Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:02,033 --> 00:00:04,000
Previously on The Practice.
2
00:00:04,066 --> 00:00:06,533
- I think we should take it.
- Sorry, Jimmy.
3
00:00:06,600 --> 00:00:09,200
- I think we should take it too.
- What? Why?
4
00:00:09,266 --> 00:00:11,866
Because 11 people
in a two-mile radius
got cancer.
5
00:00:11,933 --> 00:00:14,000
Dates scare me,
6
00:00:14,066 --> 00:00:17,400
especially
the first-kiss part.
7
00:00:17,466 --> 00:00:20,833
We both agreed,if either of us metsomebody who could--
8
00:00:20,900 --> 00:00:24,533
It doesn't bother you?
I'll make do
with the memories.
9
00:00:24,600 --> 00:00:28,400
Maybe we should celebrate
that we were able
to keep the secret,
10
00:00:28,466 --> 00:00:30,600
and it was some secret
while it lasted.
11
00:00:33,900 --> 00:00:36,033
[ Shower Running ]
It's a summary
judgment hearing.
12
00:00:36,100 --> 00:00:39,300
All you have to do is
show some dispute of fact.
13
00:00:39,366 --> 00:00:41,966
Jimmy,
it's 10:00 at night.
I'm tired.
14
00:00:42,033 --> 00:00:44,033
I'm gonna take a shower
and go to bed.
15
00:00:44,100 --> 00:00:46,600
I'll call you
in the morning, okay? Bye.
16
00:00:49,066 --> 00:00:51,166
Oh, great.
17
00:00:55,266 --> 00:00:57,200
- Sorry.
- Oh, it's okay.
18
00:00:57,266 --> 00:00:59,333
Gave me more time
to lather.
19
00:01:11,933 --> 00:01:14,466
[ Moaning ]
20
00:01:22,966 --> 00:01:24,933
[ Grunts, Groans ]
21
00:01:25,000 --> 00:01:26,966
[ Chuckles ]
Are you okay?
22
00:01:27,033 --> 00:01:29,733
Yeah. Don't you hate it
when that happens?
23
00:01:29,800 --> 00:01:32,333
Mmm. Mmm.
24
00:01:34,133 --> 00:01:38,000
[ Panting ]
25
00:01:38,066 --> 00:01:40,200
Oh. Bobby, turn it off.
Huh?
26
00:01:40,266 --> 00:01:43,500
The shower. The shower.
Oh.
27
00:01:43,566 --> 00:01:46,200
Okay. Okay.
28
00:01:49,000 --> 00:01:50,966
[ Phone Rings ]
Oh.
29
00:01:51,033 --> 00:01:53,466
Uh, don't, uh--uh, get that.
30
00:01:53,533 --> 00:01:55,366
Uh, hello.
31
00:01:56,600 --> 00:01:59,366
You gotta be kidding me.
32
00:01:59,433 --> 00:02:01,366
Cowley?
33
00:02:01,433 --> 00:02:04,433
This is for
the Isikoff warrant, right?
34
00:02:04,500 --> 00:02:06,800
Well--
35
00:02:06,866 --> 00:02:10,000
Well, I think he still
passes Aguilar on the facts.
36
00:02:10,066 --> 00:02:12,233
You don't have to
put that in the proffer.
37
00:02:12,300 --> 00:02:15,233
All right.
Let me know.
38
00:02:17,766 --> 00:02:20,100
Problem?
A big search warrant.
39
00:02:20,166 --> 00:02:25,333
Our informant has suddenly
revealed he was Abraham Lincoln
in a past life.
40
00:02:25,400 --> 00:02:28,000
You think we need
to disclose that
to the magistrate?
41
00:02:29,333 --> 00:02:32,800
Well, let's-- let's
get out our criminal...
42
00:02:32,866 --> 00:02:36,066
procedure... books.
43
00:02:39,500 --> 00:02:41,333
Let's review.
44
00:02:54,966 --> 00:02:56,533
[ Line Ringing ]
45
00:03:03,866 --> 00:03:05,333
[ Cell Door Opens, Closes ]
46
00:03:11,233 --> 00:03:15,766
[ Sirens Wailing ]
47
00:03:31,158 --> 00:03:33,524
[ Thunder Rumbling ]
48
00:03:54,791 --> 00:03:58,324
What's the emergency?
Our big dealer in Jamaica
Plain. Is his name Isikoff?
49
00:03:58,391 --> 00:04:00,991
Bobby, you said
I wouldn't have to do--
This isn't about that.
50
00:04:01,058 --> 00:04:03,724
I just want to know,
is his name Isikoff?
John Isikoff. Yeah. Why?
51
00:04:03,791 --> 00:04:06,824
We took his retainer?
Took his retainer? We pay
our rent with the interest.
52
00:04:06,891 --> 00:04:08,991
So we still do
represent him?
Somewhat.
53
00:04:09,058 --> 00:04:10,891
Oh, no.
What?
54
00:04:10,958 --> 00:04:13,024
He's about to get raided.
He is? But who--
55
00:04:13,091 --> 00:04:15,591
Helen got a call last night.
Trouble with an informant.
56
00:04:15,658 --> 00:04:18,858
It was a warrant
for Isikoff.
You were at Helen's?
57
00:04:18,924 --> 00:04:21,291
Maybe
it was another Isikoff.
A different one.
58
00:04:21,358 --> 00:04:23,024
Bobby, "Isikoff"
isn't very common.
59
00:04:23,091 --> 00:04:25,658
We just happen
to represent one who's
a major cartel player.
60
00:04:25,724 --> 00:04:27,958
The D.A. just happens
to have one scheduled
for a raid.
61
00:04:28,024 --> 00:04:31,124
I would make a wild guess
that it's the same guy.
[ Sighs ]
62
00:04:31,191 --> 00:04:33,058
So what do we do?
63
00:04:33,124 --> 00:04:35,691
- We let him know.
- Yeah, but I got
the information by--
64
00:04:35,758 --> 00:04:37,658
It doesn't matter how
you got it, Bobby.
65
00:04:37,724 --> 00:04:41,191
You got knowledge that a client
is about to get raided.
We can't not tell him.
66
00:04:41,258 --> 00:04:44,291
I don't believe this.
67
00:04:44,358 --> 00:04:46,358
You'd better notify
this guy fast too.
68
00:04:46,424 --> 00:04:49,924
If this is goin'
to the magistrate today,
the raid won't be far behind.
69
00:04:52,224 --> 00:04:54,324
Basically,
it's a legal motion.
70
00:04:54,391 --> 00:04:57,524
They're claiming,
as a matter of law,
we can't win.
71
00:04:57,591 --> 00:04:59,658
So they're asking
the judge to kick it.
72
00:04:59,724 --> 00:05:01,624
But you expect us
to get by it.
73
00:05:01,691 --> 00:05:05,058
Well, we expect to because
the benefit of the doubt
goes to the plaintiff.
74
00:05:05,124 --> 00:05:06,624
- But--
- But what?
75
00:05:06,691 --> 00:05:10,291
But Judge Walsh is famousfor trying to keepthe docket down.
76
00:05:10,358 --> 00:05:14,158
He practically
crusades against,
well, dubious claims.
77
00:05:14,224 --> 00:05:18,224
And us getting cancer?
We shouldn't waste
the court's time?
78
00:05:18,291 --> 00:05:23,824
It's not that.
It's the connection between
cancer and power lines.
79
00:05:23,891 --> 00:05:26,824
Isn't that what a trial is for?
To prove our case?
80
00:05:26,891 --> 00:05:29,924
The truth is, judges are
becoming more inclined to
toss out cases they don't like,
81
00:05:29,991 --> 00:05:32,558
and this judge
in particular--
82
00:05:32,624 --> 00:05:35,091
[ Jimmy ]We expect to survive this.
83
00:05:35,158 --> 00:05:37,791
But it's no lock.
84
00:05:51,258 --> 00:05:53,091
[ Horn Honks ]
85
00:06:00,324 --> 00:06:03,791
What's the matter?
You know a guy
named Cowley?
86
00:06:03,858 --> 00:06:07,391
Jackie Cowley. Why?
The D.A.'s gone in
to get a warrant.
87
00:06:07,458 --> 00:06:09,924
You're about to get hit,
maybe any second.
88
00:06:09,991 --> 00:06:13,791
What are you talking about?
As we speak, you're
about to get raided.
89
00:06:20,158 --> 00:06:22,691
Helen.
Hey.
90
00:06:22,758 --> 00:06:25,158
So, Bobby was over
last night, huh?
He told you?
91
00:06:25,224 --> 00:06:27,758
Well, not really.
It kind of slipped out.
How'd it go?
92
00:06:27,824 --> 00:06:30,358
You mean,
how far did it go?
Yeah. How far?
93
00:06:30,424 --> 00:06:34,524
Well, all I'll say is,
anything further would be
uncharted territory for me.
94
00:06:34,591 --> 00:06:36,658
Really?
I mean, for you--
Don't even go there.
95
00:06:36,724 --> 00:06:38,724
So he-- I mean--
It was good?
96
00:06:38,791 --> 00:06:40,758
It was huge.
Yeah. I don't know
what happened.
97
00:06:40,824 --> 00:06:43,324
But for a guy who was
so stuck in neutral--
98
00:06:43,391 --> 00:06:46,291
Maybe he went out
and hired a surrogate
to get himself unstuck.
99
00:06:46,358 --> 00:06:48,724
[ Laughing ]
100
00:06:49,791 --> 00:06:51,558
Huh.
101
00:06:53,258 --> 00:06:57,058
- You think you could have been
any more discouraging?
- Sorry?
102
00:06:57,124 --> 00:07:00,591
I'm trying to prop
these people up, give them
somethin' to hope for a little.
103
00:07:00,658 --> 00:07:03,458
- Why?
- Why?
104
00:07:03,524 --> 00:07:07,491
Yeah. Why? This case
is a Hail Mary, Jimmy.
They gotta know that.
105
00:07:07,558 --> 00:07:10,624
You go into somethin'
thinking you're gonna lose,
you usually lose.
106
00:07:10,691 --> 00:07:12,758
That's my experience.
107
00:07:12,824 --> 00:07:15,158
I want that judge
to look out there
and see people...
108
00:07:15,224 --> 00:07:17,724
who feel they have
a right to be sitting
in that courtroom,
109
00:07:17,791 --> 00:07:20,924
not people apologizing
for taking up his time.
110
00:07:20,991 --> 00:07:23,091
I understand that, Jimmy.
I do.
111
00:07:23,158 --> 00:07:26,491
But the best way to accomplish
that is by telling your clients
exactly that.
112
00:07:26,558 --> 00:07:30,091
- Don't mislead them.
- If you don't wanna be with me,
you don't gotta be with me.
113
00:07:30,158 --> 00:07:32,624
Okay. Fine.
114
00:07:32,691 --> 00:07:36,691
- So, does that mean
you're with me or not?
- Yes, Jimmy, I am with you.
115
00:07:36,758 --> 00:07:39,458
Bobby? Bobby,
come look at this!
116
00:07:39,524 --> 00:07:41,491
What?
Just hurry!
117
00:07:41,558 --> 00:07:44,391
[ Man On TV ] Janet,
what can you tell us about
what's happening down there?
118
00:07:44,458 --> 00:07:48,924
At this point, three officers
have been confirmed dead,
as well as two suspects.
119
00:07:48,991 --> 00:07:52,391
A third man, identified as
Jack Cowley, was also killed,
120
00:07:52,458 --> 00:07:55,924
but police think this wasan execution-style hit.
121
00:07:55,991 --> 00:07:58,091
He was found
inside a body bag.
122
00:07:58,158 --> 00:08:02,091
The two wounded suspects were
taken to Saint Elizabeth
in critical condition.
123
00:08:02,158 --> 00:08:04,958
Any reports on what caused
the shoot-out, Janet?
124
00:08:05,024 --> 00:08:08,158
Well, it seems
it started off
as a routine drug raid,
125
00:08:08,224 --> 00:08:10,791
but police believethe suspectswere tipped off.
126
00:08:10,858 --> 00:08:15,291
They were waiting with guns,
packing up, trying to get out,
when the police arrived,
127
00:08:15,358 --> 00:08:18,158
and they had a lot morefirepower than the police.
128
00:08:18,224 --> 00:08:21,191
It was a gruesomebloodbath here, Tom.
129
00:08:23,658 --> 00:08:26,558
I'm Mr. Isikoff's
attorney.
Nobody goes inside.
130
00:08:26,624 --> 00:08:30,091
Well, I'm sure my client
wants to see his lawyer.
Why don't you go ask him?
131
00:08:30,158 --> 00:08:32,991
Bobby?
Hey. Mike.
132
00:08:33,058 --> 00:08:35,758
Um, I'm sorry to hear
about your men.
133
00:08:35,824 --> 00:08:39,058
Yeah.
I should see him.
134
00:08:40,491 --> 00:08:42,624
Let him in.
135
00:08:44,058 --> 00:08:47,658
[ Machinery Beeping,Hissing ]
136
00:08:56,958 --> 00:08:59,624
I told them that you're
represented by counsel.
137
00:08:59,691 --> 00:09:01,624
They've been instructed
not to ask you anything.
138
00:09:01,691 --> 00:09:03,591
But three cops are dead,
139
00:09:03,658 --> 00:09:08,024
so I'm not expecting
your constitutional rights
to have top priority.
140
00:09:08,091 --> 00:09:12,391
John, I may stick a man in here.
We'll see how it goes.
141
00:09:12,458 --> 00:09:16,191
For now, you just--
just concentrate
on getting stronger.
142
00:09:28,324 --> 00:09:30,058
This man's your client?
143
00:09:32,091 --> 00:09:33,991
Yeah.
144
00:09:41,758 --> 00:09:44,158
[ Woman On P.A. ]
Dr. Ramirez, Ward 318.
145
00:09:48,558 --> 00:09:50,691
[ Elevator Bell Dings ]
146
00:09:50,758 --> 00:09:52,824
[ Elevator Doors Closing ]
147
00:09:58,758 --> 00:10:01,924
Are you okay?
No.
148
00:10:01,991 --> 00:10:03,824
What's goin' on?
149
00:10:05,591 --> 00:10:08,058
I think I know
the source of the tip.
150
00:10:10,158 --> 00:10:12,124
Bobby Donnell.
151
00:10:12,191 --> 00:10:14,058
How would he have known?
152
00:10:15,424 --> 00:10:17,524
I think I told him.
153
00:10:20,424 --> 00:10:23,158
A review of the depositions
and interrogatories reveals...
154
00:10:23,224 --> 00:10:25,924
there are simply no facts
to support the claim...
155
00:10:25,991 --> 00:10:28,824
that electric and magnetic
fields cause cancer.
156
00:10:28,891 --> 00:10:31,691
Your Honor,
the complaint states
paragraph after paragraph...
157
00:10:31,758 --> 00:10:34,224
of factual facts
which support the claim.
158
00:10:34,291 --> 00:10:39,258
At trial, we intend to
offer evidence in support
of these... factual facts.
159
00:10:39,324 --> 00:10:42,991
Well, we could allege
the alignment of the stars
as a possible defense,
160
00:10:43,058 --> 00:10:46,024
and I suppose that, too,
would be a factual fact
in dispute.
161
00:10:46,091 --> 00:10:48,424
I don't think you
have to get like that.
162
00:10:48,491 --> 00:10:50,691
Actually, Mr. Berluti,
I'm afraid I do.
163
00:10:50,758 --> 00:10:54,524
And this brings me to
the portion of today's argument
that I don't find pleasant--
164
00:10:54,591 --> 00:10:57,124
our Rule 11 motion.
165
00:10:57,191 --> 00:10:59,591
You really intend
to argue that, counsel?
166
00:10:59,658 --> 00:11:01,524
I do so reluctantly,
Your Honor.
167
00:11:01,591 --> 00:11:04,758
It is certainly not my habit
to seek sanctions
against other attorneys,
168
00:11:04,824 --> 00:11:08,324
but I think
this is a particularly
egregious situation.
169
00:11:08,391 --> 00:11:11,558
Can we at least finish with
the summary judgment arguments
before the personal attacks?
170
00:11:11,624 --> 00:11:15,924
No, the attack is not personal
in spirit, and it is certainly
relevant to today's hearing.
171
00:11:15,991 --> 00:11:18,524
Our position is basically
that they have no case...
172
00:11:18,591 --> 00:11:23,458
and it's no coincidence
that this is the attorney
claiming that they do.
173
00:11:23,524 --> 00:11:25,791
With your permission,
Your Honor?
174
00:11:32,624 --> 00:11:35,424
Do you know me?
You shouldn't.
No reason to.
175
00:11:35,491 --> 00:11:39,791
I'm just a down-in-the-trenches
lawyer who does cases that'll
never be in the newspapers.
176
00:11:39,858 --> 00:11:42,624
Unexciting stuff, except
to the people involved...
177
00:11:42,691 --> 00:11:44,691
'cause their injuries
are real...
178
00:11:44,758 --> 00:11:46,724
and the money I get
for them is real.
179
00:11:46,791 --> 00:11:48,624
Somebody bang
into your car lately?
180
00:11:48,691 --> 00:11:51,091
Has a ladderfallen on your head?You step into a pothole?
181
00:11:51,158 --> 00:11:53,724
Go to a big firm.
See how much they care.
182
00:11:53,791 --> 00:11:57,458
Then come to me.
Think nobody will
fight for you?
183
00:11:57,524 --> 00:12:00,024
You're just a grunt.
I'm a grunt.
184
00:12:00,091 --> 00:12:03,891
There's a lawyer
out there for you.
It's me.
185
00:12:03,958 --> 00:12:07,558
Just dial the number:
555-GRNT.
186
00:12:07,624 --> 00:12:11,524
And ask for Jimmy.
I'll get you money.
187
00:12:12,691 --> 00:12:14,924
Well, I think
this advertisement
makes the point.
188
00:12:14,991 --> 00:12:18,658
"Jimmy the Grunt"
is a lawyer who will
push forward with anything.
189
00:12:18,724 --> 00:12:20,958
This is an attorney who,
as our documents will show,
190
00:12:21,024 --> 00:12:25,091
falsified bank records
in order to secure funds
for his firm.
191
00:12:25,158 --> 00:12:27,124
That's stealing.
192
00:12:27,191 --> 00:12:30,758
This is an attorney
who was very recently arrested
for soliciting a prostitute.
193
00:12:30,824 --> 00:12:33,591
This is an attorney
who demeans our profession.
194
00:12:33,658 --> 00:12:38,391
And he continues to do so today
by prosecuting a claim
he knows he can't make.
195
00:12:38,458 --> 00:12:40,424
You don't know
what I can or can't make.
196
00:12:40,491 --> 00:12:44,391
I know that you are pandering
to cancer victims, and I
find that very unfortunate.
197
00:12:44,458 --> 00:12:47,724
What's unfortunate is
this cheap ambush, Your Honor,
which isn't relevant to any--
198
00:12:47,791 --> 00:12:50,191
It's relevantto a Rule 11 motion--
199
00:12:50,258 --> 00:12:52,458
whether or not an attorney
is acting in good faith--
200
00:12:52,524 --> 00:12:54,458
and your firm
historically does not.
201
00:12:54,524 --> 00:12:57,924
Mr. Berluti solicits
clients on television.
That's how he got these clients.
202
00:12:57,991 --> 00:13:02,224
That's how he got this case--
one which no other attorney
of reputation would accept.
203
00:13:02,291 --> 00:13:04,491
So, I put before the court,
204
00:13:04,558 --> 00:13:07,858
the civil action before you
is commensurate with
the attorney bringing it.
205
00:13:07,924 --> 00:13:11,458
And I must say
that in 27 years of practice,
206
00:13:11,524 --> 00:13:15,358
this is the first argument
of this nature
I have ever had to make.
207
00:13:15,424 --> 00:13:17,991
Mr. Berluti?
208
00:13:21,524 --> 00:13:24,791
Mr. Berluti,
do you have a response?
209
00:13:24,858 --> 00:13:27,891
Oh, Your Honor,
if you please, I'd...
210
00:13:28,891 --> 00:13:33,491
like a recess
so I can respond to...
211
00:13:33,558 --> 00:13:35,658
these things.
212
00:13:36,658 --> 00:13:38,624
10:00 tomorrow.
Adjourned.
213
00:13:38,691 --> 00:13:40,791
[ Gavel Raps ]
214
00:13:42,091 --> 00:13:44,191
What'd she say?
215
00:13:44,258 --> 00:13:46,158
Nothing.
216
00:13:47,258 --> 00:13:49,158
What could she say?
217
00:13:50,391 --> 00:13:52,824
What could I say?
I--
218
00:13:52,891 --> 00:13:54,824
I just left.
219
00:13:54,891 --> 00:13:58,324
[ Lindsay ]Bobby, this was a flukeof circumstances.
220
00:13:58,391 --> 00:14:00,058
You both have to
realize this.
221
00:14:01,458 --> 00:14:03,924
Five people are dead.
222
00:14:07,524 --> 00:14:09,558
You want me down
at the hospital?
223
00:14:09,624 --> 00:14:11,724
I don't know.
I don't trust them to--
224
00:14:11,791 --> 00:14:14,791
You know, sometimes
when cops get shot-- Oh.
225
00:14:16,624 --> 00:14:19,124
I don't know.
226
00:14:19,191 --> 00:14:21,691
Maybe.
[ Door Opens ]
227
00:14:21,758 --> 00:14:23,958
- Robert Donnell?
- Yeah.
228
00:14:24,024 --> 00:14:26,224
- Please put your handsbehind your back, sir.- What? Why?
229
00:14:26,291 --> 00:14:28,558
Please, sir.
[ Eugene ]What's the charge here?
230
00:14:28,624 --> 00:14:30,091
Reckless homicide.
Homicide?
231
00:14:30,158 --> 00:14:33,024
You have the right to remain--
Give me a break.
I know my rights.
232
00:14:33,091 --> 00:14:35,924
I'll surrender him to you!
Get your hands off me!
What are you doin'?
233
00:14:35,991 --> 00:14:38,058
Get off of him!
234
00:14:38,124 --> 00:14:41,224
Hey! Whoa, whoa!
Get your hands off me!
235
00:14:41,291 --> 00:14:45,124
You stay the hell back!
I said,
get your hands off me!
236
00:14:45,191 --> 00:14:47,091
Get him out of here!
237
00:14:50,191 --> 00:14:52,191
[ Ellenor ]
Jimmy, you have got
to calm down.
238
00:14:52,258 --> 00:14:55,024
Calm down? I'm just glad
my father's dead.
You know that?
239
00:14:55,091 --> 00:14:57,891
So what got said in there
never gets back to him.
I'm just glad--
240
00:14:57,958 --> 00:15:00,724
I want to kill him.
I thought you said
he was already dead.
241
00:15:00,791 --> 00:15:03,791
Not my father.
I want to kill West.
I'm not a violent person.
242
00:15:03,858 --> 00:15:06,691
I wanted to drive
over him with my car.
Would you listen to me?
243
00:15:06,758 --> 00:15:09,158
You have to
keep your head and just
talk about the case.
244
00:15:09,224 --> 00:15:11,191
What about what
he said about me,
about us?
245
00:15:11,258 --> 00:15:13,458
Just cover it quickly
and get back to the case.
246
00:15:13,524 --> 00:15:15,691
The clients heard all that.
Why should they
trust whatever--
247
00:15:15,758 --> 00:15:19,191
The clients are gonna be happy
if we just win the motion.
Jimmy, look at me.
248
00:15:19,258 --> 00:15:22,058
You cannot go back in there
and ramble, for God's sake.
You have--
249
00:15:22,124 --> 00:15:25,724
Just try not to
sweat so much.
Oh, thank you.
250
00:15:25,791 --> 00:15:28,458
Look, you keep your head
and you talk about the case.
251
00:15:28,524 --> 00:15:31,791
Summary judgment
favors the plaintiff,
so just address the claim.
252
00:15:31,858 --> 00:15:36,658
You have to argue that there's
sufficient facts to sustain the
cause of action and that's all.
253
00:15:36,724 --> 00:15:39,458
I want to kill him.
Well, you can
kill him later.
254
00:15:43,558 --> 00:15:46,791
They'll be arraigning you
in about an hour. We shouldn't
have to worry about bail.
255
00:15:46,858 --> 00:15:50,024
Who's the D.A.?
I'm not sure.
256
00:15:50,091 --> 00:15:52,391
Look, they can't make
any of this stick.
257
00:15:52,458 --> 00:15:56,658
- Three cops are dead, and they
want you to have a lousy day.
- [ Door Closes ]
258
00:15:56,724 --> 00:15:59,458
Eugene?
Could I have a second?
259
00:16:04,624 --> 00:16:06,624
He is represented
by counsel.
260
00:16:06,691 --> 00:16:08,924
Thank you.
I'll keep that in mind.
261
00:16:09,891 --> 00:16:13,558
[ Cell Door Sliding Shut ]
262
00:16:13,624 --> 00:16:15,591
[ Lock Clicking ]
263
00:16:15,658 --> 00:16:18,991
Is this you to me,
or D.A. to suspect?
264
00:16:19,058 --> 00:16:21,524
That's a funny question
for you to be asking.
265
00:16:23,624 --> 00:16:25,191
It's you and me, Bobby.
266
00:16:26,991 --> 00:16:30,058
Firstly, I'm sorry.
You have to know that.
267
00:16:30,124 --> 00:16:35,124
You got information as a result
of our personal relationship.
268
00:16:35,191 --> 00:16:39,158
You used that information
to put police officers at risk.
269
00:16:40,458 --> 00:16:42,491
And police officers
were killed.
270
00:16:42,558 --> 00:16:46,091
Saying you're sorry--
It didn't matter how I got
the information, Helen.
271
00:16:46,158 --> 00:16:49,891
Once I got it, it would
have been unethical for me
not to tell the client.
272
00:16:50,891 --> 00:16:52,924
You were doing
the ethical thing?
273
00:16:54,791 --> 00:16:58,824
Telling drug dealers--
men with assault weapons--
274
00:16:58,891 --> 00:17:01,524
Telling them
that the police officers
were on their way.
275
00:17:01,591 --> 00:17:03,591
That was
the ethical thing to do?
276
00:17:03,658 --> 00:17:06,224
Put yourself
in my position.
277
00:17:06,291 --> 00:17:09,158
For the last two hours,
I've been trying to do that.
278
00:17:17,691 --> 00:17:20,658
Then I guess we have nothing
left to talk about, do we?
279
00:17:23,258 --> 00:17:25,158
I guess we don't.
280
00:17:26,691 --> 00:17:30,491
41842,Commonwealth
versus Robert Donnell,
281
00:17:30,558 --> 00:17:32,658
reckless homicide.
282
00:17:32,724 --> 00:17:35,158
Eugene Young representingthe defendant, Your Honor.
283
00:17:35,224 --> 00:17:38,891
We'll waive reading
and ask that you dismiss these
ridiculous charges right now.
284
00:17:38,958 --> 00:17:41,991
Asher Silvermanfor the People,Your Honor.
285
00:17:42,058 --> 00:17:46,624
The commonwealth takes
these "ridiculous charges"
very seriously.
286
00:17:46,691 --> 00:17:50,191
Three police officers
are dead as a result of
this man's recklessness.
287
00:17:50,258 --> 00:17:52,558
This man is an attorney
who has a legal obligation
to inform his clients--
288
00:17:52,624 --> 00:17:55,224
There is never any legal
obligation to set up law
enforcement for an ambush.
289
00:17:55,291 --> 00:17:57,724
that they were about to
become the object of a raid.
290
00:17:57,791 --> 00:18:00,058
I don't listen when
everybody talks, gentlemen.
291
00:18:01,391 --> 00:18:03,991
Your Honor,
may I take a second to
confer with my client?
292
00:18:04,058 --> 00:18:06,624
Take two.
293
00:18:11,324 --> 00:18:14,358
It's decision time.
Obviously, they're playin'
for keeps.
294
00:18:14,424 --> 00:18:17,858
They brought in Silverman.
We don't want a jury to get
a crack at this, Bobby.
295
00:18:17,924 --> 00:18:20,624
Three of the good guys
were killed.
296
00:18:20,691 --> 00:18:23,024
Probable cause hearing?
And we put on
a full defense.
297
00:18:23,091 --> 00:18:26,258
We're better off
with a judge than a jury.
298
00:18:26,324 --> 00:18:28,224
What do we know about her?
299
00:18:28,291 --> 00:18:30,958
[ Eugene ]
Wacko out of the robe,
stickler in it.
300
00:18:31,024 --> 00:18:32,924
Which is what we want.
301
00:18:35,958 --> 00:18:37,791
Okay.
302
00:18:39,858 --> 00:18:44,791
- Your Honor, defense moves
for a probable cause hearing.
- 10:00 tomorrow.
303
00:18:44,858 --> 00:18:47,024
The Commonwealth would be
seeking bail, Your Honor,
in that--
304
00:18:47,091 --> 00:18:48,891
Nope.
I'll grant O.R.
305
00:18:48,958 --> 00:18:51,158
Three police officers
are dead.
306
00:18:52,424 --> 00:18:54,491
Let's not turn that
into a jingle.
307
00:18:54,558 --> 00:18:57,391
Personal recognizance,10:00 tomorrow.
308
00:18:57,458 --> 00:19:00,191
I like to start on time.
309
00:19:00,258 --> 00:19:02,058
[ Gavel Raps ]
310
00:19:04,324 --> 00:19:07,091
You really can't
take it personally, Helen.
You know you can't.
311
00:19:07,158 --> 00:19:08,958
You don't think that--
312
00:19:12,558 --> 00:19:16,091
Lindsay, we were making love
on the bathroom floor
when that call came in.
313
00:19:16,158 --> 00:19:17,791
Bobby? In a bathroom?
314
00:19:17,858 --> 00:19:19,824
That's not really the issue.
315
00:19:19,891 --> 00:19:24,558
I know. But a bathroom.
It just seems a little exotic
for him-- from what you tell me.
316
00:19:24,624 --> 00:19:26,891
Well, you know him
more than I.
317
00:19:26,958 --> 00:19:29,524
I know he felt
an obligation
to the client.
318
00:19:29,591 --> 00:19:31,291
He's an honest person,
right?
319
00:19:31,358 --> 00:19:34,924
Bobby? Of course.
He's-- He's honest.
320
00:19:36,158 --> 00:19:38,391
- Why do you say it like that?
- Like what?
321
00:19:38,458 --> 00:19:40,724
- With your voice
flittering a little, like--
- I'm not flittering.
322
00:19:40,791 --> 00:19:42,791
You are.
I'm not.
323
00:19:44,024 --> 00:19:46,424
Is there something
you're not telling me?
324
00:19:46,491 --> 00:19:48,524
What? What would I
not be telling you?
325
00:19:50,191 --> 00:19:53,791
- Flitter.
- I'm not flittering.
Damn it.
326
00:19:56,491 --> 00:19:58,224
What do you mean
you want to tell her?
327
00:19:58,291 --> 00:20:01,824
I know the timing of this
couldn't be worse, but she's
one of my best friends.
328
00:20:01,891 --> 00:20:03,891
I can't lie to her.I just can't.
329
00:20:03,958 --> 00:20:07,058
Let me just recap things
to see if I understand
things correctly.
330
00:20:07,124 --> 00:20:09,924
While you and I
were being recreational,
331
00:20:09,991 --> 00:20:12,458
Helen asked you
if there was anything
going on between us,
332
00:20:12,524 --> 00:20:15,391
and you said no
because you sensed that she
was interested in me...
333
00:20:15,458 --> 00:20:19,291
and if she knew about
you and me, this would
be a-- a deterrent...
334
00:20:19,358 --> 00:20:21,191
to Helen and me
ever getting together.
335
00:20:21,258 --> 00:20:23,724
Correct.
336
00:20:23,791 --> 00:20:26,024
Then Helen and I
did get together,
337
00:20:26,091 --> 00:20:29,558
and you and I stopped
being recreational.
338
00:20:29,624 --> 00:20:31,924
And you said there was
no reason to tell her...
339
00:20:31,991 --> 00:20:35,191
because the past was the past,
and it-- it really
didn't affect her.
340
00:20:35,258 --> 00:20:37,658
Correct.
341
00:20:37,724 --> 00:20:40,324
So, what now has changed?
342
00:20:40,391 --> 00:20:42,924
What's changed is this is
a little bit of a crisis here,
343
00:20:42,991 --> 00:20:46,091
and I feel like a liar
by not telling her.
344
00:20:46,158 --> 00:20:48,524
Okay. Here's the thing.
345
00:20:51,024 --> 00:20:53,024
I really like her.
346
00:20:53,091 --> 00:20:57,124
At this moment, she's
not particularly liking me.
347
00:20:57,191 --> 00:20:59,124
She thinks I betrayed her.
348
00:20:59,191 --> 00:21:02,224
If she were now to learn
that I have been sleeping
with her best friend,
349
00:21:02,291 --> 00:21:06,058
I'm afraid
it could be detrimental
to our progress as a couple.
350
00:21:06,124 --> 00:21:08,624
Yes. But--
351
00:21:08,691 --> 00:21:10,958
Lindsay, I agree at some point
maybe we should tell her.
352
00:21:11,024 --> 00:21:13,158
But could you please allow me
to put a little distance...
353
00:21:13,224 --> 00:21:15,624
between me and these
multiple murder charges...
354
00:21:15,691 --> 00:21:17,991
before we do that?
355
00:21:18,058 --> 00:21:21,024
Okay. Of course.
356
00:21:21,091 --> 00:21:22,991
Great.
357
00:21:30,171 --> 00:21:32,038
You can't do this to me.
358
00:21:32,104 --> 00:21:35,504
I have no choice.
I've got to show
a chain of events.
359
00:21:35,571 --> 00:21:37,938
I don't think I'm somebody
you want to be calling.
360
00:21:38,004 --> 00:21:40,238
I'm not sympathetic
to this prosecution.
361
00:21:40,304 --> 00:21:43,604
Well, I won't be calling
upon you as an advocate.
I just need the facts.
362
00:21:43,671 --> 00:21:46,138
I'll stipulate that he got
the information from me.
363
00:21:46,204 --> 00:21:48,904
Ms. Gamble.
364
00:21:48,971 --> 00:21:52,638
I'm not a man prone
to vulgarity, but your ass
is already in the grinder here.
365
00:21:52,704 --> 00:21:57,038
I suggest you cooperate with
the office that employs you.
366
00:21:59,504 --> 00:22:02,804
Mr. Silverman,
you don't scare me.
367
00:22:05,871 --> 00:22:07,804
Well, in that case,
368
00:22:08,938 --> 00:22:11,538
here's a subpoena.
369
00:22:15,038 --> 00:22:17,871
[ Bell Dinging ]
370
00:22:17,938 --> 00:22:20,804
[ Dinging Continues ]
371
00:22:23,238 --> 00:22:25,604
This is me.
Oh, pardon me.
372
00:22:27,038 --> 00:22:28,938
[ Sighs ]
373
00:22:31,938 --> 00:22:34,104
[ Elevator Doors Close ]
374
00:22:34,171 --> 00:22:38,504
I hope you do realize that
was one of the more unpleasant
arguments I ever had to make.
375
00:22:38,571 --> 00:22:41,838
But you got through it
just the same.
Jimmy.
376
00:22:41,904 --> 00:22:43,938
Mr. Berluti,
this is not the time.
377
00:22:44,004 --> 00:22:46,571
No, don't you apologize
or look at me like
you had no choice.
378
00:22:46,638 --> 00:22:48,538
Jimmy.
You made your choice.
379
00:22:48,604 --> 00:22:50,671
Yes.
And you made yours.
380
00:22:54,438 --> 00:22:56,538
[ Doors Opening ]
381
00:22:58,571 --> 00:23:01,338
Well, I suppose I should be
grateful I wasn't assaulted.
382
00:23:01,404 --> 00:23:03,438
Not yet.
383
00:23:03,504 --> 00:23:06,904
You could've taken it
to chambers, Mr. West, but you
chose to do it in open court.
384
00:23:06,971 --> 00:23:10,138
You're suing us
in the open, counsel.
We respond in kind.
385
00:23:10,204 --> 00:23:12,938
Yeah? Well, so do we.
386
00:23:16,004 --> 00:23:18,638
[ Silverman ]
What were you doing
when the phone call came in?
387
00:23:18,704 --> 00:23:20,771
I had just taken a shower.
388
00:23:20,838 --> 00:23:23,471
- And what did
Officer Walpole tell you?
- Hearsay.
389
00:23:23,538 --> 00:23:27,238
Not offered for the truth,
Your Honor. Just to establish
the words were spoken.
390
00:23:27,304 --> 00:23:30,738
- I'll allow it.
- What did he say?
391
00:23:30,804 --> 00:23:35,771
Something to the effect that
our informant thought he was
Abraham Lincoln in a past life.
392
00:23:35,838 --> 00:23:39,671
We were concerned that hemight not pass reliabilityunder the Aguilar test...
393
00:23:39,738 --> 00:23:41,771
and we wouldn't get
our warrant.
394
00:23:41,838 --> 00:23:44,338
Your informant thought
he was Abraham Lincoln?
Yes.
395
00:23:44,404 --> 00:23:46,938
He'd get headaches
when he went to the theater.
396
00:23:47,004 --> 00:23:50,404
Is that his joke
or yours, Ms. Gamble?
397
00:23:51,971 --> 00:23:54,104
You have
a personal relationship
with the defendant?
398
00:23:54,171 --> 00:23:59,138
We date. That's why
he was in my apartment
when the phone call came in.
399
00:23:59,204 --> 00:24:03,871
That's how he overheard
we were scheduling a raid
on Mr. Isikoff's safe house.
400
00:24:03,938 --> 00:24:05,704
So, the defendant knew
about the raid?
401
00:24:05,771 --> 00:24:09,304
- I'd answer, but the defense
is about to object.
- Objection.
402
00:24:09,371 --> 00:24:13,071
The witness isn't competent
to say what the defendant
may or may not have known.
403
00:24:13,138 --> 00:24:15,004
Let's speed this up.
404
00:24:15,071 --> 00:24:18,138
After the shoot-out,
did you and the defendant
have a conversation?
405
00:24:18,204 --> 00:24:20,171
Yes.
406
00:24:20,238 --> 00:24:23,338
And did he tell you
whether he informed
Mr. Isikoff in advance...
407
00:24:23,404 --> 00:24:25,804
that a police raid
was coming?
408
00:24:25,871 --> 00:24:28,871
He told me that he felt
legally obligated...
409
00:24:28,938 --> 00:24:33,571
to reveal the information
to his client, yes.
410
00:24:33,638 --> 00:24:36,338
Thank you, Ms. Gamble.
411
00:24:36,404 --> 00:24:39,304
[ Eugene ]
My client ever ask you for
information about this raid?
412
00:24:39,371 --> 00:24:41,404
No.
413
00:24:41,471 --> 00:24:43,471
Did Mr. Donnell continue
to discuss this case...
414
00:24:43,538 --> 00:24:45,871
after he learned the suspect
was his own client?
415
00:24:45,938 --> 00:24:48,738
No.
Thank you.
416
00:24:48,804 --> 00:24:51,038
That's all.
Mr. Silverman?
417
00:24:52,204 --> 00:24:54,104
The witness may step down.
418
00:25:00,371 --> 00:25:02,404
Mr. Berluti?
419
00:25:08,804 --> 00:25:12,004
The complaint alleges
material facts in dispute.
420
00:25:12,071 --> 00:25:16,404
The discovery includes
epidemiological studies
suggesting a causal link...
421
00:25:16,471 --> 00:25:19,704
between power lines
and certain types of cancer.
422
00:25:19,771 --> 00:25:23,904
The complaint also alleges
a lack of serious
statewide studies...
423
00:25:23,971 --> 00:25:27,071
to determine the risks
of electromagnetic fields.
424
00:25:28,938 --> 00:25:33,704
Those four people live
within 100 yards of Boston
Power Company power lines.
425
00:25:33,771 --> 00:25:38,004
They live within
one square mile
of each other.
426
00:25:38,071 --> 00:25:41,971
This one has a brain tumor,
this one leukemia,
427
00:25:42,038 --> 00:25:44,171
this one also leukemia,
428
00:25:44,238 --> 00:25:46,971
and this one
brain cancer.
429
00:25:47,038 --> 00:25:50,371
They didn't get sick
because I ran a commercial.
430
00:25:50,438 --> 00:25:55,504
They didn't get sick
because I demeaned
the legal profession.
431
00:25:55,571 --> 00:25:58,504
There's a cancer cluster
in Fairfield, Massachusetts.
432
00:25:58,571 --> 00:26:00,671
People are dying.
433
00:26:00,738 --> 00:26:05,771
And he's asking you to
ignore this because he thinks
my law firm is disreputable.
434
00:26:07,204 --> 00:26:11,471
We've been called
these things before
at my disreputable firm.
435
00:26:11,538 --> 00:26:14,038
The last time
was when we sued
a tobacco company.
436
00:26:14,104 --> 00:26:17,371
They brought a summary
judgment motion, too,
437
00:26:17,438 --> 00:26:20,704
arguing, as a matter of law,
we had no case.
438
00:26:20,771 --> 00:26:24,404
Cigarettes couldn't
possibly cause cancer.
439
00:26:30,038 --> 00:26:33,471
When we first got to
the apartment building,
we did notice some activity,
440
00:26:33,538 --> 00:26:35,538
though we didn't really think
there was a connection.
441
00:26:35,604 --> 00:26:38,838
- What do you mean "activity"?
- Well, there were cars leaving,
pulling out.
442
00:26:38,904 --> 00:26:42,004
No people or plates
that we'd recognized.
443
00:26:42,071 --> 00:26:46,438
But the feel--
It just wasn't sleepy,
is the best I can describe it.
444
00:26:46,504 --> 00:26:50,304
Could you describe
what happened next?
445
00:26:50,371 --> 00:26:54,038
We moved in.
We had 11 officers in all.
446
00:26:54,104 --> 00:26:56,404
We wore vests,
and the front line
had helmets.
447
00:26:56,471 --> 00:27:00,038
Six of us went up
the stairway, the other five
secured the area.
448
00:27:00,104 --> 00:27:03,804
We weren't using the battering
ram because our informant
had actually given us a key.
449
00:27:03,871 --> 00:27:06,804
To Mr. Isikoff's apartment?
Yes. We approached
the door.
450
00:27:06,871 --> 00:27:10,071
And we did hearsome scuffling behind it,but not much.
451
00:27:10,138 --> 00:27:13,104
And then
that's when it happened.
What happened?
452
00:27:15,038 --> 00:27:19,738
We sprang through the door,
and there they were, waiting,
453
00:27:19,804 --> 00:27:21,971
like theywere expecting us.
454
00:27:22,038 --> 00:27:25,471
Continue.
I just heard the shots.I could smell the powder.
455
00:27:25,538 --> 00:27:28,471
Assault weapons.
It's like they had
an arsenal.
456
00:27:28,538 --> 00:27:31,438
You were shot?
In the shoulder.
457
00:27:31,504 --> 00:27:33,871
It knocked me back
down the stairs.
458
00:27:33,938 --> 00:27:36,404
And the shooting just seemed
to go on and on.
459
00:27:36,471 --> 00:27:40,838
- What'd you see next?
- The next thing I remember
seeing was Kevin Greene.
460
00:27:40,904 --> 00:27:43,671
He fell on top of me.
Who is Kevin Greene?
461
00:27:43,738 --> 00:27:47,404
My part--
He was my partner.
462
00:27:47,471 --> 00:27:50,438
He had been shotin the head.
463
00:27:50,504 --> 00:27:52,738
He was dead?
Not yet.
464
00:27:52,804 --> 00:27:56,471
He was looking at me, like he
didn't know what had happened.
465
00:27:56,538 --> 00:28:00,804
And, uh, it looked likehe couldn't breathe,
466
00:28:00,871 --> 00:28:03,471
'cause there wasthis stuff in his mouth.
467
00:28:03,538 --> 00:28:06,171
And I tried
to help him breathe.
468
00:28:06,238 --> 00:28:08,571
I tried to clear his mouth.
469
00:28:11,771 --> 00:28:14,504
He just kept looking back--
470
00:28:14,571 --> 00:28:16,738
looking back at me.
471
00:28:16,804 --> 00:28:19,804
Were you able
to get him to breathe?
472
00:28:19,871 --> 00:28:21,771
[ Inhales ]
473
00:28:22,838 --> 00:28:24,704
No.
474
00:28:26,971 --> 00:28:28,838
He was near dead then.
475
00:28:31,038 --> 00:28:34,938
Officer Horton,you've testified thatthey were waiting.
476
00:28:37,604 --> 00:28:39,771
Are you sure about this?
477
00:28:39,838 --> 00:28:42,204
Yes, I am.
478
00:28:42,271 --> 00:28:45,238
As soon as the door opened,
we were looking at gun barrels,
479
00:28:45,304 --> 00:28:47,771
and I saw someof their eyes.
480
00:28:48,738 --> 00:28:50,771
They weren't surprised.
481
00:28:50,838 --> 00:28:55,404
We were the ones surprised.
They knew we were coming.
482
00:28:58,671 --> 00:29:00,738
[ Ellenor ]
So, you didn't
do any cross?
483
00:29:00,804 --> 00:29:04,071
No point.
This is a lousy time
to say "I told you so."
484
00:29:04,138 --> 00:29:07,604
Then maybe you shouldn't.
Drug lawyers always
become targets.
485
00:29:07,671 --> 00:29:10,271
It's not just that.
We've been beating them
on everything.
486
00:29:10,338 --> 00:29:12,271
Gerald Braun,
Victoria Keenan.
487
00:29:12,338 --> 00:29:15,804
And you know what?
We've been under attack
on our power lines case too.
488
00:29:15,871 --> 00:29:18,304
The defendant's lawyer--
You should have heard
his little spew.
489
00:29:18,371 --> 00:29:20,938
So, did we winthe motion?
490
00:29:21,004 --> 00:29:22,938
No, not yet.
491
00:29:25,138 --> 00:29:27,938
[ Knocking On Door ]
492
00:29:34,338 --> 00:29:36,738
Hey.
493
00:29:36,804 --> 00:29:40,071
I tried calling,
but you wouldn't pick up.
494
00:29:41,738 --> 00:29:44,438
Well, you've got me
in person now.
495
00:29:44,504 --> 00:29:46,771
What can I do for you?
496
00:29:46,838 --> 00:29:48,604
Can I come in?
497
00:29:59,504 --> 00:30:01,838
Firstly, I wanted
to thank you for today.
498
00:30:01,904 --> 00:30:03,904
I know you were
under a subpoena.
499
00:30:03,971 --> 00:30:06,404
And I-I'd also like
to thank you for--
500
00:30:06,471 --> 00:30:09,404
For what?
For sticking by you?
501
00:30:09,471 --> 00:30:11,604
I didn't do that.
502
00:30:11,671 --> 00:30:14,438
I objected to you
being prosecuted.
503
00:30:14,504 --> 00:30:16,504
I wasn't defending
what you did.
504
00:30:16,571 --> 00:30:19,171
- Helen, I know--
- Bobby, look.
505
00:30:19,238 --> 00:30:22,271
If you've come here to account
for yourself, please get out.
506
00:30:22,338 --> 00:30:24,404
I get your position.
507
00:30:24,471 --> 00:30:26,371
Plus, you'll be
on stand tomorrow,
508
00:30:26,438 --> 00:30:30,104
and we both know testimony
comes off more persuasive
when it isn't rehearsed.
509
00:30:30,171 --> 00:30:33,104
You say you get my position.
Well, I'm here, hoping
that you'll understand--
510
00:30:33,171 --> 00:30:35,671
Just get out.
Just get out. Get out!
Come on, Helen. Please.
511
00:30:35,738 --> 00:30:40,038
Just get out! Get out!
Get out! Get out! Get out!
512
00:30:40,104 --> 00:30:41,904
[ Sobbing ]
513
00:30:41,971 --> 00:30:44,871
It isn't you!
Don't you think I know that?
514
00:30:44,938 --> 00:30:48,538
You're a defense attorney!
The guy's your client!
515
00:30:49,538 --> 00:30:51,538
I'm the one
who screwed up!
516
00:30:51,604 --> 00:30:53,971
You? You can't
blame yourself!
517
00:30:54,038 --> 00:30:57,071
Are you crazy?
518
00:30:59,771 --> 00:31:02,938
Everybody was doing
their job except me.
519
00:31:04,138 --> 00:31:07,504
Those people are dead
'cause I didn't do mine.
520
00:31:11,471 --> 00:31:14,538
I'm angry at myself.
521
00:31:14,604 --> 00:31:17,604
Maybe I even hate what--
522
00:31:19,071 --> 00:31:21,471
But I won't lie.
523
00:31:21,538 --> 00:31:24,804
I'm not sure I can ever
look at you without--
524
00:31:30,238 --> 00:31:32,171
Please, just get out.
525
00:31:32,238 --> 00:31:33,804
[ Door Opens ]
Helen.
526
00:31:51,895 --> 00:31:54,529
I had no way of knowing
a shoot-out would ensue,
527
00:31:54,595 --> 00:31:57,362
and I certainly never counseled
my client toward violence.
528
00:31:57,429 --> 00:32:00,729
Thank you. That's all.
529
00:32:00,795 --> 00:32:04,162
Did you know that your client
had sophisticated
assault weapons?
530
00:32:04,229 --> 00:32:06,562
Did I know it? No.
531
00:32:06,629 --> 00:32:08,862
Did it surprise you
to learn...
532
00:32:08,929 --> 00:32:12,762
that Mr. Isikoff had weapons
in his safe house?
533
00:32:12,829 --> 00:32:16,262
I had no specific knowledge
that they had weapons.
534
00:32:16,329 --> 00:32:19,695
- Did it surprise you
to learn that he did?
- No.
535
00:32:19,762 --> 00:32:23,395
Did it surprise you that they
had cocaine and heroin there?
536
00:32:23,462 --> 00:32:25,062
No.
537
00:32:25,129 --> 00:32:27,595
In your mind,
when you told Mr. Isikoff...
538
00:32:27,662 --> 00:32:30,195
that the police were aboutto raid his safe house,
539
00:32:30,262 --> 00:32:33,795
did you make room for
the possibility that they might
use those weapons to fight back?
540
00:32:33,862 --> 00:32:36,229
Well, I really didn't
think that far ahead.
541
00:32:36,295 --> 00:32:38,295
You didn't think
that far ahead.
542
00:32:38,362 --> 00:32:41,862
What did you think Mr. Isikoff
would do with the information
you'd given him?
543
00:32:41,929 --> 00:32:45,362
Well, my job
was just to give him
the information, counsel.
544
00:32:45,429 --> 00:32:48,495
Oh. You're quite
a taskmaster with your job,
aren't you?
545
00:32:48,562 --> 00:32:50,362
- Objection.
- Sustained.
546
00:32:50,429 --> 00:32:52,862
When Mr. Isikoff
left your car,
547
00:32:52,929 --> 00:32:55,562
did you consider that he
might go to his house,
548
00:32:55,629 --> 00:32:58,395
gather his belongings
before the police
could get there?
549
00:32:58,462 --> 00:33:01,095
I considered that. Yes.
550
00:33:01,162 --> 00:33:04,595
Did you consider that the police
could get there while Isikoff
was still in the house?
551
00:33:06,895 --> 00:33:10,362
Did you considerthat the policecould get there...
552
00:33:10,429 --> 00:33:12,829
while Mr. Isikoff
was still in the house?
553
00:33:12,895 --> 00:33:16,495
I don't remember
specifically considering it,
554
00:33:16,562 --> 00:33:19,695
but nor do I remember
ruling that possibility out.
555
00:33:19,762 --> 00:33:22,429
Oh, what a lovely answer.
556
00:33:22,495 --> 00:33:25,195
- Objection!
- Sustained.
557
00:33:25,262 --> 00:33:28,629
Did you ever consider
calling the police and saying,
558
00:33:28,695 --> 00:33:31,562
"Hey, call off your raid.
They know you're coming."
559
00:33:31,629 --> 00:33:35,195
Did you ever think of
telling the police that?
No.
560
00:33:38,995 --> 00:33:40,862
Who is Jack Cowley?
561
00:33:46,362 --> 00:33:48,362
Who is Jack Cowley?
562
00:33:52,062 --> 00:33:54,462
He was evidently the informant
the police were using...
563
00:33:54,529 --> 00:33:56,629
to get their search warrant.
564
00:33:56,695 --> 00:33:59,695
Did you tell Mr. Isikoff
that Jack Cowley was working
with the police?
565
00:33:59,762 --> 00:34:04,895
My communication
with Mr. Isikoff would be
privileged, Mr. Silverman.
566
00:34:04,962 --> 00:34:08,995
You're quite correct, but that
privilege belongs to Isikoff,
and he has waived it.
567
00:34:09,062 --> 00:34:13,729
And he told the police that you
told him that Jack Cowley
was the informant.
568
00:34:13,795 --> 00:34:17,095
- Would that be correct?
- Objection! Mr. Isikoff
is represented by counsel.
569
00:34:17,162 --> 00:34:19,795
The police were told
not to speak to him.
570
00:34:19,862 --> 00:34:23,495
Any conversation with
John Isikoff is a violation
of the Sixth Amendment.
571
00:34:23,562 --> 00:34:26,962
- Sixth Amendment protections go
to the client, not the lawyer.
- Doesn't matter.
572
00:34:27,029 --> 00:34:31,895
John Isikoff lacks the legal
capacity to waive that right--
Innes versus Rhode Island.
573
00:34:31,962 --> 00:34:35,029
Yes, and should the police
ever use those statements
against Mr. Isikoff,
574
00:34:35,095 --> 00:34:36,929
you would have cause
to suppress them.
575
00:34:36,995 --> 00:34:40,695
But I'm not goingafter Mr. Isikoff here.
576
00:34:40,762 --> 00:34:43,195
I'm going after you.
[ Eugene ]Your Honor!
577
00:34:43,262 --> 00:34:47,595
He's right. You can't
assert somebody else's
constitutional rights...
578
00:34:47,662 --> 00:34:50,529
in order to protect
Mr. Donnell, counsel.
579
00:34:50,595 --> 00:34:53,895
I don't really believeI need to tell you that.
580
00:34:53,962 --> 00:34:57,329
Did you tell Mr. Isikoffthat Jack Cowley wasthe police informant?
581
00:34:57,395 --> 00:35:00,795
No. I asked him
if he knew him.
582
00:35:00,862 --> 00:35:03,629
When he said yes,
did you tell him
about the police raid?
583
00:35:06,795 --> 00:35:09,462
- That's right.
- Hmm.
584
00:35:09,529 --> 00:35:13,962
Did you ever consider
that your client might be able
to put two and two together?
585
00:35:14,029 --> 00:35:15,962
[ Eugene ]
Objection!
Sustained.
586
00:35:16,029 --> 00:35:20,795
Were you shocked to learn
Cowley was found dead with a
bullet in the back of his head?
587
00:35:20,862 --> 00:35:22,029
Objection!
Sustained.
588
00:35:22,095 --> 00:35:24,662
I think we're done.
589
00:35:28,829 --> 00:35:30,729
We're in trouble.
590
00:35:30,795 --> 00:35:34,595
Bobby, if this goes to trial,
we're gonna have to
consider a plea.
591
00:35:35,762 --> 00:35:38,629
A drug lawyer sets up
the police for an ambush.
592
00:35:38,695 --> 00:35:42,129
Uh, you were pretty much
an executioner for Cowley.
593
00:35:42,195 --> 00:35:44,329
Our only defense
is the canon of ethics.
594
00:35:44,395 --> 00:35:47,229
Legally, we gotta argue that
what you did was ethical...
595
00:35:47,295 --> 00:35:49,895
and hope that
the judge will buy it...
596
00:35:49,962 --> 00:35:52,895
because no jury ever will.
597
00:35:55,862 --> 00:35:58,462
I'll close.
598
00:35:58,529 --> 00:36:01,195
I'm not so sure
that's smart.
599
00:36:03,095 --> 00:36:05,562
I'll close.
600
00:36:07,295 --> 00:36:09,662
Mr. Berluti,
would you stand up?
601
00:36:12,695 --> 00:36:15,329
I'm tempted to say,
"Will the defendant
please rise?"
602
00:36:17,262 --> 00:36:20,229
One of the problemswith the proliferationof law schools,
603
00:36:20,295 --> 00:36:23,162
night schools,
part-time schools,
salons--
604
00:36:23,229 --> 00:36:27,929
Come get a shampoo, earna law degree while you waitfor your hair to dry.
605
00:36:27,995 --> 00:36:31,962
We overflood the market
with attorneys who, because
of the competition,
606
00:36:32,029 --> 00:36:35,895
have to go out and create
litigation just so they
can scratch a living.
607
00:36:35,962 --> 00:36:39,895
I hate it.And you're a poster boyfor the problem.
608
00:36:39,962 --> 00:36:42,329
That having been said,
609
00:36:42,395 --> 00:36:45,562
this complaint does allege
disputable questions of fact.
610
00:36:45,629 --> 00:36:48,429
The defendant's motionfor summary judgmentis denied.
611
00:36:48,495 --> 00:36:50,662
I'm schedulinga pretrial for Monday.
612
00:36:50,729 --> 00:36:55,495
I want witness listsno later than Friday.See you soon.
613
00:36:55,562 --> 00:36:58,795
[ Gavel Raps ]
[ Gasping ]
614
00:36:58,862 --> 00:37:00,829
We won.
We did.
615
00:37:00,895 --> 00:37:03,995
He didn't kick it.
Nope. Of course, now we
have to try it, Jimmy.
616
00:37:04,062 --> 00:37:06,329
We'll try it.
I'm ready.
617
00:37:10,129 --> 00:37:12,595
Thank you very much.
618
00:37:12,662 --> 00:37:15,962
I'm not gonna stand up hereand defend my actions...
619
00:37:16,029 --> 00:37:18,762
from a moral position.
620
00:37:18,829 --> 00:37:21,495
Not to you.
621
00:37:24,895 --> 00:37:27,362
Certainly not
to any of you.
622
00:37:30,695 --> 00:37:32,595
I'm sorry.
623
00:37:36,562 --> 00:37:40,329
Legally, I fulfilled
my ethical obligation
to my client.
624
00:37:41,495 --> 00:37:44,429
Morally, I betrayed
the men who were killed.
625
00:37:44,495 --> 00:37:47,362
Legally,I traded on information...
626
00:37:47,429 --> 00:37:50,195
I received through
a social relationship.
627
00:37:51,329 --> 00:37:54,495
Morally, I betrayed a trust
with Helen Gamble.
628
00:37:56,295 --> 00:37:59,862
My only defense here...
is legal.
629
00:38:02,062 --> 00:38:04,795
I'm a criminal
defense attorney.
630
00:38:04,862 --> 00:38:07,362
I represent bad people.
631
00:38:07,429 --> 00:38:10,329
The adversary system
is premised...
632
00:38:10,395 --> 00:38:13,629
on the defense attorney
doing whatever he can...
633
00:38:13,695 --> 00:38:17,162
to get the guy off.
634
00:38:17,229 --> 00:38:19,095
It's drummed into us.
635
00:38:19,162 --> 00:38:23,462
We are bound by
the limits of the law,
but only the law.
636
00:38:24,695 --> 00:38:26,295
Morality?
637
00:38:26,362 --> 00:38:29,029
Right or wrong?
638
00:38:29,095 --> 00:38:31,195
Justice?
639
00:38:33,362 --> 00:38:35,829
If a criminal lawyer
starts asking himself,
640
00:38:35,895 --> 00:38:40,362
"What's the just result here?
How should we get to there?"
641
00:38:42,162 --> 00:38:44,195
he's lost.
642
00:38:48,295 --> 00:38:50,762
It's not a noble excuse,
643
00:38:54,595 --> 00:38:56,462
but a legal one.
644
00:39:06,162 --> 00:39:08,462
Do whatever you can
to get the guy off.
645
00:39:10,662 --> 00:39:14,729
Mr. Donnell says
that is the credo
of a defense attorney.
646
00:39:14,795 --> 00:39:18,195
Today he stands here
apologizing for it.
647
00:39:18,262 --> 00:39:20,595
Last year,
648
00:39:20,662 --> 00:39:24,195
after one of your clients
committed a premeditated
revenge murder,
649
00:39:25,162 --> 00:39:27,595
you stood
in this very courthouse...
650
00:39:27,662 --> 00:39:30,529
and argued law be damned,
morality should win out.
651
00:39:30,595 --> 00:39:34,262
Today you exalt the law
to justify immorality.
652
00:39:34,329 --> 00:39:36,795
Whatever you can
to get the guy off.
653
00:39:36,862 --> 00:39:38,629
Face me, Mr. Silverman.
654
00:39:40,662 --> 00:39:43,495
If a client
is about to kill,
655
00:39:43,562 --> 00:39:46,929
his lawyer has always been
allowed to reveal that.
656
00:39:46,995 --> 00:39:51,362
Privilege has never
been given priority over
the threat of bodily harm.
657
00:39:53,195 --> 00:39:56,395
Mr. Donnell knew that
his clients were violent.
658
00:39:56,462 --> 00:39:58,562
By his own admission,
659
00:39:58,629 --> 00:40:01,029
he knew of the possibility
that people could be killed.
660
00:40:01,095 --> 00:40:03,329
Innocent people.
661
00:40:05,029 --> 00:40:07,362
And he sat on it.
662
00:40:10,762 --> 00:40:12,629
He let the fathers...
663
00:40:13,695 --> 00:40:17,695
and the husbands
of those people...
664
00:40:17,762 --> 00:40:21,129
walk headfirst into an ambush
to their deaths...
665
00:40:22,095 --> 00:40:25,262
because in his mind,
666
00:40:25,329 --> 00:40:28,995
he had the legal duty
to ignore justice and morality.
667
00:40:29,062 --> 00:40:33,595
In his mind, if he did anything
to prevent those violent deaths,
668
00:40:34,729 --> 00:40:36,595
he'd be lost.
669
00:40:41,195 --> 00:40:44,029
I don't think
the defendant...
670
00:40:44,095 --> 00:40:47,595
has any idea how truly lost
he really is.
671
00:40:56,229 --> 00:40:58,962
How long?
She just asked us
to wait.
672
00:40:59,029 --> 00:41:02,062
She can't make him
stand trial for murder.
She just can't.
673
00:41:02,129 --> 00:41:04,195
With this public outcry?
674
00:41:08,262 --> 00:41:10,362
Come on, everybody.
675
00:41:13,095 --> 00:41:15,195
We'll be right outside.
676
00:41:26,162 --> 00:41:28,729
I'm not nearly ready
to put this behind me,
677
00:41:32,262 --> 00:41:36,195
but... I'm not ready to
put you behind me either.
678
00:41:42,395 --> 00:41:44,595
She's coming back.
Let's go.
679
00:41:49,195 --> 00:41:51,662
I called you back in
because I'd made up my mind.
680
00:41:51,729 --> 00:41:56,662
But in the two minutes
it took you to file back in,
I changed it.
681
00:41:56,729 --> 00:42:00,462
Whether or notyou're guilty here,Mr. Donnell,
682
00:42:00,529 --> 00:42:03,695
really dependson exactly...
683
00:42:03,762 --> 00:42:08,129
where you were in your head
when you talked to your client,
684
00:42:08,195 --> 00:42:10,829
what you knew
would happen...
685
00:42:10,895 --> 00:42:14,295
or what you thought might.
686
00:42:14,362 --> 00:42:17,295
Unfortunately for me,
as a judge,
687
00:42:17,362 --> 00:42:19,595
that answer still lies
within your head...
688
00:42:21,095 --> 00:42:24,162
and your head alone.
689
00:42:24,229 --> 00:42:26,329
On the facts,
690
00:42:27,229 --> 00:42:29,295
dismissed with prejudice.
691
00:42:29,362 --> 00:42:31,829
- The defendant is free to go.
- [ Gavel Raps ]
692
00:42:32,995 --> 00:42:35,229
[ Spectators Murmuring ]
693
00:42:51,729 --> 00:42:53,595
No. Not yet.
694
00:42:53,662 --> 00:42:55,729
I will say it
for the last time.
695
00:42:55,795 --> 00:42:58,495
It won't be the last time,
It's never the last time
with you.
696
00:42:58,562 --> 00:43:02,429
All I'm saying is if we keep
defending the druggies, this
kind of stuff's gonna happen.
697
00:43:02,495 --> 00:43:06,229
Yeah, well, let's just get
some new clients before you
dump the old ones, okay?
698
00:43:06,295 --> 00:43:09,495
- And your cancer case survived?
- It did.
699
00:43:09,562 --> 00:43:11,795
With Judge Walsh?
He likes me.
700
00:43:11,862 --> 00:43:13,362
[ Jimmy ]
Where's Bobby?
701
00:43:13,429 --> 00:43:16,195
I think he ran off
to make up with Helen.
702
00:43:17,995 --> 00:43:19,862
Are those two
sleepin' together?
703
00:43:25,329 --> 00:43:30,829
[ Bell Tolling ]
704
00:43:45,962 --> 00:43:50,762
♪ [ Bugle Playing Taps ]
705
00:44:08,229 --> 00:44:10,729
[ Man Shouts Order ]
706
00:44:10,795 --> 00:44:13,129
Arms, fire!
707
00:44:13,195 --> 00:44:16,562
[ Man Shouts Order ]
708
00:44:18,729 --> 00:44:20,829
[ Rifles Firing ]
709
00:44:20,895 --> 00:44:22,729
[ Man Shouts Order ]
710
00:44:24,929 --> 00:44:26,729
[ Rifles Firing ]
711
00:44:49,162 --> 00:44:50,862
[ Woman ]You stinker!
60103
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.