Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:02,474
No-one alive or dead could say you
haven't earned it.
2
00:00:02,474 --> 00:00:04,447
- To Bill.
- To Bill!
3
00:00:04,471 --> 00:00:07,517
It might be a late one. I need to
run Bill back to Southbay.
4
00:00:07,541 --> 00:00:08,448
Be safe.
5
00:00:08,472 --> 00:00:10,991
The deceased is a Carol Laing.
6
00:00:11,015 --> 00:00:14,725
That angry man outside is her ex,
Sergeant Michael Laing.
7
00:00:14,815 --> 00:00:17,472
Chief Superintendent Bridget Laing
is his mother.
8
00:00:17,496 --> 00:00:19,450
Is there anything you want to tell me?
9
00:00:19,474 --> 00:00:25,184
When Mike was 11 or 12, Bridget fostered
both Andrew and his little sister, Lisa.
10
00:00:25,209 --> 00:00:28,723
You attacked her in her own bed whilst
her son slept just across the hall.
11
00:00:28,748 --> 00:00:31,454
And when she fought back,
you stabbed her through the heart.
12
00:00:31,479 --> 00:00:33,780
It's very obvious
why my client's in custody.
13
00:00:33,781 --> 00:00:36,323
Because Southbay CID bears a grudge.
14
00:00:36,558 --> 00:00:42,469
Six months ago my police partner,
PC Fred Woods, just disappeared.
15
00:00:42,494 --> 00:00:44,831
His car was found at Southbay Bridge.
16
00:00:44,832 --> 00:00:48,032
You know how many people go
over the side there every year?
17
00:00:48,033 --> 00:00:49,793
Fred received a threat to life
18
00:00:49,794 --> 00:00:52,074
from Detective Super Intendent
Ray Palmer.
19
00:00:52,075 --> 00:00:54,635
Why did you tell us
you'd never been upstairs?
20
00:00:54,636 --> 00:00:56,556
Why did you lie to us?
21
00:00:56,557 --> 00:00:58,677
Something happened in this room.
22
00:01:02,490 --> 00:01:05,890
He said, "If you or your brother
try to leave this room, I'll know."
23
00:01:05,891 --> 00:01:07,598
Are you sure it was a man?
24
00:01:08,012 --> 00:01:11,572
Kate Freeman, you're charged
that on the 14th of August
25
00:01:11,573 --> 00:01:15,533
at Markland Avenue, Southbay,
you did murder Carol Laing,
26
00:01:15,534 --> 00:01:17,547
contrary to common law.
27
00:02:03,587 --> 00:02:05,172
Tell me, Ryan...
28
00:02:06,430 --> 00:02:08,242
..the man in the mask.
29
00:02:08,790 --> 00:02:11,019
Can you remember the colour of his eyes?
30
00:02:17,880 --> 00:02:20,189
But you said you thought
you recognised him?
31
00:02:20,190 --> 00:02:23,069
I said I thought I'd heard
his voice before.
32
00:02:23,070 --> 00:02:26,482
- If I recognised him, I'd tell you.
- Of course.
33
00:02:27,861 --> 00:02:32,023
And he made no attempt to
restrain you or bind your hands,
34
00:02:32,048 --> 00:02:33,308
nothing like that?
35
00:02:33,550 --> 00:02:36,000
No. Why?
36
00:02:37,110 --> 00:02:40,027
- Thank you, Ryan.
- Can I have a word?
37
00:02:45,579 --> 00:02:48,338
Is there a reason you asked him
if his hands were tied?
38
00:02:48,339 --> 00:02:50,179
The killer tied his mother's hands.
39
00:02:50,662 --> 00:02:51,641
What?
40
00:02:51,665 --> 00:02:53,936
Just a very specific
question, that's all.
41
00:02:53,960 --> 00:02:54,995
You're reading too much...
42
00:02:55,019 --> 00:02:57,177
Yesterday, you were saying you didn't
want anyone jumping to conclusions.
43
00:02:57,178 --> 00:02:58,799
- What did you mean by that?
- Nothing.
44
00:02:58,824 --> 00:03:01,851
What conclusions are you
afraid we'll jump to? The truth?
45
00:03:02,083 --> 00:03:04,725
Kate Freeman is facing life in prison.
46
00:03:04,726 --> 00:03:06,452
Not because she might be guilty,
47
00:03:06,453 --> 00:03:09,922
but because Southbay CID
want to shut her up.
48
00:03:10,893 --> 00:03:12,706
- That's ridiculous.
- Is it?
49
00:03:12,888 --> 00:03:17,783
Her partner questioned the lack of patrols
in Harbour Fields and vanished without trace.
50
00:03:17,808 --> 00:03:20,381
How about you do your job
and let me do mine?
51
00:03:20,382 --> 00:03:23,803
- Are you testing Ryan's pyjamas?
- For fibres and DNA, as we speak.
52
00:03:23,804 --> 00:03:25,250
Everything all right?
53
00:03:27,844 --> 00:03:30,260
Ryan would like to get
some things from his room.
54
00:04:03,734 --> 00:04:05,173
Hi. Meena.
55
00:04:05,174 --> 00:04:06,534
Lisa.
56
00:04:07,454 --> 00:04:10,038
- Is Andrew in?
- No.
57
00:04:10,509 --> 00:04:13,105
He's not at work and I couldn't
reach him on his mobile.
58
00:04:13,130 --> 00:04:15,751
He should be back by six,
cos we're going to the cinema.
59
00:04:16,477 --> 00:04:17,626
OK.
60
00:04:19,929 --> 00:04:21,766
Can I come in and wait for him?
61
00:04:23,141 --> 00:04:24,421
Thank you.
62
00:04:29,614 --> 00:04:31,056
Is that Mike?
63
00:04:31,334 --> 00:04:32,735
On the left, yeah.
64
00:04:33,050 --> 00:04:35,099
Corsica, 2001.
65
00:04:35,124 --> 00:04:36,235
Good memory.
66
00:04:37,478 --> 00:04:41,606
Remember the good, forget the bad,
that's my philosophy!
67
00:04:42,174 --> 00:04:44,412
We barely see Mike these days.
68
00:04:45,734 --> 00:04:48,656
Why's that, if you don't mind me asking?
69
00:04:49,654 --> 00:04:52,333
Andrew wasn't impressed
he walked out on Carol.
70
00:04:52,334 --> 00:04:55,533
Mike being Mike, he didn't
think it was anyone's business.
71
00:05:03,168 --> 00:05:04,208
Hi.
72
00:05:22,665 --> 00:05:24,185
Poor Andrew.
73
00:05:26,101 --> 00:05:28,421
He's taken Carol's death hard.
74
00:05:29,349 --> 00:05:30,949
Very hard.
75
00:05:30,974 --> 00:05:33,454
I didn't know him and Carol were close.
76
00:05:33,663 --> 00:05:35,533
They dated when they were kids.
77
00:05:35,534 --> 00:05:37,173
I was so jealous.
78
00:05:37,174 --> 00:05:40,094
Up until then, I always had
his undivided attention.
79
00:05:41,454 --> 00:05:44,053
Carol had her 18th at the sailing club.
80
00:05:44,054 --> 00:05:45,813
Andrew organised it.
81
00:05:45,814 --> 00:05:47,893
He was good at organising things.
82
00:05:47,894 --> 00:05:49,733
What did I do?
83
00:05:49,734 --> 00:05:52,659
Threw the biggest meltdown
I could muster.
84
00:05:53,854 --> 00:05:56,453
Andrew blew out the party
to stay with me,
85
00:05:56,454 --> 00:06:00,260
and by midnight
Mike and Carol were an item.
86
00:06:01,199 --> 00:06:04,070
I was so happy when they got
together again recently.
87
00:06:04,095 --> 00:06:05,374
Andrew and Carol?
88
00:06:06,894 --> 00:06:08,101
Meena.
89
00:06:14,362 --> 00:06:15,933
What are you doing here?
90
00:06:15,934 --> 00:06:19,334
You blank me at work, ignore
my calls, what am I supposed to do?
91
00:06:21,058 --> 00:06:22,574
What is it, Meena?
92
00:06:24,350 --> 00:06:26,573
I took a statement
from Ryan Laing which,
93
00:06:26,574 --> 00:06:28,493
if corroborated, kills our case.
94
00:06:28,494 --> 00:06:29,629
In what way?
95
00:06:30,014 --> 00:06:31,654
In every way.
96
00:06:31,919 --> 00:06:34,441
As in Kate Freeman didn't do this.
97
00:06:38,323 --> 00:06:41,882
Ryan's testimony is compelling,
but not a knockout blow.
98
00:06:41,883 --> 00:06:45,314
The CPS are too invested to drop
the charges unless they have to.
99
00:06:45,839 --> 00:06:47,842
I say we focus on the timeline.
100
00:06:47,843 --> 00:06:51,539
It's central to showing the Crown's
case is fundamentally flawed.
101
00:06:52,260 --> 00:06:58,158
OK, well, we know that the boys went
to bed earlier than usual, 9:00pm,
102
00:06:58,183 --> 00:07:01,243
because they were going fishing
with their dad at the crack of dawn.
103
00:07:01,244 --> 00:07:04,403
Dom Laing says that when he heard
his mother arguing with Kate,
104
00:07:04,404 --> 00:07:07,526
his brother was watching the Spurs
game on his phone with headphones.
105
00:07:07,527 --> 00:07:10,153
- What time did that game finish?
- 9:30pm.
106
00:07:10,154 --> 00:07:13,962
A 9:00pm to 9:30pm window does
fit with the pathology evidence.
107
00:07:13,963 --> 00:07:17,131
It's when Carol sustained the blow
to the head downstairs.
108
00:07:17,155 --> 00:07:17,905
Yes.
109
00:07:17,929 --> 00:07:21,762
And now we hit the two-hour
gap before the killer
110
00:07:21,763 --> 00:07:24,042
inflicts the fatal chest wound.
111
00:07:24,043 --> 00:07:27,682
And apart from a partial clean-up
and moving Carol to the bedroom,
112
00:07:27,683 --> 00:07:29,521
here's where we're drawing the blank.
113
00:07:29,522 --> 00:07:31,556
Did they go away and come back?
114
00:07:31,557 --> 00:07:35,261
Or are we looking at two timeframes...
115
00:07:35,811 --> 00:07:37,535
..and two offenders?
116
00:07:37,536 --> 00:07:40,682
I'm stuck on him carrying her upstairs.
117
00:07:40,683 --> 00:07:43,242
Why? What purpose did it serve?
118
00:07:43,243 --> 00:07:46,242
And after having done it,
what possessed him
119
00:07:46,243 --> 00:07:48,962
to go into the boys' room and be seen?
120
00:07:48,963 --> 00:07:51,042
And he didn't just go into the room.
121
00:07:51,043 --> 00:07:55,202
He made physical contact with Ryan
and he let him hear his voice.
122
00:07:55,203 --> 00:07:57,522
Again, all seriously odd.
123
00:07:57,523 --> 00:08:01,682
OK, 'seriously odd' sounds like
we're doubting Ryan's account.
124
00:08:01,683 --> 00:08:04,522
We're establishing a factual
sequence of events.
125
00:08:04,523 --> 00:08:06,802
How you then frame it is up to you.
126
00:08:06,803 --> 00:08:09,430
- I'm sorry, that's disingenuous.
- Meaning?
127
00:08:09,455 --> 00:08:12,133
Meaning you're an expert witness for
the defence.
128
00:08:12,158 --> 00:08:13,949
- You know the drill.
- I thought I did.
129
00:08:13,950 --> 00:08:17,279
We refract all the evidence through
the prism of Kate's innocence.
130
00:08:17,280 --> 00:08:20,208
We can't assume Kate's innocence
without a grasp
131
00:08:20,209 --> 00:08:22,886
on the totality of that evidence.
132
00:08:22,944 --> 00:08:24,923
Take PC Woods' disappearance,
133
00:08:24,948 --> 00:08:27,562
it may or may not pertain
to the Crown's case.
134
00:08:27,563 --> 00:08:29,242
We don't know.
135
00:08:29,243 --> 00:08:31,563
'Don't know' means 'no'.
136
00:08:31,805 --> 00:08:34,278
I get your impulse to find out
what's happened to Woods,
137
00:08:34,279 --> 00:08:37,119
but it's pulling focus
and threatening my ability
138
00:08:37,120 --> 00:08:40,002
to offer a clear, exculpatory narrative.
139
00:08:40,003 --> 00:08:44,720
OK. Let's start with the narrative,
if only to move the conversation on.
140
00:08:48,057 --> 00:08:51,602
Ryan Laing saw and heard
a male intruder.
141
00:08:51,603 --> 00:08:53,642
Not a woman, not Kate.
142
00:08:53,643 --> 00:08:57,147
So his brother was mistaken
about hearing Kate?
143
00:08:58,024 --> 00:09:00,923
'Mistaken' being a charitable
interpretation.
144
00:09:01,759 --> 00:09:03,848
And why did Southbay CID miss this?
145
00:09:04,103 --> 00:09:06,954
Because their myopic focus
on Kate Freeman
146
00:09:06,979 --> 00:09:10,541
demonstrably blinded them
to the key elements of the scene.
147
00:09:10,566 --> 00:09:11,774
Examples?
148
00:09:11,775 --> 00:09:14,366
The two hours gap
the killer spent on site
149
00:09:14,391 --> 00:09:17,197
and the initial attack
with the dumbbell downstairs.
150
00:09:18,526 --> 00:09:19,611
Sorry.
151
00:09:20,764 --> 00:09:22,044
Hello?
152
00:09:23,672 --> 00:09:25,797
Oh. Yeah, come on up.
153
00:09:30,203 --> 00:09:31,696
How can we help?
154
00:09:32,176 --> 00:09:35,576
Meena just brought me
up to speed about Ryan.
155
00:09:36,991 --> 00:09:39,962
And... there's something we need to
share as a matter of urgency.
156
00:09:39,963 --> 00:09:43,922
Sorry, do I infer you haven't shared
his testimony with your superiors?
157
00:09:43,923 --> 00:09:45,683
- No, we have.
- And?
158
00:09:47,203 --> 00:09:49,083
I'll get to that in a minute.
159
00:09:50,095 --> 00:09:53,964
About four months ago, West
Yorkshire CID got in contact in...
160
00:09:54,297 --> 00:09:56,363
..unusual circumstances.
161
00:09:56,576 --> 00:09:58,634
They'd had this spate of robberies
162
00:09:58,659 --> 00:10:00,603
targeting these cash in transit vans,
163
00:10:00,762 --> 00:10:03,442
carried out by a man
in a black ski mask.
164
00:10:03,467 --> 00:10:05,602
He bound the driver with cable ties.
165
00:10:05,603 --> 00:10:07,922
Then he threatened them
with a hunting knife.
166
00:10:07,923 --> 00:10:10,394
They had a strong suspect
named Wes Carter,
167
00:10:10,419 --> 00:10:13,162
who they pulled in a few times
but didn't have enough for a charge.
168
00:10:13,163 --> 00:10:15,122
Why did West Yorkshire get in touch?
169
00:10:15,123 --> 00:10:17,413
Because Wes Carter had
moved down to Southbay,
170
00:10:17,414 --> 00:10:20,442
no doubt hoping for police
interest in him to cool.
171
00:10:20,443 --> 00:10:22,874
Yorkshire must have been
pretty sure he was their man.
172
00:10:22,875 --> 00:10:25,837
They were warning us to keep an eye
and expect the worst.
173
00:10:25,838 --> 00:10:30,764
Now, clearly this man, Wes Carter
according to Yorkshire CID,
174
00:10:30,789 --> 00:10:33,723
looks and sounds a lot
like the man Ryan described.
175
00:10:37,838 --> 00:10:40,118
Don't take this the wrong way, but...
176
00:10:41,483 --> 00:10:43,242
..why are you coming to us?
177
00:10:43,563 --> 00:10:44,803
I, er...
178
00:10:45,374 --> 00:10:49,252
We have been sidelined by
Detective Super Ray Palmer.
179
00:10:49,755 --> 00:10:53,101
I took Ryan's statement
and formally entered it in the file.
180
00:10:53,102 --> 00:10:58,042
We're here to ensure that this
new avenue is fully explored.
181
00:10:58,043 --> 00:11:00,995
Sounds like you don't trust
your colleagues in CID
182
00:11:00,996 --> 00:11:03,899
to do their job
and we're the safety net.
183
00:11:04,950 --> 00:11:06,603
Insurance policy.
184
00:11:09,218 --> 00:11:12,298
Would you be kind enough
to step out for a moment?
185
00:11:12,790 --> 00:11:13,845
Sure.
186
00:11:15,017 --> 00:11:16,706
We'll go wait in the lobby.
187
00:11:23,323 --> 00:11:25,802
We need to give the CPS
pause for thought,
188
00:11:25,803 --> 00:11:28,362
make them aware how flawed
their case really is.
189
00:11:28,363 --> 00:11:31,094
I don't want to play my best cards
and leave nothing for the trial.
190
00:11:31,095 --> 00:11:32,578
I think it's worth the risk.
191
00:11:32,579 --> 00:11:34,825
I know someone in the CPS who can help,
192
00:11:34,826 --> 00:11:37,363
if I'm still on her Christmas card list.
193
00:11:39,725 --> 00:11:43,067
You told me Freeman's brief tapped
Lyell for a second PM
194
00:11:43,092 --> 00:11:44,651
and a look at the forensics...
195
00:11:44,882 --> 00:11:45,969
And?
196
00:11:46,363 --> 00:11:50,562
You neglected to add their findings
differ significantly from yours.
197
00:11:50,563 --> 00:11:51,882
That worries me.
198
00:11:51,883 --> 00:11:53,240
It shouldn't.
199
00:11:53,241 --> 00:11:56,355
It makes me think
"ambush down the line in court".
200
00:11:56,563 --> 00:11:59,113
Now I'm hearing about a witness
statement from Ryan Laing
201
00:11:59,114 --> 00:12:01,337
that essentially
contradicts his brother's.
202
00:12:01,803 --> 00:12:04,636
It's led me to look deeper
into the background of the case,
203
00:12:05,030 --> 00:12:06,476
specifically Kate Freeman.
204
00:12:06,477 --> 00:12:08,541
- I hear that after...
- I don't believe this.
205
00:12:08,542 --> 00:12:11,165
I hear that after her
partner disappeared,
206
00:12:11,166 --> 00:12:12,786
Kate was making trouble.
207
00:12:13,123 --> 00:12:14,854
Bandying stories about.
208
00:12:15,163 --> 00:12:19,184
Stories like Woods didn't take his
own life and had enemies in CID.
209
00:12:19,214 --> 00:12:21,682
Key word there being "stories".
210
00:12:21,683 --> 00:12:24,162
Still, putting her on suspension
might play like you're
211
00:12:24,163 --> 00:12:25,922
muzzling her to a jury.
212
00:12:25,923 --> 00:12:28,042
Christ, Bridget,
it might play like that to me.
213
00:12:28,043 --> 00:12:30,682
Who's pouring poison in your ear, Alan?
214
00:12:30,683 --> 00:12:32,522
And Kate luring your son
from the marital bed
215
00:12:32,523 --> 00:12:34,002
doesn't exactly simplify matters.
216
00:12:34,003 --> 00:12:36,171
Someone's put the frighteners
on you, haven't they, eh?
217
00:12:36,172 --> 00:12:37,327
All right.
218
00:12:38,963 --> 00:12:41,331
Look, I understand your wariness.
219
00:12:41,971 --> 00:12:45,470
As you say, Kate Freeman is not
a straightforward suspect.
220
00:12:45,471 --> 00:12:47,045
How do we move things forward?
221
00:12:50,243 --> 00:12:51,741
We get it all out in the open.
222
00:12:51,742 --> 00:12:54,306
- We do that in court, right?
- I mean now.
223
00:12:55,148 --> 00:12:57,561
We hear both sides' evidence early doors
224
00:12:57,562 --> 00:13:01,564
so no-one can say the CPS rushed to
judgment in charging Kate Freeman.
225
00:13:02,673 --> 00:13:05,123
Well, that's
pretty unorthodox, isn't it?
226
00:13:07,512 --> 00:13:09,033
But not unprecedented.
227
00:13:15,751 --> 00:13:18,446
Thank you all for coming
up to London today.
228
00:13:19,503 --> 00:13:24,630
Dr Burnett, can you clarify
your interpretation of the pathology
229
00:13:24,655 --> 00:13:27,509
evidence with regard to
sequence and timeframe?
230
00:13:27,603 --> 00:13:28,817
Gladly.
231
00:13:28,818 --> 00:13:30,802
We're looking at two distinct attacks.
232
00:13:30,803 --> 00:13:33,402
First the blow to the head and
then, after a short delay,
233
00:13:33,403 --> 00:13:34,842
the fatal stab wound.
234
00:13:34,843 --> 00:13:36,474
How short a delay?
235
00:13:36,763 --> 00:13:38,563
5 to 15 minutes.
236
00:13:39,338 --> 00:13:42,683
How do you account
for the accumulation of blood
237
00:13:42,684 --> 00:13:44,402
between the brain and the skull?
238
00:13:44,403 --> 00:13:45,834
Very easily.
239
00:13:45,835 --> 00:13:48,698
The stab wound was fatal,
but not immediately so.
240
00:13:49,806 --> 00:13:51,593
I find that unlikely.
241
00:13:51,963 --> 00:13:56,522
For one, hilt bruising on the
skin shows that the impact
242
00:13:56,523 --> 00:14:00,708
was exceptionally forceful and the
wound is in a position where the
243
00:14:00,733 --> 00:14:03,202
internal haemorrhage was torrential.
244
00:14:03,203 --> 00:14:04,842
It would induce death swiftly?
245
00:14:04,843 --> 00:14:10,602
Mm. For two, grooving on the base
of the brain suggests that Carol was
246
00:14:10,603 --> 00:14:14,980
alive for a longer period of time,
possibly a couple of hours,
247
00:14:15,005 --> 00:14:17,446
between the initial head
injury and the stabbing.
248
00:14:17,447 --> 00:14:19,602
Not the shorter time
Dr Burnett's suggesting?
249
00:14:19,603 --> 00:14:20,286
No.
250
00:14:20,311 --> 00:14:23,911
Can you really exclude other
causation for the grooving?
251
00:14:24,163 --> 00:14:26,654
Cardiac arrest, for example?
252
00:14:26,963 --> 00:14:29,375
You can't and you know you can't.
253
00:14:31,392 --> 00:14:35,318
In your report, you class the head wound
254
00:14:35,319 --> 00:14:37,482
as a "contrecoup injury",
255
00:14:37,483 --> 00:14:40,602
ie, one caused by the
victim falling onto an object.
256
00:14:40,603 --> 00:14:43,433
Let me guess -
you think it was a coup injury.
257
00:14:43,765 --> 00:14:47,002
I think Carol was struck by
a moving object, yes,
258
00:14:47,003 --> 00:14:48,722
not the other way round.
259
00:14:48,723 --> 00:14:50,602
Based on what evidence?
260
00:14:50,603 --> 00:14:56,807
If this was a contrecoup, can you
specify the object she fell onto
261
00:14:56,852 --> 00:15:00,497
that caused these distinctive marks?
262
00:15:01,377 --> 00:15:05,162
She sustained the injury
in a struggle in the bedroom.
263
00:15:05,163 --> 00:15:08,922
There were any number of objects and
corners she could have fallen on.
264
00:15:08,923 --> 00:15:11,359
Then you'd expect to find blood
transfer, surely.
265
00:15:11,360 --> 00:15:14,248
Not if the killer wiped
that object down.
266
00:15:14,273 --> 00:15:17,202
Dr Burnett... The absence of
evidence is not evidence.
267
00:15:17,203 --> 00:15:19,882
For the avoidance of doubt,
are you saying that you failed to
268
00:15:19,883 --> 00:15:22,322
identify the object that
caused this injury?
269
00:15:22,323 --> 00:15:24,442
Look, I didn't process the scene.
270
00:15:24,443 --> 00:15:25,642
Jack did.
271
00:15:25,643 --> 00:15:26,683
What?
272
00:15:27,458 --> 00:15:31,466
Sadly, he didn't swab or photograph
all of the potential edges
273
00:15:31,491 --> 00:15:34,597
and corners she could've fallen on,
or close to all of them.
274
00:15:36,563 --> 00:15:37,842
I didn't finish processing
275
00:15:37,843 --> 00:15:40,328
because I was removed from the scene
by Chief Superintendent Laing.
276
00:15:40,329 --> 00:15:43,589
That was later, you broke away
from the scene of your own volition.
277
00:15:43,590 --> 00:15:45,131
What are you talking about, Bill?
278
00:15:45,132 --> 00:15:47,802
You were distracted and
less than stringent
279
00:15:47,803 --> 00:15:49,522
in observing scene etiquette.
280
00:15:49,523 --> 00:15:51,277
Are you having a laugh?
I did you a bloody favour.
281
00:15:51,278 --> 00:15:54,429
Perhaps it was the effect of
meeting Kate Freeman outside.
282
00:15:55,161 --> 00:15:57,242
She made quite an impression on you.
283
00:16:00,267 --> 00:16:04,870
And you'd had so much to drink, I'm
surprised you remember anything!
284
00:16:17,403 --> 00:16:18,516
Um...
285
00:16:20,920 --> 00:16:24,322
..we'd like to present an
alternative reading of the evidence,
286
00:16:24,323 --> 00:16:25,479
if that's all right.
287
00:16:25,480 --> 00:16:26,765
It's why we're all here.
288
00:16:27,040 --> 00:16:29,884
We believe we've found
a second crime scene
289
00:16:29,940 --> 00:16:31,722
in the downstairs sitting room.
290
00:16:31,723 --> 00:16:35,087
Not only have we found Carol's
blood on the floor,
291
00:16:35,088 --> 00:16:40,813
we matched the tiered pattern of her
head wound to one of her dumbbells.
292
00:16:42,076 --> 00:16:45,937
Significantly, the other dumbbell
is missing from the house,
293
00:16:46,190 --> 00:16:49,244
and, yes, they're sold as a pair.
294
00:16:49,717 --> 00:16:54,113
Expirated blood on the halfway
landing and transfer of paint
295
00:16:54,114 --> 00:16:58,941
under Carol's toenails further
proved that the attack unfolded
296
00:16:58,966 --> 00:17:02,385
in two locations and two timeframes -
297
00:17:02,386 --> 00:17:05,755
circa 9pm and circa 11pm.
298
00:17:05,756 --> 00:17:10,162
The Crown's investigation completely
failed to unearth these basic
299
00:17:10,163 --> 00:17:11,456
elements of the scene.
300
00:17:11,576 --> 00:17:14,012
We've effectively had to
do their job for them.
301
00:17:14,013 --> 00:17:17,120
And when we factor in Ryan's
testimony that he saw
302
00:17:17,121 --> 00:17:18,955
a male intruder
303
00:17:19,203 --> 00:17:24,414
and Dr Burnett's inebriation,
it adds up to one thing -
304
00:17:24,657 --> 00:17:28,084
you need to release Kate Freeman
immediately.
305
00:17:46,392 --> 00:17:48,257
Why do you think Bill said all that?
306
00:17:53,643 --> 00:17:54,768
Velvy?
307
00:17:54,769 --> 00:17:56,618
I enlisted my botanist friend.
308
00:17:56,855 --> 00:18:00,442
Foliage in PC Woods's car is
predominantly leaves
309
00:18:00,443 --> 00:18:01,964
from a black poplar.
310
00:18:01,965 --> 00:18:04,504
OK, rare, but not as rare as I'd like.
311
00:18:04,529 --> 00:18:08,461
Well, the good news is there's
an arboretum of black poplars
312
00:18:08,462 --> 00:18:12,043
near one of the two roads
that comes off Southbay Bridge.
313
00:18:12,199 --> 00:18:15,889
Now, as you know, speculation is
something that I try to avoid.
314
00:18:15,890 --> 00:18:17,319
What do you think happened, Velvy?
315
00:18:17,320 --> 00:18:22,760
I think that Woods was killed and
possibly buried at the arboretum.
316
00:18:23,083 --> 00:18:26,882
The killer then drove Woods's
car to Southbay Bridge
317
00:18:26,883 --> 00:18:31,122
in the knowledge that - A,
people jump off it, and - B,
318
00:18:31,123 --> 00:18:34,867
bodies that go in the water are
often swept out to sea.
319
00:18:35,445 --> 00:18:37,643
Speculation suits you, Velvy.
320
00:19:12,880 --> 00:19:15,608
..29. Looks like we've got
an indication here.
321
00:19:21,865 --> 00:19:23,366
What is it? What've they found?
322
00:19:23,367 --> 00:19:25,458
Andrew, just give us a minute, yeah?
323
00:19:39,479 --> 00:19:44,031
Body is partly skeletal,
partly adiopocere.
324
00:19:44,377 --> 00:19:47,711
Hair has fallen away,
face is decomposed.
325
00:19:48,294 --> 00:19:52,400
Woods was last seen wearing
an anorak with Man United insignia.
326
00:19:52,833 --> 00:19:54,629
Hands are bound behind his back.
327
00:19:55,299 --> 00:19:57,319
Looks like they used cable ties.
328
00:19:57,320 --> 00:19:58,629
The cash van guy?
329
00:19:58,630 --> 00:20:00,697
- Wes Carter.
- Used cable ties, didn't he?
330
00:20:00,875 --> 00:20:02,443
What about Wes Carter?
331
00:20:08,972 --> 00:20:11,265
Meena! Wes Carter.
332
00:20:18,963 --> 00:20:20,763
Police. Open up!
333
00:20:23,080 --> 00:20:25,918
- I appreciate you doing this.
- It's our job.
334
00:20:26,304 --> 00:20:30,369
After everything,
asking Bill Burnett just felt wrong.
335
00:20:31,361 --> 00:20:32,721
Was there something else?
336
00:20:34,699 --> 00:20:37,738
Kate would like to sit in on the PM.
337
00:20:40,970 --> 00:20:43,523
It's OK with me, if it's OK with you.
338
00:20:44,578 --> 00:20:45,938
Are you sure?
339
00:21:01,323 --> 00:21:02,723
Have you said anything?
340
00:21:08,563 --> 00:21:10,882
- What are you doing here, Andrew?
- Following a lead.
341
00:21:10,883 --> 00:21:12,162
A link, anyway.
342
00:21:12,163 --> 00:21:17,194
A link? Oh, let me guess, between
Ryan's testimony about a masked man
343
00:21:17,219 --> 00:21:20,258
and a tip-off from West Yorks
about a bloke doing over cash vans?
344
00:21:20,259 --> 00:21:24,442
We just found a body matching the
clothes Woods was last seen wearing,
345
00:21:24,443 --> 00:21:26,802
about a mile from Southbay Bridge.
346
00:21:26,803 --> 00:21:28,883
Hands bound with cable ties.
347
00:21:29,233 --> 00:21:31,562
A rather more compelling
link than a mask,
348
00:21:31,563 --> 00:21:32,961
wouldn't you say?
349
00:21:39,083 --> 00:21:40,563
There's nothing here.
350
00:21:41,462 --> 00:21:43,243
I'm not so sure, sir.
351
00:21:48,843 --> 00:21:50,871
Let's not tip this one over the floor.
352
00:21:53,123 --> 00:21:54,468
Cor.
353
00:21:54,575 --> 00:21:56,698
There's got to be at least two
hundred grand here.
354
00:21:56,699 --> 00:21:58,974
We need to check this against
the cash from the vans.
355
00:21:58,975 --> 00:22:00,124
Oh, no shit.
356
00:22:00,469 --> 00:22:01,738
Is there any more?
357
00:22:05,003 --> 00:22:06,377
Just this.
358
00:22:12,843 --> 00:22:14,292
Ventight.
359
00:22:14,942 --> 00:22:17,363
Same brand of tie we found on Woods.
360
00:22:21,979 --> 00:22:23,967
The deceased is an adult male,
361
00:22:23,968 --> 00:22:26,977
provisionally identified as Fred Woods.
362
00:22:27,643 --> 00:22:29,725
We're waiting for DNA confirmation.
363
00:22:29,923 --> 00:22:32,899
There's putrefaction,
consistent with the body being
364
00:22:32,900 --> 00:22:35,753
deceased for a significant
period of time.
365
00:22:35,754 --> 00:22:38,103
There's evidence of a broken neck.
366
00:22:38,522 --> 00:22:41,740
There is grit embedded in the skull
that we'll be comparing
367
00:22:41,741 --> 00:22:45,060
to the sandstone boulders in the stream.
368
00:22:45,323 --> 00:22:49,162
So, what, he fell head first
into the creek,
369
00:22:49,163 --> 00:22:52,384
cracked his skull on a boulder
and broke his neck?
370
00:22:52,749 --> 00:22:55,921
Easy to imagine with his hands
bound behind his back.
371
00:23:05,963 --> 00:23:09,802
So Fred's just lying there
in the dark with a smashed skull
372
00:23:09,803 --> 00:23:15,257
and a broken neck, potentially still
conscious or semi-conscious...
373
00:23:16,223 --> 00:23:19,158
..and then he drowns?
374
00:23:19,427 --> 00:23:20,887
We can't say for sure.
375
00:23:21,333 --> 00:23:24,148
The C2 fracture could've
been rapidly fatal,
376
00:23:24,425 --> 00:23:28,635
but we just don't know
when decomposition's this advanced.
377
00:23:31,004 --> 00:23:35,083
We'd better catch this bastard,
Ma'am, that's all I can say.
378
00:24:02,247 --> 00:24:04,479
Wes! Wes! Wes!
379
00:24:04,523 --> 00:24:06,123
Don't be fucking stupid!
380
00:24:08,150 --> 00:24:10,262
Head that way, cut him off.
381
00:24:56,723 --> 00:24:57,763
UH!
382
00:25:14,723 --> 00:25:16,363
Ah, sh...
383
00:26:42,757 --> 00:26:45,312
Here! OVER HERE!
384
00:26:49,523 --> 00:26:52,216
What happened? Walsh?
385
00:26:52,217 --> 00:26:54,110
I told him to stop. He wouldn't.
386
00:26:54,111 --> 00:26:55,883
Tried to push me over.
387
00:27:07,713 --> 00:27:10,976
We've matched the size
and waffle-style tread
388
00:27:10,977 --> 00:27:12,913
of Nike trainers in your closet
389
00:27:12,937 --> 00:27:15,765
to the
muddy print on PC Woods's brake pedal.
390
00:27:16,413 --> 00:27:19,066
We also DNA'd
the head-rest inside Woods's car
391
00:27:19,067 --> 00:27:20,735
and scored a match... to you.
392
00:27:22,101 --> 00:27:25,081
The forensics tie you to the
murder of a policeman, Neil.
393
00:27:25,082 --> 00:27:27,509
So now's the time to cooperate.
394
00:27:27,652 --> 00:27:29,392
Don't dig your hole any deeper.
395
00:27:31,412 --> 00:27:34,475
Look, I didn't kill anyone, all
right? Nothing like that.
396
00:27:34,831 --> 00:27:35,778
OK.
397
00:27:36,055 --> 00:27:37,309
So what happened?
398
00:27:38,283 --> 00:27:41,362
I was paid to hassle a few
residents in Harbour Fields.
399
00:27:41,363 --> 00:27:43,842
Protestors against the
Goshawk Construction development?
400
00:27:43,843 --> 00:27:47,283
Numpties fighting against the
compulsory purchase order.
401
00:27:47,370 --> 00:27:49,325
What did "hassling" them entail?
402
00:27:49,399 --> 00:27:51,776
A broken window here,
a late night call there.
403
00:27:52,137 --> 00:27:53,516
A few slashed tyres.
404
00:27:53,643 --> 00:27:55,789
Then, when Wes came to stay,
405
00:27:56,270 --> 00:27:58,446
it's safe to say I was...
406
00:27:58,723 --> 00:28:00,989
..able to bolster my services.
407
00:28:01,283 --> 00:28:02,512
Who paid you?
408
00:28:02,763 --> 00:28:03,727
Don't know.
409
00:28:03,728 --> 00:28:06,375
I mean, I assume Goshawk
Construction, ultimately,
410
00:28:06,376 --> 00:28:07,485
somewhere down the line.
411
00:28:07,576 --> 00:28:09,184
How were you paid, then?
412
00:28:09,185 --> 00:28:12,982
Money was put into my account via
a front called Standant LTD.
413
00:28:13,007 --> 00:28:14,457
A shell company?
414
00:28:14,458 --> 00:28:16,362
Yeah, I googled 'em.
415
00:28:16,363 --> 00:28:17,922
Based in the Virgin Islands.
416
00:28:17,923 --> 00:28:22,476
I only dealt with one bloke -
called himself Marcus, via a burner.
417
00:28:23,826 --> 00:28:25,322
Caller unknown.
418
00:28:25,323 --> 00:28:26,819
So you can't help us?
419
00:28:27,433 --> 00:28:29,390
Can't help us help you?
420
00:28:30,595 --> 00:28:32,707
You've got to give us something,
Neil. And the sooner the better,
421
00:28:32,708 --> 00:28:34,961
or this stops looking like cooperation
422
00:28:35,210 --> 00:28:36,438
and more like desperation.
423
00:28:36,439 --> 00:28:39,344
Bear in mind, your phone and laptop
are being examined right now.
424
00:28:51,747 --> 00:28:54,962
Marcus told me and Wes
to give Woods a scare, right,
425
00:28:54,963 --> 00:28:56,933
cos he'd been asking difficult
questions at work.
426
00:28:56,934 --> 00:29:00,442
I didn't start out wanting to hurt
him. He's a copper, right,
427
00:29:00,443 --> 00:29:01,609
I'm not daft.
428
00:29:01,610 --> 00:29:03,666
What, just roughed him up a bit?
429
00:29:03,883 --> 00:29:05,227
Wes did.
430
00:29:05,762 --> 00:29:08,418
He cable tied his hands
while I showed him the money.
431
00:29:09,075 --> 00:29:11,081
Look, I thought he was going
to go for it,
432
00:29:11,421 --> 00:29:16,993
but then he just belted it
into the trees, that was that.
433
00:29:20,563 --> 00:29:22,257
Let's talk about Carol Laing.
434
00:29:22,882 --> 00:29:26,041
There's eyewitness testimony that
places Wes at the scene.
435
00:29:26,403 --> 00:29:28,070
It points towards him killing Carol
436
00:29:28,071 --> 00:29:30,225
in the process of stealing her
jewellery.
437
00:29:30,762 --> 00:29:33,226
Yeah, nice try.
438
00:29:33,498 --> 00:29:35,306
- He didn't do that.
- How do you know?
439
00:29:35,331 --> 00:29:36,947
Cos I was his favourite uncle.
440
00:29:36,948 --> 00:29:38,430
He never kept anything from me.
441
00:29:38,431 --> 00:29:40,446
That's not exactly compelling, Neil.
442
00:29:41,460 --> 00:29:45,762
He 'fessed up to those cash vans
robberies as soon as I asked him.
443
00:29:45,883 --> 00:29:49,213
And for that very reason,
I asked him about the Laing woman.
444
00:29:49,298 --> 00:29:51,695
The fact you even had to ask him
contradicts your statement
445
00:29:51,720 --> 00:29:55,484
that he spent the night fixing
a leak at the pub, doesn't it, Neil?
446
00:29:57,234 --> 00:30:00,820
So, forgive us if we take everything
you say with a pinch of salt.
447
00:30:08,416 --> 00:30:11,566
Detectives? I need to tell you
something in confidence.
448
00:30:12,203 --> 00:30:16,756
According to Kate Freeman,
Palmer threatened Woods
449
00:30:16,781 --> 00:30:20,381
when he asked why patrols were being
diverted from Harbour Fields.
450
00:30:20,406 --> 00:30:22,162
Well, what did Palmer say to Woods?
451
00:30:22,163 --> 00:30:24,363
"There are faster ways to
die than cancer."
452
00:30:26,896 --> 00:30:29,163
I'll have to pass that on to
Police Conduct.
453
00:30:38,135 --> 00:30:40,725
There's massive trauma to
the body and head,
454
00:30:40,726 --> 00:30:44,074
consistent with a significant
fall onto a hard surface.
455
00:30:45,193 --> 00:30:47,982
There's damage to the side
of the skull, consistent with him
456
00:30:47,983 --> 00:30:50,112
landing on his right side.
457
00:30:50,523 --> 00:30:52,699
There's a contusion to the forehead
458
00:30:53,003 --> 00:30:55,489
and some particles
embedded in the wound.
459
00:31:06,363 --> 00:31:10,087
Contusions in the left
upper frontotemporal region.
460
00:31:10,578 --> 00:31:13,029
Unusual, given the plane of impact.
461
00:31:13,483 --> 00:31:16,442
And it's inconsistent with
Jack's account of grappling
462
00:31:16,443 --> 00:31:18,146
and fighting with the deceased.
463
00:31:18,495 --> 00:31:20,265
You spoke to Andrew in detail,
464
00:31:20,290 --> 00:31:22,862
do you think you could flesh out
the scene for us?
465
00:31:23,003 --> 00:31:24,085
I'll try.
466
00:31:24,086 --> 00:31:27,809
He said he saw Carter walking up
the path in a westerly direction?
467
00:31:27,834 --> 00:31:28,667
Yes.
468
00:31:28,668 --> 00:31:30,602
Andrew ran onto the path, ahead of him.
469
00:31:30,603 --> 00:31:32,828
He told him to stop,
then Wes grabbed him
470
00:31:32,829 --> 00:31:34,563
and tried to shove him over.
471
00:31:35,573 --> 00:31:39,928
The front of Wes's T-shirt
is bloody from his nose injury.
472
00:31:40,971 --> 00:31:44,763
I found what could be
a handprint in the blood.
473
00:31:46,108 --> 00:31:49,436
I asked Andrew point-blank
if he pushed Wes.
474
00:31:49,923 --> 00:31:52,482
He said he didn't remember
but conceded that, yes,
475
00:31:52,483 --> 00:31:54,802
he could've pushed him
in the altercation,
476
00:31:54,803 --> 00:31:58,162
because... he was in fear for his life.
477
00:32:11,843 --> 00:32:13,203
Come in.
478
00:32:21,362 --> 00:32:23,450
If I was to look at your
bank account, Ray,
479
00:32:23,451 --> 00:32:25,865
would I find any unexplained payments?
480
00:32:25,866 --> 00:32:28,173
Specifically from some untraceable,
481
00:32:28,174 --> 00:32:32,443
bounced-around-the-world shell
company called Standant LTD?
482
00:32:34,345 --> 00:32:36,185
I need an answer, I'm afraid.
483
00:32:54,340 --> 00:32:55,964
Oh, Ray,
484
00:32:56,276 --> 00:32:58,955
how could you be so bloody stupid?
485
00:32:58,980 --> 00:33:02,754
All I did was shift patrols
away from Harbour Fields, that's it.
486
00:33:02,825 --> 00:33:04,181
Why was that so important?
487
00:33:04,182 --> 00:33:06,612
I don't know, to drive the crime
stats up, I suppose.
488
00:33:06,613 --> 00:33:07,675
You suppose?
489
00:33:07,676 --> 00:33:10,169
Look, I had nothing to do with
Fred Woods, all right? Nothing.
490
00:33:10,170 --> 00:33:12,134
But you threatened him, didn't you?
491
00:33:13,514 --> 00:33:14,678
I had a word.
492
00:33:14,679 --> 00:33:15,950
Big deal.
493
00:33:16,185 --> 00:33:17,463
"Big deal"?
494
00:33:17,801 --> 00:33:21,147
I placed Kate Freeman on
fucking suspension
495
00:33:21,172 --> 00:33:24,243
because she came to me
with nothing less than the truth!
496
00:33:24,494 --> 00:33:26,838
Can't believe you'd do this, Ray.
497
00:33:26,990 --> 00:33:28,706
Just for a bit of cash.
498
00:33:29,180 --> 00:33:33,627
They offered me a fortune to stop
police operations in Harbour Fields.
499
00:33:33,628 --> 00:33:35,592
Let it go to the dogs.
500
00:33:35,640 --> 00:33:39,218
So some fucking property
developer got it for a song.
501
00:33:39,219 --> 00:33:42,986
Listen, I knew Neil Carter was scaring
the protestors at Harbour Fields,
502
00:33:42,987 --> 00:33:46,994
but I had no idea that his ex-para
nephew was hitting town.
503
00:33:46,995 --> 00:33:49,252
I thought West Yorkshire dealt
with this when he moved down.
504
00:33:49,253 --> 00:33:51,722
Yeah, well, they did.
But Andrew Walsh took the call.
505
00:33:51,723 --> 00:33:54,369
- And...?
- In his wisdom, he sat on it.
506
00:33:55,516 --> 00:33:58,171
Only him and Puri knew until this week.
507
00:34:01,740 --> 00:34:04,094
The Carol Laing inquiry
is being wound down.
508
00:34:04,754 --> 00:34:08,297
We just wanted to say thank you for
your critical involvement
509
00:34:08,298 --> 00:34:10,723
- and working in a pretty...
- Wound down?
510
00:34:10,724 --> 00:34:13,580
Obviously, the Coroner's work is ongoing
and there'll be an inquest...
511
00:34:13,581 --> 00:34:16,159
Because guilt is being
ascribed to Wes Carter?
512
00:34:16,806 --> 00:34:19,557
I think that's premature.
513
00:34:19,740 --> 00:34:20,817
Well, with respect...
514
00:34:20,818 --> 00:34:22,244
Why do you think it's premature?
515
00:34:22,245 --> 00:34:26,480
There are things about Carol's
murder that chime with Carter's MO.
516
00:34:26,481 --> 00:34:30,899
Lots of things - the mask,
the knife, the black clothes,
517
00:34:30,900 --> 00:34:32,773
tying his victim's
hands behind their back...
518
00:34:32,774 --> 00:34:35,008
But there are significant
differences too.
519
00:34:35,009 --> 00:34:37,380
Carter never targeted
private residences,
520
00:34:37,381 --> 00:34:41,325
he used cable-ties, and his booty
of choice was cash, not jewellery.
521
00:34:41,460 --> 00:34:43,299
I still go back to the "why?"
522
00:34:43,300 --> 00:34:46,006
Why did he go into the boys'
room and make contact?
523
00:34:46,007 --> 00:34:47,240
Why take that risk?
524
00:34:47,241 --> 00:34:48,875
He wanted to be seen and heard.
525
00:34:48,876 --> 00:34:51,578
Whoever grabbed Ryan Laing
couldn't shut up!
526
00:34:51,579 --> 00:34:53,438
The only explanation is,
527
00:34:53,684 --> 00:34:56,954
he wanted Ryan Laing to give
the testimony that he did.
528
00:34:56,955 --> 00:34:59,752
If we were in court that would
definitely be deemed "conjecture".
529
00:34:59,753 --> 00:35:01,190
But we're not in court.
530
00:35:01,639 --> 00:35:04,039
If you're right, there's a problem.
531
00:35:04,495 --> 00:35:07,459
If the killer was trying to
lead us to Wes, then...
532
00:35:07,460 --> 00:35:09,227
How did they get
hold of the information?
533
00:35:09,228 --> 00:35:10,164
Hey?
534
00:35:10,860 --> 00:35:12,925
When West Yorkshire
got in touch about Wes,
535
00:35:12,926 --> 00:35:17,068
we decided to keep the intel
on a... strictly need-to-know basis.
536
00:35:18,900 --> 00:35:20,051
Why?
537
00:35:20,460 --> 00:35:21,539
Frankly?
538
00:35:21,540 --> 00:35:24,859
Cos Wes's uncle, Neil Carter,
has a lot of mates in CID.
539
00:35:24,860 --> 00:35:26,467
From Ray Palmer down.
540
00:35:33,131 --> 00:35:35,342
It's Bridget. Need to go and update her.
541
00:35:35,950 --> 00:35:38,659
Ray Palmer's been suspended
and I've replaced him.
542
00:35:38,820 --> 00:35:40,071
Acting DCI.
543
00:35:40,340 --> 00:35:41,380
Huh.
544
00:36:00,901 --> 00:36:02,581
I'm looking for my scarf.
545
00:36:03,532 --> 00:36:04,972
You seen it?
546
00:36:05,321 --> 00:36:06,708
What scarf?
547
00:36:06,758 --> 00:36:08,651
The gingham one I got in the sale.
548
00:36:12,412 --> 00:36:13,678
What?
549
00:36:17,518 --> 00:36:18,766
Doesn't matter.
550
00:36:25,387 --> 00:36:27,827
Could you zoom in on the
knife, please, Velvy?
551
00:36:29,955 --> 00:36:31,557
It's a double-edged blade.
552
00:36:31,558 --> 00:36:32,969
Yes, it is.
553
00:36:33,278 --> 00:36:36,831
The stab wound looks symmetrical -
both ends of the wound pointed,
554
00:36:36,856 --> 00:36:38,229
sharp, V-shaped.
555
00:36:38,230 --> 00:36:39,752
Key word there being "looks".
556
00:36:39,753 --> 00:36:42,954
We're actually looking at a single
edged blade wielded with such
557
00:36:42,955 --> 00:36:45,457
force the skin behind
the blunt edge split.
558
00:36:45,458 --> 00:36:48,493
Leaving something which looks
V-shaped but isn't quite.
559
00:36:48,494 --> 00:36:50,543
One of the ends has a fishtail.
560
00:36:51,530 --> 00:36:54,705
So, if someone was trying
to mimic Carter's MO,
561
00:36:54,953 --> 00:36:57,117
it was likely improvised, not planned.
562
00:36:57,118 --> 00:36:59,037
Otherwise you'd bring a
double-edged blade?
563
00:36:59,038 --> 00:37:00,277
And cable ties.
564
00:37:00,278 --> 00:37:01,437
Both easy to source.
565
00:37:01,438 --> 00:37:03,100
What about the mask and the coat?
566
00:37:03,438 --> 00:37:05,782
Could've used Carol's gym
leggings for the former,
567
00:37:05,783 --> 00:37:08,958
and Mike says he's missing a
black coat from his closet.
568
00:37:09,734 --> 00:37:13,838
The brown particles I retrieved
from the wound on Wes's forehead...
569
00:37:14,220 --> 00:37:18,658
it's bark from a Fraxinus
excelsior, AKA the common ash.
570
00:37:18,659 --> 00:37:20,408
OK. How did it get there?
571
00:37:20,679 --> 00:37:22,408
No wood or trees down on the rocks.
572
00:37:22,409 --> 00:37:26,096
Suggesting contact was
made before he fell.
573
00:37:27,515 --> 00:37:30,566
And with sufficient force to
penetrate his scalp.
574
00:37:31,189 --> 00:37:32,462
What are you saying?
575
00:37:32,801 --> 00:37:36,277
I'm sorry, Meena,
but the evidence is telling us
576
00:37:36,278 --> 00:37:38,409
that Andrew was the aggressor.
577
00:37:46,988 --> 00:37:50,526
What's all this?
You're not going back to work?
578
00:37:51,821 --> 00:37:53,084
Not today.
579
00:38:07,518 --> 00:38:09,438
I'm worried about you.
580
00:38:09,797 --> 00:38:11,160
Drinking...
581
00:38:11,998 --> 00:38:13,438
..missing work.
582
00:38:14,558 --> 00:38:16,158
It's Carol, isn't it?
583
00:38:18,238 --> 00:38:20,063
I don't want to talk about Carol.
584
00:38:24,785 --> 00:38:28,438
Let's talk about your scarf,
where it could be.
585
00:38:28,697 --> 00:38:31,576
Oh, if I knew, I wouldn't be
looking for it, would I?
586
00:38:33,718 --> 00:38:35,338
No, I suppose not.
587
00:38:38,700 --> 00:38:40,261
I'm not stupid.
588
00:38:41,838 --> 00:38:43,516
I can tell something's up.
589
00:38:44,378 --> 00:38:45,678
What is it?
590
00:38:47,926 --> 00:38:50,078
All right, be like that.
591
00:38:51,958 --> 00:38:53,577
I know what you did.
592
00:38:55,336 --> 00:38:57,718
I found your scarf at Carol's...
593
00:38:59,518 --> 00:39:00,918
..in her blood.
594
00:39:21,558 --> 00:39:23,118
Carol? No...
595
00:39:25,158 --> 00:39:26,478
No!
596
00:39:46,358 --> 00:39:48,128
I understand.
597
00:39:48,796 --> 00:39:50,567
You weren't jealous.
598
00:39:52,068 --> 00:39:54,046
You were just scared of losing me.
599
00:39:56,763 --> 00:39:59,070
So, you removed the competition.
600
00:40:02,238 --> 00:40:03,648
It's OK.
601
00:40:04,678 --> 00:40:06,363
I'm want to take care of you
602
00:40:07,018 --> 00:40:08,595
and protect you...
603
00:40:10,734 --> 00:40:14,221
..now and wherever we end up next.
604
00:40:17,464 --> 00:40:19,117
What are you talking about?
605
00:40:19,118 --> 00:40:20,958
Just tell me what happened.
606
00:40:22,582 --> 00:40:24,380
I did go and see Carol...
607
00:40:25,798 --> 00:40:27,367
..but just for a coffee.
608
00:40:28,728 --> 00:40:30,924
Everyone thinks you're married to me,
609
00:40:31,953 --> 00:40:34,621
that I'm your ball and chain.
610
00:40:36,661 --> 00:40:40,101
I didn't want that to spoil things
when you'd waited so long.
611
00:40:40,398 --> 00:40:45,957
What happened, Lisa? She took it
the wrong way? You lost it? What?
612
00:40:45,958 --> 00:40:49,312
No. No, she was fine...
613
00:40:50,279 --> 00:40:52,331
She said she was touched...
614
00:40:53,669 --> 00:40:58,852
..just a bit taken aback,
you know, by me going round.
615
00:41:00,324 --> 00:41:03,718
She didn't deny there was something
going on, but she said it was
616
00:41:03,798 --> 00:41:08,096
early days and Mike was still
a big part of her life.
617
00:41:09,862 --> 00:41:11,198
But she said...
618
00:41:15,473 --> 00:41:18,705
..she said she was hopeful
for a future with YOU.
619
00:41:22,998 --> 00:41:24,472
And then I left.
620
00:41:26,156 --> 00:41:27,611
I went to the gym,
621
00:41:28,130 --> 00:41:29,714
popped to the supermarket...
622
00:41:30,580 --> 00:41:32,253
..and I came home.
623
00:42:15,515 --> 00:42:17,638
All our years in foster care...
624
00:42:19,966 --> 00:42:21,517
I'm not making excuses...
625
00:42:21,518 --> 00:42:22,558
But?
626
00:42:25,278 --> 00:42:27,838
It's hard-wired in me, defending her...
627
00:42:30,057 --> 00:42:31,337
..protecting her.
628
00:42:33,311 --> 00:42:37,169
All I could think was if she comes
round and ID's Lisa, then it's over.
629
00:42:37,518 --> 00:42:39,303
And then it just came into my head.
630
00:42:40,465 --> 00:42:43,677
Earlier that day, I'd got
an email from West Yorks asking
631
00:42:43,678 --> 00:42:46,808
if Wes was still keeping his nose clean.
632
00:42:50,920 --> 00:42:52,438
I knew what to do.
633
00:43:28,868 --> 00:43:32,221
Carol was dying anyway -
you didn't need to stab her.
634
00:43:32,248 --> 00:43:33,915
You didn't need to do a thing!
635
00:43:34,447 --> 00:43:36,604
You've no idea how true that is.
636
00:43:37,468 --> 00:43:40,373
There was nothing stopping me
rushing her to A&E.
637
00:43:41,220 --> 00:43:42,477
Nothing at all.
638
00:43:42,478 --> 00:43:43,678
So why didn't you?
639
00:43:44,505 --> 00:43:45,869
I saw Lisa's scarf
640
00:43:45,870 --> 00:43:47,926
and I jumped to the wrong conclusion.
641
00:43:49,478 --> 00:43:51,438
Lisa had nothing to do with it.
642
00:43:52,878 --> 00:43:54,638
She was at the gym...
643
00:43:55,718 --> 00:43:57,368
..and then the supermarket.
644
00:43:57,369 --> 00:43:59,146
What about Wesley Carter?
645
00:43:59,558 --> 00:44:01,314
He dropped like a stone.
646
00:44:01,690 --> 00:44:03,264
I only hit him once.
647
00:44:04,758 --> 00:44:06,706
And I was hoping Lisa would be the same.
648
00:44:22,878 --> 00:44:24,265
Andrew!
649
00:44:24,438 --> 00:44:25,831
ANDREW!
650
00:44:26,198 --> 00:44:27,717
Andrew, come here.
651
00:44:27,718 --> 00:44:29,197
I'm going to kill you!
652
00:44:29,198 --> 00:44:30,757
I'M GOING TO KILL YOU!
653
00:44:41,038 --> 00:44:42,280
Where are we?
654
00:44:42,891 --> 00:44:44,273
Essentially?
655
00:44:44,750 --> 00:44:48,340
Sadly, we have no reason to doubt
Andrew's version of events,
656
00:44:48,365 --> 00:44:51,117
especially in the light of him
confessing to Wes Carter.
657
00:44:51,118 --> 00:44:55,158
He also directed us to a
bin bag containing these items.
658
00:44:55,438 --> 00:44:56,918
Kitchen knife...
659
00:44:58,318 --> 00:44:59,918
Lisa's scarf...
660
00:45:01,789 --> 00:45:03,115
..Mike's coat.
661
00:45:05,346 --> 00:45:08,741
But he says that he didn't see
a dumbbell when he arrived
662
00:45:08,742 --> 00:45:11,458
at the scene and found Carol
unconscious on the floor.
663
00:45:11,739 --> 00:45:14,557
As a detective,
he said he looked for a weapon,
664
00:45:14,558 --> 00:45:16,758
but couldn't find a likely candidate.
665
00:45:17,261 --> 00:45:19,981
For what it's worth,
I'm inclined to believe him.
666
00:45:21,209 --> 00:45:23,117
And we're sure Lisa's in the clear?
667
00:45:23,118 --> 00:45:25,843
We're sure - CCTV has her
leaving the gym at 9.30,
668
00:45:25,844 --> 00:45:29,808
stopping in a supermarket, then
entering her street just before ten.
669
00:45:30,253 --> 00:45:32,677
At least we've solved
the mystery as to why the killer
670
00:45:32,678 --> 00:45:34,237
waited in the house for two hours.
671
00:45:34,238 --> 00:45:37,542
They didn't -
we're dealing with two offenders.
672
00:45:37,981 --> 00:45:41,237
And it's important to stress that
whoever hit Carol with
673
00:45:41,238 --> 00:45:43,518
the dumbbell used massive force.
674
00:45:43,837 --> 00:45:46,478
And regardless of what Andrew did later,
675
00:45:47,084 --> 00:45:50,210
it could have been a
fatal injury, eventually.
676
00:45:50,298 --> 00:45:51,557
Attempted murder,
677
00:45:51,558 --> 00:45:52,838
at the very least.
678
00:45:52,940 --> 00:45:54,358
Something else, Ma'am.
679
00:45:54,359 --> 00:45:57,397
I trawled the notes from house to
house with fresh eyes.
680
00:45:57,398 --> 00:46:00,317
A witness saw someone throw
something over the sea wall
681
00:46:00,318 --> 00:46:04,157
in front of Carol's
house between 9.15 pm and 9.30 pm.
682
00:46:04,158 --> 00:46:05,557
Jesus.
683
00:46:05,558 --> 00:46:08,741
Time and location fit with the
attacker discarding the dumbbell.
684
00:46:08,918 --> 00:46:10,637
You want to search the shoreline?
685
00:46:10,638 --> 00:46:13,440
We'll cover it
and whatever else you need.
686
00:46:25,678 --> 00:46:27,318
Hey, Hey!
687
00:46:36,918 --> 00:46:38,198
Let me see it!
688
00:46:47,718 --> 00:46:51,101
A bus passes twice an hour,
cameras front and back.
689
00:46:51,518 --> 00:46:52,957
Check the timetable.
690
00:46:52,958 --> 00:46:54,598
If the last bus was on time,
691
00:46:54,838 --> 00:46:56,518
we could be in business.
692
00:46:57,638 --> 00:46:58,807
Oh...
693
00:46:58,998 --> 00:47:00,529
Here we go.
694
00:47:07,799 --> 00:47:09,437
That's not Mike Laing.
695
00:47:09,438 --> 00:47:10,589
Too slight.
696
00:47:11,141 --> 00:47:12,237
Kate Freeman?
697
00:47:12,238 --> 00:47:15,517
Look at their right hand when the
bus passes and the lights hit.
698
00:47:15,518 --> 00:47:16,709
I'll call Puri.
699
00:47:18,084 --> 00:47:19,242
Wait.
700
00:47:19,243 --> 00:47:20,709
Let me have a crack at this.
701
00:47:20,710 --> 00:47:22,877
I've got some gait analysis software
702
00:47:22,878 --> 00:47:24,505
that I've been waiting to use.
703
00:47:49,038 --> 00:47:51,696
Sue said I should've packed it in at 60.
704
00:47:52,494 --> 00:47:56,291
The moral of that story is you
should always listen to your wife.
705
00:47:56,398 --> 00:47:59,556
Who knows?
I might actually enjoy retirement.
706
00:47:59,581 --> 00:48:01,398
Lisa, could you get some more onions?
707
00:48:01,963 --> 00:48:04,597
Cheer up, Bill, might never happen.
708
00:48:04,598 --> 00:48:05,824
Ignore him.
709
00:48:05,998 --> 00:48:07,481
There's drinks over there.
710
00:48:07,482 --> 00:48:10,021
There are more beers in the fridge,
if they're not cold enough.
711
00:48:12,001 --> 00:48:13,438
Oh, Mum.
712
00:48:15,198 --> 00:48:16,773
You want me to get rid of him?
713
00:48:16,998 --> 00:48:18,038
Please.
714
00:48:19,478 --> 00:48:21,564
Don't... burn... the chicken wings.
715
00:48:29,810 --> 00:48:30,942
Kate!
716
00:48:34,038 --> 00:48:37,377
I just want to say,
I really appreciate you coming.
717
00:48:38,141 --> 00:48:39,843
I'm happy to be here.
718
00:48:40,078 --> 00:48:42,758
We're not going to fix things
overnight, but it's a start...
719
00:48:42,881 --> 00:48:44,111
It is.
720
00:48:44,445 --> 00:48:47,276
- What did I say about the wings?!
- Sorry.
721
00:48:48,951 --> 00:48:51,180
Oh, shit, it's going to blow away!
722
00:48:56,158 --> 00:48:57,678
Do you need a hand, boys?
723
00:49:14,766 --> 00:49:17,376
I promise we'll come back to
Granny's soon, all right?
724
00:49:19,038 --> 00:49:21,148
That's it, go on, in you get.
725
00:49:23,215 --> 00:49:24,797
Football practice?
726
00:49:24,798 --> 00:49:26,517
Yeah. I totally forgot.
727
00:49:26,518 --> 00:49:28,037
But that's Tuesdays?
728
00:49:28,038 --> 00:49:29,823
Yeah, well, they changed it.
729
00:49:30,304 --> 00:49:31,786
Don't ask me why.
730
00:49:34,947 --> 00:49:36,415
I'll come and get you later.
731
00:49:37,034 --> 00:49:38,838
No hurry, I can help clean up.
732
00:50:06,518 --> 00:50:07,558
Mike?
733
00:50:09,725 --> 00:50:11,941
Let's, um... Take it over here.
734
00:50:15,492 --> 00:50:16,799
Is Dom OK?
735
00:50:19,438 --> 00:50:21,038
What did you want to ask me?
736
00:50:22,118 --> 00:50:24,582
When you and Kate
first came to the Lyell,
737
00:50:24,854 --> 00:50:26,383
the day after the murder,
738
00:50:26,408 --> 00:50:28,393
she had bruises on her right wrist.
739
00:50:28,418 --> 00:50:29,978
She said you made them.
740
00:50:30,037 --> 00:50:31,759
We'd been drinking.
741
00:50:32,198 --> 00:50:35,985
I was feeling low
about being stuck in uniform.
742
00:50:36,295 --> 00:50:37,733
And I said that...
743
00:50:37,758 --> 00:50:41,053
the only way Mum was going to let me
back in the CID was...
744
00:50:42,078 --> 00:50:43,682
..if I moved home to Carol.
745
00:50:44,034 --> 00:50:45,389
And she lost it.
746
00:50:45,414 --> 00:50:47,104
She really, really lost it.
747
00:50:47,318 --> 00:50:49,197
Said that she was going to go
and stay at a mate's
748
00:50:49,198 --> 00:50:51,318
but she'd had way too much to drink,
and...
749
00:50:54,344 --> 00:50:56,338
..I had to get her keys off her somehow.
750
00:51:02,438 --> 00:51:03,786
What is it, Mike?
751
00:51:06,758 --> 00:51:08,157
Dom's adamant...
752
00:51:08,158 --> 00:51:12,640
He's adamant that it was Kate's
voice he heard speaking to his mum.
753
00:51:14,518 --> 00:51:16,158
And you believe him now?
754
00:51:17,678 --> 00:51:18,758
Dom?
755
00:51:20,038 --> 00:51:21,158
Come here.
756
00:51:27,478 --> 00:51:28,643
Look...
757
00:51:29,558 --> 00:51:31,278
I believe you, mate.
758
00:51:32,478 --> 00:51:36,103
I believe it was Kate's voice
that you heard.
759
00:51:40,407 --> 00:51:43,415
Do you remember what
they were arguing about, Dom?
760
00:51:44,005 --> 00:51:46,986
Do you remember any specific words?
761
00:51:52,838 --> 00:51:54,445
"Uniform".
762
00:51:55,621 --> 00:51:58,078
They were arguing about uniforms.
763
00:52:00,598 --> 00:52:02,358
Well done, mate. Go on.
764
00:52:07,302 --> 00:52:09,107
You gave Kate a scare.
765
00:52:09,586 --> 00:52:12,936
She knew how much you wanted
to get back in CID.
766
00:52:13,560 --> 00:52:15,554
How much you missed the boys.
767
00:52:15,638 --> 00:52:19,307
So, the next day, hungover and paranoid,
768
00:52:19,308 --> 00:52:21,117
she confronts Carol.
769
00:52:21,118 --> 00:52:22,837
A pre-emptive strike.
770
00:52:23,344 --> 00:52:26,798
"If you went back,
it wouldn't be for love.
771
00:52:28,794 --> 00:52:31,671
"It would be to get
out of that bloody uniform."
772
00:52:33,038 --> 00:52:34,744
That sound plausible?
773
00:52:40,150 --> 00:52:41,657
Just in time.
774
00:52:41,658 --> 00:52:44,121
Come! Come!
775
00:52:55,550 --> 00:52:56,830
It all went!
776
00:52:57,025 --> 00:52:58,834
I normally make too much.
777
00:53:02,158 --> 00:53:04,176
Do you think Mike's OK?
778
00:53:04,998 --> 00:53:06,159
Yeah.
779
00:53:06,398 --> 00:53:09,243
I mean, under the circumstances.
780
00:53:10,108 --> 00:53:11,220
Why?
781
00:53:12,532 --> 00:53:14,327
Just him shooting off like that.
782
00:53:15,038 --> 00:53:16,445
I'm sure he's fine.
783
00:53:43,061 --> 00:53:44,442
Is Kate still there?
784
00:53:44,443 --> 00:53:45,862
You've got to keep her there!
785
00:53:46,278 --> 00:53:47,878
I'm still here, Mike.
786
00:53:54,249 --> 00:53:56,008
What's the matter?
787
00:54:15,238 --> 00:54:18,158
- Why...?
- Funny you should ask,
788
00:54:18,965 --> 00:54:22,437
cos in so many ways, you were to blame.
789
00:54:22,438 --> 00:54:24,974
Do you know what, Kate? I'm not
having this conversation with you.
790
00:54:24,975 --> 00:54:27,353
Don't fucking walk away from me.
You know as much as I do,
791
00:54:27,354 --> 00:54:30,178
if Mike came back here, it's only
cos of Bridget. Don't be fooled!
792
00:54:30,179 --> 00:54:33,243
Oh, what? You think he's that
desperate to get out of uniform?
793
00:54:33,244 --> 00:54:35,554
Jesus, you don't know him at all, do ya?
794
00:54:35,618 --> 00:54:40,169
Cos if you did, you'd know that if
he comes back, it's cos he wants to.
795
00:54:41,236 --> 00:54:44,037
You didn't really think
you were the first, did ya?
796
00:54:44,038 --> 00:54:45,818
You didn't fall for that line, eh?
797
00:54:46,212 --> 00:54:48,624
You did! Wow, this is priceless!
798
00:54:48,625 --> 00:54:53,070
This is fucking hilarious!
Let me guess. What was it? Kids?
799
00:54:53,602 --> 00:54:55,262
Mm? Nuptials?
800
00:54:55,545 --> 00:54:57,878
- You shut it...
- Do you know what?
801
00:54:58,462 --> 00:55:00,757
I ALMOST feel sorry for you.
802
00:55:01,598 --> 00:55:02,678
Almost.
803
00:55:03,998 --> 00:55:05,834
I mean, he said you were thick...
804
00:55:06,659 --> 00:55:08,116
..but Jesus Christ...
805
00:55:20,238 --> 00:55:22,597
Kate Freeman, I am arresting you
806
00:55:22,598 --> 00:55:25,691
on suspicion of the murder
of Carol Laing in Southbay, Essex.
807
00:55:25,838 --> 00:55:27,637
You do not have to say anything,
808
00:55:27,638 --> 00:55:30,717
but it may harm your defence if you
do not mention, when questioned,
809
00:55:30,718 --> 00:55:32,890
something which you later
rely on in court.
810
00:55:51,478 --> 00:55:52,979
I can take her in.
811
00:55:53,612 --> 00:55:55,877
It's years since I felt a collar.
812
00:55:55,878 --> 00:55:57,518
I've missed it.
813
00:56:37,718 --> 00:56:39,584
- You OK?
- Yeah.
814
00:56:40,770 --> 00:56:42,890
Been a nightmare,
this whole thing, hasn't it?
815
00:56:43,078 --> 00:56:45,253
- Bill?
- Bill.
816
00:56:46,998 --> 00:56:49,798
- Can you salvage it?
- I don't know. It's...
817
00:56:50,958 --> 00:56:52,758
..hard to get back, you know?
818
00:56:53,897 --> 00:56:55,577
You think you know someone.
819
00:57:00,758 --> 00:57:03,237
- Southbay's kind of grown on me.
- Uh-oh!
820
00:57:03,238 --> 00:57:05,269
- Bank Holiday coming up...
- Mm-hm.
821
00:57:05,294 --> 00:57:07,570
Fancy a long weekend back in Southbay?
822
00:57:07,595 --> 00:57:09,638
Mmmmmm...
823
00:57:10,638 --> 00:57:12,157
..no.
824
00:57:12,158 --> 00:57:15,298
Why not? Come on,
there's a beautiful beach.
825
00:57:15,299 --> 00:57:17,265
- Come on.
- It's so romantic.
826
00:57:18,250 --> 00:57:20,970
You and I have different
ideas of romance in that case.
827
00:57:37,158 --> 00:57:39,397
Do not throw me in!
828
00:57:49,694 --> 00:57:52,485
Sub extracted from file & improved
by Se7enOfNin9 for Addic7ed.com
63648
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.