Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:00,902 --> 00:00:02,606
DOLE: Previously on
"The Practice"...
2
00:00:02,639 --> 00:00:03,641
STRINGER: Okay.
3
00:00:03,674 --> 00:00:05,110
The search seems to be bogus.
4
00:00:05,143 --> 00:00:07,816
She was pulled over for
rolling through a stop sign.
5
00:00:07,849 --> 00:00:08,951
Who's sitting? Do you know?
6
00:00:08,984 --> 00:00:10,788
Judge Brenford. Why?
7
00:00:10,822 --> 00:00:11,624
You're home.
8
00:00:11,657 --> 00:00:12,526
I'm sorry?
9
00:00:12,559 --> 00:00:14,630
Brenford is the flirting judge
10
00:00:14,663 --> 00:00:16,834
and you've got blonde hair.
11
00:00:16,867 --> 00:00:19,806
All you have to do
is smile at him,
12
00:00:19,840 --> 00:00:22,010
big smile, over the top.
13
00:00:22,410 --> 00:00:24,950
If he thinks you think
he's cute,
14
00:00:24,983 --> 00:00:26,687
he'll suppress on the spot.
15
00:00:26,720 --> 00:00:27,789
What?
16
00:00:27,822 --> 00:00:29,926
Your Honor, we'd like to,
17
00:00:29,960 --> 00:00:31,462
you know, waive reading,
18
00:00:31,495 --> 00:00:32,632
if that's all right?
19
00:00:32,666 --> 00:00:34,034
Why are you so happy?
20
00:00:34,068 --> 00:00:37,074
Just happy to be here,
Your Honor.
21
00:00:37,107 --> 00:00:38,242
Are you coming onto me?
22
00:00:38,678 --> 00:00:39,646
STRINGER: I would never,
23
00:00:39,680 --> 00:00:42,050
as hard as it is to resist.
24
00:00:46,258 --> 00:00:47,996
I cannot believe you did that.
25
00:00:48,029 --> 00:00:49,031
It was a joke, Jamie.
26
00:00:49,064 --> 00:00:49,766
Calm down.
27
00:00:49,800 --> 00:00:51,202
You humiliated me!
28
00:00:51,235 --> 00:00:54,208
I'm gonna let what little doubt
I have cut in your favor.
29
00:00:54,241 --> 00:00:55,511
I'm suppressing the search
30
00:00:55,544 --> 00:00:56,780
and dismissing the indictment.
31
00:00:56,814 --> 00:00:58,049
(gavel bangs)
32
00:00:59,519 --> 00:01:00,393
Excellent.
33
00:01:06,974 --> 00:01:08,644
You're telling me this now?
34
00:01:08,677 --> 00:01:11,684
Normally, we like to present
a united front,
35
00:01:11,717 --> 00:01:14,623
but Ellenor feels strongly
that we should plead and--
36
00:01:14,656 --> 00:01:16,827
Why?
FRUTT: Basically, the media.
37
00:01:16,860 --> 00:01:20,233
On the evidence alone,
I think our chances are okay,
38
00:01:20,266 --> 00:01:21,870
but the press is killing you.
39
00:01:21,904 --> 00:01:24,274
You're already guilty
in the public's eye.
40
00:01:24,308 --> 00:01:27,581
Jurors are instructed
to disregard
41
00:01:27,616 --> 00:01:28,918
what they see and hear.
42
00:01:28,951 --> 00:01:31,055
FRUTT: Of course
they are, but...
43
00:01:31,088 --> 00:01:35,665
these images have been on
every broadcast every night.
44
00:01:35,698 --> 00:01:37,000
Look at the pictures.
45
00:01:37,034 --> 00:01:38,638
I don't need to see
them again.
46
00:01:38,671 --> 00:01:42,044
FRUTT: Steven, to the extent
that you're in denial,
47
00:01:42,077 --> 00:01:43,446
I think you do.
48
00:01:44,048 --> 00:01:47,020
I want you to really look.
49
00:01:47,054 --> 00:01:49,793
(music playing)
50
00:01:53,868 --> 00:01:55,571
FRUTT: For the past week
51
00:01:55,604 --> 00:01:58,342
leading every broadcast.
52
00:01:58,376 --> 00:02:00,788
I'm getting a very
bad feeling.
53
00:02:10,040 --> 00:02:12,377
But you think we can win this?
54
00:02:12,410 --> 00:02:14,048
The case is circumstantial.
55
00:02:14,081 --> 00:02:16,754
On the evidence,
I think we have a shot.
56
00:02:16,787 --> 00:02:18,691
Then I'm going with you.
57
00:02:19,959 --> 00:02:21,195
No plea.
58
00:02:26,506 --> 00:02:30,547
(music playing)
59
00:03:16,814 --> 00:03:18,951
Kathy and I
met freshman year.
60
00:03:18,984 --> 00:03:21,556
She lived on my hall
in one of the dorms.
61
00:03:21,589 --> 00:03:24,394
After that, we got an
apartment off campus.
62
00:03:24,428 --> 00:03:26,566
She was my best friend
for four years.
63
00:03:26,599 --> 00:03:31,075
Amy, why did you go see
Dr. Barrett?
64
00:03:31,108 --> 00:03:33,446
Well, we both decided
to get breast implants
65
00:03:33,479 --> 00:03:35,517
as kind of a
graduation present.
66
00:03:35,752 --> 00:03:38,189
We talked to a bunch
of different doctors,
67
00:03:38,222 --> 00:03:40,627
but Kathy and Steven
had this connection.
68
00:03:40,661 --> 00:03:42,064
GAMBLE: They were a couple.
69
00:03:42,097 --> 00:03:45,571
AMY: Oh, yes, even though
he was married.
70
00:03:45,838 --> 00:03:48,376
At first, it was just
for the surgery,
71
00:03:48,409 --> 00:03:50,748
but Kathy had a thing
about older guys.
72
00:03:50,782 --> 00:03:52,484
GAMBLE: How often did you
see them together?
73
00:03:52,518 --> 00:03:53,788
AMY: All the time.
74
00:03:53,821 --> 00:03:55,724
They went out at least
a few nights a week.
75
00:03:55,758 --> 00:03:58,931
She was always talking about
the restaurants they went to
76
00:03:58,964 --> 00:04:01,308
or how great it was
at his house on the cape.
77
00:04:01,342 --> 00:04:03,948
She said they were in love.
78
00:04:03,981 --> 00:04:05,383
Did you ever see
them fight?
79
00:04:05,416 --> 00:04:08,791
AMY: I saw them
argue a lot.
80
00:04:08,824 --> 00:04:11,529
The last time was a few nights
before she was killed.
81
00:04:11,563 --> 00:04:13,901
Could you hear what they
were fighting about?
82
00:04:13,934 --> 00:04:16,005
AMY: The same thing
they always did.
83
00:04:16,038 --> 00:04:19,679
Kathy wanted Steven
to get a divorce.
84
00:04:19,712 --> 00:04:22,050
I didn't hear everything
85
00:04:22,084 --> 00:04:23,620
but it was bad.
86
00:04:23,653 --> 00:04:25,156
She slapped him,
87
00:04:25,190 --> 00:04:26,927
and she told him
to get the hell out.
88
00:04:28,964 --> 00:04:31,837
Two days later,
she was dead.
89
00:04:33,206 --> 00:04:36,145
You never heard my client
threaten Ms. Vance, did you?
90
00:04:36,178 --> 00:04:37,080
No.
91
00:04:37,113 --> 00:04:37,915
YOUNG: You never saw
him hit her
92
00:04:37,949 --> 00:04:40,086
or be violent with her
in any way?
93
00:04:40,119 --> 00:04:40,988
AMY: No.
94
00:04:41,022 --> 00:04:42,157
YOUNG: And when you saw
Ms. Vance
95
00:04:42,190 --> 00:04:44,261
slap Dr. Barrett,
96
00:04:44,294 --> 00:04:46,098
how did he respond to that?
97
00:04:46,132 --> 00:04:47,434
He didn't.
98
00:04:47,467 --> 00:04:49,071
He didn't lose his temper?
99
00:04:49,104 --> 00:04:50,406
He didn't hit her back?
100
00:04:50,440 --> 00:04:52,778
No, he just turned around
and walked out.
101
00:04:53,146 --> 00:04:54,615
YOUNG: Could you tell us
how you heard
102
00:04:54,649 --> 00:04:56,854
that Ms. Vance
had been killed?
103
00:04:56,887 --> 00:04:59,424
I got a phone call from Steven
the day she was found.
104
00:04:59,458 --> 00:05:01,536
Then how did he sound
when you talked to him?
105
00:05:01,569 --> 00:05:03,106
He was crying.
106
00:05:03,139 --> 00:05:05,343
In your opinion,
he was devastated.
107
00:05:05,376 --> 00:05:06,947
Isn't that what you told
the police?
108
00:05:08,717 --> 00:05:09,652
Yes.
109
00:05:11,689 --> 00:05:15,330
(indistinct chatter)
110
00:05:15,363 --> 00:05:17,000
(alarm buzzes)
111
00:05:30,527 --> 00:05:32,430
Thank you so much
for coming.
112
00:05:32,464 --> 00:05:34,134
Well, you left me
six messages.
113
00:05:35,270 --> 00:05:37,040
You are such
a beautiful woman.
114
00:05:38,009 --> 00:05:40,213
The newspapers
make you look fatter.
115
00:05:40,246 --> 00:05:43,386
Mr. Deeks--
I really needed to see you.
116
00:05:43,419 --> 00:05:44,388
You're the only lawyer
who could--
117
00:05:44,421 --> 00:05:46,526
DOLE: Mr. Deeks,
I need to stop you.
118
00:05:46,559 --> 00:05:49,364
I read your indictment
and the court file.
119
00:05:49,398 --> 00:05:51,669
I'm sorry. I'm not taking any
criminal cases anymore,
120
00:05:51,703 --> 00:05:53,406
especially murder cases.
121
00:05:55,310 --> 00:05:56,546
There are many
other lawyers who--
122
00:05:56,579 --> 00:05:58,984
DEEKS: Not like you.
123
00:06:00,594 --> 00:06:01,897
Why am I different?
124
00:06:02,464 --> 00:06:03,901
You killed somebody.
125
00:06:05,003 --> 00:06:07,775
You can understand
126
00:06:07,808 --> 00:06:10,046
what it feels like.
And it's in part
127
00:06:10,080 --> 00:06:11,315
because I'm still
trying to deal with--
128
00:06:11,348 --> 00:06:13,820
I killed somebody.
129
00:06:16,158 --> 00:06:17,394
I took a life.
130
00:06:19,464 --> 00:06:23,406
I need someone
who understands.
131
00:06:24,642 --> 00:06:26,212
Why?
132
00:06:26,412 --> 00:06:29,051
Because...
133
00:06:29,084 --> 00:06:31,589
I know there's something
wrong with me,
134
00:06:33,392 --> 00:06:36,766
something that just
told me to do it.
135
00:06:36,799 --> 00:06:40,841
I know it's not the same
as what you did,
136
00:06:40,874 --> 00:06:44,014
but if anyone can understand...
137
00:06:44,048 --> 00:06:45,784
look.
138
00:06:45,817 --> 00:06:47,487
I don't wanna go to jail
for the rest of my life.
139
00:06:47,521 --> 00:06:51,095
If I could get into
a hospital--
140
00:06:51,128 --> 00:06:54,101
I don't have much money
141
00:06:56,272 --> 00:06:59,244
but I'll pay you...
142
00:06:59,278 --> 00:07:00,988
everything I have.
143
00:07:08,570 --> 00:07:09,404
Hi.
144
00:07:09,438 --> 00:07:10,807
You wanted to see me?
145
00:07:10,841 --> 00:07:12,611
Yes, I did.
146
00:07:14,114 --> 00:07:16,418
I meant to grab you
after last week's hearing.
147
00:07:17,721 --> 00:07:19,859
I wanted you to know that
after a rather shaky start,
148
00:07:19,892 --> 00:07:21,829
I thought that you, uh,
149
00:07:21,863 --> 00:07:23,767
argued a persuasive motion.
150
00:07:23,800 --> 00:07:25,804
Thank you.
151
00:07:25,837 --> 00:07:27,575
This was my first
real victory.
152
00:07:27,608 --> 00:07:30,346
So I'm feeling excellent.
153
00:07:30,380 --> 00:07:32,518
BRENFORD:
Yeah, a difficult issue,
154
00:07:32,551 --> 00:07:35,190
one on which I could
have gone either way.
155
00:07:35,223 --> 00:07:37,227
Most judges, I might add,
156
00:07:37,260 --> 00:07:38,830
probably would have gone
the other way.
157
00:07:38,863 --> 00:07:42,270
STRINGER: Oh, well,
I'm glad for my side that--
158
00:07:42,304 --> 00:07:43,139
You got me.
159
00:07:43,640 --> 00:07:44,609
(chuckles)
160
00:07:45,711 --> 00:07:47,515
I thought perhaps you might
like to grab some lunch.
161
00:07:49,084 --> 00:07:51,956
Um, wouldn't that be,
162
00:07:51,990 --> 00:07:53,426
like, uh...
163
00:07:53,459 --> 00:07:54,895
incredibly improper?
164
00:07:55,931 --> 00:07:57,234
The case is over.
165
00:07:57,267 --> 00:08:00,106
I take great pride
in mentoring young lawyers.
166
00:08:00,140 --> 00:08:01,749
It's not something
that's done often enough
167
00:08:01,783 --> 00:08:02,986
in the legal community.
168
00:08:03,486 --> 00:08:05,423
Well--
169
00:08:05,456 --> 00:08:06,759
I can't order you.
170
00:08:06,793 --> 00:08:08,530
That would be an abuse
of my discretion.
171
00:08:08,563 --> 00:08:11,235
So let's just call it
a request.
172
00:08:16,779 --> 00:08:18,449
DETECTIVE: The defendant
himself notified us
173
00:08:18,482 --> 00:08:20,453
that the victim was missing.
174
00:08:20,486 --> 00:08:23,459
Upon locating her car not
far from his office,
175
00:08:23,492 --> 00:08:25,396
we conducted an area search.
176
00:08:25,430 --> 00:08:28,001
Detective, could you tell us
what you found?
177
00:08:28,036 --> 00:08:30,173
DETECTIVE: In a wooded area
behind the building,
178
00:08:30,206 --> 00:08:31,809
we located the body
of the victim.
179
00:08:31,843 --> 00:08:33,146
Identified as...
180
00:08:33,179 --> 00:08:34,715
DETECTIVE: Katherine Vance.
181
00:08:34,749 --> 00:08:37,788
She had multiple stab wounds
around her chest
182
00:08:37,821 --> 00:08:39,825
and defensive cuts
on both of her hands.
183
00:08:40,226 --> 00:08:41,663
The body was naked.
184
00:08:41,696 --> 00:08:44,535
So we requested a rape kit
be sent to the lab.
185
00:08:44,569 --> 00:08:46,773
Do you know the result
of those tests?
186
00:08:46,806 --> 00:08:49,278
It was positive for semen
inside the victim.
187
00:08:49,311 --> 00:08:51,883
The sample was a genetic
match to the defendant.
188
00:08:53,620 --> 00:08:54,789
YOUNG: My client told you
he was involved
189
00:08:54,822 --> 00:08:57,127
with Katherine Vance.
Yes.
190
00:08:57,160 --> 00:08:58,763
YOUNG: That they were having
sexual relations.
191
00:08:58,797 --> 00:08:59,799
Yes.
192
00:08:59,832 --> 00:09:01,709
So she could have been
killed by some stranger
193
00:09:01,743 --> 00:09:04,348
after having sex
with my client.
194
00:09:04,381 --> 00:09:05,584
Is that possible,
detective?
195
00:09:05,617 --> 00:09:07,254
Anything is possible.
That doesn't mean--
196
00:09:07,287 --> 00:09:08,256
YOUNG: Thank you.
197
00:09:08,289 --> 00:09:09,825
Did you find
the murder weapon?
198
00:09:09,859 --> 00:09:11,362
No, the knife
was never recovered.
199
00:09:11,395 --> 00:09:13,099
YOUNG: And what about
the victim's blood?
200
00:09:13,132 --> 00:09:14,835
Could you connect it
with my client?
201
00:09:14,869 --> 00:09:16,072
No.
202
00:09:16,172 --> 00:09:18,843
YOUNG: So you searched
his office, his house,
203
00:09:18,877 --> 00:09:21,182
his car, his clothes.
204
00:09:21,215 --> 00:09:24,321
Did you find any trace
of the victim's blood?
205
00:09:24,354 --> 00:09:25,691
No.
206
00:09:25,724 --> 00:09:27,795
Does it make sense to you,
detective,
207
00:09:27,828 --> 00:09:29,899
that he would be so
meticulous about the blood
208
00:09:29,932 --> 00:09:32,370
and physical evidence
only to dump the body
209
00:09:32,404 --> 00:09:34,274
right behind
his own office building?
210
00:09:34,308 --> 00:09:36,112
Murders don't typically
make sense.
211
00:09:36,145 --> 00:09:37,948
He called the police.
212
00:09:37,981 --> 00:09:39,785
He led you to her car.
213
00:09:39,819 --> 00:09:43,226
He gave you a sample
of his own DNA.
214
00:09:43,259 --> 00:09:44,562
All true?
215
00:09:44,595 --> 00:09:45,931
Yes.
216
00:09:48,570 --> 00:09:50,373
You understand I confessed.
217
00:09:50,406 --> 00:09:52,945
I do, but you only
confessed after
218
00:09:52,978 --> 00:09:55,049
they discovered the body
in the trunk.
219
00:09:55,082 --> 00:09:56,819
If we can suppress
the search,
220
00:09:56,853 --> 00:09:58,790
the confession
goes out, too.
221
00:09:58,823 --> 00:10:00,634
That would give us some
leverage to make a deal,
222
00:10:00,667 --> 00:10:04,642
which we would need
to get you in a hospital.
223
00:10:04,675 --> 00:10:05,777
Are you with me?
224
00:10:06,212 --> 00:10:08,116
You can undo my confession?
225
00:10:08,149 --> 00:10:09,351
Maybe.
226
00:10:09,585 --> 00:10:11,756
But I'm willing to confess
if that is what--
227
00:10:11,789 --> 00:10:14,093
DOLE: I understand,
but the problem with that
228
00:10:14,128 --> 00:10:17,300
is we would be left
with no bargaining power.
229
00:10:17,334 --> 00:10:18,637
Can you appreciate that?
230
00:10:19,404 --> 00:10:20,641
Yes.
231
00:10:20,674 --> 00:10:22,678
I just don't wanna go
to a prison.
232
00:10:22,711 --> 00:10:25,115
Anything to keep me out
of prison.
233
00:10:25,150 --> 00:10:26,385
DOLE: I understand.
234
00:10:28,523 --> 00:10:31,262
Now, you answer
only what I ask you,
235
00:10:31,295 --> 00:10:32,565
nothing more, because--
236
00:10:32,598 --> 00:10:34,434
I strangled her.
237
00:10:35,971 --> 00:10:39,378
Stanley,
I know you're ill,
238
00:10:39,411 --> 00:10:41,248
and I know you
wanna get better.
239
00:10:41,282 --> 00:10:42,350
Carol.
240
00:10:44,321 --> 00:10:45,423
I'm sorry?
241
00:10:45,456 --> 00:10:48,362
Her name was Carol.
242
00:10:48,396 --> 00:10:50,634
She worked in my building.
243
00:10:51,034 --> 00:10:53,105
She was very nice to me.
244
00:10:53,138 --> 00:10:56,111
I was a security guard
and I killed her.
245
00:10:58,015 --> 00:11:00,085
Listen to me.
246
00:11:00,119 --> 00:11:02,898
I will never succeed
in keeping you out of prison
247
00:11:02,931 --> 00:11:04,234
if you don't do as I say.
248
00:11:05,737 --> 00:11:07,575
Do not be telling anybody else
249
00:11:07,608 --> 00:11:09,178
you strangled this girl.
250
00:11:10,514 --> 00:11:11,883
Are we clear?
251
00:11:14,989 --> 00:11:16,325
Okay.
252
00:11:26,148 --> 00:11:27,918
You're the D. A. on this?
253
00:11:27,951 --> 00:11:30,156
Perfect, isn't it?
254
00:11:30,189 --> 00:11:31,525
I graduate to the rubber room
255
00:11:31,558 --> 00:11:32,828
after trying to put you away.
256
00:11:32,861 --> 00:11:34,998
One month on the happy farm,
I'm back,
257
00:11:35,032 --> 00:11:38,639
only to find myself
up against--boom.
258
00:11:38,672 --> 00:11:40,276
Oh, that's what I call you.
259
00:11:40,309 --> 00:11:42,613
I used to give my defendants
a one word moniker.
260
00:11:42,647 --> 00:11:43,883
It's how I kept track.
261
00:11:43,916 --> 00:11:47,123
My name for you was "boom"
262
00:11:47,157 --> 00:11:48,625
since you were a shooter.
263
00:11:48,659 --> 00:11:50,129
I see. Listen--
264
00:11:50,163 --> 00:11:51,665
WALSH:
Now, I call you "techie"
265
00:11:51,698 --> 00:11:54,104
since you got off
on a technicality.
266
00:11:54,137 --> 00:11:57,076
Which do you like better,
boom or techie?
267
00:12:02,293 --> 00:12:03,395
Lindsay...
268
00:12:04,898 --> 00:12:07,036
I'm sort of half kidding.
269
00:12:07,069 --> 00:12:10,409
I'm trying to make light
of my situation
270
00:12:10,443 --> 00:12:12,413
because I'm...
271
00:12:12,613 --> 00:12:15,987
so deeply embarrassed
over, uh--
272
00:12:17,257 --> 00:12:21,899
listen, I'm not gonna
give you a hug,
273
00:12:21,932 --> 00:12:25,273
but I'll try to be fair
274
00:12:25,306 --> 00:12:28,078
and more importantly,
275
00:12:28,112 --> 00:12:30,950
a noble officer
of the court....
276
00:12:32,553 --> 00:12:33,722
really.
277
00:12:37,597 --> 00:12:38,699
Walsh?
278
00:12:38,732 --> 00:12:41,070
Why would they put one
of their top people on this?
279
00:12:41,105 --> 00:12:42,807
DOLE: Stanley,
this is a murder case.
280
00:12:42,840 --> 00:12:44,277
You strangled somebody.
281
00:12:44,311 --> 00:12:46,949
Look, I'll confess.
282
00:12:46,982 --> 00:12:48,185
Don't start that again.
283
00:12:48,219 --> 00:12:51,090
He is gonna go for prison.
284
00:12:51,125 --> 00:12:53,429
Calm down.
285
00:12:53,462 --> 00:12:55,233
What if...
286
00:12:55,399 --> 00:12:58,305
I can give them
other information
287
00:12:58,339 --> 00:13:00,683
I can trade in exchange
288
00:13:00,716 --> 00:13:02,620
for getting in a hospital
289
00:13:02,653 --> 00:13:04,291
instead of jail?
290
00:13:05,859 --> 00:13:07,463
What other information?
291
00:13:07,998 --> 00:13:10,203
I did other things...
292
00:13:11,805 --> 00:13:13,142
that they don't know about.
293
00:13:13,175 --> 00:13:14,877
I don't wanna know
about it either.
294
00:13:16,080 --> 00:13:18,885
Look, let's tackle
the suppression hearing
295
00:13:18,920 --> 00:13:21,825
and then go from there, okay?
296
00:13:23,695 --> 00:13:24,564
Carol.
297
00:13:24,897 --> 00:13:25,899
What?
298
00:13:28,105 --> 00:13:30,243
Her name was Carol.
299
00:13:37,723 --> 00:13:40,028
I don't deny
having the affair.
300
00:13:40,062 --> 00:13:41,631
Doctor, did you see
Kathy Vance
301
00:13:41,665 --> 00:13:43,169
the night she was killed?
302
00:13:43,202 --> 00:13:44,704
STEVEN: Yes, she stopped
by the office.
303
00:13:44,737 --> 00:13:46,675
That's where
we would often meet.
304
00:13:46,708 --> 00:13:49,681
I work there at night
when the staff is gone and--
305
00:13:49,714 --> 00:13:50,649
Can you tell us
what happened
306
00:13:50,683 --> 00:13:51,918
that particular night?
307
00:13:52,120 --> 00:13:54,124
STEVEN: She came
by a little after 9:00,
308
00:13:54,824 --> 00:13:57,463
hung around while
I finished some work.
309
00:13:57,497 --> 00:14:00,676
After that, we opened up
a bottle of wine.
310
00:14:00,709 --> 00:14:01,911
We made love.
311
00:14:01,946 --> 00:14:02,847
In the office?
312
00:14:02,880 --> 00:14:03,582
Yes.
313
00:14:03,615 --> 00:14:05,186
FRUTT: And after?
314
00:14:05,219 --> 00:14:07,723
She left. She said
she had a party to go to.
315
00:14:08,058 --> 00:14:09,294
I walked her to the door.
316
00:14:09,327 --> 00:14:11,966
We said goodbye and that was...
317
00:14:11,999 --> 00:14:14,003
the last time that I saw her.
318
00:14:14,036 --> 00:14:16,141
When did you realize
something was wrong?
319
00:14:16,175 --> 00:14:18,512
STEVEN: Later that night
when I left to go home,
320
00:14:18,545 --> 00:14:20,649
I saw her car was still
in the parking lot.
321
00:14:20,683 --> 00:14:22,620
I knew that it
didn't make any sense,
322
00:14:22,653 --> 00:14:26,027
but I thought perhaps
she got a ride from a friend,
323
00:14:26,060 --> 00:14:28,965
so it didn't really bother me.
324
00:14:29,000 --> 00:14:31,371
The next day,
her car was still there.
325
00:14:31,405 --> 00:14:32,373
And what did you do?
326
00:14:32,407 --> 00:14:34,043
STEVEN:
Now, I got concerned.
327
00:14:34,076 --> 00:14:35,613
I called her roommate,
Amy Wyatt.
328
00:14:35,646 --> 00:14:38,852
She told me that Kathy
hadn't been home all night.
329
00:14:38,885 --> 00:14:40,123
I hung up the phone.
330
00:14:40,156 --> 00:14:43,329
I immediately called
the police.
331
00:14:43,362 --> 00:14:45,499
They found her
later that day.
332
00:14:45,533 --> 00:14:48,639
FRUTT: Dr. Barrett,
did you kill Kathy Vance?
333
00:14:49,641 --> 00:14:51,378
No.
334
00:14:51,411 --> 00:14:54,484
I cared
about Kathy very much.
335
00:14:54,517 --> 00:14:56,921
I have done everything
in my power
336
00:14:56,955 --> 00:14:57,923
to help the police.
337
00:14:58,625 --> 00:15:01,105
I swear, I don't know
what happened to her.
338
00:15:02,807 --> 00:15:04,577
I wish to God that I did.
339
00:15:14,497 --> 00:15:16,635
GAMBLE: You recognize
this bottle, doctor?
340
00:15:16,668 --> 00:15:18,872
It looks like a prescription
bottle for painkillers.
341
00:15:19,974 --> 00:15:23,449
A prescription you wrote
for Katherine Vance, correct?
342
00:15:23,482 --> 00:15:26,355
Yes. Kathy was still
experiencing some discomfort.
343
00:15:26,388 --> 00:15:28,559
Pain medication
was an appropriate treatment.
344
00:15:28,592 --> 00:15:30,729
Well, according to her
autopsy results,
345
00:15:30,763 --> 00:15:32,900
she wasn't taking
any pain medication.
346
00:15:32,933 --> 00:15:36,006
In fact, there were
no medications
347
00:15:36,040 --> 00:15:37,410
found in her system.
348
00:15:37,443 --> 00:15:39,481
STEVEN: I don't know
why that would be.
349
00:15:39,514 --> 00:15:41,518
GAMBLE: Doctor,
this bottle is half empty.
350
00:15:41,551 --> 00:15:44,991
It was found in your desk
in your office.
351
00:15:45,024 --> 00:15:46,060
She must have left
them there.
352
00:15:46,094 --> 00:15:47,463
GAMBLE: Well,
I'm sure she did because
353
00:15:47,497 --> 00:15:49,701
you were the one
who was taking the pills.
354
00:15:49,734 --> 00:15:52,005
That's absolutely false.
355
00:15:52,038 --> 00:15:55,044
(music playing)
356
00:15:56,681 --> 00:15:58,419
GAMBLE: I have here
357
00:15:58,452 --> 00:16:02,633
seven prescriptions
written by you,
358
00:16:02,667 --> 00:16:04,904
all in the name
of Katherine Vance.
359
00:16:04,937 --> 00:16:07,843
They were all filled
in different locations,
360
00:16:07,877 --> 00:16:09,981
all in the last few months.
361
00:16:12,853 --> 00:16:15,493
Why so many prescriptions,
doctor?
362
00:16:17,563 --> 00:16:20,769
We also ran some new tests
363
00:16:20,803 --> 00:16:23,007
on your blood sample.
364
00:16:23,040 --> 00:16:26,215
Would you care to amend
your answer now, doctor?
365
00:16:30,423 --> 00:16:32,293
Okay.
366
00:16:32,327 --> 00:16:35,266
Look, I have a problem.
367
00:16:36,435 --> 00:16:38,272
She was getting
the pills for me,
368
00:16:39,307 --> 00:16:42,613
but you're talking about
my addiction.
369
00:16:44,151 --> 00:16:46,155
That doesn't make me
a murderer.
370
00:16:55,673 --> 00:16:57,643
Why didn't you tell us,
Steven?
371
00:17:00,149 --> 00:17:02,025
I'm sorry.
372
00:17:02,058 --> 00:17:03,895
I was trying
to protect myself.
373
00:17:06,066 --> 00:17:07,837
I knew how it would look.
374
00:17:08,905 --> 00:17:10,976
Now, I'm with Ellenor.
375
00:17:11,009 --> 00:17:13,349
We need to think
about taking a plea.
376
00:17:13,382 --> 00:17:16,221
A plea of what?
377
00:17:16,755 --> 00:17:17,757
Murder two.
378
00:17:20,629 --> 00:17:22,333
I didn't kill anyone.
379
00:17:22,367 --> 00:17:24,537
But it looks
very much like you did.
380
00:17:25,373 --> 00:17:27,142
You were last seen with her,
381
00:17:27,177 --> 00:17:29,045
your semen was found in her,
382
00:17:29,079 --> 00:17:30,416
and she was in the woods
383
00:17:30,449 --> 00:17:32,453
behind your office.
384
00:17:32,487 --> 00:17:35,193
Someone killed her
385
00:17:35,226 --> 00:17:37,230
after she left the office.
386
00:17:37,663 --> 00:17:39,801
FRUTT: Steven,
we put you up there
387
00:17:39,834 --> 00:17:42,573
so you would look like
a responsible doctor,
388
00:17:42,607 --> 00:17:44,711
the kind of person incapable
389
00:17:44,744 --> 00:17:46,615
of committing a crime.
390
00:17:47,217 --> 00:17:49,085
You came off that stand
391
00:17:49,120 --> 00:17:50,789
a drug-addicted liar.
392
00:17:52,126 --> 00:17:54,264
I agree with Eugene.
393
00:17:54,297 --> 00:17:58,037
We at least have to think
about a plea.
394
00:17:58,070 --> 00:18:00,676
I didn't kill her, Ellenor.
395
00:18:02,587 --> 00:18:04,224
That's the truth.
396
00:18:08,765 --> 00:18:11,036
I'm not gonna plead
to second-degree murder.
397
00:18:18,151 --> 00:18:19,186
(sighs)
398
00:18:20,523 --> 00:18:22,260
What do you mean
you had lunch with him?
399
00:18:22,393 --> 00:18:23,495
I just--
400
00:18:23,529 --> 00:18:25,366
BERLUTI: The judge who
just handled your motion?
401
00:18:25,399 --> 00:18:26,601
Yes.
402
00:18:26,635 --> 00:18:28,505
He asked me yesterday.
403
00:18:28,539 --> 00:18:31,978
I felt I better not refuse.
404
00:18:32,011 --> 00:18:34,015
You better not refuse?
405
00:18:34,049 --> 00:18:35,353
STRINGER:
He said it was a request,
406
00:18:35,386 --> 00:18:37,290
but he said it in a way
407
00:18:37,323 --> 00:18:40,027
like there would be
repercussions.
408
00:18:40,061 --> 00:18:41,731
So you went to lunch.
409
00:18:41,765 --> 00:18:42,833
STRINGER: Yes.
410
00:18:42,867 --> 00:18:43,902
And what happened?
411
00:18:43,935 --> 00:18:45,573
Nothing. We had lunch, uh,
412
00:18:45,606 --> 00:18:47,008
talked about the law.
413
00:18:47,041 --> 00:18:49,681
It seemed pretty innocent
and then it was over.
414
00:18:52,787 --> 00:18:54,691
And then he asked me out
for a drink.
415
00:18:54,724 --> 00:18:55,859
And what did you say?
416
00:18:55,893 --> 00:18:56,895
I said I couldn't.
417
00:18:56,928 --> 00:18:58,899
I had work and...
418
00:19:01,411 --> 00:19:02,947
"maybe tomorrow."
419
00:19:02,980 --> 00:19:04,284
Would you like me
to go to him?
420
00:19:04,317 --> 00:19:06,821
No. God. No.
421
00:19:06,855 --> 00:19:10,596
Well, this is
a treacherous thing.
422
00:19:10,629 --> 00:19:13,033
The last thing a young
attorney needs--
423
00:19:13,067 --> 00:19:14,304
I'll call it off.
424
00:19:14,337 --> 00:19:16,073
You want me to go with you?
425
00:19:16,107 --> 00:19:17,643
No.
426
00:19:17,677 --> 00:19:19,514
I will tell him no.
427
00:19:23,154 --> 00:19:25,593
I saw a vehicle stopped
on the side of the road.
428
00:19:25,626 --> 00:19:27,162
At first, I thought it
was a police car
429
00:19:27,196 --> 00:19:28,699
because of the lights
on the roof
430
00:19:28,732 --> 00:19:30,168
and the way it was painted.
431
00:19:30,202 --> 00:19:31,905
Did you see anyone near
the vehicle?
432
00:19:31,938 --> 00:19:33,141
The defendant.
433
00:19:33,174 --> 00:19:35,077
He was in what looked like
a policeman's uniform
434
00:19:35,112 --> 00:19:36,748
and was standing
at the rear of the car.
435
00:19:36,781 --> 00:19:38,752
The trunk was open,
and he had a flashlight,
436
00:19:38,785 --> 00:19:40,956
so I assumed he was trying
to change a flat tire.
437
00:19:40,989 --> 00:19:42,560
What did you do?
I pulled over myself
438
00:19:42,593 --> 00:19:44,029
to see if I could help.
439
00:19:44,062 --> 00:19:45,866
That's when I realized
he wasn't one of us.
440
00:19:45,899 --> 00:19:48,572
He was a security guard
for a private company.
441
00:19:48,605 --> 00:19:51,043
And what happened after
you saw him, officer?
442
00:19:51,076 --> 00:19:52,913
Well, the minute he saw me,
he slammed the trunk
443
00:19:52,947 --> 00:19:54,484
like he didn't want me
to see inside.
444
00:19:54,784 --> 00:19:56,521
So naturally,
I got suspicious.
445
00:19:56,555 --> 00:19:57,790
I asked him,
"What's going on?"
446
00:19:57,823 --> 00:19:59,661
He told me he was just
having a cigarette.
447
00:19:59,694 --> 00:20:01,571
Company wouldn't allow him
to smoke in the car,
448
00:20:01,605 --> 00:20:03,108
only I didn't see any
cigarettes.
449
00:20:03,141 --> 00:20:05,946
He was acting in a furtive
and suspicious manner?
450
00:20:05,979 --> 00:20:07,817
Objection.
Sustained.
451
00:20:07,850 --> 00:20:09,321
Were you afraid
he might go for a weapon?
452
00:20:09,354 --> 00:20:10,188
Objection.
453
00:20:10,222 --> 00:20:11,525
Mr. Walsh...
454
00:20:12,360 --> 00:20:15,132
HOPE: I tried to follow up
with a few more questions,
455
00:20:15,165 --> 00:20:16,968
where he worked,
what shift he was on,
456
00:20:17,001 --> 00:20:18,772
only he wouldn't say anything.
457
00:20:18,805 --> 00:20:21,511
He just stood there
and then he tried to leave.
458
00:20:21,545 --> 00:20:22,547
Did you let him go?
459
00:20:22,813 --> 00:20:24,617
No, I could tell
something was wrong.
460
00:20:24,651 --> 00:20:27,523
So I asked him to open up
the trunk and he did.
461
00:20:27,557 --> 00:20:28,859
And what was in the trunk?
462
00:20:28,892 --> 00:20:31,565
HOPE: I found a woman, a body.
463
00:20:31,598 --> 00:20:34,002
It was lying on its side
in a curled up position.
464
00:20:34,035 --> 00:20:36,541
There were bruises
all around the neck,
465
00:20:36,575 --> 00:20:38,712
the apparent victim
of strangulation.
466
00:20:38,745 --> 00:20:41,049
It was later I learned
it was Carol Dalton.
467
00:20:43,188 --> 00:20:45,393
You asked him to open
the trunk or told him to?
468
00:20:45,426 --> 00:20:46,561
It was a request.
469
00:20:46,595 --> 00:20:48,865
Where was your weapon?
It was drawn.
470
00:20:48,899 --> 00:20:50,436
So it was a request
while you were pointing
471
00:20:50,469 --> 00:20:51,371
a gun at him.
472
00:20:51,705 --> 00:20:52,773
Yes.
473
00:20:52,973 --> 00:20:54,042
DOLE: You didn't know
there was a body
474
00:20:54,075 --> 00:20:55,513
in the trunk, did you?
475
00:20:55,546 --> 00:20:57,349
Not before
he opened it, no.
476
00:20:57,383 --> 00:20:58,952
DOLE: Didn't see blood
on the car
477
00:20:58,985 --> 00:21:00,355
or the defendant's clothes?
478
00:21:00,389 --> 00:21:01,224
HOPE: No.
479
00:21:01,257 --> 00:21:02,733
DOLE: What about sounds
from inside?
480
00:21:02,767 --> 00:21:04,571
Did you hear screaming
or cries for help?
481
00:21:04,604 --> 00:21:06,575
Obviously not.
She was dead.
482
00:21:06,608 --> 00:21:09,514
So as I understand
your testimony,
483
00:21:09,547 --> 00:21:11,217
if he had had cigarettes,
484
00:21:11,250 --> 00:21:12,820
you wouldn't have searched
his trunk.
485
00:21:12,853 --> 00:21:14,891
That's not what I said.
I testified
486
00:21:14,924 --> 00:21:16,461
he was acting suspiciously.
487
00:21:16,495 --> 00:21:18,765
Because he didn't have
cigarettes and was evasive
488
00:21:18,799 --> 00:21:19,934
about where he worked.
489
00:21:19,967 --> 00:21:22,306
HOPE: He wouldn't answer
any of my questions.
490
00:21:22,339 --> 00:21:23,809
DOLE: So you searched
his trunk
491
00:21:23,842 --> 00:21:25,879
because he chose not to talk.
492
00:21:25,913 --> 00:21:28,519
Your client had a dead woman
in the trunk of his car.
493
00:21:28,552 --> 00:21:30,789
Bottom line, I was right.
494
00:21:30,823 --> 00:21:32,326
DOLE: Is it your testimony
when you asked him
495
00:21:32,359 --> 00:21:33,462
to open the trunk,
496
00:21:33,495 --> 00:21:35,766
you suspected
he had a dead woman inside?
497
00:21:35,799 --> 00:21:37,202
I knew he had something.
498
00:21:37,236 --> 00:21:39,441
DOLE: You knew he had something,
499
00:21:39,474 --> 00:21:41,009
just not cigarettes.
500
00:21:45,586 --> 00:21:46,955
Now what?
501
00:21:46,988 --> 00:21:48,792
We'll make summations
to the judge.
502
00:21:48,825 --> 00:21:50,395
If we win, like I said,
503
00:21:50,429 --> 00:21:51,364
we're in a position--
504
00:21:51,397 --> 00:21:52,700
What if we lose?
505
00:21:54,236 --> 00:21:57,910
Then we'll either plead
or go to trial.
506
00:21:58,712 --> 00:22:02,392
So maybe I have better
negotiation power now.
507
00:22:02,427 --> 00:22:05,097
Maybe we can make
a deal now.
508
00:22:05,132 --> 00:22:06,200
DOLE: Stanley,
509
00:22:06,601 --> 00:22:09,072
they're not willing
to deal now,
510
00:22:09,106 --> 00:22:10,342
and even if they were,
511
00:22:10,375 --> 00:22:12,379
you have good
fourth-amendment issues here.
512
00:22:13,314 --> 00:22:16,053
My advice would be
to play this hearing out.
513
00:22:17,523 --> 00:22:18,424
Okay.
514
00:22:21,698 --> 00:22:23,469
Okay.
515
00:22:24,303 --> 00:22:26,741
Commonwealth has one rebuttal
witness, Your Honor.
516
00:22:26,775 --> 00:22:29,213
We call Margot Barrett.
YOUNG: Objection.
517
00:22:29,246 --> 00:22:31,317
Margot Barrett enjoys
spousal privilege.
518
00:22:31,350 --> 00:22:32,787
The Commonwealth knows--
GAMBLE: And Mrs. Barrett
519
00:22:32,820 --> 00:22:34,456
has the right to exercise it,
520
00:22:34,491 --> 00:22:37,095
not Mr. Young's
or his client's.
521
00:22:37,129 --> 00:22:39,601
Margot Barrett
is willing to testify.
522
00:22:39,634 --> 00:22:41,805
She can't testify
about private conversations.
523
00:22:41,838 --> 00:22:43,341
That's not why
we're calling her.
524
00:22:43,475 --> 00:22:44,276
Approach.
525
00:22:50,122 --> 00:22:51,858
This is definitely
unfair surprise.
526
00:22:51,891 --> 00:22:53,128
She's on the witness list.
527
00:22:53,161 --> 00:22:54,196
YOUNG: Ours not yours.
528
00:22:54,230 --> 00:22:55,599
GAMBLE: Point is you're
prepared for her.
529
00:22:55,633 --> 00:22:56,535
No, we are not.
530
00:22:56,768 --> 00:22:58,304
Have you interviewed
this woman?
531
00:22:58,505 --> 00:22:59,373
Yes.
532
00:22:59,406 --> 00:23:00,676
Then what's the problem?
533
00:23:00,709 --> 00:23:02,587
The problem is it's unfair
surprise--
534
00:23:02,620 --> 00:23:05,091
GAMBLE: I'm only calling her
to impeach.
535
00:23:05,125 --> 00:23:05,993
WHITE: All right, look,
536
00:23:06,026 --> 00:23:07,897
we'll suspend for the day
537
00:23:07,930 --> 00:23:09,901
so defense can get ready.
538
00:23:09,934 --> 00:23:12,339
Tomorrow, we'll start
with Mrs. Barrett.
539
00:23:13,108 --> 00:23:14,443
Now step back.
540
00:23:15,679 --> 00:23:16,380
We're adjourned.
541
00:23:16,414 --> 00:23:17,081
(gavel bangs)
542
00:23:19,420 --> 00:23:20,923
What the hell
is she going to say?
543
00:23:20,956 --> 00:23:23,194
I have no idea.
544
00:23:23,228 --> 00:23:24,864
(music playing)
545
00:23:32,904 --> 00:23:34,307
DOLE: Your Honor,
546
00:23:34,340 --> 00:23:35,676
we can all guess
547
00:23:35,710 --> 00:23:37,880
that my client likely murdered
548
00:23:37,914 --> 00:23:39,984
a beautiful young woman
549
00:23:40,018 --> 00:23:41,154
and he went to that park
550
00:23:41,187 --> 00:23:42,356
to dispose of her body,
551
00:23:42,389 --> 00:23:44,460
but like it or not,
552
00:23:44,494 --> 00:23:46,131
that has nothing to do
553
00:23:46,164 --> 00:23:47,567
with this hearing.
554
00:23:48,101 --> 00:23:49,871
Officer Hope saw my client
555
00:23:49,904 --> 00:23:51,775
standing by his car.
556
00:23:51,808 --> 00:23:53,445
He didn't see any blood,
557
00:23:53,478 --> 00:23:54,948
didn't hear any screams,
558
00:23:54,981 --> 00:23:57,587
nothing to justify
searching the vehicle.
559
00:23:58,188 --> 00:24:01,134
Slamming a trunk
isn't probable cause.
560
00:24:01,167 --> 00:24:03,872
Refusing to talk
isn't probable cause.
561
00:24:03,906 --> 00:24:05,242
Acting nervous
562
00:24:05,275 --> 00:24:07,547
isn't probable cause.
563
00:24:08,281 --> 00:24:11,287
I know it offends
our sense of justice
564
00:24:11,321 --> 00:24:12,323
to free a man
565
00:24:12,356 --> 00:24:14,327
who has perhaps
committed murder,
566
00:24:14,360 --> 00:24:16,064
but the courts have said
567
00:24:16,097 --> 00:24:17,266
it offends us more
568
00:24:17,299 --> 00:24:18,769
to let the police get away
569
00:24:18,802 --> 00:24:21,241
with unreasonable searches.
570
00:24:22,276 --> 00:24:26,016
This is criminal procedure 101.
571
00:24:26,050 --> 00:24:27,720
WALSH: This search
was nothing,
572
00:24:27,754 --> 00:24:29,457
but reasonable.
573
00:24:29,490 --> 00:24:31,094
It was late at night
574
00:24:31,127 --> 00:24:32,630
in a deserted park.
575
00:24:32,664 --> 00:24:33,966
There was no reason
576
00:24:33,999 --> 00:24:35,502
for the defendant
to be there
577
00:24:35,536 --> 00:24:38,141
and the reason he gave
was clearly a lie.
578
00:24:38,175 --> 00:24:40,044
Imagine being there
that night.
579
00:24:40,079 --> 00:24:41,314
Imagine seeing him
580
00:24:41,347 --> 00:24:42,750
race to that trunk,
581
00:24:42,784 --> 00:24:44,019
slam it down,
582
00:24:44,052 --> 00:24:47,025
then refuse to answer
the most basic questions.
583
00:24:47,059 --> 00:24:48,328
The nervous voice,
584
00:24:48,361 --> 00:24:49,964
the lack of eye contact,
585
00:24:49,998 --> 00:24:52,336
the fact that he tried
to flee the scene,
586
00:24:52,369 --> 00:24:54,207
the defendant was acting
587
00:24:54,240 --> 00:24:55,442
like a criminal,
588
00:24:55,475 --> 00:24:56,778
someone in the process
589
00:24:56,812 --> 00:24:58,315
of committing a crime.
590
00:24:58,348 --> 00:25:00,793
Officer Hope
had probable cause
591
00:25:00,826 --> 00:25:02,363
to believe a crime
was occurring,
592
00:25:02,396 --> 00:25:05,169
and the evidence
was inside that trunk.
593
00:25:06,572 --> 00:25:07,907
He was right
594
00:25:09,277 --> 00:25:12,216
and that may not decide
the question,
595
00:25:12,249 --> 00:25:13,619
but it certainly tells you
596
00:25:13,652 --> 00:25:16,023
he was reading the signs.
597
00:25:16,424 --> 00:25:17,994
Ms. Dole wants to talk
598
00:25:18,027 --> 00:25:21,134
about offending justice.
599
00:25:21,534 --> 00:25:22,870
She's asking you
600
00:25:22,904 --> 00:25:24,841
to set a murderer free.
601
00:25:28,716 --> 00:25:30,185
Your husband testified
602
00:25:30,219 --> 00:25:31,622
that when he went
home the night
603
00:25:31,655 --> 00:25:33,525
of Katherine Vance's death,
604
00:25:33,558 --> 00:25:35,830
he wasn't bothered.
605
00:25:35,863 --> 00:25:36,898
Mrs. Barrett,
606
00:25:37,299 --> 00:25:39,938
did he seem unbothered to you?
607
00:25:39,971 --> 00:25:41,507
No.
608
00:25:41,541 --> 00:25:43,478
He came home that night
609
00:25:43,511 --> 00:25:45,249
and he seemed agitated.
610
00:25:45,282 --> 00:25:46,251
Agitated.
611
00:25:46,284 --> 00:25:46,985
MARGOT: Yes.
612
00:25:47,353 --> 00:25:48,722
And he had
just taken a shower
613
00:25:48,756 --> 00:25:49,924
before coming home,
614
00:25:49,958 --> 00:25:51,895
which I felt was very odd.
615
00:25:52,263 --> 00:25:54,233
GAMBLE: Did you ask him
what was wrong?
616
00:25:54,267 --> 00:25:54,934
MARGOT: Yes.
617
00:25:54,968 --> 00:25:57,139
He said nothing.
618
00:25:57,173 --> 00:25:59,210
But--
But what?
619
00:25:59,844 --> 00:26:01,053
From my perspective,
620
00:26:01,087 --> 00:26:03,826
it seemed something
traumatic had happened.
621
00:26:03,859 --> 00:26:05,129
GAMBLE: Mrs. Barrett,
622
00:26:05,162 --> 00:26:07,199
do you think
your husband killed--
623
00:26:07,233 --> 00:26:08,636
Objection.
FRUTT: Objection.
624
00:26:08,669 --> 00:26:09,570
WHITE: Sustained.
625
00:26:10,139 --> 00:26:11,341
I have nothing further.
626
00:26:14,781 --> 00:26:16,084
YOUNG: Did you call the police
627
00:26:16,117 --> 00:26:17,754
with any of your suspicions?
628
00:26:17,787 --> 00:26:18,889
No,
629
00:26:18,922 --> 00:26:20,459
he's my husband
and I was hoping to be--
630
00:26:20,492 --> 00:26:21,928
YOUNG:
Oh, he's your husband now.
631
00:26:22,997 --> 00:26:24,533
You said he took a shower.
632
00:26:24,567 --> 00:26:26,738
Is it your testimony
that he never showered
633
00:26:26,772 --> 00:26:28,341
at work before coming home?
634
00:26:28,375 --> 00:26:30,445
No, he sometimes--
YOUNG: Is it your testimony
635
00:26:30,479 --> 00:26:32,717
that he never came home
from work upset?
636
00:26:32,750 --> 00:26:34,653
No, but here, it was very--
YOUNG: Is it your testimony
637
00:26:34,688 --> 00:26:35,690
that--
Ask that the witness
638
00:26:35,723 --> 00:26:37,226
be allowed to respond.
639
00:26:37,259 --> 00:26:38,561
She answered my question.
640
00:26:39,263 --> 00:26:40,866
Can you describe for this court
641
00:26:40,900 --> 00:26:42,636
your marriage,
Mrs. Barrett?
642
00:26:44,140 --> 00:26:45,275
It's rocky.
643
00:26:45,309 --> 00:26:46,377
YOUNG: Rocky?
644
00:26:46,411 --> 00:26:48,047
You've talked about divorce,
haven't you?
645
00:26:48,081 --> 00:26:49,884
MARGOT: Yes.
YOUNG: Well, with a divorce,
646
00:26:49,918 --> 00:26:50,820
you could get half.
647
00:26:50,853 --> 00:26:52,323
If he should go to prison,
648
00:26:52,356 --> 00:26:53,726
you basically
could spend it all.
649
00:26:53,759 --> 00:26:54,994
Objection.
Is that what this is?
650
00:26:55,028 --> 00:26:56,664
You turn on your husband--
Objection!
651
00:26:56,698 --> 00:26:59,103
YOUNG:
This is cross-examination.
652
00:26:59,137 --> 00:27:00,345
I'll allow it.
653
00:27:00,780 --> 00:27:02,083
YOUNG: My colleague
Ellenor Frutt
654
00:27:02,116 --> 00:27:04,153
talked to you many times.
655
00:27:04,187 --> 00:27:05,389
Why didn't you ever mention
656
00:27:05,422 --> 00:27:06,257
that your husband seemed
657
00:27:06,291 --> 00:27:07,293
agitated that night?
658
00:27:07,326 --> 00:27:08,295
Because as I--
YOUNG: You hadn't thought
659
00:27:08,328 --> 00:27:09,463
of it yet?
Objection!
660
00:27:09,497 --> 00:27:10,766
WHITE: Mr. Young--
Where were you that night?
661
00:27:10,800 --> 00:27:12,169
Here we go.
YOUNG: Sorry,
662
00:27:12,203 --> 00:27:14,307
but when we interviewed you,
663
00:27:14,340 --> 00:27:16,745
you told us you had
no information,
664
00:27:16,778 --> 00:27:18,248
and here you sit today
665
00:27:18,281 --> 00:27:19,751
with information.
666
00:27:21,687 --> 00:27:22,957
I guess that can happen
667
00:27:22,990 --> 00:27:24,460
when a conviction
can give you access
668
00:27:24,493 --> 00:27:25,996
to over $2,000,000.
669
00:27:26,030 --> 00:27:26,865
GAMBLE: Objection!
670
00:27:26,898 --> 00:27:27,734
YOUNG: Withdrawn.
671
00:27:27,767 --> 00:27:29,237
Nothing further.
672
00:27:37,286 --> 00:27:39,590
I'm afraid I'm a little
confused, Jamie.
673
00:27:39,623 --> 00:27:41,627
Well, I just think
674
00:27:41,661 --> 00:27:43,331
since you were
the judge on my case
675
00:27:43,365 --> 00:27:45,269
and I did begin the case
676
00:27:45,302 --> 00:27:47,339
with some serious flirting,
677
00:27:47,373 --> 00:27:50,011
to avoid even the appearance
678
00:27:50,044 --> 00:27:51,347
of impropriety,
679
00:27:51,381 --> 00:27:53,085
we probably shouldn't be seen
680
00:27:53,118 --> 00:27:54,453
having a drink together.
681
00:27:54,620 --> 00:27:56,091
Are you saying
682
00:27:56,124 --> 00:27:57,359
you'd rather
get it privately?
683
00:27:57,393 --> 00:27:58,829
No, no, no,
no, no, no.
684
00:27:58,862 --> 00:28:01,574
I'm saying we probably
shouldn't get it at all.
685
00:28:01,607 --> 00:28:04,347
We shouldn't be social.
686
00:28:04,380 --> 00:28:05,850
Were you flirting with me
687
00:28:05,883 --> 00:28:07,519
because you were interested
688
00:28:07,553 --> 00:28:08,655
or you simply tried
689
00:28:08,688 --> 00:28:10,659
to influence my decision?
Well--
690
00:28:10,692 --> 00:28:11,795
BRENFORD:
Because it was the latter,
691
00:28:11,828 --> 00:28:14,901
even though
you didn't influence me,
692
00:28:14,934 --> 00:28:17,539
I should nevertheless
probably vacate my decision
693
00:28:17,573 --> 00:28:19,009
and remand the matter
to another judge to,
694
00:28:19,042 --> 00:28:21,747
like you say,
avoid even the appearance
695
00:28:21,782 --> 00:28:23,651
of impropriety.
696
00:28:23,685 --> 00:28:24,788
Should I do that?
697
00:28:25,422 --> 00:28:27,827
Now, it feels like
you're threatening me
698
00:28:27,860 --> 00:28:29,798
to undo your ruling,
699
00:28:29,831 --> 00:28:30,833
in which case,
my client--
700
00:28:30,866 --> 00:28:32,303
BRENFORD:
I'm merely following up
701
00:28:32,336 --> 00:28:34,808
on your implied allegation.
702
00:28:34,841 --> 00:28:38,081
If you think
there's any impropriety,
703
00:28:38,115 --> 00:28:39,984
it would be my duty
to vacate
704
00:28:40,018 --> 00:28:42,022
and hand the matter
to another judge.
705
00:28:43,926 --> 00:28:45,996
I don't feel
there's any impropriety.
706
00:28:46,998 --> 00:28:48,168
You sure?
707
00:28:48,802 --> 00:28:50,505
Yes.
708
00:28:50,539 --> 00:28:52,376
I'm very sure.
709
00:28:52,643 --> 00:28:54,547
Because if a lawyer
710
00:28:54,580 --> 00:28:56,784
before me even questions
711
00:28:56,818 --> 00:28:58,588
whether I'd stepped
over the line...
712
00:28:59,056 --> 00:29:00,499
I'm not questioning.
713
00:29:02,469 --> 00:29:03,405
(chuckles)
714
00:29:03,438 --> 00:29:04,440
Okay.
715
00:29:04,473 --> 00:29:05,775
Then I can't see any problem
716
00:29:05,810 --> 00:29:07,513
with us having
a drink together.
717
00:29:07,546 --> 00:29:09,683
I would tell you
if I thought so.
718
00:29:09,717 --> 00:29:11,421
(music playing)
719
00:29:15,662 --> 00:29:16,898
STANLEY: Lindsay!
What happened?
720
00:29:16,932 --> 00:29:18,068
He just wigged out,
but we called the paramedics.
721
00:29:18,101 --> 00:29:19,503
STANLEY:
Lindsay! Lindsay!
722
00:29:19,537 --> 00:29:21,174
Lindsay!
723
00:29:21,207 --> 00:29:22,143
DOLE: Stanley,
I'm right here!
724
00:29:22,176 --> 00:29:23,411
I'm right here!
725
00:29:23,445 --> 00:29:24,447
I wanna plead!
726
00:29:24,480 --> 00:29:25,715
I can't take the chance!
727
00:29:25,749 --> 00:29:27,253
I want to plead!
728
00:29:27,286 --> 00:29:29,590
DOLE: Stanley,
you need to calm down.
729
00:29:30,625 --> 00:29:32,829
I want to plead.
730
00:29:33,531 --> 00:29:35,369
If they let go of you,
731
00:29:35,402 --> 00:29:36,471
can you stay calm?
732
00:29:36,872 --> 00:29:37,639
Yes.
733
00:29:39,277 --> 00:29:40,179
Go ahead.
734
00:29:40,212 --> 00:29:43,085
(panting)
735
00:29:43,118 --> 00:29:44,087
You okay?
736
00:29:44,520 --> 00:29:46,157
I need to talk
to you alone.
737
00:29:48,161 --> 00:29:49,263
Handcuff him
738
00:29:49,297 --> 00:29:51,167
and cuff his leg
to the table.
739
00:29:51,201 --> 00:29:52,603
No.
Then I don't stay
740
00:29:52,636 --> 00:29:53,671
in this room alone with you.
741
00:29:53,705 --> 00:29:55,109
Simple as that.
742
00:29:56,277 --> 00:29:57,012
Okay.
743
00:29:58,581 --> 00:29:59,317
OFFICER: Stand up.
744
00:30:12,683 --> 00:30:13,919
We'll watch
through the glass.
745
00:30:14,153 --> 00:30:15,355
Thank you.
746
00:30:21,834 --> 00:30:23,438
The reason
that I was so desperate
747
00:30:23,471 --> 00:30:25,442
to have you as my attorney,
748
00:30:25,910 --> 00:30:27,646
you're in a unique position
749
00:30:27,679 --> 00:30:28,848
to bargain for me.
750
00:30:29,183 --> 00:30:31,487
Why?
STANLEY: Your old firm,
751
00:30:31,521 --> 00:30:33,425
it's on another case that...
752
00:30:35,695 --> 00:30:38,735
I can help the police with.
753
00:30:38,768 --> 00:30:40,472
The police solved
that one, Stanley.
754
00:30:40,505 --> 00:30:42,209
I don't--
STANLEY: No, they didn't.
755
00:30:42,876 --> 00:30:45,014
I killed that woman.
756
00:30:48,455 --> 00:30:50,159
I beg your pardon?
757
00:30:50,525 --> 00:30:51,661
Kathy Vance.
758
00:30:54,667 --> 00:30:56,036
I stabbed her,
759
00:30:56,071 --> 00:30:58,908
threw her in the woods.
760
00:30:58,942 --> 00:31:01,988
I am willing to confess
761
00:31:02,022 --> 00:31:04,293
to that crime
and this one here
762
00:31:04,327 --> 00:31:07,433
if they agree
763
00:31:07,466 --> 00:31:09,137
to put me in a hospital
764
00:31:09,170 --> 00:31:10,605
instead of prison.
765
00:31:12,076 --> 00:31:12,876
(sighs)
766
00:31:14,780 --> 00:31:17,553
You killed Kathy Vance?
767
00:31:18,989 --> 00:31:20,092
Yes.
768
00:31:20,125 --> 00:31:21,761
And that's why you wanted me,
769
00:31:21,794 --> 00:31:23,531
because of my old firm?
770
00:31:23,565 --> 00:31:24,667
STANLEY: And I know
you're friends
771
00:31:24,700 --> 00:31:26,137
with the D. A.,
Helen Gamble.
772
00:31:26,171 --> 00:31:28,675
You can make it happen.
773
00:31:28,708 --> 00:31:30,145
(knocks on door)
774
00:31:30,179 --> 00:31:31,681
The judge is back.
775
00:31:32,083 --> 00:31:33,017
(door closes)
776
00:31:33,050 --> 00:31:34,187
Oh, my God.
777
00:31:34,887 --> 00:31:35,855
Look,
778
00:31:36,857 --> 00:31:39,563
what you have
to give them,
779
00:31:39,597 --> 00:31:41,301
you'll still have it
after this ruling.
780
00:31:42,336 --> 00:31:44,240
You might as well take
your chances with Hiller.
781
00:31:45,742 --> 00:31:46,844
The search was bad.
782
00:31:51,687 --> 00:31:53,258
Let's just see
what she says.
783
00:31:57,099 --> 00:31:58,268
WOMAN: Be seated.
784
00:32:05,422 --> 00:32:08,195
I have spent
the past three hours
785
00:32:08,228 --> 00:32:09,730
trying to conceive of a way
786
00:32:09,763 --> 00:32:11,434
that I can uphold the search
787
00:32:11,467 --> 00:32:13,138
of the defendant's trunk
788
00:32:13,171 --> 00:32:15,008
and the ensuing confession.
789
00:32:16,611 --> 00:32:18,248
I failed.
790
00:32:19,016 --> 00:32:21,587
This wasn't made incident to
an arrest.
791
00:32:21,621 --> 00:32:23,558
It had nothing
to do with trying
792
00:32:23,591 --> 00:32:25,028
to stop the suspect
793
00:32:25,062 --> 00:32:26,464
from obtaining a weapon.
794
00:32:26,497 --> 00:32:29,103
We've got nothing
plain sight.
795
00:32:29,137 --> 00:32:31,040
This was warrantless
796
00:32:31,074 --> 00:32:33,911
and, simply put,
unconstitutional.
797
00:32:34,647 --> 00:32:36,351
It sickens me
798
00:32:36,384 --> 00:32:37,586
to squash it
799
00:32:38,054 --> 00:32:39,890
because the result--
800
00:32:43,030 --> 00:32:46,271
this officer needs to be sent
immediately back
801
00:32:46,304 --> 00:32:47,406
to the academy.
802
00:32:48,975 --> 00:32:50,679
The search and confession
803
00:32:50,712 --> 00:32:51,981
are hereby suppressed.
804
00:32:52,014 --> 00:32:53,818
The charges are dismissed,
805
00:32:53,851 --> 00:32:55,020
and the defendant,
806
00:32:55,054 --> 00:32:57,626
I'm horrified to say,
807
00:32:57,659 --> 00:32:58,861
is free to go.
808
00:33:01,274 --> 00:33:02,443
We are adjourned.
809
00:33:02,476 --> 00:33:03,145
(gavel bangs)
810
00:33:03,178 --> 00:33:04,680
(indistinct chatter)
811
00:33:11,194 --> 00:33:12,329
What happened?
812
00:33:12,529 --> 00:33:13,765
You're free.
813
00:33:13,798 --> 00:33:15,802
She threw out the search
and the confession.
814
00:33:16,002 --> 00:33:18,408
I can just walk out?
DOLE: Yes,
815
00:33:18,441 --> 00:33:20,212
but you still
wanna help the police
816
00:33:20,245 --> 00:33:21,447
on that other matter
817
00:33:21,481 --> 00:33:22,416
and get some help.
818
00:33:22,449 --> 00:33:24,153
There's no need to now, right?
819
00:33:27,493 --> 00:33:28,628
I'm free.
820
00:33:32,969 --> 00:33:33,871
Right.
821
00:33:35,074 --> 00:33:36,377
Thank you, Lindsay.
822
00:33:38,648 --> 00:33:39,917
Thank you.
823
00:33:39,950 --> 00:33:42,123
(music playing)
824
00:33:59,490 --> 00:34:02,156
(car engine revving)
825
00:34:02,189 --> 00:34:03,727
BERLUTI: What do you mean
you couldn't get out of it?
826
00:34:03,760 --> 00:34:04,895
He kind of tricked me.
827
00:34:04,929 --> 00:34:05,964
Tricked you how?
828
00:34:05,997 --> 00:34:07,099
He sort of implied
829
00:34:07,133 --> 00:34:08,401
that he would
undo his ruling,
830
00:34:08,435 --> 00:34:09,972
though he was careful
the way he said it
831
00:34:10,005 --> 00:34:13,045
and he basically
had me insisting
832
00:34:13,078 --> 00:34:14,080
there was no impropriety,
833
00:34:14,113 --> 00:34:15,751
and, look,
the guy's a judge,
834
00:34:15,784 --> 00:34:16,819
he's smarter than me.
835
00:34:16,853 --> 00:34:18,555
Jamie--
STRINGER: Don't worry.
836
00:34:18,588 --> 00:34:19,590
I know how to dump guys
837
00:34:19,623 --> 00:34:20,927
and flatter them
at the same time.
838
00:34:20,961 --> 00:34:22,363
I'll have one drink
and I'll wiggle out
839
00:34:22,396 --> 00:34:25,035
of the situation.
BERLUTI: This isn't a frat boy.
840
00:34:25,069 --> 00:34:25,971
He's a judge.
841
00:34:26,004 --> 00:34:27,273
I can handle him.
842
00:34:27,306 --> 00:34:29,010
I can.
BERLUTI: Is he threatening you
843
00:34:29,043 --> 00:34:30,680
in any way?
No.
844
00:34:30,713 --> 00:34:33,752
BERLUTI: Jamie, you're walking
down a path here.
845
00:34:33,787 --> 00:34:35,991
This is your career
846
00:34:36,024 --> 00:34:37,126
and it's you.
847
00:34:39,063 --> 00:34:40,265
I can handle it.
848
00:34:44,207 --> 00:34:45,777
He was the last person
849
00:34:45,811 --> 00:34:48,081
to see her alive.
850
00:34:48,115 --> 00:34:49,751
Her body was found
851
00:34:49,785 --> 00:34:52,089
behind his office building
852
00:34:53,091 --> 00:34:54,895
with his semen
inside of her.
853
00:34:55,529 --> 00:34:58,035
They were recently
seen fighting.
854
00:34:58,068 --> 00:34:59,637
She had slapped him.
855
00:35:01,314 --> 00:35:04,087
The defendant's own wife
knew something
856
00:35:04,120 --> 00:35:05,389
was wrong that night.
857
00:35:05,422 --> 00:35:08,061
He came home agitated
858
00:35:08,095 --> 00:35:10,499
and then we learn
859
00:35:10,532 --> 00:35:12,036
he's a drug addict.
860
00:35:12,938 --> 00:35:15,342
Maybe Katherine Vance
was going to expose him,
861
00:35:16,344 --> 00:35:18,481
ruin his marriage,
862
00:35:18,515 --> 00:35:20,152
ruin his career,
863
00:35:21,421 --> 00:35:22,891
we don't know.
864
00:35:22,925 --> 00:35:25,595
We can't.
865
00:35:25,629 --> 00:35:27,968
Katherine Vance is dead.
866
00:35:28,535 --> 00:35:30,405
We do know
867
00:35:30,439 --> 00:35:33,245
the defendant took the stand
868
00:35:33,278 --> 00:35:35,182
and lied,
869
00:35:35,215 --> 00:35:37,019
all the defense has offered
870
00:35:37,053 --> 00:35:39,992
is the defendant's word.
871
00:35:40,025 --> 00:35:42,029
And he takes the stand
872
00:35:43,098 --> 00:35:44,835
and lies.
873
00:35:44,869 --> 00:35:48,475
YOUNG: Dr. Barrett was afraid
to admit his addiction
874
00:35:48,508 --> 00:35:49,243
because he knew
875
00:35:49,277 --> 00:35:51,447
it would hurt his career,
876
00:35:51,481 --> 00:35:53,485
but there's no evidence
it caused him
877
00:35:53,518 --> 00:35:54,989
to kill Kathy Vance.
878
00:35:55,022 --> 00:35:57,526
There's no evidence
she even made any threats
879
00:35:57,559 --> 00:35:59,397
to go public.
880
00:35:59,430 --> 00:36:02,209
My client did
everything he could
881
00:36:02,243 --> 00:36:03,545
to help the police.
882
00:36:03,746 --> 00:36:06,317
He called them to say
the victim was missing.
883
00:36:06,351 --> 00:36:08,890
He gave them permission
to search everything.
884
00:36:08,923 --> 00:36:12,296
He even provided
a blood sample.
885
00:36:12,329 --> 00:36:15,803
Someone else could have
killed Kathy Vance,
886
00:36:15,836 --> 00:36:18,175
someone outside
who saw her leave.
887
00:36:18,208 --> 00:36:19,477
All their evidence,
888
00:36:19,510 --> 00:36:20,813
her being there that night,
889
00:36:20,846 --> 00:36:21,983
the semen,
890
00:36:22,016 --> 00:36:23,485
it proves the affair.
891
00:36:23,752 --> 00:36:25,891
It doesn't prove murder.
892
00:36:26,858 --> 00:36:28,561
And as for the wife
893
00:36:28,595 --> 00:36:31,167
suddenly coming forward
saying things
894
00:36:31,201 --> 00:36:32,737
didn't seem right,
895
00:36:33,038 --> 00:36:35,109
she had a motive to lie.
896
00:36:35,142 --> 00:36:37,279
She had 2,000,000 reasons.
897
00:36:38,749 --> 00:36:39,985
She never told the police
898
00:36:40,019 --> 00:36:41,487
or defense counsel
899
00:36:41,521 --> 00:36:43,291
that Dr. Barrett
seemed agitated.
900
00:36:43,325 --> 00:36:45,229
She manufactured that later
901
00:36:45,262 --> 00:36:47,133
when she tumbled to the idea
902
00:36:47,166 --> 00:36:48,501
that she could profit
903
00:36:48,535 --> 00:36:50,272
by putting him in prison.
904
00:36:50,806 --> 00:36:52,476
She got even.
905
00:36:52,509 --> 00:36:54,647
For all we know,
906
00:36:54,681 --> 00:36:56,885
maybe she was hiding
in the bushes that night
907
00:36:56,919 --> 00:36:58,388
waiting for Katherine Vance
908
00:36:58,421 --> 00:36:59,423
to come out.
909
00:37:02,870 --> 00:37:03,872
We don't know.
910
00:37:06,477 --> 00:37:07,546
(door opens)
911
00:37:07,579 --> 00:37:09,350
HILLER:
It's not often the winner
912
00:37:09,383 --> 00:37:10,786
comes in to complain.
913
00:37:10,819 --> 00:37:12,556
I'm not complaining
914
00:37:12,589 --> 00:37:15,997
and this is about a completely
unrelated matter.
915
00:37:16,030 --> 00:37:18,534
It's just...
916
00:37:18,568 --> 00:37:20,505
I respect you
more than anyone
917
00:37:20,539 --> 00:37:21,708
on interpreting the law
918
00:37:21,742 --> 00:37:25,482
and, uh,
I have a client
919
00:37:25,515 --> 00:37:27,419
who committed a crime
somebody else stands
920
00:37:27,453 --> 00:37:29,223
to be convicted for.
921
00:37:29,257 --> 00:37:30,860
And?
922
00:37:30,893 --> 00:37:33,832
And do I have any recourse
923
00:37:33,866 --> 00:37:35,635
to cure the injustice?
924
00:37:35,669 --> 00:37:37,006
I'm sure the answer's no,
925
00:37:37,039 --> 00:37:38,075
but...
926
00:37:38,108 --> 00:37:40,079
Then why ask the question?
927
00:37:41,481 --> 00:37:42,717
Is the answer yes?
928
00:37:42,750 --> 00:37:44,353
In 49 other states,
929
00:37:44,387 --> 00:37:45,522
your hands are tied.
930
00:37:45,555 --> 00:37:46,692
In Massachusetts,
931
00:37:46,725 --> 00:37:48,495
there is a provision
932
00:37:48,528 --> 00:37:50,565
in rule 1.6.
933
00:37:50,599 --> 00:37:53,471
It allows an attorney
934
00:37:53,505 --> 00:37:54,473
to break the privilege
935
00:37:54,507 --> 00:37:56,011
to keep an innocent man
936
00:37:56,044 --> 00:37:57,513
from going to prison.
937
00:37:57,546 --> 00:37:58,548
Do you have a case?
938
00:37:58,581 --> 00:38:00,793
HILLER: No,
because there aren't any.
939
00:38:00,826 --> 00:38:02,063
There's never been
a decision
940
00:38:02,096 --> 00:38:05,569
because no attorney has ever
invoked the provision.
941
00:38:05,803 --> 00:38:06,738
Why not?
942
00:38:06,772 --> 00:38:08,541
HILLER: You know
the answer to that.
943
00:38:08,575 --> 00:38:10,312
Privilege
is the bedrock principle
944
00:38:10,345 --> 00:38:11,915
of criminal justice.
945
00:38:11,948 --> 00:38:13,618
There may be
an exception on paper,
946
00:38:13,651 --> 00:38:16,124
but no defense
attorney's ever been
947
00:38:16,157 --> 00:38:19,230
willing to use it,
rightfully so.
948
00:38:19,263 --> 00:38:20,933
But I can.
949
00:38:20,966 --> 00:38:22,369
I have the discretion.
950
00:38:22,403 --> 00:38:23,806
HILLER: That's right.
951
00:38:23,839 --> 00:38:25,442
But Lindsay,
you'd be signing
952
00:38:25,475 --> 00:38:27,980
your own career
death warrant.
953
00:38:28,015 --> 00:38:29,550
You'll be news,
a pariah
954
00:38:29,583 --> 00:38:31,521
with every other attorney,
955
00:38:31,554 --> 00:38:34,027
not just criminal.
956
00:38:34,060 --> 00:38:35,763
What type of crime
957
00:38:35,796 --> 00:38:36,965
do you have knowledge of?
958
00:38:36,999 --> 00:38:38,668
It's a murder.
959
00:38:38,702 --> 00:38:39,370
HILLER: Ah.
960
00:38:40,305 --> 00:38:42,209
Why am I not surprised?
961
00:38:43,478 --> 00:38:45,015
The reason this provision
962
00:38:45,049 --> 00:38:46,617
has never been invoked,
963
00:38:46,651 --> 00:38:47,787
most lawyers,
964
00:38:47,820 --> 00:38:49,590
most judges,
including me,
965
00:38:49,623 --> 00:38:51,361
think it's wrong.
966
00:38:51,394 --> 00:38:54,167
A client's trust
is a client's trust.
967
00:38:54,200 --> 00:38:55,803
A lawyer doesn't break it.
968
00:38:55,836 --> 00:38:58,141
It isn't always that easy.
969
00:38:58,175 --> 00:39:00,045
HILLER:
You think it was easy
970
00:39:00,079 --> 00:39:02,022
for me to kick Stanley Deeks?
971
00:39:03,025 --> 00:39:05,362
You came to me for advice.
972
00:39:05,395 --> 00:39:06,397
Technically,
973
00:39:06,431 --> 00:39:09,237
you can reveal
what you know.
974
00:39:09,270 --> 00:39:10,372
Ethically,
975
00:39:10,405 --> 00:39:12,476
I say you don't.
976
00:39:16,351 --> 00:39:17,119
BRENFORD:
I don't know about you,
977
00:39:17,153 --> 00:39:18,321
but I'm pretty hungry.
978
00:39:18,355 --> 00:39:19,691
It's only 5:00.
979
00:39:19,724 --> 00:39:21,627
I know,
but let's head over
980
00:39:21,661 --> 00:39:22,830
to Jasper's and get a bite.
981
00:39:22,864 --> 00:39:24,300
It's not too far.
982
00:39:24,333 --> 00:39:26,237
Okay.
Nice thing about being a judge
983
00:39:26,271 --> 00:39:27,573
is the ability to say,
984
00:39:27,606 --> 00:39:29,177
"Day's over, folks."
985
00:39:29,210 --> 00:39:30,345
Sometimes think
about going back
986
00:39:30,379 --> 00:39:32,917
into private practice
and then I think
987
00:39:32,950 --> 00:39:35,489
I'd miss
the control too much.
988
00:39:35,522 --> 00:39:37,659
Door's open.
989
00:39:37,694 --> 00:39:39,097
Of course,
what I'd really like
990
00:39:39,130 --> 00:39:40,365
is to captain a boat.
991
00:39:40,399 --> 00:39:41,968
That's the control
I'm looking for.
992
00:39:42,403 --> 00:39:44,073
Be out in the open sea,
993
00:39:44,107 --> 00:39:45,675
sail to Nantucket.
994
00:39:46,712 --> 00:39:47,579
What's wrong?
995
00:39:49,350 --> 00:39:50,485
Jamie?
996
00:39:54,327 --> 00:39:56,131
I can't get a drink
with you.
997
00:39:56,765 --> 00:39:58,168
I'm sorry,
but having appeared
998
00:39:58,201 --> 00:40:00,172
before you on a case,
999
00:40:00,205 --> 00:40:01,547
I think it's wrong.
1000
00:40:03,952 --> 00:40:05,856
If you feel the need
to vacate your decision,
1001
00:40:05,890 --> 00:40:07,259
that's your call.
1002
00:40:07,293 --> 00:40:09,163
My call,
1003
00:40:09,197 --> 00:40:10,565
I'm not getting this drink.
1004
00:40:13,739 --> 00:40:14,841
Good night, Your Honor.
1005
00:40:16,144 --> 00:40:19,183
(music playing)
1006
00:40:37,219 --> 00:40:39,123
WHITE: Will the defendant
please rise?
1007
00:40:40,960 --> 00:40:43,966
Mr. Foreman, has the jury
reached a unanimous verdict?
1008
00:40:44,267 --> 00:40:45,369
We have, Your Honor.
1009
00:40:45,402 --> 00:40:46,972
WHITE: What say you?
1010
00:40:47,005 --> 00:40:50,011
FOREMAN: Commonwealth
versus Steven Barrett.
1011
00:40:50,880 --> 00:40:52,082
On the charge of murder
1012
00:40:52,115 --> 00:40:53,084
in the first degree,
1013
00:40:53,117 --> 00:40:54,387
we find the defendant,
1014
00:40:54,420 --> 00:40:56,291
Steven Barrett,
1015
00:40:57,393 --> 00:40:58,228
guilty.
1016
00:40:58,261 --> 00:41:00,599
(indistinct chatter)
1017
00:41:03,345 --> 00:41:04,280
The defense moves
1018
00:41:04,313 --> 00:41:05,549
to set aside the verdict.
1019
00:41:05,582 --> 00:41:06,617
Denied.
1020
00:41:06,651 --> 00:41:08,956
Security, take charge
of the defendant.
1021
00:41:09,357 --> 00:41:10,592
Members of the jury,
1022
00:41:10,625 --> 00:41:12,563
you're dismissed
with the thanks of this court.
1023
00:41:13,565 --> 00:41:15,169
This matter
is now adjourned.
1024
00:41:15,202 --> 00:41:16,136
(gavel bangs)
1025
00:41:17,138 --> 00:41:18,475
We're gonna review the record
1026
00:41:18,508 --> 00:41:20,011
and find grounds to appeal.
1027
00:41:21,013 --> 00:41:21,848
Okay.
1028
00:41:23,585 --> 00:41:26,156
(indistinct chatter)
1029
00:41:32,804 --> 00:41:34,240
You can go.
I'll handle this.
1030
00:41:34,774 --> 00:41:37,112
Are you sure?
YOUNG: Yeah, go ahead.
1031
00:41:37,145 --> 00:41:39,650
(indistinct chatter)
1032
00:41:42,757 --> 00:41:43,625
Lindsay.
1033
00:41:43,759 --> 00:41:44,728
Hey.
1034
00:41:44,761 --> 00:41:47,599
I came to bring you luck.
1035
00:41:47,633 --> 00:41:50,305
I'm sorry.
Yeah.
1036
00:41:50,339 --> 00:41:52,343
MAN: Excuse me, Ms. Frutt.
FRUTT: Uh, Eugene Young
1037
00:41:52,376 --> 00:41:53,245
will be fielding
all your questions.
1038
00:41:53,278 --> 00:41:54,247
I've got no comment.
1039
00:41:54,280 --> 00:41:55,114
I'm sorry.
1040
00:41:57,954 --> 00:42:00,933
(indistinct chatter)
1041
00:42:09,718 --> 00:42:11,922
It's not like I thought
we would win,
1042
00:42:11,955 --> 00:42:13,190
but...
1043
00:42:13,692 --> 00:42:15,161
But what?
1044
00:42:15,495 --> 00:42:17,666
I don't know.
1045
00:42:17,700 --> 00:42:20,539
Something just tells me
1046
00:42:20,572 --> 00:42:23,210
this one was innocent.
1047
00:42:23,245 --> 00:42:26,251
(music playing)
1048
00:42:30,993 --> 00:42:32,629
Any grounds for appeal?
1049
00:42:34,667 --> 00:42:36,271
I don't know.
1050
00:42:39,176 --> 00:42:40,178
(sighs)
1051
00:42:40,211 --> 00:42:43,217
(music playing)
1052
00:42:59,517 --> 00:43:02,529
(music playing)
1053
00:43:25,876 --> 00:43:27,045
WOMAN: You stinker.
1054
00:43:29,049 --> 00:43:30,051
(music playing)
70876
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.