All language subtitles for Matlock s09e17e18 The Scam

af Afrikaans
ak Akan
sq Albanian
am Amharic
ar Arabic
hy Armenian
az Azerbaijani
eu Basque
be Belarusian
bem Bemba
bn Bengali
bh Bihari
bs Bosnian
br Breton
bg Bulgarian
km Cambodian
ca Catalan
ceb Cebuano
chr Cherokee
ny Chichewa
zh-CN Chinese (Simplified)
zh-TW Chinese (Traditional)
co Corsican
hr Croatian
cs Czech
da Danish
nl Dutch
en English
eo Esperanto
et Estonian
ee Ewe
fo Faroese
tl Filipino
fi Finnish
fr French
fy Frisian
gaa Ga
gl Galician
ka Georgian
de German
el Greek
gn Guarani
gu Gujarati
ht Haitian Creole
ha Hausa
haw Hawaiian
iw Hebrew
hi Hindi
hmn Hmong
hu Hungarian
is Icelandic
ig Igbo
id Indonesian
ia Interlingua
ga Irish
it Italian
ja Japanese
jw Javanese
kn Kannada
kk Kazakh
rw Kinyarwanda
rn Kirundi
kg Kongo
ko Korean
kri Krio (Sierra Leone)
ku Kurdish
ckb Kurdish (SoranĂ®)
ky Kyrgyz
lo Laothian
la Latin
lv Latvian
ln Lingala
lt Lithuanian
loz Lozi
lg Luganda
ach Luo
lb Luxembourgish
mk Macedonian
mg Malagasy
ms Malay
ml Malayalam
mt Maltese
mi Maori
mr Marathi
mfe Mauritian Creole
mo Moldavian
mn Mongolian
my Myanmar (Burmese)
sr-ME Montenegrin
ne Nepali
pcm Nigerian Pidgin
nso Northern Sotho
no Norwegian
nn Norwegian (Nynorsk)
oc Occitan
or Oriya
om Oromo
ps Pashto
fa Persian
pl Polish
pt-BR Portuguese (Brazil)
pt Portuguese (Portugal)
pa Punjabi
qu Quechua
ro Romanian
rm Romansh
nyn Runyakitara
ru Russian
sm Samoan
gd Scots Gaelic
sr Serbian
sh Serbo-Croatian
st Sesotho
tn Setswana
crs Seychellois Creole
sn Shona
sd Sindhi
si Sinhalese
sk Slovak
sl Slovenian
so Somali
es Spanish
es-419 Spanish (Latin American)
su Sundanese
sw Swahili
sv Swedish
tg Tajik
ta Tamil
tt Tatar
te Telugu
th Thai
ti Tigrinya
to Tonga
lua Tshiluba
tum Tumbuka
tr Turkish
tk Turkmen
tw Twi
ug Uighur
uk Ukrainian
ur Urdu
uz Uzbek
vi Vietnamese
cy Welsh
wo Wolof
xh Xhosa
yi Yiddish
yo Yoruba
zu Zulu

Original subtitles

Thank you.

So old Mark here just all of a sudden looks up at me and says, Walnut Grove

Textiles. Next thing I know, we're buying half a million shares at 13 and a

quarter. 13 and three -eight. I almost had him committed.

I mean, who the hell's even heard of Walnut Grove Textiles?

But one week later, guess who gets bought out by Value Right?

Tripled our money. Just like that.

Guy's a genius.

Or maybe he just has access to the right information.

There's no need to break the law to be a player in this business.

The information's out there. Who's making money, who's losing money, who's

smart, who's on the meat.

You just have to know how to digest it.

Actually, it's those glasses he wears.

They make it so he can read between the lines.

Don't they, Mark?

Tell you what, let's trade your glasses for my wife's here.

It's my wife, Cameron Cooper.

Sorry about that, John.

Now, what did I do with my wife?

I believe you divorced her.

Oh, so I did. In that case, quick, will you marry me? I'll buy you your very own

company. You like insurance?

I'll buy you this guy's company, Ashfield Light.

It's doing very well. I know.

He's my husband.

I need another drink.

What was that?

John throws a heck of a party, doesn't he? Mm -hmm. Anything look interesting?

Stuffed mushrooms look good.

So does Asheville's life.

All kidding aside.

So, when are you going to make me a rich man?

As soon as I'm sure I'll wind up even richer.

Thank you.

Oh, God, he's dead, isn't he?

Well, they're doing everything they can, sir.

Now, why don't you tell me what happened here? I don't know what happened. I was

just driving along. Next thing I knew, he was right in front of me.

Sir, have you been drinking?

A glass of champagne, maybe two, that's all.

Okay, I have to ask you to step over here with me, please.

Now...

I need you to stand with your feet together and close your eyes.

Come on, I'm not drunk.

Sir, are you refusing to cooperate?

Now, tilt your head back, place your arms out to the side, and with your

forefinger, reach out and touch the tip of your nose. Can you do that for me?

My client may have had some champagne before he got behind the wheel of his

that night, Your Honor.

And tragically, he may have struck and killed someone on his way home.

But I'm going to show you in the course of these proceedings that those two

facts are not necessarily related.

I'm going to show you that the charge of vehicular homicide is unwarranted, that

Mr. Ivers does not deserve to go to jail, for I am going to show that

that poor man was something no one, drunk or sober, could have avoided.

That man died not because my client had been drinking, but because he had the

misfortune of wandering out onto a dark, winding road and being struck by a car

that any one of us here could have been driving.

Thank you, Your Honor.

Thank you, Mr. Browning. Is the state ready to call its first witness?

Yes, Your Honor. Call Sergeant Travis Farrow to the stand.

Goodbye, my Coney Island baby.

Farewell, my own true love, true.

Not bad, huh?

Of course I got it. It's upstairs in my closet.

Yeah. Okay.

Count me in.

All right. I'll see you then.

Who was that?

That's an old friend from school. He's drumming up some people to come to our

class reunion.

40th. Oh, what was all that going on, baby? I used to be a member of a

barbershop quartet. Yeah?

Yeah. Yeah. It was me and Gus and George and Chuck.

Fairview Fairtones.

Fairview was the name of our dormitory. Oh.

Are they all coming to the reunion?

Yeah. Yeah, we're going to wear the outfits we used to wear and everything.

That's great.

Yeah. Yeah.

You know, we have to have this filed by 5 o 'clock.

Oh, yeah. Yeah. Where were we?

Well, we were trying to figure out if we want a jury trial or a bench trial.

Yeah.

Ben.

Ben?

Be right back.

Thank you

Do you have a moment? I need to talk to you. You alone?

Well, Ben's upstairs.

Oh, then let's talk out here.

All right.

Hey, that's some great pressure getting on the Cameron Ivers case.

Yeah. Listen, I've got a problem.

What's up?

I'm being blackmailed.

You see, I met this woman recently, and, well, she and I have gotten real close

real fast.

Oh, Craig, I thought you were happily married.

Well, I thought so, too, but then I met Rachel, and Cliff, it's like I

never had sex before. I mean, with her, it's just incredible.

The more I'm with her, the more I want to be with her. I mean, it's like I'm

addicted, you know what I mean?

No, not really, but...

Go, go ahead. Well, anyway, I thought we were being discreet, but yesterday I

got some rather graphic photos of us along with a note saying the news media

would get copies next if I didn't do as I was told.

Cliff, my wife is running for her state assembly seat.

This kind of publicity could ruin her. I mean, I may not love her, but I

certainly don't want to hurt her. She's a good person.

Well, how much does a blackmailer want?

I don't know yet. I'm supposed to meet with them this afternoon at Kelbo's bar.

I need a favor.

No, no. On second thought, Cliff, I'm going to do this right. I want to hire

you. What for?

Go to Cowboys in my place.

You want me to meet with the blackmailer? Well, I can't meet with him

public place like that. Everybody knows me.

Geez, Craig, I don't know. I mean, it's really weird, you know? Cliff, I don't

have anyone else to ask.

Now, this is a really delicate situation.

I have to have someone I can trust. Yeah.

But... I don't want you to do it if it makes you feel uncomfortable.

I'll figure out something else. Thanks anyway.

Hold on.

How am I supposed to recognize the guy?

He'll be sitting at a table by himself with a pin in his lapel. The American

flag.

Thanks, Cliff.

Waiting for Craig Browning, right?

Who the hell are you?

Cliff Lewis.

Sent me in his place.

He shouldn't have done that.

Oh, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry.

I'm sorry. I'm not a cop or anything. I'm Craig's lawyer.

I just didn't want to risk being seen in public with you, that's all.

So, how much do you want?

Oh, I don't want money.

I want Cameron Ivers to go to prison.

Cameron, his client, Ivers. That's right.

I want Craig Browning to throw the case.

Cameron Ivers goes to prison, and I tear up the negatives of those pictures, and

everybody's happy.

Ivers walks, and I send those pictures to the press, and they have a field day.

So all Browning's got to do to win is to lose.

It's that simple.

Tell him, Mr.

Lawyer.

Thank you.

Yeah. Yeah, it's Cliff Lewis. I want to talk to you. Cliff Lewis,

I'm not leaving here until I talk to you.

Let me guess.

You want your hankering.

No, I came here to make a deal. You got pictures? I got pictures. I got pictures

of you and two guys.

Their names are John Robinson and Mark Reeves. Does that ring a bell?

Who? Who? The two guys who put you out to this. You don't know what you're

talking about.

Well, you take Craig Browning down. I'll take you all down. Is that understood,

Mr. Astin? My, my, how clever you are. You know my name and where I'm staying.

But I wonder how clever Craig Browning will think you are when his picture

appears in all those papers.

Now, get out.

Hey, Ben.

Yeah? Got some donuts.

Blazed or jelly filled?

You eat them.

Hey, when's the reunion?

Uh, 23rd. Uh, getting excited?

Can't wait.

Oh, great.

Blazed or jelly filled?

Is that all you're having?

Yeah.

What are you on, some kind of diet or something?

I look like I need to be on a diet.

No, no, no. I, uh, um, just, you know.

was asking, I'll get that.

Norman! Hello, Cliff.

Hi, hi.

What can I do for you?

I'm investigating the murder of a private investigator from Savannah.

Recognize him?

I can't tell you that.

Why not?

I can't tell you that either.

Well, I know him.

Morning, Ben. What's going on?

I made it to the hotel where this man was staying, saw somebody pounding on

door to his room last night about an hour before she found him dead.

Heard the guy say his name was Cliff or Clark or something. So when we found

Cliff's business card in one of the dead man's pockets, we naturally thought

we'd check it out.

You fit the description she gave of the guy to a T.

I'm sorry.

I can't say anything more about any of this. I really am sorry, Norm.

There will be a next time.

Right.

Sorry for the waste of trip.

What's going on?

Ben, I'm so sorry. I can't tell you about this either. I... I gotta go.

Hi. Who was that? We got some work to do.

Bye.

What I'm trying to say is we're going to have to cool it for a little while.

You mean I'll see each other? Just for a couple of weeks.

Why? A few complications have arisen, that's all.

What complications?

What happened? Rachel, believe me, I want to see you.

As soon as things calm down, I'll call you. I promise.

Craig, I love you.

I want us to be together.

I gotta be in court.

Three weeks tops.

I swear.

Okay.

What's the lighting like on the road where the accident occurred?

There is no lighting.

So if a person was driving along that road at 11 .15 at night, how easy would

be to see something outside the beam of his or her headlights?

It wouldn't be easy, but it'd be even harder if that person was speeding.

Are you suggesting that my client was speeding that night?

Well, from the length of the skid marks, the damage done to the car, and the

injury sustained by the victim, we estimate he was doing 50 miles an hour.

Posted speed limit's 35.

You estimate.

You mean it's possible Mr. Ivers may have been going less than 50.

Yeah, but it's also possible... Now, about those skid marks you just

on what part of the road did you find them?

A straightaway or a curve?

Both. They began on a curve and ended on a straightaway. Okay, so Mr. Ivers came

around the curve, saw the victim standing in the road, and slammed on his

brakes? That's correct.

All right, now, taking into consideration the length of the skid

point of impact, when did Mr. Ivers start braking?

As soon as he saw the victim or an intoxicated moment or two later?

Well, it's hard to say without knowing how fast he was going.

I thought you knew how fast he was going.

Oh, no, that's right. That was just an estimate, wasn't it?

One more thing, Lieutenant.

I understand you found a set of footprints at the side of the road that

made by the victim. Is that right?

That's correct.

Have you been able to determine who did make those footprints?

No. Yet one of them was found directly on top of one of the victim's

wasn't it?

That's correct. Which indicates what?

It's possible that someone else was there that night.

Well, it's possible that this as yet unidentified person may have pushed the

victim onto the road and caused the accident, isn't it?

Objection. Call for rampant speculation.

Sustained.

Nothing further, Your Honor.

Next witness, Mr. Gerard.

I'm sorry.

Seeing Mr. Robinson without an appointment is out of the question.

Oh, but can I just slip in after he's done with Mr.

Herman?

No, you may not.

Yes, hello.

Mm -hmm.

Mm -hmm.

Sure, I'll bring them right in.

Thank you, George.

Where the hell did this come from?

From me.

I'm sorry, Mr. Robinson. She's been pestering me to let her see you. I told

her... I'll call security.

No, no, no, no.

That's all right.

Roger, we're going to have to continue this later.

No problem.

You can go two doors.

I'm Jerry Stone. I'm a private investigator.

I was just wondering what you and Mr. Reeves were talking to Scott Aston about

in the park.

I don't think that's any of your business, Ms. Stone.

Well, it's just so obvious that you were meeting with him on the sly. And since

Mr. Aston is so dead now... As you undoubtedly know,

my partner and I are what is known as corporate raiders.

Sometimes we buy whole companies.

But before we do that, we check those companies out from top to bottom. And to

do that, we hire private investigators like Scott Afton.

And if you ask me what company he was checking out, I won't tell you.

You know, that's so interesting, because that's not at all what Mr. Reeves told

me when I showed him the picture.

When did you talk to him?

This morning, about an hour ago.

That's a nice try, Miss Stone.

Mark's in L .A. on business.

I just talked to him about an hour ago.

Why did you take this picture, anyway?

Why, Mr. Robinson, I don't think that's any of your business.

But thanks for your time.

Frank!

Hey. Hey, I gotta talk to you. Yeah.

Uh, did you hear about this private investigator Scott asked me who got

last night?

Yeah, it was on the news.

Well, that's the guy who was black, really.

You're kidding.

Well, it gets worse than that.

I went to see him last night. The police found out, so I'm kind of on their

suspect list.

Went to see him?

Yeah, well, I had him followed from Calvo's, and, you know, once I found out

he was and where he was staying, I confronted him.

You did all this without telling me? Geez, Cliff, I hired you to meet with

guy. That was it.

Well, I'm going the extra mile. Now, don't worry. I didn't say anything to

police. I don't intend to.

It's all under the lawyer -client privilege.

All right, keep me posted in private.

Oh, that's a problem. I don't know where it's safe to contact you.

Try me at the office.

What if you're not at the office?

Try me at the Mayfield Hotel, Mr. and Mrs. William Gillespie.

William Gillespie? Yeah.

Mayfield Hotel. Try it.

Hey, just the person I want to see. Hey, Gary Stone, Craig Browning. Hi, Gary.

Hi, Craig. Hi. Did you have a chance to talk to John Robinson?

Yep. Hey, Pates got asked to respond for them.

That's what he said.

Now, don't buy that for a moment.

Rachel, what are you doing here?

It's okay. Cliff Lewis, Gary Stone. This is my friend, Rachel Ballard.

Hi. Hi.

Hi. This'll just take a minute.

What are you doing?

I'm sorry. I know I wasn't supposed to come, but I don't like this. I need to

talk to you. Not now. I'll call you. I promise.

I miss you.

I'll greet you later, okay?

That was her, huh?

Yeah. Remember, keep me posted.

It was outside Calvo's when you went to meet with Scott Astin. It was parked

right next to me.

Who was at the door?

Lieutenant Bigelow.

He's in the living room.

What for?

Well, a handkerchief with your initials on it and Scott Astor's blood was found

at the scene of the crime.

He wants to take you downtown.

Mr. Matlock.

Hi. Craig Browning.

I know who you are. I just heard that Cliff's been arrested.

Suspicion of murder.

Oh, my God.

Are you going to represent him? Yeah.

And as his lawyer, I have to keep whatever he tells me a secret.

He told me everything.

You mean about me?

And now you're going to tell me everything.

Starting with... Why you were at Kelbo's the afternoon you sent Cliff to see

that blackmailer.

What makes you think I was there? And whatever you do, don't lie.

I hate that.

I just wanted to get a look at the blackmailer, that's all. Why? I was

You sure you didn't follow him back to his hotel room?

What are you trying to say, that I killed Scott Astin?

Cliff didn't.

The only one I know who benefits from Scott Astin's murder and from this...

Lawyer -client relationship that prevents Cliff from telling the police

he knows is you.

You think I set this whole thing up?

Wouldn't be the first time somebody's taken advantage of Cliff. Well, you're

wrong.

Then prove it.

Go in there and release him from any and all obligations to you. Let him tell

the truth.

The person who hired Scott Astin to make sure I threw Cameron Ivers' case,

that's who you should be trying to nail. Not me.

I'm no murderer.

A coward, maybe.

But not a murderer.

Came in here two days ago around four o 'clock in the afternoon. Do either of

you remember him?

Yeah, as a matter of fact, I do.

I'm investigating his murder.

Do you happen to remember what he wanted? Well, that's why I remember him.

came in here claiming that we'd run some obituaries last month on some people

who weren't really dead.

Made us give them copies of their death certificates.

You keep copies of death certificates in here?

Well, the legal department won't let us publish an obit without one.

Do you happen to remember which ones you showed him?

No.

But the computer will.

Having previously found the defendant guilty of the lesser charge of vehicular

homicide, I sentence him to five years formal probation.

Order him to pay a $10 ,000 fine and to complete 1 ,000 hours of community

service.

This court is now in recess.

Miss Drivers, Ben Matlock.

Could I speak with you for a moment?

I suppose.

This may seem like a strange question,

but who would benefit from your going to prison?

What is this? Craig asked me the same thing two days ago.

What'd you tell him?

That I had no idea.

Now, what's this about? Craig wouldn't say.

Somebody tried to blackmail him into throwing your case so you'd wind up in

prison. Are you joking? No.

It was this man here.

Private investigator, Scott Astin. You know him?

No. But I sure as hell know these other two.

But, Mr. Ivers... Mr. Ivers, stop. You can't go in there.

What's the matter?

Were you afraid I was going to buy some company out from under your snotty

little noses? Is that why you wanted me out of the way? Just take it easy.

What's the problem?

Right here.

This is the problem.

That's you.

And that's you.

Meeting with a guy who tried to get my lawyer to send me up the river.

I don't know what you're talking about.

He was doing some investigating for us. That's all.

Liar. You're both liars. Mr. Ivers, please.

Calm down, Cameron.

That meeting had nothing to do with you. I think it did.

In fact, I know it did.

You two still have a 28 % stake in Lavinia Enterprises?

Good.

Because I just got through dumping 250 ,000 shares of it.

Don't look now, boys.

But you're bleeding.

paying my bill, Pop. I'll pay you back, I swear.

I don't know, Cliff. 200 grand.

You may have to get a paper route.

Besides, I'm gonna get it back.

Unless you're thinking about making a run for the border or something.

I'll tell you what I'm thinking about. I'm thinking it was stupid of me to let

Craig Burney set me up like that.

Now you don't know for sure that he set you up.

You trusted him. That's not stupid.

Have faith in your fellow man. That's not stupid. That's an admirable quality.

Oh, Pop, I was trying to impress him, you know? I just went overboard on this

case because I wanted him to respect me and like me.

I wanted him to think I was cool.

Yeah, that's stupid.

Hello again, Mr. Matlock. I'm sorry I took off like that. I'm a bit impulsive.

Where'd you go?

Hey, everyone. I went to see John Robinson and Mark Reeves.

They're up to something. There's no doubt about it. But while I was in their

office, something very odd happened.

What? Well, there was a young woman there. I'd never seen her before, and

she knew who I was, which is very surprising. I keep a very low profile.

Maybe she works for them.

I've been to their offices dozens of times.

I've been to parties at both their houses. I've never seen her before, I'm

What does she look like?

Mid to late 20s, 5 '6", 5 '7", dark brown hair, about shoulder length, trim,

very pretty.

Fair skin?

Yeah.

Rachel Bauer.

I promise you, as soon as the election is over, I'll tell her. Even if you did,

you wouldn't wind up with me.

I can't handle this anymore, Craig. It hurts too much.

I'm really sorry to barge in on you like this.

Hi, Rachel. I see you're still on the job here. I guess no one told you the

blackmailer's dead and Cameron Ivers was acquitted, so you can go home.

What are you talking about?

Well, Rachel here was seen this morning at the offices of John Robinson and Mark

Reeves. I'm pretty sure those are the guys who hired Aston to blackmail you,

which, if you think about it, he couldn't have done without her help.

So that's why you're blowing me off.

All along, you were working with Scott Astin, leading me on so he could take

those pictures.

I don't have to listen to this.

Rachel, listen, here is something you do have to listen to.

Chances are that one or both of those men you met with this morning killed

Astin because I found a connection between them and him.

And now I found a connection between them and you.

So what do you suppose they're going to do when they figure that out?

Rachel, go to the DA and get these guys before they get you.

There is nothing to tell the DA.

John Robinson and Mark Reeves paid me to seduce Craig. That's it.

I don't know why they wanted to blackmail him, and I know nothing of the

murders. Well, how long did you know Scott Astin? I talked to him once, the

before he was murdered. He was in a big hurry to get down to Florida.

You and me?

The whole thing was an act?

You used me for fun away from home.

I used you in a different way.

Oh, if it's any consolation, I intend to vote for your wife.

I'm not sure I follow you.

Somebody wanted Cameron Ivers to go to prison?

Is that what you think?

And I can't help but believe it had something to do with business.

Like, say, maybe he wanted to buy somebody's company.

Say, yours.

Only somebody else wanted him out of the way so they could buy your company.

Say, John Robinson, Mark Reeves.

I just met with John the other day.

I know.

He planning on buying you up?

Mr. Matlock, answering that question could land me in prison.

You're asking for what the SEC refers to as insider information.

I know, and I'm not looking to make a fortune in the stock market.

The police think my associate's a murderer, and I'm just trying to prove

not.

What I'm about to say is completely off the record. If anybody asks, I'll deny

that I ever said a thing. Of course.

The only person of late who has shown any interest in acquiring Ashfield Life.

It's Cameron Ivers. I was talking to John about something else entirely.

Have John Robinson and Mark Reeves ever expressed an interest in buying your

company? Never, never.

Although I don't know why not.

Our sales for the past two years have been monumental.

As long as we're on the subject, have you heard about the flexible premium

adjustable policy that we've just begun offering?

Right, left, right, left. Wide it out.

Right,

left. Watch my feet. Watch my feet. Now we're going to get into the monster.

Okay, here we go. Here we go.

That's it. Now we're going to get the arms into it. Ready?

Back when I tried to learn to talk, talk.

Yeah, what happened?

Broke his one foot.

Oh, yeah?

Let's do something.

That's enough for Rupert. Okay. Good job. Yeah.

Okay. We're going to move into some resistance training.

Resistance.

There you go.

Oh, I don't want to look like Arnold Schwarzenegger. I just want to lose 20

pounds by the 23rd. Let me tell you something. If you want to lose weight,

proper way to do it is to eat right and increase your metabolism.

You got it? Yeah. Okay, you stick with me, Mr. M, and you're going to be

and feeling like a million bucks in no time.

Man, I feel that's what I'm paying.

You're a pretty funny guy.

Okay. One -arm dumbbell curls. Just like this.

Shoulders back.

Chest out.

Right arm first.

Bring it up. Go ahead.

Bring it up. You exhale.

Go ahead. Right arm.

That's it. Get up.

That's it. Keep going.

That's it. That's the way to breathe.

Okay. And down slow.

There you go. Left arm up. Come on. Keep going. These are heavy.

You're darn right they're heavy. No pain, no gain.

Come on, squeeze.

Keep it going, keep it going.

Pretty soon your arms are going to feel like hot, molten lead.

They do.

Finn!

Here, she might want to talk to me.

I'm moving furniture.

Why? You could have asked me to help you.

I just felt like doing it.

Oh.

Well, I went over to Kane Mortuary. You know the place that issued the death

certificates to the three dead people that Scott Asin was so interested in at

the Atlanta Herald? Yeah.

Well, the place was completely abandoned.

I mean, really eerie. Like nobody had been there for months, maybe even years.

Well, they could have gone out of business.

Not according to the Better Business Bureau.

Are you okay?

Oh, yeah, yeah, I'm fine.

Well, they're still listed in the phone book, and when you call, you get a

machine. But get this one.

Those people whose names were on the death certificates, they're not dead.

They're not?

I traced them down through their social security numbers.

They're all very much alive, which is what Scott Aston thought.

I wonder what he was on to.

I don't know, but maybe we better find out.

May Allah...

In the kitchen.

This place stinks like onions.

Onions stink.

They make you cry, too.

You talk to D .A. yet?

About what?

Cameron Ivers.

What about him? Someone hit him with a car last night and killed him.

I know that.

Well, that proves that Cliff didn't kill Scott Afton.

I don't get it. Use your noggin, Ben.

Somebody hired Scott Astin to blackmail Cameron Ivers' lawyer so this fellow

Ivers would go to jail for hitting that guy when he was driving drunk.

You told him Craig Browning was being blackmailed? I didn't. What happened to

privileged information? You might as well put it in the newspaper. I didn't

him. So when this fellow Ivers went free, this somebody killed him just like

they killed Scott Astin.

It's probably John Robinson or Mark Reeves.

Maybe even both.

Where'd you get all this stuff? I didn't tell him. I heard you two talking the

other day. You were eavesdropping. I just heard you. The only place Cliff and

talked about this stuff was right here in the kitchen. Where were you? Right

there in that dining room.

You were hiding in the dining room listening to us?

Daggone you, Billy.

Pop, Ben is my lawyer. Any conversations we have are confidential.

Can I help it if I got all my faculties?

Doctor said I got ears like a fruit bat.

Like a what?

Fruit bat. Now listen, Ben. Cliff was with me last night. We had dinner, pot

roasts and dumplings. Then we played gin rummy till ten and I won.

So he couldn't have killed Cameron Ivers and that means he didn't kill Scott

Aston.

Billy, I can't say anything to the DA till Cliff says it's okay.

Tell him.

I can't.

They think you're a murderer. Tell him. It is a principle of the thing, Dad. I

can't tell them.

Principle? The heck with principle.

They're destroying your reputation and you don't even have one yet.

Well, if he's not going to do anything, isn't there something you can do? Yep.

Well, what?

I'm not telling you.

I'm sorry, but I'm afraid seeing Mr. Robinson and Mr. Reeves without an

appointment is absolutely out of the question. Well, just tell them that I'm

here. See what happens. Ben Matlock.

They are in conference.

Well, give it a shot. What the heck?

Yeah, I'm sorry to bother you, but there's a Ben Matlock here, and he'd

see you. I've already told him that that's...

This way, please.

Well, it really is Ben Matlock. I'm John Robinson. This is my partner, Mark

Reeves. Mr. Reeves.

Thank you, Doris.

Well, I guess I'm interrupting you fellows just as you're trying to decide

company you're going to take over next.

I was rather hoping you had a idea for it. Ah, you could put what I know about

the stock market on the head of a pen.

Now, I wanted to talk to you about Cameron Ivers.

That's a terrible tragedy. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

He came to see you yesterday.

Yes, yes, he did. Yeah.

I talked with him afterwards, and he said that there was a young woman in

with you.

The same young woman that helped Scott Astin blackmail Cameron Ivers' lawyer,

Craig Browning.

I'm afraid you've lost me.

Oh, well, at first, when you arranged for this private detective to

blackmail Craig Browning into throwing Cameron Ivers' case, all you wanted was

Mr. Ivers to go to jail. But when that didn't work, and then he came in here

confronted you the way he did, well...

You figured more drastic action should be taken.

How about it?

We may be sharks in business, but we do not kill people.

And Cameron Ivers was no threat to us.

Oh, yes, he was.

I don't know how yet, but I know he was.

Well, I hate to burst your bubble, Mr. Matlock, but Mark and I were attending a

black -tie fundraiser at the Ritz -Carlton last night.

Oh.

Well, how about the night Scott Astin was murdered, between seven and eight?

What night was that?

That'd be Tuesday the 3rd.

Playing racquetball at the spa club. With each other, I guess.

Yes.

Well, maybe this whole thing is just one big coincidence.

The blackmail, the girl, Mr. Ivers getting run down like that.

I assure you, Mr. Matlock, that's exactly what it is.

Well, thanks for your time.

And now that we've had our little talk, I...

Sure hope nothing happens to that girl, Rachel Bower, don't you?

Your friend, Ben

Matlock, is an alarmingly smart fellow.

He's not my friend. And he only looks smart compared to you two.

What's that supposed to mean?

Killing Cameron Ivers was stupid.

That's what it means.

What makes you think we'd kill him?

A man had enemies all over the world, one of whom happened to be you.

All that stuff was in Scott Asher's pocket?

Yes, it was.

A real pack rat, huh? I wonder why he let the water in before he was killed.

Where did you find them?

A sack of peanuts.

I don't know. I smell them through the wrapper.

Fat. Just fat, see?

Probably why they smell so good.

Shame to let them go to waste, though.

Garbation in the world.

Let's see what we got here.

Driver's license, library card, ATM card, car rental, video club.

Top -of -the -line car rental.

They say if you use their credit card, you can get a free rental sometime.

If he rented a car from them down in Florida, he'd have to leave a local

and phone number, wouldn't he?

Right. Fine, I'll be. Okay.

I got to go home.

What's over at the house?

I got to meet a fella and move some furniture.

Come on, fight it, fight it. Get up. Good, good, good. Keep breathing.

Keep breathing. Good, good, good.

Attaboy, keep going. Couple more, couple more.

Good job.

My stomach's on fire.

That's good, that's good. That's what we want. Burn those abs. Blast them.

I can't do anymore.

All right. Good job. You went to failure. That's what we want.

Okay, Mr. M, hop up. We're going to do some squats.

Some what?

Squats. Watch.

Three sets of 15 reps, holding 20 pounds. Maybe we'll pyramid up to 30.

see how it goes.

You know, half the time, I don't know if you're talking English.

You're right. You know that? Here, grab them.

Oh, no more dumbbells. Just make me sweat. That's something I do real good.

me sweat.

The name of the game is muscle mass.

All this exercise and all I've lost is a pound and a half.

You have got to stop measuring your progress by the scale. It's how you look

how you feel, not how much you weigh.

I hired you because I need to lose this by the 23rd.

Now give it to me straight. Is it possible? Yes or no?

Well, that depends.

On what?

On how you feel about liposuction.

Well, I'll claim mortuary, Dad.

Is this your phony death certificate?

It sure looks that way.

So far, I've located seven people who are dead, according to the claim

but are, without a doubt, alive.

They either live out of town or out of state.

They know they're supposed to be dead?

None of them had any idea that they were dead. But their obituaries had appeared

in the Atlanta Herald.

This is good.

This is good.

I used to eat like that.

Why'd you quit?

Couldn't buy pants?

What do you mean I couldn't buy pants?

I couldn't buy pants with a 33 -inch waist that fit.

No wonder.

Look at the gut.

It's not so big.

Get the tape.

Well, anyway...

I thought the best way to find out if these fake death certificates had

to do with Scott Aston's murder would be to get all the people together to find

out if they have anything in common.

How are you going to do that?

Well, I have an idea, but it could be expensive.

Excuse me.

Excuse me.

Excuse me.

Hi.

We need to get started. Welcome to Atlanta. Again, I'm Jerry Stone, and

over here is Billy Lewis. He's the one that paid to fly you out here and put

up at the nice hotel.

That's okay. I did it for my boy here.

Now, as I explained to all of you on the phone, I've reasoned to believe that

you all have something in common, and we're here to discover what that might

Okay, how many of you know a man named John Robinson?

Never heard of him.

Uh, Mark Reeve?

The guy who played Superman?

You're thinking of Steve Reeve. No, that was George Reeve. You mean Christopher

Reeve. Okay,

how about a man named Cameron Ivers?

I have heard of him.

I think I have.

What about this? Have any of you ever lived here in Atlanta?

No. My grandson lived here once.

Um, where was everybody born?

Oklahoma City.

You know,

you look really familiar.

Weren't you on that cruise I took last year to St. Thomas?

Are you kidding?

I threw up just looking at pictures of boats.

Well,

what, um, what religion is everybody?

How many of you think Atlanta would have won the pennant if there hadn't been a

strike?

Guess I'm going to Miami.

Let me get that.

No, I got it. Well, let me drive you to the airport.

I got a taxi coming.

Well, I'm a good driver.

Fair.

I'll take you for free.

No, Billy.

What's the matter with you? Free's your favorite word. You know how to say it in

ten different languages.

It wouldn't wind up being free. You'd keep butting in and try and take over.

Ben, Cliff's my only child, my sole heir, and he's in trouble right now.

Well, he's pretty smart.

I know he doesn't seem it sometime, especially now with this lawyer -client

-can't -talk -about -it stuff, but I want to help.

I'll pay for the plane tickets.

No, Billy.

Come on, Ben.

I'll stay out of your way. I won't say a single word the whole time, I promise.

I'll just go with you and hear what people have to say.

You'll butt in, Billy.

You won't even know I'm there.

I know.

Except for the colorful way you're dressed.

I'll buy you a colorful suit. That way we'll blend.

No, Billy.

meals, a hotel, pay for everything. And anything else that comes up, too.

No. I'll buy presents for everybody at the airport on the way home. Well, since

you put it that way... No.

Mr. Matlock. Yes. Hi, welcome to Miami Beach. Thank you. What can I do for you?

I called from Atlanta about a man named Scott Astin. The top -of -the -line car

rental company said he stayed here on the 2nd. That's right.

Yeah. He said he was murdered? Yeah, the next day.

You got a warrant that allows me to look at his bill?

Oh, yeah.

There you go.

Pretty minimal.

Sure is.

Pay for one night and that's about it. No meals, no parking, no calls.

Only charges for a one -page fax you receive.

Want me to see if we still have a copy of it?

Do you keep copies of all the faxes you get?

In this day and age, it pays to make backups of everything.

I'll be right back. Okay.

So you found a place okay, huh? I just followed the directions on that... that

fax you sent to Scott Astin when he came to see you.

Are you hungry? My wife just made some cookies. In fact, I can smell them all

the way out here.

Oh, yeah.

Oh, I better not.

I got my 40th college reunion coming up, and I'm trying to lose a little weight.

Well, why don't we just take a walk then? That way I can show off the place.

That sounds good.

Yeah.

Boy, this is a pretty place.

Bet you like living here.

Oh, yes, sir.

So, you said you had some questions about Scott Astin? Yeah, I wanted to

why he came all the way down here from Atlanta to see you.

I needed a private investigator, and I was thinking about hiring him. To do

what?

Why am I asking why you want to know?

He was murdered the next day.

He's dead?

Trying to find out who killed him and, you know, why.

My wife and I have two children.

Our youngest is a little boy. He's five years old.

He was born with severe disabilities.

Now, we love him dearly, but it's hard caring for him. It's hard on my wife and

me. It's hard on our daughter.

It's hard on our marriage.

I imagine.

Anyway, I... Somehow I got it in my brain and my wife was having an affair,

I... Flew Scott Aston down here to find out if it was true.

Oh, you wanted him to spy on you?

Well, I just wanted to know.

But talking to him turned out to be kind of therapeutic for me. I finally

realized that I was probably just overreacting. So I sent him home and

I'd call him after I thought things over. Well, why him? Why didn't you get

somebody local?

A friend of mine used him.

I wasn't about to use the yellow pages.

Did you call him back?

No. I decided I was overreacting.

Now that is what we call a preschool.

It's where we work out all our yearlings.

How long have you had this place?

Let's see. I retired in 92.

It's been going on about three years.

You're awful young.

How could you retire? How could you afford it? I was in the right business

the right time.

Computer software.

I made more money and I knew what to do with it.

But when our son was born, I decided enough was enough.

I wanted to stay at home and make sure that he got off to the best possible

start. Well, that's a good point.

Well, you've answered all my questions. I appreciate it. Don't you want to see

the rest of the farm?

Well, no.

Horses and I don't, really.

I'll get something to wipe that off.

The guy asked him to go all the way to Florida to talk to some potential

that's all?

Well, that squares with the mileage on the car he rented.

He drove from the airport to the hotel, drove down to the farm, drove back to

the hotel, spent the night, drove to the airport and flew out.

Such a dead end, huh?

Well, I don't know.

See what you can find out about this fella.

Chuck Ratner's his name.

He owned a horse farm down near Hialeah.

Used to work for some kind of computer software company.

Ratner. Right. I'll do that.

I told you he should have taken me with you. I would have gotten something out

of the guy right there and then.

Yeah,

sorry.

So when are you coming home?

But I'm not coming straight home.

I got to make a stop.

Can't you do something?

I think maybe you came to the wrong place, Ben.

You don't need a tailor.

You need an engineer.

Oh, come on, Marv. Everybody puts on a little weight as they get older.

What are you doing?

I'm holding my stomach in.

You are?

Yes.

Where are you putting it?

Come on, Marv. Oh, don't worry. I'm just making a little small talk while I get

a lay of the land here.

Can't you just let it out some?

Well, there's not enough material.

Well, maybe if I can find some to match the coat and...

Put it here in the back and sort of widen it out a little bit.

Move the buttons over here on the trousers and fix the zipper over there.

You'll be set.

Thanks, Mark.

I can fix that, too.

Okay, I know you're all a little anxious to get home a cookie.

This is worse than jewelry duty.

I'd like to see my grandkids.

Please,

whatever it is you people have in common, two men may be dead because of

Now, we've got to figure this out.

Hello, everybody.

Just keep talking to each other. Talk about the school, siblings, hobby, club,

job, something. You've got to have something in common.

Hi. Hi. Where's Ben?

He went over to the courthouse.

Well, I've been doing a little research. You know the guy you went to see down

in Florida, Chuck Ratner? Yeah.

Well, the guy said that he worked for a computer software company.

He lied. He worked for Roger Herman's company, Ashfield Life Insurance.

Ashfield Life?

Yeah, that's right.

I know that company. I almost bought a policy from them. Then I discovered I

could get the same thing for less somewhere else. Me too.

Well, at least they give you a free pen when you sign up an application.

Hold the phone. How many of you at one time or another have applied for life

insurance from Ashfield Life?

Yeah, I did. I did. I did.

Good, good, good. The gang's all here.

It better be as urgent as you indicated.

Oh, it's pretty complicated.

Maybe everybody better sit down. Get to the point.

Okay.

I know what you've all been up to.

And I know that Mr.

Herman here has been using information on application forms of people who

decided not to buy Ashfield Life Insurance.

They filled out the forms, but they didn't buy.

And he used the information on those applications to issue a lot of phony

insurance policies.

How in the world would I do that?

Money. That's ridiculous. How can I make any money if there's no one to pay the

premiums? Well, according to the state insurance commissioner, you could sell

those phony insurance policies to another company.

You'd remain the administrator, and you could pay the premiums for a year or

two, and then one by one issue fake death certificates. That way you'd

all the death benefits from the second insurance company, keeping all the money

for yourself.

Huh? Of course, in order to issue fake death certificates, you'd have to own a

mortuary, which you do.

Kane Mortuary.

Am I to understand that you've discussed all of this already with the state

commissioner? Oh, yeah, yeah. Yeah, he said it's a very ingenious idea.

Highly illegal, but very ingenious. He wants to talk to you.

Oh, and since the partnership of Mr. Robinson and Mr. Reeves owns

the bulk of Asheville Insurance stock outside of, of course, Mr. Herman,

I also spoke with the Securities and Exchange Commission.

Wait a minute.

We bought that stock on good faith. What you're saying is true.

It's new stocks.

Well, maybe you didn't know about the fraud when you bought the stock.

But you found out about it. And that's why Mr. Ivers was such a threat to you.

According to the agreement which you signed, you were not permitted to sell

stock.

For five months.

And if in that time, Mr. Ivers got interested, started sniffing around,

the fraud,

Ashfield Life would be out of business. And you'd be out, what, $300 million?

And so, to be sure that Mr.

Ivers was out of the way for at least five months,

You made sure he had plenty to drink at Mr.

Robinson's party. Remember Mr. Robinson's party?

And then you hired somebody to shove a bomb that nobody would ever remember

anyway out in front of his car when he was on his way home.

And then you hired that investigator, Scott Aston, to blackmail his lawyer

throwing his case so Mr.

Ivers would wind up in jail.

But, but...

Then, the investigator, Ashton, he got curious about the fraud.

And he wound up in Florida talking to an ex -Ashfield employee, a fellow

named Chuck Ratner, remember him?

About these fake life insurance policies.

The upshot of it was, you knew you had to do something about Scott Ashton. So

one of you... Went over to his hotel room and hit him over the head and

him. I repeat, John and I played racquetball that night from 6 to 8 at

club. And I was in a meeting with Chuck Ratner. He came to see me the day after

Scott Astin went to see him in Florida.

Yeah, I know. I called him this morning after I realized he had lied to me the

last time I saw him. I hate when people do that, don't you?

Any other wild accusations you'd like to hurl in our direction?

No, that about does it.

I'd talk to my lawyers, gentlemen.

I'll see you in court.

Hey, Clint.

Oh, hi, Craig. Can I talk to you for a second in private?

Yeah, sure.

I'll meet you inside.

Thanks. Uh, yeah, what's up?

Look, uh, forget all that lawyer -client privilege information stuff, okay?

Oh, no, no, no, no, no, I... No, no, I mean it. You tell the police or whomever

else you need to that I was being blackmailed because I was cheating on my

It's okay.

Whatever happens, I can deal with it.

Okay.

You got guts.

Cliff, wait, um... I don't have guts.

The police called my house yesterday and talked to my wife.

She knows everything and she wants a divorce.

What about the election?

She doesn't care whether she wins or loses anymore.

She's pretty mad.

I wanted you to think that I was taking the high road because I do it so

infrequently.

You're the one with the guts, pal.

Good luck in there.

I'll be pulling for you.

Thanks.

I understand the decedent Scott Aston had a talk with you last month, the day

before he was murdered, on your horse farm down there in Florida. Is that

Yes, it is.

What do you want to talk about?

He, uh, he suspected that Asheville Life Insurance Company was creating

fake life insurance policies, selling them to other companies in order to

defraud them out of millions of dollars in death benefits.

The last time I talked with you, you told me something else altogether.

Yes, sir.

I apologize for that, sir. This is the truth. This is the truth. Yes, sir.

why'd he come to you?

Because I used to work at Asheville Life, I guess. When you worked there,

you know that fraudulent policies were being sold to other companies?

I suspected it.

Is that why you quit, or should I say retired?

Yes. And you retired with a very generous pension, didn't you?

You mean was I being paid to keep quiet?

No.

But you did keep quiet.

My son is developmentally disabled.

Roger Herman, the president of Asheville Life, has always shown nothing but the

utmost concern and compassion for my son and my family.

I didn't report my suspicions because I... I felt I owed him.

What did you tell Scott Astin?

Nothing. Told him I didn't know what he was talking about.

What'd he do?

Got angry and left.

What'd you do?

Called Mr. Herman.

He didn't want to talk on the phone, so I flew up to Atlanta the next evening

and... Met him at his club for drinks.

The next evening would have been the third, the night of the murder.

Yes, yes. And I was with Mr. Herman from about 6 .45 till about

8 .30 that night.

Well,

during your meeting with Mr.

Aspen, did he mention Cliff Lewis?

Who? The defendant?

Oh, no, he didn't. Never.

They mentioned Craig Browning.

No. How about Cameron Ivers? Never.

Did he give you the impression that since he wasn't going to get anything

you about the fraud going on at Ashfield Life, you're going to let the matter

drop? He told me that he said something like he was going to keep rattling cages

until either the truth or somebody's head fell out in his lap.

And less than 24 hours later, he was dead.

No more questions.

Well, it seems Mr.

Herman has an alibi.

One of them.

There they are.

Right on time. They play racquetball between 6 and 8 every Tuesday and

night, and they have for the past four years.

Can I see him leaving?

Yeah, right there.

There.

20, 22.

22 minutes after 8.

Good -looking guys.

Too bad one of them's so weird and the other one's so married.

Well, thanks.

Would you mind if I took a look around?

Sure.

Hi, sir. Have you ever seen these men?

Gentlemen, do you know of a John Robinson? No.

Oh,

what the heck.

Hey,

buddy.

I've got to answer a question.

You know these two guys here?

You should

dry your hair. You'll catch a cold.

Yeah, well, the wet looks in, lady.

Hair dries well with perms.

entering the club two weeks before the murder.

And here you are leaving the club.

And here you are entering the club one week before the murder. And here you are

leaving the club.

Now, in those pictures, when you entered the club, was your hair wet or dry?

It's dry.

How about when you left the club?

Wet. How come?

We take showers after we play. How come you don't dry?

Club doesn't provide hair dryers. Oh, so you just towel dry it and leave it a

little wet. That's fashionable.

Now, here you are entering the club January 3rd, the night of the murder.

And here you are leaving the club.

Now, how could that be?

You left the club with dry hair.

How could that be?

Well, uh... Oh, I know. That was the night I hurt my knee. We only played

for about an hour, and then we had a drink. There's no record if you're

drink or anything else at the club that night.

You rented the court, and that's it.

Only you didn't play racquetball that night, did you? You or Mr. Reeves or

slipped out the back door, went over to Mr.

Ashton's... Hotel room killed him, slipped back in the club so it looked

had an alibi. Not true. It's already been established that you stood to lose

hundreds of millions of dollars if he lived to tell about the fraud going on

Asheville Life.

Right, Mr. Robinson?

I need to talk to my attorney.

Sounds like a good idea to me.

This court's in recess till 9 a .m. tomorrow.

And because we are so successful, people who are eager to get rich try to do so

by finding out about our investment plans and then acting on them even

do. Our phones have been tapped, our employees bribed, our cars have been

followed.

Secrecy has become an absolute necessity for us, and not just out of self

-interest.

Federal law demands it. Federal law?

When did you get so law -abiding? You've been indicted for fraud.

Yes. But we're not murderers.

You were right. We did use the sports club as a cover.

But were we to say where we really went that night, the SEC could very easily

consider it a violation of insider trading laws. Wait a minute.

If there's a problem with the SEC, I'll handle it.

Now, where were you?

With Carl Gottlieb, the CEO of the VSN Corporation.

Discussing a possible takeover.

Here's his sworn affidavit.

Mr. Matlock, do you mind?

Well, whoever killed Scott Astin, we know it wasn't John Robinson or Mark

Reeves. That's what you said before about Roger Herman. Well, we'll just

prove that he got Chuck Ratner to laugh on him. But you can't prove it.

And what if you can't prove it? You know, the DA's case against me is pretty

circumstantial, but it's, you know, some strong circumstance. They got the maid

who overheard me arguing with Scott Asin. They got my hankies stuffed in the

toilet. The jury likes you.

Really, do they? I think juror number eight has a crush on you.

That's very funny.

No, honestly.

Was juror number eight the blonde or the brunette?

Um...

What do people need with all this stuff?

Who uses bath gel or shower caps? When was the last time you wore a shower cap?

How long was Scott Aspin in this room?

Oh, uh, since about noon on the day he died. They gave him a new room when he

got back from Florida.

Call housekeeping and ask them if a little sewing kit comes in these

Sewing kit? Yeah. Call them and ask them.

I had drinks with Mr. Herman that night, but I left around 7.

Before, under oath, you said you left around 8 .30.

Yes, sir, I know.

Mr. Herman told me to.

He threatened to cut off my pension.

Without it, I can't care for my son.

So I lied.

I see.

One more thing. Do you happen to remember what... Mr. Herman was wearing

evening? Oh, gosh.

I think he was wearing light brown pants and a yellow striped

shirt.

No jacket?

It was warm that night. I wouldn't wear any jacket either.

No more questions.

I understand you've been indicted for fraud, Mr. Herman. I've been indicted,

yes. Well, I'm going to ask you some questions.

Some of it has to do with fraud.

Now, there's a large cast of characters, like they used to say about the movies,

cast of thousands.

So you think carefully before you answer so you don't, you know, wind up in

trouble. You ready?

Was Cameron Ivers interested in buying your business?

He never talked to me about it.

I hear that he was the kind of fellow that when he took over a company... He

went through that thing with a fine -tooth comb. Is that right?

I suppose. So if there'd been any fraud going on at Asheville Life, he'd have

found it, wouldn't he?

I wouldn't know.

Oh, come on, Mr. Herman.

I'm talking major fraud.

What if Mr. Ivers found out that you were creating fake life insurance

policies and selling them to other insurance companies?

And what if he found out that you were creating...

Fake death certificates.

And then collecting all the death benefits from these other companies for

yourself.

That's a scheme amounting to hundreds of millions of dollars. What if he found

out about that?

I refuse to answer that.

I don't blame you.

Are you following all this?

If Craig Browning had thrown Mr.

Ivers' case when Mr. Ivers had gone to...

Jail, and that'd probably been the end of it.

But he didn't throw his case.

He didn't go to jail.

What he did, Greg Browning got my associate, Cliff Lewis, to intercede for

and go to a meeting at a bar with this private investigator about this

business. He met him. He had him followed. He got pictures of Mr. Astin,

Robinson, Mr. Reeves.

He went up to Ashton's hotel room and confronted him.

He said, you take my man down, I'll take your man down.

Cliff was thrown out of the room.

Sometime later, about, oh, 10 o 'clock, a maid that worked there at the hotel

discovered Mr.

Ashton's body.

There'd been a fight.

He was dead. Hit over the head with a bottle of champagne.

Dinner was knocked over.

Stuff all over the floor is a mess.

And then she remembered Cliff pounding on Mr.

Astin's door, shouting to be let in.

Then they found Cliff's handkerchief. Somebody tried to flush it down a

The upshot of it is the police charged Cliff with Scott Astin's murder.

But I know this man.

He didn't do it.

What he did, he went the extra mile for his client.

He respected lawyer -client confidentiality, and I respect him for

He didn't do it.

You did.

You're out of your mind.

Remember your ex -employee, Chuck Ratner?

He called you, met you at your club, told you that Scott Astin was about to

out about your fraud. You knew you had to do something, and now.

So you went up to his room and did it, didn't you?

No.

Mr. Ratner just testified that you bullied him into perjuring himself by

that you were with him at the time of the murder.

I did it because I knew the truth would make me look bad.

What kind of truth?

I left the club and I walked around for a couple of hours. I needed time to

think. And when it became apparent that I'd be better off with an alibi, I asked

Chuck to give me one.

Would you say his description of what you were wearing that evening was pretty

great? I don't remember what I was wearing.

Well, could you have been wearing these?

Yes, those are mine. Yeah, those are yours.

The police got them, with Warren, of course.

Cliff and I were looking around the scene of the crime, trying to, you know,

what we could find.

What we couldn't find were those little sewing kits that housekeeping puts in

all the rooms.

You know where I'm heading, don't you?

No, no, no, I don't.

Well, like I said before, There was a fight.

And this... This man, I'm sure, was doing all he could do to save his life.

I bet grabbing at anything he could, even the killer's shirt, huh?

Rich man couldn't go out on the street with his hair all messed up like that

after a fight, with his shirt hanging half off of him.

Couldn't go home to his wife like that, could he? Your Honor, this is

preposterous.

Yes, ma 'am. We'll cut to the chase.

Now, there was a fight.

He was strong, but you were younger.

And you won the fight.

And you killed him.

And you hit him over the head with this champagne bottle.

And then you grabbed a handkerchief off the dresser.

Cliff's handkerchief.

Wiped the blood off your hands.

Then you went in the bathroom, tried to flush it down the toilet.

Then you saw the sewing kit, and you used it to sew the buttons that had

been torn off back onto your shirt before you went outside, didn't you?

No. Okay, here we have it. When the police forensics got done with this

they found that not only was the thread that were holding these three buttons on

the shirt different from the thread holding the other buttons, But it was

identical in weight and dye lot to the thread in this little sewing kit.

You know, this is really something.

Here's a man who dealt with millions of dollars every day.

A lot of it is illegal, but millions of dollars.

Often there's just a little mistake.

And one piece of thread, worth a

penny, two at the most, ties you

to Scott Astin's death for as long as you might live.

Thank you, Your Honor. That's all.

They mourn that a maid forlorn with her sweetheart by her side.

Through the window pane, she looked at the rain.

We must stay home, Joe, she cried.

There's a picnic, too, at the old Point View.

It's a shame it rained today.

They're so wonderful.

They still got it.

Ben sounds a lot better with them than he ever did by himself.

I can't believe he still fits in a costume.

He had it let out.

How do you know?

Heard him talking to his tailor.

Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.