All language subtitles for Perry Mason s06e16 Constance Doyle

Hey! They got a cigarette machine in
there?

Now the drugstore's closed, see?

Hey, what's the matter?

Come on, Cal, run!

Come back here, you lousy chicken!

You run!

I'm done, Mac.

Not against the law climbing a fence, is
it?

I'll prove it.

I got a lawyer coming.

I didn't go in that place.

Just up on the fence is all.

But oh no.

No, CBU's got to protect the rich old
people.

The chicken kids they got here.

And that's a factory watchman with a
gun!

Listen!

I hated this town since I was ten years
old.

Snootsville.

Uppityburg on the beach.

I know you could say you'll tear this
place apart for me.

Hey!

Call it, kid.

You got a visitor.

You're Cal Leonard?

Yes, so what?

Well, you wanted a lawyer, didn't you?

It's all right, Sergeant.

Look, lady.

I left his name at the desk. Doyle.

Joseph Doyle.

They said they'd call his office, but I
got to see him in person.

I'm a friend of his, a real old friend.

Now, I know he's a big shot, but I can't
just tell any... any secretary, any...

Any wife.

And law partner.

You're a lawyer.

Yes. Ever since we've been in
California, we've practiced corporation

did you get hold of our names?

Mrs. Doyle, I know I'm not president of
any banks, but will you please just tell

your husband I can't be here now? I
can't be in jail right now.

Why not? You just hit a uniformed
officer.

And you've been in jail before.

The teletype out there says you were in
the Orange County probation camp.

What of it?

Will you please just tell your husband?

Joe Doyle is dead.

He died less than two months ago. Now,
come on, tell me the truth. How did my

husband ever meet you?

Same to you, lady.

Well, all right, let's start again.

Whatever you boys wanted to steal
tonight from the Otis company, you

away with it.

Skip it. You can't help me any.

You don't trust women very much, do you?
Why don't you trust people?

Why do you come in there like that?

What if I did lie about your husband? So
I only met him once. Is there any

reason to give me that who are you
stuff?

Young man, will you? No, no. Go back to
your fancy party.

Your fancy squares. Well, I don't need
you. I don't need anybody. Get out of

here.

It's all right, Sergeant.

I think I just lost a client.

Good night, Tuffy.

I'm sorry, Mrs. Doyle, but the man on
the bench didn't know who Doyle and

was, or he wouldn't have bothered you.

Calling you down here from your party or
whatever.

I fell asleep watching television.

I never got a chance to meet your
husband.

You people only being out here a year or
two, I guess.

But I certainly heard some mighty fine
things about him.

Thank you, Sergeant.

A kid like that needs a little dose of
the youth authority anyway.

Courts know how to handle delinquents.

Sergeant, would you take care of this
for me? I think the boy's bail will be

at about 500 at the deposit.

Oh, now, look here, Mrs. Doyle. You're
not going to waste your sympathy on that

little punk.

I won't, don't worry.

But perhaps he... Well, perhaps he did
meet Joe once.

Morning, Miss Gibney.

Telephone's been ringing.

Was it a wrong number or haven't we paid
a bill?

Oh, there's a client waiting for you.

Oh, don't tell me he's out already and
has come here.

I don't know what you're talking about.
It's Mr. Otis.

Mr. Otis, what a pleasant surprise.

Well, it sure is.

And say, you're looking fine.

Thank you.

You know, I've been meaning to come by
and have a visit ever since my company

stopped using your firm as consultant.

I was sure you'd understand.

When you two first came out here, it was
a matter of Joe's name and all the big

people he knew in Washington.

But then when Joe got sick, well, my
company was up to its neck in Air Force

contracts right then.

And you didn't think I'd know all the
famous people in Washington.

Well, I didn't think you'd want to be
bothered.

Please don't apologize, Mr. Otis. You're
not the first one who was canceled.

Well, darn it.

There sure ought to be plenty of
business for one good woman lawyer in

The trouble is I don't care about
divorces and wills and suing the

dog. There must be lots of fields a
woman might be interested in.

Take the juvenile problem.

Delinquency.

Why did you come here, Mr. Otis?

That boy who hit one of my plant guards
last night.

I understand you arranged bail for him.

And is there any reason why I shouldn't
have?

Well, I just wondered what your interest
was.

You see, when I noticed his name on a
report this morning, Cal Leonard, I

realized he must be the son of a man who
worked for me once.

What sort of man?

Engineer. Radio man.

Pretty bright, believe it or not.

Even had some ideas we put to use, in
fact. The only trouble was, they always

came out smelling of liquor.

His liver gave in.

He died an alcoholic.

Tell me about his son.

Hasn't been around here for years, I
think.

But you know how these tough kids are
these days.

Mr. Rhodes, have you some idea...

That I'm one of those torch -bearing
crusaders who will claim that your

laid hands on that boy.

Now, now, nothing quite that wild,
but... Save your breath, Mr. Otis. I

expect to see Cal Leonard again.

Well, I was also going to say we'll take
care of it from here on. For the sake

of his father, I don't want any charges
pursued.

Well, that's very nice of you, Mr. Otis.

Perhaps, um...

Perhaps even more than the boy deserves.

Well, anyway, I'm glad I had a chance to
say how sorry I am about your Joe. He

was a wonderful man.

Yes, he was.

Goodbye, Mr. Otis.

Miss Gibney, you'll find the Otis spot.

They let you loose.

Did they use rubber hoses first?

No, they said I gotta stick around till
next Tuesday for the trial.

I could hear you better if you'd stand
up.

Oh, I'm sorry. Excuse me, I'm sorry.

Well, that's some progress.

Look, Mrs. Doyle, the way it happened, I
was in probation camp, sure, from

juvenile court.

That's when your husband came to give
this speech.

Well, it sounded interesting, I guess,
because I said something.

And he was around all afternoon.

And he found out that I played chess.

And he wanted to show me a couple of
real tricky chess openings.

Well, we talked a little while
afterwards, I guess.

That really is the only time I ever met
him.

So I am a...

Big liar, but I'm sorry, see?

What was Joe's speech about?

Well, I guess it was him, mostly.

But, uh... He reminded me a little of my
father when... Whenever he was sober.

How long ago was that?

My father?

I, uh... I never saw him since I was
ten.

They wouldn't let me.

They? Welfare workers, parole guys.

She had them all conned.

Anything and pants.

Well, I guess I won't ask you anything
about your mother.

Thanks.

Anyway, she died of something important,
so...

So the reason why I came is to borrow
ten bucks. I figured if I'm going to be

Seaview until Tuesday... Excuse me.

Yes?

Constant? Is that you?

Fred McCormick.

Can I call you back?

Just take a second, Connie. I have the
steamship company on the other line. You

were talking about a freighter trip.

And those reservations are hard to get.

Well, what's the use of being an old
-fashioned ship's chanderer if one can't

use a little influence for one's
friends, eh?

Oh, Fred, please.

There's a Norwegian boat leaving in just
a couple of days.

Hit Italy and Greece.

I'm hanging up.

Now, Connie, look here. If it's that
case you're handling, that boy coming up

for trial next Tuesday, well, there's no
need to let a little thing like that

interfere.

Ma, you get around, don't you?

As a matter of fact, I was just talking
to Judge Simpson.

He says it's nonsense.

Yeah, says the whole thing could be
squashed, if you like.

Fred, I'll talk to you later.

Well, I figured ten bucks.

Cal, what were you boys?

Going to steal at the oldest plant last
night?

Nothing.

See, I just want to get in the place,
that's all.

Those other guys have picked up the
bowling alley.

See, they were going to keep the
watchman busy so I could go on and...

you looking at?

I just want to get in to see somebody.

Who?

A cousin of mine, Steve Arthur.

I thought he could get me a job.

Only when I went there in the daytime...

Guards threw me out.

He's 20.

Oh, get yourself a haircut first.

Why didn't you go to his house to see
him?

Because he's never there.

See, his wife, she hates his... and vice

versa.

Anyway, those guys work late at the
plant at night, and he wouldn't answer

phone.

Why on earth did you think he would give
you a job?

Why do you ask me such stupid questions?

What do you want from me?

Cal, shut up.

Now.

Steve Arthur is his name.

Miss Smith, were you in my desk again
last night?

What did you say, Mr. Arthur?

I found all these drawers open when I
got in here just now, and I also noticed

that the filing cabinet had been moved.

Something out of the file, Mr. Arthur?

Spit out the gum. I had a racing form
and a little notebook.

Steve, why can't you get to work on
time?

Hello, Mr. Otis. Well, I ran into this
little cocktail waitress down the

Here, read that.

It's a gate report.

Go on, read the whole thing.

Mm -hmm.

Cal Leonard.

So what?

He's a useless kid.

Tried to phone me yesterday.

I told the guards to make sure he... Oh?

He was up in the fence.

Steve, I want you to take a trip.

What if they caught him leaving this
place instead of entering it?

What do you mean?

Suppose he got in here last night.

Suppose he rifled my desk.

I think you better do what I say, Mr.
Otis.

And I think you'd better let me handle
this delinquent little cousin of mine.

Well, what in the devil do you keep in
that desk besides a whiskey bottle and

racing forms?

My bank statements.

So my wife won't see them.

There are times when I could murder that
husband of mine.

Then I don't think he has any life
insurance, does he?

I wouldn't know anything about that,
Mrs. Arthur.

I thought I told you last night where
you could find out all sorts of things

about Steve.

Yeah, sure.

Do you want another drink?

Waitress.

Here, have some of this, Cal. They don't
mind here.

I never have any money.

But I'm not embarrassed.

Well, I just borrowed this someplace.

But I could pay it back pretty quick if
I wanted to. Maybe 50 times over, don't

you think?

Waitress!

I'll have another one, please.

You better make it a double this time.

You said Steve was broke.

Now, my dad paid all the bills. Steve
was a nothing.

$62 a week clerk.

That's still what he expects me to live
on.

You said Steve... Steve maybe even stole
money from my dad.

Could it have been as much as $100 ,000?

A what?

You did find something in that office,
didn't you?

Don't get excited. I'm just guessing.

But didn't Steve ever let it slip?

Didn't he ever talk in his sleep about
all that dough he spends on those dames

and how he got it? About how much was my
dad's dough and how much is really

mine? Just remember, I want my share.

All I want is just a little something,
maybe. My parents might have left me.

I mean, even if my old man left me
nothing but five bucks, okay.

You can have the rest.

But I gotta know.

Understand?

Sure, Cal.

I understand.

And your father did mean to leave you
something. I know he did.

But how'd that husband of mine manage to
get it and parlay it?

Gone.

Gone.

Okay.

Here's what you do next.

Mrs. Doyle, were you looking for... Mrs.
Doyle, are you back from lunch?

Doyle!

Stop! Stop!

Miss Gibney, what on earth are you
doing?

He was here.

He was in here. I saw him running out
the alley.

That brat, that dirty, thieving
little... Carol in it?

Yes. Well, calm down. I told him to come
back here.

Miss Gibney?

Where are my keys? I left them on the
desk.

You see?

And heaven knows what else he took.
Well, I'll fix that young man.

What are you calling?

At least, of course. What do you think?

Well, you do no such thing.

Bring me the Los Angeles telephone
directory.

Of course I remember you, Mrs. Doyle.
Friend of Perry's. I'm afraid I've

off more than I can chew.

There's a boy.

His name is Cal Leonard.

Uh -huh. But why didn't you... Oh.

Yeah, I guess there are bigger fish to
fry. But while you were trying to find

them, you sure need somebody to pin that
kid's ears back.

Well, you'd better hurry.

I suspect this young, um, you -know
-what has borrowed my car.

Do what?

I don't know.

Come on, kid.

It's my cousin, Steve Arthur.

I already told Mr.

Drake. I told the cop she called. I told
the lieutenant in the other office.

Well, it won't hurt you to tell it a few
more times.

Now, you said you went out there at 7 o
'clock. Is that right?

Yeah.

It was dark in the house, so I started
around back.

I went to the gate, and I tripped.

Over Steve's body, I guess.

Anyway, I fell on the concrete.

That's how I got this. Almost
concussion, the doc said.

Pretty clumsy at your age, don't you
think?

Baby trips and bumps his little head.

You lay off.

He's the one that's got to answer
things.

He's the one that got me out there.

It was his weekend place my cousin was
killed in, wasn't it?

Cal, I think Mr. Otis has an alibi.

Tell me exactly how he got you out
there.

Well, I was looking for Steve all
afternoon.

It was about six o 'clock. I went back
to his house.

Only one there was his wife, Lettie.

She drinks.

Anyway, the phone rang. It was Mr. Otis
wanting to talk to me.

What did he say?

He said the trouble with the guard was
being fixed.

Then he said Steve was out there with
him.

And if I'd run on out, there was a big
surprise for me.

Did you expect to get some money?

I knew Steve owed me something.

The company gave my dad some dough one
time for some ideas he had.

And Steve Arthur took it?

The money you or your father should have
had?

Mrs. Doyle, I know better than to say
too much.

Anyway, you told the lieutenant I stole
your car, didn't you?

Oh, Cal, what's the matter with you?
Now, come on, sit down and tell me about

that money.

Well, do you know how many bank accounts
my cousin Steve had?

Four. Number 3756 in Compton Security.

Number 4221 in Seaview National.

I remember them all. I wrote them down
once in a date book of Steve's.

He put all of his salary in Seaview.

But in Compton Security, last month he
put $6 ,350.

Then he made regular deposits over and
above his salary.

Sure. In the last year and a half, all
accounts totaled $100 and...

$3 ,260.

Cal, how could anyone remember such
complicated figures?

That's nothing.

When I was a kid, I'd go riding with my
old man. And he'd say, son, give me the

next five license plates.

I could remember them all. Even the cars
went by 50 miles an hour. And I'd add

up the numbers for him, too. That's when
I was 10.

No wonder my husband was so interested
in you.

We're interested, all right. We don't
need to know, isn't it? That's all I've

got to tell you.

Mr. Doyle, you can't help me.

You're not even a criminal lawyer.

And that's what I am, isn't it?

Criminal.

You saw Perry at the hospital, and he
said he'd be out in plenty of time to

defend Cal Leonard in the jury trial,
right?

Perry says at a preliminary hearing.

Anyone can hold the client's hand while
the prosecution rattles off enough facts

to bind the client over.

Of course, there are a few shots I want
to fire myself before anyone gets into

this. Certain people in Seaview are far
too interested in Cal.

If I can make them say why, maybe he
won't be even charged with murder.

Miniaturization?

What on earth?

Miniaturization of instruments. You know
what that is. You make navigational

equipment, don't you?

Oh, well, these days a ship's chandler
has to branch out a bit, but... I went

the Otis Company.

They told me to talk to Lawrence Otis.

But these days, Lawrence Otis only talks
to the district attorney in Los

Angeles. I thought there might be some
mention of it in our files, but Miss

Gibney says no.

All right, Constance.

What do you want to know?

Carl Leonard's father invented some
instrument.

The Otis Company has made a fortune from
it. Isn't that right?

Oh, well, maybe it was Leonard's idea,
the way Otis floats instruments in gas

instead of oil.

Of course, in space research, where
weight is an important... Exactly.

Why didn't you mention it when I asked
you about it yesterday?

Oh, now, Connie, see here. You didn't
even tell me that Carl Leonard's father

worked for you. Why should I?

Man was a drinker. We fired him for it,
as I recall. Anyway, it had nothing to

do with the boy.

Fred, isn't it possible that someone has
stolen Cal's father's invention?

How should I know?

Constance, look, as a friend of yours, I
felt.

Yes, and I still feel that there's just
no sense in your getting all mixed up in

this mess.

Oh, Fred, darling, what is the matter
with you? All I want to know...

until this murder business is cleared
up, I'm not going to be the one to...

Well, I am simply not going to tell you
anything about anyone that I don't know

to be absolutely true.

I'll tell you anything you want to know,
Mrs. Doran. I've got nothing to hide.

I'm celebrating my freedom.

I do feel a little sorry about Cal,
maybe.

Well, you ought to be.

You're the one who egged him on.

Now, just a minute.

Got him all excited about money and
ideas and inventions or whatever it is

husband perhaps stole from his father.

I've got news for you, Mrs. Doyle.

Sure. I knew that Steve was cashing in
on something.

And maybe Cal did help me find out how
much.

But I also know that Steve Arthur didn't
have the brains to...

Steal olives from a martini.

Who do you think did the stealing?

You really want to know? Because I
figured that out, too.

Your husband.

Excuse me, Mrs. Doyle.

Oh, I'm Bloody Arthur.

Hi. They're charging Carolina with first
-degree murder. And for some reason,

Berger's handling the case himself.

Well,

it'll be in all the papers anyway, so I
might as well give you the rest of it.

Cal Leonard's fingerprints were found
all over the inside of that cottage.

What? I must have lied to you again.

Anyway, they claim they're going to
prove that he had a fight with Steve

and then followed him outside.

Don't shake her up too much, mister.

Because I just told her something that
it seems everybody else knew first.

Her Mr.

Joe Doyle was some sort of a crook.

We found Mr. Arthur lying there on his
back.

I've already noted the two points where
he'd been stabbed, through his trench

coat and other garments.

And never mind the personal observation,
Lieutenant. We all heard the doctor's

testimony. If it pleases the court, I
should like this photograph added for

people and marked Exhibit 7.

Clerk will so mark it.

Excuse me, Your Honor.

Counselor.

Thank you, Mr. Berger.

Now, returning to People's Exhibit 5,
the police laboratory report, just to

review, what did the side of the table,
the overturned chair, and the door

moldings inside that house reveal? They
all showed fingerprints of the

defendant. That plus hair samples,
blood, the rest.

There's just no question, Your Honor.
They fought inside, and the boy followed

them out toward the garage. They
scuffled, and he stabbed them.

defense might reasonably object if you
insist on expressing an opinion, even

though the facts you introduced amply
support the conclusions you've drawn.

Let's instead return to People's Exhibit
1, this handy garden implement, which

the medical examiner has stated so
firmly he believes to be the murder

Now, where did you find this,
Lieutenant?

I was found right next to the body, sir.
A little under it. Thank you,

Lieutenant.

Counselor.

Lieutenant, in that photograph, did
anyone, to your knowledge, touch the

or move anything prior to your arrival
on the scene?

Well, of course, ma 'am. We can't tell
what might have happened before we

reached the scene.

But I do believe Mr. Paul Drake has
already testified.

That's how everything was when he got
there first.

I wasn't asking for a reminder,
Lieutenant.

I have no further questions.

The witness may step down.

We'll take a few moments at this time
while the clerk rearranges the exhibits.

Cal, you told me your cousin was nice to
you when you went into the house.

Yeah, into the house.

And then Steve said that...

He knew I might think he owed my dad
some dough.

So I gave him back that little black
book, you know, the one that put the

numbers and deposits and everything on
it.

And then he kidded me about giving me
some girls' phone numbers or something,

and then he leveled with me.

And he said he paid my dad in full.

2 ,000 bucks.

I mean, easily 2 ,000 bucks. And he
said, here, kid, here's 50 bucks. He

maybe I'll get you a job sometime.

And so then you had a fight?

Yeah.

He shoved me away.

It went outside and I grabbed him.

And then he hit me and that's the last
thing I remember.

You may proceed, Mr. Berger.

I call Mr. Lawrence Otis, please.

Well, about six o 'clock I tried to
reach young Cal Leonard.

I wanted him to come out and have a talk
with his cousin Steve.

So I phoned the office of the boy's
lawyer first.

The only one still there was Miss
Gibney, the secretary.

She said a few nasty things about the
boy.

She didn't know where he was.

So then I tried to reach Steve Arthur's
house in town.

And that was when you invited the
defendant out to the cottage.

But tell me this, Mr. Otis.

Why didn't Steve Arthur go back to his
own home to talk to the defendant?

Well, I guess I can't testify as to why
Steve always steered clear of his own

house. But, Mr. Otis, would you explain
to us, please, what it was you wanted

Stephen Arthur to talk to the defendant
about?

It occurred to me that we'd paid the
boy's father a bonus once, shortly

his death, for a manufacturing idea he'd
had.

The bonus was for $2 ,000.

Obviously, the boy had never seen any of
it, so I thought we might give Cal a

gift of the same amount.

Now, wait a minute, Mr. Otis.

Wasn't $2 ,000 a very small amount of
money to pay a man for a...

manufacturing idea which is netting your
company perhaps millions of dollars?

No, it wasn't.

I paid Mr. Leonard a good salary as a
developmental engineer.

As such, his work contract stipulated
that the company owned anything he

invented outright.

And the bonus to the father was...
Strictly a bonus, that's all.

To make sure of it, I had another quit
claim drawn up by a lawyer, which

signed when he took the money.

And now about the deceased, Stephen
Arthur.

How much did you pay him?

Above his salary, you mean? Yes.

Well, in the past year and a half, about
$103 ,000.

Why? What for?

Well, it was Stephen Arthur who
persuaded me not to fire Leonard when I

that I'd taken on a drinker.

Then Steve said that if I'd be patient,
he'd gamble his own salary and time on

seeing that Leonard delivered, provided
I'd pay him a private royalty.

on any results of their work. Counselor,
you may certainly take objection to

this type of questioning.

On the contrary, Your Honor.

I would like to hear it all.

Your Honor, I know it may seem unfair,
the creator of something getting a

of thousand, and the promoter, the
agent, ending up breaking in all the

but that's how it happened.

Oh, sure, no wonder the kid wouldn't
understand.

No wonder he might get sore enough to
even commit murder over... Now, that is

enough, Mr. Otis.

I have no more questions, Your Honor.

Mr. Otis, is there any written record of
your so -called royalty deal with

Stephen Arthur?

Well, no.

Mr. Otis, why was that money paid so
secretly?

Well, he...

He didn't want his wife to know about
it, that's all.

And you obviously conspired with him in
that.

Mr. Otis, before you tangle yourself
further, why don't you simply admit that

Stephen Arthur was blackmailing you?

Now, see here.

Blackmailing you for some sort of
swindle that involved Cal Leonard's

Your Honor.

Never mind, Mr. Berger.

Mrs. Doyle, you'll have to confine
yourself to proper questioning of the

witness. No more questions, Your Honor.

I regret doing this, Counselor.

But, Your Honor, in order to protect the
integrity of this witness, I must ask

this question. Mr. Otis, did you have
proper legal advice in your dealings

Mr. Leonard?

I thought so.

Mr. Joseph Doyle handled it for me.

It was Joe Doyle who drew up the quit
claim I referred to that Leonard signed.

And in your dealings with Stephen
Arthur?

Well, I know that Steve got together
with the lawyer Doyle, but...

what they cooked up between them.

No, no, no. I can't testify to any of
that.

Actually, I knew very little about any
of my husband's activities.

Money or anything else.

And yet, didn't you state to me that the
day after your husband's murder, you

had added up enough to know that Joseph
Doyle was responsible for helping your

husband steal? I was upset.

I'm a widow, you know.

Didn't you even claim to have knowledge
that my husband, Joseph Doyle, was some

kind of crook? Please, Your Honor, I am
aware that this subject is extremely

upsetting to Counselor, but these
questions are immaterial.

These are not immaterial questions, Your
Honor.

Mr. Berger opened the door himself when
he introduced my husband's name. I don't

like this courtroom used for the banding
of baseless hearsay.

Baseless?

He was the one who told me.

Cal Leonard.

He was the first one who used the word
crook.

Your Honor, I'm afraid I'm the one that
should apologize. If I could just

interrupt this and call a certain
unfriendly witness, I think... Well,

Honor, the reason that I handled this
case personally was to make certain that

the whole unpleasant subject of these
allegations and insinuations against the

late Mr.

Doyle... could be clarified and then set
aside for good.

Well, who is this witness, Mr. Berger?

Miss Liza Gibney.

Miss Gibney, you have to answer me.

Was there anything in your files on the
Otis Company concerning a quitclaim

letter? Yes, there was the quitclaim
that Mr. Otis mentioned a letter to Mr.

Leonard about the bonus.

I... I remember when Mr. Doyle wrote
that letter, but...

It's standard practice. There's nothing
wrong or unethical about it. Well, no

one is suggesting that there is, Miss
Gibney.

But would you tell us, please, what did
you do with your file copy of that

letter?

I... After I saw the boy had been in the
office, I destroyed it. You destroyed

it? Why?

There were some notes clipped on the
back about Steve Arthur.

Notes about meetings that Mr.

Doyle was having with him. I didn't want
Mrs. Doyle to see anything that would

upset her. I didn't want anybody to
misunderstand.

Joe Doyle made a mistake in judgment.

That's all it was.

Just a mistake.

And nobody's ever going to get me to say
anything different.

Sure, I saw those files.

I think that claim letter thing is such
a jip.

$2 ,000 is really cheap.

And so you thought all the nasty things
that I suppose everyone else in this

town is thinking.

Why didn't you tell me? Why didn't you
say something? Can't you ever learn to

trust a woman?

You mean when you kept on helping me and
I kept on lying and lying?

Sure.

I could open my fat mouth and say that
Joe Doria love was nothing but a...

Oh, Cal.

Mrs. Doyle, here's the police list of
all the things found on the body.

Oh, thank you.

Also, there's a call for you from Perry
Mason. I had it switched in here.

I've already told him that Berger's just
about wrapped up a pretty convincing

case.

Perry? Hang on, she's right here.

Yes?

I know we're in trouble.

Connie, wait a minute.

I wasn't going to say that.

I'm just sorry they had to drag in all
that insinuation.

Don't you worry.

When we take the case into jury trial,
we'll... Perry, I'll make a deal with

you.

If you don't give me any legal advice, I
won't take your temperature.

All right.

Bye.

Cal, what was in that date book you gave
back to your cousin?

When I first found it in the desk
drawer, I thought it was just a little

notebook.

Then I started putting down the bank
deposits.

Later on, in the back, I found about 12
girls' names and phone numbers. Get to

work. You're going to list off those
license plates. Paul, you're going to

12 girls.

You think maybe Steve had a date with
one of them that night?

I'll be back when court reconvenes. Oh,
Paul, leave that raincoat here for me,

will you? Sure, but what's your point?

Well, that is none of your business. I
have a date.

Well, here's the type of employment
contract that we use for an engineer.

Did Carl's father sign one of these when
he worked for you?

Yes, I guess so, but what's the point?

Well, you know very well that he might
have developed that idea while he was

still working for you instead of later
when he went to work for the Otis

Company. He was such a strange man. Kept
so much to himself.

But if he did, then you'd own the idea,
not the Otis Company.

You'd be cheated, not the Lennards. It
says so right here.

Now, Constance, I may have had wishful
thoughts.

Heavens only knows I could have used a
few of those Air Force contracts myself.

But I assure you, I have never been able
to find one shred of concrete evidence.

But suppose Steve Arthur had such
evidence.

Suppose somewhere he had dated drawings,
something, and...

And that's what Lawrence Otis was always
afraid of. You mean that's what Steve

blackmailed Otis with?

Of course.

And that's what you might have killed
Steve Arthur to get.

All right, Constance.

You've added up a lot of things.

Well, so have I.

But I'm warning you there's a stumbling
block.

Somehow it was your husband who fixed it
so that no further investigation would

be made.

Fred.

Cal Leonard's on trial.

Not Joe Doyle.

I've already told you.

I didn't see Steve for a whole week
before he was killed.

But don't you have one shred of
curiosity, Mrs. Arthur?

If you knew Cal was going out to a
meeting with Steve that night, a meeting

where... Where something was going to be
settled about money, didn't you at

least try to follow him to see what it
was all about?

I wasn't out there. It's a dark place.

There are side roads.

Wouldn't it have been easy for you to
have been there all along watching what

happened? I just didn't do it, I tell
you.

Mrs. Arthur, who is Gloria?

What? Who is Lida?

Who is Susan Bell?

I don't even know what you're talking
about.

Mrs. Arthur, if anyone is as anxious as
you are to obtain a lucrative divorce,

surely you've done some following, some
watching.

Your Honor, would you excuse me for a
moment?

Very well.

I managed to reach 11 of the girls, but
they all claim they had other dates that

night. I've assigned other men to double
-check.

What about the 12th?

Well, that was just a number and not
even the right one.

Maybe Cal got mixed up.

What do you mean?

Sea View, 6124. That's all he can
remember.

You can add other numbers, but there
isn't even a prefix.

Don't try to...

May

it please the court.

I wonder if I could recall a witness at
this time.

The police lieutenant.

Watch, theater stubs, handkerchief in
the jacket.

Yeah, I'm positive that's the whole
list, ma 'am.

That's everything we found on the body.

I see.

Now, I wonder if you'd take a look at
this photograph again.

Doesn't the coat seem to be in disarray?

Disarray? Oh, of course, ma 'am. Steve
Arthur had just been stabbed.

Your Honor, would it be asking too much
to inquire as to the purpose of this

line of questioning?

It's quite simple.

Defense will contend, Your Honor, that
something was taken from Mr. Arthur's

body by his murderer, who then
rearranged his clothing so attention

called to that fact.

Your Honor, the state is quite sure that
Cal Leonard could have taken anything

he wanted from the dead body of his
cousin after he killed him.

Lieutenant.

Cal Leonard was immediately apprehended
by Mr. Drake and then searched by you.

Did he have on him anything that
remotely could have belonged to the

No, I guess he didn't.

Very well, then.

It will be further our contention, Your
Honor, would you mind, that

the murderer took this particular item,
a small notebook for Mr. Arthur's body,

while Cal Leonard lay unconscious on the
ground.

Thank you, Mr. Berger.

Just what is it you're doing there,
Counselor? By a simple demonstration, I

to prove not only the truth of what I've
just said, but also to show who

the murderer was.

Now, Mr.

Berger, you have seen me knock Cal
Leonard out, and now you've

killed me, and you've just stolen...

The notebook from one of these pockets.

Your Honor, I certainly object to this.

Well, now, it seems I've allowed you a
great deal of latitude in this hearing,

Mr. Berger.

I think we can do the same for Mrs.
Doyle.

Very well. If you would now arrange this
coat, button one button, and tie the

belt exactly as in that photograph.

Thank you, Mr. Berger.

That will be all.

It's nice to see Mr. Berger didn't make
the same mistake as the killer did.

But then I... I doubt if any man would.

Women button their coats right over
left.

Like this.

Like the...

Victim's coat in the photograph.

That doesn't prove anything.

I wasn't out there, I tell you.

Sure, maybe I followed Steve lots of
other nights, but not that night. I

Order, order.

Mrs. Doyle, would you like to have Mrs.
Arthur return to the stand?

No, thank you, Your Honor, I wouldn't.

I doubt if she could have known the full
meaning of just how or why her husband

was blackmailing Lawrence Otis.

Or the importance of a number in that
little notebook.

Seaview 6124.

Your Honor, please.

It's the number of a safe deposit box,
isn't it, Mr. Otis?

Maybe where Steve Arthur kept his
evidence against you?

Yes, yes.

I wouldn't have perjured myself, but I
thought the boy was guilty.

May it please the court, there is
someone else who knew of the meeting at

cottage that night.

Someone with all the background
knowledge.

Someone who even added her perjury to
Mr. Oldis' today.

In obvious hope of continuing to
blackmail him herself.

Because, of course, she'd already
committed murder.

Hadn't you, Miss Gibney?

Hamilton Berger is fit to be tied.

He's called me ten times.

Says, why don't I get out of this bed so
he'll have someone easy to fight with

next time.

Seriously.

Berger's as glad as I am that the cloud
over Joe has been cleared up.

Perry, I have one more thing I have to
attend to.

Would you excuse me?

Thank you. Good night.

Well, Cal?

I was just thinking about that, um,
about that 20 bucks I owe you and

everything. Well, what about that 20
bucks? What, what do you mean

Will you stop asking questions for once?

I thought you might have some ideas.

Or you, you might be willing to, to talk
to me about, about me or... Well, don't

you know what I mean? Cal, how about...

Going out and buying the two biggest
dates in town.

Oh, uh, Mr. Doyle, you don't mind if I
haven't got that haircut, do you?

Go on.

Good night, Joe.