Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:00,016 --> 00:00:01,280
Previously on Doubt...
2
00:00:01,305 --> 00:00:02,654
I might sleep with you
and then hate you,
3
00:00:02,678 --> 00:00:04,110
and then I'll have to see you in court,
4
00:00:04,112 --> 00:00:06,265
- and it'll be really awkward.
- PETER: You might.
5
00:00:06,336 --> 00:00:07,402
BILLY: Molly's here.
6
00:00:07,404 --> 00:00:08,770
She's a witness for the prosecution.
7
00:00:08,772 --> 00:00:09,971
What are you going to tell them?
8
00:00:09,973 --> 00:00:12,037
I'm gonna say what I saw, Mother!
9
00:00:12,062 --> 00:00:15,120
These are her psychiatric
records, tapes of her sessions.
10
00:00:15,145 --> 00:00:16,569
Save my boy, Sadie.
11
00:00:16,594 --> 00:00:18,728
- Are you sleeping with Billy?
- Yes.
12
00:00:18,931 --> 00:00:21,064
The only way out of this
mess is for us to win,
13
00:00:21,184 --> 00:00:22,450
so that's what we're gonna do.
14
00:00:22,452 --> 00:00:24,185
And then I'm gonna walk away.
15
00:00:27,917 --> 00:00:29,591
(knocking on door)
16
00:00:29,725 --> 00:00:31,691
Yeah, yeah.
17
00:00:33,563 --> 00:00:35,930
- Sadie, what?
- Can you for just one minute
18
00:00:35,932 --> 00:00:37,465
forget what a disappointment I am?
19
00:00:37,467 --> 00:00:38,505
You're not.
20
00:00:38,530 --> 00:00:40,030
And just be my dad, okay?
21
00:00:40,070 --> 00:00:41,336
And not my boss.
22
00:00:41,732 --> 00:00:43,052
Because I'm gonna tell you something,
23
00:00:43,076 --> 00:00:44,372
and you're not gonna like it,
24
00:00:44,374 --> 00:00:46,115
and you're gonna want to yell,
and I'm telling you right now
25
00:00:46,139 --> 00:00:47,338
I can't handle it.
26
00:00:47,444 --> 00:00:48,543
Go ahead.
27
00:00:48,709 --> 00:00:50,075
It's bad.
28
00:00:50,264 --> 00:00:52,331
Well, tear the Band-Aid.
29
00:00:55,952 --> 00:01:00,221
I'm sleeping with Billy,
and Albert found out.
30
00:01:04,384 --> 00:01:05,827
ISAIAH: Five days.
31
00:01:06,009 --> 00:01:09,464
I'm gone five days, and
my firm is falling apart.
32
00:01:09,626 --> 00:01:11,366
I told him everything. Sorry.
33
00:01:11,368 --> 00:01:12,853
Your secrets and lies
34
00:01:12,942 --> 00:01:15,033
put this entire firm at risk.
35
00:01:15,158 --> 00:01:17,233
Everything I spent my life building.
36
00:01:17,258 --> 00:01:18,658
ALBERT: Do I really need to be here?
37
00:01:18,682 --> 00:01:19,915
Being that I'm the only one here
38
00:01:19,917 --> 00:01:21,424
who hasn't been keeping secrets.
39
00:01:21,449 --> 00:01:22,819
What secrets have I kept from you?
40
00:01:22,873 --> 00:01:23,951
You knew about Billy.
41
00:01:23,976 --> 00:01:26,006
- That's a big deal.
- So is quitting the firm.
42
00:01:26,031 --> 00:01:27,797
- CAMERON: What?
- You told him?
43
00:01:27,822 --> 00:01:29,789
- Was it a secret?
- You're leaving?
44
00:01:29,951 --> 00:01:31,217
I was gonna tell him myself.
45
00:01:31,242 --> 00:01:32,642
And I was gonna tell you about Billy.
46
00:01:32,666 --> 00:01:33,705
Don't do that.
47
00:01:33,730 --> 00:01:35,206
Don't make it like this
is the same thing.
48
00:01:35,230 --> 00:01:36,563
Okay, you're right. I'm sorry.
49
00:01:36,588 --> 00:01:38,020
Albert, you're leaving the firm?
50
00:01:38,155 --> 00:01:39,690
- Yes.
- Because of Sadie?
51
00:01:39,715 --> 00:01:41,799
- She lied to me.
- So you're gonna quit?
52
00:01:41,824 --> 00:01:43,242
Doesn't that strike you as overreacting?
53
00:01:43,266 --> 00:01:44,702
Says the person nobody lied to.
54
00:01:44,829 --> 00:01:46,016
TIFFANY: Oh, my God, what is going on?
55
00:01:46,040 --> 00:01:47,108
This is serious.
56
00:01:47,133 --> 00:01:48,164
You know what else is serious?
57
00:01:48,188 --> 00:01:50,005
Sadie asking me to look into D.A. Russo
58
00:01:50,030 --> 00:01:51,867
to find the smoking gun of corruption
59
00:01:51,869 --> 00:01:53,129
that they're pinning the
whole Brennan case on.
60
00:01:53,153 --> 00:01:55,571
Russo's squeaky clean, no scandals.
61
00:01:55,573 --> 00:01:57,613
- Oh, no.
- What?
62
00:01:57,638 --> 00:01:59,275
TIFFANY: You know that
thing that Isaiah does
63
00:01:59,277 --> 00:02:00,612
with his right hand
when he's really angry?
64
00:02:00,636 --> 00:02:01,933
- NICK: Yeah.
- Now he's doing it
65
00:02:01,958 --> 00:02:03,124
with both hands.
66
00:02:05,683 --> 00:02:08,244
Oh, man, Sadie and Albert
have been acting super weird
67
00:02:08,269 --> 00:02:09,822
around each other recently.
68
00:02:09,847 --> 00:02:11,237
Do you think that maybe they were dating
69
00:02:11,261 --> 00:02:12,655
and then they broke up?
70
00:02:12,957 --> 00:02:14,423
You got all that from
Isaiah's hand gestures?
71
00:02:14,425 --> 00:02:16,699
TIFFANY: (sighs) And Cam
is there because...
72
00:02:16,824 --> 00:02:18,794
She's in love with
Albert, Sadie found out,
73
00:02:18,796 --> 00:02:19,887
thus the breakup.
74
00:02:19,934 --> 00:02:22,431
- Oh, my God, do you think that's it?
- No.
75
00:02:22,433 --> 00:02:25,234
The graffiti kid's parents
are here for you and Cam,
76
00:02:25,236 --> 00:02:26,722
but I'm afraid to interrupt.
77
00:02:26,747 --> 00:02:28,075
TIFFANY: What do you
think is going on here?
78
00:02:28,099 --> 00:02:30,824
Well, Billy Brennan's
trial starts today.
79
00:02:30,849 --> 00:02:32,834
Maybe it's a pep talk.
80
00:02:32,998 --> 00:02:34,843
Can we please just put this aside
81
00:02:34,845 --> 00:02:36,578
until after the trial?
ALBERT: No, we can't.
82
00:02:36,580 --> 00:02:38,213
You are sleeping with our client,
83
00:02:38,215 --> 00:02:39,735
which means that your judgment is bad.
84
00:02:39,787 --> 00:02:41,417
So you don't get to be
his lawyer anymore.
85
00:02:41,419 --> 00:02:43,538
You're gonna sit at the
defense table and not speak.
86
00:02:43,563 --> 00:02:44,729
You're a potted plant.
87
00:02:44,754 --> 00:02:46,120
What did you just call me?
88
00:02:46,145 --> 00:02:48,842
Enough! This is not who we are.
89
00:02:48,867 --> 00:02:51,897
We don't fight each other.
We fight them, out there.
90
00:02:52,317 --> 00:02:54,802
So no more secrets. Is that clear?
91
00:02:54,911 --> 00:02:56,710
- Yes.
- Yes.
92
00:02:59,685 --> 00:03:02,353
I'm sleeping with a prosecutor.
93
00:03:04,675 --> 00:03:06,775
He said no more secrets.
94
00:03:08,720 --> 00:03:09,759
SADIE: I know the case.
95
00:03:09,784 --> 00:03:10,917
I've been preparing for weeks.
96
00:03:10,941 --> 00:03:12,841
Just let me do the open,
then I'll be a plant.
97
00:03:12,866 --> 00:03:14,733
I'm opening. What are you gonna say?
98
00:03:14,758 --> 00:03:16,592
I'm gonna talk about how
great your boyfriend is.
99
00:03:16,616 --> 00:03:19,050
You'll love it. There they are.
100
00:03:19,290 --> 00:03:20,648
I told them to leave the limo at home,
101
00:03:20,672 --> 00:03:22,305
at least try to seem relatable.
102
00:03:27,183 --> 00:03:30,150
Never again. He drove like a maniac.
103
00:03:30,434 --> 00:03:31,633
REPORTER: There he is!
104
00:03:31,729 --> 00:03:33,062
(reporters clamoring)
105
00:03:33,535 --> 00:03:34,598
REPORTER: Mr. Brennan, how do you feel?
106
00:03:34,622 --> 00:03:36,543
I feel... He feels happy to
finally have his day in court.
107
00:03:36,567 --> 00:03:37,785
Now if you'll let us through.
108
00:03:37,810 --> 00:03:40,175
Don't talk. Just smile, look good.
109
00:03:42,960 --> 00:03:44,726
All right, make sure you
get everything now.
110
00:03:44,792 --> 00:03:46,245
All right, here he comes...
Here he comes.
111
00:03:46,247 --> 00:03:48,233
(siren wailing)
112
00:03:48,288 --> 00:03:49,921
Please don't shoot! Please don't shoot!
113
00:03:49,923 --> 00:03:51,257
That's my son! He's my son!
114
00:03:51,282 --> 00:03:52,481
- Dad?
- We're unarmed!
115
00:03:52,506 --> 00:03:53,972
- Dad!
- All right, he's unarmed.
116
00:03:53,997 --> 00:03:55,596
- He's...
- Turn around. Get your hands up.
117
00:03:55,620 --> 00:03:56,812
- OFFICER: Show me your hands!
- It's all right!
118
00:03:56,836 --> 00:03:58,459
- Don't shoot, please!
- Down on the ground, now.
119
00:03:58,483 --> 00:03:59,812
We're surrendering, we're surrendering!
120
00:03:59,836 --> 00:04:01,102
All right, get your hands up.
121
00:04:01,203 --> 00:04:02,334
- Down on the ground! Get on the ground!
- Mom! Mom!
122
00:04:02,336 --> 00:04:03,921
- Hands where I can see them!
- Don't shoot!
123
00:04:03,945 --> 00:04:05,414
Do not shoot! Their hands are up!
124
00:04:05,522 --> 00:04:06,927
Their hands are... Don't shoot my child!
125
00:04:06,951 --> 00:04:08,107
Get that phone out of my face!
126
00:04:08,131 --> 00:04:10,291
IRIS (sobbing): Don't shoot,
don't shoot, don't shoot.
127
00:04:10,428 --> 00:04:11,632
So, what, they-they just
128
00:04:11,657 --> 00:04:14,291
drag our son away, and
now we can't see him?
129
00:04:14,448 --> 00:04:16,564
They're transporting
Heyward to family court.
130
00:04:16,589 --> 00:04:18,034
We'll be waiting for him
when he gets there.
131
00:04:18,058 --> 00:04:20,089
Can you at least tell us
what he's been charged with?
132
00:04:20,113 --> 00:04:21,511
Well, he was caught tagging,
133
00:04:21,536 --> 00:04:23,659
so that's a misdemeanor
called making graffiti.
134
00:04:23,886 --> 00:04:25,832
CAMERON: And the police pursuit
was all over the news.
135
00:04:25,856 --> 00:04:28,284
I'd expect additional charges:
Resisting, obstructing...
136
00:04:28,309 --> 00:04:30,677
No, that-that's on me. I
told him to come home.
137
00:04:30,768 --> 00:04:32,753
TIFFANY: Well, the good
news is that he's under 18,
138
00:04:32,777 --> 00:04:34,143
so the maximum sentence
139
00:04:34,168 --> 00:04:36,268
they can give him is two years
in a juvenile facility.
140
00:04:36,270 --> 00:04:37,714
Good news?
141
00:04:37,853 --> 00:04:41,143
No, no. My son has a 3.8 average.
142
00:04:41,208 --> 00:04:42,808
He is going to college.
143
00:04:43,310 --> 00:04:44,887
You know, if Heyward were
white, I don't think you'd be
144
00:04:44,911 --> 00:04:47,620
talking to me like two years
in juvie was good news.
145
00:04:47,823 --> 00:04:49,652
Oh, I'm so sorry, I didn't,
I didn't mean to imply...
146
00:04:49,676 --> 00:04:51,254
No, it's not about what you're implying.
147
00:04:51,278 --> 00:04:53,178
It's about white kids and black kids
148
00:04:53,203 --> 00:04:55,070
- don't get treated the same.
- ERIC: Hey.
149
00:04:55,557 --> 00:04:57,128
They're trying to help us.
150
00:04:57,153 --> 00:04:58,979
Did you bring us his transcripts?
151
00:04:59,126 --> 00:05:01,829
His grades, his honors,
certificates of merit.
152
00:05:01,854 --> 00:05:03,053
I mean, it's-it's all there.
153
00:05:03,230 --> 00:05:06,765
But what those papers don't
show is how good he is.
154
00:05:06,767 --> 00:05:08,274
Make them see
155
00:05:08,299 --> 00:05:10,199
who he is, Ms. Wirth.
156
00:05:10,271 --> 00:05:12,271
Please.
157
00:05:15,209 --> 00:05:16,405
BURRIS: This is Amy Meyers
158
00:05:16,430 --> 00:05:19,139
as her mother liked to remember her.
159
00:05:19,873 --> 00:05:21,428
Kind...
160
00:05:21,796 --> 00:05:23,311
warm...
161
00:05:24,069 --> 00:05:25,217
alive.
162
00:05:25,219 --> 00:05:26,985
This is 1991,
163
00:05:27,186 --> 00:05:29,303
before Billy Brennan cut her life short
164
00:05:29,376 --> 00:05:31,592
by smashing her head with such force
165
00:05:31,718 --> 00:05:33,606
that shards of her skull came to rest
166
00:05:33,631 --> 00:05:35,831
inside the gray matter of her brain.
167
00:05:36,569 --> 00:05:37,795
Over the coming days,
168
00:05:37,820 --> 00:05:39,959
we will prove beyond a reasonable doubt
169
00:05:40,073 --> 00:05:42,256
that Billy Brennan had the
motive and the opportunity
170
00:05:42,352 --> 00:05:44,419
to kill Amy Meyers.
171
00:05:45,303 --> 00:05:48,944
We have an eyewitness putting
him at the scene of the crime,
172
00:05:49,143 --> 00:05:51,787
standing over Amy's dead body.
173
00:05:52,362 --> 00:05:54,929
His own sister says he did it.
174
00:05:55,775 --> 00:05:58,944
She said it 26 years ago,
and she was silenced.
175
00:06:00,414 --> 00:06:02,569
She now finally gets the opportunity
176
00:06:02,767 --> 00:06:05,912
to tell the truth:
That Billy killed Amy.
177
00:06:06,013 --> 00:06:07,256
Pure and simple.
178
00:06:07,389 --> 00:06:09,255
Guilty.
179
00:06:09,897 --> 00:06:11,061
ALBERT: Billy Brennan
180
00:06:11,086 --> 00:06:14,053
saves lives, he doesn't take them.
181
00:06:15,420 --> 00:06:17,514
The man they want to call a murderer
182
00:06:17,613 --> 00:06:20,414
is actually a brilliant
pediatric surgeon.
183
00:06:21,470 --> 00:06:23,600
The best of the best.
184
00:06:24,973 --> 00:06:26,373
During this trial,
185
00:06:26,498 --> 00:06:27,978
you'll hear a lot about the Brennans,
186
00:06:28,092 --> 00:06:31,787
about their power, their sense
of being above the law.
187
00:06:31,949 --> 00:06:33,139
But that is not,
188
00:06:33,265 --> 00:06:35,412
and has never been, Billy.
189
00:06:35,525 --> 00:06:36,897
The evidence will show you
190
00:06:36,981 --> 00:06:40,983
that Billy is good, generous, kind,
191
00:06:41,079 --> 00:06:43,936
and most of all, honorable.
192
00:06:44,102 --> 00:06:47,970
A man falsely accused by
an overzealous prosecutor,
193
00:06:48,082 --> 00:06:51,045
based on tainted, even
fabricated evidence.
194
00:06:51,563 --> 00:06:55,756
A man who deserves not
our scorn and suspicion,
195
00:06:56,157 --> 00:06:59,859
but our praise and respect.
196
00:06:59,947 --> 00:07:04,082
Time tatters evidence
and fades memories,
197
00:07:04,317 --> 00:07:08,119
but character endures.
198
00:07:10,056 --> 00:07:14,959
Billy Brennan is the best of the best.
199
00:07:25,557 --> 00:07:27,038
(quietly): So are you.
200
00:07:27,141 --> 00:07:29,075
The best of the best.
201
00:07:29,842 --> 00:07:31,708
Thanks.
202
00:07:36,843 --> 00:07:39,963
synced & corrected by PopcornAWH
www.addic7ed.com
203
00:07:43,109 --> 00:07:44,679
Mom, Dad?
204
00:07:44,890 --> 00:07:46,397
Heyward.
205
00:07:47,230 --> 00:07:49,061
I'm so sorry about this.
206
00:07:49,148 --> 00:07:50,624
Okay. Okay, baby.
207
00:07:50,649 --> 00:07:53,233
It's okay, it's okay. We are here.
It'll be okay.
208
00:07:54,764 --> 00:07:57,514
(scoffs) Look at what
the cat dragged in.
209
00:08:00,609 --> 00:08:02,709
Peter.
210
00:08:02,937 --> 00:08:05,171
What an ass. I'm so glad you
didn't go out with him.
211
00:08:05,254 --> 00:08:07,500
Remember when I thought he was
hot for, like, one second?
212
00:08:07,524 --> 00:08:08,623
Before he opened his mouth.
213
00:08:08,648 --> 00:08:10,615
PETER: Cameron.
214
00:08:12,358 --> 00:08:14,492
What are you doing here? This
is family court. A.D.A.s...
215
00:08:14,516 --> 00:08:16,917
When a car chase makes the
news, Russo tends to send in
216
00:08:16,942 --> 00:08:20,017
a handsome rising star just to
make sure the charges stick.
217
00:08:20,198 --> 00:08:22,332
So, voilà.
218
00:08:25,059 --> 00:08:26,217
CAMERON: These charges are absurd.
219
00:08:26,241 --> 00:08:27,801
They're piling on just to make a point.
220
00:08:27,872 --> 00:08:29,205
It's called prosecutorial discretion.
221
00:08:29,207 --> 00:08:31,115
We're allowed to bring whatever
charges we think are appropriate.
222
00:08:31,139 --> 00:08:33,206
And it's his job to
dismiss the stupid ones.
223
00:08:33,378 --> 00:08:34,545
JUDGE ROUTBORT: Easy, Ms. Wirth.
224
00:08:34,569 --> 00:08:36,130
Let's keep the name calling in check.
225
00:08:36,294 --> 00:08:37,390
CAMERON: People v. Brown
226
00:08:37,415 --> 00:08:38,881
makes clear that flight from the police,
227
00:08:38,883 --> 00:08:40,908
as a general rule, is not a crime.
228
00:08:40,943 --> 00:08:42,329
He can't be charged with obstructing.
229
00:08:42,353 --> 00:08:44,406
- And yet he is.
- Which is utterly unsupported
230
00:08:44,431 --> 00:08:46,155
by statute or precedent.
231
00:08:46,157 --> 00:08:47,797
Like I said, stupid.
232
00:08:47,822 --> 00:08:48,858
Running from the police
233
00:08:48,860 --> 00:08:50,003
made it harder to get arrested.
234
00:08:50,027 --> 00:08:51,861
So, obstruction, resisting...
235
00:08:51,886 --> 00:08:54,205
Without an authorized arrest,
running can't be resisting.
236
00:08:54,230 --> 00:08:55,971
Which is why we're also
charging him with escape
237
00:08:55,995 --> 00:08:58,101
and unlawfully fleeing a police
officer in a motor vehicle.
238
00:08:58,125 --> 00:08:59,359
CAMERON: He can't be charged with escape
239
00:08:59,383 --> 00:09:00,770
if he was never in custody
in the first place.
240
00:09:00,794 --> 00:09:01,856
Would've been in custody
if he hadn't fled.
241
00:09:01,880 --> 00:09:03,913
Enough, you two. It's just me here.
242
00:09:04,375 --> 00:09:06,008
I want evidence, not argument.
243
00:09:06,010 --> 00:09:07,410
All right, Mr. Garrett, make your case.
244
00:09:07,412 --> 00:09:08,544
We'll see where the chips fall.
245
00:09:08,568 --> 00:09:11,082
And for now, Ms. Wirth,
your motions are denied.
246
00:09:13,451 --> 00:09:16,715
Amy was always so good, so responsible.
247
00:09:16,846 --> 00:09:18,745
It's why, that night...
248
00:09:18,770 --> 00:09:20,270
The night she didn't come home.
249
00:09:20,295 --> 00:09:22,729
...I wasn't worried right away.
250
00:09:22,894 --> 00:09:26,996
I knew she'd gone to a
party with Billy Brennan.
251
00:09:26,998 --> 00:09:28,231
So I waited.
252
00:09:28,233 --> 00:09:29,355
And waited.
253
00:09:29,380 --> 00:09:30,914
BURRIS: Around 2:00 a.m., what happened?
254
00:09:30,938 --> 00:09:32,838
I started calling.
255
00:09:32,937 --> 00:09:35,571
First I called the Brennans.
Margaret answered.
256
00:09:35,573 --> 00:09:37,106
She told me that
257
00:09:37,108 --> 00:09:39,875
Billy was in bed and
didn't know where Amy was.
258
00:09:40,115 --> 00:09:42,411
I can still hear her,
259
00:09:42,553 --> 00:09:45,681
"Don't worry, Gail.
I'm sure she's fine."
260
00:09:45,683 --> 00:09:47,232
BURRIS: And when did you realize
261
00:09:47,257 --> 00:09:49,358
that she wasn't fine?
262
00:09:49,621 --> 00:09:51,687
About 5:00 a.m.
263
00:09:51,689 --> 00:09:53,856
The police knocked on my door.
264
00:09:54,092 --> 00:09:55,324
They told me that
265
00:09:55,326 --> 00:09:58,527
a body had been found in the park.
266
00:09:58,811 --> 00:10:00,796
She was just lying there.
267
00:10:01,202 --> 00:10:03,266
There was blood everywhere.
268
00:10:03,514 --> 00:10:05,101
And then I saw him.
269
00:10:05,103 --> 00:10:06,732
- Billy Brennan?
- GAIL: Yes.
270
00:10:07,094 --> 00:10:08,404
When I looked at him,
271
00:10:08,406 --> 00:10:09,407
he turned away.
272
00:10:09,432 --> 00:10:10,516
Couldn't face me.
273
00:10:10,541 --> 00:10:13,008
I knew then.
274
00:10:13,211 --> 00:10:15,544
He murdered my daughter.
275
00:10:19,884 --> 00:10:22,518
ALBERT: Before you found Amy dead,
276
00:10:22,766 --> 00:10:25,087
you spent a fair amount of
time with Billy Brennan?
277
00:10:25,089 --> 00:10:26,689
Regrettably.
278
00:10:26,691 --> 00:10:28,922
In fact, you let him into your home,
279
00:10:29,110 --> 00:10:31,160
spent weekends and holidays with him.
280
00:10:31,368 --> 00:10:34,297
Well, he came from a
very chaotic family.
281
00:10:34,299 --> 00:10:37,196
ALBERT: You did those things
because you trusted him,
282
00:10:37,221 --> 00:10:40,289
because you never even
saw a hint of violence
283
00:10:40,751 --> 00:10:42,104
before you say he killed her.
284
00:10:42,106 --> 00:10:44,106
Obviously, I misjudged him.
285
00:10:44,809 --> 00:10:47,071
Is this your signature?
286
00:10:47,844 --> 00:10:49,145
It appears so.
287
00:10:49,147 --> 00:10:51,447
Could you tell us, precisely,
what is that document?
288
00:10:52,003 --> 00:10:54,032
It's a letter of recommendation.
289
00:10:54,202 --> 00:10:55,701
It's a letter to the headmaster
290
00:10:55,820 --> 00:10:57,987
of one of the most prominent
schools in Manhattan?
291
00:10:58,028 --> 00:10:59,261
Yes.
292
00:10:59,597 --> 00:11:00,823
Can you read the last sentence
293
00:11:00,825 --> 00:11:02,391
of the third paragraph?
294
00:11:02,800 --> 00:11:06,862
"Billy Brennan is a young
man of supreme integrity
295
00:11:06,864 --> 00:11:10,099
and the highest moral character."
296
00:11:15,930 --> 00:11:19,198
Like he's the best of the best?
297
00:11:19,956 --> 00:11:21,961
- I think I found something.
- What's this?
298
00:11:22,084 --> 00:11:24,284
Grace Russo's victory party
from a year and a half ago.
299
00:11:24,467 --> 00:11:26,461
Look who's there... Gail Meyers.
300
00:11:26,486 --> 00:11:29,006
This was just weeks before Billy
was charged with Amy's murder.
301
00:11:29,287 --> 00:11:31,754
Grace Russo and Gail
Meyers were friends.
302
00:11:31,756 --> 00:11:33,022
So?
303
00:11:33,172 --> 00:11:34,680
You don't find that unusual?
304
00:11:34,705 --> 00:11:37,105
That a wealthy socialite
is at a victory party
305
00:11:37,130 --> 00:11:39,530
with an ambitious politician?
306
00:11:39,622 --> 00:11:41,356
- So that's a no?
- Mm.
307
00:11:41,914 --> 00:11:43,366
The worst thing I've found
out about Russo is that
308
00:11:43,368 --> 00:11:44,803
she quit her a cappella
group in college.
309
00:11:44,827 --> 00:11:46,426
- I hate a cappella.
- Exactly.
310
00:11:46,537 --> 00:11:48,210
So quitting actually
speaks to her character.
311
00:11:48,234 --> 00:11:50,601
Keep digging.
312
00:11:51,138 --> 00:11:52,311
Is everything okay around here?
313
00:11:52,335 --> 00:11:54,368
I certainly hope so.
314
00:12:12,029 --> 00:12:13,854
Gail...
315
00:12:14,966 --> 00:12:18,151
I want you to know how
sorry I am for your pain.
316
00:12:18,903 --> 00:12:21,570
I'm glad it came through.
I wasn't sure it would.
317
00:12:22,284 --> 00:12:24,206
Excuse me?
318
00:12:24,208 --> 00:12:26,409
I was afraid that the sheer joy
319
00:12:26,411 --> 00:12:29,044
of finally being able to
testify against your son
320
00:12:29,046 --> 00:12:30,909
would impede my grieving mother act.
321
00:12:30,934 --> 00:12:32,300
I'm glad it didn't.
322
00:12:33,591 --> 00:12:36,693
You want to know when I was in pain?
323
00:12:39,089 --> 00:12:42,591
The day I realized that
there was no death penalty
324
00:12:42,593 --> 00:12:46,295
in New York, and Billy
wouldn't die in the chair.
325
00:12:46,594 --> 00:12:49,361
I cried that day.
326
00:12:50,813 --> 00:12:53,891
I've dealt with my grief, Maggie.
327
00:12:55,227 --> 00:12:58,055
What I want now is revenge.
328
00:12:59,376 --> 00:13:02,890
There was a time when
we were friends, Gail.
329
00:13:03,229 --> 00:13:06,243
And I really do mourn the loss of Amy.
330
00:13:07,735 --> 00:13:10,386
But if you think I'm
going to let you use
331
00:13:10,388 --> 00:13:13,530
your misguided vendetta to
destroy my son's life...
332
00:13:13,555 --> 00:13:14,554
(elevator bell dings)
333
00:13:14,579 --> 00:13:15,624
...well, then,
334
00:13:15,626 --> 00:13:19,428
you don't know me quite as
well as you think you do.
335
00:13:25,021 --> 00:13:26,969
OFFICER DIXON: I observed the
defendant spray-painting
336
00:13:26,971 --> 00:13:28,237
a concrete pillar.
337
00:13:28,239 --> 00:13:29,872
I approached, I ordered him to stop.
338
00:13:29,874 --> 00:13:32,508
- And did he comply?
- He stopped tagging,
339
00:13:32,510 --> 00:13:33,943
but he ran to his car and took off,
340
00:13:33,945 --> 00:13:35,177
which made everything more dangerous.
341
00:13:35,179 --> 00:13:36,378
How so?
342
00:13:36,513 --> 00:13:38,255
First off, kids in cars are scary.
343
00:13:38,341 --> 00:13:39,759
They can be reckless, you know?
344
00:13:39,784 --> 00:13:42,418
But then, does he have a gun?
345
00:13:42,568 --> 00:13:44,487
Is he under the influence
of drugs or alcohol?
346
00:13:44,489 --> 00:13:47,982
- Is he mentally unstable?
- You pursued him?
347
00:13:48,186 --> 00:13:50,881
Sure, but I took it slow, I
gave him room to maneuver,
348
00:13:50,906 --> 00:13:51,937
I didn't want to escalate.
349
00:13:51,961 --> 00:13:53,407
And what would the procedure have been
350
00:13:53,431 --> 00:13:55,090
if the defendant had simply
351
00:13:55,115 --> 00:13:56,665
obeyed your instructions?
352
00:13:56,967 --> 00:13:59,835
I would've confiscated the
spray paint, issued a citation
353
00:13:59,837 --> 00:14:01,570
and contacted his parents.
354
00:14:01,572 --> 00:14:05,274
He's here today because
of his choices, not mine.
355
00:14:11,064 --> 00:14:13,482
What's the number on the bottom right?
The 29.
356
00:14:13,484 --> 00:14:14,717
That's miles per hour.
357
00:14:14,719 --> 00:14:16,519
Heyward ever exceed the speed limit?
358
00:14:16,521 --> 00:14:17,760
No.
359
00:14:17,822 --> 00:14:19,064
Did he run a stop sign?
360
00:14:19,089 --> 00:14:21,205
- Blow through any red lights?
- No, ma'am.
361
00:14:21,392 --> 00:14:23,447
- Use his turn signals?
- Yes.
362
00:14:23,472 --> 00:14:25,639
Yield to pedestrians in the crosswalk?
363
00:14:25,689 --> 00:14:26,790
He did.
364
00:14:26,815 --> 00:14:29,039
In fact, during the
entire 35-minute pursuit,
365
00:14:29,064 --> 00:14:31,634
did he commit a single
traffic infraction?
366
00:14:31,636 --> 00:14:34,236
Other than disobeying repeated
requests to pull over, no.
367
00:14:34,455 --> 00:14:35,893
And as soon as he reached his residence,
368
00:14:35,917 --> 00:14:37,337
did he surrender peaceably?
369
00:14:37,475 --> 00:14:38,641
Yes.
370
00:14:38,643 --> 00:14:40,309
But the first thing that you did
371
00:14:40,311 --> 00:14:42,545
was jump out of your cruiser,
with your guns drawn.
372
00:14:42,547 --> 00:14:44,046
Because he could have been a threat.
373
00:14:44,048 --> 00:14:46,439
A 16-year-old who uses his turn signals?
374
00:14:46,464 --> 00:14:49,098
Look, I know you wanna make this
a black thing, but it's not.
375
00:14:49,320 --> 00:14:51,620
Statistically, it is a black thing.
376
00:14:51,622 --> 00:14:55,203
Unarmed black Americans are five
times more likely to be shot
377
00:14:55,228 --> 00:14:57,026
and killed by a police officer
378
00:14:57,028 --> 00:14:58,603
than unarmed white Americans.
379
00:14:58,628 --> 00:15:00,795
You can shout racism all
day long, if you want,
380
00:15:01,298 --> 00:15:03,399
but I have black and brown
brothers on the force,
381
00:15:03,401 --> 00:15:05,330
and we put our lives
on the line every day,
382
00:15:05,478 --> 00:15:06,914
go out in a world that is dangerous
383
00:15:06,939 --> 00:15:08,771
and is armed to the teeth.
384
00:15:09,173 --> 00:15:12,126
You want us to holster our guns?
Be social workers?
385
00:15:12,193 --> 00:15:14,193
TIFFANY: Where was the danger here?
386
00:15:14,312 --> 00:15:15,470
From Heyward?
387
00:15:15,495 --> 00:15:16,928
You saw his hands.
388
00:15:17,118 --> 00:15:18,284
From his dad?
389
00:15:18,716 --> 00:15:20,082
He had his hands in the air
390
00:15:20,084 --> 00:15:23,085
and was begging you not to shoot.
391
00:15:25,845 --> 00:15:28,157
Did you take this picture
of Billy Brennan
392
00:15:28,159 --> 00:15:31,560
- on November 1, 1991?
- Yes, ma'am.
393
00:15:31,562 --> 00:15:34,530
And did Mr. Brennan tell you
how he got the scratch?
394
00:15:34,532 --> 00:15:35,750
His cat.
395
00:15:35,775 --> 00:15:37,961
Did he say how his cat
managed to scratch him
396
00:15:37,986 --> 00:15:40,279
with only one claw, in
a way that looks like,
397
00:15:40,304 --> 00:15:42,430
I don't know, a... a fingernail scratch?
398
00:15:42,455 --> 00:15:44,255
- Objection.
- Sustained.
399
00:15:44,884 --> 00:15:46,087
Fair enough.
400
00:15:46,267 --> 00:15:47,680
ALBERT: Are you aware that
401
00:15:47,705 --> 00:15:49,812
when they scraped Amy's fingernails,
402
00:15:49,814 --> 00:15:51,714
Billy's DNA was not under them?
403
00:15:51,716 --> 00:15:52,822
I heard that, yeah.
404
00:15:52,847 --> 00:15:54,026
So is this exactly what
405
00:15:54,051 --> 00:15:55,712
- Billy's face looked like?
- Yes.
406
00:15:55,923 --> 00:15:57,407
Because if you're gonna
use it as evidence,
407
00:15:57,431 --> 00:15:59,084
it should fairly and accurately
408
00:15:59,109 --> 00:16:01,738
- depict the scratch.
- Sure.
409
00:16:02,760 --> 00:16:05,191
This is from a photographic analyst.
410
00:16:05,293 --> 00:16:07,293
Any chance that you asked the photo unit
411
00:16:07,365 --> 00:16:10,065
to use a red filter to make
the scratch more visible?
412
00:16:10,590 --> 00:16:12,134
I asked them to highlight the scratch
413
00:16:12,464 --> 00:16:13,558
to make it clearer.
414
00:16:13,660 --> 00:16:15,704
You mean fresher, right?
415
00:16:15,706 --> 00:16:18,845
Because scratches tend
to get duller over time.
416
00:16:19,615 --> 00:16:20,948
I-I don't know.
417
00:16:21,629 --> 00:16:23,096
Okay, so how about we take a look
418
00:16:23,121 --> 00:16:24,575
at the original negative
from the picture?
419
00:16:24,599 --> 00:16:27,980
The People concede that the
negative was lost or misplaced.
420
00:16:28,629 --> 00:16:32,152
BOTH: Your Honor, I'd ask
that you instruct the jury...
421
00:16:33,691 --> 00:16:35,457
ALBERT: Your Honor, I'd ask
you to instruct the jury
422
00:16:35,459 --> 00:16:37,292
that they can consider the possibility
423
00:16:37,294 --> 00:16:39,428
that this evidence has been
intentionally destroyed.
424
00:16:39,558 --> 00:16:41,144
No, we never said it was destroyed.
425
00:16:41,169 --> 00:16:43,436
ALBERT: But it's not here,
and a misleading fake is.
426
00:16:43,601 --> 00:16:45,701
Therefore, the jury should
be allowed to conclude
427
00:16:45,703 --> 00:16:47,269
that this evidence was tampered with
428
00:16:47,271 --> 00:16:48,671
on the orders of Grace Russo
429
00:16:48,673 --> 00:16:50,305
- and the D.A.'s office.
- Your Honor...
430
00:16:50,307 --> 00:16:51,996
Save your breath, Ms. Burris.
431
00:16:52,056 --> 00:16:53,361
I'm instructing the jury that,
432
00:16:53,386 --> 00:16:54,957
given the absence of the negative,
433
00:16:54,982 --> 00:16:57,574
they may disregard any evidence
434
00:16:57,757 --> 00:17:00,753
concerning a scratch on Mr.
Brennan's face.
435
00:17:12,559 --> 00:17:15,193
Sorry I jumped up. Instinct.
436
00:17:15,328 --> 00:17:17,851
To be honest, I'm amazed
you held it in that long.
437
00:17:20,467 --> 00:17:22,300
I have speeches planned, you know.
438
00:17:22,302 --> 00:17:24,569
Long speeches, where I tell you
439
00:17:24,571 --> 00:17:26,471
how sorry I am and convince
you to forgive me.
440
00:17:26,473 --> 00:17:28,773
They're pretty good. I
compliment you a lot.
441
00:17:29,017 --> 00:17:31,617
Let's just finish this trial, okay?
442
00:17:36,720 --> 00:17:38,587
Want some?
443
00:17:39,975 --> 00:17:41,319
Look, I know after the past few days
444
00:17:41,321 --> 00:17:43,354
it seems like the whole world knows,
445
00:17:43,356 --> 00:17:46,424
but really, this is just me
offering you a candy bar.
446
00:17:50,764 --> 00:17:52,903
I would never use you as my
get out of jail free card...
447
00:17:52,927 --> 00:17:54,932
You know that.
448
00:17:55,105 --> 00:17:57,341
Yeah, I know.
449
00:18:03,412 --> 00:18:06,490
I was at work when Heyward called.
450
00:18:06,584 --> 00:18:07,904
He was totally panicked.
451
00:18:07,990 --> 00:18:09,381
CAMERON: What did he tell you?
452
00:18:09,406 --> 00:18:11,773
He said he was in his car
being chased by the cops.
453
00:18:12,060 --> 00:18:14,260
I told him to keep his hands
where they could see them,
454
00:18:15,060 --> 00:18:17,021
drive safely, and to come home.
455
00:18:17,193 --> 00:18:18,912
Why did you tell him to come home?
456
00:18:19,084 --> 00:18:21,292
All I could think about was Tamir Rice,
457
00:18:21,294 --> 00:18:23,227
the young boy they shot
down in Cleveland,
458
00:18:23,229 --> 00:18:25,997
and I felt that, if he was home,
459
00:18:25,999 --> 00:18:28,935
maybe I could control the situation...
460
00:18:29,999 --> 00:18:31,566
protect my child.
461
00:18:31,623 --> 00:18:33,304
And I just started praying,
462
00:18:33,306 --> 00:18:37,310
please, God, don't let 'em kill my son.
463
00:18:38,334 --> 00:18:39,577
CAMERON: While you were praying,
464
00:18:39,579 --> 00:18:41,145
what did you do?
465
00:18:41,147 --> 00:18:43,314
ERIC: I kept talking to Heyward,
466
00:18:43,316 --> 00:18:45,295
trying to keep him calm.
467
00:18:45,320 --> 00:18:47,440
Make sure he didn't do
anything to make things worse.
468
00:18:48,029 --> 00:18:49,153
And I was at work,
469
00:18:49,155 --> 00:18:50,591
so I asked my colleague
470
00:18:50,616 --> 00:18:52,767
to call my wife and tell her
471
00:18:52,792 --> 00:18:54,712
to meet me in front of the
house with her phone.
472
00:18:54,740 --> 00:18:58,435
If something went wrong, I
wanted the world to see.
473
00:18:59,685 --> 00:19:01,599
Do you hate the police, Mr. Taylor?
474
00:19:01,601 --> 00:19:04,920
No. My uncle's a cop.
475
00:19:05,537 --> 00:19:08,365
I-I know it's not easy. I know that.
476
00:19:09,638 --> 00:19:12,877
But watching your son walk out each day,
477
00:19:13,966 --> 00:19:16,514
wondering if he's gonna be all right,
478
00:19:17,578 --> 00:19:20,388
that's not easy either.
479
00:19:26,690 --> 00:19:28,891
Did you ever have "the
talk" with your son?
480
00:19:29,229 --> 00:19:32,096
If you're asking if I talked to Heyward
481
00:19:32,098 --> 00:19:33,531
about the realities of growing up
482
00:19:33,533 --> 00:19:37,468
as a young black man in America... yes.
483
00:19:37,470 --> 00:19:39,537
Did you tell him to
listen to the police?
484
00:19:39,539 --> 00:19:40,576
Of course.
485
00:19:40,710 --> 00:19:42,543
That the most important
thing was to comply,
486
00:19:43,273 --> 00:19:45,206
and always show your hands?
487
00:19:45,631 --> 00:19:47,428
Yes.
488
00:19:48,114 --> 00:19:50,948
And that lesson goes against
everything I want my son to be.
489
00:19:51,170 --> 00:19:54,585
I want to raise a strong,
independent young man.
490
00:19:55,232 --> 00:19:57,288
But instead, I have to teach my child
491
00:19:57,290 --> 00:20:01,084
that every time he sees
blue, he has to submit.
492
00:20:02,076 --> 00:20:04,439
Lay down on the ground...
493
00:20:04,464 --> 00:20:06,664
like a dog.
494
00:20:08,067 --> 00:20:11,235
To be clear, you did
teach him to submit,
495
00:20:11,623 --> 00:20:14,438
and your son knew what
he was supposed to do,
496
00:20:15,541 --> 00:20:18,123
he just didn't do it.
497
00:20:24,705 --> 00:20:27,674
WOMAN: Amy died as a result of
blunt force trauma to the head.
498
00:20:27,768 --> 00:20:30,173
A portion of Amy's skull
was actually crushed,
499
00:20:30,198 --> 00:20:32,034
causing a large subdural hematoma...
500
00:20:32,229 --> 00:20:33,658
Bleeding inside the brain.
501
00:20:33,660 --> 00:20:34,792
Do you recognize this?
502
00:20:34,817 --> 00:20:37,729
- Yes, that's the murder weapon.
- How do you know?
503
00:20:37,921 --> 00:20:40,354
The contour is a match
for the indentation
504
00:20:40,379 --> 00:20:41,932
on the side of Amy's head.
505
00:20:43,723 --> 00:20:45,690
And what is this?
506
00:20:46,255 --> 00:20:47,534
MAYA: It's a latent print
507
00:20:47,559 --> 00:20:48,859
lifted from the murder weapon...
508
00:20:49,045 --> 00:20:50,669
- Billy Brennan's.
- Were there any other prints
509
00:20:50,693 --> 00:20:52,498
- on the weapon?
- Yes, quite a few.
510
00:20:52,523 --> 00:20:54,285
Amy's, other kids at the party.
511
00:20:54,310 --> 00:20:55,579
The weapon was passed around.
512
00:20:55,581 --> 00:20:58,015
Anything different about
Billy Brennan's prints?
513
00:20:58,380 --> 00:21:01,193
Yes. Dr. Brennan's prints
were lifted from two loci...
514
00:21:01,279 --> 00:21:03,621
A thumbprint, at the
base of the scepter,
515
00:21:03,623 --> 00:21:04,956
and an index finger, just below
516
00:21:04,958 --> 00:21:06,557
and at 45 degrees to the thumbprint.
517
00:21:06,559 --> 00:21:08,759
Dr. Reyez, what do you
conclude about the position
518
00:21:08,761 --> 00:21:10,027
of the two prints?
519
00:21:10,029 --> 00:21:11,529
Well, unlike the rest of the prints,
520
00:21:11,531 --> 00:21:13,831
which appear at various
locations on the scepter,
521
00:21:13,833 --> 00:21:15,666
Dr. Brennan appears to have
gripped it at the base,
522
00:21:15,668 --> 00:21:17,301
which is consistent with using it
523
00:21:17,303 --> 00:21:18,578
to inflict the lethal blow.
524
00:21:18,603 --> 00:21:21,235
Did you run a DNA analysis
of the blood on the scepter?
525
00:21:21,441 --> 00:21:22,711
MAYA: Yes. It was Amy's.
526
00:21:22,736 --> 00:21:24,313
BURRIS: Was there any other blood?
527
00:21:24,338 --> 00:21:26,738
MAYA: A minute trace, almost invisible.
528
00:21:27,046 --> 00:21:28,245
Was it Billy Brennan's?
529
00:21:28,330 --> 00:21:29,547
It was not.
530
00:21:29,798 --> 00:21:32,016
Oh, before the defense makes
a big deal out of that...
531
00:21:32,018 --> 00:21:34,685
(chuckles) ...did this
finding surprise you?
532
00:21:34,687 --> 00:21:36,787
No. Given how small the quantity was,
533
00:21:36,789 --> 00:21:39,256
I just assumed it was the result
of transitory crime scene
534
00:21:39,258 --> 00:21:40,992
or laboratory contamination.
535
00:21:44,497 --> 00:21:47,264
If someone else's blood
were on the scepter,
536
00:21:47,266 --> 00:21:48,699
wouldn't that be powerful evidence
537
00:21:48,701 --> 00:21:50,101
of Billy Brennan's innocence?
538
00:21:50,103 --> 00:21:51,347
Well, that depends...
539
00:21:51,372 --> 00:21:54,105
Let's put it a different way.
If the DNA matched,
540
00:21:54,252 --> 00:21:55,421
wouldn't you be here claiming
541
00:21:55,446 --> 00:21:57,182
that was powerful evidence
of Billy's guilt?
542
00:21:57,206 --> 00:21:59,010
- Possibly.
- But since that other blood sample
543
00:21:59,012 --> 00:22:00,378
would point to his innocence,
544
00:22:00,636 --> 00:22:02,113
you've chosen instead to suggest
545
00:22:02,115 --> 00:22:03,180
it was contamination.
546
00:22:03,182 --> 00:22:04,315
It has all the hallmarks
547
00:22:04,317 --> 00:22:05,416
of contamination.
548
00:22:05,418 --> 00:22:06,617
From the lab, probably.
549
00:22:06,619 --> 00:22:08,152
ALBERT: And if a lab is contaminated,
550
00:22:08,154 --> 00:22:10,454
you can't trust the results
of any tests they perform?
551
00:22:10,456 --> 00:22:12,556
It would certainly prove more difficult.
552
00:22:12,558 --> 00:22:14,125
The last four times you testified,
553
00:22:14,127 --> 00:22:16,594
when you wanted to nail
someone with DNA evidence,
554
00:22:16,596 --> 00:22:18,019
you insisted that, quote,
555
00:22:18,050 --> 00:22:21,209
"Contamination is a
virtual impossibility."
556
00:22:21,644 --> 00:22:22,714
MAYA: Yes.
557
00:22:22,739 --> 00:22:24,855
So when the prosecution
wants the DNA to match,
558
00:22:24,909 --> 00:22:27,238
contamination is "a
virtual impossibility;"
559
00:22:27,240 --> 00:22:28,839
when they don't like the results,
560
00:22:28,864 --> 00:22:30,674
they see contamination everywhere.
561
00:22:30,676 --> 00:22:32,710
It's heads I win, tails you lose,
562
00:22:32,712 --> 00:22:35,519
except the winner is always
Grace Russo, and the loser
563
00:22:35,651 --> 00:22:37,748
is always the person she's prosecuting.
564
00:22:38,034 --> 00:22:39,350
SADIE: Albert's killing it.
565
00:22:39,352 --> 00:22:40,951
- That's great.
- Yeah.
566
00:22:40,953 --> 00:22:42,386
It really is.
567
00:22:42,489 --> 00:22:43,755
Except...
568
00:22:44,542 --> 00:22:46,347
I mean, is he ever gonna forgive me?
569
00:22:46,372 --> 00:22:47,705
You just have to give him time.
570
00:22:47,956 --> 00:22:49,727
God, I really messed things up.
571
00:22:49,768 --> 00:22:51,034
Yeah.
572
00:22:51,667 --> 00:22:54,198
I invited you to drinks to cheer me up.
573
00:22:54,456 --> 00:22:55,933
How's Billy?
574
00:22:56,768 --> 00:22:58,072
I don't know, it's weird.
575
00:22:58,097 --> 00:23:00,090
It's like we got caught making
out under the bleachers,
576
00:23:00,114 --> 00:23:02,225
and now we can't look at
each other in the hallway.
577
00:23:02,558 --> 00:23:04,208
Peter's the D.A. on my graffiti case
578
00:23:04,210 --> 00:23:06,077
and he's trying to put
my client in jail.
579
00:23:06,391 --> 00:23:07,600
Ouch.
580
00:23:07,625 --> 00:23:09,814
I know. I listen to him argue,
581
00:23:09,922 --> 00:23:12,383
and I actually... I hate him.
582
00:23:12,664 --> 00:23:13,984
But then we get outside the courtroom
583
00:23:13,986 --> 00:23:18,222
and he smiles and asks to
come over and I just say yes.
584
00:23:18,852 --> 00:23:20,991
He's a good guy in a bad job.
585
00:23:21,367 --> 00:23:23,327
Doesn't that just make him a bad guy?
586
00:23:23,329 --> 00:23:24,995
You're asking the person
sleeping with the guy
587
00:23:24,997 --> 00:23:26,797
on trial for murder.
588
00:23:28,570 --> 00:23:30,484
Who are we? (Laughs)
589
00:23:30,570 --> 00:23:32,803
You know you have to disclose
your relationship, right?
590
00:23:33,367 --> 00:23:34,705
To who?
591
00:23:34,984 --> 00:23:36,740
Your clients, the judge.
592
00:23:38,117 --> 00:23:39,643
We're not letting it interfere.
593
00:23:39,645 --> 00:23:41,545
Yeah. That's what I said.
594
00:23:41,719 --> 00:23:43,647
Now look at me.
595
00:23:43,649 --> 00:23:45,182
(sighs)
596
00:23:45,184 --> 00:23:48,385
♪ Baby, I can't breathe. ♪
597
00:23:49,984 --> 00:23:51,222
Look who I found in the break room
598
00:23:51,224 --> 00:23:52,709
searching for snacks.
599
00:23:52,734 --> 00:23:53,958
I'm gonna be here all night prepping
600
00:23:53,960 --> 00:23:55,860
for Molly's testimony, so I brought him.
601
00:23:55,862 --> 00:23:57,962
- Need any help?
- I got it.
602
00:23:59,398 --> 00:24:01,465
Scott Davis, tell Albert
if he needs help, I'll be
603
00:24:01,467 --> 00:24:04,231
in the other room, and I'm an
expert on Molly's testimony.
604
00:24:04,341 --> 00:24:07,171
Scott Davis, tell Sadie she
can go home because I'm fine.
605
00:24:07,567 --> 00:24:11,108
Tell him that I literally have
the tapes committed to memory.
606
00:24:11,333 --> 00:24:12,543
I'm really fine.
607
00:24:13,067 --> 00:24:14,945
Let's let Scott Davis decide, shall we?
608
00:24:15,528 --> 00:24:17,181
I'll put him in the middle of the room.
609
00:24:17,385 --> 00:24:20,386
Whoever he goes to does Molly's cross.
610
00:24:23,099 --> 00:24:24,455
I'm doing the cross.
611
00:24:24,981 --> 00:24:26,200
(gasps)
612
00:24:26,225 --> 00:24:28,505
He's such a smart little guy.
613
00:24:28,794 --> 00:24:30,761
I'm doing the cross.
614
00:24:30,934 --> 00:24:33,631
Okay. If you have any questions at all,
615
00:24:33,633 --> 00:24:34,698
I'll be in my office.
616
00:24:34,700 --> 00:24:36,267
Sadie, go home.
617
00:24:36,292 --> 00:24:38,897
You just have to get an opening
to introduce the tapes.
618
00:24:39,115 --> 00:24:40,538
I know.
619
00:24:40,540 --> 00:24:43,607
And if there's any contradiction
to anything on the tapes,
620
00:24:43,609 --> 00:24:46,155
it's not hearsay anymore, you
can use it to impeach her.
621
00:24:46,180 --> 00:24:47,244
I know.
622
00:24:47,246 --> 00:24:49,092
She's gonna be totally blindsided,
623
00:24:49,117 --> 00:24:51,225
so you have to attack right then.
624
00:24:51,467 --> 00:24:52,850
I know.
625
00:24:53,030 --> 00:24:54,944
I know you know.
626
00:24:55,092 --> 00:24:56,185
(sighs)
627
00:24:56,227 --> 00:24:58,994
I'm just a little bit sad,
628
00:24:59,825 --> 00:25:02,493
and a little bit drunk,
629
00:25:03,061 --> 00:25:05,045
and I don't want to miss
the moment when you decide
630
00:25:05,069 --> 00:25:07,717
to let go of your totally
justifiable anger
631
00:25:07,742 --> 00:25:09,522
and forgive me.
632
00:25:10,667 --> 00:25:12,534
(exhales)
633
00:25:14,242 --> 00:25:15,506
Hey, buddy.
634
00:25:17,462 --> 00:25:20,563
You don't think I'm a
potted plant, do you?
635
00:25:21,781 --> 00:25:23,961
(inhales, exhales)
636
00:25:25,117 --> 00:25:27,557
WOMAN (on TV): Hey, why do you
even bother coming in to work?
637
00:25:27,651 --> 00:25:30,354
Hey, you are putting the kid
on the stand tomorrow, right?
638
00:25:30,760 --> 00:25:31,800
We shouldn't be talking
639
00:25:31,857 --> 00:25:33,315
about the case, that's a conflict.
640
00:25:33,340 --> 00:25:35,503
I'm not asking anything specific.
641
00:25:35,528 --> 00:25:38,034
You're trying to put my
16-year-old client in jail.
642
00:25:38,136 --> 00:25:40,136
- I'm not gonna help.
- Sorry.
643
00:25:41,526 --> 00:25:43,200
You're working on your
cross of my client
644
00:25:43,202 --> 00:25:45,369
while you're watching TV with me?
645
00:25:45,745 --> 00:25:47,972
When was I supposed to prepare?
646
00:25:47,974 --> 00:25:50,708
See? That's the problem right there.
647
00:25:56,771 --> 00:25:58,424
What's going on?
648
00:26:00,274 --> 00:26:02,219
I think we should
disclose our relationship
649
00:26:02,836 --> 00:26:05,756
to my clients and to the court.
650
00:26:06,656 --> 00:26:07,858
Really?
651
00:26:08,383 --> 00:26:11,050
It's the right thing to do.
652
00:26:13,750 --> 00:26:15,343
Yeah.
653
00:26:15,993 --> 00:26:17,401
Yeah, it probably is.
654
00:26:18,149 --> 00:26:21,572
You know that means that
everyone will know we're dating.
655
00:26:24,219 --> 00:26:26,410
Are you ready for that?
656
00:26:27,586 --> 00:26:29,713
Are you ready?
657
00:26:30,472 --> 00:26:32,093
Yes.
658
00:26:33,288 --> 00:26:34,552
Okay.
659
00:26:43,124 --> 00:26:44,233
Get up.
660
00:26:44,258 --> 00:26:45,791
What?
661
00:26:46,404 --> 00:26:47,537
Where...
662
00:26:47,586 --> 00:26:49,052
Get dressed and have some coffee.
663
00:26:49,347 --> 00:26:50,674
I'm gonna drop Scott Davis at daycare
664
00:26:50,698 --> 00:26:51,967
and meet you at court.
665
00:26:52,001 --> 00:26:54,131
I was up all night prepping
for Molly's cross.
666
00:26:54,156 --> 00:26:55,881
Then I realized I was
letting my feelings
667
00:26:55,935 --> 00:26:57,201
get in the way of my job.
668
00:26:57,226 --> 00:27:00,027
Our client deserves the best
defense, and the fact is,
669
00:27:00,154 --> 00:27:02,220
you know Molly's tapes better than I do,
670
00:27:02,363 --> 00:27:04,811
so you'll be doing the cross.
671
00:27:04,864 --> 00:27:06,522
Also, you snore.
672
00:27:06,574 --> 00:27:08,140
Oh, God, thank you.
673
00:27:08,165 --> 00:27:09,999
You're not making a mistake.
I won't let you down.
674
00:27:10,023 --> 00:27:12,190
I mean, I know that I have
already let you down,
675
00:27:12,215 --> 00:27:14,849
I'm just saying I won't again.
676
00:27:14,874 --> 00:27:16,841
You get it.
677
00:27:19,160 --> 00:27:20,326
Okay.
678
00:27:20,328 --> 00:27:21,715
Sorry, we're not there yet.
679
00:27:21,740 --> 00:27:23,674
You can't be thinking about
Billy's feelings up there.
680
00:27:23,698 --> 00:27:25,354
- We need to destroy her.
- I will.
681
00:27:25,566 --> 00:27:27,666
I mean I won't. I mean,
682
00:27:28,002 --> 00:27:29,401
won't think, will destroy.
683
00:27:29,473 --> 00:27:30,793
I'm gonna get dressed.
684
00:27:30,818 --> 00:27:32,543
- Good.
- I don't snore.
685
00:27:34,023 --> 00:27:36,365
I don't snore.
686
00:27:37,747 --> 00:27:39,211
Hey, Tiff.
687
00:27:39,848 --> 00:27:42,207
So I need to tell you something.
688
00:27:42,232 --> 00:27:43,465
I'm in a relationship.
689
00:27:43,540 --> 00:27:44,879
- With Albert.
- What?
690
00:27:44,904 --> 00:27:46,403
Oh, I knew it. I have to tell Nick.
691
00:27:46,589 --> 00:27:48,356
I'm not in a relationship
with Albert. I...
692
00:27:48,381 --> 00:27:50,825
What's A.D.A. Lowman doing here?
693
00:27:52,388 --> 00:27:53,863
Where's Mr. Garrett?
694
00:27:54,010 --> 00:27:55,433
A.D.A. Garrett's home sick,
695
00:27:55,730 --> 00:27:56,962
so I'll be taking over the case.
696
00:27:56,964 --> 00:27:59,097
Meet the new jerk, same as the old jerk.
697
00:27:59,122 --> 00:28:02,556
So, who are you in a relationship with?
698
00:28:02,867 --> 00:28:04,901
No one.
699
00:28:05,965 --> 00:28:08,598
(wand chirping)
700
00:28:12,595 --> 00:28:14,528
You nervous?
701
00:28:15,000 --> 00:28:17,167
Yeah, I didn't sleep
very well last night.
702
00:28:18,486 --> 00:28:19,952
- Good morning.
- Good morning.
703
00:28:19,954 --> 00:28:22,074
- Good morning, Isaiah.
- Uh, Sadie, give us a minute.
704
00:28:23,390 --> 00:28:25,516
Yesterday, you asked
me to be your father.
705
00:28:25,541 --> 00:28:27,007
I'm obliging.
706
00:28:34,338 --> 00:28:35,437
I promised her mother
707
00:28:35,462 --> 00:28:36,755
I'd take care of her.
708
00:28:36,864 --> 00:28:38,792
I take that job very seriously.
709
00:28:38,817 --> 00:28:40,833
- I know you do.
- Sadie loves you.
710
00:28:41,208 --> 00:28:42,786
And if we win this trial,
711
00:28:42,811 --> 00:28:45,505
I will welcome you into
my family with open arms.
712
00:28:45,530 --> 00:28:46,729
Thank you for that.
713
00:28:46,832 --> 00:28:49,637
But we both know that might not happen.
714
00:28:49,771 --> 00:28:51,348
She won't give up on you,
715
00:28:51,594 --> 00:28:54,317
so you have to be the one to let her go.
716
00:28:54,516 --> 00:28:56,731
Am I being clear?
717
00:29:00,762 --> 00:29:04,089
Everyone at school was tagging
and Instagramming pictures,
718
00:29:04,114 --> 00:29:07,782
so I hit this place in the
Bronx, and I'm doing it.
719
00:29:07,807 --> 00:29:09,640
And then this cop walks up,
720
00:29:09,665 --> 00:29:12,599
and I just... panic.
721
00:29:12,883 --> 00:29:14,910
And when he said "Stop,"
it was like instinct,
722
00:29:14,935 --> 00:29:16,167
I just took off.
723
00:29:16,740 --> 00:29:18,736
I wasn't thinking straight.
724
00:29:20,253 --> 00:29:22,433
I thought I was gonna die.
725
00:29:24,296 --> 00:29:26,830
What made you think that?
726
00:29:27,566 --> 00:29:29,799
'Cause I see it.
727
00:29:30,294 --> 00:29:32,949
YouTube, the news,
728
00:29:32,974 --> 00:29:35,775
people who look like me getting shot
729
00:29:35,800 --> 00:29:37,833
and, and choked out.
730
00:29:37,972 --> 00:29:41,172
And then I thought, maybe
the cop would see,
731
00:29:41,233 --> 00:29:43,055
see that I have a mom
732
00:29:43,080 --> 00:29:46,359
and a dad and this nice house.
733
00:29:47,675 --> 00:29:51,398
See that I'm, I'm somebody, you know?
734
00:29:52,492 --> 00:29:56,060
And then, I-I see my dad, on the lawn.
735
00:29:56,085 --> 00:29:57,885
I saw his face.
736
00:30:01,955 --> 00:30:04,396
And I knew it didn't matter.
737
00:30:04,956 --> 00:30:06,107
Why?
738
00:30:06,378 --> 00:30:07,544
'Cause they came at us
739
00:30:07,585 --> 00:30:08,776
with their guns,
740
00:30:08,801 --> 00:30:10,468
like we're nothing,
741
00:30:10,493 --> 00:30:12,893
like my dad is nothing.
742
00:30:12,918 --> 00:30:14,925
And then my dad's grabbing me,
743
00:30:14,950 --> 00:30:17,316
and my mom's screaming...
744
00:30:19,864 --> 00:30:21,558
I'm sorry.
745
00:30:23,283 --> 00:30:24,917
I'm sorry.
746
00:30:25,327 --> 00:30:26,549
I'm sorry.
747
00:30:26,574 --> 00:30:28,269
I'm so... I'm so sorry.
748
00:30:35,710 --> 00:30:37,762
Amy and I were friends.
749
00:30:37,787 --> 00:30:38,991
Really good friends.
750
00:30:39,016 --> 00:30:40,415
So, she confided in you?
751
00:30:40,623 --> 00:30:41,749
Yes.
752
00:30:41,774 --> 00:30:43,407
She told me all kinds of things,
753
00:30:43,968 --> 00:30:45,626
personal things,
754
00:30:45,628 --> 00:30:49,797
about life and school, and Billy.
755
00:30:50,647 --> 00:30:52,616
She was gonna break up
with him that night.
756
00:30:52,641 --> 00:30:53,740
Do you know why?
757
00:30:53,765 --> 00:30:55,031
He was awful.
758
00:30:55,338 --> 00:30:57,805
Abusive, controlling.
759
00:30:57,807 --> 00:30:58,998
Abusive?
760
00:30:59,023 --> 00:31:00,523
He'd make fun of the way she dressed,
761
00:31:00,548 --> 00:31:02,815
or if she said something stupid.
762
00:31:03,202 --> 00:31:04,787
He slept with her best friend
763
00:31:04,812 --> 00:31:06,114
while she was away at camp.
764
00:31:06,859 --> 00:31:08,683
And he didn't even try to hide it.
765
00:31:08,812 --> 00:31:10,468
So the night of the murder...
766
00:31:10,573 --> 00:31:13,601
I was on my way to the
party to check on her,
767
00:31:13,683 --> 00:31:16,077
and I walked past the park.
768
00:31:16,118 --> 00:31:17,551
BURRIS: What did you see?
769
00:31:17,615 --> 00:31:19,304
Billy...
770
00:31:20,563 --> 00:31:22,630
standing over Amy.
771
00:31:23,023 --> 00:31:24,298
Over her body.
772
00:31:24,546 --> 00:31:26,054
And he had this look.
773
00:31:26,079 --> 00:31:27,345
BURRIS: Ms. Han.
774
00:31:27,450 --> 00:31:29,483
What did you do when
you saw the defendant
775
00:31:29,508 --> 00:31:32,276
standing over Amy's dead body?
776
00:31:32,672 --> 00:31:34,038
I freaked out.
777
00:31:34,063 --> 00:31:36,312
I ran home, I told my mom...
778
00:31:38,273 --> 00:31:40,109
"I think Billy did something to Amy."
779
00:31:40,134 --> 00:31:42,866
And how did your mother
respond when you said that?
780
00:31:46,941 --> 00:31:49,786
She told me she'd take care of it.
781
00:31:50,748 --> 00:31:53,256
And a few weeks later, she did.
782
00:31:53,516 --> 00:31:56,350
She put me on a plane back to Korea.
783
00:31:57,256 --> 00:31:59,084
She told me my birth mother
784
00:31:59,150 --> 00:32:01,646
sued to get me back.
785
00:32:04,206 --> 00:32:06,540
And I never saw her or Billy again.
786
00:32:11,411 --> 00:32:14,435
When we're asked to apply laws to facts,
787
00:32:14,523 --> 00:32:16,356
context matters.
788
00:32:16,498 --> 00:32:17,864
So let's talk about the context
789
00:32:17,889 --> 00:32:19,271
of this case.
790
00:32:19,342 --> 00:32:21,090
About Mike Brown, Eric Garner
791
00:32:21,115 --> 00:32:23,354
and young Tamir Rice.
792
00:32:23,356 --> 00:32:25,014
We've all seen the videos.
793
00:32:25,083 --> 00:32:26,750
Black men, black children,
794
00:32:26,838 --> 00:32:28,704
some with their hands up,
795
00:32:28,729 --> 00:32:30,496
gunned down by the police.
796
00:32:30,897 --> 00:32:32,459
People are scared.
797
00:32:32,484 --> 00:32:34,185
Parents, cops.
798
00:32:34,316 --> 00:32:37,396
So when your child calls you, terrified
799
00:32:37,421 --> 00:32:39,421
and being chased by the police,
800
00:32:39,446 --> 00:32:42,771
you can't be surprised when a
black father tells his only son,
801
00:32:42,895 --> 00:32:45,929
not to pull over, but
to drive carefully,
802
00:32:45,954 --> 00:32:47,354
obey the laws,
803
00:32:47,379 --> 00:32:49,646
keep your hands where they can see them,
804
00:32:49,671 --> 00:32:52,537
and to come home now.
805
00:32:53,576 --> 00:32:54,756
The prosecution
806
00:32:54,781 --> 00:32:57,616
wants you to convict this
young man, for what?
807
00:32:57,705 --> 00:32:58,870
Escape?
808
00:32:59,334 --> 00:33:01,318
He never tried to get away.
809
00:33:01,736 --> 00:33:03,271
For obstructing?
810
00:33:03,332 --> 00:33:05,265
He didn't obstruct anyone.
811
00:33:06,065 --> 00:33:08,889
Heyward wasn't trying to avoid arrest.
812
00:33:09,014 --> 00:33:12,600
He was just trying to make
sure he didn't wind up dead.
813
00:33:16,955 --> 00:33:21,267
26 years of never telling
this to the police or anyone,
814
00:33:21,596 --> 00:33:25,548
but then Grace Russo's office
tracks you down in Korea,
815
00:33:25,970 --> 00:33:27,502
and suddenly you remember all of it?
816
00:33:27,544 --> 00:33:29,744
I always remembered, just never told.
817
00:33:29,840 --> 00:33:31,463
And we should believe you now?
818
00:33:31,545 --> 00:33:33,945
I'm not lying, if that's
what you're asking.
819
00:33:34,298 --> 00:33:36,775
SADIE: You just testified
that the night of the murder
820
00:33:36,853 --> 00:33:39,306
you were on your way to the
party to check on Amy.
821
00:33:39,331 --> 00:33:40,765
- That's right.
- The Halloween party
822
00:33:40,789 --> 00:33:43,056
- that you were invited to?
- Yes.
823
00:33:43,234 --> 00:33:45,334
- And you're sure about that?
- I'm sure.
824
00:33:45,367 --> 00:33:47,763
SADIE: As sure as you are about
the rest of your testimony?
825
00:33:47,828 --> 00:33:50,560
- What you claim you saw that night?
- MOLLY: Yes.
826
00:33:52,848 --> 00:33:54,281
YOUNG MOLLY: I don't know.
827
00:33:54,306 --> 00:33:55,909
Amy's spending all her time with Billy,
828
00:33:55,934 --> 00:33:58,168
- and it just all sucks.
- Wait.
829
00:33:58,351 --> 00:34:00,685
They didn't even invite me
to the Halloween party.
830
00:34:00,710 --> 00:34:02,899
- What was that?
- I'm gonna ask you again.
831
00:34:02,924 --> 00:34:05,327
Objection, I have no
idea what that tape is.
832
00:34:05,389 --> 00:34:06,822
They are Ms. Han's therapy tapes,
833
00:34:06,847 --> 00:34:09,281
and I am allowed to use
them to impeach her.
834
00:34:09,306 --> 00:34:10,561
Not without a foundation.
835
00:34:10,586 --> 00:34:12,086
Those are private.
836
00:34:14,057 --> 00:34:15,284
You gave them to her?
837
00:34:15,309 --> 00:34:17,753
JUDGE MENDOZA: Sounds to me like
she just laid the foundation.
838
00:34:17,777 --> 00:34:19,010
Sorry, Ms. Burris.
839
00:34:19,616 --> 00:34:21,010
SADIE: Ms. Han,
840
00:34:21,035 --> 00:34:23,791
were you invited to the
Halloween party or not?
841
00:34:23,816 --> 00:34:24,988
Because if you weren't invited,
842
00:34:25,012 --> 00:34:27,300
I find it hard to believe that
you went, and if you didn't,
843
00:34:27,324 --> 00:34:29,271
then why would you have been
in the park that night?
844
00:34:29,295 --> 00:34:31,728
You gave those to them?
845
00:34:31,769 --> 00:34:34,203
Tapes to my therapy sessions?
846
00:34:34,228 --> 00:34:36,028
To my therapy sessions?
847
00:34:36,053 --> 00:34:37,320
That's enough. Tell her to stop.
848
00:34:37,344 --> 00:34:39,416
If you want to win, shut up.
849
00:34:39,670 --> 00:34:42,534
SADIE: Were you really
in the park that night?
850
00:34:42,559 --> 00:34:43,541
MOLLY: No.
851
00:34:43,566 --> 00:34:45,620
No, I'm not gonna let you do this to me.
852
00:34:45,645 --> 00:34:46,815
Sit down.
853
00:34:46,840 --> 00:34:47,924
Ms. Han.
854
00:34:47,949 --> 00:34:49,018
Please.
855
00:34:49,043 --> 00:34:50,229
They can't do this to me,
856
00:34:50,254 --> 00:34:52,340
- I'm not on trial here.
- Please, Ms. Brennan.
857
00:34:52,365 --> 00:34:54,698
I am not a Brennan!
858
00:34:55,013 --> 00:34:57,280
I never was!
859
00:34:59,134 --> 00:35:00,267
Don't...
860
00:35:00,292 --> 00:35:01,758
Don't you see what they're doing?
861
00:35:04,116 --> 00:35:06,681
They're evil.
862
00:35:07,503 --> 00:35:10,571
He killed her.
863
00:35:10,823 --> 00:35:12,389
You killed her!
864
00:35:12,391 --> 00:35:13,557
I know it!
865
00:35:13,559 --> 00:35:14,892
- I saw it!
- JUDGE MENDOZA: Ms. Han.
866
00:35:14,894 --> 00:35:16,460
Please.
867
00:35:20,527 --> 00:35:22,032
Ms. Ellis.
868
00:35:22,574 --> 00:35:24,635
There's something else I'd
like you to listen to.
869
00:35:24,637 --> 00:35:25,836
Please, it's not fair.
870
00:35:26,152 --> 00:35:27,464
It's not fair.
871
00:35:27,489 --> 00:35:29,389
YOUNG MOLLY: I got the
pills, and I just...
872
00:35:29,980 --> 00:35:32,991
I just thought, anything's
better than this.
873
00:35:33,079 --> 00:35:36,980
Just two weeks before
you claim you saw Billy
874
00:35:37,005 --> 00:35:39,339
standing over Amy's body,
875
00:35:39,585 --> 00:35:41,652
you tried to kill yourself.
876
00:35:43,394 --> 00:35:45,768
You people are sick.
877
00:35:46,972 --> 00:35:48,941
You know that?
878
00:35:49,649 --> 00:35:51,048
(crying)
879
00:35:51,599 --> 00:35:53,433
Trying to destroy me
880
00:35:54,100 --> 00:35:56,033
to protect him.
881
00:35:58,478 --> 00:36:01,025
I understand why you would say that now.
882
00:36:01,050 --> 00:36:04,284
After 26 years of choking on anger
883
00:36:04,340 --> 00:36:06,728
and alienation.
884
00:36:07,913 --> 00:36:10,283
I have just one more thing.
885
00:36:10,704 --> 00:36:13,672
A statement from the same session.
886
00:36:14,158 --> 00:36:15,814
YOUNG MOLLY: I'm so messed up.
887
00:36:15,839 --> 00:36:19,126
I don't even know what's
real or what's true anymore.
888
00:36:22,061 --> 00:36:23,494
Nothing further.
889
00:36:26,255 --> 00:36:27,688
(sniffling)
890
00:36:39,490 --> 00:36:41,793
JUDGE ROUTBORT: On the counts
charging escape, obstructing,
891
00:36:41,817 --> 00:36:44,427
resisting, and unlawful
flight in a motor vehicle,
892
00:36:44,872 --> 00:36:47,473
I find the respondent not guilty.
893
00:36:48,108 --> 00:36:50,138
As to the charge of making graffiti,
894
00:36:50,803 --> 00:36:52,098
I am entering a finding
895
00:36:52,123 --> 00:36:53,802
of guilty against the respondent.
896
00:36:53,865 --> 00:36:55,959
Your Honor, the People would like
to be heard as to sentencing.
897
00:36:55,983 --> 00:36:57,370
On a misdemeanor?
898
00:36:57,395 --> 00:36:58,724
Under the Family Court Act,
899
00:36:58,749 --> 00:37:00,044
you are obligated to consider
900
00:37:00,069 --> 00:37:02,204
not merely the nature and
circumstances of the offense,
901
00:37:02,228 --> 00:37:04,092
- but also the character of the child.
- Honor roll, student council.
902
00:37:04,116 --> 00:37:05,731
This is a young man who doesn't listen.
903
00:37:06,060 --> 00:37:08,075
The People are asking
you to send a message
904
00:37:08,100 --> 00:37:09,466
that ignoring law enforcement
905
00:37:09,491 --> 00:37:10,924
will not be tolerated.
906
00:37:11,065 --> 00:37:14,100
We request a term of one
year in juvenile detention.
907
00:37:14,631 --> 00:37:16,343
Literally nothing will be gained
908
00:37:16,368 --> 00:37:18,677
- by incarcerating this kid.
- Actually, Ms. Wirth,
909
00:37:18,763 --> 00:37:21,191
incarceration is a powerful tool,
910
00:37:21,193 --> 00:37:22,825
and, unfortunately, my job
911
00:37:22,850 --> 00:37:25,685
requires me to consider whether
subjecting a decent young man
912
00:37:25,710 --> 00:37:28,744
to time in a penal institution is just.
913
00:37:29,505 --> 00:37:32,535
But that does require context
and it also requires me
914
00:37:32,537 --> 00:37:35,067
to acknowledge that we
all have a problem.
915
00:37:36,036 --> 00:37:37,574
We're living in a world
where kids fear cops,
916
00:37:37,576 --> 00:37:39,820
and cops fear kids.
917
00:37:40,719 --> 00:37:42,836
And the sad thing is, I
only have jurisdiction over
918
00:37:42,861 --> 00:37:44,894
one part of that problem.
919
00:37:45,063 --> 00:37:45,996
And that's the children
920
00:37:46,021 --> 00:37:48,121
that I am required to judge.
921
00:37:48,146 --> 00:37:50,859
So... no,
922
00:37:51,056 --> 00:37:53,156
I will not be sending you to jail.
923
00:37:54,414 --> 00:37:55,892
But I will be sentencing you
924
00:37:55,894 --> 00:37:58,070
to up to 200 hours of community service,
925
00:37:58,095 --> 00:38:00,789
to be attended by Officer Dixon.
926
00:38:00,935 --> 00:38:02,844
So if he doesn't commit, you get off.
927
00:38:02,869 --> 00:38:04,921
But if he invests, then you
928
00:38:04,946 --> 00:38:06,546
are required to attend.
929
00:38:07,361 --> 00:38:09,127
And maybe...
930
00:38:09,692 --> 00:38:11,086
...maybe, at the end of all this,
931
00:38:11,111 --> 00:38:13,878
you'll finally be able
to see each other.
932
00:38:15,029 --> 00:38:16,395
That-That's all.
933
00:38:16,483 --> 00:38:18,068
Thank you, sir.
934
00:38:18,093 --> 00:38:19,459
(gavel bangs)
935
00:38:20,986 --> 00:38:22,619
(sighs)
936
00:38:26,491 --> 00:38:27,686
BILLY: I've asked you here because
937
00:38:27,710 --> 00:38:28,983
I believe there's some confusion
938
00:38:29,007 --> 00:38:30,373
about my relationship with Sadie,
939
00:38:30,398 --> 00:38:31,763
and to this firm.
940
00:38:31,788 --> 00:38:34,034
I've been told that I am using Sadie
941
00:38:34,059 --> 00:38:35,697
as a get out of jail free card.
942
00:38:35,934 --> 00:38:38,011
I have also been warned that,
943
00:38:38,036 --> 00:38:40,435
should I go to prison, I
should break up with Sadie
944
00:38:40,460 --> 00:38:43,060
because, apparently, she's
helpless in the face of love.
945
00:38:43,085 --> 00:38:44,637
Now I'm paraphrasing, but
that's basically it,
946
00:38:44,661 --> 00:38:46,724
- right, Isaiah?
- You got the gist.
947
00:38:46,750 --> 00:38:47,950
What?
948
00:38:47,975 --> 00:38:49,953
BILLY: And I've noticed how
you look at me lately.
949
00:38:49,977 --> 00:38:51,271
Like you're wondering if they're right.
950
00:38:51,295 --> 00:38:52,594
They're not.
951
00:38:53,429 --> 00:38:54,861
I was furious
952
00:38:54,886 --> 00:38:56,661
and I felt misunderstood.
953
00:38:56,686 --> 00:38:58,761
But after I got over myself,
954
00:38:58,786 --> 00:38:59,880
it occurred to me
955
00:38:59,905 --> 00:39:01,849
that they're only doing
it to protect you.
956
00:39:01,874 --> 00:39:03,340
And I think that's good.
957
00:39:03,442 --> 00:39:05,408
See, I failed my sister.
958
00:39:05,504 --> 00:39:06,537
She came here
959
00:39:06,665 --> 00:39:09,380
fragile, and... after Amy's death...
960
00:39:10,495 --> 00:39:13,062
(voice breaking): Something
broke inside of her.
961
00:39:13,104 --> 00:39:16,039
And I failed Amy, I left her
alone in the park that night.
962
00:39:17,227 --> 00:39:18,927
But I am not gonna fail you.
963
00:39:19,917 --> 00:39:22,325
I had the family attorney
draft an affidavit
964
00:39:22,383 --> 00:39:25,388
which waives any past and
future conflicts of interest,
965
00:39:25,445 --> 00:39:27,712
knowingly and voluntarily
surrenders any claims
966
00:39:27,737 --> 00:39:29,229
that I might have against Sadie,
967
00:39:29,254 --> 00:39:31,052
Albert or this firm
968
00:39:31,077 --> 00:39:32,576
in any appellate proceeding.
969
00:39:33,685 --> 00:39:34,973
Now, you want to be angry, be angry.
970
00:39:34,997 --> 00:39:36,459
You want to feel betrayed, I get it.
971
00:39:36,747 --> 00:39:38,076
But it's like you said in
your opening statement,
972
00:39:38,100 --> 00:39:39,733
I am an honorable man.
973
00:39:39,758 --> 00:39:41,191
I just love your friend.
974
00:39:41,807 --> 00:39:43,474
Your daughter.
975
00:39:44,296 --> 00:39:45,552
There you go.
976
00:39:45,577 --> 00:39:48,344
I just threw away my get
out of jail free card.
977
00:39:48,836 --> 00:39:50,603
Now you better win.
978
00:39:57,249 --> 00:39:59,749
♪ Footsteps echo ♪
979
00:40:00,148 --> 00:40:01,818
♪ On the flagstone ♪
980
00:40:01,820 --> 00:40:03,720
♪ You can let go... ♪
981
00:40:03,722 --> 00:40:05,507
How are you feeling?
982
00:40:05,678 --> 00:40:06,834
Good.
983
00:40:06,917 --> 00:40:09,062
Really? That's not what I heard.
984
00:40:09,087 --> 00:40:10,460
I brought you some chicken soup.
985
00:40:10,795 --> 00:40:13,241
♪♪
986
00:40:13,518 --> 00:40:14,640
I can explain.
987
00:40:14,665 --> 00:40:17,077
No, I can explain.
988
00:40:17,202 --> 00:40:19,402
You're okay with dating me,
989
00:40:19,507 --> 00:40:21,415
but this morning it hit you, you
could actually be in a room
990
00:40:21,439 --> 00:40:24,523
full of people staring at you,
judging you, because of me.
991
00:40:25,038 --> 00:40:26,876
Suddenly things got real, you panicked,
992
00:40:27,416 --> 00:40:29,817
so you called in sick.
993
00:40:30,448 --> 00:40:31,714
Okay.
994
00:40:31,716 --> 00:40:32,968
Yeah.
995
00:40:33,080 --> 00:40:35,380
Something like that, but,
look, I just needed a day...
996
00:40:35,405 --> 00:40:37,632
You just need some time to
figure things out, right?
997
00:40:37,729 --> 00:40:39,229
You'll get there.
998
00:40:39,450 --> 00:40:42,804
This is all just so new to you, Peter?
999
00:40:43,545 --> 00:40:45,845
Well, it's feeling very familiar to me.
1000
00:40:48,081 --> 00:40:49,647
I thought I was ready, Cam.
1001
00:40:49,961 --> 00:40:52,319
And I thought you were different.
1002
00:40:52,628 --> 00:40:55,195
And the old me would
have given you a day,
1003
00:40:55,283 --> 00:40:57,265
a week, a year.
1004
00:40:57,429 --> 00:41:00,364
But you know what I decided?
1005
00:41:00,419 --> 00:41:03,219
I'm never gonna be
someone's secret again.
1006
00:41:06,646 --> 00:41:08,379
And not that you care,
1007
00:41:08,553 --> 00:41:11,154
but Heyward got community service.
1008
00:41:11,869 --> 00:41:13,268
Enjoy your soup.
1009
00:41:14,201 --> 00:41:16,899
Windsong. Nick just earned his bonus.
1010
00:41:16,924 --> 00:41:18,016
What?
1011
00:41:18,041 --> 00:41:19,175
Two weeks before the election,
1012
00:41:19,199 --> 00:41:20,732
Grace Russo was down three points.
1013
00:41:20,899 --> 00:41:22,556
Then all of a sudden she
gets a huge donation.
1014
00:41:22,580 --> 00:41:25,048
$175,000 from a super PAC.
1015
00:41:25,073 --> 00:41:27,039
- That money traces back to...
- Windsong?
1016
00:41:27,064 --> 00:41:28,597
On the therapy tapes,
1017
00:41:28,622 --> 00:41:30,462
back when Molly would go
to Amy's summer home,
1018
00:41:30,543 --> 00:41:33,345
Gail and her husband would let
the girls sleep on the sailboat.
1019
00:41:33,540 --> 00:41:36,012
- I'll give you one guess.
- No way.
1020
00:41:36,014 --> 00:41:39,048
Windsong is the name of
the Meyers' sailboat.
1021
00:41:39,073 --> 00:41:41,140
The sole owner of the Windsong group?
1022
00:41:41,486 --> 00:41:42,860
Gail Meyers.
1023
00:41:42,885 --> 00:41:44,619
This whole time we've been
looking at Grace Russo,
1024
00:41:44,643 --> 00:41:45,884
she's just a part of it.
1025
00:41:45,909 --> 00:41:47,498
So you're saying Billy
Brennan's prosecution
1026
00:41:47,522 --> 00:41:49,468
was bought and paid for
by Amy Meyers' mom?
1027
00:41:49,493 --> 00:41:50,541
Do you know what this means?
1028
00:41:50,565 --> 00:41:52,899
It means we have a real
chance of winning.
1029
00:41:53,098 --> 00:41:55,064
(chuckles)
1030
00:41:57,629 --> 00:41:59,431
Sadie just gave Albert a really big hug.
1031
00:41:59,456 --> 00:42:01,337
- What do you think happened?
- She told him she loves him,
1032
00:42:01,361 --> 00:42:03,316
now they're getting married. Really?
1033
00:42:03,341 --> 00:42:04,472
No.
1034
00:42:04,497 --> 00:42:06,948
They're just having a good five minutes.
1035
00:42:06,973 --> 00:42:09,607
Which I think is all you can ask for,
1036
00:42:09,632 --> 00:42:11,101
a good five minutes.
1037
00:42:11,126 --> 00:42:12,960
This could get really bad, really fast.
1038
00:42:13,064 --> 00:42:14,897
Oh, I know.
1039
00:42:15,220 --> 00:42:16,313
Found some dirt on Russo.
1040
00:42:16,338 --> 00:42:17,837
We're having pizza to celebrate.
1041
00:42:17,862 --> 00:42:19,595
(gasps) My kid got to go home.
1042
00:42:19,620 --> 00:42:21,140
We're having a good five minutes, too.
1043
00:42:21,253 --> 00:42:22,586
(chuckles)
1044
00:42:22,761 --> 00:42:24,813
♪ Take a little step to the east ♪
1045
00:42:24,838 --> 00:42:26,605
♪ For freedom and for peace ♪
1046
00:42:26,869 --> 00:42:28,735
♪ Take a big step to the west ♪
1047
00:42:28,933 --> 00:42:31,002
♪ For flavor and for passion ♪
1048
00:42:31,027 --> 00:42:32,961
♪ Take a big leap down south ♪
1049
00:42:33,131 --> 00:42:35,131
♪ For fashion of the season ♪
1050
00:42:35,180 --> 00:42:37,046
♪ Take a tall hop up north ♪
1051
00:42:37,275 --> 00:42:39,142
♪ No fear, just cross the bridge ♪
1052
00:42:39,144 --> 00:42:41,477
♪ It's all right to flip your lid... ♪
1053
00:42:41,554 --> 00:42:46,554
synced & corrected by PopcornAWH
www.addic7ed.com
76372
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.