Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:00,827 --> 00:00:05,068
[ Soft music plays ]
2
00:00:05,068 --> 00:00:11,793
♪♪
3
00:00:11,793 --> 00:00:15,172
-The Indus River gave its name
to India,
4
00:00:15,172 --> 00:00:17,379
and along its banks
are the sites of some
5
00:00:17,379 --> 00:00:21,068
of the earliest
urban settlements on earth.
6
00:00:21,068 --> 00:00:23,586
Though the subcontinent
was the birthplace of many
7
00:00:23,586 --> 00:00:25,482
of the world's great religions,
8
00:00:25,482 --> 00:00:29,034
excavations of these cities
have uncovered no evidence
9
00:00:29,034 --> 00:00:32,034
of any organised
religious practices.
10
00:00:32,034 --> 00:00:34,482
♪♪
11
00:00:34,482 --> 00:00:37,827
But in the last 2,000 years,
a culture of religious tolerance
12
00:00:37,827 --> 00:00:42,551
developed amongst
the many faiths of these lands.
13
00:00:42,551 --> 00:00:46,275
Buddhism, Jainism, Sikhism
all originated here,
14
00:00:46,275 --> 00:00:48,862
and the Mughal conquerors
built their Islamic mosques
15
00:00:48,862 --> 00:00:50,896
alongside Hindu temples.
16
00:00:50,896 --> 00:00:52,655
♪♪
17
00:00:52,655 --> 00:00:54,758
In 1582, when Europe
was in the grip
18
00:00:54,758 --> 00:00:57,000
of almost continuous
religious conflict
19
00:00:57,000 --> 00:00:58,793
between Christian sects,
20
00:00:58,793 --> 00:01:00,689
the Mughal Emperor
Akbar the Great
21
00:01:00,689 --> 00:01:03,241
exhorted his philosophers
to seek a way
22
00:01:03,241 --> 00:01:07,517
for all religions in his empire
to coexist.
23
00:01:07,517 --> 00:01:10,862
Even now, Hinduism
still reflects that.
24
00:01:10,862 --> 00:01:14,034
It has changed and adapted
to circumstance.
25
00:01:14,034 --> 00:01:16,862
Its followers welcome
and absorb customs and beliefs
26
00:01:16,862 --> 00:01:18,241
from other faiths.
27
00:01:18,241 --> 00:01:21,241
So today it's
the biggest faith in India
28
00:01:21,241 --> 00:01:23,620
and the third-largest
in the world.
29
00:01:25,000 --> 00:01:27,655
The temples constructed
to nurture this faith
30
00:01:27,655 --> 00:01:30,137
are some of the greatest
architectural treasures
31
00:01:30,137 --> 00:01:32,310
in India
and in this last programme,
32
00:01:32,310 --> 00:01:35,068
we are in the southern
Indian state of Tamil Nadu.
33
00:01:35,068 --> 00:01:38,689
This is where Hindu temple
culture reached its zenith,
34
00:01:38,689 --> 00:01:40,620
and there's no better place
to understand
35
00:01:40,620 --> 00:01:43,206
the story
of these remarkable buildings.
36
00:01:43,206 --> 00:01:51,379
♪♪
37
00:01:51,379 --> 00:01:54,586
[ Up-tempo music plays ]
38
00:01:54,586 --> 00:02:01,896
♪♪
39
00:02:01,896 --> 00:02:05,206
India is a country
of over a billion people,
40
00:02:05,206 --> 00:02:07,344
and the Hindu majority
understand
41
00:02:07,344 --> 00:02:09,551
and interpret their existence
42
00:02:09,551 --> 00:02:12,655
in terms of their relationship
with the divine.
43
00:02:12,655 --> 00:02:14,793
♪♪
44
00:02:14,793 --> 00:02:18,310
Their faith, a complex synthesis
of many ancient beliefs,
45
00:02:18,310 --> 00:02:21,482
is inseparable
from their everyday lives.
46
00:02:21,482 --> 00:02:26,000
The sacred and the profane
are inextricably entwined.
47
00:02:26,000 --> 00:02:28,551
♪♪
48
00:02:28,551 --> 00:02:31,206
Even some of its most ardent
followers will tell you
49
00:02:31,206 --> 00:02:36,482
that Hinduism is not a religion
but a cultural phenomenon.
50
00:02:36,482 --> 00:02:38,551
[ Soft South Asian music plays ]
51
00:02:38,551 --> 00:02:43,793
The word "Hindu" is also derived
from the mighty Indus river.
52
00:02:43,793 --> 00:02:47,620
Its followers regard the world
in which we live as illusory.
53
00:02:47,620 --> 00:02:50,448
The goal of life is
to break through this illusion
54
00:02:50,448 --> 00:02:53,379
and discover the reality beyond.
55
00:02:53,379 --> 00:02:56,689
The locus for this quest
is the temple.
56
00:02:56,689 --> 00:02:59,689
♪♪
57
00:02:59,689 --> 00:03:03,310
The Hindu temple is where
the divide between illusion
58
00:03:03,310 --> 00:03:06,137
and reality
is at its most porous,
59
00:03:06,137 --> 00:03:08,551
where the opportunity
to achieve darshan,
60
00:03:08,551 --> 00:03:11,586
a vision of the divine,
is most possible.
61
00:03:11,586 --> 00:03:15,275
Every community in India,
great or small,
62
00:03:15,275 --> 00:03:16,931
will have its own temple,
63
00:03:16,931 --> 00:03:19,862
the centre of its social
and spiritual life.
64
00:03:19,862 --> 00:03:21,586
And these places have fostered
65
00:03:21,586 --> 00:03:25,448
the greatest flowering
of Hindu artistic expression.
66
00:03:25,448 --> 00:03:28,448
♪♪
67
00:03:28,448 --> 00:03:31,793
Temples are remarkable works of
art in their own right,
68
00:03:31,793 --> 00:03:34,517
but they have also been
the cradle of creativity
69
00:03:34,517 --> 00:03:37,137
in sculpture, poetry,
song, and dance --
70
00:03:37,137 --> 00:03:39,689
the very heart of
a vibrant culture
71
00:03:39,689 --> 00:03:42,689
that is still beating
as strongly as ever.
72
00:03:42,689 --> 00:03:49,689
♪♪
73
00:03:49,689 --> 00:03:56,517
♪♪
74
00:03:56,517 --> 00:03:58,965
Descending
from the arid Deccan plateau,
75
00:03:58,965 --> 00:04:02,275
the flat and forested
landscape of southern India
76
00:04:02,275 --> 00:04:04,758
is very different to the north.
77
00:04:04,758 --> 00:04:06,827
This is a land apart --
ethnically
78
00:04:06,827 --> 00:04:11,275
and culturally distinct,
and with a separate history.
79
00:04:11,275 --> 00:04:14,379
Even the Mughal conquest
did not reach this far south.
80
00:04:14,379 --> 00:04:18,448
In the 6th century, a dynasty
known as the Pallavas
81
00:04:18,448 --> 00:04:20,827
came to power in southern India.
82
00:04:20,827 --> 00:04:24,896
Their empire thrived on trade,
and the town of Mahabalipuram,
83
00:04:24,896 --> 00:04:28,655
on the Coromandel Coast,
was their principal port.
84
00:04:28,655 --> 00:04:37,827
♪♪
85
00:04:37,827 --> 00:04:40,758
Fishing is now the mainstay
of this coast,
86
00:04:40,758 --> 00:04:43,517
part of the modern state
of Tamil Nadu.
87
00:04:43,517 --> 00:04:46,310
But in a golden age
in the 7th and 8th centuries,
88
00:04:46,310 --> 00:04:48,896
the Pallava kings
turned Mahabalipuram
89
00:04:48,896 --> 00:04:53,241
into an artisan laboratory
for the craft of stone carving
90
00:04:53,241 --> 00:04:56,448
and it now has
World Heritage status.
91
00:04:56,448 --> 00:04:59,724
♪♪
92
00:04:59,724 --> 00:05:03,103
Beached like a petrified ship
to the south of the town
93
00:05:03,103 --> 00:05:06,241
is one of the earliest
free-standing stone temples
94
00:05:06,241 --> 00:05:09,000
in India,
the Shore Temple.
95
00:05:09,000 --> 00:05:11,896
♪♪
96
00:05:11,896 --> 00:05:13,655
When this temple was built,
97
00:05:13,655 --> 00:05:15,862
many of the elements
of temple design
98
00:05:15,862 --> 00:05:18,413
had already become standardised,
99
00:05:18,413 --> 00:05:21,206
but the origins of
this architectural form
100
00:05:21,206 --> 00:05:22,827
are not buildings at all.
101
00:05:22,827 --> 00:05:24,862
♪♪
102
00:05:24,862 --> 00:05:27,931
A few hundred yards inland
from the Shore Temple
103
00:05:27,931 --> 00:05:31,103
is a shrine from the start
of the Pallava period
104
00:05:31,103 --> 00:05:32,551
that helps us appreciate
105
00:05:32,551 --> 00:05:35,862
why these buildings
evolved in the way they did.
106
00:05:35,862 --> 00:05:39,586
Like many caves and natural
rock formations in India,
107
00:05:39,586 --> 00:05:41,758
an opening
in this granite overhang
108
00:05:41,758 --> 00:05:44,379
has been enlarged and shaped
over many generations
109
00:05:44,379 --> 00:05:47,896
to provide a site
to worship local gods.
110
00:05:47,896 --> 00:05:50,241
♪♪
111
00:05:50,241 --> 00:05:52,241
These shrines could have been
112
00:05:52,241 --> 00:05:54,724
as simple as a clearing
in the forest,
113
00:05:54,724 --> 00:05:58,827
a source of spring water,
or, as in this case, a cave.
114
00:05:58,827 --> 00:06:01,310
What they all shared
was a setting
115
00:06:01,310 --> 00:06:03,172
where the natural energy
of the earth
116
00:06:03,172 --> 00:06:06,310
seemed to manifest itself.
117
00:06:06,310 --> 00:06:08,896
This remarkable
rock architecture
118
00:06:08,896 --> 00:06:11,000
is 1,400 years old,
119
00:06:11,000 --> 00:06:13,310
and the men who carved it
were trying to harness
120
00:06:13,310 --> 00:06:17,172
the spirit of the stone
from which it is formed.
121
00:06:17,172 --> 00:06:20,206
These beams mimic
timber cross-members,
122
00:06:20,206 --> 00:06:21,586
and the whole structure
123
00:06:21,586 --> 00:06:24,758
was formed
in imitation of wooden temples.
124
00:06:24,758 --> 00:06:27,275
The columns appear to be
holding the roof up,
125
00:06:27,275 --> 00:06:29,931
but it is all made
from the living rock.
126
00:06:29,931 --> 00:06:31,896
♪♪
127
00:06:31,896 --> 00:06:35,724
Inside is a small,
dark womb-like chamber
128
00:06:35,724 --> 00:06:38,551
where very little
natural light penetrates,
129
00:06:38,551 --> 00:06:42,034
and this is regarded as the most
sacred part of the temple,
130
00:06:42,034 --> 00:06:43,310
the sanctum.
131
00:06:43,310 --> 00:06:45,344
On the back wall
is a carved panel
132
00:06:45,344 --> 00:06:48,724
which tells us that this temple
is dedicated to Shiva,
133
00:06:48,724 --> 00:06:52,827
shown here with his consort,
Parvati.
134
00:06:52,827 --> 00:06:55,793
On the side wall is a panel
showing Vishnu,
135
00:06:55,793 --> 00:06:58,689
reclining on
the primordial waters.
136
00:06:58,689 --> 00:07:03,379
Shiva and Vishnu are two of
the principle gods of Hinduism.
137
00:07:03,379 --> 00:07:07,482
As Hinduism evolved,
here in southern India,
138
00:07:07,482 --> 00:07:09,551
Shiva became
the more popular deity,
139
00:07:09,551 --> 00:07:12,241
while in the north,
Vishnu is more common,
140
00:07:12,241 --> 00:07:15,586
but both are aspects
of the divine.
141
00:07:15,586 --> 00:07:18,655
At the time these cave temples
were made,
142
00:07:18,655 --> 00:07:22,137
by far the most popular faith
in India was Buddhism,
143
00:07:22,137 --> 00:07:23,862
and the people
who worshipped here
144
00:07:23,862 --> 00:07:26,206
would have been most surprised
to discover
145
00:07:26,206 --> 00:07:27,655
they would one day
be regarded
146
00:07:27,655 --> 00:07:31,413
as part of an organised
religion called Hinduism.
147
00:07:33,689 --> 00:07:37,482
♪♪
148
00:07:37,482 --> 00:07:40,896
The earliest animist practices
saw the spirit of the earth
149
00:07:40,896 --> 00:07:44,379
and its power
manifest in all natural things.
150
00:07:44,379 --> 00:07:48,793
Despite its selection
of recognisable Hindu deities,
151
00:07:48,793 --> 00:07:52,310
this isolated rural shrine
in a forest clearing
152
00:07:52,310 --> 00:07:54,931
has a powerful sense of mystery.
153
00:07:54,931 --> 00:07:58,137
When it was first venerated
by the local villagers,
154
00:07:58,137 --> 00:08:00,482
it would have
had little to do with Shiva.
155
00:08:00,482 --> 00:08:03,724
The many hundreds of clay horses
156
00:08:03,724 --> 00:08:06,103
gently decaying
in the undergrowth
157
00:08:06,103 --> 00:08:09,379
tell us that this shrine
is dedicated to Ayyanar,
158
00:08:09,379 --> 00:08:12,206
a deity who protects
rural villages
159
00:08:12,206 --> 00:08:16,275
and is almost exclusively
found in Tamil Nadu.
160
00:08:16,275 --> 00:08:17,793
He rides around on horseback,
161
00:08:17,793 --> 00:08:20,344
fighting the demons
of the forest.
162
00:08:20,344 --> 00:08:23,586
The inspiration for
this holy place
163
00:08:23,586 --> 00:08:26,517
was spiritual
rather than religious --
164
00:08:26,517 --> 00:08:30,137
a potent nexus
for the essence of the forest.
165
00:08:30,137 --> 00:08:36,275
♪♪
166
00:08:36,275 --> 00:08:39,172
A similar sense of the power
of natural forces
167
00:08:39,172 --> 00:08:42,620
is evident by the shore
at Mahabalipuram.
168
00:08:42,620 --> 00:08:45,034
Set back from the sea,
we find the next phase
169
00:08:45,034 --> 00:08:48,482
in the development
of the Pallava stone carvers.
170
00:08:48,482 --> 00:08:49,793
♪♪
171
00:08:49,793 --> 00:08:51,931
A row of rocky outcrops
and boulders
172
00:08:51,931 --> 00:08:54,689
allowed them to work
on a relatively modest scale
173
00:08:54,689 --> 00:08:58,413
to try out some of their ideas
for rock-cut temples.
174
00:08:58,413 --> 00:09:01,068
♪♪
175
00:09:01,068 --> 00:09:03,034
These are the rathas,
176
00:09:03,034 --> 00:09:05,689
the first free-standing
rock-cut temples
177
00:09:05,689 --> 00:09:07,275
in Indian architecture,
178
00:09:07,275 --> 00:09:10,482
and they are completely
without precedent.
179
00:09:10,482 --> 00:09:14,655
♪♪
180
00:09:14,655 --> 00:09:16,931
The rathas are not
strictly temples,
181
00:09:16,931 --> 00:09:18,482
because
they were never finished,
182
00:09:18,482 --> 00:09:20,827
but they functioned
as an aesthetic playground
183
00:09:20,827 --> 00:09:23,000
for the Pallava kings.
184
00:09:24,172 --> 00:09:26,655
They're extremely
architecturally diverse
185
00:09:26,655 --> 00:09:28,379
for the 7th century,
186
00:09:28,379 --> 00:09:31,310
each one trying out
different shapes and layouts
187
00:09:31,310 --> 00:09:34,275
and with a rich variety
of ornamentation.
188
00:09:34,275 --> 00:09:36,482
The smaller outcrops were used
to create animals
189
00:09:36,482 --> 00:09:39,172
and other mythical figures.
190
00:09:39,172 --> 00:09:46,448
♪♪
191
00:09:46,448 --> 00:09:48,448
But this challenge seemed to be
192
00:09:48,448 --> 00:09:51,655
one the Pallava craftsmen
relished,
193
00:09:51,655 --> 00:09:55,758
and it was in stone that
Hindu architecture came to life.
194
00:09:55,758 --> 00:09:58,758
At the four corners
of this last ratha
195
00:09:58,758 --> 00:10:01,206
are figures of Shiva
and other gods,
196
00:10:01,206 --> 00:10:05,034
with scripts in ancient Tamil
carved in the masonry above.
197
00:10:05,034 --> 00:10:08,275
One is thought to be the king,
Narasimhavarman I,
198
00:10:08,275 --> 00:10:09,862
with an inscription
199
00:10:09,862 --> 00:10:12,413
that proclaims
his patronage of the site.
200
00:10:12,413 --> 00:10:16,241
"Look on my works, ye mighty,
and despair."
201
00:10:16,241 --> 00:10:18,241
♪♪
202
00:10:18,241 --> 00:10:21,068
[ Birds chirping ]
203
00:10:21,068 --> 00:10:23,517
♪♪
204
00:10:23,517 --> 00:10:25,758
The skills developed
in the Pallava times
205
00:10:25,758 --> 00:10:27,241
have not been lost.
206
00:10:27,241 --> 00:10:28,724
In the back alleys of the town
today,
207
00:10:28,724 --> 00:10:30,655
there are hundreds
of stone artisans
208
00:10:30,655 --> 00:10:33,655
chiselling away
in ramshackle street studios,
209
00:10:33,655 --> 00:10:37,793
meticulously turning stone
into devotional art.
210
00:10:37,793 --> 00:10:42,655
♪♪
211
00:10:42,655 --> 00:10:44,758
The granite that these
stonemasons are carving
212
00:10:44,758 --> 00:10:47,448
is not found locally
and has to be transported
213
00:10:47,448 --> 00:10:50,206
from a quarry
50 kilometres away.
214
00:10:50,206 --> 00:10:53,344
But what Mahabalipuram
does have,
215
00:10:53,344 --> 00:10:56,586
which makes it the undisputed
centre of stone carving
216
00:10:56,586 --> 00:10:59,655
along this coast,
are the craftsmen.
217
00:10:59,655 --> 00:11:03,000
The apprenticeship to become
a master mason here
218
00:11:03,000 --> 00:11:04,931
takes a minimum of seven years,
219
00:11:04,931 --> 00:11:08,551
and in that time, every aspect
of the process is covered.
220
00:11:08,551 --> 00:11:12,689
The workshop even manufacture
their own chisels.
221
00:11:12,689 --> 00:11:14,862
There is no doubt
that the modern carvers
222
00:11:14,862 --> 00:11:16,482
have developed their own style.
223
00:11:16,482 --> 00:11:18,724
Though they are depicting
the same deities,
224
00:11:18,724 --> 00:11:20,517
these figures
are subtly different
225
00:11:20,517 --> 00:11:24,103
from those that we see
from a thousand years ago.
226
00:11:24,103 --> 00:11:29,137
♪♪
227
00:11:29,137 --> 00:11:31,620
As any Bollywood filmgoer
will tell you,
228
00:11:31,620 --> 00:11:34,034
the Indians love a good yarn.
229
00:11:34,034 --> 00:11:37,689
This passion for storytelling
is extravagantly indulged
230
00:11:37,689 --> 00:11:40,137
at Mahabalipuram's
greatest treasure,
231
00:11:40,137 --> 00:11:44,517
the low-relief carving known as
The Descent of the Ganges.
232
00:11:44,517 --> 00:11:48,517
Carved in the early 7th century,
at the same time as the rathas,
233
00:11:48,517 --> 00:11:51,620
this exuberant panorama
is packed with life,
234
00:11:51,620 --> 00:11:54,793
spilling down the faces
of two monolithic boulders,
235
00:11:54,793 --> 00:11:57,206
some 43 feet high.
236
00:11:57,206 --> 00:11:59,965
As far as storytelling
in stone goes,
237
00:11:59,965 --> 00:12:02,137
this is pretty hard to beat,
238
00:12:02,137 --> 00:12:05,448
but it's also an example
of inspired planning.
239
00:12:05,448 --> 00:12:09,103
The sculptors have adapted
a natural cleft in the rock
240
00:12:09,103 --> 00:12:11,275
to represent the story
of the Ganges,
241
00:12:11,275 --> 00:12:16,103
whose life-giving waters are so
central to the Hindu world view.
242
00:12:16,103 --> 00:12:19,068
The simple version
of the story is
243
00:12:19,068 --> 00:12:22,689
that the mythical sage
Bhagiratha is entreating Shiva
244
00:12:22,689 --> 00:12:26,241
to bring the celestial river
Ganga to earth.
245
00:12:26,241 --> 00:12:27,896
The gods are rushing
to the banks
246
00:12:27,896 --> 00:12:29,517
to see this miracle, and
247
00:12:29,517 --> 00:12:32,862
all the creatures of creation
are watching in admiration,
248
00:12:32,862 --> 00:12:36,103
including a family
of life-sized elephants.
249
00:12:36,103 --> 00:12:38,344
It's full of beautifully
observed details
250
00:12:38,344 --> 00:12:40,620
and comic allusion.
251
00:12:40,620 --> 00:12:45,758
Bhagiratha is shown as a sadhu,
a holy man, balanced on one leg.
252
00:12:45,758 --> 00:12:48,068
But his holiness
is somewhat undermined
253
00:12:48,068 --> 00:12:51,551
when we see a pose imitated
lower down by a cat.
254
00:12:51,551 --> 00:12:53,482
♪♪
255
00:12:53,482 --> 00:12:56,758
For Hindus, Ganga is personified
as a goddess.
256
00:12:56,758 --> 00:12:59,000
So powerful was her force,
however,
257
00:12:59,000 --> 00:13:02,793
that Shiva broke her descent
by extending his matted locks,
258
00:13:02,793 --> 00:13:04,413
lest she flood the earth.
259
00:13:04,413 --> 00:13:08,000
Thus you see the union
of male and female forces.
260
00:13:08,000 --> 00:13:10,827
[ Birds chirping ]
261
00:13:10,827 --> 00:13:14,586
A more complex alternative
is that this is an episode
262
00:13:14,586 --> 00:13:18,275
from the early Hindu epic tale,
The Mahabharata.
263
00:13:18,275 --> 00:13:21,379
The holy man is, in fact,
a character called Arjuna,
264
00:13:21,379 --> 00:13:24,862
standing on one leg as a penance
in the hope that Shiva
265
00:13:24,862 --> 00:13:29,379
will grant him an invincible
weapon to destroy his enemies.
266
00:13:29,379 --> 00:13:32,758
Both narratives resist
complete explanation,
267
00:13:32,758 --> 00:13:35,620
with equal stubbornness.
268
00:13:35,620 --> 00:13:38,448
What we are seeing here
is an early example
269
00:13:38,448 --> 00:13:40,655
of the taste
for complex ornament,
270
00:13:40,655 --> 00:13:42,620
and this seething mass
of deities
271
00:13:42,620 --> 00:13:46,758
will eventually become
a staple of temple decoration.
272
00:13:46,758 --> 00:13:54,551
♪♪
273
00:13:54,551 --> 00:13:57,241
For the Pallavas,
their greatest moment
274
00:13:57,241 --> 00:13:59,620
was the construction
of the Shore Temple,
275
00:13:59,620 --> 00:14:02,931
a landmark not just for
their own progress as masons
276
00:14:02,931 --> 00:14:06,241
but for the development
of the nascent Hindu faith.
277
00:14:06,241 --> 00:14:09,172
The Shore Temple marked
a significant move
278
00:14:09,172 --> 00:14:11,862
towards building
on a monumental scale.
279
00:14:11,862 --> 00:14:14,862
But whether it was an
architectural masterpiece
280
00:14:14,862 --> 00:14:17,965
or a simple carving
on the back wall of a cave,
281
00:14:17,965 --> 00:14:21,137
at the heart of any Hindu
devotional building
282
00:14:21,137 --> 00:14:24,724
is the shrine,
the small sacred space where
283
00:14:24,724 --> 00:14:29,000
the devotee experiences darshan,
the presence of the divine.
284
00:14:29,000 --> 00:14:30,862
♪♪
285
00:14:30,862 --> 00:14:33,655
As these buildings grew in size,
it became common
286
00:14:33,655 --> 00:14:36,172
to mark the presence
of the central shrine
287
00:14:36,172 --> 00:14:38,172
with an
elaborately carved tower,
288
00:14:38,172 --> 00:14:40,793
known as the vimana,
which stands as a marker,
289
00:14:40,793 --> 00:14:43,586
very visibly proclaiming
the temple's location
290
00:14:43,586 --> 00:14:45,758
to the faithful.
291
00:14:45,758 --> 00:14:47,517
♪♪
292
00:14:47,517 --> 00:14:50,620
Though this building is
a freestanding structure,
293
00:14:50,620 --> 00:14:54,413
the way the rock is carved
harks back to the rathas.
294
00:14:54,413 --> 00:14:57,551
It is not made of regular
stone blocks and mortar
295
00:14:57,551 --> 00:15:00,965
but huge sections
of precisely shaped granite.
296
00:15:00,965 --> 00:15:03,482
♪♪
297
00:15:03,482 --> 00:15:05,551
The Shore Temple shows
298
00:15:05,551 --> 00:15:09,724
just how far early Hinduism
had come by the 8th century.
299
00:15:09,724 --> 00:15:11,931
By then, there was
a group of holy men,
300
00:15:11,931 --> 00:15:16,241
known as the Nayanmars,
or the Hounds of Shiva.
301
00:15:16,241 --> 00:15:19,551
♪♪
302
00:15:19,551 --> 00:15:23,000
This pantheon of
63 mystics and philosophers,
303
00:15:23,000 --> 00:15:25,379
also known as the Tamil Saints,
304
00:15:25,379 --> 00:15:28,793
promoted a new kind of
devotional Hinduism.
305
00:15:28,793 --> 00:15:30,724
They were devotees of Shiva,
306
00:15:30,724 --> 00:15:33,931
and their teaching was beginning
to win a sizeable following.
307
00:15:33,931 --> 00:15:35,551
-[ Singing in native language ]
308
00:15:35,551 --> 00:15:38,551
-The hymns written by the saints
were central to their success.
309
00:15:38,551 --> 00:15:42,137
The Nayanmars are said to have
sung the Buddhists out of India,
310
00:15:42,137 --> 00:15:46,172
and their songs are still sung
in the temples today.
311
00:15:46,172 --> 00:15:48,413
-[ Singing in native language ]
312
00:15:48,413 --> 00:15:53,758
♪♪
313
00:15:53,758 --> 00:15:57,413
They offered a path to salvation
that was open to all.
314
00:15:57,413 --> 00:15:59,275
Their great attraction was
315
00:15:59,275 --> 00:16:01,551
that a personal expression
of devotion
316
00:16:01,551 --> 00:16:04,551
was the way to become
one with the divine.
317
00:16:04,551 --> 00:16:09,448
Many of the rituals
associated with Hinduism today,
318
00:16:09,448 --> 00:16:12,000
such as the chanting
of the names of the deities
319
00:16:12,000 --> 00:16:14,482
and pilgrimages
to holy sites,
320
00:16:14,482 --> 00:16:17,241
were established
by the Nayanmars.
321
00:16:17,241 --> 00:16:18,655
But in a practical sense,
322
00:16:18,655 --> 00:16:22,517
the goal was also
to give Hinduism a popular face.
323
00:16:22,517 --> 00:16:24,103
The fantastic array of gods
324
00:16:24,103 --> 00:16:27,689
meant that everyone could find
their own personal deity
325
00:16:27,689 --> 00:16:30,827
and set them to work
on behalf of their soul.
326
00:16:30,827 --> 00:16:34,068
But what they
were all striving towards
327
00:16:34,068 --> 00:16:36,103
was a structure for Hinduism --
328
00:16:36,103 --> 00:16:39,517
a way to formalise and codify
the disparate rituals,
329
00:16:39,517 --> 00:16:43,034
they had adopted to give it
a unity and authority.
330
00:16:43,034 --> 00:16:46,137
And to do that, they needed
to write it all down.
331
00:16:46,137 --> 00:16:48,137
♪♪
332
00:16:48,137 --> 00:16:50,862
Hinduism is not
a "religion of the book."
333
00:16:50,862 --> 00:16:53,310
There is no central
source of authority,
334
00:16:53,310 --> 00:16:56,241
like the Bible or the Koran,
to refer to,
335
00:16:56,241 --> 00:16:58,758
to promulgate
the absolute word of God,
336
00:16:58,758 --> 00:17:02,482
but that doesn't mean there is
any shortage of scripture.
337
00:17:02,482 --> 00:17:05,137
The whole canon
of Hindu philosophy
338
00:17:05,137 --> 00:17:07,827
thrives on debate
and spiritual enquiry,
339
00:17:07,827 --> 00:17:11,724
much of it
delightfully contradictory.
340
00:17:11,724 --> 00:17:13,379
If you tried to collect it
all together,
341
00:17:13,379 --> 00:17:15,724
it would fill
a myriad libraries.
342
00:17:17,413 --> 00:17:20,103
What was added to this
at the time of the Tamil Saints
343
00:17:20,103 --> 00:17:23,620
was a far more rigorous set
of instructions for the devotee,
344
00:17:23,620 --> 00:17:26,724
the Agamas.
345
00:17:26,724 --> 00:17:31,310
The Agamas are a set of rules
to guide the Hindu devotee.
346
00:17:31,310 --> 00:17:33,586
They are incredibly
wide-ranging,
347
00:17:33,586 --> 00:17:36,344
offering advice
on temple construction,
348
00:17:36,344 --> 00:17:39,965
on the intricacies of
the guru-disciple relationship,
349
00:17:39,965 --> 00:17:42,586
on meditations
on the nature of Lord Shiva,
350
00:17:42,586 --> 00:17:46,758
covering every moment of life
from waking to sleeping.
351
00:17:46,758 --> 00:17:49,275
♪♪
352
00:17:49,275 --> 00:17:55,482
-[ Speaking native language ]
353
00:17:55,482 --> 00:17:58,482
-The Agamas
originated in Tamil Nadu
354
00:17:58,482 --> 00:18:01,275
and are written
in the ancient Tamil language.
355
00:18:01,275 --> 00:18:06,310
-[ Speaking native language ]
356
00:18:06,310 --> 00:18:10,206
-All 8,000 bundles
are now being translated
357
00:18:10,206 --> 00:18:13,103
before being photographed
and digitised,
358
00:18:13,103 --> 00:18:15,724
allowing them
to be accessed online.
359
00:18:15,724 --> 00:18:21,103
♪♪
360
00:18:21,103 --> 00:18:26,482
♪♪
361
00:18:26,482 --> 00:18:29,689
The Agamas now gave Hinduism
a formal structure
362
00:18:29,689 --> 00:18:33,000
that is still a keystone
of its practice today.
363
00:18:33,000 --> 00:18:36,517
In the wake of this change,
we begin to see a significant
364
00:18:36,517 --> 00:18:40,172
decline in the Buddhist
presence in India.
365
00:18:40,172 --> 00:18:43,137
Buddhism, a faith
that had once counted itself
366
00:18:43,137 --> 00:18:46,586
as the main religion of India,
had been successfully
367
00:18:46,586 --> 00:18:49,172
exported to China
and across Asia,
368
00:18:49,172 --> 00:18:51,655
and was now destined
to disappear entirely
369
00:18:51,655 --> 00:18:54,310
from the land
where the Buddha was born
370
00:18:54,310 --> 00:18:56,206
and where he had sat
under a tree
371
00:18:56,206 --> 00:18:58,551
and attained enlightenment.
372
00:18:58,551 --> 00:19:02,551
Why this happened is still
a matter of fierce debate.
373
00:19:02,551 --> 00:19:05,103
The two religions share
many central beliefs,
374
00:19:05,103 --> 00:19:06,931
and there is some evidence
to suggest
375
00:19:06,931 --> 00:19:10,206
that Hinduism simply absorbed
many adherents of Buddhism
376
00:19:10,206 --> 00:19:12,724
by borrowing their ideas.
377
00:19:12,724 --> 00:19:14,965
There may have been
some persecution,
378
00:19:14,965 --> 00:19:16,724
but there was no major conflict,
379
00:19:16,724 --> 00:19:19,172
just an increasingly rapid
acceptance
380
00:19:19,172 --> 00:19:22,931
of the newly invigorated
Hindu teaching.
381
00:19:22,931 --> 00:19:25,965
-[ Speaking native language ]
382
00:19:25,965 --> 00:19:29,793
♪♪
383
00:19:29,793 --> 00:19:31,931
-Towards the end
of the 9th century,
384
00:19:31,931 --> 00:19:35,551
a new dynasty established itself
in Tamil Nadu.
385
00:19:35,551 --> 00:19:39,862
From their origins on the banks
of the Kaveri River,
386
00:19:39,862 --> 00:19:43,724
the Cholas quickly gained
control of Peninsular India
387
00:19:43,724 --> 00:19:46,172
and spread their influence
into Sri Lanka,
388
00:19:46,172 --> 00:19:48,862
ultimately becoming
the principal military,
389
00:19:48,862 --> 00:19:52,896
economic, and cultural force
in southern Asia.
390
00:19:52,896 --> 00:19:55,344
♪♪
391
00:19:55,344 --> 00:19:57,793
Once established,
they turned their attention
392
00:19:57,793 --> 00:20:00,413
to the glorification
of their new capital,
393
00:20:00,413 --> 00:20:02,586
here at Thanjavur,
394
00:20:02,586 --> 00:20:06,068
and they certainly left
an incredible legacy.
395
00:20:06,068 --> 00:20:08,206
[ Indistinct conversations ]
396
00:20:08,206 --> 00:20:11,172
The Chola dynasty produced
many notable kings.
397
00:20:11,172 --> 00:20:13,172
One of the greatest
came to the throne
398
00:20:13,172 --> 00:20:15,241
at the end of the 11th century.
399
00:20:15,241 --> 00:20:18,068
Raja Raja Chola
was that rare combination
400
00:20:18,068 --> 00:20:21,137
of empire-builder,
able administrator,
401
00:20:21,137 --> 00:20:22,655
and patron of the arts,
402
00:20:22,655 --> 00:20:24,862
but his most tangible legacy
today
403
00:20:24,862 --> 00:20:28,482
is as a builder, and
this is his greatest triumph.
404
00:20:28,482 --> 00:20:32,275
♪♪
405
00:20:32,275 --> 00:20:34,827
This building was completed
in 1010,
406
00:20:34,827 --> 00:20:39,068
so has not long since celebrated
its 1,000th birthday.
407
00:20:39,068 --> 00:20:42,482
It was started and completed
in one continuous push
408
00:20:42,482 --> 00:20:45,482
during the lifetime
of Raja Raja Chola,
409
00:20:45,482 --> 00:20:48,379
and in the immediate aftermath
of the Hindu revolution
410
00:20:48,379 --> 00:20:50,793
sparked by the Tamil Saints.
411
00:20:50,793 --> 00:20:52,896
It's 300 years
since the Shore Temple
412
00:20:52,896 --> 00:20:56,103
at Mahabalipuram was built,
but we can clearly see
413
00:20:56,103 --> 00:20:58,172
that a great leap forward
has occurred.
414
00:20:58,172 --> 00:21:01,000
It sheer size speaks
of a building created
415
00:21:01,000 --> 00:21:02,896
for a dominant faith.
416
00:21:02,896 --> 00:21:07,724
Inscriptions in ancient Tamil
tell us that Raja Raja Chola
417
00:21:07,724 --> 00:21:10,655
was instructed
to build the temple in a dream,
418
00:21:10,655 --> 00:21:12,344
but the real inspiration
419
00:21:12,344 --> 00:21:15,724
was surely
the architecture of power.
420
00:21:15,724 --> 00:21:19,000
It is, of course,
dedicated to Shiva,
421
00:21:19,000 --> 00:21:20,827
and the message is clear --
422
00:21:20,827 --> 00:21:26,758
Raja Raja and Lord Shiva
were two sides of the same coin.
423
00:21:26,758 --> 00:21:30,137
As a work of art, it established
a distinctive Chola style,
424
00:21:30,137 --> 00:21:32,517
both in design
and ornamentation,
425
00:21:32,517 --> 00:21:35,620
which was to last
for the next few centuries.
426
00:21:35,620 --> 00:21:40,448
The multifaceted columns and
their projecting square capitals
427
00:21:40,448 --> 00:21:42,344
were widely copied.
428
00:21:42,344 --> 00:21:44,827
But it was the height
of the central tower
429
00:21:44,827 --> 00:21:46,827
over the shrine,
the vimana,
430
00:21:46,827 --> 00:21:50,000
and its monumental gateways,
the gopurams,
431
00:21:50,000 --> 00:21:52,310
that were
its greatest innovations.
432
00:21:52,310 --> 00:21:55,620
-[ Singing in native language ]
433
00:21:55,620 --> 00:21:58,655
-The temple gopurams
that Raja Raja built here
434
00:21:58,655 --> 00:22:01,137
were more opulently embellished
with sculpture,
435
00:22:01,137 --> 00:22:03,241
and on a far impressive scale,
436
00:22:03,241 --> 00:22:06,241
than anything that had been
attempted before.
437
00:22:06,241 --> 00:22:08,793
In the flat landscape
of Tamil Nadu,
438
00:22:08,793 --> 00:22:11,827
these mighty stone doorways
dominated the view,
439
00:22:11,827 --> 00:22:14,034
dramatically announcing
the presence
440
00:22:14,034 --> 00:22:16,241
of this colossal building.
441
00:22:16,241 --> 00:22:19,931
So we're entering through
the great stone gopuram
442
00:22:19,931 --> 00:22:21,379
of Raja Raja.
-Yeah.
443
00:22:21,379 --> 00:22:24,241
-Dr. Nagaswamy was formerly
the Director
444
00:22:24,241 --> 00:22:26,310
of the Archaeological Survey
of India
445
00:22:26,310 --> 00:22:29,275
and took a particular interest
in this building.
446
00:22:29,275 --> 00:22:31,275
He probably knows more
about its construction
447
00:22:31,275 --> 00:22:33,758
than Raja Raja Chola ever did,
starting with
448
00:22:33,758 --> 00:22:38,689
the very first marker peg
the builders set in the earth.
449
00:22:38,689 --> 00:22:41,517
-When the sun rises,
the shadow will be thrown
450
00:22:41,517 --> 00:22:43,896
on the western side.
That will be marked.
451
00:22:43,896 --> 00:22:49,103
And then on the same day,
when the sun sets,
452
00:22:49,103 --> 00:22:53,793
they draw the central line --
exact central line.
453
00:22:53,793 --> 00:22:57,379
-The central axis is the basis
of the sacred geometry
454
00:22:57,379 --> 00:22:59,689
of the temple.
Along this line,
455
00:22:59,689 --> 00:23:02,103
the location of
the main shrine is determined.
456
00:23:02,103 --> 00:23:06,172
And this point directly below
the finial on the central tower,
457
00:23:06,172 --> 00:23:08,241
the vimana,
becomes the focus
458
00:23:08,241 --> 00:23:11,206
from which the entire complex
is plotted.
459
00:23:11,206 --> 00:23:13,413
[ Birds chirping ]
460
00:23:13,413 --> 00:23:15,413
[ Indistinct conversations ]
461
00:23:15,413 --> 00:23:17,551
-Now in this plan,
462
00:23:17,551 --> 00:23:22,206
you see the central vimana,
or the main tower...
463
00:23:22,206 --> 00:23:24,034
-And the inner sanctum.
464
00:23:24,034 --> 00:23:28,896
-Now this is exactly in the
centre of this outer square.
465
00:23:28,896 --> 00:23:30,275
-Sure.
466
00:23:30,275 --> 00:23:33,862
-This outer square, which
we call the back square,
467
00:23:33,862 --> 00:23:39,344
is the original cosmic diagram
on which it is laid out...
468
00:23:39,344 --> 00:23:43,620
-Yeah.
-...and then that is doubled.
469
00:23:43,620 --> 00:23:47,620
-In many ways, Raja Raja Chola
was only doing
470
00:23:47,620 --> 00:23:51,172
what had been done before,
on a monumental scale.
471
00:23:51,172 --> 00:23:55,448
The vimana is only a few feet
shorter than Westminster Abbey.
472
00:23:55,448 --> 00:23:57,827
But Raja Raja couldn't just
do as he pleased here.
473
00:23:57,827 --> 00:24:01,655
He was bound by the rules
laid down in the Agamas.
474
00:24:01,655 --> 00:24:03,655
-They prescribe
475
00:24:03,655 --> 00:24:07,655
that you must first
prepare the measuring scale.
476
00:24:07,655 --> 00:24:10,448
-So, what are the measurements
of this based on?
477
00:24:10,448 --> 00:24:15,068
-The central finger of
the builder Raja Raja Chola.
478
00:24:15,068 --> 00:24:16,793
-I imagine it would take
479
00:24:16,793 --> 00:24:19,586
quite a few multiples
of Raja Raja's middle finger
480
00:24:19,586 --> 00:24:23,896
to reach 216 feet
to the top of the vimana here,
481
00:24:23,896 --> 00:24:27,586
but he seemed to have his finger
in every aspect of the temple.
482
00:24:27,586 --> 00:24:32,413
-This inscription, which says
that the King Raja Raja
483
00:24:32,413 --> 00:24:38,068
covered the entire tall vimana
at the back with gold.
484
00:24:38,068 --> 00:24:41,103
Tower is called Maha Meru.
-Maha Meru.
485
00:24:41,103 --> 00:24:46,068
-"Maha Meru" means "the golden
mountain beyond the Himalayas,"
486
00:24:46,068 --> 00:24:48,482
which is a mythical mountain.
-Sure.
487
00:24:48,482 --> 00:24:52,103
-But that was the place
where Shiva is said to reside.
488
00:24:52,103 --> 00:24:54,551
-Yep.
Shiva's mountain abode.
489
00:24:54,551 --> 00:24:55,931
-Yeah.
490
00:24:55,931 --> 00:24:59,103
-The inscriptions are
extraordinarily comprehensive.
491
00:24:59,103 --> 00:25:02,034
Just like the Tamil Saints
who preceded him,
492
00:25:02,034 --> 00:25:04,620
Raja Raja
was codifying Hinduism,
493
00:25:04,620 --> 00:25:07,724
recording the operational
practices of his temple.
494
00:25:07,724 --> 00:25:11,413
-Every detail,
who is responsible,
495
00:25:11,413 --> 00:25:14,965
how much money he was given,
for what purpose.
496
00:25:14,965 --> 00:25:19,827
And then he says, at the end,
that so long as the sun
497
00:25:19,827 --> 00:25:23,793
and the moon lasts,
this gift must be protected.
498
00:25:23,793 --> 00:25:26,448
[ Indistinct conversations ]
499
00:25:26,448 --> 00:25:29,241
-The rules on temple-building
which are laid down
500
00:25:29,241 --> 00:25:32,344
in the Agamas
were followed by Raja Raja Chola
501
00:25:32,344 --> 00:25:34,655
when he came
to build his temple.
502
00:25:34,655 --> 00:25:37,344
But though he was a man
of refined aesthetic taste,
503
00:25:37,344 --> 00:25:41,000
he was also
an able administrator.
504
00:25:41,000 --> 00:25:45,206
Raja Raja created a multilayered
system of government
505
00:25:45,206 --> 00:25:47,965
in which the temple
was the central authority
506
00:25:47,965 --> 00:25:51,793
and the largest employer,
with a vast permanent workforce
507
00:25:51,793 --> 00:25:54,724
that included priests
and ceremonial officers,
508
00:25:54,724 --> 00:25:58,310
financiers, maintenance teams,
cooks, and kitchen staff,
509
00:25:58,310 --> 00:26:00,827
but also
the most talented youngsters
510
00:26:00,827 --> 00:26:04,206
in the arts of poetry,
singing, and dance.
511
00:26:04,206 --> 00:26:07,448
♪♪
512
00:26:07,448 --> 00:26:10,482
But beyond its function
as a community centre,
513
00:26:10,482 --> 00:26:12,241
workplace, and school,
514
00:26:12,241 --> 00:26:14,689
the primary purpose
of a temple is spiritual,
515
00:26:14,689 --> 00:26:18,068
and right at its centre
is the shrine of the main deity,
516
00:26:18,068 --> 00:26:21,482
where the devotees
come to receive darshan.
517
00:26:21,482 --> 00:26:25,793
♪♪
518
00:26:25,793 --> 00:26:28,551
This is the route of
circumambulation,
519
00:26:28,551 --> 00:26:32,068
and it leads us to a powerful
image at the heart of Hinduism.
520
00:26:32,068 --> 00:26:34,172
♪♪
521
00:26:34,172 --> 00:26:36,655
We move from profane
to sacred space
522
00:26:36,655 --> 00:26:39,275
as we approach
the central shrine.
523
00:26:39,275 --> 00:26:41,586
In this most potent place
524
00:26:41,586 --> 00:26:45,000
is kept a phallic symbol,
the lingam.
525
00:26:45,000 --> 00:26:48,034
The lingam is
a smooth column of stone
526
00:26:48,034 --> 00:26:52,103
rising out of a circular base
that represents the female.
527
00:26:52,103 --> 00:26:55,517
It represents
the presence of Shiva,
528
00:26:55,517 --> 00:26:58,896
and to gaze on it
is to receive darshan.
529
00:26:58,896 --> 00:27:01,689
The room where it is kept
is the direct descendant
530
00:27:01,689 --> 00:27:03,793
of the recess
in the back of the cave
531
00:27:03,793 --> 00:27:06,827
that we saw
back in Mahabalipuram.
532
00:27:06,827 --> 00:27:11,689
The Nayanmars' concept of
supreme personal devotion
533
00:27:11,689 --> 00:27:14,310
to a god like Shiva,
meant that you travelled
534
00:27:14,310 --> 00:27:16,655
together on your journey
through life.
535
00:27:16,655 --> 00:27:18,793
But even with Shiva's guidance,
536
00:27:18,793 --> 00:27:21,965
where your journey led you
was largely up to you.
537
00:27:21,965 --> 00:27:25,793
Reincarnation is a central tenet
of all the religions
538
00:27:25,793 --> 00:27:27,586
that originate in India,
539
00:27:27,586 --> 00:27:29,586
and your behaviour
during this life
540
00:27:29,586 --> 00:27:32,758
will determine
how you return in the next.
541
00:27:32,758 --> 00:27:35,482
♪♪
542
00:27:35,482 --> 00:27:37,758
In pursuit
of that supreme challenge,
543
00:27:37,758 --> 00:27:41,827
we can see how the form of this
remarkable building evolved,
544
00:27:41,827 --> 00:27:44,620
channelling worshippers
towards the central shrine
545
00:27:44,620 --> 00:27:47,172
and the presence of the divine.
546
00:27:47,172 --> 00:27:49,724
It's a long way
from a forest clearing.
547
00:27:49,724 --> 00:27:52,620
By the time it was finished,
the basic precepts
548
00:27:52,620 --> 00:27:55,172
of Hindu worship
were set in stone,
549
00:27:55,172 --> 00:27:56,862
but though this building was
550
00:27:56,862 --> 00:27:59,344
the peak of
Chola artistic achievement,
551
00:27:59,344 --> 00:28:03,724
their lasting legacy
was not in granite at all.
552
00:28:03,724 --> 00:28:06,482
[ Hammering on metal ]
553
00:28:08,206 --> 00:28:10,586
It was in bronze
that the Chola craftsmen
554
00:28:10,586 --> 00:28:12,758
established
their artistic heritage,
555
00:28:12,758 --> 00:28:15,172
creating beautiful works
of sculpture
556
00:28:15,172 --> 00:28:18,793
that are still being replicated
today.
557
00:28:18,793 --> 00:28:21,517
Just like the stone masons
in Mahabalipuram,
558
00:28:21,517 --> 00:28:24,413
the main subjects for
the bronze sculptures made here
559
00:28:24,413 --> 00:28:27,241
are likenesses
of the Hindu deities.
560
00:28:27,241 --> 00:28:29,379
♪♪
561
00:28:29,379 --> 00:28:32,655
Like the stone Shiva lingam
in the temple shrine,
562
00:28:32,655 --> 00:28:35,655
this is another
manifestation of Shiva.
563
00:28:35,655 --> 00:28:38,689
Known as the Nataraja,
this is an avatar,
564
00:28:38,689 --> 00:28:42,620
originally a Hindu word
for an incarnation of the deity
565
00:28:42,620 --> 00:28:44,965
when they descend to the earth.
566
00:28:44,965 --> 00:28:48,689
In this form,
Shiva is the cosmic dancer,
567
00:28:48,689 --> 00:28:49,931
creating the universe
568
00:28:49,931 --> 00:28:53,896
while stamping down
the dwarf of ignorance.
569
00:28:53,896 --> 00:28:57,896
These bronze deities
are made in every size,
570
00:28:57,896 --> 00:28:59,793
from the largest temple figures
571
00:28:59,793 --> 00:29:03,620
to the smallest domestic gods
for a bedroom shrine.
572
00:29:03,620 --> 00:29:07,413
The material allows
for a fluidity of movement,
573
00:29:07,413 --> 00:29:09,896
softer expressions and gestures,
574
00:29:09,896 --> 00:29:13,310
communicating messages
of benevolence and forgiveness.
575
00:29:13,310 --> 00:29:16,689
And the more beautiful
and refined the bronze god is,
576
00:29:16,689 --> 00:29:20,103
the more likely
the spirit of the real deity is
577
00:29:20,103 --> 00:29:22,448
to inhabit the sculpture.
578
00:29:22,448 --> 00:29:25,758
♪♪
579
00:29:25,758 --> 00:29:28,724
For centuries, the stone gods
in the temple shrines
580
00:29:28,724 --> 00:29:31,310
were a fixed and
immovable presence,
581
00:29:31,310 --> 00:29:33,517
drawing the faithful to darshan.
582
00:29:33,517 --> 00:29:36,068
But the advent of
portable bronze figures
583
00:29:36,068 --> 00:29:39,103
meant that the deities
could leave their shrines.
584
00:29:39,103 --> 00:29:41,137
♪♪
585
00:29:41,137 --> 00:29:42,758
This is Madurai,
586
00:29:42,758 --> 00:29:45,551
one of the great
temple cities of southern India.
587
00:29:45,551 --> 00:29:48,827
The figure on the palanquin
is, once again, Shiva.
588
00:29:48,827 --> 00:29:52,448
He is being taken on
an excursion around the temple,
589
00:29:52,448 --> 00:29:55,413
and this ceremony shows us
how devotional practices
590
00:29:55,413 --> 00:29:58,413
changed in the period
after the Tamil Saints.
591
00:29:58,413 --> 00:30:01,689
[ Indistinct shouting ]
592
00:30:04,827 --> 00:30:06,586
The bronze statue of Shiva
593
00:30:06,586 --> 00:30:09,620
is hidden from our view,
behind the curtains,
594
00:30:09,620 --> 00:30:11,586
but for the priests
carrying him,
595
00:30:11,586 --> 00:30:13,137
he is very real.
596
00:30:13,137 --> 00:30:14,724
He is being taken
597
00:30:14,724 --> 00:30:17,517
to spend the night
with his consort, Parvati,
598
00:30:17,517 --> 00:30:21,620
known here by the name of
one of her avatars, Meenakshi,
599
00:30:21,620 --> 00:30:24,551
and the tryst will take place
in her shrine.
600
00:30:24,551 --> 00:30:27,034
These golden footprints
represent Shiva
601
00:30:27,034 --> 00:30:32,344
descending from his palanquin
to enter Meenakshi's shrine.
602
00:30:32,344 --> 00:30:34,172
The local legend tells us
603
00:30:34,172 --> 00:30:36,379
that Shiva and Meenakshi
were married in Madurai
604
00:30:36,379 --> 00:30:38,655
in a ceremony
performed by Vishnu,
605
00:30:38,655 --> 00:30:41,172
and after a long and happy life
together
606
00:30:41,172 --> 00:30:44,172
as rulers of the town,
they assumed divine form
607
00:30:44,172 --> 00:30:46,965
and she became the deity
of this temple.
608
00:30:46,965 --> 00:30:49,034
♪♪
609
00:30:49,034 --> 00:30:52,793
There may seem to be an element
of mystical pantomime here,
610
00:30:52,793 --> 00:30:56,241
but their mortal followers
are being shown an activity
611
00:30:56,241 --> 00:30:58,965
that they can relate
to their own lives.
612
00:30:58,965 --> 00:31:03,137
Shiva and Meenakshi consummate
their marriage anew each night.
613
00:31:03,137 --> 00:31:07,310
And at dawn, Shiva slips away,
back to his own shrine.
614
00:31:07,310 --> 00:31:08,793
[ Indistinct conversations ]
615
00:31:08,793 --> 00:31:10,862
♪♪
616
00:31:10,862 --> 00:31:15,000
Madurai is in the deep south
of Tamil Nadu.
617
00:31:15,000 --> 00:31:17,689
It's over 2,500 years old
618
00:31:17,689 --> 00:31:19,551
and was mentioned
by Greek travellers
619
00:31:19,551 --> 00:31:22,448
when the paint was still wet
on the Parthenon.
620
00:31:22,448 --> 00:31:25,724
The sprawling complex
of halls and courtyards
621
00:31:25,724 --> 00:31:28,172
that make up
its labyrinthine temple
622
00:31:28,172 --> 00:31:31,551
cover an area
the size of 25 football pitches,
623
00:31:31,551 --> 00:31:35,517
and it has no less
than 14 gopurams.
624
00:31:35,517 --> 00:31:38,586
♪♪
625
00:31:38,586 --> 00:31:40,724
The other very visible feature
626
00:31:40,724 --> 00:31:43,448
is the colourful riot
of sculpture on the towers.
627
00:31:43,448 --> 00:31:46,000
These plaster figures proclaim
to the faithful
628
00:31:46,000 --> 00:31:47,793
just what an army of deities
629
00:31:47,793 --> 00:31:50,137
are working away
on behalf of their soul.
630
00:31:50,137 --> 00:31:54,068
But the lurid choice of colours
is a fairly recent addition.
631
00:31:54,068 --> 00:31:56,275
♪♪
632
00:31:56,275 --> 00:31:58,931
The custodians of the temple,
the priestly class
633
00:31:58,931 --> 00:32:01,172
who manage the building
and its day-to-day affairs,
634
00:32:01,172 --> 00:32:05,448
are Brahmins - the top rung
of the Indian caste system.
635
00:32:05,448 --> 00:32:08,620
At the opposite end of the
spectrum are "untouchables,"
636
00:32:08,620 --> 00:32:11,724
not considered worthy
to enter the temple shrine,
637
00:32:11,724 --> 00:32:14,172
but they, too, need
an opportunity
638
00:32:14,172 --> 00:32:16,241
to experience darshan.
639
00:32:16,241 --> 00:32:20,137
♪♪
640
00:32:20,137 --> 00:32:22,275
For them and
for those who simply feel
641
00:32:22,275 --> 00:32:24,724
they can navigate life
without the guiding hand
642
00:32:24,724 --> 00:32:28,103
of a Brahmin priest,
there are alternatives.
643
00:32:28,103 --> 00:32:30,862
In a corner of
the main temple courtyard,
644
00:32:30,862 --> 00:32:33,103
genuinely accessible to all,
645
00:32:33,103 --> 00:32:35,206
there is a small shrine
to Ganesh,
646
00:32:35,206 --> 00:32:39,758
the remover of obstacles,
which is extremely busy.
647
00:32:39,758 --> 00:32:42,758
These worshippers are allowed
to touch the deity,
648
00:32:42,758 --> 00:32:44,206
to make their own offerings,
649
00:32:44,206 --> 00:32:46,793
and to conduct
their own personal rituals.
650
00:32:46,793 --> 00:32:49,241
But by doing so, they remain
651
00:32:49,241 --> 00:32:51,862
very much part
of Hindu practices.
652
00:32:51,862 --> 00:32:57,931
♪♪
653
00:32:57,931 --> 00:33:01,172
Familiar religious images are
now emerging from the temples
654
00:33:01,172 --> 00:33:04,758
and becoming part
of mainstream Indian life --
655
00:33:04,758 --> 00:33:06,586
a process that began
with the advent
656
00:33:06,586 --> 00:33:09,586
of cheap colour printing
in the late 19th century.
657
00:33:09,586 --> 00:33:13,482
The painter Raja Ravi Varma
became hugely popular
658
00:33:13,482 --> 00:33:16,758
by portraying the deities
in a contemporary Western style,
659
00:33:16,758 --> 00:33:18,586
using oil paint.
660
00:33:18,586 --> 00:33:21,620
♪♪
661
00:33:21,620 --> 00:33:24,379
The performance artist
Pushpamala has re-created
662
00:33:24,379 --> 00:33:26,620
his familiar image
of the goddess Lakshmi,
663
00:33:26,620 --> 00:33:29,413
casting herself as the deity.
664
00:33:29,413 --> 00:33:32,827
-Lakshmi, of course, is
the goddess of wealth,
665
00:33:32,827 --> 00:33:34,965
but Ravi Varma also created
666
00:33:34,965 --> 00:33:39,344
this kind of fair-skinned,
aristocratic ideal Indian woman.
667
00:33:39,344 --> 00:33:40,827
-Mm.
668
00:33:40,827 --> 00:33:44,517
Pushpamala has also made work
based on a series of photographs
669
00:33:44,517 --> 00:33:47,724
taken by British ethnographers
in the 19th century
670
00:33:47,724 --> 00:33:51,413
that sought to categorise
the races of India.
671
00:33:51,413 --> 00:33:54,310
These images,
being regarded as scientific,
672
00:33:54,310 --> 00:33:55,758
are not concerned to disguise
673
00:33:55,758 --> 00:33:58,689
the darker skin
of their subjects.
674
00:33:58,689 --> 00:34:00,655
-In fact,
the Andamanese Islander picture
675
00:34:00,655 --> 00:34:02,586
comes from a very famous study,
676
00:34:02,586 --> 00:34:04,551
and they were doing it
in all the colonies.
677
00:34:04,551 --> 00:34:07,689
And that was, in a sense,
to control and understand,
678
00:34:07,689 --> 00:34:09,965
so that was to kind of really,
you know,
679
00:34:09,965 --> 00:34:11,379
get a grasp on the world,
680
00:34:11,379 --> 00:34:14,206
which was rapidly
sort of expanding.
681
00:34:14,206 --> 00:34:19,448
-In fact, the term "Hindu"
only came into widespread use
682
00:34:19,448 --> 00:34:21,000
during the British Raj,
683
00:34:21,000 --> 00:34:23,655
and these religious and ethnic
classifications
684
00:34:23,655 --> 00:34:25,413
certainly contributed
685
00:34:25,413 --> 00:34:29,034
to the rigidity
of the Indian caste system.
686
00:34:29,034 --> 00:34:31,034
But once these
religious stratifications
687
00:34:31,034 --> 00:34:32,482
had been formulated,
688
00:34:32,482 --> 00:34:36,344
they became a welcome badge
for those they labelled.
689
00:34:36,344 --> 00:34:38,000
The temple is still the focus
690
00:34:38,000 --> 00:34:41,034
for the religious life
of Hindu communities,
691
00:34:41,034 --> 00:34:43,689
but the younger generation
are growing up in a country
692
00:34:43,689 --> 00:34:46,655
where their government now wears
this religious badge,
693
00:34:46,655 --> 00:34:50,655
and religion is more present
in everyday culture than ever.
694
00:34:50,655 --> 00:34:54,724
♪♪
695
00:34:54,724 --> 00:34:57,000
The intensely expressive
sculptures
696
00:34:57,000 --> 00:34:58,793
that cover the temple gopurams
697
00:34:58,793 --> 00:35:01,862
are appearing
in an unlikely new guise.
698
00:35:01,862 --> 00:35:04,965
The Hindu legends are now
being retold in comic art,
699
00:35:04,965 --> 00:35:07,827
and graphic novels
based on these ancient stories
700
00:35:07,827 --> 00:35:10,931
are becoming hugely popular.
701
00:35:10,931 --> 00:35:14,034
But for a group of young
comic book enthusiasts,
702
00:35:14,034 --> 00:35:17,344
working in a small apartment,
these home-grown efforts
703
00:35:17,344 --> 00:35:19,758
retelling the familiar stories
of Shiva
704
00:35:19,758 --> 00:35:22,000
need a bit of updating.
705
00:35:22,000 --> 00:35:23,827
Here's their take
706
00:35:23,827 --> 00:35:26,206
on the marriage
of Shiva and Meenakshi
707
00:35:26,206 --> 00:35:29,000
that inspired the night ceremony
in Madurai.
708
00:35:29,000 --> 00:35:31,793
But the scene
has now become a mash-up
709
00:35:31,793 --> 00:35:34,517
of Gotham City and Middle Earth.
710
00:35:34,517 --> 00:35:38,241
-I used to read comics,
you know, Superman, Batman.
711
00:35:38,241 --> 00:35:40,655
I love the graphics
in those comics.
712
00:35:40,655 --> 00:35:43,793
Then, I read a few comics
from Indian publishing houses.
713
00:35:43,793 --> 00:35:46,586
The stories were good,
but the graphics were
714
00:35:46,586 --> 00:35:48,172
a little bit obsolete,
basically.
715
00:35:48,172 --> 00:35:50,448
I mean, I used to see Marvel,
and then I see how much --
716
00:35:50,448 --> 00:35:51,827
and I see the difference.
717
00:35:51,827 --> 00:35:55,965
So I said, "Why not bring
these three together,
718
00:35:55,965 --> 00:35:58,517
where I have graphics
which are universal,
719
00:35:58,517 --> 00:36:03,310
and bring in stories
which touch our Hindu legends
720
00:36:03,310 --> 00:36:06,482
and bring in the art
of narration from Tolkien
721
00:36:06,482 --> 00:36:10,379
and make graphic novels
with these three elements?"
722
00:36:10,379 --> 00:36:12,517
-Although the style
of the graphics
723
00:36:12,517 --> 00:36:15,275
and the narration are new,
for a true Hindu,
724
00:36:15,275 --> 00:36:17,448
there is very little room
for innovation
725
00:36:17,448 --> 00:36:19,448
when it comes to the stories.
726
00:36:19,448 --> 00:36:21,379
-It doesn't make any sense
to deviate,
727
00:36:21,379 --> 00:36:24,344
because if the story is there,
existed,
728
00:36:24,344 --> 00:36:26,655
a lot of people,
especially the young ones
729
00:36:26,655 --> 00:36:28,862
or the youth of today
or the "Y" generation,
730
00:36:28,862 --> 00:36:31,413
whatever you may call it,
in our country and abroad,
731
00:36:31,413 --> 00:36:33,448
don't know much about the story.
732
00:36:33,448 --> 00:36:36,689
And the story itself
is so interesting,
733
00:36:36,689 --> 00:36:39,379
why do you want to deviate
and rock the boat?
734
00:36:39,379 --> 00:36:41,137
-As keen as these guys are
735
00:36:41,137 --> 00:36:43,206
on sticking
to the authentic stories,
736
00:36:43,206 --> 00:36:46,310
they have some interesting ideas
about Hinduism.
737
00:36:46,310 --> 00:36:49,034
-Hindu was never a religion,
I believe.
738
00:36:49,034 --> 00:36:51,172
This is my personal view.
It is a culture.
739
00:36:51,172 --> 00:36:53,586
It was a way of living.
740
00:36:53,586 --> 00:36:56,551
All of the answers
are there in the past.
741
00:36:56,551 --> 00:36:58,586
You know, children from all ages
742
00:36:58,586 --> 00:37:00,551
look at the graphic novel
and get attracted.
743
00:37:00,551 --> 00:37:02,862
"Wow.
This is such appealing art.
744
00:37:02,862 --> 00:37:04,862
I love it.
It's so awesome. It's so cool."
745
00:37:04,862 --> 00:37:06,103
Okay, then he starts to read.
746
00:37:06,103 --> 00:37:08,482
And in that whole process,
747
00:37:08,482 --> 00:37:10,068
he understands the story.
748
00:37:10,068 --> 00:37:11,724
That's where we come in.
749
00:37:11,724 --> 00:37:16,586
♪♪
750
00:37:16,586 --> 00:37:18,758
-However adroit Hinduism is
751
00:37:18,758 --> 00:37:21,068
at adapting itself
to the modern world,
752
00:37:21,068 --> 00:37:24,620
Hindu philosophy is
still difficult to reconcile
753
00:37:24,620 --> 00:37:27,620
with Western notions
of religious experience.
754
00:37:27,620 --> 00:37:30,310
One of the most fundamental
disconnects
755
00:37:30,310 --> 00:37:32,206
between Eastern
and Western thought
756
00:37:32,206 --> 00:37:34,931
is represented
by Shiva Nataraja,
757
00:37:34,931 --> 00:37:37,275
and his ring of fire.
758
00:37:37,275 --> 00:37:39,379
Today, in many fields,
759
00:37:39,379 --> 00:37:42,827
India is leading
global technological progress.
760
00:37:42,827 --> 00:37:46,000
So, how does it reconcile
scientific advances
761
00:37:46,000 --> 00:37:48,793
with ancient myths and legends?
762
00:37:48,793 --> 00:37:51,931
Victorian Christianity
was severely tested
763
00:37:51,931 --> 00:37:54,586
by the theories of scientists
like Charles Darwin,
764
00:37:54,586 --> 00:37:57,758
and many evangelical Christians
still cannot accept
765
00:37:57,758 --> 00:38:00,551
the scientific truth
of evolution.
766
00:38:00,551 --> 00:38:04,344
Hinduism, it seems,
has no such issues.
767
00:38:04,344 --> 00:38:07,586
Outside the CERN particle
research centre in Geneva,
768
00:38:07,586 --> 00:38:11,068
a Shiva Nataraja, donated
by the Indian Government,
769
00:38:11,068 --> 00:38:14,275
celebrates the involvement
of many Indian tech companies
770
00:38:14,275 --> 00:38:16,241
in the project.
771
00:38:16,241 --> 00:38:19,137
Whether you call it
the Large Hadron Collider
772
00:38:19,137 --> 00:38:20,827
or Shiva Nataraja,
773
00:38:20,827 --> 00:38:23,137
the fact that the origins
of the universe
774
00:38:23,137 --> 00:38:24,896
lie in a ring of cosmic energy
775
00:38:24,896 --> 00:38:29,103
is just confirmation of
something Hindus already knew.
776
00:38:29,103 --> 00:38:32,000
♪♪
777
00:38:32,000 --> 00:38:34,241
-I can be a Hindu
778
00:38:34,241 --> 00:38:38,448
without having to subscribe
to a particular god,
779
00:38:38,448 --> 00:38:40,344
to a particular book,
780
00:38:40,344 --> 00:38:42,827
or to a particular
religious practice,
781
00:38:42,827 --> 00:38:47,172
which means that I can be
completely independent,
782
00:38:47,172 --> 00:38:49,793
I can have my own view
of the world,
783
00:38:49,793 --> 00:38:52,241
I can have my own view
of the universe,
784
00:38:52,241 --> 00:38:57,482
and I can accommodate different
views from different systems
785
00:38:57,482 --> 00:39:00,586
and synthesise them in my mind.
786
00:39:00,586 --> 00:39:03,103
♪♪
787
00:39:03,103 --> 00:39:05,413
-For a Hindu, the black water,
788
00:39:05,413 --> 00:39:07,758
the Indus river
or the Indian Ocean,
789
00:39:07,758 --> 00:39:11,000
mark the boundaries
of their homeland.
790
00:39:11,000 --> 00:39:12,689
In the days before mass travel,
791
00:39:12,689 --> 00:39:15,517
to cross the black water
and leave India
792
00:39:15,517 --> 00:39:17,517
was to cease to be a Hindu,
793
00:39:17,517 --> 00:39:19,413
and the rise
of Hindu nationalism
794
00:39:19,413 --> 00:39:20,931
has reinforced the idea
795
00:39:20,931 --> 00:39:23,620
that to be Indian
is to be Hindu,
796
00:39:23,620 --> 00:39:25,310
and vice versa.
797
00:39:25,310 --> 00:39:28,827
But Hindu nationalism
is directly at odds
798
00:39:28,827 --> 00:39:30,655
with its inclusive tradition.
799
00:39:30,655 --> 00:39:33,482
And as India emerges
as a major economic force
800
00:39:33,482 --> 00:39:35,793
at the forefront
of globalisation,
801
00:39:35,793 --> 00:39:38,241
the role of Hinduism
in its society
802
00:39:38,241 --> 00:39:40,241
is becoming incendiary.
803
00:39:40,241 --> 00:39:44,413
[ Fireworks crackling ]
804
00:39:44,413 --> 00:39:46,448
This is the festival
of Karthigai,
805
00:39:46,448 --> 00:39:49,068
deep in the Tamil heartlands
of southern India.
806
00:39:49,068 --> 00:39:51,758
It celebrates a story
from the Hindu scriptures,
807
00:39:51,758 --> 00:39:55,103
which casts Lord Shiva
in a very favorable light.
808
00:39:55,103 --> 00:39:57,413
♪♪
809
00:39:57,413 --> 00:39:59,517
The central story tells how,
810
00:39:59,517 --> 00:40:02,241
in a moment of
celestial competitiveness,
811
00:40:02,241 --> 00:40:04,931
Shiva appeared
to Vishnu and Brahma
812
00:40:04,931 --> 00:40:07,344
as an endless flame of light
813
00:40:07,344 --> 00:40:10,620
and challenged them
to find his head and his feet.
814
00:40:10,620 --> 00:40:14,034
To cut a long story short --
and it is a long story --
815
00:40:14,034 --> 00:40:17,482
they fail,
and Shiva remains supreme.
816
00:40:17,482 --> 00:40:19,862
Like so many other elements
of Hinduism,
817
00:40:19,862 --> 00:40:23,965
this festival offers the devotee
a bewildering array of choices.
818
00:40:23,965 --> 00:40:26,689
The basic tale has become
freighted with other cargo,
819
00:40:26,689 --> 00:40:30,068
competing traditions that
obscure the central meaning
820
00:40:30,068 --> 00:40:31,620
with excess baggage.
821
00:40:31,620 --> 00:40:36,275
In one tradition, the oil lamps
ward off evil forces
822
00:40:36,275 --> 00:40:38,344
and bring prosperity and joy.
823
00:40:38,344 --> 00:40:40,793
In another, the relationship
of brothers and sisters
824
00:40:40,793 --> 00:40:44,310
is remembered,
and siblings exchange gifts.
825
00:40:44,310 --> 00:40:47,931
Yet another tale is
the alignment of six stars
826
00:40:47,931 --> 00:40:50,758
at this point in the year,
said to represent
827
00:40:50,758 --> 00:40:54,034
the six faces of Murugan,
the Hindu god of war.
828
00:40:54,034 --> 00:40:56,000
♪♪
829
00:40:56,000 --> 00:40:57,689
The complexity that results
830
00:40:57,689 --> 00:41:00,724
from this amalgamation
of myth and celebration
831
00:41:00,724 --> 00:41:03,517
makes it impossible
to give a simple answer
832
00:41:03,517 --> 00:41:06,965
to the question,
"What is this festival for?"
833
00:41:06,965 --> 00:41:09,275
Quite simply,
834
00:41:09,275 --> 00:41:12,172
though it can mean something
different to each person,
835
00:41:12,172 --> 00:41:14,655
everyone can enjoy it together.
836
00:41:14,655 --> 00:41:16,517
And in this simple fact,
you have
837
00:41:16,517 --> 00:41:19,241
the secret
to Hinduism's success.
838
00:41:19,241 --> 00:41:22,689
♪♪
839
00:41:22,689 --> 00:41:25,689
The temples are as busy
as they have ever been.
840
00:41:25,689 --> 00:41:27,413
And as their traditions
spill out
841
00:41:27,413 --> 00:41:29,758
into mainstream Indian life
once more,
842
00:41:29,758 --> 00:41:32,137
their devotees
are still seeking answers
843
00:41:32,137 --> 00:41:34,413
to questions that are eternal.
844
00:41:34,413 --> 00:41:37,310
♪♪
845
00:41:37,310 --> 00:41:39,137
The many different religions
846
00:41:39,137 --> 00:41:42,241
that have vied for the souls of
the faithful over the centuries
847
00:41:42,241 --> 00:41:45,517
have left a rich legacy
in these lands.
848
00:41:45,517 --> 00:41:48,206
The haunting relics of
the Buddhist culture
849
00:41:48,206 --> 00:41:50,344
are now just ruins,
850
00:41:50,344 --> 00:41:52,103
but their beautiful
devotional art
851
00:41:52,103 --> 00:41:54,793
reminds us of their
remarkable achievements.
852
00:41:54,793 --> 00:41:56,724
♪♪
853
00:41:56,724 --> 00:41:59,551
The great mosques and mausoleums
of the Mughal conquest
854
00:41:59,551 --> 00:42:03,896
are architectural masterpieces,
venerated around the world,
855
00:42:03,896 --> 00:42:07,206
and the skill of their painters
and their musical heritage
856
00:42:07,206 --> 00:42:11,172
are as cherished today
as they have always been.
857
00:42:11,172 --> 00:42:14,724
5,000 years ago, when the first
great urban settlements
858
00:42:14,724 --> 00:42:17,344
grew up on the banks
of the Indus River,
859
00:42:17,344 --> 00:42:20,517
the citizens had to devise ways
of living together
860
00:42:20,517 --> 00:42:22,758
in some of
the world's first cities,
861
00:42:22,758 --> 00:42:25,275
and they face
similar problems now.
862
00:42:25,275 --> 00:42:28,620
But as we know,
in the Hindu worldview,
863
00:42:28,620 --> 00:42:31,931
time is cyclical, not linear.
864
00:42:31,931 --> 00:42:33,620
The cities of these lands today
865
00:42:33,620 --> 00:42:37,482
have to find new strategies
to support vast populations,
866
00:42:37,482 --> 00:42:41,034
but they have a genius for
coping with immense challenges.
867
00:42:41,034 --> 00:42:43,586
And as they strive
towards solutions,
868
00:42:43,586 --> 00:42:45,448
it is perhaps some comfort
to know
869
00:42:45,448 --> 00:42:47,862
that they have been here before.
870
00:42:47,862 --> 00:42:49,758
In the West, time marches on,
871
00:42:49,758 --> 00:42:53,103
but here, what goes around
comes around.
872
00:42:53,103 --> 00:42:56,103
[ South Asian music plays ]
873
00:42:56,103 --> 00:43:05,034
♪♪
874
00:43:05,034 --> 00:43:14,000
♪♪
875
00:43:14,000 --> 00:43:23,103
♪♪
68918
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.