288
00:12:23,886 --> 00:12:25,851
Foreign DNA.
289
00:12:25,852 --> 00:12:27,506
She might have scratched
her attacker.
290
00:12:27,507 --> 00:12:29,437
[papers rustling]
291
00:12:29,438 --> 00:12:32,437
[echoing gavel]
292
00:12:32,438 --> 00:12:34,023
- Look, I don't know
what happened to Cara,
293
00:12:34,024 --> 00:12:35,954
I was in Kingston.
294
00:12:35,955 --> 00:12:38,747
Can we do this later?
I have a job this afternoon.
295
00:12:38,748 --> 00:12:41,471
- No, I'd prefer to talk
now because that, uh,
296
00:12:41,472 --> 00:12:43,782
that bandage?
On your neck there?
297
00:12:43,783 --> 00:12:45,092
That might tell
a different story.
298
00:12:45,093 --> 00:12:46,609
- Oh, yeah? What's it gonna say?
299
00:12:46,610 --> 00:12:48,851
- That you were maybe
with Cara last night?
300
00:12:48,852 --> 00:12:50,471
[scoffing]
301
00:12:50,472 --> 00:12:52,713
- Cara scratched someone
before she was killed.
302
00:12:52,714 --> 00:12:55,609
Skin cells under the fingernails
and if those cells
303
00:12:55,610 --> 00:12:58,126
happened to belong to you
and you're not cooperating,
304
00:12:58,127 --> 00:12:59,782
you know,
it just doesn't look good.
305
00:12:59,783 --> 00:13:00,816
- Fine.
306
00:13:00,817 --> 00:13:03,368
Fine. I was with Cara
last night.
307
00:13:03,369 --> 00:13:06,437
We argued and she scratched me,
but I didn't kill her.
308
00:13:06,438 --> 00:13:08,816
- You sure?
- Yes. I swear.
309
00:13:08,817 --> 00:13:11,127
I was on the road.
You can check my GPS.
310
00:13:12,127 --> 00:13:14,748
Look, I know it sounds bad,
but I just...
311
00:13:15,714 --> 00:13:17,402
needed to know the truth.
312
00:13:17,403 --> 00:13:19,299
- The truth about what, Tate?
313
00:13:19,300 --> 00:13:20,644
[Tate sighing]
314
00:13:20,645 --> 00:13:23,195
- After the hearing,
Cara said something weird.
315
00:13:23,196 --> 00:13:28,126
She said that she had more than
one hair to exonerate herself.
316
00:13:28,127 --> 00:13:29,920
- Well, if she had
new evidence,
317
00:13:29,921 --> 00:13:33,057
new information wh-why didn't
she bring it up at the hearing?
318
00:13:33,058 --> 00:13:35,989
- Well, that's what Plath
and Dreyfus said, but...
319
00:13:35,990 --> 00:13:38,989
I couldn't get it out of
my head, so I went to the motel,
320
00:13:38,990 --> 00:13:40,471
she wouldn't tell me,
said she couldn't
321
00:13:40,472 --> 00:13:42,161
because she hadn't collected
enough evidence yet.
322
00:13:42,162 --> 00:13:44,161
- Tate, did Cara think
323
00:13:44,162 --> 00:13:46,161
that someone else
killed your daughter?
324
00:13:46,162 --> 00:13:50,713
- Apparently. She was collecting
proof on some hard drive.
325
00:13:50,714 --> 00:13:52,747
But it was stolen.
326
00:13:52,748 --> 00:13:54,713
How convenient, right?
327
00:13:54,714 --> 00:13:57,195
- Where was this drive
stolen from?
328
00:13:57,196 --> 00:14:00,333
- Uh, a public library the day
before she died.
329
00:14:00,334 --> 00:14:01,644
- Which library?
330
00:14:01,645 --> 00:14:04,057
- I don't know, I-
331
00:14:04,058 --> 00:14:05,713
[phone ringing]
332
00:14:05,714 --> 00:14:07,402
This is Audrey.
Do you mind?
333
00:14:07,403 --> 00:14:09,713
- Of course.
- Hey.
334
00:14:09,714 --> 00:14:11,540
Yeah. Yeah, okay.
335
00:14:11,541 --> 00:14:14,644
- What if, uh,
Cara did have new evidence?
336
00:14:14,645 --> 00:14:16,782
I mean, she'd only just
found out about the hair.
337
00:14:16,783 --> 00:14:18,954
Maybe she had a hunch as to...
338
00:14:18,955 --> 00:14:20,471
who it belonged to.
339
00:14:20,472 --> 00:14:22,851
- Hmm, someone she knew.
And if that someone knew
340
00:14:22,852 --> 00:14:23,989
that Cara was on to them,
341
00:14:23,990 --> 00:14:26,645
that is a reason
to steal a drive.
342
00:14:26,646 --> 00:14:29,368
We're gonna have to check out
every library in the city
343
00:14:29,369 --> 00:14:30,540
to find a thief, aren't we?
344
00:14:30,541 --> 00:14:32,411
- You make that sound
like a bad thing.
345
00:14:33,127 --> 00:14:34,817
[sighing]
346
00:14:38,541 --> 00:14:40,195
- Tate's alibi is solid.
347
00:14:40,196 --> 00:14:42,264
We caught him on camera
348
00:14:42,265 --> 00:14:44,333
at a gas station
near Oshawa at 8 PM.
349
00:14:44,334 --> 00:14:45,782
You found Cara?
350
00:14:45,783 --> 00:14:48,678
- Security footage came
in from the library she went to.
351
00:14:48,679 --> 00:14:51,954
- Yeah, confirms Cara was at
this branch every day for a week
352
00:14:51,955 --> 00:14:54,816
before she died, researching
on their computers.
353
00:14:54,817 --> 00:14:56,644
- We know what
she was looking at?
354
00:14:56,645 --> 00:14:57,954
- No idea.
355
00:14:57,955 --> 00:14:59,230
The history auto clears
on these terminals,
356
00:14:59,231 --> 00:15:01,609
but this was the day
before she was killed.
357
00:15:01,610 --> 00:15:02,885
- And lookie-loo.
358
00:15:02,886 --> 00:15:05,817
Our blonde drive thief
approaches.
359
00:15:06,763 --> 00:15:12,057
- If the hair that was found
on Izzy came from this guy,
360
00:15:12,058 --> 00:15:14,816
we could be looking
at a real killer.
361
00:15:14,817 --> 00:15:17,402
- Yeah and if, uh,
Cara had something on that drive
362
00:15:17,403 --> 00:15:20,575
that further proved
he was responsible...
363
00:15:20,576 --> 00:15:23,299
we may be looking
at Cara's killer, too.
364
00:15:23,300 --> 00:15:25,196
[suspenseful music]
365
00:15:30,921 --> 00:15:34,678
- So, you think Cara suspected
someone else of killing her kid
366
00:15:34,679 --> 00:15:37,609
and that person murdered Cara.
367
00:15:37,610 --> 00:15:40,126
Anyone from the family
recognize this guy?
368
00:15:40,127 --> 00:15:41,920
- No. We showed this to Tate,
369
00:15:41,921 --> 00:15:44,575
Audrey, Dreyfus,
no one knows who he is.
370
00:15:44,576 --> 00:15:46,851
- Maybe there's a reason
that no one knows who he is.
371
00:15:46,852 --> 00:15:48,402
I mean, this may
sound indelicate,
372
00:15:48,403 --> 00:15:51,092
but Tate was out of town
the night that Izzy died.
373
00:15:51,093 --> 00:15:52,264
And Cara was alone.
374
00:15:52,265 --> 00:15:54,161
- You think Cara
had a secret boyfriend?
375
00:15:54,162 --> 00:15:56,471
- Maybe invited him over
the night Izzy died,
376
00:15:56,472 --> 00:15:58,264
she didn't think
he could've hurt Izzy
377
00:15:58,265 --> 00:16:00,782
until she found out about
the undisclosed hair.
378
00:16:00,783 --> 00:16:04,195
- So Cara gets out of prison,
starts looking into him...
379
00:16:04,196 --> 00:16:06,437
- He finds out
she's suspicious of him,
380
00:16:06,438 --> 00:16:07,678
he follows her...
381
00:16:07,679 --> 00:16:09,402
- And steals the drive
and then kills her
382
00:16:09,403 --> 00:16:11,230
before she can expose him
as a child murderer.
383
00:16:11,231 --> 00:16:14,299
- If Cara's dead
then the appeal is abated
384
00:16:14,300 --> 00:16:16,885
and she dies, guilty of
second-degree murder.
385
00:16:16,886 --> 00:16:19,333
The whole case disappears.
386
00:16:19,334 --> 00:16:21,783
- No one's looking
for the real killer.
387
00:16:22,610 --> 00:16:24,126
[echoing gavel]
388
00:16:24,127 --> 00:16:25,644
- I've never seen
this guy before.
389
00:16:25,645 --> 00:16:27,885
- Cara didn't mention
the evidence she was collecting
390
00:16:27,886 --> 00:16:29,782
to try to find
Izzy's real killer?
391
00:16:29,783 --> 00:16:31,851
- Finding real killers
is your job, detectives.
392
00:16:31,852 --> 00:16:34,299
I was very clear with Cara
about what my job was.
393
00:16:34,300 --> 00:16:37,506
Show the council did not
get all the evidence they needed
394
00:16:37,507 --> 00:16:39,092
to adequately defend her.
395
00:16:39,093 --> 00:16:41,471
Then exonerate her
and call it a day.
396
00:16:41,472 --> 00:16:43,299
- Even without the hair?
- I didn't need it.
397
00:16:43,300 --> 00:16:45,471
I have the photo
and Doctor Garvey's testimony.
398
00:16:45,472 --> 00:16:47,161
- Are they still
looking for it?
399
00:16:47,162 --> 00:16:48,161
- Why?
400
00:16:48,162 --> 00:16:49,954
You wanna compare it
to this guy?
401
00:16:49,955 --> 00:16:51,713
- Well, if he's a match,
it could well be
402
00:16:51,714 --> 00:16:53,747
that he's Izzy's killer
and Cara's killer.
403
00:16:53,748 --> 00:16:56,575
True, but I don't think
that hair will help you
404
00:16:56,576 --> 00:16:57,885
prosecute Cara's killer.
405
00:16:57,886 --> 00:16:59,264
There's zero connection
406
00:16:59,265 --> 00:17:01,230
between her crime scene
and a hair
407
00:17:01,231 --> 00:17:03,161
found in a kid's hand
three years ago.
408
00:17:03,162 --> 00:17:05,885
- Wait.
Did you say in the hand?
409
00:17:05,886 --> 00:17:09,057
- The photo that we saw,
it looked like the hair
410
00:17:09,058 --> 00:17:11,644
was on Izzy's hand, not in it.
411
00:17:11,645 --> 00:17:13,507
- Not according
to Doctor Garvey.
412
00:17:15,610 --> 00:17:17,369
[echoing gavel]
413
00:17:17,679 --> 00:17:20,540
Yes, that is what I told
Ms. Cross.
414
00:17:20,541 --> 00:17:23,678
In the ER,
I saw a hair in Izzy's hand.
415
00:17:23,679 --> 00:17:25,989
It got dislodged in our efforts
to save her life.
416
00:17:25,990 --> 00:17:27,195
- You didn't tell the police?
417
00:17:27,196 --> 00:17:29,299
- I thought the message
had been relayed.
418
00:17:29,300 --> 00:17:31,851
It wasn't.
So when Edith contacted me,
419
00:17:31,852 --> 00:17:34,816
I told her it had been
entwined in Izzy's fingers
420
00:17:34,817 --> 00:17:37,644
like she had, um,
grasped hair and pulled.
421
00:17:37,645 --> 00:17:39,954
- So the hair
wasn't a contaminant.
422
00:17:39,955 --> 00:17:42,506
If she'd pulled Cara's hair,
it would've been dark.
423
00:17:42,507 --> 00:17:44,920
- No, that means it must've been
someone else inside that house
424
00:17:44,921 --> 00:17:47,989
between 10 PM and 5 AM
when Izzy was hurt.
425
00:17:47,990 --> 00:17:50,816
- Maybe or maybe
it happened earlier.
426
00:17:50,817 --> 00:17:52,093
- What do you mean?
427
00:17:53,024 --> 00:17:55,954
[lowly]: I think the timeline
stated was, um,
428
00:17:55,955 --> 00:17:57,609
too conservative.
429
00:17:57,610 --> 00:17:59,747
Doctor Plath
is the preeminent expert,
430
00:17:59,748 --> 00:18:04,954
but I've seen shaken baby deaths
occur 10, 12 hours after injury.
431
00:18:04,955 --> 00:18:07,471
- Hold on. You're saying that
Izzy could have been hurt
432
00:18:07,472 --> 00:18:09,092
much earlier that evening?
433
00:18:09,093 --> 00:18:12,851
- Like when she being minded by,
uh, her half-sister Audrey.
434
00:18:12,852 --> 00:18:14,609
Thank you, Doctor Garvey.
435
00:18:14,610 --> 00:18:16,126
- Yeah.
436
00:18:16,127 --> 00:18:18,782
- Well, if he's right,
Audrey wasn't alone that night.
437
00:18:18,783 --> 00:18:20,954
- Yeah, and she lied about
not knowing who our blonde is.
438
00:18:20,955 --> 00:18:22,609
I think you're on to something
439
00:18:22,610 --> 00:18:24,264
with this secret boyfriend
theory.
440
00:18:24,265 --> 00:18:27,403
- Right idea, wrong woman.
441
00:18:30,300 --> 00:18:32,126
- Okay, I lied.
442
00:18:32,127 --> 00:18:33,920
But I barely know Christian.
443
00:18:33,921 --> 00:18:36,299
He was two grades older
and we hooked up once.
444
00:18:36,300 --> 00:18:37,747
- Was it that night?
445
00:18:37,748 --> 00:18:39,162
- I was there.
446
00:18:39,610 --> 00:18:41,231
But I didn't hurt that baby.
447
00:18:41,955 --> 00:18:44,678
- I wasn't allowed
to have guys over.
448
00:18:44,679 --> 00:18:46,645
I didn't want my dad to know.
449
00:18:47,403 --> 00:18:49,816
Besides, Christian
didn't do anything.
450
00:18:49,817 --> 00:18:51,230
- Well,
if you didn't do anything,
451
00:18:51,231 --> 00:18:53,023
why did you steal
Cara's drive?
452
00:18:53,024 --> 00:18:56,230
- Can you tell me about when
he reached out to you recently?
453
00:18:56,231 --> 00:18:58,368
- He heard that Cara
got released.
454
00:18:58,369 --> 00:19:00,816
Read about the hair
in the news and texted me.
455
00:19:00,817 --> 00:19:03,161
I hadn't heard from him
since that night.
456
00:19:03,162 --> 00:19:05,989
He was freaking out that Cara
was gonna blame us.
457
00:19:05,990 --> 00:19:09,644
- Did you tell him what Cara
said to your dad?
458
00:19:09,645 --> 00:19:13,264
- Yeah, but she was lying
about having more evidence.
459
00:19:13,265 --> 00:19:16,126
[suspenseful music]
My dad told me.
460
00:19:16,127 --> 00:19:19,437
I know Christian
didn't hurt Izzy.
461
00:19:19,438 --> 00:19:22,333
Cara did it way after we left.
462
00:19:22,334 --> 00:19:24,541
- Audrey,
that's not necessarily true.
463
00:19:25,852 --> 00:19:29,300
All it takes is five seconds
of forceful shaking.
464
00:19:30,817 --> 00:19:34,333
- The only person
I touched was Audrey.
465
00:19:34,334 --> 00:19:35,851
- Sure.
[sighing]
466
00:19:35,852 --> 00:19:37,954
You know, I heard that...
467
00:19:37,955 --> 00:19:39,816
poor little Izzy was...
468
00:19:39,817 --> 00:19:41,851
was quite the crier.
469
00:19:41,852 --> 00:19:45,333
Did Audrey have to keep getting
up to, uh, go take care of her?
470
00:19:45,334 --> 00:19:46,782
- My client has already said
471
00:19:46,783 --> 00:19:48,851
he doesn't recall
specific events.
472
00:19:48,852 --> 00:19:51,471
- I don't think Goldilocks
here even understood
473
00:19:51,472 --> 00:19:54,023
the specific events that
he might have done something
474
00:19:54,024 --> 00:19:55,299
that hurt Izzy.
475
00:19:55,300 --> 00:19:57,816
- I need you to think back, okay?
476
00:19:57,817 --> 00:20:00,885
Try as hard as you can
to remember.
477
00:20:00,886 --> 00:20:04,333
Was there any time when
Christian was alone with her?
478
00:20:04,334 --> 00:20:08,541
- I, I mean,
I went to the bathroom once.
479
00:20:10,541 --> 00:20:14,644
Izzy started crying, but then...
480
00:20:14,645 --> 00:20:16,196
she stopped.
481
00:20:19,541 --> 00:20:23,333
When I came out, Christian,
he was in the hall.
482
00:20:23,334 --> 00:20:25,230
He wasn't in her room.
483
00:20:25,231 --> 00:20:29,472
- Then, how did a blonde hair
get entwined in Izzy's fingers?
484
00:20:32,024 --> 00:20:33,471
[shaky breathing]
485
00:20:33,472 --> 00:20:35,851
- Are you trying
to implicate my client
486
00:20:35,852 --> 00:20:39,161
in a crime that Cara Melville
was already imprisoned for?
487
00:20:39,162 --> 00:20:40,851
[door opening]
- Oh, we'll leave that to, uh,
488
00:20:40,852 --> 00:20:44,161
Detective Dreyfus
to further investigate.
489
00:20:44,162 --> 00:20:47,368
Our little chat here
is to establish your motive
490
00:20:47,369 --> 00:20:49,057
in the murder
of Cara Melville.
491
00:20:49,058 --> 00:20:52,126
- Audrey told you
about Cara's evidence.
492
00:20:52,127 --> 00:20:54,368
That she had more than a hair
regarding the real killer.
493
00:20:54,369 --> 00:20:56,609
- So you stole the drive, uh,
494
00:20:56,610 --> 00:20:59,747
discovered that Cara had
dirt on you,
495
00:20:59,748 --> 00:21:01,437
and you went to the motel
and you killed her.
496
00:21:01,438 --> 00:21:03,472
- No! No.
497
00:21:04,576 --> 00:21:07,575
Look, I may have been
at Cara's the night Izzy died-
498
00:21:07,576 --> 00:21:11,644
- Christian.
- But I didn't touch that baby.
499
00:21:11,645 --> 00:21:14,092
And I was nowhere near
that motel when Cara was killed.
500
00:21:14,093 --> 00:21:16,575
- Well, where were you,
Prince Charming?
501
00:21:16,576 --> 00:21:18,851
- Tell 'em.
502
00:21:18,852 --> 00:21:22,678
- Christian was doing community
service for vandalism.
503
00:21:22,679 --> 00:21:25,368
He was at a food bank
until 9 PM.
504
00:21:25,369 --> 00:21:30,230
- Oh, so being a delinquent, uh,
finally worked in your favour.
505
00:21:30,231 --> 00:21:31,989
What's on the drive?
506
00:21:31,990 --> 00:21:33,989
- I don't even know.
507
00:21:33,990 --> 00:21:37,816
The files were
password protected.
508
00:21:37,817 --> 00:21:39,747
[door opening]
509
00:21:39,748 --> 00:21:41,506
- I cracked the drive.
[sighing]
510
00:21:41,507 --> 00:21:43,540
Christian may look good
for Izzy's murder,
511
00:21:43,541 --> 00:21:46,541
but Cara was not collecting
evidence on him.
512
00:21:48,024 --> 00:21:49,644
- These are just articles
513
00:21:49,645 --> 00:21:52,023
about other parents who went to
prison for killing their kids.
514
00:21:52,024 --> 00:21:53,782
- Then there's nothing
on the drive about, uh,
515
00:21:53,783 --> 00:21:55,264
a new suspect
in Izzy's murder?
516
00:21:55,265 --> 00:21:56,782
- Not as far as I can tell.
517
00:21:56,783 --> 00:21:59,264
- Okay, so why would Cara think
this would exonerate her?
518
00:21:59,265 --> 00:22:01,437
I mean, none of it even
has to do with her daughter.
519
00:22:01,438 --> 00:22:03,679
- Hmm.
Open the directory for me.
520
00:22:05,369 --> 00:22:09,023
Who's this Nina Shuter and
why's she got her own folder?
521
00:22:09,024 --> 00:22:10,782
- Yeah, hold on.
522
00:22:10,783 --> 00:22:12,714
Okay, uh...
523
00:22:12,715 --> 00:22:15,161
Nina was an infant.
Her mother, Maxine,
524
00:22:15,162 --> 00:22:18,195
was convicted of
her second-degree murder.
525
00:22:18,196 --> 00:22:22,609
And she was incarcerated
at the same prison as Cara.
526
00:22:22,610 --> 00:22:24,126
- And lived on the same PC Ward.
527
00:22:24,127 --> 00:22:26,402
- Okay, so they were neighbours.
[sighing]
528
00:22:26,403 --> 00:22:27,954
But Maxine couldn't have given
529
00:22:27,955 --> 00:22:30,161
Cara any of this, I mean,
she didn't have access.
530
00:22:30,162 --> 00:22:32,471
- And Cara couldn't have gotten
any of this on her own either.
531
00:22:32,472 --> 00:22:34,506
I mean,
here's Nina's autopsy report,
532
00:22:34,507 --> 00:22:36,264
a second opinion
from a pathologist,
533
00:22:36,265 --> 00:22:37,471
I mean, these are documents
534
00:22:37,472 --> 00:22:39,368
that only the Shuter family
could acquire.
535
00:22:39,369 --> 00:22:41,092
- Hang on.
536
00:22:41,093 --> 00:22:43,023
It says here
the original autopsy
537
00:22:43,024 --> 00:22:45,851
failed to take into account
a hereditary disease.
538
00:22:45,852 --> 00:22:48,575
- "Which may invalidate
the assumption of child abuse
539
00:22:48,576 --> 00:22:50,472
having caused asphyxia as...
540
00:22:51,990 --> 00:22:55,265
determined by
Doctor Victor Plath."
541
00:22:57,093 --> 00:22:58,782
- Maybe when Cara said
542
00:22:58,783 --> 00:23:00,575
she had more than a hair,
she meant-
543
00:23:00,576 --> 00:23:02,438
- More than a missing hair.
544
00:23:02,439 --> 00:23:05,402
And what do you get
when you combine
545
00:23:05,403 --> 00:23:08,023
lost exculpatory evidence
with, uh,
546
00:23:08,024 --> 00:23:10,540
proof of a genetic
oversight?
547
00:23:10,541 --> 00:23:12,713
- A pathologist who may be
responsible
548
00:23:12,714 --> 00:23:15,609
for the wrongful convictions
of both Cara and Maxine.
549
00:23:15,610 --> 00:23:18,402
What if Cara was planning
to expose Plath's misconduct?
550
00:23:18,403 --> 00:23:20,782
- And he killed her
to keep her quiet.
551
00:23:20,783 --> 00:23:22,471
[phone]: Doctor Plath,
as Christian's lawyer,
552
00:23:22,472 --> 00:23:25,299
I'm concerned. The police may
charge him with Izzy's murder.
553
00:23:25,300 --> 00:23:28,023
- I'll testify in his defence
if you need me to.
554
00:23:28,024 --> 00:23:29,885
Like I said,
my timeline is correct.
555
00:23:29,886 --> 00:23:31,471
Cara killed Izzy.
556
00:23:31,472 --> 00:23:33,506
- You haven't found
that hair yet?
557
00:23:33,507 --> 00:23:37,713
- No, but, uh, even if I did,
it doesn't trump my expertise.
558
00:23:37,714 --> 00:23:39,540
We're looking, but...
559
00:23:39,541 --> 00:23:41,299
I don't know
if I'll ever find it.
560
00:23:41,300 --> 00:23:44,023
- Okay. Keep me posted.
561
00:23:44,024 --> 00:23:46,714
[tense music continues]
562
00:23:53,127 --> 00:23:55,230
[indiscernible chatter]
563
00:23:55,231 --> 00:23:57,368
- There you are.
I've been looking for you guys.
564
00:23:57,369 --> 00:23:58,816
- And were coming to find you.
565
00:23:58,817 --> 00:24:00,299
Major break
in the Cara Melville case.
566
00:24:00,300 --> 00:24:02,057
- Yeah, turns out
she was collecting intel
567
00:24:02,058 --> 00:24:04,230
that could ruin
Doctor Plath's career.
568
00:24:04,231 --> 00:24:06,713
[stammering]: Botched autopsies,
missing evidence-
569
00:24:06,714 --> 00:24:08,471
- We think he put
two and two together,
570
00:24:08,472 --> 00:24:10,161
suspected Cara
was looking into him.
571
00:24:10,162 --> 00:24:13,678
- Whoa, whoa, whoa.
You're not suggesting that Plath...
572
00:24:13,679 --> 00:24:16,540
The Doctor Victor Plath
killed someone.
573
00:24:16,541 --> 00:24:18,161
- To cover up malfeasance, yes.
574
00:24:18,162 --> 00:24:19,645
- Okay!
575
00:24:19,990 --> 00:24:21,851
Okay, you have to stick
a pin in this.
576
00:24:21,852 --> 00:24:24,609
Come with me.
- No, Inspector...
577
00:24:24,610 --> 00:24:27,816
Plath was there
when Cara told Tate
578
00:24:27,817 --> 00:24:29,989
that she had more than just
a hair to exonerate herself.
579
00:24:29,990 --> 00:24:32,713
- We think, uh,
Plath was in Cara's motel room.
580
00:24:32,714 --> 00:24:35,092
The smudge on the bathroom
doorframe was caused
581
00:24:35,093 --> 00:24:36,678
by sodium hypochlorite.
582
00:24:36,679 --> 00:24:38,816
- Yeah. AKA DNA clean wipes.
583
00:24:38,817 --> 00:24:40,782
- No, doesn't that sound like
something a...
584
00:24:40,783 --> 00:24:43,954
careful pathologist might take
with him to a crime scene?
585
00:24:43,955 --> 00:24:46,195
- Why don't you
ask him yourself?
586
00:24:46,196 --> 00:24:48,886
Doctor Plath is in my office
right now.
587
00:24:54,196 --> 00:24:56,265
[clearing throat]
588
00:24:57,369 --> 00:24:58,920
- Detectives.
589
00:24:58,921 --> 00:25:01,920
I hear you have a new suspect
in the Izzy Melville case.
590
00:25:01,921 --> 00:25:03,230
I just wanted to let you know
591
00:25:03,231 --> 00:25:06,264
I'm happy to provide my reports,
uh, brainstorm?
592
00:25:06,265 --> 00:25:08,092
- We appreciate that,
Doctor Plath.
593
00:25:08,093 --> 00:25:10,471
- Oh, you should speak
with Detective Dreyfus.
594
00:25:10,472 --> 00:25:12,126
She's handling Izzy's case.
595
00:25:12,127 --> 00:25:14,369
- We're still busy
with Cara's murder.
596
00:25:15,265 --> 00:25:18,057
- I thought we were looking
at the ex-husband for that.
597
00:25:18,058 --> 00:25:20,816
- Oh, we are looking
into a lot of people.
598
00:25:20,817 --> 00:25:22,333
- Alright then.
599
00:25:22,334 --> 00:25:23,782
I'll go speak to Dreyfus.
600
00:25:23,783 --> 00:25:26,575
I'm sure you've got Cara's
investigation well in hand.
601
00:25:26,576 --> 00:25:30,161
- Uh, you know, we could always
use a second opinion.
602
00:25:30,162 --> 00:25:32,782
I mean, do you have
any instincts, Doctor Plath,
603
00:25:32,783 --> 00:25:35,540
uh, to be honest, it kind of
feels like we may be missing
604
00:25:35,541 --> 00:25:36,954
something that's right
in front of us.
605
00:25:36,955 --> 00:25:40,333
- Hmm. That's funny,
I heard a great quote
606
00:25:40,334 --> 00:25:41,885
the other night at this reading,
607
00:25:41,886 --> 00:25:46,161
"When you hear hoof beats,
think horses, not zebras."
608
00:25:46,162 --> 00:25:50,195
Sometimes the correct answer
is the most obvious one.
609
00:25:50,196 --> 00:25:52,023
- Oh, what event was that?
610
00:25:52,024 --> 00:25:53,540
- Uh, the Brighton Reading
Series.
611
00:25:53,541 --> 00:25:54,851
I take my mother every month.
612
00:25:54,852 --> 00:25:57,333
- Right.
[Graff]: Your mother, huh?
613
00:25:57,334 --> 00:25:58,954
You must be close.
614
00:25:58,955 --> 00:26:00,782
- Well, it was just
the two of us growing up.
615
00:26:00,783 --> 00:26:02,299
Least I can do.
616
00:26:02,300 --> 00:26:05,609
Anyway, please,
let me know if I can help.
617
00:26:05,610 --> 00:26:07,954
- Thank you.
618
00:26:07,955 --> 00:26:11,023
[suspenseful music]
619
00:26:11,024 --> 00:26:15,713
- Well. Guess who just casually
dropped his alibi.
620
00:26:15,714 --> 00:26:18,782
[sighing]: The Brighton Reading
Series took place
621
00:26:18,783 --> 00:26:21,368
the night of Cara's murder
from six to nine PM.
622
00:26:21,369 --> 00:26:24,402
- How convenient.
Look.
623
00:26:24,403 --> 00:26:26,230
I'm not saying that you guys
are right,
624
00:26:26,231 --> 00:26:27,747
because if you are,
this is gonna be
625
00:26:27,748 --> 00:26:28,954
one hell of a miss.
626
00:26:28,955 --> 00:26:31,954
So you had better
make absolutely sure
627
00:26:31,955 --> 00:26:33,954
that he was actually
doing something wrong
628
00:26:33,955 --> 00:26:36,748
before you go
near him for murder.
629
00:26:38,955 --> 00:26:41,437
[echoing gavel]
630
00:26:41,438 --> 00:26:44,816
- Wrong doesn't even begin
to express what he did to me.
631
00:26:44,817 --> 00:26:46,885
- And how did you figure
this out, Maxine?
632
00:26:46,886 --> 00:26:49,334
- Cara and I met in therapy.
633
00:26:49,817 --> 00:26:53,161
We had to talk a lot about
admitting to what we did.
634
00:26:53,162 --> 00:26:56,333
But we both knew
we were innocent.
635
00:26:56,334 --> 00:26:58,195
We didn't do what Plath said.
636
00:26:58,196 --> 00:27:01,678
We think my daughter died
of a genetic disorder.
637
00:27:01,679 --> 00:27:03,195
[intriguing music]
My mom's cousin had it.
638
00:27:03,196 --> 00:27:05,920
- We told the police
it ran in our family.
639
00:27:05,921 --> 00:27:07,609
But Plath didn't test Nina.
640
00:27:07,610 --> 00:27:10,196
- He was too busy telling
everyone I killed her.
641
00:27:11,024 --> 00:27:14,713
Because I was single.
And had post-partum.
642
00:27:14,714 --> 00:27:17,437
- He said similar things
about Cara.
643
00:27:17,438 --> 00:27:19,023
That she was an alcoholic,
644
00:27:19,024 --> 00:27:21,264
who was driven to drink
by a colic baby.
645
00:27:21,265 --> 00:27:23,747
- He didn't know
anything about us.
646
00:27:23,748 --> 00:27:25,645
What kind of parents we were.
647
00:27:27,196 --> 00:27:30,127
Cara loved Izzy.
648
00:27:31,127 --> 00:27:33,231
I loved Nina.
649
00:27:33,886 --> 00:27:36,368
Can you imagine
losing the person
650
00:27:36,369 --> 00:27:38,057
you love most in this world
651
00:27:38,058 --> 00:27:40,782
and having everyone
think you killed them?
652
00:27:40,783 --> 00:27:42,230
[inhaling deeply]
653
00:27:42,231 --> 00:27:44,851
We hoped that if Cara got free,
654
00:27:44,852 --> 00:27:47,402
she would use
her exoneration as a way
655
00:27:47,403 --> 00:27:50,231
to start a real conversation
about Plath.
656
00:27:51,058 --> 00:27:54,058
Be a voice for all of us.
657
00:27:57,162 --> 00:27:58,782
- I know you're doing your best,
658
00:27:58,783 --> 00:28:01,678
but I am still getting calls
about this Izzy Melville case.
659
00:28:01,679 --> 00:28:03,782
- From who?
- Detective Dreyfus.
660
00:28:03,783 --> 00:28:06,057
She wants us to look
for that hair evidence.
661
00:28:06,058 --> 00:28:07,402
Again.
662
00:28:07,403 --> 00:28:09,609
[sighing]: I checked that box.
I'm telling you,
663
00:28:09,610 --> 00:28:12,402
it is not there.
- Victor, as the Chief Coroner,
664
00:28:12,403 --> 00:28:15,678
it is my job to make sure
that the autopsies we perform
665
00:28:15,679 --> 00:28:19,126
and the reports we issue
are timely and accurate.
666
00:28:19,127 --> 00:28:20,471
- You know me.
667
00:28:20,472 --> 00:28:22,747
I dot my i's, I cross my t's,
668
00:28:22,748 --> 00:28:24,954
I care more than anything
about accuracy
669
00:28:24,955 --> 00:28:26,644
and getting justice
for these victims.
670
00:28:26,645 --> 00:28:27,989
- I know.
671
00:28:27,990 --> 00:28:29,885
And I think you're exceptional
at it, Victor.
672
00:28:29,886 --> 00:28:31,816
But if you made a mistake,
you need to tell me.
673
00:28:31,817 --> 00:28:34,092
I can't help you
if I'm in the dark.
674
00:28:34,093 --> 00:28:35,954
- Francine.
675
00:28:35,955 --> 00:28:37,816
I don't make mistakes.
676
00:28:37,817 --> 00:28:40,402
[suspenseful music]
- I am shocked at what I found.
677
00:28:40,403 --> 00:28:45,092
I looked at 20 of
Plath's most recent autopsies.
678
00:28:45,093 --> 00:28:47,437
They are full of mistakes
and inaccuracies,
679
00:28:47,438 --> 00:28:48,885
just like Nina and Izzy's.
680
00:28:48,886 --> 00:28:51,644
- They led to 12 parents
being convicted
681
00:28:51,645 --> 00:28:53,506
in their own child's deaths?
682
00:28:53,507 --> 00:28:54,920
All of them mothers.
683
00:28:54,921 --> 00:28:56,299
- Single mothers.
684
00:28:56,300 --> 00:28:58,954
Or mothers with addiction
and mental health issues.
685
00:28:58,955 --> 00:29:00,333
But they were not killers.
686
00:29:00,334 --> 00:29:03,816
Look, um.
The McMahon's case.
687
00:29:03,817 --> 00:29:07,954
Plath said the mom stabbed her
child with a meat skewer,
688
00:29:07,955 --> 00:29:10,057
but these look like
animal bites to me.
689
00:29:10,058 --> 00:29:12,058
And the Bailer case,
690
00:29:12,472 --> 00:29:16,713
Plath thought that normal,
post-mortem lividity
691
00:29:16,714 --> 00:29:18,920
was actually evidence
of strangulation, sorry,
692
00:29:18,921 --> 00:29:21,644
I-I-I just, I can't believe
what I'm seeing.
693
00:29:21,645 --> 00:29:23,540
- How did no one notice this?
694
00:29:23,541 --> 00:29:27,333
- He is the expert
in pediatric forensics.
695
00:29:27,334 --> 00:29:28,713
- Which allows him to what?
696
00:29:28,714 --> 00:29:31,540
Just make up his own mind
about cause of death?
697
00:29:31,541 --> 00:29:33,299
- It's an inexact science!
698
00:29:33,300 --> 00:29:35,023
[sighing]
699
00:29:35,024 --> 00:29:38,609
Something that an adult could
survive might kill a child.
700
00:29:38,610 --> 00:29:41,092
Plath purports to know
the difference,
701
00:29:41,093 --> 00:29:43,195
but he's supposed to look
at the whole picture,
702
00:29:43,196 --> 00:29:45,506
use background in tandem
with forensics,
703
00:29:45,507 --> 00:29:46,782
not in lieu of it.
704
00:29:46,783 --> 00:29:49,540
These mistakes are egregious.
705
00:29:49,541 --> 00:29:51,126
- I don't think
these are mistakes.
706
00:29:51,127 --> 00:29:54,195
It seems Plath saw certain
type of women,
707
00:29:54,196 --> 00:29:55,713
made an assumption of abuse.
708
00:29:55,714 --> 00:29:58,644
- And spread misinformation
to lead to her convictions.
709
00:29:58,645 --> 00:30:00,402
[sighing]
Jesus.
710
00:30:00,403 --> 00:30:02,747
Okay, but how do we connect
this to Cara?
711
00:30:02,748 --> 00:30:05,471
It still doesn't prove
that Plath killed Cara.
712
00:30:05,472 --> 00:30:06,885
- Actually, it might.
713
00:30:06,886 --> 00:30:09,713
You know, if he's okay
with spreading misinformation,
714
00:30:09,714 --> 00:30:11,920
maybe he's okay
with withholding evidence.
715
00:30:11,921 --> 00:30:13,920
- Like the hair that could
have exonerated Cara?
716
00:30:13,921 --> 00:30:16,851
- We don't get to pick
and choose what evidence
717
00:30:16,852 --> 00:30:19,989
we share with the police.
We disclose everything,
718
00:30:19,990 --> 00:30:21,540
we save everything.
719
00:30:21,541 --> 00:30:23,161
It is drilled into us.
720
00:30:23,162 --> 00:30:25,333
The chain of custody is king.
721
00:30:25,334 --> 00:30:26,851
- Then maybe Plath
still has the hair.
722
00:30:26,852 --> 00:30:27,954
- And if he does,
723
00:30:27,955 --> 00:30:29,540
that in and of itself
is a crime.
724
00:30:29,541 --> 00:30:32,333
- Now we're one step closer
to a murder confession.
725
00:30:32,334 --> 00:30:34,644
- Hey, good job.
726
00:30:34,645 --> 00:30:36,023
[sighing]
727
00:30:36,024 --> 00:30:38,645
[drawer rasping]
728
00:30:42,024 --> 00:30:43,990
- Vicky?
- Mother!
729
00:30:45,196 --> 00:30:47,126
Sorry, uh,
I didn't mean to wake you.
730
00:30:47,127 --> 00:30:50,058
- That's fine.
My show's about to start.
731
00:30:50,059 --> 00:30:52,402
What were you doing over there?
732
00:30:52,403 --> 00:30:53,851
- Oh, nothing.
733
00:30:53,852 --> 00:30:55,885
I-I came by to drop off
your prescription.
734
00:30:55,886 --> 00:30:57,540
- Oh.
[plastic thudding softly]
735
00:30:57,541 --> 00:30:58,885
Is that all?
736
00:30:58,886 --> 00:31:01,161
- Well, is there...
737
00:31:01,162 --> 00:31:02,576
anything else you need?
738
00:31:03,921 --> 00:31:04,971
- No?
739
00:31:05,679 --> 00:31:07,195
- Alright.
740
00:31:07,196 --> 00:31:09,402
- Hmm.
- I need to go to work.
741
00:31:09,403 --> 00:31:11,886
- A cup of tea would be nice.
742
00:31:12,886 --> 00:31:14,541
- Sure.
743
00:31:16,541 --> 00:31:18,057
- I got the one you like.
744
00:31:18,058 --> 00:31:20,092
- Oh, it's okay.
I, uh, I don't want any.
745
00:31:20,093 --> 00:31:22,231
- Oh, come on. Have a cup
of tea with your mom.
746
00:31:23,541 --> 00:31:24,990
- Alright.
747
00:31:24,991 --> 00:31:27,816
- And you're coming over
Saturday, right?
748
00:31:27,817 --> 00:31:30,437
- I told you,
I'm away this weekend.
749
00:31:30,438 --> 00:31:33,540
I've been, uh,
asked to go to a conference.
750
00:31:33,541 --> 00:31:35,264
I've actually been invited to be
the keynote speaker-
751
00:31:35,265 --> 00:31:37,161
- Not that one.
The blue one.
752
00:31:37,162 --> 00:31:39,921
[tense music]
753
00:31:41,541 --> 00:31:43,748
[dishes clinking]
- Sorry.
754
00:31:44,852 --> 00:31:47,783
- You always were
a clumsy boy.
755
00:31:48,505 --> 00:31:54,126
- Plath thinks that he's saving
the world from abusers,
756
00:31:54,127 --> 00:31:55,644
locking them up one at the time.
757
00:31:55,645 --> 00:31:57,816
- But he's a pathologist,
it is not his job
758
00:31:57,817 --> 00:31:59,885
to be judge, jury,
or executioner.
759
00:31:59,886 --> 00:32:01,402
Theo, we gotta do something.
760
00:32:01,403 --> 00:32:02,472
- Oh, we will.
761
00:32:02,473 --> 00:32:06,264
But considering how entangled
Plath is with the Crown,
762
00:32:06,265 --> 00:32:07,816
the Defence...
763
00:32:07,817 --> 00:32:09,437
[file rustling]
We can't just confront him.
764
00:32:09,438 --> 00:32:10,713
What about his alibi?
765
00:32:10,714 --> 00:32:12,782
- Oh, the organizer
of the Brighton Reading
766
00:32:12,783 --> 00:32:14,678
says that he was there,
but she can't confirm that
767
00:32:14,679 --> 00:32:16,023
he was there for the whole time.
768
00:32:16,024 --> 00:32:19,609
- How many times has Plath
testified for you, Theo?
769
00:32:19,610 --> 00:32:21,333
- I don't know. Like, 20, 30?
770
00:32:21,334 --> 00:32:22,885
40 times?
771
00:32:22,886 --> 00:32:26,092
- And how often does he wax
on about his expertise?
772
00:32:26,093 --> 00:32:27,851
- That's literally
why he's there.
773
00:32:27,852 --> 00:32:30,506
- There he has status,
he was power.
774
00:32:30,507 --> 00:32:33,264
So, what happens if
we take that away from him,
775
00:32:33,265 --> 00:32:35,575
strip him from his medals
in public?
776
00:32:35,576 --> 00:32:37,333
- He'd be vulnerable.
777
00:32:37,334 --> 00:32:38,506
He might crack.
778
00:32:38,507 --> 00:32:40,506
- You can't just pop up
at any old trial
779
00:32:40,507 --> 00:32:41,989
that he's at and start
questioning him.
780
00:32:41,990 --> 00:32:44,575
- Oh, I'm not talking about us.
I'm talking about you.
781
00:32:44,576 --> 00:32:48,230
Come on, Theo, you can exonerate
Cara for Izzy's murder
782
00:32:48,231 --> 00:32:50,299
and prosecute someone new, yeah?
783
00:32:50,300 --> 00:32:52,126
- Like Christian?
- Like Christian.
784
00:32:52,127 --> 00:32:54,230
- You wanna charge him?
- Well, we all believe
785
00:32:54,231 --> 00:32:55,575
that Christian killed
that little girl.
786
00:32:55,576 --> 00:32:58,816
The only one who does
not and cannot is Plath.
787
00:32:58,817 --> 00:33:00,575
He'll have to get up
on that stand and say,
788
00:33:00,576 --> 00:33:01,885
"That hair is irrelevant."
789
00:33:01,886 --> 00:33:03,575
- Yeah, it's true.
If he doesn't,
790
00:33:03,576 --> 00:33:06,230
he'll basically be admitting
that he was wrong about Cara.
791
00:33:06,231 --> 00:33:08,575
- Except I don't think
I could even try Christian
792
00:33:08,576 --> 00:33:10,161
without that hair evidence.
793
00:33:10,162 --> 00:33:12,333
- Oh, come on, Theo.
There has to be a way.
794
00:33:12,334 --> 00:33:13,748
- Wait.
795
00:33:14,714 --> 00:33:16,989
If your objective
is to discredit Plath,
796
00:33:16,990 --> 00:33:19,920
we could use
Christian's preliminary inquiry
797
00:33:19,921 --> 00:33:21,437
to our advantage.
798
00:33:21,438 --> 00:33:24,713
I mean, the entire purpose
of the proceedings is to test
799
00:33:24,714 --> 00:33:27,437
the evidence and challenge
the witnesses.
800
00:33:27,438 --> 00:33:29,989
It's the perfect form
to undermine Plath's expertise.
801
00:33:29,990 --> 00:33:31,852
And if I call him...
802
00:33:33,093 --> 00:33:35,610
he has to come.
803
00:33:40,541 --> 00:33:43,437
Doctor Plath, with regard
to chain of custody,
804
00:33:43,438 --> 00:33:45,678
did your duties include
collecting evidence
805
00:33:45,679 --> 00:33:47,195
in the Izzy Melville case?
806
00:33:47,196 --> 00:33:50,368
- Uh, it's a bit more than that,
but... yes.
807
00:33:50,369 --> 00:33:52,161
- And did you collect
the hair that was visible
808
00:33:52,162 --> 00:33:53,816
in the police photo
taken in the ER
809
00:33:53,817 --> 00:33:55,161
shortly after Izzy died?
810
00:33:55,162 --> 00:33:56,540
- I didn't see it on her.
811
00:33:56,541 --> 00:33:59,678
It did not arrive with
the body for the autopsy.
812
00:33:59,679 --> 00:34:02,541
- As a continuity witness,
I-I need you to be specific.
813
00:34:03,576 --> 00:34:06,024
You didn't see it,
or it wasn't there?
814
00:34:06,852 --> 00:34:08,816
- I did not see it.
815
00:34:08,817 --> 00:34:11,196
- No further questions.
816
00:34:12,127 --> 00:34:13,368
- Hello, Doctor Plath.
817
00:34:13,369 --> 00:34:14,816
[suspenseful music]
818
00:34:14,817 --> 00:34:15,885
In your opinion,
819
00:34:15,886 --> 00:34:18,713
what was Izzy Melville's
cause of death-
820
00:34:18,714 --> 00:34:20,161
- Objection.
821
00:34:20,162 --> 00:34:22,644
Doctor Plath cannot give
his professional opinion.
822
00:34:22,645 --> 00:34:26,023
He has not been qualified
as an expert in this trial.
823
00:34:26,024 --> 00:34:28,402
Just a continuity witness.
824
00:34:28,403 --> 00:34:29,989
- Wha-, of course,
I'm an expert.
825
00:34:29,990 --> 00:34:32,471
- Okay. I'll qualify him
right now.
826
00:34:32,472 --> 00:34:35,299
Doctor Plath,
state your credentials.
827
00:34:35,300 --> 00:34:37,644
- I am a published
forensic pathologist.
828
00:34:37,645 --> 00:34:40,023
I performed over 800 autopsies,
829
00:34:40,024 --> 00:34:44,023
testified in 100 trials,
many of them for the Crown.
830
00:34:44,024 --> 00:34:46,852
- Doctor Plath is now
qualified as an expert.
831
00:34:47,507 --> 00:34:50,092
- Doctor Plath,
in your opinion,
832
00:34:50,093 --> 00:34:52,885
what was Izzy Melville's
cause of death?
833
00:34:52,886 --> 00:34:54,747
- Subdural hematoma.
834
00:34:54,748 --> 00:34:57,161
Occurred between the hours
of 10 PM and 5 AM.
835
00:34:57,162 --> 00:34:59,402
- And in your opinion,
836
00:34:59,403 --> 00:35:01,954
what is the relevance
of the hair evidence
837
00:35:01,955 --> 00:35:05,333
that was found in relation
to cause of death?
838
00:35:05,334 --> 00:35:07,471
- I don't think it
has any relevance.
839
00:35:07,472 --> 00:35:09,783
I believe it was a contaminant.
840
00:35:10,886 --> 00:35:12,540
- No further questions.
841
00:35:12,541 --> 00:35:14,506
[Judge]: You may step down.
842
00:35:14,507 --> 00:35:18,713
[suspenseful music]
843
00:35:18,714 --> 00:35:20,230
- What are you doing here?
844
00:35:20,231 --> 00:35:23,402
- Oh, I invited her.
Shh, court's in session.
845
00:35:23,403 --> 00:35:26,299
- The Crown calls previously
qualified, expert witness,
846
00:35:26,300 --> 00:35:28,403
Doctor Lucy Da Silva.
847
00:35:29,438 --> 00:35:32,575
[suspenseful music continues]
848
00:35:32,576 --> 00:35:36,023
Doctor Da Silva,
you reviewed the evidence.
849
00:35:36,024 --> 00:35:39,195
In your expert opinion,
850
00:35:39,196 --> 00:35:42,402
how long was the timeline
between Izzy Melville's injury
851
00:35:42,403 --> 00:35:44,161
and her death?
852
00:35:44,162 --> 00:35:48,402
- It may have been longer
than four to six hours.
853
00:35:48,403 --> 00:35:50,678
She may have been injured
before 10 PM.
854
00:35:50,679 --> 00:35:55,161
- And in your expert opinion,
what created this discrepancy
855
00:35:55,162 --> 00:35:57,392
between your findings
and Doctor Plath's?
856
00:35:58,265 --> 00:36:00,954
- I believed that Doctor Plath
was biased.
857
00:36:00,955 --> 00:36:03,816
[crowd mutterings]
858
00:36:03,817 --> 00:36:07,299
- Thank you, Doctor Da Silva.
859
00:36:07,300 --> 00:36:10,092
Oh. Actually, one more question.
860
00:36:10,093 --> 00:36:12,954
Have you had the opportunity
to review
861
00:36:12,955 --> 00:36:15,540
any of Doctor Plath's
other case files?
862
00:36:15,541 --> 00:36:18,471
- Objection, Your Honour.
Relevance?
863
00:36:18,472 --> 00:36:20,471
- It's a preliminary inquiry, counsel.
864
00:36:20,472 --> 00:36:22,782
I'll allow it.
[sighing]
865
00:36:22,783 --> 00:36:24,609
Continue, Doctor Da Silva.
866
00:36:24,610 --> 00:36:25,713
[tense music]
867
00:36:25,714 --> 00:36:27,644
- I have reviewed
other autopsies
868
00:36:27,645 --> 00:36:30,126
that he was responsible for.
869
00:36:30,127 --> 00:36:32,609
And I found them
to be lacking.
870
00:36:32,610 --> 00:36:34,851
[crowd grunting]
Doctor Plath failed to preserve
871
00:36:34,852 --> 00:36:37,506
pathology material,
he misinterpreted
872
00:36:37,507 --> 00:36:39,816
autopsy findings-
- Objection.
873
00:36:39,817 --> 00:36:42,299
- And he referenced parental
history irrelevant
874
00:36:42,300 --> 00:36:43,575
to pathology-
- Objection!
875
00:36:43,576 --> 00:36:44,920
- Which, in my opinion,
876
00:36:44,921 --> 00:36:47,644
compromised the administration
of justice!
877
00:36:47,645 --> 00:36:49,057
- Objection, Your Honour!
878
00:36:49,058 --> 00:36:50,540
- Overruled.
879
00:36:50,541 --> 00:36:52,195
[crowd muttering]
880
00:36:52,196 --> 00:36:54,369
[tense music continues]
881
00:36:55,058 --> 00:36:56,679
- Vicky, what's going on?
882
00:37:01,507 --> 00:37:03,230
- You need to call me again.
883
00:37:03,231 --> 00:37:05,885
I need to respond to what
she said, as an expert.
884
00:37:05,886 --> 00:37:07,678
- I think we've established,
885
00:37:07,679 --> 00:37:09,885
you are far
from being an expert.
886
00:37:09,886 --> 00:37:11,368
[scoffing]
887
00:37:11,369 --> 00:37:12,920
- Theo.
888
00:37:12,921 --> 00:37:14,195
We're on the same side.
889
00:37:14,196 --> 00:37:15,678
We've worked together
countless times.
890
00:37:15,679 --> 00:37:17,852
- And if I knew then
what I know now?
891
00:37:18,714 --> 00:37:20,369
I never would have used you.
892
00:37:21,265 --> 00:37:24,885
And frankly, this conversation's
becoming a conflict of interest.
893
00:37:24,886 --> 00:37:26,368
- What is that supposed to mean?
894
00:37:26,369 --> 00:37:29,230
- That means he can't be
your ally and prosecute you.
895
00:37:29,231 --> 00:37:31,437
- Prosecute me?
For what?
896
00:37:31,438 --> 00:37:33,437
- For the murder
of Cara Melville.
897
00:37:33,438 --> 00:37:35,782
- Murder?
Vicky, what's happening?
898
00:37:35,783 --> 00:37:37,437
- Nothing, mother.
These people are trying
899
00:37:37,438 --> 00:37:40,092
to destroy my career
with outlandish accusations.
900
00:37:40,093 --> 00:37:42,299
They set up my...
subordinate to slander me-
901
00:37:42,300 --> 00:37:43,885
- I called the Chief Coroner.
902
00:37:43,886 --> 00:37:45,609
She's starting an inquiry
into your cases.
903
00:37:45,610 --> 00:37:46,851
- You pull that thread,
904
00:37:46,852 --> 00:37:48,126
you'll flood the city
with killers.
905
00:37:48,127 --> 00:37:50,644
- No, Victor,
you already did that.
906
00:37:50,645 --> 00:37:52,368
- I wasn't wrong
about those women.
907
00:37:52,369 --> 00:37:54,471
They-they did terrible things
to their children!
908
00:37:54,472 --> 00:37:57,230
- All children
of bad mothers, right?
909
00:37:57,231 --> 00:37:58,644
- I don't have a bias, Graff.
910
00:37:58,645 --> 00:38:00,368
- No, you don't have a bias.
911
00:38:00,369 --> 00:38:02,437
You've something deeper.
912
00:38:02,438 --> 00:38:04,265
You have personal experience.
913
00:38:05,093 --> 00:38:08,576
You saw yourself in those kids,
didn't you?
914
00:38:10,955 --> 00:38:14,920
Six trips to the hospital
before you were 14 years old?
915
00:38:14,921 --> 00:38:19,161
Uh, broken bones, concussion?
Burns?
916
00:38:19,162 --> 00:38:22,230
- Those were accidents.
He was a clumsy boy.
917
00:38:22,231 --> 00:38:23,747
- Oh, was he?
918
00:38:23,748 --> 00:38:25,437
Or is that just a lie
you told yourself
919
00:38:25,438 --> 00:38:27,230
so you could sleep at night?
920
00:38:27,231 --> 00:38:29,299
The lie that he was too small
to fight?
921
00:38:29,300 --> 00:38:30,989
Do you remember
that hospital room?
922
00:38:30,990 --> 00:38:33,092
Yeah, your mother on the other
side of the curtain,
923
00:38:33,093 --> 00:38:35,816
weaving her stories about
how you fell, how you...
924
00:38:35,817 --> 00:38:38,437
how you wrenched your arm
on the monkey bars?
925
00:38:38,438 --> 00:38:41,920
Feeling sick to your stomach
about what would happen
926
00:38:41,921 --> 00:38:43,885
if you were to tell your truth.
927
00:38:43,886 --> 00:38:45,644
- She's your mother.
928
00:38:45,645 --> 00:38:47,954
Victor, she's supposed
to protect you.
929
00:38:47,955 --> 00:38:49,403
And she didn't.
930
00:38:49,852 --> 00:38:51,885
And every single time,
931
00:38:51,886 --> 00:38:53,989
they would send you
right back home to her.
932
00:38:53,990 --> 00:38:55,575
- You don't know anything
about Victor.
933
00:38:55,576 --> 00:38:57,161
He had a wonderful home.
934
00:38:57,162 --> 00:38:58,851
- No, a wonderful home
is a safe home
935
00:38:58,852 --> 00:38:59,954
and yours wasn't, was it?
936
00:38:59,955 --> 00:39:01,851
So what'd you do?
937
00:39:01,852 --> 00:39:04,678
You tiptoe around her moods
as if they were landmines?
938
00:39:04,679 --> 00:39:06,644
- Why do you care what happened
to me as a child?
939
00:39:06,645 --> 00:39:08,437
- Because it happened
to me as a child.
940
00:39:08,438 --> 00:39:10,299
And I care.
941
00:39:10,300 --> 00:39:12,506
See, I wanted to find
your hiding place.
942
00:39:12,507 --> 00:39:14,540
Mine was under the stairs,
943
00:39:14,541 --> 00:39:16,471
but I wasn't sure about you,
so I went
944
00:39:16,472 --> 00:39:17,471
to your mother's house.
945
00:39:17,472 --> 00:39:19,161
And we had a cup of tea,
we talked.
946
00:39:19,162 --> 00:39:23,575
I looked around because you have
something that we need.
947
00:39:23,576 --> 00:39:26,645
And I was sure I'd find it
in your hiding spot.
948
00:39:27,196 --> 00:39:28,575
Where was it?
949
00:39:28,576 --> 00:39:30,540
Was it in the little nook
behind the front door,
950
00:39:30,541 --> 00:39:32,161
was it in the crawlspace?
951
00:39:32,162 --> 00:39:33,299
No.
952
00:39:33,300 --> 00:39:34,885
See, the sad thing is,
953
00:39:34,886 --> 00:39:37,679
is that there was nowhere
for you to hide.
954
00:39:38,886 --> 00:39:42,471
But I did find this...
955
00:39:42,472 --> 00:39:44,748
all the same.
956
00:39:45,507 --> 00:39:47,610
- You, uh...
957
00:39:48,438 --> 00:39:49,885
gave it to him?
958
00:39:49,886 --> 00:39:53,540
- You said I would be helping
Victor if I...
959
00:39:53,541 --> 00:39:56,126
if I showed you where
his things were.
960
00:39:56,127 --> 00:40:00,023
- That is not his.
That is evidence.
961
00:40:00,024 --> 00:40:03,678
- I can't believe you took it
off Izzy's body
962
00:40:03,679 --> 00:40:05,506
and kept it
all these years.
963
00:40:05,507 --> 00:40:08,092
You swore an oath to do no harm.
964
00:40:08,093 --> 00:40:09,851
- I put a criminal behind bars!
965
00:40:09,852 --> 00:40:11,678
- Yeah.
The wrong one.
966
00:40:11,679 --> 00:40:14,023
- I have spent
my entire life in service
967
00:40:14,024 --> 00:40:16,299
of justice
for the defenceless.
968
00:40:16,300 --> 00:40:17,920
- You were not protecting
those kids.
969
00:40:17,921 --> 00:40:19,816
You were trying to protect
that little boy.
970
00:40:19,817 --> 00:40:22,851
Because having the power
to decide who gets punished
971
00:40:22,852 --> 00:40:25,023
means no one
is punishing you anymore.
972
00:40:25,024 --> 00:40:27,609
- You are not gonna blame me
for this.
973
00:40:27,610 --> 00:40:28,851
I was a good mother!
974
00:40:28,852 --> 00:40:30,471
I raised him right.
[sighing]
975
00:40:30,472 --> 00:40:32,851
I mean, look at him,
he's successful,
976
00:40:32,852 --> 00:40:35,023
and wealthy, and good manners-
- Mother.
977
00:40:35,024 --> 00:40:37,023
- And loyal!
He was-he was a good boy!
978
00:40:37,024 --> 00:40:38,816
- Mother!
- I mean, sure,
979
00:40:38,817 --> 00:40:41,023
sometimes I had to use
a firm hand,
980
00:40:41,024 --> 00:40:43,403
it's what he needed!
- What I needed...
981
00:40:44,507 --> 00:40:46,714
was for you to stop...
982
00:40:47,300 --> 00:40:48,990
hurting me.
983
00:40:51,472 --> 00:40:55,438
[somber music]
984
00:40:57,093 --> 00:40:58,679
You were terrifying.
985
00:41:00,852 --> 00:41:02,886
I was just a boy.
986
00:41:05,886 --> 00:41:08,886
[Victor sobbing]
987
00:41:12,645 --> 00:41:14,713
- You were just a boy.
988
00:41:14,714 --> 00:41:18,093
No one should have ever
laid a hand on you, Victor.
989
00:41:18,403 --> 00:41:20,230
You deserved safety.
990
00:41:20,231 --> 00:41:24,540
And you were just trying
to make it right
991
00:41:24,541 --> 00:41:26,126
for those kids,
weren't you?
992
00:41:26,127 --> 00:41:28,127
When you went to see Cara?
993
00:41:30,576 --> 00:41:32,747
- I had to stop her.
994
00:41:32,748 --> 00:41:35,057
- From what?
- Talking.
995
00:41:35,058 --> 00:41:37,024
- Yeah.
996
00:41:37,610 --> 00:41:39,024
Tell me what happened?
997
00:41:40,921 --> 00:41:43,369
- I got into her motel room.
998
00:41:43,783 --> 00:41:45,920
[heavy breathing]
999
00:41:45,921 --> 00:41:48,057
I had to find her evidence.
1000
00:41:48,058 --> 00:41:49,645
- Mm-hmm.
- But...
1001
00:41:51,127 --> 00:41:53,575
I made a noise!
1002
00:41:53,576 --> 00:41:54,885
[groaning]
1003
00:41:54,886 --> 00:41:57,472
She came out of the bathroom...
1004
00:42:01,127 --> 00:42:03,576
I hit her.
[sniffling]
1005
00:42:04,576 --> 00:42:06,127
- And then?
1006
00:42:09,265 --> 00:42:11,438
- I pushed her into the tub.
1007
00:42:13,714 --> 00:42:15,265
- And then?
1008
00:42:16,990 --> 00:42:20,058
[somber music continues]
1009
00:42:21,300 --> 00:42:24,438
- I threw the hairdryer in.
1010
00:42:26,162 --> 00:42:28,369
[sobbing]
1011
00:42:32,783 --> 00:42:35,852
[somber music continues]
1012
00:42:39,196 --> 00:42:40,990
[sobbing]
1013
00:42:50,403 --> 00:42:52,851
[sobbing]
1014
00:42:52,852 --> 00:42:54,368
[bell tolling]
- The Judge agreed.
1015
00:42:54,369 --> 00:42:56,506
We'll declare a mistrial,
start over.
1016
00:42:56,507 --> 00:42:59,195
Try Christian with the hair
and evidence once it's tested.
1017
00:42:59,196 --> 00:43:00,713
Get justice for Izzy.
1018
00:43:00,714 --> 00:43:02,954
- And with this whole Plath
thing cracked open,
1019
00:43:02,955 --> 00:43:04,609
maybe for Maxine and Cara too.
1020
00:43:04,610 --> 00:43:06,024
- Hmm.
1021
00:43:06,921 --> 00:43:10,126
- Well, it's good to be
reminded from time to time
1022
00:43:10,127 --> 00:43:12,402
that our system
of law is human,
1023
00:43:12,403 --> 00:43:14,161
and therefore fallible.
1024
00:43:14,162 --> 00:43:16,471
- "And that the most
we can hope to achieve
1025
00:43:16,472 --> 00:43:18,644
is a certain justice?"
1026
00:43:18,645 --> 00:43:20,506
P.D. James.
1027
00:43:20,507 --> 00:43:22,333
It's a little popular
for your taste.
1028
00:43:22,334 --> 00:43:25,161
- Well, I'm not above
a beach read, Bateman.
1029
00:43:25,162 --> 00:43:29,402
Not after this.
Well, I think I'm overdue.
1030
00:43:29,403 --> 00:43:32,092
[theme song]
1031
00:43:32,093 --> 00:43:35,438
Subtitling: difuze
1032
00:43:35,488 --> 00:43:40,038
Repair and Synchronization by
Easy Subtitles Synchronizer 1.0.0.0
76795
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.
Afrikaans
Akan
Albanian
Amharic
Arabic
Armenian
Azerbaijani
Basque
Belarusian
Bemba
Bengali
Bihari
Bosnian
Breton
Bulgarian
Cambodian
Catalan
Cebuano
Cherokee
Chichewa
Chinese (Simplified)
Chinese (Traditional)
Corsican
Croatian
Czech
Danish
English
Esperanto
Estonian
Faroese
Finnish
Frisian
Galician
Georgian
German
Greek
Guarani
Haitian Creole
Hausa
Hawaiian
Hebrew
Hmong
Hungarian
Icelandic
Indonesian
Irish
Italian
Japanese
Kazakh
Kinyarwanda
Kirundi
Kongo
Korean
Krio (Sierra Leone)
Kurdish
Kyrgyz
Laothian
Latin
Latvian
Lithuanian
Luganda
Luo
Luxembourgish
Macedonian
Malagasy
Malay
Maltese
Maori
Mauritian Creole
Moldavian
Mongolian
Myanmar (Burmese)
Montenegrin
Nepali
Norwegian
Pashto
Persian
Polish
Portuguese (Brazil)
Portuguese (Portugal)
Quechua
Romanian
Romansh
Russian
Samoan
Scots Gaelic
Serbian
Sesotho
Setswana
Seychellois Creole
Shona
Sindhi
Sinhalese
Slovak
Slovenian
Somali
Spanish
Swedish
Tajik
Thai
Tigrinya
Tonga
Turkish
Turkmen
Ukrainian
Uzbek
Vietnamese
Welsh
Wolof