Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:25,625 --> 00:00:28,504
PHANTOM INDIA
Reflections on a Journey
1
00:01:19,646 --> 00:01:21,626
“My name is Thomas Howard
1
00:01:21,814 --> 00:01:24,317
I'm an American
with the Peace Corps.
1
00:01:24,516 --> 00:01:27,656
I've come to India
as a specialist in agriculture-
1
00:01:28,221 --> 00:01:30,064
I talk to the peasants-
1
00:01:30,256 --> 00:01:33,396
I tell them, 'Instead of doing a crop
in the old method
1
00:01:33,593 --> 00:01:37,131
why don't you try something new?”
1
00:01:44,804 --> 00:01:46,715
There are hundreds like him."
1
00:01:46,906 --> 00:01:49,352
young American Peace Corps
volunteers
1
00:01:49,542 --> 00:01:52,317
living for two years in Indian villages-
1
00:01:52,512 --> 00:01:55,424
The Communists accuse them
of spying for the CIA-
1
00:01:55,614 --> 00:01:58,527
A//'s fair in war,
even if ifs not actually true-
1
00:01:58,885 --> 00:02:02,355
Thomas Howard lives on his own
in a village of 800 inhabitants
1
00:02:02,555 --> 00:02:05,297
in the mountainous region
of the state of Madras.
1
00:02:05,724 --> 00:02:09,968
“The prob/em is convincing them t0 adopt
several new techniques at once.
1
00:02:10,597 --> 00:02:13,441
For example,
when they use a new variety of grain,
1
00:02:13,633 --> 00:02:18,104
the y must use a lot of fertilizer
and insecticide-
1
00:02:18,403 --> 00:02:20,406
I have to be really careful,
1
00:02:20,606 --> 00:02:23,849
because if I've convinced someone
to invest money in new methods
1
00:02:24,043 --> 00:02:28,389
and it doesn't grow the way it should,
that's very bad for me- ”
1
00:02:37,223 --> 00:02:40,636
The presence of Tom Howard
and his friends is largely symbolic.
1
00:02:40,926 --> 00:02:42,769
There are barely 700 of them
1
00:02:42,961 --> 00:02:46,101
and 560, 000 villages in India.
1
00:03:49,628 --> 00:03:53,872
Everyone tells you, "The villages
are the real face of India- ”
1
00:03:54,067 --> 00:03:59,710
ifs where 80% of the population lives,
a life unchanged for centuries-
1
00:03:59,906 --> 00:04:02,182
One passes through these villages,
ignoring them,
1
00:04:02,375 --> 00:04:05,480
or repeating one
of the countless trite remarks
1
00:04:05,812 --> 00:04:09,783
about the Indian peasant's sluggishness,
fata/fsm, and refusal to change -
1
00:04:09,983 --> 00:04:12,963
the usual cliches
expressed by foreign visitors.
1
00:04:14,520 --> 00:04:18,559
At the start of our journey,
we stayed in a village in Haryana,
1
00:04:18,757 --> 00:04:21,204
about 60 miles from Delhi.
1
00:04:21,761 --> 00:04:24,264
It was a very cold January.
1
00:04:24,463 --> 00:04:28,435
Maybe it was the climate, the landscape,
their clothing or the irrigation system,
1
00:04:28,634 --> 00:04:31,137
but nothing really seemed
exotic to me-
1
00:04:31,670 --> 00:04:33,911
The women covered their faces
when we approached,
1
00:04:34,107 --> 00:04:36,849
as if in an Arabic country.
1
00:04:37,043 --> 00:04:40,047
Islamic influence is so strong
in this part of north west India
1
00:04:40,245 --> 00:04:43,283
that you'd think
you were in North Africa or Syria.
1
00:04:59,499 --> 00:05:02,070
No farms or houses
stood ofi' on their own.
1
00:05:02,267 --> 00:05:04,577
All the peasants lived in the village,
1
00:05:04,771 --> 00:05:08,081
one of the most prosperous in the region,
despite appearances.
1
00:05:09,675 --> 00:05:11,747
A village like any other.
1
00:05:11,944 --> 00:05:15,482
Peasant life, with its repetitive tasks
and empty stretches of time,
1
00:05:15,682 --> 00:05:18,322
wasn't exactly inspiring.
1
00:05:18,517 --> 00:05:20,963
We tried t0 film in snatches
1
00:05:21,153 --> 00:05:23,225
to avoid disturbing the natural order.
1
00:05:23,689 --> 00:05:26,466
But every villager was aware
of our presence,
1
00:05:26,658 --> 00:05:29,105
and this seeming naturalness
is a bit fake.
1
00:07:09,327 --> 00:07:12,865
The women spend hours
each morning making chapat/j
1
00:07:13,064 --> 00:07:15,567
a flat bread
of wheat, com, or millet
1
00:07:15,767 --> 00:07:18,304
that is the basis
of the northern Indian diet.
1
00:07:18,504 --> 00:07:20,984
ItS eaten with very spicy vegetables,
1
00:07:21,173 --> 00:07:23,120
a lentil puree cal/ed dal,
1
00:07:23,309 --> 00:07:27,621
milk, yogurt, and sometimes
butter and molasses.
1
00:07:27,814 --> 00:07:30,522
These villagers are vegetarians.
1
00:08:29,141 --> 00:08:31,712
We were often tempted
t0 direct them.
1
00:08:31,911 --> 00:08:33,822
Very basic direction,
1
00:08:34,013 --> 00:08:37,961
like trying to get this woman
not to look at the camera,
1
00:08:38,149 --> 00:08:40,925
to act as if we weren't there-
1
00:08:41,120 --> 00:08:43,066
The woman gets involved in her role.
1
00:08:43,255 --> 00:08:46,065
She watches her child,
she watches herself
1
00:08:46,259 --> 00:08:48,205
It becomes a kind of performance
1
00:08:48,394 --> 00:08:51,203
in which she plays herself a spinner.
1
00:09:30,436 --> 00:09:34,714
We quickly gave up trying
to organize or compose their reality.
1
00:09:35,240 --> 00:09:36,879
Like this man and girl
1
00:09:37,076 --> 00:09:38,986
cutting mustard leaves for fodder.
1
00:09:39,177 --> 00:09:40,679
I don't direct them.
1
00:09:40,879 --> 00:09:43,086
Between the watchful precision
of their gestures
1
00:09:43,282 --> 00:09:45,262
and their awareness of being filmed,
1
00:09:45,451 --> 00:09:48,022
they're being directed,
but by themselves.
1
00:10:09,875 --> 00:10:12,947
At dayS end, the villagers
put on a performance for us,
1
00:10:13,144 --> 00:10:14,680
a real one this time.
1
00:10:14,879 --> 00:10:16,654
As a treat for us,
1
00:10:16,849 --> 00:10:19,295
they dust ofi' instruments
that haven 't been used in years
1
00:10:19,485 --> 00:10:21,863
and that need to be tuned.
1
00:10:26,258 --> 00:10:29,296
They're having a great time
reconstructing this scene.
1
00:13:53,097 --> 00:13:54,940
After this charming folkloric scene,
1
00:13:55,134 --> 00:13:57,614
we left the village at nightfall
1
00:13:57,802 --> 00:14:01,716
fol/owed, as always,
by a flock of kids and onlookers.
1
00:14:03,576 --> 00:14:05,749
Over the f0//0 wing days,
1
00:14:05,945 --> 00:14:07,947
the villagers gradually get used to us-
1
00:14:08,147 --> 00:14:10,650
Within the villagers' daily routine
1
00:14:10,850 --> 00:14:12,796
we 'd make discoveries.
1
00:14:23,962 --> 00:14:26,238
Cow dung isn't for the birds.
1
00:14:26,432 --> 00:14:29,311
Children gather it
like precious material,
1
00:14:29,500 --> 00:14:31,605
and the women mix it with straw
1
00:14:31,803 --> 00:14:34,307
to shape it into patties,
which are kneaded for a long time
1
00:14:34,505 --> 00:14:38,885
before being placed against walls
or on the ground to dry.
1
00:14:39,945 --> 00:14:42,016
There are almost
no forests in this region.
1
00:14:42,214 --> 00:14:44,956
Wood is rare, and coal unknown.
1
00:14:45,149 --> 00:14:49,326
Cow dung is the only fuel
available to the villagers,
1
00:14:49,520 --> 00:14:53,024
an excellent fuel that bums slowly
and gives ofi' lots of heat
1
00:14:53,558 --> 00:14:56,198
It isn't used as fertilizer,
1
00:14:56,394 --> 00:14:59,274
which would be the best we y -
but that's not their custom-
1
00:15:57,722 --> 00:16:01,363
Another traditional women S chore
is fetching water.
1
00:16:01,559 --> 00:16:03,630
For this village of 2, 000 inhabitants,
1
00:16:03,828 --> 00:16:05,739
there are about 20 wells.
1
00:16:05,931 --> 00:16:09,743
But the women don't fill their buckets
where ver they please.
1
00:16:09,934 --> 00:16:13,711
We quickly notice that the same women
always go t0 the same wells.
1
00:16:13,905 --> 00:16:16,078
Each has her assigned well,
1
00:16:16,274 --> 00:16:19,153
which she shares with other women
of the same caste.
1
00:16:19,445 --> 00:16:20,685
For the first time,
1
00:16:20,879 --> 00:16:24,383
we were seeing a physical manifestation
of the caste system.
1
00:17:04,890 --> 00:17:06,836
For foreigners,
1
00:17:07,026 --> 00:17:09,904
the caste system is incomprehensible,
and even invisible.
1
00:17:10,095 --> 00:17:12,540
Ifs manifest in every gesture
of daily life,
1
00:17:12,730 --> 00:17:15,540
yet we hardly ever see it.
1
00:17:15,733 --> 00:17:19,203
Indians don't like to talk about it.
They feel no need to-
1
00:17:19,404 --> 00:17:21,681
Everything rests on a tacit agreement.
1
00:17:21,874 --> 00:17:26,152
From childhood on, women always
draw water from the same well.
1
00:17:26,577 --> 00:17:29,456
To them, caste divisions
are like natural law.
1
00:17:29,647 --> 00:17:32,321
They're a reflex,
not a conscious choice.
1
00:18:27,306 --> 00:18:30,809
The caste system was ofiicial/y
abolished by the /ndian constitution,
1
00:18:31,009 --> 00:18:34,012
but laws can't erase
a tradition dating back millennia.
1
00:18:34,212 --> 00:18:36,921
When the government
digs wells in a village,
1
00:18:37,115 --> 00:18:40,062
it digs 10
where two would sufi7ce -
1
00:18:40,251 --> 00:18:42,492
to accommodate the caste system-
1
00:18:43,355 --> 00:18:46,461
Guidebooks explain
that there are four castes in India."
1
00:18:46,657 --> 00:18:48,432
Brahmans, the priests,
1
00:18:48,626 --> 00:18:50,799
K shatriyas, the warriors,
1
00:18:50,996 --> 00:18:53,237
Vaisyas, peasants and merchants,
1
00:18:53,432 --> 00:18:56,276
and at the bottom,
Sudras, who serve the others.
1
00:18:57,135 --> 00:19:00,878
Outside the system are
the outcastes, the Untouchables.
1
00:19:01,973 --> 00:19:05,284
This simplistic division
bears no relation to reality.
1
00:19:05,477 --> 00:19:09,391
From one region to the next, castes
divide and multiply almost to infinity.
1
00:19:09,580 --> 00:19:13,255
Each village has a hierarchy
thatS both strict and fluid,
1
00:19:13,451 --> 00:19:16,228
in which everyone has a role,
including the Untouchables,
1
00:19:16,421 --> 00:19:18,730
who are also divided
into distinct groups
1
00:19:18,923 --> 00:19:22,370
and are as necessary to the balance
of the whole as the Brahmans-
1
00:19:23,194 --> 00:19:25,765
In this village
there are over 20 castes.
1
00:19:42,280 --> 00:19:44,521
After our first contact
with the caste system,
1
00:19:44,715 --> 00:19:46,923
we saw villagers difierent/y
1
00:19:47,118 --> 00:19:50,031
We imagined the place
each held in the hierarchy,
1
00:19:50,221 --> 00:19:52,065
but how to know for sure?
1
00:19:52,257 --> 00:19:55,170
To our questions,
the few villagers who spoke English
1
00:19:55,359 --> 00:19:58,500
gave vague answers
or changed the subject'.
1
00:19:59,230 --> 00:20:01,211
The words in themselves
don't mean anything.
1
00:20:01,400 --> 00:20:03,573
“Pariah, ” “Untouchable, ” and “caste”
1
00:20:03,769 --> 00:20:05,770
are words invented by Europeans
1
00:20:05,971 --> 00:20:08,383
that don't exist
in Indian languages-
1
00:20:08,574 --> 00:20:11,384
Reality is more comp/ex
than terms used to describe it.
1
00:20:24,923 --> 00:20:28,268
One day, passing some houses
set apart from the rest,
1
00:20:28,460 --> 00:20:32,134
the sarpanch, the village leader
who interpreted for us,
1
00:20:32,330 --> 00:20:38,303
said nonchalantly
“Those are the Backward Classes. ”
1
00:20:38,836 --> 00:20:42,717
Its the expression often used in India
to designate the Untouchables.
1
00:20:42,907 --> 00:20:44,978
In newspapers
and political speeches,
1
00:20:45,176 --> 00:20:48,646
the preferred term is har/jah,
which means “child of God. ”
1
00:20:48,846 --> 00:20:50,985
The term was coined by Gandhi
1
00:20:51,182 --> 00:20:54,994
to show his intention
of giving equal rights to everyone.
1
00:20:56,188 --> 00:20:59,692
The har/jan don't seem any difierent
from other villagers.
1
00:20:59,891 --> 00:21:02,565
The leader of the village seems
to have a good relationship with them,
1
00:21:02,760 --> 00:21:07,106
a slightly paternal one that implies
everyone knows their place,
1
00:21:07,298 --> 00:21:10,836
reminiscent, perhaps, of relations
between blacks and whites
1
00:21:11,036 --> 00:21:13,846
in small towns in the American South.
1
00:21:15,273 --> 00:21:18,948
Sometimes there are articles
in Indian newspapers like-"
1
00:21:19,144 --> 00:21:23,524
“l-lar/jan Stoned t0 Death in Village
for Wearing Sandals. ”
1
00:21:23,714 --> 00:21:26,320
In certain regions, the Untouchables
are obliged to go barefoot
1
00:21:26,984 --> 00:21:29,863
Or, "In a Small Town in Andhra Pradesh,
1
00:21:30,055 --> 00:21:33,036
Young Har/jan Tied Up
and Burned Alive. ”
1
00:21:33,224 --> 00:21:36,535
Why? He was suspected
of stealing two copper pitchers.
1
00:21:37,395 --> 00:21:39,204
For the scandal to be exposed,
1
00:21:39,397 --> 00:21:43,743
a policeman or civil servant
had to break the /aw of silence-
1
00:21:48,807 --> 00:21:50,877
I notice that the countless
Untouchable children
1
00:21:51,076 --> 00:21:54,922
never set foot in the village school,
1
00:21:55,113 --> 00:21:57,115
even though the government
has passed laws
1
00:21:57,316 --> 00:22:00,387
promoting education for har/jan.
1
00:22:00,585 --> 00:22:02,792
Do the y really want them
to take advantage of it?
1
00:22:03,454 --> 00:22:06,697
I was told that peasants of the inferior
classes were against change
1
00:22:06,892 --> 00:22:08,894
more than anyone else,
1
00:22:09,094 --> 00:22:11,096
that they would refuse
agricultural reform
1
00:22:11,296 --> 00:22:14,174
if it altered the traditional hierarchy,
1
00:22:14,365 --> 00:22:17,244
and that thus, regressive thinking
and lack of education
1
00:22:17,435 --> 00:22:21,884
made the systems worst victims
its staunchest defenders.
1
00:22:40,525 --> 00:22:43,369
I'm told this courtyard, quite near
the neighborhood of the Untouchables,
1
00:22:43,561 --> 00:22:46,735
is the home of an upper-caste family.
1
00:22:46,932 --> 00:22:50,072
What makes this house
and these women difiereht?
1
00:22:50,769 --> 00:22:55,012
M/e begin to understand that there are
in visible - or almost in visible - lines
1
00:22:55,207 --> 00:22:57,778
separating neighborhoods,
houses and people.
1
00:22:57,976 --> 00:23:01,719
These lines exist in people's minds,
not in the material world.
1
00:23:31,108 --> 00:23:33,110
It seems like an everyday scene.
1
00:23:33,310 --> 00:23:36,086
The village leader smokes the hookah
with friends in front of his house.
1
00:23:37,281 --> 00:23:39,352
The hookah is the Indian water pipe.
1
00:23:39,550 --> 00:23:43,396
Smoke from very pungent tobacco
is passed through a reservoir of water.
1
00:23:43,587 --> 00:23:46,158
The mouthpiece passes
from hand to banal,
1
00:23:46,825 --> 00:23:49,066
but not from mouth to mouth-
1
00:23:49,260 --> 00:23:52,764
The smoker places his closed fist
between the mouthpiece and his lips-
1
00:23:52,963 --> 00:23:55,637
Once again, caste taboos intervene.
1
00:23:55,834 --> 00:23:58,747
Touching oneS lips to a mouthpiece
after someone of a lower caste
1
00:23:58,936 --> 00:24:01,212
would be a source of great impurity.
1
00:24:01,405 --> 00:24:03,942
One doesn't smoke the hookah
with just anyone.
1
00:24:04,142 --> 00:24:07,588
These villagers are in the same caste,
or in castes close to their own-
1
00:24:09,413 --> 00:24:12,724
/t may seem anecdotal,
but it touches the heart of the prob/em.
1
00:24:12,917 --> 00:24:17,298
The caste system is based above all
on ideas of purity and impurity
1
00:24:17,489 --> 00:24:19,866
of religious origin.
1
00:25:03,434 --> 00:25:05,711
In a small town near our village,
1
00:25:05,903 --> 00:25:09,442
this public bath
is always filled with bathers.
1
00:25:10,075 --> 00:25:13,284
I ask if the bathers
belong t0 difierent castes.
1
00:25:13,612 --> 00:25:15,990
As usual, I get evasive answers-
1
00:25:16,714 --> 00:25:19,661
Theres been a definite loosening
of taboos, especially in the cities,
1
00:25:20,618 --> 00:25:25,590
but for many Indians,
the essential questions remain-"
1
00:25:25,789 --> 00:25:29,168
With whom do you do this or that
activity? Whom can you marry?
1
00:25:29,361 --> 00:25:34,105
With whom can you
bathe, eat or smoke?
1
00:25:35,400 --> 00:25:39,007
/h the West, the basic unit
of society is the individual.
1
00:25:39,203 --> 00:25:41,581
In India, individual people don't matter.
1
00:25:41,772 --> 00:25:44,013
Ifs their relationship that matters-
1
00:25:44,209 --> 00:25:48,351
One isn't pure or impure. One is
more or less pure than someone else.
1
00:26:01,859 --> 00:26:05,466
On the roof of the baths, we found
a charming little outdoor school.
1
00:26:05,963 --> 00:26:10,434
The children are learning to count
in Hindi and English-
1
00:26:29,386 --> 00:26:32,095
Schoolmasters are often
of the Brahman caste,
1
00:26:32,289 --> 00:26:34,930
as teaching is one
of their traditional roles-
1
00:26:35,125 --> 00:26:38,572
How can we expect them
to attack the caste system
1
00:26:38,762 --> 00:26:41,242
when they occupy its highest rung?
1
00:26:42,534 --> 00:26:47,950
One of the kids asked
in faltering English if I was American-
1
00:26:48,506 --> 00:26:51,952
My negative response troubled him,
and he asked,
1
00:26:52,143 --> 00:26:54,144
“Then what caste do you belong to?”
1
00:26:54,346 --> 00:26:56,326
Wisdom from the mouths of babes.
1
00:26:56,681 --> 00:27:00,355
This child already knows that castes
are barriers between people,
1
00:27:00,551 --> 00:27:04,658
and for him, nationalities
are no doubt just foreign castes.
1
00:28:58,536 --> 00:29:00,674
Every day we spent in the village,
1
00:29:00,872 --> 00:29:03,580
we saw this blind camel
1
00:29:03,775 --> 00:29:06,415
circling tirelessly from dawn til/ dusk,
1
00:29:06,744 --> 00:29:09,691
dragging a mil/stone behind him
t0 mix the cement.
1
00:29:10,248 --> 00:29:12,091
Finally we filmed him
1
00:29:12,282 --> 00:29:15,593
as a heavy-handed symbol
of Indian society.
1
00:29:16,488 --> 00:29:20,368
An Indian of the caste system is caught
in a web of rights and responsibilities,
1
00:29:20,657 --> 00:29:23,433
absolutely unaware of the concept
of individual freedom
1
00:29:23,627 --> 00:29:26,073
that we value so highly.
1
00:29:26,263 --> 00:29:30,575
His destiny is laid out from birth,
with almost no possibility for free will
1
00:29:31,201 --> 00:29:32,942
But there is a reward."
1
00:29:33,137 --> 00:29:35,481
Living interdependently,
in relation to everyone else,
1
00:29:35,673 --> 00:29:39,143
he S part of a whole,
shielded from solitude.
1
00:30:42,840 --> 00:30:47,311
Day after day, we saw the same teams
take turns at this well.
1
00:30:47,511 --> 00:30:51,460
The precise division of labor
is a direct corollary of the caste system.
1
00:30:51,648 --> 00:30:54,026
This man is a water carrier
and nothing else.
1
00:30:54,219 --> 00:30:57,860
Its his dharma, his duty,
his place in the hierarchy.
1
00:30:59,123 --> 00:31:02,365
In the past, when villages
formed a closed economic system,
1
00:31:02,559 --> 00:31:05,005
the 20 or 30 castes
of the community were linked
1
00:31:05,195 --> 00:31:08,938
by an elaborate and codified
exchange of services.
1
00:31:09,366 --> 00:31:12,438
Priest, peasant',
barber, water carrier."
1
00:31:12,636 --> 00:31:14,638
Each carried out
his hereditary function,
1
00:31:14,838 --> 00:31:18,809
and in exchange
received goods and services.
1
00:31:19,777 --> 00:31:22,121
An idyllic vision
of agricultural communism
1
00:31:22,313 --> 00:31:24,350
where everyone's needs are met,
1
00:31:24,548 --> 00:31:28,655
which, even if it did once exist,
is lost to the villagers today.
1
00:31:28,853 --> 00:31:31,595
These water carriers
are no longer linked to the community
1
00:31:31,788 --> 00:31:35,167
but to the landowners
who pay their salary.
1
00:31:35,759 --> 00:31:40,731
Today, the division of labor looks
more like one person exploiting another.
1
00:32:20,538 --> 00:32:22,608
A few hundred yards from the village,
1
00:32:22,807 --> 00:32:25,913
these men and women
live in huts in a clearing.
1
00:32:26,477 --> 00:32:28,479
Originally from a mountain tribe,
1
00:32:28,680 --> 00:32:31,456
they came down t0 the plains
in search of work.
1
00:32:31,950 --> 00:32:33,861
They live in quarantine.
1
00:32:34,051 --> 00:32:36,622
We never once saw them
enter the village.
1
00:32:36,820 --> 00:32:41,064
These are the real outcastes.
Without a place in the system,
1
00:32:41,259 --> 00:32:43,671
their lot is worse
than that of the Untouchables-
1
00:32:59,143 --> 00:33:00,747
At the nearby river,
1
00:33:00,944 --> 00:33:03,152
the village clothes washers
attack the washing
1
00:33:03,347 --> 00:33:06,521
with an energy that makes up
for the lack of soap.
1
00:33:08,219 --> 00:33:11,359
Washing laundry
is a particularly impure task
1
00:33:11,556 --> 00:33:15,799
and is therefore reserved for
the lowest ranks of the Untouchables,
1
00:33:15,993 --> 00:33:17,995
cal/ed dhobi.
1
00:33:18,195 --> 00:33:23,042
By giving this task to the dhobi,
upper-caste housewives avoid defile-meat.
1
00:33:56,567 --> 00:33:59,137
Dhobi are found all over India.
1
00:33:59,336 --> 00:34:01,646
Here, on the riverbed in Madras,
1
00:34:01,838 --> 00:34:04,842
hundreds of dhobi wash
the dirty laundry of the entire city.
1
00:34:05,276 --> 00:34:07,313
They're remarkably organized.
1
00:34:07,511 --> 00:34:10,549
Men, women and children
all share the work.
1
00:34:10,748 --> 00:34:13,786
The laundry is collected,
washed, dried ironed
1
00:34:13,985 --> 00:34:16,693
and returned to the client
the same day.
1
00:34:24,594 --> 00:34:27,541
The historical origin of the castes
is generally attributed
1
00:34:28,231 --> 00:34:30,871
to the traditional divisions
among the Aryan people -
1
00:34:31,068 --> 00:34:33,241
priests, warriors and farmers -
1
00:34:33,438 --> 00:34:37,545
also found in the ancient civilizations
of Greece, Rome and Germany.
1
00:34:37,742 --> 00:34:40,689
Ifs said the Aryans, after invading
India over 3, 000 years ago,
1
00:34:41,344 --> 00:34:43,585
integrated the local population
into the hierarchy
1
00:34:43,780 --> 00:34:47,284
by placing them at the bottom.
1
00:34:47,751 --> 00:34:52,029
But recent discoveries show that castes
existed in the first /ndian civilizations,
1
00:34:52,222 --> 00:34:54,498
before the arrival of the Aryans.
1
00:35:15,246 --> 00:35:17,123
In the modem city of Bombay,
1
00:35:17,315 --> 00:35:19,818
washers are cooped up
in this enormous washhouse
1
00:35:20,016 --> 00:35:22,929
with cement stalls and running water.
1
00:35:23,286 --> 00:35:25,323
Modernization hasn 't changed
essential facts."
1
00:35:26,056 --> 00:35:28,559
it's still the dhobi caste,
and they alone,
1
00:35:28,759 --> 00:35:31,239
in charge of this impure task.
1
00:35:56,253 --> 00:35:58,255
In front of the Red For!' in Delhi}
1
00:35:58,456 --> 00:36:01,369
d yers dry long pieces
of multicolored cloth
1
00:36:01,559 --> 00:36:03,664
that will become turbans.
1
00:36:03,860 --> 00:36:06,807
In the cities, the craftsmens castes
1
00:36:06,998 --> 00:36:09,637
resemble the craft guilds
of medieval Christian Europe.
1
00:36:51,442 --> 00:36:54,753
One wonders how castes survive
in modem India.
1
00:36:55,579 --> 00:36:58,561
In 1853, Karl Marx prophesied
1
00:36:58,748 --> 00:37:02,696
that railroad construction would alter
the division of labor in India
1
00:37:02,887 --> 00:37:05,629
and, at the same time,
destroy the caste system.
1
00:37:06,224 --> 00:37:08,864
It seems Marx was wrong.
1
00:37:09,059 --> 00:37:11,039
Railroads have long
crisscrossed the country,
1
00:37:11,628 --> 00:37:13,665
yet the castes are still here,
1
00:37:13,864 --> 00:37:16,208
even if they don't oficial/J/ exist.
1
00:37:18,135 --> 00:37:21,139
For example, castes play
a decisive role in elections,
1
00:37:21,338 --> 00:37:23,875
which completely negates
the concept of democracy.
1
00:37:24,074 --> 00:37:28,318
Almost everyone votes
according to caste.
1
00:37:28,512 --> 00:37:30,492
Candidates, regardless of party,
1
00:37:30,681 --> 00:37:33,958
represent, above all else,
a caste or alliance of castes,
1
00:37:34,485 --> 00:37:37,329
and the political arena,
all ideology aside,
1
00:37:37,521 --> 00:37:40,502
is nothing but a power struggle
between rival castes.
1
00:37:43,527 --> 00:37:46,565
The caste system has even survived
pro/etarianization.
1
00:37:46,764 --> 00:37:49,403
The southern Indians crammed
into this shantytown in Bombay
1
00:37:49,599 --> 00:37:51,978
haven 't lost their roots.
1
00:37:52,168 --> 00:37:56,208
They regroup according to family,
native village or region.
1
00:37:58,275 --> 00:38:01,552
In cities, caste solidarity
also plays a part at work.
1
00:38:01,746 --> 00:38:04,488
Certain government administrations
only admit members
1
00:38:04,681 --> 00:38:06,888
of a certain caste.
1
00:38:14,824 --> 00:38:17,931
That's why, in modern India,
instead of disappearing,
1
00:38:18,128 --> 00:38:20,369
castes are becoming rigid,
autonomous blocks
1
00:38:20,563 --> 00:38:24,409
that are no longer interdependent,
but rivals and competitors.
1
00:38:25,436 --> 00:38:27,608
The hierarchy remains,
1
00:38:27,804 --> 00:38:29,750
but stripped
of its traditional frame work,
1
00:38:29,940 --> 00:38:32,853
its become a plain and simple form
of economic oppression.
1
00:39:05,076 --> 00:39:07,851
We came across this funeral
in the streets of Madras.
1
00:39:08,045 --> 00:39:10,787
The musicians play Marlborough.
1
00:39:13,150 --> 00:39:17,860
The flower-covered corpse is carried
t0 the place where it will be burned.
1
00:39:18,054 --> 00:39:22,025
I see no sufiering or tears,
nor even sadness.
1
00:39:22,492 --> 00:39:24,768
To us, for whom death is so tragic,
1
00:39:24,961 --> 00:39:27,704
this aspect of Hinduism is stunning.
1
00:40:13,943 --> 00:40:15,753
The bonfire is prepared.
1
00:40:15,945 --> 00:40:19,757
The older brother will perform
the ritual, assisted by a priest
1
00:40:34,465 --> 00:40:37,639
Balls of rice are held to the mouth
and forehead of the deceased
1
00:40:40,503 --> 00:40:43,541
Death is not an end,
nor even a separation.
1
00:40:43,740 --> 00:40:47,382
One lives and dies
and is then reborn,
1
00:40:47,577 --> 00:40:50,387
over and over
in an unbroken chain.
1
00:40:50,581 --> 00:40:52,423
Each life is judged,
1
00:40:52,615 --> 00:40:54,755
and the next life
constitutes the verdict
1
00:40:54,952 --> 00:40:57,626
/f you ire born an Untouchable,
ifs your fault,
1
00:40:57,822 --> 00:41:01,201
because in a previous life
you proved yourself unworthy.
1
00:41:01,659 --> 00:41:04,697
You can imagine
the social efiicienc y of the system.
1
00:41:05,463 --> 00:41:07,807
No penalty is permanent',
1
00:41:07,998 --> 00:41:10,342
unlike the heaven and hell
of the Christians,
1
00:41:10,534 --> 00:41:12,945
where residence is eternal.
1
00:41:13,137 --> 00:41:15,947
Hindus are given
a suspended sentence,
1
00:41:16,139 --> 00:41:18,176
as if books were kept
on their conduct
1
00:41:18,375 --> 00:41:20,684
from one birth to the next.
1
00:42:23,206 --> 00:42:27,451
This ceremony of propitiation takes
place in the days f0//owing the death.
1
00:42:27,644 --> 00:42:30,023
The deceased still lingers
near the earth,
1
00:42:30,213 --> 00:42:33,889
so the last ties t0 the body
left behind must be severed.
1
00:42:34,751 --> 00:42:37,755
The deceased s closest relatives
contact him,
1
00:42:37,954 --> 00:42:39,991
assure him that hes still
respected by the living,
1
00:42:40,190 --> 00:42:44,001
and ask him to enter
the specially prepared balls of rice-
1
00:42:44,193 --> 00:42:46,867
The ofierings include flowers, urine,
1
00:42:47,063 --> 00:42:50,272
cow dung, fire and dirt.
1
00:42:50,467 --> 00:42:55,711
When itS finished, the rice balls
are fed t0 a cow, the sacred animal.
1
00:42:55,905 --> 00:42:58,579
The priest invokes
gods and demons in alternation,
1
00:42:58,775 --> 00:43:02,917
transferring the sacred thread
from one shoulder t0 the other.
1
00:44:39,643 --> 00:44:43,420
Now liberated the soul of the deceased
can reihcamate in another body
1
00:44:43,614 --> 00:44:45,684
or disappear forever,
1
00:44:45,882 --> 00:44:48,590
because the supreme goal
is to one day not be reborn,
1
00:44:48,786 --> 00:44:51,231
but to dissolve into the Absolute
once and for all,
1
00:44:51,422 --> 00:44:53,527
to merge with the cosmic void.
1
00:44:54,925 --> 00:44:58,896
M/haz' can the concepts we treasure
mean to an Indian believer,
1
00:44:59,096 --> 00:45:02,702
concepts like progress, individual
freedom, a higher living standard?
1
00:45:02,900 --> 00:45:06,039
They 're taught
to live and act without desire,
1
00:45:06,235 --> 00:45:08,181
to disregard material reality,
1
00:45:08,371 --> 00:45:11,250
to accept the way things are
as divine judgment.
1
00:45:11,675 --> 00:45:15,144
The caste system is
a logical extension of this worldview.
1
00:45:18,981 --> 00:45:21,427
Modernizing Indian farmers
1
00:45:21,617 --> 00:45:24,929
is not a matter
of fertilizers and irrigation.
1
00:45:25,121 --> 00:45:28,034
It's a matter of changing
what's in their heads-
1
00:45:28,224 --> 00:45:30,864
They'd have t0 see
the world difierent/y
1
00:46:20,110 --> 00:46:22,488
The villagers don't want us to leave
1
00:46:22,679 --> 00:46:24,659
without filming their traditional sport,
1
00:46:24,847 --> 00:46:27,954
a mixture of Red Rover
and Greco-Roman wrestling.
1
00:46:28,619 --> 00:46:30,189
There are two teams,
1
00:46:30,387 --> 00:46:33,834
and each player
in tum attacks his opponents.
1
00:46:34,023 --> 00:46:36,697
But no one knows the rules,
or they've been forgotten.
1
00:46:37,094 --> 00:46:39,869
The game quickly degenerates
into a huge wrestling match,
1
00:46:40,063 --> 00:46:42,407
to the great joy of the spectators-
1
00:46:43,467 --> 00:46:45,878
Maybe some hope can be found
in this forgetting of rules,
1
00:46:46,068 --> 00:46:49,106
a sign and symbol
of rejection of the past.
1
00:48:01,545 --> 00:48:04,958
The panchayat is a son'
of town council,
1
00:48:05,148 --> 00:48:09,062
an elected assembly whose leader
is the sarpanch, the village leader.
1
00:48:09,253 --> 00:48:11,563
In principle,
its composed of six members.
1
00:48:11,755 --> 00:48:15,669
Today, our villages panchayat
has gathered for a special session,
1
00:48:16,059 --> 00:48:19,063
because a villager
has lodged a complaint.
1
00:48:19,262 --> 00:48:21,936
A government ofiicia/ from
a neighboring village will handle the case.
1
00:48:58,135 --> 00:49:00,115
At first, / was very impressed.
1
00:49:00,304 --> 00:49:03,478
I was seeing Athenian-style
direct democracy in action.
1
00:49:03,673 --> 00:49:07,246
There was a large crowd.
The witnesses gave testimony in turn.
1
00:49:07,443 --> 00:49:09,719
The discussion was
open and lively.
1
00:49:46,115 --> 00:49:50,155
I 'd heard each panohayat must include
an Untouchable and a woman-
1
00:49:51,088 --> 00:49:55,298
M/hen I ask to see them, I in? told
the y're absent from today/s meeting.
1
00:49:55,492 --> 00:49:57,335
First surprise.
1
00:50:31,728 --> 00:50:35,767
Second surprise." We finally
/earn the reason for the investigation.
1
00:50:35,965 --> 00:50:38,105
The sarpanch, the village leader,
1
00:50:38,300 --> 00:50:41,144
the dignified old man
who accompanied us everywhere,
1
00:50:41,338 --> 00:50:43,409
is accused of embezzling
2, 000 rupees
1
00:50:43,606 --> 00:50:46,644
of go vernment money
allotted to the village.
1
00:50:46,842 --> 00:50:50,312
I learned the outcome
from a disgruntled villager."
1
00:50:50,514 --> 00:50:52,686
The investigation was unable
to reach a conclusion,
1
00:50:52,882 --> 00:50:54,953
and the case was closed.
1
00:50:55,152 --> 00:50:57,291
The government ofiicia/ was
a close friend of the village leader,
1
00:50:57,487 --> 00:50:59,489
who is an important landowner.
1
00:50:59,688 --> 00:51:02,795
I gradually realize that beneath
its democratic appearance,
1
00:51:02,992 --> 00:51:06,565
the panchayat is just a tool
of the rich peasantry.
1
00:51:07,963 --> 00:51:09,909
There aren 't
any large holdings of land.
1
00:51:10,099 --> 00:51:13,376
In the region,
ifs exceptional to own 30 acres,
1
00:51:13,570 --> 00:51:17,245
but the wealth y peasants, who almost
always belong to the same caste,
1
00:51:17,440 --> 00:51:19,351
are often moneylenders.
1
00:51:19,543 --> 00:51:21,784
The entire village is indebted to them,
1
00:51:21,978 --> 00:51:24,584
which allows them
to monopolize production.
1
00:51:24,780 --> 00:51:28,092
They stockpile grain
t0 later manipulate prices.
1
00:51:28,284 --> 00:51:30,594
These sh y/ocks with political clout
1
00:51:31,153 --> 00:51:33,134
seem to prove Marx right."
1
00:51:33,322 --> 00:51:36,030
Castes tum into social classes.
1
00:51:36,659 --> 00:51:39,333
But one must be wary
of simplistic analyses,
1
00:51:39,528 --> 00:51:44,034
for India's complexity will continue
to amaze for a long time to come-
1
00:51:45,501 --> 00:51:48,141
Translation by LYNN MASSEY
for SUBTEXT SUBTITLING
33078
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.