원제작자님 감사합니다
먹는게낙
2
00:00:09,000 --> 00:01:09,000
3 00:01:34,956 --> 00:01:37,476
What's going
-on, Steve?
-Oh, it's not good.
4
00:01:37,476 --> 00:01:37,511
5 00:01:37,511 --> 00:01:38,650
What are they
doing in there?
6
00:01:38,650 --> 00:01:38,684
7 00:01:38,684 --> 00:01:40,100
That is a hell
of a long recess.
8
00:01:40,100 --> 00:01:40,134
9 00:01:40,134 --> 00:01:41,756
Longest recess yet. 10 00:01:41,756 --> 00:01:41,791
11 00:01:41,791 --> 00:01:44,034
-I've seen longer.
-I thought the trial would
be over by now.
12
00:01:44,034 --> 00:01:44,069
13 00:01:44,069 --> 00:01:46,347
All they do is
swear somebody in
and recess,
14
00:01:46,347 --> 00:01:46,382
15 00:01:46,382 --> 00:01:47,900
and then look at a paper,
recess, look at a...
16
00:01:47,900 --> 00:01:47,935
17 00:01:47,935 --> 00:01:49,454
You won't tell me
what you're doing,
18
00:01:49,454 --> 00:01:49,488
19 00:01:49,488 --> 00:01:51,594
how you're gonna
conduct my case,
what I'm supposed to say.
20
00:01:51,594 --> 00:01:51,628
21 00:01:51,628 --> 00:01:52,733
It would only
confuse you.
22
00:01:52,733 --> 00:01:52,767
23 00:01:52,767 --> 00:01:54,148
I don't like the way
you're handling me.
24
00:01:54,148 --> 00:01:54,183
25 00:01:54,183 --> 00:01:57,393
Good. That makes us even.
I don't like handling you.
26
00:01:57,393 --> 00:01:57,427
27 00:01:57,427 --> 00:01:59,188
What? Well, then,
maybe I'd better just
go into court and...
28
00:01:59,188 --> 00:01:59,222
29 00:01:59,222 --> 00:02:00,879
Maryk, I'd rather
be prosecuting you
than defending you.
30
00:02:00,879 --> 00:02:00,913
31 00:02:00,913 --> 00:02:02,570
I told you that
the first time we met.
32
00:02:02,570 --> 00:02:02,605
33 00:02:02,605 --> 00:02:04,296
Nevertheless,
I am defending you.
34
00:02:04,296 --> 00:02:04,331
35 00:02:04,331 --> 00:02:06,195
If it is humanly
possible to win an
acquittal in this case
36
00:02:06,195 --> 00:02:06,229
37 00:02:06,229 --> 00:02:08,024
I'm gonna win you
an acquittal.
38
00:02:08,024 --> 00:02:08,058
39 00:02:08,058 --> 00:02:10,302
If you want a prediction,
I'm gonna get you off.
40
00:02:10,302 --> 00:02:10,337
41 00:02:10,337 --> 00:02:12,753
But you can't help me,
so just leave me be.
42
00:02:12,753 --> 00:02:14,617
43 00:02:14,617 --> 00:02:17,413
Hell of a thing to say,
you'd rather be prosecuting
me than defending me.
44
00:02:17,413 --> 00:02:17,447
45 00:02:17,447 --> 00:02:20,001
How do you suppose
that makes me feel?
46
00:02:20,001 --> 00:02:20,036
47 00:02:20,036 --> 00:02:22,970
-You're nervous.
-Oh, sure I am.
48
00:02:22,970 --> 00:02:23,004
49 00:02:23,004 --> 00:02:25,490
I am too,
a bit. Sorry.
50
00:02:25,490 --> 00:02:25,524
51 00:02:25,524 --> 00:02:27,733
I can ask the court
for a different counsel.
52
00:02:27,733 --> 00:02:27,768
53 00:02:27,768 --> 00:02:29,563
Forget it.
I don't take on a case
just to lose it.
54
00:02:29,563 --> 00:02:29,597
55 00:02:29,597 --> 00:02:31,634
You do think I was right
to relieve Captain Queeg?
56
00:02:31,634 --> 00:02:31,668
57 00:02:31,668 --> 00:02:33,325
I can't say that. 58 00:02:33,325 --> 00:02:33,360
59 00:02:33,360 --> 00:02:37,122
After everything I've
told you, you still do
not think he was nuts?
60
00:02:37,122 --> 00:02:37,157
61 00:02:37,157 --> 00:02:38,468
No, I don't. 62 00:02:38,468 --> 00:02:38,503
63 00:02:38,503 --> 00:02:39,918
Then I get hung. 64 00:02:39,918 --> 00:02:39,952
65 00:02:39,952 --> 00:02:41,195
Not necessarily. 66 00:02:41,195 --> 00:02:42,610
67 00:02:42,610 --> 00:02:43,853
Maybe I should
plead guilty.
68
00:02:43,853 --> 00:02:43,887
69 00:02:43,887 --> 00:02:45,682
Eight legal officers
advised me...
70
00:02:45,682 --> 00:02:45,717
71 00:02:45,717 --> 00:02:48,409
I don't care if every
legal officer in the
Navy says otherwise,
72
00:02:48,409 --> 00:02:48,444
73 00:02:48,444 --> 00:02:50,342
I think I can
get you off.
74
00:02:50,342 --> 00:02:50,377
75 00:02:50,377 --> 00:02:51,964
This is
a whole foul up.
76
00:02:51,964 --> 00:02:51,999
77 00:02:51,999 --> 00:02:55,175
You'll do nobly.
You may come out of this
a great naval hero.
78
00:02:55,175 --> 00:02:55,209
79 00:02:55,209 --> 00:02:56,624
Greenwald,
is something
eating at you?
80
00:02:56,624 --> 00:02:56,659
81 00:02:56,659 --> 00:02:59,179
I used to daydream about
a court-martial coming up
82
00:02:59,179 --> 00:02:59,213
83 00:02:59,213 --> 00:03:00,697
and some poor Joe
would be defending,
84
00:03:00,697 --> 00:03:00,732
85 00:03:00,732 --> 00:03:03,804
and I'd step in, take over,
twist the Navy's arm,
86
00:03:03,804 --> 00:03:03,838
87 00:03:03,838 --> 00:03:05,668
make it holler Uncle. 88 00:03:05,668 --> 00:03:05,702
89 00:03:05,702 --> 00:03:09,258
Well, now here's
my dream come true.
You know something?
90
00:03:09,258 --> 00:03:09,292
91 00:03:09,292 --> 00:03:11,950
I don't look forward
to twisting the Navy's arm.
Not one bit.
92
00:03:11,950 --> 00:03:11,984
93 00:03:11,984 --> 00:03:13,710
-Scared of the brass, huh?
-Worse.
94
00:03:13,710 --> 00:03:13,745
95 00:03:13,745 --> 00:03:16,299
-What?
-Respectful.
96
00:03:16,299 --> 00:03:16,334
97 00:03:16,334 --> 00:03:19,337
Ah, look, I put in for
transfer to the regulars.
I respect the Navy, too.
98
00:03:19,337 --> 00:03:19,371
99 00:03:19,371 --> 00:03:21,166
It's just...
I don't know, Maryk.
100
00:03:21,166 --> 00:03:21,201
101 00:03:21,201 --> 00:03:22,961
I'm a damn good
lawyer and I'm
a pretty poor...
102
00:03:22,961 --> 00:03:22,995
103 00:03:22,995 --> 00:03:25,343
We're spending
excessive time on
all these recesses.
104
00:03:25,343 --> 00:03:25,377
105 00:03:25,377 --> 00:03:27,552
I appreciate
your wanting to have
the record letter perfect.
106
00:03:27,552 --> 00:03:27,586
107 00:03:27,586 --> 00:03:30,279
I think there is
a big pile of foolishness
connected with the Navy.
108
00:03:30,279 --> 00:03:30,313
109 00:03:30,313 --> 00:03:32,867
In fact, sometimes
I think that the Navy
is just a master plan
110
00:03:32,867 --> 00:03:32,902
111 00:03:32,902 --> 00:03:35,801
designed by geniuses
for execution by idiots.
112
00:03:35,801 --> 00:03:35,836
113 00:03:35,836 --> 00:03:37,631
You think what? 114 00:03:37,631 --> 00:03:37,665
115 00:03:37,665 --> 00:03:39,149
That the Navy is
just a master plan
116
00:03:39,149 --> 00:03:39,184
117 00:03:39,184 --> 00:03:41,428
designed by geniuses
for execution by idiots.
118
00:03:41,428 --> 00:03:41,462
119 00:03:41,462 --> 00:03:43,084
Where'd
you hear that?
120
00:03:43,084 --> 00:03:43,119
121 00:03:43,119 --> 00:03:44,569
Couldn't I have
just made it up?
122
00:03:44,569 --> 00:03:44,603
123 00:03:44,603 --> 00:03:46,329
You could
have just made up the
Gettysburg address, too.
124
00:03:46,329 --> 00:03:46,364
125 00:03:46,364 --> 00:03:48,814
Where'd you hear it? 126 00:03:48,814 --> 00:03:48,849
127 00:03:48,849 --> 00:03:52,611
Well, as a matter of fact,
it's one of Tom Keefer's
favorite cracks.
128
00:03:52,611 --> 00:03:52,646
129 00:03:52,646 --> 00:03:55,476
Ah, yes. You echo
your novelist friend
quite a bit, don't you?
130
00:03:55,476 --> 00:03:55,511
131 00:03:55,511 --> 00:03:56,615
Well, let's get
on with the case,
132
00:03:56,615 --> 00:03:56,650
133 00:03:56,650 --> 00:03:57,823
keep thetechnicalities to a minimum. 134 00:03:57,823 --> 00:03:57,858
135 00:03:57,858 --> 00:03:58,962
Aye, aye, sir. 136 00:03:58,962 --> 00:04:02,345
137 00:04:02,345 --> 00:04:03,726
Well, here we go. 138 00:04:03,726 --> 00:04:03,760
139 00:04:03,760 --> 00:04:05,417
Better you did it
out of your own
noble judgment
140
00:04:05,417 --> 00:04:05,452
141 00:04:05,452 --> 00:04:07,350
than you took
the advice of
a sensitive novelist.
142
00:04:07,350 --> 00:04:08,144
143 00:04:08,144 --> 00:04:09,421
Attention! 144 00:04:09,421 --> 00:04:10,388
145 00:04:10,388 --> 00:04:11,975
Court is in session. 146 00:04:11,975 --> 00:04:14,564
147 00:04:14,564 --> 00:04:18,327
Court finds the charge and
specification in due form
and technically correct.
148
00:04:18,327 --> 00:04:18,361
149 00:04:18,361 --> 00:04:20,432
Is the accused
-ready for trial?
-Yes, sir.
150
00:04:20,432 --> 00:04:20,467
151 00:04:20,467 --> 00:04:23,470
"Charge. Conduct to
the prejudice of good
order and discipline.
152
00:04:23,470 --> 00:04:23,504
153 00:04:23,504 --> 00:04:27,059
"Specification.
In that Lieutenant
Stephen Maryk, USNR,
154
00:04:27,059 --> 00:04:27,094
155 00:04:27,094 --> 00:04:30,994
"did, on or about
18 December, 1944,
aboard the USS Caine,
156
00:04:30,994 --> 00:04:31,029
157 00:04:31,029 --> 00:04:34,446
"willfully, without
proper authority and
without justifiable cause,
158
00:04:34,446 --> 00:04:34,481
159 00:04:34,481 --> 00:04:36,414
"did relieve from his duty
as commanding officer,
160
00:04:36,414 --> 00:04:36,448
161 00:04:36,448 --> 00:04:39,140
"Lieutenant Commander Philip
Francis Queeg, USN,
162
00:04:39,140 --> 00:04:39,175
163 00:04:39,175 --> 00:04:41,142
"the duly assigned
commanding officer
of said ship,
164
00:04:41,142 --> 00:04:41,177
165 00:04:41,177 --> 00:04:43,766
"who was then and there
in lawful exercise
of his command,
166
00:04:43,766 --> 00:04:43,800
167 00:04:43,800 --> 00:04:46,147
"the United States then
being in a state of war."
168
00:04:46,147 --> 00:04:46,182
169 00:04:46,182 --> 00:04:48,667
Stephen Maryk, Lieutenant,
United States Naval Reserve,
170
00:04:48,667 --> 00:04:48,702
171 00:04:48,702 --> 00:04:51,187
you have heard the
charge and specification
preferred against you.
172
00:04:51,187 --> 00:04:51,221
173 00:04:51,221 --> 00:04:52,361
-How say you?
-Not guilty.
174
00:04:52,361 --> 00:04:52,395
175 00:04:52,395 --> 00:04:54,639
Guilty or not guilty? 176 00:04:54,639 --> 00:04:55,778
177 00:04:55,778 --> 00:04:57,262
Not guilty. 178 00:04:57,262 --> 00:04:57,297
179 00:04:57,297 --> 00:04:59,091
Judge advocate,
present your case.
180
00:04:59,091 --> 00:04:59,126
181 00:04:59,126 --> 00:05:01,059
Call Lieutenant
Commander Queeg.
182
00:05:01,059 --> 00:05:01,093
183 00:05:01,093 --> 00:05:02,854
Lieutenant Commander Queeg. 184 00:05:02,854 --> 00:05:10,896
185 00:05:10,896 --> 00:05:13,727
This guy had a ship
we used to call
the USS Purgatory.
186
00:05:13,727 --> 00:05:27,568
187 00:05:27,568 --> 00:05:29,432
You do solemnly swear
the evidence you shall
give in this court
188
00:05:29,432 --> 00:05:29,467
189 00:05:29,467 --> 00:05:31,365
shall be the truth,
the whole truth, and
nothing but the truth,
190
00:05:31,365 --> 00:05:31,400
191 00:05:31,400 --> 00:05:32,918
-so help you God?
-I do.
192
00:05:32,918 --> 00:05:40,892
193 00:05:40,892 --> 00:05:42,859
State your name, rank
and present position.
194
00:05:42,859 --> 00:05:42,894
195 00:05:42,894 --> 00:05:46,553
Philip Frances Queeg,
Lieutenant Commander,
United States Navy,
196
00:05:46,553 --> 00:05:46,587
197 00:05:46,587 --> 00:05:48,486
temporarily assigned
to commandant,
198
00:05:48,486 --> 00:05:48,520
199 00:05:48,520 --> 00:05:51,143
12th Naval District,
awaiting reassignment
by Bupers.
200
00:05:51,143 --> 00:05:51,178
201 00:05:51,178 --> 00:05:54,284
If you recognize
the accused,
state as whom.
202
00:05:54,284 --> 00:05:54,319
203 00:05:54,319 --> 00:05:57,943
Lieutenant Stephen Maryk,
USNR.
204
00:05:57,943 --> 00:05:57,978
205 00:05:57,978 --> 00:06:00,532
Commander Queeg,
on December 18, 1944,
206
00:06:00,532 --> 00:06:00,567
207 00:06:00,567 --> 00:06:02,707
were you in command
of the USS Caine?
208
00:06:02,707 --> 00:06:02,741
209 00:06:02,741 --> 00:06:04,847
-I was.
-What type of
vessel is the Caine?
210
00:06:04,847 --> 00:06:06,883
211 00:06:06,883 --> 00:06:10,508
Her official designation
is high-speed mine-sweeper.
212
00:06:10,508 --> 00:06:10,542
213 00:06:10,542 --> 00:06:12,579
What she is,
is a four-piper,
214
00:06:12,579 --> 00:06:12,613
215 00:06:12,613 --> 00:06:16,272
one of those flush deck,
1,200 ton destroyers
from World War One,
216
00:06:16,272 --> 00:06:16,306
217 00:06:16,306 --> 00:06:19,482
fixed up with
-mine-sweeping gear.
An old ship, then?
218
00:06:19,482 --> 00:06:19,517
219 00:06:19,517 --> 00:06:22,209
I guess about
the oldest type still
doing combat duty.
220
00:06:22,209 --> 00:06:22,243
221 00:06:22,243 --> 00:06:23,900
What is her
primary mission?
222
00:06:23,900 --> 00:06:23,935
223 00:06:23,935 --> 00:06:25,868
Well, that's a hard one. 224 00:06:25,868 --> 00:06:25,902
225 00:06:25,902 --> 00:06:29,665
These old buckets
are regarded as
pretty expendable.
226
00:06:29,665 --> 00:06:29,699
227 00:06:29,699 --> 00:06:31,770
By and large,
we were doing the
usual destroyer duty,
228
00:06:31,770 --> 00:06:31,805
229 00:06:31,805 --> 00:06:37,155
anti-submarine screening,
also ran the mail,
transported marines,
230
00:06:37,155 --> 00:06:37,189
231 00:06:37,189 --> 00:06:39,606
carried aviation gas
and torpedoes,
232
00:06:39,606 --> 00:06:39,640
233 00:06:39,640 --> 00:06:42,885
gave fire support
in minor landings,
or what have you.
234
00:06:42,885 --> 00:06:42,919
235 00:06:42,919 --> 00:06:44,818
Also swept mines
now and then.
236
00:06:44,818 --> 00:06:44,852
237 00:06:44,852 --> 00:06:47,027
Commander,
on December 18, 1944,
238
00:06:47,027 --> 00:06:47,061
239 00:06:47,061 --> 00:06:48,960
were you relieved of
command of the Caine?
240
00:06:48,960 --> 00:06:50,133
241 00:06:50,133 --> 00:06:51,411
-Yes.
-By whom?
242
00:06:51,411 --> 00:06:51,445
243 00:06:51,445 --> 00:06:53,723
-By the accused.
-Was this a regular relief?
244
00:06:53,723 --> 00:06:53,758
245 00:06:53,758 --> 00:06:56,450
It was totally
irregular, sir.
246
00:06:56,450 --> 00:06:56,485
247 00:06:56,485 --> 00:06:57,900
How would you describe it? 248 00:06:57,900 --> 00:07:01,006
249 00:07:01,006 --> 00:07:03,906
The most charitable
description would be
that it was an incident,
250
00:07:03,906 --> 00:07:03,940
251 00:07:03,940 --> 00:07:07,461
a regrettable incident of
temporary and total collapse
of military discipline.
252
00:07:07,461 --> 00:07:07,496
253 00:07:07,496 --> 00:07:11,810
Commander, please
relate all the facts that bear
on this unauthorized relief.
254
00:07:11,810 --> 00:07:11,845
255 00:07:11,845 --> 00:07:13,018
Okay. 256 00:07:13,018 --> 00:07:14,123
257 00:07:14,123 --> 00:07:16,919
I'll try to do this
consecutively, here.
258
00:07:16,919 --> 00:07:16,953
259 00:07:16,953 --> 00:07:22,476
We sortied, the Caine,
sortied, from Ulithi Atoll
on the 16th of December.
260
00:07:22,476 --> 00:07:22,511
261 00:07:22,511 --> 00:07:24,409
I believe the
15th or the 16th.
262
00:07:24,409 --> 00:07:24,444
263 00:07:24,444 --> 00:07:27,343
We were a screening vessel
with a group of fleet oilers.
264
00:07:27,343 --> 00:07:27,377
265 00:07:27,377 --> 00:07:30,484
Our mission was to
rendezvous with and refuel
266
00:07:30,484 --> 00:07:30,519
267 00:07:30,519 --> 00:07:33,970
Admiral Halsey's
fast carrier force
in the Philippine Sea.
268
00:07:33,970 --> 00:07:35,385
269 00:07:35,385 --> 00:07:39,493
Okay. Well, we made
the rendezvous,
270
00:07:39,493 --> 00:07:39,528
271 00:07:39,528 --> 00:07:42,496
and then this
typhoon came along.
272
00:07:42,496 --> 00:07:42,531
273 00:07:42,531 --> 00:07:45,499
The fueling was broken off
and the fleet began to
maneuver to evade the storm.
274
00:07:45,499 --> 00:07:45,534
275 00:07:45,534 --> 00:07:47,743
Now, the storm was
traveling due west,
276
00:07:47,743 --> 00:07:47,777
277 00:07:47,777 --> 00:07:50,780
so Admiral Halsey
set fleet course due south,
278
00:07:50,780 --> 00:07:50,815
279 00:07:50,815 --> 00:07:53,645
and we began to
make a run for the
safe semi-circle.
280
00:07:53,645 --> 00:07:53,680
281 00:07:53,680 --> 00:07:56,130
What was
the date and time of
that course change?
282
00:07:56,130 --> 00:07:56,165
283 00:07:56,165 --> 00:07:59,789
That would be the
morning of the 18th, sir.
284
00:07:59,789 --> 00:07:59,824
285 00:07:59,824 --> 00:08:03,828
Well, uh, as I say,
visibility was almost zero.
286
00:08:03,828 --> 00:08:03,862
287 00:08:03,862 --> 00:08:05,519
The storm was pretty
bad at this point.
288
00:08:05,519 --> 00:08:05,554
289 00:08:05,554 --> 00:08:08,936
Couldn't see the guide
or even the next ship
in the screen.
290
00:08:08,936 --> 00:08:08,971
291 00:08:08,971 --> 00:08:12,768
We were just steaming
blindly through
rain and spray.
292
00:08:12,768 --> 00:08:12,802
293 00:08:12,802 --> 00:08:15,564
And, of course,
with the wind and
sea and all,
294
00:08:15,564 --> 00:08:15,598
295 00:08:15,598 --> 00:08:17,289
we had to maneuver
pretty smartly
296
00:08:17,289 --> 00:08:17,324
297 00:08:17,324 --> 00:08:20,292
with engines and
rudder to hold fleet
course and speed.
298
00:08:20,292 --> 00:08:20,327
299 00:08:20,327 --> 00:08:22,605
But we were doing fine. 300 00:08:22,605 --> 00:08:22,640
301 00:08:22,640 --> 00:08:28,128
My executive officer,
however, pretty early in
the game began to show
302
00:08:28,128 --> 00:08:28,162
303 00:08:28,162 --> 00:08:31,683
unusual symptoms
of nervousness.
304
00:08:31,683 --> 00:08:31,718
305 00:08:31,718 --> 00:08:33,858
What were
these symptoms
of nervousness?
306
00:08:33,858 --> 00:08:33,892
307 00:08:33,892 --> 00:08:38,345
Well, for instance,
he began talking
very early,
308
00:08:38,345 --> 00:08:38,379
309 00:08:38,379 --> 00:08:40,968
oh, it couldn't have been half
an hour after the fleet
started to run south,
310
00:08:40,968 --> 00:08:41,003
311 00:08:41,003 --> 00:08:43,695
that we should operate
independently and
come around north.
312
00:08:43,695 --> 00:08:46,387
313 00:08:46,387 --> 00:08:48,148
And why would
he want to do that?
314
00:08:48,148 --> 00:08:50,081
315 00:08:50,081 --> 00:08:52,566
To give you
a picture on that.
316
00:08:52,566 --> 00:08:52,601
317 00:08:52,601 --> 00:08:55,431
You see, the typhoon
was coming at us
from the east,
318
00:08:55,431 --> 00:08:55,465
319 00:08:55,465 --> 00:08:58,261
and we were on
the western edge of it.
320
00:08:58,261 --> 00:08:58,296
321 00:08:58,296 --> 00:09:04,026
Now, as you know, these
blows spin counter-clockwise
above the equator.
322
00:09:04,026 --> 00:09:04,060
323 00:09:04,060 --> 00:09:07,754
That means where
we were, the wind was
coming from due north.
324
00:09:07,754 --> 00:09:07,788
325 00:09:07,788 --> 00:09:10,929
Admiral Halsey, of course,
was running south,
with the wind,
326
00:09:10,929 --> 00:09:10,964
327 00:09:10,964 --> 00:09:13,898
to get out of
the storm's path.
328
00:09:13,898 --> 00:09:13,932
329 00:09:13,932 --> 00:09:17,833
Now this is in accordance
with all existing storm
doctrine from Bowditch on up.
330
00:09:17,833 --> 00:09:17,867
331 00:09:17,867 --> 00:09:21,871
But my exec insisted
that the ship was
on the verge of foundering,
332
00:09:21,871 --> 00:09:21,906
333 00:09:21,906 --> 00:09:24,080
and that we had
better come around
and head into the wind,
334
00:09:24,080 --> 00:09:24,115
335 00:09:24,115 --> 00:09:27,705
that is, north,
if we were to survive.
336
00:09:27,705 --> 00:09:27,739
337 00:09:27,739 --> 00:09:31,501
Of course we weren't in any
such bad shape at all.
338
00:09:31,501 --> 00:09:31,536
339 00:09:31,536 --> 00:09:33,365
And that's what I mean
by nervousness.
340
00:09:33,365 --> 00:09:33,400
341 00:09:33,400 --> 00:09:36,368
What was your objection
to coming north, as your
executive officer suggested?
342
00:09:36,368 --> 00:09:36,403
343 00:09:36,403 --> 00:09:39,302
Why, everything was
wrong with that idea that
could be wrong with it, sir.
344
00:09:39,302 --> 00:09:39,337
345 00:09:39,337 --> 00:09:42,685
In the first place,
my orders were
to proceed south.
346
00:09:42,685 --> 00:09:42,720
347 00:09:42,720 --> 00:09:44,825
My mission was screening. 348 00:09:44,825 --> 00:09:44,860
349 00:09:44,860 --> 00:09:47,621
My ship was in
no danger and was
functioning normally.
350
00:09:47,621 --> 00:09:47,656
351 00:09:47,656 --> 00:09:49,727
Why, to drop out of station 352 00:09:49,727 --> 00:09:49,761
353 00:09:49,761 --> 00:09:53,144
and act independently
under those conditions
was unthinkable.
354
00:09:53,144 --> 00:09:53,178
355 00:09:53,178 --> 00:09:55,042
Coming around to north 356 00:09:55,042 --> 00:09:55,077
357 00:09:55,077 --> 00:09:58,632
would have headed
the ship directly into
the heart of the typhoon.
358
00:09:58,632 --> 00:10:00,047
359 00:10:00,047 --> 00:10:03,257
It was not only
a senseless suggestion,
360
00:10:03,257 --> 00:10:03,292
361 00:10:03,292 --> 00:10:05,432
in the circumstances,
it was almost suicidal.
362
00:10:05,432 --> 00:10:05,466
363 00:10:05,466 --> 00:10:09,091
And, I might add, I have
since checked my decisions
of December 18th
364
00:10:09,091 --> 00:10:09,125
365 00:10:09,125 --> 00:10:11,024
with the finest
ship handlers I know,
366
00:10:11,024 --> 00:10:11,058
367 00:10:11,058 --> 00:10:12,715
up to the rank
of rear admiral,
368
00:10:12,715 --> 00:10:12,750
369 00:10:12,750 --> 00:10:14,579
and they've all
Commander...
370
00:10:14,579 --> 00:10:14,614
371 00:10:14,614 --> 00:10:16,201
...that the only course
in that situation
372
00:10:16,201 --> 00:10:16,236
373 00:10:16,236 --> 00:10:18,410
-was south!
-Your last remark...
374
00:10:18,410 --> 00:10:18,445
375 00:10:18,445 --> 00:10:21,413
Commander, your last
remark was hearsay evidence.
That is not acceptable.
376
00:10:21,413 --> 00:10:21,448
377 00:10:21,448 --> 00:10:23,726
I'm sorry, sir.
I'm not up on these
legal distinctions
378
00:10:23,726 --> 00:10:23,761
379 00:10:23,761 --> 00:10:26,108
as much as I should
be, I guess.
380
00:10:26,108 --> 00:10:26,142
381 00:10:26,142 --> 00:10:27,868
Perfectly all right. 382 00:10:27,868 --> 00:10:27,903
383 00:10:27,903 --> 00:10:30,353
Does the defense counsel
move to strike out that
part of the testimony
384
00:10:30,353 --> 00:10:30,388
385 00:10:30,388 --> 00:10:31,803
that was hearsay evidence? 386 00:10:31,803 --> 00:10:33,149
387 00:10:33,149 --> 00:10:37,464
All right, sir,
-I so move.
-No objection.
388
00:10:37,464 --> 00:10:37,498
389 00:10:37,498 --> 00:10:40,156
A ship-handling expert
will be called to testify
on that point, Commander.
390
00:10:40,156 --> 00:10:40,191
391 00:10:40,191 --> 00:10:42,883
I see, and I'm very
glad to know that, sir.
Thank you.
392
00:10:42,883 --> 00:10:42,918
393 00:10:42,918 --> 00:10:45,092
Proceed with
your description
of the relief.
394
00:10:45,092 --> 00:10:46,404
395 00:10:46,404 --> 00:10:47,888
Okay. 396 00:10:47,888 --> 00:10:47,923
397 00:10:47,923 --> 00:10:51,202
Well, it's just that 398 00:10:51,202 --> 00:10:51,236
399 00:10:51,236 --> 00:10:54,343
Maryk kept insisting
on coming north,
400
00:10:54,343 --> 00:10:54,377
401 00:10:54,377 --> 00:10:58,243
more and more stridently
as the weather deteriorated.
402
00:10:58,243 --> 00:10:58,278
403 00:10:58,278 --> 00:11:02,351
Finally, I began
to be a little
concerned about him.
404
00:11:02,351 --> 00:11:02,385
405 00:11:02,385 --> 00:11:05,285
Suddenly he walked up
to me out of the clear sky
406
00:11:05,285 --> 00:11:05,319
407 00:11:05,319 --> 00:11:08,668
and told me
I was on the sick list
and he was relieving me.
408
00:11:08,668 --> 00:11:08,702
409 00:11:08,702 --> 00:11:11,118
It was only when I heard
him shouting orders at
the officer of the deck
410
00:11:11,118 --> 00:11:11,153
411 00:11:11,153 --> 00:11:13,742
[CHATTERING INDISTINCTLY]and countermanding my
instructions to the helm
412
00:11:13,742 --> 00:11:13,776
413 00:11:13,776 --> 00:11:16,779
that I began to realize
what was going on.
414
00:11:16,779 --> 00:11:16,814
415 00:11:16,814 --> 00:11:19,126
Commander,
can you recall
anything at all
416
00:11:19,126 --> 00:11:19,161
417 00:11:19,161 --> 00:11:20,852
in your own bearing
or manner that could
418
00:11:20,852 --> 00:11:20,887
419 00:11:20,887 --> 00:11:23,924
have provoked your
executive officer's act?
420
00:11:23,924 --> 00:11:23,959
421 00:11:23,959 --> 00:11:26,616
Well, truthfully,
sir, I cannot.
422
00:11:26,616 --> 00:11:26,651
423 00:11:26,651 --> 00:11:31,000
Frankly, I don't think
my bearing or manner
had anything to do with it.
424
00:11:31,000 --> 00:11:31,035
425 00:11:31,035 --> 00:11:34,590
It was a pretty
scary situation
at the wheelhouse.
426
00:11:34,590 --> 00:11:34,624
427 00:11:34,624 --> 00:11:38,525
The wind was force 10 to 12,
screeching and all that.
428
00:11:38,525 --> 00:11:38,559
429 00:11:38,559 --> 00:11:40,527
The waves were mountainous. 430 00:11:40,527 --> 00:11:40,561
431 00:11:40,561 --> 00:11:44,669
The barometer was about
as low as it's ever been
in the US Navy history.
432
00:11:44,669 --> 00:11:44,704
433 00:11:44,704 --> 00:11:47,741
We took one
very bad roll, and
I mean a bad one,
434
00:11:47,741 --> 00:11:47,776
435 00:11:47,776 --> 00:11:50,848
and I've done a lot of
North Atlantic rolling, too.
436
00:11:50,848 --> 00:11:50,882
437 00:11:50,882 --> 00:11:53,367
Well, I think Maryk
simply went into panic.
438
00:11:53,367 --> 00:11:53,402
439 00:11:53,402 --> 00:11:55,818
Was the Cainein
grave danger at that moment?
440
00:11:55,818 --> 00:11:57,164
441 00:11:57,164 --> 00:11:59,995
Oh, oh, no, I wouldn't
say that. No, sir.
442
00:11:59,995 --> 00:12:00,029
443 00:12:00,029 --> 00:12:02,342
We righted very nicely
from that bad roll.
444
00:12:02,342 --> 00:12:04,585
445 00:12:04,585 --> 00:12:07,761
He repeatedly tried to
order me off the bridge,
446
00:12:07,761 --> 00:12:07,796
447 00:12:07,796 --> 00:12:10,177
but I stayed
right where I was.
448
00:12:10,177 --> 00:12:10,212
449 00:12:10,212 --> 00:12:14,492
I only gave him orders
when it seemed necessary
for the safety of the ship.
450
00:12:14,492 --> 00:12:14,526
451 00:12:14,526 --> 00:12:16,805
In the situation, 452 00:12:16,805 --> 00:12:16,839
453 00:12:16,839 --> 00:12:21,602
I thought the chief hazard
was any further acts of
frenzy on his part.
454
00:12:21,602 --> 00:12:21,637
455 00:12:21,637 --> 00:12:25,745
And to the extent
that the Cainedid come
safely through the storm,
456
00:12:25,745 --> 00:12:25,779
457 00:12:25,779 --> 00:12:29,990
despite this
unprecedented running amuck
of my executive officer,
458
00:12:29,990 --> 00:12:30,025
459 00:12:30,025 --> 00:12:32,613
I believe my handling
of the emergency
was the correct one.
460
00:12:32,613 --> 00:12:34,512
461 00:12:34,512 --> 00:12:37,446
Did Mr. Maryk cite
any authority at all
when he relieved you?
462
00:12:37,446 --> 00:12:37,480
463 00:12:37,480 --> 00:12:40,552
Oh, he mumbled
something about
Article 184.
464
00:12:40,552 --> 00:12:40,587
465 00:12:40,587 --> 00:12:42,796
I didn't even
catch it at the time.
466
00:12:42,796 --> 00:12:42,831
467 00:12:42,831 --> 00:12:46,075
Later, he said his
authority came from
Articles 184, 185 and 186
468
00:12:46,075 --> 00:12:46,110
469 00:12:46,110 --> 00:12:47,767
of the Navy regulations. 470 00:12:47,767 --> 00:12:47,801
471 00:12:47,801 --> 00:12:49,838
Are you familiar
-with these articles?
Certainly.
472
00:12:49,838 --> 00:12:49,872
473 00:12:49,872 --> 00:12:53,427
In substance,
what do they provide?
474
00:12:53,427 --> 00:12:53,462
475 00:12:53,462 --> 00:12:56,465
Well, as I
understand it, they
make it possible for
476
00:12:56,465 --> 00:12:56,499
477 00:12:56,499 --> 00:12:59,433
an executive officer to
take over in an emergency.
478
00:12:59,433 --> 00:12:59,468
479 00:12:59,468 --> 00:13:03,127
A highly unusual emergency,
where the Captain is...
480
00:13:03,127 --> 00:13:03,161
481 00:13:03,161 --> 00:13:07,821
Well, frankly, where the
Captain's gone absolutely
and hopelessly loony.
482
00:13:07,821 --> 00:13:07,856
483 00:13:07,856 --> 00:13:11,618
Were these articles
properly invoked
in your situation?
484
00:13:11,618 --> 00:13:11,652
485 00:13:11,652 --> 00:13:14,794
Well, I'm sort of an
interested party here.
486
00:13:14,794 --> 00:13:14,828
487 00:13:14,828 --> 00:13:17,003
But you won't have to
take my word for it.
488
00:13:17,003 --> 00:13:17,037
489 00:13:17,037 --> 00:13:20,040
I was successfully
conning my ship
through a typhoon.
490
00:13:20,040 --> 00:13:20,075
491 00:13:20,075 --> 00:13:22,663
Fortunately, there are
130 witnesses to that fact,
492
00:13:22,663 --> 00:13:22,698
493 00:13:22,698 --> 00:13:24,838
every man who was
aboard that ship.
494
00:13:24,838 --> 00:13:24,873
495 00:13:24,873 --> 00:13:27,461
There, again, sir,
you're testifying to the
conclusions of others.
496
00:13:27,461 --> 00:13:27,496
497 00:13:27,496 --> 00:13:29,670
Strike the last sentence of
-the answer from the record.
-I'm sorry.
498
00:13:29,670 --> 00:13:29,705
499 00:13:29,705 --> 00:13:31,465
I'm obviously
no legal expert.
500
00:13:31,465 --> 00:13:31,500
501 00:13:31,500 --> 00:13:32,881
I'll withdraw the sentence. 502 00:13:32,881 --> 00:13:32,915
503 00:13:32,915 --> 00:13:34,641
Have you ever been
mentally ill, sir?
504
00:13:34,641 --> 00:13:36,436
505 00:13:36,436 --> 00:13:38,024
No, sir. 506 00:13:38,024 --> 00:13:38,058
507 00:13:38,058 --> 00:13:40,440
Were you ill
in any way when
Mr. Maryk relieved you?
508
00:13:40,440 --> 00:13:40,474
509 00:13:40,474 --> 00:13:42,097
I was not. 510 00:13:42,097 --> 00:13:42,131
511 00:13:42,131 --> 00:13:44,858
Did you warn your
executive officer of the
consequences of his act?
512
00:13:44,858 --> 00:13:44,893
513 00:13:44,893 --> 00:13:47,171
I told him
he was performing
a mutinous act.
514
00:13:47,171 --> 00:13:47,205
515 00:13:47,205 --> 00:13:48,413
What was his reply? 516 00:13:48,413 --> 00:13:48,448
517 00:13:48,448 --> 00:13:50,588
That he expected
to be court-martialed,
518
00:13:50,588 --> 00:13:50,622
519 00:13:50,622 --> 00:13:53,177
but was going to
retain command anyway.
520
00:13:53,177 --> 00:13:53,211
521 00:13:53,211 --> 00:13:57,215
What was the attitude of
Lieutenant Junior Grade Keith,
the officer of the deck?
522
00:13:57,215 --> 00:13:57,250
523 00:13:57,250 --> 00:13:58,976
He was in a state of panic
as bad as Maryk's.
524
00:13:58,976 --> 00:13:59,010
525 00:13:59,010 --> 00:14:00,391
What was the attitude
of the helmsman?
526
00:14:00,391 --> 00:14:00,425
527 00:14:00,425 --> 00:14:02,876
Stilwell was
emotionally unbalanced,
528
00:14:02,876 --> 00:14:02,911
529 00:14:02,911 --> 00:14:06,362
and for some reason
was very devoted
to Mr. Keith.
530
00:14:06,362 --> 00:14:06,397
531 00:14:06,397 --> 00:14:07,708
They both backed up Maryk. 532 00:14:07,708 --> 00:14:07,743
533 00:14:07,743 --> 00:14:09,365
Is there anything
else you care to
state, Commander,
534
00:14:09,365 --> 00:14:09,400
535 00:14:09,400 --> 00:14:12,506
in connection with the
events of December 18
aboard the Caine?
536
00:14:12,506 --> 00:14:14,129
537 00:14:14,129 --> 00:14:19,237
Well, I've thought a lot
about it all, of course.
538
00:14:19,237 --> 00:14:19,272
539 00:14:19,272 --> 00:14:21,722
It's the gravest
occurrence of my career,
540
00:14:21,722 --> 00:14:21,757
541 00:14:21,757 --> 00:14:25,381
and the only
questionable one
that I'm aware of.
542
00:14:25,381 --> 00:14:25,416
543 00:14:25,416 --> 00:14:28,764
It was an unfortunate
freak accident.
544
00:14:28,764 --> 00:14:28,798
545 00:14:28,798 --> 00:14:33,803
If the OOD
had been anyone
but this immature Keith,
546
00:14:33,803 --> 00:14:33,838
547 00:14:33,838 --> 00:14:36,116
and the helmsman
anyone but Stilwell,
548
00:14:36,116 --> 00:14:36,151
549 00:14:36,151 --> 00:14:38,912
I don't think it
would have happened.
550
00:14:38,912 --> 00:14:38,947
551 00:14:38,947 --> 00:14:42,329
A confident officer
of the deck would have
repudiated Maryk's orders.
552
00:14:42,329 --> 00:14:42,364
553 00:14:42,364 --> 00:14:46,886
And a normal sailor at the
helm would have disregarded
both officers and obeyed me.
554
00:14:46,886 --> 00:14:46,920
555 00:14:46,920 --> 00:14:50,959
It was just bad luck
that these three men,
Maryk, Keith and Stilwell
556
00:14:50,959 --> 00:14:50,993
557 00:14:50,993 --> 00:14:53,375
were combined against me
at a crucial time.
558
00:14:53,375 --> 00:14:53,409
559 00:14:53,409 --> 00:14:56,447
Bad luck for me,
and I'm afraid
worse luck for them.
560
00:14:56,447 --> 00:14:59,450
561 00:14:59,450 --> 00:15:01,383
Court would like
to question the witness.
562
00:15:01,383 --> 00:15:01,417
563 00:15:01,417 --> 00:15:04,593
Commander, you've taken
all the prescribed physical
and mental examinations
564
00:15:04,593 --> 00:15:04,627
565 00:15:04,627 --> 00:15:07,113
incident to entrance
to the Academy,
566
00:15:07,113 --> 00:15:07,147
567 00:15:07,147 --> 00:15:11,186
graduation, commissioning,
promotions and so forth?
568
00:15:11,186 --> 00:15:11,220
569 00:15:11,220 --> 00:15:13,222
Yes, sir,
for 14 years.
570
00:15:13,222 --> 00:15:13,257
571 00:15:13,257 --> 00:15:16,881
Does your medical record
contain any history of
illness, mental or physical?
572
00:15:16,881 --> 00:15:16,916
573 00:15:16,916 --> 00:15:21,575
It does not, sir.
My tonsils were removed
in the fall of 1938.
574
00:15:21,575 --> 00:15:21,610
575 00:15:21,610 --> 00:15:23,957
Have you ever had
an unsatisfactory fitness
report, Commander?
576
00:15:23,957 --> 00:15:23,992
577 00:15:23,992 --> 00:15:27,961
Negative, sir.
I have one letter of
commendation in my jacket.
578
00:15:27,961 --> 00:15:27,996
579 00:15:27,996 --> 00:15:30,205
Commander,
can you account for
Lieutenant Maryk's opinion
580
00:15:30,205 --> 00:15:30,239
581 00:15:30,239 --> 00:15:31,931
that you were mentally ill? 582 00:15:31,931 --> 00:15:37,005
583 00:15:37,005 --> 00:15:39,628
Well, sir, that's
rather a tough one.
584
00:15:39,628 --> 00:15:39,662
585 00:15:39,662 --> 00:15:42,286
Well, I appreciate
that, but I think it
might be helpful.
586
00:15:42,286 --> 00:15:43,701
587 00:15:43,701 --> 00:15:46,221
Well, sir, 588 00:15:46,221 --> 00:15:46,255
589 00:15:46,255 --> 00:15:51,674
I will say that I did assume
command of an extremely
disorganized and dirty ship.
590
00:15:51,674 --> 00:15:51,709
591 00:15:51,709 --> 00:15:54,850
Now that's no reflection
on the officer I relieved.
592
00:15:54,850 --> 00:15:54,884
593 00:15:54,884 --> 00:15:57,473
The Cainehad had a year
and a half of the most
arduous combat duty
594
00:15:57,473 --> 00:15:57,508
595 00:15:57,508 --> 00:15:59,441
and it was understandable. 596 00:15:59,441 --> 00:15:59,475
597 00:15:59,475 --> 00:16:03,479
Still, the safety of that ship
and its crew demanded its
being brought up to snuff.
598
00:16:03,479 --> 00:16:04,308
599 00:16:04,308 --> 00:16:07,138
I took many stern measures. 600 00:16:07,138 --> 00:16:07,173
601 00:16:07,173 --> 00:16:09,589
Lieutenant Maryk,
I may say, from the first,
602
00:16:09,589 --> 00:16:09,623
603 00:16:09,623 --> 00:16:12,281
never saw eye to eye
with me at all on the idea
604
00:16:12,281 --> 00:16:12,316
605 00:16:12,316 --> 00:16:15,215
of making the Caine
a taut ship again.
606
00:16:15,215 --> 00:16:15,250
607 00:16:15,250 --> 00:16:17,631
Maybe he thought I was
crazy to keep trying.
608
00:16:17,631 --> 00:16:22,188
609 00:16:22,188 --> 00:16:23,948
I guess that's
the picture, sir.
610
00:16:23,948 --> 00:16:25,363
611 00:16:25,363 --> 00:16:26,744
No more questions. 612 00:16:26,744 --> 00:16:34,994
613 00:16:34,994 --> 00:16:37,168
Commander Queeg, I should
like to ask you whether
you have ever heard
614
00:16:37,168 --> 00:16:37,203
615 00:16:37,203 --> 00:16:39,101
the expression
"Old Yellow Stain"?
616
00:16:39,101 --> 00:16:40,275
617 00:16:40,275 --> 00:16:42,553
-In what connection?
-In any connection.
618
00:16:42,553 --> 00:16:44,727
619 00:16:44,727 --> 00:16:46,557
Old Yellow Stone? 620 00:16:46,557 --> 00:16:47,558
621 00:16:47,558 --> 00:16:49,905
Old Yellow Stain, sir. 622 00:16:49,905 --> 00:16:50,733
623 00:16:50,733 --> 00:16:53,081
I have not. 624 00:16:53,081 --> 00:16:53,115
625 00:16:53,115 --> 00:16:55,704
You are not aware,
then, that all the
officers of the Caine
626
00:16:55,704 --> 00:16:55,738
627 00:16:55,738 --> 00:16:57,947
habitually referred to
you as Old Yellow Stain?
628
00:16:57,947 --> 00:16:57,982
629 00:16:57,982 --> 00:17:02,952
I object to the question.
This is impertinent
badgering of the witness.
630
00:17:02,952 --> 00:17:05,369
631 00:17:05,369 --> 00:17:08,855
How does Defense Counsel
Greenwald justify this
line of questioning?
632
00:17:08,855 --> 00:17:08,889
633 00:17:08,889 --> 00:17:11,858
If it please the court,
the nickname
Old Yellow Stain
634
00:17:11,858 --> 00:17:11,892
635 00:17:11,892 --> 00:17:14,102
used by the officers
of the Cainewill be
636
00:17:14,102 --> 00:17:14,136
637 00:17:14,136 --> 00:17:18,140
relevant to the issue
of mental competence, sir.
638
00:17:18,140 --> 00:17:18,175
639 00:17:18,175 --> 00:17:21,557
Before ruling,
the court would like to
caution defense counsel.
640
00:17:21,557 --> 00:17:21,592
641 00:17:21,592 --> 00:17:24,077
This is a most unusual
and delicate case.
642
00:17:24,077 --> 00:17:24,112
643 00:17:24,112 --> 00:17:26,355
The honor and career
of an officer with
644
00:17:26,355 --> 00:17:26,390
645 00:17:26,390 --> 00:17:30,566
an unblemished record
of 14 years standing
is involved here.
646
00:17:30,566 --> 00:17:30,601
647 00:17:30,601 --> 00:17:35,054
Defense counsel will have
to take full responsibility
for the conduct of this case.
648
00:17:35,054 --> 00:17:35,088
649 00:17:35,088 --> 00:17:39,196
Subject to the foregoing
comment, the judge advocate's
objection is overruled.
650
00:17:39,196 --> 00:17:39,230
651 00:17:39,230 --> 00:17:41,336
The stenographer will
repeat the question.
652
00:17:41,336 --> 00:17:45,064
653 00:17:45,064 --> 00:17:48,550
"You are not aware,
then, that all the
officers of the Caine
654
00:17:48,550 --> 00:17:48,584
655 00:17:48,584 --> 00:17:52,140
"habitually referred to
you as Old Yellow Stain?"
656
00:17:52,140 --> 00:17:55,626
657 00:17:55,626 --> 00:17:56,868
I'm not aware of it. 658 00:17:56,868 --> 00:17:58,387
659 00:17:58,387 --> 00:18:00,700
No further questions
at this time.
660
00:18:00,700 --> 00:18:00,734
661 00:18:00,734 --> 00:18:03,979
Is that the extent
of your cross-examination,
Lieutenant Greenwald?
662
00:18:03,979 --> 00:18:04,013
663 00:18:04,013 --> 00:18:07,258
Commander Queeg
will be called as a witness
for the defense, sir.
664
00:18:07,258 --> 00:18:07,293
665 00:18:07,293 --> 00:18:08,432
For the defense? 666 00:18:08,432 --> 00:18:09,847
667 00:18:09,847 --> 00:18:11,193
Yes, sir. 668 00:18:11,193 --> 00:18:13,471
669 00:18:13,471 --> 00:18:17,165
Commander, you will refrain
from conversing with
any person, whomsoever,
670
00:18:17,165 --> 00:18:17,199
671 00:18:17,199 --> 00:18:18,959
regarding your
testimony here today.
672
00:18:18,959 --> 00:18:18,994
673 00:18:18,994 --> 00:18:20,478
Aye, sir. 674 00:18:20,478 --> 00:18:20,513
675 00:18:20,513 --> 00:18:21,893
You're excused,
and thank you.
676
00:18:21,893 --> 00:18:22,860
677 00:18:22,860 --> 00:18:24,172
Thank you, Captain. 678 00:18:24,172 --> 00:18:27,140
679 00:18:27,140 --> 00:18:29,556
Call Lieutenant
Thomas Keefer.
680
00:18:29,556 --> 00:18:29,591
681 00:18:29,591 --> 00:18:31,248
Lieutenant Thomas Keefer. 682 00:18:31,248 --> 00:18:32,835
683 00:18:32,835 --> 00:18:34,078
How do I look? 684 00:18:34,078 --> 00:18:34,837
685 00:18:34,837 --> 00:18:36,322
Like an idiot. 686 00:18:36,322 --> 00:18:37,495
687 00:18:37,495 --> 00:18:38,565
Give 'em hell, Tom. 688 00:18:38,565 --> 00:19:02,417
689 00:19:02,417 --> 00:19:05,178
I'm glad he's
-here to testify.
You are?
690
00:19:05,178 --> 00:19:05,213
691 00:19:05,213 --> 00:19:08,043
Hell, he knows
everything Captain Queeg did.
692
00:19:08,043 --> 00:19:08,077
693 00:19:08,077 --> 00:19:10,079
You do solemnly swear
the evidence you shall
give in this court
694
00:19:10,079 --> 00:19:10,114
695 00:19:10,114 --> 00:19:11,874
shall be the truth,
the whole truth and
nothing but the truth,
696
00:19:11,874 --> 00:19:11,909
697 00:19:11,909 --> 00:19:13,669
-so help you God?
-I do so swear.
698
00:19:13,669 --> 00:19:16,948
699 00:19:16,948 --> 00:19:19,537
Tom Keefer will tell
the things straight.
700
00:19:19,537 --> 00:19:19,572
701 00:19:19,572 --> 00:19:21,160
If I had my way,
Lieutenant Thomas Keefer
702
00:19:21,160 --> 00:19:21,194
703 00:19:21,194 --> 00:19:22,575
would never appear
in this courtroom.
704
00:19:22,575 --> 00:19:22,609
705 00:19:22,609 --> 00:19:24,473
State your name,
rank and present station.
706
00:19:24,473 --> 00:19:24,508
707 00:19:24,508 --> 00:19:26,648
Thomas Keefer,
Lieutenant USNR,
708
00:19:26,648 --> 00:19:26,682
709 00:19:26,682 --> 00:19:28,822
communication officer
of the USS Caine.
710
00:19:28,822 --> 00:19:28,857
711 00:19:28,857 --> 00:19:30,997
If you recognize
the accused, state as whom.
712
00:19:30,997 --> 00:19:32,723
713 00:19:32,723 --> 00:19:34,932
Steve Maryk,
Lieutenant Stephen Maryk,
714
00:19:34,932 --> 00:19:34,966
715 00:19:34,966 --> 00:19:37,452
executive officer
of the Caine.
716
00:19:37,452 --> 00:19:37,486
717 00:19:37,486 --> 00:19:39,557
What is your occupation
in civilian life?
718
00:19:39,557 --> 00:19:40,731
719 00:19:40,731 --> 00:19:42,146
I'm a writer. 720 00:19:42,146 --> 00:19:42,181
721 00:19:42,181 --> 00:19:44,113
And has your work
been published?
722
00:19:44,113 --> 00:19:44,148
723 00:19:44,148 --> 00:19:47,289
A number of my short
stories have been
published, yes, sir.
724
00:19:47,289 --> 00:19:47,324
725 00:19:47,324 --> 00:19:49,084
In national magazines. 726 00:19:49,084 --> 00:19:49,118
727 00:19:49,118 --> 00:19:52,087
Have you done any
writing in your spare time
while in service?
728
00:19:52,087 --> 00:19:52,121
729 00:19:52,121 --> 00:19:54,365
I've completed
half a war novel.
730
00:19:54,365 --> 00:19:54,400
731 00:19:54,400 --> 00:19:57,196
What is the title? Multitudes, Multitudes. 732 00:19:57,196 --> 00:19:58,887
733 00:19:58,887 --> 00:20:02,615
What was that? Multitudes, Multitudes,sir. 734 00:20:02,615 --> 00:20:02,649
735 00:20:02,649 --> 00:20:04,444
Oh, thank you. 736 00:20:04,444 --> 00:20:04,479
737 00:20:04,479 --> 00:20:07,378
And has this novel
Multitudes, Multitudes,
though incomplete,
738
00:20:07,378 --> 00:20:07,413
739 00:20:07,413 --> 00:20:09,553
recently been accepted
by a New York publisher?
740
00:20:09,553 --> 00:20:09,587
741 00:20:09,587 --> 00:20:11,071
Yes. 742 00:20:11,071 --> 00:20:11,106
743 00:20:11,106 --> 00:20:13,419
I'm asking these
questions to establish
your reliability
744
00:20:13,419 --> 00:20:13,453
745 00:20:13,453 --> 00:20:15,283
as an observer
of personalities.
746
00:20:15,283 --> 00:20:15,317
747 00:20:15,317 --> 00:20:17,285
I understand, sir. 748 00:20:17,285 --> 00:20:17,319
749 00:20:17,319 --> 00:20:20,943
Now, Lieutenant Keefer,
were you serving aboard the
Caineon December 18, 1944,
750
00:20:20,943 --> 00:20:20,978
751 00:20:20,978 --> 00:20:23,187
-in your present capacity?
Yes.
752
00:20:23,187 --> 00:20:23,222
753 00:20:23,222 --> 00:20:25,845
Was Captain Queeg
relieved of command
on that date?
754
00:20:25,845 --> 00:20:25,879
755 00:20:25,879 --> 00:20:27,398
-He was, sir.
-By whom?
756
00:20:27,398 --> 00:20:28,917
757 00:20:28,917 --> 00:20:30,608
The accused. 758 00:20:30,608 --> 00:20:30,643
759 00:20:30,643 --> 00:20:33,818
Describe how
you learned the
Captain had been relieved.
760
00:20:33,818 --> 00:20:33,853
761 00:20:33,853 --> 00:20:37,097
Well, Mr. Maryk
passed over
the loudspeaker
762
00:20:37,097 --> 00:20:37,132
763 00:20:37,132 --> 00:20:40,066
for all officers to
lay up to the wheelhouse.
764
00:20:40,066 --> 00:20:40,100
765 00:20:40,100 --> 00:20:42,827
When we got there,
he told us that the
Captain was sick
766
00:20:42,827 --> 00:20:42,862
767 00:20:42,862 --> 00:20:45,623
and that he had
assumed command.
768
00:20:45,623 --> 00:20:45,658
769 00:20:45,658 --> 00:20:50,145
Did Captain Queeg
exhibit any external
signs of being sick?
770
00:20:50,145 --> 00:20:50,179
771 00:20:50,179 --> 00:20:54,632
Well, at the height of
a typhoon nobody aboard
a four-piper looks very well.
772
00:20:54,632 --> 00:20:56,185
773 00:20:56,185 --> 00:20:58,187
Was he raving,
-or foaming?
-No.
774
00:20:58,187 --> 00:20:58,222
775 00:20:58,222 --> 00:21:01,398
Did he look any worse,
-say, than Lieutenant Keith?
-No.
776
00:21:01,398 --> 00:21:01,432
777 00:21:01,432 --> 00:21:03,158
Or Maryk? 778 00:21:03,158 --> 00:21:03,192
779 00:21:03,192 --> 00:21:08,577
Well, we were all tired
and dripping and
just knocked out.
780
00:21:08,577 --> 00:21:08,612
781 00:21:08,612 --> 00:21:13,306
Mr. Keefer, did you make
any effort to persuade Maryk
to restore Queeg to command?
782
00:21:13,306 --> 00:21:13,341
783 00:21:13,341 --> 00:21:15,964
I did not. 784 00:21:15,964 --> 00:21:15,998
785 00:21:15,998 --> 00:21:18,656
Didn't you feel
the seriousness
of the situation?
786
00:21:18,656 --> 00:21:18,691
787 00:21:18,691 --> 00:21:20,486
I certainly did, sir. 788 00:21:20,486 --> 00:21:22,660
789 00:21:22,660 --> 00:21:25,284
Well, why'd you take
no remedial action?
790
00:21:25,284 --> 00:21:25,318
791 00:21:25,318 --> 00:21:30,254
I wasn't present when the
Captain was relieved.
Maryk was in full command.
792
00:21:30,254 --> 00:21:31,324
793 00:21:31,324 --> 00:21:33,222
The entire ship was
obeying his orders.
794
00:21:33,222 --> 00:21:33,257
795 00:21:33,257 --> 00:21:36,398
I decided that
for the safety
of the entire ship
796
00:21:36,398 --> 00:21:36,433
797 00:21:36,433 --> 00:21:40,091
my best course was
to obey his orders.
That was what I did.
798
00:21:40,091 --> 00:21:40,126
799 00:21:40,126 --> 00:21:41,748
Now, Mr. Keefer,
were you aboard the Caine
800
00:21:41,748 --> 00:21:41,783
801 00:21:41,783 --> 00:21:44,406
throughout the period
Captain Queeg was in command?
802
00:21:44,406 --> 00:21:44,441
803 00:21:44,441 --> 00:21:45,890
I was. 804 00:21:45,890 --> 00:21:45,925
805 00:21:45,925 --> 00:21:48,962
Did you ever
observe any evidence
of insanity in him?
806
00:21:48,962 --> 00:21:48,997
807 00:21:48,997 --> 00:21:53,312
I don't... I can't
answer that question,
not being a psychiatrist.
808
00:21:53,312 --> 00:21:53,346
809 00:21:53,346 --> 00:21:55,072
Well, surely now,
Mr. Keefer, as a writer,
810
00:21:55,072 --> 00:21:55,106
811 00:21:55,106 --> 00:21:57,419
you're not
wholly ignorant
of such matters.
812
00:21:57,419 --> 00:21:57,454
813 00:21:57,454 --> 00:22:00,353
Well, not wholly
ignorant, I hope not, sir.
814
00:22:00,353 --> 00:22:00,388
815 00:22:00,388 --> 00:22:03,598
What, for example,
is a Rorschach Test?
816
00:22:03,598 --> 00:22:03,632
817 00:22:03,632 --> 00:22:05,945
I believe that's
the inkblot test.
818
00:22:05,945 --> 00:22:05,979
819 00:22:05,979 --> 00:22:10,018
The analyst detects
psychopathic tendencies
in a person
820
00:22:10,018 --> 00:22:10,052
821 00:22:10,052 --> 00:22:12,123
by showing him inkblots
and getting the person
822
00:22:12,123 --> 00:22:12,158
823 00:22:12,158 --> 00:22:14,160
to say what the
shapes resemble.
824
00:22:14,160 --> 00:22:14,194
825 00:22:14,194 --> 00:22:16,300
And who's Alfred Adler? 826 00:22:16,300 --> 00:22:16,335
827 00:22:16,335 --> 00:22:19,890
Well, these things
are very elementary.
Adler split from Freud.
828
00:22:19,890 --> 00:22:19,924
829 00:22:19,924 --> 00:22:22,306
Any college man can
tell you that much, sir.
830
00:22:22,306 --> 00:22:22,341
831 00:22:22,341 --> 00:22:25,551
A novelist, however,
is apt to understand and
appreciate these things
832
00:22:25,551 --> 00:22:25,585
833 00:22:25,585 --> 00:22:29,002
more than the
average man.
834
00:22:29,002 --> 00:22:29,037
835 00:22:29,037 --> 00:22:32,178
Well, our work
is in the narration
of human conduct.
836
00:22:32,178 --> 00:22:33,352
837 00:22:33,352 --> 00:22:35,146
Naturally. 838 00:22:35,146 --> 00:22:35,181
839 00:22:35,181 --> 00:22:37,114
Now, Mr. Keefer, with
your grasp of such matters,
840
00:22:37,114 --> 00:22:37,148
841 00:22:37,148 --> 00:22:38,978
if you see a man
rushing up and
down passageways
842
00:22:38,978 --> 00:22:39,012
843 00:22:39,012 --> 00:22:41,912
screaming that
a tiger is after him
when there is no tiger,
844
00:22:41,912 --> 00:22:41,946
845 00:22:41,946 --> 00:22:45,053
would you venture
to say the man was
temporarily deranged?
846
00:22:45,053 --> 00:22:45,674
847 00:22:45,674 --> 00:22:46,848
I would, sir. 848 00:22:46,848 --> 00:22:46,882
849 00:22:46,882 --> 00:22:49,782
Did Captain Queeg ever
exhibit such behavior?
850
00:22:49,782 --> 00:22:49,816
851 00:22:49,816 --> 00:22:52,716
No. Nothing like that. 852 00:22:52,716 --> 00:22:52,750
853 00:22:52,750 --> 00:22:54,442
Did you ever think
he may be insane?
854
00:22:54,442 --> 00:22:57,237
855 00:22:57,237 --> 00:22:58,963
Did you ever think
he might be insane?
856
00:22:58,963 --> 00:22:58,998
857 00:22:58,998 --> 00:23:00,620
Objection. The witness
isn't an expert.
858
00:23:00,620 --> 00:23:00,655
859 00:23:00,655 --> 00:23:02,104
I withdraw the question. 860 00:23:02,104 --> 00:23:03,796
861 00:23:03,796 --> 00:23:07,282
Now, Mr. Keefer,
were you informed at any
time prior to December 18
862
00:23:07,282 --> 00:23:07,316
863 00:23:07,316 --> 00:23:10,078
that Mr. Maryk
suspected Queeg
of being mentally ill?
864
00:23:10,078 --> 00:23:10,112
865 00:23:10,112 --> 00:23:12,598
-Yes, sir.
-Describe how you
learned this fact.
866
00:23:12,598 --> 00:23:14,220
867 00:23:14,220 --> 00:23:15,635
Now let me see. 868 00:23:15,635 --> 00:23:15,670
869 00:23:15,670 --> 00:23:19,570
Two weeks before the typhoon,
Maryk showed me a medical log
870
00:23:19,570 --> 00:23:19,605
871 00:23:19,605 --> 00:23:22,055
he'd kept on
Queeg's behavior.
872
00:23:22,055 --> 00:23:22,090
873 00:23:22,090 --> 00:23:24,748
He asked me
to come with him
to the New Jersey
874
00:23:24,748 --> 00:23:24,782
875 00:23:24,782 --> 00:23:27,682
to report the situation
to Admiral Halsey.
876
00:23:27,682 --> 00:23:27,716
877 00:23:27,716 --> 00:23:29,960
Did you consent
-to go with him?
-Yes, I did.
878
00:23:29,960 --> 00:23:33,895
879 00:23:33,895 --> 00:23:34,965
Why? 880 00:23:34,965 --> 00:23:35,828
881 00:23:35,828 --> 00:23:39,590
He was my executive officer 882 00:23:39,590 --> 00:23:39,625
883 00:23:39,625 --> 00:23:41,730
and my close friend. 884 00:23:41,730 --> 00:23:46,494
885 00:23:46,494 --> 00:23:49,980
Did you believe
the log justified the
relief of Captain Queeg?
886
00:23:49,980 --> 00:23:51,395
887 00:23:51,395 --> 00:23:53,880
No. No. 888 00:23:53,880 --> 00:23:53,915
889 00:23:53,915 --> 00:23:56,469
When we arrived
aboard the New Jersey
890
00:23:56,469 --> 00:23:57,505
891 00:23:57,505 --> 00:23:59,783
I told him as
forcibly as I could
892
00:23:59,783 --> 00:23:59,817
893 00:23:59,817 --> 00:24:02,613
that the log would not
justify the action.
894
00:24:02,613 --> 00:24:06,237
895 00:24:06,237 --> 00:24:07,618
What was
his response?
896
00:24:07,618 --> 00:24:10,241
897 00:24:10,241 --> 00:24:12,934
Well, after a lot of arguing, 898 00:24:12,934 --> 00:24:12,968
899 00:24:12,968 --> 00:24:17,663
he followed my advice.
We returned to the Caine.
900
00:24:17,663 --> 00:24:17,697
901 00:24:17,697 --> 00:24:21,252
Were you surprised then
two weeks later when
he relieved the Captain?
902
00:24:21,252 --> 00:24:22,461
903 00:24:22,461 --> 00:24:24,428
I was flabbergasted. 904 00:24:24,428 --> 00:24:24,463
905 00:24:24,463 --> 00:24:26,948
Lieutenant,
speak up so the
court can hear you.
906
00:24:26,948 --> 00:24:26,982
907 00:24:26,982 --> 00:24:29,260
I was flabbergasted, sir. 908 00:24:29,260 --> 00:24:29,295
909 00:24:29,295 --> 00:24:31,159
Were you pleased,
Mr. Keefer?
910
00:24:31,159 --> 00:24:32,988
911 00:24:32,988 --> 00:24:34,093
No. 912 00:24:34,093 --> 00:24:35,094
913 00:24:35,094 --> 00:24:37,579
I was badly disturbed. 914 00:24:37,579 --> 00:24:37,614
915 00:24:37,614 --> 00:24:39,132
We still can't
hear you, Lieutenant.
916
00:24:39,132 --> 00:24:39,167
917 00:24:39,167 --> 00:24:41,272
I was badly disturbed, sir. 918 00:24:41,272 --> 00:24:41,307
919 00:24:41,307 --> 00:24:45,656
I thought at best
he would be in
grave difficulties.
920
00:24:45,656 --> 00:24:47,969
921 00:24:47,969 --> 00:24:49,833
It was a terrible situation. 922 00:24:49,833 --> 00:24:54,182
923 00:24:54,182 --> 00:24:56,184
No further questions. 924 00:24:56,184 --> 00:24:56,218
925 00:24:56,218 --> 00:24:58,635
No questions at this time. 926 00:24:58,635 --> 00:24:58,669
927 00:24:58,669 --> 00:25:01,534
Does defense counsel
intend to recall this
witness at a later date?
928
00:25:01,534 --> 00:25:01,569
929 00:25:01,569 --> 00:25:03,122
No, sir. 930 00:25:03,122 --> 00:25:03,156
931 00:25:03,156 --> 00:25:05,158
No cross-examination of this
highly material witness?
932
00:25:05,158 --> 00:25:05,193
933 00:25:05,193 --> 00:25:06,435
No, sir. 934 00:25:06,435 --> 00:25:08,265
935 00:25:08,265 --> 00:25:11,233
The court will
question the witness.
936
00:25:11,233 --> 00:25:11,268
937 00:25:11,268 --> 00:25:14,961
Now, Mr. Keefer,
as to this so-called
medical log,
938
00:25:14,961 --> 00:25:14,996
939 00:25:14,996 --> 00:25:16,998
the facts are contained
which convinced
Lieutenant Maryk
940
00:25:16,998 --> 00:25:17,032
941 00:25:17,032 --> 00:25:19,552
that he should
report the Captain
to Admiral Halsey,
942
00:25:19,552 --> 00:25:19,587
943 00:25:19,587 --> 00:25:20,933
didn't convince you.
Is that right?
944
00:25:20,933 --> 00:25:20,967
945 00:25:20,967 --> 00:25:22,313
-They did not, sir.
-Why not?
946
00:25:22,313 --> 00:25:24,143
947 00:25:24,143 --> 00:25:29,113
Sir, speaking
from ignorance...
948
00:25:29,113 --> 00:25:29,148
949 00:25:29,148 --> 00:25:34,809
It's always seemed to me
that mental disability was
a relative thing.
950
00:25:34,809 --> 00:25:34,843
951 00:25:34,843 --> 00:25:38,467
Captain Queeg was
a very strict disciplinarian
952
00:25:38,467 --> 00:25:38,502
953 00:25:38,502 --> 00:25:43,403
and extremely meticulous
at hunting down small matters.
954
00:25:43,403 --> 00:25:43,438
955 00:25:43,438 --> 00:25:48,477
There were several
occasions where I thought
he bore down too hard
956
00:25:48,477 --> 00:25:48,512
957 00:25:48,512 --> 00:25:51,722
and those were
the things that were
recorded in the medical log.
958
00:25:51,722 --> 00:25:53,068
959 00:25:53,068 --> 00:25:55,450
They were very unpleasant. 960 00:25:55,450 --> 00:25:55,484
961 00:25:55,484 --> 00:26:01,145
But to jump from them
to a conclusion that the
Captain was a maniac, no.
962
00:26:01,145 --> 00:26:01,180
963 00:26:01,180 --> 00:26:05,667
No, in all honesty
I was against
Maryk doing that.
964
00:26:05,667 --> 00:26:07,635
965 00:26:07,635 --> 00:26:09,119
No further questions. 966 00:26:09,119 --> 00:26:09,153
967 00:26:09,153 --> 00:26:11,984
You'll not discuss your
testimony outside of
this courtroom.
968
00:26:11,984 --> 00:26:12,018
969 00:26:12,018 --> 00:26:13,468
Witness excused. 970 00:26:13,468 --> 00:26:19,647
971 00:26:19,647 --> 00:26:21,303
Why didn't you
cross-examine
Tom Keefer?
972
00:26:21,303 --> 00:26:21,338
973 00:26:21,338 --> 00:26:22,719
Why'd you let him
off like that?
974
00:26:22,719 --> 00:26:22,753
975 00:26:22,753 --> 00:26:25,135
Call Signalman
Third Class Urban.
976
00:26:25,135 --> 00:26:29,380
977 00:26:29,380 --> 00:26:32,556
Signalman Third Class Urban. 978 00:26:32,556 --> 00:26:32,591
979 00:26:32,591 --> 00:26:35,835
Just tell the truth,
the whole truth
and nothing but the truth.
980
00:26:35,835 --> 00:26:35,870
981 00:26:35,870 --> 00:26:37,526
Excuse me, sir. Sir. 982 00:26:37,526 --> 00:26:39,667
983 00:26:39,667 --> 00:26:41,496
Damn it,
he should have
talked himself.
984
00:26:41,496 --> 00:26:41,530
985 00:26:41,530 --> 00:26:44,395
Sure he should.
You don't understand,
do you?
986
00:26:44,395 --> 00:26:47,675
987 00:26:47,675 --> 00:26:49,504
Come up here and
be sworn in, son.
988
00:26:49,504 --> 00:26:54,889
989 00:26:54,889 --> 00:26:56,891
You do solemnly swear
the evidence you shall
give in this court
990
00:26:56,891 --> 00:26:56,925
991 00:26:56,925 --> 00:26:58,824
shall be the truth,
the whole truth, and
nothing but the truth,
992
00:26:58,824 --> 00:26:58,858
993 00:26:58,858 --> 00:27:00,135
-so help you God?
-Aye, sir.
994
00:27:00,135 --> 00:27:08,765
995 00:27:08,765 --> 00:27:11,664
State your name, rank
and present position.
996
00:27:11,664 --> 00:27:11,699
997 00:27:11,699 --> 00:27:17,152
Junius Hannerford Urban,
Signalman, Third Class,
USN of the USS Caine,sir.
998
00:27:17,152 --> 00:27:17,187
999 00:27:17,187 --> 00:27:19,258
If you recognize
the accused,
state as whom.
1000
00:27:19,258 --> 00:27:19,879
1001 00:27:19,879 --> 00:27:20,984
Sir? 1002 00:27:20,984 --> 00:27:22,433
1003 00:27:22,433 --> 00:27:24,159
Do you recognize the
officer at that table?
1004
00:27:24,159 --> 00:27:26,023
1005 00:27:26,023 --> 00:27:27,784
Which one, sir?
There are four.
1006
00:27:27,784 --> 00:27:27,818
1007 00:27:27,818 --> 00:27:29,613
Name the one you recognize. 1008 00:27:29,613 --> 00:27:29,648
1009 00:27:29,648 --> 00:27:31,511
Well, that's
the exec, sir.
1010
00:27:31,511 --> 00:27:31,546
1011 00:27:31,546 --> 00:27:32,685
His name? 1012 00:27:32,685 --> 00:27:32,720
1013 00:27:32,720 --> 00:27:33,824
He's Mr. Maryk. 1014 00:27:33,824 --> 00:27:33,859
1015 00:27:33,859 --> 00:27:35,550
What's he the exec of? 1016 00:27:35,550 --> 00:27:35,584
1017 00:27:35,584 --> 00:27:36,620
Well, the ship. 1018 00:27:36,620 --> 00:27:36,655
1019 00:27:36,655 --> 00:27:37,656
Name the ship. 1020 00:27:37,656 --> 00:27:38,311
1021 00:27:38,311 --> 00:27:39,416
The Caine. 1022 00:27:39,416 --> 00:27:39,450
1023 00:27:39,450 --> 00:27:40,486
Thank you. 1024 00:27:40,486 --> 00:27:40,520
1025 00:27:40,520 --> 00:27:42,591
Sorry, sir. 1026 00:27:42,591 --> 00:27:42,626
1027 00:27:42,626 --> 00:27:46,699
Urban, were you serving aboard
the Cainein your present
capacity on 18 December, 1944?
1028
00:27:46,699 --> 00:27:47,735
1029 00:27:47,735 --> 00:27:49,944
Sure, I was aboard, sir. 1030 00:27:49,944 --> 00:27:49,978
1031 00:27:49,978 --> 00:27:53,361
Were you in the pilot house
when Lieutenant Maryk
relieved Captain Queeg?
1032
00:27:53,361 --> 00:27:54,120
1033 00:27:54,120 --> 00:27:55,328
Yes, sir. 1034 00:27:55,328 --> 00:27:55,363
1035 00:27:55,363 --> 00:27:58,435
Who else was in the
wheelhouse at the time?
1036
00:27:58,435 --> 00:27:58,469
1037 00:27:58,469 --> 00:28:00,851
Well,
there was the Captain
and Mr. Maryk, sir.
1038
00:28:00,851 --> 00:28:01,749
1039 00:28:01,749 --> 00:28:03,095
Yes. 1040 00:28:03,095 --> 00:28:04,234
1041 00:28:04,234 --> 00:28:05,545
And the helmsman. 1042 00:28:05,545 --> 00:28:05,580
1043 00:28:05,580 --> 00:28:06,926
His name? 1044 00:28:06,926 --> 00:28:06,961
1045 00:28:06,961 --> 00:28:07,996
Stilwell. 1046 00:28:07,996 --> 00:28:08,031
1047 00:28:08,031 --> 00:28:09,032
Who else? 1048 00:28:09,032 --> 00:28:11,759
1049 00:28:11,759 --> 00:28:13,761
-The OOD.
-His name?
1050
00:28:13,761 --> 00:28:13,795
1051 00:28:13,795 --> 00:28:15,107
Mr. Keith. 1052 00:28:15,107 --> 00:28:15,141
1053 00:28:15,141 --> 00:28:17,109
What were you doing
in the wheelhouse
at the time?
1054
00:28:17,109 --> 00:28:17,143
1055 00:28:17,143 --> 00:28:19,456
Well, I had
the watch, sir.
1056
00:28:19,456 --> 00:28:19,490
1057 00:28:19,490 --> 00:28:23,046
Urban, describe,
in your own words,
1058
00:28:23,046 --> 00:28:23,080
1059 00:28:23,080 --> 00:28:24,806
how Lieutenant Maryk
relieved Captain Queeg.
1060
00:28:24,806 --> 00:28:26,946
1061 00:28:26,946 --> 00:28:29,880
Well, he said,
"I relieve you, sir."
1062
00:28:29,880 --> 00:28:33,056
1063 00:28:33,056 --> 00:28:35,127
What was
happening at the time?
1064
00:28:35,127 --> 00:28:36,507
1065 00:28:36,507 --> 00:28:39,752
Well, the ship was
rolling very bad.
1066
00:28:39,752 --> 00:28:39,787
1067 00:28:39,787 --> 00:28:44,136
Urban, describe
everything that happened
1068
00:28:44,136 --> 00:28:44,170
1069 00:28:44,170 --> 00:28:47,587
in the 10 minutes
before the Captain
was relieved.
1070
00:28:47,587 --> 00:28:47,622
1071 00:28:47,622 --> 00:28:50,211
Well, like I say,
the ship was
rolling very bad.
1072
00:28:50,211 --> 00:28:54,318
1073 00:28:54,318 --> 00:28:56,389
That's all? 1074 00:28:56,389 --> 00:28:56,424
1075 00:28:56,424 --> 00:28:57,977
Did the exec
say anything?
1076
00:28:57,977 --> 00:28:59,634
1077 00:28:59,634 --> 00:29:02,257
Did the Captain
say anything?
1078
00:29:02,257 --> 00:29:02,292
1079 00:29:02,292 --> 00:29:04,087
Did the OOD
say anything?
1080
00:29:04,087 --> 00:29:06,675
1081 00:29:06,675 --> 00:29:09,989
Did the ship just
roll in silence
for 10 minutes?
1082
00:29:09,989 --> 00:29:10,024
1083 00:29:10,024 --> 00:29:11,439
Well... 1084 00:29:11,439 --> 00:29:12,923
1085 00:29:12,923 --> 00:29:15,892
I think the Captain
wanted to come north
1086
00:29:15,892 --> 00:29:15,926
1087 00:29:15,926 --> 00:29:18,998
and the exec wanted
to come south.
1088
00:29:18,998 --> 00:29:19,033
1089 00:29:19,033 --> 00:29:21,518
Or the other way around
or something like that.
1090
00:29:21,518 --> 00:29:21,552
1091 00:29:21,552 --> 00:29:23,831
Why did the Captain
want to come south?
1092
00:29:23,831 --> 00:29:23,865
1093 00:29:23,865 --> 00:29:25,833
I don't know, sir. 1094 00:29:25,833 --> 00:29:25,867
1095 00:29:25,867 --> 00:29:28,318
Why did the exec
want to come north?
1096
00:29:28,318 --> 00:29:28,352
1097 00:29:28,352 --> 00:29:29,491
Sir, I'm a signalman. 1098 00:29:29,491 --> 00:29:29,526
1099 00:29:29,526 --> 00:29:32,529
But the Captain did not 1100 00:29:32,529 --> 00:29:32,563
1101 00:29:32,563 --> 00:29:36,636
act queer or crazy
in any way, at any time
that morning, correct?
1102
00:29:36,636 --> 00:29:36,671
1103 00:29:36,671 --> 00:29:39,398
The Captain was the
same as always, sir.
1104
00:29:39,398 --> 00:29:40,261
1105 00:29:40,261 --> 00:29:41,952
Crazy or sane, Urban? 1106 00:29:41,952 --> 00:29:41,987
1107 00:29:41,987 --> 00:29:45,335
He was sane, sir.
As far as I knew.
1108
00:29:45,335 --> 00:29:45,369
1109 00:29:45,369 --> 00:29:46,681
No further questions. 1110 00:29:46,681 --> 00:29:51,686
1111 00:29:51,686 --> 00:29:54,240
Urban, were you aboard
when the Cainecut
its own tow cable
1112
00:29:54,240 --> 00:29:54,275
1113 00:29:54,275 --> 00:29:56,449
the time it was towing targets
outside Pearl Harbor?
1114
00:29:56,449 --> 00:29:56,484
1115 00:29:56,484 --> 00:29:58,831
Yes, sir.
-What were you doing at
the time that it happened?
1116
00:29:58,831 --> 00:29:58,866
1117 00:29:58,866 --> 00:30:00,799
Well, I was... 1118 00:30:00,799 --> 00:30:00,833
1119 00:30:00,833 --> 00:30:04,664
Well, that is,
the Captain was eating...
1120
00:30:04,664 --> 00:30:04,699
1121 00:30:04,699 --> 00:30:07,184
He was balling me out
on the bridge, sir.
1122
00:30:07,184 --> 00:30:07,219
1123 00:30:07,219 --> 00:30:08,668
What for? 1124 00:30:08,668 --> 00:30:08,703
1125 00:30:08,703 --> 00:30:10,291
My shirt tails was out. 1126 00:30:10,291 --> 00:30:10,325
1127 00:30:10,325 --> 00:30:12,707
Was the Captain
very strict on the
subject of shirt tails?
1128
00:30:12,707 --> 00:30:12,741
1129 00:30:12,741 --> 00:30:15,192
Oh, he was nut... 1130 00:30:15,192 --> 00:30:15,227
1131 00:30:15,227 --> 00:30:19,541
I mean, yes, sir.
He was very strict
on shirt tails, sir.
1132
00:30:19,541 --> 00:30:19,576
1133 00:30:19,576 --> 00:30:22,096
So, while the
Captain was discussing
your shirt tails
1134
00:30:22,096 --> 00:30:22,130
1135 00:30:22,130 --> 00:30:24,650
the ship went around in
a circle and steamed over
her own towline.
1136
00:30:24,650 --> 00:30:24,684
1137 00:30:24,684 --> 00:30:26,755
I object
to the question.
1138
00:30:26,755 --> 00:30:26,790
1139 00:30:26,790 --> 00:30:29,034
I object to the question.
Counsel has tricked
the witness
1140
00:30:29,034 --> 00:30:29,068
1141 00:30:29,068 --> 00:30:32,071
with leading questions
into asserting as fact
the Cainecut a towline.
1142
00:30:32,071 --> 00:30:32,106
1143 00:30:32,106 --> 00:30:35,557
A material point
not touched upon
in direct examination.
1144
00:30:35,557 --> 00:30:35,592
1145 00:30:35,592 --> 00:30:37,318
If it please the court,
the witness stated
1146
00:30:37,318 --> 00:30:37,352
1147 00:30:37,352 --> 00:30:38,664
he had never
seen the Captain
do anything crazy.
1148
00:30:38,664 --> 00:30:38,698
1149 00:30:38,698 --> 00:30:40,562
I'm attempting
to refute this.
1150
00:30:40,562 --> 00:30:40,597
1151 00:30:40,597 --> 00:30:44,083
Defense counsel have
the opportunity to
originate evidence later.
1152
00:30:44,083 --> 00:30:44,118
1153 00:30:44,118 --> 00:30:45,947
Objection sustained. 1154 00:30:45,947 --> 00:30:45,982
1155 00:30:45,982 --> 00:30:48,363
The cross-examination
thus far will be stricken
from the record.
1156
00:30:48,363 --> 00:30:50,814
1157 00:30:50,814 --> 00:30:53,472
Urban, what is a
paranoid personality?
1158
00:30:53,472 --> 00:30:55,715
1159 00:30:55,715 --> 00:30:56,855
Sir? 1160 00:30:56,855 --> 00:30:56,889
1161 00:30:56,889 --> 00:30:59,581
Could you recognize
a psychotic person?
1162
00:30:59,581 --> 00:31:00,272
1163 00:31:00,272 --> 00:31:01,756
Me? 1164 00:31:01,756 --> 00:31:03,068
1165 00:31:03,068 --> 00:31:05,242
No further questions. 1166 00:31:05,242 --> 00:31:06,209
1167 00:31:06,209 --> 00:31:08,383
Urban, 1168 00:31:08,383 --> 00:31:08,418
1169 00:31:08,418 --> 00:31:11,317
you will not discuss your
testimony with anyone outside
this courtroom, understood?
1170
00:31:11,317 --> 00:31:11,352
1171 00:31:11,352 --> 00:31:12,560
No, sir. 1172 00:31:12,560 --> 00:31:12,594
1173 00:31:12,594 --> 00:31:13,941
Excused. 1174 00:31:13,941 --> 00:31:13,975
1175 00:31:13,975 --> 00:31:15,597
Thank you, sir. 1176 00:31:15,597 --> 00:31:20,154
1177 00:31:20,154 --> 00:31:21,741
Call Chief Watertender,
Bud.
1178
00:31:21,741 --> 00:31:21,776
1179 00:31:21,776 --> 00:31:23,191
One moment. 1180 00:31:23,191 --> 00:31:23,226
1181 00:31:23,226 --> 00:31:25,711
I understand that
the judge advocate
intends to call
1182
00:31:25,711 --> 00:31:25,745
1183 00:31:25,745 --> 00:31:28,196
a dozen members of
the crew of the Caine.
1184
00:31:28,196 --> 00:31:28,231
1185 00:31:28,231 --> 00:31:29,888
That's correct. 1186 00:31:29,888 --> 00:31:29,922
1187 00:31:29,922 --> 00:31:31,924
Is the purpose to confirm
Urban's testimony
1188
00:31:31,924 --> 00:31:31,959
1189 00:31:31,959 --> 00:31:34,375
that the Captain
was never seen to
do anything crazy?
1190
00:31:34,375 --> 00:31:34,409
1191 00:31:34,409 --> 00:31:36,342
That's the purpose. 1192 00:31:36,342 --> 00:31:36,377
1193 00:31:36,377 --> 00:31:37,965
Defense will concede 1194 00:31:37,965 --> 00:31:37,999
1195 00:31:37,999 --> 00:31:41,002
that the testimony of
these witnesses will
corroborate Urban's,
1196
00:31:41,002 --> 00:31:41,037
1197 00:31:41,037 --> 00:31:43,384
if the judge advocate
concedes that
1198
00:31:43,384 --> 00:31:43,418
1199 00:31:43,418 --> 00:31:46,594
these 12 men don't know
anymore about a paranoid
than Urban.
1200
00:31:46,594 --> 00:31:48,389
1201 00:31:48,389 --> 00:31:52,082
I'll gladly make
that concession, sir,
on those terms.
1202
00:31:52,082 --> 00:31:52,117
1203 00:31:52,117 --> 00:31:54,464
Lieutenant Greenwald, you're making
a weighty concession.
1204
00:31:54,464 --> 00:31:54,498
1205 00:31:54,498 --> 00:31:56,949
By your leave, sir,
I make that concession.
1206
00:31:56,949 --> 00:31:56,984
1207 00:31:56,984 --> 00:31:59,055
Just don't record that. 1208 00:31:59,055 --> 00:31:59,089
1209 00:31:59,089 --> 00:32:01,195
-Mr. Greenwald?
Yes, sir.
1210
00:32:01,195 --> 00:32:01,229
1211 00:32:01,229 --> 00:32:06,441
The court understands that
you were appointed defense
counsel by the judge advocate.
1212
00:32:06,441 --> 00:32:06,476
1213 00:32:06,476 --> 00:32:08,478
Is that right? 1214 00:32:08,478 --> 00:32:08,512
1215 00:32:08,512 --> 00:32:10,652
-Yes, sir.
When were
you appointed?
1216
00:32:10,652 --> 00:32:10,687
1217 00:32:10,687 --> 00:32:12,240
Four days ago, sir. 1218 00:32:12,240 --> 00:32:12,275
1219 00:32:12,275 --> 00:32:14,449
Do you think
you've had time
to prepare your case?
1220
00:32:14,449 --> 00:32:14,484
1221 00:32:14,484 --> 00:32:16,796
May it please the court,
Lieutenant Greenwald
accepted this assignment
1222
00:32:16,796 --> 00:32:16,831
1223 00:32:16,831 --> 00:32:19,696
at my earnest request. 1224 00:32:19,696 --> 00:32:19,730
1225 00:32:19,730 --> 00:32:22,388
I see by your uniform,
you're a flying officer.
1226
00:32:22,388 --> 00:32:22,423
1227 00:32:22,423 --> 00:32:24,183
-Yes, sir.
What do you fly?
1228
00:32:24,183 --> 00:32:24,218
1229 00:32:24,218 --> 00:32:25,702
-F6
-F's, sir.
1230
00:32:25,702 --> 00:32:25,736
1231 00:32:25,736 --> 00:32:27,773
What're you doing
on the beach?
Were you grounded?
1232
00:32:27,773 --> 00:32:27,807
1233 00:32:27,807 --> 00:32:30,638
Hospitalized for
third degree burns, sir.
1234
00:32:30,638 --> 00:32:30,672
1235 00:32:30,672 --> 00:32:32,985
I see.
How were you burned?
1236
00:32:32,985 --> 00:32:33,020
1237 00:32:33,020 --> 00:32:35,988
Crashed a barrier
on the USS Wasp,sir.
1238
00:32:35,988 --> 00:32:36,023
1239 00:32:36,023 --> 00:32:39,164
Did you have a chance
to practice much law
before the war came along?
1240
00:32:39,164 --> 00:32:40,165
1241 00:32:40,165 --> 00:32:42,546
A little, sir. 1242 00:32:42,546 --> 00:32:42,581
1243 00:32:42,581 --> 00:32:44,963
Court will speak to the
accused off the record.
1244
00:32:44,963 --> 00:32:47,034
1245 00:32:47,034 --> 00:32:48,173
Yes, sir. 1246 00:32:48,173 --> 00:32:48,207
1247 00:32:48,207 --> 00:32:50,658
Come up here,
Lieutenant.
1248
00:32:50,658 --> 00:32:53,350
1249 00:32:53,350 --> 00:32:54,938
Come here. 1250 00:32:54,938 --> 00:32:56,975
1251 00:32:56,975 --> 00:32:58,804
It seems the court's duty
at this point to inquire
1252
00:32:58,804 --> 00:32:58,838
1253 00:32:58,838 --> 00:33:01,807
whether your counsel's
conduct of the defense
meets with your approval.
1254
00:33:01,807 --> 00:33:01,841
1255 00:33:01,841 --> 00:33:04,154
May it please the court,
if the accused answers
that question now,
1256
00:33:04,154 --> 00:33:04,189
1257 00:33:04,189 --> 00:33:06,191
he must do so
on blind faith.
1258
00:33:06,191 --> 00:33:06,225
1259 00:33:06,225 --> 00:33:08,952
I beg the court
for an opportunity
to speak to my client first.
1260
00:33:08,952 --> 00:33:08,987
1261 00:33:08,987 --> 00:33:10,712
No, we've had
too many recesses here.
1262
00:33:10,712 --> 00:33:10,747
1263 00:33:10,747 --> 00:33:14,337
Not a recess, sir,
a brief delay, two minutes.
1264
00:33:14,337 --> 00:33:14,371
1265 00:33:14,371 --> 00:33:15,786
All right, court will
remain in session.
1266
00:33:15,786 --> 00:33:15,821
1267 00:33:15,821 --> 00:33:17,996
There'll be a two minute
pause in the proceedings.
1268
00:33:17,996 --> 00:33:22,069
1269 00:33:22,069 --> 00:33:23,794
Challee. 1270 00:33:23,794 --> 00:33:23,829
1271 00:33:23,829 --> 00:33:25,382
Well,
do you want to
get rid of me?
1272
00:33:25,382 --> 00:33:25,417
1273 00:33:25,417 --> 00:33:27,005
I don't know. 1274 00:33:27,005 --> 00:33:27,039
1275 00:33:27,039 --> 00:33:28,730
Everything's
all right up till now.
1276
00:33:28,730 --> 00:33:28,765
1277 00:33:28,765 --> 00:33:30,491
-I'm sunk.
-You're not.
1278
00:33:30,491 --> 00:33:30,525
1279 00:33:30,525 --> 00:33:31,802
Fifteen years
-in the brig.
-You won't go to the brig.
1280
00:33:31,802 --> 00:33:31,837
1281 00:33:31,837 --> 00:33:33,804
What's going on here, Jack?
Where'd you get this bird?
1282
00:33:33,804 --> 00:33:33,839
1283 00:33:33,839 --> 00:33:37,049
Sir, Barney Greenwald.
We went to
Georgetown Law together.
1284
00:33:37,049 --> 00:33:37,084
1285 00:33:37,084 --> 00:33:40,466
Before the war, he was
one of the most successful
young lawyers in Washington.
1286
00:33:40,466 --> 00:33:40,501
1287 00:33:40,501 --> 00:33:42,503
-He was?
-Yes, sir.
1288
00:33:42,503 --> 00:33:42,537
1289 00:33:42,537 --> 00:33:44,401
Well, don't you think
he's putting on a damned
queer show here?
1290
00:33:44,401 --> 00:33:44,436
1291 00:33:44,436 --> 00:33:46,472
-Well, yes, sir, I do.
-Why didn't you
cross-examine Tom Keefer?
1292
00:33:46,472 --> 00:33:46,507
1293 00:33:46,507 --> 00:33:48,612
-There isn't time to tell.
-He knows everything that
Captain Queeg did. Everything.
1294
00:33:48,612 --> 00:33:48,647
1295 00:33:48,647 --> 00:33:50,062
-Sure he does.
-And if he wouldn't talk,
1296
00:33:50,062 --> 00:33:50,097
1297 00:33:50,097 --> 00:33:51,374
it was up to you
to drag it out of
him, wasn't it?
1298
00:33:51,374 --> 00:33:51,408
1299 00:33:51,408 --> 00:33:53,065
You don't begin to
understand...
1300
00:33:53,065 --> 00:33:53,100
1301 00:33:53,100 --> 00:33:56,620
I don't understand
what you're doing, mister,
that's for sure.
1302
00:33:56,620 --> 00:33:56,655
1303 00:33:56,655 --> 00:33:58,691
I just happen to want
to fight this case.
1304
00:33:58,691 --> 00:33:58,726
1305 00:33:58,726 --> 00:34:01,246
Why? Why?
What's it matter to you?
You're a total stranger.
1306
00:34:01,246 --> 00:34:01,280
1307 00:34:01,280 --> 00:34:02,316
I want to win it. 1308 00:34:02,316 --> 00:34:02,350
1309 00:34:02,350 --> 00:34:04,456
I want
to believe you.
1310
00:34:04,456 --> 00:34:04,490
1311 00:34:04,490 --> 00:34:06,596
It's God's truth. 1312 00:34:06,596 --> 00:34:06,630
1313 00:34:06,630 --> 00:34:08,874
No, you said you'd
rather be prosecuting
me than defending me.
1314
00:34:08,874 --> 00:34:08,908
1315 00:34:08,908 --> 00:34:11,532
Maybe this is
your screwy way
of prosecuting me.
1316
00:34:11,532 --> 00:34:11,566
1317 00:34:11,566 --> 00:34:12,705
A Jewish fellow, isn't he? 1318 00:34:12,705 --> 00:34:12,740
1319 00:34:12,740 --> 00:34:15,881
Yes, sir.
Barney's Jewish.
1320
00:34:15,881 --> 00:34:15,915
1321 00:34:15,915 --> 00:34:20,127
You're telling me
he's a hell of a lot
sharper than he seems.
1322
00:34:20,127 --> 00:34:21,231
1323 00:34:21,231 --> 00:34:22,577
Gentlemen. 1324 00:34:22,577 --> 00:34:32,380
1325 00:34:32,380 --> 00:34:35,694
The court again
asks the accused,
are you satisfied?
1326
00:34:35,694 --> 00:34:37,454
1327 00:34:37,454 --> 00:34:39,560
I'm satisfied, sir. 1328 00:34:39,560 --> 00:34:39,594
1329 00:34:39,594 --> 00:34:41,527
Court will not
reopen this question.
1330
00:34:41,527 --> 00:34:41,562
1331 00:34:41,562 --> 00:34:46,084
I understand that, sir.
I'm satisfied with
Lieutenant Greenwald.
1332
00:34:46,084 --> 00:34:46,118
1333 00:34:46,118 --> 00:34:48,155
Continue your case,
Commander Challee.
1334
00:34:48,155 --> 00:34:48,189
1335 00:34:48,189 --> 00:34:49,915
Call Lieutenant Keith. 1336 00:34:49,915 --> 00:34:49,949
1337 00:34:49,949 --> 00:34:51,675
Lieutenant Keith. 1338 00:34:51,675 --> 00:35:07,035
1339 00:35:07,035 --> 00:35:08,934
You do solemnly swear
the evidence you shall
give in this court
1340
00:35:08,934 --> 00:35:08,968
1341 00:35:08,968 --> 00:35:10,142
shall be the truth,
the whole truth and
1342
00:35:10,142 --> 00:35:10,177
1343 00:35:10,177 --> 00:35:11,178
nothing but the truth,
so help you God?
1344
00:35:11,178 --> 00:35:11,212
1345 00:35:11,212 --> 00:35:12,834
I do. 1346 00:35:12,834 --> 00:35:19,186
1347 00:35:19,186 --> 00:35:21,119
State your name,
rank and present station.
1348
00:35:21,119 --> 00:35:21,153
1349 00:35:21,153 --> 00:35:24,225
Willis Seward Keith,
Lieutenant,
Junior Grade, USNR,
1350
00:35:24,225 --> 00:35:24,260
1351 00:35:24,260 --> 00:35:27,228
Assistant Communications
Officer of the USS Caine.
1352
00:35:27,228 --> 00:35:27,263
1353 00:35:27,263 --> 00:35:29,610
If you recognize
the accused, state as so.
1354
00:35:29,610 --> 00:35:29,644
1355 00:35:29,644 --> 00:35:32,647
Steve Maryk, my executive
officer on the Caine.
1356
00:35:32,647 --> 00:35:32,682
1357 00:35:32,682 --> 00:35:35,754
Mr. Keith, were you officer
of the deck of the Caine
during the forenoon watch
1358
00:35:35,754 --> 00:35:35,788
1359 00:35:35,788 --> 00:35:37,894
-on 18th December, 1944?
Yes.
1360
00:35:37,894 --> 00:35:37,928
1361 00:35:37,928 --> 00:35:40,621
Was the Captain relieved
of his command during
your watch?
1362
00:35:40,621 --> 00:35:40,655
1363 00:35:40,655 --> 00:35:42,588
-Yes, he was.
-Do you know why
the executive officer
1364
00:35:42,588 --> 00:35:42,623
1365 00:35:42,623 --> 00:35:44,003
relieved the Captain? 1366 00:35:44,003 --> 00:35:44,038
1367 00:35:44,038 --> 00:35:46,420
Yes. Captain Queeg
had lost control of himself
1368
00:35:46,420 --> 00:35:46,454
1369 00:35:46,454 --> 00:35:49,077
and the ship was in
grave danger of foundering.
1370
00:35:49,077 --> 00:35:51,977
1371 00:35:51,977 --> 00:35:54,290
How many years have you
served at sea, Lieutenant?
1372
00:35:54,290 --> 00:35:54,324
1373 00:35:54,324 --> 00:35:57,051
One year and three months. 1374 00:35:57,051 --> 00:35:57,085
1375 00:35:57,085 --> 00:36:00,192
Do you know how many
years Commander Queeg
has served at sea?
1376
00:36:00,192 --> 00:36:00,227
1377 00:36:00,227 --> 00:36:02,298
I guess about 10 years. 1378 00:36:02,298 --> 00:36:02,332
1379 00:36:02,332 --> 00:36:04,300
Which of you
is better qualified to judge
1380
00:36:04,300 --> 00:36:04,334
1381 00:36:04,334 --> 00:36:07,026
whether a ship is
foundering or not?
1382
00:36:07,026 --> 00:36:07,061
1383 00:36:07,061 --> 00:36:12,204
Myself, sir, if I'm in
possession of my faculties
and Commander Queeg isn't.
1384
00:36:12,204 --> 00:36:12,239
1385 00:36:12,239 --> 00:36:15,034
What makes you think
he isn't in possession
of his faculties?
1386
00:36:15,034 --> 00:36:15,069
1387 00:36:15,069 --> 00:36:17,623
He wasn't on the morning
of December 18.
1388
00:36:17,623 --> 00:36:17,658
1389 00:36:17,658 --> 00:36:20,143
Have you studied
medicine or psychiatry?
1390
00:36:20,143 --> 00:36:20,178
1391 00:36:20,178 --> 00:36:21,834
No. 1392 00:36:21,834 --> 00:36:21,869
1393 00:36:21,869 --> 00:36:24,527
Did the Captain rave,
or foam, or make
insane gestures?
1394
00:36:24,527 --> 00:36:24,561
1395 00:36:24,561 --> 00:36:27,323
No, but what he did
do was just as bad.
1396
00:36:27,323 --> 00:36:27,357
1397 00:36:27,357 --> 00:36:30,118
Clarify that a bit,
if you will.
1398
00:36:30,118 --> 00:36:30,153
1399 00:36:30,153 --> 00:36:36,263
His orders were
vague and sluggish
and not appropriate.
1400
00:36:36,263 --> 00:36:36,297
1401 00:36:36,297 --> 00:36:37,781
He insisted on going south, 1402 00:36:37,781 --> 00:36:37,816
1403 00:36:37,816 --> 00:36:41,199
when we had a
north wind of 90 miles
an hour behind us.
1404
00:36:41,199 --> 00:36:41,233
1405 00:36:41,233 --> 00:36:44,098
With a stern wind
that strong, the ship
couldn't be controlled.
1406
00:36:44,098 --> 00:36:44,132
1407 00:36:44,132 --> 00:36:47,343
In your expert opinion,
as a ship handler, that is.
1408
00:36:47,343 --> 00:36:47,377
1409 00:36:47,377 --> 00:36:50,518
Steve Maryk
thought so, and he's
an expert ship handler.
1410
00:36:50,518 --> 00:36:50,553
1411 00:36:50,553 --> 00:36:52,969
Mr. Keith,
were you wholeheartedly
loyal to your captain
1412
00:36:52,969 --> 00:36:53,003
1413 00:36:53,003 --> 00:36:56,800
or antagonistic to him,
prior to 18th December?
1414
00:36:56,800 --> 00:36:56,835
1415 00:36:56,835 --> 00:37:00,287
I was antagonistic
to Captain Queeg at
certain isolated times.
1416
00:37:00,287 --> 00:37:00,321
1417 00:37:00,321 --> 00:37:03,221
At what isolated times
were you antagonistic
to him?
1418
00:37:03,221 --> 00:37:03,255
1419 00:37:03,255 --> 00:37:06,362
When Captain Queeg
maltreated the men,
I opposed him.
1420
00:37:06,362 --> 00:37:06,396
1421 00:37:06,396 --> 00:37:09,296
When did Captain Queeg
ever maltreat the men?
1422
00:37:09,296 --> 00:37:11,056
1423 00:37:11,056 --> 00:37:13,714
Well, for one thing,
he systematically persecuted
1424
00:37:13,714 --> 00:37:13,748
1425 00:37:13,748 --> 00:37:15,543
Gunner's Mate
Second Class Stilwell.
1426
00:37:15,543 --> 00:37:15,578
1427 00:37:15,578 --> 00:37:17,752
In what way? 1428 00:37:17,752 --> 00:37:17,787
1429 00:37:17,787 --> 00:37:22,240
First he restricted him
to the ship for six months
for reading on watch.
1430
00:37:22,240 --> 00:37:22,274
1431 00:37:22,274 --> 00:37:26,968
He refused to grant him leave
in the States when we were
back here in December '43.
1432
00:37:26,968 --> 00:37:27,003
1433 00:37:27,003 --> 00:37:31,870
The man was getting
anonymous letters about
his wife's infidelity.
1434
00:37:31,870 --> 00:37:31,904
1435 00:37:31,904 --> 00:37:34,700
Maryk gave Stilwell
a 72-hour emergency leave
1436
00:37:34,700 --> 00:37:34,735
1437 00:37:34,735 --> 00:37:36,219
and he returned
a few hours over
leave and...
1438
00:37:36,219 --> 00:37:36,254
1439 00:37:36,254 --> 00:37:38,221
Mr. Keith, you say Maryk
gave Stilwell a pass.
1440
00:37:38,221 --> 00:37:38,256
1441 00:37:38,256 --> 00:37:41,328
Did Maryk know
the Captain had denied
leave to Stilwell?
1442
00:37:41,328 --> 00:37:41,362
1443 00:37:41,362 --> 00:37:43,606
Yes, sir. 1444 00:37:43,606 --> 00:37:43,640
1445 00:37:43,640 --> 00:37:47,195
Did Maryk check with
the Captain before
issuing the pass?
1446
00:37:47,195 --> 00:37:47,230
1447 00:37:47,230 --> 00:37:48,645
No, sir. 1448 00:37:48,645 --> 00:37:48,680
1449 00:37:48,680 --> 00:37:50,371
Mr. Keith, are you
testifying that Maryk
1450
00:37:50,371 --> 00:37:50,406
1451 00:37:50,406 --> 00:37:53,340
deliberately violated
his captain's orders?
1452
00:37:53,340 --> 00:37:53,374
1453 00:37:53,374 --> 00:37:55,307
Well, I mean, it was
my fault, actually.
1454
00:37:55,307 --> 00:37:55,342
1455 00:37:55,342 --> 00:37:56,929
I begged him to.
I was morale officer.
1456
00:37:56,929 --> 00:37:56,964
1457 00:37:56,964 --> 00:38:00,208
-Mr. Keith. Mr. Keith.
-And I thought
the man's morale...
1458
00:38:00,208 --> 00:38:00,243
1459 00:38:00,243 --> 00:38:03,522
We now have your
testimony that you,
Maryk and Stilwell
1460
00:38:03,522 --> 00:38:03,557
1461 00:38:03,557 --> 00:38:07,112
connived to circumvent
an express order of your
commanding officer,
1462
00:38:07,112 --> 00:38:07,146
1463 00:38:07,146 --> 00:38:10,495
a whole year
before the typhoon
of 18th December.
1464
00:38:10,495 --> 00:38:12,255
1465 00:38:12,255 --> 00:38:14,602
Please tell the court
any other instances of
1466
00:38:14,602 --> 00:38:14,637
1467 00:38:14,637 --> 00:38:17,985
maltreatment that occur to you. 1468 00:38:17,985 --> 00:38:18,019
1469 00:38:18,019 --> 00:38:19,952
He cut off the movies
for six months
1470
00:38:19,952 --> 00:38:19,987
1471 00:38:19,987 --> 00:38:23,853
just because he wasn't
invited to a showing
by mistake.
1472
00:38:23,853 --> 00:38:23,887
1473 00:38:23,887 --> 00:38:25,786
He cut off the water
at the equator
1474
00:38:25,786 --> 00:38:25,820
1475 00:38:25,820 --> 00:38:29,099
because he said the men
were using too much and
had to be taught a lesson.
1476
00:38:29,099 --> 00:38:29,134
1477 00:38:29,134 --> 00:38:31,447
Mr. Keith, 1478 00:38:31,447 --> 00:38:31,481
1479 00:38:31,481 --> 00:38:34,726
did Captain Queeg ever issue
any rules or punishments not
permitted by regulations?
1480
00:38:34,726 --> 00:38:34,760
1481 00:38:34,760 --> 00:38:38,005
He never did anything
not allowed by regulations.
1482
00:38:38,005 --> 00:38:38,039
1483 00:38:38,039 --> 00:38:41,353
You didn't like the Captain,
did you, Lieutenant?
1484
00:38:41,353 --> 00:38:41,388
1485 00:38:41,388 --> 00:38:43,562
I did, at first, very much. 1486 00:38:43,562 --> 00:38:43,597
1487 00:38:43,597 --> 00:38:48,602
But gradually I realized
that he was a petty tyrant
and utterly incompetent.
1488
00:38:48,602 --> 00:38:48,636
1489 00:38:48,636 --> 00:38:50,914
Did you think
he was insane, too?
1490
00:38:50,914 --> 00:38:50,949
1491 00:38:50,949 --> 00:38:52,916
Not until the day
of the typhoon.
1492
00:38:52,916 --> 00:38:52,951
1493 00:38:52,951 --> 00:38:55,263
Very well.
Come to the day
of the typhoon.
1494
00:38:55,263 --> 00:38:55,298
1495 00:38:55,298 --> 00:38:58,750
Was your decision to obey
Maryk based on your judgment
that the Captain had gone mad
1496
00:38:58,750 --> 00:38:58,784
1497 00:38:58,784 --> 00:39:02,650
or was it based
on your hatred
of Captain Queeg?
1498
00:39:02,650 --> 00:39:02,685
1499 00:39:02,685 --> 00:39:06,309
I just don't remember my
state of mind that long ago.
1500
00:39:06,309 --> 00:39:07,828
1501 00:39:07,828 --> 00:39:09,623
No further questions. 1502 00:39:09,623 --> 00:39:19,253
1503 00:39:19,253 --> 00:39:22,394
Mr. Keith, you stated
you disliked Captain Queeg.
1504
00:39:22,394 --> 00:39:23,706
1505 00:39:23,706 --> 00:39:25,639
I did dislike him. 1506 00:39:25,639 --> 00:39:25,673
1507 00:39:25,673 --> 00:39:28,780
Did you state under
direct examination all your
reasons for disliking him?
1508
00:39:28,780 --> 00:39:28,814
1509 00:39:28,814 --> 00:39:30,678
Not at all. 1510 00:39:30,678 --> 00:39:30,713
1511 00:39:30,713 --> 00:39:33,094
State the rest of your
reasons now, please.
1512
00:39:33,094 --> 00:39:33,129
1513 00:39:33,129 --> 00:39:35,959
Well, for one thing,
he extorted $100 from me.
1514
00:39:35,959 --> 00:39:35,994
1515 00:39:35,994 --> 00:39:37,823
Objection. 1516 00:39:37,823 --> 00:39:37,858
1517 00:39:37,858 --> 00:39:40,481
The issue in this case is
not whether Captain Queeg
was a model officer,
1518
00:39:40,481 --> 00:39:40,516
1519 00:39:40,516 --> 00:39:43,035
but whether he was
insane on 18th December.
1520
00:39:43,035 --> 00:39:43,070
1521 00:39:43,070 --> 00:39:45,969
Defense counsel hasn't
even touched this issue.
1522
00:39:45,969 --> 00:39:46,004
1523 00:39:46,004 --> 00:39:47,523
Please the court,
this will bear directly on
1524
00:39:47,523 --> 00:39:47,557
1525 00:39:47,557 --> 00:39:50,629
the mental fitness
of Captain Queeg to
command a naval vessel,
1526
00:39:50,629 --> 00:39:50,664
1527 00:39:50,664 --> 00:39:52,424
and as evidence,
it is nothing but
a clarification
1528
00:39:52,424 --> 00:39:52,459
1529 00:39:52,459 --> 00:39:54,840
of Mr. Keith's dislike
for his commanding officer,
1530
00:39:54,840 --> 00:39:54,875
1531 00:39:54,875 --> 00:39:59,569
a fact established by the
judge advocate at great
pains in direct examination.
1532
00:39:59,569 --> 00:39:59,604
1533 00:39:59,604 --> 00:40:01,813
Objection's overruled. 1534 00:40:01,813 --> 00:40:01,847
1535 00:40:01,847 --> 00:40:04,056
Describe this so-called
extortion, Mr. Keith.
1536
00:40:04,056 --> 00:40:04,091
1537 00:40:04,091 --> 00:40:08,440
Well, this was
back last December
in San Francisco Bay.
1538
00:40:08,440 --> 00:40:08,475
1539 00:40:08,475 --> 00:40:10,338
The Captain had
this big crate
1540
00:40:10,338 --> 00:40:10,373
1541 00:40:10,373 --> 00:40:12,720
full of cheap tax-free
whiskey from Pearl Harbor
1542
00:40:12,720 --> 00:40:12,755
1543 00:40:12,755 --> 00:40:14,619
he wanted to
sneak into Oakland.
1544
00:40:14,619 --> 00:40:14,653
1545 00:40:14,653 --> 00:40:16,103
He appointed me
boat officer,
1546
00:40:16,103 --> 00:40:16,137
1547 00:40:16,137 --> 00:40:19,865
and a working party
started to load the
crate into the gig.
1548
00:40:19,865 --> 00:40:19,900
1549 00:40:19,900 --> 00:40:24,560
It was terrifically
heavy and Captain
Queeg got excited
1550
00:40:24,560 --> 00:40:24,594
1551 00:40:24,594 --> 00:40:28,011
and screeched a whole bunch
of contradictory orders.
1552
00:40:28,011 --> 00:40:28,046
1553 00:40:28,046 --> 00:40:32,809
The sailors got rattled
and dropped the crate
into the water.
1554
00:40:32,809 --> 00:40:32,844
1555 00:40:32,844 --> 00:40:36,537
It sank like a stone,
and I was out $110.
1556
00:40:36,537 --> 00:40:36,572
1557 00:40:36,572 --> 00:40:38,608
You mean the Captain was? 1558 00:40:38,608 --> 00:40:38,643
1559 00:40:38,643 --> 00:40:40,472
No, sir, I was. 1560 00:40:40,472 --> 00:40:40,507
1561 00:40:40,507 --> 00:40:43,475
The Captain informed me
that I was responsible
1562
00:40:43,475 --> 00:40:43,510
1563 00:40:43,510 --> 00:40:45,995
because I was the boat officer
in charge of the loading
1564
00:40:45,995 --> 00:40:46,029
1565 00:40:46,029 --> 00:40:50,275
and he asked me
to think over what I
ought to do about it.
1566
00:40:50,275 --> 00:40:50,309
1567 00:40:50,309 --> 00:40:53,243
Well, I was supposed to
go on leave the next day,
1568
00:40:53,243 --> 00:40:53,278
1569 00:40:53,278 --> 00:40:56,902
my girl had flown in
from New York to be with me.
1570
00:40:56,902 --> 00:40:56,937
1571 00:40:56,937 --> 00:41:00,665
So I went to the Captain and
I apologized for my stupidity
1572
00:41:00,665 --> 00:41:00,699
1573 00:41:00,699 --> 00:41:03,771
and said that I'd like to
pay for the lost crate.
1574
00:41:03,771 --> 00:41:03,806
1575 00:41:03,806 --> 00:41:07,430
He took my money gladly
and then he signed my
leave papers.
1576
00:41:07,430 --> 00:41:07,465
1577 00:41:07,465 --> 00:41:10,847
What further reasons did you
have for disliking Queeg?
1578
00:41:10,847 --> 00:41:10,882
1579 00:41:10,882 --> 00:41:16,439
My chief reason
for disliking Captain Queeg
was his cowardice in battle.
1580
00:41:16,439 --> 00:41:16,474
1581 00:41:16,474 --> 00:41:17,716
What cowardice? 1582 00:41:17,716 --> 00:41:17,751
1583 00:41:17,751 --> 00:41:19,925
He repeatedly ran
from shore batteries.
1584
00:41:19,925 --> 00:41:19,960
1585 00:41:19,960 --> 00:41:22,100
Objection! 1586 00:41:22,100 --> 00:41:22,134
1587 00:41:22,134 --> 00:41:24,999
Counsel's originating
evidence beyond the
scope of direct examination.
1588
00:41:24,999 --> 00:41:25,034
1589 00:41:25,034 --> 00:41:30,315
He is leading the witness
into irresponsible libels
of an officer of the Navy.
1590
00:41:30,315 --> 00:41:30,349
1591 00:41:30,349 --> 00:41:33,145
Please the court,
Mr. Keith's dislike for his
commanding officer
1592
00:41:33,145 --> 00:41:33,180
1593 00:41:33,180 --> 00:41:38,150
is not only within the scope
of direct examination, it was
the key fact brought out.
1594
00:41:38,150 --> 00:41:38,185
1595 00:41:38,185 --> 00:41:41,637
Now the witness has
confessed an ignorance
of psychiatry.
1596
00:41:41,637 --> 00:41:41,671
1597 00:41:41,671 --> 00:41:45,641
Things Queeg did
which caused the witness in
his ignorance to dislike him
1598
00:41:45,641 --> 00:41:45,675
1599 00:41:45,675 --> 00:41:48,540
may in fact have been
the helpless acts of a
sick man.
1600
00:41:48,540 --> 00:41:48,575
1601 00:41:48,575 --> 00:41:50,577
I respectfully
urge my objection, sir.
1602
00:41:50,577 --> 00:41:50,611
1603 00:41:50,611 --> 00:41:53,441
Court finds the question
within the scope of
direct examination.
1604
00:41:53,441 --> 00:41:53,476
1605 00:41:53,476 --> 00:41:58,619
And the answer is material.
Objection overruled. Proceed.
1606
00:41:58,619 --> 00:41:58,654
1607 00:41:58,654 --> 00:42:00,690
Mr. Keith,
where and when
did Captain Queeg
1608
00:42:00,690 --> 00:42:00,725
1609 00:42:00,725 --> 00:42:02,347
run from shore batteries? 1610 00:42:02,347 --> 00:42:02,381
1611 00:42:02,381 --> 00:42:06,489
Practically every time we heard
gunfire from the beach.
1612
00:42:06,489 --> 00:42:06,524
1613 00:42:06,524 --> 00:42:08,871
I guess the worst time
was at Kwajalein.
1614
00:42:08,871 --> 00:42:08,905
1615 00:42:08,905 --> 00:42:11,701
That's where he got the
nickname, Old Yellow Stain.
1616
00:42:11,701 --> 00:42:11,736
1617 00:42:11,736 --> 00:42:15,049
What did this nickname,
Old Yellow Stain, imply?
1618
00:42:15,049 --> 00:42:15,084
1619 00:42:15,084 --> 00:42:17,880
Well, cowardice, of course. 1620 00:42:17,880 --> 00:42:17,914
1621 00:42:17,914 --> 00:42:21,366
It referred to a
yellow dye marker he
dropped over the side.
1622
00:42:21,366 --> 00:42:21,400
1623 00:42:21,400 --> 00:42:23,748
Describe this
Yellow Stain incident.
1624
00:42:23,748 --> 00:42:23,782
1625 00:42:23,782 --> 00:42:26,267
Well, I wasn't
on the bridge, so I only
heard about it afterwards.
1626
00:42:26,267 --> 00:42:26,302
1627 00:42:26,302 --> 00:42:28,235
-Objection.
What happened was...
1628
00:42:28,235 --> 00:42:28,269
1629 00:42:28,269 --> 00:42:31,307
Does defense counsel seriously
intend to enter these hearsay
libels on the record?
1630
00:42:31,307 --> 00:42:31,341
1631 00:42:31,341 --> 00:42:33,205
I withdraw the question. 1632 00:42:33,205 --> 00:42:33,240
1633 00:42:33,240 --> 00:42:35,829
Defense will introduce
direct evidence on the
Yellow Stain incident.
1634
00:42:35,829 --> 00:42:35,863
1635 00:42:35,863 --> 00:42:38,210
Strike the question and
the answer from the record.
1636
00:42:38,210 --> 00:42:38,245
1637 00:42:38,245 --> 00:42:40,178
Can you
describe any incidents
of cowardice
1638
00:42:40,178 --> 00:42:40,212
1639 00:42:40,212 --> 00:42:42,318
to which you were
an eyewitness, Mr. Keith?
1640
00:42:42,318 --> 00:42:42,352
1641 00:42:42,352 --> 00:42:44,872
Well, in any
combat situation,
1642
00:42:44,872 --> 00:42:44,907
1643 00:42:44,907 --> 00:42:49,497
the Captain was always
found on the side of the
bridge away from the firing.
1644
00:42:49,497 --> 00:42:49,532
1645 00:42:49,532 --> 00:42:51,983
I saw that a dozen times
when I was OOD.
1646
00:42:51,983 --> 00:42:56,125
1647 00:42:56,125 --> 00:42:57,954
No further questions. 1648 00:42:57,954 --> 00:42:57,989
1649 00:42:57,989 --> 00:43:00,198
Mr. Keith, 1650 00:43:00,198 --> 00:43:00,232
1651 00:43:00,232 --> 00:43:02,925
has Commander Queeg ever
been court-martialed by
a higher authority
1652
00:43:02,925 --> 00:43:02,959
1653 00:43:02,959 --> 00:43:05,721
for any of the alleged acts
of cowardice you described?
1654
00:43:05,721 --> 00:43:05,755
1655 00:43:05,755 --> 00:43:07,550
No. 1656 00:43:07,550 --> 00:43:07,585
1657 00:43:07,585 --> 00:43:10,795
Well, can you cite
any official records that
might substantiate these
1658
00:43:10,795 --> 00:43:10,829
1659 00:43:10,829 --> 00:43:13,936
fantastic and
libelous stories
you've been telling,
1660
00:43:13,936 --> 00:43:13,970
1661 00:43:13,970 --> 00:43:16,317
under the guidance
of defense counsel?
1662
00:43:16,317 --> 00:43:16,352
1663 00:43:16,352 --> 00:43:18,423
Official records, no. 1664 00:43:18,423 --> 00:43:18,457
1665 00:43:18,457 --> 00:43:22,358
Can you state
as fact, that the crate
that was lost at sea
1666
00:43:22,358 --> 00:43:22,392
1667 00:43:22,392 --> 00:43:24,360
contained smuggled liquor? 1668 00:43:24,360 --> 00:43:24,394
1669 00:43:24,394 --> 00:43:26,465
It was
-common knowledge.
Common knowledge?
1670
00:43:26,465 --> 00:43:26,500
1671 00:43:26,500 --> 00:43:29,503
Did you see any liquor
-in the crate?
-No.
1672
00:43:29,503 --> 00:43:29,537
1673 00:43:29,537 --> 00:43:32,782
Can you name one person
who will testify that they
saw liquor in the crate?
1674
00:43:32,782 --> 00:43:32,817
1675 00:43:32,817 --> 00:43:35,785
Well, naturally, he was
pretty careful about that.
1676
00:43:35,785 --> 00:43:35,820
1677 00:43:35,820 --> 00:43:39,444
-Not one person.
-I just don't know who'd
have actually seen it.
1678
00:43:39,444 --> 00:43:39,478
1679 00:43:39,478 --> 00:43:42,171
Mr. Keith,
you've testified that
you hate Captain Queeg.
1680
00:43:42,171 --> 00:43:42,205
1681 00:43:42,205 --> 00:43:46,175
You've reported, as fact,
every evil rumor about him
1682
00:43:46,175 --> 00:43:46,209
1683 00:43:46,209 --> 00:43:48,177
and you've made wild,
irresponsible charges
under oath.
1684
00:43:48,177 --> 00:43:48,211
1685 00:43:48,211 --> 00:43:50,248
Isn't that the
plain truth of your
testimony, Mr. Keith?
1686
00:43:50,248 --> 00:43:50,282
1687 00:43:50,282 --> 00:43:51,801
I haven't lied once. 1688 00:43:51,801 --> 00:43:51,836
1689 00:43:51,836 --> 00:43:55,494
Mr. Keith, on the morning
the Captain was relieved,
1690
00:43:55,494 --> 00:43:55,529
1691 00:43:55,529 --> 00:43:57,531
did you really think
he had gone crazy?
1692
00:43:57,531 --> 00:43:59,395
1693 00:43:59,395 --> 00:44:03,779
I said before,
I can't say for sure
what my state of mind was.
1694
00:44:03,779 --> 00:44:05,643
1695 00:44:05,643 --> 00:44:07,679
No more questions. 1696 00:44:07,679 --> 00:44:07,714
1697 00:44:07,714 --> 00:44:09,508
You'll not discuss
any details of your testimony
1698
00:44:09,508 --> 00:44:09,543
1699 00:44:09,543 --> 00:44:10,924
outside this courtroom,
Lieutenant.
1700
00:44:10,924 --> 00:44:10,958
1701 00:44:10,958 --> 00:44:12,166
Aye, aye, sir. 1702 00:44:12,166 --> 00:44:12,201
1703 00:44:12,201 --> 00:44:13,996
You're excused. 1704 00:44:13,996 --> 00:44:16,377
1705 00:44:16,377 --> 00:44:18,656
Call Captain Southard. 1706 00:44:18,656 --> 00:44:21,797
1707 00:44:21,797 --> 00:44:25,110
Captain Southard. 1708 00:44:25,110 --> 00:44:25,145
1709 00:44:25,145 --> 00:44:28,010
What will
they ask Captain Southard?
1710
00:44:28,010 --> 00:44:28,044
1711 00:44:28,044 --> 00:44:31,116
I don't know.
But we'll soon find out.
1712
00:44:31,116 --> 00:44:41,299
1713 00:44:41,299 --> 00:44:44,026
Come on up here,
Captain, we'll swear you in.
1714
00:44:44,026 --> 00:44:49,756
1715 00:44:49,756 --> 00:44:51,033
Do you solemnly swear
the evidence you shall give
1716
00:44:51,033 --> 00:44:51,067
1717 00:44:51,067 --> 00:44:52,724
in this court
shall be the truth,
the whole truth
1718
00:44:52,724 --> 00:44:52,759
1719 00:44:52,759 --> 00:44:53,587
and nothing
but the truth,
so help you God?
1720
00:44:53,587 --> 00:44:53,621
1721 00:44:53,621 --> 00:44:54,726
I do. 1722 00:44:54,726 --> 00:45:05,081
1723 00:45:05,081 --> 00:45:08,809
State your name, rank
and present station.
1724
00:45:08,809 --> 00:45:08,844
1725 00:45:08,844 --> 00:45:10,708
Randolph Patterson Southard, 1726 00:45:10,708 --> 00:45:10,742
1727 00:45:10,742 --> 00:45:15,747
Captain US Navy, Commander,
Destroyer Squadron Eight.
1728
00:45:15,747 --> 00:45:15,782
1729 00:45:15,782 --> 00:45:18,439
You understand, sir,
that you've been called
as an expert witness
1730
00:45:18,439 --> 00:45:18,474
1731 00:45:18,474 --> 00:45:20,890
on destroyer
-ship handling?
-I do.
1732
00:45:20,890 --> 00:45:20,925
1733 00:45:20,925 --> 00:45:22,409
State your
qualifications.
1734
00:45:22,409 --> 00:45:22,443
1735 00:45:22,443 --> 00:45:24,549
Some 20 years in destroyers. 1736 00:45:24,549 --> 00:45:24,583
1737 00:45:24,583 --> 00:45:26,758
Ten years
commanding all types,
1738
00:45:26,758 --> 00:45:26,793
1739 00:45:26,793 --> 00:45:31,418
from the World War One
four-piper on up to
the newest 2,200 tonner.
1740
00:45:31,418 --> 00:45:31,452
1741 00:45:31,452 --> 00:45:33,869
Now, sir, 1742 00:45:33,869 --> 00:45:33,903
1743 00:45:33,903 --> 00:45:37,044
I'm going to describe
a hypothetical
ship handling problem
1744
00:45:37,044 --> 00:45:37,079
1745 00:45:37,079 --> 00:45:38,425
for your expert opinion. 1746 00:45:38,425 --> 00:45:38,459
1747 00:45:38,459 --> 00:45:40,151
Very well. 1748 00:45:40,151 --> 00:45:40,185
1749 00:45:40,185 --> 00:45:43,533
You're in command
of a destroyer
in the Philippine Sea.
1750
00:45:43,533 --> 00:45:43,568
1751 00:45:43,568 --> 00:45:46,985
A typhoon blows up,
without warning,
traveling west.
1752
00:45:46,985 --> 00:45:47,020
1753 00:45:47,020 --> 00:45:50,782
The wind keeps increasing,
its direction holding
steady from the north.
1754
00:45:50,782 --> 00:45:50,817
1755 00:45:50,817 --> 00:45:54,061
The wind is now
force 10 to 12,
your seas are mountainous.
1756
00:45:54,061 --> 00:45:54,096
1757 00:45:54,096 --> 00:45:57,271
Under those circumstances,
sir, what would you do?
1758
00:45:57,271 --> 00:45:57,306
1759 00:45:57,306 --> 00:46:02,898
I believe I'd execute the
classic Navy maneuver known as
getting the hell out of there.
1760
00:46:02,898 --> 00:46:04,175
1761 00:46:04,175 --> 00:46:06,694
How would you
go about that, Captain?
1762
00:46:06,694 --> 00:46:06,729
1763 00:46:06,729 --> 00:46:08,558
It's almost a
rule of thumb.
1764
00:46:08,558 --> 00:46:08,593
1765 00:46:08,593 --> 00:46:11,492
You say the wind's from
the north at 90 knots,
1766
00:46:11,492 --> 00:46:11,527
1767 00:46:11,527 --> 00:46:14,737
the center of the
typhoon is coming
at you from the east.
1768
00:46:14,737 --> 00:46:14,772
1769 00:46:14,772 --> 00:46:16,981
The best course is south. 1770 00:46:16,981 --> 00:46:17,015
1771 00:46:17,015 --> 00:46:21,330
How about turning north
under those circumstances
and heading into the wind?
1772
00:46:21,330 --> 00:46:21,364
1773 00:46:21,364 --> 00:46:24,471
That would be dubious
and dangerous,
not to say idiotic.
1774
00:46:24,471 --> 00:46:24,505
1775 00:46:24,505 --> 00:46:26,645
Why, Captain? 1776 00:46:26,645 --> 00:46:26,680
1777 00:46:26,680 --> 00:46:28,268
Because you're
headed right back into
the path of the typhoon.
1778
00:46:28,268 --> 00:46:28,302
1779 00:46:28,302 --> 00:46:32,065
Unless you're interested in
sinking, that's not smart.
1780
00:46:32,065 --> 00:46:32,099
1781 00:46:32,099 --> 00:46:33,791
That's all, sir. 1782 00:46:33,791 --> 00:46:39,313
1783 00:46:39,313 --> 00:46:43,110
Captain, have you ever
conned a ship through
the center of a typhoon?
1784
00:46:43,110 --> 00:46:43,145
1785 00:46:43,145 --> 00:46:46,804
I have not handled
a DMS at the center
of a typhoon, no.
1786
00:46:46,804 --> 00:46:46,838
1787 00:46:46,838 --> 00:46:50,946
But I don't know
who the hell has beside
the skipper of the Caine.
1788
00:46:50,946 --> 00:46:50,980
1789 00:46:50,980 --> 00:46:52,671
Will you state,
without reservation,
1790
00:46:52,671 --> 00:46:52,706
1791 00:46:52,706 --> 00:46:54,397
that the rules of
destroyer handling
1792
00:46:54,397 --> 00:46:54,432
1793 00:46:54,432 --> 00:46:57,262
would hold for a DMS
in the center of a typhoon?
1794
00:46:57,262 --> 00:46:57,297
1795 00:46:57,297 --> 00:47:00,679
At the center of
a typhoon there are
no hard and fast rules.
1796
00:47:00,679 --> 00:47:00,714
1797 00:47:00,714 --> 00:47:04,683
That's one situation
where it's entirely up
to the commanding officer.
1798
00:47:04,683 --> 00:47:04,718
1799 00:47:04,718 --> 00:47:06,858
Too many things
can happen too fast.
1800
00:47:06,858 --> 00:47:06,893
1801 00:47:06,893 --> 00:47:10,517
Captain,
you remember the
hypothetical question
1802
00:47:10,517 --> 00:47:10,551
1803 00:47:10,551 --> 00:47:12,691
of the judge advocate
about the typhoon?
1804
00:47:12,691 --> 00:47:12,726
1805 00:47:12,726 --> 00:47:14,210
I do. 1806 00:47:14,210 --> 00:47:14,245
1807 00:47:14,245 --> 00:47:16,247
Now in that situation,
I ask you to assume that
1808
00:47:16,247 --> 00:47:16,281
1809 00:47:16,281 --> 00:47:20,768
the winds and seas
have become worse than
any you've experienced.
1810
00:47:20,768 --> 00:47:20,803
1811 00:47:20,803 --> 00:47:23,357
The ship is
wallowing broadside,
1812
00:47:23,357 --> 00:47:23,392
1813 00:47:23,392 --> 00:47:26,498
you actually believe
your ship is foundering,
1814
00:47:26,498 --> 00:47:26,533
1815 00:47:26,533 --> 00:47:29,122
you're in the
last extremity.
1816
00:47:29,122 --> 00:47:29,156
1817 00:47:29,156 --> 00:47:33,574
Now, do you bring your
ship north into the wind,
1818
00:47:33,574 --> 00:47:33,609
1819 00:47:33,609 --> 00:47:37,164
or do you continue south,
stern to wind?
1820
00:47:37,164 --> 00:47:37,199
1821 00:47:37,199 --> 00:47:38,890
You're getting
mighty hypothetical.
1822
00:47:38,890 --> 00:47:38,925
1823 00:47:38,925 --> 00:47:42,238
Yes, sir.
You prefer not to answer
that question, Captain?
1824
00:47:42,238 --> 00:47:42,273
1825 00:47:42,273 --> 00:47:43,412
I'll answer it. 1826 00:47:43,412 --> 00:47:43,446
1827 00:47:43,446 --> 00:47:44,896
In the last extremity, 1828 00:47:44,896 --> 00:47:44,931
1829 00:47:44,931 --> 00:47:47,381
I'd come around to the north
and head into the wind,
1830
00:47:47,381 --> 00:47:47,416
1831 00:47:47,416 --> 00:47:50,660
if I could,
but only in the
last extremity.
1832
00:47:50,660 --> 00:47:50,695
1833 00:47:50,695 --> 00:47:52,697
No further questions. 1834 00:47:52,697 --> 00:47:55,389
1835 00:47:55,389 --> 00:47:57,081
In your opinion, Captain, 1836 00:47:57,081 --> 00:47:57,115
1837 00:47:57,115 --> 00:48:01,188
who is the best judge
as to when a ship
is in its last extremity?
1838
00:48:01,188 --> 00:48:01,223
1839 00:48:01,223 --> 00:48:03,984
There's only one judge,
the commanding officer.
1840
00:48:03,984 --> 00:48:04,019
1841 00:48:04,019 --> 00:48:05,503
Why, sir? 1842 00:48:05,503 --> 00:48:05,537
1843 00:48:05,537 --> 00:48:07,539
Well, the Navy has
made him captain
1844
00:48:07,539 --> 00:48:07,574
1845 00:48:07,574 --> 00:48:09,748
because his knowledge
of the sea and of ships
1846
00:48:09,748 --> 00:48:09,783
1847 00:48:09,783 --> 00:48:12,820
is better than anyone
else's on the ship.
1848
00:48:12,820 --> 00:48:12,855
1849 00:48:12,855 --> 00:48:14,926
Panic is a common
hazard at sea.
1850
00:48:14,926 --> 00:48:14,961
1851 00:48:14,961 --> 00:48:18,205
The highest function
of command is to override it,
1852
00:48:18,205 --> 00:48:18,240
1853 00:48:18,240 --> 00:48:21,968
to listen to nothing
but the voice of his
own professional judgment.
1854
00:48:21,968 --> 00:48:22,796
1855 00:48:22,796 --> 00:48:25,557
Thank you, Captain. 1856 00:48:25,557 --> 00:48:25,592
1857 00:48:25,592 --> 00:48:28,767
You will not discuss
your testimony outside the
courtroom, Captain.
1858
00:48:28,767 --> 00:48:28,802
1859 00:48:28,802 --> 00:48:29,941
Understood. 1860 00:48:29,941 --> 00:48:29,976
1861 00:48:29,976 --> 00:48:32,116
You're excused
and thank you.
1862
00:48:32,116 --> 00:48:39,606
1863 00:48:39,606 --> 00:48:42,540
Call Dr. Forest Lundeen. 1864 00:48:42,540 --> 00:49:02,525
1865 00:49:02,525 --> 00:49:05,735
Raise your right hand. You do
solemnly swear the evidence
you shall give in this court
1866
00:49:05,735 --> 00:49:05,770
1867 00:49:05,770 --> 00:49:07,047
shall be the truth,
the whole truth,
1868
00:49:07,047 --> 00:49:07,082
1869 00:49:07,082 --> 00:49:07,979
and nothing but
the truth,
so help you God?
1870
00:49:07,979 --> 00:49:08,014
1871 00:49:08,014 --> 00:49:09,291
I do. 1872 00:49:09,291 --> 00:49:16,470
1873 00:49:16,470 --> 00:49:18,576
State your name,
rank and present station.
1874
00:49:18,576 --> 00:49:18,610
1875 00:49:18,610 --> 00:49:21,579
Forest Lundeen, MD,
Captain US Navy.
1876
00:49:21,579 --> 00:49:21,613
1877 00:49:21,613 --> 00:49:24,685
Head of psychiatry,
US Naval Hospital,
San Francisco.
1878
00:49:24,685 --> 00:49:24,720
1879 00:49:24,720 --> 00:49:26,411
Were you
head of the medical
board which examined
1880
00:49:26,411 --> 00:49:26,446
1881 00:49:26,446 --> 00:49:27,895
-Lieutenant Commander Queeg?
I was.
1882
00:49:27,895 --> 00:49:27,930
1883 00:49:27,930 --> 00:49:29,690
How long did the
examination last,
Doctor?
1884
00:49:29,690 --> 00:49:29,725
1885 00:49:29,725 --> 00:49:33,280
We had the commander under
constant observation and
testing for three weeks.
1886
00:49:33,280 --> 00:49:33,315
1887 00:49:33,315 --> 00:49:35,006
What was the finding
of the board?
1888
00:49:35,006 --> 00:49:35,041
1889 00:49:35,041 --> 00:49:38,699
Commander Queeg
was discharged with
a clean bill of health.
1890
00:49:38,699 --> 00:49:38,734
1891 00:49:38,734 --> 00:49:42,013
Doctor, is it possible
that two months ago
on December 18
1892
00:49:42,013 --> 00:49:42,048
1893 00:49:42,048 --> 00:49:44,947
he was in such a state
of psychotic collapse
1894
00:49:44,947 --> 00:49:44,982
1895 00:49:44,982 --> 00:49:47,398
that relieving him
from a naval command
would be justified?
1896
00:49:47,398 --> 00:49:47,432
1897 00:49:47,432 --> 00:49:49,469
It's utterly impossible. 1898 00:49:49,469 --> 00:49:49,503
1899 00:49:49,503 --> 00:49:52,782
We're going to place
your report in evidence
and hear Dr. Bird.
1900
00:49:52,782 --> 00:49:52,817
1901 00:49:52,817 --> 00:49:54,301
Thank you, Doctor. 1902 00:49:54,301 --> 00:49:59,306
1903 00:49:59,306 --> 00:50:02,378
Dr. Lundeen,
my background is
legal, not medical,
1904
00:50:02,378 --> 00:50:02,413
1905 00:50:02,413 --> 00:50:05,795
so I hope you'll
bear with me if I try to
clarify technical terms.
1906
00:50:05,795 --> 00:50:05,830
1907 00:50:05,830 --> 00:50:07,004
Of course,
of course.
1908
00:50:07,004 --> 00:50:07,038
1909 00:50:07,038 --> 00:50:08,971
I'll probably ask some
elementary questions.
1910
00:50:08,971 --> 00:50:09,006
1911 00:50:09,006 --> 00:50:11,422
Perfectly all right. 1912 00:50:11,422 --> 00:50:11,456
1913 00:50:11,456 --> 00:50:16,082
Now, Doctor, would you
say Commander Queeg
is absolutely normal?
1914
00:50:16,082 --> 00:50:16,116
1915 00:50:16,116 --> 00:50:20,396
Well, normality, you know,
is a fiction in psychiatry.
1916
00:50:20,396 --> 00:50:20,431
1917 00:50:20,431 --> 00:50:23,468
No adult's without problems,
except a happy imbecile.
1918
00:50:23,468 --> 00:50:25,091
1919 00:50:25,091 --> 00:50:28,059
Can you describe
Commander Queeg's
problems, please?
1920
00:50:28,059 --> 00:50:28,094
1921 00:50:28,094 --> 00:50:32,512
Well, you might say
his overall problem is
one of inferiority feelings,
1922
00:50:32,512 --> 00:50:32,546
1923 00:50:32,546 --> 00:50:35,204
generated by an
unfavorable childhood
1924
00:50:35,204 --> 00:50:35,239
1925 00:50:35,239 --> 00:50:38,311
and aggravated by
certain adult experiences.
1926
00:50:38,311 --> 00:50:38,345
1927 00:50:38,345 --> 00:50:41,210
Unfavorable childhood
in what way?
1928
00:50:41,210 --> 00:50:41,245
1929 00:50:41,245 --> 00:50:46,767
Disturbed background,
divorced parents, financial
trouble, schooling problems.
1930
00:50:46,767 --> 00:50:46,802
1931 00:50:46,802 --> 00:50:50,012
And the aggravating
factors in adult life?
1932
00:50:50,012 --> 00:50:50,047
1933 00:50:50,047 --> 00:50:54,810
In general, the commander
is rather troubled
by his short stature,
1934
00:50:54,810 --> 00:50:54,844
1935 00:50:54,844 --> 00:50:57,123
his low standing
in his class
and such factors.
1936
00:50:57,123 --> 00:50:57,157
1937 00:50:57,157 --> 00:51:00,195
The commander is
well adjusted to
all these things.
1938
00:51:00,195 --> 00:51:00,229
1939 00:51:00,229 --> 00:51:02,162
Can you describe
the nature of
this adjustment?
1940
00:51:02,162 --> 00:51:02,197
1941 00:51:02,197 --> 00:51:06,477
Yes, I can. His identity
as a naval officer is the
essential balancing factor.
1942
00:51:06,477 --> 00:51:06,511
1943 00:51:06,511 --> 00:51:09,031
It's the key to
his personal security.
1944
00:51:09,031 --> 00:51:09,066
1945 00:51:09,066 --> 00:51:11,861
Therefore, he has
a fixed anxiety about
protecting his standing.
1946
00:51:11,861 --> 00:51:11,896
1947 00:51:11,896 --> 00:51:15,658
That would account
for the harshness
and ill-temper.
1948
00:51:15,658 --> 00:51:15,693
1949 00:51:15,693 --> 00:51:19,179
Would he be disinclined
to admit to mistakes?
1950
00:51:19,179 --> 00:51:19,214
1951 00:51:19,214 --> 00:51:21,802
Yes. Of course,
there's nothing
unbalanced in that.
1952
00:51:21,802 --> 00:51:21,837
1953 00:51:21,837 --> 00:51:25,358
Oh. Would he be
a perfectionist?
1954
00:51:25,358 --> 00:51:25,392
1955 00:51:25,392 --> 00:51:27,187
Such a personality would be. 1956 00:51:27,187 --> 00:51:27,222
1957 00:51:27,222 --> 00:51:32,296
Suspicious of subordinates?
Inclined to hound them
over small details?
1958
00:51:32,296 --> 00:51:32,330
1959 00:51:32,330 --> 00:51:37,542
Any mistake by a subordinate
is intolerable because it
might endanger him.
1960
00:51:37,542 --> 00:51:37,577
1961 00:51:37,577 --> 00:51:40,235
And yet he will not
admit mistakes when
he makes them himself.
1962
00:51:40,235 --> 00:51:40,269
1963 00:51:40,269 --> 00:51:43,100
You might say
he revises reality
in his own mind,
1964
00:51:43,100 --> 00:51:43,134
1965 00:51:43,134 --> 00:51:45,999
so that he comes
out blameless.
1966
00:51:45,999 --> 00:51:46,033
1967 00:51:46,033 --> 00:51:50,624
Yes, but, Doctor, isn't
distorting reality a symptom
of mental illness?
1968
00:51:50,624 --> 00:51:50,659
1969 00:51:50,659 --> 00:51:55,560
Well, it's a question
of degree. None of us
wholly faces reality.
1970
00:51:55,560 --> 00:51:55,595
1971 00:51:55,595 --> 00:51:59,426
But doesn't the commander
distort reality more than,
say, you do?
1972
00:51:59,426 --> 00:51:59,461
1973 00:51:59,461 --> 00:52:02,153
That's his weakness.
Other people have
other weaknesses.
1974
00:52:02,153 --> 00:52:02,188
1975 00:52:02,188 --> 00:52:04,224
It's definitely
not disabling.
1976
00:52:04,224 --> 00:52:04,259
1977 00:52:04,259 --> 00:52:06,847
Would he be inclined
to stubbornness?
1978
00:52:06,847 --> 00:52:06,882
1979 00:52:06,882 --> 00:52:11,266
You'll have a certain
rigidity of personality
in such an individual.
1980
00:52:11,266 --> 00:52:11,300
1981 00:52:11,300 --> 00:52:13,544
The inner insecurity
checks him
1982
00:52:13,544 --> 00:52:13,578
1983 00:52:13,578 --> 00:52:16,926
from admitting that
those who differ with
him may be right.
1984
00:52:16,926 --> 00:52:18,411
1985 00:52:18,411 --> 00:52:21,414
Doctor, you've testified
that the following symptoms
1986
00:52:21,414 --> 00:52:21,448
1987 00:52:21,448 --> 00:52:24,451
exist in commander
Queeg's behavior.
1988
00:52:24,451 --> 00:52:24,486
1989 00:52:24,486 --> 00:52:30,181
Rigidity of personality,
feelings of persecution,
unreasonable suspicion,
1990
00:52:30,181 --> 00:52:30,216
1991 00:52:30,216 --> 00:52:36,601
withdrawal from reality,
perfectionist anxiety,
an unreal basic premise
1992
00:52:36,601 --> 00:52:36,636
1993 00:52:36,636 --> 00:52:39,052
and an obsessive sense
of self-righteousness.
1994
00:52:39,052 --> 00:52:41,296
1995 00:52:41,296 --> 00:52:45,265
All mild, sir.
All well compensated.
1996
00:52:45,265 --> 00:52:45,300
1997 00:52:45,300 --> 00:52:47,543
Yes, Doctor. 1998 00:52:47,543 --> 00:52:47,578
1999 00:52:47,578 --> 00:52:50,926
Now, is there an inclusive
psychiatric term,
2000
00:52:50,926 --> 00:52:50,960
2001 00:52:50,960 --> 00:52:53,239
one label for this syndrome? 2002 00:52:53,239 --> 00:52:53,273
2003 00:52:53,273 --> 00:52:56,103
Syndrome? Who said
anything about a syndrome?
2004
00:52:56,103 --> 00:52:56,138
2005 00:52:56,138 --> 00:53:00,211
You're misusing the term.
There's no syndrome
because there's no disease.
2006
00:53:00,211 --> 00:53:00,246
2007 00:53:00,246 --> 00:53:03,525
Thank you for the correction,
Doctor. I'll rephrase it.
2008
00:53:03,525 --> 00:53:03,559
2009 00:53:03,559 --> 00:53:07,770
Do these symptoms fall
into a single pattern
of neurotic disturbance?
2010
00:53:07,770 --> 00:53:07,805
2011 00:53:07,805 --> 00:53:09,531
A common psychiatric class? 2012 00:53:09,531 --> 00:53:09,565
2013 00:53:09,565 --> 00:53:11,981
I know what you're driving
at, of course. It's a
paranoid personality.
2014
00:53:11,981 --> 00:53:12,016
2015 00:53:12,016 --> 00:53:14,294
But that is not
a disabling affliction.
2016
00:53:14,294 --> 00:53:14,329
2017 00:53:14,329 --> 00:53:16,331
What sort of
-personality, Doctor?
-Paranoid.
2018
00:53:16,331 --> 00:53:16,365
2019 00:53:16,365 --> 00:53:18,919
-Paranoid, Doctor.
-Yes, paranoid.
2020
00:53:18,919 --> 00:53:20,576
2021 00:53:20,576 --> 00:53:23,234
Thank you, Doctor.
No more questions.
2022
00:53:23,234 --> 00:53:25,616
2023 00:53:25,616 --> 00:53:28,929
You will not discuss your
testimony outside this
courtroom. You're excused.
2024
00:53:28,929 --> 00:53:36,420
2025 00:53:36,420 --> 00:53:38,180
Call Dr. Bird. 2026 00:53:38,180 --> 00:53:39,906
2027 00:53:39,906 --> 00:53:41,010
Dr. Bird. 2028 00:53:41,010 --> 00:53:41,045
2029 00:53:41,045 --> 00:53:42,633
These things are
such a waste of time.
2030
00:53:42,633 --> 00:53:42,667
2031 00:53:42,667 --> 00:53:45,118
I don't know why
a deposition
couldn't do the same thing.
2032
00:53:45,118 --> 00:53:45,152
2033 00:53:45,152 --> 00:53:46,223
Yes, sir. 2034 00:53:46,223 --> 00:53:54,817
2035 00:53:54,817 --> 00:53:58,545
These doctors.
Ought to run every one
of them through boot camp.
2036
00:53:58,545 --> 00:53:58,580
2037 00:53:58,580 --> 00:54:02,100
Get your hands out of
your pockets, sailor.
2038
00:54:02,100 --> 00:54:02,135
2039 00:54:02,135 --> 00:54:03,585
You do solemnly swear
the evidence you shall
2040
00:54:03,585 --> 00:54:03,619
2041 00:54:03,619 --> 00:54:05,138
give in this court
shall be the truth,
the whole truth,
2042
00:54:05,138 --> 00:54:05,172
2043 00:54:05,172 --> 00:54:07,278
and nothing but the truth,
-so help you God?
-I do.
2044
00:54:07,278 --> 00:54:13,077
2045 00:54:13,077 --> 00:54:14,906
State your name,
rank and present station.
2046
00:54:14,906 --> 00:54:14,941
2047 00:54:14,941 --> 00:54:17,840
Alan Winston Bird,
MD, Lieutenant USNR,
2048
00:54:17,840 --> 00:54:17,875
2049 00:54:17,875 --> 00:54:21,603
on the psychiatric staff
of the US Naval Hospital,
San Francisco.
2050
00:54:21,603 --> 00:54:21,637
2051 00:54:21,637 --> 00:54:23,708
Were you a member
of the board, headed
by Dr. Lundeen,
2052
00:54:23,708 --> 00:54:23,743
2053 00:54:23,743 --> 00:54:26,815
which recently inquired
into the mental health of
Lieutenant Commander Queeg?
2054
00:54:26,815 --> 00:54:26,849
2055 00:54:26,849 --> 00:54:28,886
-Yes, sir.
-What was the finding
of the board?
2056
00:54:28,886 --> 00:54:28,920
2057 00:54:28,920 --> 00:54:32,510
We found the commander
mentally fit for command
now and has never been unfit.
2058
00:54:32,510 --> 00:54:32,545
2059 00:54:32,545 --> 00:54:34,374
Did you find
any indication
in Commander Queeg
2060
00:54:34,374 --> 00:54:34,409
2061 00:54:34,409 --> 00:54:37,446
of what is known as
a paranoid personality?
2062
00:54:37,446 --> 00:54:37,481
2063 00:54:37,481 --> 00:54:40,794
Well, I prefer to call
it obsessive personality with
paranoid features.
2064
00:54:40,794 --> 00:54:40,829
2065 00:54:40,829 --> 00:54:43,107
But this
did not indicate any
mental unfitness however?
2066
00:54:43,107 --> 00:54:43,141
2067 00:54:43,141 --> 00:54:44,488
Oh, no. 2068 00:54:44,488 --> 00:54:44,522
2069 00:54:44,522 --> 00:54:47,007
You unanimously agreed then,
Doctor, that Commander Queeg
2070
00:54:47,007 --> 00:54:47,042
2071 00:54:47,042 --> 00:54:50,528
is mentally fit now and
must have been mentally fit
on December 18
2072
00:54:50,528 --> 00:54:50,563
2073 00:54:50,563 --> 00:54:53,704
when he was relieved
from naval command on the
grounds of mental illness?
2074
00:54:53,704 --> 00:54:53,738
2075 00:54:53,738 --> 00:54:56,223
That was our
unanimous conclusion.
2076
00:54:56,223 --> 00:54:56,258
2077 00:54:56,258 --> 00:54:58,536
Thank you, Doctor.
No further questions.
2078
00:54:58,536 --> 00:55:05,647
2079 00:55:05,647 --> 00:55:08,166
Doctor, you
have a special training
in Freudian technique?
2080
00:55:08,166 --> 00:55:08,201
2081 00:55:08,201 --> 00:55:09,789
Yes. 2082 00:55:09,789 --> 00:55:09,823
2083 00:55:09,823 --> 00:55:12,343
In Freudian analysis,
is there such a thing
as mental illness?
2084
00:55:12,343 --> 00:55:12,378
2085 00:55:12,378 --> 00:55:14,897
Well, there are
disturbed people
and adjusted people.
2086
00:55:14,897 --> 00:55:14,932
2087 00:55:14,932 --> 00:55:17,175
But disturbed and
adjusted correspond
roughly, don't they,
2088
00:55:17,175 --> 00:55:17,210
2089 00:55:17,210 --> 00:55:19,902
to the terms sick and well,
as laymen use them?
2090
00:55:19,902 --> 00:55:19,937
2091 00:55:19,937 --> 00:55:22,422
Very roughly, yes. 2092 00:55:22,422 --> 00:55:22,457
2093 00:55:22,457 --> 00:55:25,839
Would you say that
Commander Queeg suffers
from inferiority feelings?
2094
00:55:25,839 --> 00:55:25,874
2095 00:55:25,874 --> 00:55:27,807
Yes, but they are
well compensated.
2096
00:55:27,807 --> 00:55:27,841
2097 00:55:27,841 --> 00:55:30,396
Is there a difference
between compensated
and adjusted?
2098
00:55:30,396 --> 00:55:30,430
2099 00:55:30,430 --> 00:55:32,052
Most definitely. 2100 00:55:32,052 --> 00:55:32,087
2101 00:55:32,087 --> 00:55:33,778
Can you explain it? 2102 00:55:33,778 --> 00:55:33,813
2103 00:55:33,813 --> 00:55:38,783
Well, let's say
a man has some deep-seated
psychological disturbance.
2104
00:55:38,783 --> 00:55:38,818
2105 00:55:38,818 --> 00:55:41,924
He can compensate by
finding outlets for
his peculiar drives.
2106
00:55:41,924 --> 00:55:41,959
2107 00:55:41,959 --> 00:55:45,756
He can never adjust
without undergoing
psychoanalysis.
2108
00:55:45,756 --> 00:55:45,790
2109 00:55:45,790 --> 00:55:48,103
Has Commander Queeg
ever been psychoanalyzed?
2110
00:55:48,103 --> 00:55:48,137
2111 00:55:48,137 --> 00:55:50,726
-No.
-He is, then,
a disturbed person?
2112
00:55:50,726 --> 00:55:50,761
2113 00:55:50,761 --> 00:55:54,489
Yes, he is. Not disabled,
however, by the disturbance.
2114
00:55:54,489 --> 00:55:54,523
2115 00:55:54,523 --> 00:55:56,456
How has he compensated? 2116 00:55:56,456 --> 00:55:56,491
2117 00:55:56,491 --> 00:55:58,700
Well, two ways mainly. 2118 00:55:58,700 --> 00:55:58,734
2119 00:55:58,734 --> 00:56:01,875
The paranoid pattern,
which is useless
and undesirable,
2120
00:56:01,875 --> 00:56:01,910
2121 00:56:01,910 --> 00:56:06,017
and his naval career,
which is extremely
useful and desirable.
2122
00:56:06,017 --> 00:56:06,052
2123 00:56:06,052 --> 00:56:09,331
You say that his
military career is a
result of the disturbance?
2124
00:56:09,331 --> 00:56:09,366
2125 00:56:09,366 --> 00:56:11,091
Most military careers are. 2126 00:56:11,091 --> 00:56:11,126
2127 00:56:11,126 --> 00:56:14,681
Doctor,
did you note any peculiar
habit of Commander Queeg?
2128
00:56:14,681 --> 00:56:14,716
2129 00:56:14,716 --> 00:56:16,303
Something he did
with his hands?
2130
00:56:16,303 --> 00:56:16,338
2131 00:56:16,338 --> 00:56:18,444
You mean the rolling
of the steel balls?
2132
00:56:18,444 --> 00:56:18,478
2133 00:56:18,478 --> 00:56:19,893
Yes. Describe
the habit, please.
2134
00:56:19,893 --> 00:56:19,928
2135 00:56:19,928 --> 00:56:21,964
Well, it's an incessant
rolling, or rattling
2136
00:56:21,964 --> 00:56:21,999
2137 00:56:21,999 --> 00:56:24,622
of two marbles in his hand,
either hand.
2138
00:56:24,622 --> 00:56:24,657
2139 00:56:24,657 --> 00:56:26,555
Why does he do it? 2140 00:56:26,555 --> 00:56:26,590
2141 00:56:26,590 --> 00:56:29,144
His hands tremble.
He does it to conceal the
trembling, to still his hands.
2142
00:56:29,144 --> 00:56:29,178
2143 00:56:29,178 --> 00:56:31,767
It makes him feel
more comfortable.
2144
00:56:31,767 --> 00:56:31,802
2145 00:56:31,802 --> 00:56:33,390
Why do his
hands tremble?
2146
00:56:33,390 --> 00:56:33,424
2147 00:56:33,424 --> 00:56:37,324
The inner tension.
It's one of the
surface symptoms.
2148
00:56:37,324 --> 00:56:37,359
2149 00:56:37,359 --> 00:56:41,570
Does this rolling motion
have any significance
in Freudian analysis?
2150
00:56:41,570 --> 00:56:41,605
2151 00:56:41,605 --> 00:56:44,504
Well, it's an obvious
sexual symbol, of course.
2152
00:56:44,504 --> 00:56:44,539
2153 00:56:44,539 --> 00:56:46,575
How far
is this totally
2154
00:56:46,575 --> 00:56:46,610
2155 00:56:46,610 --> 00:56:49,406
irrelevant technical
discussion going to
be pushed?
2156
00:56:49,406 --> 00:56:49,440
2157 00:56:49,440 --> 00:56:51,649
Are you objecting
to the question?
2158
00:56:51,649 --> 00:56:51,684
2159 00:56:51,684 --> 00:56:53,720
I'm requesting
the court set limits to
time wasting by the defense.
2160
00:56:53,720 --> 00:56:53,755
2161 00:56:53,755 --> 00:56:57,172
Request is noted.
Proceed with your
cross-examination.
2162
00:56:57,172 --> 00:56:57,206
2163 00:56:57,206 --> 00:56:59,277
Doctor, you've testified
that Commander Queeg
2164
00:56:59,277 --> 00:56:59,312
2165 00:56:59,312 --> 00:57:01,935
is a disturbed,
not an adjusted person?
2166
00:57:01,935 --> 00:57:01,970
2167 00:57:01,970 --> 00:57:05,456
-Yes.
-He is, then, in
laymen's terms sick?
2168
00:57:05,456 --> 00:57:05,491
2169 00:57:05,491 --> 00:57:09,978
I remember agreeing to the
rough resemblance between
the terms disturbed and sick.
2170
00:57:09,978 --> 00:57:10,012
2171 00:57:10,012 --> 00:57:12,705
But by those terms,
an awful lot of
people are sick.
2172
00:57:12,705 --> 00:57:12,739
2173 00:57:12,739 --> 00:57:17,503
Yes, but this trial only
has Commander Queeg's
sickness at issue.
2174
00:57:17,503 --> 00:57:17,537
2175 00:57:17,537 --> 00:57:20,264
Now if he's sick, how could
your board have given him
a clean bill of health?
2176
00:57:20,264 --> 00:57:20,298
2177 00:57:20,298 --> 00:57:24,889
You're playing
on words, I'm afraid.
We found no disability.
2178
00:57:24,889 --> 00:57:24,924
2179 00:57:24,924 --> 00:57:27,029
Doctor,
supposing the
requirements of command
2180
00:57:27,029 --> 00:57:27,064
2181 00:57:27,064 --> 00:57:30,308
were many times
as severe as you
believe them to be,
2182
00:57:30,308 --> 00:57:30,343
2183 00:57:30,343 --> 00:57:32,725
wouldn't even this mild
sickness disable Queeg?
2184
00:57:32,725 --> 00:57:32,759
2185 00:57:32,759 --> 00:57:35,037
-That's absurdly hypothetic.
-Is it?
2186
00:57:35,037 --> 00:57:35,072
2187 00:57:35,072 --> 00:57:37,212
Have you ever had
-sea duty, Doctor?
-No.
2188
00:57:37,212 --> 00:57:37,246
2189 00:57:37,246 --> 00:57:39,041
Have you ever
-been to sea?
-No.
2190
00:57:39,041 --> 00:57:39,076
2191 00:57:39,076 --> 00:57:40,491
How long have you
been in the Navy?
2192
00:57:40,491 --> 00:57:40,526
2193 00:57:40,526 --> 00:57:42,044
-Five months.
-Have you had
any dealings
2194
00:57:42,044 --> 00:57:42,079
2195 00:57:42,079 --> 00:57:43,839
with ships' captains
-before this case?
-No.
2196
00:57:43,839 --> 00:57:43,874
2197 00:57:43,874 --> 00:57:47,015
Upon what do you base
your estimate of the
stresses of command?
2198
00:57:47,015 --> 00:57:47,049
2199 00:57:47,049 --> 00:57:48,741
Well, my general
knowledge on...
2200
00:57:48,741 --> 00:57:48,775
2201 00:57:48,775 --> 00:57:52,261
Do you think command
requires a highly gifted,
exceptional person?
2202
00:57:52,261 --> 00:57:52,296
2203 00:57:52,296 --> 00:57:54,367
-Well, no.
-It doesn't?
2204
00:57:54,367 --> 00:57:54,401
2205 00:57:54,401 --> 00:57:58,164
Not highly gifted, no.
Adequate responses,
fairly good intelligence
2206
00:57:58,164 --> 00:57:58,198
2207 00:57:58,198 --> 00:58:01,029
and sufficient training
and experience, but...
2208
00:58:01,029 --> 00:58:01,063
2209 00:58:01,063 --> 00:58:07,311
Is that enough equipment
for, say, a highly gifted,
highly skilled psychiatrist?
2210
00:58:07,311 --> 00:58:07,345
2211 00:58:07,345 --> 00:58:09,106
Well, not exactly. 2212 00:58:09,106 --> 00:58:09,140
2213 00:58:09,140 --> 00:58:12,972
In other words,
it takes more ability
to be a psychiatrist
2214
00:58:12,972 --> 00:58:13,006
2215 00:58:13,006 --> 00:58:14,767
than the Captain
of a naval vessel?
2216
00:58:14,767 --> 00:58:14,801
2217 00:58:14,801 --> 00:58:16,527
It takes... 2218 00:58:16,527 --> 00:58:17,942
2219 00:58:17,942 --> 00:58:22,533
That is, different
abilities are required.
2220
00:58:22,533 --> 00:58:22,568
2221 00:58:22,568 --> 00:58:25,950
You're making the
invidious comparison,
not I.
2222
00:58:25,950 --> 00:58:25,985
2223 00:58:25,985 --> 00:58:30,161
Doctor, you've admitted
Commander Queeg is sick.
2224
00:58:30,161 --> 00:58:30,196
2225 00:58:30,196 --> 00:58:33,613
The only remaining
question is, how sick?
2226
00:58:33,613 --> 00:58:33,648
2227 00:58:33,648 --> 00:58:36,651
You don't think
he's sick enough to
be disabled from command.
2228
00:58:36,651 --> 00:58:36,685
2229 00:58:36,685 --> 00:58:38,653
I suggest that,
since you evidently
don't know very much
2230
00:58:38,653 --> 00:58:38,687
2231 00:58:38,687 --> 00:58:40,758
about the requirements
of command,
2232
00:58:40,758 --> 00:58:40,793
2233 00:58:40,793 --> 00:58:42,553
you may be wrong
in your conclusion.
2234
00:58:42,553 --> 00:58:42,588
2235 00:58:42,588 --> 00:58:44,451
I repudiate
your suggestion.
2236
00:58:44,451 --> 00:58:44,486
2237 00:58:44,486 --> 00:58:47,351
You deliberatelysubstituted the word "sick." 2238 00:58:47,351 --> 00:58:47,385
2239 00:58:47,385 --> 00:58:49,456
Which is a loose...
A polarized word...
2240
00:58:49,456 --> 00:58:49,491
2241 00:58:49,491 --> 00:58:51,286
I'm sorry,
what kind of word?
2242
00:58:51,286 --> 00:58:51,320
2243 00:58:51,320 --> 00:58:52,356
Polarized. 2244 00:58:52,356 --> 00:58:52,390
2245 00:58:52,390 --> 00:58:54,427
-Polarized?
-Invidious.
2246
00:58:54,427 --> 00:58:54,461
2247 00:58:54,461 --> 00:58:57,085
I never said "sick." 2248 00:58:57,085 --> 00:58:57,119
2249 00:58:57,119 --> 00:58:59,777
Now, my grasp
of the requirements
of command is adequate,
2250
00:58:59,777 --> 00:58:59,812
2251 00:58:59,812 --> 00:59:03,816
or I would have
disqualified myself
from serving on the board.
2252
00:59:03,816 --> 00:59:03,850
2253 00:59:03,850 --> 00:59:05,058
Maybe you should have. 2254 00:59:05,058 --> 00:59:05,093
2255 00:59:05,093 --> 00:59:06,922
The witness
is being badgered.
2256
00:59:06,922 --> 00:59:09,028
2257 00:59:09,028 --> 00:59:12,583
I withdraw
my last statement.
No further questions.
2258
00:59:12,583 --> 00:59:12,618
2259 00:59:12,618 --> 00:59:16,449
Dr. Bird, the defense
counsel has managed to
put words in your mouth
2260
00:59:16,449 --> 00:59:16,483
2261 00:59:16,483 --> 00:59:18,485
that I'm certain
you don't mean.
2262
00:59:18,485 --> 00:59:18,520
2263 00:59:18,520 --> 00:59:22,697
I am not aware
he succeeded in putting
any words into my mouth.
2264
00:59:22,697 --> 00:59:22,731
2265 00:59:22,731 --> 00:59:26,010
Doctor, he drew from
you the implication
that Captain Queeg...
2266
00:59:26,010 --> 00:59:26,045
2267 00:59:26,045 --> 00:59:30,532
Sir, I am careful in
my use of terminology.
2268
00:59:30,532 --> 00:59:30,567
2269 00:59:30,567 --> 00:59:32,810
I did not introduce
the term "sick."
2270
00:59:32,810 --> 00:59:32,845
2271 00:59:32,845 --> 00:59:35,019
I do not regard it
as a precise term.
2272
00:59:35,019 --> 00:59:35,054
2273 00:59:35,054 --> 00:59:39,541
Nevertheless, if you're
going to use such a loose
term, then Captain Queeg,
2274
00:59:39,541 --> 00:59:39,576
2275 00:59:39,576 --> 00:59:44,615
like a vast number of
seemingly healthy
people, is sick.
2276
00:59:44,615 --> 00:59:44,650
2277 00:59:44,650 --> 00:59:48,481
However, he is
definitely not
disabled for command,
2278
00:59:48,481 --> 00:59:48,515
2279 00:59:48,515 --> 00:59:50,483
which is the
only issue here.
2280
00:59:50,483 --> 00:59:52,899
2281 00:59:52,899 --> 00:59:55,764
Sir, that sounds
like a contradiction,
which I'm...
2282
00:59:55,764 --> 00:59:55,799
2283 00:59:55,799 --> 00:59:59,216
We live in a
sick civilization.
2284
00:59:59,216 --> 00:59:59,250
2285 00:59:59,250 --> 01:00:00,804
The well people
are exceptional.
2286
01:00:00,804 --> 01:00:00,838
2287 01:00:00,838 --> 01:00:04,221
And Captain Queeg
certainly isn't exceptional
in that regard.
2288
01:00:04,221 --> 01:00:04,255
2289 01:00:04,255 --> 01:00:06,913
And furthermore,
I'd like ...ank you.
2290
01:00:06,913 --> 01:00:06,948
2291 01:00:06,948 --> 01:00:10,537
Thank you, Doctor.
Certainly clarifies
the matter.
2292
01:00:10,537 --> 01:00:10,572
2293 01:00:10,572 --> 01:00:12,091
No more questions. 2294 01:00:12,091 --> 01:00:16,198
2295 01:00:16,198 --> 01:00:21,548
Doctor, Doctor, you'll
not discuss your testimony
outside this courtroom.
2296
01:00:21,548 --> 01:00:21,583
2297 01:00:21,583 --> 01:00:23,550
Yes, sir.
-You're excused.
2298
01:00:23,550 --> 01:00:26,553
2299 01:00:26,553 --> 01:00:28,866
Prosecution rests. 2300 01:00:28,866 --> 01:00:28,901
2301 01:00:28,901 --> 01:00:31,041
Is defense ready
to present its case?
2302
01:00:31,041 --> 01:00:31,075
2303 01:00:31,075 --> 01:00:32,352
Yes, sir. 2304 01:00:32,352 --> 01:00:32,387
2305 01:00:32,387 --> 01:00:33,802
How many witnesses
are you calling?
2306
01:00:33,802 --> 01:00:33,837
2307 01:00:33,837 --> 01:00:36,425
Only two, sir.
The first is the accused.
2308
01:00:36,425 --> 01:00:36,460
2309 01:00:36,460 --> 01:00:38,151
We can button this all
up tomorrow morning?
2310
01:00:38,151 --> 01:00:38,186
2311 01:00:38,186 --> 01:00:41,292
I believe so, sir. 2312 01:00:41,292 --> 01:00:42,086
2313 01:00:42,086 --> 01:00:43,398
Recess until 0900. 2314 01:00:43,398 --> 01:00:45,952
2315 01:00:45,952 --> 01:00:48,610
That was marvelous,
cutting up that doctor
like that.
2316
01:00:48,610 --> 01:00:48,645
2317 01:00:48,645 --> 01:00:49,715
Wise little bastard. 2318 01:00:49,715 --> 01:00:49,749
2319 01:00:49,749 --> 01:00:51,993
-Did you ever read it?
-What?
2320
01:00:51,993 --> 01:00:52,027
2321 01:00:52,027 --> 01:00:54,478
Your friend
-Tom Keefer's novel?
-Huh?
2322
01:00:54,478 --> 01:00:54,512
2323 01:00:54,512 --> 01:00:56,342
Multitudes, Multitudes.
You ever read it?
2324
01:00:56,342 --> 01:00:56,376
2325 01:00:56,376 --> 01:00:59,379
Tom's novel? No. He's always
-kept it in a black satchel.
-I'd like to read it.
2326
01:00:59,379 --> 01:00:59,414
2327 01:00:59,414 --> 01:01:01,623
Quite a job you did
on Bird, Barney.
2328
01:01:01,623 --> 01:01:01,658
2329 01:01:01,658 --> 01:01:02,969
Thanks, Jack. 2330 01:01:02,969 --> 01:01:03,004
2331 01:01:03,004 --> 01:01:04,868
-It won't cut any ice.
-No?
2332
01:01:04,868 --> 01:01:04,902
2333 01:01:04,902 --> 01:01:07,249
No, Blakely's headed up
a lot of these courts.
2334
01:01:07,249 --> 01:01:07,284
2335 01:01:07,284 --> 01:01:09,182
He doesn't go
for vaudeville.
2336
01:01:09,182 --> 01:01:09,217
2337 01:01:09,217 --> 01:01:13,117
-See you tomorrow, Jack.
-See you tomorrow.
2338
01:01:13,117 --> 01:01:13,152
2339 01:01:13,152 --> 01:01:16,707
I'm sure it exposes this
-war for all its grim futility.
-What does?
2340
01:01:16,707 --> 01:01:16,742
2341 01:01:16,742 --> 01:01:18,916
The book. 2342 01:01:18,916 --> 01:01:18,951
2343 01:01:18,951 --> 01:01:23,334
I'm sure it shows up
all the regular Army
and Navy officers,
2344
01:01:23,334 --> 01:01:23,369
2345 01:01:23,369 --> 01:01:26,821
bunch of stupid sadists,
bitching up the campaigns,
2346
01:01:26,821 --> 01:01:26,855
2347 01:01:26,855 --> 01:01:31,308
throwing away the lives
of fatalistic, humorous,
lovable citizen soldiers,
2348
01:01:31,308 --> 01:01:31,342
2349 01:01:31,342 --> 01:01:34,691
lots of sexy scenes
where the prose becomes
rhythmic and beautiful
2350
01:01:34,691 --> 01:01:34,725
2351 01:01:34,725 --> 01:01:38,073
while the girl gets
-her pants pulled down.
-What's eating you?
2352
01:01:38,073 --> 01:01:38,108
2353 01:01:38,108 --> 01:01:40,110
I hate this case,
you know.
2354
01:01:40,110 --> 01:01:40,144
2355 01:01:40,144 --> 01:01:41,870
More so because
I want to win
it so bad.
2356
01:01:41,870 --> 01:01:41,905
2357 01:01:41,905 --> 01:01:43,665
Because of what
I have to do
to win it.
2358
01:01:43,665 --> 01:01:43,700
2359 01:01:43,700 --> 01:01:44,942
I'm beginning
to think you...
2360
01:01:44,942 --> 01:01:44,977
2361 01:01:44,977 --> 01:01:46,219
I've got a pretty
good chance here.
2362
01:01:46,219 --> 01:01:46,254
2363 01:01:46,254 --> 01:01:47,669
You're pretty keen,
all right.
2364
01:01:47,669 --> 01:01:47,704
2365 01:01:47,704 --> 01:01:49,567
Almost as keen
as Tom Keefer?
2366
01:01:49,567 --> 01:01:49,602
2367 01:01:49,602 --> 01:01:52,881
Oh, boy, you were...
You sure were right
about him.
2368
01:01:52,881 --> 01:01:52,916
2369 01:01:52,916 --> 01:01:55,573
Why did he do it, anyway?
I mean, he didn't have to
implicate himself.
2370
01:01:55,573 --> 01:01:55,608
2371 01:01:55,608 --> 01:01:57,368
He could have said
what he really
thought about Queeg.
2372
01:01:57,368 --> 01:01:57,403
2373 01:01:57,403 --> 01:02:00,026
What, to Blakely? Blakely's
sniffing around the edges
of Keefer as it is.
2374
01:02:00,026 --> 01:02:00,061
2375 01:02:00,061 --> 01:02:02,926
No, sir. Your friend's
one course was to
clam up. He's smart.
2376
01:02:02,926 --> 01:02:02,960
2377 01:02:02,960 --> 01:02:06,101
It's all right.
You don't like Tom much.
2378
01:02:06,101 --> 01:02:09,070
2379 01:02:09,070 --> 01:02:12,590
When I look at Tom
Keefer, I see myself
a couple of years ago.
2380
01:02:12,590 --> 01:02:12,625
2381 01:02:12,625 --> 01:02:16,111
Only like in a crazy
mirror, all distorted
and upside down.
2382
01:02:16,111 --> 01:02:16,146
2383 01:02:16,146 --> 01:02:18,010
I'm not amused. 2384 01:02:18,010 --> 01:02:18,044
2385 01:02:18,044 --> 01:02:21,323
Maybe Tom Keefer didn't
enjoy sailing under Queeg
for half a year.
2386
01:02:21,323 --> 01:02:21,358
2387 01:02:21,358 --> 01:02:23,394
Maybe he'd enjoy it less
if the Nazis and the Japs
2388
01:02:23,394 --> 01:02:23,429
2389 01:02:23,429 --> 01:02:26,259
were shaking hands
right now at the
Mississippi River.
2390
01:02:26,259 --> 01:02:26,294
2391 01:02:26,294 --> 01:02:28,123
I guess one thing
I found out, Maryk,
2392
01:02:28,123 --> 01:02:28,158
2393 01:02:28,158 --> 01:02:30,954
is there's a time for
everything, including
rebellious youth.
2394
01:02:30,954 --> 01:02:30,988
2395 01:02:30,988 --> 01:02:33,473
Possibly you and
Mr. Keefer were dead
wrong in your timing.
2396
01:02:33,473 --> 01:02:33,508
2397 01:02:33,508 --> 01:02:35,303
If that's the case, well,
the next question is,
2398
01:02:35,303 --> 01:02:35,337
2399 01:02:35,337 --> 01:02:37,788
who's the real victim
in this courtroom?
You or Captain Queeg?
2400
01:02:37,788 --> 01:02:37,823
2401 01:02:37,823 --> 01:02:39,376
Captain Queeg
was nuts.
2402
01:02:39,376 --> 01:02:39,410
2403 01:02:39,410 --> 01:02:41,067
You heard Dr. Lundeen.
It's a question of degree.
2404
01:02:41,067 --> 01:02:41,102
2405 01:02:41,102 --> 01:02:43,242
If you're at war and
your command personnel
is stretched thin,
2406
01:02:43,242 --> 01:02:43,276
2407 01:02:43,276 --> 01:02:44,968
maybe you use him
because he's got
the training.
2408
01:02:44,968 --> 01:02:45,002
2409 01:02:45,002 --> 01:02:47,108
I think Captain Queeg
is a mean, stupid
son of a bitch.
2410
01:02:47,108 --> 01:02:47,142
2411 01:02:47,142 --> 01:02:48,799
Okay! 2412 01:02:48,799 --> 01:02:48,834
2413 01:02:48,834 --> 01:02:50,076
If that was
grounds for deposing
your superior officer,
2414
01:02:50,076 --> 01:02:50,111
2415 01:02:50,111 --> 01:02:51,664
we wouldn't have
an Army or a Navy.
2416
01:02:51,664 --> 01:02:51,698
2417 01:02:51,698 --> 01:02:53,908
That's a wide-spread opinion
of superior officers.
2418
01:02:53,908 --> 01:02:53,942
2419 01:02:53,942 --> 01:02:55,150
Well, they're
not all Queegs.
2420
01:02:55,150 --> 01:02:55,185
2421 01:02:55,185 --> 01:02:56,807
Superiors all tend to look
like Queeg from underneath.
2422
01:02:56,807 --> 01:02:56,842
2423 01:02:56,842 --> 01:02:59,499
It's an
unflattering angle.
2424
01:02:59,499 --> 01:02:59,534
2425 01:02:59,534 --> 01:03:02,364
What do
you do when you
really get a Queeg?
2426
01:03:02,364 --> 01:03:02,399
2427 01:03:02,399 --> 01:03:06,679
You fight the war.
Where can we get drunk?
I mean drunk.
2428
01:03:06,679 --> 01:04:06,679
2429 01:04:33,145 --> 01:04:34,491
Attention! 2430 01:04:34,491 --> 01:04:40,566
2431 01:04:40,566 --> 01:04:42,430
Court is in session. 2432 01:04:42,430 --> 01:04:45,364
2433 01:04:45,364 --> 01:04:47,193
Defense, present your case. 2434 01:04:47,193 --> 01:04:47,228
2435 01:04:47,228 --> 01:04:48,954
I call the accused. 2436 01:04:48,954 --> 01:04:53,613
2437 01:04:53,613 --> 01:04:55,512
Do you solemnly swear
the evidence you shall
give in this court
2438
01:04:55,512 --> 01:04:55,546
2439 01:04:55,546 --> 01:04:58,377
shall be the truth, the
whole truth and nothing but
the truth, so help you God?
2440
01:04:58,377 --> 01:04:58,411
2441 01:04:58,411 --> 01:04:59,757
I do. 2442 01:04:59,757 --> 01:05:07,973
2443 01:05:07,973 --> 01:05:09,802
State your name, rank
and present station.
2444
01:05:09,802 --> 01:05:09,836
2445 01:05:09,836 --> 01:05:13,633
Stephen Maryk, Lieutenant,
USNR, executive officer
of the USS Caine.
2446
01:05:13,633 --> 01:05:13,668
2447 01:05:13,668 --> 01:05:15,773
Are you the accused
in this court-martial?
2448
01:05:15,773 --> 01:05:15,808
2449 01:05:15,808 --> 01:05:17,361
I am. 2450 01:05:17,361 --> 01:05:17,396
2451 01:05:17,396 --> 01:05:19,536
What was your
occupation in
civilian life?
2452
01:05:19,536 --> 01:05:19,570
2453 01:05:19,570 --> 01:05:22,125
Helping in
my father's fishing business.
2454
01:05:22,125 --> 01:05:22,159
2455 01:05:22,159 --> 01:05:23,678
We own a couple of boats. 2456 01:05:23,678 --> 01:05:23,712
2457 01:05:23,712 --> 01:05:26,336
Where?
-In San Francisco.
2458
01:05:26,336 --> 01:05:26,370
2459 01:05:26,370 --> 01:05:28,200
Then you were familiar with
the problems of ocean going
2460
01:05:28,200 --> 01:05:28,234
2461 01:05:28,234 --> 01:05:30,788
ship handling before
entering the Navy?
2462
01:05:30,788 --> 01:05:30,823
2463 01:05:30,823 --> 01:05:33,515
Well, I've been on
boats since I was 14.
2464
01:05:33,515 --> 01:05:34,896
2465 01:05:34,896 --> 01:05:37,174
Did you relieve the
commanding officer
of the Caine
2466
01:05:37,174 --> 01:05:37,209
2467 01:05:37,209 --> 01:05:40,315
of his command on
December 18, 1944?
2468
01:05:40,315 --> 01:05:40,350
2469 01:05:40,350 --> 01:05:42,524
-I did.
-Was the Cainein
the last extremity
2470
01:05:42,524 --> 01:05:42,559
2471 01:05:42,559 --> 01:05:43,870
when you relieved
the Captain?
2472
01:05:43,870 --> 01:05:43,905
2473 01:05:43,905 --> 01:05:47,288
-It was.
-On what fact do you
base this judgment?
2474
01:05:47,288 --> 01:05:47,322
2475 01:05:47,322 --> 01:05:50,947
Well, on several...
Well, we were unable to
hold course.
2476
01:05:50,947 --> 01:05:50,981
2477 01:05:50,981 --> 01:05:52,707
We broached to
three times in an hour.
2478
01:05:52,707 --> 01:05:52,741
2479 01:05:52,741 --> 01:05:54,536
Broached to? 2480 01:05:54,536 --> 01:05:54,571
2481 01:05:54,571 --> 01:05:58,747
Yes. Wind and sea took
charge, tossed us sideways
for 10 minutes at a time.
2482
01:05:58,747 --> 01:05:58,782
2483 01:05:58,782 --> 01:06:01,854
We were rolling
too steeply for the
inclinometer to record.
2484
01:06:01,854 --> 01:06:01,888
2485 01:06:01,888 --> 01:06:05,237
We were shipping solid green
water in the wheelhouse.
Generators were cutting out.
2486
01:06:05,237 --> 01:06:05,271
2487 01:06:05,271 --> 01:06:09,241
The ship wasn't answering
to emergency rudder and
engine settings.
2488
01:06:09,241 --> 01:06:09,275
2489 01:06:09,275 --> 01:06:11,795
We were lost
and out of control.
2490
01:06:11,795 --> 01:06:11,829
2491 01:06:11,829 --> 01:06:14,039
Did you point these
things out to the Captain?
2492
01:06:14,039 --> 01:06:14,073
2493 01:06:14,073 --> 01:06:17,766
Repeatedly, for over an hour.
I begged him to come north,
head into the wind.
2494
01:06:17,766 --> 01:06:17,801
2495 01:06:17,801 --> 01:06:19,320
What was his response? 2496 01:06:19,320 --> 01:06:19,354
2497 01:06:19,354 --> 01:06:21,978
Mostly a glazed look
and no answer,
2498
01:06:21,978 --> 01:06:22,012
2499 01:06:22,012 --> 01:06:24,497
or a repetition
of his own desires.
2500
01:06:24,497 --> 01:06:24,532
2501 01:06:24,532 --> 01:06:26,534
Which were what? 2502 01:06:26,534 --> 01:06:26,568
2503 01:06:26,568 --> 01:06:29,675
Well, I guess to hold
fleet course until
we went down.
2504
01:06:29,675 --> 01:06:29,709
2505 01:06:29,709 --> 01:06:34,369
Mr. Maryk, when did you
start keeping your medical
log on Captain Queeg?
2506
01:06:34,369 --> 01:06:34,404
2507 01:06:34,404 --> 01:06:36,544
Shortly after the
Kwajalein invasion.
2508
01:06:36,544 --> 01:06:36,578
2509 01:06:36,578 --> 01:06:38,891
Why did you start it? 2510 01:06:38,891 --> 01:06:38,925
2511 01:06:38,925 --> 01:06:42,032
I began to think
the Captain might
be mentally ill.
2512
01:06:42,032 --> 01:06:42,067
2513 01:06:42,067 --> 01:06:43,792
Why? 2514 01:06:43,792 --> 01:06:43,827
2515 01:06:43,827 --> 01:06:46,485
That yellow dye
marker business.
2516
01:06:46,485 --> 01:06:46,519
2517 01:06:46,519 --> 01:06:48,418
Was that
the incident in
which Captain Queeg
2518
01:06:48,418 --> 01:06:48,452
2519 01:06:48,452 --> 01:06:50,696
acquired the nickname
Old Yellow Stain?
2520
01:06:50,696 --> 01:06:50,730
2521 01:06:50,730 --> 01:06:52,042
Yes, it was. 2522 01:06:52,042 --> 01:06:52,077
2523 01:06:52,077 --> 01:06:53,940
You witnessed the
occurrence yourself?
2524
01:06:53,940 --> 01:06:53,975
2525 01:06:53,975 --> 01:06:55,390
I was navigator.
I was right there
on the bridge.
2526
01:06:55,390 --> 01:06:55,425
2527 01:06:55,425 --> 01:06:57,461
Describe the
Yellow Stain incident, please.
2528
01:06:57,461 --> 01:06:57,496
2529 01:06:57,496 --> 01:06:59,843
Well,
it was the first morning
of the invasion.
2530
01:06:59,843 --> 01:06:59,877
2531 01:06:59,877 --> 01:07:02,432
We were ordered to lead
a group of attack boats
into the beach.
2532
01:07:02,432 --> 01:07:02,466
2533 01:07:02,466 --> 01:07:04,710
Uh, that is, we had to
take them to their
line of departure,
2534
01:07:04,710 --> 01:07:04,744
2535 01:07:04,744 --> 01:07:07,161
1,000 yards
from the beach.
2536
01:07:07,161 --> 01:07:07,195
2537 01:07:07,195 --> 01:07:09,059
These little boats, they
lay so low in the water
2538
01:07:09,059 --> 01:07:09,094
2539 01:07:09,094 --> 01:07:11,027
that they couldn't see to
navigate for themselves.
2540
01:07:11,027 --> 01:07:11,061
2541 01:07:11,061 --> 01:07:13,822
They needed a guide
to make sure that they
hit the right island.
2542
01:07:13,822 --> 01:07:13,857
2543 01:07:13,857 --> 01:07:15,686
The right beach. 2544 01:07:15,686 --> 01:07:15,721
2545 01:07:15,721 --> 01:07:18,827
Captain Queeg rang up 10 knots
and we started to head in
towards this island.
2546
01:07:18,827 --> 01:07:18,862
2547 01:07:18,862 --> 01:07:20,898
Uh... 2548 01:07:20,898 --> 01:07:20,933
2549 01:07:20,933 --> 01:07:24,833
Yeah, it had some funny
Jap name. Our code name
for it was Jacob Island.
2550
01:07:24,833 --> 01:07:24,868
2551 01:07:24,868 --> 01:07:28,423
It was a choppy sea.
And the assault boats could
only make five or six knots.
2552
01:07:28,423 --> 01:07:28,458
2553 01:07:28,458 --> 01:07:30,253
And at that they were
shipping solid water,
2554
01:07:30,253 --> 01:07:30,287
2555 01:07:30,287 --> 01:07:32,531
and the marines were
getting just about
drowned in spray.
2556
01:07:32,531 --> 01:07:32,565
2557 01:07:32,565 --> 01:07:34,395
And they began to
fall way behind.
2558
01:07:34,395 --> 01:07:34,429
2559 01:07:34,429 --> 01:07:36,811
And naturally,
they signaled for
us to slow down.
2560
01:07:36,811 --> 01:07:36,845
2561 01:07:36,845 --> 01:07:38,916
But the Captain
just ignored them.
2562
01:07:38,916 --> 01:07:38,951
2563 01:07:38,951 --> 01:07:42,196
We pulled further
and further ahead until
we could hardly see them.
2564
01:07:42,196 --> 01:07:42,230
2565 01:07:42,230 --> 01:07:46,200
Then, when we were about
2,500 yards from the beach,
we heard some gunfire.
2566
01:07:46,200 --> 01:07:46,234
2567 01:07:46,234 --> 01:07:49,099
And the Captain suddenly
yelled, "We're running
up on the beach!
2568
01:07:49,099 --> 01:07:49,134
2569 01:07:49,134 --> 01:07:50,652
"Reverse course!
Make 30 knots!"
2570
01:07:50,652 --> 01:07:50,687
2571 01:07:50,687 --> 01:07:52,309
And while we were
turning, he...
2572
01:07:52,309 --> 01:07:52,344
2573 01:07:52,344 --> 01:07:54,277
He threw over one of
these yellow dye
markers he used
2574
01:07:54,277 --> 01:07:54,311
2575 01:07:54,311 --> 01:07:57,003
to mark water when
there's a floating
mine or something.
2576
01:07:57,003 --> 01:07:57,038
2577 01:07:57,038 --> 01:07:58,488
So we went barreling
out of there.
2578
01:07:58,488 --> 01:07:58,522
2579 01:07:58,522 --> 01:08:02,733
The attack boats were
just a lot of specks
way off in the distance,
2580
01:08:02,733 --> 01:08:02,768
2581 01:08:02,768 --> 01:08:07,083
and all you could see
behind us was this big
spread of yellow,
2582
01:08:07,083 --> 01:08:07,117
2583 01:08:07,117 --> 01:08:08,877
all over the water. 2584 01:08:08,877 --> 01:08:08,912
2585 01:08:08,912 --> 01:08:10,327
Now, Mr. Maryk,
why didn't...
2586
01:08:10,327 --> 01:08:10,362
2587 01:08:10,362 --> 01:08:12,122
Court wants
to question the witness.
2588
01:08:12,122 --> 01:08:12,157
2589 01:08:12,157 --> 01:08:14,745
Lieutenant, how do you know
you were 2,500 yards from
the beach when you turned?
2590
01:08:14,745 --> 01:08:14,780
2591 01:08:14,780 --> 01:08:16,782
Sir, I was navigating.
There wasn't a doubt
in the world
2592
01:08:16,782 --> 01:08:16,816
2593 01:08:16,816 --> 01:08:18,646
where we were
by visual plot
2594
01:08:18,646 --> 01:08:18,680
2595 01:08:18,680 --> 01:08:21,718
and our radar range
to the beach was also
2,500 when we turned.
2596
01:08:21,718 --> 01:08:24,307
2597 01:08:24,307 --> 01:08:26,930
Now, Mr. Maryk,
why didn't you go to
higher authority at once
2598
01:08:26,930 --> 01:08:26,964
2599 01:08:26,964 --> 01:08:30,968
with your doubts
about the Captain's
mental health?
2600
01:08:30,968 --> 01:08:31,003
2601 01:08:31,003 --> 01:08:34,317
Uh, well, I figured
if only I had a record
I'd be on stronger ground.
2602
01:08:34,317 --> 01:08:34,351
2603 01:08:34,351 --> 01:08:36,491
So I decided
to start the log.
2604
01:08:36,491 --> 01:08:36,526
2605 01:08:36,526 --> 01:08:38,976
I figured if ever
I was all wrong,
I'd just burn it.
2606
01:08:38,976 --> 01:08:39,011
2607 01:08:39,011 --> 01:08:41,117
I kept it under
lock and key.
2608
01:08:41,117 --> 01:08:41,151
2609 01:08:41,151 --> 01:08:44,499
What made an
incident worthy of record
in your medical log?
2610
01:08:44,499 --> 01:08:44,534
2611 01:08:44,534 --> 01:08:47,433
Well, just any act
that seemed strange
or abnormal.
2612
01:08:47,433 --> 01:08:47,468
2613 01:08:47,468 --> 01:08:49,263
Like the Silex business. 2614 01:08:49,263 --> 01:08:49,297
2615 01:08:49,297 --> 01:08:50,919
Describe the Silex business. 2616 01:08:50,919 --> 01:08:50,954
2617 01:08:50,954 --> 01:08:54,060
A mess boy slopped coffee
on a Silex. Burned it out.
2618
01:08:54,060 --> 01:08:54,095
2619 01:08:54,095 --> 01:08:56,201
Now, none of the mess
boys would admit which
one did it.
2620
01:08:56,201 --> 01:08:56,235
2621 01:08:56,235 --> 01:08:59,997
So, the Captain,
he ordered all of the
officers of the ship
2622
01:08:59,997 --> 01:09:00,032
2623 01:09:00,032 --> 01:09:03,829
to sit as a court of
inquiry until we found out
who burned out the Silex.
2624
01:09:03,829 --> 01:09:03,863
2625 01:09:03,863 --> 01:09:05,624
I mean, in itself
it's a silly little thing,
2626
01:09:05,624 --> 01:09:05,658
2627 01:09:05,658 --> 01:09:09,421
but it went on and
on for 36 hours.
2628
01:09:09,421 --> 01:09:09,455
2629 01:09:09,455 --> 01:09:13,252
All ship's work stopped.
And there we all were,
sitting in a wardroom,
2630
01:09:13,252 --> 01:09:13,287
2631 01:09:13,287 --> 01:09:15,634
dying for sleep,
needing shaves
2632
01:09:15,634 --> 01:09:15,668
2633 01:09:15,668 --> 01:09:19,362
and still trying to find out
which of those poor colored
boys burned out the Silex.
2634
01:09:19,362 --> 01:09:19,396
2635 01:09:19,396 --> 01:09:21,916
And by then those kids
thought whoever
did it was gonna get hung.
2636
01:09:21,916 --> 01:09:21,950
2637 01:09:21,950 --> 01:09:24,850
They'd have died
before telling us.
2638
01:09:24,850 --> 01:09:24,884
2639 01:09:24,884 --> 01:09:26,921
So finally, I had to go
to the Captain and tell him
2640
01:09:26,921 --> 01:09:26,955
2641 01:09:26,955 --> 01:09:29,579
that all of the officers
admitted to being
incompetent investigators,
2642
01:09:29,579 --> 01:09:29,613
2643 01:09:29,613 --> 01:09:31,305
they'd take cuts in
their fitness reports,
2644
01:09:31,305 --> 01:09:31,339
2645 01:09:31,339 --> 01:09:35,723
but that they couldn't
find out who slopped
coffee on the Silex.
2646
01:09:35,723 --> 01:09:35,757
2647 01:09:35,757 --> 01:09:39,589
So he made a note in
his black book and
called off the inquiry.
2648
01:09:39,589 --> 01:09:39,623
2649 01:09:39,623 --> 01:09:43,282
Things like that,
or like the water
business.
2650
01:09:43,282 --> 01:09:43,317
2651 01:09:43,317 --> 01:09:45,491
Describe the water business. 2652 01:09:45,491 --> 01:09:45,526
2653 01:09:45,526 --> 01:09:47,873
Well, it's all in
the log, how he cut off
the water at the equator
2654
01:09:47,873 --> 01:09:47,907
2655 01:09:47,907 --> 01:09:50,945
for two days for the whole
ship just because he caught
one simple deckhand
2656
01:09:50,945 --> 01:09:50,979
2657 01:09:50,979 --> 01:09:53,292
stealing a drink
during water
conservation hours.
2658
01:09:53,292 --> 01:09:53,327
2659 01:09:53,327 --> 01:09:56,364
Or plain crazy things,
like the strawberry business.
2660
01:09:56,364 --> 01:09:56,399
2661 01:09:56,399 --> 01:09:58,159
Describe the
-strawberry business.
-Well, there...
2662
01:09:58,159 --> 01:09:58,194
2663 01:09:58,194 --> 01:10:01,438
Objection.
The so-called medical log
was introduced as evidence
2664
01:10:01,438 --> 01:10:01,473
2665 01:10:01,473 --> 01:10:03,406
at the start of
these proceedings.
2666
01:10:03,406 --> 01:10:03,440
2667 01:10:03,440 --> 01:10:06,616
All this is just
repeating a lot of
trivial disloyal gripes.
2668
01:10:06,616 --> 01:10:06,650
2669 01:10:06,650 --> 01:10:09,791
If the court concurs,
I'll pass over the
medical log.
2670
01:10:09,791 --> 01:10:09,826
2671 01:10:09,826 --> 01:10:11,621
Well, let's
not take up time here.
2672
01:10:11,621 --> 01:10:11,655
2673 01:10:11,655 --> 01:10:13,105
Aye, aye, sir. 2674 01:10:13,105 --> 01:10:13,139
2675 01:10:13,139 --> 01:10:15,245
Only there seems
to be some confusion
2676
01:10:15,245 --> 01:10:15,280
2677 01:10:15,280 --> 01:10:18,110
about this so-called
strawberry business.
2678
01:10:18,110 --> 01:10:18,144
2679 01:10:18,144 --> 01:10:21,389
Now it started out as
a search for a quart of
strawberries, is that right?
2680
01:10:21,389 --> 01:10:21,424
2681 01:10:21,424 --> 01:10:22,908
-Yes, sir.
And it
somehow turned
2682
01:10:22,908 --> 01:10:22,942
2683 01:10:22,942 --> 01:10:24,254
into a search for a key? 2684 01:10:24,254 --> 01:10:24,289
2685 01:10:24,289 --> 01:10:26,291
-That's right.
-How was that?
2686
01:10:26,291 --> 01:10:26,325
2687 01:10:26,325 --> 01:10:29,086
That's on account
of the cheese business.
2688
01:10:29,086 --> 01:10:29,121
2689 01:10:29,121 --> 01:10:32,366
The cheese business? I don't
recall any cheese business.
2690
01:10:32,366 --> 01:10:32,400
2691 01:10:32,400 --> 01:10:34,575
Well, that was
on the first ship Captain
Queeg served on, sir,
2692
01:10:34,575 --> 01:10:34,609
2693 01:10:34,609 --> 01:10:36,232
when he was an ensign. 2694 01:10:36,232 --> 01:10:36,266
2695 01:10:36,266 --> 01:10:38,199
Cheese had been
disappearing from
ship's store.
2696
01:10:38,199 --> 01:10:38,234
2697 01:10:38,234 --> 01:10:40,339
He investigated
and he caught
a sailor
2698
01:10:40,339 --> 01:10:40,374
2699 01:10:40,374 --> 01:10:42,790
who had made himself
a duplicate key to the
padlock on the refrigerator.
2700
01:10:42,790 --> 01:10:42,824
2701 01:10:42,824 --> 01:10:44,205
Now from catching
this cheese thief,
2702
01:10:44,205 --> 01:10:44,240
2703 01:10:44,240 --> 01:10:46,345
the Captain had gotten
a letter of commendation.
2704
01:10:46,345 --> 01:10:46,380
2705 01:10:46,380 --> 01:10:49,245
This was peace time.
Naturally, he was
real proud of it.
2706
01:10:49,245 --> 01:10:49,279
2707 01:10:49,279 --> 01:10:51,937
When the strawberry thing
came up, he insisted it
was the same thing.
2708
01:10:51,937 --> 01:10:51,971
2709 01:10:51,971 --> 01:10:53,249
All we had to do
was find out
2710
01:10:53,249 --> 01:10:53,283
2711 01:10:53,283 --> 01:10:55,906
who'd made a duplicate key
to the wardroom icebox.
2712
01:10:55,906 --> 01:10:55,941
2713 01:10:55,941 --> 01:10:58,288
But, of course, it was
ridiculous. It was
the mess boys again.
2714
01:10:58,288 --> 01:10:58,323
2715 01:10:58,323 --> 01:11:01,187
We all knew they'd
eaten up this quart
of strawberries.
2716
01:11:01,187 --> 01:11:01,222
2717 01:11:01,222 --> 01:11:03,086
It was just...
It was leavings from
the wardroom mess
2718
01:11:03,086 --> 01:11:03,120
2719 01:11:03,120 --> 01:11:06,089
and they were entitled
to eat it. That was
the custom.
2720
01:11:06,089 --> 01:11:06,123
2721 01:11:06,123 --> 01:11:08,194
But naturally,
when the Captain started
2722
01:11:08,194 --> 01:11:08,229
2723 01:11:08,229 --> 01:11:10,818
to roar around about
those strawberries, why,
2724
01:11:10,818 --> 01:11:10,852
2725 01:11:10,852 --> 01:11:13,545
the boys, they froze up
and swore they hadn't
eaten 'em.
2726
01:11:13,545 --> 01:11:13,579
2727 01:11:13,579 --> 01:11:16,824
And the Captain, he was
so steamed up on this key
theory he believed.
2728
01:11:16,824 --> 01:11:16,858
2729 01:11:16,858 --> 01:11:19,240
So he ordered the
search for the key?
2730
01:11:19,240 --> 01:11:19,275
2731 01:11:19,275 --> 01:11:23,417
Yes, sir. We ain't
never saw Captain Queeg so
happy before or since.
2732
01:11:23,417 --> 01:11:23,451
2733 01:11:23,451 --> 01:11:25,695
He was living the cheese
business all over again.
2734
01:11:25,695 --> 01:11:25,729
2735 01:11:25,729 --> 01:11:30,147
Organized the search
himself. All ship's
work was suspended.
2736
01:11:30,147 --> 01:11:30,182
2737 01:11:30,182 --> 01:11:33,599
And we collected every
single key on the ship.
2738
01:11:33,599 --> 01:11:33,634
2739 01:11:33,634 --> 01:11:36,464
We had boxes of keys.
We had barrels of keys.
2740
01:11:36,464 --> 01:11:36,499
2741 01:11:36,499 --> 01:11:39,191
About 2,800 of 'em.
All tagged with the
owner's name.
2742
01:11:39,191 --> 01:11:41,262
2743 01:11:41,262 --> 01:11:43,160
Then to make sure
we had them all,
we searched the ship.
2744
01:11:43,160 --> 01:11:43,195
2745 01:11:43,195 --> 01:11:44,817
From stem to stern.
From the crow's nest
to the build.
2746
01:11:44,817 --> 01:11:44,852
2747 01:11:44,852 --> 01:11:46,474
We stripped the crew
stark naked.
2748
01:11:46,474 --> 01:11:46,509
2749 01:11:46,509 --> 01:11:49,235
Every one of them shook out
their clothes, we
searched their lockers,
2750
01:11:49,235 --> 01:11:49,270
2751 01:11:49,270 --> 01:11:52,446
we crawled in to every
hole and every space
in the ship.
2752
01:11:52,446 --> 01:11:52,480
2753 01:11:52,480 --> 01:11:53,723
This went on for three days. 2754 01:11:53,723 --> 01:11:53,757
2755 01:11:53,757 --> 01:11:56,553
All of it over a key
which never existed.
2756
01:11:56,553 --> 01:11:56,588
2757 01:11:56,588 --> 01:11:59,142
When I saw Captain Queeg
sitting by the icebox
2758
01:11:59,142 --> 01:11:59,176
2759 01:11:59,176 --> 01:12:01,834
taking those keys
one by one out
of the barrels,
2760
01:12:01,834 --> 01:12:01,869
2761 01:12:01,869 --> 01:12:06,252
trying them on the
padlock, hours on end,
with a gleam in his eye,
2762
01:12:06,252 --> 01:12:07,392
2763 01:12:07,392 --> 01:12:09,014
I just gave up. 2764 01:12:09,014 --> 01:12:11,292
2765 01:12:11,292 --> 01:12:14,088
Continue your examination. 2766 01:12:14,088 --> 01:12:14,122
2767 01:12:14,122 --> 01:12:16,401
Mr. Maryk, when
the typhoon was over,
2768
01:12:16,401 --> 01:12:16,435
2769 01:12:16,435 --> 01:12:19,473
did Captain Queeg
make any effort to
regain command?
2770
01:12:19,473 --> 01:12:19,507
2771 01:12:19,507 --> 01:12:21,267
Yes, on the morning
of the 19th.
2772
01:12:21,267 --> 01:12:21,302
2773 01:12:21,302 --> 01:12:23,546
The storm had blown out,
we'd just sighted the fleet.
2774
01:12:23,546 --> 01:12:23,580
2775 01:12:23,580 --> 01:12:25,927
Describe what happened. 2776 01:12:25,927 --> 01:12:25,962
2777 01:12:25,962 --> 01:12:28,758
Well,
I was in the charthouse,
writing up a dispatch
2778
01:12:28,758 --> 01:12:28,792
2779 01:12:28,792 --> 01:12:30,794
to report the relief
to Admiral Halsey.
2780
01:12:30,794 --> 01:12:30,829
2781 01:12:30,829 --> 01:12:33,832
The Captain came in and
he said, "Do you mind
coming to my cabin
2782
01:12:33,832 --> 01:12:33,866
2783 01:12:33,866 --> 01:12:36,593
"and having a talk
before you send that?"
2784
01:12:36,593 --> 01:12:36,628
2785 01:12:36,628 --> 01:12:39,389
So I went below
and we talked.
2786
01:12:39,389 --> 01:12:39,424
2787 01:12:39,424 --> 01:12:41,218
It was the same thing. 2788 01:12:41,218 --> 01:12:41,253
2789 01:12:41,253 --> 01:12:43,704
First about how I'd be
court-martialed for
mutiny, and then...
2790
01:12:43,704 --> 01:12:43,738
2791 01:12:43,738 --> 01:12:46,223
Then he said, "You've
applied for transfer
to the regular Navy.
2792
01:12:46,223 --> 01:12:46,258
2793 01:12:46,258 --> 01:12:48,294
"You know this means
an end to all that."
2794
01:12:48,294 --> 01:12:48,329
2795 01:12:48,329 --> 01:12:51,539
And then he went into
this long thing about
how he loved the Navy,
2796
01:12:51,539 --> 01:12:51,574
2797 01:12:51,574 --> 01:12:54,093
he had no other interest
in life and even if he
was cleared,
2798
01:12:54,093 --> 01:12:54,128
2799 01:12:54,128 --> 01:12:55,647
this would ruin his record. 2800 01:12:55,647 --> 01:12:55,681
2801 01:12:55,681 --> 01:12:57,752
And I said I felt sorry
for him, and I really did.
2802
01:12:57,752 --> 01:12:58,960
2803 01:12:58,960 --> 01:13:01,411
Finally, he came out
with his proposal.
2804
01:13:01,411 --> 01:13:01,446
2805 01:13:01,446 --> 01:13:05,311
He said he would forget
the whole thing and
never report me.
2806
01:13:05,311 --> 01:13:05,346
2807 01:13:05,346 --> 01:13:07,244
He would resume command, 2808 01:13:07,244 --> 01:13:07,279
2809 01:13:07,279 --> 01:13:08,798
and the whole matter
would be forgotten
and written off...
2810
01:13:08,798 --> 01:13:08,832
2811 01:13:08,832 --> 01:13:11,387
What did you
say to this proposal?
2812
01:13:11,387 --> 01:13:11,421
2813 01:13:11,421 --> 01:13:12,767
Well, I was amazed.
I said,
2814
01:13:12,767 --> 01:13:12,802
2815 01:13:12,802 --> 01:13:14,320
"Captain, the whole
ship knows about it.
2816
01:13:14,320 --> 01:13:14,355
2817 01:13:14,355 --> 01:13:16,771
"It's written up in
the quartermaster's log
and the OOD's log."
2818
01:13:16,771 --> 01:13:16,806
2819 01:13:16,806 --> 01:13:19,533
And, well, he just...
He hemmed and hawed,
2820
01:13:19,533 --> 01:13:19,567
2821 01:13:19,567 --> 01:13:21,397
and finally he said, 2822 01:13:21,397 --> 01:13:21,431
2823 01:13:21,431 --> 01:13:23,191
"Well, it wouldn't be
the first time that
a penciled rough log
2824
01:13:23,191 --> 01:13:23,226
2825 01:13:23,226 --> 01:13:25,815
"had been fixed up
and corrected after
the fact."
2826
01:13:25,815 --> 01:13:25,849
2827 01:13:25,849 --> 01:13:28,680
Did you remind him
about the rule
against erasure?
2828
01:13:28,680 --> 01:13:28,714
2829 01:13:28,714 --> 01:13:30,785
Yes, he kind
of laughed and he said,
2830
01:13:30,785 --> 01:13:30,820
2831 01:13:30,820 --> 01:13:32,960
"It's either that or
court-martial for
mutiny for me."
2832
01:13:32,960 --> 01:13:32,994
2833 01:13:32,994 --> 01:13:35,100
And a black mark on
his record which he
didn't deserve.
2834
01:13:35,100 --> 01:13:35,134
2835 01:13:35,134 --> 01:13:38,206
He didn't see that a few
penciled rough lines
were worth all that.
2836
01:13:38,206 --> 01:13:38,241
2837 01:13:38,241 --> 01:13:40,001
What followed? 2838 01:13:40,001 --> 01:13:40,036
2839 01:13:40,036 --> 01:13:45,455
Well, he began
to plead and beg.
2840
01:13:45,455 --> 01:13:46,939
2841 01:13:46,939 --> 01:13:50,046
Uh, he cried at one point. 2842 01:13:50,046 --> 01:13:50,080
2843 01:13:50,080 --> 01:13:54,947
And in the end, he became
terrifically angry and
ordered me out of his cabin.
2844
01:13:54,947 --> 01:13:54,982
2845 01:13:54,982 --> 01:13:56,432
So I sent the dispatch. 2846 01:13:56,432 --> 01:13:57,605
2847 01:13:57,605 --> 01:14:00,470
Then you had the chance,
24 hours later,
2848
01:14:00,470 --> 01:14:00,505
2849 01:14:00,505 --> 01:14:03,508
of expunging the
whole event from
the official record
2850
01:14:03,508 --> 01:14:03,542
2851 01:14:03,542 --> 01:14:06,096
with the Captain's
knowledge and approval?
2852
01:14:06,096 --> 01:14:06,131
2853 01:14:06,131 --> 01:14:07,788
Yes. 2854 01:14:07,788 --> 01:14:09,341
2855 01:14:09,341 --> 01:14:13,414
Mr. Maryk,
were you panicky at all
during the typhoon?
2856
01:14:13,414 --> 01:14:13,449
2857 01:14:13,449 --> 01:14:14,933
I was not. 2858 01:14:14,933 --> 01:14:14,967
2859 01:14:14,967 --> 01:14:16,866
Now, Lieutenant,
you are charged
2860
01:14:16,866 --> 01:14:16,900
2861 01:14:16,900 --> 01:14:19,075
with relieving your
captain willfully,
2862
01:14:19,075 --> 01:14:19,109
2863 01:14:19,109 --> 01:14:22,319
without authority and
without justifiable cause.
2864
01:14:22,319 --> 01:14:22,354
2865 01:14:22,354 --> 01:14:24,563
Did you relieve
Captain Queeg willfully?
2866
01:14:24,563 --> 01:14:24,598
2867 01:14:24,598 --> 01:14:26,945
Yes. I knew
what I was doing.
2868
01:14:26,945 --> 01:14:26,979
2869 01:14:26,979 --> 01:14:28,705
Did you relieve
without authority?
2870
01:14:28,705 --> 01:14:28,740
2871 01:14:28,740 --> 01:14:32,502
No. My authority was
Articles 184, 185, 186.
2872
01:14:32,502 --> 01:14:32,537
2873 01:14:32,537 --> 01:14:34,504
Did you relieve
without justifiable cause?
2874
01:14:34,504 --> 01:14:34,539
2875 01:14:34,539 --> 01:14:37,438
No. My justifiable
cause was the Captain's
mental breakdown
2876
01:14:37,438 --> 01:14:37,473
2877 01:14:37,473 --> 01:14:39,475
at a time when the
ship was in danger.
2878
01:14:39,475 --> 01:14:44,549
2879 01:14:44,549 --> 01:14:45,791
No further questions. 2880 01:14:45,791 --> 01:14:49,208
2881 01:14:49,208 --> 01:14:51,694
Mr. Maryk, 2882 01:14:51,694 --> 01:14:51,728
2883 01:14:51,728 --> 01:14:54,938
this amazing interview,
in which the Captain offered
to falsify official records,
2884
01:14:54,938 --> 01:14:54,973
2885 01:14:54,973 --> 01:14:56,871
were there any
witnesses to it?
2886
01:14:56,871 --> 01:14:56,906
2887 01:14:56,906 --> 01:14:59,598
We were alone in the
Captain's cabin. No.
2888
01:14:59,598 --> 01:14:59,633
2889 01:14:59,633 --> 01:15:03,326
This incident at Kwajalein,
did anyone else see this chart
which, according to you,
2890
01:15:03,326 --> 01:15:03,360
2891 01:15:03,360 --> 01:15:05,880
indicated your ship
turned away from
the beach too soon?
2892
01:15:05,880 --> 01:15:05,915
2893 01:15:05,915 --> 01:15:08,642
About an hour after it
happened, the Captain
asked to see the chart.
2894
01:15:08,642 --> 01:15:08,676
2895 01:15:08,676 --> 01:15:10,782
He took it to his cabin. 2896 01:15:10,782 --> 01:15:10,816
2897 01:15:10,816 --> 01:15:13,025
When I got it back, all my
bearings and course lines
had been erased.
2898
01:15:13,025 --> 01:15:13,060
2899 01:15:13,060 --> 01:15:15,752
Then you have no
documentary corroboration
of this story.
2900
01:15:15,752 --> 01:15:15,787
2901 01:15:15,787 --> 01:15:17,064
No. 2902 01:15:17,064 --> 01:15:17,098
2903 01:15:17,098 --> 01:15:18,893
How about the radar men
who called off the ranges?
2904
01:15:18,893 --> 01:15:18,928
2905 01:15:18,928 --> 01:15:21,344
Won't they confirm this story? 2906 01:15:21,344 --> 01:15:21,378
2907 01:15:21,378 --> 01:15:24,554
Sir, you can't
expect them to remember
one single radar range
2908
01:15:24,554 --> 01:15:24,589
2909 01:15:24,589 --> 01:15:27,557
when they call them
by the thousands in
every invasion.
2910
01:15:27,557 --> 01:15:27,592
2911 01:15:27,592 --> 01:15:29,490
These poor abandoned
Marines in the assault boats
2912
01:15:29,490 --> 01:15:29,525
2913 01:15:29,525 --> 01:15:33,908
never complained to higher
authority of the dastardly
conduct of the Caine.
2914
01:15:33,908 --> 01:15:33,943
2915 01:15:33,943 --> 01:15:35,565
-No.
-Strange.
2916
01:15:35,565 --> 01:15:35,600
2917 01:15:35,600 --> 01:15:38,154
Sir, they landed against
machine gunfire.
2918
01:15:38,154 --> 01:15:38,188
2919 01:15:38,188 --> 01:15:40,087
The ones that survived,
I don't think they remember
2920
01:15:40,087 --> 01:15:40,121
2921 01:15:40,121 --> 01:15:43,228
much else besides
that landing.
2922
01:15:43,228 --> 01:15:43,262
2923 01:15:43,262 --> 01:15:47,784
Mr. Maryk,
who coined this scurrilous
nickname, Old Yellow Stain?
2924
01:15:47,784 --> 01:15:47,819
2925 01:15:47,819 --> 01:15:49,096
Uh... 2926 01:15:49,096 --> 01:15:49,130
2927 01:15:49,130 --> 01:15:50,511
It just sprang
into existence.
2928
01:15:50,511 --> 01:15:50,546
2929 01:15:50,546 --> 01:15:53,410
Throughout the ship?
Or just among the officers?
2930
01:15:53,410 --> 01:15:54,170
2931 01:15:54,170 --> 01:15:55,412
Among the officers. 2932 01:15:55,412 --> 01:15:55,447
2933 01:15:55,447 --> 01:15:57,311
Are you sure you didn't
coin it yourself?
2934
01:15:57,311 --> 01:15:57,345
2935 01:15:57,345 --> 01:15:59,278
I didn't. 2936 01:15:59,278 --> 01:15:59,313
2937 01:15:59,313 --> 01:16:02,488
Mr. Maryk, what kind of
rating would you give yourself
for loyalty to your captain?
2938
01:16:02,488 --> 01:16:02,523
2939 01:16:02,523 --> 01:16:05,664
I think I was a loyal officer. 2940 01:16:05,664 --> 01:16:05,699
2941 01:16:05,699 --> 01:16:08,805
Did you issue
a 72-hour pass to Stilwell
in December '43,
2942
01:16:08,805 --> 01:16:08,840
2943 01:16:08,840 --> 01:16:10,842
against your captain's
express instructions?
2944
01:16:10,842 --> 01:16:10,876
2945 01:16:10,876 --> 01:16:12,568
I did. 2946 01:16:12,568 --> 01:16:12,602
2947 01:16:12,602 --> 01:16:15,674
You admit to a
disloyal act in your first
days as executive officer?
2948
01:16:15,674 --> 01:16:15,709
2949 01:16:15,709 --> 01:16:17,503
Yes. 2950 01:16:17,503 --> 01:16:17,538
2951 01:16:17,538 --> 01:16:21,818
Mr. Maryk, where did
you get your schooling?
2952
01:16:21,818 --> 01:16:21,853
2953 01:16:21,853 --> 01:16:25,546
Um, in public schools
in San Francisco, and
San Francisco University.
2954
01:16:25,546 --> 01:16:25,581
2955 01:16:25,581 --> 01:16:27,272
How were your grades
in elementary school?
2956
01:16:27,272 --> 01:16:27,306
2957 01:16:27,306 --> 01:16:29,239
Okay. 2958 01:16:29,239 --> 01:16:29,274
2959 01:16:29,274 --> 01:16:31,690
Average, above average,
-below average?
-Average.
2960
01:16:31,690 --> 01:16:31,725
2961 01:16:31,725 --> 01:16:33,554
How were your grades
in high school?
2962
01:16:33,554 --> 01:16:33,589
2963 01:16:33,589 --> 01:16:37,006
Oh, well, I didn't
do so good there.
Below average.
2964
01:16:37,006 --> 01:16:37,040
2965 01:16:37,040 --> 01:16:38,973
What kind of course
did you take at college?
2966
01:16:38,973 --> 01:16:39,008
2967 01:16:39,008 --> 01:16:41,217
-Business course.
-Any pre-medical courses?
2968
01:16:41,217 --> 01:16:41,251
2969 01:16:41,251 --> 01:16:44,358
-No.
-Any psychology
or psychiatry?
2970
01:16:44,358 --> 01:16:44,392
2971 01:16:44,392 --> 01:16:45,980
-No.
-Uh...
2972
01:16:45,980 --> 01:16:47,016
2973 01:16:47,016 --> 01:16:49,259
How were your
grades at college?
2974
01:16:49,259 --> 01:16:49,294
2975 01:16:49,294 --> 01:16:51,814
-I scraped by.
-Below average?
2976
01:16:51,814 --> 01:16:51,848
2977 01:16:51,848 --> 01:16:54,264
Yes. 2978 01:16:54,264 --> 01:16:54,299
2979 01:16:54,299 --> 01:16:58,475
Where did you get
these highfalutin ideas
about paranoia?
2980
01:16:58,475 --> 01:16:58,510
2981 01:16:58,510 --> 01:17:00,305
Uh, out of books. 2982 01:17:00,305 --> 01:17:00,339
2983 01:17:00,339 --> 01:17:02,065
What books?
Name the titles.
2984
01:17:02,065 --> 01:17:02,100
2985 01:17:02,100 --> 01:17:04,205
Medical type books
about mental illness.
2986
01:17:04,205 --> 01:17:04,240
2987 01:17:04,240 --> 01:17:06,898
Is this your
intellectual hobby,
reading about psychiatry?
2988
01:17:06,898 --> 01:17:06,932
2989 01:17:06,932 --> 01:17:08,554
No. 2990 01:17:08,554 --> 01:17:08,589
2991 01:17:08,589 --> 01:17:11,281
Where did you
get these books?
2992
01:17:11,281 --> 01:17:11,316
2993 01:17:11,316 --> 01:17:14,319
I borrowed them off
ships' doctors here
and there.
2994
01:17:14,319 --> 01:17:14,353
2995 01:17:14,353 --> 01:17:19,289
And with your background,
your scholastic record,
did you imagine that
2996
01:17:19,289 --> 01:17:19,324
2997 01:17:19,324 --> 01:17:23,086
you understood these
highly technical,
scientific works?
2998
01:17:23,086 --> 01:17:23,121
2999 01:17:23,121 --> 01:17:24,501
Well, I got something
out of them.
3000
01:17:24,501 --> 01:17:24,536
3001 01:17:24,536 --> 01:17:26,538
What's a conditioned
reflex?
3002
01:17:26,538 --> 01:17:26,572
3003 01:17:26,572 --> 01:17:29,368
-I don't know.
-What's schizophrenia?
3004
01:17:29,368 --> 01:17:29,403
3005 01:17:29,403 --> 01:17:30,680
I think that's
a mental illness.
3006
01:17:30,680 --> 01:17:30,715
3007 01:17:30,715 --> 01:17:33,027
You think so.
What are its symptoms?
3008
01:17:33,027 --> 01:17:33,062
3009 01:17:33,062 --> 01:17:34,511
I don't know. 3010 01:17:34,511 --> 01:17:34,546
3011 01:17:34,546 --> 01:17:35,685
In fact, you don't know
what you're talking about
3012
01:17:35,685 --> 01:17:35,720
3013 01:17:35,720 --> 01:17:37,894
when you discuss mental
illness, is that right?
3014
01:17:37,894 --> 01:17:37,929
3015 01:17:37,929 --> 01:17:41,173
Well, I didn't say
I knew much about it.
3016
01:17:41,173 --> 01:17:41,208
3017 01:17:41,208 --> 01:17:44,073
Have you ever heard the
expression, a little learning
is a dangerous thing?
3018
01:17:44,073 --> 01:17:44,107
3019 01:17:44,107 --> 01:17:45,177
Yes. 3020 01:17:45,177 --> 01:17:46,662
3021 01:17:46,662 --> 01:17:48,594
You got a head full
of terms you didn't
understand
3022
01:17:48,594 --> 01:17:48,629
3023 01:17:48,629 --> 01:17:50,596
and on that basis
you had the
temerity to depose
3024
01:17:50,596 --> 01:17:50,631
3025 01:17:50,631 --> 01:17:52,806
a commanding officer on the
grounds of mental illness.
Is that right?
3026
01:17:52,806 --> 01:17:52,840
3027 01:17:52,840 --> 01:17:54,462
Well, I didn't relieve
him because of what
the book said.
3028
01:17:54,462 --> 01:17:54,497
3029 01:17:54,497 --> 01:17:56,913
The ship was in danger ...ver mind the ship. 3030 01:17:56,913 --> 01:17:56,948
3031 01:17:56,948 --> 01:17:59,122
We're discussing your
grasp of psychiatry.
3032
01:17:59,122 --> 01:17:59,157
3033 01:17:59,157 --> 01:18:02,263
Have you heard the diagnosis
of the qualified psychiatrist
who examined your captain?
3034
01:18:02,263 --> 01:18:02,298
3035 01:18:02,298 --> 01:18:03,540
-Yes.
-And what was
their diagnosis?
3036
01:18:03,540 --> 01:18:03,575
3037 01:18:03,575 --> 01:18:05,266
Was he crazy or wasn't
he on 18 December?
3038
01:18:05,266 --> 01:18:05,301
3039 01:18:05,301 --> 01:18:07,165
They say he wasn't. 3040 01:18:07,165 --> 01:18:07,199
3041 01:18:07,199 --> 01:18:09,546
But you, with your whining
gripes about strawberries
and Silexes, know better.
3042
01:18:09,546 --> 01:18:09,581
3043 01:18:09,581 --> 01:18:12,584
Mr. Maryk, who was
the third ranking
officer on your ship?
3044
01:18:12,584 --> 01:18:12,618
3045 01:18:12,618 --> 01:18:15,173
-Uh, Lieutenant Keefer.
Was he
a good officer?
3046
01:18:15,173 --> 01:18:15,207
3047 01:18:15,207 --> 01:18:16,692
-Yes.
-Did you consider his mind
3048
01:18:16,692 --> 01:18:16,726
3049 01:18:16,726 --> 01:18:20,419
to be as good as yours,
or, perhaps even better?
3050
01:18:20,419 --> 01:18:22,007
3051 01:18:22,007 --> 01:18:23,215
Better. 3052 01:18:23,215 --> 01:18:24,872
3053 01:18:24,872 --> 01:18:27,530
You showed this medical
-log of yours to him?
-Yes.
3054
01:18:27,530 --> 01:18:27,564
3055 01:18:27,564 --> 01:18:30,360
He wasn't convinced
by it that the Captain
was mentally ill.
3056
01:18:30,360 --> 01:18:30,395
3057 01:18:30,395 --> 01:18:31,568
-No.
-He talked you out of
3058
01:18:31,568 --> 01:18:31,603
3059 01:18:31,603 --> 01:18:32,673
trying to have
the Captain relieved.
3060
01:18:32,673 --> 01:18:32,708
3061 01:18:32,708 --> 01:18:34,779
Yes. 3062 01:18:34,779 --> 01:18:34,813
3063 01:18:34,813 --> 01:18:38,230
And two weeks later,
despite the whole weight
of naval discipline,
3064
01:18:38,230 --> 01:18:38,265
3065 01:18:38,265 --> 01:18:40,301
despite the arguments
of the next officer
in rank to you,
3066
01:18:40,301 --> 01:18:40,336
3067 01:18:40,336 --> 01:18:42,096
a superior intellect, 3068 01:18:42,096 --> 01:18:42,131
3069 01:18:42,131 --> 01:18:45,099
despite all this, you still
went ahead and seized
command of your ship?
3070
01:18:45,099 --> 01:18:45,134
3071 01:18:45,134 --> 01:18:48,793
I relieved him because
he definitely seemed
sick during the typhoon.
3072
01:18:48,793 --> 01:18:51,934
3073 01:18:51,934 --> 01:18:55,454
You still imagine
that your diagnosis
of Captain Queeg
3074
01:18:55,454 --> 01:18:55,489
3075 01:18:55,489 --> 01:18:57,249
is superior to the doctor's? 3076 01:18:57,249 --> 01:18:57,284
3077 01:18:57,284 --> 01:19:00,356
Only about Queeg on the
morning of the typhoon.
3078
01:19:00,356 --> 01:19:05,223
3079 01:19:05,223 --> 01:19:07,121
No more questions. 3080 01:19:07,121 --> 01:19:09,675
3081 01:19:09,675 --> 01:19:11,367
No re-examination. 3082 01:19:11,367 --> 01:19:11,401
3083 01:19:11,401 --> 01:19:12,644
Please step down. 3084 01:19:12,644 --> 01:19:22,688
3085 01:19:22,688 --> 01:19:26,347
Call Lieutenant
Commander Queeg.
3086
01:19:26,347 --> 01:19:26,382
3087 01:19:26,382 --> 01:19:27,866
Lieutenant Commander... 3088 01:19:27,866 --> 01:19:41,949
3089 01:19:41,949 --> 01:19:44,020
Commander, the oath... 3090 01:19:44,020 --> 01:19:44,055
3091 01:19:44,055 --> 01:19:46,712
The oath previously taken
by you is still binding.
3092
01:19:46,712 --> 01:19:48,093
3093 01:19:48,093 --> 01:19:49,577
Oh, yes, sir. 3094 01:19:49,577 --> 01:20:01,003
3095 01:20:01,003 --> 01:20:03,764
Commander, on the morning
of the 19 December,
3096
01:20:03,764 --> 01:20:03,799
3097 01:20:03,799 --> 01:20:07,112
did you have an interview
in your room with
Lieutenant Maryk?
3098
01:20:07,112 --> 01:20:07,147
3099 01:20:07,147 --> 01:20:09,701
Let's see. That's the
day after the typhoon.
Yes, I did.
3100
01:20:09,701 --> 01:20:09,735
3101 01:20:09,735 --> 01:20:12,048
-Was it at your request?
-Yes.
3102
01:20:12,048 --> 01:20:12,083
3103 01:20:12,083 --> 01:20:13,601
What was the substance
of that interview?
3104
01:20:13,601 --> 01:20:14,775
3105 01:20:14,775 --> 01:20:16,812
Well, as I say,
I felt sorry for him.
3106
01:20:16,812 --> 01:20:16,846
3107 01:20:16,846 --> 01:20:20,022
I hated to see him
ruining his life with
one panicky mistake.
3108
01:20:20,022 --> 01:20:20,056
3109 01:20:20,056 --> 01:20:24,474
Particularly, as I knew
it was his ambition to
make the Navy his career.
3110
01:20:24,474 --> 01:20:24,509
3111 01:20:24,509 --> 01:20:27,961
I tried as hard as
I could to show him
what a mistake he'd made.
3112
01:20:27,961 --> 01:20:27,995
3113 01:20:27,995 --> 01:20:29,963
I recommended he
relinquish command
to me,
3114
01:20:29,963 --> 01:20:29,997
3115 01:20:29,997 --> 01:20:32,034
and I offered
to be as lenient
as I could
3116
01:20:32,034 --> 01:20:32,068
3117 01:20:32,068 --> 01:20:34,105
in reporting what
had happened.
3118
01:20:34,105 --> 01:20:34,139
3119 01:20:34,139 --> 01:20:37,073
You never offered not
to report the incident?
3120
01:20:37,073 --> 01:20:37,108
3121 01:20:37,108 --> 01:20:40,421
Oh, how could I?
It was already
recorded in the logs.
3122
01:20:40,421 --> 01:20:40,456
3123 01:20:40,456 --> 01:20:43,217
Were the logs in pencil,
or typed, or what?
3124
01:20:43,217 --> 01:20:43,252
3125 01:20:43,252 --> 01:20:44,529
That would
make no difference.
3126
01:20:44,529 --> 01:20:44,563
3127 01:20:44,563 --> 01:20:46,876
Were they in pencil,
Commander?
3128
01:20:46,876 --> 01:20:46,911
3129 01:20:46,911 --> 01:20:49,361
Well, let's see.
Probably they were.
3130
01:20:49,361 --> 01:20:49,396
3131 01:20:49,396 --> 01:20:52,399
Quartermaster log
and OOD rough
log always are.
3132
01:20:52,399 --> 01:20:52,433
3133 01:20:52,433 --> 01:20:54,435
I doubt the yeoman
would have gotten
around to typing
3134
01:20:54,435 --> 01:20:54,470
3135 01:20:54,470 --> 01:20:57,404
smooth logs in
all the excitement!
3136
01:20:57,404 --> 01:20:57,438
3137 01:20:57,438 --> 01:20:59,682
Did you offer to
erase the incident
from the penciled logs
3138
01:20:59,682 --> 01:20:59,716
3139 01:20:59,716 --> 01:21:01,753
and make no
report at all?
3140
01:21:01,753 --> 01:21:01,787
3141 01:21:01,787 --> 01:21:05,446
Oh, I did not.
Erasures aren't permitted
in penciled logs.
3142
01:21:05,446 --> 01:21:05,481
3143 01:21:05,481 --> 01:21:07,690
Lieutenant Maryk has
testified under oath,
Commander,
3144
01:21:07,690 --> 01:21:07,724
3145 01:21:07,724 --> 01:21:09,830
that you made
such an offer.
3146
01:21:09,830 --> 01:21:09,865
3147 01:21:09,865 --> 01:21:12,902
Not only that, but that
you begged and pleaded and
even wept to get him to agree
3148
01:21:12,902 --> 01:21:12,937
3149 01:21:12,937 --> 01:21:15,111
to erase those
few pencil lines,
3150
01:21:15,111 --> 01:21:15,146
3151 01:21:15,146 --> 01:21:16,664
in return for which 3152 01:21:16,664 --> 01:21:16,699
3153 01:21:16,699 --> 01:21:20,910
you promised to hush up
the incident completely
and make no report.
3154
01:21:20,910 --> 01:21:20,945
3155 01:21:20,945 --> 01:21:23,223
-That isn't true.
There isn't
any truth in it at all?
3156
01:21:23,223 --> 01:21:23,257
3157 01:21:23,257 --> 01:21:25,087
Well, it's a distortion
of what I told you.
3158
01:21:25,087 --> 01:21:25,121
3159 01:21:25,121 --> 01:21:27,399
My version is
the exact truth.
3160
01:21:27,399 --> 01:21:27,434
3161 01:21:27,434 --> 01:21:30,644
You deny the
proposal to erase the logs
and hush up the story?
3162
01:21:30,644 --> 01:21:30,678
3163 01:21:30,678 --> 01:21:34,717
I deny it completely.
That's the part
he made up.
3164
01:21:34,717 --> 01:21:34,751
3165 01:21:34,751 --> 01:21:36,961
The weeping
and the pleading.
3166
01:21:36,961 --> 01:21:36,995
3167 01:21:36,995 --> 01:21:38,755
That's fantastic! 3168 01:21:38,755 --> 01:21:38,790
3169 01:21:38,790 --> 01:21:41,103
You're accusing
Lieutenant Maryk
of perjury?
3170
01:21:41,103 --> 01:21:41,137
3171 01:21:41,137 --> 01:21:42,345
I'm not accusing him. 3172 01:21:42,345 --> 01:21:42,380
3173 01:21:42,380 --> 01:21:44,865
He's accused of
enough as it stands.
3174
01:21:44,865 --> 01:21:44,900
3175 01:21:44,900 --> 01:21:46,936
You're likely to hear
a lot of strange things
3176
01:21:46,936 --> 01:21:46,971
3177 01:21:46,971 --> 01:21:50,595
about me from Mr. Maryk,
that's all.
3178
01:21:50,595 --> 01:21:50,629
3179 01:21:50,629 --> 01:21:53,494
Isn't one of you obviously
not telling the truth
about that interview?
3180
01:21:53,494 --> 01:21:53,529
3181 01:21:53,529 --> 01:21:55,738
It appears so. 3182 01:21:55,738 --> 01:21:55,772
3183 01:21:55,772 --> 01:21:57,947
Can you prove
it isn't you?
3184
01:21:57,947 --> 01:21:57,982
3185 01:21:57,982 --> 01:22:00,777
Only by citing
a clean record
of over 14 years
3186
01:22:00,777 --> 01:22:00,812
3187 01:22:00,812 --> 01:22:04,540
as a Navy officer against
the word of a man on trial
for a mutinous act.
3188
01:22:04,540 --> 01:22:12,962
3189 01:22:12,962 --> 01:22:14,515
Commander, 3190 01:22:14,515 --> 01:22:14,550
3191 01:22:14,550 --> 01:22:19,072
did you ever receive
$110 from Lieutenant
Junior Grade Keith?
3192
01:22:19,072 --> 01:22:19,106
3193 01:22:19,106 --> 01:22:20,521
I don't recall
offhand that I did.
3194
01:22:20,521 --> 01:22:20,556
3195 01:22:20,556 --> 01:22:23,352
-He testified that you did.
-I did?
3196
01:22:23,352 --> 01:22:23,386
3197 01:22:23,386 --> 01:22:24,870
I did?
On what occasion?
3198
01:22:24,870 --> 01:22:24,905
3199 01:22:24,905 --> 01:22:29,082
On the occasion of
a loss of a crate of
yours in San Francisco Bay.
3200
01:22:29,082 --> 01:22:29,116
3201 01:22:29,116 --> 01:22:31,843
Yes, I remember. Uh... 3202 01:22:31,843 --> 01:22:31,877
3203 01:22:31,877 --> 01:22:34,570
It was over a year ago.
December or thereabouts.
3204
01:22:34,570 --> 01:22:34,604
3205 01:22:34,604 --> 01:22:38,332
He was responsible for
the loss and insisted
on paying, and so he did.
3206
01:22:38,332 --> 01:22:38,367
3207 01:22:38,367 --> 01:22:40,921
What was in
the crate that cost
$110, Commander?
3208
01:22:40,921 --> 01:22:40,956
3209 01:22:40,956 --> 01:22:45,132
Uh, uniforms, books,
navigating instruments.
The usual.
3210
01:22:45,132 --> 01:22:45,167
3211 01:22:45,167 --> 01:22:47,134
How was Keith
responsible for
the loss?
3212
01:22:47,134 --> 01:22:47,169
3213 01:22:47,169 --> 01:22:49,965
Well, he was boat officer
and in charge of the loading.
3214
01:22:49,965 --> 01:22:49,999
3215 01:22:49,999 --> 01:22:52,795
He issued foolish and
contradictory orders.
3216
01:22:52,795 --> 01:22:52,829
3217 01:22:52,829 --> 01:22:55,729
The men got rattled
and the crate fell into
the water and sank.
3218
01:22:55,729 --> 01:22:55,763
3219 01:22:55,763 --> 01:22:58,421
A wooden crate full
of clothing sank?
3220
01:22:58,421 --> 01:22:58,456
3221 01:22:58,456 --> 01:23:00,941
Well, there were other
things in it, I guess.
3222
01:23:00,941 --> 01:23:00,976
3223 01:23:00,976 --> 01:23:02,632
I had some souvenir
coral rocks.
3224
01:23:02,632 --> 01:23:02,667
3225 01:23:02,667 --> 01:23:06,326
Commander, wasn't the crate
entirely full of bottles
of intoxicating liquor?
3226
01:23:06,326 --> 01:23:06,360
3227 01:23:06,360 --> 01:23:09,018
Certainly not! 3228 01:23:09,018 --> 01:23:09,053
3229 01:23:09,053 --> 01:23:13,229
Keith has testified that
you charged him for
a crate full of liquor.
3230
01:23:13,229 --> 01:23:13,264
3231 01:23:13,264 --> 01:23:17,716
You'll hear plenty of
strange distortions about
me from Keith and Maryk.
3232
01:23:17,716 --> 01:23:17,751
3233 01:23:17,751 --> 01:23:19,408
They are the two
culprits here and
they're apt to make
3234
01:23:19,408 --> 01:23:19,442
3235 01:23:19,442 --> 01:23:22,169
all kinds of
strange statements!
3236
01:23:22,169 --> 01:23:22,204
3237 01:23:22,204 --> 01:23:24,033
Did you make
this crate yourself?
3238
01:23:24,033 --> 01:23:24,068
3239 01:23:24,068 --> 01:23:26,035
No. My carpenter's mate did. 3240 01:23:26,035 --> 01:23:26,070
3241 01:23:26,070 --> 01:23:27,830
What's his name? 3242 01:23:27,830 --> 01:23:27,864
3243 01:23:27,864 --> 01:23:30,212
I don't recall. It'll be
on the personnel records.
3244
01:23:30,212 --> 01:23:30,246
3245 01:23:30,246 --> 01:23:32,179
He's been gone from
the ship a long time.
3246
01:23:32,179 --> 01:23:32,214
3247 01:23:32,214 --> 01:23:35,389
Was your carpenter's
mate Second Class
Otis F. Langhorne?
3248
01:23:35,389 --> 01:23:36,632
3249 01:23:36,632 --> 01:23:42,224
Lang, Langhorne.
Sounds right.
3250
01:23:42,224 --> 01:23:42,258
3251 01:23:42,258 --> 01:23:44,640
There's a carpenter's
mate, First Class
Otis F. Langhorne,
3252
01:23:44,640 --> 01:23:44,674
3253 01:23:44,674 --> 01:23:48,678
at present in damage control
school at Treasure Island
right here in the bay.
3254
01:23:48,678 --> 01:23:48,713
3255 01:23:48,713 --> 01:23:51,612
Defense has arranged
to subpoena him,
if necessary.
3256
01:23:51,612 --> 01:23:51,647
3257 01:23:51,647 --> 01:23:53,269
You're sure it's
the same one?
3258
01:23:53,269 --> 01:23:53,304
3259 01:23:53,304 --> 01:23:55,271
His service
record shows 21 months
aboard the Caine.
3260
01:23:55,271 --> 01:23:55,306
3261 01:23:55,306 --> 01:23:57,791
Your signature is in it.
Would it be useful to have
him subpoenaed, sir?
3262
01:23:57,791 --> 01:23:57,825
3263 01:23:57,825 --> 01:24:01,001
Objection to this entire
irrelevancy about the crate.
3264
01:24:01,001 --> 01:24:01,036
3265 01:24:01,036 --> 01:24:02,968
And request it be
stricken from the
record, sir.
3266
01:24:02,968 --> 01:24:03,003
3267 01:24:03,003 --> 01:24:06,006
The credibility of
the witness is being
established.
3268
01:24:06,006 --> 01:24:06,041
3269 01:24:06,041 --> 01:24:09,492
I submit to the court
that nothing could be
more relevant to this trial.
3270
01:24:09,492 --> 01:24:09,527
3271 01:24:09,527 --> 01:24:10,838
Overruled. 3272 01:24:10,838 --> 01:24:13,220
3273 01:24:13,220 --> 01:24:16,258
"Would it be
useful to have him
subpoenaed, sir?"
3274
01:24:16,258 --> 01:24:18,501
3275 01:24:18,501 --> 01:24:20,745
Well, it's a question
of which crate Langhorne
nailed up.
3276
01:24:20,745 --> 01:24:20,779
3277 01:24:20,779 --> 01:24:22,781
I had two crates,
as I recall now.
3278
01:24:22,781 --> 01:24:22,816
3279 01:24:22,816 --> 01:24:27,096
Well, this is a new
angle, not mentioned
by Keith. Uh...
3280
01:24:27,096 --> 01:24:27,131
3281 01:24:27,131 --> 01:24:29,961
Did Langhorne make
both crates, sir?
3282
01:24:29,961 --> 01:24:29,995
3283 01:24:29,995 --> 01:24:32,722
I don't recall whether
I had both crates on
that occasion
3284
01:24:32,722 --> 01:24:32,757
3285 01:24:32,757 --> 01:24:36,174
or two crates on two
different occasions.
3286
01:24:36,174 --> 01:24:36,209
3287 01:24:36,209 --> 01:24:38,970
It's all very trivial
and happened a long time ago
3288
01:24:38,970 --> 01:24:39,004
3289 01:24:39,004 --> 01:24:40,799
and I've had a year of
combat steaming in between
3290
01:24:40,799 --> 01:24:40,834
3291 01:24:40,834 --> 01:24:45,459
and that typhoon and all
this hospital business,
I'm not too clear.
3292
01:24:45,459 --> 01:24:45,494
3293 01:24:45,494 --> 01:24:47,289
Commander, there are
many points in this trial
3294
01:24:47,289 --> 01:24:47,323
3295 01:24:47,323 --> 01:24:51,258
that turn on the issue of
credibility between yourself
and other officers.
3296
01:24:51,258 --> 01:24:51,293
3297 01:24:51,293 --> 01:24:53,743
Now if you wish,
I will request
a five minute recess
3298
01:24:53,743 --> 01:24:53,778
3299 01:24:53,778 --> 01:24:58,541
while you clear your mind,
as best you can on the
issue of these crates.
3300
01:24:58,541 --> 01:24:58,576
3301 01:24:58,576 --> 01:25:01,786
That won't be necessary.
Just let me think for
a moment, please.
3302
01:25:01,786 --> 01:25:09,518
3303 01:25:09,518 --> 01:25:11,899
Okay. I have it
straight now.
3304
01:25:11,899 --> 01:25:11,934
3305 01:25:11,934 --> 01:25:13,763
I made a misstatement. 3306 01:25:13,763 --> 01:25:13,798
3307 01:25:13,798 --> 01:25:17,181
I lost a crate
in San Diego Harbor
back in '38 or '39,
3308
01:25:17,181 --> 01:25:17,215
3309 01:25:17,215 --> 01:25:18,872
I think it was,
under similar
circumstances.
3310
01:25:18,872 --> 01:25:18,906
3311 01:25:18,906 --> 01:25:20,908
That was the one
containing clothes.
3312
01:25:20,908 --> 01:25:20,943
3313 01:25:20,943 --> 01:25:23,152
The crate Keith lost
did contain liquor.
3314
01:25:23,152 --> 01:25:23,187
3315 01:25:23,187 --> 01:25:26,500
How did you obtain
a crate full of whiskey
during wartime, Commander?
3316
01:25:26,500 --> 01:25:26,535
3317 01:25:26,535 --> 01:25:30,159
Bought up the
rations of my officers
at the wine mess in Pearl.
3318
01:25:30,159 --> 01:25:30,194
3319 01:25:30,194 --> 01:25:33,197
You transported this liquor
from Pearl to the States
in your ship?
3320
01:25:33,197 --> 01:25:33,231
3321 01:25:33,231 --> 01:25:34,957
Do you know the
regulations regarding
the transporting...
3322
01:25:34,957 --> 01:25:34,991
3323 01:25:34,991 --> 01:25:38,478
I'm aware of regulations!
The crate was sealed prior
to getting under way.
3324
01:25:38,478 --> 01:25:38,512
3325 01:25:38,512 --> 01:25:41,964
I gave it the same
locked stowage I gave
the medicinal brandy.
3326
01:25:41,964 --> 01:25:41,998
3327 01:25:41,998 --> 01:25:45,450
Liquor was damned scarce
and expensive in the States.
3328
01:25:45,450 --> 01:25:45,485
3329 01:25:45,485 --> 01:25:50,317
I'd had three years of
steady combat duty and
I gave myself this leeway,
3330
01:25:50,317 --> 01:25:50,352
3331 01:25:50,352 --> 01:25:52,595
as captain of the Caine. 3332 01:25:52,595 --> 01:25:52,630
3333 01:25:52,630 --> 01:25:57,462
And it's a common practice
and I believe rank has its
privileges, as they say.
3334
01:25:57,462 --> 01:25:57,497
3335 01:25:57,497 --> 01:25:59,982
I had no intention
of concealing it
from the court.
3336
01:25:59,982 --> 01:26:00,016
3337 01:26:00,016 --> 01:26:04,089
And I'm not ashamed
of it. I simply mixed up
the two crates in my mind.
3338
01:26:04,089 --> 01:26:05,125
3339 01:26:05,125 --> 01:26:06,851
Keith testified that you 3340 01:26:06,851 --> 01:26:06,885
3341 01:26:06,885 --> 01:26:10,544
gave all the orders to
the boat crew which caused
the loss of the crate.
3342
01:26:10,544 --> 01:26:10,579
3343 01:26:10,579 --> 01:26:11,890
That's a lie. 3344 01:26:11,890 --> 01:26:11,925
3345 01:26:11,925 --> 01:26:13,375
And that
you refused to sign
his leave papers
3346
01:26:13,375 --> 01:26:13,409
3347 01:26:13,409 --> 01:26:15,204
until he paid
for the loss.
3348
01:26:15,204 --> 01:26:15,239
3349 01:26:15,239 --> 01:26:16,999
That's another lie. 3350 01:26:16,999 --> 01:26:20,105
3351 01:26:20,105 --> 01:26:22,004
Seems to be the issue
of credibility again, sir,
3352
01:26:22,004 --> 01:26:22,038
3353 01:26:22,038 --> 01:26:25,525
this time your word
against Keith's.
Correct?
3354
01:26:25,525 --> 01:26:25,559
3355 01:26:25,559 --> 01:26:28,459
You'll hear nothing but lies
about me from Keith.
3356
01:26:28,459 --> 01:26:28,493
3357 01:26:28,493 --> 01:26:30,702
He has an insane
hatred of me.
3358
01:26:30,702 --> 01:26:32,359
3359 01:26:32,359 --> 01:26:35,086
Do you
-know why, sir?
-I can't say.
3360
01:26:35,086 --> 01:26:35,120
3361 01:26:35,120 --> 01:26:37,778
Unless it's his resentment
against fancied injuries
3362
01:26:37,778 --> 01:26:37,813
3363 01:26:37,813 --> 01:26:41,057
to his crony,
the sailor, Stilwell.
3364
01:26:41,057 --> 01:26:41,092
3365 01:26:41,092 --> 01:26:43,094
Those two were
mighty affectionate.
3366
01:26:43,094 --> 01:26:45,303
3367 01:26:45,303 --> 01:26:46,511
Affectionate, sir? 3368 01:26:46,511 --> 01:26:46,546
3369 01:26:46,546 --> 01:26:48,064
Well, it just
seemed to me that
3370
01:26:48,064 --> 01:26:48,099
3371 01:26:48,099 --> 01:26:50,446
every time Keith
thought I looked
cross-eyed at Stilwell,
3372
01:26:50,446 --> 01:26:50,481
3373 01:26:50,481 --> 01:26:53,138
there was all kinds of
screeching and hollering
from Keith,
3374
01:26:53,138 --> 01:26:53,173
3375 01:26:53,173 --> 01:26:55,727
as though I were picking
on his wife or something.
3376
01:26:55,727 --> 01:26:55,762
3377 01:26:55,762 --> 01:26:58,765
Well, those two sure ganged
up mighty fast to back Maryk
when he relieved me.
3378
01:26:58,765 --> 01:26:58,799
3379 01:26:58,799 --> 01:27:00,905
Are you suggesting
there were abnormal
relations between
3380
01:27:00,905 --> 01:27:00,939
3381 01:27:00,939 --> 01:27:02,976
Lieutenant Keith and
the sailor, Stilwell?
3382
01:27:02,976 --> 01:27:03,010
3383 01:27:03,010 --> 01:27:05,047
I'm not suggesting a thing. 3384 01:27:05,047 --> 01:27:05,081
3385 01:27:05,081 --> 01:27:08,878
I'm stating plain facts
that everybody knew who
had eyes to see.
3386
01:27:08,878 --> 01:27:10,225
3387 01:27:10,225 --> 01:27:11,605
Does the court desire
to caution the witness
3388
01:27:11,605 --> 01:27:11,640
3389 01:27:11,640 --> 01:27:13,676
on the gravity of
the insinuated charge?
3390
01:27:13,676 --> 01:27:13,711
3391 01:27:13,711 --> 01:27:15,885
I'm not
insinuating a thing, sir!
3392
01:27:15,885 --> 01:27:15,920
3393 01:27:15,920 --> 01:27:18,681
I don't know of
anything improper
between those two men
3394
01:27:18,681 --> 01:27:18,716
3395 01:27:18,716 --> 01:27:20,821
and I deny
insinuating anything.
3396
01:27:20,821 --> 01:27:20,856
3397 01:27:20,856 --> 01:27:23,514
All I said was Keith
was always taking
Stilwell's part
3398
01:27:23,514 --> 01:27:23,548
3399 01:27:23,548 --> 01:27:25,930
and it's the easiest
thing in the world
to prove
3400
01:27:25,930 --> 01:27:25,964
3401 01:27:25,964 --> 01:27:28,657
and that's all
I said or meant.
3402
01:27:28,657 --> 01:27:28,691
3403 01:27:28,691 --> 01:27:31,004
Are you gonna
pursue this topic?
3404
01:27:31,004 --> 01:27:34,628
3405 01:27:34,628 --> 01:27:36,561
-No, sir.
-Very well. Go ahead.
3406
01:27:36,561 --> 01:27:47,883
3407 01:27:47,883 --> 01:27:51,369
Commander, during the period
when the Cainewas towing
targets at Pearl Harbor,
3408
01:27:51,369 --> 01:27:51,404
3409 01:27:51,404 --> 01:27:52,681
did you ever steam over
your own tow line?
3410
01:27:52,681 --> 01:27:52,715
3411 01:27:52,715 --> 01:27:55,960
Objection! This tow line
business is the last straw.
3412
01:27:55,960 --> 01:27:55,994
3413 01:27:55,994 --> 01:28:01,345
The tactics of the defense
are an outrage on the dignity
of these proceedings.
3414
01:28:01,345 --> 01:28:01,379
3415 01:28:01,379 --> 01:28:04,002
He's systematically
turning this trial
into a court-martial
3416
01:28:04,002 --> 01:28:04,037
3417 01:28:04,037 --> 01:28:05,452
of Commander Queeg. 3418 01:28:05,452 --> 01:28:05,487
3419 01:28:05,487 --> 01:28:08,283
Sir, the judge advocate
has made it perfectly clear
3420
01:28:08,283 --> 01:28:08,317
3421 01:28:08,317 --> 01:28:10,008
that he thinks that he
has a prima facie case
3422
01:28:10,008 --> 01:28:10,043
3423 01:28:10,043 --> 01:28:12,114
on the report of the
two psychiatrists.
3424
01:28:12,114 --> 01:28:12,148
3425 01:28:12,148 --> 01:28:13,771
But I say that it is
still up to the court
3426
01:28:13,771 --> 01:28:13,805
3427 01:28:13,805 --> 01:28:16,532
not to shore-bound doctors,
however brilliant,
3428
01:28:16,532 --> 01:28:16,567
3429 01:28:16,567 --> 01:28:18,914
to decide whether the
Captain of the Caine
was mentally well enough
3430
01:28:18,914 --> 01:28:18,948
3431 01:28:18,948 --> 01:28:20,709
to retain his self-control 3432 01:28:20,709 --> 01:28:20,743
3433 01:28:20,743 --> 01:28:22,883
and his post
during a typhoon.
3434
01:28:22,883 --> 01:28:25,300
3435 01:28:25,300 --> 01:28:30,546
Objection is overruled.
Witness will answer
the question.
3436
01:28:30,546 --> 01:28:30,581
3437 01:28:30,581 --> 01:28:35,137
"Commander, during the period
when the Cainewas towing
targets at Pearl Harbor,
3438
01:28:35,137 --> 01:28:35,171
3439 01:28:35,171 --> 01:28:38,140
"did you ever steam
over your own tow line
and cut it?"
3440
01:28:38,140 --> 01:28:39,624
3441 01:28:39,624 --> 01:28:44,940
Okay. Now, here's the story
on that particular slander.
3442
01:28:44,940 --> 01:28:44,974
3443 01:28:44,974 --> 01:28:47,977
I started to make a turn
when I noticed some
anti-aircraft bursts
3444
01:28:47,977 --> 01:28:48,012
3445 01:28:48,012 --> 01:28:49,531
close aboard to starboard. 3446 01:28:49,531 --> 01:28:49,565
3447 01:28:49,565 --> 01:28:51,533
I was gravely concerned
that my ship was in...
3448
01:28:51,533 --> 01:28:51,567
3449 01:28:51,567 --> 01:28:53,328
Was within range of
somebody's firing.
3450
01:28:53,328 --> 01:28:53,362
3451 01:28:53,362 --> 01:28:54,639
We were in a gunnery area. 3452 01:28:54,639 --> 01:28:54,674
3453 01:28:54,674 --> 01:28:56,745
I was watching the bursts. 3454 01:28:56,745 --> 01:28:56,779
3455 01:28:56,779 --> 01:29:01,681
The same sailor, Stilwell,
a very dreamy and unreliable
man, was at the helm.
3456
01:29:01,681 --> 01:29:01,715
3457 01:29:01,715 --> 01:29:03,407
He failed to warn me
that we were coming around
3458
01:29:03,407 --> 01:29:03,441
3459 01:29:03,441 --> 01:29:05,719
the full 360 degrees. 3460 01:29:05,719 --> 01:29:05,754
3461 01:29:05,754 --> 01:29:09,136
I saw what was happening,
finally, and instantly
reversed course.
3462
01:29:09,136 --> 01:29:09,171
3463 01:29:09,171 --> 01:29:12,105
And I avoided passing
over the tow line
to my best knowledge.
3464
01:29:12,105 --> 01:29:12,139
3465 01:29:12,139 --> 01:29:16,420
However, the line
parted during the turn.
3466
01:29:16,420 --> 01:29:16,454
3467 01:29:16,454 --> 01:29:19,319
You say you were distracted
by AA bursts? Did anything
else distract you?
3468
01:29:19,319 --> 01:29:19,354
3469 01:29:19,354 --> 01:29:21,356
Not that I recall. 3470 01:29:21,356 --> 01:29:21,390
3471 01:29:21,390 --> 01:29:24,013
Were you engaged
in reprimanding
a signalman named
3472
01:29:24,013 --> 01:29:24,048
3473 01:29:24,048 --> 01:29:26,119
Urban, at length,
for having a shirt tail out
3474
01:29:26,119 --> 01:29:26,153
3475 01:29:26,153 --> 01:29:28,535
while the ship was
turning 360 degrees?
3476
01:29:28,535 --> 01:29:28,570
3477 01:29:28,570 --> 01:29:30,710
Who said that?
Keith again?
3478
01:29:30,710 --> 01:29:30,744
3479 01:29:30,744 --> 01:29:32,884
Will you answer the
question, Commander?
3480
01:29:32,884 --> 01:29:32,919
3481 01:29:32,919 --> 01:29:34,507
It's a malicious lie,
of course.
3482
01:29:34,507 --> 01:29:36,025
3483 01:29:36,025 --> 01:29:38,580
Was Urban on the
bridge at that time?
3484
01:29:38,580 --> 01:29:38,614
3485 01:29:38,614 --> 01:29:41,445
-Yes.
-Was his shirt tail out?
3486
01:29:41,445 --> 01:29:41,479
3487 01:29:41,479 --> 01:29:46,484
Yes. And I reprimanded
him. That took me
about two seconds.
3488
01:29:46,484 --> 01:29:46,519
3489 01:29:46,519 --> 01:29:48,900
I'm not in the
habit on dwelling
on those things.
3490
01:29:48,900 --> 01:29:48,935
3491 01:29:48,935 --> 01:29:52,628
And then there were those
AA bursts and that was
what distracted me.
3492
01:29:52,628 --> 01:29:52,663
3493 01:29:52,663 --> 01:29:55,666
Did you point out these
AA bursts to the officer
of the deck or the exec?
3494
01:29:55,666 --> 01:29:55,700
3495 01:29:55,700 --> 01:29:57,461
I may have.
I don't recall.
3496
01:29:57,461 --> 01:29:57,495
3497 01:29:57,495 --> 01:30:01,119
I didn't run
weeping to my OOD
on every occasion.
3498
01:30:01,119 --> 01:30:01,154
3499 01:30:01,154 --> 01:30:03,225
I may very well have
kept my own council.
3500
01:30:03,225 --> 01:30:03,259
3501 01:30:03,259 --> 01:30:05,123
And since this shirt tail
thing has been brought up,
3502
01:30:05,123 --> 01:30:05,158
3503 01:30:05,158 --> 01:30:07,091
I would just like to say 3504 01:30:07,091 --> 01:30:07,125
3505 01:30:07,125 --> 01:30:10,370
that Ensign Keith as morale
officer was in charge of
enforcing uniform regulations
3506
01:30:10,370 --> 01:30:10,405
3507 01:30:10,405 --> 01:30:12,234
and completely
soldiered on the job.
3508
01:30:12,234 --> 01:30:12,268
3509 01:30:12,268 --> 01:30:14,719
When I took over that ship,
it was like the Chinese Navy
3510
01:30:14,719 --> 01:30:14,754
3511 01:30:14,754 --> 01:30:17,653
and I bore down on Keith
to watch those shirt tails.
3512
01:30:17,653 --> 01:30:17,688
3513 01:30:17,688 --> 01:30:19,655
As far as I know,
that's another reason
he hated me
3514
01:30:19,655 --> 01:30:19,690
3515 01:30:19,690 --> 01:30:23,418
and circulated all this
about my cutting the
tow line.
3516
01:30:23,418 --> 01:30:23,452
3517 01:30:23,452 --> 01:30:25,420
Did you drop a yellow
dye marker off Jacob Island
3518
01:30:25,420 --> 01:30:25,454
3519 01:30:25,454 --> 01:30:28,526
on the first morning of
the invasion of Kwajalein?
3520
01:30:28,526 --> 01:30:28,561
3521 01:30:28,561 --> 01:30:30,321
I may have.
I don't recall.
3522
01:30:30,321 --> 01:30:30,355
3523 01:30:30,355 --> 01:30:32,737
Do you recall
what your first mission was
during the invasion?
3524
01:30:32,737 --> 01:30:32,772
3525 01:30:32,772 --> 01:30:35,740
To lead the group of attack
boats to the line of departure
for Jacob Island.
3526
01:30:35,740 --> 01:30:35,775
3527 01:30:35,775 --> 01:30:37,535
Did you
fulfill your mission?
3528
01:30:37,535 --> 01:30:37,570
3529 01:30:37,570 --> 01:30:40,987
Yes.
Why did you
drop a dye marker?
3530
01:30:40,987 --> 01:30:41,021
3531 01:30:41,021 --> 01:30:43,472
I don't know for sure
that I did drop one.
3532
01:30:43,472 --> 01:30:43,507
3533 01:30:43,507 --> 01:30:46,475
Maybe I dropped one
to mark the line of
departure plainly.
3534
01:30:46,475 --> 01:30:49,685
3535 01:30:49,685 --> 01:30:52,170
How far was the line
of departure from
the beach?
3536
01:30:52,170 --> 01:30:52,205
3537 01:30:52,205 --> 01:30:55,001
As I recall, 1,000 yards. 3538 01:30:55,001 --> 01:30:55,035
3539 01:30:55,035 --> 01:30:57,382
Commander,
didn't you run a mile
ahead of the attack boats,
3540
01:30:57,382 --> 01:30:57,417
3541 01:30:57,417 --> 01:31:00,489
drop your dye marker
more than a half
a mile short,
3542
01:31:00,489 --> 01:31:00,524
3543 01:31:00,524 --> 01:31:03,112
then retire at high speed
leaving the boats
to grope their way
3544
01:31:03,112 --> 01:31:03,147
3545 01:31:03,147 --> 01:31:04,838
to the line of departure
as best they could?
3546
01:31:04,838 --> 01:31:04,873
3547 01:31:04,873 --> 01:31:08,083
The question is abusive
and flagrantly leading.
3548
01:31:08,083 --> 01:31:09,015
3549 01:31:09,015 --> 01:31:11,086
I'm willing to withdraw
my question,
3550
01:31:11,086 --> 01:31:11,120
3551 01:31:11,120 --> 01:31:16,091
in view of the Captain's
dim memory and proceed to
more recent events.
3552
01:31:16,091 --> 01:31:16,125
3553 01:31:16,125 --> 01:31:18,403
Court desires
to question the witness.
3554
01:31:18,403 --> 01:31:18,438
3555 01:31:18,438 --> 01:31:22,028
Commander Queeg, in view
of the implications involved
in this line of testimony,
3556
01:31:22,028 --> 01:31:22,062
3557 01:31:22,062 --> 01:31:25,376
I urge you to search your
memory for correct answers.
3558
01:31:25,376 --> 01:31:25,410
3559 01:31:25,410 --> 01:31:26,860
I'm certainly
trying to do that, sir,
3560
01:31:26,860 --> 01:31:26,895
3561 01:31:26,895 --> 01:31:28,655
but these are
very small points.
3562
01:31:28,655 --> 01:31:28,690
3563 01:31:28,690 --> 01:31:31,382
I've been through several
campaigns since Kwajalein
3564
01:31:31,382 --> 01:31:31,416
3565 01:31:31,416 --> 01:31:33,798
and the typhoon and
now all this business.
3566
01:31:33,798 --> 01:31:33,833
3567 01:31:33,833 --> 01:31:36,180
I appreciate that.
It will facilitate justice
3568
01:31:36,180 --> 01:31:36,214
3569 01:31:36,214 --> 01:31:39,459
if you can remember enough
to give a few answers
on points of fact.
3570
01:31:39,459 --> 01:31:39,494
3571 01:31:39,494 --> 01:31:41,530
First of all, 3572 01:31:41,530 --> 01:31:41,565
3573 01:31:41,565 --> 01:31:44,533
were those boats on the
line of departure when you
turned away from the beach?
3574
01:31:44,533 --> 01:31:44,568
3575 01:31:44,568 --> 01:31:46,535
As near as
I could calculate, yes.
3576
01:31:46,535 --> 01:31:46,570
3577 01:31:46,570 --> 01:31:48,330
If that's the case, Commander,
and they were all on the line,
3578
01:31:48,330 --> 01:31:48,364
3579 01:31:48,364 --> 01:31:50,332
what purpose did
the dye marker serve?
3580
01:31:50,332 --> 01:31:51,713
3581 01:31:51,713 --> 01:31:54,474
Well, you might
say a safety factor.
3582
01:31:54,474 --> 01:31:54,509
3583 01:31:54,509 --> 01:31:55,820
Just another added mark. 3584 01:31:55,820 --> 01:31:55,855
3585 01:31:55,855 --> 01:31:58,133
Now maybe I erred in
being overcautious
3586
01:31:58,133 --> 01:31:58,167
3587 01:31:58,167 --> 01:32:00,100
and making sure they
knew where they were.
3588
01:32:00,100 --> 01:32:00,135
3589 01:32:00,135 --> 01:32:02,171
But then again, sir,
I've always believed
3590
01:32:02,171 --> 01:32:02,206
3591 01:32:02,206 --> 01:32:04,449
you can't err
on the side of safety.
3592
01:32:04,449 --> 01:32:04,484
3593 01:32:04,484 --> 01:32:06,659
Did you have the con? 3594 01:32:06,659 --> 01:32:06,693
3595 01:32:06,693 --> 01:32:08,453
As I recall now,
Lieutenant Maryk
had the con.
3596
01:32:08,453 --> 01:32:08,488
3597 01:32:08,488 --> 01:32:11,422
And I now recall
I had to caution him for
opening the gap too wide,
3598
01:32:11,422 --> 01:32:11,456
3599 01:32:11,456 --> 01:32:13,562
between us
-and the boats.
How wide?
3600
01:32:13,562 --> 01:32:13,597
3601 01:32:13,597 --> 01:32:15,184
I can't say,
but at one point
there was definitely
3602
01:32:15,184 --> 01:32:15,219
3603 01:32:15,219 --> 01:32:18,153
too much open water.
And I called him aside
and I admonished him,
3604
01:32:18,153 --> 01:32:18,187
3605 01:32:18,187 --> 01:32:19,948
not to run away
from the boats.
3606
01:32:19,948 --> 01:32:19,982
3607 01:32:19,982 --> 01:32:23,572
Did you direct him
to slow down when you saw
the gap widening?
3608
01:32:23,572 --> 01:32:23,607
3609 01:32:23,607 --> 01:32:26,264
Well, but it was all
happening very fast, sir.
3610
01:32:26,264 --> 01:32:26,299
3611 01:32:26,299 --> 01:32:28,439
I may have been watching
the beach for a few seconds,
3612
01:32:28,439 --> 01:32:28,473
3613 01:32:28,473 --> 01:32:30,372
and then I saw
we were running away.
3614
01:32:30,372 --> 01:32:30,406
3615 01:32:30,406 --> 01:32:31,994
And so, that's why
I dropped the marker,
3616
01:32:31,994 --> 01:32:32,029
3617 01:32:32,029 --> 01:32:34,479
to compensate for Maryk's
running away from the boats.
3618
01:32:34,479 --> 01:32:34,514
3619 01:32:34,514 --> 01:32:36,689
These are your factual
recollections, Commander?
3620
01:32:36,689 --> 01:32:36,723
3621 01:32:36,723 --> 01:32:39,243
Those are the facts, sir. 3622 01:32:39,243 --> 01:32:39,277
3623 01:32:39,277 --> 01:32:42,280
Resume your examination. 3624 01:32:42,280 --> 01:32:42,315
3625 01:32:42,315 --> 01:32:45,007
Commander Queeg,
did you make it a practice
during invasions
3626
01:32:45,007 --> 01:32:45,042
3627 01:32:45,042 --> 01:32:46,837
to station yourself
on the side of the bridge
3628
01:32:46,837 --> 01:32:46,871
3629 01:32:46,871 --> 01:32:48,252
that was sheltered
from the beach?
3630
01:32:48,252 --> 01:32:53,222
3631 01:32:53,222 --> 01:32:55,431
That's an insulting
question,
3632
01:32:55,431 --> 01:32:56,536
3633 01:32:56,536 --> 01:32:59,228
and the answer is no. 3634 01:32:59,228 --> 01:32:59,263
3635 01:32:59,263 --> 01:33:01,403
I had to be on all sides
of the bridge at once,
3636
01:33:01,403 --> 01:33:01,437
3637 01:33:01,437 --> 01:33:05,338
constantly moving
from one side to the other
because Maryk was navigator
3638
01:33:05,338 --> 01:33:05,372
3639 01:33:05,372 --> 01:33:07,823
and Keith was my OOD
at general quarters...
3640
01:33:07,823 --> 01:33:10,101
3641 01:33:10,101 --> 01:33:12,932
And both of them were
invariably scurrying to
the safe side of the bridge,
3642
01:33:12,932 --> 01:33:12,966
3643 01:33:12,966 --> 01:33:17,557
so I was captain and navigator
and OOD all rolled into
one and that's the truth!
3644
01:33:17,557 --> 01:33:17,592
3645 01:33:17,592 --> 01:33:20,249
That's why I had to move
constantly from one side
of the bridge to the other,
3646
01:33:20,249 --> 01:33:20,284
3647 01:33:20,284 --> 01:33:24,150
and that's the truth,
whatever lies may have been
said about me in this court!
3648
01:33:24,150 --> 01:33:24,184
3649 01:33:24,184 --> 01:33:26,152
Court will question
the witness.
3650
01:33:26,152 --> 01:33:26,186
3651 01:33:26,186 --> 01:33:30,708
Sir, the witness is obviously
and understandably agitated
by this ordeal,
3652
01:33:30,708 --> 01:33:30,743
3653 01:33:30,743 --> 01:33:33,849
and I request a recess
to give him a breathing space.
3654
01:33:33,849 --> 01:33:33,884
3655 01:33:33,884 --> 01:33:35,644
I'm not in
the least agitated
3656
01:33:35,644 --> 01:33:37,404
3657 01:33:37,404 --> 01:33:40,442
and I'm glad to answer
any and all questions here.
3658
01:33:40,442 --> 01:33:40,476
3659 01:33:40,476 --> 01:33:43,859
In fact, I demand
a chance to set
the record straight on
3660
01:33:43,859 --> 01:33:43,894
3661 01:33:43,894 --> 01:33:47,380
anything derogatory to me
in the testimony
that's gone before.
3662
01:33:47,380 --> 01:33:47,414
3663 01:33:47,414 --> 01:33:52,212
I didn't make a single mistake
in 15 months aboard the Caine
and I can prove it.
3664
01:33:52,212 --> 01:33:52,247
3665 01:33:52,247 --> 01:33:54,318
My record has been
spotless until now
3666
01:33:54,318 --> 01:33:54,352
3667 01:33:54,352 --> 01:33:57,252
and I don't want it smirched
by a whole lot of lies
and distortions
3668
01:33:57,252 --> 01:33:57,286
3669 01:33:57,286 --> 01:33:59,357
by disloyal officers. 3670 01:33:59,357 --> 01:33:59,392
3671 01:33:59,392 --> 01:34:01,256
Would you like
a recess, Commander?
3672
01:34:01,256 --> 01:34:01,290
3673 01:34:01,290 --> 01:34:04,604
Definitely not, sir.
I request there be no
recess, if it's up to me.
3674
01:34:04,604 --> 01:34:04,639
3675 01:34:04,639 --> 01:34:07,296
Very well.
I simply want to ask,
3676
01:34:07,296 --> 01:34:07,331
3677 01:34:07,331 --> 01:34:09,747
if the performance of
these two officers
was so unspeakably bad,
3678
01:34:09,747 --> 01:34:09,782
3679 01:34:09,782 --> 01:34:11,473
why did you tolerate it? 3680 01:34:11,473 --> 01:34:11,507
3681 01:34:11,507 --> 01:34:13,475
Why didn't you beach them? 3682 01:34:13,475 --> 01:34:13,509
3683 01:34:13,509 --> 01:34:15,650
Or at least rotate them
to less responsible
battle stations?
3684
01:34:15,650 --> 01:34:17,306
3685 01:34:17,306 --> 01:34:19,999
Well, strange
as it may seem,
3686
01:34:19,999 --> 01:34:20,033
3687 01:34:20,033 --> 01:34:25,107
the fact is I'm a very
soft-hearted guy.
Not many people know that.
3688
01:34:25,107 --> 01:34:25,142
3689 01:34:25,142 --> 01:34:28,041
I never despaired of
training those two men up
3690
01:34:28,041 --> 01:34:28,076
3691 01:34:28,076 --> 01:34:29,871
and making Navy
officers of them.
3692
01:34:29,871 --> 01:34:29,905
3693 01:34:29,905 --> 01:34:33,253
I kept them under my eye
just because I wanted
to train them up.
3694
01:34:33,253 --> 01:34:33,288
3695 01:34:33,288 --> 01:34:36,740
The last thing
I wanted to do was
wreck their careers,
3696
01:34:36,740 --> 01:34:36,774
3697 01:34:36,774 --> 01:34:40,605
not that they had any
similar concern for me,
either of them.
3698
01:34:40,605 --> 01:34:44,023
3699 01:34:44,023 --> 01:34:45,990
Resume your examination. 3700 01:34:45,990 --> 01:34:50,823
3701 01:34:50,823 --> 01:34:55,206
Commander, on the morning
of 18 December when you
were relieved,
3702
01:34:55,206 --> 01:34:55,241
3703 01:34:55,241 --> 01:34:57,277
was the Cainein
the last extremity?
3704
01:34:57,277 --> 01:34:57,312
3705 01:34:57,312 --> 01:34:59,107
It certainly was not! 3706 01:34:59,107 --> 01:34:59,141
3707 01:34:59,141 --> 01:35:01,109
Was it in grave danger
at that moment?
3708
01:35:01,109 --> 01:35:01,143
3709 01:35:01,143 --> 01:35:04,906
Absolutely not! I had that
ship under complete control.
3710
01:35:04,906 --> 01:35:04,940
3711 01:35:04,940 --> 01:35:06,839
Did you ever indicate
to your other officers
3712
01:35:06,839 --> 01:35:06,873
3713 01:35:06,873 --> 01:35:09,151
that it had been
your intention
to change course
3714
01:35:09,151 --> 01:35:09,186
3715 01:35:09,186 --> 01:35:11,050
and come north
at 10 o'clock
3716
01:35:11,050 --> 01:35:11,084
3717 01:35:11,084 --> 01:35:13,500
or 15 minutes
after Maryk did?
3718
01:35:13,500 --> 01:35:13,535
3719 01:35:13,535 --> 01:35:17,608
Yes, I did make that
statement, and such
had been my intention.
3720
01:35:17,608 --> 01:35:17,642
3721 01:35:17,642 --> 01:35:20,231
Why did you
intend to abandon fleet
course, Commander,
3722
01:35:20,231 --> 01:35:20,266
3723 01:35:20,266 --> 01:35:22,406
if the ship
wasn't in danger?
3724
01:35:22,406 --> 01:35:23,787
3725 01:35:23,787 --> 01:35:26,168
I don't see any
inconsistency there.
3726
01:35:26,168 --> 01:35:26,203
3727 01:35:26,203 --> 01:35:30,552
I've repeatedly stated in
my testimony that my rule
is safety first.
3728
01:35:30,552 --> 01:35:30,586
3729 01:35:30,586 --> 01:35:32,209
As I say, the ship
wasn't in danger,
3730
01:35:32,209 --> 01:35:32,243
3731 01:35:32,243 --> 01:35:34,418
but a typhoon is
still a typhoon
3732
01:35:34,418 --> 01:35:34,452
3733 01:35:34,452 --> 01:35:37,904
and I'd just about decided
that we'd do as well
coming around to north.
3734
01:35:37,904 --> 01:35:37,939
3735 01:35:37,939 --> 01:35:40,804
I might have executed
my intention at 10 o'clock,
3736
01:35:40,804 --> 01:35:40,838
3737 01:35:40,838 --> 01:35:43,151
and then again
I might not have.
3738
01:35:43,151 --> 01:35:43,185
3739 01:35:43,185 --> 01:35:48,466
Then Maryk's decision to
come north was not a panicky
irrational blunder.
3740
01:35:48,466 --> 01:35:48,501
3741 01:35:48,501 --> 01:35:52,332
His panicky blunder
was relieving me.
3742
01:35:52,332 --> 01:35:52,367
3743 01:35:52,367 --> 01:35:54,990
I kept him from making
any disastrous
mistakes thereafter.
3744
01:35:54,990 --> 01:35:55,025
3745 01:35:55,025 --> 01:35:58,511
I didn't intend to vindicate
myself at the cost of
all the lives on the Caine!
3746
01:35:58,511 --> 01:36:01,721
3747 01:36:01,721 --> 01:36:06,588
Commander Queeg, have you
read Lieutenant Maryk's
medical log?
3748
01:36:06,588 --> 01:36:06,622
3749 01:36:06,622 --> 01:36:11,179
Oh, yes, I have read that
interesting document,
yes, sir, I have.
3750
01:36:11,179 --> 01:36:11,213
3751 01:36:11,213 --> 01:36:13,975
It is the biggest
conglomeration of lies
and distortions
3752
01:36:13,975 --> 01:36:14,009
3753 01:36:14,009 --> 01:36:15,942
and half-truths
I've ever seen,
3754
01:36:15,942 --> 01:36:15,977
3755 01:36:15,977 --> 01:36:17,461
and I'm extremely
glad you asked me
3756
01:36:17,461 --> 01:36:17,495
3757 01:36:17,495 --> 01:36:20,705
because I want to get my side
of it all on the record.
3758
01:36:20,705 --> 01:36:20,740
3759 01:36:20,740 --> 01:36:25,745
Please state your version,
or any factual comments on
the episodes in the log, sir.
3760
01:36:25,745 --> 01:36:28,783
3761 01:36:28,783 --> 01:36:30,854
Okay. 3762 01:36:30,854 --> 01:36:30,888
3763 01:36:30,888 --> 01:36:32,856
Now... 3764 01:36:32,856 --> 01:36:32,890
3765 01:36:32,890 --> 01:36:35,548
Well, starting right with
that strawberry business.
3766
01:36:35,548 --> 01:36:35,582
3767 01:36:35,582 --> 01:36:40,001
The real truth is that
I was betrayed and thrown
and double-crossed
3768
01:36:40,001 --> 01:36:40,035
3769 01:36:40,035 --> 01:36:44,039
by my executive officer
and this precious
gentleman, Mr. Keith,
3770
01:36:44,039 --> 01:36:44,074
3771 01:36:44,074 --> 01:36:46,179
who between them
corrupted my wardrooms
3772
01:36:46,179 --> 01:36:46,214
3773 01:36:46,214 --> 01:36:50,321
so that I was one man against
a whole ship without
any support from my officers.
3774
01:36:50,321 --> 01:36:52,289
3775 01:36:52,289 --> 01:36:56,811
Okay. Now you take that
strawberry business.
3776
01:36:56,811 --> 01:36:56,845
3777 01:36:56,845 --> 01:37:01,574
Why, if that wasn't a case of
outright conspiracy to protect
a malefactor from justice.
3778
01:37:01,574 --> 01:37:01,608
3779 01:37:01,608 --> 01:37:04,266
Maryk carefully leaves
out the little fact
3780
01:37:04,266 --> 01:37:04,301
3781 01:37:04,301 --> 01:37:07,925
that I had conclusively
proved, by a process
of elimination,
3782
01:37:07,925 --> 01:37:07,960
3783 01:37:07,960 --> 01:37:10,686
that somebody had
a key to the icebox.
3784
01:37:10,686 --> 01:37:10,721
3785 01:37:10,721 --> 01:37:13,689
He says it was the
steward's mates
who ate the strawberries.
3786
01:37:13,689 --> 01:37:13,724
3787 01:37:13,724 --> 01:37:15,795
But if I wanted
to take the trouble,
3788
01:37:15,795 --> 01:37:15,830
3789 01:37:15,830 --> 01:37:19,488
I could prove to this court,
geometrically, that they
couldn't have.
3790
01:37:19,488 --> 01:37:19,523
3791 01:37:19,523 --> 01:37:21,111
No, it was the water
business all over again,
3792
01:37:21,111 --> 01:37:21,145
3793 01:37:21,145 --> 01:37:23,907
like when the crew
was taking baths
seven times a day
3794
01:37:23,907 --> 01:37:23,941
3795 01:37:23,941 --> 01:37:26,806
and our evaps were
definitely on the
fritz half the time,
3796
01:37:26,806 --> 01:37:26,841
3797 01:37:26,841 --> 01:37:32,363
and I was trying to inculcate
the simplest principles
of water conservation.
3798
01:37:32,363 --> 01:37:32,398
3799 01:37:32,398 --> 01:37:35,642
But, no. Mr. Maryk,
the hero of the crew,
3800
01:37:35,642 --> 01:37:35,677
3801 01:37:35,677 --> 01:37:38,438
wanted to go right on
molly-coddling them
3802
01:37:38,438 --> 01:37:38,473
3803 01:37:38,473 --> 01:37:41,510
and, well, you take
that coffee business.
3804
01:37:41,510 --> 01:37:41,545
3805 01:37:41,545 --> 01:37:45,721
No! The strawberry
thing first.
3806
01:37:45,721 --> 01:37:45,756
3807 01:37:45,756 --> 01:37:49,691
It all hinged on
a thorough search
for the key
3808
01:37:49,691 --> 01:37:49,725
3809 01:37:49,725 --> 01:37:51,589
and that was where
Mr. Maryk, as usual,
3810
01:37:51,589 --> 01:37:51,624
3811 01:37:51,624 --> 01:37:53,902
with the help of
Mr. Keith, fudged it!
3812
01:37:53,902 --> 01:37:53,937
3813 01:37:53,937 --> 01:37:57,664
Just went through
a lot of phony motions
that proved nothing.
3814
01:37:57,664 --> 01:37:57,699
3815 01:37:57,699 --> 01:38:00,460
And like thinking
the incessant burning
out of Silexes
3816
01:38:00,460 --> 01:38:00,495
3817 01:38:00,495 --> 01:38:03,153
which were government
property was a joke.
3818
01:38:03,153 --> 01:38:03,187
3819 01:38:03,187 --> 01:38:05,224
No sense of responsibility. 3820 01:38:05,224 --> 01:38:05,258
3821 01:38:05,258 --> 01:38:07,122
Which was the attitude of
everybody from Maryk down.
3822
01:38:07,122 --> 01:38:07,157
3823 01:38:07,157 --> 01:38:10,539
No sense of responsibility,
though I emphasized
over and over
3824
01:38:10,539 --> 01:38:10,574
3825 01:38:10,574 --> 01:38:12,541
that the war
wouldn't last forever,
3826
01:38:12,541 --> 01:38:12,576
3827 01:38:12,576 --> 01:38:15,751
that all these things
would have to be
accounted for.
3828
01:38:15,751 --> 01:38:15,786
3829 01:38:15,786 --> 01:38:19,272
Oh, it was a constant battle.
Always the same thing.
3830
01:38:19,272 --> 01:38:19,307
3831 01:38:19,307 --> 01:38:22,586
Maryk and Keith
undermining my authority.
3832
01:38:22,586 --> 01:38:22,620
3833 01:38:22,620 --> 01:38:24,588
Always arguments. 3834 01:38:24,588 --> 01:38:24,622
3835 01:38:24,622 --> 01:38:28,005
Though I personally liked
Keith and kept trying to
train him up,
3836
01:38:28,005 --> 01:38:28,040
3837 01:38:28,040 --> 01:38:30,594
only to get stabbed
in the back when...
3838
01:38:30,594 --> 01:38:32,423
3839 01:38:32,423 --> 01:38:36,462
Okay. I think
I've covered the
strawberry business.
3840
01:38:36,462 --> 01:38:38,567
3841 01:38:38,567 --> 01:38:42,571
And, oh, yes, this
mess account business.
3842
01:38:42,571 --> 01:38:42,606
3843 01:38:42,606 --> 01:38:44,021
I had to watch
them like a hawk.
3844
01:38:44,021 --> 01:38:44,056
3845 01:38:44,056 --> 01:38:45,712
And believe me, I did. 3846 01:38:45,712 --> 01:38:45,747
3847 01:38:45,747 --> 01:38:48,819
They didn't sneak
any fast one by, but it
wasn't for not trying.
3848
01:38:48,819 --> 01:38:48,853
3849 01:38:48,853 --> 01:38:50,683
Instead of paying
some attention
to their accounts
3850
01:38:50,683 --> 01:38:50,717
3851 01:38:50,717 --> 01:38:52,961
and their inventories,
which I had to check,
over and over.
3852
01:38:52,961 --> 01:38:52,996
3853 01:38:52,996 --> 01:38:55,067
Always a few pennies short
or a few dollars over.
3854
01:38:55,067 --> 01:38:55,101
3855 01:38:55,101 --> 01:38:57,414
What did it matter to them,
keeping accurate records?
3856
01:38:57,414 --> 01:38:57,448
3857 01:38:57,448 --> 01:38:59,002
Let the Captain
worry about it.
3858
01:38:59,002 --> 01:38:59,036
3859 01:38:59,036 --> 01:39:01,004
And I did, by God! 3860 01:39:01,004 --> 01:39:01,038
3861 01:39:01,038 --> 01:39:04,455
I defy anyone to look
over a single wardroom
mess statement
3862
01:39:04,455 --> 01:39:04,490
3863 01:39:04,490 --> 01:39:08,149
or ship service inventory
filed aboard the USS Caine
while I was captain
3864
01:39:08,149 --> 01:39:08,183
3865 01:39:08,183 --> 01:39:11,186
and find a mistake of
one single solitary cent.
3866
01:39:11,186 --> 01:39:11,221
3867 01:39:11,221 --> 01:39:14,362
I defy a certified
public accountant
to do it.
3868
01:39:14,362 --> 01:39:15,087
3869 01:39:15,087 --> 01:39:17,330
Okay, what else? 3870 01:39:17,330 --> 01:39:17,365
3871 01:39:17,365 --> 01:39:21,196
There's so much tripe
in that precious log
of Mr. Maryk's.
3872
01:39:21,196 --> 01:39:24,544
3873 01:39:24,544 --> 01:39:28,410
Oh, yes, the
movie business.
3874
01:39:28,410 --> 01:39:31,068
3875 01:39:31,068 --> 01:39:32,828
Okay. 3876 01:39:32,828 --> 01:39:32,863
3877 01:39:32,863 --> 01:39:35,141
No respect for command 3878 01:39:35,141 --> 01:39:35,176
3879 01:39:35,176 --> 01:39:38,110
was the whole trouble
with that ship.
3880
01:39:38,110 --> 01:39:38,144
3881 01:39:38,144 --> 01:39:43,632
The movie operator,
who had a disrespect,
surly manner, anyway,
3882
01:39:43,632 --> 01:39:43,667
3883 01:39:43,667 --> 01:39:46,014
blithely started the movie
without waiting for
3884
01:39:46,014 --> 01:39:46,049
3885 01:39:46,049 --> 01:39:48,223
the arrival of the
commanding officer.
3886
01:39:48,223 --> 01:39:48,258
3887 01:39:48,258 --> 01:39:52,469
And out of that
whole ship's crew,
officers and men,
3888
01:39:52,469 --> 01:39:52,503
3889 01:39:52,503 --> 01:39:57,198
did one person call
a halt or even notice that
the Captain wasn't present?
3890
01:39:57,198 --> 01:39:59,165
3891 01:39:59,165 --> 01:40:02,651
I missed those movies
more than they did,
but I banned them,
3892
01:40:02,651 --> 01:40:02,686
3893 01:40:02,686 --> 01:40:04,964
and by God
I'd do it again.
3894
01:40:04,964 --> 01:40:04,999
3895 01:40:04,999 --> 01:40:07,794
What was I supposed to do,
issue letters of commendation
to all of them
3896
01:40:07,794 --> 01:40:07,829
3897 01:40:07,829 --> 01:40:12,454
for this gratuitous insult
to the commanding officer?
3898
01:40:12,454 --> 01:40:12,489
3899 01:40:12,489 --> 01:40:15,906
Not that I took
it personally.
It was the principle.
3900
01:40:15,906 --> 01:40:15,940
3901 01:40:15,940 --> 01:40:19,220
The principle of
respect for command.
3902
01:40:19,220 --> 01:40:19,254
3903 01:40:19,254 --> 01:40:21,463
That principle was dead
when I came aboard that ship,
3904
01:40:21,463 --> 01:40:21,498
3905 01:40:21,498 --> 01:40:23,948
but I brought it to life 3906 01:40:23,948 --> 01:40:23,983
3907 01:40:23,983 --> 01:40:28,056
and I nagged and I crabbed
and I bitched and I hollered,
3908
01:40:28,056 --> 01:40:28,091
3909 01:40:28,091 --> 01:40:33,096
but by God,
I made it stick while
I was the Captain!
3910
01:40:33,096 --> 01:40:33,130
3911 01:40:33,130 --> 01:40:36,064
And so I say,
like the Silexes.
3912
01:40:36,064 --> 01:40:36,099
3913 01:40:36,099 --> 01:40:40,551
It wasn't only the Silexes,
it was a matter of respect.
3914
01:40:40,551 --> 01:40:40,586
3915 01:40:40,586 --> 01:40:43,313
When I ask a sailor
a question, I want
a straight answer!
3916
01:40:43,313 --> 01:40:43,347
3917 01:40:43,347 --> 01:40:45,315
And nobody's gonna get
away with shifty evasions,
3918
01:40:45,315 --> 01:40:45,349
3919 01:40:45,349 --> 01:40:48,283
if I have to hold
a court of inquiry
for a week!
3920
01:40:48,283 --> 01:40:48,318
3921 01:40:48,318 --> 01:40:51,148
What do I care
for strawberries?
3922
01:40:51,148 --> 01:40:51,183
3923 01:40:51,183 --> 01:40:53,944
It was a question
of principle.
3924
01:40:53,944 --> 01:40:53,978
3925 01:40:53,978 --> 01:40:57,810
Pilfering is pilfering,
and on my ship...
3926
01:40:57,810 --> 01:40:57,844
3927 01:40:57,844 --> 01:41:00,537
Oh, not that we had
so many treats, either.
3928
01:41:00,537 --> 01:41:00,571
3929 01:41:00,571 --> 01:41:03,781
With those slow-motion
mess treasurers of ours.
3930
01:41:03,781 --> 01:41:03,816
3931 01:41:03,816 --> 01:41:08,303
Not like when I was an
ensign. Believe me, they
made me jump sure enough.
3932
01:41:08,303 --> 01:41:08,338
3933 01:41:08,338 --> 01:41:11,237
When did we get something
pleasant like strawberries?
3934
01:41:11,237 --> 01:41:11,272
3935 01:41:11,272 --> 01:41:12,721
Once in a blue moon, why, 3936 01:41:12,721 --> 01:41:12,756
3937 01:41:12,756 --> 01:41:16,484
it was an outrage not
to have another helping
if I felt like it.
3938
01:41:16,484 --> 01:41:16,518
3939 01:41:16,518 --> 01:41:19,452
And I wasn't gonna let them
get away with that,
and I didn't, by God,
3940
01:41:19,452 --> 01:41:19,487
3941 01:41:19,487 --> 01:41:21,868
there was no more of that
again on that ship.
3942
01:41:21,868 --> 01:41:22,731
3943 01:41:22,731 --> 01:41:24,837
And as I say... 3944 01:41:24,837 --> 01:41:26,425
3945 01:41:26,425 --> 01:41:29,324
Okay. How many of
these things have
I covered?
3946
01:41:29,324 --> 01:41:29,359
3947 01:41:29,359 --> 01:41:32,155
I can only do this roughly
from memory,
3948
01:41:32,155 --> 01:41:32,189
3949 01:41:32,189 --> 01:41:35,882
but you ask me specific
questions and I'll
tackle 'em one by one.
3950
01:41:35,882 --> 01:41:35,917
3951 01:41:35,917 --> 01:41:39,714
It was a very thorough
and complete answer,
Commander, thank you.
3952
01:41:39,714 --> 01:41:47,618
3953 01:41:47,618 --> 01:41:49,620
May I have Exhibit 12? 3954 01:41:49,620 --> 01:42:06,603
3955 01:42:06,603 --> 01:42:09,468
Commander, I show you
an authenticated copy
of a fitness report
3956
01:42:09,468 --> 01:42:09,502
3957 01:42:09,502 --> 01:42:12,505
you wrote on
Lieutenant Maryk,
dated 1 July, 1944.
3958
01:42:12,505 --> 01:42:12,540
3959 01:42:12,540 --> 01:42:14,369
Do you recognize
it as such?
3960
01:42:14,369 --> 01:42:14,404
3961 01:42:14,404 --> 01:42:16,337
Yes. 3962 01:42:16,337 --> 01:42:16,371
3963 01:42:16,371 --> 01:42:19,512
By that date, had the
following incidents
already occurred?
3964
01:42:19,512 --> 01:42:19,547
3965 01:42:19,547 --> 01:42:22,205
The water shortage,
the Silex investigation,
3966
01:42:22,205 --> 01:42:22,239
3967 01:42:22,239 --> 01:42:24,172
the suspension of movies,
among others?
3968
01:42:24,172 --> 01:42:25,725
3969 01:42:25,725 --> 01:42:28,625
Well, by then,
yes, I think.
3970
01:42:28,625 --> 01:42:30,834
3971 01:42:30,834 --> 01:42:34,148
Please read to the court
your comment of 1 July,
on Lieutenant Maryk.
3972
01:42:34,148 --> 01:42:45,435
3973 01:42:45,435 --> 01:42:47,506
Naturally, not being
vindictive, I...
3974
01:42:47,506 --> 01:42:49,335
3975 01:42:49,335 --> 01:42:51,199
I didn't write
every single thing down.
3976
01:42:51,199 --> 01:42:51,234
3977 01:42:51,234 --> 01:42:54,271
A service report goes
into a man's record.
3978
01:42:54,271 --> 01:42:54,306
3979 01:42:54,306 --> 01:42:57,205
I tried...
I tried to go easy.
I always have.
3980
01:42:57,205 --> 01:42:57,240
3981 01:42:57,240 --> 01:42:58,931
I always will. 3982 01:42:58,931 --> 01:42:58,965
3983 01:42:58,965 --> 01:43:01,382
I appreciate
that, sir. Please read
your comment.
3984
01:43:01,382 --> 01:43:06,041
3985 01:43:06,041 --> 01:43:07,836
"This officer has... 3986 01:43:07,836 --> 01:43:22,782
3987 01:43:22,782 --> 01:43:25,406
"This officer has,
if anything,
3988
01:43:25,406 --> 01:43:25,440
3989 01:43:25,440 --> 01:43:29,272
"improved in his performance
of duty since his last
fitness report.
3990
01:43:29,272 --> 01:43:31,066
3991 01:43:31,066 --> 01:43:37,038
"He is consistently loyal,
unflagging, thorough,
3992
01:43:37,038 --> 01:43:37,072
3993 01:43:37,072 --> 01:43:39,351
"courageous and efficient. 3994 01:43:39,351 --> 01:43:41,456
3995 01:43:41,456 --> 01:43:46,289
"He is considered at present
fully qualified for command
of a 1,200-ton DMS.
3996
01:43:46,289 --> 01:43:48,118
3997 01:43:48,118 --> 01:43:50,707
"His professional zeal and
integrity set him apart
3998
01:43:50,707 --> 01:43:52,329
3999 01:43:52,329 --> 01:43:54,849
"as an outstanding example
for other officers,
4000
01:43:54,849 --> 01:43:54,883
4001 01:43:54,883 --> 01:43:56,678
"reserve and regular alike. 4002 01:43:56,678 --> 01:43:58,266
4003 01:43:58,266 --> 01:44:00,303
"He cannot be too
highly recommended.
4004
01:44:00,303 --> 01:44:02,788
4005 01:44:02,788 --> 01:44:05,963
"He is recommended
for transfer to the
regular Navy."
4006
01:44:05,963 --> 01:44:18,528
4007 01:44:18,528 --> 01:44:21,151
Thank you, Commander.
No further questions.
4008
01:44:21,151 --> 01:44:30,194
4009 01:44:30,194 --> 01:44:32,852
No cross-examination. 4010 01:44:32,852 --> 01:44:32,887
4011 01:44:32,887 --> 01:44:35,165
You are
excused, Commander.
4012
01:44:35,165 --> 01:44:39,514
4013 01:44:39,514 --> 01:44:41,896
Defense rests. 4014 01:44:41,896 --> 01:44:41,930
4015 01:44:41,930 --> 01:44:44,001
Is the
judge advocate ready?
4016
01:44:44,001 --> 01:44:46,003
4017 01:44:46,003 --> 01:44:47,177
Commander? 4018 01:44:47,177 --> 01:44:54,495
4019 01:44:54,495 --> 01:44:55,634
You're excused. 4020 01:44:55,634 --> 01:45:16,758
4021 01:45:16,758 --> 01:45:19,071
Is the judge advocate
ready to present his
closing argument?
4022
01:45:19,071 --> 01:45:19,865
4023 01:45:19,865 --> 01:45:21,729
If it please the court... 4024 01:45:21,729 --> 01:45:25,249
4025 01:45:25,249 --> 01:45:27,597
I'm... 4026 01:45:27,597 --> 01:45:27,631
4027 01:45:27,631 --> 01:45:31,359
I'm at a loss to discuss
the case the defense
has presented.
4028
01:45:31,359 --> 01:45:33,361
4029 01:45:33,361 --> 01:45:37,365
I have nothing to refute.
It's no case at all.
4030
01:45:37,365 --> 01:45:37,400
4031 01:45:37,400 --> 01:45:41,473
It has nothing
to do with the charge
or specification.
4032
01:45:41,473 --> 01:45:41,507
4033 01:45:41,507 --> 01:45:45,477
The defense counsel's
very first question
in this trial was,
4034
01:45:45,477 --> 01:45:45,511
4035 01:45:45,511 --> 01:45:49,273
"Commander, have you ever
heard the expression
Old Yellow Stain?"
4036
01:45:49,273 --> 01:45:50,482
4037 01:45:50,482 --> 01:45:53,347
That was the key
to his entire strategy,
4038
01:45:53,347 --> 01:45:53,381
4039 01:45:53,381 --> 01:45:55,418
which was simply to twist
the proceedings around
4040
01:45:55,418 --> 01:45:55,452
4041 01:45:55,452 --> 01:45:59,387
so the accused would
become not Maryk but
Commander Queeg.
4042
01:45:59,387 --> 01:45:59,422
4043 01:45:59,422 --> 01:46:03,218
He's...
He's dragged out
every possible,
4044
01:46:03,218 --> 01:46:03,253
4045 01:46:03,253 --> 01:46:06,498
vicious and malicious
criticism of the commander
from the other witnesses.
4046
01:46:06,498 --> 01:46:06,532
4047 01:46:06,532 --> 01:46:11,399
He's forced Queeg to
defend himself against
them in an open court,
4048
01:46:11,399 --> 01:46:11,434
4049 01:46:11,434 --> 01:46:13,367
on the spur of the moment,
without advice of counsel,
4050
01:46:13,367 --> 01:46:13,401
4051 01:46:13,401 --> 01:46:16,749
without any of the normal
privileges and safeguards
4052
01:46:16,749 --> 01:46:16,784
4053 01:46:16,784 --> 01:46:19,407
of an accused man
under naval law.
4054
01:46:19,407 --> 01:46:22,445
4055 01:46:22,445 --> 01:46:26,034
Can this court possibly
endorse the precedent that
4056
01:46:26,034 --> 01:46:26,069
4057 01:46:26,069 --> 01:46:28,796
a captain who doesn't
please his underlings
can be deposed by them?
4058
01:46:28,796 --> 01:46:28,830
4059 01:46:28,830 --> 01:46:31,764
That this captain's
only recourse afterward
4060
01:46:31,764 --> 01:46:31,799
4061 01:46:31,799 --> 01:46:34,353
is to be placed on
the witness stand at
a general court-martial
4062
01:46:34,353 --> 01:46:34,388
4063 01:46:34,388 --> 01:46:37,529
to answer every petty gripe 4064 01:46:37,529 --> 01:46:37,563
4065 01:46:37,563 --> 01:46:40,877
and to justify all his
command decisions to
a hostile lawyer
4066
01:46:40,877 --> 01:46:40,911
4067 01:46:40,911 --> 01:46:43,293
taking the part of his
insubordinate inferiors?
4068
01:46:43,293 --> 01:46:44,984
4069 01:46:44,984 --> 01:46:50,956
Such a precedent is
nothing but a blank
check for mutiny.
4070
01:46:50,956 --> 01:46:55,339
4071 01:46:55,339 --> 01:47:00,379
However, all this
doesn't worry me, sir.
4072
01:47:00,379 --> 01:47:00,414
4073 01:47:00,414 --> 01:47:07,351
I'm confident that this court
hasn't been impressed
by such shyster tactics.
4074
01:47:07,351 --> 01:47:07,386
4075 01:47:07,386 --> 01:47:10,389
I know this court will
reject this cynical play
on its emotions,
4076
01:47:10,389 --> 01:47:10,424
4077 01:47:10,424 --> 01:47:12,080
this insult
to its intelligence,
4078
01:47:12,080 --> 01:47:12,115
4079 01:47:12,115 --> 01:47:14,980
and find the specification
proven by the facts.
4080
01:47:14,980 --> 01:47:20,088
4081 01:47:20,088 --> 01:47:22,263
I've only this to say, sir. 4082 01:47:22,263 --> 01:47:22,297
4083 01:47:22,297 --> 01:47:24,679
Whatever the verdict
on the accused,
4084
01:47:24,679 --> 01:47:24,714
4085 01:47:24,714 --> 01:47:27,371
I formally recommend
that Defense Counsel
Greenwald be reprimanded
4086
01:47:27,371 --> 01:47:27,406
4087 01:47:27,406 --> 01:47:31,203
by this court for
conduct unbecoming
an officer of the Navy
4088
01:47:31,203 --> 01:47:31,237
4089 01:47:31,237 --> 01:47:34,033
and that this reprimand
be made part of his record.
4090
01:47:34,033 --> 01:47:41,765
4091 01:47:41,765 --> 01:47:44,181
Defense Counsel,
closing argument.
4092
01:47:44,181 --> 01:47:56,228
4093 01:47:56,228 --> 01:47:58,506
Please the court, 4094 01:47:58,506 --> 01:47:58,541
4095 01:47:58,541 --> 01:48:02,303
I undertook the defense
of the accused
very reluctantly,
4096
01:48:02,303 --> 01:48:02,337
4097 01:48:02,337 --> 01:48:04,063
and only at the urging
of the judge advocate
4098
01:48:04,063 --> 01:48:04,098
4099 01:48:04,098 --> 01:48:07,342
that no other defense
counsel was available.
4100
01:48:07,342 --> 01:48:07,377
4101 01:48:07,377 --> 01:48:11,277
I was reluctant because
I knew the only possible
defense was to show in court
4102
01:48:11,277 --> 01:48:11,312
4103 01:48:11,312 --> 01:48:15,592
the mental incompetence
of an officer of the Navy.
4104
01:48:15,592 --> 01:48:15,627
4105 01:48:15,627 --> 01:48:19,734
It has been the most
unpleasant duty I've
ever had to perform.
4106
01:48:19,734 --> 01:48:19,769
4107 01:48:19,769 --> 01:48:21,771
Having undertaken it,
I did what I could
to win an acquittal.
4108
01:48:21,771 --> 01:48:21,805
4109 01:48:21,805 --> 01:48:25,913
I thought that was my duty,
both as defense counsel
appointed by the Navy
4110
01:48:25,913 --> 01:48:25,947
4111 01:48:25,947 --> 01:48:27,431
and as a member of the Bar. 4112 01:48:27,431 --> 01:48:29,675
4113 01:48:29,675 --> 01:48:31,228
Let me make
one thing clear.
4114
01:48:31,228 --> 01:48:32,678
4115 01:48:32,678 --> 01:48:35,439
It is not, and never has been,
the contention of the defense
4116
01:48:35,439 --> 01:48:35,474
4117 01:48:35,474 --> 01:48:38,581
that Commander Queeg
is a coward.
4118
01:48:38,581 --> 01:48:38,615
4119 01:48:38,615 --> 01:48:41,238
The entire case of the defense
rests on the assumption that
4120
01:48:41,238 --> 01:48:41,273
4121 01:48:41,273 --> 01:48:45,173
no man who rises
to the command of
a United States Naval ship
4122
01:48:45,173 --> 01:48:45,208
4123 01:48:45,208 --> 01:48:47,313
could possibly be a coward. 4124 01:48:47,313 --> 01:48:48,556
4125 01:48:48,556 --> 01:48:50,869
And that therefore,
if he commits...
4126
01:48:50,869 --> 01:48:53,147
4127 01:48:53,147 --> 01:48:55,183
If he commits
questionable acts under fire,
4128
01:48:55,183 --> 01:48:55,218
4129 01:48:55,218 --> 01:48:57,013
the explanation
must lie elsewhere.
4130
01:48:57,013 --> 01:48:59,394
4131 01:48:59,394 --> 01:49:02,536
The court saw the bearing
of Captain Queeg on the stand.
4132
01:49:02,536 --> 01:49:04,261
4133 01:49:04,261 --> 01:49:06,332
The court can picture
what his bearing
must have been
4134
01:49:06,332 --> 01:49:06,367
4135 01:49:06,367 --> 01:49:09,163
at the height of a typhoon. 4136 01:49:09,163 --> 01:49:09,197
4137 01:49:09,197 --> 01:49:12,269
On that basis,
the court will decide
the fate of the accused.
4138
01:49:12,269 --> 01:49:27,077
4139 01:49:27,077 --> 01:49:28,596
Lieutenant Greenwald. 4140 01:49:28,596 --> 01:49:31,806
4141 01:49:31,806 --> 01:49:33,290
Yes, sir. 4142 01:49:33,290 --> 01:49:33,325
4143 01:49:33,325 --> 01:49:36,397
Lieutenant, this has been
a strange and tragic trial.
4144
01:49:36,397 --> 01:49:38,433
4145 01:49:38,433 --> 01:49:42,506
You presented your case
with striking ingenuity.
4146
01:49:42,506 --> 01:49:42,541
4147 01:49:42,541 --> 01:49:49,030
The judge advocate's remark
about shyster tactics was an
unfortunate personal slur.
4148
01:49:49,030 --> 01:49:49,065
4149 01:49:49,065 --> 01:49:52,586
But your conduct has been
puzzling, and it does
raise questions.
4150
01:49:52,586 --> 01:49:52,620
4151 01:49:52,620 --> 01:49:54,588
With talent
comes responsibility.
4152
01:49:54,588 --> 01:49:56,244
4153 01:49:56,244 --> 01:49:59,213
Has your conduct here
been responsible,
Lieutenant Greenwald?
4154
01:49:59,213 --> 01:50:00,939
4155 01:50:00,939 --> 01:50:02,457
The reprimand,
if there's to be one,
4156
01:50:02,457 --> 01:50:02,492
4157 01:50:02,492 --> 01:50:04,874
must come from
your own conscience.
4158
01:50:04,874 --> 01:50:04,908
4159 01:50:04,908 --> 01:50:08,222
Counsel's words and
acts are privileged
4160
01:50:08,222 --> 01:50:08,256
4161 01:50:08,256 --> 01:50:10,465
under the broad limits
of contempt of court.
4162
01:50:10,465 --> 01:50:12,019
4163 01:50:12,019 --> 01:50:15,125
Court finds
the defense counsel
has not been in contempt.
4164
01:50:15,125 --> 01:50:15,160
4165 01:50:15,160 --> 01:50:16,955
Recommendation to
reprimand denied.
4166
01:50:16,955 --> 01:50:22,616
4167 01:50:22,616 --> 01:50:25,515
What happens now?
That's
the ball game.
4168
01:50:25,515 --> 01:50:26,550
4169 01:50:26,550 --> 01:50:27,793
When do we find out? 4170 01:50:27,793 --> 01:50:27,828
4171 01:50:27,828 --> 01:50:30,244
If it's an acquittal,
in an hour or so.
4172
01:50:30,244 --> 01:50:30,278
4173 01:50:30,278 --> 01:50:33,316
If it isn't, they may
take weeks before they
publish their findings.
4174
01:50:33,316 --> 01:50:33,350
4175 01:50:33,350 --> 01:50:34,973
Meanwhile,
would I be confined?
4176
01:50:34,973 --> 01:50:35,007
4177 01:50:35,007 --> 01:50:36,664
No, hardly. 4178 01:50:36,664 --> 01:50:36,699
4179 01:50:36,699 --> 01:50:41,531
What do you think?
Listen, you were terrific.
4180
01:50:41,531 --> 01:50:41,565
4181 01:50:41,565 --> 01:50:43,291
-Thanks.
-You murdered Queeg.
4182
01:50:43,291 --> 01:50:43,326
4183 01:50:43,326 --> 01:50:45,604
Yeah, I murdered him. 4184 01:50:45,604 --> 01:50:45,639
4185 01:50:45,639 --> 01:50:47,433
I'm grateful to you,
win or lose.
4186
01:50:47,433 --> 01:50:48,089
4187 01:50:48,089 --> 01:50:50,574
Okay. 4188 01:50:50,574 --> 01:50:50,609
4189 01:50:50,609 --> 01:50:54,578
What's the matter?
You bothered by what
Challee said? Or Blakely?
4190
01:50:54,578 --> 01:50:54,613
4191 01:50:54,613 --> 01:50:56,304
No. Why...
Why should I be?
4192
01:50:56,304 --> 01:50:56,339
4193 01:50:56,339 --> 01:50:58,652
I had a job to do.
I did it. That's all.
4194
01:50:58,652 --> 01:50:58,686
4195 01:50:58,686 --> 01:51:00,446
Yeah, well,
that's the spirit.
4196
01:51:00,446 --> 01:51:00,481
4197 01:51:00,481 --> 01:51:03,691
Look, Tom Keefer's
throwing a party over
at the Fairmont Hotel.
4198
01:51:03,691 --> 01:51:03,726
4199 01:51:03,726 --> 01:51:05,382
This morning he got
a check for 1,000 bucks.
4200
01:51:05,382 --> 01:51:05,417
4201 01:51:05,417 --> 01:51:07,868
Advance on his novel. 4202 01:51:07,868 --> 01:51:07,902
4203 01:51:07,902 --> 01:51:09,386
-Good for him.
-Yeah.
4204
01:51:09,386 --> 01:51:09,421
4205 01:51:09,421 --> 01:51:11,699
If he wins the Pulitzer
Prize, the Nobel Prize,
4206
01:51:11,699 --> 01:51:11,734
4207 01:51:11,734 --> 01:51:13,183
the Congressional
Medal of Honor,
4208
01:51:13,183 --> 01:51:13,218
4209 01:51:13,218 --> 01:51:14,944
gets his bust
in the Hall of Fame.
4210
01:51:14,944 --> 01:51:14,978
4211 01:51:14,978 --> 01:51:16,670
We're both
invited to the party.
4212
01:51:16,670 --> 01:51:16,704
4213 01:51:16,704 --> 01:51:18,741
♪ Bottom's up,
we've got to go
4214
01:51:18,741 --> 01:51:18,775
4215 01:51:18,775 --> 01:51:20,639
♪ The captain's gotten
loose, you know
4216
01:51:20,639 --> 01:51:20,674
4217 01:51:20,674 --> 01:51:27,163
♪ We'll have to tie
him to the tow ♪
4218
01:51:27,163 --> 01:51:33,410
4219 01:51:33,410 --> 01:51:36,379
Hey, Willy. Willy,
I want you to meet
someone.
4220
01:51:36,379 --> 01:51:36,413
4221 01:51:36,413 --> 01:51:40,348
Gentlemen, I'd like you
to meet somebody.
4222
01:51:40,348 --> 01:51:40,383
4223 01:51:40,383 --> 01:51:43,627
-A friend of mine.
This is, this is Huey.
4224
01:51:43,627 --> 01:51:43,662
4225 01:51:43,662 --> 01:51:45,629
How are you, fellas?
Nice to meet you.
4226
01:51:45,629 --> 01:51:45,664
4227 01:51:45,664 --> 01:51:47,631
That reminds me,
I need to call
Herman Melville.
4228
01:51:47,631 --> 01:51:47,666
4229 01:51:47,666 --> 01:51:49,357
Okay, gentlemen,
you're in the military?
4230
01:51:49,357 --> 01:51:49,392
4231 01:51:49,392 --> 01:51:51,049
I got one for you here. 4232 01:51:51,049 --> 01:51:51,083
4233 01:51:51,083 --> 01:51:53,776
Here you go.
Anyone here know
what this is?
4234
01:51:53,776 --> 01:51:58,953
4235 01:51:58,953 --> 01:52:00,506
I don't know.
What is it? What
is it? What is it?
4236
01:52:00,506 --> 01:52:00,541
4237 01:52:00,541 --> 01:52:02,577
I don't know, either,
but it got me out of the
Marine Corps
4238
01:52:02,577 --> 01:52:02,612
4239 01:52:02,612 --> 01:52:04,752
[ALL LAUGHING]three years early. 4240 01:52:04,752 --> 01:52:04,787
4241 01:52:04,787 --> 01:52:08,307
Yes, thank you.
Matinees at
2:00 and 3:30.
4242
01:52:08,307 --> 01:52:15,901
4243 01:52:15,901 --> 01:52:17,834
Hey. 4244 01:52:17,834 --> 01:52:17,869
4245 01:52:17,869 --> 01:52:20,388
Wait a second.
All right, quiet! Quiet!
You drunken bums of the Caine.
4246
01:52:20,388 --> 01:52:20,423
4247 01:52:20,423 --> 01:52:23,219
You made it! 4248 01:52:23,219 --> 01:52:23,253
4249 01:52:23,253 --> 01:52:27,188
Now quiet! Come on,
here he is, the man of the...
The man of the hour.
4250
01:52:27,188 --> 01:52:28,431
4251 01:52:28,431 --> 01:52:30,295
Greenwald the Magnificent. 4252 01:52:30,295 --> 01:52:32,746
4253 01:52:32,746 --> 01:52:36,784
Now, this
is the man who won
the acquittal.
4254
01:52:36,784 --> 01:52:36,819
4255 01:52:36,819 --> 01:52:38,234
Come on, let's
hear it for him.
4256
01:52:38,234 --> 01:52:38,268
4257 01:52:38,268 --> 01:52:40,995
Yeah! A toast! 4258 01:52:40,995 --> 01:52:41,030
4259 01:52:41,030 --> 01:52:44,723
I'm a little drunk
to be doing Thomas,
the Rhymer tonight.
4260
01:52:44,723 --> 01:52:46,173
4261 01:52:46,173 --> 01:52:48,796
But to honor this
great man, I'll try my best.
4262
01:52:48,796 --> 01:52:49,866
4263 01:52:49,866 --> 01:52:52,351
"To Lieutenant
Barney Greenwald,
4264
01:52:52,351 --> 01:52:52,386
4265 01:52:52,386 --> 01:52:55,113
"who fought with
might and main.
4266
01:52:55,113 --> 01:52:55,147
4267 01:52:55,147 --> 01:52:57,736
"The terror of
judge advocates,
4268
01:52:57,736 --> 01:52:57,771
4269 01:52:57,771 --> 01:52:59,565
"the massive legal brain. 4270 01:52:59,565 --> 01:53:01,084
4271 01:53:01,084 --> 01:53:02,706
"Who hit the Navy
where it lived
4272
01:53:02,706 --> 01:53:02,741
4273 01:53:02,741 --> 01:53:04,329
"and made it
writhe with pain.
4274
01:53:04,329 --> 01:53:05,502
4275 01:53:05,502 --> 01:53:08,851
"Who wrought
the great deliverance
4276
01:53:08,851 --> 01:53:08,885
4277 01:53:08,885 --> 01:53:11,267
"for the galley slaves
of the Caine.
4278
01:53:11,267 --> 01:53:12,751
4279 01:53:12,751 --> 01:53:16,859
"And gave us all
the Fifth freedom.
4280
01:53:16,859 --> 01:53:16,893
4281 01:53:16,893 --> 01:53:19,378
"Freedom from
Old Yellow Stain!"
4282
01:53:19,378 --> 01:53:23,003
4283 01:53:23,003 --> 01:53:24,073
-Speech! 4284 01:53:24,073 --> 01:53:24,107
4285 01:53:24,107 --> 01:53:25,384
-No, no.
-Speech!
4286
01:53:25,384 --> 01:53:25,419
4287 01:53:25,419 --> 01:53:27,007
No, no, I'm drunker
than any of you guys.
4288
01:53:27,007 --> 01:53:27,041
4289 01:53:27,041 --> 01:53:29,319
I've been out drinking
with the judge advocate,
4290
01:53:29,319 --> 01:53:29,354
4291 01:53:29,354 --> 01:53:32,771
tryin' to get him
to take back some of those
dirty names he called me.
4292
01:53:32,771 --> 01:53:32,806
4293 01:53:32,806 --> 01:53:36,085
Finally got him
to shake hands on the
ninth whiskey sour...
4294
01:53:36,085 --> 01:53:36,119
4295 01:53:36,119 --> 01:53:38,328
That's good.
That is good.
4296
01:53:38,328 --> 01:53:38,363
4297 01:53:38,363 --> 01:53:42,263
You know, I played pretty
dirty pool in that court.
What's this?
4298
01:53:42,263 --> 01:53:42,298
4299 01:53:42,298 --> 01:53:44,541
It's a double
celebration.
4300
01:53:44,541 --> 01:53:44,576
4301 01:53:44,576 --> 01:53:48,200
"Multitudes, Multitudes,
by Thomas Keefer."
4302
01:53:48,200 --> 01:53:49,443
4303 01:53:49,443 --> 01:53:51,652
A thousand bucks
came in the mail today.
4304
01:53:51,652 --> 01:53:51,686
4305 01:53:51,686 --> 01:53:53,550
-Advance on my novel.
-Yeah.
4306
01:53:53,550 --> 01:53:53,585
4307 01:53:53,585 --> 01:53:55,587
A thousand bucks, huh? 4308 01:53:55,587 --> 01:53:55,621
4309 01:53:55,621 --> 01:54:01,696
Well, maybe I should return
the toast of our celebrated
novelist's little speech, huh?
4310
01:54:01,696 --> 01:54:01,731
4311 01:54:01,731 --> 01:54:03,112
That was very nice. 4312 01:54:03,112 --> 01:54:03,146
4313 01:54:03,146 --> 01:54:04,596
-Thank you.
-That was very nice.
4314
01:54:04,596 --> 01:54:04,630
4315 01:54:04,630 --> 01:54:06,667
Well, what is it,
a war novel?
4316
01:54:06,667 --> 01:54:06,701
4317 01:54:06,701 --> 01:54:08,772
What else? 4318 01:54:08,772 --> 01:54:08,807
4319 01:54:08,807 --> 01:54:11,672
Yeah. Well,
I bet you give the, give
the Navy a good pasting, huh?
4320
01:54:11,672 --> 01:54:11,706
4321 01:54:11,706 --> 01:54:14,882
Oh, yeah. I don't think
Public Relations
would clear it.
4322
01:54:14,882 --> 01:54:16,677
4323 01:54:16,677 --> 01:54:20,577
Somebody should
show up these stuffy,
stupid Prussians.
4324
01:54:20,577 --> 01:54:20,612
4325 01:54:20,612 --> 01:54:22,234
Who's the hero, you? 4326 01:54:22,234 --> 01:54:22,269
4327 01:54:22,269 --> 01:54:26,618
Well, any resemblance
is purely accidental.
I promise you.
4328
01:54:26,618 --> 01:54:26,652
4329 01:54:26,652 --> 01:54:28,171
Yeah. I'm drunk
and I'm warped,
4330
01:54:28,171 --> 01:54:28,206
4331 01:54:28,206 --> 01:54:31,899
but it certainly seems
to me that if I wrote
a war novel,
4332
01:54:31,899 --> 01:54:31,934
4333 01:54:31,934 --> 01:54:35,040
I'd make
Old Yellow Stain a hero.
4334
01:54:35,040 --> 01:54:35,075
4335 01:54:35,075 --> 01:54:38,457
I would. I would.
I tell you why.
I'm serious.
4336
01:54:38,457 --> 01:54:38,492
4337 01:54:38,492 --> 01:54:39,803
Tell you why. 4338 01:54:39,803 --> 01:54:39,838
4339 01:54:39,838 --> 01:54:43,083
I'm a Jew. I mean,
I guess you all
know that.
4340
01:54:43,083 --> 01:54:43,117
4341 01:54:43,117 --> 01:54:47,087
Jack Challee said I used
smart Jew lawyer tactics,
4342
01:54:47,087 --> 01:54:47,121
4343 01:54:47,121 --> 01:54:49,330
but, you know, anyway, 4344 01:54:49,330 --> 01:54:49,365
4345 01:54:49,365 --> 01:54:52,230
the reason why I'd make
Old Yellow Stain...
4346
01:54:52,230 --> 01:54:52,264
4347 01:54:52,264 --> 01:54:55,198
The reason why I'd make
Old Yellow Stain a hero
4348
01:54:55,198 --> 01:54:55,233
4349 01:54:55,233 --> 01:54:58,305
is on account of my mother,
a little gray-haired...
4350
01:54:58,305 --> 01:54:58,339
4351 01:54:58,339 --> 01:55:00,755
Little, little
gray-haired Jewish lady.
4352
01:55:00,755 --> 01:55:00,790
4353 01:55:00,790 --> 01:55:05,450
Fat, you know.
Of course, you guys
all have mothers,
4354
01:55:05,450 --> 01:55:05,484
4355 01:55:05,484 --> 01:55:08,936
but they wouldn't be
in the same bad shape
as mine would,
4356
01:55:08,936 --> 01:55:08,971
4357 01:55:08,971 --> 01:55:11,490
if we'd lost this war,
you know?
4358
01:55:11,490 --> 01:55:11,525
4359 01:55:11,525 --> 01:55:14,079
I mean, Germans
aren't kidding
about the Jews.
4360
01:55:14,079 --> 01:55:14,114
4361 01:55:14,114 --> 01:55:17,600
They're... They're cookin'
us down to soap over there.
4362
01:55:17,600 --> 01:55:17,634
4363 01:55:17,634 --> 01:55:20,706
You know, they think
we're all vermin,
should be exterminated
4364
01:55:20,706 --> 01:55:20,741
4365 01:55:20,741 --> 01:55:23,640
and our corpses turned
into something useful.
4366
01:55:23,640 --> 01:55:23,675
4367 01:55:23,675 --> 01:55:26,229
Granting the premise,
being warped.
4368
01:55:26,229 --> 01:55:26,264
4369 01:55:26,264 --> 01:55:31,338
I don't, but granting
the premise, soap is as
good as an idea as any.
4370
01:55:31,338 --> 01:55:31,372
4371 01:55:31,372 --> 01:55:36,860
I just... I just can't
cotton to the idea
4372
01:55:36,860 --> 01:55:36,895
4373 01:55:36,895 --> 01:55:41,486
of my mother being cooked
down to a bar of soap.
4374
01:55:41,486 --> 01:55:41,520
4375 01:55:41,520 --> 01:55:44,454
You see. I'm comin' to...
I'm comin' to Yellow Stain.
4376
01:55:44,454 --> 01:55:44,489
4377 01:55:44,489 --> 01:55:48,458
I'm comin' to him.
See, Mr. Keefer,
when I was in law school,
4378
01:55:48,458 --> 01:55:48,493
4379 01:55:48,493 --> 01:55:51,461
and you were writing
your short stories
4380
01:55:51,461 --> 01:55:51,496
4381 01:55:51,496 --> 01:55:54,464
for national magazines 4382 01:55:54,464 --> 01:55:54,499
4383 01:55:54,499 --> 01:55:59,090
and little Willie Keith here
was on the, on the playing
fields of Princeton.
4384
01:55:59,090 --> 01:55:59,124
4385 01:55:59,124 --> 01:56:00,815
What? Princeton?
Cheers to me.
4386
01:56:00,815 --> 01:56:00,850
4387 01:56:00,850 --> 01:56:03,542
All that
time these birds we
call regulars,
4388
01:56:03,542 --> 01:56:03,577
4389 01:56:03,577 --> 01:56:06,131
these stupid,
stuffy Prussians,
4390
01:56:06,131 --> 01:56:06,166
4391 01:56:06,166 --> 01:56:11,792
see, they were standing
guard on this fat, dumb,
happy country of ours.
4392
01:56:11,792 --> 01:56:11,826
4393 01:56:11,826 --> 01:56:14,346
Of course
they were doing it
for dough,
4394
01:56:14,346 --> 01:56:14,381
4395 01:56:14,381 --> 01:56:16,624
but same as everybody
does what they do.
4396
01:56:16,624 --> 01:56:16,659
4397 01:56:16,659 --> 01:56:21,043
But the question is,
the question is in
the last analysis...
4398
01:56:21,043 --> 01:56:21,077
4399 01:56:21,077 --> 01:56:23,493
-Hey, hey, hey, hey.
-Why do you do what
you do for dough?
4400
01:56:23,493 --> 01:56:23,528
4401 01:56:23,528 --> 01:56:26,980
See, you and me,
what we do for dough,
4402
01:56:26,980 --> 01:56:27,014
4403 01:56:27,014 --> 01:56:30,880
we're advancing our free
little non-Prussian careers.
4404
01:56:30,880 --> 01:56:30,914
4405 01:56:30,914 --> 01:56:34,470
So, when all hell
broke loose and the...
4406
01:56:34,470 --> 01:56:34,504
4407 01:56:34,504 --> 01:56:36,679
Germans started
running out of soap,
4408
01:56:36,679 --> 01:56:36,713
4409 01:56:36,713 --> 01:56:42,236
they figured time to
go get Miss Greenwald.
Who's gonna stop 'em?
4410
01:56:42,236 --> 01:56:42,271
4411 01:56:42,271 --> 01:56:47,517
Not her boy, Barney.
Can't stop a Nazi
with a law book.
4412
01:56:47,517 --> 01:56:47,552
4413 01:56:47,552 --> 01:56:50,348
So, I run to
learn how to fly.
4414
01:56:50,348 --> 01:56:50,382
4415 01:56:50,382 --> 01:56:54,904
In the meantime,
it's a year and half
before I was any good.
4416
01:56:54,904 --> 01:56:54,938
4417 01:56:54,938 --> 01:56:58,494
Who is keeping Mama
out of the soap dish?
4418
01:56:58,494 --> 01:56:58,528
4419 01:56:58,528 --> 01:57:02,153
Tom Keefer?
Communication school.
4420
01:57:02,153 --> 01:57:02,187
4421 01:57:02,187 --> 01:57:06,053
Willie Keith? Willie Keith?
Mid-shipmen school.
4422
01:57:06,053 --> 01:57:06,088
4423 01:57:06,088 --> 01:57:11,783
Old Yellow Stain, maybe?
Why, yes, even poor,
sad Queeg.
4424
01:57:11,783 --> 01:57:11,817
4425 01:57:11,817 --> 01:57:13,578
And most of them
not sad at all,
4426
01:57:13,578 --> 01:57:13,612
4427 01:57:13,612 --> 01:57:16,132
fellows, a lot of them
sharper than you and me.
4428
01:57:16,132 --> 01:57:16,167
4429 01:57:16,167 --> 01:57:18,065
Don't kid yourself. 4430 01:57:18,065 --> 01:57:18,100
4431 01:57:18,100 --> 01:57:22,138
You can't be good in
the Army or Navy unless
you're goddamn good.
4432
01:57:22,138 --> 01:57:22,173
4433 01:57:22,173 --> 01:57:23,657
Come on. Come on. 4434 01:57:23,657 --> 01:57:23,691
4435 01:57:23,691 --> 01:57:26,073
Unless you're up on
Finnegans Wakeand
Proust and all of that.
4436
01:57:26,073 --> 01:57:26,108
4437 01:57:26,108 --> 01:57:27,626
Barney, just forget it!
It's all over.
4438
01:57:27,626 --> 01:57:27,661
4439 01:57:27,661 --> 01:57:29,801
This set is a phony... 4440 01:57:29,801 --> 01:57:29,835
4441 01:57:29,835 --> 01:57:32,355
This is a dinner
-for Christ's sake.
-You're guilty!
4442
01:57:32,355 --> 01:57:32,390
4443 01:57:32,390 --> 01:57:34,012
Course, you're
only half guilty.
4444
01:57:34,012 --> 01:57:34,047
4445 01:57:34,047 --> 01:57:37,188
There's another guy
who stayed very neatly
out of the picture.
4446
01:57:37,188 --> 01:57:37,222
4447 01:57:37,222 --> 01:57:40,605
The one who thought
up the whole idea
4448
01:57:40,605 --> 01:57:40,639
4449 01:57:40,639 --> 01:57:43,573
that Queeg was
a dangerous paranoiac,
4450
01:57:43,573 --> 01:57:43,608
4451 01:57:43,608 --> 01:57:46,024
who argued you into
it for half a year,
4452
01:57:46,024 --> 01:57:46,059
4453 01:57:46,059 --> 01:57:48,992
invented the nickname
Old Yellow Stain,
4454
01:57:48,992 --> 01:57:49,027
4455 01:57:49,027 --> 01:57:51,857
had to drag it out
of Steve, Mr. Keefer.
4456
01:57:51,857 --> 01:57:51,892
4457 01:57:51,892 --> 01:57:55,689
Big, dumb fisherman,
trying to tell me it
was all his own idea.
4458
01:57:55,689 --> 01:57:55,723
4459 01:57:55,723 --> 01:57:58,761
Doesn't know the
difference between a
paranoid and an anthropoid.
4460
01:57:58,761 --> 01:57:58,795
4461 01:57:58,795 --> 01:58:01,591
But you knew.
You told him
his medical logs
4462
01:58:01,591 --> 01:58:01,626
4463 01:58:01,626 --> 01:58:04,836
were a clinical
picture of a paranoid.
4464
01:58:04,836 --> 01:58:04,870
4465 01:58:04,870 --> 01:58:08,736
Advised him to go to Halsey.
Offered to go with him.
4466
01:58:08,736 --> 01:58:08,771
4467 01:58:08,771 --> 01:58:10,669
Didn't get cold feet 4468 01:58:10,669 --> 01:58:10,704
4469 01:58:10,704 --> 01:58:13,638
till you were
standing outside Halsey's
cabin in the New Jersey.
4470
01:58:13,638 --> 01:58:13,672
4471 01:58:13,672 --> 01:58:16,261
Then you ducked,
you've been ducking
ever since.
4472
01:58:16,261 --> 01:58:16,296
4473 01:58:16,296 --> 01:58:17,573
Hey, I don't know where
you got all this, Barney.
4474
01:58:17,573 --> 01:58:17,607
4475 01:58:17,607 --> 01:58:19,195
The biggest favor
you could've done Steve
4476
01:58:19,195 --> 01:58:19,230
4477 01:58:19,230 --> 01:58:22,888
as far as winning an
acquittal, though
I doubt you realize it.
4478
01:58:22,888 --> 01:58:22,923
4479 01:58:22,923 --> 01:58:27,652
But if there's a guilty
party at this celebration,
Mr. Keefer, it's you.
4480
01:58:27,652 --> 01:58:27,686
4481 01:58:27,686 --> 01:58:29,930
If you hadn't
filled Steve Maryk's
thick head
4482
01:58:29,930 --> 01:58:29,964
4483 01:58:29,964 --> 01:58:32,588
full of paranoia
-and Article 184.
-I'm not a thick head!
4484
01:58:32,588 --> 01:58:32,622
4485 01:58:32,622 --> 01:58:37,282
...would've got Queeg
to come north or maybe
help the poor bastard
4486
01:58:37,282 --> 01:58:37,317
4487 01:58:37,317 --> 01:58:38,939
-pull through the south.
Hey!
4488
01:58:38,939 --> 01:58:38,973
4489 01:58:38,973 --> 01:58:42,701
That's your
contribution to good
old USA, Mr. Keefer.
4490
01:58:42,701 --> 01:58:42,736
4491 01:58:42,736 --> 01:58:46,602
Pulling a mine-sweeper
out of the south Pacific
when it was most needed.
4492
01:58:46,602 --> 01:58:46,636
4493 01:58:46,636 --> 01:58:49,260
That and
Multitudes, Multitudes!
4494
01:58:49,260 --> 01:58:49,294
4495 01:58:49,294 --> 01:58:51,503
That's it. I think, you're
a little drunk, Barney.
That's what I think!
4496
01:58:51,503 --> 01:58:51,538
4497 01:58:51,538 --> 01:58:55,438
Excuse me, excuse me,
Mr. Keefer. I'm all finished.
I'm up to the toast.
4498
01:58:55,438 --> 01:58:55,473
4499 01:58:55,473 --> 01:58:57,647
-Great.
-Here's to you!
4500
01:58:57,647 --> 01:58:57,682
4501 01:58:57,682 --> 01:59:01,927
You bowled a perfect score.
You went after Queeg
and you got him.
4502
01:59:01,927 --> 01:59:01,962
4503 01:59:01,962 --> 01:59:04,792
Kept your skirts
all white and starchy.
4504
01:59:04,792 --> 01:59:04,827
4505 01:59:04,827 --> 01:59:07,968
You'll publish your novel,
proving the Navy stinks
4506
01:59:07,968 --> 01:59:08,002
4507 01:59:08,002 --> 01:59:11,592
and you'll make
a million bucks and
you'll marry Hedy Lamarr.
4508
01:59:11,592 --> 01:59:11,627
4509 01:59:11,627 --> 01:59:15,389
So you won't mind
a little verbal reprimand
from me. What does it mean?
4510
01:59:15,389 --> 01:59:16,977
4511 01:59:16,977 --> 01:59:21,326
I defended Steve 'cause
I found out the wrong
guy was on trial.
4512
01:59:21,326 --> 01:59:21,361
4513 01:59:21,361 --> 01:59:25,399
Only way to defend him was
to murder Queeg for you.
4514
01:59:25,399 --> 01:59:25,434
4515 01:59:25,434 --> 01:59:28,368
I'm sorry I was
pushed into that spot.
4516
01:59:28,368 --> 01:59:28,402
4517 01:59:28,402 --> 01:59:30,887
I'm ashamed
of what I did.
4518
01:59:30,887 --> 01:59:30,922
4519 01:59:30,922 --> 01:59:32,372
That's why I'm drunk. 4520 01:59:32,372 --> 01:59:34,719
4521 01:59:34,719 --> 01:59:40,173
Queeg deserved better
at my hands. Don't you
see? I owed him a favor!
4522
01:59:40,173 --> 01:59:40,207
4523 01:59:40,207 --> 01:59:44,315
He stopped Hermann Goering
from washing his fat
behind with my mother!
4524
01:59:44,315 --> 01:59:44,349
4525 01:59:44,349 --> 01:59:46,144
Oh, come on. 4526 01:59:46,144 --> 01:59:46,179
4527 01:59:46,179 --> 01:59:48,042
So, no,
Mr. Keefer, I'm not
gonna eat your dinner
4528
01:59:48,042 --> 01:59:48,077
4529 01:59:48,077 --> 01:59:49,768
and I'm not gonna
drink your wine,
4530
01:59:49,768 --> 01:59:49,803
4531 01:59:49,803 --> 01:59:53,082
I'm simply gonna
say my toast and go.
4532
01:59:53,082 --> 01:59:53,116
4533 01:59:53,116 --> 01:59:57,500
Here's to you,
Mr. Caine's
favorite author,
4534
01:59:57,500 --> 01:59:57,535
4535 01:59:57,535 --> 01:59:59,433
and here's to your book. 4536 01:59:59,433 --> 02:00:02,333
4537 02:00:02,333 --> 02:00:03,541
Missed. 4538 02:00:03,541 --> 02:00:06,854
4539 02:00:06,854 --> 02:00:10,479
Why, for the rest of your
life, you'll never wipe
off that yellow stain.
4540
02:00:10,479 --> 02:00:20,454
4541 02:00:20,454 --> 02:00:21,697
Hey, Barney! 4542 02:00:21,697 --> 02:00:21,731
4543 02:00:21,731 --> 02:00:24,044
See you
in Tokyo, mutineer.
4544
02:00:24,044 --> 02:00:24,078
4545 02:00:24,078 --> 02:00:27,185
♪ Old Yellow Stain blues 4546 02:00:27,185 --> 02:00:29,152
4547 02:00:29,152 --> 02:00:30,844
Come on. Come on. 4548 02:00:30,844 --> 02:00:34,296
4549 02:00:34,296 --> 02:00:37,954
You'll get my
second chapter,
it's the second chapter.
4550
02:00:37,954 --> 02:00:37,989
4551 02:00:37,989 --> 02:00:39,404
♪ Look up, look up 4552 02:00:39,404 --> 02:00:39,439
4553 02:00:39,439 --> 02:00:41,026
♪ Look down, look down 4554 02:00:41,026 --> 02:00:41,061
4555 02:00:41,061 --> 02:00:43,408
♪ Give me that ugly crown 4556 02:00:43,408 --> 02:00:45,307
4557 02:00:45,307 --> 02:00:48,758
♪ Come on, take them down 4558 02:00:48,758 --> 02:00:48,793
4559 02:00:48,793 --> 02:00:52,521
♪ I got the Yellow,
I got the Yellow Stain blues
4560
02:00:52,521 --> 02:00:54,523
4561 02:00:54,523 --> 02:00:58,975
This is the romance,
this is the romance part.
4562
02:00:58,975 --> 02:00:59,010
4563 02:00:59,010 --> 02:01:04,187
♪ 'Cause I got some fancy
bootleg brew
4564
02:01:04,187 --> 02:01:04,222
4565 02:01:04,222 --> 02:01:06,742
♪ For all you fellows,
I got some news
4566
02:01:06,742 --> 02:01:06,776
4567 02:01:06,776 --> 02:01:09,434
♪ I've got the
Yellow Stain blues
4568
02:01:09,434 --> 02:01:09,469
4569 02:01:09,469 --> 02:01:10,780
♪ Look up, look up 4570 02:01:10,780 --> 02:01:10,815
4571 02:01:10,815 --> 02:01:12,748
♪ Look down, look down 4572 02:01:12,748 --> 02:01:12,782
4573 02:01:12,782 --> 02:01:16,027
♪ Throw me that
jacket overboard,
I'm going to drown
4574
02:01:16,027 --> 02:01:16,061
4575 02:01:16,061 --> 02:01:18,029
♪ Going under,
somebody help me
4576
02:01:18,029 --> 02:01:18,063
4577 02:01:18,063 --> 02:01:19,858
Chapter seven. 4578 02:01:19,858 --> 02:01:19,893
4579 02:01:19,893 --> 02:01:24,415
♪ I've got the Yellow,
I've got the
Yellow Stain blues
4580
02:01:24,415 --> 02:01:24,449
4581 02:01:24,449 --> 02:01:26,209
This is my bullet wound. 4582 02:01:26,209 --> 02:01:30,006
4583 02:01:30,006 --> 02:01:33,251
♪ And when danger comes
you've got no time to lose
4584
02:01:33,251 --> 02:01:34,804
4585 02:01:34,804 --> 02:01:37,807
♪ If you hear that gun,
baby, start to run
4586
02:01:37,807 --> 02:01:37,842
4587 02:01:37,842 --> 02:01:40,293
♪ You've got
the Yellow Stain blues
4588
02:01:40,293 --> 02:01:40,327
4589 02:01:40,327 --> 02:01:41,466
♪ Get up, get up 4590 02:01:41,466 --> 02:01:41,501
4591 02:01:41,501 --> 02:01:43,019
♪ Don't bend, don't bend 4592 02:01:43,019 --> 02:01:43,054
4593 02:01:43,054 --> 02:01:45,677
♪ What's that
running down my leg?
4594
02:01:45,677 --> 02:01:47,541
4595 02:01:47,541 --> 02:01:49,302
♪ It's all over my shoes 4596 02:01:49,302 --> 02:01:50,372
4597 02:01:50,372 --> 02:01:52,581
♪ It's Yellow 4598 02:01:52,581 --> 02:01:52,615
4599 02:01:52,615 --> 02:01:58,690
♪ It's the
Yellow Stain blues ♪
4600
02:01:58,690 --> 02:02:58,690
393357
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.