Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:00,968 --> 00:00:02,709
NARRATOR:
In the criminal justice system
2
00:00:02,769 --> 00:00:06,649
the people are represented by two
separate yet equally important groups,
3
00:00:06,707 --> 00:00:08,550
the police
who investigate crime
4
00:00:08,609 --> 00:00:11,419
and the district attorneys
who prosecute the offenders.
5
00:00:11,478 --> 00:00:13,151
These are their stories.
6
00:00:16,517 --> 00:00:19,259
Good morning, Mrs. Hallenbeck.
Time for us to...
7
00:00:20,220 --> 00:00:21,426
Mrs. Hallenbeck?
8
00:00:21,488 --> 00:00:22,694
Did they take
my mother already?
9
00:00:22,756 --> 00:00:24,429
She wasn't supposed
to go till 9:30.
10
00:00:24,491 --> 00:00:26,437
Must be down the hall
somewhere.
11
00:00:26,493 --> 00:00:28,734
Isn't it your job
to keep track of the patients?
12
00:00:28,795 --> 00:00:31,036
Your mother's around, darling.
We'll find her.
13
00:00:36,436 --> 00:00:39,815
Marjorie Hallenbeck,
53, Missus.
14
00:00:39,873 --> 00:00:43,320
There are two deep bruises on the
torso, this one on her head.
15
00:00:43,377 --> 00:00:44,515
Caused by what?
16
00:00:44,578 --> 00:00:47,582
Looks like somebody punched her twice.
She fell, hit her head.
17
00:00:47,681 --> 00:00:49,058
ED: Which one's fatal?
18
00:00:49,116 --> 00:00:51,027
Head wound knocked her out.
I doubt if it killed her.
19
00:00:51,084 --> 00:00:52,893
Best guess now
is internal bleeding.
20
00:00:52,953 --> 00:00:54,364
How long would that take?
21
00:00:54,421 --> 00:00:57,459
A minute, a day. I won't
know till the autopsy.
22
00:00:57,524 --> 00:00:58,798
Time of death?
23
00:00:58,859 --> 00:01:03,274
Given the temperature and lack of
rigor, within the last five hours.
24
00:01:03,430 --> 00:01:06,274
So she was lyin' here since 3:00
a.m., and nobody found her?
25
00:01:06,333 --> 00:01:08,836
She could've been
lyin' here longer than that.
26
00:01:09,136 --> 00:01:11,275
We can't check every
square inch of the place.
27
00:01:11,338 --> 00:01:12,408
What was she in for?
28
00:01:12,472 --> 00:01:14,645
Lymph node biopsy
and some tests.
29
00:01:14,708 --> 00:01:16,119
Anybody notify the family?
30
00:01:16,176 --> 00:01:17,746
Father and daughter were
here when we found the body.
31
00:01:17,811 --> 00:01:20,291
They're waiting in
Mrs. Hallenbeck's room, 1284.
32
00:01:20,347 --> 00:01:22,418
Was anybody on patrol
here last night?
33
00:01:22,482 --> 00:01:24,519
Watkins. He didn't see
anything out of the ordinary.
34
00:01:24,585 --> 00:01:25,962
What, he forget his glasses?
35
00:01:26,019 --> 00:01:27,760
We have excellent security.
36
00:01:27,821 --> 00:01:29,164
Yeah, so I see.
37
00:01:29,222 --> 00:01:30,496
You want to talk to Watkins?
38
00:01:30,557 --> 00:01:31,865
That would be nice.
39
00:01:32,559 --> 00:01:35,563
She comes in for a biopsy,
and they manage to kill her?
40
00:01:35,629 --> 00:01:37,939
That's why they call it
managed care.
41
00:02:27,314 --> 00:02:29,692
She checked herself in
yesterday afternoon.
42
00:02:30,317 --> 00:02:32,297
My dad and I
visited her last night.
43
00:02:33,053 --> 00:02:34,760
How could this have happened?
44
00:02:34,821 --> 00:02:36,129
What time did you leave?
45
00:02:36,456 --> 00:02:37,662
A little after 11:00.
46
00:02:37,724 --> 00:02:41,228
Did you buy something from
the gift shop at 7:42?
47
00:02:41,294 --> 00:02:43,296
No, we didn't get here
till almost 9:00.
48
00:02:43,764 --> 00:02:45,710
A couple of magazines
and some candy.
49
00:02:45,766 --> 00:02:47,245
Maybe your mother bought them?
50
00:02:47,300 --> 00:02:48,938
Uh, I don't know.
51
00:02:49,069 --> 00:02:51,379
You both came in together
and left together?
52
00:02:51,438 --> 00:02:52,508
Yes.
53
00:02:52,906 --> 00:02:54,908
Mr. Hallenbeck, was you
wife still in the solarium
54
00:02:54,975 --> 00:02:56,147
when you left her?
55
00:02:56,643 --> 00:02:59,954
My dad's in shock. Did you
find my mother's jewelry?
56
00:03:00,447 --> 00:03:01,687
Wedding ring was on her finger.
57
00:03:01,748 --> 00:03:04,126
Not that. The stuff that's missing.
The cross, the earrings,
58
00:03:04,184 --> 00:03:05,993
the watch my dad gave her?
59
00:03:06,887 --> 00:03:08,332
Beaten to death.
Jewelry missing.
60
00:03:08,388 --> 00:03:11,392
One antique gold cross
on a neck chain,
61
00:03:11,458 --> 00:03:14,405
expensive watch with her
initials engraved on the back,
62
00:03:14,461 --> 00:03:16,964
and a pair of diamond
earrings with gold filigree.
63
00:03:17,030 --> 00:03:18,703
Mrs. Hallenbeck
checked in yesterday.
64
00:03:18,765 --> 00:03:20,767
Family says nobody but them
knew she was going in.
65
00:03:21,168 --> 00:03:22,704
Then start with
the hospital staff.
66
00:03:22,769 --> 00:03:24,544
LaMotte's
checking them for priors.
67
00:03:24,604 --> 00:03:27,175
There's nothin' in her room
except her overnight bag,
68
00:03:27,240 --> 00:03:30,414
a couple of magazines, and a receipt
from the hospital gift shop.
69
00:03:30,677 --> 00:03:31,985
Jewelry worth a lot?
70
00:03:32,212 --> 00:03:35,750
To Bill Gates, no. To a
janitor makin' 1350 an hour,
71
00:03:35,816 --> 00:03:37,796
ten, 12 grand
sounds pretty good.
72
00:03:37,851 --> 00:03:40,798
Well, who wears
10, 12 grand in a hospital?
73
00:03:40,887 --> 00:03:43,493
Well, the daughter says the
gold cross was an heirloom.
74
00:03:43,557 --> 00:03:45,161
Mom almost never took it off.
75
00:03:45,492 --> 00:03:48,564
Why was the victim in the solarium
in the middle of the night?
76
00:03:48,829 --> 00:03:49,830
Insomnia?
77
00:03:49,896 --> 00:03:50,966
We don't know when it was.
78
00:03:51,031 --> 00:03:52,533
The family
they left around 11:00.
79
00:03:52,599 --> 00:03:54,306
The attack could have been
any time after that.
80
00:03:54,367 --> 00:03:56,813
Well, you said she died
between 4:00 and 5:00 a.m.
81
00:03:56,870 --> 00:03:58,645
M.E. at the scene
differentiated between
82
00:03:58,705 --> 00:04:00,548
time of attack
and time of death.
83
00:04:00,607 --> 00:04:02,348
Well, nail it down.
84
00:04:02,909 --> 00:04:05,185
RODGERS: Victim had a lot
of superficial bruising.
85
00:04:05,245 --> 00:04:06,986
Injuries looked worse
than they were.
86
00:04:07,047 --> 00:04:08,617
What looks worse than dead?
87
00:04:08,682 --> 00:04:10,889
(SIGHS) Somebody'd found her
earlier, she wouldn't be dead.
88
00:04:10,951 --> 00:04:11,986
What killed her?
89
00:04:12,052 --> 00:04:13,156
Ruptured spleen.
90
00:04:13,220 --> 00:04:14,597
How long did it
take her to die?
91
00:04:14,654 --> 00:04:16,190
I won't know until I
determine the clotting rate.
92
00:04:16,256 --> 00:04:17,462
(PHONE RINGING)
93
00:04:20,527 --> 00:04:23,474
Rodgers.
Yeah, right here.
94
00:04:23,930 --> 00:04:25,034
Your lieutenant.
95
00:04:25,432 --> 00:04:27,378
What's that
on your phone, brains?
96
00:04:28,235 --> 00:04:29,578
It's egg salad maybe.
97
00:04:30,437 --> 00:04:31,848
You got another phone?
98
00:04:34,474 --> 00:04:37,148
When will you know what time
Mrs. Hallenbeck was attacked?
99
00:04:37,611 --> 00:04:39,887
Tomorrow morning. Maybe earlier.
ED: Green.
100
00:04:39,946 --> 00:04:42,290
Right now, I gotta get a javelin
out of somebody's chest.
101
00:04:42,883 --> 00:04:44,487
All right. Yeah. What made you
go into this line of work?
102
00:04:45,185 --> 00:04:46,186
Free javelins.
103
00:04:46,853 --> 00:04:48,423
Okay, later.
104
00:04:48,889 --> 00:04:50,527
LaMotte got a hit
on an orderly.
105
00:04:50,590 --> 00:04:53,537
Two burglary priors, and he was
workin' that ward last night.
106
00:04:57,764 --> 00:04:58,799
ED: Vic Fazioli?
107
00:04:58,865 --> 00:05:01,539
Hey, uh, my P.O. told me
to get a job, I got a job.
108
00:05:01,601 --> 00:05:03,342
I'm clean.
You got the wrong party.
109
00:05:03,403 --> 00:05:04,643
You mind if we come in?
110
00:05:04,905 --> 00:05:07,078
Yeah. See, I'm leavin'.
I got a date.
111
00:05:07,140 --> 00:05:09,017
You got a date? Where you
takin' her, the opera?
112
00:05:09,075 --> 00:05:10,850
It's cold outside.
You might need a jacket.
113
00:05:15,448 --> 00:05:17,257
Here, or at the precinct.
114
00:05:17,784 --> 00:05:19,923
Let's work somethin' out, okay?
115
00:05:19,986 --> 00:05:21,897
I take the stuff back,
you forget about it.
116
00:05:21,955 --> 00:05:23,832
I won't do it again, I swear.
117
00:05:24,090 --> 00:05:26,593
Okay, show us the jewelry
and we'll consider it.
118
00:05:26,927 --> 00:05:28,406
What jewelry?
119
00:05:29,896 --> 00:05:32,672
I'm guessin' this did not
come from D'Agostino's.
120
00:05:32,799 --> 00:05:34,176
This has gotta be a first.
121
00:05:34,234 --> 00:05:35,611
Somebody stealin'
hospital food.
122
00:05:36,236 --> 00:05:39,115
(CHUCKLES) Imagine that.
Third conviction, 20-to-life
123
00:05:39,172 --> 00:05:42,210
for 300 pounds
of Very Young Early Peas.
124
00:05:42,275 --> 00:05:44,721
Not to mention the jewelry.
And the murder.
125
00:05:44,778 --> 00:05:46,018
I don't know what you
guys are talkin' about.
126
00:05:46,079 --> 00:05:47,456
I'm just stockin' up
for the winter.
127
00:05:47,514 --> 00:05:49,551
Yeah, you and my chipmunk.
128
00:05:49,716 --> 00:05:51,923
I thought only good boys
ate their peas.
129
00:05:54,020 --> 00:05:55,727
But I'm telling you,
he was tall,
130
00:05:55,789 --> 00:05:57,769
and good-looking
and great hair.
131
00:05:57,824 --> 00:05:59,098
Comin' out of Room 1284?
132
00:05:59,159 --> 00:06:00,263
Yeah.
At 8:30?
133
00:06:00,327 --> 00:06:01,362
Give or take.
134
00:06:01,428 --> 00:06:02,668
How was he dressed?
135
00:06:02,729 --> 00:06:05,505
Expensive.
In a dark gray suit,
136
00:06:05,565 --> 00:06:09,138
a real nice tie,
and a gold stick pin.
137
00:06:09,536 --> 00:06:11,379
You see the patient,
Mrs. Hallenbeck?
138
00:06:11,438 --> 00:06:15,011
I... I saw a woman in a
nightgown, 50, 55. That her?
139
00:06:16,009 --> 00:06:17,716
Okay, well, she was
tryin' to get rid of him.
140
00:06:17,777 --> 00:06:18,881
Look like he was botherin' her?
141
00:06:18,945 --> 00:06:20,549
No, they seemed to
like each other fine.
142
00:06:20,614 --> 00:06:23,527
She just wanted him to go. I mean, maybe
she had to use the john or somethin.
143
00:06:23,583 --> 00:06:25,722
Yeah, it's a cute story, Vic,
but let's move on.
144
00:06:25,785 --> 00:06:27,526
Where were you after 11:00?
145
00:06:27,587 --> 00:06:30,295
Not at the hospital.
I left at 9:45.
146
00:06:30,357 --> 00:06:33,133
Your time card says
you punched out at 11:08.
147
00:06:33,426 --> 00:06:35,667
No, no. You see,
the kitchen closes at 9:15,
148
00:06:35,729 --> 00:06:38,539
so, 9:20, I'm down there loadin'
up cans in a laundry cart.
149
00:06:38,732 --> 00:06:39,802
Then what?
150
00:06:39,866 --> 00:06:42,870
I rolled the cart to my van, I
loaded it up, I took the cart back,
151
00:06:42,936 --> 00:06:45,917
I asked the guy to punch me out at 11:00.
I left at 9:45.
152
00:06:46,506 --> 00:06:47,849
Who punched you out?
153
00:06:48,875 --> 00:06:50,650
Look, I don't want to
get him in trouble, okay?
154
00:06:50,710 --> 00:06:52,280
You or him. Take your pick.
155
00:06:53,380 --> 00:06:55,587
Curtis Brown backs up
Fazioli's story.
156
00:06:55,649 --> 00:06:58,220
He says he saw him
drive off at around 9:45.
157
00:06:58,318 --> 00:07:00,195
And punched him out at 11:08?
158
00:07:00,854 --> 00:07:02,356
So it wasn't Fazioli.
159
00:07:02,422 --> 00:07:03,526
Yeah.
160
00:07:04,391 --> 00:07:07,861
I can't believe this.
My kid's laptop.
161
00:07:07,961 --> 00:07:11,465
The computer company from hell
sent it back without repairing it.
162
00:07:11,598 --> 00:07:13,703
I told you.
Those gizmos...
163
00:07:14,134 --> 00:07:15,511
I heard you the first time.
164
00:07:16,503 --> 00:07:18,642
Is there any chance Fazioli
was telling the truth
165
00:07:18,705 --> 00:07:21,015
about the man he saw leaving
Mrs. Hallenbeck's room?
166
00:07:21,074 --> 00:07:23,054
ED: Might account for the receipt
from the hospital gift shop.
167
00:07:23,343 --> 00:07:26,586
So what? This Mr. X left
before the family showed up.
168
00:07:26,813 --> 00:07:29,089
Left her room. May not
have left the hospital.
169
00:07:29,382 --> 00:07:31,328
And then what? He hung around
for two and a half hours
170
00:07:31,384 --> 00:07:32,829
so he could go
back up and kill her?
171
00:07:32,886 --> 00:07:35,423
Listen, before we figure out
his itinerary,
172
00:07:35,488 --> 00:07:37,399
why don't we find out
if he exists?
173
00:07:41,227 --> 00:07:44,333
Two nights ago,
right before I closed up.
174
00:07:44,397 --> 00:07:46,343
Two magazines
and a Kit Kat bar?
175
00:07:46,399 --> 00:07:50,211
Phillip Greitz. He gave me
the flower from his lapel.
176
00:07:50,470 --> 00:07:53,246
Told me my husband
was a lucky man,
177
00:07:53,306 --> 00:07:56,480
and I told him I was a widow
He gave me his card.
178
00:07:57,110 --> 00:08:00,455
"Philip Greitz, Esquire.
International Patent Law."
179
00:08:01,181 --> 00:08:02,387
No address or phone number.
180
00:08:02,615 --> 00:08:04,424
Everything about him
said window dressing.
181
00:08:04,484 --> 00:08:06,760
I assumed the card was
part of the show.
182
00:08:07,787 --> 00:08:10,267
I have no idea who he is.
183
00:08:10,323 --> 00:08:11,324
Michael?
184
00:08:11,424 --> 00:08:12,459
No.
185
00:08:12,592 --> 00:08:14,833
Does the name Philip Greitz
mean anything?
186
00:08:24,070 --> 00:08:26,641
My father's still in shock.
He can't help you.
187
00:08:26,706 --> 00:08:28,049
Lisa.
188
00:08:30,210 --> 00:08:31,621
Our father has Alzheimer's.
189
00:08:31,811 --> 00:08:35,315
Michael.
I know all Mom's friends.
190
00:08:35,382 --> 00:08:37,726
My brother lives in Brooklyn.
He's got kids.
191
00:08:37,784 --> 00:08:38,956
He's never here.
192
00:08:39,586 --> 00:08:41,327
So you were home
the night your mother died?
193
00:08:41,388 --> 00:08:43,493
Yeah. My wife's parents
were visiting.
194
00:08:43,556 --> 00:08:46,969
With all due respect, is it possible
your mother had a special friend?
195
00:08:47,260 --> 00:08:49,900
(SCOFFS) God knows
she needed one.
196
00:08:49,963 --> 00:08:51,203
LISA: Stop it!
197
00:08:51,898 --> 00:08:52,933
What makes you say that?
198
00:08:52,999 --> 00:08:55,343
Mom wouldn't betray
my father. She wouldn't.
199
00:08:55,402 --> 00:08:58,110
This man was seen coming
out of your mother's room
200
00:08:58,171 --> 00:09:00,082
shortly before you
and your father got there.
201
00:09:00,140 --> 00:09:01,949
And based on that, you think
she was having an affair?
202
00:09:02,008 --> 00:09:03,180
It's ridiculous.
203
00:09:03,510 --> 00:09:06,855
Lisa's having a hard time accepting
the situation, but she's got a point.
204
00:09:06,913 --> 00:09:08,051
How so?
205
00:09:08,114 --> 00:09:10,060
Well, between taking care of
my father and keeping house,
206
00:09:10,116 --> 00:09:12,187
I don't see how my mother would
have found time to have an affair.
207
00:09:12,252 --> 00:09:13,629
You make her sound like
such a saint.
208
00:09:13,687 --> 00:09:16,293
She found time to go to that stupid
support group two nights a week.
209
00:09:16,356 --> 00:09:18,393
That support group was the
only thing that kept her sane,
210
00:09:18,458 --> 00:09:19,960
and you know it.
211
00:09:20,026 --> 00:09:23,439
She should have been with Dad instead of
talking about him with a bunch of strangers.
212
00:09:23,496 --> 00:09:24,839
It wasn't right.
213
00:09:36,109 --> 00:09:37,816
ED: Three Philip Greitzes
in our database.
214
00:09:37,877 --> 00:09:39,584
One of them's too young
to be our guy,
215
00:09:39,646 --> 00:09:40,716
and the woman at the gift shop
216
00:09:40,780 --> 00:09:42,259
didn't recognize the other two.
217
00:09:42,315 --> 00:09:44,727
We found four more
in the tri-state area.
218
00:09:44,784 --> 00:09:46,024
Our man's not among them.
219
00:09:46,086 --> 00:09:47,622
What about from the other end?
220
00:09:47,687 --> 00:09:50,896
Family says Mrs. Hallenbeck
hasn't had much of a social life
221
00:09:50,957 --> 00:09:52,630
since her husband
started goin' downhill.
222
00:09:52,692 --> 00:09:53,898
Well, she met Greitz somewhere.
223
00:09:53,960 --> 00:09:55,439
How far gone is the husband?
224
00:09:55,762 --> 00:09:57,673
About halfway
to the vegetable patch.
225
00:09:57,731 --> 00:09:59,972
The family's already been torn apart
by Mr. Hallenbeck's condition.
226
00:10:00,033 --> 00:10:01,273
Now this.
227
00:10:01,334 --> 00:10:03,507
Mrs. Hallenbeck went to an
Alzheimer's support group
228
00:10:03,570 --> 00:10:04,605
two evenings a week?
229
00:10:04,671 --> 00:10:06,082
That's our next stop.
230
00:10:10,977 --> 00:10:12,684
Do you recognize this man?
231
00:10:13,847 --> 00:10:17,317
Looks like Philip Greitz.
He was in Marjorie's group.
232
00:10:17,383 --> 00:10:19,260
Why are you asking about him?
233
00:10:19,519 --> 00:10:20,862
Do you know where
we can find him?
234
00:10:21,788 --> 00:10:24,769
You don't think he killed her?
Nice man like that?
235
00:10:27,026 --> 00:10:31,566
Uh, Philip, lives at
"203 East 20th Street."
236
00:10:32,665 --> 00:10:34,906
I don't think so.
That's the Police Academy.
237
00:10:35,135 --> 00:10:36,478
Can we have a copy
of that file?
238
00:10:37,137 --> 00:10:39,242
I suppose so.
I won't be needing it anymore.
239
00:10:39,672 --> 00:10:40,673
Why not?
240
00:10:40,740 --> 00:10:43,516
He dropped out about six weeks ago.
Said his wife had died.
241
00:10:44,043 --> 00:10:45,181
Oh. my...
242
00:10:45,845 --> 00:10:48,883
Marjorie stopped coming to
group about that same time.
243
00:10:51,885 --> 00:10:53,990
Lisa Hallenbeck says
her mother went out
244
00:10:54,053 --> 00:10:55,691
every Tuesday
and Thursday evening,
245
00:10:55,755 --> 00:10:56,859
like she was goin to the group.
246
00:10:56,923 --> 00:10:58,527
We pulled her
credit card receipts.
247
00:10:58,591 --> 00:11:01,868
The opera. Thursday night seats
for the season. 1200 bucks.
248
00:11:02,128 --> 00:11:05,575
Dinner at LeCirque 2000 every
Tuesday night, six weeks in a row.
249
00:11:05,632 --> 00:11:09,341
Charges at Barneys for ties,
men's dress shirts.
250
00:11:09,402 --> 00:11:11,507
Diamond cuff links
from Tiffany's.
251
00:11:11,804 --> 00:11:14,284
Yeah, the cuff links can't be for her husband.
He'd stick 'em in his ears.
252
00:11:14,340 --> 00:11:15,444
These people wealthy?
253
00:11:15,508 --> 00:11:18,250
They're comfortable. Mr. Hallenbeck's
on a generous pension.
254
00:11:18,311 --> 00:11:19,722
They got respectable savings.
255
00:11:20,046 --> 00:11:22,185
Gone in 30 seconds
at this rate.
256
00:11:22,248 --> 00:11:25,661
Five weeks ago Mrs. Hallenbeck
ran up $10,000 charge
257
00:11:25,718 --> 00:11:29,393
to a place called Romantic Getaways.
Gotta be a travel agency.
258
00:11:30,857 --> 00:11:32,962
For 10 grand, you shouldn't
have to come back.
259
00:11:34,594 --> 00:11:37,234
Well, Mrs. Hallenbeck
booked a luxury stateroom
260
00:11:37,297 --> 00:11:39,208
on the Queen Sophia.
261
00:11:39,332 --> 00:11:42,142
That's the flagship of the
Stafford-Kensington cruise line.
262
00:11:42,235 --> 00:11:43,475
It doesn't come cheap.
263
00:11:43,536 --> 00:11:44,742
Passage for two?
264
00:11:44,804 --> 00:11:45,908
She and her husband.
265
00:11:45,972 --> 00:11:47,451
Did you happen to meet
Mr. Hallenbeck?
266
00:11:47,507 --> 00:11:48,952
Yes, he picked up the tickets.
267
00:11:49,008 --> 00:11:50,282
He's very friendly.
We chatted.
268
00:11:50,343 --> 00:11:51,481
What about?
269
00:11:51,544 --> 00:11:53,182
Well, he saw I had on
a Dolce & Gabbana,
270
00:11:53,246 --> 00:11:54,816
so we talked about
men's fashions.
271
00:11:55,748 --> 00:11:56,920
This him?
272
00:11:56,983 --> 00:11:58,018
Yes.
273
00:11:59,152 --> 00:12:00,358
What'd he do?
274
00:12:00,620 --> 00:12:02,156
You got an address for him?
275
00:12:03,223 --> 00:12:04,327
Probably Gracie Mansion.
276
00:12:04,390 --> 00:12:06,392
642 East 87th Street.
277
00:12:06,459 --> 00:12:07,802
That's the same
as Mrs. Hallenbeck.
278
00:12:07,860 --> 00:12:09,237
You want me to write that down?
279
00:12:09,295 --> 00:12:11,400
No, it's okay, we got it. Did he
ever happen to come back again?
280
00:12:11,464 --> 00:12:12,704
Maybe leave a phone number?
281
00:12:13,466 --> 00:12:16,743
A fax. He wanted me to fax some
information on the ship's activities.
282
00:12:17,537 --> 00:12:19,881
He was interested
in ballroom dancing.
283
00:12:20,740 --> 00:12:22,742
Please tell me
you kept the fax number.
284
00:12:23,409 --> 00:12:27,755
Yes, that's Mr. Greitz. He had an account here.
He closed it about a week ago.
285
00:12:27,947 --> 00:12:29,119
How did he pay?
286
00:12:29,182 --> 00:12:32,595
Cash. I can't imagine why the
police are looking for him.
287
00:12:32,652 --> 00:12:34,461
He is so not a criminal.
288
00:12:34,520 --> 00:12:37,262
Did he, uh, leave you an
address or a phone number?
289
00:12:38,057 --> 00:12:39,127
He was staying with a friend.
290
00:12:39,192 --> 00:12:41,832
Didn't want to tie up the phone
with his personal calls.
291
00:12:41,895 --> 00:12:43,135
Very considerate of him.
292
00:12:43,196 --> 00:12:45,005
He was just the nicest man.
293
00:12:45,064 --> 00:12:47,704
So he got faxes here. Did
you deliver them anywhere?
294
00:12:47,767 --> 00:12:49,804
Oh, no. He picked them up.
295
00:12:50,003 --> 00:12:51,880
He ever use your fax
for outgoing?
296
00:12:52,138 --> 00:12:54,812
Uh, wouldn't that
be privileged?
297
00:12:55,675 --> 00:12:56,949
Uh, no.
298
00:13:00,680 --> 00:13:02,523
I don't know anyone
named Philip Greitz.
299
00:13:02,582 --> 00:13:05,256
Maybe you never met him.
He sent you a couple of faxes.
300
00:13:06,286 --> 00:13:07,663
This looks like Eric.
301
00:13:08,821 --> 00:13:10,232
There must be some mistake.
302
00:13:10,290 --> 00:13:11,963
What's Eric's last name?
303
00:13:12,025 --> 00:13:15,234
DeChagas. So why are you
calling him Philip Greitz?
304
00:13:15,295 --> 00:13:17,332
What does Mr. DeChagas do?
305
00:13:17,864 --> 00:13:20,708
He imports antiques and fine
art from Europe and Asia.
306
00:13:20,767 --> 00:13:23,509
All right. Can you tell us
how you met Mr. DeChagas?
307
00:13:23,870 --> 00:13:26,817
My husband had cancer.
I went to a support group.
308
00:13:26,873 --> 00:13:30,616
And Mr. DeChagas was there because
his wife was dying of cancer?
309
00:13:30,743 --> 00:13:32,484
That's right.
At Sloan-Kettering.
310
00:13:33,212 --> 00:13:34,452
What is this about?
311
00:13:34,714 --> 00:13:37,024
(SIGHS) Mrs. Wynnick,
we think that this man
312
00:13:37,083 --> 00:13:39,586
preys on wealthy women
in support groups.
313
00:13:39,686 --> 00:13:41,597
Oh, no, that's not possible.
314
00:13:41,654 --> 00:13:45,158
You have no idea how kind
Eric is, and generous.
315
00:13:45,325 --> 00:13:47,236
Otherwise, why would
he have given me this watch?
316
00:13:49,062 --> 00:13:52,305
Does that watch have the initials M.H.
engraved on the back?
317
00:13:52,999 --> 00:13:56,640
Why, yes. It was his mother's.
Her name was Mary Helen.
318
00:13:57,503 --> 00:13:59,210
Well, I hope
you've got another one,
319
00:13:59,272 --> 00:14:01,377
because that one was
stolen off a corpse.
320
00:14:03,509 --> 00:14:05,250
Lisa Hallenbeck ID'd
the watch as her mother's,
321
00:14:05,311 --> 00:14:07,518
but there's no prints on it
except for Mrs. Wynnick's.
322
00:14:07,580 --> 00:14:08,957
And I take it there wasn't any
323
00:14:09,015 --> 00:14:10,756
Mrs. DeChagas
at Sloan-Kettering?
324
00:14:10,817 --> 00:14:13,127
Big surprise.
This guy's good.
325
00:14:13,319 --> 00:14:14,992
His trail's colder than dead.
326
00:14:15,154 --> 00:14:16,724
Well, there can't be
more than a thousand
327
00:14:16,789 --> 00:14:19,167
support groups
in New York City, gentlemen.
328
00:14:21,828 --> 00:14:25,708
Oh, yes, certainly I know him.
This is Dr. Gary Kennit.
329
00:14:25,765 --> 00:14:26,937
Doctor this time.
330
00:14:26,999 --> 00:14:28,945
Are you sure? Because we've
talked to a lot of people
331
00:14:29,001 --> 00:14:32,380
who think that maybe they might have
seen him somewhere, sometime...
332
00:14:32,438 --> 00:14:35,783
I've never had a member so
supportive of the other poor souls.
333
00:14:35,842 --> 00:14:38,220
You don't forget
a man like Gary.
334
00:14:38,277 --> 00:14:39,654
Why are you looking for him?
335
00:14:39,712 --> 00:14:41,487
The Mayor wants
to give him a medal.
336
00:14:41,547 --> 00:14:42,992
What night does he come here?
337
00:14:43,049 --> 00:14:45,222
Oh, he hasn't come
for a few weeks now.
338
00:14:45,284 --> 00:14:49,096
He, uh, called to tell me
that his wife had passed on,
339
00:14:49,155 --> 00:14:50,896
and to thank me for my help.
340
00:14:51,023 --> 00:14:52,161
What address did he give you?
341
00:14:52,225 --> 00:14:53,533
No address.
342
00:14:53,860 --> 00:14:56,966
Any of the women members go
missing in the last few weeks?
343
00:14:57,030 --> 00:14:59,704
Well, Gloria Blumberg's
been absent.
344
00:14:59,766 --> 00:15:01,473
We'll take her address.
345
00:15:02,268 --> 00:15:04,839
Guy's juggling at least
three lady friends.
346
00:15:04,904 --> 00:15:06,906
Must be putting
somethin' extra in his tank.
347
00:15:06,973 --> 00:15:08,281
Jealous?
348
00:15:11,244 --> 00:15:14,953
You think true love can't
happen twice, but then it does.
349
00:15:15,281 --> 00:15:16,589
It's amazing.
350
00:15:16,649 --> 00:15:18,754
That mean you're still
seeing Dr. Kennit?
351
00:15:18,818 --> 00:15:20,297
Of course.
352
00:15:20,486 --> 00:15:22,557
What is it you want
to talk to him about?
353
00:15:22,622 --> 00:15:24,431
We think he has
some information for us.
354
00:15:24,490 --> 00:15:25,764
Do you know
where we can reach him?
355
00:15:25,825 --> 00:15:28,567
I'm afraid he's somewhere
over the Atlantic right now.
356
00:15:29,295 --> 00:15:33,141
It's so tragic.
First his wife dies,
357
00:15:33,199 --> 00:15:36,112
then his brother gets killed in a
car accident outside of Paris.
358
00:15:36,169 --> 00:15:37,580
I bet you paid his airfare.
359
00:15:37,637 --> 00:15:39,378
Oh, poor man.
360
00:15:39,739 --> 00:15:41,480
He'd maxed out
his credit cards.
361
00:15:41,541 --> 00:15:42,713
ED: First class?
362
00:15:42,775 --> 00:15:45,016
Of course.
He'll pay me back.
363
00:15:45,111 --> 00:15:46,283
BRISCOE: What airline?
364
00:15:46,345 --> 00:15:47,949
British Airways to Paris.
365
00:15:48,014 --> 00:15:49,186
What time was the flight?
366
00:15:50,316 --> 00:15:51,795
Uh, four hours ago.
367
00:15:53,052 --> 00:15:56,659
Yeah. Thank you, very much.
He never got on the plane.
368
00:15:56,722 --> 00:15:58,668
He's traded his ticket
for one to St. Kitts.
369
00:15:58,724 --> 00:16:01,432
Sure. No passport requirements,
no extradition treaty.
370
00:16:01,494 --> 00:16:04,168
And a plane that doesn't leave
for an hour and a half.
371
00:16:06,866 --> 00:16:07,970
May I help you?
372
00:16:08,034 --> 00:16:09,411
We'll be discreet.
373
00:16:13,139 --> 00:16:14,243
Mr. Greitz?
374
00:16:16,075 --> 00:16:17,748
I'm sorry, I'm Dr. Kennit.
375
00:16:17,810 --> 00:16:20,222
And about 17 other people.
Is this your bag?
376
00:16:20,479 --> 00:16:21,549
Yes, it is.
377
00:16:21,781 --> 00:16:23,089
You mind if we look in it?
378
00:16:23,382 --> 00:16:24,656
Gary, what's this about?
379
00:16:24,717 --> 00:16:26,355
Ma'am, would you excuse us
for a minute?
380
00:16:26,586 --> 00:16:27,997
Well, I...
381
00:16:28,654 --> 00:16:29,792
Did I hear a yes?
382
00:16:30,022 --> 00:16:31,330
What happens if I say no?
383
00:16:31,390 --> 00:16:33,233
Pretty much the same
as if you say yes.
384
00:16:33,292 --> 00:16:34,635
Then go ahead.
385
00:16:41,934 --> 00:16:43,504
My late wife's jewelry.
386
00:16:43,569 --> 00:16:45,446
Uh-huh.
Minus the watch.
387
00:16:45,671 --> 00:16:48,618
You're under arrest for the
murder of Marjorie Hallenbeck.
388
00:16:48,674 --> 00:16:50,551
You have the right
to remain silent.
389
00:16:50,610 --> 00:16:54,387
You also have the right to an
attorney unless you actually are one.
390
00:17:00,553 --> 00:17:02,396
He refuses to tell us
his real name, Your Honor,
391
00:17:02,455 --> 00:17:03,866
and he doesn't
have an attorney.
392
00:17:04,123 --> 00:17:06,103
I've had a long day,
Ms. Carmichael.
393
00:17:07,293 --> 00:17:08,704
What about his fingerprints?
394
00:17:08,861 --> 00:17:10,238
Nothing came up
on the computer.
395
00:17:12,198 --> 00:17:13,438
Mr. Rumer...
396
00:17:13,633 --> 00:17:15,943
Uh, sorry, Judge.
Uh, I have an appointment.
397
00:17:16,269 --> 00:17:17,805
You'll be a little late.
398
00:17:19,672 --> 00:17:21,879
Met your new client, John Doe.
399
00:17:22,141 --> 00:17:25,953
Mr. Doe,
I'm postponing arraignment
400
00:17:26,012 --> 00:17:28,492
until the police
can determine your identity.
401
00:17:28,547 --> 00:17:30,458
Until such time,
I'm remanding you to custody.
402
00:17:30,883 --> 00:17:32,863
That won't be necessary,
Your Honor.
403
00:17:32,919 --> 00:17:37,493
Mr. Weiss. Do I take it you're
representing our Mr. Doe?
404
00:17:37,890 --> 00:17:39,267
May I have a moment?
405
00:17:47,700 --> 00:17:49,441
My client's name
is Raymond Quinn,
406
00:17:49,502 --> 00:17:51,607
and he pleads not guilty
to the charges.
407
00:17:52,171 --> 00:17:54,981
He's committed no crime.
I ask he be ROR'd.
408
00:17:55,074 --> 00:17:56,348
CARMICHAEL:
Remand, Your Honor.
409
00:17:56,409 --> 00:17:58,787
Mr. Quinn was apprehended
fleeing the country.
410
00:17:58,845 --> 00:18:00,916
He was traveling
on a round-trip ticket.
411
00:18:00,980 --> 00:18:03,460
Which he could have cashed
in once he got to St. Kitts,
412
00:18:03,516 --> 00:18:06,360
and lived happily ever after
with no fear of extradition.
413
00:18:07,486 --> 00:18:09,966
Bail is set at $500,000.
414
00:18:10,122 --> 00:18:12,534
Judge, Mr. Quinn
is virtually indigent.
415
00:18:12,592 --> 00:18:15,095
Really?
Who-S paying your fees?
416
00:18:15,761 --> 00:18:17,468
Mr. Quinn has
generous friends.
417
00:18:17,530 --> 00:18:19,737
Let them pony up his bail.
418
00:18:22,335 --> 00:18:23,905
Marjorie realized
it was foolish
419
00:18:23,970 --> 00:18:25,608
to have her jewelry
at the hospital,
420
00:18:25,671 --> 00:18:27,378
and she gave it to me
for safekeeping.
421
00:18:27,440 --> 00:18:29,920
To you instead of
to her family?
422
00:18:29,976 --> 00:18:31,785
How exactly
did that come about?
423
00:18:32,278 --> 00:18:34,622
A husband with Alzheimer's,
a grasping daughter,
424
00:18:34,680 --> 00:18:36,956
a son who couldn't
make time to help her.
425
00:18:37,450 --> 00:18:39,396
Is it so odd
she'd rather I had it?
426
00:18:39,452 --> 00:18:42,228
So you could give it
to your other lady friends.
427
00:18:42,755 --> 00:18:46,498
You told the police you left Mrs. Hallenbeck's
room around 8:30 that evening.
428
00:18:46,559 --> 00:18:48,368
And I had the jewelry
with me at that time,
429
00:18:48,427 --> 00:18:51,636
so obviously, I didn't need to
come back and kill her for it.
430
00:18:51,797 --> 00:18:54,368
CARMICHAEL: Lisa Hallenbeck
says her mother had the jewelry
431
00:18:54,433 --> 00:18:56,106
when she and her father
were there.
432
00:18:56,168 --> 00:18:57,704
That was after
you say you left.
433
00:18:57,970 --> 00:18:59,108
She's mistaken.
434
00:18:59,171 --> 00:19:00,673
JACK: She's mistaken?
435
00:19:00,740 --> 00:19:02,185
We're supposed to take
your word for it?
436
00:19:02,241 --> 00:19:04,551
A jury is supposed to take
your word that he killed her?
437
00:19:04,610 --> 00:19:05,680
Where's your evidence?
438
00:19:06,178 --> 00:19:08,283
For starters,
your client's bad character.
439
00:19:08,347 --> 00:19:10,452
Maybe by your
narrow-minded standards.
440
00:19:12,118 --> 00:19:13,722
I'll entertain murder two.
441
00:19:14,220 --> 00:19:15,221
Not a chance.
442
00:19:15,288 --> 00:19:18,735
Mr. Quinn romances lonely
women who buy him gifts.
443
00:19:18,824 --> 00:19:20,098
I have five of them so far
444
00:19:20,159 --> 00:19:22,799
who'll testify that his
passions are far from violent.
445
00:19:26,899 --> 00:19:28,310
We need to dig deeper.
446
00:19:29,502 --> 00:19:30,981
Find women who are less...
447
00:19:31,037 --> 00:19:32,209
Stupid?
448
00:19:32,271 --> 00:19:33,750
Romantic.
449
00:19:33,806 --> 00:19:35,843
It'd also be nice to find
someone beside the daughter
450
00:19:35,908 --> 00:19:39,720
who can say Mrs. Hallenbeck still had
her jewelry after Mr. Quinn left.
451
00:19:43,082 --> 00:19:45,358
No, she just had on her wedding
ring, no other jewelry.
452
00:19:45,418 --> 00:19:46,624
How can you be sure?
453
00:19:46,686 --> 00:19:47,824
Because I noticed her pendant,
454
00:19:47,887 --> 00:19:49,195
and asked her about it earlier.
455
00:19:49,255 --> 00:19:51,758
She said it was her great-grandma's
and got passed down.
456
00:19:52,625 --> 00:19:53,968
When you saw
she wasn't wearing it later,
457
00:19:54,026 --> 00:19:55,505
did you ask her where it was?
458
00:19:56,028 --> 00:19:57,473
She said it was safe.
459
00:19:57,763 --> 00:19:59,367
You're positive about the time?
460
00:19:59,432 --> 00:20:00,570
A little before 9:00,
461
00:20:00,633 --> 00:20:02,476
just before her husband and
her daughter came to visit.
462
00:20:03,969 --> 00:20:05,607
CARMICHAEL: Mr. Hallenbeck,
do you remember
463
00:20:05,671 --> 00:20:08,174
when you went to visit
your wife at the hospital?
464
00:20:09,408 --> 00:20:12,389
Yes. Lisa and I went
to see her.
465
00:20:13,479 --> 00:20:14,787
Then she died.
466
00:20:16,515 --> 00:20:17,926
Yes, sir, I'm sorry.
467
00:20:18,851 --> 00:20:21,297
Was she wearing her jewelry
when you saw her?
468
00:20:22,421 --> 00:20:24,992
The gold cross that was
handed down to her?
469
00:20:26,258 --> 00:20:28,761
She loved that cross, you know.
470
00:20:28,828 --> 00:20:30,535
Wore it almost all the time.
471
00:20:30,863 --> 00:20:32,274
Was she wearing it that night?
472
00:20:32,331 --> 00:20:34,675
She never would have
given it to just anyone.
473
00:20:35,634 --> 00:20:37,773
Did she tell you that
she gave it to someone?
474
00:20:41,006 --> 00:20:42,485
You're pretty.
475
00:20:43,642 --> 00:20:46,179
Mother would look better
with hair like yours.
476
00:20:47,113 --> 00:20:48,888
His mother died 20 years ago.
477
00:20:48,948 --> 00:20:52,725
Stop interrupting.
I'm talking to a pretty girl.
478
00:20:53,519 --> 00:20:54,623
Mr. Hallenbeck...
479
00:20:54,687 --> 00:20:56,064
You're pretty...
480
00:20:56,122 --> 00:20:58,602
Mother would look better
with hair like yours.
481
00:21:01,761 --> 00:21:03,001
He's sundowning.
482
00:21:04,063 --> 00:21:05,133
I'm sorry?
483
00:21:05,197 --> 00:21:08,804
It's the sundown effect. He
gets worse as the day wears on.
484
00:21:08,868 --> 00:21:11,314
It's kind of like the
lights slowly goin' out.
485
00:21:11,604 --> 00:21:13,914
Would it be better if I
came back in the morning?
486
00:21:13,973 --> 00:21:15,281
You could try.
487
00:21:15,808 --> 00:21:17,446
Did you know about
your mother's affair?
488
00:21:17,710 --> 00:21:20,122
No. But I did notice
a change a few weeks ago.
489
00:21:20,179 --> 00:21:21,351
She seemed lighter,
490
00:21:21,414 --> 00:21:23,894
like some weight had been
lifted off her shoulders.
491
00:21:24,083 --> 00:21:26,256
Did your sister know about
your mother and Mr. Quinn?
492
00:21:26,318 --> 00:21:29,128
No, I doubt it. She'd have been
after me to do something about it.
493
00:21:29,588 --> 00:21:30,965
What could she
expect you to do?
494
00:21:31,023 --> 00:21:33,025
Make sure that Mom didn't
run off with that man.
495
00:21:33,092 --> 00:21:35,094
Make sure Lisa
didn't get stuck with Dad.
496
00:21:35,161 --> 00:21:37,505
Make sure Mom didn't
fritter away their savings.
497
00:21:37,797 --> 00:21:38,935
Money was a big worry?
498
00:21:38,998 --> 00:21:40,534
Yeah, sure.
499
00:21:40,599 --> 00:21:43,170
Lisa was afraid taking care
of Dad would bankrupt us.
500
00:21:43,502 --> 00:21:46,540
And now? Did your mother
have life insurance?
501
00:21:47,106 --> 00:21:49,017
Yeah. Why?
502
00:21:53,078 --> 00:21:55,080
Marjorie said her daughter
was having a hard time
503
00:21:55,147 --> 00:21:56,922
accepting the
Alzheimer's diagnosis.
504
00:21:56,982 --> 00:21:58,859
Lisa was very close
to her father.
505
00:21:59,318 --> 00:22:01,025
And how did Lisa
feel about her mother?
506
00:22:02,588 --> 00:22:05,296
Well, Marjorie never said
anything bad about her.
507
00:22:05,357 --> 00:22:06,597
But?
508
00:22:06,659 --> 00:22:09,401
I got the impression there was
some tension between them.
509
00:22:09,462 --> 00:22:10,668
What about?
510
00:22:11,630 --> 00:22:12,836
It would be a guess.
511
00:22:12,898 --> 00:22:14,206
That's fine.
512
00:22:14,600 --> 00:22:15,874
Marjorie knew
the time was coming
513
00:22:15,935 --> 00:22:18,939
when she was going to have to
put her husband in a facility.
514
00:22:19,004 --> 00:22:20,483
Well, isn't there
in-home care?
515
00:22:20,539 --> 00:22:23,042
It's just too hard
on the family after a while.
516
00:22:23,943 --> 00:22:27,117
A 60-year-old man
whose diapers need changing,
517
00:22:27,179 --> 00:22:29,659
who can't remember who you are,
518
00:22:29,715 --> 00:22:33,219
who gets angry because he thinks
you stole his tricycle...
519
00:22:33,285 --> 00:22:36,198
The man she married was
disappearing before her eyes.
520
00:22:36,255 --> 00:22:38,701
And Lisa had a problem
putting Mr. Hallenbeck away?
521
00:22:38,924 --> 00:22:41,131
Marjorie thought
it would become an issue.
522
00:22:43,496 --> 00:22:46,477
So this Casanova
killed her for her jewelry,
523
00:22:46,532 --> 00:22:49,513
or the daughter
killed her for what exactly?
524
00:22:49,568 --> 00:22:50,876
CARMICHAEL: Life insurance.
525
00:22:50,936 --> 00:22:52,574
Seven hundred
and fifty thousand dollars,
526
00:22:52,638 --> 00:22:55,118
split equally between
Michael and Lisa Hallenbeck.
527
00:22:55,174 --> 00:22:56,551
Big policy.
528
00:22:56,609 --> 00:22:59,112
She upped it after
the husband was diagnosed.
529
00:22:59,178 --> 00:23:01,385
Didn't want him to bankrupt
the kids if she died.
530
00:23:01,614 --> 00:23:04,254
A woman in her 50s.
Stiff premium.
531
00:23:04,884 --> 00:23:06,830
Her son said
she felt it was worth it.
532
00:23:06,886 --> 00:23:08,229
So what are we assuming here?
533
00:23:08,487 --> 00:23:10,592
The nurse had no reason to lie.
534
00:23:10,656 --> 00:23:13,728
She says the jewelry was gone by
the time the family came to visit.
535
00:23:14,393 --> 00:23:15,804
Wrong man in custody.
536
00:23:15,861 --> 00:23:19,308
We haven't been able to find anyone
who's seen any violence in Mr. Quinn.
537
00:23:20,599 --> 00:23:23,637
Lisa Hallenbeck seems unstable,
538
00:23:23,702 --> 00:23:26,239
extremely attached to her
father, angry at her mother.
539
00:23:26,305 --> 00:23:27,682
And don't forget
about the money.
540
00:23:27,907 --> 00:23:29,215
Speculation.
541
00:23:29,275 --> 00:23:31,277
Enough to cast doubt
on Quinn's guilt.
542
00:23:32,578 --> 00:23:34,717
Have the police talk
to Lisa Hallenbeck.
543
00:23:35,581 --> 00:23:38,653
Why won't you listen?
She had the jewelry on.
544
00:23:38,717 --> 00:23:41,129
Somebody killed her for it
after my dad and I left.
545
00:23:41,487 --> 00:23:45,401
Lisa, there was nobody there
but you and your father.
546
00:23:46,158 --> 00:23:48,502
That's not true. There were
nurses and other patients.
547
00:23:48,561 --> 00:23:49,631
It could have been anybody.
548
00:23:49,728 --> 00:23:53,505
But it wasn't just anybody.
It was somebody with a motive.
549
00:23:57,303 --> 00:23:59,078
Tell us what happened, Lisa.
550
00:24:04,843 --> 00:24:06,652
We went to my mother's room.
551
00:24:07,913 --> 00:24:11,417
She said, "Why don't we go sit
in the solarium?" So we did.
552
00:24:12,351 --> 00:24:14,490
Is that when you noticed she
wasn't wearing her jewelry?
553
00:24:14,954 --> 00:24:16,024
Yes.
554
00:24:16,589 --> 00:24:18,193
Did you ask her about it?
555
00:24:18,357 --> 00:24:19,859
She said she'd
taken it off and put it
556
00:24:19,925 --> 00:24:21,632
in the nightstand drawer
in her room.
557
00:24:22,595 --> 00:24:24,768
I said I was going to
get it and bring it home,
558
00:24:25,898 --> 00:24:27,571
and she stopped me.
559
00:24:29,802 --> 00:24:31,941
She said she'd given it
to a friend for safekeeping.
560
00:24:32,538 --> 00:24:33,846
Did you ask what friend?
561
00:24:33,906 --> 00:24:36,182
Yes. She said it was
none of my business.
562
00:24:37,409 --> 00:24:38,786
What happened after that?
563
00:24:39,478 --> 00:24:41,424
How many times
did you hit her, Lisa?
564
00:24:42,114 --> 00:24:43,889
You did hit her, didn't you?
565
00:24:44,483 --> 00:24:46,019
We're gonna ask your father.
566
00:24:46,085 --> 00:24:48,395
How long you think it's gonna
take us to get it out of him?
567
00:24:48,454 --> 00:24:49,660
Leave him alone! He's sick!
568
00:24:49,722 --> 00:24:51,201
Maybe you're hopin' he forgot.
569
00:24:51,257 --> 00:24:53,032
You son of a bitch, stop it!
570
00:24:53,092 --> 00:24:55,231
We'll stop it when you
tell us what happened.
571
00:24:55,294 --> 00:24:57,296
All right!
I hit my mother, okay?
572
00:24:57,363 --> 00:24:58,933
I didn't mean to kill her!
573
00:25:08,974 --> 00:25:10,351
What did you hit her with?
574
00:25:12,211 --> 00:25:13,884
My fists.
575
00:25:14,680 --> 00:25:18,560
(CRYING) She fell
and hit her head.
576
00:25:18,617 --> 00:25:20,654
I didn't know
she was still alive.
577
00:25:20,886 --> 00:25:23,366
I would've...
578
00:25:23,422 --> 00:25:27,268
I would've gotten help,
but Dad was getting upset.
579
00:25:27,926 --> 00:25:29,064
Why did you run?
580
00:25:29,628 --> 00:25:33,235
I thought about Dad.
If I went to jail...
581
00:25:35,100 --> 00:25:36,909
I'm all he has now.
582
00:25:41,807 --> 00:25:42,945
So what's the charge?
583
00:25:43,008 --> 00:25:44,078
Man one.
584
00:25:44,143 --> 00:25:45,247
Are you kidding?
585
00:25:45,310 --> 00:25:47,586
Heat of the moment,
unpremeditated crime of passion.
586
00:25:47,646 --> 00:25:49,125
Not to mention the money.
587
00:25:49,181 --> 00:25:50,785
And the strain of
caring for her father.
588
00:25:50,849 --> 00:25:52,055
If she intended
to kill her mother,
589
00:25:52,117 --> 00:25:53,357
she wouldn't have
used her fists.
590
00:25:53,419 --> 00:25:56,025
Maybe she didn't.
Final autopsy report.
591
00:25:56,088 --> 00:25:58,625
Center of one bruise,
there's a darker impression.
592
00:25:58,691 --> 00:26:00,364
This says
it's perfectly square.
593
00:26:00,526 --> 00:26:02,164
Doesn't sound like
any fist I ever saw.
594
00:26:03,228 --> 00:26:04,605
The M.E. say what it was?
595
00:26:04,663 --> 00:26:06,904
Just a square.
Little over half an inch.
596
00:26:06,965 --> 00:26:10,242
If Lisa Hallenbeck picked something
up and used it as a weapon,
597
00:26:10,302 --> 00:26:11,975
man one's undercharging.
598
00:26:13,138 --> 00:26:15,084
RODGERS: It's not a blunt
object somebody picked up...
599
00:26:15,140 --> 00:26:17,177
(SIGHING) It's a ring.
600
00:26:18,544 --> 00:26:22,492
Sorry, oversights happen when you let the
late shift do the finishing touches.
601
00:26:22,581 --> 00:26:24,822
Lisa Hallenbeck wears
a small sapphire.
602
00:26:25,150 --> 00:26:26,891
It'd have to be
the Star of India.
603
00:26:32,491 --> 00:26:34,334
Can you get him to take his
hands out of his pockets?
604
00:26:34,393 --> 00:26:35,497
Why?
605
00:26:35,561 --> 00:26:36,733
We need to see his hands.
606
00:26:36,795 --> 00:26:38,069
Oh, my fingernails
are dirty again.
607
00:26:38,130 --> 00:26:40,770
They just keep getting dirty
no matter what I do.
608
00:26:40,833 --> 00:26:42,176
Nice ring.
609
00:26:42,368 --> 00:26:43,870
It's my dad's.
610
00:26:44,103 --> 00:26:46,606
Mr. Hallenbeck, we're going to have
to take you down to the precinct.
611
00:26:46,672 --> 00:26:48,345
Whoa, whoa, whoa.
What're you talking about?
612
00:26:48,674 --> 00:26:49,709
I'm gonna put these on you.
613
00:26:49,775 --> 00:26:51,254
It won't hurt.
It's just routine.
614
00:26:52,511 --> 00:26:55,151
You son of a bitch! No one
told you you could touch me!
615
00:26:55,247 --> 00:26:56,954
Dad! What makes you
think you can...
616
00:26:57,016 --> 00:26:58,256
Dad, Dad!
What are you doing?
617
00:26:58,317 --> 00:26:59,591
BRISCOE: My God...
618
00:26:59,651 --> 00:27:01,062
MICHAEL:
Hey! Take it easy!
619
00:27:02,421 --> 00:27:04,401
ED: You're under arrest
for the murder of your wife.
620
00:27:04,456 --> 00:27:06,902
My dad says I have to be
home before dark.
621
00:27:07,025 --> 00:27:08,299
ED: You have the right
to remain silent.
622
00:27:08,360 --> 00:27:11,068
Anything you say can and
will be used against you...
623
00:27:16,502 --> 00:27:19,005
Sole count is murder
in the second degree.
624
00:27:19,071 --> 00:27:20,414
Can we get a plea, Counselor?
625
00:27:20,472 --> 00:27:22,383
On behalf of my client,
not guilty.
626
00:27:22,975 --> 00:27:24,181
People on bail?
627
00:27:24,643 --> 00:27:26,782
The defendant killed his wife
in a jealous rage, Your Honor.
628
00:27:26,845 --> 00:27:28,017
People ask remand.
629
00:27:28,080 --> 00:27:29,582
PAULSEN: My client suffers
from Alzheimer's.
630
00:27:29,648 --> 00:27:32,322
He's not capable of the kind
of premeditated assault
631
00:27:32,384 --> 00:27:33,886
Ms. Carmichael
attributes to him.
632
00:27:34,119 --> 00:27:35,530
What is he capable of?
633
00:27:35,587 --> 00:27:37,191
Well, like most
Alzheimer's patients,
634
00:27:37,256 --> 00:27:38,792
he's prone to
uncontrolled fits.
635
00:27:38,857 --> 00:27:40,393
He's irrational.
636
00:27:40,459 --> 00:27:43,065
He reacts only to
the crossed wires in his head.
637
00:27:43,328 --> 00:27:46,571
I have an affidavit
from Phelps at Johns Hopkins
638
00:27:46,632 --> 00:27:48,942
and scientific studies
published in leading journals.
639
00:27:49,001 --> 00:27:52,881
Planning to interpose mental
disease as a defense, Ms. Paulsen?
640
00:27:53,038 --> 00:27:54,676
That would be premature
at this time.
641
00:27:55,040 --> 00:27:56,917
Then, save it
for the trial judge.
642
00:27:57,976 --> 00:28:00,616
Until then, the defendant
doesn't look like
643
00:28:00,679 --> 00:28:02,681
he's going anywhere,
Ms. Carmichael.
644
00:28:03,816 --> 00:28:06,797
Bail is set at 150,000.
645
00:28:09,288 --> 00:28:10,358
His wife was having an affair.
646
00:28:10,422 --> 00:28:12,834
She and the daughter had a
tiff about it in front of him.
647
00:28:12,891 --> 00:28:14,529
Did he grasp what was going on?
648
00:28:14,593 --> 00:28:17,130
We were hoping
you could tell us.
649
00:28:17,329 --> 00:28:19,570
Where was the daughter while
he was killing her mother?
650
00:28:19,798 --> 00:28:23,007
She says she went to her mother's
room to look for the jewelry.
651
00:28:23,101 --> 00:28:25,172
A nurse confirmed
seeing her in the hallway.
652
00:28:25,304 --> 00:28:26,442
How long was she gone?
653
00:28:26,505 --> 00:28:28,075
Four or five minutes.
654
00:28:28,140 --> 00:28:29,619
And it was all over
when she got back?
655
00:28:29,675 --> 00:28:31,154
All but the dying.
656
00:28:31,477 --> 00:28:35,118
So, for all you know, Mr. Hallenbeck
thought his wife was an alien demon.
657
00:28:35,280 --> 00:28:37,920
We're not trying to rail road him, Emil.
We just need to know.
658
00:28:38,917 --> 00:28:41,397
Alzheimer's patients
have good days and bad days.
659
00:28:41,453 --> 00:28:43,228
Good days,
they're almost normal.
660
00:28:43,288 --> 00:28:44,892
Bad days...
661
00:28:45,491 --> 00:28:46,993
What were the injuries
to the victim?
662
00:28:47,759 --> 00:28:51,730
These bruises on her arms indicate
he grabbed her from behind.
663
00:28:52,631 --> 00:28:54,440
Two hard punches
to the solar plexus...
664
00:28:54,499 --> 00:28:56,035
So he must have
spun her around.
665
00:28:57,202 --> 00:28:59,273
She went down, hit her head
on the corner of the table.
666
00:28:59,338 --> 00:29:00,476
Happened fast.
667
00:29:00,739 --> 00:29:02,582
Were there any other injuries
after she was on the floor?
668
00:29:02,641 --> 00:29:03,881
No. The attack stopped.
669
00:29:03,942 --> 00:29:05,580
So much for
the uncontrolled fit.
670
00:29:06,211 --> 00:29:08,714
Maybe. What'd he do after?
671
00:29:08,781 --> 00:29:10,283
Did he panic?
Did he try to get help?
672
00:29:10,549 --> 00:29:11,653
We don't know.
673
00:29:11,717 --> 00:29:13,025
Well, then I'm sorry,
I can't help you
674
00:29:13,085 --> 00:29:15,190
unless I can get a sit-down
with Mr. Hallenbeck.
675
00:29:15,420 --> 00:29:16,990
I'll talk to his lawyer
and arrange it.
676
00:29:19,224 --> 00:29:20,464
(SIGHS)
677
00:29:21,193 --> 00:29:25,471
I was at the hospital.
Marjorie was there.
678
00:29:26,899 --> 00:29:28,435
And your daughter?
679
00:29:29,635 --> 00:29:33,811
Lisa wanted to know
about the jewelry.
680
00:29:34,673 --> 00:29:36,243
Boy, was she mad.
681
00:29:37,109 --> 00:29:38,850
What about you?
Were you mad?
682
00:29:39,177 --> 00:29:42,624
She said she deserved
some happiness.
683
00:29:43,849 --> 00:29:45,123
Who did?
684
00:29:49,555 --> 00:29:52,331
Your wife was happy with somebody else.
Were you jealous?
685
00:29:54,059 --> 00:29:56,005
Do you know
where they'll put me?
686
00:29:56,628 --> 00:29:58,608
I have some problems, you know.
687
00:29:59,531 --> 00:30:00,976
What kind of problems?
688
00:30:02,067 --> 00:30:03,671
I keep forgetting things.
689
00:30:03,735 --> 00:30:05,078
(SIGHS)
690
00:30:05,337 --> 00:30:06,975
Does that frighten you?
691
00:30:12,878 --> 00:30:14,323
Why did you hit your wife?
692
00:30:16,882 --> 00:30:18,725
She gave the watch
to her boyfriend.
693
00:30:19,251 --> 00:30:20,594
It was her watch, wasn't it?
694
00:30:20,819 --> 00:30:22,457
I gave her that watch!
695
00:30:23,655 --> 00:30:27,296
She gave it to some
damn bastard gigolo!
696
00:30:27,359 --> 00:30:30,431
She had no right!
Supposed to be with me!
697
00:30:30,495 --> 00:30:31,667
Take care of me!
698
00:30:41,373 --> 00:30:43,580
After you hit her,
did you go for help?
699
00:30:47,846 --> 00:30:49,086
No.
700
00:30:50,616 --> 00:30:51,822
(SIGHS)
701
00:30:52,584 --> 00:30:57,465
I, uh, left the room.
702
00:31:01,126 --> 00:31:03,504
Lisa was standing
in the hallway.
703
00:31:04,363 --> 00:31:06,104
Did you ask her to go for help?
704
00:31:08,700 --> 00:31:10,202
I didn't.
705
00:31:14,139 --> 00:31:15,948
I just told her that...
706
00:31:17,709 --> 00:31:21,486
I want to go home.
707
00:31:29,454 --> 00:31:31,195
Skoda says
Mr. Hallenbeck understood
708
00:31:31,256 --> 00:31:32,826
what was happening
in the solarium.
709
00:31:32,891 --> 00:31:34,529
He knew his wife
was seeing another man.
710
00:31:34,593 --> 00:31:36,630
So he was sane
at the time of the killing.
711
00:31:36,695 --> 00:31:38,834
Is he fit to stand trial?
712
00:31:38,897 --> 00:31:42,140
In Skoda's opinion, he's in the
intermediate stages of the disease.
713
00:31:42,200 --> 00:31:45,204
It could be as much as eight to
10 years before he's incompetent.
714
00:31:45,270 --> 00:31:47,750
Jury's gonna see a pathetic
old man with Alzheimer's.
715
00:31:47,806 --> 00:31:49,046
Make a deal.
716
00:31:53,245 --> 00:31:55,054
JACK: Man one, six-to-12.
717
00:31:55,113 --> 00:31:56,217
No jail time.
718
00:31:56,481 --> 00:31:58,518
Misdemeanor assault?
Not possible.
719
00:31:58,583 --> 00:32:00,460
It was unpremeditated.
720
00:32:00,986 --> 00:32:02,329
I talked to both the children.
721
00:32:02,387 --> 00:32:04,389
Mr. Hallenbeck was
a controlling man
722
00:32:04,456 --> 00:32:06,129
long before he got Alzheimer's.
723
00:32:06,191 --> 00:32:07,397
Everything had to be
done his way.
724
00:32:07,459 --> 00:32:11,134
I've talked to them, too. He was never
violent, never physically abusive.
725
00:32:11,363 --> 00:32:13,070
Did you read
Dr. Skoda's report?
726
00:32:13,265 --> 00:32:14,437
There's nothing new.
727
00:32:14,499 --> 00:32:16,035
Read it again.
728
00:32:16,101 --> 00:32:20,015
Skoda says Hallenbeck
was capable of lucid rage,
729
00:32:20,072 --> 00:32:22,313
and was rational
at the time of the attack.
730
00:32:23,542 --> 00:32:24,919
Man one, or we go to trial.
731
00:32:24,976 --> 00:32:26,922
Assume you convince a jury,
732
00:32:26,978 --> 00:32:28,184
where you going to put him?
733
00:32:28,246 --> 00:32:29,418
State prison.
734
00:32:29,481 --> 00:32:31,586
Where he'll be at the mercy
of every maggot in the system.
735
00:32:31,650 --> 00:32:34,426
All prisons in the State of New
York have a hospital ward.
736
00:32:35,420 --> 00:32:36,831
I'll give you
the benefit of the doubt
737
00:32:36,888 --> 00:32:38,959
and assume
you've never seen one.
738
00:32:39,024 --> 00:32:43,200
In the meantime, here's
some, uh, light lifting.
739
00:32:44,563 --> 00:32:45,701
What's this?
740
00:32:45,764 --> 00:32:48,040
Motion to dismiss
in the interests of justice.
741
00:32:48,200 --> 00:32:49,702
On what basis?
742
00:32:49,801 --> 00:32:51,144
The Eighth Amendment.
743
00:32:51,203 --> 00:32:53,513
Putting an Alzheimer's patient
in a prison hospital ward
744
00:32:53,572 --> 00:32:55,984
is tantamount to cruel
and unusual punishment.
745
00:32:59,644 --> 00:33:01,248
Seems like a stretch.
746
00:33:02,080 --> 00:33:04,856
Well, what do they do with
Alzheimer's patients in prison?
747
00:33:05,817 --> 00:33:09,196
Whatever it is, I can't see how
it could be cruel or unusual.
748
00:33:10,255 --> 00:33:13,725
We're underfunded, understaffed,
and overcrowded...
749
00:33:13,859 --> 00:33:15,497
We have no
Alzheimer's specialists,
750
00:33:15,560 --> 00:33:17,369
and we're not likely
to get one.
751
00:33:17,729 --> 00:33:21,108
Alzheimer's patients need to
be in familiar surroundings
752
00:33:21,166 --> 00:33:22,702
with people who
care about them.
753
00:33:22,768 --> 00:33:25,408
Here, they have no contact
with their families,
754
00:33:25,470 --> 00:33:29,384
no one who has one-on-one
time for them, no privacy.
755
00:33:30,008 --> 00:33:31,715
You have any Alzheimer's
cases here now?
756
00:33:31,776 --> 00:33:33,813
Eleven, with more on the way.
757
00:33:33,879 --> 00:33:38,055
I've been trying for months to get
them moved someplace more appropriate.
758
00:33:38,450 --> 00:33:41,954
Try to understand. We're
really doing the best we can.
759
00:33:44,122 --> 00:33:45,601
(PEOPLE SHOUTING)
760
00:33:46,391 --> 00:33:48,701
It's revolting, Jack.
761
00:33:48,760 --> 00:33:52,264
You walk in, and the stench
knocks you back six feet.
762
00:33:52,798 --> 00:33:55,802
There's screaming and babbling.
763
00:33:55,867 --> 00:33:58,438
It's like you've entered
the fourth circle of hell.
764
00:33:59,471 --> 00:34:02,452
There are a dozen men
strapped down to beds,
765
00:34:02,507 --> 00:34:05,317
wearing nothing
but dirty diapers.
766
00:34:05,544 --> 00:34:09,686
Half of them are crying, and the
others are spouting gibberish...
767
00:34:10,949 --> 00:34:13,828
There are two nurses and
three orderlies per shift.
768
00:34:15,086 --> 00:34:17,430
It's the most appalling
place I've ever seen.
769
00:34:18,290 --> 00:34:19,564
Where are the doctors?
770
00:34:19,624 --> 00:34:22,366
A doctor comes by once a week.
771
00:34:22,427 --> 00:34:24,100
And for some kinds
of emergencies,
772
00:34:24,162 --> 00:34:26,904
a psychiatrist wanders
through there once a month
773
00:34:26,965 --> 00:34:28,137
if they're lucky.
774
00:34:28,967 --> 00:34:31,106
What would this kind of
setting do to Mr. Hallenbeck?
775
00:34:32,170 --> 00:34:35,640
Sixty-year-old man in diapers
chained to his bed,
776
00:34:35,707 --> 00:34:39,655
with no privacy, no dignity, nobody
with time to take care of him?
777
00:34:40,145 --> 00:34:41,317
What do you think?
778
00:34:41,613 --> 00:34:43,786
And if he's found not guilty
by reason of insanity?
779
00:34:43,848 --> 00:34:45,623
Then the options improve.
780
00:34:45,684 --> 00:34:47,595
Better facilities,
more personnel.
781
00:34:48,320 --> 00:34:49,697
More humane all around.
782
00:34:50,355 --> 00:34:52,596
Prison wards aren't
deliberately inhumane.
783
00:34:52,657 --> 00:34:54,102
I'm not blaming
the Department of Correction.
784
00:34:54,159 --> 00:34:57,299
Things are just marginally
better on the outside.
785
00:34:58,830 --> 00:35:03,973
But 20 years from now, when the baby
boomers reach their golden years...
786
00:35:05,470 --> 00:35:07,575
We're just seeing
the tip of the iceberg.
787
00:35:08,473 --> 00:35:09,474
Good luck.
788
00:35:09,708 --> 00:35:13,019
Thanks for the editorial.
Now, how about a solution?
789
00:35:14,346 --> 00:35:15,416
Good luck.
790
00:35:18,083 --> 00:35:19,994
We should let Hallenbeck
take the insanity plea
791
00:35:20,051 --> 00:35:21,689
and send him somewhere livable.
792
00:35:22,020 --> 00:35:23,795
He isn't legally insane.
793
00:35:24,756 --> 00:35:26,201
And he did commit homicide.
794
00:35:26,258 --> 00:35:27,931
Unpremeditated.
795
00:35:28,426 --> 00:35:30,770
I'm not talking about
letting him go.
796
00:35:31,796 --> 00:35:34,037
You didn't see this place.
You have no idea.
797
00:35:34,266 --> 00:35:36,803
Do I hear a soft side
scratching toward the light?
798
00:35:36,868 --> 00:35:37,903
Jack...
799
00:35:37,969 --> 00:35:39,471
I don't see a way out, Abbie.
800
00:35:41,506 --> 00:35:44,248
But if you think you can work
something out, be my guest.
801
00:35:47,912 --> 00:35:50,449
CARMICHAEL: One option might
be a determinate sentence
802
00:35:50,515 --> 00:35:53,291
to be served in some kind of
halfway house.
803
00:35:53,552 --> 00:35:54,690
PAULSEN: How much time?
804
00:35:54,753 --> 00:35:55,891
Six years.
805
00:35:56,154 --> 00:35:57,394
A halfway house?
What does that mean?
806
00:35:57,455 --> 00:35:58,900
Would he just
have to sleep there?
807
00:35:59,324 --> 00:36:03,864
No. He'd be subject to the same
rules as if he was in prison.
808
00:36:04,196 --> 00:36:06,642
No, no. Dad has to be
at home with me.
809
00:36:07,565 --> 00:36:10,239
I told you what I want. They're
not taking him away from me.
810
00:36:11,536 --> 00:36:12,537
Next option?
811
00:36:12,604 --> 00:36:15,175
We're trying to work out
a humane situation here.
812
00:36:15,340 --> 00:36:18,253
It's already on the table. You
don't oppose his insanity plea.
813
00:36:18,643 --> 00:36:20,247
Even though
he was legally sane?
814
00:36:20,412 --> 00:36:21,914
That's neither here nor there.
815
00:36:21,980 --> 00:36:23,516
Incarceration is not an option.
816
00:36:23,581 --> 00:36:25,720
Why? Because
he's old and pitiful?
817
00:36:26,952 --> 00:36:29,364
Send him where you send everybody
else who kills people.
818
00:36:29,921 --> 00:36:31,628
Why should he rate
all this consideration?
819
00:36:31,690 --> 00:36:33,431
Michael, Dad can hear you.
820
00:36:33,492 --> 00:36:37,804
I don't care, Lisa. I am so sick and
tired of making excuses for him.
821
00:36:38,229 --> 00:36:40,937
He never gave a damn
about Mom or me or you.
822
00:36:40,999 --> 00:36:44,139
And she finally takes one step
away from him, and he kills her.
823
00:36:44,202 --> 00:36:45,545
You never liked him.
824
00:36:45,604 --> 00:36:47,447
You always took Mom's side.
825
00:36:47,505 --> 00:36:50,315
He didn't mean to kill her, and
he had every right to be mad.
826
00:36:50,375 --> 00:36:52,719
He's a jerk, and he's
never been anything but.
827
00:36:55,046 --> 00:36:59,426
He deprived my kids of a grandmother
that they needed and loved.
828
00:36:59,484 --> 00:37:01,122
And you want to
deprive them of a grandfather.
829
00:37:01,186 --> 00:37:02,893
Wake up, Lisa.
830
00:37:03,321 --> 00:37:06,632
If you think I would ever let him near
my kids again, you've lost your mind!
831
00:37:08,493 --> 00:37:10,837
Okay, if the law says
that he's sane,
832
00:37:10,895 --> 00:37:13,398
your shrink says that
he's competent,
833
00:37:13,465 --> 00:37:16,469
why are we here, huh?
What's the problem?
834
00:37:17,502 --> 00:37:19,778
What the hell's the matter
with you people?
835
00:37:23,642 --> 00:37:24,746
Compassion?
836
00:37:24,809 --> 00:37:26,811
If he weren't sick,
I'd say fry him.
837
00:37:27,645 --> 00:37:29,784
They're all sick,
one way or another.
838
00:37:30,115 --> 00:37:31,560
What makes him different?
839
00:37:31,616 --> 00:37:34,426
Well, let's see.
Oh, yeah. Alzheimer's.
840
00:37:34,686 --> 00:37:36,256
Abbie, you tried.
841
00:37:36,321 --> 00:37:38,096
The daughter refuses to let go.
842
00:37:38,356 --> 00:37:39,926
What do you want to do?
843
00:37:40,292 --> 00:37:41,703
Sleep on it.
844
00:37:43,295 --> 00:37:45,741
Shall I tell you again
what the prison ward is like?
845
00:37:45,830 --> 00:37:47,002
We'll factor it in, Abbie,
846
00:37:47,065 --> 00:37:49,409
but we're not basing
our decision on that alone.
847
00:37:50,135 --> 00:37:51,944
All right,
it's been a long day.
848
00:37:59,044 --> 00:38:00,990
Should've gone
to Sing Sing yourself.
849
00:38:06,918 --> 00:38:09,421
The conditions under which a
prisoner is forced to live,
850
00:38:09,487 --> 00:38:11,194
whether in prison or hospital,
851
00:38:11,256 --> 00:38:13,566
cannot violate
the Constitutional ban
852
00:38:13,625 --> 00:38:15,366
on cruel and
unusual punishment.
853
00:38:15,960 --> 00:38:17,564
Whether those conditions
are the product of
854
00:38:17,629 --> 00:38:19,233
design or neglect
doesn't matter.
855
00:38:19,297 --> 00:38:23,541
The mere existence of intolerable,
inhuman circumstances
856
00:38:23,601 --> 00:38:25,080
triggers the ban.
857
00:38:25,136 --> 00:38:28,117
If convicted, my client will
be forced into a prison system
858
00:38:28,173 --> 00:38:30,312
that cannot provide
the care he needs.
859
00:38:30,942 --> 00:38:34,048
Worse, once his disease fully
overwhelms his faculties,
860
00:38:34,112 --> 00:38:37,286
he will be housed
in such execrable conditions
861
00:38:37,349 --> 00:38:40,819
as to hasten not only his mental
and physical deterioration,
862
00:38:40,885 --> 00:38:43,957
but his death under
appalling circumstances.
863
00:38:44,289 --> 00:38:47,566
Whatever his transgressions,
nobody deserves such a fate.
864
00:38:48,493 --> 00:38:50,973
There's a time for justice
and a time for mercy.
865
00:38:51,896 --> 00:38:55,343
The Criminal Procedure Law provides
for the dismissal of charges
866
00:38:55,400 --> 00:38:59,041
even where the elements of
the crime are not in dispute
867
00:38:59,104 --> 00:39:02,017
in certain cases
in the interest of justice.
868
00:39:03,174 --> 00:39:04,915
This is such a case.
869
00:39:11,116 --> 00:39:16,031
The Eighth Amendment does not
prohibit capital punishment,
870
00:39:16,087 --> 00:39:19,034
or solitary confinement,
or hard labor.
871
00:39:20,458 --> 00:39:24,838
As long as the punishment is not meant
to inflict pain for pain's sake,
872
00:39:24,896 --> 00:39:27,206
the Eighth Amendment
doesn't apply.
873
00:39:27,265 --> 00:39:31,042
Mr. Hallenbeck will receive the
same punishment as other prisoners.
874
00:39:31,636 --> 00:39:33,274
The same food,
875
00:39:33,338 --> 00:39:36,217
he will share
the same living conditions,
876
00:39:36,274 --> 00:39:38,652
and get the same level
of medical care.
877
00:39:38,843 --> 00:39:42,086
Mr. Hallenbeck is the victim
of a terrible disease.
878
00:39:43,748 --> 00:39:45,887
He faces
a grim future in prison,
879
00:39:47,352 --> 00:39:49,855
but it's a future
largely of his own making.
880
00:39:49,921 --> 00:39:54,131
He was sane when he killed his
wife in a fit of jealous rage.
881
00:39:54,392 --> 00:39:56,394
He's responsible for his crime,
882
00:39:56,461 --> 00:39:58,805
and he's responsible
for his punishment.
883
00:39:59,297 --> 00:40:04,212
Instead, he wants this court
to excuse his brutal act.
884
00:40:04,869 --> 00:40:09,614
But society and the law demands
punishment for murder.
885
00:40:09,874 --> 00:40:13,651
It was wrong of Mr. Hallenbeck
to kill his wife
886
00:40:13,711 --> 00:40:16,123
just because
he felt sorry for himself.
887
00:40:17,615 --> 00:40:22,689
And it would be wrong for this court
to turn a blind eye to his crime
888
00:40:23,555 --> 00:40:25,557
just because
we feel sorry for him.
889
00:40:35,867 --> 00:40:40,577
I find the application of Charles
Hallenbeck for dismissal of the charge
890
00:40:40,638 --> 00:40:43,619
of murder in the second
degree is not without merit.
891
00:40:44,576 --> 00:40:47,614
Mr. Hallenbeck is
facing that dark night,
892
00:40:47,679 --> 00:40:50,125
which in some ways
is worse than death.
893
00:40:50,181 --> 00:40:53,128
By the nature of his condition,
he will face it alone.
894
00:40:53,952 --> 00:40:57,092
That being said,
I cannot determine that
895
00:40:57,155 --> 00:41:01,467
subjecting Mr. Hallenbeck to
atrial and possible conviction
896
00:41:01,526 --> 00:41:04,439
is violative of the
Constitutional prohibition
897
00:41:04,495 --> 00:41:06,168
against cruel
and unusual punishment.
898
00:41:06,864 --> 00:41:11,142
At this time, he is of sufficiently
sound mind to assist his attorney,
899
00:41:11,202 --> 00:41:13,842
and to understand the nature of
the proceedings against him.
900
00:41:13,905 --> 00:41:15,213
The motion is denied.
901
00:41:21,179 --> 00:41:22,351
McCoy.
902
00:41:23,615 --> 00:41:26,459
If Mr. Hallenbeck doesn't
want to go through a trial...
903
00:41:28,386 --> 00:41:29,865
I'm willing to knock it down,
904
00:41:29,921 --> 00:41:31,366
but he has to do
some prison time.
905
00:41:32,590 --> 00:41:34,797
You offered time
in a halfway house.
906
00:41:34,893 --> 00:41:36,770
Yes. Six years.
907
00:41:37,662 --> 00:41:40,074
That's not fair. If he
hadn't gotten sick, then...
908
00:41:40,131 --> 00:41:42,577
Lisa, please.
It's all over.
909
00:41:48,206 --> 00:41:49,913
(SIGHS) We'll take it.
910
00:41:59,384 --> 00:42:01,364
We were at the hospital...
911
00:42:03,154 --> 00:42:09,002
My wife was, uh, was telling
my daughter about the jewelry.
912
00:42:13,031 --> 00:42:14,408
Mr. Hallenbeck?
913
00:42:15,533 --> 00:42:17,877
Is it August already?
914
00:42:18,703 --> 00:42:20,046
Hot in the summer.
915
00:42:21,539 --> 00:42:23,143
Will the People inquire?
916
00:42:28,079 --> 00:42:30,992
Mr. Hallenbeck,
in the hospital,
917
00:42:33,051 --> 00:42:35,463
did you punch your wife
with your fists?
918
00:42:39,123 --> 00:42:40,534
Yeah, I did that.
919
00:42:40,591 --> 00:42:41,592
Why?
920
00:42:44,395 --> 00:42:46,534
She didn't want me anymore.
921
00:42:47,999 --> 00:42:51,276
Oh, I'm a sick old man.
922
00:42:51,602 --> 00:42:53,138
(CRYING) She didn't want me.
923
00:42:53,504 --> 00:42:55,142
Is that why you killed her?
924
00:42:56,207 --> 00:42:58,187
You were angry that
she might leave you?
925
00:42:59,310 --> 00:43:02,519
She had no right.
I needed her.
926
00:43:03,081 --> 00:43:04,389
I needed her!
927
00:43:09,754 --> 00:43:12,064
The plea is satisfactory
to the People.
928
00:43:12,890 --> 00:43:18,067
Mr. Hallenbeck, in accordance with
the terms of your plea agreement,
929
00:43:18,129 --> 00:43:22,100
you are hereby sentenced
to a term of six-to-12 years
930
00:43:22,166 --> 00:43:24,840
and remanded to the custody of
the Department of Correction.
931
00:43:34,979 --> 00:43:36,686
I have to go away now.
932
00:43:50,328 --> 00:43:53,866
Lost her father twice.
Lousy deal all around.
933
00:43:54,766 --> 00:43:57,110
The law went
as far as it could.
934
00:43:57,602 --> 00:43:59,673
Lisa Hallenbeck
wanted all or nothing.
935
00:44:01,406 --> 00:44:03,909
One day, we might all wish
we had a kid like that.
936
00:44:03,959 --> 00:44:08,509
Repair and Synchronization by
Easy Subtitles Synchronizer 1.0.0.0
72613
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.