All language subtitles for Secrets.of.Playboy.S01E12_English

My name is Lisa Guerrero.
Playboy, in many ways,

is the reason
I am where I am today.

Why would you try to take
advantage of young women?

You might have seen me
on "Inside Edition."

Were you trying
to rip me off?

In my early 20s, I was
a "Playboy" lingerie model.

20 years later,

I became a celebrity cover model
for "Playboy"

in January of 2006.

This series is about women
like me,

who have an association
with "Playboy"

but are now looking back
and questioning

some really serious things.

They've bravely shared
their stories,

but the backlash has been swift.

Tonight, they'll share
the aftermath of speaking out.

My name is Sondra Theodore,

and I was Hef's girlfriend
in the '70s and early '80s

for five years.

It was like living a fairy tale,
and...he made me believe it,

and everybody else did, too,

'cause I don't know if they--
they all felt like

it was a fairy tale, too,
that we were so in love.

I would have never thought
she would speak about Hef,

'cause boy,
was she loyal to him.

Hefner--he broke me like
you would break a horse.

Hef used, uh, cocaine.
He had a drawerful of drugs.

The drugs fueled how many people
you could get in your bed,

and all of a sudden,
there's three of us,

and three girls became five,
and it got ridiculous up there.

He twisted my mind so much that

if I loved him, that proved
how much I loved him.

And I didn't wanna be
with those people.

He scared me a lot
at the end,

because you--you couldn't
satisfy him.

He had to have more and more
and more.

You know, pretty wild.

♪

One of the misconceptions

that some audience members
might have...

- Uh-huh.
- ...is, you know,

why didn't you tell this story
earlier?

Because if I admitted it,

it made my story--
the fairy tale,

turn into a nightmare, and--

and so many people
counted on that fairy tale

like my own children.

thinking I had been a princess,
at thyou know?res,

When most people break up
with somebody...

- Mm-hmm.
- ...they move on.

They're not involved
- Thwith their families.in.

They don't go back
for reunions.

- Your situation was different.
- Yeah.

Because when you
and Hef broke up,

you continued to be part
of his life.

Yeah. You know,
I'm not even sure how--

how I ended up back there,

because it was a painful
breakup, but I did.

I ran from the bad by

working really hard at being
normal, by getting married.

On my wedding day,
I thought, "See?

See? I did it.
I was able to get married."

Hef came to my wedding, and he
gave me my wedding reception,

and the pictures.

- You married one of his friends.
- Yeah.

He was in the business.

He ended up handling a lot
of the Playmates.

He understood me
and what I'd been through.

So I didn't have
to explain myself,

and for a while,
we had a great life.

We have two beautiful children,

and forever grateful for them.

All the girlfriends came back.

We brought our children up
for Easter.

Easter was very family-oriented,
and so that really helped

make everything okay.

It was the only family we knew.

20 years
after we'd been together,

if I showed up, Hef would make
a big show of "Here she is"

and the fake,
"I'm about ready to cry."

And so you believe it.
You get sucked back into it,

and all the bad things--
you think,

"Well, everybody else thinks
he's okay. He's great.

So maybe it's me."
He was that good.

It's charm
and smoke and mirrors.

Everybody kept it alive--
that fantasy.

- And you bought into this.
- -I bought--
- Well, yeah--

- Forever.
- Forever.

you brought your kids back.
- FYou kept going back.rs,

...with these women. You kept
in touch with them until what?

What was the breaking point
for you where you said,

"Enough. I'm not going to play
into this fantasy anymore"?

It was a long journey
to get here.

I had nobody to talk to
back then.

And then I saw him
indoctrinating my daughter.

Wait. What?

Well, he never touched her,
or I would've killed him.

But the same thing--
when she would walk in,

he singles her out
and made her feel special,

and I'd say to him,
"You can't have her.

Don't you touch her."

And, um...

[voice breaking] And...

That's obviously
a really difficult thing

for you to remember.
- Yeah. Yeah.

[exhales deeply]
Because if he had touched her,

I would just have died. Um...

You knew more than anybody
how dark...

- Yeah.
- ...Hugh Hefner really was...

Yeah.

...and that there were
no boundaries.

- Nowhere.
- Would you have been surprised

if he would have tried
to lure your daughter in?

He would've. He would've.

One of the things I was
interested in asking you about

is how your family reacted
to your story,

specifically your daughter.

It was not easy.
It was not good.

I'm saying these things,
and she's so confused.

We went through many years of
I was feeling like an outcast

from my family, because I didn't
have the support of them

in the beginning.

They loved me
and they wanted to support me,

but they didn't understand it.

They couldn't--
They couldn't go there.

By the end of the documentary,
they finally came around,

when their father finally said
to my daughter,

"Hef wasn't always a good guy.

He did some bad things
to your mother,"

and that was the moment

she was able to let go
of the fairy tale, too,

and that was really a huge,
huge breaking point for us,

for my child to accept it.

I wanna ask you
about the Playboy family.

Can you describe
some of the backlash,

once you told the story?
- Yeah.

What has that been like?

I'm being chewed up
and spit up by my own.

Not one of them picked up
the phone to ask me why

I was doing this.

They're afraid
to be shunned themselves.

I loved a lot of those girls.
We were lifetime friends.

And to walk away from them,

self-exile was very hard
because that's all I knew.

♪

Tell me about the first time
you went online

and saw the reaction
to your story.

Ugh. The warrior in me
wanted to just write back

and say, "Are you kidding me?"
But I, you know,

I just stopped myself.
I thought, this will play out,

and hopefully, by the end
of the documentary,

they will see the whole picture,

and they'll have to come
to their own truth.

- And--
- And they need to respect mine,

because nobody can tell you
your story's a lie,

because it's not their story.
Um, I'm not attacking them.

I'm just bringing to light
another part of the reality.

- Your identity for decades...
- Yeah.

Was connected to--to Hugh Hefner
and this Playboy brand.

Yeah.
And to say that it was a lie,

that "I was hurt,"
that "I saw other people hurt,"

that "I saw him hurting
other people"...

Yeah.

...that is a big, brave,
bold thing to do.

Thank you.

And there are some people
who support you.

Yeah.

Lisa Loving Barrett is somebody
you haven't seen in a while,

and she plays an essential part
of your...

- Story.
- ...story, really.

- Yes. Yeah.
- And so are you ready to...

- Yes, I am so ready.
- Here's Lisa Loving Barrett.

Oh, my God.

- It's been a minute. [laughs]
- It's been a minute.

I don't know if I wanna hug you
or feed you.

[laughter]

One of the things that I loved
about the documentary

was how you women connected
through something

that was a little dark, Lisa.

What was your role there
before you met Sondra?

I actually was working
part-time under the table,

helping someone invite people
up for the movies

for Fridays and Sunday evenings,

and I did that for months
until I was introduced to Mary.

She was ready for an assistant,
so I segued into that position.

Hef came to me and said,
"I've hired this secretary

that--she's your age,
and I think--

I think you'll really like her,
and I thought

that maybe you guys
could hang out."

And I didn't think
that I was hired to spy on her.

It segued into this thing
where Hef was saying,

"What are you doing
Tuesday night?

Why don't you and Sondra go do
something Tuesday night?"

But he would say on Wednesdays,

"Oh, what'd you girls do
last night?"

It didn't feel bad to say,
"Oh, no, we had a great time"

and kind of recant
what we had done.

And it wasn't until it started
to feel a little bit invasive

that I finally just had to say,
"I can't do this.

I can't come back
and report to you."

Was he jealous? Was he worried
that she was cheating on him?

What do you think
he was worried about?

All of the above. Attention.

- Period?
- Yeah. Yeah, don't you think?

- Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- Yeah.

It drove him nuts when he
thought of me having fun

outside of his clutches,
you know?

DiYeah. What he was doing wasg
otry to open up the timeslots.

He had other things to do.

Other people to do.

And that was heartbreaking
for me, and she saw it all.

You know, she saw the pain
that it caused me.

She told me a great story

I had completely forgotten about
on Thanksgiving.

- What's the story? Tell me.
- On Thanksgiving.

It's Thanksgiving,
and we're partying.

We're cooking
in my little 2-bedroom,

above-a-garage apartment.

It's very innocent but very fun,

and Mary called and said
Hef wanted to talk to Sondra.

About five minutes
after you hung up from him,

Mary called back and said,
"Hef's coming over.

He wants to hang out
with you girls."

He left whomever he was with
to be with me.

So before Hef comes
a little car with a butler

who brought in satin sheets.
- [laughs]

He goes into my bedroom
and remakes my bed.

- With his sheets?
- Yes.

Yes, with these satin sheets.
So then a few minutes later,

security knocked at the door,

and Hef came into my bedroom
with Sondra.

So I left, and about an hour,
Hef came back out.

So I scurried around upstairs
and peeled her off the sheets.

I have to say,
that just sounds so dark.

- And it was disrespectful.
- It was all about him.

It went
from being fun and adoring

to being exhausting and abusive.
- Uh-huh.

Lisa, now as you look back,
do you have any regrets

about your participation?

- I do not.
- No regrets?

I do not. I have no regrets.

I didn't have a-a perspective
of evil or wrongdoing

at that point.

Okay, but what is your response
to people today

that say, "You worked for him.
You should have known this"?

Well, I mean, look, it was
very homogenized then.

It was made okay. It made--

It was okay for me to tell
my grandparents

that I worked at Playboy.

From an experience perspective,
it's easy to see it differently.

With Sondra, I saw a hopeful
young woman in love.

I loved him,
and I kept thinking,

"He'll tire of this,
it'll change."

And 'cause he was telling me,
"We'll be together forever,"

and I was the first girl he'd
like to have a baby together.

He didn't just walk in one day
and start doing, you know...

- Yeah.
- ...monstrous things.

- -It was--
- It was an evolution.
- Yeah.

And the more she gave him,
the more he wanted...

Yeah.

...the more he needed,
the more he expected.

This picture, I'm being silly.
- I'm--
- I'm happy.

- Yeah.
- And in this picture,

he's whispering in my ear,
isn't he?

I wonder what he's saying.
[laughs]

And then you look at my face
in that one.

I'd been told to go up
and orchestrate an evening,

and... [exhales deeply]

Can you see it? It was like
the feeling I had every day.

I could believe everything
was wonderful and I was happy,

and I was in love.

♪

And then as
the evening approached...

there it was.

There was the whisper.
There was...

his wishes
that needed to be met.

The group sex--it was at least
five nights a week.

They had a protocol.

Everyone had their role
they played,

but I wasn't in a romantic
relationship with this man.

I was in a work relationship
with this man.

And it isn't because I thought
I was above it all.

It was because I knew
the parameters of my job

that I knew was expected of me,

and I knew
90% of it was business.

Lisa, you were part
of the business side...

- Yeah.
- ...of the Playboy brand.

Can you tell me about
the really disturbing things

that either happened to you

or that you noticed happened
to somebody else?

Yeah, there were a couple
of times

that I put myself in a position.

When we were in the game house,

Hef would ask me,
"Why don't you stay tonight?"

I just told Hef that I--
I just couldn't do that.

My daddy told me you don't
[bleep] where you eat.

The buffer was
I wasn't a Playmate.

I was with Mary,
and I had a job,

and that was the easy way
for me.

But one night, I was working,

and Hef was still out
in the game house.

I had a date that night.

I wanted to go home,
but we couldn't go home

until Hef went upstairs
for the evening.

So while he was still
in the game house,

I quickly ran upstairs
to the master bedroom,

and there were other women there
that were showering

and dressing, and I think
you were in the tub,

and I sat on the edge
of the tub

and hiked up my skirt
and shaved my legs.

And unexpectedly, Hef came up
much sooner than I thought,

and he came up behind me and...

- [laughs] Oh, my God.
- I'm trying not to picture it.

And he sort of squeezed
my shoulders and said,

"Oh, my God.
You're joining us tonight?

- Oh. [sighs]
- And I just instantly thought,

"Oh, I put myself
in this position."

That's where the decision
was made that

I didn't wanna ever feel
like that again.

I'm reading a lot
of these criticisms

that say,
"Oh, I went to the Mansion.

I never saw any
of that happening."

The same people that--
that would tend to believe

somebody in an office
or a different environment,

but they're not believing
these women.

- -WI don't think--
- I thinks? they're believing us,

but they think we deserved it.

Mm, that's really harsh, but...

Why wouldBecause--rve that?
WhBecause Playboy's Playboy.at?

It's sexual. It's not a convent.
What do you expect?

I mean, I also am getting
backlash from this.

"Why did she wait so long?
I stand by Hefner."

And to come after us,
we didn't do the harm.

It was done to us

and excused the person
who did it.

You have had two
very different experiences.

Lisa, can you just sum up
why you decided to come forward

and support Sondra
during this experience for her?

- Because she is my friend.
- She asked me to.

Every woman should have a Lisa
in their life.

Everyone should be more
supportive of women

and their story.

[sniffles]

Sondra, you were so brave

to share so many of your
traumatic experiences with us,

but I know that one of
the reasons you did that

is in the hope
that other people

would share their stories, too.

And there's one other woman
that's joining us...

- [sniffles]
- ...that has had

some very similar experiences--

Susie Krabacher.

- Hi. [laughs]
- [gasps]

- You're--
- You're grown up now.

- It doesn't seem real.
- No, no, no. [laughs]

I've only been visualizing
you guys just as you were.

I know. You still scare me
to death, you're so pretty.

- [laughter]
- Stop.

Don't be afraid.
Don't be afraid. [laughs]

- Hi.
- I'm so glad you're okay.

I'm okay. I'm okay.

I'm so glad you're okay
and strong.

And I'm so glad you are, too.

I was just talking
in the makeup room.

I never could come up to you
and talk to you

because you were so beautiful
and so intimidating

and so perfect.
- Oh, I'm so sorry.

No! I just... I'm so amazed
that you pulled off

being so strong
during all of that.

None of us had any idea.

Yeah. I was hiding it.

If we had only talked,
can you imagine?

Yeah. Yeah.

- It's been many years...
- Yeah.

...since the two of you
have seen each other in person.

- How many years? 20 years?
- Well, we were girls.

- Oh, it's longer than that.
- We were girls. We--

- 35?
- 35 years, maybe.

- 35 years.
- BOTH: Yeah.

Can you first tell me, Susie,
a little bit

about what brought you
to Playboy

and what--what your story was
back then.

Well, I started Playboy
because I needed the money.

I was making $3.25 an hour
at my job,

and I was approached by
a photographer from "Playboy,"

and you know, at first,
I said, "Yes, you know,

this sounds great,"
but then when the offer came

to actually go to the Mansion,
it became really real.

I had this moment as I was
going through those gates,

you know, I can run now.

[laughter]

I did believe that
what I was doing was wrong,

but I thought, you know,
God's gonna forgive me.

I need this opportunity,
and I'll never be able

to make this kind of money.

I was Playmate of the Month
of May 1983.

I was staying
at the Playboy Mansion.

It was all very intimidating
and really new.

I felt safe in my room,
and that's where I stayed.

Hef--he was telling me,
"Susie, I've heard that

you're nervous and that you've
been staying in your room,

but I want you to know
it's safe here."

And I'm thinking to myself,
you know, okay,

I've never had a strong
father figure in my life,

and I don't know if
you knew it, but I--

my grandfather was a pedophile.
- I did not know that.

And I was his victim
from 4 years old...

- Oh, my God. I'm so sorry.
- ...to 8,

And so I'm thinking, finally
I have a grandfather figure

that's nice and safe.

One day, I was talking to Hef,
and I said, "You know,

- I just--
- I-I need to know about my future.

Will I have to go home?
Or you know, what will I do?"

I trusted him so much.

He really made me feel like
he cared for me...

- Mm-hmm.
- ...as, you know,

as like a family member.

You were special.
Yeah, you were special.

So he gave me a pill.
I don't even remember

ending my sentence,
and I woke up,

and then, you know,
I'm coming out of it.

I'm coming out
of what's actually happened.

This is happening.
This is not a dream.

This is happening. Am I--
Am I a rape victim again?

Could this possibly
be happening?

The next day, I said,
"I need to talk to Marilyn."

So I went into her office,
and I just broke down.

I was so ashamed
and felt so gross.

All I could say is,
"He did it to me,"

and then she said,
"Don't worry. It's okay,"

and so I'm like, "Okay,
so it's okay. It's okay.

It's okay. It's okay,"

and then I went back
to the makeup room,

and the entire time,
you're being told,

"Well, you know, you could be
Playmate of the Year,

and this is so important,
and the money--

your life will be
changed forever."

Ever, yeah. [sniffles]

"You'll never have to worry
about money again."

And you're, like, what?
What's gonna happen after this?

If I'm not Playmate of the Year,
I can't go back home.

I mean, at least I couldn't.

I think a lot of girls did
have their family's support,

but I had nowhere else to go.

He was always nice
in front of other people.

Yes, yes.

I didn't like going
to the parties.

Boy, did I get in trouble
for that. That lasted--

Oh, yeah, if you didn't
socialize, ooh.

Yeah. It's like, "Oh, well,
just go to the party.

Have your meal."
That's not what it was.

Socialize is flirting,
older guys.

Older men.

Not anywhere near our age range.

And they said
inappropriate things also.

- They said inappropriate things.
- Touched you.

Like, uh,
"How would you like a 36DD?"

He wants to buy me
breast augmentation.

- I just met the man.
- Yeah, yeah, right.

This is unbelievable because
what you're describing

is, uh, kind of a circle
of people

that expected you
to be sexually available...

- Uh-huh.
- ...for these men.

- Is that fair to say?
- Day and night.

So there was
this uncomfortable experience

that a lot of women
were traumatized by,

and yet if you talk about it
to each other,

then it makes it real.

It's a problem,
and it becomes a problem, see?

- It becomes a problem.
- Yeah.

Okay. What did you do instead?

We talked about everything else.

You never really talked
about what happened in there.

Susie, you wrote about
your experience 25 years later

in your memoir.

Yeah. Mm-hmm.

This is important.

Sondra, you heard
that Susie wrote a book.

It helped me...

- Really?
- ...come to terms

with what I had, yeah.

And you hadn't talked
before then.

Yeah. Yeah.-So you had no idea...

- None.
- ...Susie, that you were

the catalyst...
- No!

...for Sondra deciding
to come forward.

- No, and...
- My God. [laughs]

It was one of the--
one of the things

that just triggered me,

- and, uh, I just--
- I didn't want the girls to think

that I was condoning
these things.

Um...it's still a phenomenon
to me that

the very girls that we know
were involved

in this kind of activity
will not, um,

hold him accountable for it.

But the thing is, it was not
that we got ourself

completely into it.

We thought
we were doing something

that would better our lives.

I felt like this was--
this was it for me.

I have such a huge amount
of empathy

because it could have been me.
- I went to--
- I went to--

Could've been anybody.

I went to the Mansion
when I was 20.

One of the amazing parts
of doing this special

is hearing the feedback
from people

that have seen Sondra's story,

and, Audrey, you're somebody
that came forward

with your own story.

So can you tell me
a little bit about

what brought you to Playboy
to begin with?

Well, when I was younger,
I wanted to model.

So everyone told me
I was not tall enough.

So I thought, hmm,
well, maybe "Playboy."

And I sent my pictures in
when I turned 18,

and they sent me a letter
accepting me,

and I was thrilled.

I flew out to the Mansion,
got to stay in the guest house

and meet Hef.

So you were a teenager.
Did it feel safe to be with him?

- Yeah, very.
- You felt safe?

Yeah. He was married,
number one.

He was married to Kimberley
at the time,

and I read it in an article.

He had plenty of women,
but through his marriages,

he was always faithful.

I do.

As you reached into the '90s,
it was a big, big change.

Kimberley was the lady
of the house,

and the partying kinda ended.

Kimberley's presence
was definitely known

around the Mansion.

Hef did not hit
on any of the Playmates.

As far as talking to him,

we were told that's a good way
to get yourself blacklisted

from the Mansion.

You know, if he--if we saw him
coming one way,

we'd go the other way.

So it's 1994. You came out
to shoot for "Playboy."

- Mm-hmm.
- What you thought would be

potentially a centerfold.

- Yes.
- And then what happened?

We did shoot for a day or two,

and Kimberley wasn't there.
She was skiing.

- Hef, though, was there.
- Yeah.

- Okay.
- I spoke with him.

Um, that's when he invited me
to his room.

He said,
"I have some photos of you

you might wanna take a look at."

Everybody left,
and I was sitting

at the bottom of the stairs

deciding whether or not
if I should go upstairs.

But then I'm thinking,

you only live once.
This is my opportunity.

This is my chance
to make connections

and get out there
and go in my career and...

I had no thoughts in my mind
that anything would happen.

So you decided to go upstairs.

What happened?

He showed me the pictures of me.

They were right there
by the door,

and then immediately,
he walked me over to the bed,

and I sat down.

He was to the right of me,

and he pulled out a joint
to split it,

and now I'm starting
to get speechless.

I'm not talking. I'm like, what?
This is all happening so fast.

- Yeah.
- -What's--
- And he gave it to me,

and then he's pulling down
his pants,

- and I-I just started--
- I froze.

And...he got on top of me.

[whispers] I'm sorry.

And, um, I just froze.

Did he have sex with you
without your consent?

Yes, he did.
I didn't say anything.

I didn't give him permission.

What was I gonna do?

If I said no, would he
have stopped? I don't know.

- I just--
- But no. He wouldn't have.

I laid there,
and when he was done,

he walked me down
to the guest house.

I didn't know what to think
that night.

- I just--
- I cried myself to sleep.

So, you know,
this isn't a fairy tale.

This isn't what I signed up for.

What are you feeling right now,
Sondra?

Lots of girls have ambitions.
Many have ambitions.

If that's what she was thinking,

it didn't give him the right
to do what he did.

The next day, I had a shoot,

and I couldn't move.
I didn't get out of the bed.

And I-I didn't go,
and the makeup artist, Missy,

came at the time
and to check on me,

and I said, "I just don't--
I just don't feel

I wanna do this right now,"

And they said, "Okay,"
and then they flew me home.

Did you tell anybody that
this had just happened to you?

No.

I-I didn't know what to think.
I was scared.

I thought I was gonna get
in trouble.

- Yeah.
- His house, his power,

She should've known better,
his enterprright?d be quiet--

Right. So I had to just
shut my mouth and go home,

and I did, and then I got
a letter in the mail--

a termination letter.

There was a moment,
wasn't there,

where Kimberley,
his wife at the time,

reached out to you?
- She did.

What happened?

She called my house phone,
and she's like,

"Um, I heard that you were up
in the room with Hugh,"

and she asked me
if I went up there willingly

or did he invite me?

Yeah, of course he invited me,
but I didn't tell her that.

I didn't wanna get him
in trouble.

- I didn't wanna get him--
- You didn't wanna get the man

that raped you in trouble?
- Yeah. Yeah.

I mean, that is so crazy.

He didn't care about me or...

what happened to me,

and I was protecting him.

After this happened to you,

did you ever see Hugh Hefner
again?

No. That was it.
I was thrown away,

and I shut my mouth.

Can you describe
how that experience back then

changed your life
and your image of yourself?

It does change you,
especially the way

you allow men to treat you sexually.

And it took me a long time
to figure it all out.

Never let a man
ever disrespected me.

He altered your destiny
for your life.

He altered it,
and not in a good way.

Audrey, can you tell me
what it was like for you

to try to track down Sondra?

It was just divine intervention.

A friend of mine said,

"Audrey, they're doing something
about Playboy,"

and then I saw her,
and I was like, oh, my God.

This could be the chance
that I get to...

- Yes.
- ...to tell what he did to me.

- Yeah.
- I just said,

"I have to talk to her. I have
to tell her what happened.

She needs to hear this."

Sondra, what did it feel like
the moment

that you got that phone message?

It was a voicemail I got,
and listening to it,

I was stunned. It was like

the air had been sucked
out of me,

and--and I was shaking.

I called her immediately,

and she just started talking,
and she told me the story,

and... [sniffles] and I told her
it wasn't her fault,

and she started crying,
and then I started crying.

- It--
- It touched me so deeply.

The whole reason why
I came forward

was being brought to me
and showing me

that I was doing
the right thing.

You just believed me instantly,
and that just felt so rewarding.

Deep, deep, deep in my soul,
I was just... [sighs deeply]

Sondra, you start the show.

One of the very first things
you say

in the very first episode while
you're getting miked up is...

I'm not doing this
for 15 minutes of fame.

I mean, who would wanna
throw themselves

under the train for that?

And you're kind of making fun
of it 'cause you're not here...

- No.
- ...for publicity.

- No.
- You're not here for publicity.

No, freedom.

- Freedom.
- Freedom.

- Yeah.
- What does that mean?

Freedom from keeping

such a dirty secret inside
for so long.

Freedom for everyone out there
who is having to...

- Yeah.
- ...to just stop and speak up

and say no and--and...

And say, "You're not getting
away with this."

Whether you're dead or not,

you're not getting away
with this.

You were part of a sisterhood,
as you called it,

with the other Playmates.
- [sniffles] Yeah.

Do you think it's possible that
you're now starting a movement

with a new sisterhood?
- Well, I hope so.

Women coming together for women
and holding each other up,

whether it's the good times
or the bad times.

I can't even imagine
how strong you are

and how brave you are and...

- See? [laughs]
- I endured one night of it.

- You endured years of it.
- [sniffles] Yeah.

I-I can't even imagine
what that

would do to you mentally
and--and spiritually.

Yeah. Thank you.

I wish I had the courage to say
something a long time ago.

You have the courage today.

- Yeah. Yeah.
- I do. I do.

Here we are, left with these
stories from these women,

and what do we do with it now?

And we wanted to bring
somebody onboard

that can give us some insight,
and that's Dr. Kate Balestrieri,

and I wanna ask you first,
Dr. Kate,

there's a real...confusion
for a lot of us

that were part
of the Playboy family

because we feel on one hand
that we're proud

of being able to powerful
in our femininity...

- Yeah.
- ...and our sexuality

and take control of that.
- Yeah.

But the other part,
especially after watching

what has transpired
over the last 10 weeks--

there's a part of me that feels
really awful about it.

In reality, human beings
are incredibly messy,

and we're complicated
and we're dimensional,

so there's room for there to be
really positive aspects

of anyone's experience there,
as well as really

terrifying and really horrifying
experiences and elements of it,

because if they were all bad,
people would have left.

- Yeah.
- Right?

sit there and take that
- over and over and over againt

if there weren't
some positive aspects

to being a part of this world.

You know, it's easy for people
to judge

when you're not
in that situation.

Yeah.

I wanna understand why people
would hear these stories

and either not believe
the stories,

or believe the stories and
still choose to be critical.

Let's get to a tweet
from Cooper Hefner.

And for those that don't know,

Cooper Hefner is Hugh Hefner's
son with Kimberley.

So, um, here's what he had
to say on Twitter.

"Some may not approve
of the life my dad chose,

but my father was not a liar.

However unconventional,

he was sincere in his approach
and lived honestly.

He was generous in nature
and cared deeply for people.

These salacious stories

are a case study
of regret becoming revenge."

I... [sighs] He was not in bed
with us.

He has no idea
what he's talking about.

He wasn't there.

What happened to me was not,
um, generous, kind.

- No.
- It was nothing but evil.

Yeah.

Here's one of my favorites,

and I've seen this a bunch online.

"Hef never did anything bad
to me."

Yeah.

And to me, that is
a strange argument.

Just because somebody never
did anything bad to you,

doesn't mean he didn't do
something bad to her.

- He targeted vulnerable women.
- Mm-hmm.

It was almost like he found
a niche in your armor somehow

to put upon you.
- Yeah, well, yeah,

we were easy to control,
easy to manipulate.

There's a document referred
to now as "the Manifesto"--

the Hefner Manifesto--
that is referred to

by a lot of side commentators
about this show.

"The girl next door should smell
like soap and be like a bunny."

"When you feel like
caressing it, playing with it,

the girl resembles a bunny."

"The sex that we fight for
is innocent sex.

Anybody can join."

"Consider the girl
we made popular--

the Playmate of the Month.

She is never sophisticated,

the girl you cannot
really have."

"She is
a young, healthy, simple girl.

The girl next door."

"We are not interested

in the mysterious,
difficult woman."

"The Playboy girl has no lace,
no underwear.

She's naked, well washed
with soap and water...

and she's happy."

And it's why he chose
certain girls.

If you're too difficult
and too much trouble...

- You're out of there.
- ...you're out of there.

Why do you think that was,
Dr. Kate?

Majority of predators, again,
are not going to go into their--

their party and start being
abusive in front of people,

because they need
to maintain this image

of being the trustworthy, safe,
smart, kind, empowering host.

The women who have come forward
with these stories

were very, very young,

and there's a naivete
that comes with that

no matter how old a soul
you might be.

Predators--they don't come
with a bulletin board that says,

"Here's how I'm gonna hurt you."
- Yeah.

They go out of their way
to convince you

that they are safe and that
there's a special bond here.

Here's another one.

Why didn't these women
report these abuses earlier?

I didn't want people to look
at me and think, "You did what?"

[stammers] I didn't want--
I didn't want them to look at me

and think that I was dirty.

They fear they're
not going to be believed,

which was the case
for many of the women

who have talked about it now,

and they do feel like
they were at fault

or somehow brought it upon themselves,

which is absolutely not true,

but that's how many predators
make them feel.

One of the interesting things
as we've seen the journey

of so many of these women
who have come forward,

women have experienced
these buried memories.

Mm-hmm.

Repression is our number one
defense mechanism,

so when things are scary,

our mind works overtime
to keep them out of view,

and as we see different things

that remind us
of that experience,

sometime those memories

can come flooding back
really intrusively,

um, and they can be overwhelming.

In my case, this bothers me
to this day.

Occasionally, I would get
a letter from a woman.

I don't know if you ever got
the wives writing you letters,

saying things like, "You know,
my husband just thinks

you're the most beautiful woman
in the world,

and you know, could you give me
any kind of tips?

Because, you know,
I wanna look like you."

I'm like, "Okay,
you wanna look like me?

Then hire a lighting specialist,
get, um, someone

that can spend three hours
on makeup,

spend $10,000 on a photographer.
You'll look just like me."

You never saw yourself look
of so pretty.ion.

It wasn't like people snapped
six pictures,

and those six pictures ended up
in the magazines.

- [laughs] No.
- No.

I remember adding up
the rolls of film,

and I came up
with 3,000 pictures

for my centerfold.

Of all of those images
that you shot,

where did the rest
of those images go

that didn't go in "Playboy"?

- Who knows? I--
- I know.

Do you?

- You don't know?
- No.

They're on dirty porn sites.

♪

After significant
financial losses,

in 2011, Playboy Enterprises
sold Playboy assets

to a company called MindGeek,

and since then,
a lot of former Playmates

have seen their explicit images
on porn sites--

places that they never believed
their images would end up.

What you're telling me is that
you're not in control

of those images.
- Oh, no, not at all,

and--and no woman deserves
to be on a porn site

unless she wants to be.

I can see you're so upset, Susie.

Well, this is
very new information.

- I'm sorry. I thought you knew.
- I didn't.

- This is news to me.
- Our images are used.

We are used as carnival barkers
to lure people in.

There are images, and our names
are on these sites,

and it looks like
we're endorsing this.

What?

They've not only sold
our beautiful images.

They sold our outtakes.

What?!

Why are the outtakes
so different

than what ends up
in the magazine?

Why would you be okay
with being nude in the magazine

but not okay with these outtakes
being out there in the internet?

- They're graphic.
- They're graphic.

Uh, I was told that my pictures
were being revered as art.

Yeah.

This is your private,
most intimate part of yourself,

and to have that
violated like that,

our images being soiled
and our legacies...

Did you have a lawyer with you, Susie,

when you signed a contract?
- No!

First of all, what 19-year-oldcan afford a lawyer?

- Yeah.
- I was in the makeup chair,

and I was handed something
saying, "Sign this."

Yep. Yep.

- I didn't--
- I didn't even have the--the time to read it.

You had your clothes off.
You were about ready to go on.

- You're--
- You're nervous, and they stuff it to you like...

- Yep.
- ...like they're handing you

a birthday card that everybody's
signing for the boss.

And you signed it,
and it was gone,

and you never saw it again.

They may have had
the legal right to do this,

but they don't--
morally, it is so wrong.

♪

His promise was to always
protect us and keep us

within the framework
of Girl Next Door.

He lied. The Playboy contract
gave Hefner and Playboy

the right to use the photos
and the filming

in any media that he saw fit.

HEFNER: Much of what began
with the magazine

has expanded now
to the internet.

It's just a tremendous,
exciting time.

My name is attached
to every porn site

you can imagine.

That's bull[bleep].

They just opened the floodgates
and let 'em go.

And Hef didn't respect
his girlfriends' photos either.

Even Hefner's private party
photos have somehow leaked.

When you would go out with Hef,

he's taking all kinds of
naked pictures of these women,

when we're wasted
out of our minds,

and he would print out, like,
eight copies

for him and all the women.

You would pass them around.
It's just gross.

There was just this mountain
of revenge porn

just waiting to come out.

After Holly's episode,
Hefner's widow Crystal wrote,

"I found thousands of those
disposable camera photos

you are talking about, Holly.

I immediately ripped them up
and destroyed

every single one of them
for you

and the countless other women
in them.

They're gone."

What do you want women
at home right now

that are sharing
these experiences to do next?

Well, first of all, I want them
to know it's not their fault.

It's not their fault.
It's his.

And, uh, I hope
that they come forward,

because united,
we can make a difference.

- That's right.
- We can make a difference.

I mean, there's just a few of us
right now...

- Mm-hmm.
- ...that are talking openly

about really embarrassing stuff.-Yeah.

Audrey said that she didn't want
to let Hugh Hefner

get away with it.
- Yeah. Yeah.

- That's why she's here.
- Uh-huh.

- Oh, yeah,]
- Doethat's exactly right.ou?

He cannot get away with this.

You don't want
the next generation

of young women to think that
that was okay and he was okay.

Yeah, and so they'll fall
for the next guy...

- Mm-hmm.
- ...who gives them these lines

and you start saying,
"No, this isn't right."

that's watching this and--
and give a final message?

It's time for them to stand up
for their daughters

so that it won't happen to them.

They need to, uh,
take their power back,

I think in order to become fully
who they were supposed to be.

We really need to stop
idolizing a man

who I can tell you was a rapist.

I don't need it to sign
any legal documents.

That's my testimony.

We're not the bad guys here.

We didn't do these awful things.
He did.

We're not rewriting history.
We're just writing it.

- Yeah.
- And we're never been allowed

to tell our story,
and it's our time.

♪

We are strong.

[laughter]

♪