Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:02,000 --> 00:00:07,000
Downloaded from
YTS.MX
2
00:00:08,000 --> 00:00:13,000
Official YIFY movies site:
YTS.MX
3
00:00:20,175 --> 00:00:26,388
On August 18,
1934, 20-year-old Ann Cooper Hewitt,
4
00:00:26,457 --> 00:00:28,701
heiress to one of the largest fortunes
5
00:00:28,736 --> 00:00:30,703
in the United States,
6
00:00:30,738 --> 00:00:33,325
was admitted to a San Francisco hospital
7
00:00:33,326 --> 00:00:36,674
for an emergency appendectomy.
8
00:00:36,675 --> 00:00:38,435
She later learned
9
00:00:38,504 --> 00:00:40,850
the surgeons not only
had removed her appendix,
10
00:00:40,851 --> 00:00:43,889
but also a length of her fallopian tubes -
11
00:00:43,923 --> 00:00:47,858
rendering her incapable
of ever becoming pregnant.
12
00:00:47,893 --> 00:00:51,828
The story of the "sterilized heiress"
13
00:00:51,862 --> 00:00:56,383
hit the papers just after
the New Year in 1936,
14
00:00:56,384 --> 00:00:59,421
when Ann filed a half-
million-dollar damage claim
15
00:00:59,456 --> 00:01:02,424
against the surgeons and her own mother
16
00:01:02,493 --> 00:01:03,771
for sterilizing her
17
00:01:03,840 --> 00:01:07,015
without her knowledge or consent.
18
00:01:07,050 --> 00:01:10,467
Ann's mother denied any wrongdoing.
19
00:01:10,536 --> 00:01:12,918
She'd done what she'd done
for "society's sake,"
20
00:01:12,987 --> 00:01:14,401
she insisted,
21
00:01:14,402 --> 00:01:17,785
because her daughter was
"feebleminded."
22
00:01:17,854 --> 00:01:21,374
It was the sort of bizarre,
high-society scandal
23
00:01:21,409 --> 00:01:23,721
that would have captured
the national imagination
24
00:01:23,722 --> 00:01:26,068
under any circumstances.
25
00:01:26,069 --> 00:01:29,210
But that one word, "feeble-minded,"
26
00:01:29,244 --> 00:01:32,419
struck a familiar chord for Americans
27
00:01:32,420 --> 00:01:35,595
and linked Ann's plight
to a decades-old campaign
28
00:01:35,596 --> 00:01:41,049
to control human reproduction,
known as eugenics.
29
00:01:41,084 --> 00:01:43,051
What is
the bearing of the laws of heredity
30
00:01:43,086 --> 00:01:44,984
upon human affairs?
31
00:01:45,053 --> 00:01:47,608
Eugenics provides the answer.
32
00:01:47,642 --> 00:01:51,576
Eugenics was
proposed as the scientific solution
33
00:01:51,577 --> 00:01:53,130
for social problems.
34
00:01:53,165 --> 00:01:58,826
It was a combination of hope
and aspiration on one side
35
00:01:58,895 --> 00:02:02,623
and on the other side, it was about fear
36
00:02:02,657 --> 00:02:06,005
and in some cases about hate.
37
00:02:06,074 --> 00:02:07,937
They are identified early,
38
00:02:07,938 --> 00:02:13,633
categorized feebleminded, imbecile, idiot.
39
00:02:13,634 --> 00:02:16,567
It would have been
better by far if they had never been born.
40
00:02:20,295 --> 00:02:22,953
People tend to think
41
00:02:22,988 --> 00:02:26,128
that eugenics was a doctrine
that originated with the Nazis,
42
00:02:26,129 --> 00:02:29,201
that it was grounded in wild claims
43
00:02:29,270 --> 00:02:33,550
that were far outside
the scientific mainstream.
44
00:02:33,619 --> 00:02:38,141
Both of those impressions are
fundamentally not true.
45
00:02:38,175 --> 00:02:39,521
It was almost a mania
46
00:02:39,590 --> 00:02:40,868
that sort of swept through the country.
47
00:02:40,937 --> 00:02:42,972
And there was that kind of na ïve,
48
00:02:42,973 --> 00:02:44,492
optimistic vision of eugenics,
49
00:02:44,526 --> 00:02:46,943
like, "Hey, let's all get together
50
00:02:46,977 --> 00:02:50,291
and make better people."
51
00:02:50,325 --> 00:02:54,364
The eugenics movement
was about having healthy children,
52
00:02:54,433 --> 00:02:59,196
about having a stronger society.
53
00:02:59,231 --> 00:03:01,543
There's nothing wrong with that.
54
00:03:01,612 --> 00:03:03,856
You have to look at the underbelly
55
00:03:03,891 --> 00:03:07,964
of what was implemented
in the name of eugenics
56
00:03:07,998 --> 00:03:10,691
to see what was so problematic about it.
57
00:03:40,721 --> 00:03:42,722
In the fall of 1902,
58
00:03:42,723 --> 00:03:46,761
an American biologist named
Charles Benedict Davenport
59
00:03:46,830 --> 00:03:51,214
arrived in London on a sort of pilgrimage.
60
00:03:51,248 --> 00:03:53,664
He was 36, Harvard-educated,
61
00:03:53,699 --> 00:03:56,771
and like many biologists
of his generation,
62
00:03:56,840 --> 00:03:59,360
absorbed with the study of evolution.
63
00:04:01,224 --> 00:04:03,605
He'd been traveling in Europe
with his wife,
64
00:04:03,640 --> 00:04:07,885
collecting seashells for
research on species variation,
65
00:04:07,886 --> 00:04:10,751
but this was to be the highlight
of the trip:
66
00:04:10,785 --> 00:04:14,063
a meeting with the world-
renowned gentleman scientist,
67
00:04:14,064 --> 00:04:18,448
Sir Francis Galton.
68
00:04:18,517 --> 00:04:20,553
A pioneering statistician,
69
00:04:20,588 --> 00:04:24,695
Galton had lived his 80 years
by a single motto,
70
00:04:24,730 --> 00:04:28,561
"Whenever you can, count."
71
00:04:28,596 --> 00:04:31,633
His obsession with measurements
and patterns
72
00:04:31,668 --> 00:04:34,774
had led him to create
the world's first weather maps,
73
00:04:34,775 --> 00:04:39,433
establish fingerprinting
as a means of identification,
74
00:04:39,434 --> 00:04:41,126
and set data-backed parameters
75
00:04:41,160 --> 00:04:45,682
for the perfect cup of tea.
76
00:04:45,751 --> 00:04:50,135
Charles Davenport had come
to discuss another matter:
77
00:04:50,169 --> 00:04:53,034
Galton's work on heredity.
78
00:04:53,103 --> 00:04:57,314
Francis Galton was a great quantifier.
79
00:04:57,349 --> 00:05:01,111
He liked to quantify height, hair color.
80
00:05:01,146 --> 00:05:03,112
You know, what is the chest size
of an average man?
81
00:05:03,113 --> 00:05:05,460
What is the thigh length
of an average man?
82
00:05:05,495 --> 00:05:09,637
Even things like intelligence.
83
00:05:09,671 --> 00:05:14,366
Galton had a
theory that talent, as he called it...
84
00:05:14,435 --> 00:05:16,092
what we would call intelligence...
85
00:05:16,126 --> 00:05:17,818
seemed to run in families.
86
00:05:17,852 --> 00:05:20,268
And so it quickly occurred to him,
87
00:05:20,303 --> 00:05:22,029
"If we can get people with high talent
88
00:05:22,098 --> 00:05:23,478
"to mate with each other,
89
00:05:23,513 --> 00:05:26,619
"prevent people with low talent
from mating with each other,
90
00:05:26,654 --> 00:05:28,483
"we will, within a few generations,
91
00:05:28,518 --> 00:05:31,485
create this race of super men."
92
00:05:31,486 --> 00:05:35,628
Francis Galton was borrowing ideas
93
00:05:35,663 --> 00:05:38,666
and kind of riffing off of the work
94
00:05:38,700 --> 00:05:40,495
of his half-cousin, Charles Darwin.
95
00:05:40,530 --> 00:05:46,018
Darwin believed
that evolution was this natural process
96
00:05:46,053 --> 00:05:48,331
that was inevitably leading
towards what they called
97
00:05:48,365 --> 00:05:51,160
the "survival of the fittest."
98
00:05:51,161 --> 00:05:53,681
Galton really turns that idea on its head
99
00:05:53,715 --> 00:05:55,131
and says,
100
00:05:55,165 --> 00:05:58,512
"You know, natural selection
isn't working very well.
101
00:05:58,513 --> 00:06:01,896
"We need to do a form of selection.
102
00:06:01,965 --> 00:06:04,865
We need to intervene."
103
00:06:04,899 --> 00:06:06,348
To name the effort,
104
00:06:06,349 --> 00:06:09,524
Galton had coined the term "eugenics" -
105
00:06:09,559 --> 00:06:12,182
a hybrid derived from two Greek words
106
00:06:12,217 --> 00:06:15,840
meaning "well" and "born."
107
00:06:15,841 --> 00:06:20,501
Charles Davenport believed, as Galton did,
108
00:06:20,535 --> 00:06:25,367
that selective breeding
could transform the human race.
109
00:06:25,368 --> 00:06:28,233
What was needed was
a scientific understanding
110
00:06:28,267 --> 00:06:31,545
of how heredity actually worked...
111
00:06:31,546 --> 00:06:33,548
and over dinner at Galton's home,
112
00:06:33,583 --> 00:06:38,001
Davenport declared his intention
to get to the bottom of it.
113
00:06:38,036 --> 00:06:39,382
Davenport said,
114
00:06:39,416 --> 00:06:42,730
"I'm going to create
a new kind of institution,
115
00:06:42,764 --> 00:06:47,528
"a station for experimental evolution,
116
00:06:47,562 --> 00:06:49,530
"not Darwinian natural selection
117
00:06:49,564 --> 00:06:50,945
"that you just go out and observe,
118
00:06:51,014 --> 00:06:55,708
"but can we figure out
how inheritance works,
119
00:06:55,743 --> 00:06:57,641
"can we do experiments
120
00:06:57,710 --> 00:07:01,680
and find the patterns
of heredity?"
121
00:07:06,098 --> 00:07:10,378
When Davenport
sailed for home in December 1902,
122
00:07:10,413 --> 00:07:13,071
he carried with him not only
a letter of recommendation
123
00:07:13,105 --> 00:07:15,073
signed by Galton,
124
00:07:15,107 --> 00:07:16,937
but also, he later wrote,
125
00:07:16,971 --> 00:07:22,424
"a renewed courage
for the study of evolution."
126
00:07:22,425 --> 00:07:27,154
Davenport and Galton really did imagine
127
00:07:27,223 --> 00:07:30,778
that the idea of improving human heredity
128
00:07:30,812 --> 00:07:34,609
was of almost religious significance,
129
00:07:34,644 --> 00:07:38,682
of profound moral importance.
130
00:07:38,751 --> 00:07:42,169
They also believed they were qualified
131
00:07:42,238 --> 00:07:44,136
to breed a better race,
132
00:07:44,171 --> 00:07:46,552
because they believed
that they were the best
133
00:07:46,587 --> 00:07:50,073
and the brightest.
134
00:07:56,010 --> 00:07:57,804
Scarcely more than a year later,
135
00:07:57,805 --> 00:08:00,463
with funding
from the Carnegie Institution,
136
00:08:00,497 --> 00:08:03,292
Davenport opened his research station
137
00:08:03,293 --> 00:08:05,330
on the north shore of Long Island,
138
00:08:05,364 --> 00:08:08,264
at Cold Spring Harbor.
139
00:08:08,298 --> 00:08:11,336
Situated on ten acres along Oyster Bay,
140
00:08:11,370 --> 00:08:13,338
the place had been purpose-built
141
00:08:13,372 --> 00:08:17,134
for the breeding and analyzing
of plants and animals...
142
00:08:17,135 --> 00:08:20,138
complete with sprawling garden plots,
143
00:08:20,172 --> 00:08:23,140
an aviary,
and a half-dozen tidy enclosures
144
00:08:23,141 --> 00:08:27,489
housing chickens, goats, and sheep.
145
00:08:27,490 --> 00:08:32,633
By mating organisms
with unusual characteristics...
146
00:08:32,667 --> 00:08:37,155
a tailless Manx cat
or a rooster with a black comb...
147
00:08:37,189 --> 00:08:38,984
and then studying their offspring,
148
00:08:39,019 --> 00:08:41,159
generation after generation,
149
00:08:41,193 --> 00:08:45,128
Davenport hoped to unlock
the mystery of evolution.
150
00:08:47,406 --> 00:08:51,341
Davenport wasn't
yet thinking much about humans.
151
00:08:51,376 --> 00:08:56,036
He was just absorbing all these
different theories of heredity
152
00:08:56,070 --> 00:08:58,176
and trying to figure out
which ones applied when
153
00:08:58,210 --> 00:08:59,384
and under what conditions.
154
00:09:02,214 --> 00:09:04,423
After scores of experiments,
155
00:09:04,492 --> 00:09:07,599
one theory seemed to stand out
from the rest:
156
00:09:07,668 --> 00:09:09,083
the recently discovered work
157
00:09:09,152 --> 00:09:11,982
of an Austrian monk named Gregor Mendel,
158
00:09:12,017 --> 00:09:14,847
who'd spent a decade
in the mid-19th century
159
00:09:14,882 --> 00:09:18,161
experimenting with peas.
160
00:09:18,196 --> 00:09:20,439
Mendel learned that there was a pattern
161
00:09:20,508 --> 00:09:23,925
to how pea plants
passed down certain traits.
162
00:09:23,960 --> 00:09:27,343
And you could come up with certain ratios
163
00:09:27,377 --> 00:09:29,621
to predict how likely it was
164
00:09:29,690 --> 00:09:31,553
that a pea plant would look
one way or another.
165
00:09:31,554 --> 00:09:36,800
Davenport took that and ran with it.
166
00:09:36,869 --> 00:09:39,182
He goes about breeding all kinds
of animals,
167
00:09:39,217 --> 00:09:41,390
looking for the Mendelian ratio,
168
00:09:41,391 --> 00:09:44,187
and in trait after trait,
169
00:09:44,222 --> 00:09:46,431
he seems to find the Mendelian ratio.
170
00:09:49,227 --> 00:09:50,399
Suddenly,
171
00:09:50,400 --> 00:09:51,401
they're beginning to see
172
00:09:51,436 --> 00:09:53,196
a mathematical, scientific explanation
173
00:09:53,231 --> 00:09:56,096
for things that had been
merely conjectural before.
174
00:09:56,130 --> 00:09:58,443
It's becoming obvious that in fact
175
00:09:58,477 --> 00:09:59,927
there are these things called genes.
176
00:09:59,961 --> 00:10:02,894
These units are being transmitted
177
00:10:02,895 --> 00:10:05,069
from parents to their offspring,
178
00:10:05,070 --> 00:10:08,729
and they're giving rise
to physical traits.
179
00:10:18,739 --> 00:10:22,639
By 1906, the work at Cold Spring Harbor
180
00:10:22,674 --> 00:10:24,916
had caught the attention of the press...
181
00:10:24,917 --> 00:10:27,023
and established Charles Davenport
182
00:10:27,092 --> 00:10:30,716
as a rising star
in the new science of genetics.
183
00:10:32,408 --> 00:10:34,341
Thanks to Mendel's laws of heredity,
184
00:10:34,410 --> 00:10:36,343
Davenport told one reporter,
185
00:10:36,412 --> 00:10:39,276
agricultural breeders
could now precisely select
186
00:10:39,277 --> 00:10:40,519
for desirable traits...
187
00:10:40,588 --> 00:10:44,627
to develop a strain of protein-rich wheat
188
00:10:44,661 --> 00:10:47,285
or a chicken that laid more eggs.
189
00:10:47,319 --> 00:10:50,874
The same methods would one day
lead, he predicted,
190
00:10:50,943 --> 00:10:53,532
to a "rapid and thoroughgoing improvement
191
00:10:53,601 --> 00:10:56,639
of the human race."
192
00:10:56,673 --> 00:11:00,987
Davenport was
tantalized by the possibility
193
00:11:00,988 --> 00:11:04,164
that you could take charge
of human evolution.
194
00:11:04,198 --> 00:11:07,476
And then along comes Mendelian genetics,
195
00:11:07,477 --> 00:11:10,653
which seems to offer a very powerful tool.
196
00:11:10,687 --> 00:11:12,309
So extrapolating from the work
197
00:11:12,310 --> 00:11:15,002
that the breeders were doing in animals
198
00:11:15,036 --> 00:11:18,523
to the breeding of better human beings
199
00:11:18,557 --> 00:11:21,974
was a natural step.
200
00:11:25,012 --> 00:11:28,153
In 1909, Davenport informed his funder,
201
00:11:28,188 --> 00:11:29,809
the Carnegie Institution,
202
00:11:29,810 --> 00:11:31,708
that he'd shifted his focus
203
00:11:31,743 --> 00:11:34,159
from the breeding of cats and roosters
204
00:11:34,194 --> 00:11:39,199
to an investigation of human traits.
205
00:11:39,233 --> 00:11:42,202
Having already found the Mendelian ratio
206
00:11:42,236 --> 00:11:45,757
in early studies of eye color
and hair color...
207
00:11:45,826 --> 00:11:48,380
and convinced he was on the right track...
208
00:11:48,415 --> 00:11:49,864
he now began to collect data
209
00:11:49,899 --> 00:11:54,179
on a wide range
of other human characteristics.
210
00:11:54,214 --> 00:11:57,147
He sent out a family history questionnaire
211
00:11:57,182 --> 00:11:59,598
to hundreds of individuals
212
00:11:59,667 --> 00:12:02,083
and solicited prisons, hospitals,
213
00:12:02,118 --> 00:12:06,502
and educational institutions
for their records.
214
00:12:06,536 --> 00:12:08,193
You can't really do breeding experiments
215
00:12:08,228 --> 00:12:09,574
with human beings.
216
00:12:09,608 --> 00:12:11,955
Aside from the ethics,
you just can't live long enough
217
00:12:12,024 --> 00:12:14,371
to see generations and generations.
218
00:12:14,372 --> 00:12:17,167
So it was Davenport's genius to realize
219
00:12:17,202 --> 00:12:20,549
if he could collect family pedigrees,
220
00:12:20,550 --> 00:12:23,450
he could trace family inheritances
221
00:12:23,519 --> 00:12:26,211
and try to prove that
evolution works for human beings
222
00:12:26,246 --> 00:12:27,488
the way it works for animals.
223
00:12:29,904 --> 00:12:32,872
Davenport's plan
was to analyze the pedigree charts
224
00:12:32,873 --> 00:12:35,427
for Mendelian patterns...
225
00:12:35,462 --> 00:12:37,739
and to identify the desirable traits
226
00:12:37,740 --> 00:12:41,398
human beings might encourage
through careful breeding...
227
00:12:41,399 --> 00:12:45,748
and the undesirable ones
they could breed out.
228
00:12:55,102 --> 00:12:57,967
"Wouldn't it be a better world
229
00:12:58,036 --> 00:13:02,178
"if we could wipe out poverty?
230
00:13:02,247 --> 00:13:05,939
"Wouldn't it be a better world
if we didn't have criminals?
231
00:13:05,940 --> 00:13:07,390
"Wouldn't it be a better world
232
00:13:07,425 --> 00:13:10,117
"if everyone behaved themselves?
233
00:13:10,151 --> 00:13:16,330
"And if the reason
we have poverty and crime
234
00:13:16,399 --> 00:13:18,607
"is something that's determined
by our genes,
235
00:13:18,608 --> 00:13:22,198
"if we can change that and make it
236
00:13:22,267 --> 00:13:24,165
"so that the people
who have those bad traits
237
00:13:24,234 --> 00:13:26,789
"don't pass them down,
238
00:13:26,823 --> 00:13:30,310
wouldn't that be
a better world?"
239
00:13:40,285 --> 00:13:42,460
Among Americans
240
00:13:42,494 --> 00:13:45,117
of Charles Davenport's class
and generation,
241
00:13:45,152 --> 00:13:48,500
there was perhaps no word
that had more currency
242
00:13:48,535 --> 00:13:50,122
at the turn of the century
243
00:13:50,157 --> 00:13:52,608
than improvement.
244
00:13:54,644 --> 00:13:58,303
They had come of age
in the midst of a revolution...
245
00:13:58,338 --> 00:14:02,307
a seismic shift that had made
the United States
246
00:14:02,342 --> 00:14:04,965
the most prosperous
and powerful nation on earth...
247
00:14:04,999 --> 00:14:08,140
and, in the eyes of many,
248
00:14:08,175 --> 00:14:10,902
had simultaneously plunged it into chaos.
249
00:14:10,971 --> 00:14:14,733
It's the beginning of the 20th century,
250
00:14:14,802 --> 00:14:16,839
and we have rampant urbanization,
251
00:14:16,873 --> 00:14:21,119
rampant industrialization,
rampant immigration.
252
00:14:21,153 --> 00:14:22,879
The old order is passing,
253
00:14:22,914 --> 00:14:24,155
and wherever you look,
254
00:14:24,156 --> 00:14:25,882
society seems to be deteriorating.
255
00:14:25,917 --> 00:14:30,922
More and more
farms were giving way to factories,
256
00:14:30,991 --> 00:14:34,165
and the cities were overrun
with newcomers,
257
00:14:34,166 --> 00:14:35,858
many from the countryside,
258
00:14:35,892 --> 00:14:40,172
many hundreds of thousands more
from abroad.
259
00:14:40,207 --> 00:14:44,936
There was impure
water, and the schools were awful,
260
00:14:45,005 --> 00:14:47,524
and the disease was rampant,
261
00:14:47,525 --> 00:14:49,906
and immigrants were pouring in.
262
00:14:49,941 --> 00:14:52,737
People were
apprehensive about rapid change,
263
00:14:52,771 --> 00:14:55,084
about the kinds of people
you saw on the streets...
264
00:14:55,118 --> 00:15:00,503
slums, crime, alcoholism, prostitution.
265
00:15:00,538 --> 00:15:02,022
Native white Protestants felt
266
00:15:02,056 --> 00:15:06,544
that they were losing control
of American society.
267
00:15:06,578 --> 00:15:11,202
Determined not
only to meet the new challenges,
268
00:15:11,203 --> 00:15:12,412
but to master them,
269
00:15:12,446 --> 00:15:15,069
a veritable army of educated,
270
00:15:15,104 --> 00:15:17,070
middle- and upper-middle-class Americans
271
00:15:17,071 --> 00:15:20,247
had launched a crusade
to remake society...
272
00:15:20,281 --> 00:15:25,735
to eliminate corruption,
stamp out disease and vice,
273
00:15:25,770 --> 00:15:28,462
assimilate the immigrant,
and uplift the poor...
274
00:15:28,531 --> 00:15:34,088
all in the name of progress.
275
00:15:34,123 --> 00:15:36,090
The world had never seen invention
276
00:15:36,125 --> 00:15:40,439
as powerful and remarkable
and as influential
277
00:15:40,440 --> 00:15:43,822
as the last three decades
of the 19th century.
278
00:15:43,891 --> 00:15:49,240
This fueled an already existing
American optimism
279
00:15:49,241 --> 00:15:51,416
about what can be improved
280
00:15:51,451 --> 00:15:53,970
and it directed it
into a particular track,
281
00:15:54,005 --> 00:15:56,076
which was scientific improvement.
282
00:15:56,110 --> 00:16:00,183
There was a great belief in science.
283
00:16:00,252 --> 00:16:02,599
There was a great belief in government,
284
00:16:02,600 --> 00:16:06,604
in bureaucracy as a tool
for solving social problems,
285
00:16:06,638 --> 00:16:10,470
and also a belief in collectivism,
286
00:16:10,504 --> 00:16:13,403
that the population needs to work together
287
00:16:13,438 --> 00:16:16,785
to improve society.
288
00:16:16,786 --> 00:16:19,099
The progressive movement said,
289
00:16:19,133 --> 00:16:23,483
"We can use state power
and expert advice and knowledge
290
00:16:23,517 --> 00:16:25,485
"to solve things like poverty,
291
00:16:25,519 --> 00:16:27,624
to solve things
like alcoholism."
292
00:16:27,625 --> 00:16:33,354
So that was an incredibly
hopeful and optimistic idea.
293
00:16:33,423 --> 00:16:37,186
Eugenics was part of that.
294
00:16:41,466 --> 00:16:45,987
When the letter from
Charles Davenport arrived in 1909
295
00:16:45,988 --> 00:16:47,955
at New Jersey's Vineland Training School
296
00:16:47,990 --> 00:16:49,854
for the Feebleminded,
297
00:16:49,888 --> 00:16:52,857
the staff hadn't known
quite what to make of it...
298
00:16:52,891 --> 00:16:58,241
a mere two-line note requesting
hereditary information,
299
00:16:58,310 --> 00:17:02,175
one of hundreds Davenport had sent.
300
00:17:02,176 --> 00:17:07,009
Davenport
investigated any and all traits...
301
00:17:07,043 --> 00:17:11,322
eye color, weight, mood, habit,
302
00:17:11,323 --> 00:17:14,499
temperament, diseases, anything.
303
00:17:14,534 --> 00:17:18,745
And then he finds this
psychologist in New Jersey,
304
00:17:18,814 --> 00:17:25,372
and he begins to zero in
on low intelligence,
305
00:17:25,406 --> 00:17:29,859
something known as feeblemindedness.
306
00:17:29,894 --> 00:17:35,209
Psychologist Henry
Goddard, Vineland's director of research,
307
00:17:35,244 --> 00:17:38,558
had no family histories to share.
308
00:17:38,592 --> 00:17:40,180
But what he lacked in data,
309
00:17:40,214 --> 00:17:43,562
he more than made up for with enthusiasm.
310
00:17:43,563 --> 00:17:48,359
Not only was Goddard interested
in the new science of heredity,
311
00:17:48,360 --> 00:17:50,086
he asked Davenport to guide him
312
00:17:50,121 --> 00:17:54,194
in making his own study
of feeblemindedness.
313
00:17:54,228 --> 00:17:59,026
Like lots of people
who are working in institutions,
314
00:17:59,061 --> 00:18:01,926
doctors or social workers,
315
00:18:01,960 --> 00:18:03,236
Henry Goddard was interested
316
00:18:03,237 --> 00:18:05,688
in identifying the kinds of conditions
317
00:18:05,723 --> 00:18:07,378
that were passed down in heredity
318
00:18:07,379 --> 00:18:10,969
and preventing them.
319
00:18:11,038 --> 00:18:13,040
Henry Goddard was 42
320
00:18:13,075 --> 00:18:16,422
and a one-time teacher in Quaker schools.
321
00:18:16,423 --> 00:18:18,770
It was, in part, an interest in education
322
00:18:18,805 --> 00:18:21,738
that had brought him to Vineland in 1906.
323
00:18:21,739 --> 00:18:24,120
He'd spent the three years since
324
00:18:24,155 --> 00:18:27,916
trying to parse the many
varieties of feeblemindedness,
325
00:18:27,917 --> 00:18:30,333
an all-too-common mental deficiency
326
00:18:30,402 --> 00:18:35,580
associated with anti-social behavior.
327
00:18:35,615 --> 00:18:40,827
Some of Vineland's 300 inmates
were violent or deranged,
328
00:18:40,896 --> 00:18:42,932
others unruly,
329
00:18:42,967 --> 00:18:45,762
still others merely slow.
330
00:18:45,763 --> 00:18:50,181
Hoping to improve their
individual care and training,
331
00:18:50,250 --> 00:18:53,011
Goddard had pioneered the use
of an "intelligence test,"
332
00:18:53,080 --> 00:18:56,808
which purported to measure
a person's mental abilities
333
00:18:56,843 --> 00:18:59,811
in relation to that
of so-called "normal" people
334
00:18:59,846 --> 00:19:02,538
of the same age.
335
00:19:02,607 --> 00:19:05,230
The scores enabled him to sort his charges
336
00:19:05,265 --> 00:19:07,508
into categories.
337
00:19:07,543 --> 00:19:10,960
To the existing classifications
of "idiot" and "imbecile,"
338
00:19:10,995 --> 00:19:12,134
which long had been used
339
00:19:12,168 --> 00:19:15,274
to describe debilitating
mental impairment,
340
00:19:15,275 --> 00:19:17,657
Goddard had added a third -
341
00:19:17,691 --> 00:19:20,832
a higher-functioning group
he called "morons."
342
00:19:23,317 --> 00:19:25,043
That was actually a diagnostic term
343
00:19:25,112 --> 00:19:27,976
and not just an insult.
344
00:19:27,977 --> 00:19:30,186
Henry Goddard argued the high-grade moron
345
00:19:30,221 --> 00:19:33,396
is high functioning enough to act normal,
346
00:19:33,465 --> 00:19:37,469
but they're kind of stuck
in this evolutionary phase,
347
00:19:37,504 --> 00:19:40,161
and they don't emerge as true adults.
348
00:19:40,162 --> 00:19:44,165
What's missing is moral judgment.
349
00:19:44,166 --> 00:19:49,170
So Goddard constructs that term, "moron,"
350
00:19:49,171 --> 00:19:51,518
and "mental deficiency" and "immorality"
351
00:19:51,552 --> 00:19:53,831
become basically interchangeable.
352
00:19:58,076 --> 00:20:00,664
Now, with Davenport's tutoring,
353
00:20:00,665 --> 00:20:03,185
Goddard began to survey
the family histories
354
00:20:03,219 --> 00:20:06,878
of 35 of his students at Vineland.
355
00:20:06,913 --> 00:20:12,194
What he found made him
an instant believer in eugenics.
356
00:20:12,228 --> 00:20:13,850
Not only did morons seem clearly
357
00:20:13,851 --> 00:20:15,715
to pass on their feeblemindedness
358
00:20:15,749 --> 00:20:17,681
to their offspring,
359
00:20:17,682 --> 00:20:20,064
their family trees often were rife
360
00:20:20,098 --> 00:20:24,827
with alcoholics, prostitutes,
criminals, and paupers.
361
00:20:26,518 --> 00:20:28,900
As Goddard put it to
the New Jersey State Conference
362
00:20:28,935 --> 00:20:32,766
of Charities and Corrections in 1910,
363
00:20:32,835 --> 00:20:34,561
"Feeblemindedness is at the root
364
00:20:34,595 --> 00:20:36,839
"of probably two-thirds of the problems
365
00:20:36,874 --> 00:20:39,083
that you have before you."
366
00:20:39,117 --> 00:20:43,915
The cause was
"defective ancestry."
367
00:20:43,950 --> 00:20:46,193
Henry Goddard puts forward this idea
368
00:20:46,228 --> 00:20:48,575
that if you got rid of feeblemindedness,
369
00:20:48,609 --> 00:20:50,957
you would get rid
of all of these problems,
370
00:20:51,026 --> 00:20:52,959
or at least greatly reduce them.
371
00:20:53,028 --> 00:20:55,064
And we love explanations like that.
372
00:20:55,099 --> 00:20:56,237
It's so simple.
373
00:20:56,238 --> 00:20:57,929
"Oh, it's just feeblemindedness
374
00:20:57,964 --> 00:21:00,000
so let's, you know,
that's the fix."
375
00:21:02,244 --> 00:21:05,385
Goddard reasoned
that if the test he'd devised
376
00:21:05,419 --> 00:21:07,075
to better care for the feebleminded
377
00:21:07,076 --> 00:21:09,458
instead were used to identify them,
378
00:21:09,527 --> 00:21:12,150
the contagion could be halted...
379
00:21:12,219 --> 00:21:14,946
and future generations spared the scourges
380
00:21:14,981 --> 00:21:16,741
of mental deficiency.
381
00:21:19,813 --> 00:21:21,332
Henry Goddard said,
382
00:21:21,401 --> 00:21:23,679
"You know, it takes an expert
383
00:21:23,748 --> 00:21:26,475
"to identify the true menace
of feeblemindedness.
384
00:21:26,509 --> 00:21:28,925
"So someone you're sitting next to
385
00:21:28,926 --> 00:21:30,617
"at a restaurant or in a theater
386
00:21:30,651 --> 00:21:33,275
"could look perfectly normal to you,
387
00:21:33,309 --> 00:21:36,726
"and it only takes one feebleminded person
388
00:21:36,761 --> 00:21:38,004
"marrying another one,
389
00:21:38,073 --> 00:21:40,454
"even someone who's not feebleminded,
390
00:21:40,489 --> 00:21:43,975
to create generations
of feeblemindedness."
391
00:21:44,010 --> 00:21:48,635
What it did is up the stakes
of feeblemindedness
392
00:21:48,669 --> 00:21:51,949
by claiming that it was a hidden menace
393
00:21:51,983 --> 00:21:53,950
that was more difficult to pinpoint
394
00:21:53,951 --> 00:21:56,988
than people might think.
395
00:22:04,616 --> 00:22:08,724
By early 1910,
Charles Davenport was convinced
396
00:22:08,793 --> 00:22:11,037
that certain human traits were passed down
397
00:22:11,106 --> 00:22:13,522
in a predictable way
398
00:22:13,556 --> 00:22:17,008
and that American society
could be dramatically improved
399
00:22:17,043 --> 00:22:21,185
if only reproduction were controlled.
400
00:22:21,219 --> 00:22:23,290
Anxious to spread the word,
401
00:22:23,325 --> 00:22:26,535
he began to lay plans
for a new institution
402
00:22:26,569 --> 00:22:30,021
dedicated to eugenic research
and education.
403
00:22:34,992 --> 00:22:37,615
In February, in search of a patron,
404
00:22:37,649 --> 00:22:39,823
Davenport traveled to New York
405
00:22:39,824 --> 00:22:43,034
to lunch
with Mrs. E.H. Harriman,
406
00:22:43,069 --> 00:22:48,246
widow of a recently deceased
railroad magnate.
407
00:22:48,315 --> 00:22:50,662
Davenport's pitch to Mrs. Harriman
408
00:22:50,697 --> 00:22:52,595
was to say, "Right now you give your money
409
00:22:52,664 --> 00:22:54,356
"to all kinds of good organizations.
410
00:22:54,390 --> 00:22:56,323
"They feed the poor, they clothe the poor.
411
00:22:56,358 --> 00:23:01,017
"They do many wonderful things,
but it's never-ending.
412
00:23:01,018 --> 00:23:02,743
"With eugenics,
413
00:23:02,778 --> 00:23:05,401
"we eventually won't need
your philanthropy and charity,
414
00:23:05,436 --> 00:23:07,023
"because we'll solve the problems
415
00:23:07,024 --> 00:23:09,060
that right now
you're just throwing money at."
416
00:23:09,095 --> 00:23:12,995
He persuaded Mrs. Harriman
417
00:23:13,030 --> 00:23:15,584
that the future of the country
was at stake
418
00:23:15,618 --> 00:23:20,727
and that only a eugenic project
could save it.
419
00:23:20,761 --> 00:23:22,694
Charles Davenport says,
420
00:23:22,729 --> 00:23:26,112
"All you people who think that
if we just educate the poor,
421
00:23:26,181 --> 00:23:27,630
"if we just give them charity,
422
00:23:27,699 --> 00:23:29,632
"if we just reform their environment,
423
00:23:29,701 --> 00:23:31,289
"even the poor can rise to our level,
424
00:23:31,358 --> 00:23:34,223
"forget about it.
425
00:23:34,258 --> 00:23:36,915
"That's just sentimental hogwash.
426
00:23:36,916 --> 00:23:39,021
"It's not the environment
that makes you what you are.
427
00:23:39,056 --> 00:23:43,094
"It's your genetic inheritance
from your parents.
428
00:23:43,129 --> 00:23:46,097
"So now, yes, let's regulate
the matings of human beings,
429
00:23:46,132 --> 00:23:48,754
"eliminate the bad genes
from the population,
430
00:23:48,755 --> 00:23:51,585
and keep the fittest genes
in the gene pool."
431
00:23:51,620 --> 00:23:58,938
By limiting the birth of
people who were deemed to be unfit,
432
00:23:58,972 --> 00:24:04,564
you were by definition enhancing
the stock of human society.
433
00:24:04,598 --> 00:24:06,910
And so there was this social mission
434
00:24:06,911 --> 00:24:09,949
of really fighting dependency,
435
00:24:09,983 --> 00:24:11,709
fighting crime,
436
00:24:11,743 --> 00:24:13,400
through eugenics.
437
00:24:13,435 --> 00:24:16,472
The idea was that eugenics would solve
438
00:24:16,507 --> 00:24:19,440
all of these broader social problems
439
00:24:19,441 --> 00:24:22,340
if enacted in a robust way.
440
00:24:22,409 --> 00:24:25,412
Mrs. Harriman
was a great believer
441
00:24:25,447 --> 00:24:28,588
in the importance of proper matings.
442
00:24:28,622 --> 00:24:30,279
She credited her late husband's interest
443
00:24:30,314 --> 00:24:33,006
in horse-breeding for that,
444
00:24:33,075 --> 00:24:34,974
and she enthusiastically pledged
445
00:24:35,008 --> 00:24:38,874
to finance Davenport's eugenic enterprise.
446
00:24:38,943 --> 00:24:42,843
It was, Davenport later wrote
in his journal,
447
00:24:42,912 --> 00:24:47,020
"a red letter day for humanity."
448
00:24:52,129 --> 00:24:57,788
The impulse to
perfect humanity is an ancient aspiration.
449
00:24:57,789 --> 00:25:00,827
The idea that, somehow or the other,
450
00:25:00,861 --> 00:25:03,450
that you can get the best humans
451
00:25:03,485 --> 00:25:08,490
by selectively breeding
the best, most fit,
452
00:25:08,524 --> 00:25:10,629
hardiest, most beautiful...
453
00:25:10,630 --> 00:25:13,149
it's an ancient desire.
454
00:25:13,150 --> 00:25:15,496
You find it in Sanskrit texts.
455
00:25:15,497 --> 00:25:17,982
You find it in Greek texts.
456
00:25:18,017 --> 00:25:21,227
The trouble is that only
some human beings can dictate
457
00:25:21,296 --> 00:25:24,299
or decide what those...
458
00:25:24,333 --> 00:25:25,955
what the correct features might be.
459
00:25:25,990 --> 00:25:28,268
Who decides?
460
00:25:31,823 --> 00:25:33,894
Charles Davenport thought,
461
00:25:33,963 --> 00:25:36,656
"By breeding a superior race of people,
462
00:25:36,690 --> 00:25:42,420
we can bring about the
millennial kingdom on earth."
463
00:25:42,489 --> 00:25:46,321
The problem with utopias is that
464
00:25:46,355 --> 00:25:49,393
they set a set of aspirations
465
00:25:49,427 --> 00:25:50,703
that then blind you
466
00:25:50,704 --> 00:25:53,189
to a certain set of consequences.
467
00:25:53,190 --> 00:25:58,022
And that can be dangerous.
468
00:26:03,372 --> 00:26:06,858
In October
1910, on a 80-acre plot adjacent
469
00:26:06,893 --> 00:26:10,241
to the Cold Spring Harbor campus,
470
00:26:10,276 --> 00:26:11,898
Charles Davenport opened the doors
471
00:26:11,932 --> 00:26:14,280
of his new institute.
472
00:26:14,349 --> 00:26:18,111
It was a modest structure built
for a grand purpose:
473
00:26:18,146 --> 00:26:22,736
to house hereditary information
on American families
474
00:26:22,771 --> 00:26:25,222
and use it to guide
the reproductive choices
475
00:26:25,256 --> 00:26:27,086
of the nation.
476
00:26:27,120 --> 00:26:31,124
He called it the Eugenics Record Office.
477
00:26:31,159 --> 00:26:35,301
Eugenic ideas
were very much floating around
478
00:26:35,370 --> 00:26:38,406
as early as 1880.
479
00:26:38,407 --> 00:26:41,721
But Davenport gave eugenics teeth.
480
00:26:41,755 --> 00:26:44,412
He was institutionalizing eugenics.
481
00:26:44,413 --> 00:26:47,589
He was marshaling people
around a research program.
482
00:26:47,623 --> 00:26:50,833
Davenport already had assembled
483
00:26:50,902 --> 00:26:54,113
a prestigious Board
of Scientific Directors,
484
00:26:54,147 --> 00:26:57,495
among them prominent scientists,
physicians,
485
00:26:57,564 --> 00:27:01,741
and famed inventor Alexander Graham Bell.
486
00:27:01,775 --> 00:27:04,433
Day-to-day operations, meanwhile,
487
00:27:04,468 --> 00:27:06,952
would be overseen by Harry Laughlin,
488
00:27:06,953 --> 00:27:09,680
a high school superintendent
from the Midwest
489
00:27:09,749 --> 00:27:14,340
with a lifelong passion
for poultry breeding.
490
00:27:14,409 --> 00:27:15,927
Laughlin was
491
00:27:15,962 --> 00:27:18,482
a very zealous proponent of eugenics,
492
00:27:18,516 --> 00:27:19,897
and in that sense, he got along well
493
00:27:19,931 --> 00:27:20,932
with Davenport.
494
00:27:20,967 --> 00:27:22,589
They both believed in the mission,
495
00:27:22,624 --> 00:27:24,452
they believed in the cause.
496
00:27:24,453 --> 00:27:26,627
For Davenport, a lot of it was about
497
00:27:26,628 --> 00:27:28,319
what you could do in the laboratory
498
00:27:28,354 --> 00:27:30,803
and how you can analyze the data.
499
00:27:30,804 --> 00:27:32,496
For Laughlin, a lot of it was about,
500
00:27:32,530 --> 00:27:34,635
"Well, how are we going
to get out there in the world
501
00:27:34,636 --> 00:27:39,157
and change the direction
of history?"
502
00:27:39,158 --> 00:27:42,470
To gather new disciples to the cause...
503
00:27:42,471 --> 00:27:44,784
and to aid in the collection of data...
504
00:27:44,818 --> 00:27:48,167
Laughlin and Davenport launched
an academic program,
505
00:27:48,201 --> 00:27:49,547
which offered training
506
00:27:49,616 --> 00:27:52,791
in eugenic field-research techniques.
507
00:27:55,312 --> 00:27:58,211
Over the course of six weeks each summer,
508
00:27:58,246 --> 00:28:03,008
recent college graduates...
from Vassar, Harvard, Oberlin...
509
00:28:03,009 --> 00:28:05,529
were taught how to investigate
family histories;
510
00:28:05,563 --> 00:28:08,014
how to conduct interviews
511
00:28:08,048 --> 00:28:10,810
and make eugenically useful measurements;
512
00:28:10,844 --> 00:28:13,502
and how to chart family pedigrees
513
00:28:13,537 --> 00:28:15,158
and analyze them.
514
00:28:15,159 --> 00:28:18,506
Then, at a salary of $75 a month,
515
00:28:18,507 --> 00:28:21,200
came a year's work in the field.
516
00:28:21,234 --> 00:28:25,031
Armed with the official Trait Book,
517
00:28:25,065 --> 00:28:26,688
which assigned numerical codes
518
00:28:26,722 --> 00:28:30,312
to a broad spectrum
of human characteristics,
519
00:28:30,347 --> 00:28:34,004
the newly minted researchers fanned out:
520
00:28:34,005 --> 00:28:35,593
to study delinquents
521
00:28:35,662 --> 00:28:39,390
in the Juvenile Psychopathic
Institute of Chicago;
522
00:28:39,425 --> 00:28:41,841
the insane
at the New Jersey State Hospital
523
00:28:41,875 --> 00:28:43,531
at Matawan;
524
00:28:43,532 --> 00:28:46,397
albinos in Massachusetts;
525
00:28:46,432 --> 00:28:49,192
circus families at Coney Island;
526
00:28:49,193 --> 00:28:52,955
the Amish in Pennsylvania.
527
00:28:53,024 --> 00:28:55,924
They would go into some holler in Virginia
528
00:28:55,993 --> 00:28:57,615
and find some family
529
00:28:57,684 --> 00:29:02,448
that seemed to have a lot
of alcoholics and criminals,
530
00:29:02,517 --> 00:29:04,381
and, you know, other ne'er-do-wells,
531
00:29:04,415 --> 00:29:05,934
and they would go, "Aha.
532
00:29:05,968 --> 00:29:08,764
We've found a family
with terrible genes."
533
00:29:08,799 --> 00:29:10,870
And they'd interview someone,
and they'd say,
534
00:29:10,904 --> 00:29:12,561
"Oh, yeah, you know,
535
00:29:12,596 --> 00:29:13,907
"John seems a little slow,
536
00:29:13,942 --> 00:29:16,634
but I knew his uncle,
and his uncle was a big drunk."
537
00:29:16,703 --> 00:29:18,809
And they'd write that down,
"Uncle a big drunk."
538
00:29:18,878 --> 00:29:21,259
So they would come back
with all this evidence
539
00:29:21,260 --> 00:29:26,091
of the way in which human traits
were inherited.
540
00:29:26,092 --> 00:29:28,715
Of course the reliability of the data
541
00:29:28,750 --> 00:29:30,578
was not questioned,
542
00:29:30,579 --> 00:29:33,996
even though it was based
on interpretation, impression,
543
00:29:34,065 --> 00:29:35,826
recollection by the living members
544
00:29:35,895 --> 00:29:37,931
of the family with whom they spoke.
545
00:29:37,966 --> 00:29:40,037
No checking.
546
00:29:43,074 --> 00:29:44,765
Year by year...
547
00:29:44,766 --> 00:29:47,389
as trainees rotated out
of the summer program
548
00:29:47,424 --> 00:29:49,011
and into positions
549
00:29:49,080 --> 00:29:52,117
at universities, hospitals,
and mental institutions...
550
00:29:52,118 --> 00:29:55,086
Davenport's assumptions
and methods of fieldwork
551
00:29:55,121 --> 00:29:58,814
gained currency all across the country.
552
00:29:58,849 --> 00:30:03,198
And year by year, the data accumulated.
553
00:30:03,267 --> 00:30:06,650
Stored in fireproof cabinets
and intricately indexed,
554
00:30:06,684 --> 00:30:09,962
it comprised, as
Scientific American noted,
555
00:30:09,963 --> 00:30:14,104
"A sort of inventory
of the blood of the community"
556
00:30:14,105 --> 00:30:15,831
and supplied grist for a multitude
557
00:30:15,866 --> 00:30:19,697
of books, pamphlets, lectures,
and press releases
558
00:30:19,766 --> 00:30:24,253
regarding the danger of
so-called "inferior germ-plasm."
559
00:30:27,153 --> 00:30:29,500
They're using the family records
560
00:30:29,535 --> 00:30:33,159
that are stored in the fireproof vault
561
00:30:33,193 --> 00:30:35,230
to prove that all these traits,
562
00:30:35,299 --> 00:30:38,509
not just physical
but mental traits, moral traits,
563
00:30:38,544 --> 00:30:41,132
are caused by genes.
564
00:30:41,167 --> 00:30:42,686
There's nothing you can do about it.
565
00:30:42,720 --> 00:30:46,310
This is cold, hard, pure science.
566
00:30:46,345 --> 00:30:51,798
"Just as we have
strains of scholars, of military men,"
567
00:30:51,833 --> 00:30:54,353
Davenport told The New York Times,
568
00:30:54,387 --> 00:30:57,632
"we have strains of paupers,
of sex offenders...
569
00:30:57,666 --> 00:31:01,498
"strains with strong tendencies
toward larceny,
570
00:31:01,532 --> 00:31:05,087
"assault, lying, running away...
571
00:31:05,156 --> 00:31:10,196
The cost to society
of these strains is enormous."
572
00:31:10,230 --> 00:31:13,199
Davenport took this basic idea,
573
00:31:13,233 --> 00:31:17,583
applied it far more widely
than it had ever been before,
574
00:31:17,652 --> 00:31:22,001
and really promoted
this probabilistic idea
575
00:31:22,035 --> 00:31:24,313
as if it were a deterministic one.
576
00:31:24,348 --> 00:31:27,524
That is to say, it's not just likelihoods,
577
00:31:27,558 --> 00:31:31,009
but in some ways,
we're dealing with certainties.
578
00:31:31,010 --> 00:31:33,806
And that idea really sold.
579
00:31:37,603 --> 00:31:39,570
By the time the Eugenics Record Office
580
00:31:39,605 --> 00:31:42,953
issued its first official report in 1913,
581
00:31:43,022 --> 00:31:48,303
many Americans had begun
to see the wisdom in eugenics.
582
00:31:48,372 --> 00:31:50,961
"I agree with you
that society has no business
583
00:31:51,030 --> 00:31:54,136
to permit degenerates
to reproduce their kind,"
584
00:31:54,205 --> 00:31:56,380
former president Theodore Roosevelt
585
00:31:56,415 --> 00:31:58,727
wrote Davenport that year.
586
00:31:58,762 --> 00:32:01,420
"It is really extraordinary
that our people refuse
587
00:32:01,454 --> 00:32:04,457
"to apply to human beings such knowledge
588
00:32:04,492 --> 00:32:07,908
"as every successful farmer
is obliged to apply
589
00:32:07,909 --> 00:32:10,187
to his own stock breeding."
590
00:32:12,741 --> 00:32:16,331
If you're going to
be in the business of breeding,
591
00:32:16,400 --> 00:32:19,645
you're going to have to convince
thought leaders and politicians,
592
00:32:19,714 --> 00:32:22,094
most especially the government,
593
00:32:22,095 --> 00:32:25,097
to begin a kind of unprecedented program.
594
00:32:25,098 --> 00:32:27,584
So they understood from the beginning
595
00:32:27,618 --> 00:32:30,241
that they needed to persuade those
596
00:32:30,276 --> 00:32:33,003
who were in a position
to do something about it
597
00:32:33,072 --> 00:32:37,663
that it was possible, indeed, desirable.
598
00:32:37,697 --> 00:32:40,182
The eugenicists
thought that people's base interests
599
00:32:40,251 --> 00:32:42,944
are just self-serving, selfish, right?
600
00:32:42,978 --> 00:32:44,427
And if you just leave them to themselves,
601
00:32:44,428 --> 00:32:45,671
they're going to evolve
602
00:32:45,740 --> 00:32:47,673
in all these random, dumb directions.
603
00:32:47,742 --> 00:32:51,434
The Eugenics Record Office recommended
604
00:32:51,435 --> 00:32:54,334
both widespread eugenic education
605
00:32:54,369 --> 00:32:56,854
and aggressive government intervention:
606
00:32:56,923 --> 00:32:59,788
laws that would keep defectives
out of the country,
607
00:32:59,823 --> 00:33:02,791
prohibit them from marrying,
608
00:33:02,826 --> 00:33:06,277
and prevent them from becoming parents
609
00:33:06,312 --> 00:33:07,865
by segregating them in asylums
610
00:33:07,934 --> 00:33:13,250
throughout their reproductive years.
611
00:33:13,284 --> 00:33:14,872
Also recommended was a new
612
00:33:14,941 --> 00:33:17,634
and somewhat controversial
surgical procedure
613
00:33:17,668 --> 00:33:19,532
known as sterilization.
614
00:33:19,567 --> 00:33:24,330
By cutting and sealing
organs involved in reproduction,
615
00:33:24,364 --> 00:33:29,334
both men and women
could be made infertile.
616
00:33:29,335 --> 00:33:32,269
So far, the technique had been
used primarily on criminals...
617
00:33:32,303 --> 00:33:34,822
particularly sex offenders...
618
00:33:34,823 --> 00:33:37,861
and it was thought to have
a curative effect.
619
00:33:37,895 --> 00:33:42,348
Harry Laughlin envisioned
a broader application:
620
00:33:42,382 --> 00:33:46,179
as a eugenic tool that would
eliminate defective germ-plasm
621
00:33:46,214 --> 00:33:48,319
once and for all.
622
00:33:48,354 --> 00:33:50,805
Harry Laughlin
really has this political vision
623
00:33:50,839 --> 00:33:52,565
of what we can do with eugenics.
624
00:33:52,634 --> 00:33:54,843
And he said,
625
00:33:54,878 --> 00:33:56,224
"In order for eugenic sterilization
626
00:33:56,258 --> 00:33:57,674
to really do what had to be done,
627
00:33:57,708 --> 00:34:00,986
15 million Americans would have
to go under the knife.
628
00:34:05,026 --> 00:34:08,684
The idea was that eugenics was
for the common good
629
00:34:08,685 --> 00:34:12,860
and by implementing
the science of heredity,
630
00:34:12,861 --> 00:34:17,797
they could protect America
and strengthen America.
631
00:34:17,866 --> 00:34:21,076
They thought of it
as the beginning of a revolution,
632
00:34:21,111 --> 00:34:23,526
of a religious movement.
633
00:34:23,527 --> 00:34:25,701
You have to start with a few converts,
634
00:34:25,702 --> 00:34:29,706
and then you try to grow it
into a bigger movement.
635
00:34:29,740 --> 00:34:33,261
All that seemed exciting
and full of possibility,
636
00:34:33,295 --> 00:34:37,092
and they were going to create a new world.
637
00:34:51,451 --> 00:34:52,798
The eugenics movement
638
00:34:52,867 --> 00:34:55,214
that Charles Davenport had launched
639
00:34:55,248 --> 00:34:57,699
rested on Mendel's laws of inheritance,
640
00:34:57,734 --> 00:35:02,048
which assumed each trait
was governed by one gene
641
00:35:02,083 --> 00:35:05,569
and was passed down
in predictable patterns.
642
00:35:05,604 --> 00:35:09,573
But for all of Davenport's
certainty about the gene,
643
00:35:09,608 --> 00:35:11,747
there remained open questions...
644
00:35:11,748 --> 00:35:15,130
about the gene's physical properties
645
00:35:15,165 --> 00:35:17,236
and its location within the cell,
646
00:35:17,270 --> 00:35:20,929
and the means by which
it accomplished its function.
647
00:35:20,964 --> 00:35:23,138
All over the world,
648
00:35:23,173 --> 00:35:25,727
scientists looked
to fast-breeding organisms
649
00:35:25,762 --> 00:35:27,107
in search of clues.
650
00:35:27,108 --> 00:35:31,181
Some focused their experiments
on the sea urchin,
651
00:35:31,250 --> 00:35:34,011
which turned out
a new generation each year;
652
00:35:34,080 --> 00:35:38,118
others on the even speedier meal worm,
653
00:35:38,119 --> 00:35:41,501
with its larvae-to-larvae cycle
of four months.
654
00:35:41,570 --> 00:35:44,780
For zoologist Thomas Hunt Morgan,
655
00:35:44,781 --> 00:35:48,198
the organism of choice was the fruit fly,
656
00:35:48,267 --> 00:35:52,927
which was capable of reproducing
in just ten days.
657
00:35:52,961 --> 00:35:54,962
The organism breeds so quickly
658
00:35:54,963 --> 00:35:56,862
that Morgan is able to see things
659
00:35:56,931 --> 00:35:58,310
that the eugenicists cannot,
660
00:35:58,311 --> 00:36:01,142
because he's watching mutations move
661
00:36:01,176 --> 00:36:03,109
across multiple generations.
662
00:36:05,422 --> 00:36:07,182
By 1913,
663
00:36:07,217 --> 00:36:09,771
Morgan had been studying
fruit flies for so long
664
00:36:09,806 --> 00:36:12,532
that his laboratory at Columbia University
665
00:36:12,601 --> 00:36:15,846
was known simply as "the Fly Room,"
666
00:36:15,881 --> 00:36:18,849
and his assistants
"the Fly Boys."
667
00:36:18,884 --> 00:36:22,681
For nearly a decade,
they'd been holed up there,
668
00:36:22,715 --> 00:36:25,510
on the sixth floor of Schermerhorn Hall,
669
00:36:25,511 --> 00:36:28,478
breeding flies in half-pint milk bottles
670
00:36:28,479 --> 00:36:31,793
pilfered from the campus cafeteria.
671
00:36:31,828 --> 00:36:34,830
Thousands upon thousands
of mutants were crossed
672
00:36:34,831 --> 00:36:37,972
and the results meticulously recorded:
673
00:36:38,006 --> 00:36:43,839
white-eyed, bristled,
red-eyed, short-winged.
674
00:36:43,840 --> 00:36:47,084
When the data was collated,
675
00:36:47,153 --> 00:36:50,156
Morgan made a startling discovery:
676
00:36:50,191 --> 00:36:52,503
the mechanism of heredity in flies
677
00:36:52,538 --> 00:36:55,714
was far more complex
than in Mendel's peas.
678
00:36:55,748 --> 00:36:58,647
Gregor Mendel thought that every gene
679
00:36:58,682 --> 00:37:03,031
was its own unique, discrete entity.
680
00:37:03,066 --> 00:37:05,033
Morgan showed that, in fact,
that's not the case.
681
00:37:05,068 --> 00:37:08,312
That, in fact, genes live,
genes have a physical entity.
682
00:37:08,347 --> 00:37:10,280
They live in chromosomes.
683
00:37:10,349 --> 00:37:11,695
Because they live in chromosomes,
684
00:37:11,730 --> 00:37:14,041
often they travel in packs.
685
00:37:14,042 --> 00:37:19,220
Morgan's work complicates
the idea of simple eugenics,
686
00:37:19,254 --> 00:37:23,776
because you don't just pick
one thing out of one drawer,
687
00:37:23,845 --> 00:37:25,225
a second thing out of another drawer,
688
00:37:25,226 --> 00:37:28,884
until you get your ideal child.
689
00:37:28,885 --> 00:37:32,404
It's not so easy to pick and choose
690
00:37:32,405 --> 00:37:34,683
what your next generation might be.
691
00:37:37,376 --> 00:37:40,724
It makes sense
in pea plants, it makes sense in cattle,
692
00:37:40,759 --> 00:37:43,416
it should make sense in humans,
693
00:37:43,451 --> 00:37:45,245
but there were no experiments
694
00:37:45,246 --> 00:37:50,044
that really could support
Davenport's theory.
695
00:37:52,494 --> 00:37:54,634
Thomas Hunt Morgan was a believer
696
00:37:54,669 --> 00:37:58,328
in the transformative power of eugenics.
697
00:37:58,397 --> 00:38:00,916
He had served on the board
at the Eugenics Record Office
698
00:38:00,917 --> 00:38:02,781
since it opened.
699
00:38:02,815 --> 00:38:05,991
But based on the lessons
he'd learned in the Fly Room,
700
00:38:06,060 --> 00:38:09,788
it seemed clear that
eugenic science, such as it was,
701
00:38:09,822 --> 00:38:13,964
had no business informing American laws.
702
00:38:13,999 --> 00:38:18,105
"If the eugenicists want to do
this sort of thing,
703
00:38:18,106 --> 00:38:20,833
well and good," Morgan wrote a friend,
704
00:38:20,902 --> 00:38:22,454
"but I think it is just as well
705
00:38:22,455 --> 00:38:24,941
"for some of us to set a better standard
706
00:38:24,975 --> 00:38:29,945
and not appear as participators
in the show."
707
00:38:29,946 --> 00:38:32,672
Morgan writes a letter saying,
708
00:38:32,707 --> 00:38:36,779
"I'm going to ask to be
taken off this letterhead.
709
00:38:36,780 --> 00:38:38,747
"I study fruit flies,
710
00:38:38,782 --> 00:38:41,440
"and I can't figure out
how their eyes work.
711
00:38:41,474 --> 00:38:43,200
"I can't figure out which one's going
712
00:38:43,269 --> 00:38:46,445
"to inherit certain kinds of wings,
713
00:38:46,479 --> 00:38:50,035
"and you seem to be saying
you can understand
714
00:38:50,104 --> 00:38:52,140
"who's going to inherit something as vague
715
00:38:52,175 --> 00:38:54,625
as criminality or pauperism."
716
00:38:54,660 --> 00:38:59,320
So he backed away but privately.
717
00:38:59,354 --> 00:39:03,358
Morgan's withdrawal
from the Record Office was regrettable;
718
00:39:03,393 --> 00:39:06,051
but Davenport was undeterred.
719
00:39:06,120 --> 00:39:07,328
At this point,
720
00:39:07,362 --> 00:39:09,709
the eugenics movement would not be stalled
721
00:39:09,778 --> 00:39:11,953
by the minutiae of science.
722
00:39:14,128 --> 00:39:15,853
What genes are
723
00:39:15,854 --> 00:39:19,339
is a great biological
and biochemical question.
724
00:39:19,340 --> 00:39:23,515
But there's kind of a Yankee practicality
725
00:39:23,516 --> 00:39:26,968
about eugenics,
"Let's get this job done."
726
00:39:27,003 --> 00:39:28,832
And so they move right along.
727
00:39:36,219 --> 00:39:39,669
When the
Panama-Pacific International Exposition
728
00:39:39,670 --> 00:39:41,431
opened in San Francisco
729
00:39:41,500 --> 00:39:45,365
on the morning of February 20, 1915,
730
00:39:45,366 --> 00:39:49,646
100,000 people streamed
through its turnstiles.
731
00:39:49,680 --> 00:39:52,027
Over the next nine months,
732
00:39:52,028 --> 00:39:56,756
the number would reach
more than 18 million.
733
00:39:56,791 --> 00:39:59,242
Billed as "an encyclopedia
of modern achievement,"
734
00:39:59,276 --> 00:40:02,348
the fair offered a dizzying array
735
00:40:02,383 --> 00:40:04,764
of diversions and curiosities:
736
00:40:04,799 --> 00:40:09,390
a 23-minute ride
over a functioning replica
737
00:40:09,424 --> 00:40:12,219
of the recently completed Panama Canal;
738
00:40:12,220 --> 00:40:17,086
an assembly line that turned out
18 Model Ts a day;
739
00:40:17,087 --> 00:40:22,541
a 57-tier tower built entirely
of Heinz condiment products.
740
00:40:24,060 --> 00:40:26,579
The Panama-Pacific Expo
741
00:40:26,614 --> 00:40:28,512
was a celebration of science,
742
00:40:28,547 --> 00:40:31,930
efficiency, engineering.
743
00:40:31,964 --> 00:40:33,966
It was an opportunity
for the United States
744
00:40:34,001 --> 00:40:39,627
to demonstrate the power
of science and technology,
745
00:40:39,661 --> 00:40:42,905
and also a utopian vision
looking towards the future.
746
00:40:45,115 --> 00:40:46,910
Nowhere did the future look brighter
747
00:40:46,945 --> 00:40:50,293
than from the Race Betterment Exhibit.
748
00:40:50,327 --> 00:40:52,881
Housed in the Palace of Education,
749
00:40:52,916 --> 00:40:55,608
the display featured
imposing plaster casts
750
00:40:55,643 --> 00:40:58,611
of Atlas, Venus, and Apollo;
751
00:40:58,646 --> 00:41:00,993
a collection of medical instruments
752
00:41:01,062 --> 00:41:04,479
used to gauge human biological capacity;
753
00:41:04,514 --> 00:41:08,138
and a welter of charts, graphs, and lists
754
00:41:08,173 --> 00:41:12,039
that outlined the way eugenics
would better the human race.
755
00:41:14,455 --> 00:41:18,666
All of it was the work
of Dr. John Harvey Kellogg,
756
00:41:18,700 --> 00:41:23,257
a fierce proponent of what
he called, "biologic living."
757
00:41:25,984 --> 00:41:30,642
John Harvey Kellogg
was an incredibly energetic man.
758
00:41:30,643 --> 00:41:33,198
He was a health reformer, and a physician,
759
00:41:33,267 --> 00:41:36,856
and an amazing entrepreneur.
760
00:41:36,925 --> 00:41:38,927
And he developed all these regimens
761
00:41:38,962 --> 00:41:43,518
and invented different
medical instruments,
762
00:41:43,553 --> 00:41:45,279
had a whole dietary plan.
763
00:41:45,313 --> 00:41:50,145
He was obsessed
with cleanliness, with purity,
764
00:41:50,146 --> 00:41:53,804
and he believed that the key
to reforming society
765
00:41:53,839 --> 00:41:56,841
is to cleanse our bowels
on a regular basis.
766
00:41:56,842 --> 00:42:01,122
He invents something called Corn Flakes
767
00:42:01,157 --> 00:42:03,986
to help cleanse your bowels.
768
00:42:03,987 --> 00:42:09,889
And he had a spa
in Battle Creek, Michigan.
769
00:42:09,924 --> 00:42:13,652
Lots of eugenicists came
to the Battle Creek Sanatorium
770
00:42:13,686 --> 00:42:15,825
to have their bowels cleansed
771
00:42:15,826 --> 00:42:20,245
and to talk about eugenics.
772
00:42:20,314 --> 00:42:23,627
For Kellogg, eugenics made perfect sense.
773
00:42:23,662 --> 00:42:25,319
It was about health.
774
00:42:25,353 --> 00:42:27,528
He linked these views about heredity,
775
00:42:27,562 --> 00:42:28,770
which were difficult to change,
776
00:42:28,839 --> 00:42:31,669
with these ideas
about what human beings can do
777
00:42:31,670 --> 00:42:34,052
to improve themselves.
778
00:42:34,086 --> 00:42:36,708
John Harvey Kellogg believed
779
00:42:36,709 --> 00:42:39,264
that the environment can affect the gene,
780
00:42:39,333 --> 00:42:43,751
that consuming alcohol
or consuming meat could lead
781
00:42:43,785 --> 00:42:48,720
to genetic inferiority in offspring.
782
00:42:48,721 --> 00:42:51,655
So there was more than one way
to improve heredity.
783
00:42:54,382 --> 00:42:58,283
At the Expo,
784
00:42:58,352 --> 00:43:00,699
Kellogg sought to usher
his brand of eugenics
785
00:43:00,733 --> 00:43:02,873
onto the national stage.
786
00:43:02,908 --> 00:43:06,532
With assistance from Charles Davenport...
787
00:43:06,567 --> 00:43:09,397
who had supplied him
with both data and contacts...
788
00:43:09,432 --> 00:43:13,229
Kellogg had organized not only
the Race Betterment exhibit,
789
00:43:13,263 --> 00:43:17,371
but also a major
eugenics conference at the fair.
790
00:43:19,890 --> 00:43:22,409
The turnout exceeded expectation,
791
00:43:22,410 --> 00:43:25,620
drawing reform-minded
medical professionals,
792
00:43:25,655 --> 00:43:30,004
university presidents, conservationists,
793
00:43:30,073 --> 00:43:32,489
and business leaders
from all over the country
794
00:43:32,558 --> 00:43:35,389
and across the political spectrum.
795
00:43:35,423 --> 00:43:38,806
Eugenics had a
little bit of something for everyone.
796
00:43:38,875 --> 00:43:42,429
So if you're a social hygienist,
797
00:43:42,430 --> 00:43:44,225
you're interested
in wiping out prostitution,
798
00:43:44,260 --> 00:43:46,227
eugenics is interested in that too.
799
00:43:46,262 --> 00:43:48,056
If you're a prohibitionist,
800
00:43:48,091 --> 00:43:49,644
and you want to get rid of alcohol,
801
00:43:49,679 --> 00:43:52,439
because alcohol breaks up families,
802
00:43:52,440 --> 00:43:54,442
it makes men unemployable...
803
00:43:54,477 --> 00:43:58,584
eugenics wants to get rid
of all those things too.
804
00:43:58,619 --> 00:44:03,071
So it manages to match up
with the concerns
805
00:44:03,106 --> 00:44:05,419
of many other different kinds of reforms.
806
00:44:08,284 --> 00:44:11,045
What led people to
get behind the eugenics campaign
807
00:44:11,114 --> 00:44:16,119
wasn't just their ardent belief
in the science or in heredity.
808
00:44:16,154 --> 00:44:18,363
It was a fundamentally broad
809
00:44:18,432 --> 00:44:21,642
and sweeping social and political agenda
810
00:44:21,676 --> 00:44:25,093
to try to recreate society, one might say,
811
00:44:25,128 --> 00:44:27,337
in their own image.
812
00:44:27,372 --> 00:44:30,823
They're almost all
white, they're almost all Protestant,
813
00:44:30,858 --> 00:44:33,135
middle-to-upper-middle class,
814
00:44:33,136 --> 00:44:35,655
and they tended to equate human worth
815
00:44:35,656 --> 00:44:38,417
with the qualities
that they themselves possessed.
816
00:44:41,834 --> 00:44:43,698
Over five days in August,
817
00:44:43,733 --> 00:44:46,322
the 60-odd conference delegates
delivered talks
818
00:44:46,356 --> 00:44:48,668
on everything from proper toothbrushing
819
00:44:48,669 --> 00:44:52,190
to eugenic sterilization.
820
00:44:52,224 --> 00:44:54,122
"Unless we weed out the weaklings,"
821
00:44:54,157 --> 00:44:55,813
one speaker warned,
822
00:44:55,814 --> 00:44:57,194
"we will reach a point
823
00:44:57,195 --> 00:45:00,025
"where many of those born
and helped to survive
824
00:45:00,059 --> 00:45:02,338
will be a burden to the race."
825
00:45:04,029 --> 00:45:06,858
All told, the Race Betterment Conference
826
00:45:06,859 --> 00:45:09,345
drew an estimated 10,000 people
827
00:45:09,379 --> 00:45:14,349
and generated more than
a million lines of press.
828
00:45:14,350 --> 00:45:16,421
"Your efforts on behalf of eugenics
829
00:45:16,490 --> 00:45:18,561
are certainly beginning to bear fruit,"
830
00:45:18,595 --> 00:45:21,840
Kellogg told Charles Davenport.
831
00:45:21,874 --> 00:45:24,186
"The public is beginning
to understand better
832
00:45:24,187 --> 00:45:27,915
and appreciate more."
833
00:45:27,949 --> 00:45:31,711
The Panama-Pacific Expo
was really a defining moment
834
00:45:31,712 --> 00:45:33,403
for the American eugenics movement.
835
00:45:33,438 --> 00:45:37,372
The eugenics movement was coalescing.
836
00:45:37,373 --> 00:45:40,030
It was solidifying.
837
00:45:40,065 --> 00:45:42,067
These elites are all saying,
838
00:45:42,101 --> 00:45:44,034
"Yes, you know, we believe in progress,
839
00:45:44,069 --> 00:45:46,208
and this is progress."
840
00:45:46,209 --> 00:45:48,107
Eugenics gave them a way to view the world
841
00:45:48,176 --> 00:45:50,386
and to say, "Okay, you know,
842
00:45:50,420 --> 00:45:53,734
"all these vague anxieties
I have about the present
843
00:45:53,768 --> 00:45:56,702
and particularly the future,
this is what the problem is.
844
00:45:56,737 --> 00:45:58,877
Well, let's get to work
on solving that."
845
00:46:05,884 --> 00:46:10,578
In May 1917, as new
converts spread the eugenic creed
846
00:46:10,613 --> 00:46:13,235
in cities and towns across America,
847
00:46:13,236 --> 00:46:15,273
a half-dozen psychologists gathered
848
00:46:15,307 --> 00:46:18,586
at the Vineland Training School
for the Feebleminded
849
00:46:18,621 --> 00:46:21,416
to meet with Henry Goddard,
850
00:46:21,417 --> 00:46:23,798
by now considered
the nation's leading expert
851
00:46:23,867 --> 00:46:27,940
on mental deficiency.
852
00:46:27,975 --> 00:46:32,013
His groundbreaking 1912 study,
The Kallikak Family,
853
00:46:32,082 --> 00:46:35,741
had awakened the public to
the menace of the feebleminded,
854
00:46:35,776 --> 00:46:39,261
with its true-life tale
of an old-stock American,
855
00:46:39,262 --> 00:46:41,781
a feebleminded tavern girl,
856
00:46:41,782 --> 00:46:44,957
and a fateful tryst
that over several generations
857
00:46:44,992 --> 00:46:48,615
had spawned more than
a hundred mental defectives,
858
00:46:48,616 --> 00:46:52,792
among them one of Goddard's
own patients at Vineland,
859
00:46:52,793 --> 00:46:55,313
a girl he'd diagnosed as a moron.
860
00:46:57,211 --> 00:46:59,937
The Kallikak Family was a huge best seller
861
00:46:59,938 --> 00:47:02,629
for many, many years.
862
00:47:02,630 --> 00:47:07,048
References to the Kallikaks were
in the speeches of politicians,
863
00:47:07,117 --> 00:47:11,018
books, scholarly journals,
popular magazines.
864
00:47:11,052 --> 00:47:14,297
Everyone knew what the Kallikaks meant.
865
00:47:14,332 --> 00:47:16,299
"You have to watch out who you mate with
866
00:47:16,334 --> 00:47:18,025
"or your descendants could turn out
867
00:47:18,059 --> 00:47:22,270
to be feebleminded, criminals,
alcoholics, and so forth."
868
00:47:24,376 --> 00:47:25,515
Goddard was eager
869
00:47:25,550 --> 00:47:28,138
to demonstrate the value
of intelligence testing
870
00:47:28,173 --> 00:47:30,555
as a diagnostic tool...
871
00:47:30,624 --> 00:47:33,040
and he'd spent the years since
his book's publication
872
00:47:33,074 --> 00:47:36,699
administering tests to scores
of institutional inmates,
873
00:47:36,733 --> 00:47:39,391
immigrants, school children.
874
00:47:39,426 --> 00:47:42,981
Now, with his colleagues,
he designed a program
875
00:47:43,015 --> 00:47:45,154
to carry out intelligence testing
876
00:47:45,155 --> 00:47:47,019
on a mass scale.
877
00:47:49,677 --> 00:47:51,403
Just seven weeks earlier,
878
00:47:51,438 --> 00:47:54,889
the United States had plunged
into the First World War...
879
00:47:54,924 --> 00:47:58,858
and the draft ultimately
would swell the army's ranks
880
00:47:58,859 --> 00:48:01,517
by nearly three million men.
881
00:48:01,551 --> 00:48:04,312
The aim of the testing program
882
00:48:04,347 --> 00:48:06,729
was to classify them for service
883
00:48:06,763 --> 00:48:09,248
and to identify the mental defectives
884
00:48:09,317 --> 00:48:12,079
lurking among them.
885
00:48:12,113 --> 00:48:17,015
They began in late September 1917
886
00:48:17,049 --> 00:48:20,950
at Camp Lee and Camp Taylor,
887
00:48:21,019 --> 00:48:24,055
Camp Devens, and Camp Dix.
888
00:48:24,056 --> 00:48:26,956
First, new recruits were sorted
889
00:48:27,025 --> 00:48:29,199
according to their level of literacy
890
00:48:29,234 --> 00:48:32,789
and then administered one of two tests.
891
00:48:32,858 --> 00:48:36,275
They had one test called the Alpha Test
892
00:48:36,310 --> 00:48:38,174
for draftees who were literate in English
893
00:48:38,208 --> 00:48:40,452
and another called the Beta Test
894
00:48:40,521 --> 00:48:42,868
for draftees
who were not literate in English
895
00:48:42,903 --> 00:48:46,250
or illiterate completely.
896
00:48:46,251 --> 00:48:49,081
One of the questions
on the Alpha Test was,
897
00:48:49,116 --> 00:48:51,946
"The Knight engine is used
898
00:48:51,981 --> 00:48:55,743
in the Ford, the Pierce-Arrow,
or the Lozier car?"
899
00:48:55,778 --> 00:48:59,885
Now, tell me, is that known to you?
900
00:48:59,920 --> 00:49:03,406
While the literate testers puzzled
901
00:49:03,441 --> 00:49:05,477
over multiple-choice questions,
902
00:49:05,546 --> 00:49:06,926
the others attempted
903
00:49:06,927 --> 00:49:09,100
to draw their way out of mazes
904
00:49:09,101 --> 00:49:13,554
and sketch in the missing bits
of simple pictures.
905
00:49:13,589 --> 00:49:16,730
One Sicilian recruit, a Catholic,
906
00:49:16,764 --> 00:49:18,938
considered an image of a house
907
00:49:18,939 --> 00:49:22,424
and drew a crucifix
where a chimney might be.
908
00:49:22,425 --> 00:49:24,876
He was marked wrong.
909
00:49:24,910 --> 00:49:27,913
"It was touching
910
00:49:27,948 --> 00:49:31,123
to see the intense effort put
into answering the questions,"
911
00:49:31,158 --> 00:49:33,608
an Army examiner later recalled,
912
00:49:33,609 --> 00:49:35,955
"often by men who never before
913
00:49:35,956 --> 00:49:39,338
had held a pencil
in their hands."
914
00:49:39,407 --> 00:49:41,132
The tests were
915
00:49:41,133 --> 00:49:43,411
by no means measures of intelligence,
916
00:49:43,446 --> 00:49:44,446
whatever that may mean.
917
00:49:44,447 --> 00:49:46,345
How well you did on them
918
00:49:46,414 --> 00:49:48,934
depended upon your degree of education,
919
00:49:48,969 --> 00:49:50,764
how many years you'd been in school,
920
00:49:50,798 --> 00:49:56,114
and also how attuned you were
with middle-class culture.
921
00:49:58,012 --> 00:50:01,152
Administered
to 1.7 million Army personnel
922
00:50:01,153 --> 00:50:02,983
over the course of the conflict...
923
00:50:03,017 --> 00:50:05,295
officers and enlisted men,
924
00:50:05,330 --> 00:50:07,435
black soldiers as well as white...
925
00:50:07,470 --> 00:50:11,370
the tests led to a shocking conclusion.
926
00:50:11,405 --> 00:50:15,374
Roughly half of the draftees
were considered to be morons.
927
00:50:18,308 --> 00:50:21,864
The Army's experience became a headline,
928
00:50:21,898 --> 00:50:24,831
"America is degenerating.
929
00:50:24,832 --> 00:50:28,767
We have to somehow interrupt
this swamp of defect."
930
00:50:32,495 --> 00:50:33,841
There was a movement
931
00:50:33,876 --> 00:50:36,671
to institutionalize more people
at this time,
932
00:50:36,672 --> 00:50:39,018
driven by eugenics.
933
00:50:39,019 --> 00:50:42,540
You can see how an IQ test
can really grease the wheels.
934
00:50:42,574 --> 00:50:45,059
If you're going to start
moving people into institutions,
935
00:50:45,094 --> 00:50:46,716
if you're going to start
sterilizing them and all that,
936
00:50:46,751 --> 00:50:48,891
you need some numbers,
and the IQ test provided that.
937
00:50:50,789 --> 00:50:55,587
By 1919, intelligence
testing was a full-fledged craze.
938
00:50:55,656 --> 00:50:58,659
An adapted version of the Army test,
939
00:50:58,694 --> 00:51:00,661
the National Intelligence Test,
940
00:51:00,696 --> 00:51:03,837
sold half a million copies in one year.
941
00:51:03,871 --> 00:51:06,355
Businesses administered mental tests
942
00:51:06,356 --> 00:51:09,083
to prospective employees;
943
00:51:09,118 --> 00:51:12,397
schools and universities
evaluated their students;
944
00:51:12,431 --> 00:51:15,193
and ever more paupers,
prostitutes, drunkards,
945
00:51:15,227 --> 00:51:18,161
and delinquents found themselves suddenly
946
00:51:18,196 --> 00:51:20,198
with pencil in hand.
947
00:51:22,614 --> 00:51:26,100
Feeblemindedness
was a big fear in that era.
948
00:51:26,169 --> 00:51:27,584
There was a thought
949
00:51:27,585 --> 00:51:28,551
that there were a lot
of these people out there
950
00:51:28,586 --> 00:51:29,552
who were deficient,
951
00:51:29,587 --> 00:51:32,141
who were morons,
952
00:51:32,210 --> 00:51:34,039
and they were not only out there,
953
00:51:34,074 --> 00:51:36,973
they were reproducing much
more rapidly than other people.
954
00:51:37,042 --> 00:51:39,942
The trouble is that in practice
955
00:51:39,976 --> 00:51:43,221
the word "moron" could be anyone
956
00:51:43,255 --> 00:51:45,361
who was not part of the, you know,
957
00:51:45,395 --> 00:51:47,121
the so-called social norm.
958
00:51:47,156 --> 00:51:53,127
So the word "moron" begins
as a scientific attempt
959
00:51:53,162 --> 00:51:55,094
to classify intelligence
960
00:51:55,095 --> 00:51:56,890
but very soon becomes usable
961
00:51:56,924 --> 00:52:01,239
as a means of social control.
962
00:52:01,273 --> 00:52:02,792
By 1920,
963
00:52:02,827 --> 00:52:04,759
the vast majority of those committed
964
00:52:04,760 --> 00:52:06,761
to institutions for the feebleminded
965
00:52:06,762 --> 00:52:11,248
were classified as morons.
966
00:52:18,428 --> 00:52:19,947
To some extent,
967
00:52:19,982 --> 00:52:22,674
humanity's always been about othering
968
00:52:22,743 --> 00:52:23,950
and about, you know,
969
00:52:23,951 --> 00:52:26,367
"There's us,
and there's the other."
970
00:52:26,436 --> 00:52:28,128
The eugenics movement really gave
971
00:52:28,162 --> 00:52:31,683
this scientific, you know,
punch to this idea that,
972
00:52:31,752 --> 00:52:33,927
"There are us, and there are the others,
973
00:52:33,961 --> 00:52:35,479
"and we're the right people.
974
00:52:35,480 --> 00:52:36,792
"We're the people that it's important
975
00:52:36,826 --> 00:52:39,518
"not only to favor now,
976
00:52:39,553 --> 00:52:42,694
but we're the people
who have to own the future."
977
00:52:42,763 --> 00:52:44,662
Suddenly eugenics comes along
978
00:52:44,696 --> 00:52:46,353
and gives them a scientific basis
979
00:52:46,422 --> 00:52:47,768
for believing that.
980
00:52:49,390 --> 00:52:52,670
Eugenics is easy to accept,
981
00:52:52,704 --> 00:52:57,605
because it preserves existing hierarchies.
982
00:52:57,640 --> 00:53:00,988
It doesn't seek to overturn them.
983
00:53:01,023 --> 00:53:04,992
What it did was lend new weight
to established hierarchies.
984
00:53:05,027 --> 00:53:09,065
I don't think there has ever been a time
985
00:53:09,134 --> 00:53:12,482
when people didn't think
986
00:53:12,517 --> 00:53:15,416
that some people simply better
than others.
987
00:53:15,485 --> 00:53:18,488
The eugenics movement, like a chameleon,
988
00:53:18,523 --> 00:53:20,524
took on the colors of those attitudes
989
00:53:20,525 --> 00:53:24,563
which existed before the word
"eugenics" was coined
990
00:53:24,632 --> 00:53:26,324
and certainly exist today.
991
00:53:36,161 --> 00:53:39,889
They'd been swarming
the ports of entry since 1890...
992
00:53:39,924 --> 00:53:43,548
as many as a million of them a year,
993
00:53:43,582 --> 00:53:48,242
in flight from poverty and oppression,
994
00:53:48,277 --> 00:53:51,452
lured by the promise
of equality and opportunity.
995
00:53:51,521 --> 00:53:56,492
The Great War had staunched the flow;
996
00:53:56,526 --> 00:53:57,873
but with the armistice,
997
00:53:57,907 --> 00:54:01,186
the tap had been opened once more.
998
00:54:01,221 --> 00:54:05,707
By 1920, some 75,000 new immigrants
999
00:54:05,708 --> 00:54:09,677
were landing at Ellis Island each month.
1000
00:54:09,712 --> 00:54:13,302
That May, at Cold Spring Harbor,
1001
00:54:13,371 --> 00:54:16,891
Charles Davenport penned
a letter to a friend:
1002
00:54:16,892 --> 00:54:19,549
"Can we build a wall high
enough around this country,"
1003
00:54:19,584 --> 00:54:21,240
he wondered,
1004
00:54:21,241 --> 00:54:24,209
"so as to keep out
these cheaper races?"
1005
00:54:29,318 --> 00:54:32,355
Charles Davenport
was born into a very fancy,
1006
00:54:32,390 --> 00:54:34,425
old-stock family.
1007
00:54:34,426 --> 00:54:37,878
So he was someone brought up
to believe that family mattered
1008
00:54:37,913 --> 00:54:39,258
and that, you know,
1009
00:54:39,259 --> 00:54:42,952
good qualities ran
in good families like his.
1010
00:54:42,987 --> 00:54:44,885
Charles Davenport was very focused
1011
00:54:44,920 --> 00:54:48,924
on wanting to maintain
the traditional American stock.
1012
00:54:48,958 --> 00:54:50,270
And he wasn't alone in that.
1013
00:54:50,304 --> 00:54:53,169
There was this fear that
the right sort of American
1014
00:54:53,238 --> 00:54:55,585
wasn't having enough children.
1015
00:54:55,620 --> 00:54:57,794
And the race as it existed
1016
00:54:57,795 --> 00:55:04,249
was being diluted and polluted
by incoming waves of immigrants.
1017
00:55:04,284 --> 00:55:06,595
Most immigrants used to come
1018
00:55:06,596 --> 00:55:08,806
from northern and western Europe,
1019
00:55:08,840 --> 00:55:10,669
from the British Isles, from Germany.
1020
00:55:10,738 --> 00:55:13,500
And then all of a sudden in the 1890s,
1021
00:55:13,534 --> 00:55:16,020
immigrants started coming here
from eastern Europe,
1022
00:55:16,089 --> 00:55:17,504
from southern Europe.
1023
00:55:17,538 --> 00:55:19,954
These are Catholics, these are Jews,
1024
00:55:19,955 --> 00:55:22,611
these are peasants.
1025
00:55:22,612 --> 00:55:24,545
And Davenport feels correctly
1026
00:55:24,614 --> 00:55:27,169
that his race is losing
the demographic game.
1027
00:55:27,203 --> 00:55:31,311
On the receiving end of Davenport's letter
1028
00:55:31,345 --> 00:55:33,657
was Madison Grant,
1029
00:55:33,658 --> 00:55:36,799
a zealous convert to the eugenics cause
1030
00:55:36,834 --> 00:55:39,146
with a sterling American pedigree
1031
00:55:39,181 --> 00:55:44,289
and an abiding preoccupation
with endangered species.
1032
00:55:44,324 --> 00:55:48,293
Madison Grant was a very wealthy lawyer.
1033
00:55:48,328 --> 00:55:49,846
His ancestors are traced back
1034
00:55:49,847 --> 00:55:52,573
to the original Puritan founders
of the United States.
1035
00:55:52,642 --> 00:55:56,888
Some of his ancestors signed
the Declaration of Independence.
1036
00:55:56,957 --> 00:56:01,237
He was a committed conservationist.
1037
00:56:01,306 --> 00:56:04,482
He saved the redwoods from extinction.
1038
00:56:04,516 --> 00:56:06,864
At some point he realized,
1039
00:56:06,898 --> 00:56:08,727
"I'm spending all my time and effort
1040
00:56:08,762 --> 00:56:13,008
"trying to save
our nation's flora and fauna
1041
00:56:13,042 --> 00:56:17,666
while my own race is dying out."
1042
00:56:17,667 --> 00:56:19,704
When Madison Grant walks out the door
1043
00:56:19,738 --> 00:56:21,844
of his Wall Street law office,
1044
00:56:21,879 --> 00:56:27,193
he is accosted by thousands
of foreign-speaking peasants.
1045
00:56:27,194 --> 00:56:28,712
They don't know
1046
00:56:28,713 --> 00:56:31,681
and they don't care
that Madison Grant's ancestors
1047
00:56:31,716 --> 00:56:33,097
signed the Declaration of Independence,
1048
00:56:33,166 --> 00:56:38,412
and he is offended.
1049
00:56:38,447 --> 00:56:42,830
Grant had sounded the
alarm for old-stock Americans in 1916
1050
00:56:42,865 --> 00:56:45,592
with The Passing of the Great Race,
1051
00:56:45,626 --> 00:56:49,561
a 476-page elegy for what he called
1052
00:56:49,596 --> 00:56:54,531
"The white man par excellence."
1053
00:56:54,532 --> 00:56:55,877
His vision is one
1054
00:56:55,878 --> 00:57:00,607
of America as a country wrought
by great men
1055
00:57:00,676 --> 00:57:02,746
who ventured from Europe,
1056
00:57:02,747 --> 00:57:07,131
and an America that is facing an onslaught
1057
00:57:07,200 --> 00:57:09,478
from the undesirable hoards
1058
00:57:09,547 --> 00:57:14,138
from most of the rest of the world.
1059
00:57:14,207 --> 00:57:16,450
He invents this race called the Nordics,
1060
00:57:16,485 --> 00:57:19,902
this tall, blond-haired, blue-eyed race.
1061
00:57:19,937 --> 00:57:21,628
According to Grant,
1062
00:57:21,662 --> 00:57:23,699
the Nordics are the most recently evolved
1063
00:57:23,733 --> 00:57:24,942
of all the races.
1064
00:57:24,976 --> 00:57:29,705
That means their genetic traits
are still fragile.
1065
00:57:29,739 --> 00:57:31,810
They're not fully formed.
1066
00:57:31,845 --> 00:57:35,228
And so if a blond-haired, blue-eyed Nordic
1067
00:57:35,262 --> 00:57:38,437
mates with a more primitive race...
1068
00:57:38,438 --> 00:57:41,441
a Mediterranean, a Jew, certainly a Negro
1069
00:57:41,475 --> 00:57:43,581
or an Asiatic...
1070
00:57:43,615 --> 00:57:47,309
the more primitive genes
of the inferior race
1071
00:57:47,343 --> 00:57:49,794
will actually overwhelm
1072
00:57:49,828 --> 00:57:53,280
the superior but not yet stable genes
1073
00:57:53,315 --> 00:57:55,454
of the Nordics.
1074
00:57:55,455 --> 00:57:57,077
So this is a threat,
1075
00:57:57,112 --> 00:57:58,768
and a threat not just, you know,
1076
00:57:58,803 --> 00:58:00,114
"Hey, I look around the city,
1077
00:58:00,115 --> 00:58:01,357
and it looks
a little different."
1078
00:58:01,426 --> 00:58:02,945
This is a genetic invasion.
1079
00:58:04,533 --> 00:58:06,120
As Grant saw it,
1080
00:58:06,121 --> 00:58:10,124
the threat from the Negro race
was mostly neutralized
1081
00:58:10,125 --> 00:58:12,472
by laws already on the books
in many states,
1082
00:58:12,506 --> 00:58:16,372
that forbid marriage
between blacks and whites.
1083
00:58:16,441 --> 00:58:19,305
The threat posed
by the foreign-born, however,
1084
00:58:19,306 --> 00:58:24,001
was at once more insidious
and more pressing.
1085
00:58:24,035 --> 00:58:25,692
"We Americans must realize
1086
00:58:25,726 --> 00:58:29,799
"that the altruistic ideals
and the maudlin sentimentalism
1087
00:58:29,834 --> 00:58:33,631
"that has made America
'an asylum for the oppressed'
1088
00:58:33,665 --> 00:58:36,530
are sweeping the nation
toward a racial abyss,"
1089
00:58:36,599 --> 00:58:39,637
Grant declared.
1090
00:58:39,671 --> 00:58:41,018
"This generation must completely repudiate
1091
00:58:41,052 --> 00:58:43,123
"the proud boast of our fathers
1092
00:58:43,158 --> 00:58:45,367
"that they acknowledged no distinction
1093
00:58:45,401 --> 00:58:48,335
"in 'race, creed, or color, '
1094
00:58:48,370 --> 00:58:50,303
"or else turn the page of history
1095
00:58:50,337 --> 00:58:54,340
and write, 'Finis Americae.'"
1096
00:58:54,341 --> 00:58:56,964
Madison Grant takes eugenics,
1097
00:58:56,999 --> 00:58:58,552
which had hitherto been concerned
1098
00:58:58,587 --> 00:59:01,659
only with survival
of the fittest individual,
1099
00:59:01,693 --> 00:59:05,180
and he says, "We need to be concerned
1100
00:59:05,214 --> 00:59:07,906
"with the survival of the fittest race.
1101
00:59:07,975 --> 00:59:12,083
We need to preserve
the Nordic race."
1102
00:59:12,118 --> 00:59:16,777
Grant's mission in
1920 was to rally his fellow eugenicists
1103
00:59:16,846 --> 00:59:18,538
and convince the federal government
1104
00:59:18,572 --> 00:59:21,885
to drastically reduce immigration.
1105
00:59:21,886 --> 00:59:25,614
He began with a charm offensive directed
1106
00:59:25,683 --> 00:59:28,099
at Congressman Albert Johnson,
1107
00:59:28,168 --> 00:59:29,894
the chairman of the House Committee
1108
00:59:29,928 --> 00:59:32,828
on Immigration and Naturalization,
1109
00:59:32,862 --> 00:59:35,555
inviting Johnson to New York,
1110
00:59:35,589 --> 00:59:38,246
plying him with whiskey and cigars,
1111
00:59:38,247 --> 00:59:43,873
and gradually persuading him
of the urgent need for eugenics.
1112
00:59:43,908 --> 00:59:46,117
Once Johnson was in the fold,
1113
00:59:46,186 --> 00:59:48,775
Grant suggested he bring Harry Laughlin,
1114
00:59:48,809 --> 00:59:51,191
the superintendent
of the Eugenics Record Office,
1115
00:59:51,226 --> 00:59:52,917
to Washington D.C.,
1116
00:59:52,951 --> 00:59:55,126
to testify on the so-called
1117
00:59:55,195 --> 00:59:59,060
"biological aspects
of immigration."
1118
00:59:59,061 --> 01:00:01,822
Johnson was so impressed
with the presentation,
1119
01:00:01,891 --> 01:00:05,136
he named Laughlin "Expert Eugenics Agent"
1120
01:00:05,171 --> 01:00:09,209
and commissioned him to make
a study of the foreign-born.
1121
01:00:11,970 --> 01:00:13,386
In the meantime...
1122
01:00:13,420 --> 01:00:15,939
amid a rising anti-immigrant clamor
1123
01:00:15,940 --> 01:00:20,151
from labor unions, social
workers, conservationists...
1124
01:00:20,220 --> 01:00:22,291
Congress curbed the influx
1125
01:00:22,326 --> 01:00:25,605
with the Emergency Quota Act of 1921.
1126
01:00:28,608 --> 01:00:32,922
This was supposedly
a one-year temporary measure.
1127
01:00:32,957 --> 01:00:37,168
But in 1922, the bill is renewed
for another two years,
1128
01:00:37,203 --> 01:00:40,689
and that gave Madison Grant
and the eugenicists time
1129
01:00:40,758 --> 01:00:45,003
to launch a massive propaganda campaign
1130
01:00:45,072 --> 01:00:46,660
convincing Americans
1131
01:00:46,695 --> 01:00:50,630
that immigration restriction
must be permanent.
1132
01:00:50,664 --> 01:00:54,461
In September 1921,
1133
01:00:54,496 --> 01:00:57,291
at New York's American Museum
of Natural History,
1134
01:00:57,292 --> 01:01:01,365
Grant convened an
international eugenics congress
1135
01:01:01,434 --> 01:01:04,713
to whip up support for the cause.
1136
01:01:04,782 --> 01:01:08,061
Organized in tandem
with Charles Davenport,
1137
01:01:08,130 --> 01:01:10,684
the week-long event
drew some 300 delegates
1138
01:01:10,719 --> 01:01:13,722
from 28 foreign countries.
1139
01:01:13,791 --> 01:01:16,552
Numerous members of the Senate
and House immigration committees
1140
01:01:16,621 --> 01:01:18,382
were in attendance,
1141
01:01:18,451 --> 01:01:21,178
as was actress Lillian Russell...
1142
01:01:21,212 --> 01:01:24,318
who now informed her legions of fans
1143
01:01:24,319 --> 01:01:28,219
that the American melting pot
was a catastrophe.
1144
01:01:28,288 --> 01:01:31,740
"If we don't put up the bars
1145
01:01:31,809 --> 01:01:34,846
and make them higher
and stronger," she warned,
1146
01:01:34,881 --> 01:01:39,920
"there no longer will be
an America for Americans."
1147
01:01:39,989 --> 01:01:42,406
There are all kinds
of exhibits at the Congress
1148
01:01:42,475 --> 01:01:45,409
showing that Negro fetuses
have smaller skulls,
1149
01:01:45,478 --> 01:01:48,032
Italians have a higher level
of criminality
1150
01:01:48,066 --> 01:01:49,827
than other people.
1151
01:01:49,861 --> 01:01:52,726
And at the end of the Congress,
1152
01:01:52,761 --> 01:01:56,903
the exhibits are packed up
and shipped to Washington, D.C.,
1153
01:01:56,937 --> 01:01:58,836
where they are prominently displayed
1154
01:01:58,870 --> 01:02:00,354
in the committee rooms
1155
01:02:00,355 --> 01:02:03,427
so that congressmen could not help
1156
01:02:03,496 --> 01:02:05,187
but, consciously or not,
1157
01:02:05,222 --> 01:02:10,296
imbibe all the latest
scientific findings of eugenics.
1158
01:02:10,365 --> 01:02:14,886
But it was Harry
Laughlin's return to Capitol Hill...
1159
01:02:14,921 --> 01:02:16,888
and the reports on his study...
1160
01:02:16,923 --> 01:02:19,063
that convinced many on the House Committee
1161
01:02:19,097 --> 01:02:23,861
of the perils of unchecked immigration.
1162
01:02:23,895 --> 01:02:25,896
He had numbers that purported to show
1163
01:02:25,897 --> 01:02:28,175
that rates of insanity were different
1164
01:02:28,210 --> 01:02:30,556
among immigrants from different countries,
1165
01:02:30,557 --> 01:02:32,456
that certain nationalities
were much more likely
1166
01:02:32,525 --> 01:02:36,356
to have their immigrants
become prison inmates.
1167
01:02:36,391 --> 01:02:39,256
And he also argued that just biologically,
1168
01:02:39,290 --> 01:02:41,395
because we were largely a Nordic,
1169
01:02:41,396 --> 01:02:42,983
northern European country,
1170
01:02:43,052 --> 01:02:44,882
it was harder to assimilate immigrants
1171
01:02:44,916 --> 01:02:48,230
from other parts of the world.
1172
01:02:48,265 --> 01:02:51,232
Citing data
from the Army intelligence tests,
1173
01:02:51,233 --> 01:02:53,752
Laughlin claimed
that foreign-born whites...
1174
01:02:53,753 --> 01:02:56,100
and in particular Jews...
1175
01:02:56,134 --> 01:02:59,621
were intellectually inferior
to native-born Americans
1176
01:02:59,655 --> 01:03:02,382
and therefore likely, over time,
1177
01:03:02,417 --> 01:03:06,283
to diminish the intelligence
of the nation.
1178
01:03:06,317 --> 01:03:11,079
The Jews on the
Immigration Committee object.
1179
01:03:11,080 --> 01:03:12,461
They claim correctly
1180
01:03:12,496 --> 01:03:15,775
that the eugenicists have
first come up with their theory
1181
01:03:15,809 --> 01:03:17,673
that Jews are inferior
1182
01:03:17,742 --> 01:03:21,090
and then found the data to back it up.
1183
01:03:21,125 --> 01:03:24,680
But Congress is converted
to the cause of eugenics.
1184
01:03:24,749 --> 01:03:26,441
The Congressional Record is filled
1185
01:03:26,475 --> 01:03:28,166
with Congressmen reading excerpts
1186
01:03:28,235 --> 01:03:30,030
from The Passing of the Great Race,
1187
01:03:30,099 --> 01:03:33,310
Madison Grant's book,
on the floor of Congress.
1188
01:03:33,344 --> 01:03:35,760
And so the restrictionists win the day,
1189
01:03:35,795 --> 01:03:38,625
and Congress passes immigration
restriction legislation.
1190
01:03:40,455 --> 01:03:43,491
On May 26, 1924,
1191
01:03:43,492 --> 01:03:48,670
President Calvin Coolidge signed
the restriction act into law.
1192
01:03:48,704 --> 01:03:51,154
Madison Grant hailed it
1193
01:03:51,155 --> 01:03:53,433
as "one of the greatest steps forward
1194
01:03:53,468 --> 01:03:57,092
in the history of this country."
1195
01:03:57,126 --> 01:03:59,197
They shut the door
1196
01:03:59,232 --> 01:04:03,131
and reduced immigration
to the United States by 97%.
1197
01:04:03,132 --> 01:04:04,202
The door was shut,
1198
01:04:04,271 --> 01:04:06,481
and it didn't open again for 40 years.
1199
01:04:06,515 --> 01:04:08,827
And in a very real sense,
1200
01:04:08,828 --> 01:04:13,488
this was a political,
policy victory for eugenics.
1201
01:04:15,835 --> 01:04:18,492
The new policy
would help the nation to remain,
1202
01:04:18,493 --> 01:04:21,565
as one congressman said
on the House floor,
1203
01:04:21,634 --> 01:04:23,912
"The home of a great people:
1204
01:04:23,981 --> 01:04:27,985
"English-speaking,
a white race with great ideals,
1205
01:04:28,019 --> 01:04:30,574
"the Christian religion.
1206
01:04:30,643 --> 01:04:35,199
One race, one country,
one destiny."
1207
01:04:35,233 --> 01:04:38,858
It was really a reversal of, you know,
1208
01:04:38,892 --> 01:04:41,860
"Give us your tired
and your huddled masses,"
1209
01:04:41,861 --> 01:04:46,486
and it sends a message that
the open arms of Ellis Island
1210
01:04:46,521 --> 01:04:47,694
are now closed.
1211
01:04:50,766 --> 01:04:53,044
For many of those across the Atlantic
1212
01:04:53,079 --> 01:04:56,876
who would pin their hopes
on America in the years to come,
1213
01:04:56,910 --> 01:05:00,673
the consequences would be dire.
1214
01:05:00,707 --> 01:05:03,745
Congress passed
this law and closed the door
1215
01:05:03,779 --> 01:05:06,367
on Jews in eastern Europe and Germany
1216
01:05:06,368 --> 01:05:08,370
who were trying to flee the Nazis.
1217
01:05:08,405 --> 01:05:11,890
Otto Frank wrote
to the U.S. State Department,
1218
01:05:11,891 --> 01:05:14,376
trying to get visas for his family.
1219
01:05:14,411 --> 01:05:16,689
And he wrote repeatedly,
and he had connections,
1220
01:05:16,723 --> 01:05:19,761
and he was turned down,
because of this law.
1221
01:05:19,795 --> 01:05:24,144
We think about Anne Frank dying
in a concentration camp
1222
01:05:24,213 --> 01:05:28,390
because the Germans thought the
Jews were genetically inferior,
1223
01:05:28,425 --> 01:05:29,874
but to some extent,
1224
01:05:29,909 --> 01:05:32,429
Anne Frank died in a concentration camp
1225
01:05:32,463 --> 01:05:35,673
because the U.S. Congress
believed that as well.
1226
01:05:41,230 --> 01:05:44,095
We believe that married people
1227
01:05:44,130 --> 01:05:47,754
who have transmissible diseases
1228
01:05:47,789 --> 01:05:50,723
should not have children.
1229
01:05:50,757 --> 01:05:55,659
No couple who has the disease
of feeblemindedness
1230
01:05:55,728 --> 01:05:59,732
or insanity or epilepsy
should have children.
1231
01:05:59,766 --> 01:06:04,943
Babies should not be brought
into the world
1232
01:06:04,944 --> 01:06:10,087
when the father's income
is obviously inadequate
1233
01:06:10,121 --> 01:06:14,125
to provide for its food,
clothing, or shelter.
1234
01:06:17,819 --> 01:06:19,785
On August 5, 1926,
1235
01:06:19,786 --> 01:06:22,479
a crowd gathered at Vassar College
1236
01:06:22,513 --> 01:06:25,827
to hear a lecture given
by Margaret Sanger,
1237
01:06:25,861 --> 01:06:27,276
the controversial founder
1238
01:06:27,311 --> 01:06:30,279
of the American Birth Control League.
1239
01:06:30,314 --> 01:06:34,144
Sanger's reputation preceded her.
1240
01:06:34,145 --> 01:06:36,044
In her dozen years as a crusader
1241
01:06:36,113 --> 01:06:38,632
for contraception and family planning,
1242
01:06:38,633 --> 01:06:43,603
she'd been denounced, jeered,
and jailed repeatedly.
1243
01:06:43,638 --> 01:06:46,537
Now, she'd undertaken
a cross-country speaking tour
1244
01:06:46,572 --> 01:06:50,507
intended to bolster her cause
by linking it to eugenics.
1245
01:06:52,025 --> 01:06:55,303
Margaret Sanger was laser-beam focused
1246
01:06:55,304 --> 01:06:56,685
on promoting birth control,
1247
01:06:56,720 --> 01:07:00,482
which she saw
as a liberatory agent for women.
1248
01:07:02,104 --> 01:07:03,657
It was a hard push,
1249
01:07:03,658 --> 01:07:07,213
reproductive rights, contraception.
1250
01:07:07,282 --> 01:07:09,664
Her embrace of the eugenicists
1251
01:07:09,698 --> 01:07:13,357
was a way of getting some
influential and powerful allies
1252
01:07:13,391 --> 01:07:17,050
behind her cause.
1253
01:07:17,085 --> 01:07:19,190
"The question of race betterment,"
1254
01:07:19,225 --> 01:07:21,191
Sanger told the Vassar audience,
1255
01:07:21,192 --> 01:07:23,331
"is one of immediate concern.
1256
01:07:23,332 --> 01:07:24,678
"And I am glad to say
1257
01:07:24,679 --> 01:07:27,233
"that the government
has already taken certain steps
1258
01:07:27,267 --> 01:07:30,167
"to control the quality of our population
1259
01:07:30,201 --> 01:07:33,653
"through the drastic immigration laws.
1260
01:07:33,688 --> 01:07:35,241
"But while we close our gates
1261
01:07:35,275 --> 01:07:38,692
"to the so-called 'undesirables'
from other countries,
1262
01:07:38,693 --> 01:07:40,383
"we make no attempt
1263
01:07:40,384 --> 01:07:43,421
"to discourage or cut down
the rapid multiplication
1264
01:07:43,490 --> 01:07:47,494
of the unfit and undesirable
at home."
1265
01:07:49,427 --> 01:07:52,499
Margaret Sanger is
struggling to open a conversation
1266
01:07:52,534 --> 01:07:53,846
at a time when
1267
01:07:53,880 --> 01:07:55,951
public discussion of birth control,
1268
01:07:56,020 --> 01:07:58,402
let alone access
to birth control, was illegal.
1269
01:07:58,436 --> 01:08:02,855
But her views are fairly persistent
1270
01:08:02,889 --> 01:08:06,928
with regard to issues
of biological inferiority.
1271
01:08:06,962 --> 01:08:09,239
You could argue that they're strategic,
1272
01:08:09,240 --> 01:08:12,381
but the difference is not that significant
1273
01:08:12,416 --> 01:08:14,591
from the standpoint
of those listening to her words.
1274
01:08:14,625 --> 01:08:17,973
Once birth control is packaged
1275
01:08:18,042 --> 01:08:21,080
as a way of improving the human race,
1276
01:08:21,114 --> 01:08:24,254
it seems more manageable.
1277
01:08:24,255 --> 01:08:27,051
And there are a lot of people
that were on the fence
1278
01:08:27,086 --> 01:08:30,744
that she convinced
to embrace birth control,
1279
01:08:30,745 --> 01:08:33,126
because of its eugenic potential.
1280
01:08:33,161 --> 01:08:35,922
It was being labeled
a birth-control activist
1281
01:08:35,957 --> 01:08:38,579
that was truly controversial.
1282
01:08:38,580 --> 01:08:42,583
Being a eugenicist was
far more acceptable.
1283
01:08:47,589 --> 01:08:49,798
Amid the many American enthusiasms
1284
01:08:49,833 --> 01:08:51,662
of the 1920s...
1285
01:08:51,731 --> 01:08:56,702
skimpy dresses,
dance marathons, mahjong...
1286
01:08:56,771 --> 01:09:02,086
breeding a better human race
was perhaps the most unlikely.
1287
01:09:02,121 --> 01:09:04,019
But by the middle years of the decade,
1288
01:09:04,088 --> 01:09:06,124
the notion was everywhere.
1289
01:09:06,125 --> 01:09:08,610
Included in the curriculum
1290
01:09:08,645 --> 01:09:12,958
at more than 350 American
colleges and universities...
1291
01:09:12,959 --> 01:09:14,823
among them Harvard, Northwestern,
1292
01:09:14,858 --> 01:09:18,862
and the University of California
at Berkeley...
1293
01:09:18,931 --> 01:09:22,762
eugenics also was preached from pulpits,
1294
01:09:22,797 --> 01:09:24,419
promoted on lecture circuits,
1295
01:09:24,453 --> 01:09:27,594
and appropriated to sell everything
1296
01:09:27,629 --> 01:09:29,286
from newfangled beauty treatments
1297
01:09:29,320 --> 01:09:32,151
to children's toys.
1298
01:09:32,185 --> 01:09:36,155
Disseminated by a host of popularizers,
1299
01:09:36,189 --> 01:09:40,849
and at times diluted, distorted, or both,
1300
01:09:40,884 --> 01:09:44,301
the eugenic creed filtered down
to the masses
1301
01:09:44,335 --> 01:09:47,960
through magazine articles, advice manuals,
1302
01:09:47,994 --> 01:09:51,135
even a movie called Are You Fit to Marry?
1303
01:09:53,655 --> 01:09:57,485
This was really
something that permeated the culture.
1304
01:09:57,486 --> 01:09:59,972
It was really a craze.
1305
01:10:00,006 --> 01:10:02,319
It was something people
were excited about.
1306
01:10:02,353 --> 01:10:06,979
Eugenics starts to trickle
into mainstream popular culture
1307
01:10:07,013 --> 01:10:09,326
in the 1920s.
1308
01:10:09,360 --> 01:10:11,362
And it says to individual Americans,
1309
01:10:11,397 --> 01:10:13,640
"If you want your society to improve,
1310
01:10:13,675 --> 01:10:16,264
"you have to marry the right person.
1311
01:10:16,333 --> 01:10:18,576
"You have to have healthy children.
1312
01:10:18,611 --> 01:10:21,165
"You have obligations to the human race
1313
01:10:21,200 --> 01:10:22,891
and to your country."
1314
01:10:22,926 --> 01:10:25,273
As one newlywed confessed
1315
01:10:25,342 --> 01:10:28,551
in a letter to his local eugenics society:
1316
01:10:28,552 --> 01:10:31,348
"My wife and I are both extremely tall,
1317
01:10:31,382 --> 01:10:33,211
"and this worries us,
1318
01:10:33,212 --> 01:10:36,077
"as we do not wish to bring
abnormally tall children
1319
01:10:36,111 --> 01:10:38,562
into the world."
1320
01:10:44,119 --> 01:10:45,465
At state and county fairs
1321
01:10:45,534 --> 01:10:48,365
across the country...
in Massachusetts,
1322
01:10:48,399 --> 01:10:52,058
Kansas, Georgia, Texas...
1323
01:10:52,093 --> 01:10:55,096
a human stock contest known as
1324
01:10:55,130 --> 01:10:58,237
"Fitter Families for Future Firesides"
1325
01:10:58,271 --> 01:11:00,066
drew throngs.
1326
01:11:00,101 --> 01:11:04,312
Sponsored by
the American Eugenics Society,
1327
01:11:04,381 --> 01:11:07,901
a propaganda organization run
by the movement's evangelists,
1328
01:11:07,902 --> 01:11:10,731
Harry Laughlin and Madison Grant,
1329
01:11:10,732 --> 01:11:13,770
the competition offered a primer
on eugenics,
1330
01:11:13,804 --> 01:11:17,877
disguised as wholesome
family entertainment.
1331
01:11:19,983 --> 01:11:22,468
What the American
Eugenics Society realized
1332
01:11:22,502 --> 01:11:23,987
is that if you're going
to spread a message
1333
01:11:24,056 --> 01:11:25,608
about eugenics,
1334
01:11:25,609 --> 01:11:26,990
you have to get people involved in more
1335
01:11:27,059 --> 01:11:29,130
than just reading something
in a popular magazine.
1336
01:11:29,164 --> 01:11:33,927
Eugenics is an all-encompassing creed.
1337
01:11:33,928 --> 01:11:36,240
It's a faith, it's a religion.
1338
01:11:36,275 --> 01:11:39,588
Harry Laughlin
and Madison Grant understood,
1339
01:11:39,623 --> 01:11:42,764
"We need the people to be
converted of this religion,
1340
01:11:42,799 --> 01:11:44,628
"so that everyone will understand,
1341
01:11:44,662 --> 01:11:48,287
"'If I am eugenically superior
I cannot date
1342
01:11:48,321 --> 01:11:49,633
"'and certainly cannot mate
1343
01:11:49,667 --> 01:11:51,738
with a eugenically
unfit person.'"
1344
01:11:53,810 --> 01:11:57,640
Fitter Families
contestants came from miles around,
1345
01:11:57,641 --> 01:11:59,436
often dressed in their Sunday best,
1346
01:11:59,470 --> 01:12:01,300
and submitted themselves
1347
01:12:01,334 --> 01:12:04,474
to a rigorous three-hour inspection.
1348
01:12:04,475 --> 01:12:08,444
Straight, healthy teeth
earned them high marks,
1349
01:12:08,445 --> 01:12:10,654
as did musical talent
1350
01:12:10,688 --> 01:12:13,208
or a family history of longevity.
1351
01:12:13,277 --> 01:12:16,177
Disease or disability...
1352
01:12:16,211 --> 01:12:19,974
even a lame grandmother
or an epileptic uncle...
1353
01:12:20,008 --> 01:12:21,216
was a demerit.
1354
01:12:21,285 --> 01:12:24,737
"While the stock judges
are testing the Holsteins,
1355
01:12:24,806 --> 01:12:27,635
Jerseys, and Whitefaces
in the stock pavilion,"
1356
01:12:27,636 --> 01:12:30,053
one contest organizer said,
1357
01:12:30,122 --> 01:12:34,954
"we are judging the Joneses,
Smiths, and the Johnsons."
1358
01:12:36,576 --> 01:12:38,130
Just as they would have a contest
1359
01:12:38,164 --> 01:12:40,615
who had bred the best cows,
1360
01:12:40,649 --> 01:12:42,548
who had bred the best sheep,
1361
01:12:42,617 --> 01:12:44,481
who had bred the best children.
1362
01:12:44,515 --> 01:12:46,689
And at the end of the state fair,
1363
01:12:46,690 --> 01:12:50,003
the eugenic winning family,
the fitter family,
1364
01:12:50,004 --> 01:12:51,902
would be driven down the midway
1365
01:12:51,937 --> 01:12:56,527
and wave to the people
and show off their ribbons.
1366
01:12:56,562 --> 01:13:01,912
By the 1920s,
eugenics was a household word.
1367
01:13:01,981 --> 01:13:03,534
A generation of people grows up
1368
01:13:03,569 --> 01:13:05,329
thinking of this word
1369
01:13:05,364 --> 01:13:09,333
as a aspiration, healthy babies,
1370
01:13:09,368 --> 01:13:10,887
and as a warning.
1371
01:13:10,921 --> 01:13:15,236
They've read it in school,
they've heard it at church,
1372
01:13:15,270 --> 01:13:18,170
it has become part of the consciousness
1373
01:13:18,204 --> 01:13:20,068
of the country.
1374
01:13:23,900 --> 01:13:26,868
So pervasive was
the impulse to human improvement,
1375
01:13:26,903 --> 01:13:30,871
even prominent African Americans
took up the theme.
1376
01:13:30,872 --> 01:13:33,563
W.E.B. Du Bois,
1377
01:13:33,564 --> 01:13:35,876
one of the founders
of the National Association
1378
01:13:35,877 --> 01:13:38,568
for the Advancement of Colored People,
1379
01:13:38,569 --> 01:13:41,020
maintained that the "best"
of the black race...
1380
01:13:41,055 --> 01:13:44,196
what he called "the Talented Tenth"...
1381
01:13:44,230 --> 01:13:46,129
was the hope for the future.
1382
01:13:46,198 --> 01:13:49,856
"The Negro," Du Bois declared,
1383
01:13:49,891 --> 01:13:52,273
"must begin to breed for brains,
1384
01:13:52,307 --> 01:13:55,379
for efficiency, for beauty."
1385
01:13:55,414 --> 01:14:01,592
Du Bois' ideas are
fundamentally about combating prejudice,
1386
01:14:01,627 --> 01:14:03,767
but at the same time,
1387
01:14:03,801 --> 01:14:06,563
he talked about and embraced the notion
1388
01:14:06,597 --> 01:14:11,154
that not all blacks were equally gifted
1389
01:14:11,223 --> 01:14:13,294
and equally talented,
1390
01:14:13,328 --> 01:14:16,814
and that the future of African Americans
1391
01:14:16,883 --> 01:14:18,263
should hinge
1392
01:14:18,264 --> 01:14:20,922
on the future procreation of the talented.
1393
01:14:22,579 --> 01:14:29,447
Those ideas really are resonant
with eugenic ideals of the time.
1394
01:14:29,448 --> 01:14:34,004
Eugenics became
a really powerful ideology,
1395
01:14:34,073 --> 01:14:36,937
because it made sense
to a lot of different groups
1396
01:14:36,938 --> 01:14:39,976
who were concerned about disparate things.
1397
01:14:40,010 --> 01:14:45,636
Part of the draw is how science
can make us better human beings,
1398
01:14:45,671 --> 01:14:47,190
that we can engineer ourselves
1399
01:14:47,259 --> 01:14:48,812
into being even better than we are.
1400
01:14:48,846 --> 01:14:52,643
And viewing that as a source of progress.
1401
01:14:57,062 --> 01:14:59,960
The eugenics
movement of the early 20th century
1402
01:14:59,961 --> 01:15:03,171
got traction
because the slogans were simple,
1403
01:15:03,206 --> 01:15:07,382
things like, "Better babies
and happy families."
1404
01:15:07,451 --> 01:15:08,866
On the face of it,
1405
01:15:08,901 --> 01:15:11,007
you know, better babies, healthier babies,
1406
01:15:11,041 --> 01:15:12,180
what's not to like?
1407
01:15:12,215 --> 01:15:16,495
It would have taken considerable effort
1408
01:15:16,529 --> 01:15:18,635
to demonstrate to people
1409
01:15:18,669 --> 01:15:22,294
what that simple slogan
was actually hiding.
1410
01:15:28,679 --> 01:15:31,199
In September 1924,
1411
01:15:31,234 --> 01:15:35,307
at the Virginia Colony for
the Epileptic and Feebleminded,
1412
01:15:35,341 --> 01:15:38,896
the colony's board of directors
met to discuss the case
1413
01:15:38,965 --> 01:15:41,692
of patient 1692,
1414
01:15:41,727 --> 01:15:45,662
a 17-year-old named Carrie Buck.
1415
01:15:45,696 --> 01:15:49,010
She'd been admitted to the
colony several months before,
1416
01:15:49,045 --> 01:15:51,529
at the request of her foster parents,
1417
01:15:51,530 --> 01:15:53,014
who claimed that they could no longer
1418
01:15:53,049 --> 01:15:55,051
"control or care for her."
1419
01:15:58,261 --> 01:16:01,849
Carrie Buck had
been raised by a foster family,
1420
01:16:01,850 --> 01:16:03,093
not a nice family.
1421
01:16:03,128 --> 01:16:06,338
She is rented out to other
people in the community
1422
01:16:06,372 --> 01:16:08,167
to do house cleaning,
1423
01:16:08,202 --> 01:16:11,031
and she's pulled out of school
after fifth grade,
1424
01:16:11,032 --> 01:16:12,516
even though she's doing very well
1425
01:16:12,551 --> 01:16:15,105
and is a perfectly good student.
1426
01:16:15,174 --> 01:16:19,730
Then, a nephew
of her foster mother rapes her,
1427
01:16:19,765 --> 01:16:24,528
and she gets pregnant,
and they want to get rid of her.
1428
01:16:24,563 --> 01:16:26,461
By the time her daughter was born,
1429
01:16:26,530 --> 01:16:29,706
the state had labeled Buck
"morally delinquent"
1430
01:16:29,740 --> 01:16:32,295
for having given birth out of wedlock,
1431
01:16:32,364 --> 01:16:35,021
diagnosed her a "middle-grade moron,"
1432
01:16:35,056 --> 01:16:37,610
and confined her to the colony.
1433
01:16:37,645 --> 01:16:42,098
Sexual delinquent, sexually immoral.
1434
01:16:42,132 --> 01:16:45,135
These terms are intentionally vague.
1435
01:16:45,170 --> 01:16:49,657
Immoral tendency could be that a
woman had been sexually abused.
1436
01:16:49,726 --> 01:16:52,246
It could mean
she was going out late at night.
1437
01:16:52,280 --> 01:16:55,490
It could mean she's a prostitute.
1438
01:16:55,559 --> 01:16:56,836
If you're morally deficient,
1439
01:16:56,905 --> 01:16:59,253
that's evidence
that you're mentally deficient
1440
01:16:59,287 --> 01:17:00,288
and vice versa.
1441
01:17:00,323 --> 01:17:03,774
So the state needs to intervene.
1442
01:17:05,811 --> 01:17:09,089
The question before
the Colony's board of directors now
1443
01:17:09,090 --> 01:17:13,300
was whether or not
to sterilize Carrie Buck.
1444
01:17:13,301 --> 01:17:16,615
She lands at the Colony
for Epileptics and Feebleminded
1445
01:17:16,649 --> 01:17:21,758
right when Virginia has passed
a eugenic sterilization law,
1446
01:17:21,792 --> 01:17:24,692
and the lawyer for the state hospitals
1447
01:17:24,761 --> 01:17:28,420
really wants there to be a test
before sterilizations occur.
1448
01:17:28,454 --> 01:17:32,044
So the superintendent of the Colony
1449
01:17:32,113 --> 01:17:34,598
basically needs an inmate that he can say,
1450
01:17:34,633 --> 01:17:36,289
"I'm going to sterilize you,"
1451
01:17:36,290 --> 01:17:38,602
have that person challenge the law,
1452
01:17:38,637 --> 01:17:41,295
and then hopefully prevail against her.
1453
01:17:41,329 --> 01:17:42,951
So he's looking for someone,
1454
01:17:42,986 --> 01:17:47,715
and Carrie Buck checks a lot of boxes.
1455
01:17:47,784 --> 01:17:49,372
From the board's perspective,
1456
01:17:49,441 --> 01:17:52,168
the menace posed
by Buck's own feeblemindedness
1457
01:17:52,202 --> 01:17:54,791
was doubled by her lineage.
1458
01:17:54,825 --> 01:17:58,001
Her mother, who was alleged
to have engaged in prostitution,
1459
01:17:58,035 --> 01:18:01,694
was likewise an inmate at the Colony.
1460
01:18:01,729 --> 01:18:06,008
"By the laws of heredity,"
the board concluded,
1461
01:18:06,009 --> 01:18:08,356
"Carrie Buck is
the probable potential parent
1462
01:18:08,391 --> 01:18:11,496
of socially inadequate
offspring."
1463
01:18:11,497 --> 01:18:14,327
It was recommended she be sterilized
1464
01:18:14,328 --> 01:18:18,366
for both her own welfare
and the good of society.
1465
01:18:19,816 --> 01:18:23,302
Then Buck was assigned an attorney,
1466
01:18:23,337 --> 01:18:25,580
friendly to the eugenic cause,
1467
01:18:25,649 --> 01:18:27,893
who would appeal her sterilization...
1468
01:18:27,962 --> 01:18:29,722
ideally, all the way
1469
01:18:29,757 --> 01:18:34,002
to the Supreme Court of the United States.
1470
01:18:34,037 --> 01:18:37,903
Across the country,
eugenicists would be watching...
1471
01:18:37,972 --> 01:18:40,354
to see if the Virginia test case
1472
01:18:40,388 --> 01:18:42,527
could create a national consensus
1473
01:18:42,528 --> 01:18:45,221
on sterilization.
1474
01:18:47,361 --> 01:18:52,055
Sterilization was a radical procedure.
1475
01:18:52,089 --> 01:18:55,783
Between 1915 and the mid-1920s,
1476
01:18:55,852 --> 01:18:59,235
you have a dozen or more states
that pass laws
1477
01:18:59,269 --> 01:19:02,030
that allowed for mandatory sterilization
1478
01:19:02,065 --> 01:19:04,999
of people in institutions.
1479
01:19:05,033 --> 01:19:08,036
Some of them were used actively.
1480
01:19:08,071 --> 01:19:09,210
Many of them were just on the books,
1481
01:19:09,245 --> 01:19:11,074
but nobody was being operated on.
1482
01:19:11,108 --> 01:19:13,076
Some of them had been struck down
1483
01:19:13,110 --> 01:19:14,802
by state courts.
1484
01:19:14,871 --> 01:19:16,597
So it wasn't at all clear
1485
01:19:16,631 --> 01:19:20,808
what was going to happen
to eugenic sterilization.
1486
01:19:20,877 --> 01:19:23,017
There was a hope among eugenicists,
1487
01:19:23,051 --> 01:19:24,467
"If we could just get a case
1488
01:19:24,536 --> 01:19:26,814
"that goes up to the Supreme Court,
1489
01:19:26,883 --> 01:19:28,918
"one ruling from the Supreme Court,
1490
01:19:28,919 --> 01:19:31,715
"and suddenly we've got
a national legal standard
1491
01:19:31,750 --> 01:19:34,234
that eugenic sterilization
is acceptable."
1492
01:19:34,235 --> 01:19:36,236
So that became high on the wish list
1493
01:19:36,237 --> 01:19:38,170
of the eugenics movement.
1494
01:19:38,239 --> 01:19:42,450
No one was more
interested in the Virginia test case
1495
01:19:42,485 --> 01:19:44,280
than Harry Laughlin,
1496
01:19:44,314 --> 01:19:46,592
who had spent much of the previous decade
1497
01:19:46,627 --> 01:19:48,075
promoting sterilization
1498
01:19:48,076 --> 01:19:50,976
as a cheap, effective way
1499
01:19:51,010 --> 01:19:53,116
to rid the nation of what he called
1500
01:19:53,150 --> 01:19:56,292
"the socially inadequate
classes."
1501
01:19:56,326 --> 01:19:59,778
Harry Laughlin believes
that to really move the needle
1502
01:19:59,812 --> 01:20:03,090
on the national genetic pool
and really improve things,
1503
01:20:03,091 --> 01:20:06,267
sterilization was the answer.
1504
01:20:06,302 --> 01:20:08,924
Eugenical
sterilization was Laughlin's life work.
1505
01:20:08,925 --> 01:20:11,859
He published a book in 1922,
1506
01:20:11,928 --> 01:20:14,447
a compendium of every law
that had been passed,
1507
01:20:14,448 --> 01:20:16,622
of every case that had been brought,
1508
01:20:16,657 --> 01:20:18,140
excruciating detail
1509
01:20:18,141 --> 01:20:20,833
about the history
of eugenical sterilization.
1510
01:20:20,902 --> 01:20:22,800
And it became the bible
1511
01:20:22,801 --> 01:20:26,011
for people who wanted
to pass sterilization laws.
1512
01:20:28,358 --> 01:20:29,808
It was only a matter of time
1513
01:20:29,842 --> 01:20:32,982
before Laughlin was asked
to serve as an expert witness
1514
01:20:32,983 --> 01:20:35,123
in the case against Carrie Buck...
1515
01:20:35,158 --> 01:20:39,714
and though he was unable
to appear in person,
1516
01:20:39,783 --> 01:20:42,821
he was more than happy to help.
1517
01:20:42,855 --> 01:20:45,651
Laughlin never met Carrie Buck.
1518
01:20:45,686 --> 01:20:48,723
Laughlin never traveled
to Virginia to see her.
1519
01:20:48,792 --> 01:20:50,656
His testimony was read into the record
1520
01:20:50,691 --> 01:20:51,968
of the Carrie Buck case
1521
01:20:52,002 --> 01:20:55,315
as a deposition.
1522
01:20:55,316 --> 01:20:57,732
The Buck family, Laughlin argued,
1523
01:20:57,801 --> 01:21:00,045
was "mentally defective"...
1524
01:21:00,114 --> 01:21:01,909
members of what he described
1525
01:21:01,978 --> 01:21:05,188
as the "shiftless, ignorant,
and worthless class
1526
01:21:05,222 --> 01:21:08,812
of anti-social whites
of the South."
1527
01:21:08,847 --> 01:21:11,574
As such, Carrie was certainly likely
1528
01:21:11,643 --> 01:21:14,404
to give birth to defective children.
1529
01:21:14,473 --> 01:21:16,889
No doubt, with her infant daughter Vivian,
1530
01:21:16,958 --> 01:21:19,028
she already had.
1531
01:21:19,029 --> 01:21:23,517
Laughlin's testimony proved persuasive.
1532
01:21:23,551 --> 01:21:27,348
As the eugenicists hoped,
first the county judge,
1533
01:21:27,383 --> 01:21:29,177
then the state supreme court
1534
01:21:29,212 --> 01:21:32,698
upheld Virginia's sterilization law.
1535
01:21:34,217 --> 01:21:37,357
The next... and final... ruling
would come
1536
01:21:37,358 --> 01:21:42,190
from the Supreme Court
of the United States.
1537
01:21:42,225 --> 01:21:43,537
Poor Carrie Buck,
1538
01:21:43,571 --> 01:21:46,194
there's no weaker person perhaps
1539
01:21:46,229 --> 01:21:48,438
who's ever come before the Supreme Court.
1540
01:21:48,507 --> 01:21:52,373
She is poor, and she is alone,
1541
01:21:52,408 --> 01:21:54,375
and her mother is an inmate,
1542
01:21:54,410 --> 01:21:56,929
and she has a lawyer that's been
chosen by her enemies
1543
01:21:56,998 --> 01:21:58,414
to not represent her.
1544
01:21:58,448 --> 01:22:03,591
And she's asking the font
of justice in our society,
1545
01:22:03,626 --> 01:22:06,870
"Don't let them forcibly operate on me
1546
01:22:06,905 --> 01:22:09,425
so I can't have children."
1547
01:22:09,459 --> 01:22:12,842
And they say,
"Go ahead, sterilize her."
1548
01:22:14,084 --> 01:22:16,224
In May 1927
1549
01:22:16,259 --> 01:22:18,813
the court's majority opinion was rendered
1550
01:22:18,882 --> 01:22:22,058
by the venerable Oliver Wendell Holmes,
1551
01:22:22,092 --> 01:22:24,578
who, at 86, was widely regarded
1552
01:22:24,612 --> 01:22:27,995
as America's most brilliant legal mind.
1553
01:22:28,064 --> 01:22:31,101
"It is better for all the world,"
1554
01:22:31,136 --> 01:22:33,931
Holmes wrote, "if instead of waiting
1555
01:22:33,932 --> 01:22:37,106
"to execute degenerate offspring
for crime,
1556
01:22:37,107 --> 01:22:39,972
"or to let them starve
for their imbecility,
1557
01:22:40,007 --> 01:22:44,079
"society can prevent those
who are manifestly unfit
1558
01:22:44,080 --> 01:22:46,254
"from continuing their kind.
1559
01:22:46,289 --> 01:22:51,156
Three generations of imbeciles
are enough."
1560
01:22:53,296 --> 01:22:55,229
Justice Holmes says,
1561
01:22:55,263 --> 01:22:57,162
"If she is allowed to reproduce,
1562
01:22:57,196 --> 01:22:59,336
"or if the Carrie Bucks
of the world in general
1563
01:22:59,405 --> 01:23:01,028
"are allowed to reproduce,
1564
01:23:01,097 --> 01:23:04,134
"this will be deleterious
to American society.
1565
01:23:06,620 --> 01:23:09,450
"And so therefore the government
has the authority
1566
01:23:09,485 --> 01:23:13,971
"to step in and, in pursuit
of the greater public good,
1567
01:23:13,972 --> 01:23:18,114
to suppress her individual right
to reproduce."
1568
01:23:22,670 --> 01:23:27,848
Carrie Buck was
sterilized on October 19, 1927.
1569
01:23:27,882 --> 01:23:30,713
Less than a month afterward,
1570
01:23:30,782 --> 01:23:33,025
she was paroled from the Colony.
1571
01:23:34,820 --> 01:23:39,066
Thanks to Carrie Buck,
a jubilant Laughlin declared,
1572
01:23:39,135 --> 01:23:43,035
eugenical sterilization's
"experimental period,"
1573
01:23:43,104 --> 01:23:46,418
had come to an end.
1574
01:23:46,487 --> 01:23:49,973
Over the two decades that
preceded the Carrie Buck case,
1575
01:23:50,008 --> 01:23:55,392
only about 6,000 sterilizations
had been performed nationwide.
1576
01:23:55,461 --> 01:23:57,463
In the six years that followed it,
1577
01:23:57,498 --> 01:23:59,362
as states across the country
1578
01:23:59,396 --> 01:24:02,745
rushed to enact sterilization laws,
1579
01:24:02,814 --> 01:24:06,886
that number would more than double.
1580
01:24:06,887 --> 01:24:09,821
If you look back
at all the sterilization laws passed,
1581
01:24:09,855 --> 01:24:14,550
the easiest way to sum up
who their targets were is,
1582
01:24:14,584 --> 01:24:17,104
"Round up the usual suspects."
1583
01:24:17,173 --> 01:24:19,002
You are generally going to be dealing
1584
01:24:19,037 --> 01:24:20,590
with poor people,
1585
01:24:20,659 --> 01:24:23,386
people who are part
of a disfavored minority,
1586
01:24:23,420 --> 01:24:27,010
people who were on private charity
1587
01:24:27,045 --> 01:24:29,841
or public welfare,
1588
01:24:29,875 --> 01:24:32,015
people who had disabilities,
1589
01:24:32,050 --> 01:24:33,430
mental or physical,
1590
01:24:33,499 --> 01:24:35,535
and people who were generally considered
1591
01:24:35,536 --> 01:24:38,574
somehow on the margins of society.
1592
01:24:57,282 --> 01:24:59,248
The conceit of eugenics
1593
01:24:59,249 --> 01:25:04,910
was that scientists understood
what traits were associated
1594
01:25:04,945 --> 01:25:09,777
with health and well-being
over the long term.
1595
01:25:09,812 --> 01:25:13,229
But hereditary science
in the early 20th century
1596
01:25:13,263 --> 01:25:15,127
was still emerging.
1597
01:25:15,162 --> 01:25:19,545
Eugenics led the public discussion,
1598
01:25:19,580 --> 01:25:22,790
promoted the science of human heredity
1599
01:25:22,825 --> 01:25:25,930
in a time when hereditarian scientists
1600
01:25:25,931 --> 01:25:27,726
were themselves developing their craft.
1601
01:25:27,761 --> 01:25:29,452
And I think for a period of time
they saw this
1602
01:25:29,486 --> 01:25:31,661
as a positive development,
1603
01:25:31,730 --> 01:25:34,595
society taking interest
1604
01:25:34,630 --> 01:25:38,460
in the kind of science
that they were doing.
1605
01:25:38,461 --> 01:25:42,085
And then I think by the '20s
there's a problem.
1606
01:25:46,020 --> 01:25:48,678
It was the fall of 1926,
1607
01:25:48,747 --> 01:25:51,992
and geneticist
Hermann J. Muller,
1608
01:25:52,026 --> 01:25:54,995
a former Columbia University Fly Boy,
1609
01:25:55,029 --> 01:25:58,930
was looking for ways
to speed his experiment along.
1610
01:26:00,863 --> 01:26:03,278
He was still working with flies,
1611
01:26:03,279 --> 01:26:04,349
though now on his own,
1612
01:26:04,383 --> 01:26:07,662
at the University of Texas in Austin.
1613
01:26:07,663 --> 01:26:10,942
So far, he'd been using
the technique he'd learned
1614
01:26:10,976 --> 01:26:13,876
in the Fly Room from Thomas Hunt Morgan:
1615
01:26:13,945 --> 01:26:16,810
hunt for naturally arising mutations,
1616
01:26:16,844 --> 01:26:20,467
then track across them across generations.
1617
01:26:20,468 --> 01:26:22,022
Breed a generation,
1618
01:26:22,056 --> 01:26:25,888
peer at its members one by one
through a jeweler's loupe,
1619
01:26:25,957 --> 01:26:28,131
repeat.
1620
01:26:28,166 --> 01:26:30,755
But at this point,
Muller had lost patience.
1621
01:26:32,964 --> 01:26:34,862
It took an enormous amount of time
1622
01:26:34,897 --> 01:26:36,726
to generate these mutants.
1623
01:26:36,795 --> 01:26:38,831
You had to wait
until you basically found one.
1624
01:26:38,832 --> 01:26:40,247
It was a process of, of discovery.
1625
01:26:40,316 --> 01:26:45,183
So Muller began to wonder whether he could
1626
01:26:45,217 --> 01:26:49,325
actually create mutants
de novo, from scratch,
1627
01:26:49,359 --> 01:26:53,673
by doing something to the genes.
1628
01:26:53,674 --> 01:26:55,883
One night, on a whim,
1629
01:26:55,918 --> 01:26:58,058
Muller switched on the x-ray machine
1630
01:26:58,092 --> 01:27:01,164
and began irradiating male fruit flies.
1631
01:27:01,199 --> 01:27:04,581
Once they'd been exposed,
he slid them into glass bottles
1632
01:27:04,616 --> 01:27:08,688
with a roughly equal number
of female flies.
1633
01:27:08,689 --> 01:27:11,209
Then he waited.
1634
01:27:11,243 --> 01:27:14,867
When the larvae began to appear
on day five,
1635
01:27:14,868 --> 01:27:18,250
it was clear the whim had worked.
1636
01:27:18,319 --> 01:27:20,873
Muller,
1637
01:27:20,874 --> 01:27:23,186
by using the exact right dosage of x-rays,
1638
01:27:23,221 --> 01:27:25,119
finds that he can make dozens
of mutations,
1639
01:27:25,188 --> 01:27:29,123
mutations that would have
taken months or years to find.
1640
01:27:29,192 --> 01:27:31,608
He becomes a mutant maker.
1641
01:27:31,677 --> 01:27:34,577
He can't do it in a predictable way.
1642
01:27:34,611 --> 01:27:38,512
But the principle that human gene material
1643
01:27:38,546 --> 01:27:39,892
was malleable,
1644
01:27:39,893 --> 01:27:41,618
was changeable,
1645
01:27:41,653 --> 01:27:46,588
is an idea that Muller
understands and embraces.
1646
01:27:46,589 --> 01:27:48,729
If an insect's genes could be altered
1647
01:27:48,764 --> 01:27:51,767
by a blast of radiation, Muller realized,
1648
01:27:51,801 --> 01:27:56,806
human genes one day might be
manipulated as well...
1649
01:27:56,841 --> 01:28:00,499
and heredity would no longer be
the prerogative, he said,
1650
01:28:00,568 --> 01:28:05,263
of "an unreachable god
playing pranks on us."
1651
01:28:05,297 --> 01:28:09,888
The idea of controlling human heredity
1652
01:28:09,923 --> 01:28:12,373
had captivated Muller
since his earliest days
1653
01:28:12,408 --> 01:28:14,859
in Morgan's lab.
1654
01:28:14,928 --> 01:28:17,378
He'd been aware of the flaws
in so-called "eugenic science"
1655
01:28:17,413 --> 01:28:20,588
for nearly as long,
1656
01:28:20,623 --> 01:28:23,419
and his doubts about
the American eugenics movement
1657
01:28:23,453 --> 01:28:27,526
had been steadily mounting.
1658
01:28:27,595 --> 01:28:30,426
Muller began to think
1659
01:28:30,460 --> 01:28:33,084
that you couldn't have a eugenics movement
1660
01:28:33,118 --> 01:28:36,293
without asking questions about equality.
1661
01:28:36,294 --> 01:28:38,503
What was the criteria
for judging, you know,
1662
01:28:38,537 --> 01:28:40,539
a better human being
than a worse human being
1663
01:28:40,608 --> 01:28:43,163
and thereby sterilizing
the, the worst human being
1664
01:28:43,197 --> 01:28:44,820
or selectively breeding
the better human being?
1665
01:28:44,854 --> 01:28:48,616
Who would ensure
1666
01:28:48,651 --> 01:28:54,036
that the eugenics movement
was selecting the best features,
1667
01:28:54,070 --> 01:28:57,452
when the, when the best features
were dictated by the elites?
1668
01:29:03,666 --> 01:29:05,944
Concerns about the eugenics movement
1669
01:29:05,979 --> 01:29:07,496
had been raised before...
1670
01:29:07,497 --> 01:29:10,224
but they'd come mainly from lone voices,
1671
01:29:10,293 --> 01:29:12,951
shouting into the wind.
1672
01:29:12,986 --> 01:29:14,677
Now, increasingly,
1673
01:29:14,711 --> 01:29:18,267
hereditary scientists began
to speak as one.
1674
01:29:21,408 --> 01:29:23,928
More and more, scientists are realizing
1675
01:29:23,997 --> 01:29:27,966
that heredity's not something
that you can understand
1676
01:29:28,001 --> 01:29:32,176
simply like Mendel understood
his pea plants,
1677
01:29:32,177 --> 01:29:35,422
that some human traits are really complex,
1678
01:29:35,491 --> 01:29:37,803
and you can't predict
whether they're going to appear,
1679
01:29:37,838 --> 01:29:39,426
or reappear,
1680
01:29:39,495 --> 01:29:43,085
that some conditions
that we think of as hereditary
1681
01:29:43,154 --> 01:29:45,535
are really about social issues.
1682
01:29:45,570 --> 01:29:51,024
Nobody really discards the idea
that heredity is important,
1683
01:29:51,058 --> 01:29:52,749
but there is growing chorus
1684
01:29:52,784 --> 01:29:57,099
of scientists who are being more careful
1685
01:29:57,168 --> 01:29:59,135
in the way that they talk about heredity.
1686
01:30:00,861 --> 01:30:03,726
Even the father of the intelligence test,
1687
01:30:03,760 --> 01:30:05,038
Henry Goddard...
1688
01:30:05,072 --> 01:30:06,867
who had done so much to stoke fears
1689
01:30:06,902 --> 01:30:09,697
of hereditary feeblemindedness...
1690
01:30:09,732 --> 01:30:12,769
disavowed his earlier conclusions.
1691
01:30:12,804 --> 01:30:17,843
In particular, he regretted
having coined the term "moron."
1692
01:30:17,878 --> 01:30:20,397
With proper education, he now believed,
1693
01:30:20,398 --> 01:30:22,572
such individuals were perfectly capable
1694
01:30:22,607 --> 01:30:25,092
of managing their own affairs.
1695
01:30:25,127 --> 01:30:28,026
Eugenic scientists were doing
1696
01:30:28,061 --> 01:30:30,579
what they understood to be
reliable science,
1697
01:30:30,580 --> 01:30:32,720
and it turned out that, in many cases,
1698
01:30:32,755 --> 01:30:34,412
their science was mistaken.
1699
01:30:34,446 --> 01:30:36,655
Science is a process.
1700
01:30:36,724 --> 01:30:40,797
People make claims,
they advance evidence for it.
1701
01:30:40,866 --> 01:30:42,765
And then others come along
1702
01:30:42,799 --> 01:30:45,699
who have a more sophisticated
understanding
1703
01:30:45,733 --> 01:30:48,563
of the methodological problems.
1704
01:30:48,564 --> 01:30:49,875
And they say,
1705
01:30:49,910 --> 01:30:52,085
"Hey, prostitution may result
1706
01:30:52,119 --> 01:30:56,089
from a woman's having
no other choice economically,"
1707
01:30:56,123 --> 01:30:58,435
or, "Alcoholism may arise
1708
01:30:58,436 --> 01:31:02,958
from all sorts of stresses
in one's life."
1709
01:31:02,992 --> 01:31:06,926
You don't need genetics at all
to explain these things.
1710
01:31:09,585 --> 01:31:12,588
As the 1920s came to a close,
1711
01:31:12,622 --> 01:31:15,108
and the Great Depression
radically rearranged
1712
01:31:15,142 --> 01:31:17,800
American society,
1713
01:31:17,834 --> 01:31:19,802
the dogma of the eugenics movement
1714
01:31:19,836 --> 01:31:22,184
rang ever more hollow.
1715
01:31:22,253 --> 01:31:25,289
25% of the country's unemployed.
1716
01:31:25,290 --> 01:31:27,499
People's life savings have been wiped out
1717
01:31:27,534 --> 01:31:28,638
by both the stock market crash
1718
01:31:28,673 --> 01:31:30,916
and the bank failures.
1719
01:31:30,951 --> 01:31:34,299
The person who's now on the bread line
1720
01:31:34,334 --> 01:31:36,853
might have been a lawyer
who graduated from Harvard.
1721
01:31:36,888 --> 01:31:43,136
And this was a clear indication
that poverty was not biological.
1722
01:31:46,863 --> 01:31:48,865
When, in 1932,
1723
01:31:48,900 --> 01:31:52,386
yet another eugenics congress
convened in New York,
1724
01:31:52,455 --> 01:31:58,530
most in the scientific community
declined to attend.
1725
01:31:58,565 --> 01:32:00,394
They hold this conference
1726
01:32:00,463 --> 01:32:03,639
to propagate the idea of eugenics.
1727
01:32:03,673 --> 01:32:06,883
All the same guys are there...
1728
01:32:06,918 --> 01:32:09,748
Madison Grant, Charles Benedict Davenport,
1729
01:32:09,817 --> 01:32:13,166
Harry Laughlin...
espousing the same ideas.
1730
01:32:13,200 --> 01:32:15,822
Their ideas have not changed in 25 years,
1731
01:32:15,823 --> 01:32:18,516
and almost nobody comes.
1732
01:32:18,550 --> 01:32:20,483
Because among scientists,
1733
01:32:20,518 --> 01:32:23,209
eugenics is now viewed as the purview
1734
01:32:23,210 --> 01:32:29,009
of a bunch of old, white cranks
whom science has passed by.
1735
01:32:31,218 --> 01:32:35,395
Improbably, Hermann
Muller did turn up at the congress,
1736
01:32:35,429 --> 01:32:40,365
though only to deliver
a scathing ten-minute speech.
1737
01:32:40,400 --> 01:32:43,712
"There is no scientific basis
for the conclusion
1738
01:32:43,713 --> 01:32:45,543
"that the socially lower classes
1739
01:32:45,577 --> 01:32:48,270
have genetically inferior
intellectual equipment,"
1740
01:32:48,339 --> 01:32:49,409
he insisted.
1741
01:32:49,443 --> 01:32:52,826
"Certain slum districts of our cities
1742
01:32:52,860 --> 01:32:54,862
"are veritable factories
1743
01:32:54,897 --> 01:32:57,381
"for the production of criminality
1744
01:32:57,382 --> 01:33:00,247
"among those who happen to be
born in them.
1745
01:33:00,282 --> 01:33:03,526
"Under these circumstances, it is society,
1746
01:33:03,561 --> 01:33:04,941
"not the individual,
1747
01:33:05,010 --> 01:33:07,012
"which is the real criminal
1748
01:33:07,047 --> 01:33:10,567
and which stands to be judged."
1749
01:33:10,568 --> 01:33:14,227
The problem of eugenic
thinking was an utter ignorance
1750
01:33:14,261 --> 01:33:19,403
of social causes of social problems,
1751
01:33:19,404 --> 01:33:22,234
a tendency to over-biologize,
1752
01:33:22,235 --> 01:33:24,444
to think through the biological lens
1753
01:33:24,478 --> 01:33:26,549
about everything in society.
1754
01:33:26,584 --> 01:33:30,933
Eugenics might yet perfect the human race,
1755
01:33:30,967 --> 01:33:32,762
Muller told the audience,
1756
01:33:32,797 --> 01:33:35,938
but only in a society
"consciously organized
1757
01:33:35,972 --> 01:33:39,424
for the common good."
1758
01:33:49,434 --> 01:33:53,092
In July 1933, in Germany,
1759
01:33:53,093 --> 01:33:55,440
Adolf Hitler came to power...
1760
01:33:58,926 --> 01:34:02,619
...and immediately enshrined
eugenics in state policy,
1761
01:34:02,620 --> 01:34:05,243
with a law that mandated the sterilization
1762
01:34:05,278 --> 01:34:08,522
of men and women suffering from any one
1763
01:34:08,591 --> 01:34:11,111
of nine presumably heritable conditions.
1764
01:34:13,769 --> 01:34:18,014
It had been based on a model law
written by Harry Laughlin.
1765
01:34:20,534 --> 01:34:23,468
Before Hitler, there
was a German eugenics movement.
1766
01:34:23,503 --> 01:34:26,851
But it did not have a sterilization law.
1767
01:34:26,885 --> 01:34:30,165
The sterilization law was
ultimately enacted
1768
01:34:30,199 --> 01:34:33,685
with the inspiration of what
American states had been doing.
1769
01:34:39,864 --> 01:34:42,384
Harry Laughlin is corresponding
1770
01:34:42,453 --> 01:34:45,490
with German scientists all along
1771
01:34:45,525 --> 01:34:47,561
and encouraging them.
1772
01:34:47,630 --> 01:34:49,010
He's proud of the fact
1773
01:34:49,011 --> 01:34:52,221
that when the Nazis adopt
a eugenic sterilization law,
1774
01:34:52,290 --> 01:34:55,328
it's strongly modeled on his own law.
1775
01:34:55,362 --> 01:34:57,468
The United States has the reputation
1776
01:34:57,502 --> 01:35:00,195
of being on the forefront
of scientific endeavor.
1777
01:35:00,229 --> 01:35:04,337
When Adolf Hitler was in prison,
1778
01:35:04,371 --> 01:35:07,995
he read Madison Grant's
The Passing of the Great Race,
1779
01:35:08,030 --> 01:35:09,963
wrote Madison Grant a fan letter
1780
01:35:09,997 --> 01:35:13,379
saying, "This book is my bible,"
1781
01:35:13,380 --> 01:35:16,866
and when he wrote Mein Kampf,his autobiography, he said,
1782
01:35:16,901 --> 01:35:22,044
"We Germans must emulate
what the Americans are doing."
1783
01:35:22,078 --> 01:35:25,910
Nazi officials estimated
1784
01:35:25,944 --> 01:35:30,570
no fewer than 400,000 Germans
would be sterilized...
1785
01:35:30,604 --> 01:35:32,537
roughly 25 times
1786
01:35:32,572 --> 01:35:37,439
the number sterilized
in the United States so far.
1787
01:35:37,508 --> 01:35:39,751
The more zealous American eugenicists
1788
01:35:39,820 --> 01:35:41,718
applauded the Nazi law,
1789
01:35:41,719 --> 01:35:43,686
which applied to all people,
1790
01:35:43,721 --> 01:35:46,033
whether institutionalized or not.
1791
01:35:46,068 --> 01:35:50,245
As one Virginia
sterilization advocate put it,
1792
01:35:50,279 --> 01:35:53,178
"The Germans are beating us
at our own game."
1793
01:35:56,354 --> 01:35:58,736
But for many Americans,
the news from Germany
1794
01:35:58,770 --> 01:36:02,947
was accompanied
by an uncomfortable revelation.
1795
01:36:02,981 --> 01:36:05,260
"Many interviewed
about the Hitler proposal
1796
01:36:05,294 --> 01:36:08,608
expressed shock," the Daily N
1797
01:36:08,642 --> 01:36:10,265
"They were surprised to find out
1798
01:36:10,299 --> 01:36:12,888
"that 27 of our 48 American states
1799
01:36:12,922 --> 01:36:16,062
"have laws permitting the
performance of sterilization
1800
01:36:16,063 --> 01:36:18,203
upon the feebleminded."
1801
01:36:20,792 --> 01:36:26,833
The 1930s was
the peak of eugenic sterilization.
1802
01:36:26,902 --> 01:36:30,594
And that was after geneticists...
1803
01:36:30,595 --> 01:36:32,596
professional, scientific geneticists...
1804
01:36:32,597 --> 01:36:36,394
had largely abandoned the eugenic program.
1805
01:36:38,154 --> 01:36:42,158
There was this
trend that discredits the doctrine
1806
01:36:42,193 --> 01:36:44,437
on which eugenic sterilization is based.
1807
01:36:44,471 --> 01:36:47,336
At the same time, paradoxically,
1808
01:36:47,405 --> 01:36:49,613
sterilization rates shot up
1809
01:36:49,614 --> 01:36:51,788
in the United States,
1810
01:36:51,789 --> 01:36:54,688
because of the Depression.
1811
01:36:54,757 --> 01:36:58,934
It costs money to keep people
in homes for the feebleminded.
1812
01:36:58,968 --> 01:37:02,800
So if you want to reduce
the cost of keeping people,
1813
01:37:02,834 --> 01:37:04,939
you sterilize them,
1814
01:37:04,940 --> 01:37:08,599
and that's what happened.
1815
01:37:08,633 --> 01:37:10,946
I'd like to know
just what sterilization is.
1816
01:37:10,980 --> 01:37:12,016
So would I.
1817
01:37:12,085 --> 01:37:13,535
Just how do they do it?
1818
01:37:13,604 --> 01:37:14,674
Well, I'll tell you.
1819
01:37:17,055 --> 01:37:20,714
As public awareness
of eugenic sterilization spread,
1820
01:37:20,783 --> 01:37:24,166
a controversial Hollywood film
opened in theaters,
1821
01:37:24,200 --> 01:37:28,204
a cautionary tale about good intentions
1822
01:37:28,273 --> 01:37:29,653
gone dangerously wrong.
1823
01:37:29,654 --> 01:37:31,449
And do you mean they're going to stop me
1824
01:37:31,484 --> 01:37:33,037
from having children ever?
1825
01:37:33,106 --> 01:37:34,831
Exactly.
1826
01:37:34,832 --> 01:37:38,353
Released in 1934,
1827
01:37:38,387 --> 01:37:40,113
Tomorrow's Children told the story
1828
01:37:40,147 --> 01:37:42,633
of 17-year-old Alice Mason,
1829
01:37:42,667 --> 01:37:44,013
the sole functional member
1830
01:37:44,048 --> 01:37:49,502
of an otherwise drunken,
crippled, feebleminded family,
1831
01:37:49,536 --> 01:37:50,882
who is slated for sterilization
1832
01:37:50,917 --> 01:37:52,331
along with her parents and siblings...
1833
01:37:52,332 --> 01:37:55,404
Three generations of unfit are enough.
1834
01:37:55,439 --> 01:37:59,063
...and saved from the scalpel
only by the revelation
1835
01:37:59,132 --> 01:38:00,582
that she'd been adopted.
1836
01:38:00,651 --> 01:38:01,859
Look at me.
1837
01:38:01,893 --> 01:38:04,309
Can't you see that I'm well and strong?
1838
01:38:04,344 --> 01:38:06,172
And I'll be a good mother too, judge,
1839
01:38:06,173 --> 01:38:07,623
honest I will.
1840
01:38:09,384 --> 01:38:11,247
Tomorrow's Children raises the question
1841
01:38:11,316 --> 01:38:13,697
of whether or not you always get it right
1842
01:38:13,698 --> 01:38:15,217
when you sterilize someone.
1843
01:38:15,251 --> 01:38:18,047
How much can you really know
about someone's background?
1844
01:38:18,082 --> 01:38:21,257
Without getting into the details
1845
01:38:21,292 --> 01:38:25,019
of "How much do we understand
about genetics in 1934?"
1846
01:38:25,020 --> 01:38:26,883
it simply says,
1847
01:38:26,884 --> 01:38:29,196
"Sometimes people make mistakes
with these things,
1848
01:38:29,231 --> 01:38:32,337
and so maybe
we should be more careful."
1849
01:38:34,857 --> 01:38:36,376
Tomorrow's Children was still playing
1850
01:38:36,411 --> 01:38:38,585
on screens across the country
1851
01:38:38,620 --> 01:38:41,069
when, in 1935,
1852
01:38:41,070 --> 01:38:44,004
a committee of scientists
turned up at Cold Spring Harbor.
1853
01:38:45,765 --> 01:38:48,802
They'd been sent
by the Carnegie Institution,
1854
01:38:48,871 --> 01:38:52,496
which had sponsored the Eugenics
Record Office since 1918
1855
01:38:52,565 --> 01:38:56,810
and had long been embarrassed
by its political activities.
1856
01:38:56,879 --> 01:38:58,916
Now, Carnegie's board of directors
1857
01:38:58,950 --> 01:39:03,264
had ordered a review
of the work being done there.
1858
01:39:03,265 --> 01:39:07,649
The visiting committee's report
was decidedly unfavorable:
1859
01:39:07,718 --> 01:39:10,548
from a scientific vantage, they concluded,
1860
01:39:10,583 --> 01:39:12,239
the thousands of heredity records
1861
01:39:12,274 --> 01:39:14,931
stored in the famed fireproof vault
1862
01:39:14,932 --> 01:39:17,210
were useless
for the study of human genetics.
1863
01:39:20,420 --> 01:39:23,768
They rightly saw
that this eugenics fieldwork
1864
01:39:23,803 --> 01:39:26,460
was largely ridiculous
and was not scientific.
1865
01:39:26,461 --> 01:39:29,118
But they also were troubled
by the degree to which
1866
01:39:29,153 --> 01:39:32,259
clearly Harry Laughlin
was acting not as a scientist
1867
01:39:32,294 --> 01:39:36,298
but as a evangelist for eugenics.
1868
01:39:36,332 --> 01:39:38,783
And this was a clear indication
1869
01:39:38,818 --> 01:39:41,165
that the tide was really turning
against eugenics.
1870
01:39:41,199 --> 01:39:46,826
For the movement's
faithful, the message was plain:
1871
01:39:46,860 --> 01:39:50,311
if they were going to continue
to cull the unfit,
1872
01:39:50,312 --> 01:39:54,143
they would need
a new justification for it.
1873
01:39:56,629 --> 01:39:58,907
Extra! Extra!
1874
01:40:03,049 --> 01:40:05,430
From the moment
the case of the "sterilized heiress"
1875
01:40:05,465 --> 01:40:09,538
first hit the news, in January 1936,
1876
01:40:09,607 --> 01:40:13,059
Americans were enthralled by it.
1877
01:40:13,128 --> 01:40:17,235
First, there was the girl,
Ann Cooper Hewitt...
1878
01:40:17,304 --> 01:40:20,791
a San Francisco socialite
who stood to inherit two-thirds
1879
01:40:20,825 --> 01:40:23,552
of her late father's vast estate...
1880
01:40:23,621 --> 01:40:24,829
and her shocking claim:
1881
01:40:24,864 --> 01:40:27,659
that her mother had had her sterilized
1882
01:40:27,660 --> 01:40:30,559
to gain control of that inheritance.
1883
01:40:30,628 --> 01:40:34,149
Ann Cooper Hewitt is sent to the hospital
1884
01:40:34,183 --> 01:40:36,703
for an emergency appendectomy,
1885
01:40:36,738 --> 01:40:39,533
and she comes out sterilized.
1886
01:40:39,534 --> 01:40:43,537
And when she discovers it,
she is understandably horrified,
1887
01:40:43,538 --> 01:40:49,370
and she sues both her mother
and the two surgeons.
1888
01:40:49,371 --> 01:40:51,855
She claims that her mother has done it
1889
01:40:51,856 --> 01:40:55,066
because her father's will stipulates
1890
01:40:55,101 --> 01:40:58,242
that if Ann should die childless,
1891
01:40:58,276 --> 01:41:01,141
the inheritance would go to her mother.
1892
01:41:03,765 --> 01:41:06,906
Equally intriguing
was the claim of the mother, Maryon,
1893
01:41:06,940 --> 01:41:10,012
that her daughter Ann was feebleminded...
1894
01:41:10,047 --> 01:41:13,222
a diagnosis based on an intelligence test
1895
01:41:13,257 --> 01:41:17,882
she'd been given just hours
before her sterilization.
1896
01:41:17,917 --> 01:41:20,713
Ann says that she's writhing in pain,
1897
01:41:20,747 --> 01:41:23,198
and then a woman walks in the room,
1898
01:41:23,232 --> 01:41:26,234
and the woman starts asking her
all these questions.
1899
01:41:26,235 --> 01:41:28,790
"What's the longest river
in the United States?"
1900
01:41:28,859 --> 01:41:32,794
And "How many years is
a presidential term?"
1901
01:41:32,863 --> 01:41:34,692
And Ann's reaction is,
1902
01:41:34,727 --> 01:41:37,902
"Why are you asking me
these asinine questions?
1903
01:41:37,937 --> 01:41:40,491
What does this have to do
with appendicitis?"
1904
01:41:40,560 --> 01:41:44,150
And she doesn't answer most
of the questions.
1905
01:41:44,219 --> 01:41:46,428
Although her score identified the girl
1906
01:41:46,462 --> 01:41:48,326
as a high-grade moron,
1907
01:41:48,395 --> 01:41:51,916
a court-appointed psychiatrist
at a preliminary hearing
1908
01:41:51,951 --> 01:41:55,919
found her to be well-read,
fluent in French and Italian,
1909
01:41:55,920 --> 01:41:59,614
and "perfectly normal
in every respect."
1910
01:41:59,648 --> 01:42:02,581
The Cooper Hewitt sterilization case
1911
01:42:02,582 --> 01:42:04,619
was one of those cases that people call
1912
01:42:04,653 --> 01:42:06,379
"the trial of the century."
1913
01:42:06,413 --> 01:42:09,415
Headlines all over the country.
1914
01:42:09,416 --> 01:42:10,486
And if you weren't paying attention
1915
01:42:10,555 --> 01:42:12,764
to what sterilization was by then,
1916
01:42:12,765 --> 01:42:15,456
you would have heard in that story.
1917
01:42:15,457 --> 01:42:20,358
Ann Cooper Hewitt is not emblematic
1918
01:42:20,427 --> 01:42:23,947
of the typical sterilization patient.
1919
01:42:23,948 --> 01:42:27,849
And for that very reason,
she gets a lot more attention.
1920
01:42:27,918 --> 01:42:30,955
By eugenic standards,
1921
01:42:30,990 --> 01:42:34,338
Ann was the very definition of well-born.
1922
01:42:34,372 --> 01:42:37,133
She was the scion of the successful:
1923
01:42:37,134 --> 01:42:41,794
white, wealthy, seemingly sound
in both body and mind.
1924
01:42:43,174 --> 01:42:44,451
On what grounds, then,
1925
01:42:44,486 --> 01:42:47,351
those following the case
may well have wondered,
1926
01:42:47,385 --> 01:42:52,458
could her sterilization possibly
be justified?
1927
01:42:52,459 --> 01:42:54,151
Attorney I.M. Golden,
1928
01:42:54,185 --> 01:42:57,499
who represented
the surgeons named in the suit,
1929
01:42:57,533 --> 01:42:59,846
wondered much the same...
1930
01:42:59,881 --> 01:43:03,298
and he decided to solicit
the opinion of an expert.
1931
01:43:03,332 --> 01:43:07,335
In May 1936, he composed a letter
1932
01:43:07,336 --> 01:43:09,994
to one of California's
leading eugenicists,
1933
01:43:10,029 --> 01:43:11,582
Paul Popenoe,
1934
01:43:11,651 --> 01:43:14,516
and laid out for him
the details of the case...
1935
01:43:14,550 --> 01:43:17,795
among them, the reasons
Maryon Cooper Hewitt had given
1936
01:43:17,830 --> 01:43:19,832
for wanting her daughter sterilized.
1937
01:43:23,318 --> 01:43:27,253
Maryon makes three
charges about her daughter's behavior
1938
01:43:27,322 --> 01:43:29,842
that she sees as indicative
1939
01:43:29,876 --> 01:43:33,811
of someone who is mentally defective.
1940
01:43:33,846 --> 01:43:36,020
The first is that she becomes infatuated
1941
01:43:36,055 --> 01:43:37,884
with a chauffeur.
1942
01:43:37,919 --> 01:43:40,887
The second is that she is infatuated
1943
01:43:40,922 --> 01:43:42,889
with men in uniform.
1944
01:43:42,924 --> 01:43:46,237
And then finally that she has plans
1945
01:43:46,272 --> 01:43:50,828
to run off with a Negro porter on a train.
1946
01:43:50,863 --> 01:43:54,245
These are not people that
probably Maryon believed
1947
01:43:54,280 --> 01:43:56,178
her daughter should be associating with.
1948
01:43:56,213 --> 01:43:59,147
Not somebody
she should have children with.
1949
01:44:02,288 --> 01:44:04,428
"In your opinion," Golden asked Popenoe,
1950
01:44:04,497 --> 01:44:06,602
"was it proper to sterilize her
1951
01:44:06,637 --> 01:44:11,538
as a matter of medical
and scientific procedure?"
1952
01:44:11,573 --> 01:44:13,575
Paul Popenoe long had been a proponent
1953
01:44:13,609 --> 01:44:16,405
of eugenic sterilization.
1954
01:44:16,440 --> 01:44:19,546
But the argument that
an immoral, oversexed girl
1955
01:44:19,581 --> 01:44:22,377
would pass on those traits genetically
1956
01:44:22,411 --> 01:44:25,897
could no longer plausibly be made.
1957
01:44:25,898 --> 01:44:29,246
So Popenoe offered another rationale,
1958
01:44:29,280 --> 01:44:31,213
one that had been recently formulated
1959
01:44:31,248 --> 01:44:36,080
and recommended by
the American Eugenics Society.
1960
01:44:36,115 --> 01:44:38,773
Heredity, Popenoe told Golden,
1961
01:44:38,807 --> 01:44:42,085
is "not particularly the issue
in this case.
1962
01:44:42,086 --> 01:44:44,433
"But I suppose
we should all answer negatively
1963
01:44:44,468 --> 01:44:48,161
"the question whether a
young woman such as you describe
1964
01:44:48,230 --> 01:44:52,269
would be a desirable mother."
1965
01:44:52,303 --> 01:44:53,960
In the '30s,
1966
01:44:53,995 --> 01:44:57,653
the eugenic rationale for sterilization
1967
01:44:57,688 --> 01:45:00,898
begins to morph into a kind of
more generalized understanding
1968
01:45:00,933 --> 01:45:03,038
that this person isn't fit to be a parent.
1969
01:45:03,107 --> 01:45:08,456
That turns the whole
argument about eugenics on its head,
1970
01:45:08,457 --> 01:45:10,458
because the determining question
1971
01:45:10,459 --> 01:45:13,117
was not, "Will she spread
her genetic defect?"
1972
01:45:13,152 --> 01:45:16,983
but "Will she make
a desirable mother?"
1973
01:45:20,538 --> 01:45:22,264
When the trial of the two surgeons
1974
01:45:22,299 --> 01:45:24,300
got underway in San Francisco,
1975
01:45:24,301 --> 01:45:27,338
Ann's questionable capacity to mother
1976
01:45:27,373 --> 01:45:29,306
was the centerpiece of the defense.
1977
01:45:29,340 --> 01:45:34,137
The girl's sexual behavior
alone, Golden argued,
1978
01:45:34,138 --> 01:45:35,864
cast grave doubt on her ability
1979
01:45:35,899 --> 01:45:39,040
to provide good moral
and intellectual training
1980
01:45:39,109 --> 01:45:42,526
to her offspring.
1981
01:45:42,595 --> 01:45:44,010
In the end,
1982
01:45:44,045 --> 01:45:46,806
the argument had little effect
on the judge,
1983
01:45:46,841 --> 01:45:50,120
who, after six days
of listening to testimony,
1984
01:45:50,154 --> 01:45:52,811
abruptly called a halt to the proceedings
1985
01:45:52,812 --> 01:45:55,228
and dismissed the case on the grounds
1986
01:45:55,297 --> 01:45:59,198
that sterilization was legal
in California.
1987
01:45:59,232 --> 01:46:02,477
But in the public mind,
1988
01:46:02,511 --> 01:46:06,860
sterilization had been effectively recast
1989
01:46:06,861 --> 01:46:11,348
as a preventative measure
against inept parenting.
1990
01:46:11,382 --> 01:46:15,179
This not a story
that happens in an institution.
1991
01:46:15,214 --> 01:46:17,492
It's a story about a socialite.
1992
01:46:17,526 --> 01:46:19,355
Nevertheless, the same themes
1993
01:46:19,356 --> 01:46:22,911
of needing to sterilize people
for their own good
1994
01:46:22,980 --> 01:46:25,086
come up.
1995
01:46:25,155 --> 01:46:27,019
"Forget about heredity.
1996
01:46:27,053 --> 01:46:29,228
"These people will be unable
to take care of their children,
1997
01:46:29,262 --> 01:46:32,438
so the humane thing to do
is not to let them have any."
1998
01:46:32,507 --> 01:46:37,581
Eugenics simply
becomes part of the machinery
1999
01:46:37,615 --> 01:46:40,964
of how these state institutions function.
2000
01:46:41,033 --> 01:46:44,518
Hereditary defect is no longer
part of the conversation,
2001
01:46:44,519 --> 01:46:45,969
and it's simply a question
2002
01:46:46,038 --> 01:46:49,558
of a state attempting to use
all the tools available
2003
01:46:49,593 --> 01:46:52,561
to limit the number of people
2004
01:46:52,596 --> 01:46:55,702
who were seen to be
a social and economic burden.
2005
01:46:55,737 --> 01:47:00,638
By the close of the 1930s,
2006
01:47:00,707 --> 01:47:04,780
more than 30,000 Americans
had been sterilized nationwide.
2007
01:47:13,651 --> 01:47:18,415
I think eugenics appeals
to some real strong elements
2008
01:47:18,449 --> 01:47:21,244
in the human psyche.
2009
01:47:21,245 --> 01:47:24,145
One part of that, the positive part,
2010
01:47:24,214 --> 01:47:26,595
is that there is a desire among people
2011
01:47:26,630 --> 01:47:30,254
to perfect things.
2012
01:47:30,289 --> 01:47:31,635
The negative side is,
2013
01:47:31,669 --> 01:47:36,087
we're also a species that is
very prone to tribalism.
2014
01:47:36,088 --> 01:47:38,469
We're very prone to believe
that, you know,
2015
01:47:38,504 --> 01:47:40,609
our people are the right people,
2016
01:47:40,644 --> 01:47:45,269
and other people are a threat.
2017
01:47:55,141 --> 01:47:58,764
For a time, the
enemies within American society
2018
01:47:58,765 --> 01:48:02,079
were eclipsed by those without,
2019
01:48:02,114 --> 01:48:03,460
and the nation's attention diverted
2020
01:48:03,494 --> 01:48:08,775
by a conflict that consumed
much of the world.
2021
01:48:10,467 --> 01:48:14,780
Then came the liberation
of Buchenwald and Dachau
2022
01:48:14,781 --> 01:48:17,473
and the chilling evidence
2023
01:48:17,474 --> 01:48:21,133
of eugenic policies carried
to a monstrous extreme.
2024
01:48:24,101 --> 01:48:25,516
By the mid-1940s
2025
01:48:25,551 --> 01:48:28,139
the full horror of what happens
in Nazi Germany
2026
01:48:28,140 --> 01:48:30,486
becomes apparent...
2027
01:48:30,487 --> 01:48:34,008
the movement from sterilization
to extermination,
2028
01:48:34,042 --> 01:48:36,907
the killing of several millions
2029
01:48:36,976 --> 01:48:40,323
based on this kind of idea
of the betterment of human race.
2030
01:48:40,324 --> 01:48:43,879
And it creates a vast embarrassment
2031
01:48:43,948 --> 01:48:47,400
for the American eugenics movement.
2032
01:48:47,469 --> 01:48:49,161
People were repelled
2033
01:48:49,195 --> 01:48:51,749
and began to turn away from eugenics,
2034
01:48:51,818 --> 01:48:55,960
and "eugenics" became a dirty word.
2035
01:48:59,378 --> 01:49:04,969
The Holocaust, being tied
to a wide range of eugenic practices,
2036
01:49:05,004 --> 01:49:10,423
is a blemish on humans as a species,
2037
01:49:10,492 --> 01:49:15,841
and it undercuts any notion that
eugenics was a positive force
2038
01:49:15,842 --> 01:49:17,430
in American society.
2039
01:49:17,499 --> 01:49:19,570
Surgical sterilization
2040
01:49:19,605 --> 01:49:21,745
was thought to be too slow
2041
01:49:21,779 --> 01:49:24,334
and too expensive to be used
on a mass scale.
2042
01:49:24,368 --> 01:49:27,888
After the war,
2043
01:49:27,889 --> 01:49:31,719
when the Allies put the Nazis
on trial at Nuremburg,
2044
01:49:31,720 --> 01:49:34,896
one of the charges
was eugenic sterilization,
2045
01:49:34,930 --> 01:49:38,106
and the lawyer
for the Nazi who was charged
2046
01:49:38,175 --> 01:49:40,728
said, you know,
"How can you charge my client
2047
01:49:40,729 --> 01:49:44,250
"with the crime of eugenic sterilization
2048
01:49:44,285 --> 01:49:48,082
when your own U.S. Supreme Court
said this was okay?"
2049
01:49:52,845 --> 01:49:55,779
By the end of the 1940s,
2050
01:49:55,848 --> 01:49:58,229
the eugenics movement had faded
2051
01:49:58,230 --> 01:50:01,750
from the mainstream of American life.
2052
01:50:01,785 --> 01:50:03,614
But the laws that had been passed
2053
01:50:03,649 --> 01:50:05,064
in the name of eugenics
2054
01:50:05,099 --> 01:50:08,584
would remain on the books for decades...
2055
01:50:08,585 --> 01:50:11,035
barring some people
from entering the country
2056
01:50:11,070 --> 01:50:13,659
and others from marriage
2057
01:50:13,728 --> 01:50:17,283
and subjecting thousands
to forced sterilization
2058
01:50:17,318 --> 01:50:19,043
at the hands of the state.
2059
01:50:20,942 --> 01:50:23,565
By the time such practices
finally came to an end,
2060
01:50:23,600 --> 01:50:25,464
in the 1970s,
2061
01:50:25,498 --> 01:50:28,604
the total number of sterilized Americans
2062
01:50:28,605 --> 01:50:32,609
would exceed 60,000.
2063
01:50:32,643 --> 01:50:36,854
And no matter the cost or the casualties,
2064
01:50:36,923 --> 01:50:39,615
the scientific betterment of humanity
2065
01:50:39,616 --> 01:50:42,066
would remain an irresistible aspiration...
2066
01:50:42,101 --> 01:50:46,312
tempting generations to come
2067
01:50:46,347 --> 01:50:51,455
with the promise of perfection.
2068
01:50:51,490 --> 01:50:54,009
We believe in science.
2069
01:50:54,044 --> 01:50:59,981
We want science to solve social problems,
2070
01:51:00,015 --> 01:51:02,708
and we want to make ourselves better.
2071
01:51:02,777 --> 01:51:06,332
I think everybody wants to do that.
2072
01:51:06,367 --> 01:51:11,544
There is this idea
2073
01:51:11,613 --> 01:51:13,512
that remains a kind of hope
2074
01:51:13,546 --> 01:51:15,651
that if we just get the science right,
2075
01:51:15,652 --> 01:51:21,140
if only the right people
are put in charge,
2076
01:51:21,175 --> 01:51:24,902
that we can engineer our way
to a better world.
2077
01:51:24,971 --> 01:51:29,838
Some of the greatest social changes
2078
01:51:29,873 --> 01:51:31,494
that have ever been accomplished
2079
01:51:31,495 --> 01:51:34,464
have occurred because
people were really willing
2080
01:51:34,498 --> 01:51:37,363
to imagine impossible things.
2081
01:51:37,398 --> 01:51:39,985
But the future that
American eugenicists imagined
2082
01:51:39,986 --> 01:51:45,336
was only a future for some.
2083
01:51:45,337 --> 01:51:48,409
And so now the debate is,
2084
01:51:48,478 --> 01:51:52,343
"Are we going to use technology
2085
01:51:52,344 --> 01:51:54,829
"to try to fulfill
Galton's dream, if you will,
2086
01:51:54,863 --> 01:51:56,417
of taking charge
of our own evolution?"
2087
01:51:56,486 --> 01:52:00,559
Of course it was a pipe dream,
2088
01:52:00,593 --> 01:52:05,840
but nevertheless
it is a dream that persists.
2089
01:52:05,874 --> 01:52:10,085
We have reason to be
apprehensive about this,
2090
01:52:10,154 --> 01:52:14,228
and the test tube bears watching.
154619
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.