All language subtitles for Cold Case S01E11 Hubris Unknown TrollHD

( Adam Ant's "Wonderful"
playing )

¶ Did I tell you
how much I miss ¶

¶ Your sweet kiss? ¶

¶ Did I tell you I didn't cry? ¶

¶ Well, I lied ¶

¶ I lie, lie lied ¶

¶ Over, real over ¶

¶ When I nearly hit
the face I loved ¶

¶ So tired of packaging
the anger ¶

¶ Always pushing you away ¶

¶ Did I tell you
you're wonderful? ¶

¶ I miss you ¶

¶ Yes, I do ¶

¶ Did I tell you
that I was wrong? ¶

¶ I was wrong ¶

¶ 'Cause you're wonderful,
yeah ¶

¶ Did I tell you
you're wonderful? ¶

( metal snapping )

( screaming )

( metal whipping )

( screaming )

( metal whipping, shouting )

( phone ringing
in the distance )

Detective Rush, cold jobs.

Uh, Roy Minard,

uh, Fallen from Grace.

( laughs )

Is that right?

Yes.

You're looking at a ruined man,
I'm afraid.

Want to sit down?

Thank you.

I was a, uh...

I was a professor
at the university,

enjoying a quiet life
of arts and sciences,

when I became embroiled
in a murder case.

My unfortunate role was
as the number one suspect.

Who had the unfortunate
role of victim?

Uh...

Holly Richardson.

Here.

She was one of my students.

Very promising young mind.

Killed on campus?

Nine years ago.

Whipped and strangled
with a car antenna.

Awful.

Well, there must have been
a reason you were investigated.

And one reason only.

Holly and I were having
an affair.

Ah.

Which I lied about
at the time.

Why?

Why does
a philanderer lie?

I was married.

Ashamed
of my behavior.

Covering your tracks.

And my dishonesty
on that matter

was seen as guilt
in this far
more serious charge.

The press went
to town.

My wife and child
left town...

and I was soon relieved
of my professorship

and banned
from the campus.

Well, you're here
talking to me,

so clearly you weren't
convicted of anything.

Not in a court of law.

And you're innocent,
of course.

You've heard
of Richard Jewell?

Yeah.

He and I would have
a lot to talk about.

So why come in today, Roy?

Uh, I found this
in the newspaper.

A prostitute in Norristown

was killed and dumped
in the Schuylkill
two weeks ago.

Same as Holly.

A lot of bodies
are dumped in the river.

Yes, but this one
was also killed

with a car antenna.

I saw that
and I thought

maybe I've found
my one-armed man.

Now you're Richard Kimble.

If there is a connection,

maybe you can solve
two murders.

And save my life
in the process.

Captioning sponsored by
WARNER BROS. TELEVISION

"Holly Richardson, 21.

"Killed in West
Philly, May '95.

"14 lashes
with an antenna

before he strangled
her with it."

Little humiliation
before the grand finale.

Dumped in the Schuylkill.

Doer was probably trying
to wash away evidence.

They found semen.

Professor Minard's?
Yup.

So they did it
the night of the murder.

Outside of that,
what do we got?

He and Holly were
at the same party at the...

Elizabethan Club.

Some people saw them
having words.

"Words."

I love how them Ivy Leaguers
talk.

They had a fight,
okay, dummy?

Okay, so that's the whole case?

That's about it.

VALENS:
That's nothing.

Why'd this guy get the pinch?

He lied about the affair
till the DNA came back.

Then he changed
his story.

VALENS:
How's the Norristown
murder

come into play?

This hooker job had
a pretty similar M.O.--

the antenna,
the river dump.

Worth getting a look
at that Norristown file.

Vera won't mind taking a ride.

This professor still teaching
Art History?

English
as a second language.

Step or two down.

Paid a high price
if he's innocent.

Or if he's guilty,

he's gotten a lot
of free years.

So, we reinvestigate him,
too.

Hi, we meet again.
Excuse me.

Professor Minard,
my partner Scotty Valens.

Hi.

Hi. You're very kind
to call me "professor,"

but around here
I'm just "Mr. Roy."

Yeah, okay.

So does this visit mean

there was something
to my amateur
detective's theory?

We don't know yet.

I've spent a lot of time
the last nine years

reading mystery novels.

I thought maybe I was getting
carried away.

Well, we haven't seen
that file from Norristown yet.

But we were wondering
where you were

the uh, night that hooker
got killed.

Right, um...

I teach here nights,
Monday through Thursday.

What night was she killed?

RUSH:
It was a Tuesday.

Then I was here.

22 other witnesses
will tell you the same,

in broken
but improving English.

Lying about your affair
with Holly

got you in a lot of hot water.

I was arrogant.

Bill Clinton lied
to America about the intern.

I lied to Philadelphia.

And you both got caught
in the end.

I wouldn't do it again.

DNA...

will get you
every time.

So when Holly

was killed,
how were you two getting along?

Well, in
my first statement,

I said things
were great.

Hm. I know.

But to be honest,

there was
some tension.

If I had a small dinner party,
would you come?

Small,
as in you and me?

Maybe six people or eight.

No, I wouldn't.

Why not?

Holly...
there are rules.

Well, I want
to see you in public.

You can't.

God, don't you ever even think
about me outside this office?

Sure. Thinking
is perfectly fair.

Seeing each other outside
of these four walls...

it's not possible.

What if I don't like
those rules anymore?

Sounds like you laid it out
pretty clear.

My campus and home lives
stayed separate.

No contact outside
of office hours.

Is that
what you called it?

Not even phone calls.

Here's the deal, Roy.

If we're going to look
at this case again,

you gotta be
an open book this time.

Done. In fact...

Here it is.
RUSH:
What is this?

It's a list of women,

who were also...

Conquests?

RUSH:
Did you offer
these names

in the first
investigation?

No, I was pretending
Holly was the only one.

They'll probably badmouth me.

You'll hear a lot
about bad behavior,

but nothing that says "murder."

I wouldn't say that name
too loudly around here.

We need to know about your
relationship with him.

In '94?

I'm on the faculty now.

It'd be bad
for me if that got out.

Is that why you kept it
from the police nine years ago?

I was never asked.

Look, this isn't popular
opinion around campus,

but Roy didn't kill Holly.

You don't think so?

He was unethical
but he's not a murderer.

You didn't think he
was unethical in '94.

I didn't really get
what an abuse

it was until
I started teaching.

It's just so easy
to impress students.

And Roy's
very charismatic.

We've met him.

Did you know
Holly Richardson?

I tried to warn her not
to get in too deep with Roy.

I talked to her that night
at the Elizabethan Club.

( growling playfully )

Haven't seen you all day!
How you doing?

¶ Did I tell you that I was
wrong, I was wrong... ¶

It's not so easy seeing
them in the flesh, is it?

What?

The wife, the kid.

No. It's not.

Holly, this time
last year,

I was standing
right where you are.

Did you feel like you'd
just been hit by a truck?

Yeah.

He's happy with them.
He won't leave.

Why does he have affairs
if he's so happy?

I don't know
his psychology.

But there's a new girl
every year.

And the year's almost over.

¶ I miss you... ¶

I think it's different
this time.

¶ Did I tell you
that I was... ¶

I felt for her.

I was her at one point.

But she was upset at him...
not the other way around.

So after two hours
of making copies

of every page from
this Norristown job...

Stillman told us
about the flat tire.

Yeah, that precinct's copier
was from the mimeograph era.

Look, guys, it was bad luck.

Yeah, well, we finish
up your dog call,

finally get out of traic
on Ridge Pike...

Prostitute's name
was Lenore Grandy.

JEFFRIES:
And bam!

And we were in the fast lane.

RUSH:
Vera, Jeffries, thank you.

You risked your very lives
for this job.

Hey, guys, can we talk about
Lenore Grandy now?

Whipped 14 times
with a car antenna,

then strangled
with it.

And dumped in the Schuylkill.

That's just like Holly.

VERA:
But here's the money.

Lenore... Holly.

RUSH:
Wow...

Yeah.

RUSH:
Gotta be the same doer.

How did no one
catch this?

Different counties.
Computers don't talk.

Roy Menard have an alibi
for the second murder?

He was teaching his class
that night-- it checked out.

Maybe he did get
the jewel treatment.

( printer whirring )

I got something we can run with.

Yeah.
Cross-referenced

the names from vice sweeps
in Norristown

with the university
alumni records.

Two hits.

Clarence Grimes.

Graduated 20 years ago.

He wouldn't
know Holly.

Yeah, but Barry Tepler would.

He was in school
same time as her.

He only lives eight blocks
from where Lenore was dumped.

I don't have...
people over...

We're here about
Holly Richardson.

Don't bring her up.

Why not?

I stay away from Holly,
just like she told me to.

Holly told you
to stay away, Barry?

She invited me home
for Thanksgiving...

I misinterpreted her gesture
of friendship

for a deeper interest,

but I changed my behavior when
she relayed her true feelings.

Your therapist
tell you that?

Or lawyer?

When she asked me
to leave her alone... I did.

¶ You say ¶

¶ I only hear
what I want to... ¶

Hi.
What you doing here?

I go to school here.

Well, you don't have any
classes in Williams Hall.

I wanted to see you.

Barry, you're following me.

I like you.

I'm not interested in you
in that way.

You took me
to meet your parents.

It was Thanksgiving.

You had nowhere else to go.

Well, can we talk
about it, or...

No. Nope.

I don't want
to talk about it,

I don't want you
to call me or follow me.

Uh-huh.

And I don't want
any more letters.

Those are yours.

No, they're yours.

¶ Yeah, yeah... ¶

¶ I missed you... ¶

¶ You say... ¶

VALENS:
So you stalked Holly.

I pursued her
with too much enthusiasm.

You still have
those letters, Barry?

No.

You save dental reminders
from three years ago,

but not those letters?

I... I was in my dorm room
when she was killed.

Where were you when
Lenore Grandy was killed?

I don't know who that is.

A hooker.

Murdered December 30,
eight blocks from here.

That's a Tuesday.
Tuesdays I paint.

I have therapy at 5:00,

then I go to Wawa
for a Red Bull,

uh, get a Newsweek,
I'm home by 10:00.

Plenty of time for prostitutes
on that schedule.

I don't use prostitutes.

Risperdol.
You got schizophrenia?

Yeah.

Hear voices?

God talking
through the garbage?

I'm better now.

It's tough getting better.

You stop taking thes
you can fall into
psychotic behavior.

I take 'em.
Well, maybe you lapsed

right around December 30,
voices started saying

you should hurt
that hooker.

I don't go near those ...!

Yeah, he comes here
all the time.

Hangs around and
tries to talk to us.

He ever talk
to your friend Lenore?

Oh, he especially liked her.

Stared at her from
across the street.

He the one killed her?

Uh, we don't know.

I figured it was
a bad john did it.

This kid
was never Lenore's trick?

HOOKER:
Mm-mm.

He walked up to her
once, though.

Said he loved her
flaxen hair

and asked would
she go back with him.

She go?
Hell, no!

He didn't have
no money.

Man! I never would've
thought it could've
been this creep.

We don't know that it is,
Trish.

You know...

I thought you guys would've
blown Lenore off.

Dead hooker, who cares?

No one's getting
blown off.

Come here.

I want to show
you something.

Get in.

Hey! Not you, her.

Tight fit in here, huh?

I'm not staying anywhere
right now.

Lenore and me met

while we was studying
to be beauticians.

We hit if off right away.

Look. That's us.

( laughs gently )

Best friends, huh?

Figured you should have
a real picture of her,
not some mug shot.

What's this one?

( laughing ):
Oh...

Lenore had this rich john.

He was gonna divorce, so he gave
Lenore the diamond earrings

he had just bought
for his wife.

Nice.
Yeah.

Instead of just keeping it
for herself,

she gives me one.

We made friendship rings...
but for the belly.

Lenore had the other one, huh?

She wore it all the time.

This is difficult
for us.

We only had one child.

We understand.

FATHER:
We already know
who killed our daughter.

Uh, we have
another suspect

we want to ask you about.

Hmm.
Maybe I wasn't clear.

Roy Menard killed Holly.

Maybe I wasn't clear.

We're Homicide and we're
looking at someone else.

Who?

Barry Tepler.

He went to college
with Holly.

He was here
for Thanksgiving.

That kid was harmless.

Mr. Richardson, if someone else
is responsible,

don't you want to know that?

I know who killed Holly.
A father knows.

( sighs )

Well, Barry was infatuated
with your daughter.

So was Menard.

HOLLY:
I'll come back early,
if you break the rules

and come see a movie with me
in public.

I gotta go.
My mom has the cake out.

Is that for me?

( sweetly ):
Yeah.

( laughs )

A ticket to Paris?

( laughs )

Who was that on the phone?

A friend from school.

A man called for
you earlier.

Dad, I'm not a kid.

Then talk to me
like an adult.

Um... he is my art history
professor.

He seduced her.

He fell in love with her...
and who wouldn't?

She was just
so damn special.

RUSH:
Thought you kept your home
and campus life

separate, Roy.

Not even a phone call.
Ain't that what he said?

That's right.

Except you called Holly
on her birthday.

At her parents' house.

That's right, I did.

Open book.

Remember, Roy?

I'd forgotten about that.
And maybe you were

a little more invested in Holly
than you're telling us.

You got some other motive
here, Menard?

My motive was to get my life
and my career back.

As far as the phone call's
concerned, Holly...

insisted that I call her
on her birthday.

Said if didn't,
she was going to call me.

So what? You said your
wife knew about the affairs.

Knowing about it
in the back of your mind


and hearing a girl's voice
on the line--

they're two different things.

RUSH:
Holly told her dad
she broke things off

with you in April.

But you were still going strong
in May.

You'd tell your dad the truth
about your sex life?

VALENS:
What's all that?

( wry laugh )

Two hundred and twenty-eight...

articles on Roy Menard...

Murderer.

The President's Award
for Outstanding Lecturer.

Why can't they put
that on the news?

People like a story.

You're a postmodernist.

A what?

Well, that's the crux
of the theory, anyway.

Social construction of reality.

What are you talking about?

Society needs a narrative.

You know, given seemingly random
facts and events,

we need to weave them
into a story.

Otherwise, the world
wouldn't make any sense.

I can see that.

How do we process

this beautiful young girl dying?

We can't.

Not without a perpetrator.

And so, if one isn't obvious,
we find one.

We assign the blame.

It makes the story
complete.

It's an action--
explanation.

Order restored.

Makes some sense.

Well, I'd be even

more fascinated if I weren't
the foil of it all,

but, yes, it does.

It makes some sense.

RUSH:
Kite!

Uh, office is closed, Rush.

Seven o'clock?

Yeah, well, spare me
the Homicide mantra:

"When your day ends,
ours just begins."

It's true.

Yeah, I've seen
the t-shirt.

I don't know what I'd do
with myself

if I went home at 7:00.

Uh, you remember
the Holly Richardson job?

Yeah, everybody
wanted that one.

Why? There's nothing on it.

Pretty Ivy League girl,
philandering professor,

kind of case gets you
on Court TV.

Where you'd look like a fool,
'cause the Commonwealth
had crap?

I guess.
Have you eaten?

Look, I need a search warrant
on this kid Barry.

Do you know
any Norristown DA's?

'Cause I haven't eaten.
I need it right away.

This kid knows we're looking
at him.

Sit with me.
We'll run the case.

Or we can do it tomorrow.

I've got, like,
15 minutes at 4:30.

( quiet laugh )

( quiet groan )

Barry Tepler fits
for both jobs.

Oh, I got a narrative
on him.

A what?

A story that adds up.

He had it bad
for Holly, right?

Gets rejected by her.

Then he's hanging
around this hooker Lenore

the last few months.

Who he claims
he didn't know.

Who also rejected him.

Both girls end up
dead in the water.

Well, if he's so
in love with 'em,

why no sexual element
to these murders?

Well, Barry's
schizophrenic.

A lot of people with that
condition, no sex drive.

And the voices you hear,
they're powerful.

They tell you to kill
someone, you do it.

You're, uh,
knowledgeable, huh?

Yeah.

I know someone.

Where's Lil?

She's getting a
warrant for Barry's.

To find the hooker's
belly ring,

those letters to Holly.

Maybe he starts
owning up.

Uh-huh. All right.

Good night, Scotty.

Yeah.

So, Roy Menard
is innocent after all?

I don't
assume anything

but this Barry kid makes...

more sense.

So what's he like--
Menard?

Kind of a cad.

But a charming one?

I guess.

So you figure
a guy's bad news

if he mixes
work and pleasure?

I don't have a big
opinion on that.

Hmm.

So, uh, I'll call
this Norristown guy
in the morning.

How come we always
talk about work?

'Cause we work together.

Well, tell me
something personal.

No!

Why not?

Come on, Rush. Why not?

( laughing ):
Because...

I'm bad at it,
and...

I gotta go.

Well, let me walk you.

I'll be fine!
I'm packing.

Uh, watch...

You know...
stand still, okay?

What are you doing?

I'm going to kiss you.

No.

Just give it a try.

( laughing ):
Come on...

Come on, Rush.

All you, all you gotta do
is stand there.

Don't panic.
It's over in three seconds.

Um...

so sit with that
overnight and, uh...

see how it settles in.

( laughs quietly )

place.
Everything has its...

Everything has its place.

RUSH:
Read the warrant;
we got a right.

Why are you
doing this to me?

What did I do wrong?

VALENS:
You lied about that

flaxen-haired hooker--
asking her home and all.

I just wanted to paint her.

Pay dirt.

Guess you lied about having
these letters to Holly, too.

Please don't take those.

Got to read 'em, Barry.

They sent you to ruin my life.

I know...

they watch outside
in the shadows,

in the closet,
behind the coats...

Stress is bringing
on an episode.

You think I can't hear them?

Take him out for some air,
will you?

That high pitch? Huh?

Like a whistle?

That tries

to make you crazy?

What's it say?

"To my Holly:

"'If thou wilt needs marry,
marry a fool;

"'for wise men know well enough

what monsters
you make of them.'"

Some kind of poetry?

Maybe Shakespeare?

No belly ring
at Barry's?

Mm. Turned his place
inside out.

Maybe sold it for cash.

VERA:
"Who set this

ancient quarrel new abroach?"

What the hell? I thought this
was about a girl on a balcony.

Just find the quote
from Barry's letter.
Hold up.

"Is your name Shylock?"

That's not the quote.

I know-- it's just
the first thing

I've understood
in about an hour.

It's here, in Hamlet.

Thank God.

"If thou wilt needs marry,

"marry a fool;

"for wise men know well enough
what monsters you make of them.

To a nunnery, go,
and quickly, too."

Hamlet says it

to Ophelia.

Looks like it was
a one-sided kind of love.

He rejects her.

But Barry was
the one rejected.
RUSH:
Right.

Flip to the back.

How's it end?

Uh, she... goes
mad and drowns.

Both our vics were
found in the drink.

VERA:
The "drink"?

You the Bard now?

Monster could mean...
Barry's illness.

He blames it on Holly?

Let's find out.

About that belly ring,
Scotty's right.

Barry could've sold it--
you want to check

consignment and pawn shops?

Yeah. Once I'm finished with
this scintillating play.

Selling or buying?
Buying.

Pawn shop on the corner said
you might have what we want.

Don't give that schmuck
your business.

The schmuck that has this...

diamond belly ring...

is the one gets our business.

Just got some vintage cufflinks.

VERA:
The belly ring.

That's all we want.

You're missing out, fellas.

They're tigereye.

( quietly ):
Yeah.

This what you had in mind?

VERA:
Yeah.

Exactly.

Nice stone. Two carats.

How much?

Ten Bens.

Call the seller-- tell
him to come down here

and collect his dough.

So you saw you and Holly
as a kind of modern-day

Hamlet and
Ophelia, huh?
So?

VALENS:
That didn't end well

for that chick
in the play, Barry.

Didn't end well
for Holly, either.

It's just a letter.

"'Wise men know well
enough what monsters
you make of them.'"

You saying she made
you into a monster?

No, passion.
Passion is the monster.

I just... I...

I wanted to get her attention,

show her I was
sensitive.

Not like that old...
guy she was seeing.

Oh, you knew about Minard?

He shouldn't date students.

It's not an equal relationship.

( sighs )

So when Holly
was stupid enough

not to be moved by
your borrowed poetry...

Throw those letters
back in your face.

When she stayed in her
unequal relationship

with Minard, and
told you to leave her
the hell alone,

you wanted
to punish her.
Followed her that night,

snapped off an antenna,
then whip, whip, whip,

strangle, strangle.

Splash.

I saw her that night.

But I only talked to her.

( sniffling )
Are you okay?

Mm-hmm.

Well, I know I'm...
I know I'm not supposed

to come near you...
No, it's all right,
you can.

( sniffles )

I, uh...
Oh.

( sniffles )

What happened?

I found out what a ... I am.

You're not a ...

I saw Minard's wife...
and their kid.

They're real.
( sniffles )

I pretended
they weren't, but...

they're a family.
Guy's not right

for you anyway.

Oh. Well,
he doesn't think so.

He wants to stay together.

Really?

But, you know, the truth is,

I don't care about him.

I was just playing a game,

and I... I don't love him.

Maybe...

Maybe you could love me.

No.

I'll never love you, either.

Girl you love
says that to you,

and you just... get up
and go back to the dorm?

Yeah.

Lil.

What's going on?

Holly's mother called.

( grunting )
( tires screech )

I won't fight you.

I don't care how many
times you hit me,

Mr. Richardson,
I'm not gonna
hit you back.

this won't solve anything.
You won't take care
of this guy,

I'll do it myself.

I am taking care of it.
I'm reinvestigating.

Holly was
an innocent girl,

and this ...

took advantage of her.

MINARD:
I was wrong.

Okay? I shouldn't
have been with her.

You have every reason
to hate me for that,

but I did not
hurt Holly.
Don't say that.

I know you did it.
I know it.

Please let me handle this.

I miss her.

I know.

Holly was special.

M-Maybe you don't want
to hear that from me,

bushe talked about
you all the time.

She adored you.

I know he did it.

Whoa.

Hey...

Did you get
that warrant okay?

I did.
All right.

Thanks.
Yeah.

I guess we won't talk
about the other thing.

Yeah. Okay.
Okay.

( speaks Spanish )

Shut up!

Who's this?

Jesus Torres. Ex-con.

Tried to sell
Lenore Grandy's belly ring.

( Torres speaking Spanish )

What's he sayin'?

Something not so nice
about Vera's sister.

Well, looks like you got
two suspects now.

This ring belonged
to Lenore Grandy,

the hooker you killed
up in Norristown.

I tell you--

told you-- I didn't kill no one.

VERA:
What's your parole officer

gonna think about all this?

Six months out

and you already got
ties to two murders.

Two?

JEFFRIES:
Yeah. Lenore Grandy,

two weeks ago, Holly
Richardson in '95. Same doer.

They say, "Jesus
has not adjusted to life

after prison
the way we had hoped."

Maybe I took the diamond.

VERA:
Now, that's a start.

Yeah, but it ain't
like you say.

Hmm.

What is it like?

I go to the river.

I find the girl dead
already, in the water.

I see the ring.

I think, she don't
need it now, right?

Nah, she's iced.

That's all I do.

I steal from someone
don't need it anymore.

Now, here's my vision
for what happened, Bar.

You met Lenore in your hood,

fell in love
with that flaxen hair,

which was a lot like
Holly's...

Holly was a honey blonde.

...and thought, "Well,
here's a Holly look-alike,

"and she's just a hooker.

Maybe I can get this one."

I just wanted to paint
Lenore; I'm a painter.

But then she gives
you the high hat.

Rejected by a ...
That's humiliating.

The last straw.

So you figure, let me

give this ... the same
treatment I gave Holly.

TEST TEST

John Everett Millais
one of your favorites?

It's called "Ophelia".

I never saw that.

VALENS:
Yeah, but you do
recognize that, uh,

Lenore was posed just
like poor Ophelia here.

I don't know nothing
about paintings.

No?

All I did was steal the ring.

She was layin' in the water...

lyin' in the water already dead.

Say that again.

She was lyin' in the water dead.

Chickens lay.

People lie.

You take ESL with Mr. Roy?

No. Nah.

VALENS:
It's easy to prove, Jesus.

There's a registry
for that.

You and him made a deal,
didn't you?

Murder for hire
gets you the death penalty

nine times
out of ten, Jesus.

Lucky part for you is,
we want Roy more than you.

VALENS:
Tell your side,

we tell the DA you cooperated.

I done this before--
10,000.

MINARD:
I can't do ten.
Five maybe.

Come on, it... it's a hooker.

It'll be the easiest
money you've ever made.

( chuckles slightly )

It's so easy, you do it,

and it'll cost you nothing.

I have to
be in class

to establish my alibi.

Okay.

I do for six.

All right, but remember,
you stick to the script.

Everything's got to be done

exactly like the way it was
last time.

Comprende, Jesus?
Si.

I end up teaching this
pathetic class, and, uh...

it was all to meet
you, my friend.

( chuckles )

That's destiny.

I'll be back after this...

where I belong.

Minard, what's destiny?

It's what sets you free.

I thought it was truth.

Truth sets you free.

No. It's destiny. Trust me.

He only pay me $3,000.

So I figure
I deserved the jewelry.

Seems only fair.

Oh, thank you. Bye.

RUSH:
Back inside the Ivy walls.

Yeah, I had a lunch
with the dean.

I don't want to
appear too hopeful,

but the head of my
old department

is stepping down
in the fall.

Getting your name cleared
would help a lot, huh?

It couldn't hurt.
Well, you'll be glad to know

we have someone in custody.

No.

Who is it?
Jesus Torres.

A student in your ESL class.

Jesus... No, I'm sorry,
that doesn't ring a bell.

RUSH:
That's not what he says.

He says you told him
you killed Holly.

What?

And hired him

to kill Lenore
in a copycat killing.

That... that's absurd.

Well, I know you are

the brilliant professor,
and we're just dumb cops...

I don't think
you're dumb.

...who couldn't possibly
have heard of Ophelia.

I don't think
you're dumb.

I just think you're
falling for a story.

Almost, Minard.

I almost fell for your story.

VALENS:
But your boy Jesus

screwed up your plan.

And he got greedy,
stole something off the body.

Led us back to you.

Jesus is a lifetime criminal

with a third-world education.

I thought you didn't know him.

You have his
word against mine.

It hardly makes a case.

No. But the second body being
posed just like the first--

that makes my case.

VALENS:
Public didn't know
those details.

Only Holly's killer did.

And who's gonna believe
a dummy like Jesus

ever studied
art history.

I had to regain my station.

And Jesus offered a way
to do that.

You knew about
Barry's letters to Holly.

Calling her his "Ophelia."

She showed me a few of them.

Pillow talk, if you will.

So you just needed to find
another girl to link Barry to.

Make it look like
she was his second Ophelia.

VALENS:
Frame him for both.

Guy's just a schizo,
what's his life worth, anyway?

I contribute.

Don't look
at me like

I'm some kind of monster.

Holly shares some of the blame
of this, too.

Oh, really? What'd Holly do?

She made me love her.

You left angry...

I could tell.

What? What's wrong?

Nothing's wrong.
It's just over.

What makes you say that?

You have a wife.

Then I'll leave
her for you.
No.

I will. I will.
I really will.

I thought I loved you, but
it was only in a childish way.

You know, this
hard-to-get act

is a little
juvenile for you.

( sighs )

You know, I just
wanted to have fun.

I didn't even think
about your family.

Hey...

Did you hear what
I just said--

that I love you?

Well, I don't love you.

I don't love anyone.

Except yourself.

Yeah, and you love you, and
that's why we get along so well.

I say when it's over.

I make the rules.

(metal clanking)

I decide.

( yelps )

I decide!

I decide!

( groaning and whimpering )

I decide.

( gasps )

( Oasis' "Don't Look Back
in Anger" plays )

¶ Slip inside
the eye of your mind ¶

¶ Don't you know
you might find ¶

¶ A better place to play ¶

¶ You said that
you'd never been ¶

¶ But all the things
that you've seen ¶

¶ Slowly fade away ¶

¶ So I start a revolution
from my bed ¶

¶ 'Cause you said the brains
I had went to my head ¶

¶ Step outside,
summertime's in bloom ¶

¶ Stand up beside
the fireplace ¶

¶ Take that look
from off your face ¶

¶ You ain't never gonna
burn my heart out ¶

¶ My soul slides away ¶

¶ "But don't look back
in anger," I heard you say ¶

¶ My soul slides away... ¶

¶ "But don't look back
in anger ¶

¶ Don't look back in anger..." ¶

¶ I heard you say. ¶

Captioning sponsored by
WARNER BROS. TELEVISION