All language subtitles for When Calls the Heart s13e04 Until Proven Guilty

Previously on When Calls the Heart How
are those insurance claims coming? I am

hosting a legal clinic at the
schoolhouse tomorrow night. I would love

That's McGinty. What are we still doing
here? Let's go arrest the guy. We'll

know if it's arson in a day or two. I'm
right about this one.

We stopped to have some soup for lunch
with just a small cooking fire.

We are responsible for starting the
fire.

Boys, why don't you tell Constable
Graham what you told your parents and

There you go, fellas.

Thank you.

When we went out to set trail markers,
Toby and I decided to make a fire.

We wanted to heat up some stew, but then
we put it out.

And doused it with water, buried the
coals. From what Cooper told me, they

everything right.

Where exactly did you light this fire?

Do you remember?

Up the north side, just past Bell Rock.

We could take you there.

No. It's okay. We know Bell Rock.

As soon as the fireside is safe, we'll
head up to inspect.

Did either of you actually see this fire
start?

No. We didn't notice anything until we
were almost down North Ridge.

That's when we smelled smoke.

And just like that, we were surrounded
by fire.

I promise I thought it was out.

We must have missed a step.

We're so sorry.

It's all right.

You both did great in there.

I'm so proud of you boys for telling the
truth.

I wish we never made that fire.

So we still don't know what caused the
fire.

And if it was the boys?

Well, they're minors, so this will go on
the record.

They may have some community service,
but they won't serve any jail time.

I do have to warn you that if Cooper and
Toby are found responsible...

Your family could be liable for all
property loss and damage.

That's half the town.

We can't possibly pay for that. What do
we do?

Well, you can certainly fight it in
court.

So my advice is to get the best lawyer
you can.

The sooner the better.

Lady, I'm so sorry.

I got... I got stuck at this ridiculous
dinner, and by the time I ran over to

the meeting, everyone had left.

Well, once people realized the governor
wasn't joining as I had promised, no one

saw a reason to stay.

I really am sorry.

It was an important last -minute meeting
for my campaign. You know what?

In my work in Capital City, I spent a
lot of time around politicians.

Then they always complained about the
same thing.

Compromises, tough choices, the games.
But deep down in their core, they loved

it. I thought maybe you were different,
that you wanted to change the rules.

I guess I was wrong.

Now, if you'll excuse me, my clients
expect my full attention, not

New saddle.

Newton is going to love it.

Actually, this is for Oliver's official
service horse.

We get him in on Monday.

I thought he didn't get a horse until
he's 18.

Well, after Sunday, he'll be 18.

Sunday?

Oh, my goodness.

I have so much to do.

Bye, Dad.

Sorry, Judge Avery.

Where's she off to in such a hurry? I
think I might have just released the

hounds on someone.

It's Oliver's birthday this weekend.

At least someone will be enjoying
themselves.

Yeah, I know.

I really hate this part of the job.

Oh, we still have McGinty we can look
into.

We bring him in for questioning.

All right, I'll get him in today.

Anything so we don't have to charge
those boys.

Here you go.

I had wondered where you two scampered
off to after breakfast.

Yep, just want to show you what we've
been working on.

I thought Goldie could use it for
adults.

And I made this for myself. Goodness.

Oh, oh, oh, all right now. Oh, gosh.

Well,

I can tell the craftsmanship is quite
good.

Can I walk Goldie to daycare again?

Gwen, of course.

Thank you. That's very helpful.

Gwen's going to walk you to daycare, all
right?

Off you go.

Bye -bye.

It was good for me to get back to making
something again.

Which got me thinking. You know how last
night at the meeting a lot of people

were complaining about the construction
company jacking their prices to profit

off Benson Hills and their tragedy?

Yes, it's terrible. It's reprehensible.
So, what if we expand coulter lumber

into coulter construction?

A one -stop shop for the Benson Hills
rebuild. What do you think?

Lee, I think it's wonderful.

I heard it was old man McGinty.

That's why Mayor Coulter went after him.

Focus on your reading, please.

What does arson mean?

Someone did this to us. A fire like that
doesn't just happen.

I know how difficult this is for you
all. Though it may be tempting.

Until we have all of the answers, we
shouldn't be hearing unfounded rumors.

Now let's turn our attention to science,
please.

We have a witness that saw you entering
the park with a can of fuel the day of

the fire.

Oh, yeah? Who? We're asking the
question. Your history with the park

person of interest.

You can choose to withhold information
or not cooperate, but that didn't serve

you very well last time, did it?

Look, A .J.

We know you lost your ranch in the fire.
We don't want to drag this out any more

than we have to, but if it was you
entering the park with a can of fuel on

day of the fire, what do you expect us
to think?

It wasn't fuel. It was a cat.

Excuse me?

I was burying my cat.

So the can was a cat? I buried the cat
in the can to protect

it from wildlife so he could rest in
peace, all right?

Do you expect us to believe... His name
was Mr. Mittens. He was a Maine Coon and

the best mouser I ever had.

Well, I'm inclined to believe you.

Because I don't want anybody to make up
a story like that.

But it still puts you in the forest the
day of the fire. And you could have set

that fire after the... burial.

Fine. Ask the barkeep at Shivering
Timbers.

Shivering timbers in Benson Hill, though
they're all afternoon.

Toasting the memory of mittens?

Mr. Mittens.

And there you are. Fifteen cents change.

Thank you, Denise.

Oh, good afternoon, Minnie. Good
afternoon, Ned.

Florence. Minnie.

How are the jam sales going?

Pretty good, I suppose. More folks are
buying provisions since the fire. And

they do love the jam. They do. Oh,
that's wonderful.

Would you be able to sell more if I
brought in a double batch this week and

next few weeks?

We wouldn't be able to pay you up front,
but, of course, you'll keep all the

proceeds of what we sell.

All right.

I'll bring some more jars.

Very good.

Minnie, are you all right?

Yes. Yes, of course.

See you both tomorrow.

Cheerio. Good day. All right.

Hmm. Hmm.

Oh, back already?

Yeah.

Found the barkeep.

He's been living in Buxton since the
fire.

So did AJ's story check out?

Seems so.

McGinty talked the poor guy's ear off
about mittens all afternoon.

I think you mean Mr. Mittens.

Oh, well, without another lead, I'd just
leave. Yeah, I know.

And we keep looking.

Hi.

Hi.

Oh, no.

Bad day?

It started bad.

It got worse.

We cleared McGinty.

So Cooper and Toby?

Yeah. It's looking like it more and
more.

Those poor boys.

And their families.

Is there anything we can do to protect
them?

I can't withhold our strongest lead from
my report, but I can redact their names

because they're minors.

It's not much. But it's something.

Yeah.

Have I told you lately how impeccable I
think you are?

Not lately.

Hey there, you two.

You seem awful chipper.

I'm planning a surprise party.

Oliver turns 18 on Sunday.

And it'll be his first birthday party.
Ever?

Ever.

And hearing out, I'm thinking circus.

Okay, maybe circus is a bit overboard.

What do you think Oliver would want?

Probably something smaller, more
personal.

Sounds about right.

I don't know. I just really want it to
be special.

Allie, I think whatever you do, it's
going to be special.

Do you think you could both help?

Yes.

You're the best.

It's Maisie.

Those aren't the clothes we put out for
donation.

Well, I made some executive decisions.

You know, I must say, Mae, you and
Michael are two peas in a pod.

Neither one of you has much fashion
sense.

I'm all for donating. We're a good
cause.

But she's even taken the matching hats
we got on our honeymoon.

And your blue suit. You wore this at our
wedding.

She's never liked me in blue.

Mike, you aren't going to say anything?

I found with Maisie, it's best to just
pick your battles.

Well, in order for that to work, you
actually have to pick some battles.

Enjoy.

Hi, Allie. The usual?

Not today.

I just came by to give you this.

It's a surprise party for Oliver's
birthday.

Thanks anyway, but I can't come.

Why? Are you working?

Maybe the host can cover your shift.

I don't think I should go.

But everyone's going to be there.

It was me, Cooper.

We lit a fire in the woods when you and
Opal were off, and obviously that must

have been what started the fire.

Until we... We told the constable. So
everybody's going to know soon enough.

So I don't think you want us at your
party.

So I talked to everyone, and they're all
on board for the expansion.

What? What is it?

I read the most recent RCMP report about
the fire.

A .G. McGinty was in the woods on the
day of the fire. I knew it! He did not

start it.

He didn't? He was burying his cat, one
Mr. Mittens.

He was back in Benson Hills and
accounted for by the time the fire

Well...

Back to square one.

Still have no idea who started the fire.

Well, there is one more thing in the
report.

The only lead now is two kids from Hope
Valley.

An accidental fire that got out of
control.

The kids who went hiking?

Yes.

You're not going to publish that,
though, right? No, I will not.

But I'm sure the Benson Hills Beatle
will.

You seen this?

Don't want to.

Can you do me a favor?

There's something missing from this
shepherd's pie, and I don't know what it

Basil. I already put some in.

Pepper, maybe.

Elizabeth. I know.

I know.

If you had heard the children whispering
in class today, everyone's just looking

for someone to blame once they figure
out it was those boys.

You just find a way to stop the
speculation.

Well, maybe if people heard it directly
from you, then you could answer their

questions.

Call a meeting.

At least for the people here in town.

I think gossip is always the worst than
the truth.

That is a great idea.

I just heard from Nathan and Elizabeth.

They're calling a town meeting about the
fire investigation.

Are they going to talk about Cooper?

I don't know.

We should go.

I need to focus on what I can control.

Baby, what's all this?

I called that defense lawyer Bill
recommended.

And he's not cheap.

What about Edie? Can't she help us?

No, she's one of the victims of the
fire, too. So it's a conflict of

We need the best.

I know it's hard.

But what Cooper did was an accident.

We're going to be all right.

I have faith.

How can you pay for Angela's tuition and
a good lawyer for Cooper?

Job, you can put all your trust in God's
hands.

But right now, I need to use the hands
God gave me.

I can do both.

Put me to work.

Thank you all for being here on such
short notice.

Now, we know that the fire investigation
is a topic of great interest.

I'm sure many of you have read the
article in the Benson Hills Beatle.

So we're here today to give you the
facts of the investigation, quell any

rumors, and answer any questions that
you may have.

Is it true that you questioned A .J.
McGinty?

Why hasn't he been arrested?

A .J. McGinty had a verified alibi
during the fire.

He's no longer a suspect, but we are
still looking.

The Beatle says two kids from Hope
Valley started the fire. Is that true?

Calm down, everyone. Calm down.

It's true that there was a group of kids
hiking in the woods at the time, and

they lit a small camping fire.

But it is still under investigation.
There's no proof yet that that is what

caused the wildfire. But that is what
you suspect.

Under investigation does not mean
arrested or convicted.

Is it true that your daughter was one of
those hikers?

All right, let's just remember that the
people of Hope Valley took us in during

our time of need. No, what we need right
now is a little trust. We

want to believe that you are telling us
all you know and not putting your kids

and your jobs ahead of closing this out.

You all get to sleep in your own beds.

It's easy to forget that some of us have
nothing.

Mayor Hickam, we are working as quickly
as we can, but not quicker.

Well, it sure sounds like you're keeping
secrets. I know

how hard it is

waiting for answers.

You all have lost so much and everyone
is just looking for why.

But what if...

It does turn out that all of this
happened because some kids lit a

What if your suffering isn't caused by
anyone trying to hide the truth from you

or hurt you?

What if it really was just a terrible
accident?

As much as you're hurting, finding blame
today isn't going to bring back your

homes or restore your businesses.

When you all showed up in Hope Valley
with the few things you could carry, we

became a community.

And that's the only way we're going to
get through this.

I just feel so helpless, Nathan.

I know.

I mean, if it was our kids, what would
you do?

I would make sure they felt loved and
supported.

No matter the outcome.

Well, then that's exactly what we're
gonna do for Cooper and Toby.

Cooper! Cooper Canfield!

What do you think you're doing?

I don't want to burden you anymore.

I read that.

And it's nonsense.

I heard you and Dad last night.

I know I'm ruining everyone's lives.

Better if I go.

You listen to me.

You have never been and will never be a
burden.

You and Dad have so much to worry about.

With Angela, with the church, I'm
supposed to be the easy one.

If Angela has to leave school because of
my mistake, I won't be

able to live with myself.

Cooper, please hear this.

You've brought us light and joy since
the day you were born.

And this accident, this mistake, it
changes nothing.

You are known.

And you are loved.

Okay?

After all the business I've done at your
bank, this is what you pull?

Forget the loan.

I'll do it on my own.

There you go.

You got no ranch, no insurance, and no
loan.

You ruin.

You got your wish.

So, after we check on the cupcake and
pick up the balloons, we'll be all set

decorate.

Hi, Maxine. Rupert.

Um, maybe this whole party is a mistake.

What? It's too late to cancel it. Why
would you say that?

Well, I thought it would be good to try
and have fun together. Mm -hmm.

But I invited the kids from Benson
Hills, and none of them were coming.

Ellie, listen.

Everyone heals at their own pace.

And you are doing something beautiful
for a friend.

Oh.

There's the birthday boy now.

Do you mind if I... Of course.

Oliver, wait up.

Hi, Alex. Where are you headed?

Oh, just doing errands.

Um, how is everything today?

I mean, after that town meeting.

About the same.

Rupert's mother wouldn't even look at
me.

If you want answers, it'll take time.

I know who it was.

Toby told me yesterday.

Then why didn't you defend yourself at
the meeting last night? You let everyone

think it could be you.

It's like Mrs. Thornton said.

It shouldn't matter who it was.

It was an accident.

I taught them to get stoned this summer.

Now it feels like it'll never be like
that again.

Hey, want to meet later?

Maybe go for a ride?

Yeah, okay.

Sure.

Meet at the stables?

Actually, meet at the cafe.

Three o 'clock.

I have got to bring something to Mrs.
Canfield.

Okay. Sure.

So, it's a date.

Well, it's not a date, but a plan.

It's a plan.

I'll see you later.

Can't wait.

Mikey, I am trying to breathe some life
back into this so -called garden of

yours. What is it?

Well, Maisie, you remember how you
taught me not to overcrowd the

bulbs or else they won't bloom?

Yes, and it doesn't look like you've
been taking that advice.

Well, what I'm trying to say is we'll
all flourish if we have our own space

that we respect.

Our house.

And May and I are very happy to have you
here as long as you need.

But, well, you're not the mayor here.

So, what are the terms?

I'm going to wear blue.

Powder. Royal.

Navy.

Periwinkle. Oh, periwinkle.

All of them.

All of them.

All right.

And?

And May and I would like you to join us
at a birthday party.

A birthday party?

These are your terms, Michael.

Our young Mountie is turning 18, and
everyone is invited.

Oh, I highly doubt that some young man
is going to miss an old lady mayor.

You're exactly who we need right now.

I saw you at that meeting.

People follow you, and they always have.

If you show a little community spirit
right now, you'll inspire everyone else.

Just think about it.

Only if you want to.

May, I did it.

Am I interrupting?

Good.

Didn't see you at the town meeting last
night.

Wasn't sure if you'd heard that
McGinty'd been cleared.

I did hear that.

Rosie told me about Cooper and Toby and
the campfire.

And I'm so sorry for those boys.

That is a...

Terrible weight to have to carry.

How are you?

How you holding up?

If I'm being honest, I don't know right
now how we're gonna get through this.

Yeah.

I think that's why I was in such a rush
to blame McGinty. I needed to hold

someone responsible for everything that
I'd lost.

You're not alone in that.

Yeah. Guess I'm no better than anybody
else at that meeting.

Demanding names, needing someone to
blame.

I wouldn't go that far.

No.

You're willing to forgive Cooper and
Toby.

Maybe you could find some forgiveness
for Mr. McGinty.

He didn't start the fire.

I was wrong about that.

That's as far as I'm willing to go.

You know, Lee, mercy means the most when
it's hardest to give.

I hear you have an exciting announcement
to make. Yes,

I do.

I am officially seeking my second term
as your governor, and my reelection

campaign begins today.

Well, you heard it here first,
listeners, on the Valley Voice Radio

But now, tell us, why would people give
you another term?

I will continue to think broadly and
locally.

For all the people in the territory, we
will be helping the people of Benson

Hills rebuild their community.

That is a top priority.

In fact, I promise that the rebuild of
Benson Hills will be completed within

year. One year? Governor, the territory
famously carries a deficit. How can you

make a promise like that without money
to do it?

You're right.

We do need revenue.

Does that mean raising taxes?

That is one way for us to secure the
necessary funds, yes.

Look, I can tell people what they want
to hear about not raising taxes and then

do exactly that when I'm in office. But
I'm not going to lie to you.

I am going to do everything in my power
to bring our community back onto its

feet.

You pulled it off in record time.

Thanks for all your help.

Oliver, we'll be here soon.

There's no one here from Benson Hills.

I know you did your best, kiddo.

But it looks like somebody showed up.

Maisie, you made it.

Thank you for coming.

Thanks very much.

We so appreciate you coming, Mayor
Hickam.

Oh, my gosh.

Look.

Oh, my goodness. I am so happy you're
here. You were right. This

is our community now, too.

Really nice.

Ready to go?

Actually, there's something I want to
show you first.

Come with me.

Surprise!

Happy birthday, Oliver.

You did all this?

Oh, I know you never got to have a
party, so... Something for every

met.

Sort of like 18th and 2001.

What do you think?

I think this is the best thing ever.

Thank you.

Well, were you surprised?

More like shocked.

And amazed.

Glad to hear it. Let's get this party
started!

Yes!

Cornhole? Where's Cooper? He's the
master.

Where is he?

Manitoba.

They invited them, but I guess they
decided not to come.

You know.

Yeah.

This is all incredible, but I promise
I'll be right back.

Remember what Oliver said.

Loosen your wrist a little more and then
fling.

It's not just the wrist. You also got to
snap the elbow.

Oliver, what are you doing here?

Yeah, isn't your birthday party now?

It is, but you guys weren't there.

Trust me, that's how you want it.

Yeah. We set the fire, and you're a
Mountie. You shouldn't be hanging out

us. You didn't do anything on purpose.
You're not criminals.

Anyway, the whole point of a birthday
party is being with your friends, so if

you're not going, I'm not going.

Okay, but we have one condition.

He's not back yet.

Gather around, everyone. I just want to
say something really quick.

Thank you all for coming to my first
ever birthday party.

Before I came to Hope Valley, I didn't
really have friends, but now I do.

And I feel like the luckiest guy.

Because friends are always there for
you.

I'm glad I was able to convince my two
pals, Toby and Cooper, to join me here

today.

Maybe something they want to say to all
of us.

Our cooking fire sparked a wildfire.

It was a horrible action, and we're both
really sorry. So, so sorry.

Well, the first time I convinced my
parents to let me babysit all of my

siblings, baby Mikey went missing.

Missing! First rule of babysitting is
don't lose the baby, right?

Oh, I panicked.

Called in the town mounting.

Started a search party. And do you know
where we found him?

Asleep in the cupboard.

That's our Mikey.

That's right, even an old mayor like me
has made plenty of mistakes.

I'm pretty sure everyone here has.

I could keep you all here most of the
night talking about all my mistakes, but

this is a party.

Let's get back to having fun.

Well done.

Constable.

Happy birthday.

Thank you, Mayor Hickam.

Isn't that your tie?

I left the blue tie for you, Michael.

Even if it does wash you out.

Well, it's a start. Thank you.

Good luck.

Elizabeth, we heard about you beautiful.

beach of the town meeting.

Thank you for inspiring all this.

I just said the truth.

Cooper is an incredible kid. He's the
inspiration.

And he deserves everyone's support.

Well, just knowing we have that support
is enough to see us through.

That was the best party I've ever had.

Oliver, it's the only party you've ever
had.

I, um, I didn't get a chance to give
this to you.

You didn't have to get me anything.

This collection made me fall in love
with poetry.

Yeah, some for you, too.

You're not supposed to get other people
gifts on your birthday.

It's actually from your birthday.

I didn't get to give it to you last
year.

Nope, now it's okay.

Kept it all this time?

Go ahead.

Hold her.

It's a wolf.

Because, well, you love nature, and
you're so...

Brave. It's really beautiful.

Thank you.

Here, you have to...

really did a great job on that party.

Yeah. It's a special group of kids.

I tend to think that all kids are
special.

That's because of you.

We know that, right?

Those kids being generous today and
showing up for Toby and Cooper, that's

because of you, Elizabeth.

You inspired me.

I'd say it was more of a team effort.

I'm proud to be on your team.

Elizabeth Thornton.

Disaster has a way of breaking things
down beyond recognition, shattering the

world around us.

You look around and you think your life
will never be whole again.

But when you accept a little help, you
can start to put the pieces back

together.

You may be surprised to find what you
end up with.

AJ?

I've come to apologize.

I never should have accused you of
starting that fire, and I definitely...

I shouldn't have lost my temper.

So I am here today to humbly ask you for
a favor.

Would you be willing to let me launch my
construction company by building you a

cabin here?

I don't need your charity.

Well, that's good news, because this
wouldn't be charity. I would be using

cabin as a model for prospective
clients.

I guess that could work.

Good.

There is one more thing, Lee.

Right, yes, of course. The most
important thing, as a matter of fact.

May we suggest the name Dr.

Socks?

Because loss always comes with a hidden
gift.

And when we lean on our community, there
are greater riches to be found.