All language subtitles for American.Monster.S02E09.The.Craigslist.Killer.1080p.AMZN.WEB-DL.DDP2.0.H.264-NTb_track3_[eng]

BE CAREFUL.

EXCLUSIVE HOME MOVIES
SHOW A GIRL

ENJOYING THE HAPPIEST DAYS
OF HER LIFE...

WE HAD A BIG, PEACEFUL,
HAPPY FAMILY,

AND THERE WERE NO NEGATIVES.

...IN A FAMILY
DEDICATED TO SERVING GOD

AND HELPING THE NEEDY.

♪ HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO YOU ♪

BUT THE LORD'S WORK
CAN BE A DANGEROUS BUSINESS.

PEOPLE WERE LITERALLY
PULLING WEAPONS ON HIM.

HE HAD NO FEAR.

BENEATH THE GOODWILL,
A DARKNESS IS GROWING...

Young man: BROGAN, HIT HIM!

EVIL, DEATH. IT'S ALL I SEEN
IN THAT MAN'S EYES.

...UNTIL IT EXPLODES
IN A WAVE OF VIOLENCE

THAT HORRIFIES THE COMMUNITY.

IT BECAME VERY CLEAR
AT THAT POINT

THAT WE WERE DEALING
WITH A SERIAL KILLER.

AND SOMEWHERE IN THESE VIDEOS

HIDES A GENUINE
AMERICAN MONSTER.

LET ME LOOK IN THERE.

Captions by VITAC--
www.vitac.com

CAPTIONS PAID FOR BY
DISCOVERY COMMUNICATIONS

HOLD ON.
HOLD ON.

IT'S MEMORIAL DAY 1996,

AND THE WEATHER'S PERFECT
FOR A FAMILY TRIP

TO TUSCORA AMUSEMENT PARK
HERE IN NORTHEAST OHIO.

FOR 2-YEAR-OLD TONYA BEASLEY,

IT'S JUST ABOUT
THE BEST PLACE IN THE WORLD.

THAT WAS FUN, HUH?

GRANDMA CAROL
AND HER HUSBAND JIM

ARE CAPTURING
THE ENTIRE FUN-FILLED DAY

IN THIS NEVER-BEFORE-BROADCAST
HOME VIDEO.

OKAY, HERE WE GO.

MY FAMILY SETTLED
IN THE AKRON AREA.

I'VE BEEN THERE MY WHOLE LIFE.

MY MOM HAS LIVED THERE
MOST OF HER WHOLE LIFE,

MY GRANDMA AS WELL.

AND I WAS THE FIRST GRANDCHILD,

SO IT WAS A BIG EVENT
FOR EVERYBODY.

WAS THAT FUN?

I ASKED HER--
I ASKED HER IF SHE WAS SCARED.

SHE SAID, "NO."

THERE THEY GO.

MOM TINA BEASLEY

ENJOYS THE RIDES
ALMOST AS MUCH AS HER DAUGHTER.

WE WERE A HAPPY FAMILY.

I MEAN, THE TIMES
WE HAD WERE FANTASTIC.

WE DONE EVERYTHING
AS A FAMILY UNIT.

NOW THEY'RE GONNA BE ACROBATS.

THERE GOES--
THERE GOES MAMA UP THERE.

LITTLE TONYA'S THRILL-SEEKING

MAY HAVE BEEN INHERITED
FROM MOM AND DAD.

TINA IS A BIG-TIME
MOTORCYCLE FAN,

WHICH IS HOW SHE MET HER HUSBAND
AND TONYA'S FATHER,

RICHARD BEASLEY.

WE WAS
BOTH INTO THE BIKE SCENE,

AND WE WENT TO A CLUB POKER RUN,

AND I HAD AGREED
TO GO TO COFFEE WITH HIM,

AND HE WAS A NICE GUY.

I MEAN, VERY POLITE,
VERY SOFT-SPOKEN,

AN ALL-AROUND GOOD GUY.

DESPITE HIS RUGGED APPEARANCE,

TONYA'S DAD IS
A WELL-LOVED LOCAL FIGURE

IN THEIR HOMETOWN OF AKRON.

HE WAS JUST KNOWN
AS A BIG TEDDY BEAR.

I MEAN, MY DAD'S
A VERY TALL MAN,

HE'S A VERY WIDE MAN,
AND PEOPLE,

INSTEAD OF BEING SCARED BY THAT,
THE WAY HE CARRIED HIMSELF,

IT WAS COMFORTING TO PEOPLE.

AND FOR TINA,
HE'S THE MODEL HUSBAND.

ALL THE BILLS WERE PAID.

ME AND TONYA
DIDN'T WANT FOR NOTHING.

SHE HAD THE BEST BABY THINGS.

I HAD ALL THE CLOTHES
THAT I COULD EVER WANT.

HE JUST BROUGHT SO MUCH JOY.

THERE WERE TIMES WHEN
HE WOULD GRAB MY HANDS,

AND WE WOULD SWING,
AND I LITERALLY FELT

LIKE I WAS FLYING
WHEN I WAS DOING THAT.

BIG SWING, DADDY.
SHE LIKES TO SWING BIG.

THIS HOME MOVIE

CAPTURES A HAPPY FAMILY
IN PERFECT HARMONY.

BUT RICHARD'S ASSOCIATION
WITH AKRON'S BIKER SCENE

WILL COST HIM AND HIS FAMILY.

HE'S INVOLVED
IN AN UNLAWFUL SIDE BUSINESS

SELLING ILLEGAL FIREARMS.

HE DID NOT TELL ME
THE WHOLE TRUTH.

YOU KNOW,
THAT'S A BIG LIE TO TELL.

HE NEVER TOLD ME
HE WAS IN TROUBLE.

A LOT OF HIS CRIMES
WERE ILLEGAL,

BUT IT WAS THINGS
THAT WERE CONSIDERED NORMAL

FOR THE TYPE OF MOTORCYCLE
GROUPS HE HUNG AROUND WITH.

HE WAS NEVER DOING ANYTHING
TO HARM ANYBODY.

HE WAS JUST TRYING
TO SUPPORT HIS FAMILY

AND DID NOT DO IT
IN THE PROPER WAY.

HE'S CHARGED WITH
UNLAWFUL TRANSPORT OF FIREARMS,

AND, IN 1997,

HE'S SENTENCED
TO 7 YEARS IN PRISON.

I JUST KNEW IT WAS
WHERE BAD PEOPLE WENT,

BUT I DIDN'T THINK
IT WAS ANYTHING SERIOUS.

I JUST THOUGHT, "OH,
HE'S GOING TO GO AWAY

FOR A LITTLE BIT,
AND THEN HE'LL BE BACK."

BUT I DIDN'T REALIZE THE EXTENT
OF HOW LONG IT WAS GOING TO BE.

DID YOU LIKE THE PARADE,
TONYA?

WE WENT FROM THIS PEACEFUL,
HAPPY FAMILY,

MY MOM FINALLY HAVING THE BABY

SHE ALWAYS WANTED
WITH THE HUSBAND

SHE ALWAYS WANTED,

TO ALL OF A SUDDEN HAVING TO
RAISE A CHILD ON HER OWN.

THIS IS YOUR BACKYARD, ISN'T IT?

TINA'S MARRIAGE TO
RICHARD ENDS IN DIVORCE,

BUT SHE MAKES SURE HE CONTINUES
TO SEE HIS DAUGHTER.

HE ABSOLUTELY LOVED OUR VISITS,
AND HE WOULD WRITE ME

A LETTER A DAY ALMOST
AND SEND THEM TO ME.

HIS LETTERS AND HIS VISITS
WERE SUPER FUN.

HE TRIED TO MAKE IT AS MUCH OF A
POSITIVE ATMOSPHERE AS HE COULD.

SHE WAS DADDY'S GIRL
AT THAT POINT.

I TOLD HER, "YOU SHOULD
STILL LOVE YOUR DAD.

YOUR DAD STILL LOVES YOU."

I GOT TONYA, AND I'LL GET
A CLOSE-UP OF HER.

HOW OLD ARE YOU, TONYA?

10 GOING ON 11.

TONYA IS AT
HER GRANDMA'S HOUSE

CELEBRATING GRANDPA JIM'S
76th BIRTHDAY,

BUT THE FAMILY GATHERING
IS EXTRA SPECIAL.

AFTER SIX YEARS IN JAIL,
TONYA'S FATHER, RICHARD,

HAS BEEN RELEASED EARLY
FOR GOOD BEHAVIOR.

I GOT A GOOD CLOSE-UP
OF YOU, RICH.

OH, GOOD.
AM I CLEAR?

YES, YOU ARE.

I WASN'T EVEN ABLE
TO PROCESS ANYTHING ELSE,

OTHER THAN THE FACT THAT,

"OH, MY GOSH.
HE'S RIGHT THERE.

HE'S SITTING RIGHT THERE."

RICHARD HAS MOVED
IN WITH HIS MOM...

THERE'S MOM.

...AND HE'S THRILLED
TO BE MAKING UP

FOR LOST TIME WITH HIS DAUGHTER.

YEAH, YEARS AGO
WHEN I WAS JUST A KID.

I'D JUST LOOK OVER AT HIM
AND INSTANTLY BE HAPPY

BECAUSE HE JUST ALWAYS
LOOKED HAPPY, ALL THE TIME.

HE HAD THE OPPORTUNITY

TO CREATE THIS AWESOME LIFE
AGAIN FOR HIMSELF,

AND HE WAS VERY
OPTIMISTIC ABOUT IT,

AND IT RUBBED OFF
ON EVERYONE AROUND HIM.

DURING HIS INCARCERATION,

RICH MADE A DEEP CONNECTION
WITH GOD,

AND HE'S EAGER
TO PROVE TO EVERYONE

THAT HE'S A CHANGED MAN.

EVERY CHILD NEEDS A FATHER,
AND HE HAD SAID HE CHANGED.

HE SAID HE FOUND GOD TRUTHFULLY.

SO I THOUGHT, "WELL,
MAYBE IT IS FOR THE GOOD."

RICHARD'S ROAD TO
REDEMPTION BEGINS WITH A NEW JOB

FOR A TRUCKING COMPANY,

BUT IT'S THE CHURCH
THAT IS NOW HIS PASSION.

PLEASE TAKE OUT YOUR BIBLES.

LET'S READ FROM PSALM 61.

ONE THING IS CLEAR--

RICHARD'S JAILHOUSE
RELIGIOUS EPIPHANY IS FOR REAL.

IT LITERALLY WENT FROM

PRISON BEING HIS LIFE
TO CHURCH LIFE,

AND MY DAD ALWAYS STRONGLY
EMPHASIZED FAITH AND FAMILY.

THE REFORMED EX-CON
BECOMES DEEPLY COMMITTED,

NOT ONLY TO TURNING
HIS LIFE AROUND,

BUT ALSO HELPING
VULNERABLE MEMBERS

OF THE AKRON COMMUNITY

AVOID THE SAME
MISTAKE HE'S MADE.

EVERYTHING HE DID ALWAYS
HAD A PURPOSE OR A CAUSE,

AND HE SEEMED PRETTY
WRAPPED UP IN IT.

AND THAT'S ALL EVERYONE
KNEW HIM FOR,

WAS ALL THE GOOD THINGS
THAT HE HAD DONE.

HE HELPED EVERYBODY.

RICH WOULD GIVE YOU
THE SHIRT OFF OF HIS BACK.

HIS NEWFOUND
DEDICATION TO HELPING OTHERS

STARTS WITH HIS OLD FRIEND
AND BIKER BUDDY

MICHAEL RAFFERTY.

BROGAN,
TIME TO GET UP.

MICHAEL'S A SINGLE FATHER

STRUGGLING TO TAKE CARE
OF HIS 10-YEAR-OLD SON, BROGAN,

WHILE HOLDING DOWN
HIS JOB AS A MACHINIST.

ME AND BROGAN SHARE
THE SAME MOTHER

AND WE HAVE DIFFERENT DADS.

MY MOM STRUGGLED WITH ADDICTION
FROM A VERY YOUNG AGE.

SHE KIND OF LEFT US.

BROGAN AND HIS DAD
LIVE ALONE,

AND BROGAN, A QUIET BOY
WITH FEW FRIENDS,

HAS LEARNED TO FEND
FOR HIMSELF.

HE GOT HIMSELF UP
IN THE MORNING,

HE MADE HIMSELF BREAKFAST,
HE WENT TO SCHOOL,

HE CAME HOME, AND HE READ.

HE READ A LOT.

HEY, BROGAN.

TONYA'S WAITING
OUT IN THE CAR.

COME ON, LET'S GO.

MY DAD WOULD ALWAYS
GO PICK BROGAN UP FOR CHURCH

BECAUSE HE WANTED TO BE
A POSITIVE INFLUENCE.

THE LORD IS MY SHEPHERD...

RICH FIGURES BROGAN
COULD USE A FRIEND,

SOMEONE MORE BUBBLY
AND OUTGOING LIKE TONYA.

BROGAN WAS VERY GENTLE,
IN A SENSE.

LIKE, HE WAS VERY SOFT-SPOKEN,
VERY NICE, VERY KIND.

BROGAN RAFFERTY
SOON BECOMES JUST ANOTHER MEMBER

OF THE BEASLEY FAMILY.

Thank you.

RICH'S DEDICATION TO THE CHURCH
GOES WAY BEYOND SUNDAY SERVICE.

EVERY SPARE MOMENT HE GETS,

HE VOLUNTEERS
OVER AT THE HOPE CAFé,

A CHURCH-RUN CHARITY

IN ONE OF AKRON'S
TOUGHEST NEIGHBORHOODS.

GET A FREE CUP OF COFFEE
AND WEEKLY DINNERS

FOR INDIVIDUALS
WHO WERE HOMELESS,

AND YOU TALK ABOUT THE GOSPEL.

TONYA, COME AND READ SOMETHING
FOR MY BROTHER OVER HERE.

HE AT SOME POINT
OR ANOTHER HAD HELPED OUT

LITERALLY EVERY PERSON
IN THE ROOM,

EMOTIONALLY OR MONETARILY,

AND HE EXPOSED ME TO REAL LIFE,

AND IT JUST GAVE ME THIS VISION
FOR THE REST OF MY LIFE

THAT I WANTED TO BE
EXACTLY LIKE HIM.

DID YOU TELL THEM
ABOUT BREAKFAST?

THE MAN IN THIS HOME
VIDEO HAS BECOME THE FATHER

AND ROLE MODEL TONYA'S
ALWAYS DREAMED OF HAVING.

BUT NO ONE AT THIS
BIRTHDAY CELEBRATION

POSSIBLY HAVE KNOWN

RICHARD'S WORK
HELPING THE COMMUNITY

WILL SPAWN A MONSTER

THAT WILL DESTROY THESE
HAPPY MEMORIES FOREVER.

CAROL, ZOOM IN.
ZOOM IN, UP CLOSE.

TIME TO THROW HER
TO THEM, DADDY!

HERE IN AKRON, OHIO,

RICHARD BEASLEY IS MAKING AMENDS
FOR HIS WAYWARD PAST.

DO YOU SEE
LEO AND CLEO?

THE 2-YEAR-OLD GIRL
SPENDING QUALITY TIME

WITH HER DADDY IN THESE
NEVER-BEFORE-SEEN HOME VIDEOS

IS NOW A TEENAGER.

THEY'D LIKE A NICE LITTLE GIRL
LIKE YOU FOR LUNCH.

BUT TONYA BEASLEY STILL
ENJOYS PRECIOUS TIME WITH DAD.

WE WOULD GO TO THE ZOO
BECAUSE THAT WAS THE THING

WE SHARED FROM THE PAST

THAT WE COULD STILL
KIND OF RELATE OVER,

AND WE WOULD LOOK
AT ALL THE ANIMALS.

AND SINCE IT WAS SO CLOSE,
WE WOULD GO ALL THE TIME.

HIS FUTURE WAS ALL GOING TO BE
ABOUT BEING A DAD

AND BEING THERE FOR ME.

I WAS APPREHENSIVE,
BUT AT THE SAME TIME

I HAD HOPED HE HONESTLY CHANGED
AND WOULD BE A DAD TO HER.

SHE NEEDED A DAD.

AND RICHARD'S DEVOTION
TO HIS DAUGHTER

IS MATCHED ONLY BY
HIS DEVOTION TO THE BIBLE.

THE IMPORTANCE OF SCRIPTURE
IN OUR LIVES HAS GOT TO BE...

HE NOW GIVES SO MUCH
OF HIS TIME TO HELPING THE NEEDY

THAT THE LOCALS
CALL HIM CHAPLAIN RICH.

PEOPLE COME TO ME LIKE, "HEY,
YOU'RE CHAPLAIN RICH'S DAUGHTER.

HE'S A REALLY GOOD GUY."

THE EFFECT IT HAS...

I WAS EXTREMELY PROUD OF HIM, LIKE,

"HE'S GONNA BE
A GOOD GUY PERMANENTLY."

BUT JUST AS RICH SEEMS
TO HAVE HIS LIFE IN ORDER,

CATASTROPHE STRIKES.

DAD?

WHEN HIS CAR
IS HIT BY A TRUCK,

HE'S LUCKY TO COME OUT ALIVE.

HE HAD SNAPPED
HIS ACHILLES TENDON,

AND CRUSHED HIS STERNUM

AND A BUNCH OF OTHER
BACK INJURIES.

HIS JOB AT THE TRUCK
COMPANY IS OVER...

I'M SO SORRY.

...BUT RICHARD BEASLEY
IS DETERMINED

TO TURN A NEGATIVE
INTO A POSITIVE.

USING COMPENSATION MONEY
FROM THE ACCIDENT,

RICH BUYS A LITTLE TWO-STORY
HOUSE OVER ON YALE STREET,

AND THERE CHAPLAIN RICH
DOES SOMETHING REMARKABLE.

COME RIGHT THIS WAY.

HE OPENS HIS DOORS

AND OFFERS SHELTER
TO THOSE WHO NEED IT...

PLACE COULD USE A WOMAN'S TOUCH.

...AKRON'S HOMELESS
AND VULNERABLE.

THIS HERE
IS THE LIVING ROOM.

TO HIM IT WAS PERFECT BECAUSE
HE COULD TAKE THIS HOUSE,

USE HALF OF IT
FOR HIMSELF TO LIVE,

AND THEN AT THE SAME TIME
PROVIDE A HALFWAY HOUSE

TO HELP ALL THESE INDIVIDUALS.

YOU CAN STAY
RIGHT HERE.

BUT HIS TROUBLED TENANTS

ARE OFTEN ESCAPING
DANGEROUS LIVES.

WHO IS IT?

IRIS? WHERE ARE YOU?

SHE AIN'T GOING
WITH YOU, SON.

PEOPLE WERE LITERALLY,
LIKE, THREATENING HIM,

AND PULLING WEAPONS ON HIM,
AND GETTING PHYSICAL WITH HIM.

HE HAD NO FEAR AND NO WORRIES
OTHER THAN HELPING THESE PEOPLE.

THIS HERE IS GOD'S HOUSE,
AND YOU AIN'T COMING IN.

ACROSS TOWN, RICH'S
BEST FRIEND, MIKE RAFFERTY,

HAS HIS OWN PROBLEMS.

THE SINGLE FATHER
IS STRUGGLING TO COPE

WITH HIS NOW
TEENAGE SON, BROGAN.

DAD?
DAD, WHAT ARE YOU DOING?

COME ON, MAN.
THAT'S MY STUFF.

I CAN SEE WHY YOU'RE HIDING
YOUR REPORT CARD.

WHAT THE HELL IS THIS?
WHAT THE HELL IS THIS?

BROGAN WAS, I GUESS, STARTING
TO GET INTO MORE TROUBLE

AT HOME AND AT SCHOOL.

GET YOUR HANDS
OFF MY STUFF.

IN THE ABSENCE
OF HIS DRUG-ADDICTED MOM...

EVERYTHING IN THIS HOUSE
IS MY STUFF!

YOU GOT THAT, BOY?!

...HE IS SUBJECTED TO
HIS DAD'S TOUGH LOVE.

JUST GIVE ME THAT.

- WHERE ARE YOU GOING?!
- WHAT DO YOU CARE?

AND INCREASINGLY

HE TURNS TO MENTOR
CHAPLAIN RICH.

BROGAN COULD CALL HIM
WHEN HE NEEDED ANYTHING.

WHO ELSE COULD BROGAN CALL?

HE COULDN'T CALL HIS DAD.

HIS DAD WAS EITHER
WORKING OR SLEEPING.

HE NEVER KNEW IF MY MOM
WAS GOING TO BE THERE FOR HIM.

RICHARD'S HALFWAY HOUSE

BECOMES BROGAN'S SECOND HOME.

BUT FOR TONYA, IT'S NOW
AN UNWELCOMING ENVIRONMENT.

ARE YOU GOING TO CHURCH LATER?

I DON'T KNOW. MAYBE.

DEPENDS ON UNCLE RICH,
IF HE WANTS TO.

WHERE'S MY DAD?

HAVE YOU SEEN HIM?

I FELT
VERY UNCOMFORTABLE THERE.

THE MEN THAT HE HOUSED,
WHEN HE WASN'T IN THE ROOM,

THEY WOULD MAKE
INAPPROPRIATE COMMENTS.

IT JUST WAS NOT
A POSITIVE ATMOSPHERE.

I MEAN, SHE WANTED TO HAVE
FATHER-DAUGHTER TIME,

BUT THAT'S NOWHERE, TO ME,

FOR A 13,
14-YEAR-OLD GIRL TO BE.

BUT THE CRACKLING
THREAT OF DANGER FROM THE GUESTS

AT CHAPLAIN RICH'S HOUSE

SEEMS TO HAVE THE REVERSE EFFECT
ON YOUNG BROGAN.

NICE GUN.

HE THOUGHT THAT WHEN YOU
GOT AWAY WITH ILLEGAL THINGS

TO MAKE MONEY, IT WAS COOL.

THAT THAT'S HOW YOU'RE
SUPPOSED TO MAKE MONEY.

THAT'S HOW THEY SHOW IT
IN THE TV SHOWS, YOU KNOW?

THROUGH HISTORY, THAT'S HOW
CRIMINALS HAVE MADE MONEY.

MORE THAN EVER, THE
TROUBLED TEEN NEEDS THE GUIDANCE

OF HIS MENTOR,
RICHARD BEASLEY.

OH, A BABY MONKEY.

BUT HIS POSITIVE INFLUENCE

IS ABOUT TO COME
TO AN ABRUPT END.

TEENAGE TONYA WILL RECEIVE
A SURPRISE VOICEMAIL

FROM HER FATHER.

ALLS IT REALLY SAID
WAS SOMETHING ABOUT HOW

HE'D BE OUT OF TOWN
AND I WON'T BE ABLE

TO GET HOLD OF HIM FOR A WHILE,
BUT HE REALLY LOVES ME.

ALL AT ONCE, HE JUST
DROPPED OUT OF SIGHT.

THERE GOES DAD AND TONYA
INTO THE BUTTERFLY HOUSE.

THE GOOD SAMARITAN
WHO OVERCAME HIS DARK PAST

TO BECOME A BEACON OF LIGHT
IS GONE,

HIS WHEREABOUTS A MYSTERY.

AND THE MYSTERY WILL DEEPEN
IN THE MOST TERRIFYING WAY.

I SHOULD HAVE KNOWN
THE SECOND HE ENTERED MY DOOR

SOMETHING WAS WRONG.

HAPPY MEMORIES
OF A FAMILY DAY OUT

CAPTURED ON NEWLY DISCOVERED
HOME-MOVIE FOOTAGE.

WHO'S THIS GUY?

IT'S 1996,

AND TONYA BEASLEY
CAN ALWAYS TURN TO DAD, RICHARD,

WHEN SHE NEEDS A HUG.

HERE COMES
THE NICE CLOWNS.

THEIR SPECIAL BOND
WILL LAST ANOTHER 15 YEARS

UNTIL RICHARD
MYSTERIOUSLY DISAPPEARS.

HE DID HAVE A FRIEND
IN SOUTHERN OHIO

THAT HE ALWAYS TALKED ABOUT,
THAT HAD A WHOLE BUNCH OF LAND,

SO I JUST FIGURED
HE WAS STAYING THERE.

WHAT DO YOU SEE, HUH?

LET ME LOOK IN THERE.

FOUR MONTHS AFTER
RICHARD'S DISAPPEARANCE,

100 MILES AWAY,
POLICE GET A 911 CALL.

YEAH, I HAD GOT A CALL
LATE ON THE EVENING,

NOVEMBER 6th, 2011.

THE SHERIFF HAD CALLED ME
TO INFORM ME

THAT THEY HAD HAD
A SHOOTING.

THE SHERIFF
THOUGHT IT WAS PRETTY STRANGE.

THE VICTIM
IS A 50-YEAR-OLD MAN.

HE'S BEEN SHOT IN THE ARM.

DETECTIVE MACKIE PAYS HIM
A VISIT IN THE HOSPITAL.

WHY DON'T YOU TELL ME
WHAT HAPPENED.

HIS NAME IS SCOTT DAVIS, AND HE
HAS AN INCREDIBLE STORY TO TELL.

SO I GOT INTO
TOWN YESTERDAY.

SCOTT SAYS HE DROVE UP YESTERDAY
FROM SOUTH CAROLINA

IN RESPONSE TO A JOB ADVERTISED
ON CRAIGSLIST.

IT SAID 688 ACRES, $300 A WEEK,
FREE ROOM AND BOARD.

I WAS LIKE,
"THAT DON'T SOUND BAD."

HEY, JACK.
IT'S SCOTT.

HE ARRANGED TO MEET
HIS NEW BOSS,

SOMEONE NAMED JACK,

AT A DINER IN A SMALL TOWN ON
THE OHIO-WEST VIRGINIA BORDER.

OKAY, BUDDY.

ALL HIS BELONGINGS
ARE PACKED

INTO THE BACK OF HIS CAR,
READY TO BEGIN A NEW LIFE.

THE FIRST TIME
THAT I HAD MET JACK,

HE JUST LOOKED LIKE
A NORMAL FARMER GUY.

HE HAD ON, YOU KNOW,
JEANS AND LEATHER JACKET.

JUST LOOKED LIKE
A NORMAL JOE TO ME.

JACK'S NEPHEW IS ALSO THERE

TO HELP SCOTT MOVE HIS STUFF
INTO THE FARMSTEAD.

BUT FIRST, THEY EAT BREAKFAST.

"GET WHATEVER YOU WANT, MAN.

WHATEVER YOU'RE HUNGRY FOR."

THE ALL-YOU-CAN-EAT MENU
OR WHATEVER.

AFTER EATING,
THEY RIDE OUT

TO THE PROPERTY TOGETHER
IN JACK'S TRUCK.

WE WENT UP OVER GULLIES,
AND THERE WAS A COUPLE TIMES

I THOUGHT WE WERE
GOING TO GO OFF.

IT WAS JUST THAT NARROW.

THE ROAD BECOMES
IMPASSABLE, SO JACK PULLS OVER.

WE STARTED WALKING BACK
IN THE WOODS,

AND AT THAT POINT THE KID
DROVE OFF IN THE CAR.

I WAS SEEING THE WOODS
GETTING THICKER

AND THEY'RE GETTING THICKER.

THIS IS REAL COUNTRY OUT HERE.
I MEAN, THERE'S NOTHING AROUND.

HE SAID, "YOU KNOW SOMETHING?"

HE SAID, "THIS MUST
BE THE WRONG SPOT."

MY FIRST MISTAKE WAS
WHEN I TURNED MY BACK ON HIM.

AND AS SOON AS I TURNED AROUND,
I HEARD CLICK.

THE GUN MUST'VE MISFIRED
OR SOMETHING

BECAUSE WHEN I TURNED AROUND,

THAT GUN
WAS ALREADY COMING BACK UP.

THAT'S WHEN I LOOKED AT HIM.

EVIL. THAT'S ALL I SEEN
IN THAT MAN'S EYES.

AND I MEAN I WAS
FIVE FEET AWAY FROM HIM

AND THEY WERE JUST--
NOTHING THERE, EMPTY.

ALL I HEAR
IS BANG, BANG, BANG, BANG.

I'M TRYING TO GET AWAY.
I SCAMPERED FOR MY LIFE.

IT'S ONLY WHEN SCOTT HIDES

THAT HE NOTICES HE'S WOUNDED.

SCOTT STAYS HIDDEN FOR THE NEXT
7 HOURS, BLEEDING AND EXHAUSTED,

UNTIL HE CAN TAKE NO MORE
AND MAKES A RUN FOR IT.

I'VE BEEN SHOT.
CAN YOU HELP ME?

THE OUTLANDISH STORY
SOUNDS LIKE

IT'S RIPPED STRAIGHT FROM
THE PAGES OF A THRILLER.

BUT IF SCOTT'S
TELLING THE TRUTH,

THEN DETECTIVE MACKIE'S

GOT A TRIGGER-HAPPY MADMAN
ON HIS HANDS.

AT THAT POINT, WE DIDN'T
KNOW WHERE THE CRIME SCENE WAS.

SO AT THE ONSET, WE DIDN'T HAVE
A LOT OF INFORMATION.

THE DETECTIVE STARTS HIS
INVESTIGATION AT THE PARKING LOT

WHERE SCOTT MET JACK
AND HIS NEPHEW.

SCOTT'S CAR IS RIGHT
WHERE HE LEFT IT

PACKED FULL OF HIS BELONGINGS.

I FOUND A NOTE IN THERE
WHERE HE HAD WROTE DOWN

"SHONEY'S, MARIETTA, OHIO,
9:00 A.M.,"

WHICH CORROBORATES HIS STORY.

A SHONEY'S DINER

IS WHERE SCOTT CLAIMED
THE MEN ATE BREAKFAST.

I IMMEDIATELY GOT IN CONTACT

WITH THE MANAGEMENT OF SHONEY'S

AND REQUESTED
THEIR SURVEILLANCE VIDEOS.

RETRIEVING THE FILES
TAKES TIME,

SO DETECTIVE MACKIE
HAS A WAIT ON HIS HANDS.

BUT THERE COULD BE
AN IMMEDIATE SOLUTION

TO FINDING SCOTT'S ATTACKERS.

THEY HAVE LEFT
A DIGITAL FOOTPRINT.

WE HAD THE CRAIGSLIST AD,

AND WE HAD A PHONE NUMBER.

FINDING THE SOURCE WAS PARAMOUNT
TO THE CASE AT THAT POINT.

I'D LIKE YOU TO TRACE
AN I.P. FOR ME.

I'LL SEND YOU THE LINK SO YOU
CAN SEE WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT.

IN THE CYBER CRIMES UNIT,

THE FBI IS SET UP TO GET THIS
INFORMATION VERY QUICKLY.

DETECTIVE MACKIE
ENLISTS THE HELP OF THE FBI.

THEY CAN TRACE JACK'S PHONE
NUMBER AND THE EXACT LOCATION

OF THE COMPUTER
THAT UPLOADED THE CRAIGSLIST AD.

THIS WAS URGENT,

THAT WE NEEDED TO LOCATE
WHOEVER PLACED THIS AD

AS QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE.

AT THAT POINT WE WERE JUST
WAITING FOR A BREAK IN THE CASE.

TONYA BEASLEY IS ALSO WAITING

TO HEAR FROM HER FATHER, RICHARD.

HE'S BEEN MISSING FROM AKRON
FOR FOUR MONTHS.

ALL THOSE YEARS OF TRYING

TO MAKE THIS RELATIONSHIP
WITH HIM,

ALL FOR IT TO JUST BE GONE
JUST LIKE THAT.

AND SHE'S NOT
THE ONLY ONE AFFECTED

BY RICH'S DISAPPEARANCE.

BROGAN RAFFERTY, THE HIGH SCHOOL
KID RICHARD'S BEEN MENTORING,

IS GETTING INTO TROUBLE
AT SCHOOL,

AS SHOWN IN THIS SHOCKING,
NEVER-BEFORE-BROADCAST VIDEO.

Young man: BROGAN, HIT HIM!

OH! OH!

BROGAN, AT OVER 6 FEET
AND DRESSED ALL IN BLACK,

IS A PHYSICALLY
IMPOSING PRESENCE.

HE REMAINS A MYSTERY,
EVEN TO HIS FAMILY.

Young man: OH!

HE DIDN'T TELL PEOPLE
HIS PROBLEMS.

OF COURSE HE NEVER WOULD.
HE'S GOT THAT STRAIGHT FACE.

HE'S GOT A GREAT POKER FACE.

HE STILL HAD THIS KIND OF WALL
AROUND HIM.

HE DIDN'T SEEM TO
REALLY LIKE PEOPLE.

HE DIDN'T TRUST PEOPLE.

"YOU WHACK 'EM,"
IS WHAT HE USED TO SAY.

LIKE, LITERALLY, YOU JUST BEAT
UP THE PERSON OR KILL THEM.

NOBLE COUNTY DETECTIVES

CONTINUE THEIR SEARCH FOR
THE MAN WHO SHOT SCOTT DAVIS,

AND FIVE DAYS
AFTER THE INCIDENT,

THEY RECEIVE
A MISSING PERSONS REPORT

THAT LIGHTS A FIRE
UNDER THE INVESTIGATION.

HELLO.

MY BROTHER'S GONE MISSING.

A DISTRAUGHT WOMAN
BY THE NAME OF DEBORAH BRUCE

HAS A DISTRESSINGLY FAMILIAR
STORY TO TELL.

SHE STATED THAT HER BROTHER,
DAVID PAULEY, HAD RESPONDED

TO AN AD ON CRAIGSLIST
BACK IN OCTOBER,

AND THE LAST CONVERSATION
SHE HAD WITH HIM

WAS THAT HE HAD
TO GO MEET HIS EMPLOYERS

FOR BREAKFAST
THE FOLLOWING MORNING.

THE SIMILARITIES WITH
SCOTT DAVIS' STORY ARE ALARMING.

SAME CRAIGSLIST AD,
SAME EMPLOYER,

SAME PHONE NUMBER.

THE ONLY DIFFERENCE
IN THIS CASE IS,

WE HAVEN'T HEARD
FROM DAVID PAULEY.

WE'VE HEARD FROM SCOTT DAVIS.

I KNEW AT THAT POINT WE PROBABLY
HAD A REAL PROBLEM.

AS THE LIST OF
POTENTIAL VICTIMS GROWS,

DETECTIVES WILL SOON DISCOVER

THE SHOCKING CONNECTION
BETWEEN THE CRAIGSLIST KILLER

AND MISSING CHAPLAIN
RICHARD BEASLEY.

I GOT A GOOD CLOSE-UP
OF YOU, RICH.

OH, GOOD.

AKRON, OHIO, 2004,

AND RICHARD BEASLEY
PLAYS THE DOTING FATHER

AND PERFECT ROLE MODEL
FOR DAUGHTER TONYA.

EVERYONE ALWAYS CALLED HIM

THE REAL-LIFE SANTA CLAUS

BECAUSE HE HAD
THE LONG WHITE HAIR

AND THE LONG BEARD,

AND HE JUST BROUGHT
SO MUCH JOY TO PEOPLE.

EVERYBODY'S LIVES
THAT HE TOUCHED, HE MADE BETTER,

AND THERE WERE NO NEGATIVES.

BUT AFTER SIX YEARS
AS AKRON'S GOOD SAMARITAN,

RICHARD HAS VANISHED.

THERE WAS NO CONTACT.

I HADN'T HEARD ANYTHING
ABOUT HIM, FROM HIM.

IT WAS STILL THIS EMPTY HOLE
THAT HE HAD LEFT.

DOWN SOUTH IN NOBLE COUNTY,

MEN MATCHING
RICHARD'S DESCRIPTION

ARE FALLING VICTIM
TO A DEADLY CRAIGSLIST AD.

SCOTT DAVIS SURVIVED
AN ATTEMPT ON HIS LIFE.

I'VE BEEN SHOT.

NOW DETECTIVES ARE SEARCHING

FOR ANOTHER
POTENTIAL VICTIM.

KEEP YOUR EYES OPEN.
LOOK FOR DISTURBED SOIL.

ANYTHING THAT LOOKS
OUT OF PLACE, OKAY?

ANOTHER
DOWN-ON-HIS-LUCK MIDDLE-AGED MAN

HAS BEEN MISSING SINCE APPLYING
FOR THE SAME FAKE JOB.

HIS NAME, DAVID PAULEY.

HAVE A GOOD LOOK AT THAT.

PASS IT AROUND.
EVERYONE HAVE A LOOK.

NOW, WE KNOW SCOTT DAVIS
WAS LURED TO THIS REMOTE AREA

WHERE HE WAS SHOT.

AT THAT POINT, WE COULD
ONLY ASSUME THAT DAVID PAULEY

PROBABLY WENT THROUGH
A SIMILAR SITUATION,

BUT HE DIDN'T ESCAPE.

LET'S GET GOING.
LET'S GO.

I PLANNED A SEARCH OF THE AREA
NEAR WHERE SCOTT DAVIS WAS SHOT.

THIS INVOLVED LINING UP
CADAVER DOGS,

ADDITIONAL SEARCH MEMBERS,
ADDITIONAL INVESTIGATORS.

IT'S MOSTLY WOODED,
VERY REMOTE.

IT WAS LIKE TRYING TO FIND
A NEEDLE IN A HAYSTACK.

WE HAD ONE OF THE CADAVER DOGS
INDICATE ON AN AREA.

AND IN THE GRASS
THEY FIND SOMETHING.

THE DOG ACTUALLY BEGAN
TO DIG A LITTLE BIT,

AND, ULTIMATELY,
WE LOCATED A BODY.

UPON EXCAVATING THE AREA
AND EXHUMING THE BODY,

IT APPEARED TO ME THAT IT WAS
A GUNSHOT WOUND TO THE HEAD.

THE BODY CARRIES NO I.D.,

BUT DETECTIVES ALREADY
HAVE A STRONG IDEA

OF WHO THIS MAN IS.

YEAH.
THIS SILVER CHAIN, THAT'S RIGHT.

I HAD TO MAKE A CALL
TO DEBORAH BRUCE.

I ASKED HER ABOUT THIS BRACELET.

YEAH.

DEBORAH CONFIRMS
THAT THE CHAIN IS HER BROTHER'S.

IT LOOKED LIKE WHAT HAD
HAPPENED TO DAVID PAULEY

IS WHAT THEY HAD INTENDED
TO HAPPEN TO SCOTT DAVIS,

THAT THIS WAS A SUCCESSFUL
MURDER, EXECUTION, AND BURIAL.

I'M AFRAID I'VE GOT
SOME TERRIBLE NEWS.

THE BODY OF DAVID PAULEY

WAS FOUND BURIED IN THE WOODS
NEAR CALDWELL THIS MORNING.

THE 51-YEAR-OLD'S BEEN MISSING
FOR THREE MONTHS

AFTER APPLYING
FOR A FARM JOB ON CRAIGSLIST,

THE SAME JOB AD THAT LURED
SCOTT DAVIS TO THE SAME WOODS

BEFORE HE WAS SHOT
FIVE DAYS AGO.

IT BECAME VERY CLEAR
AT THAT POINT THAT

WE WERE PROBABLY DEALING
WITH A SERIAL KILLER.

AND INVESTIGATORS COULD BE

A STEP CLOSER TO
IDENTIFYING HIM.

THEY NOW HAVE ACCESS TO THE
FOOTAGE FROM THE SHONEY'S DINER

WHERE THE KILLER BROUGHT HIS
VICTIMS BEFORE HE ATTACKED.

AND AROUND 9:45 A.M.,
SCOTT DAVIS ENTERS WITH JACK

AND HIS YOUNG ACCOMPLICE.

THE BEST PICTURE
WE HAVE OF THEM

IS STANDING IN THE LOBBY AREA,
WAITING TO BE SEATED.

I NOTICED IN THE PICTURE THAT
THE OLDER GENTLEMAN WAS WEARING

A BLACK LEATHER JACKET
WHICH WAS PRETTY SPECIFIC.

AND THEN THERE WAS A
MUCH YOUNGER WHITE MALE ALSO.

WHILE DETECTIVE MACKIE
HAS UNCOVERED THE FACES

OF THE SUSPECTS,

THE FBI HAVE MADE
THEIR OWN VITAL BREAKTHROUGH.

THEY'VE TRACED THE LOCATION
OF THE E-MAIL ADDRESS

USED TO CREATE
THE CRAIGSLIST AD.

THE TWO MEN IN THE DINER CCTV
SET UP THEIR DEADLY OPERATION

FROM A HOUSE 100 MILES NORTH...

...IN AKRON.

HELLO?

- YEAH?
- GOOD DAY, SIR.

ARE YOU THE OWNER
OF THESE PREMISES?

YEAH, I AM.

WE HAVE A SEARCH WARRANT
FOR THE PREMISES.

WHAT THEY FIND THERE
IS A MAN WHO SAYS

HE HAS BEEN RENTING
ONE OF HIS ROOMS.

WHEN SHOWN A STILL
OF JACK FROM THE CCTV FOOTAGE,

HE RECOGNIZES HIS TENANT.

YEAH, HE RENTS
THAT ROOM OVER THERE.

BUT THE LANDLORD KNOWS HIM
BY ANOTHER NAME.

UPON SEARCHING THE ROOM,
THEY FIND, LIKE,

SOME PRESCRIPTION DRUGS,

DIFFERENT THINGS
WITH THE NAME RALPH GEIGER.

THIS RALPH GEIGER
IS NOT AT HOME,

BUT FINDING HIM
IS NOW TOP PRIORITY.

SO IT DEFINITELY TOOK
THE INVESTIGATION

TO A WHOLE NOTHER LEVEL.

THE PACE WAS ALREADY
PRETTY QUICK,

BUT WE GO EVEN FASTER NOW.

WITH THE HUNT ON
FOR RALPH GEIGER

AND HIS YOUNG ACCOMPLICE,

DETECTIVE MACKIE HEADS NORTH
TO AKRON.

THE FBI HAVE A NEW LEAD.

THE CELLPHONE USED
TO CALL VICTIM SCOTT DAVIS

HAS BEEN TRACED
TO A HIGH SCHOOL KID.

IS THIS YOU WITH SCOTT DAVIS
DOWN AT SHONEY'S DINER?

THE YOUNG MAN IN THE CCTV STILL
IS A MATCH FOR BROGAN RAFFERTY.

I DON'T KNOW.

HE WAS VERY ARROGANT.

IT WAS VERY CLEAR THAT HE KNEW
HE DIDN'T HAVE TO TALK TO US

IF HE DIDN'T WANT TO.

- YOU DON'T KNOW?
- MAYBE.

WELL, WHY DON'T YOU THINK
ABOUT THAT, LET ME KNOW.

UPON SEARCHING BROGAN'S HOUSE,

WE FIND MANY ITEMS THAT APPEAR
TO BE ITEMS

THAT DAVID PAULEY HAD BROUGHT
WITH HIM FROM VIRGINIA

WHEN HE CAME HERE.

- BROGAN?
- IT'S NOTHING, DAD.

TO MICHAEL RAFFERTY'S
SHOCK AND HORROR,

THE POLICE TAKE
HIS SON INTO CUSTODY.

...DOWN TO THE STATION
FOR A FEW WORDS

IN CONNECTION
WITH A MURDER.

MURDER?

BROGAN, HE'S 16.

"WHAT DO YOU MEAN HE'S
BEEN ARRESTED FOR MURDER?

MY BROGAN?

THAT'S NOT TRUE."

BUT THE EVIDENCE
GATHERED FROM HIS BEDROOM

TIES HIM TO THE VICTIMS.

WE LOCATED A SHOTGUN,
A HANDGUN.

THESE WERE LOCATED
IN BROGAN'S ROOM.

SOME OTHER ITEMS IN THERE, BUT
IT APPEARED TO BE A KILLING KIT.

AND SCOTT DAVIS
CONFIRMS THAT BROGAN RAFFERTY

IS THE KID WHO DROVE HIM
TO THE WOODS.

THEY HAD ME LOOK
AT PICTURES TO SEE, YOU KNOW,

WHO BROGAN WAS AND,
YOU KNOW, POINT HIM OUT

TO MAKE SURE
THEY HAD THE RIGHT KID,

AND I SAID, "YEAH. THAT'S HIM."

UPON BROGAN'S ARREST, AND THEN
THE SUBSEQUENT INTERVIEW

THE NEXT DAY, YOU KNOW,

BROGAN ADMITS
TO BEING INVOLVED

IN THE SHOOTING SCOTT DAVIS.

HE ADMITS TO BEING INVOLVED
IN THE DEATH OF DAVID PAULEY.

WITH ONE MAN IN CUSTODY,

THE NET IS CLOSING IN
ON THE CRAIGSLIST KILLERS,

AND RALPH GEIGER'S LANDLORD
CONTACTS POLICE

WITH A VITAL NEW LEAD.

WE HAD A CALL FROM
THIS HOMEOWNER SAYING, "HEY.

I RETURNED HOME A LITTLE BIT AGO

AND THERE'S A NOTE ON THE DOOR
FROM MY RENTER SAYING,

'HEY, WHAT'S GOING ON?
I HEARD THE COPS WERE HERE.'"

AND HE LEFT A CELLPHONE NUMBER.

YEP.
CONFIRMED.

IT'S ALL THE FBI NEED
TO PINPOINT THE EXACT LOCATION

OF WHO THEY THINK TO BE
THE SECOND CRAIGSLIST KILLER.

- STOP MOVING!
- GET DOWN! GET DOWN!

LET ME SEE YOUR HANDS!

IT WAS LIKE A SCENE
OUT OF TELEVISION.

TWO OR THREE BLOCKS SHUT DOWN
AND SWAT TEAMS EVERYWHERE.

YOU'RE UNDER ARREST
FOR MURDER.

THE MYSTERY OF
RICHARD BEASLEY'S DISAPPEARANCE

IS ABOUT TO BE UNRAVELED.

HANDS TO YOUR SIDE!
DO IT NOW!

COPS HAVE CAUGHT UP WITH
THE SECOND CRAIGSLIST KILLER.

YOU'RE RALPH GEIGER?

HE'S BEEN GOING BY
THE NAME OF RALPH GEIGER,

BUT ON CAPTURE,
THE NAME TURNS OUT TO BE A LIE.

YOU'RE UNDER ARREST
FOR MURDER.

FOR TONYA BEASLEY,

THE WHEREABOUTS OF HER FATHER,
RICHARD, IS A MYSTERY.

THE MIDDLE-AGED CHAPLAIN
WHO FITS THE DESCRIPTION

OF THE CRAIGSLIST VICTIMS HAS
BEEN MISSING FOR FOUR MONTHS,

BUT TONYA IS ABOUT TO
DISCOVER THE TERRIBLE TRUTH

SURROUNDING HIS DISAPPEARANCE.

ARE YOU TONYA BEASLEY?

YEAH.

DETECTIVE MACKIE.

I'M HERE TO TALK TO YOU
ABOUT RICHARD BEASLEY.

AT FIRST
I WAS A LITTLE BIT TAKEN ABACK

BECAUSE I DIDN'T KNOW
WHO THIS MAN WAS

OR WHY HE KNEW MY NAME,

BUT HE WAS THERE
TO TALK ABOUT MY DAD.

WHEN LAST
DID YOU SEE HIM?

I DON'T KNOW.
WELL, I CAN'T REMEMBER.

YEAH.
THAT'S MY DAD.

THE MAN KNOWN TO
INVESTIGATORS AS RALPH GEIGER

IS NONE OTHER
THAN RICHARD BEASLEY...

YOU'RE UNDER ARREST
FOR MURDER.

...THE REFORMED CONVICT
WHO CONVINCED HIS DAUGHTER

HE WAS A CHANGED MAN

NEVER DID GIVE UP
HIS LIFE OF CRIME.

THE HALFWAY HOUSE HE OPENED
TO SHELTER THE VULNERABLE

WAS IN FACT A BROTHEL
AND DRUG-DEALING OPERATION.

AND WHEN POLICE FOUND OUT,

RICHARD WENT ON THE RUN,
ASSUMING THE NAME RALPH GEIGER

NOW HE'S IN CUSTODY FOR CRIMES
FAR GREATER THAN DEALING DRUGS.

DID MY DAD
KILL SOMEBODY?

YOU HAVE THIS INTUITION,
AND I JUST KNEW.

I MEAN, IT WAS JUST
A TOTAL COMPLETE SHOCK.

IT WAS JUST UNBELIEVABLE THAT
SOMEONE THAT COULD BE SO NICE,

DONE SOMETHING SO HIDEOUS.

WHEN I THINK OF
ALL THE MEMORIES, LIKE,

THAT WE DID HAVE OF DOING THINGS
WITH THE CHURCH,

WHERE THINGS FINALLY STARTED
TO FEEL NORMAL,

BUT THEN I REALIZE
THAT ALL THOSE NORMAL THINGS

WERE A COVER
FOR WHAT HE WAS REALLY DOING

AND I WAS JUST THE IDIOT
WHO WAS COMPLETELY OBLIVIOUS.

I HAD NO IDEA.

IT'S ALMOST LIKE THERE'S SO MUCH
GOING THROUGH YOUR BRAIN

THAT YOU CAN'T EVEN PROCESS IT.

SO YOU START QUESTIONING
ALL OF THE INTERACTIONS

THAT YOU'VE EVER HAD WITH HIM.

NOW IN POLICE CUSTODY,

RICHARD IS GRILLED
BY DETECTIVE MACKIE

ABOUT HIS MEETING
WITH VICTIM SCOTT DAVIS.

RICHARD CLAIMS HE'S INNOCENT,
BUT THERE'S A WITNESS

WHO'S BEEN BY HIS SIDE
FOR THE LAST FOUR MONTHS.

INVESTIGATORS OFFER RICHARD'S
YOUNG ACCOMPLICE A DEAL.

IF BROGAN RAFFERTY
TELLS EVERYTHING,

THE CHARGES AGAINST HIM
WILL BE REDUCED.

AND DURING THE MURDER TRIAL,

HE TESTIFIES AGAINST
HIS FRIEND AND MENTOR.

WAS THERE
A POINT IN YOUR LIFE

WHEN YOUR OPINION
OF RICHARD BEASLEY HAD CHANGED?

ABSOLUTELY.

AND WHEN WAS THAT?

THAT WAS THE MORNING THAT HE
MURDERED A MAN IN FRONT OF ME.

WHAT WAS HIS NAME?

I FOUND OUT AFTERWARDS THAT
HIS NAME WAS MR. RALPH GEIGER.

RALPH GEIGER
WAS THE FIRST VICTIM

OF THE CRAIGSLIST KILLERS.

FUGITIVE RICH BEASLEY
COULDN'T FACE THE PROSPECT

OF ANOTHER STINT IN JAIL,

SO HE DECIDED TO
CHANGE HIS IDENTITY.

THEY HAD LOCATED
THIS MAN, RALPH GEIGER.

RALPH HAD BEEN HOMELESS.
HE WAS KIND OF DOWN ON HIS LUCK.

AND HE BORE A STRIKING
RESEMBLANCE TO RICHARD BEASLEY.

AFTER RALPH GEIGER'S DEATH,

RICHARD BEASLEY
BECAME RALPH GEIGER.

SHOULD I ADD IN
THE HECTARES FOR HOW IT IS?

WITH THEIR FIRST
MURDER A SUCCESS,

RICHARD AND BROGAN
REPEAT THE SCAM.

ADVERTISING ON CRAIGSLIST,

THEIR FAKE JOB OFFER IS
DESIGNED TO TRAP

DESPERATE MIDDLE-AGED MEN
CARRYING ALL THEIR BELONGINGS

IN SEARCH OF A NEW LIFE.

THEY KILLED DAVID PAULEY
AND SOLD HIS POSSESSIONS

FOR A FEW THOUSAND DOLLARS.

AND THE FAILED ATTEMPT ON
SCOTT DAVIS' LIFE PUSHED RICHARD

TO TAKE A FOURTH VICTIM.

TIMOTHY KERN WAS SHOT DEAD

JUST DAYS BEFORE
THE KILLERS WERE ARRESTED.

AND THEY TAKE HIM OUT
AND THEY EXECUTE HIM

AND BURY HIM IN A SHALLOW GRAVE
FOR $5 AND A PACK OF CIGARETTES.

BROGAN RAFFERTY CLAIMS
HIS ROLE WAS MOTIVATED

BY A CRIPPLING FEAR
AND THAT RICHARD BEASLEY

THREATENED TO HARM BROGAN'S
FAMILY IF HE DIDN'T PLAY ALONG.

BUT THE JURY DECIDED

THAT BROGAN WAS A WILLING
PARTICIPANT IN THE CRIMES.

THE JURY FINDS YOU GUILTY
OF AGGRAVATED MURDER.

IS THERE ANYTHING THAT THE WORLD
SHOULD KNOW ABOUT YOU?

IN NOVEMBER OF 2012,

HE'S FOUND GUILTY
OF AGGRAVATED MURDER

AND ATTEMPTED MURDER.

HE RECEIVES LIFE WITH NO PAROLE.

WHAT DO YOU HAVE TO SAY
TO THOSE FAMILIES?

I'M SORRY.

I THINK
THAT'S WHEN IT, LIKE, HIT

THAT HE WOULDN'T BE
AT MY BIRTHDAY PARTIES.

HE WOULDN'T BE THERE
WHEN MY KID WAS BORN.

HE WOULDN'T BE THERE AT
MY WEDDING, ANYTHING LIKE THAT.

FOR MASTERMINDING THE KILLINGS,

RICHARD BEASLEY RECEIVES
THE ULTIMATE PUNISHMENT.

DO UNANIMOUSLY FIND
THAT THE SENTENCE OF DEATH

SHOULD BE IMPOSED ON
RICHARD JAMES BEASLEY.

ANYBODY THAT COULD DO
WHAT HE DID IS A MONSTER

WITH NO CONSCIOUS AND NO SOUL,

AND I DON'T BELIEVE

THAT THEY'VE FOUND EVERYBODY
RICH BEASLEY'S KILLED.

I BELIEVE HE'S BEEN DOING IT
SINCE HE WAS YOUNGER,

AND I HATE HIM.
TOTALLY RAW HATRED FOR THE MAN.

IT'S JUST SO NORMAL.
I'M NOT USED TO THAT WITH HIM.

THAT'S THE SAD PART.

THIS IS THE ONLY HAPPY
THAT THERE WAS.

THIS IS LIKE HAVING A DAD
THAT NEVER REALLY EXISTED,

BUT YOU'RE STILL STUCK
WITH THOSE HAPPY MEMORIES.

THERE IS NO SYSTEM.

THERE'S NO BOOK
TELLING YOU HOW TO HANDLE

IF YOUR DAD'S A SERIAL KILLER.

YOU LITERALLY JUST WAKE UP
AND LIVE YOUR LIFE NORMALLY

AND HANDLE
EVERYTHING AS IT COMES.