Original subtitles

- It's a beautiful day! - It is.

I was able to finish the laundry before breakfast.

Mother was very happy.

- Wonderful. - One less chore.

One less chore.

I'm so very proud of you, Emma.

You're wiser than most of the men in our community.

Father!

You are smart, strong, responsible,

and you will make a wonderful mother one day.

Oh, I prayed for a daughter.

Made this for you on the day you were born,

and I hope one day you give it to your daughter.

Thank you, Father.

I will treasure it.

Good.

Look at these wild onions.

Mother's favorite!

Eh, I brought the wrong shovel.

Oh, I'll get the hand trowels.

Hello?

Hello?

Oh, hello, Mother. Sorry, you startled me.

Oh, I'm sorry, Dear.

Where's your father?

I thought you were together.

We forgot the trowels,

and we found a surprise.

Father? Father?

Hello?

Father? Where are you?

Father, where are you?

Father! Father!

Father! Please, please, please!

Oh my God!

Please help!

Please, please help me, please help me. Please!

Oh, I prayed for a daughter.

You are smart, strong, responsible,

and one day you will make a wonderful mother.

Mother?

Emma?

Bishop David? Why are you here?

Widows need guidance with their husband's business.

He offered to help. Isn't that nice?

Here are the deeds you requested.

If you really wanted to help,

you and the elders could put more of an effort

into finding out how my father died.

We honored him with a proper burial

and the needed time of mourning.

You should've allowed the police to ask more questions!

They concluded that he slipped and fell.

That should be the end of it.

But I heard and saw someone running off.

They could have seen it or even done something,

and I-- - Emma, enough!

I'm sure finding him out there

must have been heartbreaking.

But this obsession is not going to help.

Only prayer can console you now, child.

I have chores.

You've been quiet.

Is this still about your father?

I miss him so much.

I do too.

I know that you and your father shared a closeness.

It's a void that I can't fill,

but Emma, I'm always here for you.

Then why don't you wanna know what really happened to him?

Would knowing bring him back?

Maybe it would bring me peace.

Hello? Hello?

Who's there? Hello?

Hello?

Shh, shh, shh!

It's me, it's me, it's me.

Goodness, Rebecca. You scared me!

What are doing out here?

Is that a cell phone?

Can I see it?

Have you been out all night

in the English world again?

Whatever do you mean?

I've been in my room sleeping.

So tell me about the English world.

You know, with Father gone

and Mother excommunicated,

I don't know, I guess I just needed to see it for myself

and try to understand.

I suppose I was looking for a distraction,

or answers?

Maybe, um, sometime I could go to the city with you?

You? Really?

I don't know. It's pretty risky.

I-- I'll think about it.

Okay.

I better get back to the house.

Hey, we'll always have our community

and each other.

Okay? Okay.

Goodness, Caleb!

Oh you half scared me to death!

Well, you looked like you needed help,

so I gave you a hand.

I could have done it myself.

I know, but I like helping you

and I've missed you.

Well, I have not seen you much since you've been back.

Why?

When are you going to let me take you

on a carriage ride again?

Why do you change the subject?

I've heard that you were resistant at service last week.

I'm trying, Emma.

Ever since my Rumspringa, I have struggled a bit.

It's hard to see what's out there and then come back here.

I thought Rumspringa was supposed to be fun.

Maybe too much fun.

I'm trying not to let it influence me any further.

I still would love to hear about your experience.

There's just not that much to tell.

I've realized I'm ready to be baptized,

settle down, find a wife...

Emma, you know how I've always felt about you,

and we've always been close.

I wish to be closer.

Emma, will you marry me?

Oh, um, Caleb, this is, uh,

quite unexpected, um--

I'm, I'm very flattered, but I must say no.

Wha-why?

I, before I left, I thought you felt something for me.

And--

I'm sorry I wasn't here when your father died, but I--

I understand and I-I'm sorry too.

I- I just, I don't think I'm ready for--

No, I'm sorry. Never mind.

You know, I-- I should have gone

to your mother for her permission

and her blessings. - Emma, I--

Oh, Caleb.

Mrs. Miller. I was just, um--

I do hope that you're not distracting Emma from her work.

No, ma'am, of course not.

I do hope we can talk later.

There's still much to do.

Emma!

Is your uncle home.

No.

So I was thinking,

are you ready to see the English world?

I think so.

I never experienced my own Rumspringa

and Caleb won't tell me about his.

He's probably just embarrassed, but never mind.

I think it could be good for you.

See what it's all about and decide for yourself.

I am ready.

I don't think you're quite ready.

If you wanna move through the English world

and not let them know that you're Amish,

you need to speak like them,

and you need to look like them.

We'll work on it.

So does that mean you'll take me?

You realize what we're risking if we get caught?

We'll be shunned, excommunicated,

so you can't tell a soul ever.

Are you sure?

Okay.

We go tonight.

Go, get ready.

Rebecca? Rebecca?

Emma!

Sorry.

So? What do you think?

You want me to wear that?

Well, you definitely can't go out looking like that.

Come on, get ready.

Go!

Mm. How's it look?

Oh, good.

Okay.

You look so hot!

Here, let me take a picture.

Okay, well, you can't just stand there like a stick.

Put your hands on your hips.

Mm-hmm, bevel a foot, and stick a hip out.

There you go. We'll work on it.

See, you look so hot.

Right?

Oh my gosh.

Okay, come on. Let's go.

Okay.

It's gonna be so fun.

Oh, here, memorize the info in case they ask questions,

- Jade. - This girl has brown

hair. I'm... I'm blonde!

So you changed it.

Okay.

Thank you.

Thank you.

So isn't this amazing?

Yeah!

Let's grab a drink.

Uh, I need to go to the bathroom.

Okay. Meet me on the dance floor.

Okay.

Ooh! Go get me a drink, bud.

- All right, okay. - Hey, make sure

they pour it strong too.

You got this.

Hm!

Hey, I'm Carl.

Saw you walk in, I just thought you look so beautiful.

Oh, uh, thank you.

You here with friends, family, just like to party?

Uh, I-I actually need to get back to my friend.

Well, don't be such a snob

when all I'm trying to do is be nice.

It's my first night here, so if,

if you could please move, I--

I think you need to let her go.

Yeah? Whatever, dude.

Are you okay?

She's fine.

Seems like you're causing her problems,

which means you and I are about to have a problem.

How about you just go to the bar and get us some drinks?

I've got.

Chill. Chill, chill, chill!

Just chill. We're good, we're good.

We're good.

Guys like that give us such a bad rap.

Are you okay?

Yeah.

Your hands, they're shaking.

How about some water?

- Okay? - Mm.

Yeah?

Hey, Jimmy, glass of water, please,

and a vodka soda for me.

No problem.

Thank you for helping me.

It's nothing. Dude's an idiot.

Pretty sure women are always wiser and smarter than men.

That's funny.

Why?

My father once said that he thought I was wiser

than most of the men that he knew.

Well, then he and I think alike.

Here we go.

Cheers. I'm Heath.

I'm... Jade.

So Jade, first time here?

Mm-hmm.

Hey, uh, do you wanna dance?

I don't really know how to dance.

There's nothing to it.

First and foremost, just relax, have fun.

And if you're ever unsure what to do,

just jump and spin.

Like this?

I'm just kidding.

All right, move to the beat. Okay?

There you go.

Like this?

Just like that.

This okay?

Mm-hmm.

Come on, we gotta go!

It's getting late.

I have to go.

What are you doing tomorrow?

Wanna have dinner? Maybe lunch?

Uh, maybe?

Gimme me your phone.

I don't have a phone.

I mean, I don't have my phone on me.

Okay, then meet me at Baker Street, one o'clock.

If you make it, you make it.

If you don't, I'll be disappointed,

but I'll understand.

Okay.

Bye.

Is that what the English world is always like?

I told you, it's pretty crazy.

Oh! Oh, what an amazing night.

I'm glad you had fun.

It's more than that. I-- I feel--

Alive?

Inspired.

So are you gonna go back and meet him?

I don't know. We have Sunday service tomorrow.

Play sick. What's one service?

You keep it. It looks better on you.

Besides, you need options for different occasions.

Oh! And this.

Just in case you go back to meet him.

You'll need it for a ride share.

Thank you. You're the best.

- Fun, right? - Yeah. Very.

Emma?

- Uh. - Emma, are you up?

Yes, Mother!

We're gonna be late for service

if you don't get a move on.

I'm, I'm almost ready.

I heard noises last night.

Were you having restless sleep?

As soon as I settled in, I slept like a newborn.

Hm, great.

Okay, well, get a move-on.

Yes, Mother.

As I have said many times,

the outside world will always offer us temptations

to challenge our faith.

But we must not bend.

We must keep rigid in our four core values;

faith, family, community,

and simplicity.

And that is a Godly life.

So if there are no other words to honor God

or raise up this community--

I would like to say something.

Emma, what are you doing?

Since my father's death,

I have struggled with our four pillars,

since I feel ignored and pushed aside,

when there is something in my heart I know to be true.

Someone else was in the woods the day of my father's death.

We need to request a more thorough investigation

from the police and ideally an autopsy.

So all I am asking is for my community

to put their faith in me and honor my father.

Emma, wait!

Emma, will you stop?

You realize you are asking me to exhume your father's body.

You should have come to me first

before putting your feelings on display.

Just yesterday I came to you.

You said you'd be there for me, but you're not.

I am there for you.

This is just a matter that needs to be handled privately.

Emma! Emma!

Hi. Hi, are you going to, to Baker Street?

Yes, I am. Hop in.

Okay.

- Oh, hi. - Hi.

Is there a reservation for Heath here?

Uh, let me see.

Oh, I see him.

- Oh! Enjoy! - Thank you.

Hi. I am so sorry I'm late.

I knew you'd be here.

Is something wrong?

Oh, nothing. Just you look beautiful.

I-- I mean, don't get me wrong; you looked great in the dark,

but lunch lighting looks good on you too.

But now having my own company,

I feel like I have a lot more flexibility and freedom.

Don't get me wrong, I still work like a dog,

but what can I say it's, uh, it's high pressure

in a club brawl.

Yeah.

Heath, I have to tell you something.

You know, there's, uh, something I,

I have to tell you too.

Oh! Okay.

Look, I'm just getting out of a relationship

and it's taking a lot longer than originally anticipated

because we shared our business together.

Anyway, it's complicated.

And it's been a while

since I've dated anyone, so--

Okay.

I'm, I'm just telling you this

because I wanna be honest, you know?

Yeah. Yeah, sure.

I-- I didn't mean to drop all that on you.

It's just my ex lied to me and...

Oh, anyway...

I appreciate your honesty.

Okay, enough of the heavy stuff for now, right?

Let's talk games.

Are you any good at ping pong, darts, pool?

Um, probably not.

Well, you know, it's still pretty early.

If you have to head back, totally cool,

but if you wanna stick around for a little while longer,

play some games?

I can give you a ride back after.

No pressure.

Okay.

This is amazing.

Glad you like it.

Come on.

This is all yours?

Uh-huh.

Can I get you something to drink?

I make a mean strawberry margarita.

Oh, I don't drink.

At least, I-I haven't in a while.

Water or soda, then?

Uh, actually, I'll have a small margarita.

I'll see what I can do. Have a look outside.

It's beautiful out there. Make yourself at home.

Drink's up.

Thank you.

You like the view?

Yeah, it's incredible.

Cheers.

You gotta be kidding me.

I have to hop on a flight to Chicago.

Deal's closing in the morning, and I have to be there.

Oh yeah. I-I-I can go.

I don't wanna be in your way.

No, you don't have to leave.

You can stay here, enjoy the pad.

Make yourself at home.

There's uh-- There's a stocked fridge, movies, music, bathtub.

Or I can take you back to your family.

No pressure.

You know what? You don't have to decide now.

You can think about it.

Okay.

Have a good trip.

Be back in the morning.

Okay. Be safe!

No!

Hello?

Heath?

Hello?

Hello? Heath?

Okay, if you're trying to scare me,

I don't find this kind of thing funny.

Hello?

Oh my God.

Oh my God!

Oh my God!

No! No, no, no, no.

Thank you.

Emma!

Caleb! What are you doing out here?

Oh, I was with David.

Are your arms okay?

W-- What happened to your arms?

I was, um, going for a walk and I fell.

Where you coming from?

Oh, um, I was just headed home.

I was at Rebecca's and I couldn't sleep,

so I took the long way home.

Hm.

- I'll walk you home. - No, thank you. Good night.

Emma?

Why are you coming through the window?

Ah. I didn't wanna wake you.

Where have you been?

I was just clearing my head.

I'm sorry about earlier.

It's okay. I was just worried about you.

I'm sorry, too.

You look tired.

Let's get some rest.

Emma? Are you okay?

Did something happen last night?

Where did you go?

I just wanna get back to life the way it was.

Well, that starts by getting out of bed.

Uh, let me wash up first.

Okay.

Hello?

Jade, I'm back.

Hello?

Oh, no, Kim!

Oh my God.

So did you go?

I wanna hear every single detail.

Hey, that's my stuff. Wait, stop!

What is this about?

You don't understand.

What happened.

Heath left me at his house.

I came downstairs and there was a woman dead on the floor.

Someone hit me, knocked me out.

I woke up and I was covered in blood.

I- I-I just, I didn't know what to do.

I was gonna call the police, but I got scared.

I just ran.

And you're sure she's dead?

Go ahead, throw it in.

You need to cover your tracks the best you can.

Are you okay?

I'm not. I just, I feel so guilty, Rebecca.

Hey. Hey, stop that.

No, I should have done something.

I shouldn't have just run.

What could you have done if you stayed?

Wha.

Did you see anyone else? Did anyone see you?

No.

Did you see it happen?

Then you would've just gotten yourself into more trouble.

So from this point on, you forget about it.

All of it. Okay?

There is one more thing and we can't burn it.

Where did you get that?

It was in my hand when I woke up.

Okay, I have an idea. Come on.

- Okay. - Come on!

Okay.

Are you sure about this?

What if somebody finds it?

It's our secret.

No one will ever know. You can't tell a soul ever.

We must not ever discuss any of our travels

or any of what happened.

Never. Not with anyone.

Of course. Never.

Rebecca, I just feel awful.

I know you do.

I wish there was more we could do,

but this is the best option, okay?

Thank you. Rebecca.

I don't know what I'd do without you.

Mmm!

Emma prepared the meal herself.

You've had us worried over your outburst the other day.

Hm. I let my grief get the better of me.

It won't happen again.

And all that business about exhuming your father's body?

I don't even really remember saying that.

Then I don't think you need to worry

about any repercussions from the elders

over your little tantrum.

I'll be back soon, Mother!

All right, dear.

Hello, Caleb, Emma's not here,

and I'm not sure when she's gonna be back.

Actually, I'm, um, here to speak with you,

if you have the time.

Very well.

I'm here asking for your permission to pursue Emma

with the hopes that she will agree to marry me.

Have you broached this with Emma?

I have. But your support is equally important to me.

Hm.

Well, in the end it's not really up to me,

it's up to her.

But, I do appreciate you coming here the way you have.

So you have my permission to marry Emma.

You don't know how much this means to me, Mrs. Miller.

I'll see myself out.

Thank you Mrs. Miller.

Did you and my mother have a nice conversation?

Emma? I was just going to come find you.

So you two think you know what's best for me?

No, that's not it.

Do I get a say in who I marry? Or is this deal done?

Emma, that's not what this is.

It's bad enough that no one respects me

or my feelings in this community.

Not you, not my mother, not Bishop David.

But now I get no say in who I marry?

Emma, I want to prove to you

that I can be the man you deserve,

and that we can be close like we were before my Rumspringa.

That I will be a good husband... protect you.

A good father--

Do you know what this is about?

Did you say anything?

No. Did you?

No. Why would I?

I don't know. 'Cause you felt bad?

I did, but I promise I said nothing.

Okay.

All I know is that Uncle left in a hurry this morning.

Could all of the young women ages 18 to 25

please step forward?

Please line up, shoulder-to-shoulder.

This is starting to feel pointless.

From the way you describe Jade

as someone who doesn't drink, doesn't drive,

who's naive and lives far from town,

we're looking for an Amish woman.

Fine.

How many of these places are there?

Only a few left. So let's keep going.

Okay.

You! Eyes up.

Hello, Jade.

This is her.

This is the girl I met at the club who came to my house,

stayed after I left.

What's your name? Real name?

Emma Miller.

Well, Emma Miller, we need

to ask you a few questions.

What is this?

What's going on?

We need to speak with this woman.

There's been a murder in this man's home.

Well, I am this woman's mother

and you will be doing no such thing.

You're making a mistake,

she's never even left the community.

Mother!

Come with me.

I need to be with her.

Ma'am, please.

David?

If you don't mind,

please allow the girl's mother to sit in.

Fine.

You wait by the car.

Emma, I'm Detective Fisher

and this is my partner, Detective Moreno.

We need you to tell us everything that happened.

I understand.

So you were at his house in Fort Wayne, for how long?

Not long.

As soon as we got there, Heath got a text message

that he had to go to Chicago.

So he left.

Soon as he left, the house felt big and intimidating.

I mean, look at where I'm from. So I left.

So you never saw this woman?

She was killed with a sharp instrument,

like a knife, in her own home.

She lived there?

This is Kim Halverson. Heath's wife.

What?

I never met this woman. I have never spoken to her.

Heath never mentioned he had a wife. I had no idea.

So what time did you leave?

The sun had just set.

I- if I may?

Why are you not questioning this poor woman's husband?

I mean, how do we know

that he actually went to-- Where was it? Chicago?

We have confirmation that he boarded the plane

at 7:00 PM and landed in Chicago at 8:25.

He couldn't have done it.

I see.

I am sorry for the shame I've brought on our family.

I hope you can find it in your heart to forgive me

and help me find a way out of this.

A false witness breathes many lies, Emma.

But I do believe you and I forgive you.

You don't have it in your heart to kill.

I could never, Mother. Never!

So what do I do?

Well, the bishop and the elders

have decided you will be excommunicated,

and you can't sit idly by around here

and wait for the police to return,

because they will.

Mother, can I be honest about one last thing?

Why yes, of course.

I still don't believe that father fell.

Somebody else was there that day.

I saw them in the woods!

Maybe this is all connected somehow.

I mean, Caleb has been acting strangely the last few days

and I believe he may be following me!

Could he have something to do with this?

And what about our land? Our farm?

Why did Bishop David come and suddenly take our legal deeds?

I know I sound mad,

but something is not adding up.

And Heath has to know I did not kill his wife.

I have to convince him.

Okay, I understand.

We'll get through this together.

Emma, you'll need a change of clothes.

If the police are looking for you,

they'll be looking for an Amish woman.

Thank you, Mother.

Be smart, be safe,

and be careful.

You'll find the answers.

I don't know what in the hell you think you're doing

by coming here, but I'm calling the police.

Heath, Heath! Please stop, okay?

I-- I. Give me a chance to tell you the truth.

I know the truth.

I know you think you know,

but you don't, okay?

Please just, just hear me out. Okay?

Five minutes.

Thank you.

Detectives! Can I help you?

Search warrant.

Is Emma home?

No.

Where is she?

I don't know.

That's what happened!

Okay, let's just, uh,

let's just say I believe your story

about a third person staging all of this.

Why come to me?

I need you to believe me,

and I need your help, please.

I never thought it was done maliciously or cold-blooded.

I thought you just got scared,

and in the heat of the moment, you just lashed out.

I promise, I could never hurt or kill anyone!

You were here when it happened.

Yes, I was, but I didn't even know you were married.

You never said that!

I did.

You said you were getting

out of a long-term relationship,

not that she was living here with you.

Okay, she wasn't living here.

We were legally separated.

All right? She had her own place across town.

Well, why was she here at your place then?

I don't know. Maybe to pick up some mail?

It could have been any number of reasons.

Well, I wanna find the person who actually did this.

The police are doing that.

No, they are focused on me.

They're not focused on the person

who killed your wife.

Please, Heath, you have to believe me!

Who else knows all this?

Um, just you, my mother,

uh, and Rebecca, that's it.

Look, my neighbor has a security camera.

He called and said he was gonna bring over the footage.

Maybe that'll clear things up.

I don't see a scythe anywhere.

That's the one with the curved blade, right?

Mm-hmm.

Of course we have one. It was Isaac's.

It has his initials on the handle.

I'm sure I can find it. Give me a minute.

Hold on. Our investigator found something.

Take us to the fire pit.

Of course. Right this way.

Hey, buddy. Here it is.

How you doing? You okay?

Yeah. Hanging in there.

Trying to get to the bottom of this.

I didn't have time to look at it,

but hopefully there's something there that can help you.

Thanks, Barry.

- You're welcome. - Appreciate it.

I'll take this to the police.

Good luck.

All right, this is it.

Let's see what we got.

Jade Miller.

We need to know where your daughter is right now.

That's Kim being dropped off.

Then you. Running.

Wait, go back!

Right there. There's someone in the bushes.

Who is that?

Can we, can we go through it again?

And this time just a little bit slower.

Could be a guy. Hard to tell.

It's so dark.

Is he wearing a hat?

Oh my God.

What?

I know who it is.

Who?

It has to be Caleb.

I saw him in the woods that night!

His arms were all scratched up and bloody.

I'm sure he was following me!

Maybe he followed me here.

Maybe he was trying to confront you

and he ran into Kim instead.

Heath, I know you have no reason to believe me,

but give me a chance to prove it to you.

How?

Come with me to Caleb's house.

No, listen, you can hide, I'll get him to confess.

Look, no offense, but this is your problem. It's not mine.

He may have killed your wife!

Don't you wanna know the truth?

Hey, I'm sorry, I just gotta take this.

Sure.

I'll just be a minute.

Hey.

Yeah.

I thought you already did that.

Why not?

Look, slow down. Just tell me what happened.

All right, I'll take care of it myself.

No, I don't want.

I'll do it. Yeah, it'll all work out.

I've got this.

- Are you okay? - She's fine!

Hey. What's wrong?

Stay there.

Okay. Okay, just relax, all right?

Why do you have a photo with the guy

who harassed me at the club?

I wish you hadn't seen that.

It was s-stupid.

I hadn't white-knighted in years.

"White-knighted"?

It's a college thing.

Y-- You pick out a girl you like

and that you wanna impress.

One guy plays the jerk, which allows the other guy

to come in and be the hero.

Look, I told you I hadn't dated anyone since Kim.

I thought you were outta my league.

It was stupid. I'm sorry.

You were dishonest.

Yeah, but hey, you did the same thing, right?

Not telling me you're Amish?

Right.

Are we, are we good,

or are you gonna hit me with my photo album?

Oh, sorry.

Uh, these are... beautiful photos.

You look really happy.

We were happy,

but then she cheated on me,

and the only thing she was upset about

was that she couldn't keep half the business

after the divorce.

What? I-- I don't understand.

In our business agreement, there's a clause

that if either one of us has an affair,

there will be a divorce,

and the cheater doesn't keep the business.

You know, it doesn't even matter now;

she's-- She's dead.

I'm so sorry, Heath.

Thank you.

- Of course. - It means a lot.

I wanna find out who murdered Kim.

Let's hear what Caleb has to say.

Mary, what's wrong?

The police have issued a warrant for Emma's arrest.

We knew it was just a matter of time, did we not?

Once they find her, this whole thing can be put to bed.

Even though she didn't do it?

Mary, why don't we come inside?

Look, Mary, I don't want to fight with you.

I don't have the energy for it either.

But if you came here for our support,

the elders and I will support you, but not Emma.

I didn't come here for your support, nor the elders'.

I need everything you took from the house,

everything dealing with Isaac and the businesses.

Emma will need all of my resources and my help.

You realize that if you support Emma,

you too risk being shunned and excommunicated?

All due respect, Bishop,

but Emma is all that I have left,

and I will protect her with my life!

She did not kill that woman.

You cannot prove that she didn't.

And you can't prove that she did!

And why would you want to prove

that Emma could hurt someone?

But this is not a good example of leadership.

We are here to protect our community,

not condemn its members!

You need to do better.

I don't appreciate your disobedience.

Don't touch me!

Emma's poisoned you against me.

Is there a reason

that you have been so adamant against raising Isaac?

What could you be insinuating?

You've always wanted to purchase the back 40 from us,

but Isaac would never sell.

Maybe the two of you got into a fight.

Maybe it was you Emma saw running from the woods that day.

How dare you suggest

I had something to do with Isaac's death?

Don't touch me!

Oh, park here. We can walk the rest of the way.

Hope you know what you're doing.

There he is.

I'll try to get him to confess.

Once he does, go to the police.

I'll make my way home.

Emma, be careful.

Caleb!

What are you doing here?

I didn't like the way we ended things before.

I was hoping we could talk.

The police are looking for you.

I know.

We're supposed to notify them if we see you.

Are you prepared to do that?

No. I will say nothing.

I'm sorry for what I said before.

I really was trying to apologize,

but I just made things worse.

I didn't help with that either.

Do you really love me?

Yes.

Do you love me enough to tell me the truth?

You know I do.

You were following me that night, weren't you?

What do you mean?

The night in the woods?

When your arms were covered in blood.

I told you.

It was dark, I stumbled, I fell.

Come on, Caleb,

you can tell me what really happened, okay?

It'll be our secret.

I don't have secrets. I told you everything!

I just happened to be out there that night

going for a walk after talking to the bishop!

Why do you keep looking back?

I-- I mean, the police are, are looking for me.

You're acting so strange, Emma.

Could you put the ax down?

You're making me nervous.

What is this about?

I know you were at Heath's home.

I saw you in the woods!

You followed me. You've been following me.

You murdered that woman!

Why do you say these things

when all I've ever done

is try to protect you?

Is try to love you?

I want you to be my wife!

Heath? Heath!

Emma!

That was not nice.

What are you doing here?

I know you're not supposed to speak with me,

but I need your help.

Uncle's in town. Come inside.

Okay.

What's wrong?

It's Caleb! It's always been Caleb.

What?

He killed that woman.

Do you have another phone?

No.

Okay, well, could you go with me back to my place?

He could be making his way there now.

I need to warn Mother.

Of course. Anything for you.

Gimme a minute. I need to wash up.

Okay. Please hurry.

I can't believe Caleb would do such a thing!

But then again, he hasn't been the same

since he came back from his Rumspringa.

Uh-huh.

Did Caleb say anything about seeing

anyone else around Heath's house?

No.

He's such an oaf.

I can't believe he was sly enough to break into a home.

I guess you never know what people are capable of.

Guess he's more slick and patient than we thought.

It's a good thing you didn't agree to marry him.

What a disaster that would've been.

But things always work out for the best

when your heart is in the right place.

That's what my mother used to say.

All right, let's go take care of this.

And don't worry, I've got your back.

Where you going?

Oh, um, I thought I saw your uncle.

We should get moving. Avoid the roads.

You mean go out into the woods?

It's faster.

Hello?

Hello?

What are you doing?

I'm sad to tell you, your daughter killed my wife.

That's impossible.

Look for yourself. Look!

No, no.

You put that there.

The police, they were just here!

They searched everything and they're--

They are coming back.

Well, then...

you are gonna tell me where they didn't look.

If you ever wanna see your daughter again,

you'll do as I say.

Even though Caleb killed Kim,

there are still some open questions

about my father's death.

I thought you were over that?

I'm starting to think that Kim's death

and my father's death are connected.

Makes sense.

Your father didn't have the fondest opinion of Caleb,

and didn't he even try to keep you two apart?

Yes, while my father did express

his discontent with Caleb, Caleb was on Rumspringa

when my father died,

so it couldn't have been him.

He could have snuck back.

That's true. He could have.

But even still, I wanna know who did this.

Look that person in the eye and ask them why.

Then I can move on.

What if there is no big answer?

What if your father was simply in the wrong place

at the wrong time?

That would still be an answer.

Hopefully you get that and more soon enough,

and find the peace you've longed for.

The more I consider it,

the more I think about why someone in our community

would turn to violence.

I mean, from the day we are born, we are taught

that violence goes against God's wishes

and the four pillars.

Well, maybe the person who strikes out in violence

was never meant for this community to begin with.

Or maybe they were put here to test our faith.

You're right.

Emma, I don't think right now

is the appropriate time for prayer.

Just tying my shoe.

I don't think so!

Drop it.

So where did I slip up?

Would this be considered a slip-up?

What is this obsession?

Coveting another woman's husband?

Where did you get that?

Emma?

Emma!

Mrs. Miller? This is Caleb!

Emma?

Emma!

Emma!

Emma!

Where are we going?

You'll see.

Mother!

- Emma! - Mother!

That's enough outta you!

Mother!

Mother!

No, let me go!

Mother, no! Let me see her!

You finish the job?

Nice and tidy.

Your mother was never supposed to be a part of this.

For that, I am sorry.

So I know you killed Kim, but did you also kill my father?

Hello?

Rebecca?

Why are you with this man?

He caught Heath and me together and vowed to tell Uncle.

And we knew what that would mean.

You've broken the rules of our Ordnung

and God's commandments.

You must confess to the bishop and face the consequences.

I begged him not to,

but his righteousness got the better of him.

No, I can't do that.

Rebecca, you have no choice.

I wouldn't be able to go home

because I would be shunned and excommunicated,

and Heath-- Heath would lose everything.

His wife would get the business and the house.

So between the two of us, we would have nothing.

And I would be destitute, thrown to the wolves.

Just like my mother.

You know what happened to my mother!

- Please! - Rebecca, wait. Wait!

So you see, we didn't have a choice.

So you planned on framing me for Kim's death?

I needed you to stop looking into your father's death,

but you wouldn't... and we needed to make sure

Kim never found out about our affair.

So the whole story you told me about your wife cheating

and losing everything in the divorce was...

was really about you and Rebecca?

Pretty smart for a country girl.

Did you ever have feelings for me?

Rebecca? Rebecca, you should know.

Heath and I slept together this morning.

It's a lie.

I wanted to go to a hotel,

but he convinced me to stay with him.

Not gonna work, Emma.

He brought me to his guest room.

- We-- - Just shut up!

You can't believe a word of that.

I don't. Are you done?

Where's the scythe? The murder weapon.

It's buried.

It was buried.

I put it where belongs; in Emma's bedroom.

The police will find it soon enough.

Great work, Babe.

Now let's get this going.

We have a lot to do before the cops show up.

What do you mean?

Are you gonna kill us too?

Murder-suicide.

Amish girl goes crazy with guilt and fear,

kills her lover's wife

and then kills her disapproving mother.

Great headline.

Don't make me hurt you.

You'll have to kill me!

Okay.

Do it.

I killed Isaac and Kim. You kill Emma and Mary.

That's the deal.

I know.

Heath, Heath, Heath! Do not do this!

I'm sorry.

Please don't.

You don't have to.

But I do.

No. No!

No! No!

No!

No!

Caleb, are you okay?

You were my friend!

You think I wanted this?

I just wanted out of this place!

You could've just left!

I would've had nothing!

No money, no community. Nothing!

Neither you or your father

were gonna keep me from happiness.

Please, please, I don't wanna die this way. Please!

Emma, stop.

She killed Father.

And she will pay for it.

But not like this. God will be her judge.

Then let God be her judge.

Oh! Caleb!

Are you okay?

I will be.

Are you?

I will be.

Thank you.

So you came from that direction?

Yes, I-- I ran at him and tackled him,

and, and he pinned be down

and started punching me over and over again.

Your father would be so proud.

You sure about this?

The elders might disapprove.

Let them.

It was lovely having you for dinner tonight, Caleb.

Thank you for a wonderful meal.

Have a good night.

I had a lovely time with you.

Me too.

See you tomorrow?

Of course.